رونوشت 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:06.000 --> 01:15.000
Here, kitten, kitten
Michelle: Do you wanna know what book I just finished?
Kimberly: What?
Michelle: It was called Kitten by Stacy Yu
Kimberly: Okay, I just finished that too.
Michelle: It was an interesting read to me because I've always considered myself a little bit neurodivergent, and in this book it really explored the nature of our connection with ourselves and our community and our responsibilities as adults. Uh, so I thought we could talk about that today
Kimberly: What I discovered first and foremost is that from now on, any time a book says title, a novel, we're in for an emotional ride. So I'm gonna, so I'm gonna be a little, just like go into it cautiously because I, I, this was, this was a difficult read for me.
And not, not hard to read, but the story itself was just painful.
Michelle: So I really wanna get into it, and I wanna say first of all, there will be spoilers. That's the whole purpose of this conversation, so go read the book, Kitten. It's a, it's a good book, well-written, I like the author quite a bit, and then come back and listen to the conversation. Because I think you and I had different, um, different reactions to this book.
00:01:15.000 --> 04:36.000
Un-dynamic duo
Michelle: So the, at the beginning of the book, I really felt like this poor woman, the main character named Katie, she was dating a guy named James who has a lot of money, and I felt like James and Katie were not a good match, and I didn't see why they were together. And then as the book developed and we got more into Katie's head and learned how she interacted with herself and her world, and how she saw herself as an adult being responsible for herself and being responsible for relationships with other people, it, it just, it gave, made me much more, much, much more sympathetic to who she is as a character
Kimberly: I find that in real life there are a lot of young couples that I know, 'cause my kids are about that age, um, and my kids aren't seeing anyone right now, so it's n- none of my kids. But I do see some of their friends, and they're so very clearly not matched. it's, it m- it, I think what happens is that people sometimes they just find other people who are willing to put up with whatever just because they feel like being with someone with whatever is the, is better than being alone. And if you are that kind of person and you find yourself with another person that's that kind of person, and then you find each other, then you just sort of cling to the, like, the hope and the security or the perceived security of the relationship more so than the actual person.
And this is exactly what I found in this story, because neither character was particularly easy to get to know
Michelle: Right. Right. I think they both had their own version of neurodivergence, and I think James's was much more difficult to see. But I, I think he, he was all about caring for other people and being sort of selfless in this way, and almost rooting for the other person to, the, the person in a relationship with him, to be needy.
He really loved Isabelle, and she was very needy, and Katie, his girlfriend, who was very needy. Even taking care of his, his cats, um, and I, I was gonna say his mother, but his mother took care of him that way, was very, very nurturing, very caring, very forgiving with him. And I think he just carried that to the, to his relationships.
Kimberly: And it's an interesting archetype because typically you would see that sort of character, uh, as, as the female character
Michelle: Oh, interesting. Yes. Yes. I, I noticed to myself several times when Katie would interact with James and James would react a certain way, I thought, "That's not how James would normally react," or, "That's not how a man would normally react." So it was definitely written by a woman, and I, I don't, I don't know that there are people who behave like James behaved throughout the book
No.
Kimberly: those people. It's just we don't... I think we overlook those people because they're
Michelle: Hmm
Kimberly: um, c- complacent and easy to manipulate that I think we just sort of overlook them as, as people in the world. They're like, they're like NPCs,
Michelle: non-playable characters
Kimberly: Non-playable characters. That, I mean, not that they are for real, but that's how I think sometimes we as a culture perceive those people. Because if people don't talk, you don't, you don't know what's going on in their head, then they're r- then they're really hard to, they're har- they're hard to get to know.
Michelle: So
Kimberly: th- that is just what I found with both of the characters
00:04:36.000 --> 06:40.000
Inside Katie’s beautiful neurodivergent mind
Michelle: It's interesting you say that, I think particularly about Katie, because the author of the book really took us into Katie's mind, and she was able to articulate a lot of things that I would assume people with neurodivergence in the real world probably are not able to articulate, even within their own head.
So I feel like we were getting sort of an inside view into something that even neurodivergent people don't know about themselves. It's sort of a discovery when we, we got the, the back, the backstage pass to Katie's neurodivergence.
Kimberly: That was, I think, the strength of the book was just how much insight we gained into such a neurodivergent brain. And the reason that I say she was hard to, to get to know, um, we got to know her really well because we got the thoughts. she would have these long strings of thoughts, and then what would come out of her mouth would be, "yeah, okay."
Michelle: Right. Right
Kimberly: and, and just... That's, that's part of what I find so painful about the book was there was just, there was so much going on in there, and none of it was coming out. And people like, people like her get blamed for things, um, they can't articulate their thought process. And when you actually go through the
Load full transcript
entire thought process with them like we got to do in this book, it all makes sense, and it doesn't make them terrible people, and it doesn't make them rude or selfish. Their thought process is just so vastly different that what comes out on the outside appears rude or selfish
Michelle: Right. I think there was a whole theme in there of Katie not wanting to talk with other people because she didn't, she didn't really understand that other people wanted to hear what she had to say. So when, when Isabel finally took her to coffee and really had a lot of sympathy or, or empathy with her because Isabel was struggling as well, I think Isabel got Katie to talk, and it was sort of a discovery on Katie's part.
"Oh, Kat- Isabel wants to hear what I have to say." And so she, against her normal judgment, said stuff to, to Isabel that she probably could have been saying to, to James and other people in her life
Kimberly: Yeah.
00:06:40.000 --> 09:49.000
Misreading friendship signals
Kimberly: And, and the way that she described Isabel throughout the story made Isabel seem as though she really didn't care that much about Katie other than that they were hanging out. Until at, like you said, at the end, we find out that no, she actually really did like Katie. She liked her. They were f- really good friends.
Isabel was actually hurt when she learned that Katie kind of thought that. And, um, so it's, it was interesting also to, to kind of get that perspective of a person through Katie's eyes, and then realize that that was just all filtered through her unique brain
Michelle: Like, she felt like that with everybody. She thought that Isabelle's mother didn't like her and she snapped back at Isabelle's mother.
That was a recurring theme throughout the book. She thought that, she constantly said that Lou didn't like her. She constantly said that Isabelle didn't like her. She thought that Isabelle's mother didn't like her, and that might have been true, and she snapped back at Isabelle's mother. But it's almost like all these people who Katie thought didn't like her, she didn't care if they liked her or not, or it didn't occur to her to care whether they liked her or not.
It was just that's the way it is
Kimberly: Yeah. Okay, I need to back up because I was saying Isabelle when I was talking about Lou
Michelle: Oh, okay. Okay
Kimberly: When she was... So when she was describing Lou throughout the whole story, I thought Lou really didn't like her that much, and they were, they were just, like, convenient because they were roommates. then, uh, in fact, we'd found out at the end that Lou actually really did like her, and that she was actually a little bit hurt that, Katie thought that about her, that she didn't... she, that she, that Katie wasn't important to her
Michelle: I think even the, the male roommate, I forgot what his name was
Kimberly: He had an accent in my story
Michelle: Yeah, he had an accent in my story too. So the, the male roommate even ended up liking Katie a lot, suggested that she end up being the third roommate, which would've been inconvenient for both, so it wasn't like he was looking to save money. He really liked her. And that was, I think that was, yeah
Kimberly: so that's interesting too because even knowing all of the thoughts that she had in, going on in her brain, lot of times I found that her conclusions to things were uncomfortable or distasteful. So I as a human being felt like it would be very hard to like her based on all of the things that we learned inside her head
Michelle: Right, but we also don't know her, right? And we, we, if we were in a relationship with a real person like Katie, we wouldn't know all the stuff going on in their head
Kimberly: Yeah, but you also wouldn't know them because they don't say anything.
Michelle: Right. Right, but some people like that
Kimberly: yeah, I, I prefer being around people who are a little bit easier to read.
Michelle: Ja
Kimberly: but that's just a personal preference. I'm not saying that she was inherently unlikable. I just found it myself having a difficult time rooting for her because her decisions were sometimes just so,
Michelle: Deadly?
Kimberly: Yeah. Okay.
00:09:49.000 --> 13:15.000
The cat controversy
Kimberly: Okay, let's talk about the cat. Let's talk about the cat. She did not kill that cat. She didn't
Michelle: Yes, but if she hadn't kidnapped the cat, the cat wouldn't have died
Kimberly: Well, she, first of- she didn't kidnap the cat. She coerced her partner into letting her keep the cat.
Michelle: He had, he had no choice. He had no choice. He had to get in the car and go back to the city
Kimberly: okay, let's say that that was the case. one of the things that we learned about the cat's death was that it was very likely the exact scenario that you and I were just talking about earlier before the podcast, where pets and people too to be alone when they pass, or they want to be in nature.
And so this cat was gonna find a way escape the house way or another. And if it wasn't that night, it would've been soon because that cat was ready to go. So she did not kill the cat. The only thing that she did was she turned the knob one way instead of the other way, and that is hardly blame.
You cannot blame a person for the death of a cat that's desperate to die
Michelle: We don't know that the cat was going to die anyway. We don't know that
Kimberly: do. Yeah, we do. He is old. She was old. It was old
Michelle: I don't think it was that old. But, but then, but then there was a repeating pattern of that cat using up its nine lives. It ate the, ate the baker, the, it ate the brownies or the cupcakes that Lou had made. It then ate the paints, and had to go to the hospital for $1,200. So it's, it's a repeated pattern of, of, uh, of Katie not being able to care for the cat.
And I think that was another of the themes, is that Katie wasn't able to care for herself. And I don't mean care for, like making sure you're
bathed and things like that. I mean care for, like love, and have an interest in making sure that things are going okay. That she wasn't able to do that for herself throughout most of the book.
She wasn't able to do that for Lou or James, honestly, and for the cat particularly. And I think the cat was mostly reflective of her and her inability to care for herself, to have a, have a, a sympathy for herself and to do things for herself that she needed to do, and it was represented in the cat. So I, I feel like this not being able to find a job or losing your apartment was sort of the reflected in the cats eating the paint or eating the, the cupcakes
Kimberly: Yeah. Making, making choices in the moment that seem like a good idea at the time that are actually really quite, quite devastating in the end.
Michelle: Right. Right.
Kimberly: Yeah.
Michelle: I f-
Kimberly: part of why I found it so hard to like her, because she just couldn't, she couldn't bring all that together. And, and I think you alluded to this, that as the book went on and we started to really get much more insight into how she got here and, and who she was, she did become a little bit easier to like by the end, particularly by the very, very end when she sort of had her own revelation, it was kind of a turning point for her. Then it felt like a lot of this pressure that I had been feeling like building up inside my head about this person was just like, "Okay. She might be okay. She hasn't ruined all her relationships. she, she hasn't ruined her... You know, she's not homeless yet." So like,
Michelle: Well, she was
Kimberly: Well, sh- no, she was, by the end she was r- paying rent
Michelle: Right, right, right, right. She didn't end up homeless. I, I feel like
Kimberly: Ja
00:13:15.000 --> 16:54.000
Not deciding is a decision
Michelle: I have a thing that I call the demons, right? 3:00 in the morning, 4:00 in the morning, pretty much every night for most of my adult life, and not right now, but most of my adult life I'd wake up with these, this pressure of things that are going wrong.
And I can count, if, if I were in Katie's position, I would count, I'm not talking to my mother who was a huge piece of my life. I'm not, I, I don't have a home to live in. I don't have any money. I don't have a job. I don't have the motivation to find a job. So all of those things are the exactly the kinds of things that I've, if that were me, I would wake up in the middle of the night with those things weighing on me, and I would spiral into what am I gonna do with my life?
And I don't think Katie had that approach. I think her approach was she's just gonna float through and not make any decisions. And then I think one of the turning points for her, and there were many turning points, one of the major turning points was she realized that not making decisions is 100% making a decision.
And I feel like that's a big thing that a lot of young adults don't get, that they're gonna float through and therefore they're subject to or victims of their lives or their circumstances when that's not true. When you don't make a decision, that's a decision. And I, I, I wish that everybody would understand that about their lives.
And when she realized that, she started getting motivation to find a job. She called her mom. She got back in, back together with Lou. She started hanging out with Isabelle. I mean, all these great things that she then had motivation to do because she realized it was her responsibility to do something or to do nothing.
If you're doing nothing, that's still your responsibility.
Kimberly: I think that that's a really, that's a really good insight. I think that that's a pretty typical, passageway for young people because when you're a child, your parents make all the decisions for you, and when you're adult, hopefully you get to a point where you make decisions for yourself. But there's gonna be that in-between time when you're wrestling with what decisions am I supposed to make for myself now?
Or, um... And in her case, she just decided to just not, not act, not, n- not beha- and let the people around her care for her, you know, do those things for her.
Michelle: Right
Kimberly: And for a while, those people were willing to do that. but I do think that when, when a person comes to that recognition of, "I am the only person that gets to make decisions that affect my life, that affect the rest of my life, and that it is my responsibility," I, I think that that is a huge awakening for people.
And I, I found when I discovered that, and I was not as young as Katie was, um, when I finally figured out that I could take responsibility for my choices and live whatever kind of life I choose to live for myself, it was incredibly liberating
Michelle: I think there's a, a deeper perception shift that takes place too, because you're talking about someone taking responsibility for those decisions. And oftentimes when people go from childhood to adulthood, they don't wanna take responsibility for those decisions. Adulthood is really scary, and really, really ridiculously complicated.
We overcomplicate everything. But being an adult is really complicated, and so a, a kid who's emerging into adulthood in their 20s, they might say, "No, I don't wanna take responsibility for that." And then they don't make decisions, which is a decision. And then when they realize that it's not I have to take responsibility for these decisions, it is I have the control, and I have the, the, the, the right and the privilege of making these decisions for myself, then it switches to something that's a little bit more positive.
And I think that, that helps people to recognize, yeah, if I, if I, if I decide something good for myself, that's gonna be good for myself, instead of just going with the flow and making a decision to not do responsibilities
00:16:54.000 --> 20:07.000
The victimhood vs accountability balancing act
Kimberly: Most of the most miserable people
that I know are victims of their circumstances in, like, everything.
Kimberly: Most of the most miserable people that I know are victims of their circumstances in, like, everything. Like, everything that happens, happens to them. they, and they sort of put out this air of, like, "I don't have any control over this, and life just keeps coming at me, and life keeps shitting on me." And, and t- truly, there are s- people who to have a lot more knocks.
Michelle: Yes
Kimberly: but the people that are the most miserable who have an average amount of knock ... you know, knock you downs, um, y- it's ... I don't think that they've ever gotten that, that awareness, and it, it's, it's frustrating. It's frustrating to be an adult with other adults and have them be s- so self-unaware
Michelle: It's not easy because I have at, at different times in my life thought the universe is shitting on me. Seriously. I, I have had, I, I, I've had such a big knock that I don't deserve another knock. And then I got that knock, right? So there have been times in my life where I say, "What?" You know, there are only so many things that I should be responsible for absorbing.
So I have felt that way, and it's, it's difficult to just say this is a normal thing to do when I need to make decisions about accepting this and moving forward. Not, not making myself a victim of my circumstances. It's hard
Kimberly: So here's the thing though, that the cir- circumstances you're discussing, you literally were the victim of. not talking about those. Like, you had no control over f- con- phys- like medical conditions or illnesses. That I'm not talking about that. You, 'cause you don't have any choice. I'm talking about, "Oh my God, this person cut me off on the street and it made me swerve and I almost crashed my car, and I'm a victim of the circumstance," instead of saying, my God, that was really close.
I'm really lucky that I, you know, can that, that I had the presence of mind to not swerve into the tree." You know, like, it's the sa- you know, those are the ones that I'm talking about, the, that everything that happens around those people is attacking them. And, and in that specific case of the, of the, of the car, the p- these people that I know that, that behave like this, like truly believe that the person in the other car did it on purpose to them, that they s- they, uh, intentionally attacked them by cutting them off, and it just never crosses their mind that, oops, people make mistakes sometimes. you know, and I think if you, if you, you lean into that for your whole entire life, I think you're gonna be miserable forever. I'm just ... I
Michelle: It's a really difficult line to draw between those things that truly do happen to somebody. So I had cancer, that wasn't my fault, right? And it took me a long time to realize it's not my fault. Not- nothing I could have done differently. I wasn't attracting that cancer. Things like that, I think we can put def- s- securely on the way of I was a victim of that circumstance.
But
00:20:07.000 --> 22:41.000
The middle ground of accountability
Michelle: then we get to this middle ground, which I think is a very complicated place, and, and I think this is where the adulting takes place. Let's say someone is claiming victimhood for being hit by a car.
And yes, if you're hit by a car, you're hit by a car, and the driver has a lot of responsibility. But asking that question of, what was my responsibility in that? And was I not paying attention? Was I on my phone? Was I feeling entitled to cross against the light because I'm a pedestrian and therefore don't have the, the, the, the car doesn't have the right to hit me, and the car didn't just, it didn't see you?
I think there is some responsibility in that to ask that question, what was the role that I played in that middle ground of victimhood?
Kimberly: think that's the, essentially what adulting is, is, is asking yourself that question. 'Cause when you're a child, somebody else takes care of you and makes all the decisions for you. And when you're adult, ideally you make all the decisions for yourself. But there's that in-between time you're growing up and you're kind of wrestling with which decisions are no longer, uh, f- no longer someone else's to make for me, and which ones, you know, which ones do I need to make for myself? And so I do think it's a really natural period of time, which, and this is the time that Katie was written into. But I think that at some point you do have to start asking that question for those things that lie in that middle ground. what, what was my role in it. And I would even argue that that would include scenarios like you got cancer and, and we differ on this I think a little bit. We've, we've talked about this before. I do think that you, that you still need to ask yourself, "What was my role in this?" So that you can conclude, I had no role in this. I... This was one of those scenarios where I was completely a victim of this. Because then we can stop blaming ourselves for the things that real- really are outside of our control. And we are a culture of blame. We like to put blame places and, um, some people, it, like, take all the blame onto themselves, and other people, like, never blame themselves. I think we find comfort in finding, in determining who's to blame than as if that's gonna make whatever the s- situation is any better. I do think that it gives us the illusion of control. If there's someone behind it, then it's not chaos.
And, and it's gonna always be gray. It's always gonna be like y- we may not figure out every single scenario, and we may not have... It, it, it, it's not that concrete. I do think that we have to ask the question
00:22:41.000 --> 25:48.000
Inviting victimhood
Michelle: I, I think you really hit it on the head right there. Asking the question moves us from victimhood into potential growth. So I, I have a friend who just constantly invites victimhood, constantly. So
when we were kids, in the teens or whatever, we're walking down a field together, a gigantic field, and this field had one big pho- well, like a light pole in the middle of it.
So we're walking down the field, and someone called him from behind, and he turned around, and he was talking with them as we continued to walk. And then the minute he turned around, bonk, into the pole. And I just, I'm like, "Yeah, that's your life, right? That's your life," and just inviting victimhood the entire time.
And I, I, I feel like there are people who invite the trauma, and I hate saying that because it makes me feel like, like I'm blaming them for it. But again, I think blame is not... It's not about the blame. It's about the accountability we can take by asking the question, "What was my role in this?" Right? Could I have been looking forward a little bit instead of looking backwards?
What- whatever it might be
Kimberly: I hesitate a little bit to s- to suggest that people who invite trauma always have a role because I, like, l- you know, in some cases they just don't. Um, but I do definitely think that there are, there are people where more shit happens to them than happens to typical people. And, uh, in those cases, I think then that the work that they have to do is just so much harder. Like, it's the same, it's the same type of work. But it's so much harder if you, if, if you are a person that has gotten shit on over and over and over and over again, it's ... I can only imagine it must be really, really hard to keep getting up again and again and again. There are people, though, who do that. There are people who have had the most horrific things happen to them, they turn out great, and they, they find a way to heal, and they become amazing, compassionate people in the world. I don't think I'd be one of those people. I think, I think a, a major trauma would probably fold me. but you can't then just say that it's only the external that we can, that we can turn to. Because some people have a lot hap- to, to them turn out fine, and s- other people who have nothing happen to them feel like they're victims of everything
Michelle: So this is what I was gonna get at. I think it's the mindset of it. And it's not that easy to, to create your mindset, but by asking or, or approaching the world, "I'm a victim, everything is happening to me," or, "These things are happening to me and to other people, how am I gonna react to it? How am I gonna position this in my story?"
And I, I feel like that's a, a big determinant of whether we are victims or whether we have control of our own lives. So by, by sw- switching something from this happens to me into some sort of accountability or responsibility or right or even a privilege to react to it in a certain way, I think that changes everything about how, whe- whether someone is a victim or whether they are an actor in their own life
00:25:48.000 --> 29:08.000
Neurodivergence and the limits of self-reflection
Kimberly: I think this is part of what made Katie's story for me so challenging, was because what we're discussing right now is accessible to people who are neurotypical or who are only a little bit on the spectrum of the neurodivergence. 'Cause I do wanna specify that what we're talking here is someone who is far down the spectrum of neurodivergence to the point when it be- becomes an impediment to functioning in society. Um, I don't think all neurodivergence needs to be fixed. I've l- I've come to r- recognize that some of the things that problematic for me because of my neurodivergences, now that I've figured it out for myself, I have workarounds. Like, instead of trying to fight my brain, I work with my brain. So I don't think all neurodivergence needs to be fixed. tragedy that I ha- read in Katie's story was that I don't think that her brain will ever quite come to the place where it can ask the question, you know, what, what's my role, or what's my responsibility, or what could I do differently, or what kinds of things do I need to do to take charge of my life, like finding a job and finding a place to live and getting people in your life. Some people just don't have that capacity, and for me that's the most heartbreaking thing. That was why it was so painful hear her story. Because I do have someone in my life who has a brain injury, and it's so frustrating to watch how mightily they struggle with things that just come naturally to most of the rest of us. And so to not only watch Katie struggle but then also have to follow the thought process from I'm struggling to all of this shit happened and I'm still struggling, was just, it was a painful journey for me
Michelle: I, where, where I think Kitten the novel diverges from reality, and of course it's a novel versus reality, a- and, and in a way that might be a little bit dangerous, is that Katie was on a journey and she actually came to some healing and some growth and some maturity despite her neurodivergence. And I'm not sure, A, that there are some pe- there- I, I'm sure that there are some people in the real world who have neurodivergences that will never heal.
Those are just neurological deficits that might not heal, so they might not be able to mature out of that neurodivergence or even learn how to adapt to it even though that's the biggest hope. Um, the other thing where I think it gets a little bit dangerous is that in this novel the author put on Katie the ability to come to some maturity and some conclusions and some growth like, "I need to care for myself because I tried to care for the cat and the cat died and I don't want to end up in a situation like that."
Or the ability to say, "I actually am likable and these people actually do like me." That seems like a growth that might not, might not be possible for some people in the real world. And to, to put that accountability and that responsibility on Katie might set the expectation that, that in the real world everybody has the ability, the
neurological ability to come to those kinds of conclusions as well or those kinds of growth, that kind of growth as well.
And I don't think that's always gonna be possible
00:29:08.000 --> 32:13.000
The people who caught Katie
Kimberly: That's really good insight. I- and you know, now that you're saying it, it's making me think that the only reason... So the author wrote into the story that she came to some internal shifts that helped her to get her life on track. a- and, and I, I think what you're suggesting is that that might not be accessible to everybody. But also, the author wrote in that the things that she did have were in large part due to the people that surrounded her, the other people in her life that helped her to find a living room to live in and, and offer opportunity to pay the rent and, and to do some of those things. And I think maybe that was an unintended gift of this, of this story, just how critical the other people in her life are, were and are going to be for the rest of her life for her to be able to succeed, 'cause not, not, not everybody has that
Michelle: Right. Even her university came to her aid, gave her the, a job after she graduated that was meant for students. James certainly took a lot of care of her, gave her a place to stay when she didn't have one. Lou helped her move into a, a house. Even the, the, uh, Italian roommate, even that person ended up liking her and helping her by giving her the suggestion of taking the living room as a permanent roommate.
So I th- I think what it comes down to is society helping people who need help
Kimberly: Yeah, I think one of the things that made this story, again, so painful was knowing that if she didn't have those people in her life to kinda support her and to offer up the things that she needed in those moments, she very easily could have been one of the people that we as a culture tend to look down on people who are in chronic poverty or people who have, you know, um, a- addiction issues or people who are houseless. And I think a lot of times we just tend to think that it's because they didn't do X, Y, and Z. aside from the systemic issues, which I don't wanna address today, also might be an element of that some of those people might just actually not have the capacity to make the decisions they need to make, and if they also don't have the people to help them make the decisions, then, then that's where they end up. And I think it's an invisible condition. The, the neurodivergence like Katie had in the story and like the, the, the, the person that I love who, who has brain injury, it y- y- y... They present as neurotypicals. They present as fully functioning m- members of society, and then you get under the, you know, look under the hood like we got to do in this story and, and realize that this person's gonna need a lot of support to, to get through.
And it's just heartbreaking to me of how many people probably didn't have that support and have fallen through the cracks,
and we just sorta look down on them rather than trying to figure out how do we support these people?
00:32:13.000 --> 34:20.000
Neurodivergence, addiction, and Houselessness
Michelle: So the person in your life who has a brain injury has people, and I know it's not enough, and a lot of that falls on you, and I, I hear you, and I, I feel the pain of having to read a book like this. Uh, and B, I spent s- a very brief period of time as an EMT in San Francisco, and most of the calls that we got were for people who were drug addicted or alcohol addicted, mostly drug addicted.
And in my 20s when I was an EMT, my conclusion was that San Francisco did not have a homeless problem. San Francisco had a drug problem. And now after growing, and I haven't even thought about this for decades, I believe maybe San Francisco didn't have a homeless problem and San Francisco didn't have a drug problem.
Maybe they had a neurodivergence problem, and that a lot of those neurodivergences led people to self-medicate and try to find their way through, and that led to a drug problem and led to a homeless problem. Maybe that's what it is. There's probably a, a greater connection between neurodivergence and drug addiction than perhaps we appreciate
Kimberly: say it, I also would tack on, like, mental health being one of the neurodivergences that we're discussing. Because mental health conditions like schizophrenia and some of those definitely would lead to similar consequences as, as the neurodivergence that Katie had. But yeah. But yeah, I mean,
Michelle: It's a medical problem
Kimberly: So e- even the character in, one of
Michelle: Ja
Kimberly: in the book, Isabelle, had, uh, they, they had suggested early in the story that she had gone into, um, a facility for mental health issues, and then they hinted at the very end that, you know, actually it might have been addiction issues, so maybe it was kinda all wrapped up into, i- into the same thing. When I was going through treatment for alcohol addiction, th- there was a huge, heavy component also put on mental health, because the two do tend to go hand-in-hand. and so yeah, I think your point is, is well spoken that the, the addiction isn't the core of the problem, it's the outcome of a different problem
00:34:20.000 --> 37:53.000
The ending we wanted vs. the one we got
Michelle: Okay, I wanna know who else was convinced that Isabelle and Katie should live together in New York?
Kimberly: yep.
Michelle: I think that'd be a great pair.
Kimberly: yeah, it
Michelle: Yeah. They never, they, they never ev- they, they kept flirting with that and like, okay, when are they gonna move in together? And nope. Nope. They never did. And maybe they, maybe they were making an allegory between James and Katie's relationship and Isabelle's and Katie's relationship, that, that if they had moved in together, it would be Isabelle constantly caring for Katie.
But I don't think that's what would've happened. I think katie could have met some of Isabelle's needs that other people couldn't meet
Kimberly: That would've been a really satisfying ending, but the ending that we got
Michelle: Yeah
Kimberly: was probably closer to truth, which was she always got just so close and then missed the mark, like over and over again. She got so close. Like,
Michelle: Oh. Oh.
Kimberly: she, like she was like this close to moving in with James and then, oh, missed the mark.
And then she w- oh, she was this close to getting that job, and then oh, just missed the mark. Like, that, that was, felt more real to me than what would've been a satisfying ending, which was she gets the job, she has the income, she gets to l- live with the person that can help take care of her. Like, that would've been satisfying, but, uh, the missed the mark part was really true to the character
Michelle: I don't know that it would've been as satisfying to have her just try for those things and then get them, right? I think the, the growth in the story that I saw, the redemp- the redemption arc that I saw was her, her in- internal growth, her recognizing that she needed to care for herself, her recognizing that other people needed her to care for them in a different way, or that other people
She, she, she needed to allow other people to care for her. And if she had just gotten these easy ... Not easy, they're certainly not easy. If she, he, she had gotten the job and the apartment and enough money to go pay for an apartment with Isabelle, she would've missed out on that growth of accepting help from other people and accepting other people caring for her, which she b- before didn't really seem to even care about or acknowledge was going on.
She didn't recognize that as people caring for her, and I feel like she would've missed out on that if she had had a tidy, practical ending of nice job, nice apartment
Kimberly: Yeah, and I wonder if she had, if by some chance she had landed the good job and got the good apartment, how long that would have lasted for her before it fall apart for her?
Michelle: Right. Right, that could be
Kimberly: that's like a, another whole, like a sequel to the story that was being told. But, uh, you know, when you, when, when you go through that brain journey with her, man, I just don't see, I don't, I don't see that tidy ending, ever happening, and if it happens, I don't see it lasting
Michelle: I know. I, I feel like the story was about her development despite, not despite, but in light of her neurodivergence. Not that she's gonna solve those neurodivergences, but that she, she found a way to adapt to it
Kimberly: Yeah. Yeah. She did. She
Michelle: Anyway
Kimberly: maybe that's, maybe that's what we have to have to hang onto is that sometimes maybe adapting to it is the best it's gonna get, and maybe that's enough. And, and like,
Michelle: Yeah, I think it is enough
Kimberly: is enough for now. Like, you don't have to solve five problems down the road.
You only just need to solve the next problem that's in front of you
Michelle: Right Right? And maybe that's all they have the capacity for, and that's okay