رونوشت 🔗
00:00:02
Speaker 1: Welcome to the Bloomberg Australia Podcast. I'm Chris Burke. On a remote island between Tasmania and the Australian mainland, there is a mine that comes to life whenever the world goes to war. Now it's back in action as countries race to secure supplies of tungsten, a little known metal that's critical for missiles, armor and AI. Bloomberg opinion columnist David Fickling recently visited the mine, and he joins me today to explain why tungsten has become one of the world's most strategic commodities and what that tells us about this new era of geopolitical rivalry. David, welcome back to the podcast.
00:00:43
Speaker 2: Hey that Chris. How I am?
00:00:44
Speaker 1: I'm good? Thank you. So King Island it sits in the middle of Bass Strait is home to about sixteen hundred people, I think, and renowned for its golf courses, rugged coastline and beef produce, of course, but David going there just for the stakes. Were you tell us briefly about your recent trip?
00:01:04
Speaker 2: Yeah, I mean King Island is a fascinating and fairly bleak and brutal place to be honest, maybe brutal is too strong. But the thing that stands out when you get there is it is incredibly windy. It's in the roaring forties, the area sort of forty degrees south of the equator where there's basically no land around the world, and the westerly winds come all the way from Patagonia in South America. They whip across the South Atlantic, across the Southern India Asian all the way past the south of Australia until and they slam right into king Island and then between there and back at Patagonia again, you've only got a little bit of New Zealand and a little other island in the Baths Strait and that's it. So it's very, very windy. The cows seem pretty happy there. I had a great stake while I was there, but there's not a lot of other industry there. You mentioned the golf courses. There's some sort of fishing. I think there's a lobster fishery. I went out for a run one day and there was a kelp farm. I've never seen akelp farm before, but they were just drying a lot of clp. And that's really about it except for this one other thing, which is this tungsten mind that the Dolphin mine, which is right down at the southern end of it, and actually it's been operating on and off since nineteen seventeen, so it's got quite a lot of heritage to it. And what's interesting about it is this thing that you mentioned at the top, which is that its openings and closings relate very much to quite sort of grand geopolitical maneuverings that are a long way from such an isolated spot.
00:02:30
Speaker 1: Yeah, you wrote a fascinating piece last week which used one of the most simple but compelling headlines I've seen for a while. This mine predicts major wars. It's opening again. So what is it about this tungsten mind that can tell us so much about the world? Right now, you.
00:02:49
Speaker 2: Can see it embedded in the history of the mind. As I said, it opened nineteen seventeen, if
Load full transcript
you know your history, that was in the middle of World War One, and nineteen eighteen, World War One finishes, and in nineteen twenty, after just three years in operation, the mine closes again. Because the tungsten is a fairly important military raw material, and after World War One, suddenly the world's military has been no longer using as much tungster, and they sold it all off, and so the tungster market crashed. Nineteen thirty eight, A new war is starting up. Obviously, it starts in nineteen thirty nine, the Second World War. Again, the mine opens up. After the Second World War finishes, it goes through a rough patch, but then the Cold War starts, and that keeps it going. The Korean War starts, and that keeps it going a little bit longer. It goes out of business after the Korean War, but then in the early sixties you have the ramp up towards the Vietnam War, and just a couple of months after the Gulf of Tonkin incident, which is kind of the kickoff the Vietnam War, suddenly tungsten prices surge. The mine opens is going much more strongly, and by nineteen sixty five, when the US starts the biggest bombing campaign since World War Too over Indo China is going very strongly, and it goes very strongly until nineteen ninety, twelve months after the fall of the Berlin War, a few months before the fall of the Soviet Union, it closes, and after that it's been closed really for thirty three years until twenty twenty three when it started bring up a little bit.
00:04:20
Speaker 1: And so the price of tungsten has jumped almost eightfold since the start of twenty twenty five according to your story. What's been driving that?
00:04:29
Speaker 2: I mean the main factor, I suppose there's two factors. Actually that there is a supply side factor and a demand side factor. Any time that you see a big movement in a commodity price like this, I mean it's an extraordinary move. If you look at a graph, it's basically a straight line that goes on for as long as you want, and then in the last twelve months that the line goes vertical. Now, the supply side factor to that is that China produces most of the world's tungsten, and China has imposed export controls on tungsten, which means that previously, if you wanted to buy tungsten from a Chinese you just needed to make a contract with them, and now now the miner has to get a license from the government to export that. So suddenly that has made the market much more tight. But then the other factory is a demand factor. People are consuming more tungsten because there is a fear of war. And this is what we've seen with the Dolphin Mine over more than a century. Every time there's a fear of war, the tungsten is used in munitions. It's used for hardening bullets, it's used for armor plating. It's this remarkable mineral that it's boiling point, sorry, it's melting point is three thousand degrees celsius. It's three times higher than lava. It's incredibly dense. It's as dense as gold. So it's a very potent mineral for hardening steel, weapons and things like that. As a result, whenever there's a war beckoning, suddenly there's a demand search because people are needing more weapons. People wanted to stock pile more of the metal. We saw extraordinary sort of shenanigans back in the thirties when all the sort of great powers were sort of heading towards World War Two. There was a sort of global scramble for tungsten supplies. And we're seeing something a little bit like that right now, both here in other parts of Australia and South Korea. These minds are opening up.
00:06:13
Speaker 1: So yeah.
00:06:13
Speaker 2: The company that owns it is called Group six and it's essentially a lot of the same people who've run it for a long time. But this is a company that's had a pretty checkered financial history because tungsten is so hard to make a profit from. They actually are suspended from the AX at the moment, essentially because back under a previous management they filed they're a cancelate, and they're still trying to get accepted back onto the AX. They are essentially largely owned by a lot of their senior lending group, which is what you see with a lot of these companies that have been through some sort of financial restructuring. It's very, very hard to make a good profit on tungsten, and essentially because a lot of a lot of the minds in China are just so much, so much cheaper and so much better essentially than mines elsewhere. So the previous ownership of this mine essentially went out of business because it couldn't make a profit on its product. And that's been the perpetual problem of tungstan for it for a century.
00:07:12
Speaker 1: As you say in your article, China owns eighty percent of production of tungsten in the world. So how did the West end up so dependent on a material that's so essential for both defense and industry.
00:07:29
Speaker 2: I mean, I think I need to rewind a little bit because I've described all the sort of military military importance of tungsten, but there's actually a whole other side to it. Most of the time, only about ten percent of tungsten supply goes into weaponry, and if there is fear of war, then there is a demand shock, and there's a lot of pressure on that ten percent. But most of it is used for the most boring things of all. Most of it is used for drill bits. If you go to a hardware store, you'll buy tungsten car by, drill bits, tungsten coverage. All that's are used in obviously in your toolbox, but you'll find them also in auto plants. You'll find them in mines, in oil wells. They're used everywhere in industry because tungsten carbide is one of the strongest materials that we know, so it's very good for carving other metals and sort of carving through rock and things like that. This is quite a boring market. It doesn't grow very fast because tungson carbo is quite expensive. So if you're in an auto plant, there is a box in the corner where once your drill bit wears out, you put it there in it's recycled. So it's
not a very fast growing market. It's not a very exciting market really, and China geologically just has the best assets for tungsten in the world. I think with a lot of things, we can have an argument about has China controlled so much of production because of its strategic aims, And I think you can make that argument with something like lithium lithium. There's not a lot of lithium in China itself, but China dominates processing because it really wanted to have a strong position in lithium. Tungsten's different. As far back as the nineteen twenties, China completely dominated tungsten production. China has always dominated tungsten production just because it has good geology. South Africa dominates gold and diamonds, Australia and Brazil we have the most iron, or some countries ended up winning the geological lottery with tungsten, China just ended up with the best stuff. And so when China drives miners outside of China out of business, it's generally, I think with tungsten, it's not because of subsidies or you know, state controlled companies having anti competitive practices. I think it's genuine that they're just it's much much cheaper, much better geological material, and the other miners are just going to struggle because they don't have the good geology.
00:09:50
Speaker 1: Okay, so China is now the world's most dominant producer. How did the West become so complacent about this mineral so crucial for security? Yeah, and kind of relegate it to the back rows of bummings if you like.
00:10:06
Speaker 2: Yeah, well, I mean, obviously the geology that I talked about is one part of that, but I think you're right, there's a separate element that's crucial because of course, through a lot of the twentieth century, through the Cold War, this mine was in operation and similar minds were in operation. And I think that the missing factor there is a change in the sort of philosophy of war and belief about the types of wars that we're going to fight. Through most of the twentieth century, wars were materials intensive. There were big battlefields, you know, dug in trenches and supply lines lobbing huge amounts of munitions at each other. Obviously, you know, World War One World War II Vietnam War were sort of classic examples of that. There were a lot of fears of that during the Cold War, so militaries were built up on that basis. What really changed, I think was the other thing that happened around the time of the fall of the Burnham War was the First Gulf War, which was very different war. It was highly technological, it was using precision elements, microchips, satellite guidance, It was very very materials light, and of course enormously successful. So the US basically came up with an idea of what the future of war would be like is it would be much smaller forces, much smaller numbers of munitions, much more about technologically overpowering the enemy, and that was then confirmed in the Second Gulf War, the Iraq War in two thousand and three, and
then of course the big wars of the early twenty first century were Afghanistan and Iraq, which were essentially these insurgencies. So nothing happened to change the view that twentieth century style wars would never happen again. But then in the last five years, I think two crucial things have happened that have changed that again. The first thing is obviously the war in Ukraine. The War in Ukraine looks like World War One. It is you know, it's two industrial powers running their industrial machines. They're mightiest and fighting over square kilometers and hectares of bomb land. So it's very similar to what we saw in the twentieth century. And the other thing I think is the fears of what a war between between China and the US over Taiwan might look like, and the fears of the scale of the Chinese military supply chain ability to produce vast amounts of munitions and vast amounts of anything, and whether the US can face up to that. Now, if that changes your view of what wars are going to be like, then suddenly the fact that eighty percent of the tungsten that you need for you know, many of your cruise missiles, many of your interceptors, many of your battlefield armaments, all of those things, eighty percent of that comes from China. Another five percent comes from Russia and North Korea. This is a real problem. So suddenly the whole thinking that's guided the last of the thirty five years of how we've thought about tungsten in a strategic military sense has been turned on its head within five years.
00:12:52
Speaker 1: Yet Australia has the second largest reserves of tungsten and the world, behind China, according to your story. So doesn't that seem like a massive opportunity for Australia.
00:13:07
Speaker 2: I mean, it is clearly right. But there's two crucial things that I would distinguished. One is that reserves. Having a reserve a mineral doesn't mean that you can produce it economically. You can have a great reserve on paper, but can you make money from it. You know, there's the amount of diesel that you have to truck getting it out of the ground, is the amount of process and you have to do King Island, for instance. It's an island. It's in terms of logistics, it's quite difficult to do things there in the way that it wouldn't be if you're on the mainland of Australia or even the mainland of Tasmania. So there's all these sorts of things that make it actually, consider me more difficult than it needs to be. And also, of course, we have a global market in commodities, and we have had for thirty five years of global marketing commodities, and China is clearly by far the cheapest producer of tungsten out there. So if you believe in lobal commodity markets and you don't believe in state support for uneconomic businesses, then there's no reason that you would be operating any of these mines in Australia because for most of the time they are not They're not really viable on their own feet. And even you know a lot of the people who know these minds very well, they doubt where they're viable on their own feet. But of course this is not just a purely economics question. We've been talking about war. This is a much deeper strategic question and that changes the picture considerably. But it does mean that I think for these minds to you know, to have a sort of viable future, they need a bit of certainty. They need a certainty that China's not suddenly going to end its export controls flood the market and then the price is going to go down to where it was eighteen months two years ago, and suddenly most of these mines won't be able to make money anymore. They really need these current spike conditions to make good money. And that's the real deep problem, because it's a question about how we actually structure our societies economically.
00:15:04
Speaker 1: Okay, so the West has pretty much dropped the ball on this commodity, allowing China to quietly take over the global market. But look, let's let's zoom right out. What what does this lack of financing that you that you've mentioned for these crucial minerals tell us about the world right now, in particular the end of globalization that you refer to in your article.
00:15:32
Speaker 2: Yeah, well, I think you look at the world right now and the you know, the big drivers of globalization for for decades were the US and China, and it very much feels now that the same two countries are the big drivers of deglobalization. Often in my writing, I'm being very critical of the Trump administration's approach to trade and to freedom of trade. I'm you know, I'm a free trader at heart, but I don't think the the US is the primary responsibility for what we've seen with tungsten and the sort of global scramble to secure non China tungsten supplies. Now, this is really China bears huge responsibility for what's happened because since twenty ten, I think twenty ten is the key incident for critical minerals. This was when China and Japan started a diplomatic dispute to do with some disputed islands that are sort of in the ocean between the two of them, and when that happened, China cut off supplies of rare earth. Now we will have heard of rare earth elsewhere. Rare so this suite of minerals, which are particularly important for sort of high powered permanent magnets, the sort of things that you would use to sort of clip a cable onto your phone. But also they're used in wind turbines, they're used in electric cars, they're used in drones, of course, they're used in guided missiles, they're used in you know, they're used in engines and all sorts of military uses as well. And really since then, China has been on and off threatening other countries using its control of rare earth. Rare us are very similar to tungsten in that China I think has a naturally better geological endowment of rare earth than anywhere else in the world. But there are rarests in other places. But the rest of the world has really scrambled over the last sixteen years to get a consistent
response to this, which I think needs to be that there needs to be support beyond just the free market. If you want to have these minerals secured outside of China, if you don't want to be in the control of the Chinese government, you do actually need to have some form of support for them, more than we've had for the most part. I think it's true of rare earth. I think it's true of tungsten. Of course, what that means for globalization is once you start down this road, where do you stop? And I think this becomes quite quite a difficult thing, even for people like me, who I'm basically a free trader, but I basically support a fair degree of control of your supply chain where there's a clear threat to it, as with tungsten, as with rare US have with a few other things like gallium and antimony some of these other elements. It's a bit of a difficult question where do you draw the line you don't want to have your entire supply chain separated out from Obviously, China is one of the most productive countries in the world. We know our entire economies would be so different if we weren't deeply wedded to Chinese supply chains. I drive a Chinese made car, and most of you know, most of my clothes are probably made in China, most of everything I have. So where do you draw the line. I would draw the line around critical minerals are not that much wider than it. But but of course the problem comes once there has been a motivation from Beijing to lee ridge and weaponize some of these materials, where are they going to look next? And we live in a world where choke points like this are weaponized. Obviously, you know, the US has weaponized the chip supply chain to and some people would argue that some of China's you know, attempts on rare earths and tungsten are a response to the weaponization of the chip supply chain. Obviously, what we just saw in Iran in the Strait of Hormers was another sort of checkpoint that got weaponized. There are a lot of checkpoints about this in the world, and if every single one of them gets weaponized, we end up in a very different world, and one that resembles some of those horrible twentieth century battlefields that saw the Dolphin mine producing it its sort of strongest And I don't really want to return there. I've got a lot of sympathy for the people who work at the mine, and I wish them well. But the world in which that mine really prospers, the times when it's been prospers have been times of strife and conflict. That concerns me.
00:19:50
Speaker 1: So many interesting points there, And let's finish off by returning to that mine. As you just did, what kind of about what are they producing at the moment, and what do you think their prospects are well there?
00:20:06
Speaker 2: At the moment they what they produce is tungsten concentrates, which basically looks like sand. I did handle some of it, and it's a sort of grayish sand, slightly heavy, but it doesn't look anything spectacular. But every I think every week they load up a shipping container with or a couple of shipping containers of this, and each one's worth about two million dollars, so it's pretty good money. It's sent out by shipping container. There's a port right next to the mine and it's sort of shipped there and off to the world. They want to be producing about two thousand tons a year of this of tungsten metal. The tungsten concentrates, the stuff they produce. There's a lot of other stuff in it, but the metal included in those concentrates about two thousand tons a year. They they've been digging all out of the pit and they're now dewatering these deep underground tunnels that go deep into the ground and that's where the best or deposits are and they want to be doing that, and they recoon they you doing that to the twenty mid twenty thirties. And they're also looking at some other sort of similar elements like molybdenum, which have sort of similar properties, because they recognize this is an old mine, this is a mine that's been mined for a century's It is, they say, the largest high grade tunguster mine outside of China. But every mine eventually gets gets worn out, and so they need to look for other things. What they're really worried about, I think, is that if the current panic over tungsten subsides and prices plunged right back down to where they were a couple of years ago. They've done a lot to sort of fix the operational side of this mine, and so they're hoping that it will be able to sustain itself through a period of lower prices than it's seen in the past. But the thing every mine a fears is that price is fall below their below their marginal costs. And that's happened many many times with tungsten in the past, and there's no reason to suspect that it might not happen again. So that's I think their biggest concern.
00:22:04
Speaker 1: Thank you for listening to the Bloomberg Australia podcast. I'm Chris Burke. This episode was recorded on the lands of the Warundry and Gallagal peoples. It was produced by Paul Allen and edited by Ainsley Chandler. Please follow and review the show wherever you get your podcasts. You can sign up to Bloomberg's free weekday newsletter, Australia Briefing at our website Bloomberg dot com.