رونوشت 🔗
WEBVTT
NOTE
This file was generated by Descript
00:00:00.019 --> 00:00:06.215
Alex Hill: High performance is just
high stress and the reason why is if
00:00:06.215 --> 00:00:09.815
you get it right, it has an impact, and
if you get it wrong, it has an impact,
00:00:09.815 --> 00:00:11.585
and you start to feel that pressure.
00:00:11.676 --> 00:00:15.096
and that pressure does
weird things to the brain.
00:00:16.593 --> 00:00:19.853
Ralph Grayson: Welcome to The Boardroom
Path by Sainty Hird & Partners.
00:00:20.197 --> 00:00:24.087
I'm your host, Ralph Grayson, a
partner in the board practice.
00:00:24.456 --> 00:00:29.016
In this series, we'll offer practical
steps and useful perspectives for
00:00:29.016 --> 00:00:31.356
aspiring and newly appointed NEDs.
00:00:32.391 --> 00:00:37.011
My guest today is Professor Alex Hill,
one of the most distinctive voices on
00:00:37.011 --> 00:00:39.111
long-term organisational performance.
00:00:39.711 --> 00:00:43.371
Alex is Professor of Operations
Management at Kingston Business
00:00:43.371 --> 00:00:47.391
School and co-founder and director
of the Centre for High Performance.
00:00:47.759 --> 00:00:51.719
Thinkers 50 has identified him as
one of the 30 global management
00:00:51.719 --> 00:00:55.769
thinkers most likely to shape how
organisations are managed and led.
00:00:56.939 --> 00:01:02.099
Alex brings an unusual combination of
operating experience and academic rigour.
00:01:02.789 --> 00:01:07.379
He began his career in engineering,
managing factories and progressively
00:01:07.379 --> 00:01:11.429
larger parts of business before
moving into research and teaching.
00:01:12.269 --> 00:01:15.179
Over more than 20 years, he has
studied and worked with high
00:01:15.179 --> 00:01:20.339
performing organisations across
elite sport, education, the arts,
00:01:20.519 --> 00:01:24.719
healthcare, technology, financial
services, and the military.
00:01:25.559 --> 00:01:30.269
His work has included Olympic teams,
British cycling, the New Zealand All
00:01:30.269 --> 00:01:35.699
Blacks, NASA, Eton College, the Royal
College of Arts, the Royal Academy
00:01:35.699 --> 00:01:39.119
of Music, the Royal Shakespeare
Company, and the Royal Marines.
00:01:39.899 --> 00:01:45.059
He's the author of Centennials: The 12
Habits of Great Enduring Organisations,
00:01:45.449 --> 00:01:50.399
which is the product of a 13-year
investigation into why some institutions
00:01:50.399 --> 00:01:54.689
remain relevant and successful for more
than a century, while many businesses
00:01:54.689 --> 00:01:56.519
survive for a little more than a decade.
00:01:57.216 --> 00:02:01.266
His research on architect leaders
challenged the attraction of the
00:02:01.266 --> 00:02:05.916
heroic turnaround leader, showing
that the leaders who create enduring
00:02:05.916 --> 00:02:10.506
improvement can be less celebrated
precisely because their results
00:02:10.506 --> 00:02:12.006
take longer to become visible.
00:02:12.966 --> 00:02:17.676
More recently, Alex has extended this
work from organisations to individuals,
00:02:18.096 --> 00:02:23.196
exploring how people who make an
enduring contribution evolve, fail,
00:02:23.376 --> 00:02:25.626
learn, and build the teams around them.
00:02:26.743 --> 00:02:30.793
Across his writing and public commentary,
a consistent challenge emerges.
00:02:31.303 --> 00:02:34.933
Leaders must balance today's
pressures with tomorrow's ambitions.
00:02:35.653 --> 00:02:38.983
And that makes Alex especially
relevant to the boardroom path.
00:02:39.613 --> 00:02:43.453
Boards are expected to provide
oversight in the present, foresight
00:02:43.453 --> 00:02:48.743
about the future, and insight drawn
from experience, yet their best work
00:02:48.773 --> 00:02:53.813
may not produce an immediate headline
or an easily attributable result.
00:02:54.773 --> 00:02:58.823
Today we will explore how boards can
protect purpose without protecting
00:02:58.823 --> 00:03:04.133
outdated practice, retain wisdom without
becoming captured by the past, and
00:03:04.133 --> 00:03:09.653
create enough safety, challenge and
curiosity for an organisation to adapt.
00:03:10.343 --> 00:03:13.643
We will also ask a specific question.
00:03:14.333 --> 00:03:18.113
If a board has exercised good
leadership, what evidence should
00:03:18.113 --> 00:03:20.243
remain after its members have gone?
00:03:21.263 --> 00:03:22.793
So Alex, welcome to The Boardroom Path.
00:03:22.903 --> 00:03:23.363
Alex Hill: Thank you.
00:03:23.363 --> 00:03:24.053
Thanks for having me.
00:03:24.533 --> 00:03:28.283
Ralph Grayson: So your work
begins with a simple challenge
00:03:28.283 --> 00:03:29.963
if I express it like this.
00:03:30.143 --> 00:03:34.613
Why do some organisations remain
successful and relevant for generations
00:03:35.063 --> 00:03:37.103
while so many others disappear?
00:03:37.553 --> 00:03:40.725
And I'd be fascinated just to know
what first drew you to that question.
00:03:41.187 --> 00:03:43.287
Alex Hill: So I was sponsored
through university by a big
00:03:43.287 --> 00:03:45.087
engineering firm called Dowty.
00:03:45.237 --> 00:03:46.707
They're like a family business.
00:03:46.987 --> 00:03:50.921
Whilst I was there, they were bought
by TI, which is Tube Investments.
00:03:51.551 --> 00:03:56.031
And then I was there for 10
years just before I left, they
00:03:56.031 --> 00:03:58.171
were then acquired by Smiths.
00:03:58.611 --> 00:04:03.831
So I went through watching
businesses fail, in inverted commas.
00:04:04.221 --> 00:04:08.001
They definitely weren't being
sold because they were successful.
00:04:08.871 --> 00:04:15.021
And I was working in environments
that was very high pressure.
00:04:15.541 --> 00:04:19.021
But also, we would have hourly
targets in factories, and if you
00:04:19.021 --> 00:04:21.871
didn't hit those hourly targets,
then everyone started freaking out.
00:04:22.141 -->
Load full transcript
00:04:27.331
So I came from that world that was very
short termist, where you know, suddenly
00:04:27.421 --> 00:04:32.971
no one could buy stationery or suddenly
you were scrambling to find sales from
00:04:32.971 --> 00:04:34.531
next month to bring into this month.
00:04:34.861 --> 00:04:39.271
I don't think I quite consciously
knew I was in that short term world,
00:04:39.841 --> 00:04:44.791
but it was all about the numbers and
it was all about the numbers being
00:04:44.791 --> 00:04:48.631
the same every month, I'm sure this
is very familiar to your listeners.
00:04:48.851 --> 00:04:53.171
I always knew I was going to leave
industry at some point because I
00:04:53.171 --> 00:04:59.961
followed in my dad's footsteps and I left
industry and went to Oxford and went to
00:04:59.961 --> 00:05:02.811
a college there and it was so different.
00:05:02.871 --> 00:05:04.561
It was so different.
00:05:04.761 --> 00:05:08.261
I jokingly say I think the only
short term target in the college
00:05:08.261 --> 00:05:09.731
was to try and make it to lunch.
00:05:10.117 --> 00:05:11.887
It was all about long term.
00:05:11.947 --> 00:05:14.317
It was all about thinking.
00:05:14.417 --> 00:05:17.147
The college is based just outside Oxford.
00:05:17.587 --> 00:05:20.017
So people would go there to think too.
00:05:20.017 --> 00:05:25.657
So you're in this sort of thoughtful,
long term, conscious environment
00:05:26.017 --> 00:05:29.287
where people were coming to be
thoughtful, long term and conscious too.
00:05:29.464 --> 00:05:34.504
What also really surprised me was how most
of the academics there, although it was a
00:05:34.504 --> 00:05:36.394
management college, didn't like business.
00:05:36.694 --> 00:05:40.254
I'd come from business, so I
thought they would like business,
00:05:40.254 --> 00:05:41.364
this is a management college.
00:05:41.604 --> 00:05:45.354
In hindsight, I realised that most
of them had come from medicine
00:05:45.444 --> 00:05:46.764
and they'd moved into that world.
00:05:47.094 --> 00:05:51.534
But what you started to realise is
they didn't like business and what they
00:05:51.534 --> 00:05:56.364
didn't like, whether it was conscious or
not, was the short termism of business
00:05:56.464 --> 00:06:01.984
and this desire that really, although
a lot of businesses talk long term,
00:06:01.984 --> 00:06:06.604
really it's just about this week, this
month, this quarter, maybe this year.
00:06:07.564 --> 00:06:11.014
Some businesses I know don't
really even think about this year.
00:06:11.774 --> 00:06:15.944
So I think what had happened is I'd
gone from very short term to very
00:06:15.944 --> 00:06:19.904
long term, and these worlds were
incredibly different and I hadn't
00:06:19.904 --> 00:06:22.634
really, at that time, understood why.
00:06:23.502 --> 00:06:26.932
My grandparents were coal miners in
Stoke and my mom and dad were the first
00:06:26.932 --> 00:06:31.222
generation to get educated and come
out and my dad went from working in a
00:06:31.222 --> 00:06:33.442
factory to being a Professor at Oxford.
00:06:33.442 --> 00:06:38.782
So he made the whole kind of shift and
he was very much, "You're fortunate
00:06:38.782 --> 00:06:40.822
to be in to born into a loving family.
00:06:41.122 --> 00:06:42.562
You've got opportunity.
00:06:42.612 --> 00:06:43.692
What's your contribution?
00:06:43.962 --> 00:06:44.772
What are you going to add?
00:06:44.832 --> 00:06:49.072
What's your thing?" And he would just
keep asking this not, every minute
00:06:49.072 --> 00:06:53.002
of every day, but it would keep
cropping up and I didn't really know.
00:06:53.602 --> 00:06:57.442
And I was wrestling with it and I started
to realise that I love being around
00:06:57.442 --> 00:06:59.272
people that performing at a high level.
00:06:59.788 --> 00:07:02.518
I played sports very
competitively when I was young.
00:07:03.118 --> 00:07:07.378
I went and worked in Michelin Star
kitchen too when I left industry because
00:07:07.378 --> 00:07:09.598
I wasn't sure what I wanted to do.
00:07:10.138 --> 00:07:15.208
I've always been friends with
people who push it and drive and are
00:07:15.208 --> 00:07:18.888
ambitious and driven and I realised
they're the people I'm drawn to.
00:07:19.008 --> 00:07:23.148
So I started to say, actually,
I think high performance,
00:07:23.328 --> 00:07:25.728
although I didn't realise that
was the word for it at the time.
00:07:26.028 --> 00:07:30.258
But a colleague of mine was working with
the All Blacks and that seemed interesting
00:07:30.258 --> 00:07:33.438
and then there was an opportunity to
go and work with the Olympic teams
00:07:33.988 --> 00:07:35.978
in the run up to the London Games.
00:07:36.198 --> 00:07:38.868
John, who I was working with said,
"There's something really interesting
00:07:38.868 --> 00:07:42.898
going on here. Let's see if we can
get in and find out." And we spent
00:07:42.898 --> 00:07:44.458
time with a guy called Peter Keen.
00:07:44.458 --> 00:07:47.758
Pete's got the first medals in cycling.
00:07:47.808 --> 00:07:52.038
He coached Chris Boardman, and then
he developed an investment model that
00:07:52.038 --> 00:07:57.217
basically predicted how many medals
an Olympic team would win and based
00:07:57.217 --> 00:07:58.837
on that, all the money's allocated.
00:07:58.927 --> 00:08:03.004
So it's Pete's model, it's kind of
21 factors and I said, "What keeps
00:08:03.004 --> 00:08:06.664
you awake at night, Pete?" he came
to Oxford, he spent a day with us and
00:08:06.664 --> 00:08:10.384
talked us through his journey, and
he just went, "Is it sustainable?"
00:08:10.864 --> 00:08:12.814
We've created this massive shift.
00:08:13.444 --> 00:08:18.994
Went from our worst games ever in
the mid 80s to then doing really well
00:08:19.054 --> 00:08:23.744
in London and Rio coming just behind
China and America who are infinitely
00:08:23.744 -->
00:08:25.574
bigger and wealthier than us.
00:08:26.054 --> 00:08:29.804
And Pete went to this big whiteboard
in the room, and at one end he
00:08:29.804 --> 00:08:34.694
wrote Cult, and then at the other
end he wrote Sustainable System.
00:08:35.714 --> 00:08:39.104
And he just said, "Too many of our
sports are cults." He said, "They're
00:08:39.104 --> 00:08:42.794
too dependent on one or two individuals,
and if they go, we're stuffed."
00:08:43.364 --> 00:08:49.024
So my question is how do we make it
sustainable and how do we build something
00:08:49.024 --> 00:08:55.114
where individuals can come and go, but the
system, which is the sort of the sporting
00:08:55.114 --> 00:08:59.554
words, they like to use the word system,
but for them, that's the environment.
00:08:59.554 --> 00:09:01.054
They talk a lot about environment.
00:09:01.474 --> 00:09:04.444
How can we build something that
lasts beyond the individual?
00:09:04.844 --> 00:09:07.268
And, I said, "Who could you learn
from, Pete?" And he went to the arts.
00:09:07.418 --> 00:09:08.948
They've been doing it
for hundreds of years.
00:09:09.428 --> 00:09:12.818
And so we contacted the Royal Shakespeare
Company, the Royal College of Arts,
00:09:12.868 --> 00:09:17.188
and just said, "Look, we want to try
and understand why you've been so
00:09:17.188 --> 00:09:23.308
successful for so long. We have no
idea what we're looking at. We have
00:09:23.308 --> 00:09:28.738
no idea really what we're looking for,
but could we just spend a year in your
00:09:28.738 --> 00:09:31.078
organisation just watching what you do?"
00:09:31.478 --> 00:09:37.208
So that's what we did, it wasn't every
minute of every day, but you're starting
00:09:37.208 --> 00:09:42.938
to go to what are the critical meetings
or what is critical moments or activities
00:09:42.938 --> 00:09:47.528
or who are the critical people and
you'd shadow them and watch them or
00:09:47.838 --> 00:09:51.938
just be in the environment really and
quite quickly, they start to ignore you.
00:09:52.278 --> 00:09:56.611
They're pretty busy and they've got a lot
more interesting stuff going on than you.
00:09:57.031 --> 00:10:02.961
But you just start to see the behaviour
and then we expanded the group we were
00:10:02.961 --> 00:10:09.111
looking at by just really talking to
people who are in high performance and
00:10:09.111 --> 00:10:13.921
just said, "Who are you really curious
about?" Now, what was interesting is no
00:10:13.921 --> 00:10:19.141
one said a business, and working at a
business school, I found that interesting.
00:10:19.531 --> 00:10:26.491
It was, more the All Blacks, NASA, Eton,
places like that and what you start to,
00:10:26.521 --> 00:10:34.011
to realise around this time too, is that
businesses are dying at a much younger
00:10:34.011 --> 00:10:38.691
age than they ever have done and their
lifespans have fallen quite dramatically,
00:10:39.111 --> 00:10:43.281
in the last 50 years, 60 years,
80 years.
00:10:43.884 --> 00:10:44.964
The book talks a bit about this.
00:10:45.167 --> 00:10:50.724
I think the big shift is moving from
predominantly family businesses where
00:10:50.724 --> 00:10:58.464
they were built to be passed on to public
organisations where actually I think a lot
00:10:58.464 --> 00:11:03.394
of leaders in public organisations think
that a business shouldn't last for long.
00:11:03.784 --> 00:11:07.624
It's all about a short lifespan and
extracting wealth and then moving
00:11:07.624 --> 00:11:09.634
on to next business or next idea.
00:11:09.994 --> 00:11:13.504
But we started to realise there
are these great organisations, and
00:11:13.504 --> 00:11:18.154
then it started to become, okay,
businesses don't really last.
00:11:18.424 --> 00:11:23.134
What do these great organisations
do that businesses don't do?
00:11:23.254 --> 00:11:25.774
And that became like a five-year journey.
00:11:26.344 --> 00:11:29.854
The thing that was surprising was
they're all the same and what we ended
00:11:29.854 --> 00:11:35.104
up doing was wrote a report for them
and said, "Look, this is you. This is
00:11:35.104 --> 00:11:39.124
what you all do that's all the same,"
which they found quite surprising.
00:11:39.934 --> 00:11:43.384
The lady at the Royal Shakespeare
Company was quite shocked that
00:11:43.494 --> 00:11:47.454
her organisation and NASA's
organisation looked quite similar.
00:11:48.024 --> 00:11:51.474
And then we shared it with 500
leaders from business and said,
00:11:51.474 --> 00:11:55.754
"Look, what surprises you?" And
then that became the Harvard article
00:11:55.754 --> 00:11:58.694
and then the book came out of that.
00:11:59.564 --> 00:12:06.704
It's a very long answer, but it was,
in hindsight, me moving from a very
00:12:06.704 --> 00:12:13.174
short-term world to a very long-term
world and then the research started
00:12:13.174 --> 00:12:15.244
to explain why they were so different.
00:12:15.464 --> 00:12:18.464
Ralph Grayson: Well, and I was just going
to touch on the research word there and
00:12:18.464 --> 00:12:22.304
your use of it because I think you're
very rare as somebody who's writing on
00:12:22.304 --> 00:12:26.484
some of these issues who's actually had a
background in the real world before they
00:12:26.484 --> 00:12:30.514
became an academic and I think you've
described researchers needing both the
00:12:30.514 --> 00:12:34.174
ta-da moment and the so what question.
00:12:34.634 --> 00:12:38.641
Is there anything that's made that
particularly useful for you in
00:12:38.641 --> 00:12:39.721
the practical application of it?
00:12:40.051 --> 00:12:42.741
Alex Hill: Yeah, I think it's
fundamental, but that's not very
00:12:42.741 --> 00:12:44.631
popular in universities these days.
00:12:45.021 --> 00:12:50.711
My dad was at London Business School
in the 80s, which I think was when it
00:12:50.711 --> 00:12:52.721
was really firing on all cylinders.
00:12:52.771 --> 00:12:55.821
But at that moment,
everyone was from practice.
00:12:56.648 --> 00:12:59.048
Business schools have had huge growth.
00:12:59.588 --> 00:13:04.238
That's when it started and at the
beginning, you were pulling in
00:13:04.238 --> 00:13:08.048
people from practice, a bit like
a law school or a medical school.
00:13:09.338 --> 00:13:12.685
You wouldn't have a professor at a
medical school who's never practised.
00:13:13.151 --> 00:13:17.197
But they very quickly ran out of talent
because they grew so fast and then
00:13:17.197 --> 00:13:22.717
my Dad would argue the big shift was
when they got rid of the part-time PhD
00:13:22.897 --> 00:13:28.187
at LBS because the completion rates
are lower because it's harder, and
00:13:28.187 --> 00:13:30.077
so that was affecting their rankings.
00:13:30.627 --> 00:13:34.737
But then it just became really hard to
convert, because what you have to do is
00:13:34.857 --> 00:13:36.717
basically give up three years salary.
00:13:37.327 --> 00:13:41.707
So you find people don't go
from practice into academia in
00:13:41.707 --> 00:13:43.267
business schools really anymore.
00:13:43.787 --> 00:13:48.262
But yeah, I come from practice, you
have an understanding of context, you
00:13:48.262 --> 00:13:51.112
have an understanding of pressure,
you have an understanding of what
00:13:51.112 --> 00:13:56.542
it's like to, my first job was working
shifts in a factory managing 100
00:13:56.542 --> 00:14:01.282
people who all wanted to kill me, or at
least that's how it felt at the time.
00:14:01.882 --> 00:14:04.862
I was like a young, know-it-all graduate.
00:14:05.372 --> 00:14:12.482
But that, I learned so much about people
and then ran bigger and bigger businesses.
00:14:12.482 --> 00:14:14.402
So I think there's a couple of things.
00:14:14.402 --> 00:14:15.962
One is you understand context.
00:14:16.412 --> 00:14:19.382
The second is my
motivations are different.
00:14:19.892 --> 00:14:24.452
I left industry to move into an
environment where it is more reflective,
00:14:24.932 --> 00:14:29.012
where you can then help and support
people who are working under high
00:14:29.012 --> 00:14:33.782
pressure, who often can't see the wood
for the trees, who are often wrestling
00:14:33.782 --> 00:14:38.162
with a problem that they don't realise
is common or has potentially been solved
00:14:38.162 --> 00:14:43.122
elsewhere and they're going on raw
instincts and I think the role of an
00:14:43.122 --> 00:14:46.002
academic is to help those individuals.
00:14:46.272 --> 00:14:47.772
That's my purpose.
00:14:47.982 --> 00:14:53.052
Is to do work that they think is
useful and important and to write in
00:14:53.052 --> 00:14:54.462
a way that's useful and important.
00:14:54.512 --> 00:14:57.302
You get no credit for writing
a book at a University.
00:14:57.712 --> 00:14:59.902
It's considered to be a bad thing to do.
00:15:00.142 --> 00:15:03.722
But actually people outside
universities read books, they don't
00:15:03.722 --> 00:15:07.352
read articles, and nobody talks about
the article that changed their life.
00:15:08.552 --> 00:15:13.352
I think, like all of us, you have to
make choices about where you spend
00:15:13.352 --> 00:15:14.882
your time and effort and energy.
00:15:15.012 --> 00:15:21.882
For me, my purpose is to help people who
are doing really high pressure jobs where
00:15:21.882 --> 00:15:26.432
I have the luxury of having worked in
lots and lots of different environments so
00:15:26.432 --> 00:15:31.902
you can see the patterns, but also where
I've got the time to reflect and think
00:15:31.972 --> 00:15:34.762
and hopefully help them in that moment.
00:15:35.092 --> 00:15:37.142
Ralph Grayson: So let's just apply
this to the boardroom if we can.
00:15:37.164 --> 00:15:39.864
Couple of things that have
particularly triggered me there.
00:15:40.434 --> 00:15:45.094
One is your view on the short, the
medium, and the long term, which I
00:15:45.094 --> 00:15:49.224
think is a fundamental issue a lot of
boards and board members grapple with.
00:15:49.824 --> 00:15:54.154
The application of strategy and
execution and how that enables a
00:15:54.154 --> 00:16:00.374
board to lead without stepping into
the remit of the executive, but
00:16:00.374 --> 00:16:07.354
also how we define high performance
and how the board can create that
00:16:07.354 --> 00:16:09.664
operating environment and that culture.
00:16:09.994 --> 00:16:14.554
So you've used a really powerful
analogy that I want to start with.
00:16:14.584 --> 00:16:17.270
You described high performance as steam.
00:16:17.810 --> 00:16:20.330
The world is water, but
high performance is steam.
00:16:20.660 --> 00:16:25.400
So what becomes visible in that analogy?
00:16:25.860 --> 00:16:28.910
And particularly how is that
contextual when the stakes are
00:16:28.910 --> 00:16:30.500
higher and the pressure is there?
00:16:31.540 --> 00:16:34.770
Alex Hill: I think it's important,
and I guess this is part of the
00:16:34.770 --> 00:16:39.450
attraction for me as a researcher,
is that the world is water.
00:16:39.450 --> 00:16:40.380
We're all water.
00:16:40.380 --> 00:16:43.890
We're all basically people coming
together trying to do something, and
00:16:43.890 --> 00:16:48.380
that really is the same everywhere,
every environment you walk into.
00:16:48.380 --> 00:16:54.110
There are contextual factors, definitely,
but at its core, it's groups of people
00:16:54.110 --> 00:16:55.880
coming together trying to do something.
00:16:56.540 --> 00:17:02.690
And what you realise is that high
performance is just high stress and
00:17:02.690 --> 00:17:08.160
the reason why is that if you get
it right, it has an impact, and if
00:17:08.160 --> 00:17:11.490
you get it wrong, it has an impact,
and you start to feel that pressure.
00:17:12.030 --> 00:17:18.110
Whether you are an Olympic athlete at a
games, or whether you're a surgeon,
or
00:17:18.110 --> 00:17:23.400
whether you are an actor about to walk
out on stage or you're an astronaut.
00:17:23.430 --> 00:17:30.180
Whatever it is, you are preparing for
this moment and this is the thing you
00:17:30.180 --> 00:17:33.780
realise, high performance, there is
a performance, you're preparing for
00:17:33.780 --> 00:17:38.400
this moment where you have to nail it
and you have to get it right and that
00:17:38.400 --> 00:17:41.130
pressure does weird things to the brain.
00:17:42.810 --> 00:17:47.380
The All Blacks really struggled
for a while to win a World Cup.
00:17:47.950 --> 00:17:49.180
They were really struggling.
00:17:49.690 --> 00:17:51.430
They would dominate the year.
00:17:51.490 --> 00:17:53.830
They were by far the best team.
00:17:54.260 --> 00:17:58.100
They would dominate the group stages,
destroy everyone, and there'd be a
00:17:58.100 --> 00:18:03.770
moment in the knockout phase after that
when they'd be ahead and the opposition
00:18:03.770 --> 00:18:08.910
would come back and they would freeze
and it happened, two or three times.
00:18:10.011 --> 00:18:11.481
They just didn't understand.
00:18:11.511 --> 00:18:14.301
Didn't understand why it was happening,
what was going on, and they went and
00:18:14.301 --> 00:18:19.071
worked with a criminal psychologist,
eventually a guy called Kerry Evans, who's
00:18:19.071 --> 00:18:25.111
written a great book, which is called Blue
and Red Thinking and Kerry was also, I
00:18:25.111 --> 00:18:29.191
think, a professional footballer before,
but he's criminal psychologist now.
00:18:29.701 --> 00:18:35.461
And he just explained to them, "Look, you
are going into fight, flight, or freeze.
00:18:36.031 --> 00:18:39.451
You're going to the back of your brain.
You're not in the front of your brain,
00:18:39.901 --> 00:18:45.901
and you're going into that amygdala, and
you are freaking out because something
00:18:45.901 --> 00:18:48.991
is happening to you that you hadn't
considered or hadn't thought about."
00:18:49.411 --> 00:18:53.011
So his whole work with them was
how do you stay in the blue?
00:18:53.821 --> 00:18:55.501
So how do you stay in
the front of the brain?
00:18:55.921 --> 00:18:59.561
And a lot of that is scenario planning.
00:19:00.071 --> 00:19:03.701
So actually you will walk through
scenarios or you'll do scenarios
00:19:03.701 --> 00:19:08.051
or you actually act them out or
simulate them, but work through every
00:19:08.051 --> 00:19:12.941
eventuality so that when the moment
happens, you don't start to freak out.
00:19:13.541 --> 00:19:16.361
So what happens is as an
individual, when we go into high
00:19:16.361 --> 00:19:18.101
pressure, we start to freak out.
00:19:18.161 --> 00:19:22.341
It's just what happens and if
we're not careful, we go into the
00:19:22.341 --> 00:19:26.931
back of the brain, we become rash,
emotional, quick to make decisions.
00:19:27.321 --> 00:19:29.662
But also what can happen
is the relationships in the
00:19:29.662 --> 00:19:32.032
group start to fracture too.
00:19:32.332 --> 00:19:36.672
A friend of mine was in a
very successful music band.
00:19:36.882 --> 00:19:41.142
He said it was fine until we had our
first big hit, and then it literally
00:19:41.142 --> 00:19:43.302
was like someone exploded the group.
00:19:43.542 --> 00:19:46.302
And all the fractures were
there beforehand, but the
00:19:46.302 --> 00:19:48.342
pressure just fractures them.
00:19:49.302 --> 00:19:54.252
So what you've got is individuals behave
differently under pressure and teams
00:19:54.252 --> 00:19:55.632
behave differently under pressure.
00:19:56.472 --> 00:20:00.132
But it's all normal
stuff, in inverted commas.
00:20:00.522 --> 00:20:04.242
But what happens is high performance
creates the pressure where it appears.
00:20:04.632 --> 00:20:10.212
So I think what you start to realise
is that it's just people doing things,
00:20:10.542 --> 00:20:14.352
but if you do spend time in high
performing environments and high stress
00:20:14.352 --> 00:20:19.722
environments almost like they are
more human or those sort of frailties
00:20:19.722 --> 00:20:23.082
or issues we have as humans emerge.
00:20:23.682 --> 00:20:28.962
But also the thing that we've talked
about too is that that often some of
00:20:28.962 --> 00:20:33.192
these things don't really appear until
you're stressed or under pressure.
00:20:33.312 --> 00:20:37.272
It's all easy to be a nice person,
a great leader, until the shit hits
00:20:37.272 --> 00:20:43.482
the fan and then different behaviour
or maybe real behaviour emerges.
00:20:43.726 --> 00:20:48.307
So I think they're fascinating
places to learn because what's
00:20:48.307 --> 00:20:51.517
happening is what happens elsewhere,
but it might be less visible.
00:20:52.177 --> 00:20:56.827
Also, you start to realise that if you
do work with a high performing team
00:20:56.827 --> 00:21:01.587
and a high performing organisation,
that actually there's more for them
00:21:01.587 --> 00:21:05.337
to learn by going into other high
performing, high stress environments,
00:21:05.667 --> 00:21:07.737
that often aren't in their world.
00:21:08.877 --> 00:21:13.222
If you are the All Blacks actually
going and learning from other rugby
00:21:13.222 --> 00:21:17.972
teams isn't that useful, and what they
did was they said, if we look at what
00:21:17.972 --> 00:21:21.532
we do, it's basically we lift people.
00:21:22.252 --> 00:21:23.992
Okay, who's amazing at lifting people?
00:21:23.992 --> 00:21:24.612
Who's the best in the world?
00:21:24.662 --> 00:21:28.072
at Lifting people the ballet, so let's go
and learn how to lift people from them.
00:21:28.492 --> 00:21:29.392
We grapple.
00:21:29.932 --> 00:21:31.402
Who are the best in
the world at grappling?
00:21:31.582 --> 00:21:34.942
I had no idea, but it's the
Argentinian cage fighters, apparently,
00:21:34.942 --> 00:21:36.232
so let's go and learn
from them.
00:21:36.722 --> 00:21:38.282
We make decisions under pressure.
00:21:39.002 --> 00:21:41.162
Who's the best in the world
at that It's the Marines.
00:21:41.342 --> 00:21:47.492
So really brilliant individuals, teams,
organisations, environments, whatever
00:21:47.492 --> 00:21:53.142
word you want to use, will almost
look at what they do and dissect it
00:21:53.862 --> 00:21:59.052
and then say, "Who's the best in the
world at each of those elements? Let's
00:21:59.052 --> 00:22:00.522
see what we can learn from them."
00:22:01.177 --> 00:22:04.387
It's interesting when we contacted the All
Blacks to ask them to be involved in the
00:22:04.387 --> 00:22:09.767
research I had a chat with their CEO and
he just said, "This sounds great, we think
00:22:09.767 --> 00:22:15.367
we've learned all we can from sports,
so this is where we need to go next." So
00:22:15.367 --> 00:22:18.997
there are always these sort of individuals
and organisations are looking outside of
00:22:18.997 --> 00:22:23.307
their sectors for ideas, because they know
you've you've experienced or you've solved
00:22:23.307 --> 00:22:27.987
different problems and you've developed
or got different solutions and then the
00:22:27.987 --> 00:22:29.247
question is how do you transfer them?
00:22:30.407 --> 00:22:32.787
Ralph Grayson: There's a few things
I'd like to unpick there and make
00:22:32.787 --> 00:22:35.337
sure I understood you correctly.
00:22:35.337 --> 00:22:40.497
So if we think about the board's
role then of bringing the best
00:22:40.497 --> 00:22:43.677
out of the people that work for
the company and the executive.
00:22:44.157 --> 00:22:49.827
The board's role is not to generate
steam itself, but to understand the
00:22:49.827 --> 00:22:55.407
pressure in the system and then create
the environment that can optimise
00:22:55.407 --> 00:22:59.097
that, i.e. knowing when to step in
and when to step back crucially.
00:22:59.247 --> 00:23:02.397
Alex Hill: I guess there's an interesting
question there is for the board to
00:23:02.397 --> 00:23:07.707
say, "What is our role?" So I think
it could be what you describe where
00:23:07.867 --> 00:23:12.447
there's an awareness of what it's like
to be in steam and what happens in
00:23:12.447 --> 00:23:16.297
steam because you've picked a board
that has that experience and has that
00:23:16.297 --> 00:23:17.887
knowledge and has that background.
00:23:18.397 --> 00:23:22.769
There's a second question, which is what
I have seen happen in other environments.
00:23:22.769 --> 00:23:27.939
It might be that the board sees their
role is to create steam to then help
00:23:27.939 --> 00:23:31.209
prepare those individuals for going
back into a high pressured environment.
00:23:31.209 --> 00:23:32.649
So it's almost like simulating it.
00:23:32.649 --> 00:23:36.966
But I think the board have to
understand what their role is in this
00:23:36.966 --> 00:23:40.986
organisation, and I think it will
also reflect what the organisation is
00:23:40.986 --> 00:23:42.696
going through or about to go through.
00:23:42.826 --> 00:23:47.686
And then thinking about how they want to
do that, how they want to create that.
00:23:47.939 --> 00:23:53.129
I mean, My experience, and you're more
experienced in this world than I am, is
00:23:53.129 --> 00:23:56.849
that every CEO I've worked with, every
good CEO I've worked with, always works
00:23:56.849 --> 00:24:02.129
as a pair and it's normally them plus
the FD or them plus the HR director.
00:24:02.149 --> 00:24:08.339
That's normally the pairing and one of
them's normally really challenging, and
00:24:08.339 --> 00:24:10.529
one of them's normally more supportive.
00:24:10.599 --> 00:24:12.579
I always think it's a bit like parenting.
00:24:12.769 --> 00:24:16.996
It's really hard to be a single parent
and be both challenging and supportive.
00:24:16.996 --> 00:24:18.646
It starts to freak your kids out a bit.
00:24:18.646 --> 00:24:21.736
Ralph Grayson: I think that's a unique
relationship between the chair and the CEO
00:24:21.856 --> 00:24:22.456
Alex Hill: Exactly.
00:24:22.506 --> 00:24:24.786
But I think you need both
challenge and support.
00:24:26.256 --> 00:24:31.149
Ralph Grayson: So how does a board
member make sure that it's not
00:24:31.149 --> 00:24:36.429
just creating pressure because the
optics are, we need more pressure?
00:24:36.529 --> 00:24:43.169
What's the balance between being
busy, successful, and just creating
00:24:43.469 --> 00:24:46.744
the opportunity or the environment
in which you think you're being busy?
00:24:47.431 --> 00:24:50.731
Alex Hill: I don't think necessarily
busy is always a good thing.
00:24:51.157 --> 00:24:54.037
What's interesting, you
hinted about this earlier.
00:24:54.037 --> 00:24:58.415
So the research I'm now in is looking at
high performing individuals and you tend
00:24:58.415 --> 00:25:04.475
to find high performing individuals really
structure their days incredibly carefully.
00:25:05.105 --> 00:25:08.735
I'm about to generalise massively,
but the patterns are pretty clear.
00:25:09.245 --> 00:25:14.325
It tends to be productive mornings,
creative afternoons and evenings but they
00:25:14.325 --> 00:25:20.595
will also think as carefully about their
non-work times, their work time, and
00:25:21.045 --> 00:25:26.205
will often find that it's the non-work
time where they get their breakthroughs.
00:25:26.415 --> 00:25:34.365
It's often when you are doing something
that is absorbing you enough but not too
00:25:34.365 --> 00:25:40.095
much that you start to connect the dots
and your subconscious starts to work.
00:25:41.025 --> 00:25:45.625
So I think, as you become more and
more senior in an organisation, you
00:25:45.625 --> 00:25:50.845
do need to become less operational and
your role is to become more strategic
00:25:51.285 --> 00:25:55.245
and I do think that your role is less
around doing and more around
thinking.
00:25:55.905 --> 00:25:59.085
There's always an element of both
and the environment it changes.
00:25:59.415 --> 00:26:06.585
But how you create the space and
time to think is really critical and
00:26:06.585 --> 00:26:11.222
then I think it's working out as a
board, what role do you play in that?
00:26:11.552 --> 00:26:15.122
And in part, it's going to reflect
the executive team that you're working
00:26:15.122 --> 00:26:18.797
with and the challenges they're going
through and the pressures they're under.
00:26:19.247 --> 00:26:25.647
But sometimes being incredibly challenging
is very useful, it has a role to play.
00:26:26.067 --> 00:26:29.607
You hinted a bit earlier about some
of the work we did around schools
00:26:29.667 --> 00:26:31.227
and that was looking at turnarounds.
00:26:31.617 --> 00:26:35.527
A turnaround is quite different
to how do you evolve a business
00:26:35.527 --> 00:26:36.757
that's already successful.
00:26:37.417 --> 00:26:39.547
So I think there's lots
of different scenarios.
00:26:40.207 --> 00:26:43.207
I think the simple answer is, although it
sounds a bit of a cop out, but it's not
00:26:43.207 --> 00:26:47.631
meant to be, is you need to look at the
context and the situation and say, where
00:26:47.631 --> 00:26:51.261
do we apply challenge and where do we
apply support and how do we balance that?
00:26:52.171 --> 00:26:54.781
And what's the right thing
to do in this moment?
00:26:55.081 --> 00:26:59.071
And what's the right thing to do
for this team and this organisation
00:26:59.071 --> 00:27:00.271
depending on what they're going through?
00:27:00.916 --> 00:27:04.246
Ralph Grayson: So let's dig into that
a little deeper because I think that's
00:27:04.246 --> 00:27:08.932
fundamental to how any board member needs
to think about how they're adding value
00:27:08.932 --> 00:27:13.042
and where and how they can lead both as an
individual and as part of that collective.
00:27:13.042 --> 00:27:19.268
So you describe enduring organisations
as having a stable core and a disruptive
00:27:19.268 --> 00:27:23.888
edge and I think that's the contextual
part that you were touching on there.
00:27:24.415 --> 00:27:30.025
What belongs in the stable core and what
always has to remain open to challenge?
00:27:30.025 --> 00:27:33.895
And let's just get into this idea of deep
roots and disruptive edges a little more.
00:27:34.440 --> 00:27:39.593
Alex Hill: So Centennials looked at this
idea, which actually I think applies to
00:27:39.623 --> 00:27:41.813
teams too, and we'll get onto that later.
00:27:42.233 --> 00:27:46.943
So I think even in a board, you need
a stable core and a disruptive edge.
00:27:46.943 --> 00:27:51.913
But within an organisation what you
realise is to stay successful for 100
00:27:51.913 --> 00:27:56.653
years or more, which was the question
that we ended up trying to answer.
00:27:56.863 --> 00:27:59.803
How do you outperform your
peers for 100 years or more?
00:28:00.313 --> 00:28:05.143
What you realise is that in the
Western world, we tend to have
00:28:05.143 --> 00:28:06.913
children around the age of 25.
00:28:07.513 --> 00:28:12.433
So you're building an organisation
where your grandchildren's grandchildren
00:28:12.433 --> 00:28:16.273
would want to work or that your
grandchildren's grandchildren want
00:28:16.273 --> 00:28:20.743
to support, buy things from or give
their time to or whatever it is.
00:28:21.173 --> 00:28:25.193
So you're building something that
is spanning multiple generations
00:28:25.223 --> 00:28:30.423
and I think that's important because
a lot of the ideas in the book
00:28:31.263 --> 00:28:35.433
are less relevant if you're only
here for less than one generation.
00:28:35.883 --> 00:28:41.343
So if you're a business and you're
only around 15 years, then engaging
00:28:41.343 --> 00:28:45.153
and bringing in the next generation
of money and talent is less critical.
00:28:45.543 --> 00:28:50.829
But if you want to be successful
beyond this generation of leaders
00:28:50.829 --> 00:28:56.396
or this generation of individuals in
the organisation then what becomes
00:28:56.396 --> 00:28:58.316
really important is a purpose.
00:28:58.436 --> 00:29:01.796
So the first element of
your core is this purpose.
00:29:01.796 --> 00:29:06.806
Now, I have to be honest with you, I
was a little bit disappointed when it
00:29:06.806 --> 00:29:11.996
was purpose because it's so cliché and I
really didn't want that to be the answer.
00:29:12.356 --> 00:29:15.866
But what you realise is when
you spend time with these great
00:29:15.866 --> 00:29:20.756
institutions, the first thing they
talk to you about is their purpose.
00:29:21.556 --> 00:29:23.806
They Just keep coming back
to it time and time again.
00:29:24.466 --> 00:29:29.416
The All Blacks, Steve Tew, who was
their CEO at the time, he said,
00:29:29.416 --> 00:29:33.436
"Look, you have to understand the
role we play in New Zealand society.
00:29:33.706 --> 00:29:37.366
Because if you don't understand
that role, then a lot of what we do
00:29:37.366 --> 00:29:41.356
doesn't make sense." When we started
working with the Royal Shakespeare
00:29:41.356 --> 00:29:45.316
company, they said, "Look, our
role is to democratise the arts.
00:29:45.316 --> 00:29:46.516
That's why we're here.
00:29:46.893 --> 00:29:48.873
It's not just about the RSC.
00:29:49.263 --> 00:29:53.836
So we actually raise money for
the arts." So they have this
00:29:53.836 --> 00:29:55.846
broader purpose that guides them.
00:29:56.056 --> 00:30:00.976
And also, when things go wrong,
it's often what they go back to.
00:30:01.576 --> 00:30:02.716
Why are we here?
00:30:03.076 --> 00:30:09.026
What's our role in society
in the communities we serve?
00:30:09.446 --> 00:30:13.646
The people who work for us, the products
or services we provide, what have you.
00:30:14.196 --> 00:30:18.603
So that purpose is really important
because it guides
you beyond today
00:30:18.873 --> 00:30:24.243
and it guides you beyond tomorrow and
this year and next year and actually,
00:30:24.693 --> 00:30:29.073
they are often looking 20 or 30
years ahead which is quite shocking
00:30:29.073 --> 00:30:32.163
to someone from a business that you
would think that far, but you realise
00:30:32.643 --> 00:30:34.023
they're looking at the next generation.
00:30:34.186 --> 00:30:35.506
That, that's fundamentally
what they're doing.
00:30:35.956 --> 00:30:40.336
So that purpose is important and
that purpose is often very stable
00:30:40.336 --> 00:30:44.356
and often doesn't really change
and was often captured pretty
00:30:44.356 --> 00:30:46.666
early on and was written down.
00:30:47.866 --> 00:30:51.926
When NASA came out of the the US
Army, because they were originally
00:30:51.926 --> 00:30:55.816
in the army, they restated
their purposes to help mankind.
00:30:56.026 --> 00:30:59.566
This is not about military anymore,
this is bigger and broader.
00:30:59.866 --> 00:31:05.476
So the purpose is there, it's there, it's
early on, it's very clearly articulated
00:31:05.476 --> 00:31:06.926
and it's very much talked about.
00:31:06.926 --> 00:31:08.096
What are we here to do?
00:31:08.606 --> 00:31:09.656
What's our why?
00:31:10.376 --> 00:31:14.336
The other thing that's very stable
is this idea of stewardship which
00:31:15.026 --> 00:31:19.786
you start to realise that there
aren't really big egos in these
00:31:19.786 --> 00:31:24.766
organisations, not at a leadership
level, not in terms of guidance.
00:31:25.126 --> 00:31:27.106
The All Blacks have the expression
is that, you know, leave the
00:31:27.106 --> 00:31:28.306
shirts in a better place.
00:31:28.529 --> 00:31:30.389
But when you're with
them, it's the shirts.
00:31:30.629 --> 00:31:32.519
The shirt is more
important than the player.
00:31:33.029 --> 00:31:37.303
And actually, when you join the All
Blacks, you're presented with the shirt,
00:31:37.303 --> 00:31:41.413
there's a ceremony, and then you care
for the shirt and then you pass it on.
00:31:41.413 --> 00:31:43.720
You know, that is more important than you.
00:31:43.720 --> 00:31:47.020
The organisation is more
important than the individual.
00:31:47.410 --> 00:31:50.980
So you have these people
whose role is to guide.
00:31:50.980 --> 00:31:53.200
I call them the parents
of the organisation.
00:31:53.230 --> 00:31:56.890
Their role is to guide
the communities forwards.
00:31:57.320 --> 00:31:58.668
They aren't always the most senior.
00:31:59.388 --> 00:32:02.058
They are normally scattered
throughout the organisation.
00:32:02.368 --> 00:32:05.628
The other phrase I often use is
they're like the oaks in the forest.
00:32:05.958 --> 00:32:10.708
They provide the structure and support for
the whole ecosystem and that's their role.
00:32:10.948 --> 00:32:15.908
So in the army, it's the sergeants and
they are the non-commissioned officers.
00:32:16.238
--> 00:32:18.818
They are normally
appointed to be a sergeant.
00:32:18.818 --> 00:32:22.748
I know it varies slightly between
the UK and the US, but say 10 or 15
00:32:22.748 --> 00:32:25.688
years experience before you become
a sergeant, and then it's like
00:32:25.688 --> 00:32:27.668
a 12-year role being a sergeant.
00:32:28.508 --> 00:32:33.188
Weirdly, it's almost identical
at Eton for their Head of House.
00:32:33.788 --> 00:32:38.505
It's a 5, 10, 15 year experience
beforehand at the school.
00:32:39.045 --> 00:32:41.595
So you normally take on the
role when you're in your 40s.
00:32:41.965 --> 00:32:43.555
It's then a 13-year job.
00:32:43.555 --> 00:32:47.725
You have to do it for 13 years
and your role is to guide.
00:32:47.725 --> 00:32:51.595
So I think, in the army, they call the
sergeants the backbone, don't they?
00:32:51.865 --> 00:32:56.635
So you're the backbone, you're the
oaks, you're the guidance and your
00:32:56.635 --> 00:32:59.095
role is to actually pass the values on.
00:32:59.785 --> 00:33:01.615
So you embody the values.
00:33:01.675 --> 00:33:03.415
You live and breathe the values.
00:33:03.745 --> 00:33:08.485
They're deeply connected to your purpose
and what you're trying to do and then
00:33:08.795 --> 00:33:13.755
you live and breathe those and you
then help others develop those too.
00:33:14.656 --> 00:33:17.010
Ralph Grayson: Raises a really
interesting question in my mind.
00:33:17.010 --> 00:33:21.660
So there's a lot of debates at the moment
in the boardrooms around tenure and how
00:33:21.660 --> 00:33:23.940
long a board member should be there.
00:33:23.970 --> 00:33:28.860
Whether they should be broadly a three
times three year term, and then you leave.
00:33:29.640 --> 00:33:36.104
And what you're suggesting to me there
is a much stronger argument that some of
00:33:36.104 --> 00:33:42.190
the board members should be allowed for
longer tenure because they have a purpose.
00:33:42.564 --> 00:33:43.074
Alex Hill: Completely.
00:33:43.214 --> 00:33:46.544
Again, I think we mentioned this
before, but I did some work.
00:33:46.818 --> 00:33:51.198
It was at a big investment conference
in Hong Kong and someone from
00:33:51.358 --> 00:33:55.098
Schroders was in the audience and he
came up afterwards and so I went to
00:33:55.248 --> 00:33:57.168
Schroders and talked about the work.
00:33:57.639 --> 00:34:01.479
The example I gave in the presentation
was I looked at Liz Truss coming into
00:34:01.479 --> 00:34:05.949
government and how it was the least
experienced government we've ever had or
00:34:05.949 --> 00:34:10.059
the least experienced cabinet we've ever
had and if you compare it with people
00:34:10.059 --> 00:34:15.269
like Blair or Thatcher coming in, weirdly,
they had two of the most experienced.
00:34:15.569 --> 00:34:19.179
The most experienced is actually the
one in the Second World War because
00:34:19.179 --> 00:34:21.799
we were combining both parties.
00:34:22.149 --> 00:34:24.279
But actually you need collective wisdom.
00:34:24.762 --> 00:34:27.612
In high performing long-lasting
organisations, they give
00:34:27.612 --> 00:34:28.842
names to these people.
00:34:30.072 --> 00:34:31.842
The All Blacks call them the Elders.
00:34:32.252 --> 00:34:34.352
I think the Marines call
them the grey beards.
00:34:34.606 --> 00:34:39.009
There are people who have knowledge
and wisdom who really understand your
00:34:39.009 --> 00:34:45.016
community very deeply and Schroders ran
that analysis and they said one of the
00:34:45.016 --> 00:34:50.466
best predictors of long-term success of
an organisation is how much experience
00:34:50.559 --> 00:34:53.859
that board has had of that organisation.
00:34:54.159 --> 00:34:59.799
So, I looked at, for example, Manchester
United's failure after Ferguson and
00:34:59.799 --> 00:35:04.269
how Moyes just basically fired all the
players and coaches and they lost all that
00:35:04.269 --> 00:35:09.979
collective wisdom and if you compare that
with Barcelona when they bring in a really
00:35:09.979 --> 00:35:15.019
experienced manager who doesn't understand
Barcelona or Ajax, which is where their
00:35:15.019 --> 00:35:17.779
culture has come from it's a disaster.
00:35:18.639 --> 00:35:20.799
And it doesn't matter if
they've got 30 years experience.
00:35:20.799 --> 00:35:23.469
If it's not Barcelona or
Ajax, they just don't get it.
00:35:23.809 --> 00:35:27.439
But if they bring in someone who does,
then it thrives and it really works.
00:35:27.752 --> 00:35:32.012
The whole secret to their academy
system is that when a player enters
00:35:32.012 --> 00:35:35.612
the first team, they've already got
five years Barcelona experience.
00:35:35.792 --> 00:35:38.882
So that collective
wisdom is never dipping.
00:35:39.242 --> 00:35:42.632
So you find great organisations
and great teams manage that
00:35:42.632 --> 00:35:44.162
collective knowledge and wisdom.
00:35:44.522 --> 00:35:47.732
But it's important to realise
you don't want too many oaks.
00:35:47.958 --> 00:35:53.808
You want about a quarter of your
team or your organisation to have
00:35:53.808 --> 00:35:55.908
been around for a decade or more.
00:35:56.328 --> 00:36:01.533
You actually don't want them to be around
for more than 15 years and the reason
00:36:01.533 --> 00:36:05.544
why is you're building in future risk.
00:36:06.057 --> 00:36:09.597
The issue with Ferguson and Man
U was he stayed for too long.
00:36:09.597 --> 00:36:12.777
So when he left, too much knowledge went.
00:36:13.314 --> 00:36:15.534
It's almost like a
lacquering or a layering.
00:36:15.864 --> 00:36:19.104
You don't want one plank to be too long.
00:36:19.314 --> 00:36:20.904
You want lots of different planks.
00:36:21.024 --> 00:36:22.614
You want them all overlapping too.
00:36:22.702 --> 00:36:27.412
If I saw a board and all of the
wisdom had arrived at the same point
00:36:27.412 -->
00:36:30.352
and is going to leave at the same
point, that would get me nervous too.
00:36:30.352 --> 00:36:34.929
So you're consciously building
that knowledge and wisdom.
00:36:35.169 --> 00:36:38.349
What you do need though is
that disruptive edge too.
00:36:38.371 --> 00:36:44.581
So the purpose and the stewardship is
incredibly important for guiding you and
00:36:44.581 --> 00:36:49.351
also we found like a guiding principle in
these organisations is they're very open.
00:36:49.921 --> 00:36:54.811
Which actually you realise is key for
getting you to perform at a high level.
00:36:55.361 --> 00:36:58.421
If you're being secretive and
you perform in a dark room by
00:36:58.421 --> 00:37:00.461
yourself, it's never that great.
00:37:00.461 --> 00:37:04.511
But if you're on stage, you're
heightened, you perform much better.
00:37:04.841 --> 00:37:10.451
But in terms of the disruptive edge,
you need those teenagers, we call them.
00:37:11.021 --> 00:37:13.871
The people who tell you're rubbish,
you're out of date, you don't know
00:37:13.871 --> 00:37:18.101
what you're talking about, who kick and
shove, who talk about my generation, your
00:37:18.101 --> 00:37:22.961
generation, who actually have an ego,
who actually want to make a difference,
00:37:22.961 --> 00:37:24.821
who actually want to leave a mark.
00:37:25.534 --> 00:37:30.544
We worked with the NFL and one of the
questions from the audience was, "Do
00:37:30.544 --> 00:37:33.934
you have a no dickheads policy?" There's
three of the coaches there and they're
00:37:33.934 --> 00:37:34.814
like, "What are you talking about?
00:37:35.134 --> 00:37:39.434
All of our best players are dickheads."
They're like, they do a stupid move in the
00:37:39.434 --> 00:37:45.044
stupid moment that transforms the game,
that catches everyone off guard, that does
00:37:45.044 --> 00:37:47.174
the thing that you shouldn't be doing.
00:37:48.014 --> 00:37:51.554
The question is how do we build a
strong community where they don't
00:37:51.554 --> 00:37:53.624
become toxic and damage everything else?
00:37:53.624 --> 00:37:55.304
So how do we guide them?
00:37:55.334 --> 00:37:58.664
And so the stewardship and
the wisdom is guidance.
00:37:59.171 --> 00:38:00.251
You need it.
00:38:00.281 --> 00:38:05.051
You don't need too much of
it because you don't want the
00:38:05.051 --> 00:38:07.031
oaks to overcrowd the forest.
00:38:07.061 --> 00:38:11.241
There needs to be light and room
for new growth and the future
00:38:11.241 --> 00:38:14.061
of the forest depends on the
new growth, not the old growth.
00:38:14.061 --> 00:38:16.011
I think that's also important to remember.
00:38:16.311 --> 00:38:17.841
But you need this balance.
00:38:17.931 --> 00:38:19.251
Yeah, it's a constant balancing act.
00:38:19.376 --> 00:38:20.736
Ralph Grayson: Can you
map that, quantify it?
00:38:20.746 --> 00:38:23.086
I can't believe I'm going to allow
myself to drift into AI in the boardroom.
00:38:24.589 --> 00:38:27.559
But is there some way you can
put data around that and have
00:38:27.559 --> 00:38:29.199
a kind of an optimal curve?
00:38:29.614 --> 00:38:32.464
Alex Hill: So we found that there is.
00:38:33.364 --> 00:38:37.924
So in Man U, when they got 150
years experience across the
00:38:37.924 --> 00:38:40.654
players and the coaches, they
started winning championships.
00:38:41.398 --> 00:38:46.738
I've done some work with the Norwegian
Olympic teams and also the Norwegian
00:38:46.798 --> 00:38:52.548
FA and one of the coaches I worked
with, he said "I've told everyone
00:38:52.548 --> 00:38:55.248
we're going to win the league this
season because we've now got 150
00:38:55.248 --> 00:38:57.678
years experience." And they did.
00:38:57.768 --> 00:39:00.791
I mean, as an academic, that
doesn't really stand up to rigour.
00:39:01.031 --> 00:39:06.351
But what's quite interesting, this
idea of group size, I'm diverging
00:39:06.351 --> 00:39:10.011
slightly, but you tend to find a
lot of this all stems back to Robin
00:39:10.011 --> 00:39:11.901
Dunbar's work around group size.
00:39:12.861 --> 00:39:15.801
But as humans, we tend to
live in groups of five.
00:39:16.438 --> 00:39:19.888
I call it families of five,
extended families of 15,
00:39:20.188 --> 00:39:22.768
communities of 50, sites of 150.
00:39:23.308 --> 00:39:28.228
If you look at the community
of 50, that maps onto all these
00:39:28.228 --> 00:39:29.608
high performing organisations.
00:39:29.608 --> 00:39:35.214
So you tend to have 50 astronauts at
NASA, doesn't really go beyond that.
00:39:35.484 --> 00:39:38.394
You tend to have 50 athletes at cycling.
00:39:38.884 --> 00:39:42.788
Interestingly, I remember speaking
with the old head of Eton, and he said
00:39:42.788 --> 00:39:46.298
whenever he's been to other schools
where they have more than 50 kids
00:39:46.298 --> 00:39:47.948
in a house, it starts to fracture.
00:39:48.548 --> 00:39:53.451
At Eton, they're all 50, apart from the
founding original house, which is 70.
00:39:53.794 --> 00:39:57.874
But I think what you can do is look
to those communities and say, "How
00:39:57.874 --> 00:40:04.534
much collective wisdom is there?" And
generally, you like around 150 years.
00:40:04.954 --> 00:40:10.271
But it will be made up through old and
new and I do think it's important to look
00:40:10.271 --> 00:40:12.101
at the stewardship as a different thing.
00:40:12.581 --> 00:40:17.291
Eton is probably the most
formal life structure I've seen,
00:40:17.621 --> 00:40:19.421
because it's like the army.
00:40:20.051 --> 00:40:26.031
It is 600 years old too, a lot
of its thinking does date back.
00:40:26.031 --> 00:40:30.621
But, they said, "Who are the most critical
people that guide our communities?"
00:40:30.891 --> 00:40:37.011
The head of house, I mentioned earlier,
it's a 13-year role, in part because
00:40:37.111 --> 00:40:42.061
children will stay in the school
for five
years, so you can guide,
00:40:42.331 --> 00:40:44.431
two and a half cohorts, essentially.
00:40:44.821 --> 00:40:48.808
They will then announce the next
head of house two years before
00:40:48.808 --> 00:40:50.188
the current one steps down.
00:40:50.818 --> 00:40:54.688
So the logic is that every child
has either the current or the
00:40:54.688 --> 00:40:57.328
incoming for their whole five years.
00:40:57.778 --> 00:40:59.798
But there is this two-year overlap.
00:41:00.188 --> 00:41:04.848
Also, what's important and this
becomes important around stewardship,
00:41:05.208 --> 00:41:09.514
is when the old head of house steps
down, they don't leave the school.
00:41:09.634 --> 00:41:15.781
So they're still there and actually, when
you look at really effective handovers
00:41:15.841 --> 00:41:22.133
in big businesses, big corporates, often
the chair will stay in role as you move
00:41:22.133 --> 00:41:27.323
from one CEO to another, or the CEO
may even go on to become a chair too.
00:41:27.773 --> 00:41:33.633
But also often you tend to find the old
CEO and the new CEO have worked alongside
00:41:33.633 --> 00:41:38.103
each other for four or five years, maybe
even longer before they take the role on.
00:41:38.523 --> 00:41:44.763
So that does tend to be a five or six
year handover that's happening and
00:41:45.073 --> 00:41:48.965
you find that sort of time and time
again, in successful sports teams or
00:41:49.036 --> 00:41:51.916
schools or military or wherever it is.
00:41:52.366 --> 00:41:57.316
There is this sort of long handover
and you're making sure the collective
00:41:57.316 --> 00:41:59.326
wisdom never dips too much.
00:41:59.864 --> 00:42:02.731
Ralph Grayson: I think that's
such an important point for board
00:42:02.731 --> 00:42:08.371
members to think about CEO tenure
is going down, turnover is going up.
00:42:08.421 --> 00:42:13.671
That relationship between the chair and
the CEO and the optimal size of a board
00:42:13.881 --> 00:42:16.191
as well, I think is a fascinating subject.
00:42:16.995 --> 00:42:18.255
Love to explore before we leave this.
00:42:18.511 --> 00:42:21.307
You've talked about heroic
leadership and the contrast between
00:42:21.307 --> 00:42:23.557
heroic leadership and stewardship.
00:42:24.084 --> 00:42:30.954
how does an architect leader transfer
from an individual executive to a
00:42:30.954 --> 00:42:33.714
board acting also as a collective?
00:42:34.449 --> 00:42:39.189
Alex Hill: So just to give a bit of
context for the people listening, so
00:42:39.969 --> 00:42:44.109
we ended up doing a study where we
looked at 160 schools that went in
00:42:44.109 --> 00:42:48.099
special measures and we were given
access to their computer systems and
00:42:48.099 --> 00:42:49.689
we then tracked them for 10 years.
00:42:50.469 --> 00:42:54.759
And we were able to look at
decisions that were taken.
00:42:54.916 --> 00:42:59.596
The research came about because
a student came to Kingston and I
00:42:59.926 --> 00:43:04.216
taught them and then supervised their
dissertation and they had previously
00:43:04.216 --> 00:43:06.016
worked as a consultant in schools.
00:43:06.106 --> 00:43:10.336
So deep knowledge of the context
and really good relationships.
00:43:10.856 --> 00:43:18.716
We were able to look at the actions
taken and the impact of 440 leaders over
00:43:18.776 --> 00:43:25.256
10 years and what's fascinating about
schools is they're basically the same.
00:43:25.526 --> 00:43:28.046
They think they're all different,
but they're not really.
00:43:28.426 --> 00:43:32.146
Their context is different, where
they're located, the children they're
00:43:32.146 --> 00:43:36.046
teaching, the communities they're
serving, the teachers who work
00:43:36.046 --> 00:43:37.786
there, et cetera, that's different.
00:43:38.086 --> 00:43:40.696
But the fundamentals of
what they do is the same.
00:43:41.656 --> 00:43:44.066
We work with the governments,
they're like they're pretty
00:43:44.066 --> 00:43:45.566
clear on what failure looks like.
00:43:45.596 --> 00:43:48.086
So it's okay, when a school fails,
we know what that looks like.
00:43:48.146 --> 00:43:53.276
So you're all starting from zero or
from the same point and within a failing
00:43:53.276 --> 00:43:55.376
school you have to change the head.
00:43:55.556 --> 00:43:57.866
So you've all got a new
leader in a new school.
00:43:58.346 --> 00:44:02.156
Often they've then become an academy
too, so there's new, it's new branding,
00:44:02.156 --> 00:44:04.476
it's all new, and then off you go.
00:44:04.476 --> 00:44:09.006
They're pretty comparable and what we
found was that people were doing very
00:44:09.006 --> 00:44:13.386
different things and what was interesting
is we were tracking what happened after
00:44:13.386 --> 00:44:15.036
they went as well as when they were there.
00:44:16.206 --> 00:44:20.726
We found these different types and I'm
just going to talk to you about two of
00:44:20.726 --> 00:44:22.736
them because these ones got the headlines.
00:44:23.096 --> 00:44:28.166
But the first ones we called surgeons,
and they basically just come in and cut.
00:44:29.029 --> 00:44:31.709
You see this in business all
the time, I think if you want
00:44:31.709 --> 00:44:35.239
to turn around an organisation,
it's always broadly three steps.
00:44:35.239 --> 00:44:36.259
It's refocusing.
00:44:36.589 --> 00:44:37.909
We're focused on the wrong things.
00:44:38.329 --> 00:44:39.139
It's cutting.
00:44:39.229 --> 00:44:41.239
It's getting rid of stuff
we shouldn't be doing.
00:44:41.519 --> 00:44:43.349
And then third step is you invest.
00:44:43.979 --> 00:44:47.399
But it's always refocus cuts, then invest.
00:44:47.669 --> 00:44:51.419
Some leaders though just do one and two.
00:44:51.569 --> 00:44:56.609
They just come in and they refocus
and they cut and then they go and
00:44:56.669 --> 00:45:00.089
we're finding that was happening
in schools and these surgeons were
00:45:00.089 --> 00:45:03.719
coming in, basically they were
kicking out the kids they didn't want.
00:45:04.559 --> 00:45:08.189
The exam results would go up
because it's a percentage of kids
00:45:08.189 --> 00:45:11.519
that get five GCSEs that gets
measured and then they would leave.
00:45:12.289 --> 00:45:15.392
And everyone would say how amazing they
were and they were all getting knighted.
00:45:15.392 --> 00:45:21.412
Like I think 30% of them got
knighted and 50% in total got an MBE
00:45:21.412 --> 00:45:22.892
or an OBE or something like that.
00:45:23.536 --> 00:45:25.426
You just see this in
business all the time.
00:45:25.786 --> 00:45:30.346
A leader comes in because realistically,
if I'm only there for two, three,
00:45:30.346 --> 00:45:33.046
four years, I can't really build.
00:45:33.406 --> 00:45:36.736
I can cut, I can fire
people, I can cut costs.
00:45:36.946 --> 00:45:42.016
One of the CEOs I worked for in the
company that was failing TI at the
00:45:42.016 --> 00:45:47.906
time, he refocused the entire executive
team on finding new suppliers and
00:45:47.906 --> 00:45:49.646
cutting costs, cutting material costs.
00:45:49.826 --> 00:45:53.486
Profits obviously went up, but
the business hasn't improved.
00:45:53.486 --> 00:45:56.756
And in fact, lots of those
suppliers ended up going under
00:45:56.756 --> 00:45:58.046
because we'd screwed them so hard.
00:45:58.046 --> 00:46:02.991
But if you're coming and you're just
cutting, you get immediate results.
00:46:03.411 --> 00:46:07.631
But all the evidence shows, and
there's been some really great studies
00:46:07.631 --> 00:46:11.771
of long-term business performance,
that if you just cut costs, you won't
00:46:11.771 --> 00:46:14.541
survive and I think we all know this.
00:46:14.691 --> 00:46:18.351
That really long-term performance is
about innovating and growing sales.
00:46:18.951 --> 00:46:20.631
But that doesn't come till later.
00:46:20.631 --> 00:46:25.731
So the architects are the only ones that
we found where the organisation carries
00:46:25.791 --> 00:46:31.287
on improving after they go and they are
the ones that come in and fundamentally
00:46:31.287 --> 00:46:36.487
rethink the organisation and rebuild it in
the right way for the long term success.
00:46:36.937 --> 00:46:39.577
But it takes time.
00:46:40.257 --> 00:46:45.347
In our experience, it was like at least
three years, often five years, before
00:46:45.357 --> 00:46:47.007
the results really start to show.
00:46:47.577 --> 00:46:51.507
And the work came out,
we ended up appearing on
00:46:51.507 --> 00:46:53.817
Newsnight and talking about it.
00:46:53.907 --> 00:46:58.617
And I just started to get emails from
people saying, "My wife or my husband
00:46:58.617 --> 00:47:03.477
is an architect and they've just been
fired," or, "My wife or my husband, is
00:47:03.477 --> 00:47:07.330
doing everything you say they should be
doing, but the board have lost confidence
00:47:07.330 --> 00:47:11.936
in them." And so we went back into the
data and we had all the minutes of all
00:47:11.936 --> 00:47:16.599
the board meetings and we found that
90% of them almost lost their job at the
00:47:16.599 --> 00:47:20.949
end of the second year and when you look
at CEOs, it's kind of similar patterns.
00:47:20.949 --> 00:47:26.709
The most common time to be fired is
year two, because I was thinking you
00:47:26.709 --> 00:47:30.159
can get away with bad performance year
one by blaming it on the last one.
00:47:30.159 --> 00:47:33.339
But if you're not delivering by
year two, it's now your fault.
00:47:33.379 --> 00:47:36.799
And then there were other emails we
started to get that would say, "I am
00:47:36.799 --> 00:47:40.849
an architect, but I'm also quite handy
with a knife." And I think there's a
00:47:40.849 --> 00:47:46.789
realisation if I'm working with a CEO
or a board, I will always say, "Look,
00:47:46.819 --> 00:47:52.009
you've got to keep yourself in a job
to do the stuff that's long-term.
00:47:52.399 --> 00:47:55.549
You can't just be
idealistic and long-term.
00:47:56.179 --> 00:47:57.259
There's a reality.
00:47:57.259 --> 00:47:58.849
There are short-term pressures.
00:47:59.389 --> 00:48:04.669
But if you're cutting and you're
doing short-term stuff, be aware
00:48:04.819 --> 00:48:07.879
that's what you're doing, and as
long as you're building and doing
00:48:07.879 --> 00:48:12.709
the longer term stuff alongside it
then it's all starting to happen.
00:48:13.069 --> 00:48:15.769
But surgeons create immediate impacts.
00:48:15.829 --> 00:48:16.829
Surgeons are very visible.
00:48:17.869 --> 00:48:21.919
In our study, the surgeons got paid
infinitely more than the other heads.
00:48:22.339 --> 00:48:27.359
They got the rewards, they got the
accolades, and then they just move on to
00:48:27.389 --> 00:48:29.249
their next victim and they do it again.
00:48:29.499 --> 00:48:31.389
But the impact is immediate.
00:48:31.592 --> 00:48:38.009
In the book, it looked at this idea of
vitality index, which came out of 3M
00:48:38.059 --> 00:48:42.439
which is something I really like as a
good predictor of long-term success.
00:48:42.709 --> 00:48:47.809
So that's, what percentage of this
year's sales come from products
00:48:47.809 --> 00:48:49.369
developed in the last two years?
00:48:49.579 --> 00:48:51.259
I think it's a professional services.
00:48:51.259 --> 00:48:54.589
It's like clients developed in the
last two years or services, whatever
00:48:54.589 --> 00:48:59.529
it is, a client or a service or a
product has a lifespan and what you
00:48:59.529 --> 00:49:02.769
don't want to do is trading off old
products that are all about to die.
00:49:03.399 --> 00:49:06.189
Actually it's easier to cut costs
when you're just focusing on old
00:49:06.189 --> 00:49:10.189
products, because you know what
you're doing and it's now just
00:49:10.189 -->
00:49:11.809
about doing it with less resources.
00:49:12.029 --> 00:49:15.865
The challenge is always finding
the next client or the new product
00:49:15.865 --> 00:49:19.645
or the next thing that's then at
the beginning of its life cycle.
00:49:19.845 --> 00:49:25.545
So 3M's question was particularly, most of
their products have a 15 or 20-year life
00:49:25.545 --> 00:49:32.065
cycle, how can you make sure you're going
to survive for the future when actually
00:49:32.425 --> 00:49:34.765
your markets are really quite stable?
00:49:35.175 --> 00:49:39.735
So their question was what percentage
of this year's sales come from products
00:49:39.735 --> 00:49:41.745
developed in the last two years?
00:49:42.075 --> 00:49:47.115
And making sure that's a high enough
percentage to assure long-term success.
00:49:47.705 --> 00:49:50.675
If you're a mobile phone
company, most people change
00:49:50.675 --> 00:49:52.025
their phones every two years.
00:49:52.475 --> 00:49:56.365
So, that needs to be 100% of
this year's sale come from
00:49:56.365 --> 00:49:57.415
products in the last two years.
00:49:57.985 --> 00:50:02.095
If you're making laptops, say, most
of us change them every four years.
00:50:02.605 --> 00:50:04.675
So that needs to be 50%.
00:50:04.675 --> 00:50:07.795
If its cars, it's six years, it's a third.
00:50:08.035 --> 00:50:12.655
So the need for innovation varies
depending on how fast your markets move.
00:50:13.105 --> 00:50:17.515
But that can allow you to now
start to see are we going to be
00:50:17.515 --> 00:50:21.295
successful in the future rather
than just rewarding short termism?
00:50:21.445 --> 00:50:26.815
And the book, looked at the CEO who didn't
get the job at GE, went to 3M, basically
00:50:26.815 --> 00:50:32.705
just cost cut and then when he left George
Buckley, who ended up going to Smith's, he
00:50:32.705 --> 00:50:37.005
came in and ran the Vitality Index and it
was like zero and he was like, "Oh my God,
00:50:37.215 --> 00:50:42.105
we've had our highest profits ever but our
Vitality Index has gone down because we
00:50:42.105 --> 00:50:47.985
just cut costs." And then the CEO that did
that at 3M went to Boeing and destroyed
00:50:47.985 --> 00:50:50.685
them too, just through cost cutting.
00:50:50.685 --> 00:50:55.815
So I think that's important, how do
you balance those two short and long
00:50:56.185 --> 00:50:59.668
and how do you create a business
that can be successful in the future?
00:51:00.476 --> 00:51:03.195
Ralph Grayson: So how should a
board member get that balance right?
00:51:03.255 --> 00:51:04.725
What data should they use?
00:51:04.725 --> 00:51:08.685
How should they think about the
interpretation of that data to say
00:51:08.685 --> 00:51:12.965
"My CEO is working or not working?"
If I use a football analogy, I was
00:51:13.475 --> 00:51:17.315
fortunate enough to be in the boardroom
at Brentford this week and their
00:51:17.315 --> 00:51:19.115
coach left
last year, went to Spurs.
00:51:19.535 --> 00:51:24.405
And when he started at Brentford,
he lost his first seven matches.
00:51:25.485 --> 00:51:29.805
But the data that the board looked at
showed that he was employing the system
00:51:29.805 --> 00:51:32.715
that everybody had agreed this is a
system we're going to use and the system
00:51:32.985 --> 00:51:34.545
basically was say we shouldn't have lost.
00:51:35.085 --> 00:51:39.345
He then goes to Spurs and Spurs
sack him after five matches.
00:51:40.395 --> 00:51:43.905
So if you were the board of Spurs
relative to the board of Brentford,
00:51:43.928 --> 00:51:48.008
how did their thinking show
leadership or not show leadership?
00:51:48.852 --> 00:51:51.498
Alex Hill: I think you have to be
clear on what you think are the
00:51:51.498 --> 00:51:53.718
predictors of long term success.
00:51:54.078 --> 00:51:58.518
Taking the school's analogy we ended
up doing sort of three studies there.
00:51:58.518 --> 00:52:02.853
One was like, what are the dos
and don'ts of school improvement?
00:52:02.853 --> 00:52:04.383
The second one's around leadership.
00:52:04.383 --> 00:52:10.023
The third was saying, if you do want
to transform a school long term what
00:52:10.023 --> 00:52:14.836
can you measure in year one and year
two that then is a predictor that the
00:52:14.836 --> 00:52:16.246
good results are going to come later?
00:52:17.507 --> 00:52:22.426
It is around culture and it is around
engagement and it is around leadership
00:52:22.696 --> 00:52:24.646
and it is around a lot of these factors.
00:52:25.516 --> 00:52:30.443
For me, the one hard measure
is the vitality index.
00:52:30.526 --> 00:52:34.066
I find that's incredibly
insightful, incredibly useful.
00:52:34.511 --> 00:52:39.793
Getting clarity on how fast your markets
move and the question is to ask is how
00:52:39.823 --> 00:52:43.543
quickly could a competitor come out with
a product and steal all your customers?
00:52:44.203 --> 00:52:46.333
The question is, are
you innovating enough?
00:52:46.753 --> 00:52:50.593
Some environments you don't have to
innovate, your markets move very slowly.
00:52:50.893 --> 00:52:55.393
So innovation can just be a complete waste
of time and actually just very expensive.
00:52:55.963 --> 00:52:57.607
So you don't want to over innovate.
00:52:58.447 --> 00:53:02.464
But equally, you don't want to
just be cutting costs and actually
00:53:02.704 --> 00:53:05.854
living off old products and old
ideas and not moving forward.
00:53:06.334 --> 00:53:09.254
So I think the innovation
piece is really important.
00:53:09.644 --> 00:53:15.084
If you want to take Centennials, as the
idea of predictor of long-term success
00:53:15.414 --> 00:53:21.264
the whole idea of that work was to try
and quantify these different habits
00:53:21.264 --> 00:53:24.024
or behaviours, what is your purpose?
00:53:24.024 --> 00:53:25.284
What is your stewardship?
00:53:25.344 --> 00:53:26.394
Are
you open?
00:53:27.024 --> 00:53:28.584
Are you being disruptive enough?
00:53:28.614 --> 00:53:30.054
Are you being nervous enough?
00:53:30.054 --> 00:53:30.984
Are you evolving?
00:53:30.984 --> 00:53:31.854
Are you changing?
00:53:32.424 --> 00:53:36.084
Because it is quite grey and
it is quite hard to know.
00:53:36.444 --> 00:53:39.884
But we have found that's really
useful, and there's like a sort of
00:53:40.334 --> 00:53:42.614
a checklist at the back of the book.
00:53:42.974 --> 00:53:46.394
That's a really good first step
we found when we're working with
00:53:46.394 --> 00:53:51.704
a board or a team to say, how
likely are we to survive long-term?
00:53:52.184 --> 00:53:58.724
I think it's understanding what you're
using that CEO for too and how long
00:53:58.724 --> 00:54:03.344
you're willing to back them for and what
they're here for and turnarounds are
00:54:03.344 --> 00:54:05.564
quite different to long-term success.
00:54:06.314 --> 00:54:09.674
Realistically, how long do you
think that's going to take?
00:54:10.154 --> 00:54:15.944
What are some good predictors of long-term
success as well as short-term success?
00:54:16.374 --> 00:54:18.804
How can you balance those two things?
00:54:19.284 --> 00:54:22.674
What are the pressures that are
coming onto the organisation too?
00:54:23.064 --> 00:54:24.444
Where are they coming from?
00:54:24.874 --> 00:54:29.524
What story are you telling as an
organisation or as an institution?
00:54:29.762 --> 00:54:34.272
And then I think it's about, is
it renewing, is it evolving, is
00:54:34.272 --> 00:54:35.862
it transforming, is it changing?
00:54:35.922 --> 00:54:41.022
I think these are all, they all affect
how long you want a person to be there
00:54:41.022 --> 00:54:46.902
for, and also often the kind of person you
want to be there and sometimes you want
00:54:46.902 --> 00:54:51.552
someone who's, tougher and challenging
they're not going to be there for long.
00:54:52.422 --> 00:54:54.323
But you can't just keep doing that.
00:54:54.420 --> 00:54:55.880
Long-term that's not going to work.
00:54:56.473 --> 00:55:00.013
Ralph Grayson: I think we've got an entire
new episode coming up here on how boards
00:55:00.103 --> 00:55:02.323
have to think about leadership succession.
00:55:02.390 --> 00:55:05.810
I think it's a crucial part of a
board's role and responsibility,
00:55:05.810 --> 00:55:07.760
particularly through a stakeholder lens.
00:55:08.180 --> 00:55:08.900
Alex, thank you.
00:55:08.900 --> 00:55:09.950
It's been fascinating.
00:55:10.230 --> 00:55:14.160
If listeners think, "Gosh, I
want to delve into this more,"
00:55:14.530 --> 00:55:15.670
how do they track down the book?
00:55:15.670 --> 00:55:19.060
How do they follow your academic
work and your media work?
00:55:19.420 --> 00:55:22.250
Alex Hill: I'm pretty easy to
find if you Google me Professor
00:55:22.250 --> 00:55:23.840
Alex Hill, I'm out there.
00:55:23.845 --> 00:55:27.415
The book Centennials
is a pretty good start.
00:55:28.115 --> 00:55:30.965
There's an audiobook, which I know a
lot of people would rather listen to
00:55:30.965 --> 00:55:34.835
than read and there's various podcasts
that you can listen to as well.
00:55:34.935 --> 00:55:37.055
Or just get in touch,
I'm not hard to find.
00:55:37.225 --> 00:55:38.398
Ralph Grayson: And you're
lurking on LinkedIn?
00:55:38.675 --> 00:55:42.005
Alex Hill: I'm lurking on LinkedIn
surreptitiously hiding in a corner.
00:55:42.065 --> 00:55:42.785
Yeah, I'm there.
00:55:43.115 --> 00:55:46.595
And also, I've got a website, so
you can contact me through there.
00:55:46.595 --> 00:55:48.605
Whatever, whatever makes sense for you.
00:55:48.745 --> 00:55:49.735
Ralph Grayson: Alex, thank you so much.
00:55:49.795 --> 00:55:50.635
It's been fascinating.
00:55:50.765 --> 00:55:51.185
Alex Hill: Thank you.
00:55:51.305 --> 00:55:51.695
Cheers.
00:55:51.903 --> 00:55:55.173
Ralph Grayson: I hope that you've enjoyed
listening to this podcast and have found
00:55:55.173 --> 00:55:59.433
it helpful when thinking about how to
approach your own path to the boardroom.
00:56:00.323 --> 00:56:03.463
If you would like to push this a
little bit further, Sainty Hird
00:56:03.483 --> 00:56:08.273
runs a bespoke one to one programme
designed specifically to this end.
00:56:08.608 --> 00:56:13.292
For more information, please visit
our website saintyhird.com, follow
00:56:13.292 --> 00:56:19.146
us on LinkedIn, and subscribe to the
Boardroom Path to receive new episodes.
00:56:19.493 --> 00:56:20.443
Thank you for listening.