رونوشت 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:03.279
There's something beautiful about being optimistic with technologies.
00:00:03.439 --> 00:00:07.679
There's something really gross about being ahistorical with technology, right?
00:00:07.759 --> 00:00:10.400
And that's what is bothersome right now.
00:00:24.800 --> 00:00:33.039
Hello and welcome to Tech Won't Save Us, a podcast that wonders why the government seems to be more reliant on tech giants with every crisis that passes.
00:00:33.280 --> 00:00:36.640
I'm your host, Paris Marks, and today I'll be talking to Bianca Wiley.
00:00:36.880 --> 00:00:45.439
Bianca is the co-founder of Digital Public and Tech Resech Canada, and she's also a senior fellow at the Center for International Governance Innovation.
00:00:45.679 --> 00:00:49.200
You can follow her on Twitter where her handle is at Bianca Wiley.
00:00:49.359 --> 00:01:04.640
We talked about the problem with how governments are responding to COVID-19 by centering tech companies and tech solutions instead of investing more in public services and ensuring that we have a robust uh social uh structure in place to help people who are falling through the crap.
00:01:05.280 --> 00:01:07.359
I really think you're going to like this conversation.
00:01:07.760 --> 00:01:09.439
So make sure to listen the whole way through.
00:01:10.000 --> 00:01:16.079
And obviously, if you like it, when it's all said and done, please leave a five-star review on Apple Podcasts.
00:01:16.319 --> 00:01:20.640
That really helps where the podcast is new and only launched in the past few weeks.
00:01:21.280 --> 00:01:22.799
Thanks so much and enjoy the interview.
00:01:23.439 --> 00:01:25.680
Bianca Wiley, welcome to Tech Won's Save Us.
00:01:26.079 --> 00:01:27.120
Hello, thanks for having me.
00:01:27.760 --> 00:01:38.879
A few weeks ago, the government of Canada announced that they have made a deal with Amazon to kind of manage the logistics of delivering their emergency supplies around the country.
00:01:39.040 --> 00:01:45.680
So when you read that story and sort of the very few details that have come out since, what has kind of been your reaction?
00:01:46.159 --> 00:01:47.519
Yeah, a couple points.
00:01:47.680 --> 00:01:54.400
I think the first one was reminiscent actually of something that was sidewalk Toronto as well, was when it was announced.
00:01:54.560 --> 00:02:07.519
The prime minister announced it and sort of announced we're doing a deal with Amazon Canada in the middle of this emergency and sort of looked like just be happy now, because I said that, right?
00:02:07.680 --> 00:02:16.479
Like it was sort of this like that there's somehow like a normative good associated with that announcement, which is exactly the way I remember the sidewalk Toronto thing.
00:02:16.560 --> 00:02:22.400
It was sort of like, you know, when a let's say a cat brings you a dead animal kind of thing, like a hey, look what I've got.
00:02:22.479 --> 00:02:27.919
And then, you know, it would be perceived differently dependent on where you'd be situated to the announcement.
00:02:28.159 --> 00:02:40.400
Um, and so that was that was the first thing was was the sort of that that the that the announcement was like without detail was supposed to be something that was good news, but it it had no details in it.
00:02:40.479 --> 00:02:43.439
It was just we're working with Amazon Canada, be happy.
00:02:43.599 --> 00:03:11.439
So I find that interesting because I think it's that power of Amazon Canada, sort of the the idea that the brand is somehow now something that you know gets political endorsement from the federal government of Canada, which was on the heels of the Amazon incident with Chris Smalls, where they had a uh, you know, there were there were leaked notes about the executives at Amazon, including their general counsel, um, smearing a worker.
00:03:11.840 --> 00:03:17.840
And it's one of those moments where you where you're like, wow, so that happens, that's making news.
00:03:18.000 --> 00:03:26.400
And then I turn to our federal government, and that's the brand that they're expecting us to be happy that we're doing some sort of pandemic uh reaction with, right?
00:03:26.639 --> 00:03:27.199
It's wild.
00:03:27.439 --> 00:03:28.240
It's wild to me.
00:03:28.319 --> 00:03:30.479
It's wild because it's just suck and blow, right?
00:03:30.560 --> 00:03:35.759
It's like, it's like, well, here it's like you're holding two completely conflicting moments.
00:03:36.000 --> 00:03:38.319
Um, and so so those were two things.
00:03:38.479 --> 00:03:45.840
And I think the third thing for me was that there was this sort of immediate flurry of why aren't we using Canada Post?
00:03:46.080 --> 00:04:01.680
And because they hadn't released enough details around what the thing was, because they later or in subsequent uh publication that day explained that they were going to be working with Canada Post and others, but it was almost like they sort of create this confusion by not being clear.
00:04:01.919 --> 00:04:15.039
But then what happens is because the flurry goes around sort of the logistics and its relationship to this sort of what people think of when they think of Amazon, then the thing that nobody's talking about is okay, hold on.
00:04:15.199 --> 00:04:17.439
You're saying they're doing this deal at cost.
00:04:17.680 --> 00:04:26.399
You're saying you're using their online store, you're saying nothing about what they're getting access to that has all kinds of intangible value, right?
00:04:26.639 --> 00:04:32.000
So I saw this thread, I wish I could find it on Twitter a couple of weeks ago, which was about the United States Postal Service.
00:04:32.160 --> 00:04:46.079
And somewhere in the middle of it was this really specific example of like the amount of information and uh like logistics, uh, both information that is held by the institution, you know, there's a bit a lot of institutional knowledge there.
00:04:46.160 --> 00:04:52.959
Load full transcript
Just that's just one strand of it of what is known when you get to look into and over systems, right?
00:04:53.120 --> 00:04:54.160
So that's just one.
00:04:54.399 --> 00:05:00.000
Never mind what is Amazon Canada now privy to throughout Canada's response to this.
00:05:00.160 --> 00:05:02.319
Like what is it, what is it getting access to?
00:05:02.480 --> 00:05:05.040
What information and knowledge is it getting access to?
00:05:05.199 --> 00:05:08.879
And it's being framed as like we're doing you a favor, Canada.
00:05:09.199 --> 00:05:09.519
Right?
00:05:09.680 --> 00:05:20.160
So I mean, I think these are these pieces where just between the rhetoric and the narrative and the like what's missing and then the not clarity on what it is, there's not history of the tender.
00:05:20.240 --> 00:05:21.360
I can't get a number.
00:05:21.519 --> 00:05:22.720
I mean, it could go either way.
00:05:22.800 --> 00:05:25.279
It could be a number, it could be like almost nothing.
00:05:25.360 --> 00:05:29.920
And that then they get to say, oh, look, we're doing this, you know, the sort of idea of doing something at cost.
00:05:30.160 --> 00:05:32.800
So there's just there's a lot in there that's missing.
00:05:33.040 --> 00:05:39.279
And, you know, again, it just sort of fades into the background because no one is sharing details.
00:05:39.360 --> 00:05:50.639
And the last, the, the last thing I'll say here, there was a um an article about it, which, and it's common, but it it basically said that the the details of that tender were were covered under the Privacy Act.
00:05:50.800 --> 00:05:53.920
So you can't get access to what it is.
00:05:54.480 --> 00:05:55.600
So here we are.
00:05:55.759 --> 00:05:58.399
Just be just be happy and believe that it's good for us.
00:05:58.560 --> 00:06:08.399
Like this is such a, this is again, like not the way of a government that's talking about being open and being, you know, like for me, these are these are always the same issues with governments.
00:06:08.480 --> 00:06:11.680
It's like you're in, you're always making hard decisions.
00:06:12.160 --> 00:06:13.839
Explain what you're doing.
00:06:14.000 --> 00:06:14.879
Show your work.
00:06:15.040 --> 00:06:17.279
Like if it's defensible, no problem.
00:06:17.519 --> 00:06:21.279
But don't just do the like, well, we're just leaving all this stuff out.
00:06:21.439 --> 00:06:23.519
Um, so that's those, those are my pieces there.
00:06:23.600 --> 00:06:25.279
There's really unfortunately not enough.
00:06:25.360 --> 00:06:29.120
I'm gonna keep trying to find stuff out about what that contract is.
00:06:29.279 --> 00:06:35.759
Um, all that I know is that it was, you know, through the COVID-19 response sort of action that the government is undertaking.
00:06:35.839 --> 00:06:38.639
So there's an entire suite of tenders related to this.
00:06:38.720 --> 00:06:48.560
And I think there's definitely like open contracting and others are watching this because how these tenders are going down um in the middle of crisis is something that definitely needs more attention.
00:06:48.879 --> 00:06:53.680
I'm not surprised at all that these contracts are kind of covered by the Privacy Act, right?
00:06:53.759 --> 00:06:59.120
Because we see the same thing when, say, like Uber makes deals with municipalities and stuff like that, right?
00:06:59.279 --> 00:07:05.439
All of a sudden we can't know anything about it because uh it they're dealing with this private company, blah, blah, blah, right?
00:07:05.680 --> 00:07:05.839
Right.
00:07:06.000 --> 00:07:07.759
Um, so it's really frustrating.
00:07:07.920 --> 00:07:19.439
And it presents these larger questions as we consider because as you say, this is just one part of a larger uh effort by governments to uh respond to the COVID-19 pandemic, right?
00:07:20.319 --> 00:07:34.399
And increasingly I feel like we're seeing uh this response shifting toward kind of like a technological framing, especially when we're considering things like uh contract tracing and how to keep track of where people are going.
00:07:34.879 --> 00:07:46.959
Um there's this uh this growing uh effort to kind of frame it in a way where these are things that are going to be handled by our smartphones, um technology can solve these problems for us.
00:07:47.439 --> 00:08:00.000
Um and they often leave out these larger details or seem not to consider uh these larger issues of uh like the broader effects of uh these technological solutions to the COVID-19 problem, right?
00:08:00.560 --> 00:08:16.800
Um So when it comes to the efforts of tech companies and governments to use technology to respond to COVID-19 uh with contact tracing or in other ways that you've noticed, um, what are you seeing with that and what concerns do you have with the way that's playing out?
00:08:17.120 --> 00:08:29.040
Yeah, um, and well, well framed, um, because a lot of concerns, a lot of them really have to do with the lack of political imagination that is being shown here.
00:08:29.199 --> 00:08:34.720
So I'll start by saying that there's this persistent uh social problem we have.
00:08:35.039 --> 00:08:42.960
We being, you know, I would say people who aren't in control of how governments are defining the use of technology in society or companies.
00:08:43.039 --> 00:08:56.159
Um, and that's happening, you know, they're doing that together, um, where the public response is always framed as sort of mitigating or defending against the worst version of a thing.
00:08:56.399 --> 00:08:59.120
And, you know, so so with the contact tracing app, right?
00:08:59.279 --> 00:09:12.080
It's someone and a lot of technologists too, and a lot of, you know, policy and legal professionals as well, sort of decide that there's an inevitability to it, and then go in with that frame.
00:09:12.159 --> 00:09:14.000
And I don't think it comes from malice.
00:09:14.080 --> 00:09:16.240
I think it's very well-intentioned, I get it.
00:09:16.399 --> 00:09:23.120
But what happens when you put so much force into that frame is to me, this is how you solidify the status quo.
00:09:23.279 --> 00:09:30.240
So I'm finding it very frustrating that you're having some beautiful, encouraging, and I mean amidst a time of dire crisis.
00:09:30.320 --> 00:09:33.919
Like this is a, there is so much pain right now every day.
00:09:34.080 --> 00:09:38.320
But in that, there is this sort of discussion of the, you know, there's a portal.
00:09:38.399 --> 00:09:46.480
This is our Randadi Royce, you know, like the sort of what what what could what could the next version of things look like and it's not like before?
00:09:46.639 --> 00:09:55.759
And the only way to think more that way is to be defining and designing how we're using our technologies into the future.
00:09:56.000 --> 00:10:08.480
And so I think like the the first thing for me is this sort of frustration at well-meaning people that their lack of political imagination is now defining my reality, you know, because they're holding power.
00:10:08.639 --> 00:10:17.200
And I think this is like for me, it always goes back over and over and over again to the power of rhetoric and narrative, but also how do we dislodge the status quo?
00:10:17.440 --> 00:10:21.120
And I don't mean to say that as a pejorative, I and I know some people do.
00:10:21.279 --> 00:10:28.799
I'm saying it as like more of the same coming from more of the same with more of the same frame and more of the same power.
00:10:29.039 --> 00:10:30.240
You're getting more of the same.
00:10:30.399 --> 00:10:32.480
Like they're this, this is all you're gonna get to, right?
00:10:32.639 --> 00:10:39.840
And so I feel like sometimes it's more that it's the it's the opportunity cost of a lot of these things, right?
00:10:39.919 --> 00:10:43.759
It's not always to say that the thing you get, and this is a smart city question as well.
00:10:43.919 --> 00:10:46.879
It's not to say the thing you get is necessarily the worst thing in the world.
00:10:46.960 --> 00:10:47.759
It's not that.
00:10:47.919 --> 00:10:57.039
It's that you then lose all of the opportunity to do 17, 20, 9,000 other things, you know, however many variants of different, you know, things you could do.
00:10:57.200 --> 00:10:57.440
Right.
00:10:57.600 --> 00:11:01.279
Um, and that that loss is what hurts, right?
00:11:01.440 --> 00:11:05.840
And so I think this sort of inevitability, like this is the thing.
00:11:06.000 --> 00:11:19.120
Like this, this also this focus, like with the with the technology of the contact tracing app, it's one of so many different ways you could use technology to respond to people, right?
00:11:19.279 --> 00:11:30.000
Like, let's think about the fact that for decades, I mean, in where I live in Toronto, Nasma Ahmed at Digital Justice Lab, always talking about access to the internet, access to the internet, right?
00:11:30.080 --> 00:11:31.759
So you got everybody at home now.
00:11:32.000 --> 00:11:34.159
What are
the good things that could be done?
00:11:34.320 --> 00:11:39.120
What are the equity conversations to have about access, you know, to digital services?
00:11:39.279 --> 00:11:44.799
And how would we be replicating what's, you know, currently a divide by bringing in some of these technologies?
00:11:44.960 --> 00:11:47.039
Like it just replicates what's here now.
00:11:47.279 --> 00:12:04.000
So I think, I think the challenge for a lot of us who are maybe like critical of some technologies is also talking, you know, just realizing how we're not talking about all the different ways we could be using tech to support needs, to get in and support people, to make sure people get money they need easily.
00:12:04.080 --> 00:12:06.480
Like this is a digital service moment for governments.
00:12:06.559 --> 00:12:09.519
Like there's so many ways to support each other with technology.
00:12:09.679 --> 00:12:20.399
So the idea that we're like drowning ourselves in time on this one like one little version of the technology, efficacy isn't even the conversation we have.
00:12:20.480 --> 00:12:22.559
Like this is the same problem in the smart city.
00:12:22.720 --> 00:12:26.559
It's not no one's even talking about what the thing's even doing.
00:12:26.799 --> 00:12:30.480
The whole conversation is about, you know, minimizing privacy problems.
00:12:30.559 --> 00:12:37.519
And I'm not saying that's not one of the things, but it's like, wow, how do you get so far down this really, really narrow path?
00:12:37.679 --> 00:12:39.759
And then what are all the things you don't talk about?
00:12:39.840 --> 00:12:40.080
Right.
00:12:40.240 --> 00:12:42.399
And so there's a lot to say in there.
00:12:42.559 --> 00:12:45.600
I mean, I think my heart broke the other day.
00:12:45.679 --> 00:12:50.399
Like there's things that I don't have great um mental tools to deal with.
00:12:50.480 --> 00:12:53.679
And the one of the ones that happened to me yesterday, I have two children.
00:12:53.840 --> 00:12:56.960
I had a little moment, and many people at home with kids are having.
00:12:57.039 --> 00:12:58.080
Like it's challenging, right?
00:12:58.159 --> 00:13:02.480
You're at home with your kids, you're trying to do all the things like you were doing before in some cases.
00:13:02.799 --> 00:13:09.279
And then you start to think about children that are in homes that there's where there's violence in the home.
00:13:09.600 --> 00:13:20.879
And now their one little window of time where they were maybe out of that home with you know, with people who care about them at schools or other institutions, um, is gone.
00:13:21.440 --> 00:13:30.879
And so where are we spending our money on the shelter capacity and that like the spaces for people to just like tomorrow morning be better?
00:13:31.120 --> 00:13:40.480
Like, is that like how how do we turn the volume down on these extremely obvious, you know, problems that we know how to resolve?
00:13:40.559 --> 00:13:51.360
And then we're
turning the volume way up on these kinds of, you know, technologies or solutions for things that no one's even saying the people who back those apps that they're gonna solve the thing on its own.
00:13:51.519 --> 00:14:05.120
Like it's that's not even the idea, but just the political energy and attention and the headlines and the debate about that um is completely eclipsing where we should be focusing a lot of our energy and time to like help people tomorrow morning, right?
00:14:05.200 --> 00:14:06.399
Like those are things we know.
00:14:06.559 --> 00:14:23.039
And so I would just, you know, end that point on saying that the scarcity of our politics right now are so dangerous because it makes everybody want to just have that narrative that, well, like, well, we should do this thing because they know that they don't have the resources to do the things we should be doing.
00:14:23.279 --> 00:14:25.600
Or technically, you know, technically that's not true.
00:14:25.759 --> 00:14:36.960
But from the, you know, let's keep things in the status quo, you're in a scarcity mindset of saying, well, all of that stuff's super expensive, like public health infrastructure, testing, like all of the things that we should have.
00:14:37.200 --> 00:14:45.519
So you understand that political inclination to some sort of like technology that makes people feel like something's happening, but that's terrible, right?
00:14:45.600 --> 00:14:48.399
Like that's that's scary and that's what's playing out right now.
00:14:48.639 --> 00:14:51.120
So there's a lot of different bits and pieces in there.
00:14:51.279 --> 00:14:58.879
Um, I have another thought about sort of the the term luxury surveillance, which Chris Gilliard had has talked about a lot.
00:14:59.120 --> 00:14:59.440
Sure.
00:14:59.679 --> 00:15:01.679
He's hypervisible on Twitter.
00:15:01.919 --> 00:15:12.960
And um, he wrote about this idea of luxury surveillance with um smart city technology, you know, like the idea that you would welcome more surveillance technology because why not, right?
00:15:13.120 --> 00:15:19.919
Like if it means controlled access to your to your home or you know, surveillance that would be used on others, but not yourself.
00:15:20.080 --> 00:15:27.679
Um, so surveillance in that sort of administrative term, you might say, well, these are features that I enjoy because I'm safe from their harms.
00:15:28.000 --> 00:15:40.559
Um, I feel like that's you could take that concept and just pull it a little bit into this sort of app situation where you have people being like, Well, I understand there's a little bit of this issue, but you know, I'm okay with it.
00:15:40.639 --> 00:15:42.000
I'm gonna download it, right?
00:15:42.080 --> 00:15:44.720
Like I, and and I know who says things like that.
00:15:44.879 --> 00:15:58.320
Um, and then you think about people who are way more at risk if their phone becomes the sensor that could be used to define where they're allowed to go by the state, by police.
00:15:58.399 --> 00:16:01.360
Um we're we're in emergency measures times as well, right?
00:16:01.440 --> 00:16:11.039
So this gets all the way into military potential for like if if you really want to empower these devices that way, um, you have to think about what it means in, you know, in your daily life.
00:16:11.200 --> 00:16:15.919
And I think a lot of the voices that you hear that are saying, yeah, okay, well, I'll do it, no problem.
00:16:16.080 --> 00:16:24.080
It's because it's luxury surveillance to them, because they know when they walk into the hospital, they don't get questioned about whether, well, maybe you're having a panic attack.
00:16:24.240 --> 00:16:26.000
I don't know if you saw that story the other day.
00:16:26.240 --> 00:16:34.000
Black woman in America trying to get, you know, help, trying to get tested, and is not getting access to healthcare multiple times.
00:16:34.240 --> 00:16:36.720
And unfortunately, you know, she she died.
00:16:36.799 --> 00:16:38.399
And it's it's heartbreaking.
00:16:38.639 --> 00:16:55.279
So these technologies do not land in everybody's life the same way, you know, and I think that's the piece that also gets lost is you sort of get the sort of luxury surveillance people being the ones who are out saying, oh, it's fine, it's anonymous, it's decentralized, it's X, it's Y.
00:16:55.840 --> 00:16:58.639
Um, but that's not, you know, like so.
00:16:58.720 --> 00:17:09.519
Even if you're okay, you really, and I think this is this moment in our politics to understand like, how do you make sure that you don't just think about your context with these things?
00:17:09.680 --> 00:17:10.720
And I know that's hard.
00:17:10.799 --> 00:17:13.599
Like, I'm not trying to say that I'm always great at it.
00:17:13.759 --> 00:17:16.480
I'm the first one to say it's not the way I wake up in my life.
00:17:16.559 --> 00:17:19.119
It's like feeling my life through everybody else.
00:17:19.279 --> 00:17:20.960
Um, but it's work, you know?
00:17:21.039 --> 00:17:23.519
So I think sometimes we're not sure what our political work is.
00:17:23.680 --> 00:17:35.759
That's part of our political work is you got to show up as though it's not your luxury use, it's someone else's, like completely different, dangerous, dangerous, you know, life circumstance that this stuff can enable.
00:17:35.920 --> 00:17:49.039
Um, and I think that that has been too contained a space where it's like civil liberties people, you know, there's there's obviously people who've been fighting those fights forever, but how do you turn those fights mainstream?
00:17:49.200 --> 00:17:57.039
You know, like how do you make it so that that's the kind of argument that lots of people show up with and say, yeah, this might be fine for me, but it's not fine for my neighbor.
00:17:57.119 --> 00:17:58.480
And so, you know what, I'm not in.
00:17:58.559 --> 00:18:00.480
And that I'm gonna use my voice for that, right?
00:18:00.559 -->
00:18:04.240
Like that's that's part of our work with these sort of political technologies.
00:18:04.400 --> 00:18:05.519
Um, and it's not easy.
00:18:05.599 --> 00:18:09.039
So I'm just I'm not trying to say, like, oh, we should all just do this and it's obvious.
00:18:09.119 --> 00:18:13.440
Uh, but it's definitely, I think that it's instructive as to how we could be thinking more.
00:18:13.519 --> 00:18:22.720
And I think Chris's term there, like that sort of idea of a luxury luxury surveillance, really helps you think about wait a second, like how does this land?
00:18:22.799 --> 00:18:23.039
Right?
00:18:23.200 --> 00:18:25.680
Is this something I'm I'm comfortable with because I'm safe?
00:18:25.839 --> 00:18:26.079
Right.
00:18:26.160 --> 00:18:27.839
Like I think it's it's I it's helped me.
00:18:27.920 --> 00:18:34.240
So I think it was cool to see it kind of move in my mind from the smart city context to the health context, and it still applies.
00:18:34.640 --> 00:18:43.119
What you're saying kind of reminds me of um one of the slogans from the Bernie Sanders campaign when they were saying, like, fight for someone you don't know, right?
00:18:43.279 --> 00:18:44.799
Instead of just caring about yourself.
00:18:45.039 --> 00:18:46.559
And I feel like that's so important.
00:18:46.880 --> 00:19:00.240
Um and when we think about the inequities in cities, when we think about how there was this narrative in the early days of COVID-19 that kind of like everyone has like an equal risk from the virus, right?
00:19:00.640 --> 00:19:04.720
But we know very clearly that uh that risk is not equally distributed.
00:19:05.200 --> 00:19:11.519
Um there there are essential workers who are at much greater risk of contracting the virus.
00:19:11.920 --> 00:19:28.799
Um but but the early numbers that we're seeing out of the United States also show that it's racialized people who are being affected and poor people um who are contracting the virus and dying of the virus at a much greater rate than higher income and whiter people, right?
00:19:28.960 --> 00:19:37.920
And so I feel like uh focusing on these tech solutions uh kind of uh ignores these uh inequities that already exist.
00:19:38.079 --> 00:19:51.440
And and again, like uh as you were talking about with like do people even um like have the smartphone to take advantage of this uh service and like who is it actually going to benefit if uh it's made available?
00:19:52.000 --> 00:20:00.240
Um and I feel like we're not or or at least the people making these decisions don't seem to be uh asking these questions.
00:20:00.400 --> 00:20:14.480
Uh because again, it does seem like by making an app available for contact tracing or what have you, it's potentially benefiting the people who uh are already at uh lower risk of contracting the virus.
00:20:14.640 --> 00:20:24.319
Uh obviously there have already been these concerns that uh rich people were getting tested uh when other people were not, and were kind of paying for um access to tests.
00:20:24.640 --> 00:20:44.240
And there was a story the other day that uh there's even this like wealthy community down in San Francisco of these like tech elites and they not only paid to get themselves all tested, but then they uh like used their connections to get one of the universities to set up like a medical study in their community so they would keep getting like tested, right?
00:20:44.559 --> 00:20:56.160
So they get this like really privileged access uh to not only healthcare, but like the tests and everything else that everyone else uh really needs right now, and that should be uh available for everyone, not just the people who can pay for it.
00:20:56.319 --> 00:20:59.519
Uh like I said before, like it's just wild to see how this all plays out.
00:20:59.599 --> 00:21:16.799
Uh and I think your point about uh how uh the technology allows uh political leaders to uh kind of not so much focus on the political questions and like the questions of public services and are we funding our health services properly, are we funding our social services properly?
00:21:16.960 --> 00:21:27.119
Are we funding homes for domestic violence, homes for um like you know, children who are in danger, um getting homeless people off the streets and providing them with homes, right?
00:21:27.279 --> 00:21:32.400
Like all of these things don't seem to be getting as much attention because now we're gonna solve it with this new app.
00:21:32.720 --> 00:21:33.119
Exactly.
00:21:33.279 --> 00:21:45.279
And you you touched on a couple of things in there, and I think another piece to highlight um Jay Pitter, um, in, you know, she's in she's in Toronto, she's working all over the place in different cities uh in North America and elsewhere.
00:21:45.359 --> 00:21:49.599
Uh, she wrote a piece that uses the term forgotten densities.
00:21:49.839 --> 00:21:53.759
And I think for I know you got people around who are urbanists listening.
00:21:53.920 --> 00:22:19.599
Um, this is a fantastic piece because it really talks about it, it was sort of in response to, I won't try to summarize this piece, but just just the term to say there's density where, you know, whether it's like factory dorms, prisons, like super dense neighborhood where the the lodgings are super dense, you know, rooming houses, like so many different versions of this, and what the consequences are within these forgotten densities for the people living them.
00:22:19.680 --> 00:22:23.839
And in in in and so I'm taking that term because I would just, it's so helpful.
00:22:24.000 --> 00:22:34.960
Like I think it's another example of what comes next and reorganizing talks about cities and you know urbanism around ideas like this, because this is where it is, right?
00:22:35.039 --> 00:22:36.160
Like this is where it is.
00:22:36.400 --> 00:22:39.200
There's so much to do around this issue.
00:22:39.359 --> 00:22:53.599
And so in terms of how this intersects with the COVID
situation, there's also Nora Loretto, she's been tracking across Canada, the incidence of the COVID stuff in in seniors homes, another density, right?
00:22:53.759 --> 00:23:01.119
And so and so the thing is knowing how much is happening within these known densities, right?
00:23:01.200 --> 00:23:14.079
And some of them are institutional, whether it's um care homes, whether it's homes for I've seen lots of outbreaks popping up in like um homes that care for the disabled places where like you know where this problem is hitting people.
00:23:14.160 --> 00:23:20.880
Like you know and like you've also said forgotten densities like we know where this is hitting people in cities and we know where they like it's it's known.
00:23:21.119 --> 00:23:37.759
And so not putting your response directly to that is it's just it's it's immoral, frankly, because what the the idea of sort of coming up with an app when you already know your problem definition is not that.
00:23:37.920 --> 00:23:41.920
It's not the why it's not everybody at the same time with the same problem, right?
00:23:42.079 --> 00:23:51.200
So there's something there that's also quite politically you know unfortunate to see that like it's clear who is getting hit harder with this stuff.
00:23:51.359 --> 00:24:07.759
And it's also clear that the history of elevating and putting like testing right to your point, putting the tests to those communities as priority people for testing and containment of of this outbreak um that's not happening.
00:24:07.920 --> 00:24:10.400
And that's it's like the opposite of that is happening.
00:24:10.640 --> 00:24:20.559
So when you introduce a technology that if it's even at its best actor scenario just telling you where you should be testing and you're not even doing that properly, right?
00:24:20.640 --> 00:24:28.079
Like there's just so many dominoes there that it's there's something there's something beautiful about being optimistic with technologies.
00:24:28.240 --> 00:24:52.319
There's something really gross about being historical with technology right and that's what is bothersome right now is watching a whole bunch of people be like, well maybe for the first time ever we're going to use this thing in a way that like raises raises people up and we go right to where the need is highest and we prioritize you know the people that are suffering the most like that's not what that's not how this has gone before.
00:24:52.559 --> 00:24:54.240
Like now now we're it's gonna go that way.
00:24:54.400 --> 00:24:55.519
Like it's it's not there.
00:24:55.680 --> 00:25:19.839
And so I also think that this idea about the institutional layer of this is such an important one to flag because governments and institutions and government as an institution like knowing that you know the types of housing that are at higher risk, the types of care facilities that are at higher risk, the types of shelters where homeless people are staying and spending their time because that's their option right now, right?
00:25:19.920 --> 00:25:31.279
Like those are the spaces where you would go in and go quickly because you know you have an institutional relationship to those things in a way that you don't have the same one in a liberal democracy with every person.
00:25:31.519 --> 00:25:39.920
Like there's much more complexity in the relationship between the state and the individual in some ways than there is between these sort of institution to institution responsibilities.
00:25:40.160 --> 00:25:53.039
And I think that's interesting too because it's just watching governments like go to the go to the most edge scenario to focus their energy when it's like you have a direct channel with your money to these institutions.
00:25:53.200 --> 00:26:06.559
Like you fund them how are you not following those pre-existing sort of chains of responsibility and logistics to like make sure you're helping those people right so it's like all of those things add up to me together to this real negligence story.
00:26:06.799 --> 00:26:14.079
And it is not just now I think everybody who's you know knows any recent history like we have been setting up for this for decades.
00:26:14.240 --> 00:26:27.119
So it's sort of like all those things coming together at once you know from a from a what what the state should be doing and could be doing to what it's what it's doing on a daily basis right now, like it is not showing up in its best version of itself for sure.
00:26:27.599 --> 00:26:28.319
Certainly not.
00:26:28.640 --> 00:26:53.920
So often when we turn to tech solutions as the solutions to our problems really um instead of actually looking at the deeper roots of the problems and the more political aspects of the problems what ends up happening is that we don't solve the problem that we're seeking to solve we actually further kind of entrench that inequity that is kind of at the root of the problem in the first place, right?
00:26:54.640 --> 00:27:15.599
And I think your your focus on the forgotten densities is so important because it does illustrate that like there's this broader conversation happening about how there's this concern on the right that dense places are where you are going to have a greater chance of contracting the virus.
00:27:15.839 --> 00:27:24.720
And then there are urbanists pushing back and saying no the dense places are where we have the least possibility of kind of like dying from the virus, right?
00:27:24.799 --> 00:27:26.559
They're actually the safest if we do it right.
00:27:26.960 --> 00:27:43.599
But that kind of polarization of the debate on it kind of misses the nuances of what's going on there, which that article on the forgotten densities really um pulls out really well by showing how it can kind of affect like public housing that has been neglected and all these sorts of things right.
00:27:43.759 --> 00:27:43.920
Yeah.
00:27:44.160 --> 00:27:48.880
So I I think that's a fantastic article and I'll make sure to put
it in the show notes so people can go and check it out.
00:27:49.119 --> 00:27:58.160
Beautiful but I feel like I feel like that brings us into this conversation of what the future of the city should be and how we should be focusing on the future of the city.
00:27:58.480 --> 00:28:02.880
And obviously this has been uh you know a a mutual concern for us, right?
00:28:02.960 --> 00:28:12.160
And you have done a lot of work um on Sidewalk Toronto and pointing out the flaws of that kind of smart neighborhood project that's being proposed in Toronto.
00:28:12.319 --> 00:28:17.759
And I know this has been like an ongoing kind of fight for what two plus years now I guess.
00:28:18.000 --> 00:28:26.640
So can you just kind of give us an idea of firstly what the Sidewalk Toronto project is like briefly and then what are the biggest issues that you're seeing there?
00:28:27.039 --> 00:28:52.880
The the quick way to describe what it is, I think I just take it back to the to the beginning in 2017 where Waterfront Toronto, which is a tri-governmental public agency for lack of a better word, um it's a public corporation, but they're in charge of a whole whack of land on Toronto's waterfront and they're charged through the three levels of government in Canada to it for its redevelopment and also to have an economic development plan for it.
00:28:52.960 --> 00:29:02.240
So not just let's develop this real estate as sort of a shared public asset, but also let's think about how we revitalize this like from a or vitalize it because it's you know fallow land a lot of it now.
00:29:02.400 --> 00:29:07.440
How do we turn it into a place where there's you know where there's an economic piece to it too.
00:29:07.519 --> 00:29:12.079
I raise this because they actually have a mandate for economic development which gets missed a lot.
00:29:12.319 --> 00:29:19.279
The major reason to explain why I'm starting with Waterfront Toronto, who is the the partner in this work is it's not the city of Toronto.
00:29:19.359 --> 00:29:29.680
So this is a project that's being done through like a real estate corporation and Sidewalk Labs, which is a sister company to Google and both of them are subsidiaries of Alphabet.
00:29:29.839 --> 00:29:45.759
And so in 2017 Waterfront Toronto put out a tender and said hey there's this 12 acres here we'd like to get some proposals on how to develop it for the neighborhood of the future and we want it to be many things sustainable economic development we want to have innovation you know on and on.
00:29:46.000 --> 00:29:46.720
All the keywords.
00:29:46.880 --> 00:29:52.000
All the keywords all the words are there this comes full circle to a problem with narrative.
00:29:52.079 --> 00:30:18.960
But so all the words are there and the it was announced in at the end of 2017 that Sidewalk labs had won this tender and they were going to design the neighborhood of the future on Toronto's waterfront and build it from the internet up was there's was their
saying there was sort of images of where there would be data collection and also images of all the different kinds of like non-data driven technologies like tall timber is something they're talking about, you know, building a lot they talk a lot about tall timber.
00:30:19.200 --> 00:30:30.559
So long story short the idea was let's you know get this company to design this neighborhood of the future they have a$50 million US budget to go through that process.
00:30:30.880 --> 00:30:35.599
And um it has been you know now that was October 2017.
00:30:35.759 --> 00:30:37.599
So yeah more than two years.
00:30:38.400 --> 00:31:18.880
It was it was one of these situations where you have a whole bunch of people responding to a government asking a corporation to design a neighborhood and and sort of just just that the opening salvo of that was sort of again it's that normative thing with Amazon like hey we're gonna have a company and it's uh a subsidiary of Alphabet uh design a neighborhood of the future is everyone excited good okay let's go and like completely drove over the question of hold on did the people of Toronto sign off on this tender that that was a thing we wanted to have like hold on which that question has never been resolved.
00:31:18.960 --> 00:31:33.920
But the big point to make here and we've been through years of many drawings many plans many discussions about how you use the data how you don't it's not about this it's about that like it's just it's hard from a linear perspective to bring you up to today.
00:31:34.079 --> 00:31:38.640
But long story short, it did not land in the way I think everybody thought it might.
00:31:38.720 --> 00:31:40.880
So there wasn't just this general yay.
00:31:40.960 --> 00:31:53.119
There was like hold on and I think in the point of time with the tech lash there's a factor there of a growing unease with you know tech companies moving into all the things you know it's not just it's not just urban planning.
00:31:53.200 --> 00:32:10.000
It's health it's like you can feel the the implications of these big powerful companies sort of moving into public life in ways that to my mind none of us ever have asked for and it's just sort of happening because you know it's not being challenged enough by by the state to my mind.
00:32:10.240 --> 00:32:23.440
So long story short there's been a lot going on with that thing and it's still going and I and I'm I I can tell you that the point in time where things really changed was uh October of last year, 2019.
00:32:23.680 --> 00:32:33.680
The two parties signed a sort of we're gonna keep this going agreement with each other that basically it's where the media story took off and diverges from reality.
00:32:33.839 --> 00:32:43.119
The story that was making headlines was Canada beats back big tech or this thing is reined in now, we've set rules it's fine good job.
00:32:43.279 --> 00:33:25.680
This is such a Canadian style thing too the insecurity just like oh no we got this we're fine no problem and then and it's sort of like and the tech company being like oh we should have listened you're right yeah let's listen we love listening like it's like you watch it it's it's like it's a cliche like you're watching the thing play out and you're like oh my head and this is not to say again like with the health story lots of well-intentioned people good urbanists lots of like good ideas flowing around in there but the basic premise of like an alphabet subsidiary designing uh where and how we live across multiple domains and then procuring lots of other companies it's like there was just sort of this control loss that I think has been a problem since the beginning.
00:33:25.839 --> 00:33:30.799
But the problem is that story happened and it's like everybody's sort of being like, okay, it's resolved.
00:33:30.880 --> 00:33:32.079
Everything's fine over there.
00:33:32.319 --> 00:33:39.519
The reality is it's exactly the same problem, frankly, from a governance perspective that it's been since 2017.
00:33:39.759 --> 00:33:50.480
And so this is really hard for me to watch because for me one of the big arguments was we don't have regulation to manage the idea of like this persistent data collection all over the city.
00:33:50.559 --> 00:33:53.039
Like you're turning the curb into a market.
00:33:53.200 --> 00:33:58.640
Do we want to think about that before we've got someone else setting the rules for that like this is public space.
00:33:58.720 --> 00:34:13.840
These are public assets like all kinds of them um and now we're like mitigating someone else's product roadmap because I'm not sure anymore you know like I don't even know if everybody realizes they're getting used for product development for a company like which is which is what's happening.
00:34:13.920 --> 00:34:16.400
Like this is you have to look at this on levels.
00:34:16.559 --> 00:34:25.039
But long story short, there is no regulation that we as Torontonians or we as Canadians have put in place to drive something like this.
00:34:25.280 --> 00:34:28.079
The city of Toronto was working on a digital infrastructure plan.
00:34:28.159 --> 00:34:30.159
It's being halted because of COVID.
00:34:30.320 --> 00:34:38.159
So like we don't have policy we never had policy we still don't have policy but now nobody cares anymore is what it seems like.
00:34:38.239 --> 00:34:41.920
Like now it's sort of like oh let's pretend to see if they're gonna keep going with this deal.
00:34:42.000 --> 00:34:45.119
It's like of course they are they're writing it together at this point.
00:34:45.360 --> 00:34:59.519
And so it's kind of wild from a rhetorical perspective to watch that like once everybody thinks it's fine and it gets and this is um something that Zuboff wrote about and she's got a really good cycle of words for this it's like it's a real fatigue.
00:34:59.599 --> 00:35:07.039
It's like a dispossession like you kind of get to this point of people being like okay well you
know what like it's not going away so like what's the point?
00:35:07.199 --> 00:35:08.800
And there's lots of other things going on.
00:35:08.960 --> 00:35:18.480
And so this idea I'll just you know end here that regulatory capture like if you have a lot of money and time, man, you can do it very slowly.
00:35:18.559 --> 00:35:30.880
And if you do it slowly enough, the scrutiny goes because right now the scrutiny is gone and we're in the exact same situation we were at the beginning, frankly, from a governance perspective the public is not driving it.
00:35:31.039 --> 00:35:38.480
There's contracts being figured out behind closed doors and there's no there's no public directive here.
00:35:38.559 --> 00:35:45.360
It's just we're just mitigating what these two partners have decided they want to do like it's a fundamentally anti-democratic situation.
00:35:45.599 --> 00:36:00.000
But for me as someone watching it it's kind of like a wild experience to go through like okay so everybody cared before we're in exactly the same spot and no one cares anymore because that thing happened that didn't resolve this problem.
00:36:00.159 --> 00:36:12.480
Like that's not good, but that's like that's bringing you right up to you know that's nose against the glass for me is um Waterfront Toronto says that they were going to set up government task forces and no one's answering me as to what they are.
00:36:12.639 --> 00:36:24.719
And so it's um it's it's pretty it's pretty interesting to see how this goes down because we should be we should be saying how we want data and digital governance to work in our cities.
00:36:24.880 --> 00:36:27.840
We should not be mitigating someone else's business plan.
00:36:28.000 --> 00:36:29.119
But that's what we're doing right now.
00:36:29.199 --> 00:36:31.360
And Toronto's doing it and acting like it's all good.
00:36:31.519 --> 00:36:44.559
So like it doesn't bode well but I know culturally Toronto is also a perfect place for this because you know no one wants to really make a move one way or the other like from a um from a you know taking control of this thing.
00:36:44.800 --> 00:36:46.719
And I just think everybody's tired of it.
00:36:46.880 --> 00:36:51.039
So you you know who will win out in a situation like that.
00:36:51.199 --> 00:36:54.559
And you've got all these political leaders who've thrown their capital behind it.
00:36:54.800 --> 00:37:02.559
You look at this structurally it's it's very it's very difficult to make peace with the fact that the consent of the people was never required for this deal.
00:37:02.719 --> 00:37:09.039
Like I think you got a lot of people that are in a liability that that place was not set up for.
00:37:09.199 --> 00:37:14.800
Like I'm still shocked that lawyers that are paid with public funds are signing off on what's happening in Toronto.
00:37:14.960 --> 00:37:16.239
Like this is still shocking me.
00:37:16.400 --> 00:37:18.960
But sometimes I think I'm super naive so here we are.
00:37:19.280 --> 00:37:45.679
It's so frustrating like obviously I have been watching this more from afar like not on the front lines of it like you have been and it's been so frustrating just to see this process like continue and for there to be all of these massive issues with it and and it just like doesn't seem to matter like it's it's it's absolutely wild you know yeah well we we've come full circle to inevitability.
00:37:45.840 --> 00:37:48.239
It's it's like right what we were talking about at the beginning, right?
00:37:48.320 --> 00:37:58.559
Like I think it's this idea that somehow you make it complicated enough long enough you put enough experts in there that somehow saying no almost feels like facile.
00:37:58.800 --> 00:38:04.960
You know like it's kind of like well and this is what the the management consulting companies have done over decades as well.
00:38:05.039 --> 00:38:09.360
Like there's just so much stuff going on over there that you're like, well that can't possibly be a bad idea.
00:38:09.519 --> 00:38:10.960
And it's like yeah it is.
00:38:11.199 --> 00:38:15.519
But from a from an argumentation perspective it almost feels too simple to say that.
00:38:16.079 --> 00:38:28.239
But I think that's such a it's it's I just want I'm trying to pull us out of sidewalk to say this is a frequent issue with all of this technology is that like we don't look at efficacy and we don't look at whether it's doing its thing or not.
00:38:28.400 --> 00:38:32.000
You know like how how is that something that's allowed to be skipped over?
00:38:32.159 --> 00:38:33.679
Like what is this thing even doing?
00:38:33.840 --> 00:38:36.480
Like all we're doing is mitigating issues we know about.
00:38:36.639 --> 00:38:45.280
We're not even asking like what it's like what is this actually achieving for all of us that we want, which is the way we should be talking more about our technologies.
00:38:45.440 --> 00:38:57.280
So I just want to say it's that inevitability that the thing you're describing back to me with my feeling is that thing and that is the thing that I think we need to hone in on that it's not inevitable that we have other ways to build technology.
00:38:57.440 --> 00:39:03.039
As a technologist this inevitability kills me because wow we could be doing amazing things, right?
00:39:03.119 --> 00:39:13.760
Like that's to put us on the rear guard defensive mitigation mode instead of all of our energy going to like building what we want that's that's a real letdown.
00:39:13.920 --> 00:39:24.079
And I wanted to mention something to you because of how much politics is part of you know this podcast and other things is like I don't have a grand nostalgia for the state either.
00:39:24.239 --> 00:39:30.719
Like nobody's acting right you know like it it's not something that we then revert to just well states do things too.
00:39:30.880 --> 00:39:34.960
So I think this third way that we need to invent together is so important.
00:39:35.039 --> 00:39:50.719
And it is happening through leadership of people in communities on the ground just like making things and doing things and proving them out without the support of the state either frankly right and I think that's important to acknowledge and to like applaud.
00:39:51.119 --> 00:40:01.599
Because sometimes what I get worried with some of the rhetoric around the state stuff, it's like I don't want some of these big companies entrenched into the state because the state hasn't been acting right either, you know?
00:40:01.760 --> 00:40:06.320
Like I I just I think that's that's an important thing to keep real in our politics too.
00:40:06.400 --> 00:40:13.199
So like that third way is challenging but it's going to take like much more people power outside of some of these formal structures right now.
00:40:13.519 --> 00:40:16.239
I think that is is like a fantastic point, right?
00:40:16.400 --> 00:40:28.880
We need to pay attention to how these technologies are being developed um and that doesn't simply mean kind of retrenching and looking back to a way that structures worked in the past, right?
00:40:29.280 --> 00:40:33.199
And I know that we could go on and talk about sidewalk labs for hours, I'm sure.
00:40:33.519 --> 00:40:41.599
But like obviously we we uh also need to have a vision for what the future of tech in the public interest looks like.
00:40:42.320 --> 00:40:46.559
And I think you started to uh give an idea for how that might work right there.
00:40:47.119 --> 00:41:03.599
One of the uh ideas that I have been uh really excited by um is this notion of kind of being inspired by uh public broadcasting and uh kind of like having this a public alternative to uh the tech giants, right?
00:41:03.920 --> 00:42:02.239
But uh not simply approaching that in kind of this uh state institution kind of way but uh updating it and modernizing it for the 21st century and ensuring that uh we kind of have uh teams of technologists that are uh rooted in communities that are are around the country that are responding to the technological needs of those communities and helping them learn how to use uh tech tools like uh developing technology in a much more uh decentralized democratized way um so that's a kind of an idea that's been exciting me but uh like I know that this is an issue that uh you spend uh a whole lot of time thinking about and talking about and arguing for so what are the sorts of things that you're thinking about about how we could kind of turn this around and instead of always relying on these multinational you know oligopolies to actually take control of this ourselves, make it democratic and make tech work for us.
00:42:02.719 --> 00:42:04.719
So we're both thinking a lot about this.
00:42:05.199 --> 00:42:20.480
And I'm gonna I'm gonna share uh something that my colleague Digital Public Sean McDonald said and it just sticks with me every day and it's might I might not get it exactly right, but it's basically, you know, you
don't bring knowledge to an incentive fight.
00:42:20.639 --> 00:43:02.719
And the reason I I raise this and it relates to everything we've talked about before but also here is how do you how do we bring this sort of non-commercial piece into technology and its future right because I think it's been so long understood as a consumer space and as a commercial space even in the way it's in the academe, you know, like computer science and the way so much of research has been sort of suctioned into the companies and so little of it left on the table for public interest um from you know in terms of intellectual property all of that like it we have a major, major major inequity there, right?
00:43:02.880 --> 00:43:09.440
Like and that's fascinating to me because I always think about math that you know is like you know computer science and math is not inherently capitalist.
00:43:09.679 --> 00:43:10.079
Not at all.
00:43:10.400 --> 00:43:14.960
There's nothing about it that necessitates its activity be commercial.
00:43:15.679 --> 00:43:26.320
Having said that, the extent to which the infrastructures that we have right now are owned and operated by commercial entities like we're pretty far down that path.
00:43:26.480 --> 00:43:53.360
And so I think one of the areas where we really need to think about our power is the governance of these infrastructures in terms of how many of our critical infrastructures are commercially owned and operated right now, whether it's hardware, you know, and a lot of the software that's run through a lot of our institutions, that the opportunity to get more control over use is in its governance rather than in the idea always of ownership.
00:43:53.519 --> 00:44:02.559
And again, this actually goes back to Sean some of Sean's thinking that's helped me a lot was getting off the idea of ownership And getting into the idea of how it's used.
00:44:02.719 --> 00:44:12.960
Because we can do a lot more in our governance and to bring a democratic, you know, lens to the use of things, which gets us off of needing to own them.
00:44:13.119 --> 00:44:20.880
Like I think there's something in there that's really, really important that across the board, in terms of saying, well, I don't need to own that infrastructure to define how it's used.
00:44:21.039 --> 00:44:21.280
Right.
00:44:21.440 --> 00:44:30.880
So I think this is where there's opportunity in both the regulatory spaces and in governance, whether it's at a local, regional, whatever level, to make rules.
00:44:30.960 --> 00:44:39.920
And I think hyper, hyper local rules around some of how our technologies are used, are quite a good idea and quite possible.
00:44:40.079 --> 00:44:58.960
And it's even why like the democratization of things like standards, which are historically heavily, heavily corporate driven, but flooding the tables of like standard spaces with people that aren't commercial actors but are civil society actors and saying like this software has to work this way.
00:44:59.119 --> 00:45:03.360
Like this is the only if it doesn't work this way, governments aren't buying it.
00:45:03.599 --> 00:45:08.159
Full stop and start to use the power of like of purchase, frankly.
00:45:08.320 --> 00:45:16.000
There is so much public institutional money that is, you know, gone into a lot of this stuff that we should be saying how it has to work.
00:45:16.239 --> 00:45:24.159
And so I think that's quite encouraging because not that those tables are accessible and not that people get paid to show up and sit there for three hours.
00:45:24.239 --> 00:45:27.360
Like it's not to say we're going from here to tomorrow morning, no problem.
00:45:27.679 --> 00:45:28.800
But there's an option.
00:45:28.960 --> 00:45:30.800
And that option is process.
00:45:30.960 --> 00:45:36.480
And that for me is very encouraging because of the commercial deficit thing of like, well, what are we going to do?
00:45:36.559 --> 00:45:39.679
Are we going to invest billions of dollars in public computing?
00:45:39.920 --> 00:45:40.559
I'd like to.
00:45:40.639 --> 00:45:46.559
Like, I don't get me wrong, I'd like to buy all kinds of stuff and put it under public, you know, public public control and use.
00:45:46.719 --> 00:45:57.519
But let's be pragmatic and strategic right now and say, is that what governments like I look at the US government and it's that and lots of other countries, like they're they're they're not making those infrastructure investments.
00:45:57.599 --> 00:46:05.119
So then our next best thing, and not to say we stop lobbying for them ever, and we're all, you know, in our own ways gonna keep pushing that one.
00:46:05.280 --> 00:46:17.280
But um, but it's very important to know that this sort of defining how these things can be used, which just to go back to sidewalk is why it's so wrong, is that you should say how that stuff works, and then people build tech to your spec.
00:46:17.519 --> 00:46:22.159
You like we all need to know we have the power to define how all these things work.
00:46:22.400 --> 00:46:24.639
It doesn't mean we have to build it ourselves.
00:46:24.880 --> 00:46:41.039
And so we need the confidence publicly and and and and the it really it comes to confidence, like letting people be able to say in English what they want and then having a translation sort of set of work to take that and make that sort of a technical outcome that that can be achieved.
00:46:41.280 --> 00:46:43.760
Um, that's the kind of stuff I think we can do.
00:46:43.840 --> 00:46:53.840
And I I think it's important to look at also like there between centralized and decentralized, there's also something really nice about thinking of like devolved governance.
00:46:54.000 --> 00:46:59.920
Like you don't want to have to be bespoke doing everything one-off, because I think it it really makes it hard on people.
00:47:00.159 --> 00:47:07.599
And I think a lot of the open source community and other like there's some great alternative products
to things, but you can't use them if you don't know how the stuff works.
00:47:07.760 --> 00:47:16.960
You know, like it's and and so there's there's not enough investment at some of the levels of like user interface stuff or like just general like accessibility to some of these tools.
00:47:17.119 --> 00:47:21.280
Um, how much community time can you ask for people to invest in this stuff, right?
00:47:21.360 --> 00:47:23.199
I don't think it's like the same across the board.
00:47:23.360 --> 00:47:27.760
So I think there's a few different approaches in there that like of that stuff that I'm offering up.
00:47:27.840 --> 00:47:42.480
Um, I think there's lots more than what I'm suggesting, but I do think that this is why the talk about politics and the talk about democracy and like I go on and I am like team, government, and team the man, we got this big institutional machine.
00:47:42.719 --> 00:47:49.679
It has been a violent actor, it's been a terror, but it's also something that we shouldn't be throwing away because we can make it better tomorrow.
00:47:49.840 --> 00:47:53.360
And that's the work that I think we can do through these institutions.
00:47:53.440 --> 00:47:58.159
And I wish the public institutions would be showing up and throwing their weight around a bit more.
00:47:58.320 --> 00:48:00.719
I mean, we we often talk about labor.
00:48:00.880 --> 00:48:04.079
Um, look at the power of the public sector unions.
00:48:04.239 --> 00:48:07.199
Like, oh, there's so much latent power sitting there.
00:48:07.280 --> 00:48:13.119
It sort of reminds me of tenured academics, where it's like, you're you guys have the cover, like you're it.
00:48:13.280 --> 00:48:14.079
You're it right now.
00:48:14.239 --> 00:48:18.400
Like there's not that many more people that are as safe to be as political as you could be.
00:48:18.559 --> 00:48:19.840
Like, come on out.
00:48:20.079 --> 00:48:24.159
Um, and so I think that's like those are a few different places where there's so much opportunity.
00:48:24.320 --> 00:48:26.719
Librarians, like they they pull a lot of weight.
00:48:26.800 --> 00:48:37.760
Um, but that there's room to sort of create these spaces of education, confidence, and direction so that we then point that machine to in that institutional machine to better ends.
00:48:37.920 --> 00:48:40.960
Um, because I don't think the political incentive is there.
00:48:41.119 --> 00:48:57.119
This is the problem, is that there's so much political incentive to just like go with the regulatory capture and go with the like, you know, these companies haranguing and threatening, well, I'm just not gonna set up shop in your country if you're gonna make this hard for me, you know, like I'm gonna take my thing elsewhere.
00:48:57.280 --> 00:49:02.480
Um, and so there's not a lot of incentive for that regulatory stuff to just come from a political actor.
00:49:02.559 --> 00:49:04.960
It's gotta come from more public pressure as well.
00:49:05.199 --> 00:49:10.719
And um, I think all those things together, there's opportunity there, but it's it's it's a slog, like for sure.
00:49:10.880 --> 00:49:12.800
And look at how many other priorities we have, right?
00:49:13.039 --> 00:49:16.719
I think that's something we always think about is which fights you're supposed to be fighting.
00:49:16.880 --> 00:49:25.519
Um, and there's a lot of ways to take that access to the internet fight as the primary and see how much good could come from that, exactly to your point, right?
00:49:25.679 --> 00:49:29.599
Because once you have that access, you start to get into different ways to use it.
00:49:29.679 --> 00:49:36.079
Um, I'd like to share this thing that someone at the Mozilla Foundation shared with me, and it has stuck with me too for a long time.
00:49:36.320 --> 00:49:43.360
Um, a lot of the the stats you hear about access to the internet is about through it's through mobile phones.
00:49:43.599 --> 00:49:52.239
And so, and this is differing across country, but much like literacy, you know, literacy is reading and writing.
00:49:52.400 --> 00:49:54.639
And like I never think about literacy as writing.
00:49:54.800 --> 00:49:57.360
I always think about it as reading in my little shorthand, right?
00:49:57.440 --> 00:50:00.480
When I hear literacy, boom, I'm thinking about reading and writing.
00:50:00.559 --> 00:50:03.039
And so you think about the same with computers.
00:50:03.199 --> 00:50:07.840
Like it's not just access to what you get, it's building it yourself.
00:50:07.920 --> 00:50:11.440
And you're not doing software development on a mobile phone for the most part.
00:50:11.599 --> 00:50:17.360
So, like, how do you even make sure that you're setting people up to be builders and makers and authors, right?
00:50:17.519 --> 00:50:21.840
And it's not everybody shouldn't be a software developer, it's not everybody needs to learn how to code at all.
00:50:22.000 --> 00:50:34.480
But it's certainly that you have a much wider array of stuff that you can do with the internet if you have access to be like a maker and a, you know, someone who's able to use it as a creator, not just as a recipient.
00:50:34.639 --> 00:50:40.880
Because I think even that idea of that like recipient piece is part of the inevitable the inevitability.
00:50:41.039 --> 00:50:48.960
And like when I talk to people, so many people I know are like, well, I don't really like what's going on, but I'm complicit in it as a consumer and I don't know what else to do.
00:50:49.199 --> 00:50:52.400
You know, like that's that's got to be the most common thing I hear from people.
00:50:52.639 --> 00:51:05.440
So the only way I think to start to bend on some of that inevitability is to make sure that the things you talk about in terms of like what people can do themselves, um, are also more available to the people who know how to do them and who know how to do them offline.
00:51:05.599 --> 00:51:09.920
Like you look at and I it's so
politically challenging to talk about this properly.
00:51:10.000 --> 00:51:19.360
So I'm, you know, forgive me if I say this wrong, but like there have been people who have been thriving despite every single thing our society has done to them.
00:51:19.519 --> 00:51:22.800
And they still show up with joy, with love, with care, with support.
00:51:22.960 --> 00:51:31.840
And so, like, to take that kind of knowledge and bring it into other spaces is this incredible opportunity for lots of us to learn from that, you know?
00:51:32.000 --> 00:51:37.199
Like it's it's it you don't want to make something, you don't want to make it sound like, oh, that's an opportunity because it's terrible.
00:51:37.360 --> 00:51:44.320
It's saying like people have built a lot of their own networks around things in in the offline world.
00:51:44.480 --> 00:51:47.920
And so, like, what does that look like to bring more of that into digital spaces?
00:51:48.000 --> 00:51:50.159
And what can the rest of us learn from that?
00:51:50.400 --> 00:51:58.559
Um, I never, I never ever like to use the word resilience because I was this um this wonderful poster from New Orleans and the woman's name is escaping me right now.
00:51:58.639 --> 00:52:01.920
But it's like, don't call me resilient, it just means you can do more to me.
00:52:02.079 --> 00:52:02.800
It's so good.
00:52:02.960 --> 00:52:07.519
Like that word always makes me feel uncomfortable because I think that's such a perfect way to describe it.
00:52:07.679 --> 00:52:11.599
But the reality is that let's shove resilience aside.
00:52:11.679 --> 00:52:18.880
It's pure knowledge of like how to make things work for a community despite terrible circumstances.
00:52:19.039 --> 00:52:25.519
And so that's the kind of stuff that to me needs to find a space more in the in our in our technologies.
00:52:25.679 --> 00:52:26.960
And I think there's so much there.
00:52:27.039 --> 00:52:33.920
And if and if if people are willing to share, I mean, no one has to, and not everybody's party to everybody's stuff, um, which is a whole other conversation.
00:52:34.000 --> 00:52:39.199
But I I hope you know what I'm sort of gesturing at there, that that's that's that's where I see hope.
00:52:39.360 --> 00:52:42.400
And it's like we can fall behind some of that knowledge and learning.
00:52:42.480 --> 00:52:45.519
We're not starting at zero, you know, with all of these things.
00:52:45.760 --> 00:52:51.199
So yeah, we we take our sociology of a lot of this and in history and move it into a technology lens.
00:52:51.280 --> 00:52:54.719
And I think, man, we have so much to do that's just right there.
00:52:54.880 --> 00:53:01.440
Um, but we got to break out of this everybody else's inevitability problem, um, which is hard when you go to to the media narratives.
00:53:01.599 --> 00:53:08.559
So hate to bash on journalism because they're doing a lot of good work, but they also repeat a lot of stuff that is problematic.
00:53:08.800 --> 00:53:12.320
Um, so thanks for making a space for us to not do that.
00:53:14.000 --> 00:53:15.920
And obviously, thanks for all of your work.
00:53:16.079 --> 00:53:19.440
You know, I I think that that leaves us in a really good place, right?
00:53:19.519 --> 00:53:22.800
Like the challenges ahead are large, right?
00:53:23.039 --> 00:53:23.599
They're great.
00:53:24.239 --> 00:53:47.199
But there's also a lot of opportunity um if we can kind of uh build those collective structures and kind of come together to not just demand that our our governments do better, um, but to start to kind of build alternative structures and to uh exert our power in whatever way that we can, right?
00:53:47.519 --> 00:53:50.880
Yeah, yeah, and and I love to say like we are the government.
00:53:51.119 --> 00:53:51.920
We're the government.
00:53:52.079 --> 00:53:55.360
Like we we need to understand that that's that the it's us.
00:53:55.519 --> 00:53:57.199
It's not like oh, you're bad over there.
00:53:57.360 --> 00:54:03.199
Like it's like that's because you're like everybody has a different level of responsibility to what we are the government means.
00:54:03.280 --> 00:54:11.679
It's not all the same at all, but there's a lot of people that are holding a lot of power and just sort of latent and just sitting there and just holding space, status quo kind of stuff.
00:54:11.840 --> 00:54:18.639
So I want us to take responsibility for that machine, like more of us and the people who are very close to like being able to push it differently.
00:54:18.800 --> 00:54:21.679
Um, I I'd like us to feel more ownership of that.
00:54:21.840 --> 00:54:26.480
I know people who feel zero, zero relationship to that, and that's completely reasonable as well.
00:54:26.639 --> 00:54:28.800
But yeah, that's that's that's the thing.
00:54:28.880 --> 00:54:36.320
We are the government, so we we are we are bringing its consequences, and that's uh not not great, but also opportunity to your point.
00:54:36.400 --> 00:54:36.960
So it's both.
00:54:37.519 --> 00:54:38.239
Completely agree.
00:54:38.480 --> 00:54:40.000
Bianca Wiley, thank you so much.
00:54:40.079 --> 00:54:42.000
It's been fantastic speaking with you today.
00:54:42.239 --> 00:54:43.199
Likewise, thanks a ton.
00:54:43.440 --> 00:54:44.079
Talk to you soon.
00:54:44.159 --> 00:54:48.719
Bye, Bianca Wiley is the co-founder of Digital Public and Tech Reset Canada.
00:54:48.880 --> 00:54:52.400
She's also a senior fellow at the Center for International Governance Innovation.
00:54:52.960 --> 00:54:56.559
You can follow her on Twitter as at Bianca Wiley.
00:54:57.199 --> 00:55:01.199
If you like this conversation, please leave a five-star review on Apple Podcasts.
00:55:01.760 --> 00:55:02.719
That would really help us out.
00:55:03.360 --> 00:55:06.880
You can also follow the podcast on Twitter as at TechWon't Save Us.
00:55:07.119 --> 00:55:09.599
You can follow me at ParisMarks as at ParisMarks.
00:55:10.639 --> 00:55:11.519
And thanks so much for listening.