رونوشت 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:00.160 --> 00:00:07.040
The world after COVID, or in the ongoing wake of COVID, is only Peter Thiel's world if we let it be.
00:00:07.280 --> 00:00:10.480
When he says he's being evil, that's advertising.
00:00:24.640 --> 00:00:26.559
Hello and welcome to Tech Won't Save Us.
00:00:26.640 --> 00:00:29.679
I'm your host, Paris Marks, and this week my guest is Moira Weigel.
00:00:29.920 --> 00:00:38.000
Moira is an assistant professor at Northeastern University, a faculty associate at the Berkman-Klein Center, and a founding editor of Logic Magazine.
00:00:38.159 --> 00:00:41.759
She's also the co-editor of a collection called Voices from the Valley.
00:00:41.920 --> 00:00:44.880
Tech workers talk about what they do and how they do it.
00:00:45.119 --> 00:01:01.280
In this week's conversation, we talk about a really important figure in Silicon Valley that I don't think gets enough attention for the influence that he's had on Silicon Valley, uh, and increasingly the influence that he's having on American politics, and that is obviously Peter Thiel.
00:01:01.679 --> 00:01:20.079
In the conversation, we go through many aspects of Thiel's history, including his time as a conservative provocateur at Stanford University, his time at PayPal, at Palantir, and more recently as a funder of Republican politics, including Donald Trump, Blake Masters, J.D.
00:01:20.159 --> 00:01:22.480
Vance, Josh Hawley, and others.
00:01:22.799 --> 00:01:38.079
This is important to recognize because Teal has a particular right-wing politics that I think has received a fair amount of attention, but he is often positioned as kind of an odd one out in Silicon Valley, as the representative of Silicon Valley conservatism.
00:01:38.319 --> 00:01:55.040
When actually, as Moira explains, it's probably not so easy to say that he is an exception to a general liberal rule in Silicon Valley, and that there's actually far more people who think like Peter Thiel, and you know, we'll probably see even more moving forward.
00:01:55.280 --> 00:02:47.039
One of the things that Moira points out that I think is really important and that we get to in the conversation is that we often recognize the influence that Stuart Brand and the Whole Earth catalog have had in Silicon Valley since its emergence, you know, around the 60s, 70s, that period, and then how it influences Steve Jobs and many other important figures, but how in the early 2000s there is also a very influential group of people around Peter Thiel and PayPal who emerge from there, who have a particular right-wing politics who become very influential figures in the Valley, and that maybe we haven't fully recognized the degree to which the politics of the Valley have shifted away from that kind of libertarian ideal that comes from Stuart Brand to a more conservative politics that is represented more by Peter Thiel.
00:02:47.199 --> 00:02:49.840
And so, you know, you'll find out more about that in the conversation.
00:02:49.919 --> 00:03:13.599
But I think it's really important, especially as Peter Thiel becomes a more influential and more visible figure within US politics as he is funding these Republican candidates, but as he's also funding media ventures, things like Rumble to spread that perspective or perspectives that benefit him, his worldview, and his politics, and to further elevate conservative voices.
00:03:13.919 --> 00:03:22.639
And just as a final point before we get to the conversation, something that we didn't get to was how Peter Thiel recently exited his position in Facebook.
00:03:22.800 --> 00:03:31.199
And Moira thinks that that illustrates that he believes that the attention economy is coming to an end and something else is going to replace it.
00:03:31.280 --> 00:03:40.639
And I think that you'll see us kind of pick up on that idea in the conversation, but we don't explicitly talk about Peter Thiel's exit from Facebook and what that means for the attention economy.
00:03:40.800 --> 00:03:42.639
So I just wanted to fill in that gap.
00:03:42.960 --> 00:03:50.560
Tech Won't Save Us is part of the Harbinger Media Network, a group of left-wing podcasts that are made in Canada, and you can find out more about that at Harbinger Media Network.com.
00:03:50.719 --> 00:03:54.319
If you like the show, make sure to leave a five-star review on Apple or Spotify.
00:03:54.479 --> 00:03:58.879
You can also share the show on social media or with any friends or colleagues who you think would learn from it.
00:03:58.960 --> 00:04:06.400
And this episode of Tech Won's Save Us, like every episode, is free for everybody because listeners like you support the work that goes into making it every single week.
00:04:06.639 --> 00:04:25.279
So if you like this conversation and if you like the show as a whole, you can join patrons like Kevin from Queens in New York, Melody from Montreal, Oscar Maria Grande, also from Montreal, Thomas from Vancouver, Kenneth from San Francisco, and Ben from France by going to patreon.com slash TechWon't Save Us and becoming a supporter.
00:04:25.519 --> 00:04:27.680
Thanks so much and enjoy this week's conversation.
00:04:28.639 --> 00:04:30.879
Moira, welcome to Tech Won't Save Us.
00:04:31.279 --> 00:04:32.720
Thanks so much for having me.
00:04:33.279 --> 00:04:34.800
I'm really excited to chat.
00:04:34.959 --> 00:04:40.000
I know that you've been looking into Peter Thiel and his associates like Alex Carp for quite a while.
00:04:40.160 --> 00:04:51.279
And I think that this is a figure who is quite important when thinking about Silicon Valley and the impact that he has had, but I think also maybe doesn't get the attention that he deserves sometimes in terms of that impact.
00:04:51.439 --> 00:04:57.600
And so I wanted to discuss that with you so the listeners can get a bit more insight on Peter Thiel and what he's been up to.
00:04:57.759 --> 00:05:05.360
And so I think before we get into kind of the specific moments and areas of
Load full transcript
interest that I have, I wanted to start with a broader question.
00:05:05.600 --> 00:05:09.519
If you were to briefly describe Peter Thiel to someone, how would you describe him?
00:05:09.600 --> 00:05:10.879
What is important about him?
00:05:11.360 --> 00:05:18.319
Peter Thiel is a German-born venture capitalist who grew up in the United States and South Africa.
00:05:18.800 --> 00:05:34.240
He's known for being one of the founders of PayPal in the 1990s and an early investor in Facebook, and recently has also gained attention for being a co-founder of Palantir Technologies.
00:05:34.800 --> 00:05:56.319
He's become, since the 2016 election, in ways that I imagine we'll get into, sort of a stand-in or shorthand for a right wing or right libertarian side of Silicon Valley and a kind of favorite subject of certain long-form writers about technology and the valley, including at times myself.
00:05:56.560 --> 00:06:15.920
He's a venture capitalist, but he's also recently emerged as a kind of cultural entrepreneur in different ways, sort of using both his financial resources and his network to promote certain politics and understandings of the world's and not just a cultural entrepreneur, he's also a major political donor to the Republican Party at this point.
00:06:16.079 --> 00:06:26.240
So yeah, venture capitalist, co-founder of various important companies, and increasingly important donor to the Republican Party is the headline on Peter Thiel.
00:06:26.720 --> 00:06:27.279
I love that.
00:06:27.439 --> 00:06:31.519
And I think that hits on all the main aspects of who he is, right?
00:06:31.600 --> 00:06:33.120
In a very concise way.
00:06:33.360 --> 00:06:34.480
So I appreciate that.
00:06:34.720 --> 00:06:37.600
But I do want to dig into some of those moments, right?
00:06:37.680 --> 00:06:44.879
And some of those parts of Peter Thiel's history that are really illustrative of who he is and the impact that he has had, right?
00:06:45.040 --> 00:06:54.079
Because you talk a lot about the importance of his network and and how he brings people together and how that is a really key aspect of who he is and what he does.
00:06:54.240 --> 00:07:08.959
And I think that the first time that we really see that is when he is at Stanford University as a kind of provocative right-wing figure trying to get in on the, I guess, culture war period that was going on there.
00:07:09.120 --> 00:07:16.879
The kind of controversy about what happens on colleges is not a new thing that just came up in the past few years, but it's an ongoing thing, especially on the right.
00:07:17.040 --> 00:07:25.279
So can you talk about what he was at at Stanford University and why that is important, I think, in beginning his trajectory and where he goes from there?
00:07:25.759 --> 00:07:26.639
Yeah, certainly.
00:07:26.800 --> 00:07:35.519
So Thiel was born in 1967, which means he's in college and law school at Stanford in the mid to late 1890s, 1890s.
00:07:36.160 --> 00:07:40.079
In the mid to late 1980s to the early 1990s.
00:07:40.240 --> 00:07:49.839
And as you alluded to in your question, this is also a period of the first so-called culture wars, which have all sorts of different inputs to them.
00:07:49.920 --> 00:07:56.240
But Teal arrived at Stanford in that period with an identity already as a conservative.
00:07:56.480 --> 00:08:01.759
He had been shaped by reading the National Review, which is the publication started by William F.
00:08:01.839 --> 00:08:02.560
Buckley.
00:08:02.800 --> 00:08:04.319
You know, I think we forget this.
00:08:04.480 --> 00:08:17.519
Um, and by we, I suppose, I mean the kind of people I imagine uh listen to this podcast, but conservative reaction is kind of always co-evolving since the 60s with progressive movements and left-wing movements.
00:08:17.759 --> 00:08:27.360
At the same time that these new left campus movements were developing in the mid to late 1960s, there was also the early development of these new right movements.
00:08:27.680 --> 00:08:50.320
And there's an anecdote I love about how Richard Vigory, who became this very important Republican strategist who shows up briefly in the Tale Story, uh, how he was interning, I want to say, for some Republican senator, and he was sent to an ACLU event with a bunch of civil rights activists and new left activists, uh, and came back and said, we have to figure out how to do that.
00:08:50.480 --> 00:08:53.679
We've got to do that and build a right-wing network to compete with that.
00:08:53.919 --> 00:09:08.639
And so I say this just to highlight that there's this long history of right-wing activism on campus, but also more specifically, right-wing study and sort of selective appropriation of what left-wing movements are doing.
00:09:08.720 --> 00:09:18.399
And I think that will become important later on when we talk about Teal and CARP and their sort of branding of themselves as a kind of avant-garde or cultural provocateurs.
00:09:18.480 --> 00:09:19.840
But all this to say, William F.
00:09:19.919 --> 00:09:35.679
Buckley and the National Review, ever since Buckley published his book in 1954 on God and Man at Yale, have been an important face of this sort of bowtie wearing elite conservative shock and dismay at the state of things on campus.
00:09:35.840 --> 00:09:43.679
And Teal arrived, according to classmates whom Max Chaffkin, his biographer, interviewed for his recent book, The Contrarian.
00:09:43.840 --> 00:09:47.200
Um, Teal arrived at Stanford wanting to be the next William F.
00:09:47.279 --> 00:09:54.559
Buckley, having this vision of himself as a sort of next generation conservative media entrepreneur.
00:09:54.799 --> 00:10:04.799
And at the moment he arrived, uh, as I said, you know, it's a moment where these culture wars that really take off in the late 80s and early 90s are heating up.
00:10:05.039 --> 00:10:21.360
And Stanford became a sort of focal point for these culture wars, perhaps similarly to, I don't know, the Bon Me episode at Oberlin in the in our more recent culture wars or the heckling of um Charles Murray at Middlebury.
00:10:21.440 --> 00:10:24.399
You know, there are these totemic moments in the campus culture wars.
00:10:24.559 --> 00:10:39.200
These debates that were happening at Stanford in, I want to say the late 80s and early 90s about revising their core humanities curriculum, uh, which is called Western Civ, their Western Civ curriculum became a focus of national media attention.
00:10:39.279 --> 00:10:54.159
You know, Newsweek ran huge stories on whether or not this canon great books clash should be revised, you know, whether it was a sign of the fall of Western civilization that now maybe you had to read Zora Neil Hurst in like one more book.
00:10:54.320 --> 00:11:00.960
Um, I think it was literally Their Eyes Were Watching God, that was one of the books in question, in addition to Plato and the canon of great white men.
00:11:01.039 --> 00:11:16.000
And so it was sort of a specially fertile territory for someone who's trying to launch a kind of career or at least build a profile as an aggrieved and embattled conservative on a college campus.
00:11:16.240 --> 00:11:25.360
And I should say, of course, well before the 1980s and 1990s culture wars, there had also been the establishment of the Hoover Institute at Stanford.
00:11:25.600 --> 00:11:31.120
Stanford had these historic ties to the military-industrial complex in Silicon Valley.
00:11:31.200 --> 00:11:45.919
So it's, you know, I think there's this narrative that's perpetuated in the media and in public discourse that often says, you know, Silicon Valley was all liberal and college campuses were completely liberal until this new thing happened.
00:11:46.000 --> 00:11:46.960
And that's not the case.
00:11:47.120 --> 00:12:04.799
But anyway, Teal shows up at Stanford in the 80s and becomes involved in these campus culture wars and becomes involved with organizations that were founded by right-wing donors and some of those networks coming out of the late 60s, the new right networks.
00:12:04.879 --> 00:12:13.200
So, like the Intercollegiate Studies Institute is this important network that's established to connect conservative students on college campuses.
00:12:13.440 --> 00:12:20.720
So, like Dinesh D'Souza and Anne Quilter are also coming up through ISI at Cornell and Dartmouth in roughly this period.
00:12:20.960 --> 00:12:42.000
And TEAL links up with conservative professors and student activists on Stanford's campus and co-founds the Stanford Review, which is a conservative student paper, analogous broadly again to Dinesh D'Souza's Dartmouth Review, that's also founded in this period with funding from similar donors, from the same donors.
00:12:42.240 --> 00:13:03.600
So in this milieu at Stanford Campus, already starts to build a reputation as I would say a right libertarian, a certain kind of conservative and also provocateur, uh, and through the Stanford Review
starts articulating some of his political views and also assembling a kind of network of like-minded people around him.
00:13:03.759 --> 00:13:08.559
And as Andrew Granato is someone who's written about this, I believe he was a Stanford student.
00:13:08.639 --> 00:13:14.720
I'm not certain, but Andrew Granato did this deep dive into Peter Teal's Stanford Review a few years ago.
00:13:14.960 --> 00:13:34.080
And as he shows, I mean, I haven't gone through that archive and it's very secretive actually, but as he shows in that piece, many, many key figures in Teal's world are people with whom he crosses paths already at that stage in the late 1980s and early 1990s at Stanford, and it's remained an institution through which he cultivates relationships.
00:13:34.240 --> 00:13:41.679
Josh Hawley, although I don't think Shaskin, the biographer, finds evidence that Teal and Hawley met directly at the Stanford Review.
00:13:41.840 --> 00:13:44.399
Hawley is also a Stanford Review alum.
00:13:44.799 --> 00:13:49.679
It's an important feeder for the Teal universe, which I imagine we'll continue to talk about.
00:13:49.919 --> 00:13:57.440
I should say, sorry, I've been talking too long, but another thing to note is that between undergrad and law school, he sort of befriends an enormous number of the people.
00:13:57.759 --> 00:14:08.320
Maybe befriend is the wrong verb based on how they tend to describe it, but he meets um and connects with a number of the people who remain important in his universe for decades afterwards.
00:14:08.480 --> 00:14:13.440
But he did befriend Reed Hoffman uh while they were both undergraduates at Stanford.
00:14:13.600 --> 00:14:21.840
Reed Hoffman, I believe, you know, voted Democrat and had a persona as more of a liberal, more of a liberal persona, but they were friendly.
00:14:21.919 --> 00:14:26.080
I think they even ran for student government together on a shared ticket at one point.
00:14:26.399 --> 00:14:36.480
And it's at Stanford that Teal gets to know Keith Reboyes, who was at law school with him there, and Alex Carp, who I believe was at law school too, also started a PhD.
00:14:36.559 --> 00:14:53.919
Well, they overlap there, but it's it's at the university and in this network of organizations around the Hoover Institution and the conservative campus movement that he starts to establish this identity that he has now and also to assemble the group of people who will be key to his career.
00:14:54.559 --> 00:14:57.759
Hoffman and Thiel, the bipartisan ticket, I guess.
00:14:58.159 --> 00:14:59.200
Literally, yeah.
00:14:59.519 --> 00:15:00.000
Literally.
00:15:00.159 --> 00:15:04.159
I feel like in Max Chafkin's book, he has a description of it.
00:15:04.240 --> 00:15:06.000
But they ran for student government.
00:15:06.159 --> 00:15:08.799
I think it was for like class representative or something.
00:15:09.279 --> 00:15:14.000
I want to say I'm not sure if this fits with what I was just saying or if this needs to be said.
00:15:14.159 --> 00:15:17.759
But I think there's also often I don't even know what I'm trying to say.
00:15:17.840 --> 00:15:20.879
It's like it's hard to separate the personal and the political always.
00:15:20.960 --> 00:15:22.320
And in my view, it's always both.
00:15:22.559 --> 00:15:24.000
Everything is always both.
00:15:24.240 --> 00:15:27.120
And by all accounts, you know, I've never met Teal, so what do I know?
00:15:27.200 --> 00:15:31.919
But you know, he was also a kind of awkward and not very popular student.
00:15:32.080 --> 00:15:53.039
And it seems as if this so-called contrarian identity that he established for himself and the kind of home he found in these institutions that were supporting right-wing provocation and contrarianism probably has something to do with his psychology and his personal social experiences.
00:15:53.279 --> 00:16:02.399
I think it's always tricky because certain right-wing figures do weaponize this idea of their own victimhood in really problematic ways.
00:16:02.480 --> 00:16:14.000
And I certainly would never call Peter Thiel a victim, but it does seem that he experienced a certain social alienation that then fed into this persona he developed as the right-wing provocateur.
00:16:14.399 --> 00:16:17.279
You definitely get that from reading Chafkin's book as well, right?
00:16:17.360 --> 00:16:26.159
It it definitely suggests that that is the case, or or at least that's that's one strand of understanding, you know, who he is and how he becomes who he is today.
00:16:26.320 --> 00:16:44.080
But you know, you talked about how he started the Stanford Review and how that served as one place where he grew a network and met a lot of connections through there that ended up being people who he came to know and and came to continue to be in touch with and to work with throughout his career, right?
00:16:44.399 --> 00:16:54.399
In 1995, he also published The Diversity Myth, which was a book that is along the lines of these kind of conservative talking points and conservative narratives that you would expect.
00:16:54.559 --> 00:17:11.119
So it seemed like he was headed down this direction of being one of these controversial right-wing figures like a Dinesh Jesusa, but then he takes a shift into investing and you know becomes one of the founders of PayPal or Confinity, which becomes PayPal.
00:17:11.359 --> 00:17:13.200
So what do we make of that shift?
00:17:13.279 --> 00:17:20.960
And then how important is PayPal to cementing his position in Silicon Valley and in the tech industry?
00:17:21.440 --> 00:17:30.400
Sorry, I just want to backtrack and say one more thing about Stanford because I think you know, I described him as a kind of provocature and compared him to D'Souza.
00:17:30.640 --> 00:17:40.240
You know, Teal went to law school at Stanford, and it seemed like he was on the track for a career as a corporate lawyer coming out of that.
00:17:40.559 --> 00:17:44.640
Chafkin's book does say that
classmates remember Teal wanting to be the next William F.
00:17:44.720 --> 00:17:50.240
Buckley, but I'm it's not clear to me that he ever wanted to be a media entrepreneur per se.
00:17:50.559 --> 00:18:04.799
Rather, by publishing this conservative newspaper and participating in these conservative student networks, he sort of tapped in to a network with powerful connections in New York law, corporate law, where he went briefly in Washington, D.C.
00:18:05.200 --> 00:18:14.640
He interviewed for a clerkship with Anton and Scalia, which he didn't get at various points when he's told his life story in a commencement speech at Hamilton, for instance.
00:18:14.720 --> 00:18:22.079
Uh, that's like an important turning point for him where he doesn't get this thing that he wanted and that he was sort of gunning for and then went back to the valley.
00:18:22.240 --> 00:18:25.359
So I just wanted to say when in calling him a provocative, I shouldn't overstate it.
00:18:25.440 --> 00:18:41.759
I don't think he literally wanted to be Dinesh D'Souza, but he was coming up through this network whose raison d'être is to bring together future media personalities and political figures and sort of people who will work in finance and at law firms to build a certain kind of power network.
00:18:42.160 --> 00:18:43.680
I appreciate that clarification.
00:18:43.759 --> 00:18:51.119
And it's interesting to think what could have happened had he gotten that clerkship with Scalia and you know a whole different trajectory that that he would have been on.
00:18:51.359 --> 00:18:52.000
Yeah.
00:18:52.720 --> 00:19:07.440
The one other thing I wanted to say about the campus moment is that the culture wars that are happening in the late 80s and early 90s, right, end of the Cold War, where if you wanted to be super schematic about it, you might say that these Cold Warriors are needing to invent a new kind of enemy.
00:19:07.519 --> 00:19:13.519
Um, and also that they need a pretext to defund the university, but that's a whole other conversation.
00:19:13.759 --> 00:19:25.680
In addition to these debates about the multicultural curriculum and political correctness on campus, the other big thing that's happening, of course, is anti-apartheid activism on campuses.
00:19:25.839 --> 00:19:38.480
And in Teel's biography, although he has since disputed this on a number of occasions, his sympathies with South African apartheid, and remember he had grown up partly in South Africa, come up again and again.
00:19:38.799 --> 00:19:48.559
It's funny, the New Republic made me take out all the times I pointed out someone who was a white South African in his network, which was probably wise on the part of their legal readers.
00:19:48.799 --> 00:19:57.519
But a lot of his network at Stanford seems to have been shaped, let's say, by their sense of alienation by the campus movement against apartheid.
00:19:57.680 --> 00:20:15.039
So that's just another fact that seems to bear mentioning that,
you know, if the Stanford Review is an institution that helps bring a lot of folks together, so too does anti-anti-apartheid seem to be uh a catalyst that brings together a lot of this network in the early 90s.
00:20:15.359 --> 00:20:29.759
Yeah, certainly there's another important figure whose connections to South Africa we talk about a lot, and who was with Teal at PayPal once their companies came together to become PayPal and what it is today, which is Elon Musk.
00:20:29.920 --> 00:20:40.480
And so when he goes into PayPal, when he is working with this company, you know, he's making a lot of promises around, you know, it's going to strip governments of the power to control their money supplies.
00:20:40.559 --> 00:20:48.799
And there's all this libertarian language around it before it pivots and becomes just a major middleman, I guess, for financial transactions online.
00:20:49.279 --> 00:21:00.000
So, what do we make of what he does at PayPal, and particularly the group of people who he surrounds himself with who become a really important group of people in shaping Silicon Valley, then after?
00:21:00.559 --> 00:21:23.680
PayPal also, in a sense, starts at Stanford, and there's this kind of legend or one of these mythic anecdotes that circulates in Silicon Valley about how Max Levchin, who's the technical co-founder, and Peter Thiel, meet Levchin, just finished his degree at the University of Illinois, the same department that had just produced Mark Andresen uh a few years earlier.
00:21:23.839 --> 00:21:27.759
You know, Mark Andresson developed the mosaic browser when he was there.
00:21:28.000 --> 00:21:36.880
Levchin came to the valley uh interested in starting a business or getting involved in the tech industry, as many graduates of that program did.
00:21:37.200 --> 00:21:46.319
He was actually crashing for the summer with Scott Bannister, later married to Cyan Bannister, who's I think the first female partner at Founders Fund.
00:21:46.480 --> 00:21:50.240
And I say this just to highlight kind of how tightly knit this network is.
00:21:50.400 --> 00:21:55.839
But Levchin, crashing with Scott Bannister, the legend, the sort of mythic anecdote has it.
00:21:55.920 --> 00:21:58.240
It's the summer in Palo Alto, it's hot.
00:21:58.400 --> 00:21:59.680
The apartment where Levchan is staying.
00:22:00.240 --> 00:22:06.640
Have air conditioning, so he randomly goes to talks at Stanford for the air conditioning and just kind of nods off.
00:22:06.799 --> 00:22:14.400
That he showed up at a talk that Teal was giving, I believe, through the Hoover Institute, where Teal had some kind of fellowship or affiliation.
00:22:14.720 --> 00:22:23.920
Arrives at this talk, realizes he's one of only five people in the audience, uh, and that it feels too rude to go to sleep, and listens to Teal's talk.
00:22:24.079 --> 00:22:31.200
Teal is talking about questions about currency and how to, you know, free money from the control of governments.
00:22:31.440
--> 00:22:47.599
Levchin listening to it realizes that his expertise in cryptography is relevant to what Teal is talking about, and goes up afterwards and they make a date to meet at Hobie's, this Palo Alto diner that's famous for tech meetups the next morning.
00:22:47.680 --> 00:23:00.880
And it's it that conversation that they sort of make their, you know, nothing in paper, but they agree to start PayPal and Levchin has the technical skills, and Teal's gonna put up the money, which I think is$500,000 or something to start.
00:23:01.039 --> 00:23:02.319
I could have that number wrong.
00:23:02.640 --> 00:23:12.640
I'll just cut in and say, you know, the the language that Teal is using seems very reminiscent of what we hear from cryptocurrency folks today, just to, you know, make that connection for people.
00:23:12.960 --> 00:23:15.119
Yeah, it's a very direct line.
00:23:15.200 --> 00:23:40.960
And in your original question that I'm answering at too great and digressive length, um, you said something about, you know, this idea that PayPal was built kind of with this very grand libertarian vision of creating a financial system that would not be beholden to governments and currency controls, and then ends up being something that like eBay buys and you know becomes a more mundane way of exchanging money.
00:23:41.119 --> 00:23:53.359
And perhaps we're seeing something like that in the tensions that people who know more about it than I do are pointing out around cryptocurrency and its centralization or how the state interacts with it today.
00:23:53.680 --> 00:24:00.400
Part of what PayPal does is it brings together all this engineering talent from Urbana Champagne with all these money guys from Stanford.
00:24:00.640 --> 00:24:06.799
Um, and if you go through the ranks of the folks in the PayPal mafia, that's often the way it breaks down.
00:24:07.039 --> 00:24:18.960
So they get together and start PayPal again with these very, I don't know if lofty is the word, but with a certain set of libertarian philosophies that they use to discuss the company.
00:24:19.200 --> 00:24:23.839
I think in the same building, I think it's not literally down the hall, maybe it's down the street.
00:24:23.920 --> 00:24:34.799
In the same complex, Elon Musk, that other South African child of mining money, is starting his company, x.com.
00:24:35.359 --> 00:24:38.559
x.com and PayPal are competitors.
00:24:38.640 --> 00:24:44.000
And I believe Sequoia Capital was funding x.com and Elon Musk and some of these beefs.
00:24:44.160 --> 00:24:53.759
Like I think one of the funny things about getting into this network is that it's not only friendship, but like these deep beefs that go back for decades and end up being important in all sorts of unexpected ways.
00:24:53.839 --> 00:25:02.000
But one of the beefs has to do with how Sequoia is perceived to be favoring Musk even after the merger of X.com and PayPal.
00:25:02.160 --> 00:25:08.720
But anyway, PayPal is then called
Confinity, which was a word they made up because their confidence is infinite.
00:25:08.960 --> 00:25:12.720
And X.com are pouring tons of money into competing.
00:25:12.960 --> 00:25:22.000
And Confinity in particular sees that as a fight they can't win because Elon Musk's company has the backing of Sequoia and has sort of deeper pockets behind it.
00:25:22.160 --> 00:25:25.599
I believe it's Ralph Botha, whose last name I've never said out loud.
00:25:25.680 --> 00:25:26.960
I think that's how you pronounce it.
00:25:27.119 --> 00:25:33.839
But Ralph Botha, this venture capitalist at Sequoia, who eventually helps broker a merger between the two companies.
00:25:34.000 --> 00:25:47.839
And the reason I want to point that out is that I think this was also an early moment where Teal began to develop his philosophy of tech monopoly and that it's not worthwhile to compete in a narrow niche like this.
00:25:48.000 --> 00:26:00.240
But there's sort of a natural tendency to trying to monopolize a service like payments and a rationality to monopoly, which he discusses at greater length much later in the book that he writes with Blake Masters, Zero to One.
00:26:00.319 --> 00:26:07.599
So Levchin and Teal Start PayPal hire a bunch of folks from around the Stanford Review and the technical folks from Urbana Champagne.
00:26:07.839 --> 00:26:14.559
Confinity as it is then called, merges with Elon Musk's X.com in the year 2000, I believe.
00:26:14.720 --> 00:26:20.799
There's all kinds of personality in fighting Teal and Elon never really get along.
00:26:21.039 --> 00:26:34.240
There's this line in Max Chafkin's biography where they're described by a mutual friend who I think says, Peter thinks Elon is a fraud and a braggart, and Elon thinks Peter is a sociopath.
00:26:34.799 --> 00:26:36.319
Maybe they're both right.
00:26:36.640 --> 00:26:36.880
Right.
00:26:36.960 --> 00:26:39.920
It's the one time that you uh you find yourself agreeing with them.
00:26:40.079 --> 00:26:42.240
Um but basically this this merger happens.
00:26:42.400 --> 00:26:44.400
Elon Musk is originally in charge.
00:26:44.720 --> 00:26:52.000
Teal leaves these surrogates of his in place and kind of stages a coup while Elon is away traveling uh on his honeymoon.
00:26:52.160 --> 00:26:53.519
Teal takes over the company.
00:26:53.680 --> 00:27:04.559
They sell eventually to eBay, although in a tiny misogynistic detail, I love Meg Whitman, the CEO of eBay, had been like a major target of theirs while they were developing.
00:27:04.720 --> 00:27:16.720
And in this book, The PayPal Mafia that they commission about themselves, Eric Jackson, the author, describes how in the PayPal office there was always a picture of Meg Whitman's face on a dartboard that people would throw darts at.
00:27:16.960 --> 00:27:25.279
But anyway, they're eventually bought by eBay, and a bunch of the executives as part of that deal have to stay on for a certain period of time.
00:27:25.359 --> 00:27:42.079
But Peel, without talking to the other executives about it, basically disappears pretty quickly after that, uh, which is part of a pattern of, I don't know if dubious or shadowy behavior is the way to put it, but of leaving folks he'd been working with feeling surprised, let's say.
00:27:42.400 --> 00:27:52.079
But this group of people who he assembled at PayPal go on to found a number of really important companies, including Yelp and YouTube and LinkedIn.
00:27:52.240 --> 00:28:02.319
And so in that sense, the money they make from PayPal and the sort of social network that they build at PayPal remains enormously influential in the Valley to this day.
00:28:02.720 --> 00:28:21.839
When you talk about that network that comes out of PayPal, this PayPal mafia that has all this money that goes on to create really key companies to the Valley, do they also bring that idea that Teal develops around the need to kind of create this monopoly, to lose a lot of money and then monopolize?
00:28:22.000 --> 00:28:31.839
Because after that is conceived, I guess, in this PayPal moment, it seems that that becomes quite a defining feature of tech companies and the valley itself.
00:28:32.240 --> 00:28:33.759
Yeah, that's a great question.
00:28:33.920 --> 00:28:35.680
And I think it's hard for me to answer.
00:28:35.759 --> 00:28:36.880
And I'm trying to answer it.
00:28:36.960 --> 00:28:55.839
I'll probably put my finger on something I find tricky about talking about teal in general, because as you ask the question, I find myself thinking: is it that teal sort of came up with this idea, or did he just name it in a certain way when it's what Wall Street and sort of what the market and the valley were already doing?
00:28:56.079 --> 00:28:57.759
Amazon comes to mind, of course.
00:28:57.920 --> 00:29:14.160
Amazon is also a company founded in the 90s that grasps this insight that Wall Street is valuing tech companies based on number of users, not profits, and that therefore it's possible to raise capital to expand uh while either losing money or not making very much money.
00:29:14.559 --> 00:29:18.400
I hesitate over whether idea is even the right noun to use for it.
00:29:18.480 --> 00:29:25.920
Like, is that an idea or is that a material reality about these companies that benefit from network effects?
00:29:26.079 --> 00:30:00.240
But it's certainly true that Teal, both because he's sort of the absent or secretive center of this entire network of people, but also because he self-fashions as an intellectual and you know goes to academic conferences and edits a book of philosophy papers uh and styles himself that way, he's certainly a person who is early to articulating this idea that, as I would put it, firms that benefit from network effects tend towards natural monopoly and that therefore competition is actually not desirable.
00:30:00.400 --> 00:30:10.079
Just as he and Elon, with the intervention of Sequoia, determined that it was not worthwhile for them to try to
outcompete one another with their payment startups.
00:30:10.720 --> 00:30:12.640
I think that really captures it well, right?
00:30:12.720 --> 00:30:16.720
To illustrate that it's not so much that this is something that Peter Thiel came up with.
00:30:16.880 --> 00:30:35.119
It was something that was already around and maybe he gives it a name and so it gets associated with him in particular, even as Jeff Bezos is very much building a company that is firmly based on this idea, and it's something that is pervading the valley, but that he identifies it or writes about it so it gets identified with him in particular and the group of people who are around him.
00:30:35.839 --> 00:30:40.559
Teal is very, very comfortable being the bad guy.
00:30:40.720 --> 00:30:46.799
Indeed, that's his identity, that he's, you know, what we would now call a troll, or I was calling a provocateur.
00:30:46.960 --> 00:30:55.839
And he's very comfortable with and embraces a certain philosophy in which power is sort of its own justification.
00:30:56.000 --> 00:31:04.720
Power justifies itself, and other kinds of moral criteria or social or political considerations are not legitimate or intellectually serious.
00:31:04.880 --> 00:31:16.640
Again, this is someone who is reported, though he now denies it, to have told people in undergrad apartheid is a perfectly sound economic system, and therefore I'm anti-anti-apartheid.
00:31:16.880 --> 00:31:30.960
And so, to the extent that this logic of monopoly, that as you say, powers and propels so many tech firms, if not all of our big tech firms today, is not unique to Teal, and it's certainly not his unique insight.
00:31:31.119 --> 00:31:35.359
He's pretty early in the curve and seeing how to exploit that in a certain sense.
00:31:35.599 --> 00:31:44.640
And above all, is very comfortable being identified with that, and you know, has an entire canon of thinkers, he claims.
00:31:44.720 --> 00:31:53.839
Although so often, whenever he's talking about René Girard or whomever, I think you could just say Ayn Rand, like maybe it's just Ayn Rand is the only one he's ever actually talking about.
00:31:54.079 --> 00:31:56.559
We should take his intellectualism with a grain of salt.
00:31:56.799 --> 00:32:21.519
But he has an entire ideology or kind of philosophical vocabulary for describing why, you know, what he calls zero to one, this sort of Nietzsche and heroic view of the founder, justifies the accumulation of monopoly power in the hands of just a few people, in a way that, you know, someone like Jeff Bezos will still say, oh, Amazon's great because it's good for small businesses who use it or it brings jobs to here or there.
00:32:21.680 --> 00:32:25.359
Teal is very comfortable with this language of power.
00:32:26.160 --> 00:32:30.799
Maybe we see that in the next part of Teal's life that I wanted to discuss, right?
00:32:30.960 --> 00:32:38.319
Because as you describe and as Max describes in the book, Peter Thiel kind of co-founds um Palantir in 2003.
00:32:38.480 --> 00:32:48.160
And that is very much based on technologies that were developed from PayPal that were then reoriented toward national security finding terrorists, blah, blah, blah, right?
00:32:48.400 --> 00:32:59.440
And so that is used to found this company, and I think you see a very significant shift in the narrative or the justification around it, whereas PayPal is positioned as this very kind of libertarian company.
00:32:59.519 --> 00:33:03.279
You're taking the banking system away from the government, et cetera, et cetera.
00:33:03.359 --> 00:33:13.920
Uh with Palantir, you're working very closely with the national security establishment, with militaries, with the state itself, which goes against at least how PayPal was framed.
00:33:14.079 --> 00:33:21.440
And when we talked before doing this interview, you talked about how Palantir is often positioned in terms of surveillance, right?
00:33:21.519 --> 00:33:22.480
This is the big problem.
00:33:22.720 --> 00:33:28.319
But you talk about what he does with this company is much more fascist, and that doesn't get talked about nearly enough.
00:33:28.559 --> 00:33:28.720
Yeah.
00:33:28.880 --> 00:33:30.559
So can you expand on that point?
00:33:31.039 --> 00:33:31.440
Yeah.
00:33:31.759 --> 00:33:32.880
To go back to the beginning.
00:33:32.960 --> 00:33:36.480
So Palantir is founded in 2003 or 2004.
00:33:36.799 --> 00:33:51.839
And as Max Chaftkin tells the story in his book, the sort of spark of the idea comes to Teal when he's invited through his conservative connections that he's developed since his Stanford undergraduate days to an event at the Bush White House, at the George W.
00:33:51.920 --> 00:33:54.240
Bush White House, in the wake of 9-11.
00:33:54.480 --> 00:34:28.000
And Teal recognizes that with the new Department of Homeland Security programs and these new enormous global systems of surveillance and data gathering that we all know about now, thanks to Edward Snowden, that there's going to be a huge demand by different government agencies for software that can kind of parse and organize this data, and also for ontologies and taxonomies that will make it possible to connect different sources of data and analyze them.
00:34:28.480 --> 00:34:38.559
At this time, Max Levchen and the technical team at PayPal had already developed something that they called the Igor system that was supposed to detect financial fraud.
00:34:38.800 --> 00:34:43.199
Actors who are using PayPal for money laundering or fraud and so on.
00:34:43.440 --> 00:34:59.280
This is a bit of a short version of the story, but Teal putting two and two together sees that the kinds of techniques they've developed for tracking fraud at PayPal could be useful, and that there's basically a huge business opportunity to build software for the government.
00:34:59.599 --> 00:35:05.360
It's interesting to me because critics of Teal have described this as a kind of hypocrisy on his
part, right?
00:35:05.519 --> 00:35:13.599
There was a big article in Reason Magazine, perhaps in 2020, that had some headline that said, you know, Peter Thiel was supposed to be a libertarian.
00:35:13.679 --> 00:35:14.480
What happened?
00:35:14.800 --> 00:35:33.760
I think observers have often seen that Peter Thiel's eagerness to build software for the state and for government agencies, or at least to make a lot of money saying that he's going to build software for nation states as a kind of contradiction or as intention with his libertarian political philosophy.
00:35:33.920 --> 00:35:38.559
Whereas I think that Teal thinks that corporations should take over the apparatus of the state.
00:35:38.719 --> 00:35:45.840
And in that sense, I'm not sure that I think it's as inconsistent with his worldview as other critics and observers have suggested.
00:35:46.079 --> 00:36:32.559
But in any case, Thiel looks at this new sort of enormous system of global surveillance that the United States is spinning up in the wake of 9-11, realizes that there will be demand for software that can help agencies parse it and make sense of it, and that the war on terror will be this big business opportunity, takes some of the ideas that Levchin or some of the techniques Levchin had developed at PayPal, although I should say, as TNR Legal made me say, I don't know how much of the exact software is the same, but comes up with this idea for the company Palantir that I believe he starts in 2003, and then he asks Alex Carp, his buddy from Stanford Law School, who's a very sort of eccentric character we could get into on his own, to be the CEO.
00:36:32.639 --> 00:36:50.559
And Carp, who's realized for reasons that make perfect sense to me, having spent time with his dissertation, that he doesn't want to be a philosophy professor, um, but rather wants to be an investor, is doing fundraising already, I believe, but is connected to sort of tech investors in Europe and in the United States as well.
00:36:50.800 --> 00:36:54.159
Should highlight Carp as someone who learned German as a second language.
00:36:54.320 --> 00:37:07.760
His mom is black and his dad's Jewish, so he his background is different than Thiel's, but he is a sort of Teutonophile, loves Germany, went to do his PhD there, speaks German, slightly crappy American accent, I'll say, just to be a bitch.
00:37:07.920 --> 00:37:10.559
Um, but uh but speaks German quite well and so on.
00:37:10.719 --> 00:37:34.159
Anyway, Thiel taps Carp to be the CEO of Palantir, and they ran the company from the beginning as this sort of civilizational project in a sense that it's going to help the West, which I say in quote quotation marks because I think the West is a very problematic idea, and for them includes Saudi Arabia, um, but help the West win the war on terror.
00:37:34.400 --> 00:37:43.679
And they raise money around that both privately and they get some funding from InQutel, which is the venture arm of the CIA, and sort of take Palantir from there.
00:37:44.320 --> 00:37:47.440
It's interesting because you talked about there, like the positioning of it, right?
00:37:47.599 --> 00:38:08.320
And I think what that kind of starts to get at is a larger political orientation that Peter Thiel has has suggested in recent years, in particular the need for the West or for the United States to challenge China in particular and to not allow China to achieve technological supremacy over the United States.
00:38:08.480 --> 00:38:09.920
So, what do we see in that?
00:38:10.000 --> 00:38:13.440
And I guess the relationship between what is doing with Palantir?
00:38:13.920 --> 00:38:15.280
Two things come to mind.
00:38:15.440 --> 00:38:26.800
I think that if I were being cynical and shorthandy about it, I might observe that Teal has a tendency to focus on whoever, you know, the most lucrative enemy of the United States is in that moment.
00:38:26.960 --> 00:38:34.159
And in the early 2000s, it is Islamofascism, which again I'm making air quotes, which you can't see on a podcast.
00:38:34.320 --> 00:38:45.599
But in the first case, it's the war on terror, and then he's pivoted towards a focus on China since 2015 or 2016, maybe a little bit later, since the mid-2010s, let's say.
00:38:45.920 --> 00:39:05.760
So I think one other thing that's striking, and again, as one of these things, I think there are a lot of things about Palantir because people became aware of Palantir because, in my view, I became aware of Palantir this way, because in 2016, Teal became very visible in the valley as a conservative and then as a Trump surrogate, and Palantir was his company.
00:39:05.920 --> 00:39:17.840
There were also so these important exposes of how Palantir was working with ICE and CBP in the wake of the 2016 election, and that rightly attracted public ire to Palantir.
00:39:17.920 --> 00:39:38.079
But Palantir became a kind of object of criticism in this moment of growing worry about what Shoshana Zuboff named surveillance capitalism and the power of Google and Facebook and sort of attention-driven tech firms, you know, YouTube and Instagram and all the subsidiaries of Alphabet and Meta as well.
00:39:38.320 --> 00:39:47.760
So, in a sense, I think that that led to Palantirs being sort of lumped in with these concerns about surveillance, whereas that's not exactly what Palantir does.
00:39:48.000 --> 00:39:54.239
Palantir is not a company that makes money by gathering data on normal people, you know, on people, period.
00:39:54.480 --> 00:40:04.079
Palantir is a company that makes money by selling enterprises, both state agencies and private companies, ways of looking at and organizing the data that they have.
00:40:04.400 --> 00:40:08.000
So that is a fundamentally different kind of enterprise.
00:40:08.079 --> 00:40:14.960
It's pulling on social media data at times and on data gathered through surveillance, but it itself is not surveilling.
00:40:15.119 --> 00:40:39.119
And in
connection with that, one of these things about Palantir that I think, if you were just like a person reading Bloomberg and the New York Times during the Trump administration, that felt confusing and felt confusing to me for a long time, was that Palantirians from sort of rank and file to Alex Carp have this language about privacy and civil liberties and how Palantir is a company that protects civil liberties.
00:40:39.440 --> 00:40:47.679
And I think, speaking just for myself early on, as a more casual observer of the company, I would just sort of scratch my head at that and say, what on earth are they talking about?
00:40:47.840 --> 00:41:07.440
But a fundamental part of their value proposition is that because they're building taxonomies and ontologies and ways of looking at data for different enterprises, they also can set controls on who accesses what in order to comply with different kinds of privacy regimes or different restrictions.
00:41:07.519 --> 00:41:15.360
And so they, this is a bit of a tangent, but through that develop this branding and identity around being into privacy and into civil liberties.
00:41:15.440 --> 00:41:31.679
And that is part of their branding as being invested in the West and Western values and first being a key instrument, according to them, in the fight against so-called radical Islam and now in the fight against China.
00:41:32.000 --> 00:41:42.880
I wanted to say that because I think that's the kind of thing that initially, and I, you know, I met people who work for Palantir, and I would be sort of baffled, frankly, when they would say these things about privacy and really valuing civil liberties.
00:41:43.039 --> 00:41:49.039
And I guess I only came to understand what that was about as I spent more time talking to some Palantir formers.
00:41:49.119 --> 00:41:55.519
And then also, you know, as we all learned more about the company and its business model when it filed in 2020.
00:41:55.920 --> 00:42:00.639
I mean, another whole thing that's interesting to talk about is like how much it works it all.
00:42:00.880 --> 00:42:05.119
You know, I think there was that piece in New York magazine about whether it's all smoke and mirrors.
00:42:05.199 --> 00:42:18.960
And as Chafkin points out in his biography of Teal, Palantir kind of gets an enormous amount of mileage out of this totally unsubstantiated claim that their technologies were central to the capture of Osama bin Laden.
00:42:19.280 --> 00:42:27.599
Um, and so I think, as with all these highly secretive tech companies, there are a bunch of questions to be asked about what exactly the technology does and how it works.
00:42:27.840 --> 00:42:37.119
Sometimes I, as a scholar or critic, worry that by centering it in our critique, we actually are sort of like raising its stock prices in a certain way.
00:42:37.360 --> 00:42:46.480
At the same time, I think it's really important to recognize how these companies come to be embedded within powerful institutions.
00:42:46.719 --> 00:42:51.519
Um, there's a newish book by an academic called Sarah Brain called To Predict and Surveil.
00:42:51.679 --> 00:43:01.599
And she actually did sort of deep ethnographic work with the Los Angeles Police Department during the period that they were using Palantir for sort of dragnet surveillance purposes.
00:43:01.760 --> 00:43:13.760
And reading that book, I often found myself asking this question to myself of, you know, is the problem with Palantir how its software works, or is the problem with Palantir the fact that the LAPD use it?
00:43:13.920 --> 00:43:25.599
You know, I think that it's important as people who think about the social impacts of technology to recognize that the harms it enacts often have as much to do with the institutions they're being taken up by as with the technologies.
00:43:25.679 --> 00:43:26.880
But that's a bit of a digression.
00:43:27.599 --> 00:43:59.760
I wonder if that is also a way of understanding Thiels' recent engagement in politics in a more concerted way, in the sense that, you know, as you said, he becomes a more visible figure in 2015, 2016 as he is vocally supporting Donald Trump and funding the Republican Party and particular Republican candidates, and now has made a point that he will be funding particular candidates who represent his view of what the Republican Party could be and what the politics of the United States could be, people like.
00:44:00.079 --> 00:44:01.840
JD Vance, Blake Masters.
00:44:02.079 --> 00:44:10.159
So what do we make of Teal's move into politics in such a concerted way and funding these candidates to represent his interests?
00:44:10.559 --> 00:44:13.119
Yeah, just all these, you know, white men with high cheekbones.
00:44:13.199 --> 00:44:15.119
He has this particular type, except JD Vance.
00:44:15.199 --> 00:44:17.679
I don't know how JD, I don't know how JD snuck in there.
00:44:17.920 --> 00:44:18.800
You know, it's hard.
00:44:18.880 --> 00:44:32.639
I found myself thinking while you were asking the question, this is like a goofy thing to say, but I was like, I'm more inclined to a functionalist interpretation of Peter Thiel than a psychological interpretation of Peter Thiel, where I think his psychology is impossible to know.
00:44:32.800 --> 00:44:36.159
And frankly, you know, the state of Peter Thiel's soul is his own problem.
00:44:36.320 --> 00:44:38.480
I don't, we don't need to concern ourselves with it.
00:44:38.800 --> 00:44:41.119
So he becomes super visible in 2016.
00:44:41.199 --> 00:44:45.199
He speaks at the Republican National Convention in a very prominent spot.
00:44:45.280 --> 00:44:48.159
Uh, he speaks about being a gay Republican, which is a big deal.
00:44:48.320 --> 00:44:51.920
I believe there had been one openly gay speaker at the RNC before.
00:44:52.079 --> 00:44:59.840
But you know, it's talked about in the media in the summer of 2016 as the first openly gay Republican speaker at the RNC convention.
00:45:00.079 -->
00:45:10.559
He then, in October 2016, after the Access Hollywood tape leaks, and Trump is, you know, on record saying that he likes to grab women by the pussy.
00:45:10.639 --> 00:45:13.280
And you know, the Republican establishment is kind of fleeing.
00:45:13.440 --> 00:45:18.000
Everyone mistakenly is thinking, oh God, that has to be the death knell of his campaign.
00:45:18.079 --> 00:45:19.199
That's one took over the line.
00:45:19.440 --> 00:45:24.880
Teal doubles down and donates, I want to say,$1.5 million to him right after that happens.
00:45:25.039 --> 00:45:30.800
And so the speech and these donations catapult him into a national spotlight.
00:45:31.039 --> 00:45:42.719
But I, again, it under the philosophy that we should have a functionalist interpretation of Teal rather than a psychological interpretation, it seems clear that he has ideological affinities with Trump and with Trumpism.
00:45:42.960 --> 00:45:56.880
But I also think that these donations and decisions are sort of contrarian investment bets, where he sees that he has an opportunity to back this candidate who almost no one in his world is backing.
00:45:57.039 --> 00:46:01.039
And frankly, you know, by the standards of how much money Peter Thiel has, it's not that much money.
00:46:01.199 --> 00:46:03.039
$1.5 million, it's not very much.
00:46:03.199 --> 00:46:17.119
And he sees that if Trump wins, that will put him in the position all of a sudden to be his prime connection to the valley, uh, and in a really good position to negotiate the kinds of contracts that Palantir is going after.
00:46:17.199 --> 00:46:24.960
And Palantir had cultivated relationships with Michael Flynn and General McMasters and other sort of Trump world people beforehand.
00:46:25.280 --> 00:46:32.639
All this to say, you know, I think it's a tricky and unknowable and perhaps ultimately irrelevant question what Peter Thiel actually thinks.
00:46:32.719 --> 00:46:41.440
But I think it's useful to think about these political bets that he makes within the framework of investing, which is the framework he by all accounts uses to think about everything.
00:46:41.599 --> 00:46:50.719
And that the investment in Trump is a kind of contrarian bet, you know, contrarian in the investor sense of going against dominant market trends that pays off for him.
00:46:50.880 --> 00:46:53.440
Trump gets elected, no one else had thought it would happen.
00:46:53.679 --> 00:46:57.119
Teal finds himself kind of the intermediary with Silicon Valley.
00:46:57.199 --> 00:47:01.280
He gets in office in Trump Tower, he gets close to Steve Bannon for a time.
00:47:01.440 --> 00:47:10.719
And I should say that Teal had had contacts, as do the Mercers, with folks around Breitbart and Bannon, uh, the sort of anti-Hillary Clinton universe before.
00:47:10.960 --> 00:47:18.079
But I think when I look at Teal's pronouncements and donations, I think we can't ever take them quite at face value.
00:47:18.239 --> 00:47:28.880
We should see them as like bets or moves in a certain game of chess, which is not to say that he um doesn't possibly have beliefs that we would find offensive or despicable.
00:47:29.039 --> 00:47:32.400
But I think, you know, he's not a philosopher uh at the end of the day.
00:47:32.480 --> 00:47:34.559
He's an investor, and that's where his power matters.
00:47:34.639 --> 00:47:39.360
There are a lot of little boys who like Ann Rand, only, you know, only one of them is Peter Thiel.
00:47:39.599 --> 00:47:50.000
Uh, and I mean the thing with China is also hard to say because the anti-China stance is a very Trumpist stance, but frankly, in my view, regrettably, to a large extent, it's also a very bipartisan stance right now.
00:47:50.079 --> 00:47:54.719
I mean, it's hardly controversial to be anti-China in the United States right now.
00:47:54.960 --> 00:48:09.199
But yeah, he does position himself that way and tries to position himself in contrast to Google as sort of anti-China in the latter years of the Trump administration, even though he was going and giving zero-to-one uh seminars at Tsinghua and, you know, visiting China.
00:48:09.440 --> 00:48:14.800
The book is so popular in China, actually, because it sells like a million copies in China, literally.
00:48:15.039 --> 00:48:16.480
It's fascinating though.
00:48:16.719 --> 00:48:32.880
I was just gonna say that I do want to make this point where I think for someone like me and for certain critics of Teal, there has been this attraction to him that because since he does sort of self-style as an intellectual, he feels like a good peg to like hang our ideas pieces on.
00:48:33.119 --> 00:48:47.440
And so I have felt vexed in my own work and thinking about this, about how to think about Teal's ideas, because in a sense, they're enormously important because he and members of his network are powerful and have a lot of power to realize their ideas.
00:48:47.599 --> 00:48:51.360
On the other hand, as I said, a lot of little boys like Ayn Rand.
00:48:51.440 --> 00:48:57.280
Uh, and so I feel hesitant to attribute too much causal power to them in many cases.
00:48:57.440 --> 00:49:05.679
And by extension, I think, you know, he's someone who sort of made a career out of getting attention by being hated since he was at least in college.
00:49:05.840 --> 00:49:11.199
And so I think that when he makes a controversial statement and everyone rushes to say, oh my God, how could you say that?
00:49:11.280 --> 00:49:14.480
Uh, it's important not to get pulled into his media game.
00:49:14.559 --> 00:49:19.119
And I think many people have become more sophisticated about that in the past four years.
00:49:19.280 --> 00:49:29.840
But I think that there's a way that, yeah, when we're writing and thinking about him, we have to remember that saying, oh God, how could he say that only serves to aggrandize his mythology.
00:49:30.480 --> 00:49:32.079
Yeah, I think is a really good point.
00:49:32.239 --> 00:49:41.599
As we end our conversation, I have two final questions that I think will sum up what we've been talking about in this conversation and getting these details about Peter Thiel's past.
00:49:42.000 --> 00:49:47.920
As we started this conversation, as I said at the beginning, you talked about how Peter Thiel's network is really important, right?
00:49:48.000 --> 00:49:50.880
The network that he has brought together, the network that he controls.
00:49:50.960 --> 00:50:00.320
And you described how in the 1970s, you know, there was a group of people who coalesced around Stuart Brand and the whole Earth catalog, and then went on to be influential in the decades that followed.
00:50:00.480 --> 00:50:02.960
Steve Jobs is a notable example, right?
00:50:03.199 --> 00:50:10.559
But then in the 2000s, you have this similar group that coalesced around Teal, the PayPal mafia, but then these other people who he gets to know as well.
00:50:10.960 --> 00:50:17.519
And Brand's influence was a libertarian politics that many have cited in the valley over many years.
00:50:17.840 --> 00:50:25.920
But do we underestimate the degree of Teal's influence in the Valley and the right-wing politics that he espouses?
00:50:26.480 --> 00:50:31.519
Have they become more broadly influential in the tech industry than we often recognize?
00:50:32.400 --> 00:51:02.960
I think a lot of what is often described as the Californian ideology, uh, to quote the name of a famous and important article from the 90s, or this sort of mix of social liberalism and fiscal, if not conservatism, then libertarianism, the sort of cocktail of values associated with the leadership class of Silicon Valley, is often traced back to Stuart Brand, another libertarian white male Stanford graduate.
00:51:03.199 --> 00:51:43.920
But this group of people who come together around Brand from the late 60s onward, uh, and the historian Fred Turner has a wonderful book on this subject called From Counterculture to Cyberculture, in which he argues that many of the beliefs and practices of the kinds of white leftists or hippies who sort of founded communes in Northern California during that period directly informed the development of personal computing technologies and this industry that grows up in the post-Cold War period in Silicon Valley.
00:51:44.239 --> 00:51:55.360
I interpret Teal and the PayPal Mafia as a kind of next iteration, in a sense, of this process that Fred describes in that book.
00:51:55.760 --> 00:52:01.440
My friend Quinn Slobodian, who's a historian of neoliberalism, teases me what does he say?
00:52:01.599 --> 00:52:08.159
Fred's book is called Counterculture to Cyberculture, and he teases me that mine is like cyberculture to cryptoculture.
00:52:09.119 --> 00:52:29.599
And a big point that Fred emphasizes about the Stuart Brand crew is that they both are creating new kinds of social networks and ways of living and experimenting with technology, but also creating media that mythologizes themselves doing this and creates a kind of culture and ideology to go along with the work they're doing.
00:52:29.840 --> 00:52:49.920
And in my view, the PayPal Mafia, a moniker that comes from a 2007 profile of all of them, but this group of people we've been talking about that coalesces around Stanford and PayPal in the 90s and early 2000s, it's similar in many ways to the brand, the brand mafia, but it's happening in a different historical moment, right?
00:52:50.000 --> 00:52:58.320
This isn't the end of the global 1960s when everyone's supposed to be committed to social revolution or personal transformation and change.
00:52:58.400 --> 00:52:59.199
This is the 80s.
00:52:59.280 --> 00:53:03.360
This is like the greed is good, kind of everyone wants to go be an investment banker era.
00:53:03.599 --> 00:53:15.519
And I think that the beliefs of this group and their lack of interest in social movements or personal transformation, and then that sense, as a you know, as a substitute for social movements reflects that context.
00:53:15.599 --> 00:53:16.960
Uh, and they're similar, yeah.
00:53:17.039 --> 00:53:25.199
I think I was holding up this book by Eric Jackson, but Teal is constantly self-publishing books or funding the publication of things about this group.
00:53:25.519 --> 00:53:30.400
They're building a mythos around themselves in a similar way, for sure.
00:53:30.639 --> 00:53:40.239
I think another idea I haven't quite fully developed, but I do think there's something too and is worth exploring, is that this first generation, right?
00:53:40.320 --> 00:53:43.119
And we have Stuart Brand and Steve Job Jobs.
00:53:43.199 --> 00:53:44.000
I always say Job.
00:53:44.400 --> 00:53:54.719
Steve Jobs is inspired by him, and Shell Caffin, who's one of the first engineers at Amazon, had actually worked for Brand and like lived with him or traveled around with the van uh in the whole earth catalog.
00:53:55.280 --> 00:54:00.559
That first generation is making consumer internet companies, right?
00:54:00.719 --> 00:54:04.239
And Chris Cox at Facebook is also obsessed with the whole earth catalog.
00:54:04.320 --> 00:54:07.440
And I know Patrick Collison at Stripe is obsessed with brand too.
00:54:07.519 --> 00:54:20.400
And so there are a number of founders in the valley who've remained very influenced by this Brandian idea of like making people tools, and then they'll go build whatever communities and do whatever they're gonna do with them.
00:54:20.480 --> 00:54:27.920
And it's an idea that it makes sense, that it meshes with a certain kind of socially permissive libertarian ideology, right?
00:54:28.159 --> 00:54:48.320
Because Facebook or Google or Stripe or Amazon makes money by giving us anything you might possibly want to buy in the largest product catalog in the world and giving people tools to set up whatever kinds of social media communities, whatever you want to search for, whether it's the KKK or BLM, you know, Google can make
money off that search.
00:54:48.400 --> 00:54:56.800
There's a certain kind of cultural openness that I think meshes very uh naturally with that kind of consumer-facing internet tech.
00:54:57.519 --> 00:55:13.599
Teal, interestingly, although he starts with payments and PayPal, sort of where he first makes his name and is, of course, an early investor to Facebook as part of this elaborate F you to Sequoia and the beginning of this like founder-focused investment culture, which we didn't really touch on.
00:55:13.760 --> 00:55:16.639
But anyway, Talenteer isn't is enterprise software.
00:55:16.800 --> 00:55:18.159
It's selling enterprise software.
00:55:18.320 --> 00:55:23.440
They're not making money off of you and me and everyone who wants to search for or broadcast or buy anything.
00:55:23.599 --> 00:55:27.119
Uh, they want to sell software to large corporations and governments.
00:55:27.360 --> 00:55:35.280
And I think there are technological changes, the rise of certain kinds of enterprise software in the cloud is stuff that we could think about in connection with this.
00:55:35.440 --> 00:55:41.920
I think a lot about this question of like what comes after the attention economy or something once the attention economy is made as much money as it can make.
00:55:42.239 --> 00:55:46.000
I think certain things we're seeing in China with the new tech regulation have to do with that too.
00:55:46.159 --> 00:56:07.119
But anyway, I think that, you know, the PayPal mafia is analogous in some ways to the whole earth catalog group or the counterculture to cyber culture Stuart brand types, but they're building different kinds of companies and they have this different kind of political orientation and style of self-presentation.
00:56:07.280 --> 00:56:11.599
And I think that's partly the milieu and the times, as I said.
00:56:11.679 --> 00:56:22.880
And I think it is partly about how that change in the times is pointing towards new kinds of business models and you know, the Silicon Valley of the new Cold War, however, that will be.
00:56:23.360 --> 00:56:51.360
I think it's really interesting to frame it as there was this group of people around Stuart Brand, and you know, as you described, from counterculture to cyberculture, and now there is this new group of influential people that we haven't fully recognized, have had this kind of influence that, you know, I maybe in retrospect we're recognizing that more, but at the moment it it wasn't recognized and still hasn't been recognized as much because there's still a lot of emphasis placed on brand and whole earth and and those kind of ideas that come out of it.
00:56:51.760 --> 00:56:55.599
Yeah, honestly, the framing of like Peter Thiel, he's so conservative, who can believe it?
00:56:55.760 --> 00:57:06.960
Silicon Valley has a conservative, even when pieces that critique him take that framing, they actually serve to obscure how kind of long-running the political tendencies he represents have been in
the Valley.
00:57:07.519 --> 00:57:08.079
Great point.
00:57:08.239 --> 00:57:10.639
So to end our conversation, a final question, right?
00:57:10.800 --> 00:57:31.920
Because we've talked about the influence that Peter Thiel has had in making these companies, but also in forming this network, in in having this group of people who he's close with, who he's associated with, and how this network has gone on to really create important companies that have transformed the way we live, the way we engage with a whole load of different services and things like that in our lives, right?
00:57:32.159 --> 00:57:36.880
Now we've also been through this experience of the pandemic, which is not fully over yet.
00:57:37.039 --> 00:57:43.440
And in Max Chafkin's book, he cites an interview that Teal did in August of 2020 with our develop.
00:57:43.920 --> 00:57:48.559
I might be totally mispronouncing that, and he said that COVID-19 had created an opening.
00:57:48.800 --> 00:57:54.239
In a quote, he said changes that should have taken place long ago did not come because there was resistance.
00:57:54.480 --> 00:57:57.440
Now the future is set free because of the pandemic.
00:57:57.679 --> 00:58:10.159
Do you think that in a post-pandemic world, someone like Peter Thiel and the politics that he represents have a greater influence, you know, within Silicon Valley, but also in the kind of the world that comes next?
00:58:12.639 --> 00:58:22.000
Well, to answer most concretely, Palantir did win a ton of HHS and COVID-related contracts early in the pandemic.
00:58:22.159 --> 00:58:50.079
And I think at various points in the United States, anyway, the real breakdown of sort of basic social and government services during the pandemic, I don't know if it's quite that it's given more credence to or made more plausible some of the kinds of critiques of the nation-state and its dysfunction that Teal and people in his circle, like Palaji Srinavasin, have been advocating.
00:58:50.400 --> 00:58:59.519
I wonder also, I don't remember the exact quotation that you're that you're citing, but I think also uh that COVID has produced a more bordered world again.
00:58:59.679 --> 00:59:01.679
China is still basically closed.
00:59:01.840 --> 00:59:06.239
Australia and New Zealand, as you know, are like significantly locked down.
00:59:06.719 --> 00:59:10.400
And we're also closing off Russia to the world at this moment, right?
00:59:10.719 --> 00:59:11.920
Now we're closing off Russia.
00:59:12.000 --> 00:59:19.199
So in a in a moment of deglobalization, you know, those who make the technologies that make the borders stand to make a lot of money.
00:59:19.280 --> 00:59:33.360
And to the extent that borders themselves are created and monitored by surveillance and various kinds of software, because increasingly also, you know, borders surround people and follow us around, and it's not just the physical border.
00:59:33.599 --> 00:59:43.440
My pessimistic answer to the question is that I think that there are ways that as a major disruptive event, COVID has created a world.
00:59:43.679 --> 00:59:51.679
And in the ways that it's heightened the sort of new Cold War tensions and the war is now creating this situation of heightened tension between Russia and the rest of the world.
00:59:51.840 --> 00:59:58.320
There are ways that this has created a moment of opportunity for Teal and his worldview.
00:59:58.400 --> 01:00:02.960
And I think, you know, the famous contrarian investing line, right, is to buy when there's blood in the streets.
01:00:03.119 --> 01:00:23.840
So I think that in that sense, COVID, in addition to literally making available a bunch of new government contracts to process a new kind of data for Palantir, has maybe created a moment of opportunity for those who like Teal or Schrinavas and want to see a certain kind of continued sort of evisceration of the state and tech companies moving in and so on.
01:00:24.079 --> 01:00:36.480
On the other hand, I think we have to recognize that this kind of statement, uh, and this comes back to my functionalist interpretation of Peter Thiel, we have to keep in mind that this kind of statement is like a marketing statement for himself.
01:00:36.639 --> 01:00:45.280
And so the world after COVID, or you know, in the ongoing wake of COVID, is only Peter Thiel's world if we let it be.
01:00:45.440 --> 01:00:52.079
And so I think that it's always worthwhile to take his pronouncements about these things with a grain of salt.
01:00:52.239 --> 01:00:55.280
When he says he's being evil, that's advertising.
01:00:55.599 --> 01:00:59.119
I think that's a great point to leave it on and to leave the listeners with.
01:00:59.280 --> 01:01:05.920
Moira, I have really enjoyed chatting with you to getting your insight on Peter Thiel and this network that he has created.
01:01:06.159 --> 01:01:06.960
Thank you so much.
01:01:07.199 --> 01:01:07.920
Thank you, Paris.
01:01:08.159 --> 01:01:08.960
It was fun.
01:01:09.679 --> 01:01:17.199
Moira Weigel is an assistant professor at Northeastern University, a founding editor of Logic Magazine, and the co-editor of Voices from the Valley.
01:01:17.360 --> 01:01:23.440
You can follow her on Twitter at at Moira Gene Weigel, you can follow me at Parismarks, and you can follow the show at at Techwalk Save Up.
01:01:23.599 --> 01:01:28.960
Techwalk Save Up is part of the Harpinger Media Network, and you can find it more but at harping network.com.
01:01:29.119 --> 01:01:35.360
And if you want to support the work that goes into making the show every week, you can go to Patreon.com slash Techwalk Save Up and become a supporter.