رونوشت 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:04.450 --> 00:00:08.029
Hey, everybody. Neil deGrasse Tyson here. I've got with me
2
00:00:08.369 --> 00:00:13.679
Brian Green, theoretical physicist, Columbia University. And the two of us,
3
00:00:14.179 --> 00:00:18.640
we're just going to riff on Oppenheimer, the man, and
4
00:00:18.679 --> 00:00:26.390
especially Oppenheimer, the movie. Just for your eavesdropping on our conversation. So, Brian,
5
00:00:26.989 --> 00:00:28.350
I trust you've seen the film?
6
00:00:28.910 --> 00:00:29.230
I have.
7
00:00:29.809 --> 00:00:30.160
You know, I.
8
00:00:30.679 --> 00:00:32.020
I Barbie-hymered, by the way.
9
00:00:32.600 --> 00:00:36.259
Oh, you did? I did not do that. Why not?
10
00:00:38.090 --> 00:00:39.829
Couldn't bear it, sorry, but I should see it.
11
00:00:40.850 --> 00:00:43.869
Yeah, that's seeing both movies on the same day, is
12
00:00:43.890 --> 00:00:44.490
to Barbie-hymer.
13
00:00:45.070 --> 00:00:49.450
Yeah, no, I guess that opportunity then has passed. And
14
00:00:49.509 --> 00:00:50.649
it is true, and I can, like.
15
00:00:50.710 --> 00:00:56.829
Go back. So, I met Christopher Nolan previously. We've had
16
00:00:56.850 --> 00:01:00.219
him as a guest on StarTalk after one of his
17
00:01:00.880 --> 00:01:04.500
sort of time-warping sort of movies that he had produced.
18
00:01:05.239 --> 00:01:10.780
And a very smart guy, very clever, with a lot
19
00:01:10.799 --> 00:01:13.439
of attention to detail. And my sense of the film
20
00:01:13.540 --> 00:01:18.680
was that it captured so much of what he cares about.
21
00:01:19.640 --> 00:01:23.530
He cares about science. He cares about culture. He cares
22
00:01:23.590 --> 00:01:29.189
about entertainment. He cares about all of this. And every
23
00:01:29.370 --> 00:01:34.870
little detail physics tidbitty fact that I knew from that era,
24
00:01:35.810 --> 00:01:39.810
he managed to capture, not with an entire off-ramp, just
25
00:01:39.829 --> 00:01:42.090
to put in a fact that you know should be there,
26
00:01:42.829 --> 00:01:46.400
he managed to fully stitch it and weave it so
27
00:01:46.439 --> 00:01:50.640
that I felt like I was sitting on Oppenheimer's shoulder
28
00:01:50.719 --> 00:01:52.379
watching all of this unfold before me.
29
00:01:53.760 --> 00:01:56.579
Yeah, no, I definitely had a similar feeling about it.
30
00:01:56.579 --> 00:01:58.000
I mean, there were certainly moments.
31
00:01:59.739 --> 00:02:02.840
When there were things on screen that I suspect most
32
00:02:02.900 --> 00:02:06.980
people wouldn't take much note of, such as the Einstein
33
00:02:07.000 --> 00:02:10.259
and Gödel who would famously go for walks together. I mean,
34
00:02:10.300 --> 00:02:12.419
there would be wonderful moments when I was just sitting
35
00:02:12.439 --> 00:02:16.639
there feeling like, you know, or Feynman playing the bongos.
36
00:02:16.819 --> 00:02:22.180
Yes, because Feynman is not ID'd in the movie. The
37
00:02:22.199 --> 00:02:25.120
person playing Feynman is credited at the end, but the
38
00:02:25.159 --> 00:02:28.539
word Feynman doesn't come out of anybody's mouth. And so
39
00:02:28.560 --> 00:02:30.379
you have to pay attention in that party scene. He's
40
00:02:30.419 --> 00:02:34.780
playing the bongos. And it was Feynman in the car.
41
00:02:35.699 --> 00:02:38.419
Because in one of his memoirs, watch, in one of
42
00:02:38.479 --> 00:02:42.379
his memoirs, he described the fact that he knew that
43
00:02:42.580 --> 00:02:47.219
ordinary glass is a very significant UV absorber. And so
44
00:02:47.259 --> 00:02:50.759
while they're slathering each other with what is zinc oxide
45
00:02:51.340 --> 00:02:53.949
for the explosion, he's in the car and he says, no,
46
00:02:53.960 --> 00:02:56.370
I don't need that. I've got the windshield. It's a
47
00:02:56.409 --> 00:02:58.889
heavy absorber of UV. And then they have a car.
48
00:02:59.270 --> 00:03:01.310
That was Feynman in the car. And then.
49
00:03:01.330 --> 00:03:01.770
I didn't know.
50
00:03:02.069 --> 00:03:04.689
Yeah, yeah. And then someone else says, well, but what
51
00:03:04.710 --> 00:03:09.969
will protect you from the windshield? Which I know. So
52
00:03:10.009 --> 00:03:14.250
that was a good rebuttal. So somebody had to know
53
00:03:15.240 --> 00:03:19.199
that little tidbit about Feynman and then put it in seamlessly.
54
00:03:20.520 --> 00:03:22.800
And that's not even someone who they make a big
55
00:03:22.819 --> 00:03:24.500
deal of for his presence.
56
00:03:25.389 --> 00:03:27.710
That's what was beautiful about it. It wasn't like hitting
57
00:03:27.729 --> 00:03:30.250
you over the head with it. Like, here's this obscure
58
00:03:30.330 --> 00:03:31.830
fact that only we, you know.
59
00:03:31.849 --> 00:03:36.620
Yeah, let's just meet in on the bongos, right? No, no. Yeah, exactly. Yeah.
60
00:03:36.960 --> 00:03:39.699
You know, the only moment that gave me pause, and
61
00:03:39.740 --> 00:03:41.719
I don't know if you had the similar feeling or not.
62
00:03:41.740 --> 00:03:44.740
I mean, you and I both spent time giving people
63
00:03:44.759 --> 00:03:47.199
a sense of the wonder of the cosmos and things
64
00:03:47.219 --> 00:03:50.539
like that. But the first handful of minutes of the film,
65
00:03:50.990 --> 00:03:53.069
which kind of tried to go into the mind of
66
00:03:53.210 --> 00:03:59.340
a physicist, swirling galaxies and these equations and what it
67
00:03:59.400 --> 00:04:01.919
just sort of felt like that felt a little much
68
00:04:02.360 --> 00:04:04.379
to me. I don't know if it hit you that
69
00:04:04.419 --> 00:04:04.919
way at all.
70
00:04:04.979 --> 00:04:13.159
Yeah. So I think without that Oppenheimer is really just
71
00:04:13.240 --> 00:04:21.180
a manager. We don't see him manifest much physics knowledge throughout.
72
00:04:21.220 --> 00:04:26.959
He's managing everything. the expertise of others. So that basically
73
00:04:27.019 --> 00:04:32.279
Load full transcript
established his street cred, especially since his most cited paper
74
00:04:32.399 --> 00:04:36.639
is not about normal physics. It's about the universe and
75
00:04:36.699 --> 00:04:39.850
black holes, right? Which really didn't have much to do
76
00:04:39.879 --> 00:04:42.350
with this film. Sorry, it didn't have much to do
77
00:04:42.389 --> 00:04:47.870
with his leadership in this role. So I thought that
78
00:04:47.889 --> 00:04:51.850
was okay. Otherwise, you won't get to do that And
79
00:04:52.189 --> 00:04:53.670
elsewhere where, yeah. Yeah.
80
00:04:53.730 --> 00:04:56.629
I mean, ultimately it all worked, but for the first
81
00:04:56.670 --> 00:05:02.029
few minutes, I was wondering where this was going. But yeah, I, I, I,
82
00:05:02.209 --> 00:05:08.550
I love the way that the historical facts were blended with,
83
00:05:08.569 --> 00:05:13.470
I guess, things that were well motivated, but you know,
84
00:05:13.649 --> 00:05:19.000
Oppenheimer's own personal perspective on what was happening. Versus the
85
00:05:19.100 --> 00:05:20.399
things that are in the public record.
86
00:05:20.459 --> 00:05:23.509
Yeah, in fact, it was definitely his POV, no doubt
87
00:05:23.550 --> 00:05:27.490
about it. So what I liked about it was all
88
00:05:27.529 --> 00:05:32.389
of the angst people had about the bomb in a
89
00:05:32.430 --> 00:05:36.500
military setting against the Germans, but then against the Japanese
90
00:05:37.240 --> 00:05:44.379
and the Jewish science in Germany. They tossed bones to
91
00:05:44.480 --> 00:05:48.850
each of these without actually taking off ramps. Because the
92
00:05:48.990 --> 00:05:51.829
off-ramp would be, well, we're a historical documentary. We have
93
00:05:51.850 --> 00:05:54.470
to fully cover it. No, you don't. It's just his
94
00:05:54.550 --> 00:05:57.129
point of view. But they got it all in there.
95
00:05:57.189 --> 00:06:02.279
For example, they talked about, well, how special is this bomb?
96
00:06:02.339 --> 00:06:07.560
We just firebombed Tokyo and killed 100,000 people with conventional
97
00:06:07.660 --> 00:06:11.800
incendiary bombs. And your estimates are not even that high.
98
00:06:12.560 --> 00:06:15.610
So how could you carry some guilt with this when
99
00:06:15.620 --> 00:06:24.310
we've already... committed that level of violence against noncombatant civilians.
100
00:06:24.870 --> 00:06:28.389
So that came up. And then there was the, well,
101
00:06:28.490 --> 00:06:30.870
what is this with Germany, Hitler, and the Jews? How
102
00:06:30.930 --> 00:06:33.370
is that going to play out? And my favorite line there,
103
00:06:33.410 --> 00:06:37.870
which I think encapsulates a lot of historical dimension, where
104
00:06:37.889 --> 00:06:42.139
they say, Heisenberg might know this, Because will we get it?
105
00:06:42.339 --> 00:06:45.220
Heisenberg is brilliant. Will we get it before Heisenberg? No,
106
00:06:45.680 --> 00:06:49.689
because he's Jewish and Hitler doesn't give Jews access to
107
00:06:49.699 --> 00:06:53.430
the labs. It relegates them to pencil and pads. And
108
00:06:53.569 --> 00:06:59.209
so this was so that was a fascinating indictment of
109
00:06:59.769 --> 00:07:07.089
Nazi racism, basically, and how that very fact probably contributed
110
00:07:07.170 --> 00:07:10.660
to their however slow they were on the development of
111
00:07:10.689 --> 00:07:11.009
the bomb.
112
00:07:11.709 --> 00:07:14.610
On Monday, April 8th, the great North American eclipse will
113
00:07:14.629 --> 00:07:17.730
pass over the United States with only 0.5% of the
114
00:07:17.790 --> 00:07:21.750
world's population falling within its path of totality. Yeah, that's
115
00:07:21.910 --> 00:07:25.079
just 0.5% of the world that'll be able to witness
116
00:07:25.100 --> 00:07:27.740
this reverential experience in its entirety.
117
00:07:27.959 --> 00:07:28.620
And guess what?
118
00:07:29.040 --> 00:07:32.600
Our friends in Little Rock, Arkansas are smack dab in
119
00:07:32.620 --> 00:07:34.500
the middle of it. If you're looking for one of
120
00:07:34.519 --> 00:07:37.139
the best places to view this year's eclipse, look no
121
00:07:37.240 --> 00:07:40.470
further than Little Rock. They still have hotels available to
122
00:07:40.509 --> 00:07:44.189
fit every budget. Witness complete and total darkness on April
123
00:07:44.410 --> 00:07:47.370
8th and take part in Little Rock's special events and
124
00:07:47.430 --> 00:07:51.329
celebrations leading up to the big day, starting on April 6th.
125
00:07:51.629 --> 00:07:56.350
From outdoor adventures like hiking, biking, and paddling, to educational
126
00:07:56.589 --> 00:08:01.649
activities like visiting the Clinton Presidential Library or the Museum
127
00:08:01.689 --> 00:08:05.829
of Discovery. Little Rock's got a little something for everyone.
128
00:08:06.209 --> 00:08:09.699
To book your visit and witness this monumental event in person,
129
00:08:09.980 --> 00:08:17.740
head over to littlerock.com slash eclipse. That's littlerock.com slash eclipse.
130
00:08:18.220 --> 00:08:20.680
Paid for with a combination of state funds and private
131
00:08:20.759 --> 00:08:22.680
Heart of Arkansas Association funds.
132
00:08:24.240 --> 00:08:27.279
Now, the other thing, though, I wonder your thought on this.
133
00:08:28.139 --> 00:08:32.620
I was very impressed with how the carnage was treated.
134
00:08:33.240 --> 00:08:35.070
You know, I thought it was a very dramatic moment.
135
00:08:35.210 --> 00:08:38.409
No spoiler here. You know, when the sound went off
136
00:08:38.529 --> 00:08:41.850
and you had this moment before the actual explosion. And
137
00:08:41.870 --> 00:08:45.309
then you don't really see the carnage in any gory,
138
00:08:45.370 --> 00:08:48.549
explicit way. But then I began to think about that.
139
00:08:48.769 --> 00:08:50.950
And I watched The Day After Trinity. I think that's
140
00:08:50.970 --> 00:08:53.470
the name of the documentary.
And I began to think,
141
00:08:53.490 --> 00:08:56.409
you know, for so many young people, this may be
142
00:08:56.429 --> 00:09:01.820
their only direct connection to the events that happened at
143
00:09:01.899 --> 00:09:05.980
the end of World War II. Maybe there needed to
144
00:09:06.080 --> 00:09:09.639
be more of the shocking visuals in order that the
145
00:09:09.679 --> 00:09:12.490
generation really, really understood.
146
00:09:12.529 --> 00:09:15.190
Well, they described them. They did describe them. They said
147
00:09:15.210 --> 00:09:18.590
a person with a striped shirt, where the dark stripes were,
148
00:09:18.830 --> 00:09:21.149
it burned their skin, and where the light stripes were,
149
00:09:21.250 --> 00:09:24.289
it didn't. There were other people where their shadows were
150
00:09:24.350 --> 00:09:28.990
burned into the... The exterior of their shadow was burned
151
00:09:29.009 --> 00:09:29.629
into the pavement.
152
00:09:29.909 --> 00:09:33.429
I wonder if that's enough, though. You know, especially, you know,
153
00:09:33.450 --> 00:09:34.429
if it's the only.
154
00:09:34.490 --> 00:09:36.049
Oh, the only... Yeah.
155
00:09:37.029 --> 00:09:37.509
Okay. Yeah.
156
00:09:38.750 --> 00:09:41.509
Yeah, so, because war.
157
00:09:43.210 --> 00:09:45.950
Sometimes you have to see it up close to know
158
00:09:45.990 --> 00:09:46.970
that you should never do it.
159
00:09:47.429 --> 00:09:51.070
And this is a certain kind of... of violence to
160
00:09:51.159 --> 00:09:55.330
humanity that is of a scale and of a sort
161
00:09:55.409 --> 00:10:02.539
that is so spectacularly agonizing and awful and to not
162
00:10:02.620 --> 00:10:07.480
fully feel that even momentarily may be a bit of
163
00:10:07.519 --> 00:10:07.840
a loss.
164
00:10:07.899 --> 00:10:10.799
What about the scene where he, we're inside his head
165
00:10:12.259 --> 00:10:17.190
and he's about to talk about the success of the
166
00:10:17.250 --> 00:10:24.450
bomb to the assembled people, and he sees flashes and
167
00:10:24.529 --> 00:10:28.590
people's skin burning off. Yeah, that's in his head. It's
168
00:10:28.629 --> 00:10:33.090
not the documentary of what happened in Nagasaki and Hiroshima, but.
169
00:10:33.409 --> 00:10:38.240
And it's also very relatively brief. It was brief, yes. So, yes.
170
00:10:38.360 --> 00:10:41.379
I mean, it's a difficult decision to make, because as
171
00:10:41.440 --> 00:10:42.500
a film, I thought.
172
00:10:42.320 --> 00:10:46.419
It worked spectacularly as a work of art about this
173
00:10:46.879 --> 00:10:53.419
incredibly destructive moment, and this incredibly destructive period, but as a, again,
174
00:10:53.460 --> 00:10:56.299
it's not a documentary, but it made me treat.
175
00:10:56.039 --> 00:10:58.700
It as a documentary. Yeah, as is, yeah, our movies
176
00:10:58.820 --> 00:11:02.070
are our sources of historical knowledge, for sure.
177
00:11:02.090 --> 00:11:02.610
Yeah.
178
00:11:03.659 --> 00:11:06.590
A few other things that I noticed that he did was,
179
00:11:07.730 --> 00:11:10.309
we used to say Hiroshima, and then later people started
180
00:11:10.350 --> 00:11:16.090
saying Hiroshima. In the movie, it's said both ways. In
181
00:11:16.149 --> 00:11:19.840
two different cases. It has to be on purpose. So
182
00:11:19.879 --> 00:11:25.679
he's got both bases covered. He's got both covered. Also, generally,
183
00:11:25.759 --> 00:11:28.419
when I see a movie a second time, I hear
184
00:11:28.470 --> 00:11:30.909
the soundtrack more because I'm not distracted by having to
185
00:11:30.929 --> 00:11:34.070
pay attention to the plot. In Oppenheimer, I already knew
186
00:11:34.129 --> 00:11:37.470
what was happening. So I was able to hear the soundtrack.
187
00:11:38.110 --> 00:11:41.990
And the moments leading up to the bomb test with
188
00:11:42.009 --> 00:11:48.240
the button, there is cacophonous orchestral music. And the editing
189
00:11:48.299 --> 00:11:52.250
pace is fast and the music is getting louder and
190
00:11:52.279 --> 00:11:56.750
louder and more cacophonous. And you're not going to know
191
00:11:56.809 --> 00:12:01.110
that because you're anticipating what's about to happen. And if
192
00:12:01.129 --> 00:12:03.929
you're not aware of the music, which good music in
193
00:12:03.970 --> 00:12:06.730
a movie, you're not aware of it. It's just managing
194
00:12:06.769 --> 00:12:09.929
your emotions. When they hit the button and you see
195
00:12:09.950 --> 00:12:15.779
the explosion, it is the silence is deafening because they
196
00:12:15.940 --> 00:12:19.250
take away the music. And, of course, there's the sound
197
00:12:19.289 --> 00:12:23.389
delay from the explosion to where they are. So he
198
00:12:23.529 --> 00:12:25.970
doubles up on this on the silence, right?
199
00:12:26.200 --> 00:12:28.419
Yeah, that was beautiful. That was really beautiful.
200
00:12:28.659 --> 00:12:32.899
And so they were, what, one, two miles away? Sound
201
00:12:32.919 --> 00:12:36.519
will go a mile every six seconds. So the blast
202
00:12:36.590 --> 00:12:39.190
wave moving at the speed of sound, I think that
203
00:12:39.230 --> 00:12:40.450
calculation looked right to me.
204
00:12:40.809 --> 00:12:43.899
Yeah, right. sort of eight, 10 seconds or whatever it was.
205
00:12:43.960 --> 00:12:46.159
Yeah. Yeah. Well, there were a few miles. Yeah, that's right.
206
00:12:46.340 --> 00:12:48.840
But between one and two miles away would, would do that.
207
00:12:49.919 --> 00:12:54.220
And I, they trusted their calculations. Why did they give
208
00:12:54.360 --> 00:12:57.779
so much weight to the risk of igniting the atmosphere?
209
00:12:58.200 --> 00:13:00.970
Seems to me that probability would have been so low
210
00:13:02.539 --> 00:13:06.090
to be astronomically low, but it makes a really good headline.
211
00:13:06.190 --> 00:13:07.809
Oh my gosh, we could have ended the world.
212
00:13:08.639 --> 00:13:12.559
And
it's astronomically low probability for ending the world. It
213
00:13:12.659 --> 00:13:15.220
does demand a certain degree of attention.
214
00:13:16.000 --> 00:13:16.440
Okay.
215
00:13:16.679 --> 00:13:16.879
Yeah.
216
00:13:17.080 --> 00:13:18.000
Well, I didn't mean to.
217
00:13:18.379 --> 00:13:19.299
Thank you.
218
00:13:19.639 --> 00:13:20.750
I agree.
219
00:13:21.830 --> 00:13:26.230
You know, it was a real worry, and people had
220
00:13:26.269 --> 00:13:28.389
to sit down and do the calculation. Look, we had
221
00:13:28.429 --> 00:13:31.049
the same thing with the Large Hadron Collider. People worry
222
00:13:31.090 --> 00:13:33.970
that you turn on the accelerator, create a little black
223
00:13:33.990 --> 00:13:37.029
hole that would swallow up Switzerland and then the rest
224
00:13:37.049 --> 00:13:37.429
of Europe.
225
00:13:37.750 --> 00:13:42.889
Did you see that video of a security camera in
226
00:13:42.909 --> 00:13:45.629
the parking lot of the Large Hadron Collider? And there's
227
00:13:45.649 --> 00:13:49.389
a countdown clock that went to zero. And then Elisange
228
00:13:49.429 --> 00:13:56.649
have cut off. It was sad and hilarious at the
229
00:13:56.669 --> 00:13:57.190
same time.
230
00:13:58.210 --> 00:14:01.860
But the serious point is, it's a real concern. And
231
00:14:01.889 --> 00:14:04.639
you've got to sit down and do the calculation. And
232
00:14:04.919 --> 00:14:08.620
colleagues of mine... did the calculation and showed that it
233
00:14:08.720 --> 00:14:12.539
wasn't something that we should worry about. Highly unlikely, yes.
234
00:14:12.840 --> 00:14:16.330
Spectacularly unlikely that you could put it to the side,
235
00:14:16.419 --> 00:14:19.610
but this is what we should always do, you know, because,
236
00:14:19.769 --> 00:14:22.350
you know, ending the world is kind of a big deal.
237
00:14:22.450 --> 00:14:24.730
But what reaction, I mean, when I think of the,
238
00:14:25.570 --> 00:14:30.840
you're splitting uranium-235, it sends out two neutrons, hits other
239
00:14:30.929 --> 00:14:35.649
nearby uranium atoms. What reaction? Why would that ignite the atmosphere?
240
00:14:36.129 --> 00:14:42.500
What would happen? What nuclear process in the oxygen-nitrogen atmosphere
241
00:14:42.559 --> 00:14:43.679
were they thinking would happen?
242
00:14:44.399 --> 00:14:46.379
Yeah, it's a good question. I don't know the details
243
00:14:46.700 --> 00:14:50.360
of the mechanism that was most concerning to the scientists
244
00:14:50.399 --> 00:14:55.029
of the time, but you were creating temperatures and densities
245
00:14:55.110 --> 00:14:59.190
of energy that we had never created before on Earth.
246
00:14:59.769 --> 00:15:02.620
And so you've got to ask yourself, Is there any
247
00:15:02.740 --> 00:15:07.200
collateral process that this may spark? And the answer is,
248
00:15:07.220 --> 00:15:11.120
in principle, yes. In practice, no. And that's what you
249
00:15:11.159 --> 00:15:13.350
need to do to ensure that these things are safe.
250
00:15:13.809 --> 00:15:17.750
You do know that some of the primary work on
251
00:15:17.769 --> 00:15:20.649
the process that you just described, where you two, three,
252
00:15:20.690 --> 00:15:24.330
five splits and neutrons are sent out, happened in the
253
00:15:24.370 --> 00:15:29.039
building where I'm sitting right now. At a QP at
254
00:15:29.080 --> 00:15:33.059
Columbia University had, Leo Szilard, who is one of the
255
00:15:33.120 --> 00:15:36.799
first people, in fact, the story goes, I believe, that
256
00:15:36.820 --> 00:15:40.919
he was crossing the street in 1933 in London, just
257
00:15:41.100 --> 00:15:44.480
after the discovery of the neutron by James Chadwick in 1932.
258
00:15:44.480 --> 00:15:46.250
And then it hit him. And it hit him.
259
00:15:46.279 --> 00:15:48.539
In fact, in Cosmos, we went to that very same
260
00:15:48.570 --> 00:15:49.039
street corner.
261
00:15:49.350 --> 00:15:49.759
Oh, you did?
262
00:15:49.779 --> 00:15:51.690
Yes, we did. And I walked up to the street
263
00:15:51.730 --> 00:15:57.870
corner and I had no such epiphany. First of all,
264
00:15:58.090 --> 00:16:01.470
I'm anachronistically in time and place. But we did go
265
00:16:01.490 --> 00:16:02.720
to that moment, right? Exactly.
266
00:16:02.909 --> 00:16:05.460
But then he came, Szilard came to Columbia. He was
267
00:16:05.519 --> 00:16:08.379
working here in this building. Fermi was in this building.
268
00:16:08.399 --> 00:16:13.100
They were on different floors, each trying to determine whether
269
00:16:13.639 --> 00:16:18.070
you would generate multiple neutrons from these dissociations, because if
270
00:16:18.690 --> 00:16:21.629
you could get multiple neutrons, they then could have the
271
00:16:21.649 --> 00:16:22.610
cascading effect.
272
00:16:22.730 --> 00:16:26.620
Yeah, the chain reaction. That's what chain reaction, gain currency
273
00:16:26.629 --> 00:16:29.389
is a term back then. Are you in Pupin Hall?
274
00:16:29.549 --> 00:16:30.240
Are you in Pupin Hall?
275
00:16:30.289 --> 00:16:31.559
I'm in Pupin Hall right now, yeah.
276
00:16:31.840 --> 00:16:34.100
In Pupin Hall. That's where I got my PhD from,
277
00:16:34.320 --> 00:16:37.919
on the top floors. There was Whitney Straubers on the
278
00:16:37.940 --> 00:16:39.179
top floors, by the way.
279
00:16:39.240 --> 00:16:44.100
Yeah. But then that Szilard and Wigner, when they realized
280
00:16:44.120 --> 00:16:46.860
this was a real possibility, they get in a car
281
00:16:46.879 --> 00:16:50.139
and they drive to Long Island, I think this is 1939,
282
00:16:50.139 --> 00:16:52.960
to convince Einstein to write the letter that they talk
283
00:16:52.980 --> 00:16:56.659
about in Oppenheimer. Yes. When Einstein writes to Roosevelt saying, hey,
284
00:16:56.919 --> 00:16:59.110
we got to get a move on. there's a real
285
00:16:59.350 --> 00:17:00.389
potential for a weapon.
286
00:17:00.409 --> 00:17:03.730
Because it's impossible at all. Yeah. I also heard that
287
00:17:05.789 --> 00:17:09.009
Oppenheimer did not have a one-on-one meeting with Einstein, but
288
00:17:09.049 --> 00:17:12.059
they had corresponded. And so what they did was use,
289
00:17:12.410 --> 00:17:15.759
because we knew Einstein is always wandering and alone or
290
00:17:15.880 --> 00:17:20.759
in conversation one-on-one, they created a conversation that would have
291
00:17:20.980 --> 00:17:25.380
been plausible expression of what their correspondence was. So I
292
00:17:25.400 --> 00:17:27.549
didn't have a problem with it. That I don't know of.
293
00:17:27.609 --> 00:17:30.009
I'd heard, I'd heard that. So, but I was okay
294
00:17:30.029 --> 00:17:33.109
with that just because why not? You get three for
295
00:17:33.210 --> 00:17:36.269
one there. You get, you get Oppenheimer in conversation with,
296
00:17:36.789 --> 00:17:40.359
with Albert Einstein and the Institute for Advanced Study.
297
00:17:41.119 --> 00:17:45.900
Yeah. The ingredients are all right.
298
00:17:46.339 --> 00:17:49.960
One thing I tweeted this, again, I'll give, I'll give
299
00:17:50.000 --> 00:17:54.380
him a hall pass, Christopher Nolan. So July 16th is
300
00:17:54.420 --> 00:18:00.720
the test. That's summertime, and at the latitude on Earth
301
00:18:00.789 --> 00:18:04.589
where this occurred, at 5.30 in the morning, we are
302
00:18:04.809 --> 00:18:06.769
well into morning twilight.
303
00:18:07.750 --> 00:18:08.190
Right.
304
00:18:08.210 --> 00:18:10.069
It was dark. It would not have been pitch dark.
305
00:18:10.490 --> 00:18:14.049
But if you wanted a spectacular explosion against a dark sky,
306
00:18:14.509 --> 00:18:15.690
I'd give them the dark sky.
307
00:18:16.609 --> 00:18:19.589
I've been there. I've been to where you probably have, too,
308
00:18:19.670 --> 00:18:20.859
where they did the test.
309
00:18:20.880 --> 00:18:21.099
Yes.
310
00:18:21.319 --> 00:18:23.740
Yeah, because in a NOVA program, they had me take
311
00:18:23.859 --> 00:18:27.220
a Geiger counter. And actually, you know, and yeah, you
312
00:18:27.240 --> 00:18:29.099
get some click, click, click. I mean, there's still some
313
00:18:29.140 --> 00:18:30.079
residual impact.
314
00:18:30.440 --> 00:18:34.339
Wait a minute. Wait, wait. So now you have the
315
00:18:34.539 --> 00:18:39.400
evidence of your current sterility. You haven't had a kid
316
00:18:39.420 --> 00:18:46.880
in a few years. So I thought it was two movies.
317
00:18:46.920 --> 00:18:49.269
There was The Making of the Bomb and then The Trial.
318
00:18:50.440 --> 00:18:54.410
And it's quite a challenge to keep that going, you know,
319
00:18:55.109 --> 00:18:59.170
after you have the largest explosion Earth had ever seen.
320
00:19:00.630 --> 00:19:04.230
I think the wisdom that Einstein, it was revealed that
321
00:19:04.269 --> 00:19:07.549
he shared with him at the end, was in the end,
322
00:19:08.450 --> 00:19:10.170
whatever they're doing to you now, in the end, they're
323
00:19:10.190 --> 00:19:14.769
going to have to thank you. And basically, that's where
324
00:19:14.789 --> 00:19:15.450
the movie went.
325
00:19:16.230 --> 00:19:18.150
But it's an interesting question. I mean, I don't really
326
00:19:18.170 --> 00:19:20.789
face it directly in my own work, but my kids
327
00:19:20.910 --> 00:19:24.400
asked me, would you have gone and worked on the
328
00:19:24.420 --> 00:19:28.759
Manhattan Project, if you were around at the time? And,
329
00:19:28.839 --> 00:19:31.259
you know, it's a tough question, but I suspect I
330
00:19:31.279 --> 00:19:34.829
would have gotten caught up in the same kind of fervor,
331
00:19:34.960 --> 00:19:39.210
because when you see what was happening at Los Alamos,
332
00:19:39.250 --> 00:19:40.970
and the movie does a really good job of this,
333
00:19:41.470 --> 00:19:44.529
you realize that these scientists are getting, they're caught up
334
00:19:45.190 --> 00:19:48.789
in this ocean of excitement to do something that no
335
00:19:48.809 --> 00:19:49.569
one has ever done before.
336
00:19:49.579 --> 00:19:50.799
New science. New science.
337
00:19:50.890 --> 00:19:51.920
Yeah.
338
00:19:52.039 --> 00:19:53.819
Government money to back it. Right.
339
00:19:54.079 --> 00:19:56.099
Yeah. And there's a, I don't know if you've seen this,
340
00:19:56.140 --> 00:19:58.599
but Freeman Dyson, there's a quote of his, it's in
341
00:19:58.640 --> 00:20:02.240
this documentary, Day After Trinity. He says something like the
342
00:20:02.279 --> 00:20:06.059
feeling of power. So that sense of you are grabbing
343
00:20:06.140 --> 00:20:09.829
hold of the universe and you now are using its
344
00:20:10.119 --> 00:20:14.450
most powerful forces to shape reality, it's hard not to
345
00:20:14.509 --> 00:20:15.789
get caught up in that.
346
00:20:16.190 --> 00:20:16.390
Right.
347
00:20:16.589 --> 00:20:17.809
Would you have gone?
348
00:20:17.910 --> 00:20:22.289
So it's, you know, hindsight is very hard. You have
349
00:20:22.309 --> 00:20:25.109
much more confidence in hindsight than at the time. So
350
00:20:25.309 --> 00:20:29.369
I'm a little conflicted for the following reason. My father
351
00:20:29.549 --> 00:20:35.430
was in the service, okay, at the time, and the
352
00:20:35.529 --> 00:20:39.279
army was segregated. It was a segregated army. It wasn't
353
00:20:39.339 --> 00:20:46.339
become desegregated until later. And so who, who am I
354
00:20:46.400 --> 00:20:47.259
really defending?
355
00:20:47.559 --> 00:20:47.799
Right.
356
00:20:47.859 --> 00:20:49.759
What is, who's my enemy?
357
00:20:50.599 --> 00:20:50.839
Yeah.
358
00:20:51.240 --> 00:20:53.819
You know, this is, this was a very real thing
359
00:20:54.380 --> 00:20:57.440
mixed with the lynchings in the South and the, and
360
00:20:57.869 --> 00:21:03.539
so maybe I would have joined out of, cause I,
361
00:21:03.849 --> 00:21:06.130
I don't want, I didn't want Hitler to
take over.
362
00:21:06.430 --> 00:21:08.630
because no matter what's going on here, we all agree
363
00:21:08.650 --> 00:21:12.960
Hitler was bad. But once we learned that Hitler was
364
00:21:13.019 --> 00:21:16.079
about to be defeated, to turn it on Japan, I
365
00:21:17.000 --> 00:21:21.339
don't know if I had an exit point, it would
366
00:21:21.359 --> 00:21:21.799
have been there.
367
00:21:22.589 --> 00:21:25.869
Yeah, yeah, totally. Because, you know, Leo Szilard, one of
368
00:21:25.910 --> 00:21:29.410
the things that he was advocating, and, you know, it's
369
00:21:29.869 --> 00:21:32.690
sort of a travesty that we didn't do it, explode
370
00:21:32.750 --> 00:21:37.690
the first bomb... in an uninhabited place, demonstrate the power
371
00:21:37.930 --> 00:21:41.609
of this atomic weapon. And that should be enough to
372
00:21:41.670 --> 00:21:45.500
cause any enemy combatant to say, okay, we give up.
373
00:21:45.769 --> 00:21:48.710
Don't drop that thing on us. And yet that's not
374
00:21:48.750 --> 00:21:49.849
what we did. Right.
375
00:21:49.890 --> 00:21:52.190
Well, plus we only had two of them, right?
376
00:21:52.369 --> 00:21:52.589
Yeah.
377
00:21:52.630 --> 00:21:57.200
I mean, to get uranium-235, that's not the natural state
378
00:21:57.240 --> 00:21:59.980
of uranium in the ground, right? I mean, so you
379
00:22:00.000 --> 00:22:03.079
have to centrifuge it. And I keep thinking in a centrifuge,
380
00:22:03.839 --> 00:22:06.259
Do they just liquefy the uranium? They have to have some.
381
00:22:06.619 --> 00:22:07.579
Other details, yeah.
382
00:22:07.619 --> 00:22:12.140
Yeah, yeah. And so anything else about the film that
383
00:22:12.420 --> 00:22:12.799
struck you?
384
00:22:13.960 --> 00:22:21.210
Well, I thought they caught well the achievement, which is
385
00:22:21.250 --> 00:22:24.710
sort of odd to say because so many people died
386
00:22:24.890 --> 00:22:30.150
because of the achievement. But think about this abstract idea
387
00:22:30.849 --> 00:22:35.009
that these little things called atoms have neutrons that might
388
00:22:35.150 --> 00:22:38.089
spit out a few that would break apart other atoms.
389
00:22:38.109 --> 00:22:41.349
I mean, it's such an abstract idea. The idea of
390
00:22:41.390 --> 00:22:47.640
harnessing that within a decade to actually do something to
391
00:22:47.700 --> 00:22:51.440
me is an unfathomable scientific achievement. Let me put the
392
00:22:51.519 --> 00:22:55.460
horror to the side. And I thought they captured that
393
00:22:55.500 --> 00:22:56.099
really well.
394
00:22:56.480 --> 00:23:00.319
So in my world, okay, You may not know this,
395
00:23:00.539 --> 00:23:08.960
but the uranium, the element, was discovered shortly after planet
396
00:23:09.200 --> 00:23:12.819
Uranus was named. Okay, so they wanted to sort of,
397
00:23:13.400 --> 00:23:15.759
you know, they knew the elements should have a deeper,
398
00:23:16.140 --> 00:23:20.930
more cosmically inspired nomenclature than others. So uranium is named
399
00:23:20.970 --> 00:23:22.769
after the planet Uranus, okay?
400
00:23:22.829 --> 00:23:24.130
Don't tell me plutonium is.
401
00:23:24.170 --> 00:23:25.029
I'm getting there.
402
00:23:25.190 --> 00:23:25.819
I'm... And then....
403
00:23:28.630 --> 00:23:34.150
We discovered planet Neptune, and shortly after element number 93
404
00:23:34.150 --> 00:23:40.440
was discovered, that was named Neptunium. In 1930, the object
405
00:23:40.519 --> 00:23:46.180
formerly known as a planet Pluto was discovered, and in 1940,
406
00:23:46.180 --> 00:23:50.599
element 94 was discovered, and in tradition and in that sequence,
407
00:23:50.920 --> 00:23:55.509
it was named after Pluto, Plutonium. My point is, We
408
00:23:55.569 --> 00:24:01.059
discover plutonium in 1940 and it is weaponized and tested
409
00:24:01.599 --> 00:24:02.359
five years later.
410
00:24:03.099 --> 00:24:03.279
Yeah.
411
00:24:03.579 --> 00:24:09.140
Within five years. This is an extraordinary machine that has
412
00:24:09.160 --> 00:24:10.079
been put into place.
413
00:24:10.859 --> 00:24:11.099
Yes.
414
00:24:11.519 --> 00:24:16.700
And we knew uranium was visible. So we didn't have
415
00:24:16.759 --> 00:24:20.859
to test that bomb. Yeah. The plutonium was a new element.
416
00:24:21.769 --> 00:24:24.230
So many people don't know that the bomb that was
417
00:24:24.269 --> 00:24:27.779
tested was a plutonium bomb, not a uranium bomb. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
418
00:24:27.960 --> 00:24:31.079
But even, you know, the fissile nature of uranium was
419
00:24:31.220 --> 00:24:33.819
only established in the mid to late 30s.
420
00:24:34.480 --> 00:24:37.720
Okay. Well, it's an eternity given you're fighting a whole
421
00:24:37.779 --> 00:24:39.039
war with battleships.
422
00:24:39.440 --> 00:24:43.150
Yeah. It's again, look, I mean, as a theorist who
423
00:24:43.190 --> 00:24:46.630
just plays with equations, I stand in awe of anybody
424
00:24:46.670 --> 00:24:50.720
can actually do something. And the fact that these theorists
425
00:24:50.759 --> 00:24:54.609
came together with the experimenters under the rubric of the
426
00:24:54.640 --> 00:25:00.809
organization that Oppenheimer put into place, the audacity of the goal. Yeah.
427
00:25:01.410 --> 00:25:04.150
And the fact that he was able to manage it
428
00:25:04.390 --> 00:25:09.309
and bring it to a successful and horrific conclusion, it's
429
00:25:09.349 --> 00:25:09.950
just to me.
430
00:25:09.970 --> 00:25:14.559
But do you think, do you think a half a
431
00:25:14.599 --> 00:25:18.200
dozen people could have done that? I mean, consider that
432
00:25:18.319 --> 00:25:21.599
it's a juggernaut, right? We are purifying the uranium. We
433
00:25:21.660 --> 00:25:25.619
have Hanford up in Washington, and we have all these
434
00:25:26.079 --> 00:25:30.380
sites separating the bits and pieces, and they're all coming together,
435
00:25:30.400 --> 00:25:33.980
kind of pay or play,
with or without Oppenheimer, we're
436
00:25:34.019 --> 00:25:40.579
making a bomb. I don't know how singular Oppenheimer was
437
00:25:40.619 --> 00:25:43.319
to that project. He's made singular, of course, in the film.
438
00:25:43.339 --> 00:25:48.029
Yeah, I mean, it feels singular to me because The
439
00:25:48.150 --> 00:25:53.349
organization that's required to bring together the theory and the
440
00:25:53.410 --> 00:25:57.410
experiment and the engineering and the technology, it's just sort
441
00:25:57.430 --> 00:26:02.859
of a mind-blowingly difficult challenge to bring it all together.
442
00:26:02.900 --> 00:26:05.740
Okay, so you needed someone with high managerial skills and
443
00:26:05.799 --> 00:26:06.380
people skills.
444
00:26:06.880 --> 00:26:10.259
Yeah, and I think you need someone who understands the science.
445
00:26:10.380 --> 00:26:10.599
Yeah.
446
00:26:10.799 --> 00:26:13.039
Because the worst thing in the world is when you
447
00:26:13.079 --> 00:26:16.940
have non-scientists who don't appreciate the need for certain things.
448
00:26:17.000 --> 00:26:20.349
I mean... the way Los Alamos was set up, Oppenheimer
449
00:26:20.450 --> 00:26:25.630
knew how scientists work. They come together, and without that culture,
450
00:26:25.650 --> 00:26:29.799
I don't think this would ever have come to be.
451
00:26:29.839 --> 00:26:33.599
But it's interesting to note, I believe that Oppenheimer's initial
452
00:26:33.660 --> 00:26:36.539
plan was something like, I don't know, 20 or 30 people.
453
00:26:38.000 --> 00:26:40.460
It wasn't like however many they had. I don't know
454
00:26:40.480 --> 00:26:44.579
what the final number was. It was over 1,000. I mean,
455
00:26:45.019 --> 00:26:47.779
that was not the original plan, but That was what
456
00:26:47.799 --> 00:26:51.289
it was requiring to get to the fifth one.
457
00:26:51.589 --> 00:26:55.569
Another thing I liked, which was almost, it was so,
458
00:26:56.670 --> 00:26:58.829
I was tickled by it. Each time it happened, I
459
00:26:58.869 --> 00:27:02.509
got tickled. In all those meetings that they're having are
460
00:27:02.549 --> 00:27:06.059
all these other scientists who are very famous scientists of
461
00:27:06.099 --> 00:27:09.180
the era who have formulas named after them, who have
462
00:27:09.480 --> 00:27:15.539
accelerators named after them. And it was just like, was
463
00:27:15.559 --> 00:27:16.980
that E.O. Lawrence? Who was the guy?
464
00:27:17.470 --> 00:27:19.230
Working at Lars from Lars Livermore.
465
00:27:19.269 --> 00:27:23.250
Yeah, yeah, Lars Livermore. He milled in his first cyclotron
466
00:27:23.309 --> 00:27:24.089
or whatever it was.
467
00:27:24.109 --> 00:27:28.609
Yeah, yeah, in Berkeley. Yeah, it's amazing. And it's also
468
00:27:28.650 --> 00:27:33.619
amazing to me that Oppenheimer got them to go. And
469
00:27:33.660 --> 00:27:37.440
that to me, I mean, the film shows it. Him
470
00:27:37.599 --> 00:27:39.099
talking and, you
know, getting the film.
471
00:27:39.119 --> 00:27:40.359
Convincing them, yeah.
472
00:27:40.740 --> 00:27:44.440
But wow, I mean, how do you get that many
473
00:27:44.500 --> 00:27:48.089
people involved? to get up and leave their home, move
474
00:27:48.150 --> 00:27:52.720
into the middle of nowhere. What persuasive powers that must
475
00:27:52.759 --> 00:27:56.420
have required, you know, to get people to do that.
476
00:27:56.839 --> 00:27:59.480
It's just, again, an amazing feat.
477
00:28:00.009 --> 00:28:04.029
And what do you make of their persistent discussion about
478
00:28:04.069 --> 00:28:07.529
the difference between fission and fusion? I didn't remember that
479
00:28:07.569 --> 00:28:09.670
to be a big issue at the time. We all
480
00:28:09.730 --> 00:28:12.609
knew fusion would be a whole other, another, another, right?
481
00:28:12.650 --> 00:28:17.720
Because you're fusing hydrogen into helium. Completely different nuclear physics
482
00:28:17.819 --> 00:28:20.599
from fission. But they seemed to make a big deal
483
00:28:20.640 --> 00:28:22.599
of it. And I don't remember that being an issue.
484
00:28:23.480 --> 00:28:26.519
You know, I don't know, historically speaking, but I gather
485
00:28:26.779 --> 00:28:32.730
from a plot line, the reason was because Oppenheimer's less
486
00:28:32.750 --> 00:28:35.509
than enthusiastic position.
487
00:28:36.089 --> 00:28:37.269
They needed to set that up.
488
00:28:37.880 --> 00:28:38.720
You need to set that up.
489
00:28:38.759 --> 00:28:38.980
Later.
490
00:28:39.000 --> 00:28:42.839
Because we had Edward Teller, who then testifies later on
491
00:28:43.059 --> 00:28:47.289
in the committee that ultimately revokes this Oppenheimer security clearance.
492
00:28:47.349 --> 00:28:49.170
And they shook each other's hands. You saw that.
493
00:28:49.369 --> 00:28:52.930
Yeah, they did. No, but that was, I mean, I'm...
494
00:28:53.029 --> 00:28:56.759
But where did that... Yeah, I agree. I totally agree
495
00:28:56.779 --> 00:28:58.799
with all that. But part of the.
496
00:28:58.819 --> 00:29:01.299
It was White that didn't. You shook his... Right.
497
00:29:01.619 --> 00:29:08.259
But Teller was gung-ho on the hydrogen bomb. And Oppenheimer
498
00:29:08.319 --> 00:29:11.200
was less so because he thought it would divert resources
499
00:29:11.279 --> 00:29:14.960
from the atomic weaponry, which he actually was quite a
500
00:29:15.019 --> 00:29:17.559
fan of because he viewed this as a means of
501
00:29:17.660 --> 00:29:22.640
now having some mutually assured destruction that might cause peace
502
00:29:22.720 --> 00:29:25.579
to prevail. And the hydrogen bomb was not where he
503
00:29:25.619 --> 00:29:28.160
wanted the resources to go. But I guess in order
504
00:29:28.200 --> 00:29:31.480
to set that up, they wanted us as an audience
505
00:29:31.599 --> 00:29:34.980
to know that there's a difference between the fission bombs
506
00:29:35.019 --> 00:29:36.920
that Oppenheimer developed and the fusion.
507
00:29:36.980 --> 00:29:38.549
Right, it's not just another nuke, right.
508
00:29:38.769 --> 00:29:39.950
Not just another nuke, yeah.
509
00:29:40.220 --> 00:29:44.180
Right. Right. And because when they shook hands, I thought
510
00:29:44.940 --> 00:29:53.230
Oppenheimer respected Teller's reasoning. Yeah. About he would revoke it.
511
00:29:53.329 --> 00:29:57.150
And I thought it takes two scientists to do that.
512
00:29:57.769 --> 00:29:57.990
Right.
513
00:29:58.049 --> 00:30:02.369
Yeah. I mean, Most people break out in fisticuffs, but
514
00:30:02.970 --> 00:30:07.779
if it's deeply reasoned, then the argument is sound. It's
515
00:30:07.819 --> 00:30:09.920
not a matter of what your preference is. It's this
516
00:30:09.980 --> 00:30:12.980
is the argument and I got to go with the argument. Yeah.
517
00:30:13.019 --> 00:30:16.400
And I think there's also a deep level of respect
518
00:30:16.640 --> 00:30:23.410
that underlies these relationships because this is rarefied technology. Physics knowledge.
519
00:30:23.690 --> 00:30:26.339
I mean, to be able to do quantum calculations and
520
00:30:26.440 --> 00:30:29.680
to be able to really understand the details of how
521
00:30:29.740 --> 00:30:33.900
these devices work, not many people ever get to that level.
522
00:30:33.920 --> 00:30:34.400
Right.
523
00:30:34.519 --> 00:30:38.049
And so it's a small club. And entry into that
524
00:30:38.089 --> 00:30:41.150
club is all coming from up here. And I think
525
00:30:41.190 --> 00:30:44.269
that yields this basic level of respect, even if you
526
00:30:44.329 --> 00:30:45.789
differ on critical issues.
527
00:30:46.009 --> 00:30:47.990
Here's a question I had for you. I had not
528
00:30:48.029 --> 00:30:49.670
appreciated until I saw the film.
529
00:30:50.279 --> 00:30:50.579
How.
530
00:30:51.779 --> 00:30:56.079
Shortly after the development of quantum mechanics, people had to
531
00:30:56.140 --> 00:30:59.579
make these quantum mechanical calculations. Right now, we are in
532
00:30:59.599 --> 00:31:03.420
the centennial decade of the discovery of quantum mechanics. The
533
00:31:03.480 --> 00:31:07.619
major tenets of quantum mechanics were the 1920s. And there
534
00:31:07.660 --> 00:31:10.509
you have the 30s. And right into the 40s, 15
535
00:31:10.509 --> 00:31:17.009
years later, they're manipulating all the quantum equations to make calculations.
536
00:31:17.710 --> 00:31:22.400
How could you just... put me in that moment? Was
537
00:31:22.500 --> 00:31:28.740
quantum physics so thoroughly believed and trusted that people just
538
00:31:28.799 --> 00:31:33.259
walked flat-footed into this and made the bomb with it?
539
00:31:33.420 --> 00:31:34.200
I mean, is that how.
540
00:31:35.640 --> 00:31:37.930
Well, were there people saying... I mean, was Einstein saying,
541
00:31:37.970 --> 00:31:40.230
God does not play dice with the universe? This was
542
00:31:40.250 --> 00:31:41.690
his
indictment of quantum physics.
543
00:31:42.490 --> 00:31:46.049
Yeah, but I think that's a good starting point for
544
00:31:46.089 --> 00:31:52.039
discussing it because Einstein also said That he believed that
545
00:31:52.140 --> 00:31:57.079
quantum mechanics was a correct theory, but something told him
546
00:31:57.160 --> 00:32:00.140
that there was a deeper description yet to be found.
547
00:32:00.869 --> 00:32:02.750
Okay, so not that it was wrong. Not that it
548
00:32:02.769 --> 00:32:03.849
was wrong.
549
00:32:03.950 --> 00:32:06.170
Yeah, and again, you know, Einstein, as you know, his
550
00:32:06.230 --> 00:32:09.269
Nobel Prize was for the photoelectric effect, which was one
551
00:32:09.289 --> 00:32:15.640
of the first achievements of a quantum perspective. Yeah. And
552
00:32:15.859 --> 00:32:20.500
so ever since 1926, 27, the basic equations are written down,
553
00:32:20.559 --> 00:32:26.220
Schrodinger's equations or Heisenberg's matrix mechanics formulation. They're equivalent. And
554
00:32:26.319 --> 00:32:29.720
so things have been in place for a decade. And
555
00:32:30.059 --> 00:32:34.140
triumph over triumph in these quantum equations, yeah, led people
556
00:32:34.279 --> 00:32:38.019
to a great confidence that, yeah, maybe Einstein's right. Maybe
557
00:32:38.039 --> 00:32:39.599
there's a deeper understanding. But we don't need that.
558
00:32:39.619 --> 00:32:41.049
We don't need that. You don't need it. Just shut
559
00:32:41.069 --> 00:32:41.720
up and calculate.
560
00:32:42.329 --> 00:32:45.549
Yes. And then, you know, not all the equations that
561
00:32:45.569 --> 00:32:49.470
are underlying the development of the bomb are quantum calculations.
562
00:32:49.569 --> 00:32:53.059
You know, there's a whole engineering side of things. Yeah,
563
00:32:53.119 --> 00:32:53.430
I thought.
564
00:32:54.559 --> 00:32:56.700
I don't think they gave enough credit to the engineers
565
00:32:56.759 --> 00:33:00.200
in this. Yeah. In the film. Somebody's got to build it,
566
00:33:00.240 --> 00:33:02.029
and the physicist is not building it.
567
00:33:02.519 --> 00:33:02.799
Yeah.
568
00:33:03.019 --> 00:33:06.440
The theoretical physicist doesn't know which end is up.
569
00:33:06.720 --> 00:33:10.670
Yeah, that's what leaves me in awe. I mean, I understand...
570
00:33:10.490 --> 00:33:14.309
how that those bomb designs were, you know, little boy
571
00:33:14.349 --> 00:33:18.119
fat man, it was all, all conceptually clear to me. Yes.
572
00:33:18.339 --> 00:33:21.420
But if you, even today in 2023 gave me a
573
00:33:21.460 --> 00:33:24.819
big laboratory and told me to build one of these things,
574
00:33:29.180 --> 00:33:29.559
I would.
575
00:33:29.440 --> 00:33:32.160
Do this with a hammer and a screwdriver and you
576
00:33:32.180 --> 00:33:33.579
wouldn't know what, you know.
577
00:33:33.839 --> 00:33:36.119
I'd have to, I'd have to hire a whole group.
578
00:33:36.539 --> 00:33:39.029
And I, yeah, again, be just looking at them from
579
00:33:39.069 --> 00:33:41.970
a distance.
580
00:33:43.779 --> 00:33:44.359
Arms crossed.
581
00:33:44.700 --> 00:33:49.160
Okay, I'll do it like that. I always have dreamed
582
00:33:49.180 --> 00:33:52.500
that one day I should take an experimental course, even
583
00:33:52.519 --> 00:33:54.829
given by my colleagues here at Columbia, so I'd really
584
00:33:54.849 --> 00:33:56.140
get my hands dirty.
585
00:33:55.829 --> 00:34:00.009
With some street crap. But like I said, when I
586
00:34:00.029 --> 00:34:02.869
was being tickled by all the names, all those names,
587
00:34:03.430 --> 00:34:06.650
everybody has a Nobel Prize for some And they're just
588
00:34:06.690 --> 00:34:09.969
casual names bandied about in the salon and in the
589
00:34:10.030 --> 00:34:12.090
coffee lounge and everywhere else.
590
00:34:12.510 --> 00:34:13.110
Yeah, yeah.
591
00:34:13.199 --> 00:34:16.199
One last thing. I thought they made an interesting distinction
592
00:34:16.320 --> 00:34:21.940
about his brand of communism, right? And it was, you know,
593
00:34:22.480 --> 00:34:26.420
they gave a lot of attention to this topic with
594
00:34:26.460 --> 00:34:29.480
his brother and his wife and his friends and his
595
00:34:29.599 --> 00:34:35.409
donations of money to causes. And Specifically, the movie makes
596
00:34:35.469 --> 00:34:40.349
no mention of McCarthy in the Senate, okay?
597
00:34:40.389 --> 00:34:42.210
There's a moment where we see him, right?
598
00:34:42.230 --> 00:34:45.150
We might see him, but we never at any time
599
00:34:45.650 --> 00:34:50.769
are told, McCarthy needs to interrogate you. And I think
600
00:34:50.829 --> 00:34:54.530
it's because, this is my reading onto this, that he
601
00:34:55.369 --> 00:35:01.789
was above McCarthy's pay grade, okay? McCarthy's digging out movie
602
00:35:01.829 --> 00:35:05.610
stars and people you know, and here's someone who is,
603
00:35:06.170 --> 00:35:11.050
you know, winning wars for us, right? And so my
604
00:35:11.150 --> 00:35:15.110
sense was, you don't want him mixed. Yes, there was
605
00:35:15.150 --> 00:35:18.889
a red scare, yes. But the McCarthy variant of that
606
00:35:19.590 --> 00:35:22.820
was very pedestrian relative to what was going on at
607
00:35:22.860 --> 00:35:26.500
his level in the government. That's how I knew that.
608
00:35:26.699 --> 00:35:29.900
But also, you know, what kind of, are you Karl
609
00:35:29.940 --> 00:35:32.809
Marx communist or do you just want the worker to
610
00:35:32.869 --> 00:35:36.809
have dignity, you know, there's the ways to slice this.
611
00:35:37.230 --> 00:35:37.610
Totally.
612
00:35:37.909 --> 00:35:40.130
And my sense was when they said, do you agree?
613
00:35:40.190 --> 00:35:44.449
I forgot the exact scripting here, but he said, yeah,
614
00:35:44.489 --> 00:35:47.369
there's some things they do that I resonate with. Not everything.
615
00:35:48.030 --> 00:35:48.750
Yeah. Right.
616
00:35:49.210
--> 00:35:50.829
And if you try to always, are you with us
617
00:35:50.909 --> 00:35:51.750
or you're against us?
618
00:35:52.730 --> 00:35:52.929
Yeah.
619
00:35:52.949 --> 00:35:56.199
Then you get McCarthyism. But if you, if you trust
620
00:35:56.980 --> 00:36:01.989
that not all answers are binary in this way, then
621
00:36:02.030 --> 00:36:06.000
you're allowed to be nuanced and think of Oppenheimer not
622
00:36:06.119 --> 00:36:09.780
as some traitor, but as a patriot who has his
623
00:36:09.820 --> 00:36:10.400
own conscience.
624
00:36:10.840 --> 00:36:13.420
Yeah, no, totally. I mean, you mentioned your dad before
625
00:36:13.519 --> 00:36:16.849
I grew up. My dad was very much in the
626
00:36:16.909 --> 00:36:21.710
spirit of Oppenheimer vis-a-vis his views on communism. And that
627
00:36:21.750 --> 00:36:23.309
was a tough position.
628
00:36:23.469 --> 00:36:27.480
Was he part of just that huge community of Jews
629
00:36:27.559 --> 00:36:30.000
who were totally... into the communist cause.
630
00:36:30.039 --> 00:36:32.820
Absolutely, absolutely. You know, he was one step away on,
631
00:36:32.900 --> 00:36:35.760
you know, from the Rosenbergs, you know, and he was
632
00:36:35.820 --> 00:36:38.599
very close friends with the people who ultimately adopted the
633
00:36:38.820 --> 00:36:41.420
Rosenberg kids. So it was a very, it was a
634
00:36:41.480 --> 00:36:46.989
very difficult time to hold a nuanced view, but you're
635
00:36:47.050 --> 00:36:49.409
absolutely right. You know, the world is not made up
636
00:36:49.469 --> 00:36:53.710
of black, white answers to most of these very fundamental questions.
637
00:36:53.789 --> 00:36:56.409
It's somewhere in the gray place in between.
638
00:36:56.989 --> 00:37:00.039
Just a quick aside to that. The civil rights movement,
639
00:37:00.480 --> 00:37:07.820
as it manifested in the 1960s, was brilliantly conceived. Because remember,
640
00:37:08.280 --> 00:37:11.159
a big part of that movement was, once again, dignity
641
00:37:11.239 --> 00:37:16.960
and first voting rights and housing rights, but also the
642
00:37:17.019 --> 00:37:21.239
dignity of honest pay for a day's work to get
643
00:37:21.260 --> 00:37:25.050
you out of poverty. That is centerline to the communist movement.
644
00:37:25.949 --> 00:37:29.659
And what they said was, we can't have communists leading
645
00:37:30.340 --> 00:37:34.219
this movement at a time when we're fighting communists in
646
00:37:34.239 --> 00:37:38.219
the world. So, and communists are godless, right? Because in
647
00:37:38.239 --> 00:37:40.409
the 50s, we put God on the money and God
648
00:37:40.449 --> 00:37:42.530
on the back wall of the Senate and God in
649
00:37:43.250 --> 00:37:45.789
the Pledge of Allegiance, right? God didn't used to be
650
00:37:45.829 --> 00:37:50.909
there before the 1950s. To one nation under God indivisible.
651
00:37:51.349 --> 00:37:54.500
That totally breaks up that sentence. It was one nation
652
00:37:54.619 --> 00:37:57.559
indivisible with liberty. That was the original wording.
653
00:37:57.829 --> 00:37:58.789
I did not know that.
654
00:37:59.150 --> 00:38:02.909
It's a complete service. One nation, indivisible. We win under
655
00:38:02.949 --> 00:38:07.409
God to demonstrate that we are God-fearing and communists have
656
00:38:07.429 --> 00:38:10.170
no God. All right. Point is, if you get Martin
657
00:38:10.210 --> 00:38:14.400
Luther King, a preacher, to lead a civil rights movement,
658
00:38:14.820 --> 00:38:17.940
he can speak to the rights of the workers without
659
00:38:18.119 --> 00:38:22.780
anybody thinking he's communist because he praises Jesus. Right.
660
00:38:23.099 --> 00:38:23.280
Right?
661
00:38:23.659 --> 00:38:27.269
So whatever communism the brand was at the time... it
662
00:38:27.329 --> 00:38:32.510
enabled you to still talk about workers' rights without being, um,
663
00:38:33.260 --> 00:38:36.599
a shuttled away into the communist ghetto, which is what
664
00:38:36.639 --> 00:38:37.099
that was.
665
00:38:37.519 --> 00:38:40.460
Yeah. No, I've, and I thought they handled that, that well. Yeah.
666
00:38:40.480 --> 00:38:42.199
So two thumbs up for our movie review.
667
00:38:42.280 --> 00:38:44.079
Is it? I, I give it two thumbs up.
668
00:38:44.099 --> 00:38:49.429
Yeah. And so next we'll talk about Barbie. We'll catch
669
00:38:49.449 --> 00:38:50.429
you back, Colin.
670
00:38:50.789 --> 00:38:51.409
Absolutely.
671
00:38:52.210 --> 00:38:53.550
All right, Brian. Nice chatting with you.
672
00:38:53.590 --> 00:38:54.750
Good talking to you.
673
00:38:54.789 --> 00:38:59.289
Christopher Nolan, uh, I think it's a contender for multiple
674
00:38:59.329 --> 00:39:01.929
Academy Awards. Oh, without a doubt. Without a doubt.
675
00:39:02.230 --> 00:39:02.650
All right.
676
00:39:03.269 --> 00:39:06.260
This has been a Stark Talk conversation with my friend
677
00:39:06.300 --> 00:39:11.300
and colleague, theoretical physicist Brian Green, all about Oppenheimer and
678
00:39:11.320 --> 00:39:14.110
the bomb. Until next time, keep looking up.