رونوشت 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00.000 --> 00:03.446
This is The Catholic Current with Father
00:03.542 --> 00:07.069
Robert Mattheig. 17th century Scottish statesman Andrew
00:07.569 --> 00:11.269
Fletcher said, let me make the songs of a nation and I care not who
00:11.769 --> 00:15.036
makes the laws. How might we have to update it for today?
00:15.404 --> 00:18.274
Well, I think that the best way to update that is to use the words
00:18.322 --> 00:21.640
of a 21st century Irish statesman, another Andrew,
00:21.672 --> 00:25.519
Andrew Breitbart. He said politics is downstream of culture, and he's
00:25.664 --> 00:29.190
absolutely right. And if we think the way to win is to walk
00:29.690 --> 00:32.573
away from the fight, well, then you end up with the kind of society we
00:32.637 --> 00:36.003
find ourselves in. Praise be Jesus
00:36.503 --> 00:39.498
Christ. This is Father Robert McTagg of the Society of Jesus, your daily host for
00:39.998 --> 00:42.944
The Catholic Current, where we bring Christ to the world and the world to Christ.
00:42.992 --> 00:46.166
You're listening to us from the Station of the Cross Studios, your local radio station,
00:46.743 --> 00:50.959
and the iCatholic Radio mobile app, and we proclaim the fullness of truth with
00:50.991 --> 00:54.213
clarity and charity. As always, let's start with prayer.
00:54.710 --> 00:57.820
In the name of the Father, Son, and the Holy Spirit. Almighty God, through the
00:58.320 --> 01:01.587
intercession of Saint Ignatius Loyola, we ask that you pour forth your Holy Spirit upon
01:02.087 --> 01:05.723
us, a spirit of discernment, they might hear your voice and obey your command.
01:06.236 --> 01:10.019
In the name of the Father, Son, and the Holy Spirit. Amen. Well, friends,
01:10.308 --> 01:14.508
it looks like Europe is still on fire and
01:15.008 --> 01:18.499
Europeans are allowing the vandalism of their cultural
01:18.999 --> 01:23.004
monuments and the desecration of churches. The 250th anniversary
01:23.504 --> 01:26.097
of the founding of the United States came and went. It's really different from the
01:26.597 --> 01:30.410
bicentennial that I remember as a boy. And it seems to be what the cool
01:30.442 --> 01:33.648
kids are recommending is that we hate ourselves. And it
01:34.148 --> 01:37.559
seems to be a process that is really aggressive in the
01:37.575 --> 01:41.070
West. And the case— and the question that I have is
01:41.326 --> 01:45.206
why. And I stumbled upon a video recently called
01:45.270 --> 01:49.646
Western Self-Contempt: The Hidden Malady Undermining Our Civilization.
01:49.759 --> 01:53.382
And my new guest today is the origin of that video.
01:53.446 --> 01:56.957
She's a molecular biologist and author of the Substack
01:57.037 --> 01:59.970
called Let's Be Clear. Dr. Jumi Kim,
02:00.179 --> 02:03.513
welcome to The Catholic Current. Thank you for having me. Dr. Kim,
02:03.609 --> 02:07.521
I think back to when my older brother graduated from 8th grade
02:07.633 --> 02:10.614
public school, 1968,
02:10.679 --> 02:13.692
1969 at the latest, and at his graduation,
02:13.804 --> 02:17.187
the children sang a song called This Is My Country.
02:17.235 --> 02:20.569
I just want to read to you 2 stanzas of that
02:20.633 --> 02:23.551
song. This is my country, land of my birth.
02:23.727 --> 02:27.270
This is my country, grandest on earth. I pledge thee
02:27.770 --> 02:31.646
my allegiance, America the bold, for this is my country to have
02:31.742 --> 02:36.295
and to hold. I'm willing Tibet that it would be physically
02:36.407 --> 02:40.495
impossible to have a group of schoolchildren in America sing that
02:40.995 --> 02:44.053
song today. What are your thoughts on that? Well,
02:44.262 --> 02:47.548
I mean, I have not been in school for a while, and I don't know
02:48.048 --> 02:51.026
what they're doing these days in school, but that wouldn't surprise me.
02:51.636 --> 02:55.114
There's something about that that feels almost taboo,
02:55.547 --> 02:59.138
you know? Right. It's too patriotic. Yeah. I know that on
02:59.346 --> 03:02.232
Cinco de Mayo, which is a great Mexican festival,
03:02.312 --> 03:05.566
there were schoolchildren in the Southwest and California for
03:06.066 --> 03:09.934
example, who can wear Mexican flags, but if an American
03:09.983 --> 03:13.532
child wears an American flag on Cinco de Mayo, that's considered hate speech,
03:13.548 --> 03:17.097
etc. So it seems to be trendy, almost a form
03:17.290 --> 03:21.160
of virtue signaling for the West to hate itself.
03:21.305 --> 03:25.079
And the phrase was coined called oikophobia,
03:25.095 --> 03:29.013
and my ears say, oh, Greek, I want to pay attention to that.
03:29.335 --> 03:32.723
And it's a self-loathing for what's familiar.
03:33.189 --> 03:36.863
Can you unpack that? What it is, what that term means,
03:36.895 --> 03:39.396
and why we're living it now? Yes. So,
03:40.085 --> 03:43.852
oikophobia was originally coined, I think,
03:43.868 --> 03:46.096
by Roger Scruton, the philosopher.
03:47.058 --> 03:50.970
But in the book Western Self-Contempt by Benedict Beckled,
03:50.986 --> 03:54.592
he really digs into what this is. And you can think of it
03:55.092 --> 03:58.776
like the opposite of xenophobia. So, the xenophobe rejects
03:59.276 --> 04:01.758
the foreign, whereas the oikophobe rejects things that are close to home.
04:02.447 --> 04:06.134
And it isn't just criticism of your own culture, you know, which can
04:06.634 --> 04:10.094
be healthy to some degree, but it's like this reflexive belief that one's
04:10.222 --> 04:13.284
own culture is uniquely terrible while, you know,
04:13.524 --> 04:16.746
other foreign countries are either idealized or
04:17.051 --> 04:20.946
romanticized. Right. And in your reference to
04:20.978 --> 04:24.088
Becklow's work, I said there seems to be kind of a
04:24.588 --> 04:29.025
historical cycle that you've got an emerging people
04:29.137 --> 04:33.001
and there is boldness and
Load full transcript
exploration and conquest and
04:33.501 --> 04:37.136
so on. Is it analogous to the, you know, hard men
04:37.169 --> 04:40.568
make good times, etc., etc.? Is it a similar cycle to that?
04:40.921 --> 04:45.204
Yeah, I think it's very similar. Yeah. The basic idea that Beckeld
04:46.054 --> 04:49.888
outlines in his book is that so, so when a civilization
04:49.904 --> 04:53.738
first starts out, it may be sort of more uncultured,
04:53.994 --> 04:57.138
more tribal, you know, but once they,
04:57.219 --> 05:01.437
they have some successes, like either, you know, taking over surrounding
05:01.694 --> 05:05.255
peoples and, you know, they get more wealth and prestige, you start to
05:05.319 --> 05:08.606
get like a like a class of people who are just
05:09.106 --> 05:12.710
more intellectual, you know, they don't necessarily have to defend themselves physically.
05:12.918 --> 05:17.022
It's a different type of person, you know, the intellectual or elite
05:17.522 --> 05:21.318
people who don't have to have these practical struggles anymore and no longer have
05:21.350 --> 05:23.659
to defend their own society, you know.
05:24.171 --> 05:28.083
So you can get this class of people who are more decadent,
05:28.307 --> 05:31.513
you know, and they're free from
05:31.594 --> 05:35.028
having to worry about you know, defending themselves from enemies.
05:35.076 --> 05:38.640
And they'll also— one way to stand out also among these
05:38.672 --> 05:42.349
elites is just to, to be critical of one's
05:42.429 --> 05:45.833
own society, you know, as a way to gain status or, or feel
05:46.333 --> 05:49.606
superior among their peers, you know. And this is just like
05:49.671 --> 05:53.122
the beginning of your own self-contempt,
05:53.267 --> 05:56.879
you know. So Western self-contempt, or it doesn't just have to be in the West,
05:56.896 --> 06:00.331
but it's, it's happened Mainly in the West, not in
06:00.831 --> 06:03.976
other cultures. But, um, yeah, so, and that
06:04.476 --> 06:08.615
starts a new cycle where, you know, the downfall essentially
06:09.115 --> 06:12.757
follows directly from the success of the society. Yeah,
06:13.174 --> 06:17.509
it seems to me that eventually there is enough
06:18.009 --> 06:21.587
of a profit and enough of security that you don't
06:21.603 --> 06:25.728
have to be, you know, worried about, you know, a bear rampaging through,
06:25.953 --> 06:29.720
through the cave where you're hiding, and you don't have to worry about the barbarians
06:29.800 --> 06:32.926
coming over the fence, and you have
06:33.426 --> 06:36.869
enough people who can have time on their hands, and that's how you end
06:37.369 --> 06:40.268
up with philosophy. If you're running for your life, you usually don't have time to
06:40.284 --> 06:44.163
philosophize. You have the development of, of the arts,
06:44.708 --> 06:48.683
and then eventually you want to begin to distinguish
06:48.860 --> 06:52.210
yourself, and there are no more lands to conquer,
06:52.643 --> 06:56.378
and the heavy lifting and the dirty work is done by, by the plebeians,
06:56.891 --> 07:00.113
and so the way of distinguishing yourself is kind
07:00.613 --> 07:04.378
of breaking taboos, being, being the bad boy,
07:04.507 --> 07:07.922
crossing lines. And so somewhere along the lines, we go from
07:08.098 --> 07:11.706
honest self-examination and honest self-criticism, which is
07:12.206 --> 07:15.746
important for moral maturity, and then we get to the point
07:15.874 --> 07:19.594
of parodying ourselves, holding ourselves up
07:19.658 --> 07:23.105
to ridicule, and then eventually it
07:23.169 --> 07:26.601
becomes contempt. I mean, it And
07:26.633 --> 07:30.325
we can go from, uh, I hold contempt for my society
07:30.389 --> 07:33.454
to I hold so much contempt for my society that
07:33.954 --> 07:37.980
I want to do something about it and not make it better but destroy
07:38.109 --> 07:41.993
it. As you look at the West, as you see Europe on fire,
07:42.587 --> 07:45.877
where, where do you see us in, in the life cycle of this process
07:46.377 --> 07:49.713
now? It seems we're very late in this stage,
07:50.211 --> 07:53.791
you know. We're, uh, very much people are
07:54.482 --> 07:58.353
full of self-contempt for their own Western culture.
07:59.043 --> 08:02.689
And when they look at other foreign cultures that are more exotic, I think
08:02.834 --> 08:05.837
they, they tend to make excuses for them and,
08:05.966 --> 08:09.901
you know, idealize them. And they may correctly
08:09.965 --> 08:12.599
point out that, you know, our own culture has its problems,
08:12.696 --> 08:16.486
but they make it seem like it's uniquely bad, you know,
08:16.647 --> 08:20.114
and they ignore aspects of it that are uniquely good.
08:20.675 --> 08:24.156
Right, right. I mean, for example, there— as I listen
08:24.253 --> 08:27.798
to people online or talk to young people, you get the
08:28.298 --> 08:32.098
impression that slavery was invented
08:32.676 --> 08:35.997
in 1619 when the White People's Club
08:36.045 --> 08:39.398
had a meeting and decided to enslave others,
08:39.975 --> 08:44.564
and that slavery was not practiced by anyone anywhere at
08:45.064 --> 08:48.738
any time, uh, before or since. So there seems to be a lot
08:49.238 --> 08:52.831
of bad education involved. Um, we've got 2 minutes
08:53.331 --> 08:55.543
left in this segment, and I want to talk about this more in the next
08:56.043 --> 08:59.845
segment. But they said you, uh, you said there's a fetishization,
08:59.893 --> 09:03.120
a valorization of the victim class.
09:03.666 --> 09:07.117
Is part of Western self-loathing is it can be a grift,
09:07.133 --> 09:10.648
it can be a cash grab? Do you mean, um, some people are
09:11.049 --> 09:14.147
doing it just because it gives them attention, basically?
09:14.484 --> 09:17.819
Yes. Yes, I definitely think that. Yeah, I mean, I think a lot of people
09:17.867 --> 09:20.993
believe it, but I
think, um, for sure there are some people who are probably
09:21.057 --> 09:24.696
more cynical about it, you know, and they see that this will appeal to,
09:25.081 --> 09:28.591
to, um, a lot of people. Yeah, right. And, and it
09:29.091 --> 09:32.423
seems to me that we have— we've lost a sense of
09:32.519 --> 09:35.725
history, and that's something I want to talk about in the next segment as well.
09:36.286 --> 09:40.357
Um, you know, I mean, you know, United States has, has a, a checkered history,
09:40.470 --> 09:44.285
to be sure, but I can't help but recall that the aftermath of
09:44.317 --> 09:47.589
the American Revolution was the Constitutional
09:47.605 --> 09:51.187
Convention, and the aftermath of the French Revolution was
09:51.284 --> 09:55.396
known as the Terror. And I think that's a
09:55.896 --> 09:59.059
very significant philosophical and moral difference.
09:59.879 --> 10:03.284
And I find it alarming when I
10:03.509 --> 10:06.562
see indigenous European children, you know,
10:06.803 --> 10:10.883
dancing in churches in France as they vandalize and desecrate
10:11.383 --> 10:15.490
them. And I begin to wonder who failed those children.
10:15.554 --> 10:20.123
Sure, let's have a very candid, let's have a very sober assessment
10:20.748 --> 10:24.274
of history, but let's tell the full story that
10:24.774 --> 10:28.282
there are virtues and there are victories and there are points of
10:28.362 --> 10:32.578
honor and achievement. And just as the traffic across
10:32.706 --> 10:35.880
the Berlin Wall went in only one direction,
10:36.393 --> 10:40.528
the patterns of migration seem to be almost exclusively to
10:40.544 --> 10:44.172
the north and to the West, and nobody seems to
10:44.672 --> 10:47.834
be willing to talk about what that is. If, if the
10:47.931 --> 10:51.608
West is such a horrible place, why are people so absolutely
10:51.785 --> 10:54.981
desperate to get there? And we'll talk about that in the next segment.
10:55.399 --> 10:58.932
Friends, we come back, want to continue our conversation with Dr. Jumi Kim. We are
10:58.948 --> 11:02.706
talking about the phenomenon of Western self-contempt.
11:03.364 --> 11:06.512
What is it and why is it happening and what can we do about it?
11:06.689 --> 11:10.286
Remember, rallying cry here at the Catholic Current is Christus Mundo, Mundus Christo.
11:10.672 --> 11:13.820
Bringing Christ to the world and the world to Christ. We do it because our
11:14.320 --> 11:17.193
Lord says so, for the greater glory of God, the love of our neighbor,
11:17.241 --> 11:20.823
and the salvation of our own soul. After the broadcast today, go to
11:20.871 --> 11:23.987
thestationofthecross.com, get our resources list,
11:24.003 --> 11:27.698
download our audio as podcasts. Wherever you find audio, you can
11:28.198 --> 11:31.360
find us. Take us to your family and friends. Together we'll take it to the
11:31.456 --> 11:34.492
whole world. Be back in just 2 minutes. Please do stay with us.
12:00.803 --> 12:04.362
You're listening to The Catholic Current with Father Robert McTague
12:04.862 --> 12:08.863
from the Station of the Cross Catholic Media Network. Stay connected with the show and
12:08.912 --> 12:12.626
our guests and topics by following the show on Twitter and Gab.
12:12.885 --> 12:15.533
Just search for The Catholic Current.
12:20.440 --> 12:23.595
Praise be Jesus Christ. This is Father Robert McTeague of the Society of Jesus,
12:23.612 --> 12:26.816
your daily host for The Catholic Current, where we bring Christ to the world and
12:27.316 --> 12:29.585
the world to Christ. You're listening to us from the Station of the Cross Studios,
12:29.634 --> 12:32.808
your local radio station, the iCatholic Radio mobile app, where we
12:33.308 --> 12:36.999
proclaim the fullness of truth with clarity and charity. Hey friends, did you
12:37.499 --> 12:41.295
know iCatholic Mobile supports only Catholic causes? iCatholic Mobile offers
12:41.471 --> 12:44.757
unlimited 5G data, text, and talk, and iCatholic
12:45.257 --> 12:47.963
Mobile gives a portion of every dollar earned to the Station of the Cross Catholic
12:48.463 --> 12:51.634
Media Network. By subscribing to iCatholic Mobile, you can help fund
12:51.666 --> 12:55.017
programs that defend our Catholic faith. We're talking about
12:55.517 --> 12:58.960
the strange phenomenon of Western self-contempt, and my guest is Dr.
12:59.040 --> 13:01.781
Jumi Kim, and she is author of a Substack called,
13:02.310 --> 13:06.061
uh, Let's Be Clear. Uh, Dr. Kim, in your your very interesting
13:06.093 --> 13:09.618
video, which drew me to your work, you talk about the hidden
13:09.682 --> 13:12.134
malady undermining our civilization.
13:12.726 --> 13:16.556
You talked about kind of the valorization of being
13:16.588 --> 13:20.641
a victim, that there was a time when achievement was considered
13:20.690 --> 13:24.166
a badge of honor. And now it seems that being a victim is
13:24.214 --> 13:27.451
a badge of honor. What's going on here? Oh, so many
13:27.483 --> 13:30.656
things. I think that, yeah, it's on one level,
13:30.688 --> 13:34.310
for example, you see it in how we tend to
13:35.000 --> 13:38.915
elevate minorities, right? And instead of just promoting
13:39.428 --> 13:43.488
equality. So now, for example, it's perfectly fine
13:43.600 --> 13:47.034
to just openly favor, you know, like some
13:47.534 --> 13:51.655
minority for whether it's a job or something like that over someone who is white
13:51.719 --> 13:54.976
simply because of the color of their skin, you know, or for
13:55.073 --> 13:58.972
promoting women, for example, over men, right? As opposed to just based on
13:59.164 --> 14:02.920
merit. So you see it in places like that. And it's
14:03.000 --> 14:06.502
all over the culture where it's not just that,
14:06.550 --> 14:09.875
but it's also almost like an elevation of weakness.
14:10.164 --> 14:13.585
You know, like, I think, like, when people having
14:13.698
--> 14:16.830
disabilities, you know, like, I hear, for example, that, like, there's a lot more,
14:17.296 --> 14:20.845
quote, representation of people with disabilities in literature
14:20.926 --> 14:24.267
and film and such. And that in itself is
14:24.299 --> 14:27.849
fine, but it's gotten to a point where, like, it elevates that,
14:27.881 --> 14:31.188
you know, it's elevating weakness. And so it's almost
14:31.688 --> 14:35.051
like a fetishization, you know, of weakness, which is a
14:35.551 --> 14:38.883
little strange when you think about it. It's almost against nature,
14:38.915 --> 14:42.425
you know, like naturally speaking, right? Most people want
14:42.925 --> 14:46.113
to be stronger, you know, or more skilled or, you know,
14:46.129 --> 14:49.303
so on and so forth. So it's a very strange thing that seems to be
14:49.803 --> 14:53.006
going on. Well, one of the reasons I stopped going to professional
14:53.506 --> 14:57.543
conferences in philosophy many years ago was, in my innocence,
14:57.559 --> 15:01.550
I thought that, you know, people would want to be talking about truth and discovery
15:01.983 --> 15:05.750
and so on. And instead it was, well, which grievance
15:05.894 --> 15:09.036
do you promote? And it seems to be there was a
15:09.536 --> 15:13.604
lot of carping and complaining rather than achievement.
15:14.085 --> 15:18.268
You also had an essay in your video where you talked about Nietzsche
15:18.413 --> 15:21.795
and the last man. As you can imagine, I'm not
15:22.295 --> 15:25.904
a huge fan of Nietzsche. But he was not a stupid man, and he saw
15:25.953 --> 15:30.516
things that were important. And some people said Nietzsche saw the
15:31.016 --> 15:35.963
triumph of weakness and what he called a kind of effeminacy,
15:36.960 --> 15:39.900
what Aquinas would call a softness. Could you speak to that, please?
15:40.479 --> 15:43.548
Yeah. So, I mean, this is something he wrote about in Thus
15:44.048 --> 15:47.854
Spake Zarathustra. It's only really just a few pages, but it's a very
15:47.951 --> 15:51.881
interesting few pages. Um, but he calls the last
15:52.381 --> 15:57.107
man as somebody who is essentially like the endpoint of human evolution
15:57.607 --> 16:01.933
in which the sort of highest human possibilities have been extinguished.
16:02.622 --> 16:05.972
Um, so this person who, you know, just only values
16:05.989 --> 16:09.612
like happiness and small pleasures, he's domesticated.
16:10.157 --> 16:14.597
Um, he's sort of smothered the part of himself that like aims for greatness
16:14.742 --> 16:18.573
and struggle and recognition and sacrifice. You know, he doesn't want to risk or overcome,
16:18.589 --> 16:22.392
but he just wants like security. So he's
16:22.906 --> 16:26.373
essentially describing like a smaller, more sort of fragile kind
16:26.873 --> 16:31.478
of a person preoccupied with safety and affirmation.
16:32.072 --> 16:35.267
Yeah. And you can have disagreements with lots
16:35.767
--> 16:39.200
of things that he said. I mean, I do as well. But he was
16:39.700 --> 16:43.294
a psychologist of decadence, a very astute psychologist.
16:43.374 --> 16:47.082
Oh, what an interesting term. Yeah. And it was prophetic
16:47.582 --> 16:51.225
of what humanity could become if we just kind of elevated
16:51.257 --> 16:54.307
sort of weakness or mediocrity, you know.
16:54.934 --> 16:58.771
Interesting that you use the word decadence, because when I hear decadence, I think of,
16:58.851 --> 17:02.272
you know, Weimar Republic in Germany immediately after World War I.
17:02.416 --> 17:06.880
And the Weimar Republic was certainly a decadent, you know, morally depraved
17:06.912 --> 17:10.155
place in very many ways, especially in Berlin.
17:11.247 --> 17:14.699
Do you think that's where we are now, that we have become
17:14.715 --> 17:18.585
so glutted and besotted by excess
17:18.714 --> 17:22.134
that we don't think of where wealth comes
17:22.230 --> 17:25.860
from, where electricity comes from? I remember seeing a
17:26.261 --> 17:29.729
brief video of a young lady who thinks that some evil genius has
17:29.858 --> 17:33.166
tricked people into working and that we should all just go
17:33.666 --> 17:37.084
on vacation forever, and she doesn't understand why this
17:37.584 --> 17:40.536
doesn't happen. She wasn't 7 years old. She was at least, you know, biologically she
17:41.036 --> 17:44.487
was an adult. Is that part of it? We've become so decadent that
17:44.987 --> 17:48.855
we're incapable of gratitude? I mean, I think so. I think— and I think
17:48.903 --> 17:52.645
that this is very much— this very much characterizes,
17:52.902 --> 17:56.435
um, sort of that late stage of culture that we just talked about, you know,
17:57.736 --> 18:01.334
this having agoraphobia. But, but decadent basically means
18:01.350 --> 18:04.867
like sort of, you know, self-indulgent and like in a state
18:05.367 --> 18:09.364
of sort of cultural decline, you know, and where you're—
18:09.444 --> 18:13.090
where it's characterized by just comfort and pleasure
18:13.379 --> 18:16.493
and deterioration of standards.
18:17.312 --> 18:21.181
Um, and what you just brought up is it's almost like the mentality of a,
18:21.422 --> 18:25.002
like, a pet, right, who just thinks that food or
18:25.018 --> 18:28.326
any other needs should just come to them from essentially
18:28.826 --> 18:31.777
the sky. And, uh, it's just different from, like,
18:31.938 --> 18:36.176
nature itself, right? I mean, humanity has always had to work
18:36.337 --> 18:40.415
in order to get anything, whether it was food or
18:40.915 --> 18:43.971
you know, shelter. Um, and now, I don't know, people are just so divorced from,
18:44.436 --> 18:47.658
from that, you know. Where does, where does, where does food
18:48.158 --> 18:51.025
and all these other things come from? And they, they just think that they're owed
18:51.525 --> 18:54.872
it, I guess, you know. Right, right. No, no, that, that, that is certainly true.
18:55.016 --> 18:58.479
And, you know, I think of, you know, in, in Europe, uh,
18:58.719 --> 19:02.294
in France, well, across Europe now, you know, people burning down
19:02.342 --> 19:06.015
stores and so on. And we saw this certainly in the United
19:06.515 --> 19:09.870
States more than once. And then, well, where do you think
19:09.934 --> 19:14.255
food comes from? Or, you know, you loot and plunder stores,
19:14.913 --> 19:18.286
and, you know, and we don't enforce, you know, laws for
19:18.786 --> 19:21.948
theft, for example. And then the store goes out of business and leaves,
19:21.997 --> 19:25.787
and people are indignant and astounded and attribute
19:25.932 --> 19:29.032
wicked intent and attribute it to racism and so on.
19:29.851 --> 19:33.446
Is it fair to say that there's a not just a lack of moral maturity,
19:33.479 --> 19:36.881
but a lack of moral imagination. I mean, when you're 2,
19:37.089 --> 19:40.154
you don't think that your cons— your actions have consequences.
19:40.684 --> 19:43.749
But once, once you're an adult, you should have that figured out.
19:44.070 --> 19:47.825
Is there a larger moral failure that has been taking place
19:48.325 --> 19:51.179
in our culture that gets us to the point where so many people think you
19:51.211 --> 19:54.549
can just burn and loot and cry and nothing
19:54.661 --> 19:57.887
bad happens? I don't know if it's a moral failure exactly.
19:57.935 --> 20:01.289
I mean, it might be, but the way I would put it is, um,
20:01.706 --> 20:04.818
It's, I mean, it's certainly very detached from reality.
20:05.396 --> 20:08.685
And I think that, I think they're focusing their anger
20:08.845 --> 20:13.000
on the wrong things. I mean, they may, they may have some reason
20:13.096 --> 20:15.535
to be angry, right? I, I can understand. Sure.
20:16.080 --> 20:19.224
Yeah. Yeah. Like, you know, like in France, um,
20:19.529 --> 20:22.866
I, you know, I don't know it very well exactly their situation,
20:22.978 --> 20:26.411
but yeah, their economies are stagnant and young people, you know,
20:26.828 --> 20:30.357
are having a harder time just buying a home or getting jobs. And,
20:30.982 --> 20:34.093
um, there's— and people can see that there's also wealth inequality,
20:34.125 --> 20:37.076
and, you know, that breeds resentment.
20:37.236 --> 20:40.797
Um, and but they think that the answer is that, okay, the government should take
20:40.845 --> 20:44.469
away from the rich people and give to the poor, like redistribute essentially, you know.
20:44.790 --> 20:48.125
And they don't understand that, like, maybe they're focusing their anger,
20:48.558 --> 20:51.974
like, on the wrong place when they think that the productive people are the ones
20:52.006 --> 20:55.422
who should be penalized, right? And that we just take from them.
20:56.079 --> 21:00.105
And they don't see how, you know, for example, like governments are very corrupt
21:00.605 --> 21:03.586
and they take so much tax money, but they're like wasting a lot of it,
21:03.634 --> 21:08.045
you know, like France is one of the highest taxed nations in
21:08.545 --> 21:11.541
Europe. And yet, like, they're one of the worst off. So they should be asking
21:11.637 --> 21:15.262
questions, right? Like, why is this not working, this model, you know, this essentially
21:15.762 --> 21:19.096
socialist, very similar to socialism. So I think that
21:19.596 --> 21:22.961
they are just focusing their anger on the wrong place is the way I
21:23.461 --> 21:26.379
see it. I think back to a friend of mine who's got a teenage daughter
21:26.879 --> 21:29.910
who's been working all through high school. She's graduated from high school and she's working
21:29.926 --> 21:33.312
at this job that she enjoys very much and took her to an accountant who
21:33.812 --> 21:37.244
told her, said, hey, you know, your employer isn't taking out withholding taxes, so,
21:37.389 --> 21:40.101
you know, we've got to calculate your taxes now so you don't pay a penalty.
21:40.919 --> 21:44.530
And as this young lady started to see the numbers of what she
21:44.691 --> 21:48.462
owed the government, and she said, you know how many shifts
21:48.962 --> 21:52.536
I have to work to pay for that? You know, where is this
21:52.664 --> 21:55.775
money going? Why am I not getting any of this money?
21:56.336 --> 21:58.725
And the mother just stood behind and said, well, that's how you end up with
21:59.225 --> 22:03.070
libertarians, when you begin to figure out all this money is going out
22:03.570 --> 22:07.014
of my wallet and I have no idea where it's going. So it seems to
22:07.514 --> 22:11.616
me that we have gotten used to the idea that there will always
22:11.809 --> 22:15.737
be surplus, and we have no idea where substance
22:16.237 --> 22:19.713
and surplus comes from. And sadly, in talking with a lot of
22:20.387 --> 22:24.364
what I call professional Christians, or the business of churchianity,
22:24.941 --> 22:29.126
the only Christian response to physical human need is more free
22:29.626 --> 22:35.043
stuff for everyone to infinity, which we know mathematically is impossible.
22:35.524 --> 22:39.341
Is it fair to say that whatever we need to have intelligent
22:39.373 --> 22:43.013
conversations about public policy that don't end up
22:43.077 --> 22:46.604
in violence, we've lost a lot of that? Is that fair to say?
22:47.549 --> 22:50.834
Well, I mean, yes, I think if people are resorting to violence,
22:50.850 --> 22:54.632
I mean, they're not really wanting a
22:55.132 --> 22:59.103
nuanced conversation or maybe even any kind of conversation. Yeah. And it
22:59.603 --> 23:03.190
seems to me that when we have that breakdown of conversation,
23:03.254 --> 23:06.202
you know, there's an old slogan in American politics that,
23:07.260 --> 23:10.609
you know, when the ballot box doesn't work, you go to the jury box.
23:10.690 --> 23:13.590
The jury box doesn't work, then
you go to the bullet box.
23:14.251 --> 23:17.490
And I think a lot of people are skipping the first 2 steps.
23:18.310 --> 23:21.737
I certainly see that in Europe. I see that in the United States as well,
23:23.770 --> 23:28.048
that grievance becomes a form of entitlement,
23:28.629 --> 23:31.180
and that the rule of law, the sanctity of life,
23:31.632 --> 23:35.175
private property are just not relevant because
23:35.435 --> 23:39.378
I am in the midst of my collective tantrum,
23:40.211 --> 23:44.299
and sadly, that kind of public
23:44.315 --> 23:47.825
polity is easily manipulated
23:48.562 --> 23:52.490
by tyranny, by propaganda, and can be brought
23:52.554 --> 23:56.657
to a very bad end. And history shows that once
23:57.157 --> 24:00.632
the class of useful idiots has outlived its use, they come to
24:00.745 --> 24:04.351
a very bad end. Friends, when we come back, we're going to continue our conversation
24:04.415 --> 24:08.028
with Dr. Jumi Kim. We are talking about Western self-contempt.
24:08.590 --> 24:11.801
Uh, why is it? What is it? And what can we do about
24:12.301 --> 24:15.575
it? After the broadcast today, go to thestationofthecross.com, get our
24:16.075 --> 24:19.364
resources list, download our audio podcast. Wherever you can find audio,
24:19.846 --> 24:23.314
you can find us. Follow us on your favorite platform, write a 5-star review.
24:23.780 --> 24:27.938
We need to attract the attention of the listeners so these conversations get the attention
24:28.438 --> 24:31.150
they deserve. Everything you need to take us to your family and friends. We give
24:31.650 --> 24:34.746
to you together. Let's take it around the world. We can do it with you.
24:34.939 --> 24:37.974
We cannot do it without you. Let's do this good work together.
24:38.472 --> 24:41.747
Let's strive to be more than merely relevant. Back in just
24:42.247 --> 24:43.096
2 minutes. Please do stay with us.
25:02.222 --> 25:06.593
This is The Catholic Current from the Station of the Cross Catholic Media Network.
25:06.737 --> 25:10.016
Catch up on an episode you've missed or share them with your family
25:10.516 --> 25:14.269
and friends. The Catholic Current is podcasted wherever you enjoy listening:
25:14.607 --> 25:18.152
Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Podbean, TuneIn, and the
25:18.554 --> 25:20.009
iCatholic Radio mobile app.
25:22.040 --> 25:25.334
Praise be Jesus Christ. This is Father Robert McTeague of the Society of Jesus,
25:25.383 --> 25:28.550
your daily host for The Catholic the Current, where we bring Christ to the world
25:29.050 --> 25:31.131
and the world to Christ. You're listening to us from the Station of the Cross
25:31.631 --> 25:34.802
studios, your local radio station, and the iCatholic Radio mobile app.
25:34.962 --> 25:38.104
We proclaim the fullness of truth with clarity and charity.
25:38.569 --> 25:43.650
Hey friends, if you value thoughtful Catholic analysis, help sustain this work at thestationofthecross.com.
25:44.115 --> 25:47.529
Here in the Catholic Current, we engage issues seriously and faithfully,
25:48.042 --> 25:51.505
and that intellectual freedom exists because we are listener-funded.
25:51.970 --> 25:55.881
Support us at thestationofthecross.com. My topic
25:56.381 --> 26:00.465
today is this Western self-contempt. What is it and why is it? And now
26:00.965 --> 26:03.766
we're going to talk about what we can do about it. My guest is Dr.
26:03.830 --> 26:06.938
Jumi Kim, and you can find her good work at the Substack
26:07.355 --> 26:10.880
called Let's Be Clear. We're going to link to her work in the show notes.
26:11.665 --> 26:14.998
Dr. Kim, in Roger Scruton's essay from back
26:15.046 --> 26:18.779
to 1993, he talks about oikophobia, that Western
26:18.812 --> 26:22.737
self-loathing, and he says that these are diseases that
26:23.237 --> 26:27.067
are created by thought and can be cured by thought. And he makes a reference
26:27.567 --> 26:31.082
to traditional education, philosophy, literary criticism,
26:31.628 --> 26:35.996
and history. Now, he wrote this back in 1993.
26:36.462 --> 26:40.140
Maybe things were more sanguine all those years ago,
26:40.798 --> 26:43.256
but it seems to me to be a kind of wishful thinking. I know in
26:43.288 --> 26:46.789
academia right now, philosophy is
26:47.142 --> 26:51.463
Marxism and literary criticism is Marxism and
26:51.543 --> 26:54.851
history is Marxism. So I think we need
26:55.351 --> 26:58.752
to be cautious about the tools we recommend. So for the people who
26:58.768 --> 27:02.767
are listening to us and say, gosh, this Western self-loathing,
27:03.184 --> 27:06.395
it's out of hand, it's not right, how can
27:06.895 --> 27:10.072
I boost my intellectual immune system and teach others
27:10.169 --> 27:13.830
to do the same? What would you recommend then? Yeah, I mean,
27:14.038 --> 27:17.571
just to comment on what you said about, you know, academia, I do think
27:18.071 --> 27:21.665
that unfortunately, most of academia is promoting the eco-phobia
27:21.745 --> 27:25.085
itself, right? Yeah, I mean, not all, but quite a lot of
27:25.101 --> 27:28.906
it, unfortunately, in the humanities especially. Um, but there
27:29.115 --> 27:33.113
are all kinds of resources. I mean, not just podcasts like yours
27:33.209 --> 27:36.324
or YouTube videos or books, you know, like the ones
27:36.501 --> 27:39.744
that I just mentioned, like Benedict Beckwith's books.
27:40.354 --> 27:44.095
Um, I mean, these are all useful, obviously, um, but I
27:44.224 --> 27:47.387
think that change will only come about
27:47.419 --> 27:50.935
when enough people, you know, start conversations.
27:51.353 --> 27:54.660
You know, they can start small, but they start conversations about this and they're
27:55.160 --> 27:58.706
not afraid to talk about certain taboo topics like this.
27:58.995 --> 28:02.865
You know, I think that's, that's what the everyday person can do,
28:03.074 --> 28:06.365
right? Not everyone can, you
know, have a podcast or a
28:06.865 --> 28:10.138
YouTube channel or write a book, you know. Right. But once you're
28:10.638 --> 28:13.411
aware of these things, it's just if you just push back a little in your
28:13.507 --> 28:16.780
everyday conversations, if it comes up, you know, I think that's one thing
28:16.812 --> 28:20.326
that an everyday person can do, right? It seems to me that one of the
28:20.826 --> 28:25.300
reasons why I, I started this work was because I wanted to restart
28:25.800 --> 28:29.215
the lost art of intelligent conversation, and that the
28:29.311 --> 28:33.017
work is succeeding if people talk to each
28:33.517 --> 28:37.157
other about it. And I think one part of the conversation is
28:37.253 --> 28:40.492
for people to say, hey, I think we're being lied to,
28:41.181 --> 28:44.836
and we're being lied to by people who don't wish us well.
28:45.702 --> 28:49.742
So we need to be critical consumers of
28:49.774 --> 28:52.980
the news, of the culture, and so on. And I know
28:53.480 --> 28:56.780
that part of your work, uh, you have a book club, and I always
28:56.812 --> 29:00.034
think book clubs are a really great idea. Can you tell
29:00.534 --> 29:03.865
us some about how that, that idea came to you and what it's been like
29:04.365 --> 29:07.199
to you to run that book club? What has been the response? Well,
29:07.328 --> 29:10.438
part of the reason I started the book club is that I wanted to be
29:10.938 --> 29:14.974
able to talk about books, but so many book clubs are very much dominated
29:15.022 --> 29:18.405
by, um, you know, people who have this
29:18.905 --> 29:22.604
kind of oikophobia, very, quote, liberal kind of a mindset,
29:22.797 --> 29:26.243
and very, you know, woke and all these things. And, and a
29:26.743 --> 29:30.251
lot of contemporary novels are also just, you know, very much dominated by that
29:30.751 --> 29:33.361
kind of thinking. But, um, I knew there were people out there who were like
29:33.861 --> 29:37.336
me who didn't like that and also just wanted to talk freely about novels.
29:37.448 --> 29:41.360
And, and that's why I started it. And so, you know, I've attracted
29:41.392 --> 29:44.887
people who are, who also are interested
29:44.999 --> 29:48.157
in the same things as I am, being able to talk about books and not
29:48.205 --> 29:51.347
having to tiptoe around certain issues, right? Um,
29:51.492 --> 29:55.066
being able to talk freely about it. So it's been really refreshing. And,
29:55.179 --> 29:58.545
and the people are out there, you know, the ones who, who want
29:59.045 --> 30:02.297
to be able to talk about these issues and not tiptoe around it. Well,
30:02.458 --> 30:06.249
I found that in this series that I've been doing on my Friday podcast called
30:06.749 --> 30:10.795
Novel Prophecies, and I started with what I call dystopian
30:10.827 --> 30:15.019
literature going all the way back to— it was 1904— G.K.
30:15.083 --> 30:18.778
Chesterton, The Napoleon of
Notting Hill. And I'm trying to work my way up
30:19.278 --> 30:23.372
to the present. We're on the verge of reading 1984 next.
30:23.757 --> 30:27.291
As I know, as in my own background in philosophy and theology, and I
30:27.791 --> 30:30.817
had an really excellent education but didn't really spend
30:31.317 --> 30:34.630
the time with literature that I wanted. And I said, hey, this is my platform,
30:35.367 --> 30:39.470
I, I can do what I want. And it— there seems to be a hunger,
30:39.854 --> 30:43.043
a responsiveness to that, that people
30:43.059 --> 30:46.344
haven't had the experience of being walked through a book
30:46.760 --> 30:50.638
intelligently. And it's been, it's been good for me
30:50.686 --> 30:56.022
too because it's been getting me to use aspects of, of my intelligence
30:56.522 --> 31:00.502
that were neglected in my studies. Now, you know, your background is in molecular
31:00.630 --> 31:04.369
biology. What has it been like for you trained in the empirical sciences to
31:04.401 --> 31:07.771
begin to spend time with novels and literature? Oh, well, that's an
31:08.271 --> 31:11.477
interesting question. I think in science, you know,
31:12.488 --> 31:17.013
you use empiricism, so you use evidence to
31:17.462 --> 31:20.912
analyze anything. And I think people often don't do that when
31:21.412 --> 31:24.841
it comes to literature or anything related to the
31:24.857 --> 31:28.241
arts, they don't always rely on what's actually there,
31:28.465 --> 31:32.233
for example, in the text. And people will just kind of say
31:32.733 --> 31:36.065
willy-nilly based on vibes. They'll say that this book
31:36.565 --> 31:39.528
is, you know, like their interpretation is a certain way, and they'll just kind of
31:40.028 --> 31:43.440
ignore some of the things in the text. That is something that I've found again
31:43.940 --> 31:47.786
and again, which is interesting. And I've, you know, in my
31:48.286 --> 31:51.713
training as a philosopher and a theologian, I mean, I can analyze a
31:52.213 --> 31:55.623
text to the most profound, like, you know, at this, to the subatomic
31:56.123 --> 31:58.972
level. Like, I can squeeze meaning out of a semicolon.
31:59.789 --> 32:03.138
And I know that literature isn't like that. My sister started
32:03.154 --> 32:06.438
her art career in, in comic books and graphic novels and
32:06.455 --> 32:09.627
so on. And when we were kids, she would yell at me that I was
32:09.659 --> 32:12.944
reading the comic book wrong because I was only reading the words, not looking at
32:13.444 --> 32:16.854
the picture. And so one can read literature that way,
32:16.870 --> 32:20.269
that one can look at the words the page and not enter into
32:21.119 --> 32:24.889
the life of the story. So when I taught rhetoric, I would have students
32:25.389 --> 32:28.884
begin each class by reciting a poem, and they railed
32:29.384 --> 32:32.574
against it at first because they had never been taught to do that. And I
32:33.074 --> 32:37.162
explained to them, you have to be able to enjoy how the words taste
32:37.662 --> 32:41.557
in your mouth. You have to be able to enter into the story to be
32:41.638 --> 32:44.493
able to lead people into the story yourself.
32:44.557 --> 32:48.627
And and then come out of the story with your life changed.
32:49.044 --> 32:52.360
Is it fair to say that part of what you're doing with the discussion of
32:52.456 --> 32:55.821
literature is you don't want people to merely be
32:55.917 --> 32:59.522
entertained? You're not reading novels together
33:00.022 --> 33:03.351
just so you don't all doomscroll separately. There's,
33:03.447 --> 33:07.517
there's a transformation that's, that's desired. Can, can you
33:08.017 --> 33:11.362
speak to that, please? How would you know, for example, that, that the
33:11.378 --> 33:14.312
book club was successful or that it was was working?
33:14.408 --> 33:17.745
What's the desired outcome that you're seeking? Well, for one
33:17.858 --> 33:21.099
thing, I think it's fine if some books are just for entertainment,
33:21.147 --> 33:24.308
you know. It's not— sure, of course. Yeah, yeah. But, um,
33:24.757 --> 33:28.464
but I think that there is another level
33:28.528 --> 33:32.058
of literature that is more what you speak
33:32.558 --> 33:36.582
of, that is either more transformative or that deal with issues
33:36.647 --> 33:40.257
that are like really big, you know, whether it's, um, having to do
33:40.757 --> 33:44.062
with good versus evil, these like bigger themes, much more ambitious.
33:45.379 --> 33:48.897
And it's something that sometimes I think contemporary novels
33:49.555 --> 33:52.880
shy away from that more. They tend to focus on more sort
33:53.380 --> 33:57.346
of miniature themes for whatever reason. Maybe it's
33:57.846 --> 34:00.960
just these bigger themes, they're too much for
34:01.460 --> 34:05.040
people. But I think that a lot of our writers tend
34:05.136 --> 34:09.005
to shy away from that, like these social novels,
34:09.021 --> 34:12.085
you know, that really grapple with like important
34:12.453 --> 34:15.934
things about human life these days. And that, that to me
34:15.982 --> 34:19.815
is, is very sad. It's not that they're not out there, but it's,
34:19.911 --> 34:23.055
it's hard to, to find actually good ones like that,
34:23.264 --> 34:26.535
you know. I know you had a series of
34:26.664 --> 34:31.187
videos criticizing a lot of contemporary
34:31.764 --> 34:34.795
fiction. Can you, can you address those?
34:34.972 --> 34:38.940
There are some trends that are really just delirious and, and tedious.
34:39.440 --> 34:41.820
Can, can you address that, please? Yeah, well, one of the, the big things is
34:42.320 --> 34:46.070
just how so much of it is dominated by sort of woke themes,
34:46.140 --> 34:50.040
um, and the authors are just preoccupied with
34:50.540 --> 34:53.900
this, you know, like just what we were talking about before, this sort of victim
34:54.400 --> 34:58.040
mentality. And they think that this is like the issue of our time, and I
34:58.540 --> 35:00.880
just, I mean, I just completely disagree with that, you know. I think that they're
35:01.380 --> 35:04.240
fooled into thinking that's the issue of our time, and they're ignoring sort of bigger,
35:04.740 --> 35:08.370
more important things. And but this separate point that I was just making was is
35:08.402 --> 35:11.816
just that I think there's also a tendency where writers will
35:13.274 --> 35:16.865
focus on very small minutiae and writing
35:16.961 --> 35:20.743
it very prettily, where they focus
35:21.243 --> 35:24.318
a lot of that when they go do an MFA, which is a Master of
35:24.334 --> 35:28.437
Fine Arts in writing, in creative writing. And that's— they
35:28.937 --> 35:32.219
put a lot of focus on that as opposed to becoming the type
35:32.719 --> 35:36.691
of person who can see things in a unique way, in an interesting way.
35:37.333 --> 35:40.925
And therefore have something to say in the first place, you know. Right. A lot
35:41.425 --> 35:43.524
of people, if you just go to school for writing, that's not going to make
35:44.024 --> 35:47.406
you into a more interesting person. Sure. It's just more about learning
35:47.678 --> 35:50.822
the craft, you know. So, yeah.
35:51.047 --> 35:54.623
And the craft comes, I think, especially from reading
35:54.816 --> 35:58.313
good writers. I've worked with a couple of young writers,
35:58.345 --> 36:01.745
and you could always tell, you know, when they've bought their first thesaurus,
36:02.355 --> 36:06.029
because you get you get
36:06.529 --> 36:10.348
a lot of words from the more exotic parts of the English vocabulary,
36:10.781 --> 36:14.362
and that can be kind of a distraction. But it seems
36:14.394 --> 36:17.734
to me that a lot of contemporary literature is,
36:18.569 --> 36:22.198
here are all the people I don't like, everyone I dislike
36:22.487 --> 36:25.200
is Hitler, here are my grievances,
36:25.297 --> 36:28.733
here's a list of the things that make me sad, now please
36:28.829 --> 36:32.264
applaud me and give me money. In fame.
36:32.857 --> 36:36.755
Why does that— who is the audience for that? And does that really
36:36.787 --> 36:40.155
sell? I mean, there is an audience for it, you know.
36:40.861 --> 36:44.647
Yeah. And a lot of those win the, you know, National Book Award
36:45.147 --> 36:48.496
or all these others. Like, if you were to actually go look at a
36:48.996 --> 36:52.090
lot of the bestsellers or the ones winning a lot
36:52.590 --> 36:55.651
of the literary prizes, I mean, they're all in a certain kind of bubble,
36:56.116 --> 36:59.388
you know, and they are sort of reading each other. Um, I mean, I'm not
36:59.500 --> 37:02.901
saying that all those literary works are like selling like Harry
37:02.934 --> 37:06.222
Potter or anything like that, right? I mean, I do think there is an audience,
37:06.383 --> 37:09.158
you know, and to some extent the publishers,
37:09.431 --> 37:12.960
they're definitely in that bubble. And they're, um,
37:13.586 --> 37:16.859
I, I don't know, I think that they think that that's what they need to
37:16.955 --> 37:20.212
keep selling. Um, and I don't think they realize that there
37:20.564 --> 37:24.190
is an audience out there for something drastically different or anti-woke,
37:24.254 --> 37:27.639
for example. Right, right. I think we're
37:27.864 --> 37:30.972
at a point now where— because I know there's been a lot of discussion about
37:31.100 --> 37:35.335
why male authors are not contributing to
37:35.367 --> 37:38.830
publication or they're self-publishing because they can't get
37:39.330 --> 37:43.482
a hearing because they're male. And then even more so if they're
37:43.578 --> 37:47.564
white males and white heterosexual males and Christian as well. There seems
37:47.580 --> 37:51.020
to be not a lot of welcome there with the major publishing
37:51.117 --> 37:53.739
houses. And there also seems to be,
37:54.030 --> 37:57.079
again, the grievance industry. I mean,
37:57.096 --> 38:00.308
it's a very easy formula to follow,
38:00.870 --> 38:04.115
and it's been notorious in science fiction and fantasy literature
38:04.500 --> 38:07.777
and so on. And it seems to me that, you know, we could
38:07.793 --> 38:11.005
be turning to the great books that have stood the test
38:11.505 --> 38:14.828
of time because they actually happen to be part of our heritage,
38:15.342 --> 38:18.860
and they happen to be a part of a Western civilization that
38:19.360 --> 38:22.679
we really can be be proud of. And I
38:23.192 --> 38:26.865
think somehow that's been lost. And one of the reasons I appreciate your work is
38:26.881 --> 38:30.313
that you're telling us we don't have to receive without question
38:30.746 --> 38:34.098
or uncritically some of the dreck that's coming our way,
38:34.114 --> 38:38.171
because we can actually identify the dreck as
38:38.684 --> 38:42.052
dreck. So we're going to leave it there. Dr. Jumi Kim, thank you for a
38:42.552 --> 38:45.628
fascinating conversation. I will continue to follow your work,
38:45.660 --> 38:48.887
and I hope we can talk again before long. Thank you so much. I had
38:49.387 --> 38:52.243
a wonderful time. I'm Jesuit Father Robert McTeigue, your host every day of The Catholic
38:52.743 --> 38:55.069
Current. You want to stay with us for the rest of the hour? Coming up
38:55.117 --> 38:58.618
next, Timely Thoughts. You and me reflecting on what we've heard today,
38:58.810 --> 39:02.487
and believe me, I do have a lot to say. Be part of the conversation.
39:02.584 --> 39:05.410
Follow what we're following by following us on Gab.
39:05.731 --> 39:09.087
That's gab.com. The channel is The Catholic Current,
39:09.424 --> 39:12.705
and you can influence the conversation. You can contact us
39:13.205 --> 39:13.556
at thestationofthecross.com/askfather.
39:16.880 --> 39:20.751
Comments, questions,
suggestions, recommendations— we want
39:21.251 --> 39:25.154
to hear from you. That's thestationofthecross.com/askfather.
39:25.748 --> 39:29.133
Let's do this good work together. Let's take this to your family and friends.
39:29.198 --> 39:32.442
Together we'll take it around the world. Let's strive to be ever so
39:32.942 --> 39:36.101
much more than merely relevant. We'll be back in just
39:36.601 --> 39:37.692
2 minutes. Please do stay Stay with us.
40:02.645 --> 40:05.910
Have a question or feedback about today's episode?
40:06.217 --> 40:10.653
Want to suggest suggest a guest or a future topic, go to thestationofthecross.com/askfather
40:14.413 --> 40:16.529
and help influence the conversation.
40:22.670 --> 40:25.897
Praise be Jesus Christ. This is Father Robert McTeague of the Society of Jesus,
40:25.929 --> 40:28.898
your daily host for The Catholic Current, where we bring Christ to the world and
40:29.398 --> 40:32.351
the world to Christ. You're listening to us from the Station of the Cross studios
40:32.851 --> 40:36.313
your local radio station and the iCatholic Radio mobile app. We proclaim the fullness
40:36.442 --> 40:40.054
of truth with clarity and charity. Here we are, the last segment
40:40.554 --> 40:44.389
of a Timely Tuesday. You know what that means— you and me sharing timely
40:44.889 --> 40:48.483
thoughts, reflecting what we've heard today. My new guest was Dr.
40:48.627 --> 40:53.123
Jumi Kim, and we were talking about Western self-contempt
40:53.187 --> 40:56.462
and why that is. And as I'm
40:56.558 --> 41:00.216
recording this, it is Election Day here in the United States,
41:00.488 --> 41:04.157
and a lot of our listeners are in New York State, and you should know
41:04.173 --> 41:07.569
that in Westchester County, where there's a hotly contested,
41:08.210 --> 41:10.597
very close congressional race,
41:11.142 --> 41:15.276
surprise! The machine that counts ballots has broken down.
41:16.109 --> 41:19.473
Gosh, Gloriosky, whatever are we to
41:19.973 --> 41:23.751
do? Well, don't worry. The New York Attorney General Letitia
41:23.815 --> 41:26.555
James says that her office is aware of the situation,
41:27.019 --> 41:30.593
so I'm sure we're all going going to live happily
41:31.490 --> 41:35.160
ever after. Uh, so what about this,
41:36.378 --> 41:39.967
this cultural push for the West to
41:40.159 --> 41:44.021
hate itself, for former Christendom to blame itself
41:44.150 --> 41:47.387
for everything? Well, I'm gonna, uh,
41:48.396 --> 41:51.793
I, I have an alternative, I'll put it that way. One type
41:52.293 --> 41:55.385
of person I admire very much is a
41:55.546 --> 41:59.062
strong woman of letters, and I think the
41:59.142 --> 42:03.461
only thing better than a strong woman of letters is 2 strong women
42:03.558 --> 42:06.817
of letters. So I'm going to draw upon 2 right now. Uh,
42:07.122 --> 42:10.478
the first is, uh, Flannery O'Connor,
42:11.200 --> 42:14.636
who's definitely a strong woman of letters, a mulier fortis, as we would say
42:14.652 --> 42:17.847
in Latin. And she said this: push
42:18.185 --> 42:21.685
back against the age. As hard as
42:21.797 --> 42:25.602
it pushes against you. To which I would say,
42:26.453 --> 42:30.114
amen. We're being lied to, we're being
42:30.548 --> 42:34.289
lied about, and we're being misled
42:34.546 --> 42:38.543
and misdirected, and people are trying to sell us self-loathing
42:38.800 --> 42:41.963
as virtue. And I want to say, no,
42:42.333 --> 42:45.367
that's not okay. We in the West,
42:45.945 --> 42:50.135
and I'm gonna say it, we of European descent,
42:50.761 --> 42:54.757
and we Christians have a whole lot
42:54.789 --> 42:57.582
to be proud of. Yes, yes, we're all sinners, etc.,
42:57.662 --> 43:00.936
etc. You don't have to tell an Irish Catholic about sin.
43:01.915 --> 43:05.430
Now, there is a softer version of denigrating
43:05.943 --> 43:09.554
Christendom, and that's Tolerance with a capital T,
43:10.116 --> 43:13.775
which brings me to the other strong
43:14.433 --> 43:16.985
woman of letters Dorothy Sayers.
43:17.965 --> 43:21.192
You may know her from her— she was part
43:21.692 --> 43:24.805
of the Golden Age of detective fiction in the '20s and '30s.
43:25.431 --> 43:28.851
She got very much involved in classical education in
43:29.140 --> 43:32.849
the '40s. She was a near occasion of Catholic.
43:32.898 --> 43:35.724
I think she described herself as an Anglo-Catholic.
43:36.285 --> 43:39.818
She has a really interesting essay that is very influential in
43:40.318 --> 43:43.721
classical education about recovering the classical tools of learning.
43:43.818 --> 43:47.577
She is worth reading. But she says this: in
43:47.770 --> 43:51.561
the world it is called tolerance,
43:52.108 --> 43:55.015
but in hell it is called despair.
43:55.867 --> 43:59.867
The sin that believes in nothing,
44:00.622 --> 44:04.141
cares for nothing. So I would say
44:04.157 --> 44:07.627
there are things worth living and dying for.
44:08.317 --> 44:12.025
There are things that we know to be true. There are
44:12.525 --> 44:15.876
things we know to be good. There are things we know to be evil about
44:16.376 --> 44:19.712
which honorable people may not disagree.
44:20.274 --> 44:24.238
So, men are men and women are women, and that
44:24.738 --> 44:28.347
is not interchangeable. Marriage is between one man and one
44:28.459 --> 44:32.728
woman for life and may not be redefined out
44:33.228 --> 44:36.697
of existence. Don't kill your children.
44:38.020 --> 44:41.021
I think we should be able to agree on that.
44:41.957 --> 44:45.585
I'm trying to make a discernment about some other things I want to say,
44:45.601 --> 44:48.742
but my guardian angel is telling me we'll lose our broadcast license,
44:49.305 --> 44:53.082
so I'm gonna bite my tongue for the moment. Truth really
44:53.115 --> 44:56.910
matters because truth isn't an idea or a concept
44:57.135 --> 45:00.239
or an abstraction.
Truth is a person.
45:00.869 --> 45:04.223
It's Christ our Lord who said, I am the way, the truth, and the
45:04.288 --> 45:07.722
life. And the good Catholic philosophers will tell you that,
45:07.899 --> 45:11.703
uh, truth and beauty and goodness are very strongly interrelated.
45:12.168 --> 45:15.683
And one of the reasons why Christendom worked for so long— yes,
45:15.779 --> 45:19.278
I know there were sinners— but one of the reasons it worked for so long
45:19.326 --> 45:22.970
and produced such great art and so many saints was because
45:23.082 --> 45:26.067
it was rooted in the cornerstone of Christ, who is the way,
45:26.212 --> 45:29.586
the truth, and the life, who is himself truth, beauty,
45:29.731 --> 45:34.053
and goodness. And at least since 1789,
45:34.149 --> 45:37.491
the French Revolution, and then you got Darwin,
45:37.603 --> 45:40.913
and then you got Marx, and all the mischief that followed
45:41.413 --> 45:45.155
after that, you ended up not only with a lot of bad
45:45.655 --> 45:49.862
art, but mounds and mounds and mounds of
45:49.911 --> 45:53.975
dead bodies. And now the craziness
45:54.954 --> 45:59.065
of somehow we can live not only with contempt
45:59.565 --> 46:03.609
for the West, but with the distancing of ourselves from
46:03.721 --> 46:07.607
Christ, that we can all live happily ever after
46:08.040 --> 46:11.669
in a secularist society, and somehow that's
46:12.169 --> 46:15.587
going to have the resources for standing against Sharia
46:15.603 --> 46:19.184
law. That fantasy is not being
46:19.441 --> 46:23.121
readily disabused by the senior Catholic cadres
46:23.474 --> 46:26.382
of the people who should really know better club,
46:27.475 --> 46:31.106
some of whom wear clerical garb that are shades that I
46:31.606 --> 46:35.155
don't wear, who wear hats taller than mine,
46:35.846 --> 46:39.429
and they say foolish things like, you know, they're looking forward to ordaining women,
46:39.526 --> 46:42.980
they're looking forward to ordaining married men, uh, there's no reason
46:43.480 --> 46:47.347
to proselytize, We don't have to evangelize. We're not here to make converts.
46:47.732 --> 46:51.022
We should just get along fraternally because you don't want anyone to think that we
46:51.522 --> 46:54.906
believe that one religion is better than another. These are people who
46:55.034 --> 46:58.436
are not helping. And yes,
46:58.485 --> 47:02.384
I'm gonna do it. I have to make a reference to the Three Stooges again.
47:03.283 --> 47:07.119
That episode where they're on a boat and the
47:07.215 --> 47:11.050
captain of the boat sees that the ship is sinking And
47:11.082 --> 47:15.060
he goes into the bottom of the boat and there are the Three Stooges drilling
47:15.172 --> 47:18.748
holes in the bottom of the boat. And he says, well, what are you doing?
47:19.502 --> 47:22.789
And they says, oh, we're using— there's water coming into the boat, so we're
47:22.853 --> 47:26.333
using our water letter outers to let the water out of
47:26.381 --> 47:30.086
the boat, out of the sinking ship. People who ask
47:30.586 --> 47:34.415
the West to hate itself, that somehow if we're only more
47:34.915 --> 47:38.667
tolerant of everybody but ourselves, if only we
47:38.828 --> 47:41.895
are more welcoming of everybody but Christ,
47:42.746 --> 47:46.391
then things will be better, people will like us more,
47:47.001 --> 47:50.727
and we'll all live happily ever after.
47:51.530 --> 47:56.588
And those people are either lying or they are delusional,
47:57.439 --> 48:01.052
and I can't be silent about it, and neither should you. And friends, one of
48:01.552 --> 48:05.131
the reasons I, this raging introvert who wants to be in her corner
48:05.163 --> 48:08.745
in a chapel with a fountain pen and a notebook and just writing
48:09.324 --> 48:13.082
notes and putting them into bottles and throwing them into the tides of time.
48:13.500 --> 48:16.455
One of the reasons why I show up to a microphone every day— and God
48:16.487 --> 48:20.631
help us, even a camera every now and again— is I don't
48:20.663 --> 48:25.129
want to be silent. It's real enduring civilization
48:25.225 --> 48:29.064
worthy of the name is Christian civilization,
48:29.642 --> 48:33.091
and we need to pray and worship and vote and
48:33.251 --> 48:36.922
raise our children and act as individuals,
48:37.339 --> 48:41.523
families, communities, and even nations in light
48:41.908 --> 48:45.258
of that saving truth.
48:46.156 --> 48:49.394
So no more contempt for the West.
48:49.859 --> 48:53.274
No more negotiating away Christendom.
48:53.883 --> 48:57.235
It's time to stop drilling holes in the bottom of the
48:57.735 --> 49:01.105
boat. I'm Jesuit Father Robert McTeague, your host here every day of The Catholic Current.
49:01.153 --> 49:04.397
Join us tomorrow for another round of The Catholic Current. Great guests,
49:04.445 --> 49:07.624
great topic, great conversation, because that's how we roll here
49:07.897 --> 49:11.445
every day at The Catholic Current and here at The Station of the
49:11.945 --> 49:15.106
Cross. After the broadcast today, go to thestationofthecross.com,
49:15.122 --> 49:18.237
get our resources list, download our audios, podcasts.
49:18.334 --> 49:22.027
Wherever you can find audio, you can find us. Everything you need to take
49:22.527 --> 49:25.254
this to your family and friends. We give to you together. Let's take it around
49:25.754 --> 49:29.027
the world. We can do it with you. We cannot do without you. Let's do
49:29.527 --> 49:32.945
this good work together. Let's work really hard to be very much
49:32.961 --> 49:36.494
more than merely relevant. Through the intercession of
49:36.994 --> 49:40.428
Our Lady of Mount Carmel, may Almighty God bless you, Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.
49:40.733 --> 49:44.169
Go in peace, and please do pray for me, for I am a sinner.