رونوشت 🔗
00:00:05
Speaker 1: Hello and welcome to TalkSport Australia's Football Focus, a new week and plenty to focus on. We'll be talking about a bit of Premier League later in the show, but we've got Andy Harper, which means we will start with the Australian game and things close to home in the A-League and also.
00:00:20
Speaker 2: On the continent of Asia. Andy Harper, firstly, great to see you again.
00:00:23
Speaker 3: Great to be here, Tyra. Thanks.
00:00:25
Speaker 1: And it's always great, your comments on the TalkSport Australia YouTube channel. Make sure you jump on Instagram as well. That is starting to tick over a little bit more, TalkSport Australia. And you can find us, subscribe wherever you get your podcasts. But Harps, right off the top, I want to jump into a bit of a big picture talking point with how it applies to the game in Australia. Because in the last week, we have seen four different Australian clubs play in Asian competition. The Champions League Elite, the Champions League 2 and the Champions League Women's. And our clubs have gone four losses from four. Before I give you my opinion on some of the things we've seen in the last week, is this a low point? And just how worried should we be that we are now enduring weeks like this where across three different competitions and in men's and women's football, we are losing across the board in Asia?
00:01:15
Speaker 3: Well, I'm desperate to hear your opinions, Taya, but I'll tee off with a quick one. Firstly, it's on all of us. to not just focus on the one week. I know this provides a good launching pad to talk about some of the bigger issues, and that's justifiable. But Adelaide's form in Asia to this point has been good. Victory had a good week the week before last in beating FC Seoul. That's a big scalp at home. So before we sort of pick over the carcass of the last week, which has become a pretty rancid carcass pretty quickly, We should just keep that in the back of our minds that it hasn't been a total disaster, but it was a really difficult week. Now, having just provided that little bit of context, I'm going to throw it back to you, Ted, because I'm actually really interested and not for the first time to hear what you've got to say.
00:02:06
Speaker 2: Well, the victory situation, they lost to Persib Bandung away in Indonesia. They play them at home this week. But the great worry is FC Seoul have now wrapped up the Korean League. So Seoul sent their essential reserve team, Rotated players, lots of teenagers to Australia. Victory beat them 3-0.
00:02:24
Speaker 1: FC Seoul rolled out almost their entire first team against the Kong in Vietnam and beat them 5-0, and it was 3-0 after half an hour. So when victory go away to Seoul, that is going to be a completely different proposition to what they got in Melbourne. I think they're in massive trouble to get out of their group, which when you consider that they're in a group with a team from Indonesia and a team from Vietnam.
00:02:45
Speaker 2: That is quite worrying.
00:02:46
Speaker 1: I mean, I can understand not being able to stack up against the champions of South Korea, but Adelaide United, they had won their first two games, but it's the first time an Australian team has lost at home to a club from Singapore. Now, admittedly, the Champions League has changed the rules. You can play as many foreigners as you want. I think that does compromise the competition somewhat, as opposed to the old three foreigners plus one Asian player rule that used to be in place. But looking through the Lion City Sailors team that beat Adelaide United... They had spent more than a million Australian dollars on incoming transfer fees this season, never mind the wages they're paying to players that signed.
00:03:22
Speaker 2: On free transfers.
00:03:23
Speaker 1: And unfortunately, Harps, I see a future where our reality is Australian teams, you know, the champion makes the top of the league, the Champions League elite. Newcastle Jets were overrun 5-2 in Japan. That is perhaps understandable, maybe even forgivable. But I see a future where our reality is battling to get out of groups in the Champions League too. And I just wonder, these competitions even against the powerhouses of Japan and South Korea have not been able to resonate with Australian crowds. It's going to be an even harder sell if we're playing and not even beating teams from Hong Kong and Singapore and Vietnam. It might be great for the diaspora communities in Australia, but it's not actually going to paint a rosy picture for the future, never mind that we have these pie-in-the-sky dreams of getting to the Club World Championship one day. The only way you do that is by winning the Champions League Elite, and that feels light years away at present.
00:04:16
Speaker 3: The way things are, you're right. What you've done effectively there, Teo, is seen my context and risen the stakes by providing your context, particularly on the Melbourne victory situation. It is a worry. It is a worry, and it's not going to fix itself. Whilst ever the league continues on this trajectory and not just the league i mean football australia are part of this as well because they're part of the solution at the moment and there's a there's a multiplicity of issues that coalesce around a team that goes to represent us at club or international level that become very that are laid bare completely by the starkness of the competition provided over 90 minutes that's when all the chickens come home to roost and that's happened in the champions league this week particularly with the the elite competition where Newcastle were always going to find it very difficult. Last season in the domestic league, just fantastic, earned the right to be in the Champions League elite. But very, very obviously, there is not the structure or resourcing around the Newcastle Jets football club to land blows at that level. That's the stark reality. Now, what's going to
Load full transcript
change this? Because you're right, Taya, you know, the thought When Australian clubs, Sydney FC, for example, first played in the Champions League against Persic Kadiri at the old Parramatta Stadium in the Champions League, and the away trip as well was difficult, but in the end, a formality for the Australian club. Now, the top end of town in Asia is, apart from an aberration, out of reach at this point. But we're getting overtaken by the smaller developing leagues and that is a worry the worry is because Teo we're actually still even at this point even after how many years after separation league from Football Australia the independence of the league we're still not being told where we're going with this and so people in your position and my position who follow it a lot closer than most, not as close as some, but a lot closer than most, are thinking, is this just the new normal? And if it is the new normal, and how do we know otherwise? Because head office is not shining a light on the hill saying this is where we're going. Then the very real spectre of your coefficient, explain that for us if you need to, Tao, within the Asian mathematics spectrum, So whilst we now have three places in Asia, the next step for us is to have two places in Asia. And the next place for that afterwards, if things don't change, is one place in Asia. And then after that, it's a playoff to get one place in the second tier of Asia. That's where this conceivably is heading on the basis of certainly the Jets in the Champions League, but this week in the Champions League too. and the women's competition didn't go well for us either. So it is a massive concern, primarily because it gets down to, ultimately, investment, and the A-league club owners are still investment-shy. You can understand, to a point, you can understand completely why they've hit that level, but what everyone needs to know is, having stemmed the flow... and gone through this period of austerity, the word we keep using, we're to from here. And it's about investment. And the other bow I will draw on this one is, apart from the odd isolated example, the biggest gap for us at the moment is the quality of the foreign players that clubs are bringing into this country. And they're just not worth a visa place. In too many situations. They are just not worth their place on the roster as a visa player. And this goes completely to the levels of investment from the owners. And it's the owners who can change this paradigm. It's the owners who can break this inertia.
00:08:25
Speaker 2: Yeah, absolutely right.
00:08:27
Speaker 1: And I keep having to say this in conversations, but let's not forget the A-League owners collectively govern themselves. They separated from the FA in order to do that. So When we talk about the APL, we are essentially talking about a collection of club owners who have appointed their own governors to make these decisions. One last thing on this point, Harps, before we move on to some of the
games. One bugbear of mine is that we still don't have a domestic transfer system in Australia for.
00:08:54
Speaker 2: The best part of 20 years now.
00:08:56
Speaker 1: It's been a case where if you want to move from one Australian club to another, you can only do it on a free transfer system. It does feel, and when I see, you know, Lion City sailors spending transfer fees of 500 euros, of 300 euros, of signing players from Europe. Yes, Australia does that, but only, you know, very rarely do we pay transfer fees for players. And looking at our record transfer fees ever paid, none in the space of the last 10 years or so. So we're effectively opting out of 50% of the transfer market.
00:09:27
Speaker 2: Yes, we see ourselves as a selling league. We want sell-on clauses.
00:09:30
Speaker 1: We want to make money from what you have dubbed the puppy farm of all our various puppies being purebreds and going to different corners of the world. But I still feel as though giving the clubs the ability to sell to each other will help stimulate more of this player movement. And if a club knows that if it means selling your best player to City or Victory or Sydney or Western Sydney Wanderers or whoever the club du jour is, that has the right owner and the right amount of money at that time, I still feel as though that will stimulate more activity. And where it will also create a great deal of stimulus is at NPL level. You say the foreign recruiting is poor. We know that NPL clubs outside of the A-League have amazing networks to various corners of the world that A-League clubs don't tap into. If they go and they are incentivized, then... to go and find a great foreigner, if they find a 20-goal striker that comes in as a foreign player, knowing that they can sell him to an A-League team rather than simply lose him for nothing, I think it incentivises the entire football landscape to take part in the transfer market at a far greater level than they currently do.
00:10:36
Speaker 3: Yeah, I think that's a fair point. I don't understand why a transfer system, domestic transfer system, hasn't been brought in. Let me hasten to add, I don't think it's the cure-all. I follow your logic. And I agree with your logic. But it's like a lot of these things, you're talking about little catalysts around the place and in isolation, they're not going to fix everything. And even two or three catalysts aren't going to fix everything. I just think, Tao, and that's why I sort of brought Football Australia into this Asian Champions League discussion, is because in so many ways, they present and provide and represent the foundation of the game. And clearly, by the right of mission, I've got a lot of work to do in various aspects. But this is such a meta discussion, Tao, that we keep rolling around in ever tighter balls of self-flagellation when the meta issues seemingly keep getting avoided. And I'm going to drop one of them. Even after all this time, And this might sound like a slogan, but actually, Tao, it's more than that. I cannot for the life of me see a unilateral agreement in this country that the league is everything. In our situation, we're talking about the A-League competition, men's and women's. Every competition around the world, every national governing body around the world, even in Australia, dies or lives profits or losers on the strength of their top league where do you think rugby league would be if the nrl wasn't a competition where every available first level resource went to building the nrl same with the afl right then because they've established that and there is no question about their primacy in the whole pyramid they can then go about building their business and funding this that and the other the big test for them of course is getting the examination in offshore international competition, which quite clearly is never going to happen in the Aussie rules. So they live in this quarantine bubble where they're beyond reproaching. We actually never know how good we are at Aussie rules because the Brazilians, the Germans and the Japanese don't play it. So we don't know how good our AFL, much vaunted system is. We do play Ireland in the hybrid.
00:12:53
Speaker 1: Well, when the, when the aliens land harps, that's when we'll, that's when we'll find.
00:12:57
Speaker 2: Out for sure.
00:12:58
Speaker 3: So, so the point is we, You cannot find any documentation, apart from motherhood statements about alignment, where the primacy of the league is central to everything. We look offshore, football competitions, and it's the primacy of La Liga. It's the primacy of the EPL and the pyramid that's developed over 100 years after that. We in Australia, people who so-called love the game and want the best for it, sit and take potshots. And then these same people sit back and wonder why we struggle offshore because we can't get that very foundational agreement in place. And Football Australia can play a big part. with the APL and establishing that mantra in Australia. Let's get that understood first. And then we can argue, debate, discuss, cajole, work, lobby to build from that point. But until it's just going to be a really hard slog. And the only thing in the short term that can break it without actually a plan with the league is everything centerpiece is the owners reinvesting. Now, they can short circuit this. by decision. A simple decision.
00:14:16
Speaker 1: Harps, we've certainly given plenty of things to mull over to our listeners in the comments and hopefully we continue to strike a chord because all the feedback is that fans love the discussion of the big picture in the Australian game. Let's get on to the pitch though. I'll give you a peek at the board. I won't bias you one way or another. I'll just give you the weekend results and you can pick up which game perhaps grabbed you most from the A-League weekend. A one-all draw between Brisbane and Auckland. Wellington, three wins from three, winning 3-0
away at the Newcastle Jets. Melbourne City came from behind to beat Sydney FC 2-1. A stalemate nil-all between MacArthur and Western Sydney. One-all between Victory and Central Coast after Victory went down to 10 men early in the game with a red card.
00:15:03
Speaker 2: And Perth Glory beat Adelaide United 4-0. Harps, what is the headline out of the A-League weekend?
00:15:09
Speaker 3: Well, Very quickly, firstly, the MacArthur-Western Sydney game was just fantastic. It was one of the best games you're going to get without a goal. It was excellent. The flip side of that was victory Mariners, which was forgettable, and we got two great goals. So that's the bizarreness of football. But my real talking point is going to flow off the back of that last longer discussion, and that's Perth. Not just they beat Adelaide to complete a really disappointing week for Adelaide, And not because it was a resounding 4-0 and Perth were great. This speaks to how good the bones of the game and the bones of the league.
00:15:48
Speaker 1: Are, right?
00:15:49
Speaker 3: Because I'm looking at Perth, very unlucky losers in the first two weeks and resounding winners week three, and the kids on whom they're calling. And again, it just shows that, to your point about NPL, the NPL and down into the grassroots is the eighth wonder of the world, Teo. I defy anyone to find anywhere on the planet where without help and through organic processes and democratic processes, Australia-wide has built this incredible network of community football growing up into NPL football. It is a wonder of the world. We should be so proud of it. It is so functional to the level at which it operates and provides into the A-League's This great skeletal framework, like it's there. It's fantastic. And we saw that on the weekend, albeit a depleted and slightly demoralised Adelaide for whatever reason, but Adam Griffiths did a great job and the kids he brought on just are another reflection of that. At the moment, it's not the complete answer, but we should sit back and say, mate, that honest, that whole structure nationwide, the number of people and communities that serve, not through any particular central direction over 120 years, just because that's the game and the way communities have organised themselves into these very sophisticated competitions and structures Australia-wide. It's a bloody miracle and we should be incredibly proud of it. So the bones are there, right? And Perth told me, reinforced if we needed it on the weekend, that we don't have to reinvent the wheel. There's so much there. It's the investment at the top that needs to fix it. So well done to Perth. MacArthur and the Wanderers, just an outstanding game of football. I loved it to death. I thought it was fabulous. What about you?
00:17:35
Speaker 1: Well, I'm intrigued by Melbourne City's comeback because for the second game in a row, and we spoke about him last week, Bezian Kutleshi started in midfield. He had a pretty tough
time of it playing alongside Cavie and Romani. So City went for the younger players to begin with, but they have the one asset that no other club has, and it's something that you highlighted about the Melbourne Derby. They have an experienced bench, and you stack up the two benchers, Sydney FC's 1-0 up at halftime, but they've got all kids on the bench. In fact, I think they only had one player in his 20s in the substitutes, and that was Gabriel Popovich, who, relatively speaking, is still quite an inexperienced player for someone in his early 20s, and he was left as an unused sub. Melbourne City, by contrast, had Emiliano Marcondes, who scored within 50 seconds of coming on, Matthew Leckie, Takeshi Kanemori using an import spot, Liam Bonatig, who is in his 20s and in the Olly Roos. And then they had a couple of kids, Roland Baller, who came on and Beckham Baker, who didn't. But that difference in the ability to change gears, to try something different, to go for an alternative plan, that did exist for Melbourne City and that engineered their comeback. And the first five to seven minutes of the second half was devastating because they didn't just equalise.
00:18:47
Speaker 2: Andrew Naboot hit the post.
00:18:48
Speaker 1: They were on the front foot and looked like they were going to win the game right there in that moment. And ultimately, they still did because they had one of many Socceroos in the game, Alwemar Bill, score his first goal harps in the A-League in 11 and a half years.
00:19:00
Speaker 3: Fantastic.
00:19:01
Speaker 2: A long time between drinks. I don't know if it's the A-League record.
00:19:06
Speaker 1: I found the all-time record for National League, and it was held by Paul Agostino, more than 5,000 days between a goal for West Adelaide and a goal for Adelaide United. So 15 years, but 11 and a half is still a long time, but everyone remembers the name, our mobile.
00:19:21
Speaker 2: He's been a great soccer. And I've got to say Melbourne city.
00:19:26
Speaker 1: They now, now the question they have to ask is, are they going to move into putting more of these veterans and more of their adult players into starting, or are they still going to opt for this mix and give themselves the ability to mix it up?
00:19:39
Speaker 2: What did you make of that particular game?
00:19:40
Speaker 3: Well, telling on a number of fronts. You've highlighted some of them and I'll just reinforce and then challenge a couple of things in what you said. But firstly, that record you talked about in gap between first A-League goal or last A-League goal and after returning from a European sojourn with Paul Agostino, 5,000 days. The common link there is they're both Adelaide boys. Wilma Bill and Paul Agostino both doing it for Adelaide on both ends of the planet, at both ends of their careers. So that's a That's a wonderful little reflection on how vibrant Adelaide has been over many, many years. So the Melbourne City thing. Well, the first question is, Tao, is what you finished with, is this a matter of just managing more and more minutes into the older brigade so they can then start games and dominate? Or I'm going to use the baseball analogy. Everyone's trying to moneyball their way through the A-League at the moment. Increased value for lesser inputs, kids, et cetera, et cetera. And I'm self-servingly going to drag the Milwaukee Brewers, now the World Series champions of baseball, into this discussion because Melbourne City, in a baseball sense, are running the best bullpen in the competition. They've got so many strikers, strike pitchers to come off the bench and to win games. It's just ridiculous at the moment, which frames Melbourne City in one way as a very considerable threat. If they get those more experienced players on for longer, who can beat them? But it also is directly contrasting Sydney's Moneyball approach, which is totally stripped back. Now, the underinvestment at the top end of that team, I think, is a discussion point because Sydney and Victory, if we were to pick two of the league, are the two clubs in the competition that I think everyone believes need to have the nicest curtains on the house. And irreversibly, that's to do with either having Matthew Leckie types on your roster or improving the foreigners you're bringing in. So Sydney, in tackling Melbourne City away from home, I think ran into that Mack truck head on. Their particular model and Melbourne City's model at the moment. So let's see how that one shakes down. The really disturbing thing for us is how impressive Melbourne City have been in the last two weeks overall. I mean, watching that senior team play to me is just fabulous. Unfortunately, there's not a lot of people in Melbourne who seem to agree with me. The crowd that Melbourne City attracted for a marquee match was nothing short of distressing, Tao. Distressing. I don't know where they go from here.
00:22:23
Speaker 1: Let's pick this point up because it's something that you and I debated only a couple of weeks ago. I said that Melbourne City had capped out the market and that as they exist, their current brand playing out of Amy Park under their current name As part of the CFG, this is as far as it's going to go and as good as it's going to get. Even I didn't think that a crowd for a home game against Sydney FC would be as small as 4,800. And believe me, there's mayo on that crowd. There's no way it was 4,800. And when you look across the pitch, Atkinson, capped Socceroo. Delbridge has a cap, as is Bayich, in the Socceroos right now. Awamobil, still a proposition to be a Socceroo. Andrew Nabut, capped Socceroo. Quinn McNichol, Medin Mehmedi, Bezian Kuleshi. These are some of our top prospects in national youth teams. There is a lot of footballing reasons to go and watch this team. And anyone who did watch was rewarded with a pretty entertaining game. But Harps, everything about the packaging is wrong. And you talk about the nicest curtains. Sydney
FC, you know, Takis Akene had quite a quiet game. Oriola Sunday may have had an assist for the goal, but He did struggle. Sydney FC, we know they have an upside and a capacity to draw 20,000 crowds plus. Melbourne Victory, similar. But the team that no one wants to go for has all the toys. They have all the resources. But the resource they can't generate is fans. And this speaks to sort of the holding pattern the league is stuck in. Because I know it's nice to have a functional club that pays all its bills and isn't the problem child of the league. But it's just as big a problem for people to turn on their televisions and see the green seat elite at Amy Park because it devalues the product on its aesthetic before you even watch a ball get kicked.
00:24:07
Speaker 3: Yeah, yeah. And this is totally predictable, totally predictable over many years, Taya, over many years. And look, I'm with you. I completely support Melbourne City so long as they're paying their way and putting a good product, the best product they think they can on the field. They've done that. They're beyond reproach and they've invested in facilities and that's all great. It's just upon the league and by association with Football Australia to think, hang on a minute, Melbourne City, valid licence holders, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. They can be the club they want to be, subject to the rules of the competition. That's fine. But this is not good enough for us, for the city of Melbourne. The City of Melbourne needs something else now, very obviously. The current travails of Melbourne City in the current context have been predictable almost since day one. And let's just go through a very quick potted history without digging into the detail too much. But the very moment, and we lived through this in the NSL, and we told people this is likely to be the experience. But the very moment Melbourne Heart broke cover as a branch office for Manchester City is the very start of the decline. The very moment then, on top of that, that Melbourne City bring David Villa to the league for an eight-game stint and he stays for two weeks, again, accentuates the decline. The very Melbourne City part of the biggest football enterprise on the planet that doesn't dip into building curtains for the league like everyone expected them to. And here's a key point. It's their choice to do what they feel is right. But the fact of the matter, in this business, sometimes you have to be what people expect you to be. And people expected Melbourne City to bring A-grade players out of Europe, out of their network. They brought some very good players, but their exercise with David Villa showed exactly to the people they're trying to sell tickets to where they were at. And it's been a steady decline since. Everything else around the league, some of that falls at Melbourne City and the fans are just not going to have it, clearly. And now we're faced with this situation, which is beyond anyone's control in this country. Once you have that initial divorce from the Melbourne heart mob and the Australian context by promoting one Premier League operation over others, and everyone's got a Premier League team, And why would they go and watch Manchester City when they're an Arsenal fan? And this is what we learnt in the NSL with Northern Spirit, who were packing the joint out until the money got a bit tight and they did a deal with Rangers. Now, Tao, at the time, we lived it. We were there. And at the time, I was living across the park from Northern Spirit and would talk to people at pubs before and after the games. The very moment this was the word on the street and the numbers sort of back it up, The very moment, given the sectarian nature of people, Northern Spirit had a Rangers badge on their shirt, they lost the Catholic vote. Like, overnight!
00:27:18
Speaker 1: Overnight!
00:27:21
Speaker 3: We couldn't have foreseen that coming in the days of the NSL, even as we lived in a very tribal football atmosphere. But that exodus from the Northern Spirit fanbase was stark. We learnt that lesson. And do you think anyone in the modern era... of new football wanted to listen to that lesson and still don't want to listen to that lesson. And I reckon that was the, that was the origin of the issue and it's only cascaded. And now we've got the situation with the city football group and their difficulties in the premier league with these 114 charges without casting judgment on that, who knows where it's going to go. But the fact of the matter is, doesn't that give locals in Melbourne even more of a reason just to turn off? I just think they're in a vortex and the league while supporting a member club and their right to be what they want to be, cannot leave the city of Melbourne with this much of a vacuum. They cannot.
00:28:15
Speaker 2: No, couldn't agree more, Harps. And again, it is one of many whack-a-moles.
00:28:22
Speaker 1: It's just a matter of, is this one, is the mole's teeth quite as sharp as some of the other problems that are biting a little bit harder at the moment before they have to whack it? One last one on the A-League before we move on to some Premier League. Brisbane Raw, they got a last-minute equaliser against Auckland for a one-all draw. But I don't think that really tells the story of a game where they had 19 shots. They out-XG'd Auckland by double. They had 70% possession, Harps. And in contrast to the Brisbane Raw of last season, which was bully ball, start a fight, the world's out to get us, this Brisbane team was a pleasure to watch. And they richly deserved their equaliser.
00:28:58
Speaker 2: And it's just.
00:28:59
Speaker 1: Under the same manager in Michael Valkanis, some different assistants, admittedly. He's got Jacopo La Roca and Nick Hegarty in to assist him now. A few personnel changes. Nam Tae Hee effectively played a free role as a roaming midfielder, and they've brought back Tyrese Francois, who has Premier League experience.
Brisbane Raw were a genuine pleasure to watch, and for all the problems that that club has with rather small crowds playing inside of Suncorp Stadium, at least the football itself was a good experience for 90 minutes. And hopefully that will resonate with the Queensland community, given that they are six years starved of even a finals appearance.
00:29:35
Speaker 3: Yeah, it's going to resonate. Taya. I couldn't agree more. I'm not as down on the way they started the comp last year. I don't think the turning point for them was just they ran out of anger pills. I think the turning point for them last year was that they lost key players, and Stahich is back. Their decline last year, and it was a precipitous one, all coincides with that shocking loss series of games in and around Christmas and New Year, when they lost players, and then they lost Lucas Harrington. Obviously, that speaks to its own story. But Stoich was a key one. They lost him for the rest of the season. And then, of course, they just became the bash-up boys because they'd bashed everyone else up. And I thought Valcanis' entry into the local market just broke the surface tension around Brisbane and gave them something to be. And the players responded. And initially, the fans responded. The game didn't respond terribly well. And I think Valkanis, in the fullness of time, has actually heeded the lessons that the game was trying to teach him. And that's fine. I'm not down on that process at all, right? I think that it served its purpose. It did put the club under a fair bit of pressure towards the end of last year. And I tell you how far this is reverberating. I've got a young son. He's in Europe at the moment, Tao. And he's still watching on YouTube the games.
00:30:55
Speaker 2: And he.
00:30:56
Speaker 3: contacted me about how good it was to watch Brisbane from Europe on YouTube. I thought, wow, that's more like it, right? Because he knows what he likes watching. He's not quite as, he's more progressive than his old man. I don't mind a bit of bash and barge at times because I think, you know, we try to purify everything because we don't back ourselves in Australia and we think we're missing so much of this that we forget some of the other basic ingredients like running and tackling. And anyone who's honest about the way they watch football, including the Premier League, including Liverpool Arsenal, about which we'll talk later, needs to watch that those very basic ingredients are not just consolidated, they're actually magnified. The bash and barge and the running is actually the foundation of the Premier League about which we all sing and dance. So to have Brisbane bring a little bit of that, passion-induced, I thought actually was a good disruptor. So they were fantastic on the weekend and I'm going to give a huge shout-out over and above Val Canis because he'll get his kudos and we're giving it to him now. Brilliant job, Michael. The Brisbane fans somehow, who've stuck on through
the shit, are now actually to a point where they've got a team that is promising some consistency in a style they want to watch, which is still very physical, but with a lot of great football around it. And they're making amazing noise. Amazing noise at Suncorp. And I say massive kudos to the Brisbane fans. But like the other discussions we've had, Tao, in the end, this all ends up in the lap of the owners who do, by reports, have the resourcing and the capacity to be part of the answer here, even in their own backyard. And instead of licking wounds about how hard this game is off the field and commercially, Brisbane Raw, we're told, and their ownership group does have the financial resource to say, hang on a minute. Melbourne victory, Sydney FC, you chase us. How about you chase us? And Brisbane will show the way forward rather than a cut-and-paste bean-counting exercise, which is not going to turn the dial long-term. That's the reality that faces the fans in Michael Valkanis. Actually, the big picture is in the hands of the owners of that singular club with a monopoly from Coffs Harbour to Cooktown. That's Brisbane raw space, and they've had it for 20 years. And the owners, with the resource to do something about it, should honestly sit back and say, have we maximized that? And what do we need to do to maximize it? And what do we do to make Sydney FC and Melbourne Victory chase us? They have that capacity.
00:33:29
Speaker 1: One last one on the A-League before we jump into the Premier League halves. And this is almost self-congratulatory, but After round one, we spoke about the police presence at the Sydney Derby. There was a silent protest for the first 20 minutes of the MacArthur versus Western Sydney Wanderers game where the fans were there but made no noise. Sasha Ognanovsky spoke quite passionately about it in his post-game press conference. And I just want to say that we on TalkSport Australia Football Focus, we were on to this after round one. It really resonated in the YouTube comments as well. Thank you to everyone who's helped keep it on the agenda. And it just changes the conversation that much more when instead of journalists and commentators talking about it, it's the coaches as well. And I feel like I almost don't need to add another opinion to it. I want to see how it percolates for the rest of this week, because a bit like Aurelio Vidmar talking about expansion, when it's a club spokesperson, especially MacArthur, given that they are one of the clubs that has a seat on the APL board, so quite direct influence over the competition, to hear a former Socceroo and a great Socceroo in Sascha Ognanovskiy talking so passionately about the importance of prioritising the fan experience. It was a heartwarming thing to see, but I'm really more intrigued as to what the fallout, if any, will be, and if it will resonate coming from a senior coach rather than from fan statements from fan groups or from us in the media talking about it.
00:34:53
Speaker 3: Yeah, well, I think you're right. Ufuk Taleh, when asked, weighed it in as well, and good on Ufi. Sasho Gronowski in the first three rounds has shown why MacArthur have yanked him out of NPL land down at Preston, where he did a great job with Zoran Markovsky, I'm sure, as part of the team down there with Preston. But Sash, you know, he's a bona fide, ready-to-go football product. We know that. We watched him as a player. We admired him as a player. We worked with him in the media. He did a lot of stuff with us at Fox Sports. He's clearly a thinking... He's a thinking guy's hard man, right? He knew how to box someone around the ears, but he also... understands the nuance and his coaching with that nuance. I mean, he's a great, I'm just thrilled he's back in that level of the game. And you know what? There's a lot more sashes out there in the game that the league can harness by identification, by growth, by all this sort of stuff. So when he is prepared to answer a question on behalf of the league, which he did, that was his first thing. The fans are an integral part of the league, but The reason why he did it is because the league we want, the league is everything. The league is everything. But you can have no league anywhere, to my point earlier, if you don't have fans. And we have to, the game never stood up for the fans when they got hammered all those years ago, brutally in a public sphere, whatever was going on. And we as a game and as a league need to manage ourselves well. And bad behavior is bad behavior, right? It's got to be managed and dealt with and not accepted. But my relief at turning up to Campbelltown on Saturday with no police helicopter circling the ground was a very pleasant experience by comparison. You know, that was really, really confronting on Sydney Derby night. And I don't know why or where it came from. It's a year since the Bondi atrocity. And that impact on the broader society is going to find its place in football, unfortunately, as well. We can't hide from that. And I understand the sensitivities around that. horror um because life changed that day but still football and authorities have got a history of of dealing with over policing and and we've got to support the people who are just supporting their teams and doing it with well well well within the bounds of acceptability like a drum and a banner and a flag really so good on sash good on oofy and all of us Again, but you say it's the punters from the public who need to keep this alive, not necessarily us with the megaphones. We're just here really to transmit that message and that passion and we do it the best we can when the time comes. But good on Ulfie and particularly Sash for taking the fight.
00:37:48
Speaker 1: So let's switch gears to a bit of Premier League to finish on this episode of Football Focus and Harps. It was a weekend where a lot of the top teams and a lot of the bottom teams all played each other in clusters. No bigger game
than Arsenal's 1-0 win away to Liverpool. Kai Havertz with an early goal. Liverpool with some chances, some woodwork, but Arsenal ultimately the victory at Anfield and in concert with Manchester City losing at home to Brighton. We have a shake-off now where Arsenal go top by three points. Brighton close to within just two points of Manchester City and there's a three-point gap back to Chelsea in fourth. So, What do you make of the machinations at the top of the Premier League with two big away wins for two of the top three?
00:38:29
Speaker 3: So, this morning's game, Liverpool-Arsenal gives me my tee-off point, but I'm going to save that until I say Manchester City lost playing like champions. Arsenal won playing like the Italian Azzurri-Catenaccio-Campbell. trophy winners of the 80s and 90s.
00:38:45
Speaker 2: Arteta ball, mate. That's what it is.
00:38:47
Speaker 3: Is that what they're calling it now?
00:38:48
Speaker 2: Yeah, yeah.
00:38:49
Speaker 3: He's copied it from 1950s into Milan. That was the origin of Cardinaccio. And that's Arsenal. And good luck to them. They were very strong. They defended. Mate, their penalty area in six-yard box defending was serious Cardinaccio going back through all the great Italian eras of Cardinaccio. Arsenal have bottled it. They've only got one Italian in their defensive unit in Calafiori. So kudos to them. But it was Manchester City who played like champions. They were fantastic. But they got beat by Brighton. And, mate, we've been saying since day one, Brighton have got it, right? They had to defend as well, like Liverpool did against Brighton the week before. I love... what Brighton are doing. And Manchester City, you know, there's a lot of fresh wins, but they were fantastic. I don't know how they didn't score, but they didn't. So that's my coverage of those two matches. Here's what pissed me off, Tao, about football in the Liverpool Arsenal game. Let's take the non-award of a penalty for Justin Timber pulling the shirt of Alexander Isak, right? So Bradley Barcola steps inside, down the left-hand side, cuts in on his right, crosses the ball in. There's a line of defenders, a line of strikers. The ball's going for Alexander Isak. He goes to jump. He misses it by a fraction. But what happens before then? On replay... Timberlake, Timberlake, Justin Timberlake, Justin Timber.
00:40:19
Speaker 2: I was going to correct you. I was going to correct you half, but I thought I'd let this play out.
00:40:23
Speaker 3: Let me hang myself. Good move.
00:40:24
Speaker 2: Uri and Timber.
00:40:25
Speaker 3: Yes. Timber grabs the shirt. It was a clear grab of the shirt. It wasn't a violent yank of the shirt, but it was a clear yank of the shirt that demonstrably stopped Alexander Isak's forward momentum to give him a chance of getting the ball. So the boffins and the game, this is what pisses me off about our game from time to time. The game thinks that's not a threshold moment of contact to justify a meaningful interruption to the game and to award a penalty. And I say bullshit. Because if that was an offside call, our game, through its leadership and match officials maybe driving that discussion, bends over backwards. to rule out goals for an offside that's not even measurable against the proverbial bee's dick. They rule out goals with less than convincing technology for offside by millimetres. We've seen thousands of them. Not the point of the offside rule at its origin. Separating soccer football from rugby football 130 years ago, one of the clear lines of demarcation was hacking and grabbing Now, two players struggling and jostling for position with a handful of shirt each. I understand that's a give and take call. But Timber, not making any other play of the ball, because he was beaten by position, reached out, pulled the shirt in clear view of everyone, and it stopped Isaac from having a play at the ball, which might have been an equaliser. And that really gets on my goat. Because to finish it off, if it was offside, they would have stopped the game for five minutes. They would have tried to find that millimetre that proves the goal should have been ruled out according to factual evidence. It's just garbage. And I want to know why that's acceptable. Why shirt pulling in that situation, when it's not two players yanking at each other's shirt, is acceptable. Have you got an answer for me?
00:42:34
Speaker 1: No, I don't because, again, we are talking about thresholds. What merits a foul? You've infringed. You've clearly committed the technical offence of a foul. But for whatever reason, neither referee or VAR think it is enough of a technical offence.
00:42:47
Speaker 3: To be a foul. Absolute rubbish.
00:42:49
Speaker 1: But you point out we will get extremely technical down to the millimetre when it comes to offside. With that said, Harps, and I can't add much more to it, let's cast our eyes.
00:43:01
Speaker 3: Excuse my language, by the way.
00:43:02
Speaker 1: No, hey, when you listen back to the pod, if there's beeps, you'll know you went over the line, and if there's not, play on. Let's go a little bit further down the table to fourth, because Chelsea bounce back from their very disappointing defeat to Spurs with a 2-0 win against Manchester United. Gee, it's sliding doors, because when Manchester United thought they'd taken the lead only for VAR to intervene, I actually sent to my group chat, Is it ridiculous to suggest Xabi Alonso could get sacked before Michael Carrick? Five minutes later, I then sent to the group chat, so much for that. Because Chelsea went and blitzed Manchester United. They could have had a third. That was disallowed as well. Manchester United, only by virtue of favourable results in other games, have avoided finishing the weekend in the relegation zone halves. And even though Michael Carrick earned another week, Manchester United have seven points from nine games and they are only out of the relegation zone on goal
difference. They are only two points off the foot of the Premier League table. I'm not going to say they're in any relegation danger because they will both sack managers and spend in the transfer market in the window to ensure that they avoid the drop. But just how much are they going to dice with the possibility of it before they take nuclear action?
00:44:16
Speaker 3: Well, they need to get relegated. Maybe that's the only dose of salts that is going to fix this place. It's incurable. So reading about this situation over the course of their, what's become an illustrious history to become one of the biggest sporting brands on the planet. They've actually only ever had two coaches who worked. Matt Busby, who was in the seat around the very thing that made Manchester United a big ticket item, which was the Munich air crash and that disaster. and the Busby babes that came out of it. Matt Busby into Sir Alex Ferguson are the only two coaches who've had any serious impact at Man United over all that time. And let's face it, there was a very sharp sword of Damocles hanging over even Sir Alex Ferguson before he'd won a thing in that famous FA Cup run where they ended up winning the Cup. He survived and then wrote his own story. Before and after Busby, before and after Ferguson, which is more relevant given the commercialisation of the league and the game and globalisation, Man United have had nothing but trouble. Ten Hag's been the best with a couple of cup wins. It's a disaster. And they're not evidently going to be able to organise their way out of it unless they stumble across next-gen Alex Ferguson. And they might have even got rid of next-gen Alex Ferguson already. Ten Hag could have been that person. Amiram could have been that person. Because... As we said, Ferguson was just on the precipice of getting Risold himself. So maybe they've already got rid of that person. Who's going to walk in there? Carrick is going to be around till probably the, um, the international window. Is he going to turn the ship by then? No, if not enough, because you look at that, the appalling appalling application from an incredibly highly paid international player, Lissandro Martinez in getting sent off and leaving his struggling team and captain. in the dock. This is after he broke cover and criticised the club's owners for their either erratic recruitment or just appalling recruitment. And here he is, the oracle, just leaving his coach and his team completely exposed against a Chelsea team which is beatable. They're formidable, as we've been saying since the start of the season. They're formidable. Their front four are formidable. You give them any space on the counter-attack, you're going to hemorrhage. Their defence is very leaky. Man Utd showed that. And then Lissandro Martinez decides on whatever he's on, 80, 90, 100,000 pounds a week. I mean, I don't know. I have no idea. I shouldn't have even said that. But it's just ridiculous that someone in his position should behave like that. It's just wrong. Man United need to get relegated, mate, because I can't see anything else other than fluke cleaning the place out.
00:47:08
Speaker 2: Harps, again, I can't add much other than.
00:47:13
Speaker 1: Google AI tells me that Lissandra Martinez is on 130,000 pounds per week.
00:47:19
Speaker 2: And that's what you get. Well over 200 grand Australian.
00:47:23
Speaker 1: We have gone in-depth on many of the game's issues and some of the big picture talking points of the Premier League.
00:47:29
Speaker 2: We'll leave it there for now, though. Keep the YouTube comments coming.
00:47:32
Speaker 1: Make sure you jump onto the TalkSport Australia YouTube channel if you are listening via the podcast. And that is available wherever you get your podcasts. We're on Instagram as well, TalkSportAustralia. Andy Harper, always a pleasure, and I look forward to chatting again soon.
00:47:44
Speaker 3: Always, mate. Good on you.
00:47:46
Speaker 1: And thank you to all of our listeners, all of our commenters, and all of our subscribers. On behalf of Andy Harper, I'm Teo Pellizzari. This has been TalkSport Australia's Football Focus.