رونوشت 🔗
Jordan Audio Episode
===
Edward: [00:00:00] [00:00:01] I'm Edward [00:00:02] Cohen, and this is [00:00:03] Tangent, a [00:00:04] Commercial Observer [00:00:05] podcast. [00:00:06] [00:00:07] [00:00:08] [00:00:09] Every [00:00:10] operator knows the [00:00:11] problem. Leasing [00:00:12] has their system, [00:00:13] property has [00:00:14] theirs, [00:00:15] asset management has [00:00:16] another. None of them [00:00:17] talk to each other, [00:00:18] and the data that drives [00:00:19] decisions, [00:00:20] floor plans, lease [00:00:21] abstracts, [00:00:22] inspection records, [00:00:23] and HVAC [00:00:24] history sits [00:00:25] scattered across [00:00:26] platforms that were never [00:00:27] designed to work together.
[00:00:28] [00:00:29] The result [00:00:30] is that some of the most [00:00:31] consequential [00:00:32] decisions in commercial real [00:00:33] estate, who [00:00:34] gets the space, [00:00:35] at what rent, on [00:00:36] what timeline, are [00:00:37] still being made on [00:00:38] gut instinct and [00:00:39] whoever picked up the [00:00:40] phone. We're also [00:00:41] gonna talk about today [00:00:42] the grocery market, [00:00:43] which, just [00:00:44] made this problem more [00:00:45] urgent, [00:00:46] including [00:00:47] Kroger paying [00:00:48] over $1.6 [00:00:49] billion for [00:00:50] acquiring Giant [00:00:51] Eagle while announcing [00:00:52] that it's closing [00:00:53] 60 of their [00:00:54] stores.
Amazon [00:00:55] shutting down the physical [00:00:56] locations for [00:00:57] Amazon Fresh around the [00:00:58] country, [00:00:59] and [00:01:00] operators who built their [00:01:01] centers around grocery [00:01:02] anchor could [00:01:03] start to rethink their [00:01:04] entire leasing [00:01:05] strategy. [00:01:06] I'm happy to say we [00:01:07] do have the perfect [00:01:08] guest to talk about this [00:01:09] today, [00:01:10] Jordan Herring, [00:01:11] chief strategy [00:01:12] officer at [00:01:13] ID Plans.[00:01:14]
Jordan, where does [00:01:15] this podcast find [00:01:16] you?
Jordan: Deborah, [00:01:17] thank you so much, [00:01:18] calling in from [00:01:19] Tampa, Florida
Edward: [00:01:20] Oof. The [00:01:21] Salvador [00:01:22] Dali headquarters [00:01:23] of the world
Jordan: [00:01:24] that is right, [00:01:25] Edward. How we doing [00:01:26] today?
Edward: Can't [00:01:27] complain. [00:01:28] 70 and sunny here in New York [00:01:29] City. [00:01:30] idplans [00:01:31] has been around since [00:01:32] 1999. This [00:01:33] isn't your first, [00:01:34] tech cycle [00:01:35] or rodeo. So [00:01:36] give us the origin [00:01:37] story and what the company [00:01:38] looks like today.
Jordan: [00:01:39] Yeah, I think [00:01:40] we've seen, [00:01:41] every up and [00:01:42] down. what I always tell [00:01:43] people what's [00:01:44] interesting about ID Plans [00:01:45] is that the company [00:01:46] started with a [00:01:47] problem that, I guess [00:01:48] really hadn't [00:01:49]
Load full transcript
changed since [00:01:50] nineteen [00:01:51] ninety-nine. it turns out real [00:01:52] estate is still [00:01:53] physical and somebody [00:01:54] has to understand what [00:01:55] actually exists at the [00:01:56] property.
[00:01:57] And the [00:01:58] technology around that [00:01:59] has changed [00:02:00] dramatically, but the [00:02:01] underlying [00:02:02] problem [00:02:03] hasn't. what we've [00:02:04] evolved into is [00:02:05] taking that what [00:02:06] we would call physical [00:02:07] truth and making [00:02:08] it useful [00:02:09] or actionable [00:02:10] across the entire [00:02:11] lifecycle of the asset. [00:02:12] So what does that [00:02:13] mean? I, I mean [00:02:14] leasing, [00:02:15] property management, [00:02:16] construction, asset [00:02:17] management, and [00:02:18] obviously working with the tenants.
[00:02:19] So, that's [00:02:20] what happens in the [00:02:21] field, actually becomes [00:02:22] institutional [00:02:23] knowledge
Edward: [00:02:24] Tremendous. we're gonna [00:02:25] dive deep into [00:02:26] ID plans in a little [00:02:27] bit, but just [00:02:28] for context, you [00:02:29] now cover [00:02:30] around 2.5 [00:02:31] billion square [00:02:32] feet, if I get that [00:02:33] right?
Jordan: we're past [00:02:34] 3 billion now, Edward[00:02:35]
Edward: Wow, [00:02:36] that's roughly the [00:02:37] equivalent of [00:02:38] 68 Central [00:02:39] Parks,
Jordan: That's [00:02:40] unbelievable.
I never [00:02:41] did that calculation ever, [00:02:42] to be honest with you. But [00:02:43] what I think is [00:02:44] interesting about that is I [00:02:45] think it took us from [00:02:46] 1999 [00:02:47] to 2015 [00:02:48] to, to [00:02:49] cross [00:02:50] our first billion [00:02:51] square feet. And [00:02:52] then since in the past 10 [00:02:53] years we've, [00:02:54] added just over two billion [00:02:55] square feet on top of that.
[00:02:56] So lots of, , [00:02:57] exponential [00:02:58] growth
Edward: Tremendous. [00:02:59] so let's talk about , the [00:03:00] problem that a lot of, [00:03:01] commercial real estate owners [00:03:02] and operators are [00:03:03] facing. you have a leasing [00:03:04] rep, a property manager, [00:03:05] and an asset [00:03:06] manager at the same [00:03:07] company or even [00:03:08] managing or [00:03:09] working on the same [00:03:10] property that are [00:03:11] using different [00:03:12] systems and sitting [00:03:13] in different cities [00:03:14] and, and using different [00:03:15] terms for the same [00:03:16] thing.
So [00:03:17] who owns that [00:03:18] problem, and why [00:03:19] hasn't anyone fixed [00:03:20] it?
Jordan: Yeah. I think it's a [00:03:21] great call-out, and I [00:03:22] first observed [00:03:23] this c-coming [00:03:24] into commercial real estate [00:03:25] as an [00:03:26] outsider [00:03:27] nearly a decade [00:03:28] ago. And [00:03:29] e-exactly what you [00:03:30] said, it [00:03:31] takes so many [00:03:32] different [00:03:33] people working [00:03:34] together to, [00:03:35] accomplish the [00:03:36] general goal of [00:03:37] commercial real estate, which [00:03:38] I would say very [00:03:39] simply is, hey, how do [00:03:40] we find the right tenant for [00:03:41] the right space at the right [00:03:42] time at the right price?
[00:03:43] And, [00:03:44] specifically around leasing, but, [00:03:45] high level, that's kind [00:03:46] of that. And [00:03:47] the [00:03:48] weird thing [00:03:49] was I would [00:03:50] talk with folks. Like, [00:03:51] for example, if I'm [00:03:52] talking to somebody in [00:03:53] marketing [00:03:54] about, a beautiful [00:03:55] site plan, we're gonna call it [00:03:56] a site plan. But [00:03:57] as we talk [00:03:58] to somebody in [00:03:59] construction, we're talking about [00:04:00] as-builts and different [00:04:01] vernaculars and different words and [00:04:02] things.
So [00:04:03] not only are people [00:04:04] using different [00:04:05] tools and systems, [00:04:06] they're sitting in different [00:04:07] offices, and that means different [00:04:08] cultures. You have a [00:04:09] team in Dallas and a [00:04:10] team in Manhattan, [00:04:11] you know, and you expect [00:04:12] these guys to, [00:04:13] collaborate [00:04:14] while in different systems, [00:04:15] while in different [00:04:16] offices, and while having [00:04:17] also different kind of [00:04:18] cultures.
So I [00:04:19] always found that kind of [00:04:20] interesting. [00:04:21] Now, why does [00:04:22] this exist? I think [00:04:23] the reason this problem [00:04:24] has persisted or [00:04:25] continues that nobody really [00:04:26] owns it. So leasing [00:04:27] owns leasing, property management [00:04:28] owns [00:04:29] operations, [00:04:30] accounting owns financial [00:04:31] data, construction owns [00:04:32] its workflow, but , the [00:04:33] property cuts scores [00:04:34] only across all of [00:04:35] them.
So you can [00:04:36] have really [00:04:37] good people using really good [00:04:38] systems and still have [00:04:39] three different versions of [00:04:40] the same asset. [00:04:41] Commercial real [00:04:42] estate doesn't really have a [00:04:43] data shortage. It [00:04:44] really, has a [00:04:45] shaped [00:04:46] truth problem, [00:04:47] I-I'd say
Edward: [00:04:48] could you give us like a real [00:04:49] example of what goes [00:04:50] wrong when like, say, [00:04:51] leasing and property [00:04:52] management are working [00:04:53] from different data on the [00:04:54] same vacancy?
Jordan: [00:04:55] [00:04:56] when [00:04:57] leasing is [00:04:58] operating without [00:04:59] partnership with, say, [00:05:00] property management [00:05:01] or property management or somebody [00:05:02] who's, tied to the [00:05:03] asset, at [00:05:04] the end of the day, if if you [00:05:05] review any tenant's [00:05:06] work letter, y- there's [00:05:07] tons of information [00:05:08] that's necessary and [00:05:09]
critical, for leasing to [00:05:10] take into consideration when [00:05:11] it comes to [00:05:12] estimating, [00:05:13] when it comes down [00:05:14] much TI are we gonna be [00:05:15] allocating for this [00:05:16] space or, [00:05:17] what's the [00:05:18] pipeline for how [00:05:19] long it's gonna take [00:05:20] us to get this tenant [00:05:21] open.
And so there's [00:05:22] this, really [00:05:23] huge need [00:05:24] for [00:05:25] everybody, all [00:05:26] those [00:05:27] construction, property management, [00:05:28] leasing teams are really [00:05:29] collaborating. [00:05:30] And when they [00:05:31] don't, deals get [00:05:32] built without the [00:05:33] physical reality being [00:05:34] taken into [00:05:35] consideration and [00:05:36] bad things tend to happen [00:05:37] after that
Edward: [00:05:38] So, let's talk about [00:05:39] some of the [00:05:40] solutions that the PropTech [00:05:41] industry [00:05:42] has spent [00:05:43] for a better part of [00:05:44] the last [00:05:45] decade or even more [00:05:46] selling operators, [00:05:47] which [00:05:48] is all around [00:05:49] specialization, [00:05:50] right? And, and point [00:05:51] solutions. [00:05:52] Best in class tools for [00:05:53] every function. [00:05:54] how did that [00:05:55] bet go?
Jordan: [00:05:56] Yeah, I actually think [00:05:57] specialization [00:05:58] maybe worked a little too [00:05:59] well. we built [00:06:00] really good [00:06:01] tools for [00:06:02] individual, like, point [00:06:03] solutions. So, you know, [00:06:04] leasing software got [00:06:05] better. Construction [00:06:06] software, I [00:06:07] think, really just [00:06:08] started and, got better. [00:06:09] Accounting [00:06:10] software absolutely [00:06:11] got better. But I think the [00:06:12] unintended, [00:06:13] consequence [00:06:14] was that we [00:06:15] fragmented the property [00:06:16] across all of those [00:06:17] applications.
So, [00:06:18] specialization [00:06:19] won at the [00:06:20] application layer, but in [00:06:21] many cases it [00:06:22] lost at the [00:06:23] enterprise [00:06:24] layer. we may have [00:06:25] optimized the individual [00:06:26] workflows without, [00:06:27] necessarily creating a [00:06:28] better- [00:06:29] Collective [00:06:30] understanding [00:06:31] of the [00:06:32] asset. And you [00:06:33] really-- I think when you [00:06:34] drill into it as a [00:06:35] why, as an [00:06:36] observer of the [00:06:37] industry, what we [00:06:38] discovered, and curious your take, [00:06:39] Edward, in [00:06:40] twenty fifteen it, it [00:06:41] really seemed like [00:06:42] this whole [00:06:43] proptech thing really [00:06:44] started.
You started [00:06:45] seeing a lot more aggressive [00:06:46] growth. You started seeing a [00:06:47] lot of Y Combinator [00:06:48] companies come out [00:06:49] calling out [00:06:50] proptech. [00:06:51] Definitely not retail [00:06:52] specifically, but, [00:06:53] you started to see some [00:06:54] interest here. [00:06:55] And the first companies [00:06:56] to really grow [00:06:57] were these, [00:06:58] what I would call, [00:06:59] inch wide, mile deep [00:07:00] solutions.
And [00:07:01] these folks were [00:07:02] able to [00:07:03] create businesses, [00:07:04] in like this derp [00:07:05] era where [00:07:06] it wasn't exactly [00:07:07] clear on how [00:07:08] big the market was [00:07:09] or it-- Raising money was [00:07:10] never a huge [00:07:11] issue, so you really never had [00:07:12] that [00:07:13] filtration of, [00:07:14] companies solving real [00:07:15] problems, building great [00:07:16] tools that also [00:07:17] led to a [00:07:18] really good economic [00:07:19] outcome.
and so [00:07:20] as that [00:07:21] changed, what we [00:07:22] started seeing is [00:07:23] that these [00:07:24] fragmented point [00:07:25] solution companies [00:07:26] [00:07:27] started-- [00:07:28] were really forced [00:07:29] into [00:07:30] diverting from their, [00:07:31] let's call [00:07:32] it niche [00:07:33] strategy, into [00:07:34] trying to [00:07:35] grow [00:07:36] horizontally to capture [00:07:37] more, customer share of [00:07:38] wallet. A-and [00:07:39] really I think [00:07:40] maybe that was [00:07:41] always the [00:07:42] natural, evolution [00:07:43] of these companies.
That was always going to [00:07:44] be the case. But [00:07:45] certainly, when [00:07:46] this funding [00:07:47] thing started getting [00:07:48] tighter, that [00:07:49] was absolutely a [00:07:50] catalyst to see [00:07:51] this, compression, [00:07:52] which certainly [00:07:53] made these point [00:07:54] solutions more [00:07:55] aggressive in how [00:07:56] they thought about their [00:07:57] growth. And, [00:07:58] starting to really think about [00:07:59] how durable can [00:08:00] we be from an [00:08:01] economics perspective.
So [00:08:02] I think the [00:08:03] after effects [00:08:04] of this niche shop are even [00:08:05] more interesting because you're [00:08:06] starting to see this like [00:08:07] really big obsession [00:08:08] of [00:08:09] the COI [00:08:10] company now trying to stretch [00:08:11] over and lean into [00:08:12] adjacent things and [00:08:13] continue to, break [00:08:14] into other industries. [00:08:15] The Workorder platform [00:08:16] trying to get into [00:08:17] tenant sales [00:08:18] collection, then touching [00:08:19] the tenant more.
And so [00:08:20] I think that's [00:08:21] more interesting is like [00:08:22] this evolution [00:08:23] where everyone's trying to [00:08:24] go after the same [00:08:25] platform. I was talking with a [00:08:26] CIO [00:08:27] at a very large [00:08:28] REIT recently, and [00:08:29] she always made these jokes [00:08:30] with me that, [00:08:31] "Gosh, I wish [00:08:32] you guys would just buy each [00:08:33] other." because everyone is [00:08:34] trying to build kind of the [00:08:35] same [00:08:36] sort of thing, [00:08:37] it's funny, but [00:08:38]
Watching this has been really [00:08:39] entertaining, so I'm curious to see [00:08:40] what the next five years look [00:08:41] like.
Edward: [00:08:42] I mean, she, she's not [00:08:43] wrong in, terms [00:08:44] of, buying each other or [00:08:45] merging or joining [00:08:46] forces and we are seeing [00:08:47] that play out in real [00:08:48] time with some of [00:08:49] the latest [00:08:50] acquisitions, including, [00:08:51] uh, [00:08:52] buying up, [00:08:53] Cadastral, and then there are [00:08:54] also, RealPage buying [00:08:55] up Cherry, but that's been, [00:08:56] [00:08:57] playbook for [00:08:58] as long as we can [00:08:59] remember.
A-and, [00:09:00] like this approach, [00:09:01] what you're describing of [00:09:02] becoming, a [00:09:03] monopoly in like [00:09:04] a point solution, [00:09:05] then growing from that has [00:09:06] always been Peter [00:09:07] Thiel's [00:09:08] playbook when [00:09:09] you become a [00:09:10] monopoly, even though it's [00:09:11] just in one [00:09:12] point of the value [00:09:13] chain, then you can [00:09:14] potentially expand to [00:09:15] others, and have [00:09:16] more, pricing [00:09:17] power and, and [00:09:18] control in, [00:09:19] how you grow and the value [00:09:20] that you create.
[00:09:21] now there's a lot of [00:09:22] talk about [00:09:23] data [00:09:24] migration and [00:09:25] implementing [00:09:26] not only technology, but [00:09:27] implementing more [00:09:28] specifically AI [00:09:29] across [00:09:30] everything that it [00:09:31] becomes operations. [00:09:32] So how do [00:09:33] you make the case [00:09:34] for, say, a, a [00:09:35] traditional operator [00:09:36] who has been doing [00:09:37] things the same [00:09:38] way for 40 [00:09:39] years, that, uh, [00:09:40] data migration and [00:09:41] implementation is [00:09:42] actually worth [00:09:43] it?
Jordan: Yeah, I think [00:09:44] it's interesting, and [00:09:45] I, love you brought Peter [00:09:46] Thiel. Zero to [00:09:47] One is, [00:09:48] think a [00:09:49] fantastic book and, way of [00:09:50] thinking for people in this [00:09:51] industry. [00:09:52] Although I think [00:09:53] ironically, [00:09:54] Peter also talks [00:09:55] often about [00:09:56] competition for losers. So it's [00:09:57] this really interesting [00:09:58] dynamic of, [00:09:59] yes, there's [00:10:00] an opportunity, this [00:10:01] desire to how do [00:10:02] we create a [00:10:03] monopoly?
How do we, figure [00:10:04] out, these, [00:10:05] networks to help them [00:10:06] grow? But way [00:10:07] through that, the [00:10:08] past five years have [00:10:09] seen this, [00:10:10] [00:10:11] radical, emphasis [00:10:12] on competing [00:10:13] and trying to [00:10:14] compete for kind of the [00:10:15] same overlapping or [00:10:16] adjacent [00:10:17] coverages of the other [00:10:18] point solution.
[00:10:19] But when it comes [00:10:20] to, these [00:10:21] old school [00:10:22] operators, [00:10:23] who've
without [00:10:24] technology [00:10:25] have built [00:10:26] unbelievable [00:10:27] businesses, [00:10:28] and I think the worst [00:10:29] thing you can do is walk [00:10:30] into someone who's [00:10:31] successfully [00:10:32] operated, a portfolio [00:10:33] for forty [00:10:34] years and tell them that [00:10:35] technology knows more than [00:10:36] they do.
[00:10:37] it just doesn't. [00:10:38] what [00:10:39] technology can do [00:10:40] is take [00:10:41] the institutional [00:10:42] knowledge they've [00:10:43] accumulated and make [00:10:44] it available for the rest of the [00:10:45] organization. [00:10:46] Now, in the context of [00:10:47] AI, now it's like, [00:10:48] hey, taking your [00:10:49] institutional knowledge [00:10:50] and making it even more [00:10:51] lethal, right? Making it [00:10:52] even more, [00:10:53] the, efficacy [00:10:54] of it, , which I think is [00:10:55] really interesting.
So, I [00:10:56] wouldn't sell them [00:10:57] digital transformation. [00:10:58] I would sell them [00:10:59] on fewer [00:11:00] surprises, faster [00:11:01] and better [00:11:02] decisions, [00:11:03] fewer unnecessary [00:11:04] site visits, [00:11:05] less, downtime, whatever. [00:11:06] The best [00:11:07] software doesn't replace [00:11:08] judgment or [00:11:09] their kind of knowledge. It [00:11:10] gives [00:11:11] their kind of [00:11:12] foundation a [00:11:13] better instrument [00:11:14] panel.
Edward: I [00:11:15] think that's, very [00:11:16] reasonably [00:11:17] articulated and I [00:11:18] think, that has [00:11:19] changed in, in the most [00:11:20] recent, tech cycle [00:11:21] in the space [00:11:22] where, there is seems to [00:11:23] be less, uh, [00:11:24] hubris, whether on [00:11:25] purpose or just by [00:11:26] lack of [00:11:27] experience in the [00:11:28] industry and more with the [00:11:29] Silicon Valley [00:11:30] ethos of move [00:11:31] fast and break things, [00:11:32] where is, this is a [00:11:33] building with real [00:11:34] people that they either [00:11:35] work in, use [00:11:36] to shop, or [00:11:37] they rent, [00:11:38] and we [00:11:39] can't, uh, break [00:11:40] things, or disrupt [00:11:41] things, right?
Jordan: [00:11:42] Well, that-that's [00:11:43] right. And, and I think [00:11:44] ultimately speaking, the [00:11:45] one takeaway [00:11:46] where I think what makes [00:11:47] commercial real [00:11:48] estate very [00:11:49] interesting but also [00:11:50] just radically different is [00:11:51] that, you'll move [00:11:52] fast and break things [00:11:53] to dramatically [00:11:54] change [00:11:55] an [00:11:56] industry, or exploit [00:11:57] something that needs to be [00:11:58] exploited.
But, commercial real [00:11:59] estate is, [00:12:00] technically speaking, I would [00:12:01] say has enormous [00:12:02] beta [00:12:03] and very, , [00:12:04] alpha light. And what I [00:12:05] mean by that is [00:12:06] that, there's [00:12:07] tons of macro [00:12:08] factors are the main [00:12:09] driving forces. And what, what [00:12:10] really you see is [00:12:11] that [00:12:12] competitors [00:12:13] like Kimco and [00:12:14] Brixmor are really competing on the [00:12:15] margins, [00:12:16] right?
And so their [00:12:17] influence, [00:12:18] they have these little [00:12:19] judgments that compound [00:12:20] over time. [00:12:21] moving fast and breaking things is [00:12:22] all fun [00:12:23] and great in an [00:12:24] industry that's ripe [00:12:25] for disruption. [00:12:26] In this [00:12:27] industry where the vast [00:12:28] majority of the [00:12:29] uplift is... when you're [00:12:30] talking about [00:12:31] analysis of your [00:12:32] underwriting any of these bit [00:12:33] large institutions, [00:12:34] the biggest things you're gonna be [00:12:35] underwriting is the [00:12:36] market as a whole.[00:12:37]
And [00:12:38] obviously, you're looking at the [00:12:39] operators, and obviously you're looking at [00:12:40] their strategy and some of the [00:12:41] things that make them [00:12:42] them. [00:12:43] But a-at the end of the [00:12:44] day, [00:12:45] th-this, move [00:12:46] fast, break [00:12:47] things en-environment, is [00:12:48] incredibly, [00:12:49] incredibly risky [00:12:50] considering, yes, of course, [00:12:51] there's real [00:12:52] consequences to real people [00:12:53] that are, operating [00:12:54] their own businesses in this [00:12:55] environment.
[00:12:56] obviously, there's tons of [00:12:57] financial considerations. [00:12:58] But y- in addition to [00:12:59] that, I think [00:13:00] as, Don [00:13:01] Tetteman says a lot, you know, [00:13:02] real estate's the get [00:13:03] rich slow [00:13:04] scheme, and that these [00:13:05] slow [00:13:06] incremental [00:13:07] compounding small [00:13:08] wins on the [00:13:09] margins is how [00:13:10] you see the [00:13:11] really best [00:13:12] operators [00:13:13] win.
Edward: [00:13:14] Certainly, and shout out [00:13:15] to Don Tebbe, [00:13:16] [00:13:17] AKA, Strip Mall Guy, [00:13:18] who [00:13:19] was kind enough to [00:13:20] host us at [00:13:21] his, real [00:13:22] estate gala [00:13:23] earlier this [00:13:24] year with, [00:13:25] Bob Knakal, which is [00:13:26] where Jordan and [00:13:27] I actually [00:13:28] met. [00:13:29] when you're an [00:13:30] investor today buying a [00:13:31] new shopping [00:13:32] center, how should a buyer [00:13:33] be thinking about the [00:13:34] tech and the data [00:13:35] layer as part of [00:13:36] their [00:13:37] diligence?
Jordan: [00:13:38] So like [00:13:39] everything else [00:13:40] I think buyers [00:13:41] increasingly need to think about [00:13:42] data almost [00:13:43] like another form of [00:13:44] diligence. [00:13:45] you're not just acquiring the [00:13:46] leases and the tenants in the [00:13:47] buildings, you're [00:13:48] acquiring [00:13:49] all of the [00:13:50] unknowns that come with [00:13:51] them. [00:13:52] So what physically
[00:13:53] exists? Are the drawings [00:13:54] current?
Do the lease [00:13:55] obligations match [00:13:56] what's happening in the [00:13:57] fields? what knowledge [00:13:58] disappears when the [00:13:59] seller team [00:14:00] leaves? I almost think of [00:14:01] bad property data [00:14:02] as a form of [00:14:03] deferred maintenance. [00:14:04] Uh, [00:14:05] eventually someone has [00:14:06] to pay the cost [00:14:07] of cleaning it up. [00:14:08] Now, all that being [00:14:09] said, it, [00:14:10] we're acquiring a [00:14:11] portfolio [00:14:12] [00:14:13] and we're also [00:14:14] acquiring the [00:14:15] vendors on the [00:14:16] property who are [00:14:17] working there.
And so [00:14:18] in [00:14:19] scenario [00:14:20] A, when there's a [00:14:21] really [00:14:22] robust and [00:14:23] effective tech [00:14:24] stack, it can be [00:14:25] really [00:14:26] helpful that first [00:14:27] ninety days [00:14:28] of [00:14:29] operating the asset, [00:14:30] maintaining status quo [00:14:31] while you're in the [00:14:32] background about to [00:14:33] execute your plan. [00:14:34] Now, if it's a [00:14:35] very kludgy [00:14:36] setup that [00:14:37] is [00:14:38] bumpy and [00:14:39] hard, it's just gonna make things [00:14:40] much more difficult.
So I [00:14:41] think you need to price [00:14:42] in [00:14:43] the [00:14:44] challenges of taking on the [00:14:45] center, without the [00:14:46] right... and not just [00:14:47] tech stack, but just [00:14:48] operating stack [00:14:49] wh-which can mean technology, [00:14:50] but, something in, in [00:14:51] there. I've never bought [00:14:52] a large property [00:14:53] before, so I, I'd [00:14:54] be curious to hear what [00:14:55] other people say.
But [00:14:56] from my point of view, that's how [00:14:57] I think about it
Edward: [00:14:58] let's say you now [00:14:59] bought a shopping [00:15:00] center. [00:15:01] how does the first [00:15:02] 90 days of [00:15:03] ownership look [00:15:04] different for an [00:15:05] operator who has the data [00:15:06] layer [00:15:07] right versus the [00:15:08] one who [00:15:09] doesn't?
Jordan: S-so what's exciting [00:15:10] ab-about [00:15:11] that is I get to [00:15:12] talk to so many [00:15:13] people that, [00:15:14] when we first get to [00:15:15] meet people, [00:15:16] who are just [00:15:17] getting to know ID [00:15:18] plans, [00:15:19] oftentimes [00:15:20] it's around a [00:15:21] transaction. [00:15:22] And [00:15:23] whether they [00:15:24] have contracted [00:15:25] us and our, our [00:15:26] software and our [00:15:27] services and our technology to go [00:15:28] out there to [00:15:29] enable them [00:15:30] to be smarter in [00:15:31] this diligence [00:15:32] window.
talking [00:15:33] to, industry people [00:15:34] who've been doing this a long [00:15:35] time and then [00:15:36] seeing what it's like to [00:15:37] have all this [00:15:38] information [00:15:39] aggregated in one [00:15:40] spot and [00:15:41] that's, digitally [00:15:42] coherent, that [00:15:43] fits together, it [00:15:44] integrates with their [00:15:45] ERPs. That it's [00:15:46] palpable, [00:15:47] the pain you can [00:15:48] see leaving their [00:15:49] body.
it's these little [00:15:50] things that [00:15:51] enable these [00:15:52] people who still have a day [00:15:53] job, by the way. They're [00:15:54] acquiring assets, and they're still [00:15:55] managing everything else, and now [00:15:56] they have this new [00:15:57] thing. They don't know much [00:15:58] about it. They probably travel to [00:15:59] it a bunch. [00:16:00] how can we [00:16:01] enable them to make better [00:16:02] decisions faster [00:16:03] on this [00:16:04] asset, even with [00:16:05] limited [00:16:06] information, in an office far, [00:16:07] far away? the way I [00:16:08] think about [00:16:09] our platform is less [00:16:10] about the individual [00:16:11] products and more [00:16:12] about, like, how we [00:16:13] enable the life [00:16:14] cycle of the asset [00:16:15] without them [00:16:16] having to [00:16:17] travel the, [00:16:18] property all the time [00:16:19] and rely on [00:16:20] vendors that they're still building [00:16:21] trust with.
Edward: [00:16:22] So, [00:16:23] uh, let's now move on [00:16:24] to ID plans [00:16:25] and how it works. I mean, [00:16:26] you guys are working with [00:16:27] clients like [00:16:28] Blackstone and [00:16:29] DLC [00:16:30] Management, so walk [00:16:31] us through how the [00:16:32] ID plans product [00:16:33] suite fits [00:16:34] together and what [00:16:35] problem that [00:16:36] architecture solves that a [00:16:37] collection of point [00:16:38] solutions can't
Jordan: [00:16:39] the way I [00:16:40] think about our, [00:16:41] let's call it [00:16:42] architecture is less about [00:16:43] individual products and more [00:16:44] about the life cycle of [00:16:45] the asset. you start [00:16:46] with understanding what [00:16:47] physically exists, [00:16:48] create a trusted [00:16:49] property record around [00:16:50] it, and then [00:16:51] allowing [00:16:52] leasing operations, [00:16:53] construction, and asset [00:16:54] management to use the same [00:16:55] intelligence in their [00:16:56] workflows.
[00:16:57] So the [00:16:58] [00:16:59] goal isn't to [00:17:00] give somebody another application to [00:17:01] log into, [00:17:02] it's to make [00:17:03] sure what I would [00:17:04] call the physical reality [00:17:05] of the property [00:17:06] follows that asset through [00:17:07] its entire [00:17:08] life cycle. And I think that's just a [00:17:09] big difference, [00:17:10] right? So when you're [00:17:11] stringing together this [00:17:12] cadre [00:17:13] of solutions [00:17:14] that...
And by the way, [00:17:15] there's a lot of great tech out [00:17:16] there, and there's a lot of [00:17:17] really great [00:17:18] platforms and tools. I, like, I [00:17:19] know a lot of the guys, I think [00:17:20]
they're great. [00:17:21] And what [00:17:22] we see [00:17:23] often [00:17:24] is the [00:17:25] tools are [00:17:26] myopically focused [00:17:27] on their own mission, [00:17:28] and they do [00:17:29] that really well. [00:17:30] However, [00:17:31] expecting them to not [00:17:32] simultaneously [00:17:33] integrate with the core [00:17:34] systems of record, [00:17:35] i.e.
MRI [00:17:36] or Yardi, [00:17:37] or J.D. Edwards or [00:17:38] something like that. And in [00:17:39] addition to that, [00:17:40] write [00:17:41] back [00:17:42] into [00:17:43] another platform, another [00:17:44] point solution. [00:17:45] And [00:17:46] then, [00:17:47] Edward, often [00:17:48] there's very [00:17:49] few [00:17:50] platforms [00:17:51] besides ID [00:17:52] plans that [00:17:53] radically take [00:17:54] into consideration how [00:17:55] important the [00:17:56] physical reality [00:17:57] [00:17:58] is. We always talk [00:17:59] about the world of bits and [00:18:00] the world of atoms.
I [00:18:01] think there's a lot of [00:18:02] people who've [00:18:03] been [00:18:04] wanting so [00:18:05] desperately [00:18:06] to be able to [00:18:07] effectively [00:18:08] [00:18:09] manage and [00:18:10] unlock value [00:18:11] from these assets all [00:18:12] through a screen [00:18:13] and build a solution [00:18:14] that is [00:18:15] scalable [00:18:16] and, [00:18:17] doesn't require [00:18:18] the kind of the hard [00:18:19] work, the boots on the ground [00:18:20] stuff.
And [00:18:21] in our [00:18:22] opinion, we disagree. We [00:18:23] think that, [00:18:24] touching and being [00:18:25] able to bridge the [00:18:26] world of bits and atoms is [00:18:27] incredibly important, [00:18:28] and that's the big [00:18:29] unlock. So yeah, it's [00:18:30] really important to have [00:18:31] best-in-class software that [00:18:32] prioritize [00:18:33] cybersecurity, [00:18:34] that, ha-prioritizes [00:18:35] the [00:18:36] users. But [00:18:37] at the end of the [00:18:38] day, yes, [00:18:39] our, all our platforms and [00:18:40] tools fit together well, but [00:18:41] again, it's [00:18:42] on a mission in [00:18:43] pursuit of [00:18:44] how do we [00:18:45] bring the [00:18:46] users closer to the [00:18:47] physical asset [00:18:48] in this [00:18:49] normalized data [00:18:50] structure
Edward: So [00:18:51] walk us through, how does, [00:18:52] for example, a [00:18:53] vacancy move [00:18:54] through your platform [00:18:55] from the moment it [00:18:56] hits the [00:18:57] market to the moment a [00:18:58] lease is [00:18:59] signed?
Jordan: this is where I get [00:19:00] the most pumped up [00:19:01] because we have a lot of [00:19:02] fandom [00:19:03] in property management and [00:19:04] operations [00:19:05] But I'll tell you [00:19:06] what, [00:19:07] when we're [00:19:08] talking [00:19:09] with [00:19:10] high-level [00:19:11] brokers and, [00:19:12] leasing folks [00:19:13] who get, [00:19:14] get the chance to use [00:19:15]
ID Plans, [00:19:16] the excitement [00:19:17] and [00:19:18] the, the passion that we [00:19:19] see is [00:19:20] so rewarding and so [00:19:21] exciting.
[00:19:22] for everyone [00:19:23] listening who has no [00:19:24] idea who ID [00:19:25] Plans [00:19:26] is, We [00:19:27] deploy our [00:19:28] field, service [00:19:29] techs, our actual people who [00:19:30] work for the company [00:19:31] to these [00:19:32] vacancies, and the mission [00:19:33] is [00:19:34] identifying all the [00:19:35] information that [00:19:36] could really ever be [00:19:37] asked, in a [00:19:38] tenant work letter [00:19:39] [00:19:40] immediately, oftentimes [00:19:41] even [00:19:42] before the previous tenant vacates [00:19:43] the [00:19:44] space.
[00:19:45] Why? [00:19:46] Well, if I can do [00:19:47] one thing [00:19:48] to [00:19:49] maintain our [00:19:50] success, it's [00:19:51] compressing lease [00:19:52] execution to rent [00:19:53] commencement dates. [00:19:54] And if we're [00:19:55] able to eliminate [00:19:56] the dark [00:19:57] days per year of these [00:19:58] phases [00:19:59] and, now working backwards [00:20:00] from that result, right?
[00:20:01] So if our result is [00:20:02] to, one, [00:20:03] ensure that [00:20:04] rent commencement is occurring [00:20:05] on the right [00:20:06] time, or [00:20:07] better pulling [00:20:08] that date [00:20:09] backwards, While [00:20:10] simultaneously [00:20:11] having a really great [00:20:12] tenant [00:20:13] experience and enabling [00:20:14] this new tenant [00:20:15] to focus on [00:20:16] their business rather [00:20:17] than the things they have [00:20:18] to do to be in [00:20:19] business, right?
And I'm specifically [00:20:20] talking about, , [00:20:21] non-professional [00:20:22] tenants, like smaller box [00:20:23] tenants. what gets in the [00:20:24] way of that? What gets in [00:20:25] the way of that is, [00:20:26] one, not [00:20:27] having a really [00:20:28] clear [00:20:29] vision, task [00:20:30] mastering [00:20:31] this tenant who... [00:20:32] I mean, Edward, [00:20:33] oftentimes [00:20:34] the [00:20:35] people who are [00:20:36] opening these [00:20:37] businesses, these [00:20:38] entrepreneurs, [00:20:39] they've never opened a business [00:20:40] before.
They, [00:20:41] they've never hired an [00:20:42] architect. English [00:20:43] may be a second [00:20:44] language. There's a lot of these [00:20:45] obstacles in the way. [00:20:46] And so what we, [00:20:47] as ID Plans try to [00:20:48] do is [00:20:49] how do we make it easy [00:20:50] for them to [00:20:51] see all the [00:20:52] tasks they are-- they [00:20:53] have to do to get open [00:20:54] in a very visual [00:20:55] way, [00:20:56] enable the landlord to [00:20:57] also see those [00:20:58] things, [00:20:59] help hold the tenant [00:21:00] accountable.
But then [00:21:01] even backwards [00:21:02] from that is [00:21:03] a lot of [00:21:04] things that blow [00:21:05] deals up or [00:21:06] cause delays [00:21:07] or [00:21:08] unexpected estimation [00:21:09] misses is not having [00:21:10] a really good [00:21:11] understanding [00:21:12] of the physical [00:21:13] infrastructure or phys-- [00:21:14] or physical [00:21:15] limitations in the [00:21:16] space. So when there's a [00:21:17] vacancy at the Cohen Shopping [00:21:18] Center, we're [00:21:19] going in there and we're [00:21:20] identifying, we're gonna validate [00:21:21] the GLA of the [00:21:22] space, to a high [00:21:23] quality BOMA standard.
[00:21:24] We're going to get a really great [00:21:25] virtual tour. We're gonna [00:21:26] capture all the [00:21:27] mechanicals and [00:21:28] electric and plumbing [00:21:29] information. everything that [00:21:30] could possibly be [00:21:31] asked by [00:21:32] a tenant [00:21:33] rep [00:21:34] or from the construction [00:21:35] team, [00:21:36] or information that's [00:21:37] needed for the [00:21:38] internal, construction team [00:21:39] to get a good [00:21:40] estimate, we're gonna get [00:21:41] that [00:21:42] upfront, oftentimes [00:21:43] before the previous [00:21:44] tenant vacated, [00:21:45] in pursuit of [00:21:46] efficiency.
if we [00:21:47] can get all the [00:21:48] information that's needed [00:21:49] and de-risk the [00:21:50] transaction [00:21:51] and make it [00:21:52] hyper-visible and get [00:21:53] everybody in the [00:21:54] deal into one [00:21:55] platform collaborating, [00:21:56] we're gonna see a [00:21:57] lot of efficiency. We're [00:21:58] gonna have a much better [00:21:59] experience, [00:22:00] and [00:22:01] oftentimes we're gonna see that, [00:22:02] that rent commencement [00:22:03] date either hit [00:22:04] right on or, or [00:22:05] even in some [00:22:06] cases find a way to get that [00:22:07] tenant open [00:22:08] faster
Edward: [00:22:09] Fascinating. [00:22:10] so let's zoom in [00:22:11] into the Adams [00:22:12] part then. How does [00:22:13] the aerial [00:22:14] and drone [00:22:15] imagery change the [00:22:16] decisions an operator [00:22:17] makes when managing [00:22:18] assets across multiple [00:22:19] markets?
Jordan: [00:22:20] Yeah. So this is one of [00:22:21] the first [00:22:22] acquisitions [00:22:23] that we made as a [00:22:24] company [00:22:25] when we acquired, , [00:22:26] this, drone [00:22:27] platform, back [00:22:28] in, twenty [00:22:29] eighteen or [00:22:30] something, and that went really [00:22:31] well. for those that [00:22:32] don't know, we have a, [00:22:33] product called ID [00:22:34] Vision which [00:22:35] enables, [00:22:36] super high quality, [00:22:37] drone [00:22:38] imagery, not just for [00:22:39] marketing use cases which [00:22:40] what you see very [00:22:41] often, but also for [00:22:42] operational uses.
[00:22:43] So we create a whole [00:22:44] platform around what's called the [00:22:45] [00:22:46] orthomosaic. So [00:22:47] basically stitching [00:22:48] together [00:22:49] high quality photos [00:22:50]
into one really big [00:22:51] photo. [00:22:52] And we have a lot of [00:22:53] tools and of course [00:22:54] this layers on top [00:22:55] of our other [00:22:56] kinda core product [00:22:57] offerings. I [00:22:58] think the mistake is that [00:22:59] thinking of, drone [00:23:00] imagery as just better [00:23:01] photography.
I think the [00:23:02] real [00:23:03] value is, [00:23:04] decision compression is [00:23:05] what we see a lot. [00:23:06] So if I'm [00:23:07] responsible for, [00:23:08] say, [00:23:09] hundreds of properties [00:23:10] across [00:23:11] twenty states, [00:23:12] I shouldn't have to physically [00:23:13] travel [00:23:14] somewhere every time I need [00:23:15] to understand [00:23:16] parking or [00:23:17] access, [00:23:18] signage, [00:23:19] roofing conditions, or [00:23:20] how the site [00:23:21] relates to its [00:23:22] surroundings.
you're [00:23:23] basically reducing the [00:23:24] distance between the [00:23:25] person that [00:23:26] is making [00:23:27] the decision and [00:23:28] the physical asset. [00:23:29] th-that's where we're, [00:23:30] we're trying to [00:23:31] hyper-focus on, [00:23:32] is how can we [00:23:33] radically g-get [00:23:34] users access to [00:23:35] super high [00:23:36] quality imagery of [00:23:37] the property as it was a [00:23:38] week ago, not like [00:23:39] five years ago [00:23:40] in a kinda blurry [00:23:41] view from Google Earth or [00:23:42] something.
But, like, [00:23:43] how, how can we [00:23:44] really dramatically improve [00:23:45] technology and then [00:23:46] in addition to [00:23:47] that, computer vision [00:23:48] models on top of that [00:23:49] to further [00:23:50] enable [00:23:51] value from looking at [00:23:52] the real asset
Edward: [00:23:53] so [00:23:54] tenant selection has been [00:23:55] described as one of [00:23:56] the highest impact [00:23:57] decisions in retail [00:23:58] commercial real estate , and one [00:23:59] of the least [00:24:00] scientifically informed [00:24:01] processes. why do [00:24:02] you think that has [00:24:03] stayed, that way for so [00:24:04] long?
Jordan: [00:24:05] were talking [00:24:06] earlier about, winning on [00:24:07] the margins, this is [00:24:08] certainly one of the [00:24:09] bigger of [00:24:10] those decisions [00:24:11] that the people that do [00:24:12] this really well tend to [00:24:13] win really big, and the [00:24:14] people that do this not so [00:24:15] well tend to lose pretty [00:24:16] big. I think tenant [00:24:17] selection is the [00:24:18] business, right, at its kind of [00:24:19] core.
A-and [00:24:20] by the way, I don't know [00:24:21] if instinct is [00:24:22] necessarily a [00:24:23] bad [00:24:24] thing, and what we've [00:24:25] seen a lot is [00:24:26] very [00:24:27] relationship-driven. [00:24:28] like at its worst, [00:24:29] anybody who can fog a [00:24:30] mirror and that [00:24:31] meets the space [00:24:32] requirements and is willing to pay [00:24:33] rent, we'll invite into [00:24:34] the center. [00:24:35] And I, I think [00:24:36] when [00:24:37] retail [00:24:38] wasn't as popular as, [00:24:39] as it is today, I [00:24:40] think that was a [00:24:41] very, common [00:24:42] outcome.
But I [00:24:43] mean, if you [00:24:44] look through the most [00:24:45] recent, 10 [00:24:46] Qs [00:24:47] we're seeing [00:24:48] occupancy at ninety-seven [00:24:49] percent, [00:24:50] ninety-seven point five [00:24:51] percent, something like that. [00:24:52] we're seeing [00:24:53] the [00:24:54] large institutions [00:24:55] able [00:24:56] to take [00:24:57] into consideration, [00:24:58] better placemaking [00:24:59] decisions, [00:25:00] co-tenancy [00:25:01] dynamics, and things like that.
[00:25:02] So to be honest [00:25:03] with you, it's kind of a [00:25:04] newer thing [00:25:05] that [00:25:06] the operators have [00:25:07] been spoiled with some [00:25:08] concept of [00:25:09] choice, of being [00:25:10] able to really take a [00:25:11] step backwards and [00:25:12] say, "Hey, [00:25:13] how can we [00:25:14] curate the [00:25:15] center in such a [00:25:16] way [00:25:17] that [00:25:18] compounds value?" [00:25:19] what could [00:25:20] possibly, be the [00:25:21] benefit here? And I think [00:25:22] the way we think about it at [00:25:23] IE Plans, and [00:25:24] obviously we, we spend a lot of time [00:25:25] thinking [00:25:26] not just, void [00:25:27] analyses [00:25:28] and market [00:25:29] dynamics and co-tenancy [00:25:30] dynamics, but also [00:25:31] take into consideration [00:25:32] the physical [00:25:33] limitations and [00:25:34] characteristics of the [00:25:35] space into that [00:25:36] calculus.
really, [00:25:37] how can we [00:25:38] enable our [00:25:39] customers, these [00:25:40] landlords, [00:25:41] to [00:25:42] identify very [00:25:43] unique [00:25:44] attributes of [00:25:45] the spaces that they [00:25:46] currently own, [00:25:47] whether in their [00:25:48] existing conditions [00:25:49] or with modifications, [00:25:50] meaning [00:25:51] removing walls, pushing [00:25:52] things together. How [00:25:53] do we [00:25:54] identify, , in a very [00:25:55] Moneyball type of [00:25:56] way, and this is where the [00:25:57] science comes into play, [00:25:58] the unique [00:25:59] attributes that a [00:26:00] tenant would find [00:26:01] asymmetric value for?
[00:26:02] then identifying [00:26:03] that and then putting it in [00:26:04] their face, [00:26:05] I-if we're able [00:26:06] to call out that, [00:26:07] hey, this space [00:26:08] happens to look [00:26:09] very [00:26:10] similar, to the top [00:26:11] ten percent of performing [00:26:12] locations of Jersey [00:26:13] Mike's across the [00:26:14] country, we [00:26:15] should probably identify [00:26:16] that and bubble that [00:26:17] up [00:26:18] because I, I bet you Jersey [00:26:19] Mike's should pay a little [00:26:20] more and maybe be a little [00:26:21] more willing to [00:26:22] pay
for this space as [00:26:23] opposed to another [00:26:24] space.
And This space [00:26:25] happens to perform [00:26:26] better and with this [00:26:27] specific [00:26:28] [00:26:29] permutation of [00:26:30] co-tenancy [00:26:31] dynamics or in [00:26:32] this certain [00:26:33] demographic or in this [00:26:34] certain, market [00:26:35] void. And then [00:26:36] in addition to that, [00:26:37] break-breaking the [00:26:38] atoms bits [00:26:39] wall, right? And say, [00:26:40] "Okay, this space [00:26:41] is previous [00:26:42] use is right, [00:26:43] the formatting is [00:26:44] right, the location's right, [00:26:45] all the [00:26:46] water coming in is right, [00:26:47] the power coming in [00:26:48] is right."
all this [00:26:49] comes together, and [00:26:50] then where you've [00:26:51] found a tenant that wants to grow [00:26:52] in this market, [00:26:53] it de-risks their [00:26:54] decisions for [00:26:55] them. We [00:26:56] have a high likelihood [00:26:57] of better [00:26:58] financially and having a [00:26:59] long-term, [00:27:00] occupier in the space [00:27:01] that's going to be a net [00:27:02] contributor to foot traffic [00:27:03] to the other [00:27:04] tenants [00:27:05] and, putting that all [00:27:06] together and [00:27:07] ideally- If [00:27:08] we do this right, they could [00:27:09] open [00:27:10] faster.
that's where things get [00:27:11] really exciting. [00:27:12]
Edward: Very well [00:27:13] said. , [00:27:14] Let's, move on [00:27:15] to what's been going [00:27:16] on on the [00:27:17] retail [00:27:18] industry, more, [00:27:19] more specifically the [00:27:20] [00:27:21] groceries. historically, groceries [00:27:22] have always been, and [00:27:23] by all means [00:27:24] still are, great [00:27:25] tenants. [00:27:26] They're anchors. [00:27:27] They're community, [00:27:28] centers. [00:27:29] however, more recently, [00:27:30] [00:27:31] Kroger, is closing [00:27:32] 60 stores by the [00:27:33] end of [00:27:34] 2026.
[00:27:35] Amazon shut down [00:27:36] all of its [00:27:37] 72, physical [00:27:38] grocery locations. [00:27:39] [00:27:40] Albertsons has been pulling [00:27:41] back. [00:27:42] Now, a retail [00:27:43] landlord with a grocery [00:27:44] anchor might say their [00:27:45] tenant is stable and this [00:27:46] doesn't apply to them, [00:27:47] and that could very well be [00:27:48] the case. [00:27:49] however, why do you think they should [00:27:50] be paying attention to [00:27:51] this trend?
Jordan: [00:27:52] Kroger [00:27:53] closing those [00:27:54] sixty-four, and I think [00:27:55] forty of them closed. [00:27:56] I, and think the [00:27:57] Amazon thing is [00:27:58] very [00:27:59] different. I don't know if there's a [00:28:00] feeling [00:28:01] of the [00:28:02] durability of a grocery anchor shopping [00:28:03] center, is that story gonna [00:28:04] be called into question due [00:28:05] to some slipping [00:28:06] financials or [00:28:07] from some [00:28:08] signals of the [00:28:09] grocers [00:28:10] having, a harder [00:28:11] time?
I [00:28:12] think there's competition [00:28:13] dynamics. I [00:28:14] think [00:28:15] there's, macro [00:28:16] factors that's challenging [00:28:17] some spend. [00:28:18] Kroger's making aggressive [00:28:19] moves. I mean, the Giant Eagle [00:28:20] thing is, I think, super [00:28:21] aggressive, and I think they're calling their [00:28:22] shots there in how they're gonna [00:28:23] grow.
I think the [00:28:24] Amazon thing is distinctly [00:28:25] different. I think [00:28:26] they got into that [00:28:27] business with certain [00:28:28] expectations,
I don't [00:28:29] know. haven't heard [00:28:30] anything that, makes [00:28:31] me lead to believe that there's any [00:28:32] challenging. If The [00:28:33] market's so hot for [00:28:34] these assets, [00:28:35] and if you [00:28:36] look at the site [00:28:37] centers transition to curve [00:28:38] line and saying, "You know [00:28:39] what?"
We see an [00:28:40] opportunity in these [00:28:41] neighborhood a [00:28:42] non-grocer anchor strip [00:28:43] centers, you're starting to [00:28:44] see a lot, of people put their [00:28:45] time over there, [00:28:46] partially, I think, [00:28:47] because the market's just [00:28:48] so hot for these grocery [00:28:49] anchor centers.
So [00:28:50] I don't know how it's gonna shake [00:28:51] out. I mean, we're six [00:28:52] years removed [00:28:53] from COVID, that's a [00:28:54] kind of a long [00:28:55] time. I think by [00:28:56] year ten removed from [00:28:57] COVID, we're gonna [00:28:58] really [00:28:59] understand what the future [00:29:00] looks like [00:29:01] on is the [00:29:02] grocer thing gonna be [00:29:03] evergreen, [00:29:04] and this gonna be, [00:29:05] remaining a [00:29:06] pillar of [00:29:07] durability, and [00:29:08] landlords are going to be [00:29:09] willing to pay very [00:29:10] large [00:29:11] premiums, to [00:29:12] getting into those [00:29:13] centers?
[00:29:14] Or is there gonna be an [00:29:15] alternative or another [00:29:16] large event that changes [00:29:17] things [00:29:18] and that starts to siphon [00:29:19] away some of the markup [00:29:20] on those assets? So [00:29:21] I think it's really [00:29:22] interesting, and but I think the [00:29:23] base case still remains the [00:29:24] same.
Edward: I, [00:29:25] tend to agree with [00:29:26] most, things you said. I [00:29:27] mean, [00:29:28] Amazon certainly has [00:29:29] different unit [00:29:30] economics and priorities [00:29:31] than, say, a, a [00:29:32] Kroger would [00:29:33] have. where I would push [00:29:34] back is where, [00:29:35] I mean, [00:29:36] Amazon, they [00:29:37] still run Whole [00:29:38] Foods [00:29:39] smoothly. they're still opening a lot [00:29:40] of Whole Foods, [00:29:41] especially here in, [00:29:42] in, core metro [00:29:43] areas.
but I [00:29:44] wouldn't necessarily [00:29:45] discount [00:29:46] Amazon [00:29:47]
closing dozens [00:29:48] of their [00:29:49] stores, as, being an [00:29:50] isolated, [00:29:51] issue. whether you love it or [00:29:52] you hate it, as a [00:29:53] consumer you most likely love [00:29:54] it, and, uh, as [00:29:55] a [00:29:56] competitor or as a [00:29:57] small business, or [00:29:58] regional business you [00:29:59] probably hate [00:30:00] them.
but in [00:30:01] terms of affordability, I [00:30:02] mean, I think [00:30:03] supermarkets are here to [00:30:04] stay. as affordability [00:30:05] issues, [00:30:06] persist, nationwide, [00:30:07] people are gonna opt [00:30:08] to, eat [00:30:09] more [00:30:10] supermarket food, [00:30:11] than otherwise. [00:30:12] but just [00:30:13] comparing supermarket [00:30:14] prices as a [00:30:15] consumer, [00:30:16] I'm shocked to see that [00:30:17] Whole Foods now is [00:30:18] actually not [00:30:19] near the expensive one, and [00:30:20] actually among the most [00:30:21] affordable ones, at [00:30:22] least in, in key [00:30:23] metro areas, which [00:30:24] is shocking to [00:30:25] hear just when a [00:30:26] few years ago Whole [00:30:27] Foods was the [00:30:28] most expensive and [00:30:29] premium one.
Jordan: I [00:30:30] think the Amazon [00:30:31] playbook, Everett, is, I think we're [00:30:32] starting to see the Whole Foods [00:30:33] thing take on [00:30:34] this Amazon playbook [00:30:35] of unlocking efficiency [00:30:36] at scale [00:30:37] and, finding the right [00:30:38] products [00:30:39] and, uh, [00:30:40] driving unbelievable [00:30:41] scale to [00:30:42] pass on these [00:30:43] savings to customers [00:30:44] and really [00:30:45] compete not only on [00:30:46] the premium section, but [00:30:47] also get other [00:30:48] customers too.
I think we [00:30:49] may be starting to see [00:30:50] the, [00:30:51] Bezos-ification of [00:30:52] Whole [00:30:53] Foods
Edward: [00:30:54] Bezosification, trademarked [00:30:55] by [00:30:56] Jordan Herring. [00:30:57] and to [00:30:58] your point earlier about [00:30:59] Kroger, uh, [00:31:00] yes, they did just [00:31:01] pay over 1.6 [00:31:02] billion for Giant [00:31:03] Eagles and [00:31:04] 197 [00:31:05] stores [00:31:06] across Ohio, [00:31:07] Pennsylvania, West [00:31:08] Virginia, Maryland, and [00:31:09] Indiana. I mean, [00:31:10] this is [00:31:11] institutional capital moving [00:31:12] into tertiary [00:31:13] markets.
So how do you [00:31:14] think this kind of [00:31:15] institutional [00:31:16] move [00:31:17] into markets [00:31:18] that aren't used to [00:31:19] getting this sort of [00:31:20] capital changes the [00:31:21] calculus for [00:31:22] landlords who have been [00:31:23] operating there?
Jordan: [00:31:24] I, I think it's a big [00:31:25] deal. when this news [00:31:26] dropped, [00:31:27] I reached out to a few [00:31:28] people, who [00:31:29] operate in those markets, [00:31:30] and I think there's a lot of [00:31:31] excitement, one, to see [00:31:32] Kroger, uh, [00:31:33] making some bigger [00:31:34] bets [00:31:35] and being aggressive, [00:31:36] which I think is [00:31:37] great. Giant Eagle was a [00:31:38] good operator, and I [00:31:39] think they had their own [00:31:40] kinda interesting [00:31:41] following to them.
I [00:31:42] think in [00:31:43] these centers, in [00:31:44] these tertiary [00:31:45] markets, is this [00:31:46] going to [00:31:47] trailblaze the way for [00:31:48] other [00:31:49] high-credit nationals [00:31:50] to follow into these [00:31:51] tertiary markets, [00:31:52] which maybe they [00:31:53] ordinarily would've [00:31:54] overlooked. Maybe they [00:31:55] didn't view Giant Eagle [00:31:56] as in [00:31:57] a large enough of a, of [00:31:58] an anchor [00:31:59] that it [00:32:00] could, would de-risk [00:32:01] them from expanding into [00:32:02] those, those markets, [00:32:03] and where Kroger may [00:32:04] be, large [00:32:05] enough and, uh, [00:32:06] effective enough and [00:32:07] durable enough [00:32:08] to maintain.
[00:32:09] that's something that I would [00:32:10] be watching w- is [00:32:11] that, are [00:32:12] these Kroger [00:32:13] assets, are [00:32:14] the reps looking [00:32:15] at and saying, [00:32:16] "Hey, Does this [00:32:17] unlock more [00:32:18] opportunity to get [00:32:19] people [00:32:20] who ordinarily wouldn't [00:32:21] consider West [00:32:22] Virginia [00:32:23] or, outside of, [00:32:24] Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania or something like [00:32:25] that, to move in [00:32:26] here?"
And, I think they're gonna see [00:32:27] some success. I think this [00:32:28] is gonna work
Edward: [00:32:29] We will [00:32:30] tune in and see how [00:32:31] it turns out. [00:32:32] moving [00:32:33] to more grocery [00:32:34] news, but New [00:32:35] York City just [00:32:36] announced [00:32:37] five [00:32:38] city-run grocery [00:32:39] stores that will [00:32:40] pay no [00:32:41] rent and no [00:32:42] property taxes and [00:32:43] sell food at [00:32:44] 30% below [00:32:45] market. The city [00:32:46] has allocated [00:32:47] an estimated of [00:32:48] $70 [00:32:49] million in [00:32:50] capital funds. [00:32:51] what are your thoughts on this?
Is [00:32:52] that a policy [00:32:53] story? Is this a [00:32:54] real estate story? [00:32:55] Affordability? [00:32:56] A [00:32:57] populist [00:32:58] story?
Jordan: maybe all of [00:32:59] the above. I [00:33:00] think [00:33:01] this is gonna be, I [00:33:02] think, a New York City [00:33:03] experiment. [00:33:04] and [00:33:05] I hope to see Dora [00:33:06] Mondamy at the [00:33:07] ICSC New York [00:33:08] show and, , I think it's gonna be [00:33:09] interesting to see [00:33:10] the, reaction to [00:33:11] this inside these large [00:33:12] metros. I think the competitive [00:33:13] dynamics have been pretty [00:33:14] isolated. Now, is this gonna be a [00:33:15] playbook that you're [00:33:16] gonna see across other [00:33:17] large metros?
[00:33:18] kind of adjacent to [00:33:19]
this in this populous [00:33:20] three decisions, [00:33:21] which I think do [00:33:22] affect retail, [00:33:23] do affect commercial real estate, is [00:33:24] that there's, uh, [00:33:25] at least six, maybe [00:33:26] seven or eight [00:33:27] large metros who [00:33:28] have, rent freezes on the [00:33:29] ballot this year in [00:33:30] November. If we're starting [00:33:31] to see a lot of [00:33:32] this, government [00:33:33] putting their fingers on the [00:33:34] scales in these [00:33:35] urban areas, [00:33:36] I don't necessarily [00:33:37] see that as [00:33:38] attractive to [00:33:39] our core customers, and I'd [00:33:40] be curious to see what those [00:33:41] dynamics... how that [00:33:42] changes the [00:33:43] calculus. But in [00:33:44] addition to that, I [00:33:45] think, [00:33:46] commercial has this [00:33:47] really [00:33:48] interesting competitive [00:33:49] advantage compared [00:33:50] to or relative [00:33:51] to residential or [00:33:52] multifamily, [00:33:53] considering if [00:33:54] these rent freezes do go [00:33:55] into effect or, or [00:33:56] tried or [00:33:57] whatever.
Y- I think there's very [00:33:58] few things private property [00:33:59] hates, hates more [00:34:00] than, rent [00:34:01] freezes, to be honest with [00:34:02] you. So, does [00:34:03] that rebalance [00:34:04] where [00:34:05] people are, [00:34:06] deploying capital, and [00:34:07] does retail [00:34:08] get more looks [00:34:09] now? a question that I've, [00:34:10] always had. So I [00:34:11] think it's a little bit of [00:34:12] a nothing [00:34:13] burger, as far as Mondamy's [00:34:14] grocery stores [00:34:15] go.
I hope the mission is [00:34:16] successful for them. [00:34:17] However, I'm [00:34:18] greatly skeptical, and [00:34:19] I always have a hard time think- [00:34:20] you know, viewing the government [00:34:21] competing with, with [00:34:22] business. But at the end of [00:34:23] the day, I think [00:34:24] this is gonna be a little bit of a [00:34:25] nothing burger, a- [00:34:26] And you would know better than I do, [00:34:27] Edward, but I think the [00:34:28] first one opens in [00:34:29] 2030 or something.
[00:34:30] So, we're gonna have to hold on and see [00:34:31] how this goes.[00:34:32]
Edward: Oh man, [00:34:33] I was [00:34:34] excited to get my [00:34:35] 30% below, [00:34:36] market, uh, [00:34:37] groceries. I guess [00:34:38] I'm going back to paying [00:34:39] $1 a [00:34:40] banana.
Jordan: hey, 67 [00:34:41] cents organic bananas at [00:34:42] Whole Foods. Edward, I don't, [00:34:43] I don't know if it gets much [00:34:44] cheaper
Edward: Costa Rican [00:34:45] bananas, not just
Jordan: [00:34:46] Pura Vida. [00:34:47] Pura Vida
Edward: [00:34:48] vida. Jordan, last [00:34:49] but not least, [00:34:50] collaboration superpower. [00:34:51] If you could partner with [00:34:52] one person, [00:34:53] historic or [00:34:54] living, real or [00:34:55] fictional, who would it [00:34:56] be?
Jordan: I- i- [00:34:57] it can't be Everett [00:34:58] Cohen?
Edward: [00:34:59] Well, we're already [00:35:00] collaborating, so next[00:35:01]
Jordan: I [00:35:02] like it. [00:35:03] Oh, [00:35:04] man. from an industry [00:35:05] [00:35:06] perspective, I would love to collaborate with [00:35:07] John Gray at some point [00:35:08] from Blackstone. I, I [00:35:09] think the way he thinks and, [00:35:10] everything he puts out I [00:35:11] read, and I think it's really [00:35:12] interesting.
So I would love [00:35:13] to collaborate with him, for [00:35:14] sure. how they [00:35:15] think about the business [00:35:16] and, and de-decisions [00:35:17] that they make, are [00:35:18] awesome. So I think that'd be [00:35:19] super fun, super [00:35:20] cool. and [00:35:21] obviously the legend Bob [00:35:22] Knakal. we can get Bob [00:35:23] Knakal into, more retail [00:35:24] stuff, I think that'd be super [00:35:25] cool.
So,, one of [00:35:26] those two would be really [00:35:27] cool
Edward: Well, I'm [00:35:28] sure John Gray is [00:35:29] very busy, [00:35:30] doing his, [00:35:31] TikTok video [00:35:32] while he runs in Central [00:35:33] Park. But, I [00:35:34] hope he does have time [00:35:35] to listen to this [00:35:36] Tangent [00:35:37] episode, to [00:35:38] learn and collaborate [00:35:39] with you. [00:35:40] Jordan, where can [00:35:41] Tangent listeners [00:35:42] and retail and [00:35:43] commercial real estate [00:35:44] owners and operators [00:35:45] learn more [00:35:46] about ID [00:35:47] Plans and connect with [00:35:48] you?
Jordan: Thank you so [00:35:49] much, Edward. [00:35:50] [00:35:51] idplans.com and [00:35:52] find me on LinkedIn [00:35:53] or a [00:35:54] local ICSC [00:35:55] show
Edward: [00:35:56] today we [00:35:57] covered why the data [00:35:58] problem in commercial real [00:35:59] estate is not [00:36:00] shortage of information, [00:36:01] but a shortage of [00:36:02] information in the right [00:36:03] place at the right [00:36:04] time and for the right [00:36:05] person to act on. [00:36:06] We talked about [00:36:07] why the [00:36:08] best-in-class specialization [00:36:09] bet in proptech [00:36:10] created a [00:36:11] coordination problem nobody [00:36:12] budgeted for, [00:36:13] and what a [00:36:14] platform that actually [00:36:15] connects those layers [00:36:16] look like in practice.[00:36:17]
We also got [00:36:18] into, the [00:36:19] grocery [00:36:20] sector and [00:36:21] how the activity of [00:36:22] some players like [00:36:23] Kroger and [00:36:24] Amazon may [00:36:25] impact, [00:36:26] investors, [00:36:27] across primary as well [00:36:28] as tertiary [00:36:29] markets. Jordan, [00:36:30] thanks for coming on [00:36:31] Tangent today.
Jordan: [00:36:32] Edward, thank you so [00:36:33] much [00:36:34] [00:36:35] [00:36:36] [00:36:37] Muchas [00:36:38] gracias. If [00:36:39] you learn something [00:36:40] new or enjoy the [00:36:41] conversation. [00:36:42] Text a friend the link [00:36:43] to this episode right [00:36:44] now.
[00:36:45] You [00:36:46] can find links, [00:36:47] resources, and [00:36:48] ways to connect with us [00:36:49] in the show [00:36:50] notes [00:36:51] [00:36:52] [00:36:53] [00:36:54]