رونوشت 🔗
00:00:00
Speaker 1: Your voice. Your station. Your open line.
00:00:04
Speaker 2: Walk the talk with Clement.
00:00:06
Speaker 1: Munger-Taylor on 702. All right, Jordan Hill-Lewis is the leader of the Democratic Alliance who's back with us on the line. We'll be talking a lot until there's an agreement of sorts and parties have now concluded the negotiation. So, Jordan, thank you so much for coming back to chat to us. Good morning.
00:00:24
Speaker 3: Good morning, Clement. Nice to be back with you. Sure.
00:00:27
Speaker 1: Let's start with what was reported yesterday about this swap that you have proposed allegedly to Action SA that you're willing to come to Joburg and maybe Helen comes to the city of Cape Town. Is that true?
00:00:42
Speaker 3: Well, I think that headline was naughty, to say the least. I've made no such proposal. It's an idea that has been floated with me by several people in which I've discussed with several people, and it's been going around for a week or so. And it is just that. You're just tossing around ideas, trying to figure out a way to make things work potentially, but certainly no proposal has been made. And I'm not sure that it is a practical or feasible proposal. idea in any case and.
00:01:15
Speaker 1: Speaking of the practicality and the feasibility of it i mean would the law allow for that don't you need to be a resident of johannesburg for you to be able to you do okay you.
00:01:24
Speaker 3: Do yeah so so you know i i haven't even this is how much it was just a floating of an idea is that i have not even really seriously investigated the legalities of it uh yeah the you uh you know you have to be a registered voter in the municipality so it Yeah. It's just an idea.
00:01:42
Speaker 1: And also.
00:01:43
Speaker 3: Certainly no firm offer, mate.
00:01:45
Speaker 1: And there's also like the issue of two terms. I mean, Helen has already served the two terms in Cape Town. So how would that work?
00:01:52
Speaker 3: No, Helen only served one term in Cape Town.
00:01:55
Speaker 1: Oh, she didn't do two?
00:01:57
Speaker 3: Yeah, yeah. One term and then she became the Premier.
00:01:59
Speaker 1: Oh, okay. Okay, cool. So who has been floating the idea with you though? Is it people in the DA? Yeah.
00:02:07
Speaker 3: Yes, and in the business community and others as well. And we've, look, you know, it's all in the spirit of trying to make this work. You know, I heard your introduction. Of course, you are absolutely right. Our political system, you can get the... Uh, the most votes as we did in all three of those metros, but the political system works in such a way that you have to have a, uh, a 50% plus one coalition in order to govern.
00:02:35
Speaker 1: Yeah.
00:02:36
Speaker 3: Uh, and, and we are, we are exploring every, every option to try and arrive at a deal. And, uh, that is proving very, very tough. As you've seen in the media, no doubt, it does seem as though an alternative deal is quite close to being signed. I think that would be a terrible mistake, but that is the way the political system works if a party does not get a majority.
00:03:00
Speaker 1: I've spoken to Michael Beaumont this morning again, and he's confirmed that they are literally almost at the end of signing this deal. They're just finalizing the nitty gritties. Are you willing to accept defeat that you are just not going to be in government in Gauteng? Because it looks like the train is far gone now. The ANC has made a proposal that seems to be very attractive to Action SA, and it's better than what you've made to Action SA. Are you ready to say, you know what, we've tried our best, we're not going to be in government in Gauteng?
00:03:33
Speaker 3: Well, the final whistle has not yet blown, and I'm going to keep working right until the first meeting in those councils. But if that does happen, then absolutely we are prepared to go into opposition and fight for the voters of Joburg and the Scouting metros who voted for us and fight to keep trying to get a better government there. I think it would be a profound error. I think the voters will punish them dearly. But that's my view, and time will tell. Yeah.
00:04:10
Speaker 1: And do you think, though, you can still make an attractive proposal to Action SA, practically speaking now, Jordan? Because, I mean, if the ANC says to Action SA, take Joubek, take Aguruleni, I mean, take Joubek, take Swani, the ANC takes Aguruleni, it is attractive to Action SA. So you have to come up with something better than that. Well....
00:04:31
Speaker 3: I'm not sure that we could do that, but you must also consider the concept of short-term gains but long-term pain. I mean, it may feel like a victory, but in the end, voters actually sent a very, very clear message in this election for change. And that would not deliver fundamental change in these Gauteng metros. I think it would be more of the same instability. I think it would require a six or seven party coalition in Johannesburg to make that work. And so I think you will get more of the same. And that politically is going to translate into long-term pain for the parties that did that to the people of Gauteng.
00:05:15
Speaker 1: When I spoke to you on, was it on Monday, you indicated that, you know, you are, open to whatever the requests that political parties or even conditions they're bringing as you negotiate. Is it fair to say that you have now completely closed the door to the condition that Action SA put up that, you know, drop Helen Ziller? Because, I mean, if you were considering that by now, this is something you probably would have done already.
00:05:42
Speaker 3: Yeah, I've always said, I think I said earlier in the week, it may even have been to you. Yes, it was.
00:05:48
Speaker 1: I said that that is an incredibly impossible thing to swallow.
00:05:58
Speaker 3: And I think that we remain very far from one another if that is the demand. But, you know, I've said I also don't like
Load full transcript
to use the language of I'm not prepared to talk about this because I just don't think that that's a healthy attitude in any. That's not a basis actually for a discussion to say I'm not prepared to talk about this. So my approach has been let's talk about everything. We may at the end say after this conversation, we still don't think it's doable. But let's at least have the discussion. That's I think is the least that mature adults can do.
00:06:31
Speaker 1: What do you say to those who are arguing that, well, think about the bigger strategy and long-term strategy of the organization. Why don't you just sacrifice Helen Ziller?
00:06:44
Speaker 3: Well, you know, there's something slightly different. and even preposterous about the suggestion. We have put her forward transparently as a candidate. We did not hide her name like other parties did. We did not announce a candidate like other parties did. We put her forward and we made a clear offer and that offer actually got the majority of the votes. So to sacrifice that on the basis of what is clearly a deeply felt personal issue, I think that the question should rather be put to the other side, to say, you know, this person has received the plurality of support from the voters. Is it really worth sacrificing all of that progress because of these deeply held personal issues? I'm not, for a second... diminishing or undermining those issues. I'm sure that they are serious, but the fact is that they are not political and they are not technical. They don't have anything to do with the government of that metro. They are personal. And voters want a better government in Joburg.
00:08:07
Speaker 1: Yeah, just lastly, Jordan, Michael Beeman told me this morning that you guys haven't really negotiated with Action SA. All you have done is meet as leader of the DA with Hemant Mashaba, leader of Action SA. I think you guys met last week, Thursday. But Michael Beeman seems to take a position that there hasn't really been substantial talks between Action SA and the DA. It's just been you talking to the leader of Action SA. Is that true? Has there not been a proposal that's been sent?
00:08:38
Speaker 3: Uh, I don't want to get into the detail of that, Clement. I think there has been more substantive talk than that. It is true that the two larger negotiating teams have not formally met in a kind of boardroom fashion beyond our meeting of the party leaders. But there has been a lot of back and forth correspondence with me and Terman, and it's still ongoing even now. So, you know, I don't want to get into the detail of what that contains. We've said that we're not going to go into that in public. But suffice to say that we are still serious about trying to put together a government that can give these cities the best chance of actually turning around. Even though at this late stage, it seems like they are close to another deal. We'll keep pushing, as I said, until the final whistle blows.
00:09:32
Speaker 1: Yeah. Jordan Hill-Lewis, thank you so much for speaking to us. All the best. That's the leader of the Democratic Alliance. So they're not going to give up until the final whistle blows. Guys, the reality here is it's about what is more attractive to you. So if you went for a job interview, 702 is offering you 10,000 rand. Another station is offering you 20,000 rand. What do you take? Yes, of course, you have to think strategically because it kind just be about money. You have to think in the short term, what do I benefit? In the long term, what do we benefit? What do we lose? But the reality now is Action SA has the cards. They are now officially the king maker. Whether you like it or not, And if you want them to listen to you, you have to make them an attractive proposal. The AMC has made an attractive proposal. They said, take Johannesburg, take Tswani, we will take Kuruleni. If the DA is serious about proposing a better deal, then they have to do that. But what would that entail? Because as you hear from Jordan Hill, who is there, I don't think they are prepared to sacrifice Helen Zille. in Johannesburg. They are willing to, he says, respect how the voters have voted, right? As someone who was the DA mayoral candidate, Jordan Hill Lewis believes that the reason the DA is the leading party is because of the work Helen did. So it would be weird, according to them, to sacrifice her. Then accept defeat. Walk away, be in opposition benches, and you try again next time. Because now, the ANC Annexion Essay are getting closer and closer to the deal. In fact, it's as good as done. They're just finalizing the nitty gritties. But hey, this is politics. Anything is possible. Remember, President Saul Ramaphosa was elected president in parliament and the statement of intent was finalized in the early hours of that morning. In fact, minutes before the president had to be elected. Remember, Helen Zillow was busy speaking to Figi Lembalula. They were trying to finalize the statement of intent before the DA members of parliament voted. for Cyril Ramaphosa to be president. Now, you've heard what Jordan Hill Lewis had to say. Listen to what Michael Beaumont told me. I recorded an interview with him just before we went live at 9 o'clock because he's currently engaged in more negotiations, I suspect, with the African National Congress. Here's what he told us this morning. I started... Abel, did I start with a question? Okay, let's listen to Michael Beaumont. So it looks like the ANC has made you as Action SA an attractive proposal. Is it something you are close to agreeing to?
00:12:14
Speaker 2: I think there's a lot of work to be done. It certainly is an attractive proposal if it involves Action SA leading with the mayoralty from signing in Johannesburg, given what Dr. Masipi Moya and Herman Mashaba have by way of a track record of fixing their respective cities. but certainly there's a lot more work to be done. We can't just deal with these things at the level of
positions. There needs to be very thorough analysis of whether these parties can align around how.
00:12:41
Speaker 3: These cities will be fixed.
00:12:43
Speaker 2: That's the work that I think will be explored over the coming days.
00:12:46
Speaker 1: Okay, cool. So if there's a proposal that's attractive on the table, so what? Is it the nitty-gritties? And when you say positions, are you talking more MMC positions? Is that what you're also negotiating around this proposal?
00:12:59
Speaker 2: Yeah, that'll be part of it, but I'm just saying the mere fact that the offer of mayoralty is attractive is obviously a good aspect, but it doesn't change the fact that we need to see whether there's alignment on other issues, particularly relating to a shared program of government, institutions that can fight corruption, the commitment to deal with illegal immigration. These are things that now need to be unpacked and explored in the days ahead.
00:13:23
Speaker 1: Okay, what is the most important for you? So you mentioned maybe a corruption body... You mentioned illegal immigration. Would you say those are the key issues that you are trying to make sure that they're accounted for in the agreement?
00:13:38
Speaker 2: They're amongst the key issues. If you talk about a Johannesburg-specific context, obviously infrastructure collapse is the major story there. Water has become a crisis in the city. So too has unstable electricity grids. The road network collapsed as well. These are all issues that need to form part of a plan to turn around these municipalities. And this is where we need to get into the detail because any government that is involved in leading Johannesburg that does not fix that water crisis, by way of an example, will have failed by 2031.
00:14:11
Speaker 1: Okay. So where does this leave your conversations with the DEA? Is there still hope there or you've completely closed that door and now you're focusing on the attractive proposal from the ANC, unless they have given you an attractive proposal as well, the DA?
00:14:27
Speaker 2: The truth is that the DA has never really had talks with Action SA. And this is both the strangest thing, because if we're standing a meeting between the two parties' leaders sometime last week or whenever it was, the DA has never engaged Action SA towards bilateral talks and negotiating teams the way that every other political party has engaged. in this process. So, you know, I think the point is that the DA actually has put on the table concerns relating to the merits of Brink and Villa and the commitment and willingness to work with the DA should those problems be resolved. And there hasn't really been engagement at a bilateral level between the two parties on those issues.
00:15:11
Speaker 1: Okay. And to be clear then, your focus now has just been on trying to finalize the nitty gritties around the agreement with the ANC.
00:15:20
Speaker 3: Correct.
00:15:20
Speaker 2: And we remain in conversation with the DA and we are urging them to come to the table and engage. But ultimately, you know, the ball is in their court.
00:15:29
Speaker 1: Okay. Thank you so much, Michael. I appreciate your time.
00:15:32
Speaker 2: Thank you, Clement.
00:15:34
Speaker 1: Michael Beaumont there, the chairperson of Action SA. So what's important out of that chat is that they are now focusing on the ANC. That's the proposal that has been sent to them. It's attractive to them. And he says there's no proposal or even a deal that's been considered with the Democratic Alliance. And as you heard from Jordan Hill Lewis, I think he's ready to accept defeat and just allow for DA members of council to be in the opposition benches. It looks like that's where things are headed. But will the Action SA and the ANC agree on this nitty gritties? Well, Action SA is holding the cards. The ANC is not negotiating from a position of strength. So I suspect that they will meet each other. What do you think? 011-883-0702 WhatsApps on 072-702-1702 It's 9.30.