رونوشت 🔗
WEBVTT
0
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:02.360
Andrew Dunkley: Hi there. Thanks for joining us on a Q and A
1
00:00:02.360 --> 00:00:04.480
edition of Space Nuts, where we talk
2
00:00:04.480 --> 00:00:07.240
astronomy and space science and we get all
3
00:00:07.240 --> 00:00:09.280
these questions from the audience and we
4
00:00:09.280 --> 00:00:11.320
laugh because we really don't know the
5
00:00:11.320 --> 00:00:13.360
answers. But we make it up as we go along and
6
00:00:13.440 --> 00:00:16.320
most people fall for it. Uh, on today's.
7
00:00:16.320 --> 00:00:17.680
Somebody's going to believe that.
8
00:00:17.840 --> 00:00:20.720
On today's episode, uh, we've got a question,
9
00:00:20.800 --> 00:00:23.760
a really well asked question, I might add,
10
00:00:23.940 --> 00:00:26.760
uh, about the Oort cloud and the Kuiper
11
00:00:26.760 --> 00:00:29.680
Belt. We're also going to talk dwarf
12
00:00:29.680 --> 00:00:31.600
planet theory. Somebody's got their own
13
00:00:31.600 --> 00:00:33.220
definition. Definition of a dwarf planet is
14
00:00:33.220 --> 00:00:36.140
really good. Uh, the design of landers. You
15
00:00:36.140 --> 00:00:38.780
know, when landers go on asteroids and the
16
00:00:38.780 --> 00:00:40.660
moon and other planets and sometimes they
17
00:00:40.660 --> 00:00:43.340
fall over. Well, um, one of our
18
00:00:43.340 --> 00:00:45.420
audience thinks they've got the solution to
19
00:00:45.420 --> 00:00:48.300
that and a room full
20
00:00:48.300 --> 00:00:51.220
of geniuses. We'll tell you all about that
21
00:00:51.220 --> 00:00:53.260
on this episode of space nuts.
22
00:00:53.420 --> 00:00:55.820
Professor Fred Watson: 15 seconds. Guidance is internal.
23
00:00:56.140 --> 00:00:58.780
10, 9. Ignition
24
00:00:58.860 --> 00:00:59.820
sequence start.
25
00:00:59.980 --> 00:01:00.723
Professor Fred Watson: Space nuts.
26
00:01:00.799 --> 00:01:03.774
Professor Fred Watson: 5, 4, 3. 2, 2, 3, 4, 5,
27
00:01:03.851 --> 00:01:05.720
5, 4, 3, 2, 1.
28
00:01:05.800 --> 00:01:07.000
Andrew Dunkley: Space nuts.
29
00:01:07.080 --> 00:01:08.920
Professor Fred Watson: Astronauts report it feels good.
30
00:01:10.040 --> 00:01:12.720
Andrew Dunkley: With us again to, uh, resolve all
31
00:01:12.720 --> 00:01:15.200
those issues is Professor Fred Watson Watson,
32
00:01:15.200 --> 00:01:17.160
astronomer at large. Hello, Fred Watson.
33
00:01:17.880 --> 00:01:20.360
Professor Fred Watson: Hello, Andrew. Good to be with you again.
34
00:01:20.920 --> 00:01:23.800
And good to see you too. Sorry,
35
00:01:24.440 --> 00:01:26.120
as the politicians always say.
36
00:01:26.360 --> 00:01:28.280
Andrew Dunkley: Yes, they do, don't they? Yeah, they've got
37
00:01:28.280 --> 00:01:29.960
all their catchphrases and they.
38
00:01:29.960 --> 00:01:30.840
Professor Fred Watson: What do they call them?
39
00:01:30.920 --> 00:01:33.920
Andrew Dunkley: A stump, Stump speech or something. They
40
00:01:33.920 --> 00:01:36.480
just run the same speech every time they go
41
00:01:36.480 --> 00:01:39.280
somewhere. New stump speech, I think is
42
00:01:39.280 --> 00:01:42.020
the term they use. Yes, um,
43
00:01:42.020 --> 00:01:44.760
well, you know, my introduction to Space
44
00:01:44.760 --> 00:01:46.360
Nuts is a stump intro.
45
00:01:46.360 --> 00:01:48.880
Basically. Say the same thing every time.
46
00:01:49.360 --> 00:01:52.120
Same, only different. Um, shall
47
00:01:52.120 --> 00:01:53.600
we tackle these questions?
48
00:01:54.160 --> 00:01:55.280
Professor Fred Watson: We should, yes.
49
00:01:55.680 --> 00:01:58.360
Andrew Dunkley: All right. Our first question comes from
50
00:01:58.360 --> 00:01:58.880
Wales.
51
00:01:59.520 --> 00:02:02.160
Gerwin: Hi, my name's Gerwin. I'm calling from Larne
52
00:02:02.160 --> 00:02:05.080
in West Wales township, known for
53
00:02:05.080 --> 00:02:07.660
Dylan Thomas, the poet question, um,
54
00:02:08.000 --> 00:02:10.920
about the Oort Cloud and, um, the
55
00:02:10.920 --> 00:02:11.760
Kuiper Belt.
56
00:02:15.920 --> 00:02:18.880
Not a lot known about the Oort cloud, but
57
00:02:19.600 --> 00:02:22.080
if all of the Oort cloud
58
00:02:22.080 --> 00:02:25.040
objects were to form a
59
00:02:25.040 --> 00:02:27.920
planet, how big would it be
60
00:02:28.240 --> 00:02:31.040
and what influence might it have on
61
00:02:31.850 --> 00:02:34.850
the rest of our planets? And similarly, you
62
00:02:34.850 --> 00:02:36.610
could ask the same question about the Kuiper
63
00:02:36.610 --> 00:02:39.450
Belt. Uh, what size
64
00:02:39.450 --> 00:02:42.250
planet would we suppose it
65
00:02:42.250 --> 00:02:44.370
might form? And again, what influence would
66
00:02:44.370 --> 00:02:47.130
it have on the rest of our planetary
67
00:02:47.130 --> 00:02:49.050
system? Thank you.
68
00:02:49.930 --> 00:02:52.130
Andrew Dunkley: Thank you. Galwin. I think he said his name
69
00:02:52.130 --> 00:02:54.730
was, uh, from Wales. I don't think we've had,
70
00:02:54.880 --> 00:02:56.810
um. Have we had a question from Wales before?
71
00:02:56.810 --> 00:02:57.890
And we probably have.
72
00:02:57.890 --> 00:03:00.240
Professor Fred Watson: Yes, we have. Yeah, we have and indeed, uh,
73
00:03:00.730 --> 00:03:03.210
where uh, Galwin lives.
74
00:03:03.840 --> 00:03:06.550
Uh, we were there three years ago in Larne.
75
00:03:07.190 --> 00:03:09.800
Beautiful, beautiful town. Uh,
76
00:03:10.390 --> 00:03:13.230
on the coast of Wales. Uh, some lovely
77
00:03:13.230 --> 00:03:15.470
walks there. Uh, um, we had a tour group
78
00:03:15.470 --> 00:03:17.670
there. Marnie and I took a tour group,
79
00:03:17.750 --> 00:03:20.750
including, uh, perhaps the most
80
00:03:20.750 --> 00:03:22.790
famous woman in astronomy in the uk,
81
00:03:23.480 --> 00:03:25.710
um, Jocelyn Bell Burnell, who was with us for
82
00:03:25.710 --> 00:03:28.150
that trip. Uh, and she, and
83
00:03:28.230 --> 00:03:30.310
Marnie and I had a lovely walk on the beach,
84
00:03:30.380
Load full transcript
--> 00:03:33.340
uh, uh, at Larne. So,
85
00:03:33.340 --> 00:03:36.250
um, nice to hear from. And more
86
00:03:36.250 --> 00:03:38.770
especially, this is such a good question
87
00:03:39.170 --> 00:03:41.410
and one that we definitely have not had
88
00:03:41.410 --> 00:03:41.730
before.
89
00:03:41.890 --> 00:03:42.770
Andrew Dunkley: No, we haven't.
90
00:03:43.410 --> 00:03:46.090
Professor Fred Watson: Yeah. Um, uh, I was really
91
00:03:46.090 --> 00:03:48.170
impressed with the question, uh, and the
92
00:03:48.170 --> 00:03:50.770
answers, to be honest, have
93
00:03:50.770 --> 00:03:51.730
surprised me.
94
00:03:52.220 --> 00:03:54.290
Um, so
95
00:03:55.570 --> 00:03:58.290
basically, let's do the Trans
96
00:03:58.290 --> 00:04:00.930
Neptunian objects first, the Kuiper Belt,
97
00:04:01.560 --> 00:04:04.520
um, because, um, that was mentioned in the
98
00:04:04.520 --> 00:04:06.880
question as well. Uh, and this
99
00:04:07.520 --> 00:04:10.000
didn't surprise me. If you add
100
00:04:10.560 --> 00:04:13.200
all these objects, uh, together,
101
00:04:13.600 --> 00:04:15.960
all the Trans Neptunian objects. So not just
102
00:04:15.960 --> 00:04:18.560
the Kuiper Belt, but, uh, the resonance
103
00:04:18.560 --> 00:04:20.280
objects as they're called. The scattered
104
00:04:20.280 --> 00:04:22.640
discs object, they're called. There's a whole
105
00:04:22.640 --> 00:04:25.040
array of these things way out beyond the
106
00:04:25.280 --> 00:04:28.240
orbit of Neptune. Um, you add them all up
107
00:04:28.560 --> 00:04:31.180
and you get somewhere
108
00:04:31.820 --> 00:04:34.220
between 100th and
109
00:04:34.300 --> 00:04:36.620
1/10 of the mass of the Earth.
110
00:04:36.620 --> 00:04:36.680
Professor Fred Watson: Uh.
111
00:04:37.260 --> 00:04:39.940
Professor Fred Watson: Oh, really? Wow, I
112
00:04:39.940 --> 00:04:42.900
wasn't expecting that. Well, that's what
113
00:04:42.900 --> 00:04:45.260
I. That's kind of
114
00:04:45.820 --> 00:04:47.860
where I thought it was gonna go. Because when
115
00:04:47.860 --> 00:04:50.780
you add all the asteroids together, add
116
00:04:50.780 --> 00:04:52.900
all their mass together in the main belt,
117
00:04:52.900 --> 00:04:55.780
which is far more populated than the, uh, you
118
00:04:55.780 --> 00:04:58.530
know, the Trans Neptunian belts, um,
119
00:04:59.150 --> 00:05:00.430
you get. I can't remember what it is
120
00:05:00.430 --> 00:05:02.910
something like 20% of the mass of the Moon.
121
00:05:03.070 --> 00:05:05.830
It's tiny, all these asteroids. So it
122
00:05:05.830 --> 00:05:08.310
didn't surprise me that we were looking at a
123
00:05:08.310 --> 00:05:10.270
fraction of the Earth's mass. And of course
124
00:05:10.270 --> 00:05:12.990
that includes objects like Pluto, uh, like
125
00:05:12.990 --> 00:05:15.290
Sedna, Crayole, all these, uh,
126
00:05:15.470 --> 00:05:18.190
distant objects, uh, but they're small.
127
00:05:18.190 --> 00:05:20.590
They're very small. Um,
and
128
00:05:21.710 --> 00:05:23.710
there are probably lots and lots of objects,
129
00:05:24.080 --> 00:05:26.150
uh, like Arrokoth, our old friend, the
130
00:05:26.150 --> 00:05:28.750
snowman asteroid, way out there
131
00:05:29.070 --> 00:05:31.770
that was passed by New Horizons. Uh, it did
132
00:05:31.770 --> 00:05:33.690
look like a snowman because it's a double
133
00:05:33.690 --> 00:05:36.610
load object, um, that's thrown
134
00:05:36.610 --> 00:05:39.450
in the mix as well. Um, so that didn't
135
00:05:39.450 --> 00:05:41.690
surprise me, but the other part of the
136
00:05:41.690 --> 00:05:44.010
question did, uh, because
137
00:05:44.490 --> 00:05:47.050
the Oort cloud. Yeah, so the Oort cloud,
138
00:05:47.770 --> 00:05:50.330
hypothetical cloud of,
139
00:05:50.940 --> 00:05:53.930
uh, cometary bodies, in other words, frozen
140
00:05:53.930 --> 00:05:56.810
objects. I see dusty objects,
141
00:05:56.810 --> 00:05:59.260
the things that when they get Tipped into the
142
00:05:59.420 --> 00:06:02.260
inner solar system they become very bright,
143
00:06:02.260 --> 00:06:04.940
very spectacular, uh, portents of doom.
144
00:06:05.420 --> 00:06:08.100
In historical times, uh, because of the
145
00:06:08.100 --> 00:06:10.660
effect of the sun on the ices and the dust it
146
00:06:10.660 --> 00:06:13.440
creates tails and causes uh,
147
00:06:13.440 --> 00:06:16.060
their nucleus to glow brightly and look much,
148
00:06:16.060 --> 00:06:18.580
much bigger than it is. Uh, I mean
149
00:06:18.580 --> 00:06:21.060
cometary objects are just a few kilometres
150
00:06:21.060 --> 00:06:23.540
across. Typically, um, sort of
151
00:06:23.540 --> 00:06:26.460
comparable with what you might find in the
152
00:06:27.100 --> 00:06:29.610
uh, in the Trans Neptunian objects. But
153
00:06:30.170 --> 00:06:32.410
the estimates that come from
154
00:06:33.050 --> 00:06:35.210
um, basically calculations
155
00:06:35.930 --> 00:06:38.530
to do with the early history of the solar
156
00:06:38.530 --> 00:06:41.410
system, uh, and also the number of
157
00:06:41.410 --> 00:06:43.340
comets that we see, um,
158
00:06:44.250 --> 00:06:47.210
the calculation of a possible total
159
00:06:47.210 --> 00:06:49.930
mass of the Oort cloud is somewhere between
160
00:06:50.090 --> 00:06:53.010
five and 100 times the mass of the
161
00:06:53.010 --> 00:06:55.970
Earth and that's much, much bigger. So
162
00:06:55.970 --> 00:06:58.090
remember that Jupiter is
163
00:06:58.770 --> 00:07:00.930
300 times the mass of the ah, Earth roughly.
164
00:07:01.370 --> 00:07:03.370
Uh, so you're talking, if you could put them
165
00:07:03.370 --> 00:07:05.290
all together to a planet, you're talking
166
00:07:05.290 --> 00:07:08.250
something really significant, you're talking
167
00:07:08.250 --> 00:07:11.090
something comparable with Saturn I
168
00:07:11.090 --> 00:07:12.880
guess. Um,
169
00:07:13.810 --> 00:07:16.690
so the question is a well
170
00:07:16.690 --> 00:07:18.290
founded one because that would have a
171
00:07:18.290 --> 00:07:20.130
profound effect on the solar system.
172
00:07:20.610 --> 00:07:23.370
An object of that size, uh, in the solar
173
00:07:23.370 --> 00:07:25.970
system rather than this distribution of these
174
00:07:25.970 --> 00:07:28.610
objects, uh, in a shell around the sun.
175
00:07:29.170 --> 00:07:31.990
So yeah, great question with uh, a
176
00:07:31.990 --> 00:07:33.550
few surprises in the answer.
177
00:07:33.950 --> 00:07:36.750
Andrew Dunkley: Yes, indeed. Um, of course my
178
00:07:36.750 --> 00:07:39.710
first thought was Planet nine. It's out
179
00:07:39.710 --> 00:07:41.790
there somewhere maybe, or
180
00:07:42.430 --> 00:07:44.310
there's something, there's something we don't
181
00:07:44.310 --> 00:07:46.229
know exactly what. Might not be a planet,
182
00:07:46.229 --> 00:07:47.550
might be a bunch of stuff.
183
00:07:48.590 --> 00:07:51.230
Professor Fred Watson: Yes, that's right. So you're quite right.
184
00:07:51.310 --> 00:07:53.950
That's a good um, caveat to make that
185
00:07:55.230 --> 00:07:58.000
ignores any possible Planet Nine,
186
00:07:58.540 --> 00:08:01.420
uh, which would be uh.
187
00:08:01.520 --> 00:08:04.520
And if Planet nine exists, uh, what
188
00:08:04.520 --> 00:08:07.320
it's done is profoundly affected the orbits
189
00:08:07.320 --> 00:08:09.520
of some of these Trans Neptunian objects. But
190
00:08:10.320 --> 00:08:12.960
we're not yet sure that it does exist. So
191
00:08:12.960 --> 00:08:14.000
still hypothetical.
192
00:08:14.640 --> 00:08:17.280
Andrew Dunkley: Yeah, yeah, but terrific question Galwin,
193
00:08:17.280 --> 00:08:20.280
thank you. Uh, no one's ever sort of
194
00:08:20.280 --> 00:08:22.360
come at us from that angle before and uh,
195
00:08:22.400 --> 00:08:25.330
yeah, I'm very surprised by the, the
196
00:08:25.330 --> 00:08:28.170
mass of objects in the Oort Cloud,
197
00:08:28.840 --> 00:08:31.450
um, and just as surprised that there's not
198
00:08:31.450 --> 00:08:34.370
that much in the um, Kuiper Belt and
199
00:08:34.370 --> 00:08:37.170
the asteroid belt and all that stuff.
200
00:08:37.170 --> 00:08:39.330
Yeah, they still throw rocks at us though
201
00:08:39.330 --> 00:08:39.850
Fred Watson.
202
00:08:40.250 --> 00:08:42.650
Professor Fred Watson: They do. Well a lot of those rocks
203
00:08:43.130 --> 00:08:45.210
probably originated in the Oort cloud, so
204
00:08:45.210 --> 00:08:47.970
it's not surprising perhaps. Yeah, rocks are
205
00:08:47.970 --> 00:08:48.330
nice.
206
00:08:48.570 --> 00:08:51.210
Andrew Dunkley: What did we ever do to them? Thanks
207
00:08:51.210 --> 00:08:52.970
Galvin, great to hear from you.
208
00:08:53.050 --> 00:08:55.940
Our uh, next question comes from Bob. Uh,
209
00:08:55.940 --> 00:08:58.750
Bob says Mike Brown says that Pluto
210
00:08:58.750 --> 00:09:01.190
isn't a planet I agree, but for a different
211
00:09:01.270 --> 00:09:04.150
reason. Its
motion is not always concave to
212
00:09:04.150 --> 00:09:06.870
the sun. It sometimes moves backward with
213
00:09:06.870 --> 00:09:09.350
respect to the sun. In the Pluto Charon
214
00:09:09.670 --> 00:09:12.070
barycenter orbit, Earth's
215
00:09:12.630 --> 00:09:15.190
moon's motion is always
216
00:09:15.270 --> 00:09:18.070
concave to the sun. So it's Earth's moon that
217
00:09:18.070 --> 00:09:21.030
is the ninth planet. If we must have enough
218
00:09:21.030 --> 00:09:23.870
planets for a baseball team, uh, what are
219
00:09:23.870 --> 00:09:26.550
your thoughts on the redefinition. On my
220
00:09:26.550 --> 00:09:29.300
redefinition of planet, Uh,
221
00:09:29.410 --> 00:09:32.010
a dwarf human is still a human, and we
222
00:09:32.010 --> 00:09:34.970
deny that at our peril. A dwarf planet
223
00:09:34.970 --> 00:09:37.370
is still a planet, and we deny that at our
224
00:09:37.370 --> 00:09:39.810
peril. That comes from Bob Argyle in
225
00:09:40.050 --> 00:09:42.450
Ogden, Utah, in the United States.
226
00:09:42.850 --> 00:09:45.010
Thank you, Bob. I love this question. And,
227
00:09:45.370 --> 00:09:48.210
um. Well, first of all, Mike Brown,
228
00:09:48.210 --> 00:09:50.810
we should point, um, out that he has earned
229
00:09:50.810 --> 00:09:53.090
the nickname the man who killed Pluto.
230
00:09:53.650 --> 00:09:55.490
He was one of the astronomers that got
231
00:09:55.490 --> 00:09:58.330
behind, um, its reclassification back in
232
00:09:58.330 --> 00:09:59.410
2005.
233
00:09:59.490 --> 00:09:59.880
Gerwin: Ish.
234
00:10:00.690 --> 00:10:03.430
Andrew Dunkley: Uh, so, um, that's who he's referring
235
00:10:03.430 --> 00:10:05.870
to in the question. But I think you're on
236
00:10:05.870 --> 00:10:07.790
Mike's side in that regard, aren't you,
237
00:10:07.790 --> 00:10:08.190
Fred Watson?
238
00:10:09.310 --> 00:10:11.990
Professor Fred Watson: Yeah. Actually, the man who really killed
239
00:10:11.990 --> 00:10:14.470
Pluto was Neil, um, Degrasse Tyson. Because
240
00:10:14.470 --> 00:10:17.150
he, uh, in the 90s, I think,
241
00:10:17.630 --> 00:10:20.110
left Pluto off an
242
00:10:20.110 --> 00:10:23.030
exhibition that he was responsible for. He'd
243
00:10:23.030 --> 00:10:25.630
already decided it was not a planet.
244
00:10:26.030 --> 00:10:28.950
That's very bold. Very bold. Yeah. He
245
00:10:28.950 --> 00:10:30.460
got hate mail. Hate man.
246
00:10:30.460 --> 00:10:31.460
Andrew Dunkley: I bet he did.
247
00:10:31.940 --> 00:10:33.900
Professor Fred Watson: Yeah. And I think Mike Brown's had it as
248
00:10:33.900 --> 00:10:36.100
well. You're right. Mike's also,
249
00:10:36.800 --> 00:10:39.420
uh, been a mover and shaker in that. And I
250
00:10:39.420 --> 00:10:41.100
guess on the other opposite side is Alan
251
00:10:41.100 --> 00:10:43.540
Stern, who was the, uh, project scientist for
252
00:10:44.580 --> 00:10:47.060
New Horizons for the spacecraft that flew by
253
00:10:47.380 --> 00:10:49.620
Pluto. When his spacecraft was launched at
254
00:10:49.620 --> 00:10:51.700
the beginning of 2006, it was going to a
255
00:10:51.700 --> 00:10:54.380
planet. Uh, when it got there, uh, it
256
00:10:54.380 --> 00:10:57.260
wasn't. It was a dwarf planet. Yeah.
257
00:10:57.260 --> 00:10:58.830
So, um, I.
258
00:10:59.710 --> 00:11:00.670
Andrew Dunkley: Timing is everything.
259
00:11:02.030 --> 00:11:04.510
Professor Fred Watson: Absolutely right. Um, and actually, thank
260
00:11:04.510 --> 00:11:07.510
you, Bob as well. Um, my heartfelt thanks
261
00:11:07.510 --> 00:11:10.110
to Bob, uh, for including where he comes
262
00:11:10.110 --> 00:11:12.830
from. Uh, because, um, I've got an old friend
263
00:11:12.830 --> 00:11:14.830
called Bob Argyle, and I always wondered when
264
00:11:14.830 --> 00:11:17.030
we saw Bob Argyle, whether that was who it
265
00:11:17.030 --> 00:11:19.990
was. Partly because I can imagine the
266
00:11:19.990 --> 00:11:22.670
questions that Bob from Ogun, Utah,
267
00:11:23.030 --> 00:11:24.870
uh, and including the one that we're just
268
00:11:24.870 --> 00:11:26.830
talking about, the questions he's raised are
269
00:11:26.830 --> 00:11:28.870
very similar to the kinds of things that Bob
270
00:11:28.870 --> 00:11:31.610
Argyle might have raised. Uh, my old friend.
271
00:11:31.770 --> 00:11:34.090
So it's not him. Uh, that's good. So thank
272
00:11:34.090 --> 00:11:36.650
you for that, Bob. Uh, now I
273
00:11:36.890 --> 00:11:39.440
believe that, um,
274
00:11:41.130 --> 00:11:42.730
if you look at
275
00:11:43.930 --> 00:11:46.810
most of the dwarf planets that
276
00:11:46.810 --> 00:11:49.450
we know about, they start with Ceres.
277
00:11:50.650 --> 00:11:53.580
That's the nearest one, uh, uh,
278
00:11:53.580 --> 00:11:54.730
in the asteroid belt.
279
00:11:55.100 --> 00:11:55.130
Professor Fred Watson: Ah.
280
00:11:55.130 --> 00:11:57.410
Professor Fred Watson: And then you go through all these SEDNA and
281
00:11:57.410 --> 00:11:59.770
all the ones we mentioned a few minutes ago,
282
00:12:00.300 --> 00:12:03.020
um, uh, they would also
283
00:12:03.100 --> 00:12:05.820
have, uh, orbits that are concave to the sun.
284
00:12:06.460 --> 00:12:09.460
And so I don't think your definition gets you
285
00:12:09.460 --> 00:12:12.460
any further forward. You end up with too
286
00:12:12.460 --> 00:12:14.560
many planets, basically. Uh,
287
00:12:15.260 --> 00:12:17.500
because your definition there, uh, says a
288
00:12:17.500 --> 00:12:20.500
planet has to have enough mass
289
00:12:20.500 --> 00:12:23.140
that it's differentiated. That means it's
290
00:12:23.140 --> 00:12:26.060
formed a spherical shape, uh, and it has to
291
00:12:26.060 --> 00:12:27.860
have an orbit that's always concave to the
292
00:12:27.860 --> 00:12:29.940
sun. I think that lets a whole lot of stuff
293
00:12:29.940 --> 00:12:32.940
in. Whereas the definition that
294
00:12:32.940 --> 00:12:34.660
we have arrived at by the
International
295
00:12:34.980 --> 00:12:37.660
Astronomical Union in I think it was August
296
00:12:37.660 --> 00:12:40.620
2006, uh, which says it's
297
00:12:40.620 --> 00:12:43.500
also got to be the dominant body in its part
298
00:12:43.500 --> 00:12:45.740
of the solar system. Gravitationally
299
00:12:45.740 --> 00:12:48.420
dominant. That's the crucial thing. And that
300
00:12:48.420 --> 00:12:50.260
is the definition of a planet that we have
301
00:12:50.260 --> 00:12:51.780
now. And I think it's the right one.
302
00:12:52.260 --> 00:12:54.580
Andrew Dunkley: Yeah, well, when they started discovering
303
00:12:54.580 --> 00:12:57.380
more of these things out in the
304
00:12:57.620 --> 00:13:00.540
Kuiper Belt region, I think they found that
305
00:13:00.540 --> 00:13:03.220
there was a similar dwarf
306
00:13:03.220 --> 00:13:05.380
planet to Pluto, except it was bigger. Wasn't
307
00:13:05.380 --> 00:13:05.900
that Sedna?
308
00:13:05.900 --> 00:13:06.020
Gerwin: It was.
309
00:13:06.020 --> 00:13:07.260
Andrew Dunkley: Sedna was bigger than Pluto.
310
00:13:07.260 --> 00:13:09.860
Professor Fred Watson: Was Sedna. That's right. It's more
311
00:13:09.860 --> 00:13:12.259
massive. It's about the same diameter, but
312
00:13:12.420 --> 00:13:15.020
significantly more massive, which suggests
313
00:13:15.020 --> 00:13:17.540
it's got a higher density. Yeah, that's
314
00:13:17.540 --> 00:13:20.260
right. Uh, and there are others that are of
315
00:13:20.260 --> 00:13:22.760
comparable size. Uh, so, um,
316
00:13:23.640 --> 00:13:25.880
yeah, it's a nice thought, though. I do like,
317
00:13:25.970 --> 00:13:28.160
uh, Bob's thinking on that. I think that's a
318
00:13:28.160 --> 00:13:29.240
very clever idea.
319
00:13:29.560 --> 00:13:31.880
Andrew Dunkley: Indeed it is. Um, thank you, Bob. Great to
320
00:13:31.880 --> 00:13:33.760
hear from you. Uh, thanks for sending the
321
00:13:33.760 --> 00:13:36.560
question in. This is Space Nuts with
322
00:13:36.560 --> 00:13:38.640
Andrew Dunkley and Professor Fred Watson
323
00:13:38.640 --> 00:13:39.160
Watson.
324
00:13:41.720 --> 00:13:44.120
Professor Fred Watson: Okay, we checked all four systems and being
325
00:13:44.120 --> 00:13:46.640
with a Go Space Nuts, and
326
00:13:46.640 --> 00:13:49.160
Andrew Dunkley: it's a Q and A edition. Our next question,
327
00:13:49.320 --> 00:13:51.720
Fred Watson, comes from Shumo, who is in
328
00:13:51.720 --> 00:13:54.190
Oxford in the uk. Thanks for many hours, uh,
329
00:13:54.480 --> 00:13:56.580
of pleasure, pleasurable listening. Uh,
330
00:13:56.580 --> 00:13:58.620
Fred Watson and Andrew, I heard a recent
331
00:13:58.620 --> 00:14:01.060
podcast where you describe lunar landers
332
00:14:01.060 --> 00:14:04.020
toppling over. Fred Watson, why do we design
333
00:14:04.100 --> 00:14:07.020
lunar landers like tables rather than
334
00:14:07.020 --> 00:14:09.900
like insects? Uh, recent landers
335
00:14:09.900 --> 00:14:12.420
have toppled after landing on, um, uneven
336
00:14:12.420 --> 00:14:15.140
terrain. Evolution solved this problem
337
00:14:15.220 --> 00:14:18.100
long ago. Insects have multiple articulated,
338
00:14:18.500 --> 00:14:21.100
compliant legs, uh, tolerate
339
00:14:21.100 --> 00:14:23.660
awkward landings and can often right
340
00:14:23.660 --> 00:14:26.660
themselves after falling over in the Moon's
341
00:14:26.660 --> 00:14:29.520
low gravity. Why not design small landers,
342
00:14:30.130 --> 00:14:32.720
uh, the same way, uh, with six
343
00:14:32.800 --> 00:14:35.800
articulated legs that can adapt to the
344
00:14:35.800 --> 00:14:38.280
terrain and crucially push the lander
345
00:14:38.280 --> 00:14:40.920
upright again if it topples. Has anyone
346
00:14:40.920 --> 00:14:43.440
seriously considered this kind of biometric
347
00:14:43.440 --> 00:14:46.000
approach that comes from Shumo in
348
00:14:46.000 --> 00:14:48.490
Oxford? It's a great question. Um,
349
00:14:49.600 --> 00:14:52.400
when you look at the lunar landers in the
350
00:14:52.400 --> 00:14:54.800
Apollo um, mission series,
351
00:14:55.360 --> 00:14:58.120
they had four legs, uh, they
352
00:14:58.120 --> 00:14:59.930
seemed rather stable. But um,
353
00:15:01.280 --> 00:15:03.520
we've seen a few mishaps over the years too,
354
00:15:03.520 --> 00:15:04.160
haven't we?
355
00:15:04.720 --> 00:15:07.240
Professor Fred Watson: Yes, that's right. So um, it's a great
356
00:15:07.240 --> 00:15:09.760
question. I'm sure people have looked at six
357
00:15:09.760 --> 00:15:12.450
legged landers. It's
358
00:15:12.450 --> 00:15:14.960
uh, the kind of thing that um, anybody
359
00:15:14.960 --> 00:15:17.520
designing something to land on the moon would
360
00:15:17.520 --> 00:15:20.160
look at. Do, uh, you need more legs than just
361
00:15:20.160 --> 00:15:23.080
4? So clearly in the case of
362
00:15:23.080 --> 00:15:24.880
Apollo, the decision was made that no, you
363
00:15:24.880 --> 00:15:27.100
didn't, you didn't need more legs, uh, you
364
00:15:27.100 --> 00:15:29.380
needed four for the uh,
365
00:15:29.660 --> 00:15:32.660
lunar module. But as you've kind of
366
00:15:32.660 --> 00:15:35.540
hinted at, they were well spaced. These legs
367
00:15:35.540 --> 00:15:38.060
or the feet are well spaced out. So the legs
368
00:15:38.460 --> 00:15:41.219
extend a long way from the body of the lunar
369
00:15:41.219 --> 00:15:43.740
module. And it means that you do have
370
00:15:44.460 --> 00:15:46.300
some protection against
371
00:15:46.890 --> 00:15:49.820
uh, that instability that
372
00:15:50.130 --> 00:15:52.190
um, would caused something to fall over.
373
00:15:52.750 --> 00:15:55.350
And well, you're right to
374
00:15:55.350 --> 00:15:58.340
mention, um, uh, and indeed, um,
375
00:15:58.750 --> 00:16:01.670
it's part of the question, uh,
376
00:16:01.710 --> 00:16:04.590
Shumo mentions it as well. There have been
377
00:16:04.670 --> 00:16:06.510
spacecraft that have
fallen over recently.
378
00:16:07.220 --> 00:16:09.990
Uh, and I'm thinking there's more than just
379
00:16:09.990 --> 00:16:12.270
this, but I'm thinking of the four
380
00:16:13.230 --> 00:16:15.110
spacecraft um, that have attempted to land on
381
00:16:15.110 --> 00:16:17.830
the moon in NASA's Commercial
382
00:16:17.830 --> 00:16:20.590
Lunar Payload Services mission. This
383
00:16:20.590 --> 00:16:23.590
is the idea of using commercial companies
384
00:16:23.750 --> 00:16:26.410
to send stuff to the moon, uh,
385
00:16:26.950 --> 00:16:29.830
that astronauts can then use. NASA
386
00:16:29.830 --> 00:16:31.710
sends the astronauts there, uh, the
387
00:16:31.710 --> 00:16:33.670
commercial world sends the other stuff there.
388
00:16:34.260 --> 00:16:35.750
Uh, there have been four of those
389
00:16:36.070 --> 00:16:38.390
Andrew Dunkley: to uh, Athena and
390
00:16:38.390 --> 00:16:41.340
Odysseus. And uh,
391
00:16:41.340 --> 00:16:43.870
during the um, mission In February of
392
00:16:43.870 --> 00:16:46.770
2024, the Odysseus Lander caught a
393
00:16:46.770 --> 00:16:49.410
landing leg on an uneven surface and fell
394
00:16:49.410 --> 00:16:52.370
sideways, uh, though it still operated for a
395
00:16:52.370 --> 00:16:54.770
week. And its successor
396
00:16:54.770 --> 00:16:57.290
Athena landed near the lunar South Pole in
397
00:16:57.290 --> 00:16:59.210
March 2025 and broke its leg
398
00:17:00.250 --> 00:17:03.010
and toppled into a small crater, depleting
399
00:17:03.010 --> 00:17:04.970
its batteries within 12 hours. I'm not
400
00:17:05.780 --> 00:17:08.050
um, it's not funny. Haha, I'm laughing with
401
00:17:08.050 --> 00:17:10.480
them. No I'm not. I think it's hilarious. But
402
00:17:10.480 --> 00:17:12.250
um, it's. Yeah,
403
00:17:13.770 --> 00:17:16.570
but it makes the question quite
404
00:17:16.570 --> 00:17:17.050
valid.
405
00:17:18.059 --> 00:17:20.539
Professor Fred Watson: Yeah, so, um, you're absolutely right.
406
00:17:20.939 --> 00:17:22.939
The Commercial Lunar Payload Services
407
00:17:23.019 --> 00:17:25.939
programme has so far attempted to land
408
00:17:25.939 --> 00:17:28.739
four spacecraft on the moon, of which only
409
00:17:28.739 --> 00:17:30.939
one has been successful. And that's the one
410
00:17:30.939 --> 00:17:32.699
you've just mentioned that worked for a week,
411
00:17:33.270 --> 00:17:36.059
uh, two of them tilted over, as you
412
00:17:36.059 --> 00:17:38.450
said. Um, and so, uh,
413
00:17:39.659 --> 00:17:42.619
it's an absolutely valid question. And
414
00:17:42.619 --> 00:17:45.260
to my mind it is even
415
00:17:45.260 --> 00:17:47.900
more pertinent when you look at the two
416
00:17:47.900 --> 00:17:50.780
alternative vehicles that,
417
00:17:50.970 --> 00:17:53.340
uh, NASA is looking at to bring
418
00:17:53.740 --> 00:17:55.980
astronauts down to the lunar surface.
419
00:17:56.380 --> 00:17:59.300
And, um, they haven't chosen
420
00:17:59.300 --> 00:18:02.180
which one yet. Uh, the two choices
421
00:18:02.180 --> 00:18:04.660
are Blue, ah, Moon, which is Blue
422
00:18:04.660 --> 00:18:07.500
Origin's hls, or Human Landing
423
00:18:07.500 --> 00:18:10.100
System, which looks rather like an
424
00:18:10.100 --> 00:18:12.620
overgrown lunar module. And it
425
00:18:12.620 --> 00:18:15.460
shares the wide, uh, footprint,
426
00:18:15.460 --> 00:18:17.340
if I can put it that way, the widely
427
00:18:17.340 --> 00:18:20.100
separated footprint of the old lunar
428
00:18:20.100 --> 00:18:22.260
module. It's much bigger. It's 16 metres
429
00:18:22.260 --> 00:18:24.540
tall, compared with 7 metres for the lunar
430
00:18:24.540 --> 00:18:27.380
module. But it's got the same morphology. The
431
00:18:27.380 --> 00:18:29.300
bottom half stays on the moon's surface. The
432
00:18:29.300 --> 00:18:32.260
top half is what brings, uh, astronauts back
433
00:18:32.260 --> 00:18:34.470
to the orbiting, um,
434
00:18:34.820 --> 00:18:36.980
Orion spacecraft. But the
435
00:18:37.550 --> 00:18:39.310
alternative is
436
00:18:39.790 --> 00:18:42.190
Starship, ah, which is
437
00:18:42.350 --> 00:18:45.070
52 metres tall, has
438
00:18:45.230 --> 00:18:48.150
actually got across. You know, the
439
00:18:48.150 --> 00:18:50.270
landing legs occupy a smaller
440
00:18:51.310 --> 00:18:53.910
square than they do on, um, Blue
441
00:18:53.910 --> 00:18:56.710
Origin, which is, you know, basically a
442
00:18:56.710 --> 00:18:57.710
third of the height,
443
00:18:59.710 --> 00:19:02.390
it seems like, given where
444
00:19:02.390 --> 00:19:04.910
they're waiting to happen. Absolutely,
445
00:19:05.440 --> 00:19:07.800
absolutely where they're going to land, which
446
00:19:07.800 --> 00:19:10.640
is in this very, very mountainous region
447
00:19:11.760 --> 00:19:14.480
around the South Pole. Um, I did a
448
00:19:14.480 --> 00:19:17.340
keynote talk on Saturday at M
449
00:19:17.600 --> 00:19:20.600
Macquarie University and so I prepared a talk
450
00:19:20.600 --> 00:19:23.120
about Artemis and where it's going.
451
00:19:23.590 --> 00:19:26.560
Uh, and included in that talk a, uh, video
452
00:19:27.120 --> 00:19:29.920
of the region around the South Pole.
453
00:19:30.000 --> 00:19:32.160
A flyover, effectively, which is based on
454
00:19:32.160 --> 00:19:34.800
Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter data. And
455
00:19:34.800 --> 00:19:37.440
there's barely a level patch of surface
456
00:19:37.440 --> 00:19:40.360
anywhere. You're looking at slopes, you're
457
00:19:40.360 --> 00:19:43.360
looking at, um, terrain that's rough,
458
00:19:43.360 --> 00:19:46.360
it's probably got boulders as well. Uh, and
459
00:19:47.960 --> 00:19:50.520
it does seem like a very
460
00:19:50.920 --> 00:19:53.760
awkward misfit to have something that wasn't
461
00:19:53.760 --> 00:19:55.920
originally designed to be the lunar lander.
462
00:19:55.920 --> 00:19:58.400
It was kind of almost an
463
00:19:58.400 --> 00:20:00.480
afterthought. Starship
is designed to take
464
00:20:00.480 --> 00:20:03.260
people to Mars, which it might do one
465
00:20:03.260 --> 00:20:06.260
day. Uh, but to land it on the
466
00:20:06.260 --> 00:20:08.780
Moon, I think is courting disaster.
467
00:20:09.180 --> 00:20:11.780
It's still an open question. It will not be
468
00:20:11.780 --> 00:20:14.580
resolved until after the Artemis 3 mission,
469
00:20:14.580 --> 00:20:17.290
which will be late next year, uh,
470
00:20:17.419 --> 00:20:20.300
when both those vehicles will fly in
471
00:20:20.300 --> 00:20:22.940
orbit along, uh, with the,
472
00:20:23.120 --> 00:20:25.900
um, Orion capsule containing astronauts. And
473
00:20:25.900 --> 00:20:27.540
they'll dock with both of them to see whether
474
00:20:27.540 --> 00:20:28.450
they can do the dock.
475
00:20:29.720 --> 00:20:32.320
Andrew Dunkley: At face value, you'd have to say Blue
476
00:20:32.320 --> 00:20:35.080
Origin's design makes more sense,
477
00:20:35.720 --> 00:20:37.960
but it too looks top heavy,
478
00:20:38.360 --> 00:20:40.080
really, compared
479
00:20:40.080 --> 00:20:42.960
Professor Fred Watson: with one of the, um, you know, the lams,
480
00:20:42.960 --> 00:20:45.960
the lunar Excursion modules, uh, from
481
00:20:45.960 --> 00:20:48.680
Apollo. Yes, it does. Uh, but it.
482
00:20:49.880 --> 00:20:52.680
Andrew Dunkley: But technologically probably much, much
483
00:20:52.680 --> 00:20:53.560
more Advanced.
484
00:20:53.880 --> 00:20:56.440
Professor Fred Watson: Yes, of course, of course it is. But um, will
485
00:20:56.440 --> 00:20:58.600
that stop it tipping over? Who knows?
486
00:20:59.080 --> 00:21:01.380
Andrew Dunkley: That's the 60 form billion dollar question,
487
00:21:01.380 --> 00:21:03.940
isn't it? Probably others that have fallen
488
00:21:03.940 --> 00:21:06.060
over, uh, JAXA Slim.
489
00:21:07.030 --> 00:21:09.920
Uh, okay, jaxa's smart lander for, uh,
490
00:21:09.920 --> 00:21:12.620
investigating. Um, the moon landed on its
491
00:21:12.700 --> 00:21:15.420
nose with its solar panels
492
00:21:15.420 --> 00:21:17.900
facing in the wrong direction. It's not
493
00:21:17.900 --> 00:21:20.900
funny. Uh, an engine thruster failed just
494
00:21:20.900 --> 00:21:23.740
above the surface during the point descent. I
495
00:21:23.740 --> 00:21:26.660
remember that it initially lacked power.
496
00:21:26.660 --> 00:21:29.660
The probe miraculously reawakened weeks
497
00:21:29.660 --> 00:21:32.640
later when the sun's angle shifted strike
498
00:21:32.640 --> 00:21:35.640
the panel. So, um, a successful failure
499
00:21:35.640 --> 00:21:38.440
maybe. And of course the Philate lander,
500
00:21:38.590 --> 00:21:40.120
uh, on Comet 67.
501
00:21:40.200 --> 00:21:42.890
Professor Fred Watson: Yeah, that's right, yes. Didn't um,
502
00:21:43.000 --> 00:21:45.960
Wasn't there an Israeli spacecraft or
503
00:21:45.960 --> 00:21:47.720
did that, I think that just crashed? Actually
504
00:21:47.720 --> 00:21:50.120
it didn't tip over as one
505
00:21:50.120 --> 00:21:52.520
Andrew Dunkley: of the crash don't count as failed landings.
506
00:21:52.680 --> 00:21:54.200
Professor Fred Watson: No, that's right. No, they don't.
507
00:21:54.860 --> 00:21:55.080
Andrew Dunkley: Um,
508
00:21:57.160 --> 00:22:00.040
Professor Fred Watson: they're, um. What is it? Um, unscheduled,
509
00:22:00.280 --> 00:22:03.270
uh, I can't remember unscheduled disassembly
510
00:22:03.270 --> 00:22:06.230
or what it, whatever Elon's stock phrase
511
00:22:06.230 --> 00:22:08.870
is for that assembly. Yeah,
512
00:22:09.590 --> 00:22:10.710
I'm just looking up,
513
00:22:13.030 --> 00:22:14.710
Andrew Dunkley: looking up that Israeli one.
514
00:22:15.350 --> 00:22:15.360
Professor Fred Watson: Yeah.
515
00:22:15.360 --> 00:22:18.080
Andrew Dunkley: Uh, Israel's first lunar probe. The um,
516
00:22:18.310 --> 00:22:20.990
Beresheet spacecraft crash on the
517
00:22:20.990 --> 00:22:23.590
moon, April of 2019.
518
00:22:24.390 --> 00:22:26.870
That was a crash. It didn't even get the fall
519
00:22:26.870 --> 00:22:27.190
over.
520
00:22:28.690 --> 00:22:30.970
Professor Fred Watson: No. So Schumer, it's been definitely been
521
00:22:30.970 --> 00:22:33.530
looked at the idea of six independently
522
00:22:33.530 --> 00:22:36.290
controlled legs. I'm sure that would have
523
00:22:36.290 --> 00:22:38.170
been part and parcel of some of the ideas
524
00:22:38.170 --> 00:22:40.930
that have been put forward. Uh, I think the
525
00:22:41.010 --> 00:22:43.490
lunar module, the Apollo era lunar module
526
00:22:43.490 --> 00:22:45.990
demonstrated that they got it right. Uh,
527
00:22:45.990 --> 00:22:48.770
because all of them were stable
528
00:22:48.770 --> 00:22:51.170
and one or two of them did land. Uh, the
529
00:22:51.170 --> 00:22:53.730
later ones in hilly regions of the moon, they
530
00:22:53.730 --> 00:22:55.370
played it safe with the early ones always
531
00:22:55.370 --> 00:22:58.210
landing in Maria, the very flattest areas of
532
00:22:58.210 --> 00:23:00.590
the moon. But now we going. Yep, we're going
533
00:23:00.750 --> 00:23:03.070
right to the most difficult
534
00:23:03.630 --> 00:23:06.310
part of the moon, uh, par
535
00:23:06.310 --> 00:23:08.670
excellence, as it were, uh, and
536
00:23:08.990 --> 00:23:10.990
hoping for the best to land things the right
537
00:23:10.990 --> 00:23:13.310
way up. And it's an interesting time.
538
00:23:14.190 --> 00:23:16.070
Andrew Dunkley: Yes, indeed. But you know, when you think
539
00:23:16.070 --> 00:23:17.830
about it, you're spending millions upon
540
00:23:17.830 --> 00:23:20.150
millions upon millions of dollars to send
541
00:23:20.150 --> 00:23:22.670
these spacecraft to these
542
00:23:22.670 --> 00:23:25.230
destinations in the hope that they won't fall
543
00:23:25.230 --> 00:23:27.120
over. I mean, couldn't you
544
00:23:27.840 --> 00:23:30.520
whip down to Bunnings or Home Depot
545
00:23:30.520 --> 00:23:33.400
or
Home Base and just
546
00:23:33.400 --> 00:23:35.560
buy a couple of pieces of wood and just stick
547
00:23:35.560 --> 00:23:38.480
them on the side and if it does lose balance,
548
00:23:38.480 --> 00:23:40.320
at least it'll have something to Prop on.
549
00:23:40.800 --> 00:23:43.120
Come on, spend 10 bucks.
550
00:23:44.000 --> 00:23:45.920
M. It's simple.
551
00:23:46.960 --> 00:23:49.400
I'm sure it's that simple. Wood is good in
552
00:23:49.400 --> 00:23:50.720
space, it's been proven.
553
00:23:50.960 --> 00:23:52.560
Professor Fred Watson: Yeah, we've got. That's right. Wooden
554
00:23:52.560 --> 00:23:53.200
satellites.
555
00:23:54.140 --> 00:23:55.580
Thing of the future. Exactly.
556
00:23:55.980 --> 00:23:56.500
Gerwin: Yeah.
557
00:23:56.500 --> 00:23:59.060
Professor Fred Watson: Yeah. Interesting. Really interesting topic,
558
00:23:59.060 --> 00:24:01.900
though. And we won't know. So Artemis iv, the
559
00:24:01.900 --> 00:24:03.620
first lunar landing in the Artemis programme
560
00:24:03.620 --> 00:24:06.500
is planned for early 2028.
561
00:24:06.500 --> 00:24:09.060
That might be when we find out. Uh, we'll
562
00:24:09.060 --> 00:24:11.900
know which of the two, uh, landing vehicles
563
00:24:11.900 --> 00:24:13.780
has been chosen for the first landing by
564
00:24:13.780 --> 00:24:15.900
then. Uh, and we'll find out whether they're
565
00:24:15.900 --> 00:24:17.100
going to stay vertical.
566
00:24:18.220 --> 00:24:20.620
Andrew Dunkley: Indeed. Or you could. In the uk, you could go
567
00:24:20.620 --> 00:24:22.540
to B and Q. Apparently that would be the
568
00:24:22.540 --> 00:24:22.860
place to
569
00:24:22.860 --> 00:24:24.890
Professor Fred Watson: go and get some Texas as well.
570
00:24:25.210 --> 00:24:25.690
Gerwin: Yes.
571
00:24:25.930 --> 00:24:26.490
Andrew Dunkley: There you are.
572
00:24:26.490 --> 00:24:29.050
Professor Fred Watson: Texas is the other. The other one. B and Q
573
00:24:29.050 --> 00:24:31.690
and Texas, they're the big ones in the UK
574
00:24:32.650 --> 00:24:33.210
and in
575
00:24:33.210 --> 00:24:35.770
Andrew Dunkley: Australia, um, it's Bunnings and Mitre 10.
576
00:24:36.490 --> 00:24:39.450
And I know about Home Depot.
577
00:24:39.450 --> 00:24:41.490
I'll say it the American way. And there's
578
00:24:41.490 --> 00:24:43.010
probably a couple of others over there too.
579
00:24:43.010 --> 00:24:45.890
Yeah, we went into a Home Depot once just to
580
00:24:45.890 --> 00:24:48.770
have a look because we heard about them
581
00:24:48.770 --> 00:24:50.960
all on TV and seen them and, and I thought,
582
00:24:50.960 --> 00:24:52.560
we've got to check one of these out. Yeah,
583
00:24:52.560 --> 00:24:55.320
they're pretty cool. You can pretty well buy
584
00:24:55.320 --> 00:24:57.360
a house that's already made in a place like
585
00:24:57.360 --> 00:25:00.200
that. Um, Shumo, thanks for the question.
586
00:25:00.440 --> 00:25:03.080
Absolutely love that question. And, uh, yeah,
587
00:25:03.160 --> 00:25:06.160
um, I think common sense will prevail one
588
00:25:06.160 --> 00:25:08.680
day, but maybe, maybe not in the near future.
589
00:25:11.480 --> 00:25:13.720
Professor Fred Watson: 3, 2, 1.
590
00:25:14.360 --> 00:25:15.560
Gerwin: Space nuts.
591
00:25:16.210 --> 00:25:18.690
Andrew Dunkley: 1 more question. Let's hear from Steve.
592
00:25:19.570 --> 00:25:21.690
Steve: Hey, Andrew. Hey, Fred Watson. Steve here
593
00:25:21.690 --> 00:25:24.390
from the UK questionnaire for you. Um,
594
00:25:24.610 --> 00:25:27.330
if we put all the past
595
00:25:27.330 --> 00:25:29.770
scientists from history, I,
596
00:25:29.770 --> 00:25:32.650
Einstein, Hawkins, Newton, da Vinci, Maxwell,
597
00:25:32.650 --> 00:25:35.490
you can name a list of others, put them in a
598
00:25:35.490 --> 00:25:38.250
room with current scientists. Do you think
599
00:25:38.250 --> 00:25:41.250
they'd be all collectively be able to answer
600
00:25:41.250 --> 00:25:43.250
some of the greatest mysteries we have today,
601
00:25:43.250 --> 00:25:46.210
I. E. Dark matter, dark energy, with
602
00:25:46.210 --> 00:25:49.010
that collective genius. Anyway, keep up the
603
00:25:49.010 --> 00:25:50.810
great work. Love your show. Love to
604
00:25:50.810 --> 00:25:53.650
understand what your, uh, answers might
605
00:25:53.650 --> 00:25:53.930
be.
606
00:25:55.210 --> 00:25:57.690
Andrew Dunkley: Yeah, thank you so much, Steve. I love this
607
00:25:57.690 --> 00:26:00.570
question. I love hypotheticals. And, um,
608
00:26:01.050 --> 00:26:02.770
he brings up a really good point. There have
609
00:26:02.770 --> 00:26:05.690
been some incredibly bright people in history
610
00:26:06.090 --> 00:26:08.890
who've come up with theories and concepts,
611
00:26:08.890 --> 00:26:11.490
and, um, some of them still challenge
612
00:26:11.490 --> 00:26:14.130
science today. What if you got them all
613
00:26:14.130 --> 00:26:16.470
together, dug them up out of their respective
614
00:26:16.470 --> 00:26:18.710
graves and hit them with a couple of volts of
615
00:26:18.710 --> 00:26:20.390
electricity and brought them back to life and
616
00:26:20.390 --> 00:26:22.830
said, okay, you're all here together. Sorry
617
00:26:22.830 --> 00:26:25.830
about the Smell. Um, what do you
618
00:26:25.830 --> 00:26:28.510
reckon about this? Could they solve it all?
619
00:26:30.670 --> 00:26:33.110
Professor Fred Watson: It is a great question. Um,
620
00:26:33.470 --> 00:26:36.270
Steve, uh, I love your thinking on this.
621
00:26:36.950 --> 00:26:39.870
Um, in a way, the
622
00:26:40.520 --> 00:26:43.320
genius of all these people is
623
00:26:43.320 --> 00:26:46.000
preserved in their writings. It's
624
00:26:46.000 --> 00:26:48.840
preserved in the papers that they
625
00:26:48.840 --> 00:26:51.560
authored. If you think about it in modern
626
00:26:51.560 --> 00:26:54.400
terms, uh, or the books that they wrote, the
627
00:26:54.400 --> 00:26:56.520
things that
they wrote historically,
628
00:26:57.800 --> 00:27:00.600
that genius is all, in a way, still
629
00:27:00.600 --> 00:27:03.240
around, um, and
630
00:27:03.880 --> 00:27:06.850
maybe, um, individually,
631
00:27:07.760 --> 00:27:10.700
uh, if they'd been able to go on forever, uh,
632
00:27:10.700 --> 00:27:11.490
they might have
633
00:27:13.570 --> 00:27:15.610
thought through some breakthroughs. I'm
634
00:27:15.610 --> 00:27:18.210
thinking particularly of one person who was
635
00:27:18.690 --> 00:27:21.530
clearly a genius. He, uh, was contemporary
636
00:27:21.530 --> 00:27:24.490
with Newton, uh, and in fact, he
637
00:27:24.490 --> 00:27:27.410
was described as somebody whose, uh, depth
638
00:27:27.410 --> 00:27:29.690
and profundity of thought, particularly in
639
00:27:29.690 --> 00:27:32.410
mathematics. Uh, he made him the only person
640
00:27:32.410 --> 00:27:35.130
who could rival Newton at that time. And the
641
00:27:35.130 --> 00:27:37.590
reason why his name was, uh,
642
00:27:37.770 --> 00:27:39.930
James Gregory. He was a Scottish
643
00:27:40.250 --> 00:27:42.770
astronomer and mathematician. In fact, the
644
00:27:42.770 --> 00:27:45.370
university that I was educated, uh, at, at
645
00:27:45.370 --> 00:27:48.370
St. Andrews. Uh, but he died at the age
646
00:27:48.370 --> 00:27:51.330
of 36. And so, unlike Newton, who went on
647
00:27:51.330 --> 00:27:54.050
into his 80s, he, uh, died
648
00:27:54.050 --> 00:27:57.050
before, probably before his genius really had
649
00:27:57.130 --> 00:28:00.010
time to fully blossom. And so whether
650
00:28:00.650 --> 00:28:03.370
putting all these people together would,
651
00:28:03.770 --> 00:28:06.410
after you've flashed them with a few folds
652
00:28:06.650 --> 00:28:09.010
to bring them back to life, whether that
653
00:28:09.010 --> 00:28:11.810
would m. Be any different from any one of
654
00:28:11.810 --> 00:28:13.770
them having an extended
655
00:28:14.170 --> 00:28:16.530
lifetime that would have allowed their own
656
00:28:16.530 --> 00:28:19.500
genius to, um,
657
00:28:19.500 --> 00:28:21.730
arrive at different ideas, particularly on
658
00:28:21.730 --> 00:28:23.950
things like dark matter and dark energy. Uh,
659
00:28:24.010 --> 00:28:25.610
I don't know. I think that's a moot point.
660
00:28:25.610 --> 00:28:27.610
It's a good question. It is.
661
00:28:27.920 --> 00:28:30.890
Andrew Dunkley: Um, ChatGPT has some thoughts
662
00:28:30.890 --> 00:28:31.330
on this.
663
00:28:31.570 --> 00:28:32.810
Professor Fred Watson: Okay, that's interesting.
664
00:28:32.810 --> 00:28:35.290
Andrew Dunkley: Go for it. I said, if you could put all the
665
00:28:35.290 --> 00:28:37.370
geniuses in world history together in a room,
666
00:28:37.370 --> 00:28:39.850
could they collectively solve some of the
667
00:28:39.850 --> 00:28:42.290
riddles of the universe? Uh, it said
668
00:28:42.290 --> 00:28:44.730
absolutely, but probably not in the way we
669
00:28:44.730 --> 00:28:47.050
imagine. If you could somehow put Einstein,
670
00:28:47.050 --> 00:28:50.010
Newton, Darwin, Curie, and the list goes
671
00:28:50.010 --> 00:28:52.770
on. Turing, Hawking, et cetera, and
672
00:28:52.770 --> 00:28:54.850
dozens of other extraordinary minds in the
673
00:28:54.850 --> 00:28:56.890
same room, give them access to all the
674
00:28:56.890 --> 00:28:58.650
current scientific knowledge and somehow
675
00:28:58.650 --> 00:29:01.410
eliminate the practical constraints of time
676
00:29:01.410 --> 00:29:03.650
and communication. I think they could make
677
00:29:03.650 --> 00:29:06.170
enormous progress in some of the universe's
678
00:29:06.170 --> 00:29:08.530
deepest problems. But there is a fascinating
679
00:29:08.530 --> 00:29:11.250
catch. Intelligence alone doesn't
680
00:29:11.250 --> 00:29:12.450
guarantee an answer.
681
00:29:13.650 --> 00:29:15.570
Professor Fred Watson: No, that's right. Uh, some of those people
682
00:29:15.570 --> 00:29:17.570
were pretty difficult to get on with, like
683
00:29:17.570 --> 00:29:20.130
Newton. Um, the other thing.
684
00:29:20.930 --> 00:29:23.110
You know, I'm surprised, uh,
685
00:29:23.410 --> 00:29:25.370
GPT didn't just say, well, what about
686
00:29:25.370 --> 00:29:28.110
artificial intelligence? Because that, you
687
00:29:28.110 --> 00:29:29.470
know, that's where we're headed.
688
00:29:30.270 --> 00:29:32.430
Andrew Dunkley: I think chatgpt thinks it's human,
689
00:29:33.070 --> 00:29:35.980
the way it talks back to people. Um,
690
00:29:36.270 --> 00:29:37.990
it goes on to say some of the biggest
691
00:29:37.990 --> 00:29:40.830
mysteries may not be waiting for someone
692
00:29:40.830 --> 00:29:43.230
clever enough to solve them. They may require
693
00:29:43.230 --> 00:29:45.510
new concepts that humanity hasn't invented
694
00:29:45.510 --> 00:29:48.470
yet. So there's also why we
695
00:29:48.470 --> 00:29:49.470
can't figure things out.
696
00:29:50.430 --> 00:29:53.390
Professor Fred Watson: Yeah. And I mean I also,
697
00:29:54.080 --> 00:29:56.700
um, this is m perhaps
698
00:29:56.700 --> 00:29:59.060
controversial as a scientist, but there might
699
00:29:59.060 --> 00:30:00.380
be things that we can never understand
700
00:30:00.860 --> 00:30:03.260
because we simply don't have,
701
00:30:03.740 --> 00:30:06.220
um, the mental capacity to do that.
702
00:30:06.940 --> 00:30:08.700
Andrew Dunkley: Well, how do you explain,
703
00:30:09.820 --> 00:30:12.380
um, the tens of thousands of
704
00:30:12.380 --> 00:30:15.140
experiences of near death and people
705
00:30:15.140 --> 00:30:18.020
coming back with exactly the same stories
706
00:30:18.020 --> 00:30:20.700
and scenarios? How do you explain that?
707
00:30:21.570 --> 00:30:23.170
That's just beyond comprehension.
708
00:30:24.480 --> 00:30:26.890
Professor Fred Watson: Um, yes, it might be, but there might very
709
00:30:26.890 --> 00:30:28.570
well be physiological reasons why that
710
00:30:28.570 --> 00:30:28.810
happens.
711
00:30:28.810 --> 00:30:31.050
Andrew Dunkley: There could be. And that's one of the things
712
00:30:31.050 --> 00:30:33.650
that gets thrown up as a probability. Yeah,
713
00:30:34.290 --> 00:30:36.130
but it's interesting. It is interesting
714
00:30:36.210 --> 00:30:36.810
indeed.
715
00:30:36.810 --> 00:30:37.250
Professor Fred Watson: Yeah.
716
00:30:37.320 --> 00:30:38.360
Andrew Dunkley: M. Indeed.
717
00:30:38.360 --> 00:30:41.090
Professor Fred Watson: Um, that's a joyous note to end on, isn't it?
718
00:30:41.250 --> 00:30:43.890
Andrew Dunkley: Yeah, it is, but it's a great question,
719
00:30:43.890 --> 00:30:46.890
Steve, and, um, really worth looking
720
00:30:46.890 --> 00:30:49.410
into. But, uh, the AI
721
00:30:49.490 --> 00:30:52.130
platform I use says yeah, they probably would
722
00:30:52.130 --> 00:30:55.110
make inroads, but, um, maybe not in the way
723
00:30:55.110 --> 00:30:57.350
that you would expect. And as Fred Watson
724
00:30:57.350 --> 00:30:59.880
said, they didn't all like each other. Uh,
725
00:30:59.880 --> 00:31:02.390
and some of them were pretty prickly people
726
00:31:02.390 --> 00:31:04.670
in, you know, in their time.
727
00:31:05.550 --> 00:31:08.230
Um, and even today scientists
728
00:31:08.230 --> 00:31:10.190
still argue about the
729
00:31:11.070 --> 00:31:13.390
theories that Einstein came up with,
730
00:31:14.190 --> 00:31:16.690
um, relativity, et cetera. So, uh,
731
00:31:16.990 --> 00:31:19.670
the arguments and the analysis, they keep
732
00:31:19.670 --> 00:31:22.210
trying to break relativity and they can't,
733
00:31:23.490 --> 00:31:23.890
so.
734
00:31:24.130 --> 00:31:25.250
Professor Fred Watson: That's right. Yeah.
735
00:31:25.630 --> 00:31:28.330
Andrew Dunkley: M. It's fascinating. Really good
736
00:31:28.330 --> 00:31:28.690
question.
737
00:31:29.570 --> 00:31:32.130
Professor Fred Watson: Yeah, I mean, trying to break relativity
738
00:31:32.210 --> 00:31:35.210
is trying to see, you know, to what,
739
00:31:35.210 --> 00:31:37.490
because relativity is as good as it gets, but
740
00:31:37.490 --> 00:31:39.970
to see where its limits are, uh, because
741
00:31:39.970 --> 00:31:42.010
those limits might illuminate new physics and
742
00:31:42.010 --> 00:31:44.450
things that, as chatgpt said, we haven't
743
00:31:44.450 --> 00:31:45.250
thought of yet.
744
00:31:45.490 --> 00:31:47.610
Andrew Dunkley: Yeah, yeah. And I think that's got a lot to
745
00:31:47.610 --> 00:31:50.440
do with it. And uh, as you say, and
746
00:31:50.440 --> 00:31:52.880
it's probably true, there may be things we
747
00:31:52.880 --> 00:31:55.680
will never ever be able to figure out, like
748
00:31:57.440 --> 00:31:59.800
why the universe is expanding at an
749
00:31:59.800 --> 00:32:01.280
accelerating rate. Things like that.
750
00:32:01.280 --> 00:32:02.160
We may never know.
751
00:32:02.160 --> 00:32:05.080
Professor Fred Watson: Well, yeah, I do hope we can
752
00:32:05.080 --> 00:32:06.680
noble that one because that's such an
753
00:32:06.680 --> 00:32:09.040
intriguing question. Yeah, indeed.
754
00:32:09.200 --> 00:32:11.960
Andrew Dunkley: Thanks. Steve Schumo, Bob, uh, Galwin
755
00:32:11.960 --> 00:32:14.840
and everybody who sends in questions to us.
756
00:32:14.840 --> 00:32:17.840
You can do that too on our website spacenuts
757
00:32:18.000 --> 00:32:20.740
IO and just click, uh, on the Ask me
758
00:32:20.740 --> 00:32:23.180
anything button at the top it's labelled ama.
759
00:32:23.740 --> 00:32:25.820
And send your questions there in text or
760
00:32:25.820 --> 00:32:27.980
audio format. And don't forget to tell us who
761
00:32:27.980 --> 00:32:30.000
you are and where you're from and your, um,
762
00:32:30.180 --> 00:32:33.140
cousin's sister's brother's birthday date. We
763
00:32:33.140 --> 00:32:35.460
really need to know that and whatever, uh,
764
00:32:35.780 --> 00:32:37.220
else you want to tell us. And have a look
765
00:32:37.220 --> 00:32:39.020
around while you're there. And Fred Watson,
766
00:32:39.020 --> 00:32:40.380
thank you so much. It's been a great
767
00:32:40.380 --> 00:32:41.660
pleasure. Lots of fun too.
768
00:32:42.320 --> 00:32:44.480
Professor Fred Watson: Uh, indeed it has. Thanks, Andrew. Um, uh,
769
00:32:44.480 --> 00:32:46.310
great to talk and we'll catch up next time.
770
00:32:46.380 --> 00:32:48.420
Andrew Dunkley: Time we will. Professor Fred Watson Watson,
771
00:32:48.420 --> 00:32:50.580
astronomer at large. And thanks to Huw in the
772
00:32:50.580 --> 00:32:52.940
studio, who wasn't invited
773
00:32:53.340 --> 00:32:55.980
to a room full of geniuses, which is why he's
774
00:32:55.980 --> 00:32:58.540
not with us today. Boom. Got him.
775
00:32:58.860 --> 00:33:01.660
And from me, Andrew Dunkley, Why m am I here?
776
00:33:02.700 --> 00:33:04.260
Thanks for listening. We'll catch you on the
777
00:33:04.260 --> 00:33:06.140
next episode of Space Nuts.
778
00:33:06.140 --> 00:33:06.780
Professor Fred Watson: Bye. Bye.
779
00:33:08.220 --> 00:33:10.380
Andrew Dunkley: You've been listening to the Space Nuts
780
00:33:10.380 --> 00:33:12.950
podcast, available
781
00:33:13.110 --> 00:33:15.350
at Apple Podcasts, Spotify,
782
00:33:15.510 --> 00:33:18.270
iHeartRadio or your favourite podcast
783
00:33:18.270 --> 00:33:20.070
player. You can also stream on
784
00:33:20.070 --> 00:33:21.400
demand@bytes.com.
785
00:33:21.400 --> 00:33:24.070
Professor Fred Watson: um, this has been another quality podcast
786
00:33:24.070 --> 00:33:26.230
production from bytes.um com.