رونوشت 🔗
Randy Blair: Good evening, Carl.
carl: Are you ready?
Randy Blair: How are things in Huntsville, Alabama?
carl: has been really hot. About to not be hot. Fall is here. We're going to the Texas Tennessee game in Knoxville
Randy Blair: good. I'm glad to see you're turning the corner.
carl: on Saturday and it's gonna be seventy four degrees is the high. So fall is we'll we'll
Randy Blair: Wow. All right.
carl: be joining you soon. I think it's gonna be forties in the morning, so it's proper fall in the southeast, so it's good. Episode twenty seven. we've we've made it.
Randy Blair: All right, that's that's yeah, I know it's we're moving right along, aren't we? Well listen, tonight,
carl: Yeah, yeah.
Randy Blair: you know, when you and I were discussing this last week, the possibility of this particular topic, looking at social media, its impact, not only not r not really focusing on its impact on society at large because that's such a a large animal, but in particular the things that we see quite often in the news about its impact on on kids, adolescents. You know, is it good? Is it bad? Are there long term effects? Et cetera. What made me think about it was over the last four to five months, I have had a couple of people who are friends from previous life who have contacted me, people who have listened to our podcast and decided to kind of reach out to me with Not so much something to discuss on our podcast, but just trying to get my input on it. Both have to do with social media. one is a young guy that I knew back in Grand Island, Nebraska, that I say young, he's younger than me, that doesn't make him young, but he contacted me several months ago and was bemoaning the fact that he has an eleven year old grandson whose mom got into his cell phone and found out that he had been visiting some porn sites. and as the guy told me, he said, and I'm not talking about semi graphic porn sites. He said this this was very disturbing even to him as an adult. So they they confronted the kid Because he understood and I understood the same thing that at least in the United States there were some guardrails in place for people to be able to access, having to not only state, you know, their age that they were above eighteen, but actually their guardrails in place to to have to prove that. And I'm not sure how they do it, but evidently some way of of proving that. So I asked him, I said, how in the world did the kid get through those guardrails to be able to access those sites? He said, Well, he said, it surprised me, but he said he was taught, he was shown by a friend how to use a VPN and show that he was coming from another country that did not have those guardrails in place and be able to access anything he wanted to. And I said, Well, who in the world was this person that taught him how to do that? It was a 10-year-old. It was a young boy, a year younger than this kid. So obviously this,
carl: Wow.
Randy Blair: and and I don't I'm sure this is nothing new. And
Load full transcript
for a lot of our listeners, this is probably nothing at all that is in any way surprising. but then I also had a about six or eight weeks ago, a young lady who was a student of mine when I was Was teaching at the university in Grand Island. And she was having some problems with her daughter and social media. And apparently her daughter and a group of her friends, these girls were 12 years old, sixth grade, had been using social media to bully another young girl in their class. And so the mother of that girl contacted this former student of mine and kind of you know informed her what her daughter had done. now the young lady that I know I think did the right thing. She immediately called her daughter aside, had a meeting with her daughter and her and the the father, the girl's father, and explained to her how much damage she could how much it could hurt other people when you do things like this. She said, I I told her, you know, how would you feel if a bunch of people ganged up on you and called you fat and said you would never have a boyfriend and you're ugly and all this kind of stuff. And she said, I I thought that the message got through to her. She said, you know, I I wouldn't like that at all. It wouldn't feel good. And she said in about About five days later she gets a call from the school principal and her daughter and her friends had done the very same thing. Had were still piling on to this young girl. parents came in and the principal basically told her, you know, if it happens one more time, they're gonna be expelled or they're gonna be suspended for a period of time. So she said, the only thing we knew to do. was she said we just took the phone away. I just told her said if you can't use the phone correctly, then you just can't have it at all. She said her daughter was not happy with that. But she said, I thought, you know, well, at least we've nipped this thing in the bud. about ten days later, she gets a call from the principal. They come in and her daughter and three of her friends are being suspended for three days because it's still continued. And evidently it had grown into a back and forth between the other girl and them, which was, as far as the principal was concerned, totally irrelevant. And what she found out is that her daughter had simply used one of the other girls' phones. And one of her other friends that was in the group, her parents had taken her phone away and she just used her older sisters and her older sister was fine with that. This was all happening on, I think it was happening on Snapchat, if I'm not mistaken. But anyway, I those are just a couple of examples of situations in which it I can understand the helplessness maybe that some adults that school teachers that school administrators feel. I tried to tell both of these folks that something that I used to tell parents when I was in doing youth ministry, and that is that. As parents, you are not responsible for your children. You're responsible to your children. And in this one mother's case, I said, you did everything that I would have suggested that you do. Start with having a one-on-one discussion with your daughter, follow up by taking the device away, punishing but I said there are certain things I said, I don't have the answer to that. And I told him at that time, I said, maybe we'll make this a podcast sometime, maybe we'll figure out something. The bottom line is you and I both know that kids today, I mean, my daughter didn't grow up with cell phones, but by the time she was in middle school, she had one and was using it, and social media was a big part of her life. as far as I know, she never experienced any of this kind of online bullying. I hope she wasn't involved in any of this online bullying, but but one never knows. But I know that you've got daughters younger than mine. And you probably have daughters that they've probably never known anything other than communicating through cell phones. And enough sociologists and psychologists and educators and church leaders and parents have have testified to the the potential danger that can happen through social media. So I guess the thing we I that I just want to throw out there is, you know, what what is what is social media doing to is it are the benefits greater than the dangers? how do you deal with something like this when it appears to be Almost impossible to really regulate. Is there a way you can regulate it? Is the technology good enough that it can stay ahead of our kids? Evidently at this juncture it can't. Kids can be pretty in you know ingenious when they want to get around rules. In my day it was sneaking out of the house through the window at night. You
carl: Yeah.
Randy Blair: know, but certainly that has changed a great deal. So I don't know, you you're even closer to it than I am. At least my daughter's coming up on 26 years of age. Yours are still very young. and much more involved I think in the use of the internet, the use of their cell phones, their computers, that sort of thing. where do we go? What do we do? Do we just throw up our hands and say, Hey, that's the world we live in.
carl: Yeah, so that's it's tough. I don't have all the answers just like you don't. ironically, it's very easy for me to know when the iPhone started. it was the same year Claire was born. So iPhones came into existence in 2007. So you're exactly right. neither one of my daughters know what the world is like without an iPhone. And the the problem is social media gets blamed a lot. and I think that's a part of it. But I think it's intriguing because cell phones were alone around for a long time before that. flip phones, other things, and you could text on a flip phone. It was really painful. Social media wasn't a thing. Blackberries were good at email tools and you know, they probably weren't great. But really, and there there's some data and I went and looked at it. I I'd forgotten to to go get it, but I got it right before I jumped on. I
heard this on a podcast the other day, and it really ties back to two thousand seven when the trend started. Of this really and it it really hits high school age girls. Girls get affected by a lot of this more than boys. It's affecting both, but it seems to more severely affect girls. But this this feeling of being detached, depressed, persistent sadness and hopelessness, shockingly, it starts in 2007 getting worse. really started
Randy Blair: okay.
carl: rampant again, and so I've got a couple of stats here. U.S. high school students reported persistent sadness or hopelessness. 28.5% in 2007. By 2023, it was 39.7. Girls reporting persistent sadness or hopelessness, it was 35.8 in 2007, 53% in 2023.
Randy Blair: Mm-hmm.
carl: and so girls at the peak, so good news or bad news, I don't know that's even significant. Statistically significant, hard to say. 2021, it was 57%. So it dropped a few percent, but I don't even know that that's that's even relevant. So it's you know, roughly double what you're seeing from 2007 through the 2020s, and this feeling of sadness, hopelessness, detached. and and there's one thing, and I never really thought about it, but it was a podcast I was listening to is like the i in the iPhone gets credit for it, but it's the smartphone. Apple kind of invented it, but then Samsung and others have contributed to it as well. And what did that do? It gave you tons of computing power. and sure MySpace was a thing before all that, but it all of it kind of lined up and the the iPhone slash smartphone became the vehicle to allow social media to be in everybody's pocket all the time. And ironically you're more connected than ever. But starting in two thousand seven and and beyond, people say they're more disconnected. So, you know, you got Facebook and all these social media things that are supposed to connect the world, do all these positive things. and I really believe it kind of the bottom line up front of it all is God created us to be humans in community with each other in real life, not on Snapchat or Facebook or Instagram or whatever. And I think this hijacks a lot of that. It creates this synthetic environment where you're more connected than ever, but in reality you're not. became very evident during COVID. You know, people are sitting there staring at their phones and life was sucked and you're isolated and be people became more isolated. you know, so there's an interesting trend that's hard to hard to ignore in the two thousand seven. I think there are absolutely are are good things with social media. I did not have contact with my sisters for many, many years, for different reasons. And my older sister, who has since passed away, reached out to me on Facebook. and she and I reconnected, started talking a lot, we ended up seeing each other. She got me back in touch with my younger sister, who, by the way, after the Texas Tennessee game, I will be having dinner with my brother in law and my
Randy Blair: Ha ha ha.
carl: sister and my my niece, you know, and so That there there's plenty of good things. People that, you know, I went to high school with. Like a buddy of mine lives out in Oklahoma now. I still taught him. I had lost contact with him for many years. He went in army. So there's plenty of good things.
Randy Blair: Yes.
carl: do do the good things outweigh the bad things? That's really hard. I don't know how that scale works. I I think the problem is it's just like anything else when you track the money and the power and you know, good intents get Good intent gets bastardized with with all that. You throw in the data that's being collected. Because what really happens is, you know, we could do a whole nother podcast about the echo chamber of what your social media algorithm looks like and YouTube algorithm is you start yelling at this thing and it just simply repeats back to you everything you're saying. That's social media,
Randy Blair: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
carl: that's YouTube. So again, i it's hard for me to really quantify in a scientific manner if the good outweighs the bad, but Man, I sure feel like if you turned it all off, again, I would hate to not be talking to my sisters and some of the good things that have hap happened, but overall, is it net positive or negative for society? It's really hard to see the positives. and you mentioned the bullying and you know, I had a problem with a bully when I was a kid. my dad was always very clear with me. If I was bullied, he wasn't gonna take care of it. I needed to.
Randy Blair: Mm-hmm.
carl: and this kid, it's funny, I see him from time to time now. He's really nice guy. He was think he had a full beard and looked thirty five when we were in the seventh grade. but
Randy Blair: Ha ha ha.
carl: we used to have to walk across campus and he was he was the guy that would thump you in your ear when it's cold outside or knock your books out of your hand. And I finally had enough and I said, if you do it again, I'm all I'm gonna hit you. And I did hit him right his jaw. It's like, you know, and it it worked. You know, he he kinda folded, I was still on top of him hitting him. My buddies kind of separated us and after that there were no more issues. The thing is, you
Randy Blair: It's just like a Christmas story, huh?
carl: It's it's very similar and it probably wasn't smart
Randy Blair: Ha ha ha.
carl: 'cause i i I think I just it was a s a surprise attack 'cause he probably thought I was too small and too crazy to do it, but I I had enough. You know, you get to a point and it's like I've had enough. The thing is, and around the bullying, back in the old school bullying, you know, you you had to face the bully had to face the person that they're messing with. And there's still some human connection and you know, i yes, there are absolute psychopaths who just like to torment and torture humans. Generally though, bullies are there's a sense of inadequacy, there's a insecurity. It's not just because they're terrible
people who want to kill people and do bad things to So they got to face the the human aspect of what they're doing. And that throttles how far you're willing to go and what you're willing to do. and I and a other thing that I thought was important is bullying kind of had working hours of seven thirty till about three. You know, if you played sports, you gotta go play sports and nobody got bullied in sports because that got the coaches worked that out. But bullying, you know, office hours are kind of 7:30 to 3 project. Well, with social media, and it was five days a week. With social media, bullying is a 24-7, 365 sport. And there's absolute correlation between rise and suicide among teenagers and the rise of social media and the bullying piece of it. And if you think about that, you know, how do you escape it when it's 247, 365? And you look at some of the stats I was reading off since 2007, the feelings of hopelessness. you know, you're comparing yourself, social media, no family or couple or anybody else puts when they're yelling at each other and fighting the kids are acting stupid, you know, it's this perfect sunrise on the beach. Well, that's their highlight. So you're comparing your real life to somebody else's highlight. You're doom scrolling through that as a teenager, you're getting bullied, and you can't escape. You know, and and it's kind of this downward spiral. And so, you know, the the suicide piece of then you get into TikTok, you know, and then you got our adversary in China who runs that. It's two different versions of TikTok, right? There's the Chinese version, which teaches Chinese kids to be really smart. It teaches them in intelligent things. They've got certain hours they can be on it, they've got limits, versus ours, which is the absolute dumbest part of humanity for, you know, ten seconds at a a clip. And then the thing that most people don't realize and I went and verified it. I've heard it a number of times, but I went and looked it up and it's absolutely true. To the point where, and if you want to really take your enemies out between fentanyl and there's two kids that were confirmed dead at Ole Miss today. it's supposedly something maybe worse than fentanyl and there's maybe more kids that have died. I haven't looked at it since early this afternoon, taking pills and other things and they're overdosing. So if you're our enemy and you want to really affect the next generation, Then take TikTok and and do it where it will actually convince somebody, a bored, depressed, detached, you know, bullied teenager, that suicide's a good option. And we'll give them options and encourage them and tell them it's a good way. And that's a hundred percent. There's been tests done. that's what I was looking at today. It's not just anecdotal. There's been people that have tested it to test the theory to see, and it absolutely will. And it will drag you down a deep dark hole. so to answer your question and then you know give a thought and
then turn it back to you for for more thoughts. yeah, I don't I don't know that it is better. I don't know that it is good. I think the problem is it's the typical toothpaste is out of the tube. I don't see how you get it back in. And that's really the struggle, you know, as a you know, our two girls, like you said, they don't know a life where all this stuff doesn't exist. I'm not a fan of putting kids in a bubble and saying exist in this bubble because at some point they come out of the bubble and they're not acclimated and that's not good. you know and I it's really a maturity thing too. And you got cameras on phones now, which you can document every dumb thing you've ever did and it stays with you forever. so you combine all these things and the the stakes of this game called social media and life and the mix of all that as a teenager is really hard. So I don't know that it's a net positive. It doesn't feel like it most days. I don't think it's going to go away. There's too much money involved. you know, I don't I don't think you can regulate it or take it away. Ironically, you you will remember this, but ByteDance, the company that owns TikTok, when you were still with us, we were sending out mods to contracts to make sure that, you know, the flow down that no government issued phones or phones that were issuing government information could have TikTok. That's all been overturned now. So it marked that up as one of Trump's things where, you know, he he probably is part of the group that bought bike dance or something. I don't know.
Randy Blair: Yeah.
carl: but those are all being overturned now. So i it is a world that exists. You can't put the social media back in the box. And so then the question is really how to navigate that. And I've got some ideas and things we've done. It's not perfect by any stretch. but to me it is a, it is a Balancing difficult tightrope act of it's the world that exists for these teenagers and as they grow up. And how do you teach, you know, healthy, responsible use of that and what's the right time to do that? So I'll I'll share some thoughts on that in a minute. But I think that's the the challenge. I don't think saying you can never have a phone, you can never have social media, I don't know that that's healthy. And again, the problem is we're all flying the plane. You know, and we're building it at the same time because there's no freaking data beyond w what we have today. I mean, Claire at nineteen years old is the first test group that got sent out into the world to say, How's this gonna work? so I don't know what she's gonna look like when she's thirty five. We've done the best we can and we'll we'll see. But it's it's a challenge. You know, there's a lot of conflicting priorities and mixed things that you're trying to manage through. And and the problem is there is no single answer to me, based on what I've seen with two different girls that have the same DNA but act differently. And there's no single answer. Even within our family with two different girls, it's two different answers. And it's not just, okay, here's the rule. No matter what, we're gonna do this, and I'll I'll talk about some of my rules. But I think it's it's hard. I don't know what the good answer is. I don't I don't know that it's a net positive, but it's kind of the world we're in, and I think we've got to figure it out.
Randy Blair: You know, just to touch on two things that you already mentioned. one, you know, there is the bullying aspect of it, but my recent reading on this issue, many psychologists, psychiatrists say that something that is maybe having as big an impact and may have longer term impacts, is what they call FOMO, fear of missing out, what you've already mentioned. The they see online from their friends or from influencers that are out there that are fifteen and sixteen years old and they've got the perfect life and they've got the perfect boyfriend and they're beautiful and they have, you know, they're taking spring break trips to Bemini and this sort of thing, much of which is fabricated and which is very easy to do these days, particularly The assistance of AI, which maybe we'll get to next week. And psychologists and psychiatrists are saying that that unrealistic expectation that then is planted into young, you know, adolescents who maybe do not have that or feel that they don't have that can create some real issues in terms of, you know, kids who maybe had a relatively healthy. view of themselves and begin to question whether or not what they thought was a good life really is. And and then you get into this competitive thing where, you know, you begin creating your own false narrative. And then others counter that with an even greater false narrative. And you mentioned, you know, the fact that the
carl: Well, also the bots. I mean, that's the thing that's very under discussed. There's a
Randy Blair: Right.
carl: lot of just friend to friend and all that. But when you start looking at it and it went through it when Elon was buying Twitter, and you can see some of it. The number of bots that are on these things, it's not the case on Instagram necessarily, but if you're looking at some influencer, there absolutely are bots. There are people that are paid to go, you know, hype up some of these narratives and comment on things. So again, you're getting such a distorted story that may not even be from a human and you're interacting with, it really is a alternate reality. But it becomes this comparative resource for whatever thing you're dealing with and it's man, it's just so unhealthy.
Randy Blair: Well, I heard a an interview some time ago with a member of law enforcement who said, you know, there is the concern, legitimate concern, of the kids responding to this with suicide. But he said of equal concern to him is the ones that respond by taking an AR fifteen into their middle school and deciding
carl: Yeah. Absolutely.
Randy Blair: that's the best way.
Go ahead and take themselves out, but with others as well. And you know, yes, yes.
carl: Yes. And both of those are happening. I mean, you can look at the social media footprints of a lot of these people doing this stuff and it's it's pretty evident where their head was and what they were doing and it's not great. So, you know, a combination of a number of things, but again, why have those things risen too? You know, it's it's definitely a contributing factor. It has to be.
Randy Blair: Right. And then as you mentioned, you can have outside bad actors who are instigating this for their own nefarious purposes. and you know it's interesting, our country has at least a twenty year history of trying to pass legislation at the federal and at the state levels to put guardrails in place and that sort of thing. And they really have had very, very little effect. Again, because the first thing is a self-reporting thing. Are you over 18? Or are you over 16? are you over 13, etc. And you check a box, yes or no. Most of the platforms, from what I understand, are trying to implement AI. To make a determination based on history of what sites you visited, the language that you use, et cetera, to determine whether or not someone is actually younger than what they claim, et cetera. And that probably works a little bit, except when you have really smart people out there that have an agenda based on are supported by teaching people how to get around those particular guardrails. You know, one of the things that I found interesting as I've listened to the debate, and and this this is a debate that affects everyone. Doesn't matter about their political leaning, doesn't matter really from their backgrounds. I mean, it no one is immune to it, unfortunately. but I have found the response on let's just say both sides of the aisle. to be actually there's kind of three components that I picked up on. On the conservative side, you see people really kind of laying into some of the the lifestyles that are supported by the extreme left, the anything goes kind of an attitude, my truth is my truth. And just because it's in opposition to what society believes, that's society's problem, not mine, et cetera. And I'm not saying that all conservatives take that approach, but that's where they lay a lot of the blame. On the left, you see people saying, well, the answer is in programs, government programs, education, listening to these children, finding the deeper issues, et cetera. the side of many of my Christian, particularly conservative Christian friends, it's well, the world is just an evil place. There's not anything you can do about it. It's just evil and it's this is just one of the tools. And I've had good Christian friends of mine say it's just a tool of Satan being used to attack our children and that sort of thing. So everybody is pointing fingers at someone or something or some ideology or some political leaning or whatever. I find very, very few adult type people, and I'm
talking about in the world in general, as I see the debate going back and forth, in which parents take any responsibility themselves. You know, because evil has been out there, anger has been out there, bullying has been out there since humankind has existed. and you know, in I'm not saying that all parents have the answer.
carl: Yeah, I don't think I mean I think that's a good point. Well I think that's a good point. Social media didn't create bullying, depression, you know, isolation. It didn't create any of these things. It really is something that is exacerbating a lot of these things, but
Randy Blair: Mm-hmm.
carl: it didn't create a new category of any of these things.
Randy Blair: Right, right. And I'm not saying that you know, again it goes back to what I have how I've counseled parents of young children and teenagers. Do the best that you can with what you know. hopefully you if you're in a Christian home, you can sit down with your children and and use the the teachings of scripture and the examples of Christ and and what love really means and and Turning the other cheek and this sort of thing. Now I also realize, you know, and and so you do the best you can. I also know that when you turn about twelve, thirteen years old, all of a sudden what your friends think is far more important than what your parents think. When you're a young girl, it probably starts at about nine, but anyway, and and parents get very frustrated when they like like this former student of mine who I think took the correct approach. She She's you know, she started off by trying to speak rationally to her young daughter about this, and then moved on with steps of discipline and it still didn't work. Do we just give up? you know, and say, hey, that's just the world they live in and they're gonna have to figure out how to navigate it, and hopefully they don't kill themselves or somebody else in the meantime. you know, I again
carl: Yeah, I think
Randy Blair: I wish I had an answer, but I don't think that I do.
carl: Yeah, we were I was talking to Jessica and Justin about this today. and specifically we were talking about fentanyl and drugs, but I texted both of my daughters today and I went down to see Rachel and said, Hey, text Hunter, I don't care how many times we told him, don't take pills from anybody. I don't care if you know you trust they're your best friend. Do not take anything from anyone because they may not know. And it may it's an Adderall, it's a Xanax, whatever. You know, it's what all these people seem to be taking. They may give it to you believing it is a legit Xanax or Adderall or whatever the pill of the of the week is, but in fact it may have fentanyl or something worse in it, and you you take it and you die. So to me, the you know, and I that's what I took Justin and Jessica are kind of a decade behind me, and then Rachel's a decade behind them. The worst thing, and it was still even true for for Jessica and Justin. The worst thing I was gonna do in college is if I go off the rails, you know, snort cocaine. I didn't have enough money to do it, but maybe once. but it wasn't gonna kill me. There was no decision I was gonna make one time that more than likely that one time in isolation was gonna kill me. Keep doing it, that'd be a problem. But I also, you know, I didn't have enough money to keep doing anything very long.
Randy Blair: Ha ha ha.
carl: So I drank a lot of natural light. that's all I could afford.
Randy Blair: Mm-hmm.
carl: but I think what's happened is a lot of these things, be it social media, fentanyl, you know, all it's the consequences of letting your kids figure it out have become higher. so it puts to me, there's more pressure on the parenting game than ever because the consequences of taking a wrong turn in a world where you're right, who who the heck knows what we're supposed to do and not supposed to do and every kid's different and you can take advice and figure it out. But man, there's just a lot of moving parts. The consequences of getting it wrong in an area though are tough. so I don't I don't have the answers. I've got I've got an interesting thing. I did go I was trying to find positives and negatives of you know social media. And ironically, just looking at that talking about the balance earlier, I was able to find many fewer negatives or positives than negatives. but there are some positives, and I've got some data even that goes along with that. i ironically there's a sense of loneliness and all that, but friendshi and I can tell you from my personal experience, we have Sunday night FaceTime calls with Claire now where Cassie and Kaylee and Claire and I all get on the phone. We're looking at each other. That wasn't possible prior to two thousand seven. It wasn't possible, you know, even ten years ago probably. so again, that doesn't substitute we're gonna go see her this weekend. So that's cool. And human is, you know, in in person, human real sit-down discussions are better. But for Kaylee and Claire to stay connected, you know, they snap all the time. so there is the ability to stay connected. If you only stay digitally connected, I think that does have a problem. But you know, just the to be and it's one of the things Pew Research 25 2025, 74% of teens said social media helped them feel connected to friends' lives. And 52% said it made them feel that they had people to support them through tough times. creativity and learning. There's no doubt that there's things that whether they're good things or bad things, there are there are endless possibilities for things you can learn now. Justin and I were talking about that today. You know, when you think about he and I were talking about getting an MBA and not getting an MBA, and now, you know, the that's back to education podcast we did, but There's so much information. If you want to learn how to build an airplane, you want to learn how to do whatever, you want to learn how to be the best business leader,
the amount of information, you know, you can go on X, you can go on social media, you can, and then it starts feeding you more of it. Then you go listen to podcasts. There's so much information, and even the ability to be an influencer, that is a legitimate thing now where people are making money. Whether that's beneficial for society or not is a whole
Randy Blair: Right.
carl: different discussion. But it's a career path. You know, and you think about what people have done. Mr. Beast is a phenomenal example of what he's done. And he is, I believe, good for humanity. he does a lot of a lot of philanthropy, a lot of good things, but just reinvests his business. But he's a dang billionaire off of YouTube. he's thirty-two or thirty-three years old. So the things that you can do and the creativity and the businesses you can create are really good. There's there's no doubt there's goodness in that. And and then I do think the the kind of the flip side of a lot of the isolation and all that, there is information where I think teenagers could even figure out where it is some things they're going through. They may even be able to relate to somebody that they see on social media and say, Yeah, that's what I'm suffering with. So I think there's definitely some possibilities and we've already hit or there's some positives, we've hit a bunch the negatives. And I think one of the biggest ones, you know, and I'll I'm gonna save it for the last one. har you hit you started out with this, but just harmful content that you can get to children. You know, that that's and then specifically with girls, and I think it's so bad with girls, is all the body image and comparison leading to eating disorders and ultimately suicide. I mean, that's that's so bad. We've hit the bullying piece. you know, the exclusion from the fear of missing out, you know, your buddies are all doing something, you're not there. That just instead of you finding out about it, then you go out in the yard and play with a rope or something, you just sit there and you see it. And then you see them having more fun. You're not there. I mean, I can see how that's a downward spiral. and I mean I think and I think this is not unique to teenagers because I think we're focusing a lot on kids. Social media is very unhealthy for adults. Adults are addicted to their dang phones. You know, I drive down the road and I watch and it's like three out of five people have got their phones in their hands doing something other than driving. You you walk around and people in public are staring at their phones. You know, they're gonna run into a car going down the street because they're not paying attention. So the addiction aspect of it is a real problem. And, you know, with teenagers and others, but the effect on attention span and even sleep, where, you know, people are you gotta check your message, you gotta look at it, you gotta ding, you got a noise. I and again, I like social media. I have Instagram, Facebook, X,
X I think is the best immediate breaking news story for something going on in the middle of the world on the other side, you can find it out quickly. But I have zero notifications on any of my social media. So I don't know if anybody messages me, posts something. There's no red because I'm I'm a freak and I don't like red notification things on my apps. It makes me not be able to
Randy Blair: Ha ha ha.
carl: to sleep at night. But I have them all turned off. So when I want to go engage with social media, which is usually when I wake up in the morning for minutes, I'm getting my day started. at lunch a little bit to see what's going on, and then kinda at night. That's kind of the three times that I engage with social media. But it's not constantly telling me that hey, you you're missing out. You got something you need to check it, because people's attention spans and you know, just the amount of times they pick up their phone to see, you're wasting a lot of your life. and I don't think that's good. so, you know, getting to any possible solutions, and again, I don't know if this is the right one, but I've listened to a lot of different people and what we did with girls. So this is how they're different too. Claire got her phone, she got another phone when she was 12. and we've learned this from a friend. We had her sign a contract of it was our phone. It wasn't a gift. You know, it's not yours. We didn't give it to you. You're we're letting you use our phone. Therefore at any point we want to look at anything on it. We will. It's our information. It's our phone. It's kinda like work. You know, your emails are not your emails. They're my emails. and then there was no social media at all. And the the cool thing is with the Apple ecosystem, I'm sure there's other ones, I'm just familiar with Apple. I was able to lock everything down where they couldn't get social media apps. So there was no pathway to get there. I could lock down websites and what they're doing. And and Claire was funny up until she just we just took care of it because I got tired of it when she left to call it go to college. I was still approving her apps and she didn't even care. But in along the way, out of however many apps she has on her phone today, there probably were only three or four that I'm like, Hey, what are you doing with that? Yeah, I don't think you want to do that. And she has TikTok. I hate TikTok with everything in me, but she's eighteen
Randy Blair: Mm-hmm.
carl: years old and like you can fight in a war if you want to waste your life staring at TikTok and that's that's your prerogative. so she got a phone at twelve. She had no social media, and again, she was kind of blazing this trail. So there wasn't a ton of social media when when she was coming through the phone piece, it started happening and, you know, Snapchat and all that was coming to be. And we did at I don't remember exactly, I think she was probably thirteen or so, what we found out, and she came and
talked to us about it. None of her friends were texting each other anymore. And early on we even we even kept up with who her contacts were in her phone to make sure that there weren't random people or anything else. And we would talk about that. It was only her close friend, the people we knew. But what she came and said is nobody's texting each other anymore. All of her friends had Snapchat and that's how they communicated. And although Snapchat is a social media, it's really a glorified texting. I mean, it's a group text with pictures. It's the same thing you can do on on texting. So we let her have that. And then Instagram, she won that so badly. She did and and again, there's nothing scientific, but I've listened to a lot of people and some psychologists and other people, and it was nothing scientific. But sixteen seems to be, and there's a lot of things around sixteen. When you listen to a lot of social media companies, I've listened to a bunch of different people talk about it. Sixteen seems to be a level of maturity. We kind of trust them to drive cars. That obviously there's something to that age that we decide they can get in a car and drive it down the road and and do that responsibly. and so we let her have Instagram at sixteen. And again, I she's nineteen and she's in college, she's not a Grown adult with a job yet, so I don't know if this experiment works. So don't anybody take my advice and think it's necessarily gonna work, but that seemed to work well. we we really had no issues with her bullying anyone. She didn't have any of that. And and I'm gonna end with kind of what I think about none of this has anything to do with social media. That's that's my final remark. But we did that. Then ironically with Kaylee, so Claire got her phone at twelve. Kaylee got hers at eight. So yeah,
Randy Blair: No, yeah.
carl: kids are different. At that time, Claire would stare at her phone for hours and hours and you know you'd have to make her get off of it. She probably would not even eat. Kaylee kind of used it as a tool. We gave it to her. Hers was fully locked down, had nothing on it, but we were dropping her off at soccer practice and all, like, hey, we would like you to have a phone so you can call us and we can call you. and then well, ironically, Claire started advocating for Kaylee to get Snapchat and things. So I I think Kaylee, she's fifteen now. I think she got Snapchat at twelve. And Claire has been, she's 15, she's got a few more months before she becomes 16. She still doesn't have Instagram. And even Claire's been on us to try to do it. I'm like, nope, not doing it. And again, there's nothing magic about 16, but I think it's just an interesting age and it worked with one. so, you know, is all that perfect? What we try to do is we said it's the world that these teenagers live in. It's a different world than what we understand. And helping them kind of w it just like driving a car, you know Just we've talked about guns being tools.
Social media is a tool. It can't do anything on its own. But helping kind of train them and help them navigate that and parent through that to enter the world in which they're ultimately gonna live and they're gonna be able to, whether they're, you know, fifteen or sixteen or eighteen or twenty. Because even from the ages of twenty one to twenty five, your brain's not developed. And so if you just jump in the social media world then, I don't know that it's any healthier than at 14, 15, and 16. It's just a different set of issues. but I really think, you know, just my opinion for whatever it's worth, again, just like I said earlier, I think these things have made parenting harder. It hasn't created a a new set of problems other than the cameras and some of the pictures that don't go away. That's an issue. but in general, it's made it all harder. I think it's more it it's put more pressure on being a parent, being present. And man, you gotta listen to your kids. It's made another way to have to keep up with them, but it's no different. My dad used to listen to what I said, and he listened to what my brother said, and he figured out what we were doing just by listening to what we said. and and I love it. I was bringing Claire or Kaylee and two of her friends home from Young Life last night and took them home. And they don't think that I can hear. Like there's a petition and I'm driving a limo and it's soundproof. and it's awesome because they just talk and you just listen and then later I'm like, hey.
Randy Blair: Mm-hmm.
carl: So and so said that. What what was that about? You know, like, yeah, yeah. It and and again, they don't think much about it. So if you just listen to your kids and you're present, other the other thing, there's a really good life hack. So there is a benefit to your kids getting Instagram when they're fifteen, sixteen, somewhere in there, and their friends are getting it sooner. Well, if their friends get it sooner, they know that they probably look at yours. So all of their friends will end up following you on Instagram. And then
Randy Blair: Ha ha.
carl: they don't remember that you're friends with them on there. And then you get to see things later that they're doing. And then you can say, hey, what's going on there? So I would encourage anybody
Randy Blair: Mm-hmm.
carl: who's giving their kids social media to also be on social media and follow your kid, you know. And if your kid won't let you be their friend, you probably have a problem. but participate in it, you know, understand what's going on and watch what their friends are doing and see what they're posting and don't be afraid to to dive in with them and and mix it up a little bit. So Again, I don't I don't think social media is the evil problem. I think and we could do a whole we could do a whole 50 part series on parenting. But to me, you know, it's similar to what we talked about with education. It's a participation sport. It's not a hands off, drop your kids off
and hope for the best. It's kind of the thing the same thing with with parenting and social media and everything else. It's a participation sport. And if you think you're gonna give your kid a phone and you're not gonna pay any more attention to them for the next 10 years and your phone's gonna raise them. You're gonna problems. I think you gotta be really active and it is it harder? I think so. is it inherently evil? I don't think it's Satan. I don't think it's the case. I think it's being used for evil, just like guns and cars and other things can be used to do evil things. but I think you gotta parent, you gotta be present, you gotta work through it, and you gotta figure it out and you gotta, you know, and I think the main thing too is continuing to verbalize the consequences of some of these bad decisions with it. And, you know, probably the biggest thing with social media is, and whatever genius sat in a a meeting one day and said, Hey, I got a great idea. Why don't we put a camera on a phone? And they all probably looked at that person and said, You're the dumbest thing ever. That will never work. And now it works. I'm glad that didn't exist when I was in high school and college. we did dumb
Randy Blair: Yeah.
carl: we did dumb things. We just didn't document it because it it seems to be a teenage early twenty somethings condition that doing dumb things should be photographed and shared with others. but the realization that those pictures don't ever go away. Even on Snapchat where they supposedly, you know, they're these things are disappearing and they're temporary messages. Yeah, screenshots are a real thing. So they they do stay around. So I think there's some long term effects that can happen of it, but man, you just got a parent. Make make sure the kids understand and Yes, free will or and and decision making is still a real thing and they can go sideways. But I think it's made it harder. I think you've got to be closer and participate with your kids. and it's again, it's different for every kid. You know, what does that look like? It's different for every family, just like whether your kids are gonna go to public school or private school. It it's perfectly within a family's rights to say we're not doing any social media ever. Okay, cool. That that's fine. You know, that's that's another option. I don't know if that's better or worse. They're gonna get bullied for not having social media or a a phone. So, you know, it's it's a it's a dance and a balance.
Randy Blair: You know, it's interesting as I was preparing this and thinking about, you know, really thinking about this issue from the perspective of of being a parent and how we all, I think most all of us as parents want to protect our children. We want them to have good productive lives. I recalled something when when Ali graduated from University of Alabama. And we were down, you know, celebrating with family and friends. And she and I had a chance to kind of get aside a little bit. Actually, they're on the campus after the graduation ceremony. And she said, you know, she said, she said, there are she said nothing in my life ever hurt me more than when I felt like I disappointed you and mom. And she said, I know that there were times when I did disappoint you. She said there were times when I thought I hated you and probably acted like I hated you. But she said, you know, she said, you guys being proud of me was the most important thing that I ever did. And she said, as much as possible it it kind of guided the decisions I made and the things that I did and that sort of thing. And I would like to say that, well, that's because I'm a brilliant father. I'm just smarter than most parents. You know, I I I knew all this. And it had absolutely nothing to do with this because we adopted her when I was 60. I didn't know anything. I mean, I was old, but I didn't know anything about parenting. but the one thing that I did from the time that we first brought her home at 16 months from Cambodia, every night I would pray that God would prepare. Would protect my daughter and instruct me in how to be a good father. And I'm not saying I always listened and I always accomplished that, but it was an every night thing for her entire life and it still is. And I honestly believe that if we make that commitment as parents, even though we may fail from time to time, that God honors that and that God helps to not only protect, but to guide our children and to guide our relationships with them. And I don't know of anything else certainly I can't think of anything that trumps that in terms of an approach to take. And it's something that I certainly would throw out there to our listeners
carl: Yeah. Well
Randy Blair: to to consider.
carl: Yeah, we're turning into a parenting thing, which again I think at the root of this is not a social media thing. I think when you dig down, it's probably a parenting challenge more than it's a social media challenge. it's it feels like all of our podcasts take a twist now. Our our audience is gonna think we do this on purpose. We start out with one topic and it's like Paul Harvey and we give you the rest of the
Randy Blair: Mm.
carl: story of what the real thing was. But no, I think that's true. And and I was telling I was telling somebody at lunch yesterday. and I think what you said is absolutely right. And and it I look at leaders in my career. the the ones who did not rant and rave and yell, it's the ones who were quiet professionals that I respected. It's exactly what you just said. I didn't want to disappoint them. You know, I didn't need them to say much to me. I knew if we didn't do the right thing, they were disappointed. That bothered me. It was the same way with my parents. I mean, I didn't want to I didn't want to ever hurt my parents' reputation. My parents were very well respected in in our small community. Dad had his own business. Mom's a teacher. They were both very well thought of. They worked
very hard to have their reputation. And I didn't want to screw that up. Not to say that I didn't do stupid things that I wasn't wise at 14, 15, 16, 17 years old and thought about that every time we went out of boy, I can't screw up our reputation. But it was in my head. and then I was telling somebody this two days ago, and I've said it a lot. And I've also heard very smart pastors and biblical scholars to say that what I'm about to say is wrong and you shouldn't do it, but I don't care. It's what I've done. my relationship with my earthly father heavily influenced my perception of who God is and my relationship with God in a very simplistic way. I believe that my earthly father would have killed me if need be. sometimes I felt like he was trying to. He didn't But I also knew that my dad would take a bullet for me. just like God, if I get sideways, I believe I can walk out on my front lawn on a sunny day and a lightning bolt could take me out if need be for whatever reason. And he gave his son for me. You know, so I I you know, when you really look at that, and I think that's a problem. Again, we're we're segueing into a parenting seminar now. I think too many people Take parenting as a hands-off thing. It's hard. It's the hardest freaking thing I've ever done. It's the most rewarding thing I've ever done. You know, it's the most fun thing I've ever done. It can be all those things in 15 minutes. It can cover all three of those. but it's hard and it's a commitment. And if you're gonna have a kid, then you should put everything you have into it because there is nothing else left on this planet where we're gone other than kids. And so all of that, it's like social media's made it harder, but man, just participate, be there, work through it, figure it out, do the hard things. Don't just Hand your kids a phone and a car and say good luck and hope for the best. That's not gonna work out well. And and I think there is a piece where there's a time, and I heard somebody say this one time: your kids don't want you to be their friends. They want you to be their parents. They need you to be an authority figure. They don't understand you trying to be their friends. When they're 25 and beyond, you can be their friend. Their brain will be developed and they can understand it. But zero to twenty five. be their freaking parent and discipline them and and provide them structure. That's what they need. That's what this whole discussion we're having, that's what it needs. It needs structure. It needs parenting. And I do think, and some people could say it's harsh or whatever, but I had a fear of my dad because I knew and by golly,
Randy Blair: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
carl: if he said he was going to do it, he would freaking do it. And and my mom was the loving, nurturing one, but I had a healthy respect and fear for her too.
Randy Blair: Ha ha.
carl: But dad was the one I knew that man, if I really got sideways, it was going to be bad for me. But again, he would lay down his life for me. And and I never doubted that. And it was that dichotomy that and I and I've talked about this on one of our previous podcasts, but I had friends who weren't fortunate enough to have that parenting situation. And their parents were very hands off and let the kids do whatever. And the the friends and I did some of the same stupid things. And the whole time we were doing something. In my mind, it's like, man, if we do this and we get caught, my parent, my dad's gonna leave me in jail for however long until he decides
Randy Blair: Mm-hmm.
carl: I need to get out. and then when he gets me out, it's gonna be worse than whatever happened there. And that was what is in my head. So not that I wasn't necessarily doing all of it, but it's the proverbs, right? Trying to put child child in the way you should
Randy Blair: Mm-hmm.
carl: go. And you know, you run in the ditch a little bit, but you know where the road is and you're gonna get back. I always knew what was right, I always knew what was wrong, what I should and should be doing. Whether I was perfectly abiding by that or not, I knew. But I had friends who we could be doing the same thing in their mind, that never entered their mind. The where the paved road was and what was in the ditch and way off the road didn't matter. You know, if they got arrested, their parents would come get them out, they'd be fine. And whoever arrested them or did something, they were the problem. And I think, you know, all that said to circle back. A lot of people are blaming social media for what's going on with their kids. I I don't know absent social media if the kids would be perfect anyway. And again, that's because you got free will and decision making and kids do, but parenting's hard. It's made it harder. It's a full on, full contact participation sport that takes a lot of energy, you know, and I don't so I don't again, there's positives of social
Randy Blair: You it's
carl: media, there's negatives. I think if we killed all social media today, I don't think humanity's necessarily better.
Randy Blair: You just said something that made me think of something that's off the top of my head, I think it's right. But the second most difficult thing to tell your child, and at the same time, the second most important thing to tell your child is no. And the first thing that can be the most difficult thing to tell your child. depending on circumstances. And that is at the same time the most important thing to tell your child is I love you. And if you can do both of those things and do that second one with the love that you have in that first thing, it'll go a long way. And once again, I have known wonderful, wonderful parents who did everything that appeared to be right and things didn't work out well. with their children. It happens. They have
carl: That's right. Yep. Yes.
Randy Blair: their free will. But but you're right. I think it is a parenting issue. Yeah.
carl: Just like we do with God. I mean, right?
God could make it where we all abide by everything and we're all little biblical scholars and we walk around and treat each other great and we love our God with our all of our heart, soul, mind, and strength and love our neighbors. We could all be commanded to do that and do it. It's not the way God set up the the world. And so there is free will, just like God lets us do it our ultimately the kids have the same thing. They you know, we we can't make them into little toy soldiers that are are perfect. They're the free will. So Yeah, I don't want people to think we're saying, you know, if you're if your kid does something wrong, you suck as a parent. 'Cause that's not true either. There's there's clearly great humans who worked really hard at being parents and and had a lot of challenges and things go off the rails. That's that is also an outcome.
Randy Blair: Well, you know Carl, this is mean, this has been good. This has been good. And I don't you know, I'm not sure we came up with with concrete answers. Certainly we didn't come up with technical answers or regulatory answers for this issue. You know. But you know, one of the things that
carl: I don't think there are any though. I don't I don't I d I really don't think there are any.
Randy Blair: is being one of the things that's being touted, at least on the technical side of these things, is the utilization of AI to create guardrails and and that sort of thing. Which kind of leads us into what we've talked about looking at next week, which is a an issue that has really come to the forefront now in the media and you know on the hill from among our congressional representation. And that is AI. And what is it? What can it do? What are its powers? does it do do there need to be guardrails in place? who administers those? What do you do with AI? Do you restrict access to it? These these are all questions that are being foisted about there that no one seems to have any real answers. And I think it's it's something that we certainly can can take a look at from the perspective of those of us who are going to be affected by it one way or the other. and once again, I I I doubt I know I don't have the answers. Heck, I barely understand it. But I
carl: Yeah.
Randy Blair: do know that you and I were. five years ago, six years ago, we were dabbling with AI, not only early days of chat GPT, but you know, within the confines of our our workplace and that sort of thing. And I know it has grown tremendously and you guys at T T GI are taking it to the next level. so I'm I'm interested in getting your perspective and us kicking that around a little bit and Seeing what we do know, don't know, what we fear, what we don't fear, and maybe how we should approach it as individuals, because it's here and it's
carl: Yeah.
Randy Blair: not going away.
carl: Nope. And I was joking at lunch today. I used to say I wasn't worried about AI killing me because my cell phone can't kill me. It's not possible. but I drive a Tesla Cybertruck now that is controlled by a bunch
Randy Blair: Ha ha ha.
carl: of cameras and AI in rush hour traffic. it has no linkage between the steering wheel and the steering. It is all electronic. So I have to be very nice to Grok in my car when I talk to it and I say yes, ma'am, and thank you and Because
Randy Blair: Ha ha.
carl: if they're keeping records and and Groc wants to kill me, it can run me into a wall at 100 miles an hour. So it but it's been
Randy Blair: Right.
carl: I'm I'm very excited about talking about it. I mean, I I use AI a lot. we're developing AI at work and I drive a car that's controlled by AI. And it it is unbelievable how fast it's going. I bought my truck in November,
Randy Blair: Mm.
carl: so we're not not a year away yet. And it is night and day different than what it was when I bought it. and it's and it's the training of the models. There were, I think, eight eight and a half billion combined miles with Tesla full self driving in November of last year. It's fifteen billion now. And they're learning, you know, as it goes. So the the acceleration, we were talking about this today at work. If you look back, you know, and you and I were talking about when we started looking at proposals and different things with AI, that hasn't been that long ago. And what's happened From then to now is like two different things. It's not even the same thing. And then you look back a month, two months, even in the year 2026, the the increased just hyper speed of development right now is is unbelievable. And I think a lot of people are scared of it. a lot of people are confused, a lot of people don't understand. which leads us back to our liberties and freedoms we talked about is every time people get a afraid, what happens? some regulations are coming that'll screw us over the next thirty years. So we're probably on the precipice precipice of some really good regulation. But yeah, I look forward to talking about it.
Randy Blair: Yeah. Well, you're certainly seeing it firsthand, yeah, that advancement and that development on that front is I mean, it's exponential. and is
carl: Yeah. It is. It really is.
Randy Blair: and is going to continue to be so for who knows decades.
carl: Yes. Yeah.
Randy Blair: certainly probably long after we're gone. So I think it it merits at least a discussion, if nothing else. Maybe we can feel a little better or we may come out of it feeling a little worse. I don't know. But I I look
carl: Yeah, that'll be fun.
Randy Blair: forward to it anyway.
carl: Absolutely.
Randy Blair: Well listen, thanks. This has really been good and I'm kinda glad my daughter is approaching twenty six and kind of now responsible for whatever social media gets her into.
carl: The good news is her her brain, at least physiologically, should be fully developed. That's a twenty five and sooner in female. So she's she's on the better side of that. She's got a career. I think you've I think you get the trophy. You've you've gotten to the good part of it now, so
Randy Blair: hopefully I can kick back and just enjoy it now. So we'll see. of course that
carl: Yeah, yeah.
Randy Blair: that's always true until the grandkids come along. Then you go through the same thing again, same concerns.
carl: Hey, that no, that's the easy part because you get to do the fun part. You said something earlier that I used to tell mom and dad. I would we would go pick up the girls after a weekend with mom and dad. they're hanging out with grandma and grandpa, and I'd say, How were the girls? And mom would always, they were so good. Yeah, because you didn't say one time the whole weekend that two letter word that sends them into a different mindset. If you don't ever say no to a child, you know what? They're awesome. Yeah, so that's
Randy Blair: Right. Yeah, right.
carl: That's the good news of grandkids. You don't ever have to tell them no. Everything's yes. Would you like would you like some M's for breakfast? Yeah, that'd be great. How about Kate? Yep, for lunch. That'll be great. Before bed? Sure. Maybe
Randy Blair: 'Cause after a little yeah, 'cause just after a while you get to hand them right back to mom and dad and they can deal with the consequences. So
carl: It when they get to be a problem, it's like, Hey, congratulations, you get back now. So that's the beautiful thing of it. That's the payoff. Good. This was fun.
Randy Blair: All right. Well, listen, you have a a great week and look forward to next week. All
carl: Yes, sir. Enjoyed it.
Randy Blair: right, take care now.