رونوشت 🔗
WEBVTT
Kind: captions
Language: en
00:00:00.080 --> 00:00:02.389
I was the guy in Santa Cruz who anytime
00:00:02.399 --> 00:00:04.870
my woowoo friends shared their mystical
00:00:04.880 --> 00:00:08.629
experiences, I would very kindly explain
00:00:08.639 --> 00:00:10.709
how there's confirmation bias going on.
00:00:10.719 --> 00:00:12.150
You know, I always knew the filters and
00:00:12.160 --> 00:00:14.470
how that how to explain it away. But
00:00:14.480 --> 00:00:18.630
this rocked me in a way that I couldn't
00:00:18.640 --> 00:00:20.470
at all understand how it happened. You
00:00:20.480 --> 00:00:22.630
know, I immediately emailed Daniel
00:00:22.640 --> 00:00:24.710
Dennett. He was an American philosopher
00:00:24.720 --> 00:00:26.390
just died. He was an a limitivist. So he
00:00:26.400 --> 00:00:28.230
he says consciousness is an illusion and
00:00:28.240 --> 00:00:30.630
all that. I emailed him and I told him,
00:00:30.640 --> 00:00:31.910
I just said, "Look, I love your stuff.
00:00:31.920 --> 00:00:33.750
You're kind of one of my main
00:00:33.760 --> 00:00:35.910
philosophers. Uh, this just happened." I
00:00:35.920 --> 00:00:37.510
described the dream. I described how it
00:00:37.520 --> 00:00:40.549
corresponded. And I said, "I just need
00:00:40.559 --> 00:00:42.869
to know from your point of view like
00:00:42.879 --> 00:00:45.270
what's going on." And he he says
00:00:45.280 --> 00:00:47.990
something like, "Well, Jeff, I think
00:00:48.000 --> 00:00:50.709
you're lying to me." He said, "I" he
00:00:50.719 --> 00:00:52.709
goes, "I either think it's a I think
00:00:52.719 --> 00:00:55.670
it's an incredible coincidence or I
00:00:55.680 --> 00:00:58.150
think you're lying to me." and got to
00:00:58.160 --> 00:01:00.229
run. Now imagine little postmodern me
00:01:00.239 --> 00:01:02.229
who believes everything's relative. All
00:01:02.239 --> 00:01:03.910
meaning is in a flux that's just based
00:01:03.920 --> 00:01:06.230
on contingencies. Like it suddenly
00:01:06.240 --> 00:01:09.510
brought me back to this notion.
00:01:09.520 --> 00:01:11.030
There's a ground. I don't know what it
00:01:11.040 --> 00:01:12.630
is. The mind is more mysterious than I
00:01:12.640 --> 00:01:15.830
think. And it gave me a new start.
00:01:15.840 --> 00:01:18.710
I I had hope. Go ahead, Jack. Say it.
00:01:18.720 --> 00:01:20.149
>> What's What's going on? What is this
00:01:20.159 --> 00:01:22.789
dream? What did I I missed a part? What
00:01:22.799 --> 00:01:24.149
What's happening here?
00:01:24.159 --> 00:01:31.035
>> I sat Okay, here's a dream.
00:01:31.045 --> 00:01:34.789
>> [music]
00:01:34.799 --> 00:01:36.870
>> Solomon and Smith.
00:01:36.880 --> 00:01:39.510
>> Welcome [snorts] to Solomon and Smith.
00:01:39.520 --> 00:01:43.670
I'm Jack Trrook and Ped. That is Milana.
00:01:43.680 --> 00:01:46.550
Neither one of us is Solomon or Smith,
00:01:46.560 --> 00:01:50.149
but together we are Solomon and Smith.
00:01:50.159 --> 00:01:53.429
Today you are about to witness a
00:01:53.439 --> 00:01:54.789
discussion [laughter]
00:01:54.799 --> 00:02:00.149
between the two of us and Jeff Felton
00:02:00.159 --> 00:02:03.429
or Felzone. The subject of the
00:02:03.439 --> 00:02:06.789
discussion is psychotherapy, the human
00:02:06.799 --> 00:02:10.469
mind. What is it? What's going on? Can
00:02:10.479 --> 00:02:12.869
psychotherapy cure anyone? Is it
00:02:12.879 --> 00:02:16.309
possible to cure a man or woman with
00:02:16.319 --> 00:02:18.869
psychotherapy? Why is it that when
00:02:18.879 --> 00:02:21.670
someone does this,
00:02:21.680 --> 00:02:23.910
they are far more curable from
00:02:23.920 --> 00:02:27.830
psychotherapy than if they don't do
00:02:27.840 --> 00:02:29.990
that? All this and more. But the thing
00:02:30.000 --> 00:02:32.869
about Jeff that surprised all people,
00:02:32.879 --> 00:02:35.910
including you, is um he's memorized
00:02:35.920 --> 00:02:38.790
every single Shakespeare set. And stay
00:02:38.800 --> 00:02:41.830
tuned for what is probably the strangest
00:02:41.840 --> 00:02:45.589
dream you've ever heard. We talk a great
00:02:45.599 --> 00:02:47.910
deal about dreams actually. We talked
00:02:47.920 --> 00:02:51.670
about lucid dreaming and the ability of
00:02:51.680 --> 00:02:59.350
dreams to sort of predict pred
00:02:59.360 --> 00:03:02.550
predict predict failing relationships
00:03:02.560 --> 00:03:05.270
and such things and and you know wookie
00:03:05.280 --> 00:03:07.910
dookie freaky mystical spiritual stuff.
00:03:07.920 --> 00:03:10.390
But Jeff was like a hardcore Daniel
00:03:10.400 --> 00:03:12.390
Dennit, postmodern,
00:03:12.400 --> 00:03:16.309
no truth anywhere but but evolutionary
00:03:16.319 --> 00:03:18.710
uh processes going on in the mind kind
00:03:18.720 --> 00:03:21.110
of guy who experienced some of these
00:03:21.120 --> 00:03:25.190
things and had his worldview a bit
00:03:25.200 --> 00:03:28.550
flipped around to allow entry of lots of
00:03:28.560 --> 00:03:31.030
uh things that are quite hard to fit
00:03:31.040 --> 00:03:35.030
into a hard materialist
00:03:35.040 --> 00:03:37.750
picture of the human mind. what it's
00:03:37.760 --> 00:03:40.229
capable of, what it does. This is I
00:03:40.239 --> 00:03:41.910
think this is a really good interview. I
00:03:41.920 --> 00:03:43.830
was watching some bits of it back. It's
00:03:43.840 --> 00:03:47.270
a it's a great conversation and really
00:03:47.280 --> 00:03:49.430
wide spanning. Have a look on the kind
00:03:49.440 --> 00:03:51.750
of timestamps down below if you want to
00:03:51.760 --> 00:03:53.830
skip the entire dreams part and just
00:03:53.840 --> 00:03:55.350
listen to the Shakespeare sonets part,
00:03:55.360 --> 00:03:57.750
but every part of it really fascinating.
00:03:57.760 --> 00:04:00.550
Jeff's a fascinating guy and really uh
00:04:00.560 --> 00:04:02.789
good fun to talk to. Really enjoyed this
00:04:02.799 --> 00:04:03.270
chat.
Load full transcript
00:04:03.280 --> 00:04:04.869
>> Yeah, don't take our word for it. Watch
00:04:04.879 --> 00:04:07.990
the video. Watch the whole video. I
00:04:08.000 --> 00:04:09.750
think a good uh good little tip for this
00:04:09.760 --> 00:04:11.350
video uh just keep an eye on the
00:04:11.360 --> 00:04:13.830
tongues. Every time a tongue is
00:04:13.840 --> 00:04:15.990
mentioned, lock that in the brain. It
00:04:16.000 --> 00:04:18.069
will come useful later as you go
00:04:18.079 --> 00:04:19.590
through. Maybe there'll be a tongue
00:04:19.600 --> 00:04:21.749
counter in the video. Depends if anyone
00:04:21.759 --> 00:04:23.430
can be bothered to edit that in. Keep an
00:04:23.440 --> 00:04:25.670
eye out for the tongue counter. Might
00:04:25.680 --> 00:04:29.030
not be there. [laughter]
00:04:29.040 --> 00:04:31.670
A really big one. like a huge graphic
00:04:31.680 --> 00:04:33.783
taking up a whole third of the screen.
00:04:33.793 --> 00:04:35.670
[laughter]
00:04:35.680 --> 00:04:37.749
>> Beautifully designed tongue counter.
00:04:37.759 --> 00:04:39.189
That's where all your Patreon money
00:04:39.199 --> 00:04:41.189
goes, folks.
00:04:41.199 --> 00:04:41.670
>> Yeah.
00:04:41.680 --> 00:04:43.430
>> Can't do it without you. And if it's not
00:04:43.440 --> 00:04:45.510
there, it's because not enough of you
00:04:45.520 --> 00:04:47.909
backed us when we needed it the most.
00:04:47.919 --> 00:04:49.430
And so, here you are. Video without a
00:04:49.440 --> 00:04:50.230
tongue counter.
00:04:50.240 --> 00:04:54.790
>> If you're new to the channel, hi.
00:04:54.800 --> 00:04:55.270
>> We do.
00:04:55.280 --> 00:04:58.150
>> How's it going? We we do we do beg for
00:04:58.160 --> 00:05:00.310
money at the beginning of every episode
00:05:00.320 --> 00:05:03.430
in a Patreon link down below. You gain
00:05:03.440 --> 00:05:08.070
access to extra material and to video
00:05:08.080 --> 00:05:12.790
calls with us to a Noah's Arc community
00:05:12.800 --> 00:05:15.703
being rescued from the deluge.
00:05:15.713 --> 00:05:17.270
[laughter]
00:05:17.280 --> 00:05:19.270
Just seeing myself the way I look, it
00:05:19.280 --> 00:05:20.390
makes me want to talk.
00:05:20.400 --> 00:05:21.990
>> You will be saved.
00:05:22.000 --> 00:05:25.590
>> We will save you. We will save you.
00:05:25.600 --> 00:05:29.029
Please like like this video and
00:05:29.039 --> 00:05:30.629
subscribe to the channel if you're not
00:05:30.639 --> 00:05:33.830
already. Leave a comment down below.
00:05:33.840 --> 00:05:34.790
>> Hello.
00:05:34.800 --> 00:05:37.350
>> Hey. Am I visible?
00:05:37.360 --> 00:05:38.710
>> You certainly are.
00:05:38.720 --> 00:05:39.590
>> Visible. Yeah.
00:05:39.600 --> 00:05:42.550
>> And a little giraffe figurine.
00:05:42.560 --> 00:05:45.749
And uh is that is that Ben Johnson I see
00:05:45.759 --> 00:05:46.310
over your
00:05:46.320 --> 00:05:48.230
>> Ben Johnson. Unbelievable. I wanted to
00:05:48.240 --> 00:05:49.670
be a little more
obscure. I didn't know
00:05:49.680 --> 00:05:51.749
you were going to [laughter] instantly
00:05:51.759 --> 00:05:55.029
infiltrate my room. sniped out. Wow,
00:05:55.039 --> 00:05:55.990
look at that.
00:05:56.000 --> 00:05:58.150
>> That has been Johnson. I've had to cover
00:05:58.160 --> 00:05:59.990
things up. This is all strategy and
00:06:00.000 --> 00:06:02.950
bluff. Please, [laughter] gentle.
00:06:02.960 --> 00:06:06.469
>> Yeah, yesterday was the hottest day in
00:06:06.479 --> 00:06:09.749
German history. I believe French history
00:06:09.759 --> 00:06:12.550
also. So, I don't know. I slept pretty
00:06:12.560 --> 00:06:15.430
badly. Did you sleep all right, Milo?
00:06:15.440 --> 00:06:19.749
>> So, only because the day prior I slept
00:06:19.759 --> 00:06:21.670
extremely poorly. Yeah.
00:06:21.680 --> 00:06:24.070
>> So pure exhaustion really just just
00:06:24.080 --> 00:06:26.550
knocked me out. But uh it's been it's
00:06:26.560 --> 00:06:29.029
been tough in Europe. The American will
00:06:29.039 --> 00:06:32.070
say puny temperatures. We encounter such
00:06:32.080 --> 00:06:34.959
temperatures on a leisurely stroll.
00:06:34.969 --> 00:06:35.830
[laughter] But no,
00:06:35.840 --> 00:06:38.070
>> I'll say this.
00:06:38.080 --> 00:06:40.550
>> Where I am, it's the humidity that
00:06:40.560 --> 00:06:42.950
destroys you. And I don't know where the
00:06:42.960 --> 00:06:44.550
what humidity is like in your world, but
00:06:44.560 --> 00:06:46.469
but like you can step outside and it's
00:06:46.479 --> 00:06:48.629
just 78 degrees and you're sweating from
00:06:48.639 --> 00:06:51.670
the humidity. It's like walking into a
00:06:51.680 --> 00:06:53.990
body. This is the thing that bothers me
00:06:54.000 --> 00:06:56.629
about it. It's warmer than my the inside
00:06:56.639 --> 00:06:59.510
of my body. So, it's like walking into
00:06:59.520 --> 00:07:02.150
somebody else's body, which I'm very
00:07:02.160 --> 00:07:04.710
against. That doesn't sound right to me.
00:07:04.720 --> 00:07:06.309
I'm not [laughter]
00:07:06.319 --> 00:07:09.589
>> That's the theme today.
00:07:09.599 --> 00:07:12.150
>> No, exactly. And oh and it's whenever
00:07:12.160 --> 00:07:14.550
Germany win a football game people drive
00:07:14.560 --> 00:07:16.550
around with their cars and like honk
00:07:16.560 --> 00:07:19.270
their horns continuously for like you
00:07:19.280 --> 00:07:22.309
know hours. It's like you beat Ghana,
00:07:22.319 --> 00:07:24.629
you know, you beat Kurissau,
00:07:24.639 --> 00:07:28.230
you beat like, you know, there's only 11
00:07:28.240 --> 00:07:31.270
Ghanaian who have heard of football or
00:07:31.280 --> 00:07:34.230
whatever you soccer ball football.
00:07:34.240 --> 00:07:35.670
>> I know. I know.
00:07:35.680 --> 00:07:37.830
>> I like the American I've invented a new
00:07:37.840 --> 00:07:39.909
game played almost entirely with the
00:07:39.919 --> 00:07:42.950
hands. [laughter] I got a great name for
00:07:42.960 --> 00:07:43.830
it.
00:07:43.840 --> 00:07:45.510
>> I know. I know. I'm going to tell you a
00:07:45.520 --> 00:07:46.870
little bit about my relationship with
00:07:46.880 --> 00:07:48.950
American football later, but um
00:07:48.960 --> 00:07:50.390
>> we could start with that. We could start
00:07:50.400 --> 00:07:51.990
with your relationship with American
00:07:52.000 --> 00:07:52.870
football.
00:07:52.880 --> 00:07:54.950
>> Tell us, Jeff. [laughter]
00:07:54.960 --> 00:07:57.029
>> To to tack on what you just said, uh
00:07:57.039 --> 00:07:59.430
here in America, we're going crazy
00:07:59.440 --> 00:08:01.990
because it's the first time we've had a
00:08:02.000 --> 00:08:05.589
football team that actually plays in a
00:08:05.599 --> 00:08:07.670
somewhat organized fashion. It's been
00:08:07.680 --> 00:08:09.270
interesting. I grew up playing soccer,
00:08:09.280 --> 00:08:11.189
football. it's going to come out. But I
00:08:11.199 --> 00:08:13.589
I grew up playing it and uh we've never
00:08:13.599 --> 00:08:15.270
had anything like this where the team
00:08:15.280 --> 00:08:17.830
actually at least is tricking us into
00:08:17.840 --> 00:08:20.070
thinking there's some real skills out
00:08:20.080 --> 00:08:20.469
there.
00:08:20.479 --> 00:08:22.390
>> Yeah. I'm just going to
00:08:22.400 --> 00:08:26.790
>> until we start playing one of you guys.
00:08:26.800 --> 00:08:27.510
>> Yeah. I mean,
00:08:27.520 --> 00:08:29.670
>> yeah, I there was some great headlines
00:08:29.680 --> 00:08:32.790
on the the match where USA and England
00:08:32.800 --> 00:08:35.670
drew and like the New York Post enormous
00:08:35.680 --> 00:08:38.070
victory, greatest day in America. And
00:08:38.080 --> 00:08:40.070
it's it's a 1-1 draw, but [laughter]
00:08:40.080 --> 00:08:43.190
they were and it did feel shameful over
00:08:43.200 --> 00:08:45.110
here, I have to say. So, they were they
00:08:45.120 --> 00:08:47.030
were on to something.
00:08:47.040 --> 00:08:49.670
>> No, I understand. So, um we can just I
00:08:49.680 --> 00:08:51.750
know you guys just do conversation. So,
00:08:51.760 --> 00:08:54.790
I will I'll just start with what how
00:08:54.800 --> 00:08:57.350
that connects to American soccer and
00:08:57.360 --> 00:09:00.070
football and uh it does connect to
00:09:00.080 --> 00:09:02.150
literature in a way that I often think
00:09:02.160 --> 00:09:06.070
about when I'm in the tub. Um,
00:09:06.080 --> 00:09:09.030
>> is that a euphemism of
00:09:09.040 --> 00:09:10.851
>> You're gonna have to find out.
00:09:10.861 --> 00:09:11.829
[laughter]
00:09:11.839 --> 00:09:13.990
>> I I I I think, and this is that thing
00:09:14.000 --> 00:09:16.949
that happens linguistically. I think I'm
00:09:16.959 --> 00:09:19.350
already doing a strange awkward
00:09:19.360 --> 00:09:23.509
mirroring. I never say tub. I [laughter]
00:09:23.519 --> 00:09:26.389
So, I think unconsciously I'm already in
00:09:26.399 --> 00:09:28.310
the
land of delusionally mirroring what
00:09:28.320 --> 00:09:31.509
I think you [laughter] might have said.
00:09:31.519 --> 00:09:33.190
>> We're all saying that.
00:09:33.200 --> 00:09:35.750
>> Yeah. be funny if you you just jump into
00:09:35.760 --> 00:09:37.706
I wonder by my trough what you
00:09:37.716 --> 00:09:40.470
[laughter] two fellows
00:09:40.480 --> 00:09:42.949
>> that would be well yeah and uh you know
00:09:42.959 --> 00:09:45.350
my one of my things coming on to your
00:09:45.360 --> 00:09:47.110
podcast which I'm just so in love with
00:09:47.120 --> 00:09:48.790
it happened so quickly it came into me
00:09:48.800 --> 00:09:51.110
through David Bentley Hart but then just
00:09:51.120 --> 00:09:53.590
I've been having a blast watching the
00:09:53.600 --> 00:09:55.350
episodes and I want to say it's
00:09:55.360 --> 00:09:58.230
intimidating because what your viewers
00:09:58.240 --> 00:10:00.230
may already be learning about me but not
00:10:00.240 --> 00:10:02.790
yet it'll come out
00:10:02.800 --> 00:10:05.269
>> is Very compromising indeed. [laughter]
00:10:05.279 --> 00:10:10.870
>> It's like I envy the kind of brains that
00:10:10.880 --> 00:10:13.190
not only can love literature, soak it
00:10:13.200 --> 00:10:15.670
up, read it, but can categorize and
00:10:15.680 --> 00:10:17.509
remember. That's the key word, remember.
00:10:17.519 --> 00:10:19.430
So for me, I I read a lot. I love it.
00:10:19.440 --> 00:10:20.949
But like, here's a game we're going to
00:10:20.959 --> 00:10:22.710
play. When you guys do one of your
00:10:22.720 --> 00:10:25.030
incredible illusions or references, and
00:10:25.040 --> 00:10:27.509
you're kind of laughing at each other, I
00:10:27.519 --> 00:10:29.829
will occasionally purposely fake wink
00:10:29.839 --> 00:10:32.790
wink. And it's the viewer's job to find
00:10:32.800 --> 00:10:35.430
out like when was Jeff pretending to go
00:10:35.440 --> 00:10:36.949
along with it and when was Jeff just
00:10:36.959 --> 00:10:39.030
like you know um actually there. So
00:10:39.040 --> 00:10:39.670
that's one little
00:10:39.680 --> 00:10:41.350
>> Yeah, we'll put a a scorecard up
00:10:41.360 --> 00:10:42.949
somewhere on [laughter] the on the
00:10:42.959 --> 00:10:44.870
screen.
00:10:44.880 --> 00:10:49.190
>> Yes. Okay. So with that said um Okay. So
00:10:49.200 --> 00:10:50.870
I grew up playing I'm going to say
00:10:50.880 --> 00:10:52.310
soccer for this context because it
00:10:52.320 --> 00:10:53.670
really
00:10:53.680 --> 00:10:55.670
>> most of our most of our audience are
00:10:55.680 --> 00:10:57.910
also your side of the pond. So let's you
00:10:57.920 --> 00:11:01.910
know let's submit. Thank you, David. Uh
00:11:01.920 --> 00:11:04.470
I think David drew in a bunch of us,
00:11:04.480 --> 00:11:04.949
right?
00:11:04.959 --> 00:11:06.230
>> No, that's true.
00:11:06.240 --> 00:11:10.230
>> Okay. Um Okay. So, I grew up playing
00:11:10.240 --> 00:11:12.550
soccer. I was decent.
My brother was
00:11:12.560 --> 00:11:15.110
very good. And but I grew up in a town,
00:11:15.120 --> 00:11:18.310
Jefferson City, Missouri, where our
00:11:18.320 --> 00:11:21.990
football team, American football, was so
00:11:22.000 --> 00:11:23.590
good. We would win the big state
00:11:23.600 --> 00:11:25.509
championships every year. And the entire
00:11:25.519 --> 00:11:27.190
town, it was all about American
00:11:27.200 --> 00:11:29.910
football, American football. And um so
00:11:29.920 --> 00:11:32.790
us soccer players were just peeons like
00:11:32.800 --> 00:11:35.190
nobody respected us. And so I remember
00:11:35.200 --> 00:11:38.710
in 8th grade we were I was out in a PE
00:11:38.720 --> 00:11:40.310
class and we were playing some sport out
00:11:40.320 --> 00:11:42.870
in a field and I I got a little brash
00:11:42.880 --> 00:11:45.670
and I was like you know
00:11:45.680 --> 00:11:48.389
soccer players are better athletes than
00:11:48.399 --> 00:11:50.069
American football players. They're just
00:11:50.079 --> 00:11:51.509
better athletes in general. And it
00:11:51.519 --> 00:11:55.350
started this huge debate. How could I
00:11:55.360 --> 00:11:57.910
say that? And I just got, you know, they
00:11:57.920 --> 00:12:00.550
they came at me on full cylinders. So
00:12:00.560 --> 00:12:02.550
that the next day I started thinking
00:12:02.560 --> 00:12:05.750
like, how can I claim that we're in
00:12:05.760 --> 00:12:07.829
general better athletes? And I slowly
00:12:07.839 --> 00:12:09.750
developed this notion of the obstacle
00:12:09.760 --> 00:12:12.870
course where like if you create an
00:12:12.880 --> 00:12:15.269
obstacle course that requires enough
00:12:15.279 --> 00:12:18.310
skill sets of any sport you can imagine,
00:12:18.320 --> 00:12:21.670
right? And then you run the different
00:12:21.680 --> 00:12:23.269
teams at my high school through that
00:12:23.279 --> 00:12:25.750
obstacle course. My claim would be the
00:12:25.760 --> 00:12:28.710
soccer players will on average have the
00:12:28.720 --> 00:12:30.310
fastest times getting through that
00:12:30.320 --> 00:12:34.550
course. Right? Is there a logic to that?
00:12:34.560 --> 00:12:36.790
>> I can see where you're going with this.
00:12:36.800 --> 00:12:39.110
So that was my I thought as a little
00:12:39.120 --> 00:12:41.190
eighth grader I thought I had found a
00:12:41.200 --> 00:12:45.030
scientific formula for like proving that
00:12:45.040 --> 00:12:46.550
you know soccer players are the best
00:12:46.560 --> 00:12:48.150
athletes cuz in general they're going to
00:12:48.160 --> 00:12:49.990
they have the most skill sets that could
00:12:50.000 --> 00:12:53.590
be applied to they might not push the
00:12:53.600 --> 00:12:55.190
barrier as hard as the big football
00:12:55.200 --> 00:12:57.110
player can push it but they'll they'll
00:12:57.120 --> 00:12:58.550
slow down on that part of the obstacle
00:12:58.560 --> 00:13:00.230
course but they'll speed up
on most of
00:13:00.240 --> 00:13:03.190
the others. So, I came back to school
00:13:03.200 --> 00:13:05.430
with that theory and I didn't win the
00:13:05.440 --> 00:13:09.910
debate, but it did make them pause.
00:13:09.920 --> 00:13:11.430
>> A worthy victory.
00:13:11.440 --> 00:13:13.430
>> It was a worthy victory.
00:13:13.440 --> 00:13:17.350
>> And so then as I got older, I noticed
00:13:17.360 --> 00:13:20.949
that I can't stop reading Nabokov's um
00:13:20.959 --> 00:13:24.150
The Gift, his novel, The Gift. And have
00:13:24.160 --> 00:13:25.269
either of you read that one?
00:13:25.279 --> 00:13:26.629
>> I have not. No.
00:13:26.639 --> 00:13:26.949
>> Okay.
00:13:26.959 --> 00:13:30.310
>> No, not done The Gift. And I read it a
00:13:30.320 --> 00:13:32.710
lot. And one time when I was reading it,
00:13:32.720 --> 00:13:35.430
I was just struck by, you know what
00:13:35.440 --> 00:13:37.430
happens when you're having an aesthetic
00:13:37.440 --> 00:13:39.990
moment of bliss. I was in that state.
00:13:40.000 --> 00:13:41.750
And I went to my little immature mind
00:13:41.760 --> 00:13:43.990
and I was like, this is the best. This
00:13:44.000 --> 00:13:45.670
is the best novel. I did that thing. I
00:13:45.680 --> 00:13:47.110
think we all do sometimes when you're in
00:13:47.120 --> 00:13:49.110
that state, like how could somebody have
00:13:49.120 --> 00:13:52.150
created this? And then my little
00:13:52.160 --> 00:13:54.790
metaphor for sports came in of this
00:13:54.800 --> 00:13:56.150
obstacle course. And I thought, how
00:13:56.160 --> 00:13:58.550
could we prove if aliens came down
00:13:58.560 --> 00:14:00.389
today? And they said, "Hand me one
00:14:00.399 --> 00:14:02.389
novel, just one, and we're going to
00:14:02.399 --> 00:14:04.310
decide whether we destroy you or not."
00:14:04.320 --> 00:14:07.590
And the criteria is it has to be a novel
00:14:07.600 --> 00:14:10.550
that shows us the most of what human
00:14:10.560 --> 00:14:13.269
beings are capable of in the novel form.
00:14:13.279 --> 00:14:15.590
I then started noticing that the novels
00:14:15.600 --> 00:14:17.110
that I would hand to the aliens wouldn't
00:14:17.120 --> 00:14:18.389
be my favorite ones necessarily because
00:14:18.399 --> 00:14:20.870
The Gift isn't my favorite Nabokov
00:14:20.880 --> 00:14:23.430
novel. I probably like Pale Fire and
00:14:23.440 --> 00:14:26.629
Pinion better, but I did realize the
00:14:26.639 --> 00:14:28.150
book that you would have to hand the
00:14:28.160 --> 00:14:29.910
aliens would tend to be the kind of
00:14:29.920 --> 00:14:32.949
novel that does a lot of different makes
00:14:32.959 --> 00:14:34.310
a lot of different moves.
00:14:34.320 --> 00:14:37.750
>> Yeah. Holistic, like a novel that just
00:14:37.760 --> 00:14:40.470
um pushes the edge of the pages a little
00:14:40.480 --> 00:14:41.110
bit.
00:14:41.120 --> 00:14:41.350
>> Yeah.
00:14:41.360 --> 00:14:43.189
>> I don't know. Well, maybe the aliens
00:14:43.199 --> 00:14:45.189
would just be into numbers and stuff.
00:14:45.199 --> 00:14:49.030
It's hard to I I think I I really do
00:14:49.040 --> 00:14:50.949
tend toward the theory that human
00:14:50.959 --> 00:14:54.949
aesthetics is really limited to humans.
00:14:54.959 --> 00:14:57.590
I don't I'm not very um music of the
00:14:57.600 --> 00:15:00.069
spheresbased. I think most of the things
00:15:00.079 --> 00:15:02.550
we consider most beautiful are
00:15:02.560 --> 00:15:05.509
>> really based on arbitrary facts of our
00:15:05.519 --> 00:15:06.790
anatomy
00:15:06.800 --> 00:15:11.829
>> and our planet and and our biology. I
00:15:11.839 --> 00:15:15.829
don't think that um most human beauty
00:15:15.839 --> 00:15:17.430
most of our reactions to beauty are
00:15:17.440 --> 00:15:20.949
things that um could be communicated to
00:15:20.959 --> 00:15:22.870
beings on other planets.
00:15:22.880 --> 00:15:24.310
>> Right.
00:15:24.320 --> 00:15:26.470
>> I've got two just Yeah, I've got two
00:15:26.480 --> 00:15:28.550
thoughts on that. The first of which I
00:15:28.560 --> 00:15:30.550
think I give the aliens war of the
00:15:30.560 --> 00:15:32.310
worlds just to freak him out a little
00:15:32.320 --> 00:15:34.230
bit. [laughter] Say, "Hey, think about
00:15:34.240 --> 00:15:36.710
it, guys. Think about it. You might have
00:15:36.720 --> 00:15:38.710
superior technology, but what of germ
00:15:38.720 --> 00:15:40.150
theory?" H
00:15:40.160 --> 00:15:41.269
>> Yes. Okay.
00:15:41.279 --> 00:15:43.509
>> And [laughter] and second thought after
00:15:43.519 --> 00:15:45.350
freaking them out, there are some
00:15:45.360 --> 00:15:47.430
interesting that that I've noticed at
00:15:47.440 --> 00:15:50.310
least sort of crossovers between human
00:15:50.320 --> 00:15:54.150
concepts of aesthetic beauty and the the
00:15:54.160 --> 00:15:57.189
wider sort of uh panel of life. And I
00:15:57.199 --> 00:15:58.870
noticed this while watching David
00:15:58.880 --> 00:16:00.870
Atenburgh's first life on Earth, that
00:16:00.880 --> 00:16:04.069
1970s uh landmark documentary, he was
00:16:04.079 --> 00:16:05.829
talking about how the sort of um
00:16:05.839 --> 00:16:08.710
simultaneous evolution of flowers and
00:16:08.720 --> 00:16:12.230
the various insects that feed on flowers
00:16:12.240 --> 00:16:15.110
in order to cross-pollinate and so on.
00:16:15.120 --> 00:16:17.990
And that flowers made their magnificent
00:16:18.000 --> 00:16:20.310
shapes in a way as landing pads, in a
00:16:20.320 --> 00:16:23.829
way to invite insects to uh interact
00:16:23.839 --> 00:16:25.350
with them in a certain sometimes very
00:16:25.360 --> 00:16:27.829
specific way. But essentially from a
00:16:27.839 --> 00:16:30.710
fly's point of view, the most alluring,
00:16:30.720 --> 00:16:32.150
maybe we don't say beautiful, but the
00:16:32.160 --> 00:16:34.790
most alluring shapes on the planet are
00:16:34.800 --> 00:16:36.949
these kind of outward flowing petals.
00:16:36.959 --> 00:16:39.110
And I found it a surprising quite
00:16:39.120 --> 00:16:41.749
shocking commonality that we humans who
00:16:41.759 --> 00:16:44.790
have nothing to do with flowers. We have
00:16:44.800 --> 00:16:46.389
nothing practical to do with them. And
00:16:46.399 --> 00:16:48.069
we don't share a common like we share a
00:16:48.079 --> 00:16:50.230
common ancestor with insects, but we are
00:16:50.240 --> 00:16:52.389
not actually derived from them. So the
00:16:52.399 --> 00:16:54.629
flowers and insects that relationship
00:16:54.639 --> 00:16:58.230
grew not to do with our direct ancestry.
00:16:58.240 --> 00:17:01.749
>> And yet we just as life forms somehow
00:17:01.759 --> 00:17:04.710
share this delightful appreciation for
00:17:04.720 --> 00:17:08.470
us useless for them extremely useful of
00:17:08.480 --> 00:17:10.789
these just these plants that are in many
00:17:10.799 --> 00:17:12.549
colors and shapes. And I just thought
00:17:12.559 --> 00:17:14.230
that was a remarkable maybe it's a
00:17:14.240 --> 00:17:16.390
coincidence but to have something in
00:17:16.400 --> 00:17:18.470
common with the housefly quite
00:17:18.480 --> 00:17:20.870
profoundly to really like flower is the
00:17:20.880 --> 00:17:23.750
most common metaphor for beauty in in
00:17:23.760 --> 00:17:25.590
Shakespeare's sonets for example which
00:17:25.600 --> 00:17:27.909
we will get to eventually but that that
00:17:27.919 --> 00:17:29.430
struck me and I'm not sure if this means
00:17:29.440 --> 00:17:30.950
the the aliens will probably come down
00:17:30.960 --> 00:17:33.430
and look at the mud and think wow
00:17:33.440 --> 00:17:37.270
>> look at that m [laughter] you've got
00:17:37.280 --> 00:17:39.190
nothing as good as this when they come
00:17:39.200 --> 00:17:42.630
from the flower planet but Mud grows out
00:17:42.640 --> 00:17:44.470
of the flowers. Their whole planet's
00:17:44.480 --> 00:17:47.190
made out of petals and then just filth
00:17:47.200 --> 00:17:49.270
emerges and it blows them away and then
00:17:49.280 --> 00:17:52.310
they come here and it blows backwards.
00:17:52.320 --> 00:17:53.029
Yeah,
00:17:53.039 --> 00:17:55.510
>> I've got a I've got a good I've just um
00:17:55.520 --> 00:17:58.950
I found a an epigraph poem. I thought we
00:17:58.960 --> 00:18:00.390
should, you know, I should just for
00:18:00.400 --> 00:18:01.990
form's sake it would be good to start
00:18:02.000 --> 00:18:04.310
with a poetic epigraph, but let's go
00:18:04.320 --> 00:18:06.470
back into this. This is fantastic. This
00:18:06.480 --> 00:18:08.549
is a fantastic
00:18:08.559 --> 00:18:11.350
line. Um,
00:18:11.360 --> 00:18:14.950
men evolved from apes into stones as
00:18:14.960 --> 00:18:17.750
sugar evolved into the tongue. We stare
00:18:17.760 --> 00:18:20.549
at the conveyor belt revolving glucose
00:18:20.559 --> 00:18:24.070
and dung. The room dissolves. The mind
00:18:24.080 --> 00:18:27.590
alone is
unconscious. But unconscious of
00:18:27.600 --> 00:18:31.270
what? The world was created by being
00:18:31.280 --> 00:18:35.190
destroyed. wreaking souls froth forth
00:18:35.200 --> 00:18:38.710
from the void and leech black bliss from
00:18:38.720 --> 00:18:42.150
its pulsating abyss.
00:18:42.160 --> 00:18:43.669
That's it.
00:18:43.679 --> 00:18:46.070
>> Hold on. I'm going to do what most of
00:18:46.080 --> 00:18:48.310
your uh guests do in this moment. They
00:18:48.320 --> 00:18:52.230
go they pause and they go where where
00:18:52.240 --> 00:18:54.710
did you get that?
00:18:54.720 --> 00:18:56.710
>> Where'd that come from?
00:18:56.720 --> 00:18:59.430
>> Just um I don't know what's the funniest
00:18:59.440 --> 00:19:01.830
answer. I need a I need a pat funny
00:19:01.840 --> 00:19:03.590
funny answer. It is me.
00:19:03.600 --> 00:19:05.909
>> It is me. But I I like the idea of
00:19:05.919 --> 00:19:07.750
having a funny
00:19:07.760 --> 00:19:10.710
>> I knowandom random word generation.
00:19:10.720 --> 00:19:11.909
Yeah. But
00:19:11.919 --> 00:19:14.230
>> edit it in. Edit it in. Go back and then
00:19:14.240 --> 00:19:15.750
edit in a really witty [laughter]
00:19:15.760 --> 00:19:18.230
response there
00:19:18.240 --> 00:19:20.150
>> in a completely different outfit. The
00:19:20.160 --> 00:19:22.390
clock behind the shot has gone seven
00:19:22.400 --> 00:19:23.750
hours onwards.
00:19:23.760 --> 00:19:25.990
>> Damn. Funny you should say so, Jeff.
00:19:26.000 --> 00:19:26.470
>> Yeah.
00:19:26.480 --> 00:19:29.350
>> Yeah. But it's fascinating how much is
00:19:29.360 --> 00:19:31.510
how much of what we most treasure, what
00:19:31.520 --> 00:19:34.710
we find most beautiful is pointless. Um,
00:19:34.720 --> 00:19:36.549
stars come to mind for me. I'm very
00:19:36.559 --> 00:19:39.350
astrally inclined when it comes to
00:19:39.360 --> 00:19:42.150
beauty. The moon, the constellations,
00:19:42.160 --> 00:19:45.350
the Milky Way. Uh, sunsets, clouds,
00:19:45.360 --> 00:19:47.430
things like that. None of which really
00:19:47.440 --> 00:19:49.190
have that much to do with me. I can't
00:19:49.200 --> 00:19:51.190
really interact with them. It's
00:19:51.200 --> 00:19:54.470
impossible to explain that tendency
00:19:54.480 --> 00:19:57.990
through a kind of reductive evolutionary
00:19:58.000 --> 00:20:00.470
theory. Um, even if it's even if it's
00:20:00.480 --> 00:20:02.549
misplaced, it's misplaced from a very
00:20:02.559 --> 00:20:05.669
very deep ancestral rooe. Like it's it's
00:20:05.679 --> 00:20:07.270
going back to the point where me and the
00:20:07.280 --> 00:20:10.630
flies are the same blob, you know? So,
00:20:10.640 --> 00:20:12.789
it's it's it's a as deep as anything can
00:20:12.799 --> 00:20:14.789
be while still being a biological
00:20:14.799 --> 00:20:17.190
organism.
00:20:17.200 --> 00:20:19.029
>> Evolution. Can you say the line again?
00:20:19.039 --> 00:20:20.549
Just the part the at the top
where you
00:20:20.559 --> 00:20:21.909
said the thing about the tongue. The
00:20:21.919 --> 00:20:23.830
sugar the tongue sugar becomes the
00:20:23.840 --> 00:20:24.230
tongue.
00:20:24.240 --> 00:20:28.390
>> Yeah. Men evolved from apes into stones
00:20:28.400 --> 00:20:31.750
as sugar evolved into the tongue.
00:20:31.760 --> 00:20:33.350
>> Okay. So the first half I have to
00:20:33.360 --> 00:20:35.510
bracket because that that twisted my
00:20:35.520 --> 00:20:40.070
brain. Um into stone gets me like oh wow
00:20:40.080 --> 00:20:42.950
I have to go there. But the tongue and
00:20:42.960 --> 00:20:45.190
the sugar is beautiful. It reminds me of
00:20:45.200 --> 00:20:47.830
um I I I went through a phase. I still
00:20:47.840 --> 00:20:49.830
am in it in terms of when I'm trying to
00:20:49.840 --> 00:20:53.350
think of evolution and where I stand and
00:20:53.360 --> 00:20:55.590
how I feel about it. I I really dove
00:20:55.600 --> 00:20:57.909
into Gerta's scientific works for a
00:20:57.919 --> 00:20:59.590
while to to start thinking about the
00:20:59.600 --> 00:21:01.270
wholeness of nature and is there a way
00:21:01.280 --> 00:21:03.750
that we get to keep everything we love
00:21:03.760 --> 00:21:05.669
from neodyarwinism
00:21:05.679 --> 00:21:07.990
and yet if we replace the mechanistic
00:21:08.000 --> 00:21:09.990
metaphor can we see that there's a
00:21:10.000 --> 00:21:12.789
coming into being that's not from the
00:21:12.799 --> 00:21:14.870
outside you know that's not from a being
00:21:14.880 --> 00:21:17.830
saying now now the caterpillar will you
00:21:17.840 --> 00:21:19.990
know grow one more leg it's it's it's a
00:21:20.000 --> 00:21:22.070
coming into being so that's sort of my
00:21:22.080 --> 00:21:24.950
general question But I think it was
00:21:24.960 --> 00:21:29.110
Gerta or somebody who said um
00:21:29.120 --> 00:21:31.430
wrote a beautiful passage where it's
00:21:31.440 --> 00:21:34.950
talking about the sun becomes the eye
00:21:34.960 --> 00:21:36.549
>> and I don't know it's in there somewhere
00:21:36.559 --> 00:21:38.549
but your image of the sugar in the
00:21:38.559 --> 00:21:40.149
tongue really brought me back to that.
00:21:40.159 --> 00:21:42.149
Also,
00:21:42.159 --> 00:21:44.549
our our origin story is that I emailed
00:21:44.559 --> 00:21:46.630
you because of one of your epigraphs and
00:21:46.640 --> 00:21:49.190
I demanded to you send it to me and you
00:21:49.200 --> 00:21:51.830
were very generous and sent it to me and
00:21:51.840 --> 00:21:53.750
now I've been hearing dozens and I want
00:21:53.760 --> 00:21:57.029
you you have to publish these.
00:21:57.039 --> 00:21:59.669
>> You got any friends in powerful places?
00:21:59.679 --> 00:22:01.190
>> I'm still I I [laughter]
00:22:01.200 --> 00:22:03.190
tap a few shoulders, but come on. Maybe
00:22:03.200 --> 00:22:06.070
a cool like very broad opening question,
00:22:06.080 --> 00:22:11.190
Jeff, is um what is a psych? What is a
00:22:11.200 --> 00:22:13.350
human mind?
00:22:13.360 --> 00:22:16.230
>> Gosh.
00:22:16.240 --> 00:22:18.549
>> You mean to tell me you don't know?
00:22:18.559 --> 00:22:21.430
>> I don't know.
00:22:21.440 --> 00:22:23.990
>> It's I know it whatever it is. When I
00:22:24.000 --> 00:22:25.830
turned about 13, it just began to
00:22:25.840 --> 00:22:29.190
fascinate me. Um, do there used to be
00:22:29.200 --> 00:22:30.630
this thing where they'd show you this
00:22:30.640 --> 00:22:33.029
image of a tongue, a human tongue, and
00:22:33.039 --> 00:22:35.669
then they would show parts of the tongue
00:22:35.679 --> 00:22:38.070
that one tastes the sweet part, this is
00:22:38.080 --> 00:22:39.750
the sour part, this is the bitter part.
00:22:39.760 --> 00:22:41.830
Now I think that's been I think they
00:22:41.840 --> 00:22:43.909
they no longer show that image but when
00:22:43.919 --> 00:22:45.990
I was in fifth grade that's the first
00:22:46.000 --> 00:22:49.830
memory I have of becoming fixated and
00:22:49.840 --> 00:22:52.070
fascinated with who we are and what is a
00:22:52.080 --> 00:22:54.470
mind and like wait so the tongue this
00:22:54.480 --> 00:22:58.710
spatial this spatial thing has parts
00:22:58.720 --> 00:23:01.190
that relate to this inner experience
00:23:01.200 --> 00:23:02.789
blew me away I didn't have words for it
00:23:02.799 --> 00:23:05.430
but that was my first probably felt here
00:23:05.440 --> 00:23:07.190
we'll get into the Eugene Genlin stuff
00:23:07.200 --> 00:23:10.070
my felt sense of of the mind was
00:23:10.080 --> 00:23:11.750
probably being born right then that
00:23:11.760 --> 00:23:14.470
there's a structure an exterior and an
00:23:14.480 --> 00:23:16.789
interior and they have an amazing
00:23:16.799 --> 00:23:18.470
relationship.
00:23:18.480 --> 00:23:20.470
Um, and that's what that's what started
00:23:20.480 --> 00:23:23.909
my question of like who are we? What how
00:23:23.919 --> 00:23:25.669
does this happen?
00:23:25.679 --> 00:23:27.510
>> Do you remember what specifically was
00:23:27.520 --> 00:23:29.270
was fascinating? Was it mostly the
00:23:29.280 --> 00:23:31.029
spatial thing or was it like the idea of
00:23:31.039 --> 00:23:33.510
oh sweetness? What is that exactly? How
00:23:33.520 --> 00:23:35.909
would you begin to qualify? Yeah,
00:23:35.919 --> 00:23:37.430
>> the first thing you said it was the
00:23:37.440 --> 00:23:39.830
spatial part because I think our teacher
00:23:39.840 --> 00:23:42.149
even brought in now now that they've I
00:23:42.159 --> 00:23:43.510
think they've proven this isn't true,
00:23:43.520 --> 00:23:45.510
but he he hypnotized us with this
00:23:45.520 --> 00:23:47.669
because he brought in different flavors.
00:23:47.679 --> 00:23:49.990
And I re we all really felt like
00:23:50.000 --> 00:23:51.909
>> you taste more sweet on this part of the
00:23:51.919 --> 00:23:53.830
tongue, you taste more bitter. Or if you
00:23:53.840 --> 00:23:55.350
put the
bitter part on the tip of the
00:23:55.360 --> 00:23:56.310
tongue, you don't really taste
00:23:56.320 --> 00:23:59.110
bitterness. And it worked because that,
00:23:59.120 --> 00:24:01.270
you know, that was my experience and
00:24:01.280 --> 00:24:02.789
that was what fascinated me. something
00:24:02.799 --> 00:24:05.029
about the um yeah, I I think it was the
00:24:05.039 --> 00:24:06.789
relation between oh my gosh, I just I
00:24:06.799 --> 00:24:08.230
never thought of my tongue before and
00:24:08.240 --> 00:24:10.549
now someone's showing me segments of it
00:24:10.559 --> 00:24:13.669
that relate to these really profound
00:24:13.679 --> 00:24:15.830
inner experiences. And
00:24:15.840 --> 00:24:18.710
>> do you remember I I just on the picture
00:24:18.720 --> 00:24:20.070
specifically, do you remember first
00:24:20.080 --> 00:24:22.310
seeing one of those like bisections of
00:24:22.320 --> 00:24:25.110
the brain which attempts the same thing
00:24:25.120 --> 00:24:27.590
and sort of puts your deep instincts
00:24:27.600 --> 00:24:31.029
here and sexual thoughts back there and
00:24:31.039 --> 00:24:33.669
artistic genius this sort of thing.
00:24:33.679 --> 00:24:37.510
>> Yes. Later I I would see those later. Um
00:24:37.520 --> 00:24:39.029
and and I would have a similar
00:24:39.039 --> 00:24:41.909
experience. But then um the moment that
00:24:41.919 --> 00:24:44.470
really threw me into studying like I
00:24:44.480 --> 00:24:45.990
started in fifth grade I just was
00:24:46.000 --> 00:24:47.510
fascinated by it and I don't remember
00:24:47.520 --> 00:24:49.110
anything else. I didn't read any more
00:24:49.120 --> 00:24:52.149
about it. But two years later
00:24:52.159 --> 00:24:55.430
uh our we grew up in a Methodist church
00:24:55.440 --> 00:24:59.430
but two parents who are mildly Methodist
00:24:59.440 --> 00:25:03.430
I'd say. Um and we had the minister's
00:25:03.440 --> 00:25:07.350
daughter babysitting us. Um, and she was
00:25:07.360 --> 00:25:09.350
trying to convince me to go to this
00:25:09.360 --> 00:25:11.110
weekend workshop where they teach us
00:25:11.120 --> 00:25:12.549
better communication. We were little
00:25:12.559 --> 00:25:14.870
seventh graders and like and we my
00:25:14.880 --> 00:25:16.390
brother and I just weren't having it.
00:25:16.400 --> 00:25:19.110
And he ran downstairs and then right as
00:25:19.120 --> 00:25:20.789
I was about to run downstairs, she said,
00:25:20.799 --> 00:25:23.110
"Hey, Jeff, if you come to this
00:25:23.120 --> 00:25:25.990
workshop, we'll teach you how to look at
00:25:26.000 --> 00:25:27.669
where your brother's eyes are moving
00:25:27.679 --> 00:25:30.149
when he's thinking or talking, and you
00:25:30.159 --> 00:25:31.909
can see if he's lying or telling you the
00:25:31.919 --> 00:25:33.029
truth."
00:25:33.039 --> 00:25:36.710
So for me having an older brother who
00:25:36.720 --> 00:25:39.430
dominated me intellectually, physically
00:25:39.440 --> 00:25:41.269
and we we had a good relationship that
00:25:41.279 --> 00:25:44.310
was like all it took and that that got
00:25:44.320 --> 00:25:48.470
me to start reading um in and trying to
00:25:48.480 --> 00:25:49.750
understand from that point of view. went
00:25:49.760 --> 00:25:52.070
to the workshop. I learned it comes from
00:25:52.080 --> 00:25:53.510
this thing called neural linguistic
00:25:53.520 --> 00:25:56.310
programming, which is a a I would think
00:25:56.320 --> 00:25:59.110
it's a pop psychology fad that's still
00:25:59.120 --> 00:26:01.590
going on and I think it's a lot of its
00:26:01.600 --> 00:26:04.149
bunk, but that thing about the eye
00:26:04.159 --> 00:26:07.029
movements has some validity and it was
00:26:07.039 --> 00:26:08.710
really cool. So, that started me down
00:26:08.720 --> 00:26:10.549
the track, but it was a very mechanistic
00:26:10.559 --> 00:26:12.549
track of the mind that I had to pop out
00:26:12.559 --> 00:26:16.310
of in college. I I really I I only
00:26:16.320 --> 00:26:18.070
thought of the mind as like, oh, it's so
00:26:18.080 --> 00:26:19.990
cool. You can like change your inner
00:26:20.000 --> 00:26:21.909
subjective experiences and there's no
00:26:21.919 --> 00:26:23.590
more suffering because that's kind of
00:26:23.600 --> 00:26:25.669
what this form of therapy would do. It
00:26:25.679 --> 00:26:28.870
would just have the client go inside,
00:26:28.880 --> 00:26:30.470
change the colors and the brightness,
00:26:30.480 --> 00:26:31.830
move things around, and then they're
00:26:31.840 --> 00:26:34.149
feeling happy. And that was that was its
00:26:34.159 --> 00:26:37.430
like cure. And I did all of that, but I
00:26:37.440 --> 00:26:41.029
I grew very skeptical as time went on.
00:26:41.039 --> 00:26:42.789
>> Interesting that it's all very embodied.
00:26:42.799 --> 00:26:45.830
your first interest in in psychology.
00:26:45.840 --> 00:26:47.909
It's it's it's it's starting with the
00:26:47.919 --> 00:26:50.390
tongue and then presumably going to
00:26:50.400 --> 00:26:53.510
other body parts. You can prod something
00:26:53.520 --> 00:26:55.110
something and feel something when you
00:26:55.120 --> 00:26:57.750
pro something and and then um going
00:26:57.760 --> 00:27:01.669
towards all these Yeah. Um mentalist
00:27:01.679 --> 00:27:02.710
hypnotist
00:27:02.720 --> 00:27:03.110
>> Yeah.
00:27:03.120 --> 00:27:05.990
>> style um eye movement behavior things.
00:27:06.000 --> 00:27:08.789
Was it was it all were you conscious of
00:27:08.799 --> 00:27:10.390
this at the time? It was just the the
00:27:10.400 --> 00:27:13.578
this um relationship between mind and
00:27:13.588 --> 00:27:15.750
[clears throat] body or was it
00:27:15.760 --> 00:27:17.669
>> not right away but then when you start
00:27:17.679 --> 00:27:19.590
read once you start reading the the the
00:27:19.600 --> 00:27:21.750
the people I was reading at the time
00:27:21.760 --> 00:27:26.070
first in NLP they do
start um there was
00:27:26.080 --> 00:27:28.710
this wizard guy his name was Milton
00:27:28.720 --> 00:27:31.669
Ericson and he was an old by the time I
00:27:31.679 --> 00:27:33.430
was learning about him he was an old man
00:27:33.440 --> 00:27:35.669
in a wheelchair who lived in Arizona but
00:27:35.679 --> 00:27:38.390
he was the hypnotist that people from
00:27:38.400 --> 00:27:39.830
all over the world would send their
00:27:39.840 --> 00:27:43.750
hardest clients and he became I mean
00:27:43.760 --> 00:27:46.070
just imagine a 13-year-old boy I'm I'm
00:27:46.080 --> 00:27:47.830
loving then this wizard and he'd wear
00:27:47.840 --> 00:27:49.990
purple a lot and he couldn't talk well
00:27:50.000 --> 00:27:52.070
because he'd had a lot of strokes and so
00:27:52.080 --> 00:27:54.310
he had this weird draw when he would
00:27:54.320 --> 00:27:56.950
talk and he was incredible at hypnosis
00:27:56.960 --> 00:27:59.510
and he and he changed he was the person
00:27:59.520 --> 00:28:01.830
that in the 60s remember how typically
00:28:01.840 --> 00:28:04.389
hypnosis in the beginning was like you
00:28:04.399 --> 00:28:06.870
are going into a trance
00:28:06.880 --> 00:28:09.190
>> you are feeling yourself yeah as You're
00:28:09.200 --> 00:28:11.029
very suggestible, Milo. [laughter]
00:28:11.039 --> 00:28:13.269
>> Whoa. Where was I?
00:28:13.279 --> 00:28:15.110
>> It's three hours later. Okay. It was
00:28:15.120 --> 00:28:18.789
great to talk with you, [laughter] Jeff.
00:28:18.799 --> 00:28:22.070
>> Milo's very successful. [laughter]
00:28:22.080 --> 00:28:25.629
>> Why did I buy all of these stocks?
00:28:25.639 --> 00:28:26.149
[laughter]
00:28:26.159 --> 00:28:29.510
>> So, um, so Milton Ericson was the first
00:28:29.520 --> 00:28:31.430
hypnotist that didn't do any of that
00:28:31.440 --> 00:28:33.990
stuff. He just talked to people and then
00:28:34.000 --> 00:28:35.830
they would be in a state where he would
00:28:35.840 --> 00:28:39.350
do his work. and um and he would get
00:28:39.360 --> 00:28:41.110
good great results and he was a magician
00:28:41.120 --> 00:28:43.269
and I fell into that too. Now you can
00:28:43.279 --> 00:28:45.590
hear in my voice. I eventually fell out
00:28:45.600 --> 00:28:48.389
of it because I have new ideas of what
00:28:48.399 --> 00:28:50.230
the healing was h what actually was
00:28:50.240 --> 00:28:52.630
happening during the healings. But at
00:28:52.640 --> 00:28:54.710
the time it was just to answer your
00:28:54.720 --> 00:28:57.669
question Jack um I wasn't thinking of
00:28:57.679 --> 00:29:01.830
the sense of the embodiment part. But um
00:29:01.840 --> 00:29:04.230
by the nature of who I was reading they
00:29:04.240 --> 00:29:05.430
were going more and more in that
00:29:05.440 --> 00:29:06.950
direction. And then as we'll get to
00:29:06.960 --> 00:29:09.350
Eugene Jenlin his whole thing is the
00:29:09.360 --> 00:29:12.470
embodiment aspect.
00:29:12.480 --> 00:29:17.110
I I'm curious how how much hypnotistism
00:29:17.120 --> 00:29:20.389
actually works because it's so so deeply
00:29:20.399 --> 00:29:23.510
rooted in kind of um in pop psychology
00:29:23.520 --> 00:29:25.590
but also kind of conspiracy culture
00:29:25.600 --> 00:29:27.669
>> as well, you know, MK Ultra
00:29:27.679 --> 00:29:30.149
reprogramming all of this stuff. It's so
00:29:30.159 --> 00:29:31.990
it's so deeply embedded in this kind of
00:29:32.000 --> 00:29:33.669
discourse that it's
00:29:33.679 --> 00:29:35.990
>> um as often in this kind of world kind
00:29:36.000 --> 00:29:38.950
of hard to tell what has uh truth in it
00:29:38.960 --> 00:29:41.909
and what doesn't. Like how much do do we
00:29:41.919 --> 00:29:44.389
know about hypnotism, about the extent
00:29:44.399 --> 00:29:46.310
of hypnotism? What's actually possible?
00:29:46.320 --> 00:29:49.110
Like Obi-Wan Kenobi levels of
00:29:49.120 --> 00:29:53.830
>> um credits will do fine. Does this work?
00:29:53.840 --> 00:29:55.669
>> Okay, that's such a good question. And I
00:29:55.679 --> 00:29:57.110
think the safest answer is I think at
00:29:57.120 --> 00:29:58.870
this point
00:29:58.880 --> 00:30:00.389
I think what you're hearing a lot these
00:30:00.399 --> 00:30:02.230
days from research and people in the
00:30:02.240 --> 00:30:04.870
field and practicing is that you can do
00:30:04.880 --> 00:30:06.549
some I mean I have friends that I have a
00:30:06.559 --> 00:30:10.470
friend who is um overeating and all the
00:30:10.480 --> 00:30:12.230
time his whole life and then went to one
00:30:12.240 --> 00:30:14.549
hypnotic session and for the next six
00:30:14.559 --> 00:30:18.310
months just he would he'd be s he'd have
00:30:18.320 --> 00:30:20.070
a plate of food in front of him. He'd
00:30:20.080 --> 00:30:22.149
eat some of it and then he'd feel just
00:30:22.159 --> 00:30:25.590
feel I'm done. And he was a perfect
00:30:25.600 --> 00:30:27.430
example of what I'm about to say because
00:30:27.440 --> 00:30:30.070
it lasted 6 months and then he'd go back
00:30:30.080 --> 00:30:32.230
to the hypnotist and it would last me
00:30:32.240 --> 00:30:34.149
four months. Then you go back to the
00:30:34.159 --> 00:30:35.350
hypnotist and it would last three
00:30:35.360 --> 00:30:37.590
months. And that is I think in general
00:30:37.600 --> 00:30:39.350
something they're noticing is that you
00:30:39.360 --> 00:30:41.269
can get some pretty cool effects that
00:30:41.279 --> 00:30:43.510
are like shocking even more than that.
00:30:43.520 --> 00:30:45.590
like with you can induce positive
00:30:45.600 --> 00:30:46.789
hallucinations and negative
00:30:46.799 --> 00:30:48.630
hallucinations
00:30:48.640 --> 00:30:52.070
but I think what's happening is more of
00:30:52.080 --> 00:30:55.029
what the o the older psychonamic
00:30:55.039 --> 00:30:57.510
therapists would call a transfer cure
00:30:57.520 --> 00:31:00.470
that it's not so much the mechanism
00:31:00.480 -->
00:31:05.110
that's curing it's a tangle of needs
00:31:05.120 --> 00:31:06.710
happening in the exchange between the
00:31:06.720 --> 00:31:09.110
therapist and the client in which this
00:31:09.120 --> 00:31:11.110
is too simplistic to please the
00:31:11.120 --> 00:31:13.669
therapist your mind changes you though.
00:31:13.679 --> 00:31:16.070
Um, that's way too simplistic. But I
00:31:16.080 --> 00:31:18.230
think that when I was having success
00:31:18.240 --> 00:31:20.070
getting rid of people's phobias, I'd get
00:31:20.080 --> 00:31:22.549
rid of people's phobias in seven minutes
00:31:22.559 --> 00:31:25.750
doing these these things. I think what's
00:31:25.760 --> 00:31:27.830
happening is not so much a neurological
00:31:27.840 --> 00:31:30.230
reorganization as something that has to
00:31:30.240 --> 00:31:32.070
do with the transference of expectations
00:31:32.080 --> 00:31:34.630
and the power of needing something to
00:31:34.640 --> 00:31:36.149
happen.
00:31:36.159 --> 00:31:39.350
And it sort of ties into that sort of I
00:31:39.360 --> 00:31:40.789
guess common place, but the sort of
00:31:40.799 --> 00:31:44.149
power of belief or the power of faith
00:31:44.159 --> 00:31:46.470
and the placebo effect more generally
00:31:46.480 --> 00:31:49.190
that really somehow and the mechanisms
00:31:49.200 --> 00:31:51.190
seem very obscure to me. But if you
00:31:51.200 --> 00:31:52.950
really truly believe that something is
00:31:52.960 --> 00:31:55.110
happening to you, then it can often in
00:31:55.120 --> 00:31:57.269
quite surprisingly physical ways happen
00:31:57.279 --> 00:31:59.909
to you and that bounces off into the
00:31:59.919 --> 00:32:01.750
sort of madness of manifestation. But
00:32:01.760 --> 00:32:03.190
there is a degree to which it is
00:32:03.200 --> 00:32:05.509
scientifically true that if you just
00:32:05.519 --> 00:32:07.750
believe this illness either is here or
00:32:07.760 --> 00:32:09.909
isn't here that you can or can't. It's
00:32:09.919 --> 00:32:11.750
just that is your and it's astounding
00:32:11.760 --> 00:32:13.509
just how that's possible.
00:32:13.519 --> 00:32:15.190
>> It's amazing and you can really you can
00:32:15.200 --> 00:32:17.110
see when people are pushing needles
00:32:17.120 --> 00:32:18.950
through finger I mean you see examples
00:32:18.960 --> 00:32:21.430
of how this happens. Now Milton Ericson
00:32:21.440 --> 00:32:25.029
the wizard um he could do stuff like he
00:32:25.039 --> 00:32:27.350
would do people were amazed at what he
00:32:27.360 --> 00:32:28.870
could accomplish in what's called time
00:32:28.880 --> 00:32:31.110
distortion with his clients. So like and
00:32:31.120 --> 00:32:32.630
there they're I mean just from a
00:32:32.640 --> 00:32:34.070
literature point of view reading
00:32:34.080 --> 00:32:35.909
transcripts of his transances with
00:32:35.919 --> 00:32:38.070
people and the language of what he's how
00:32:38.080 --> 00:32:40.789
he's using metaphor and simile and
00:32:40.799 --> 00:32:43.669
distracting it's really amazing but he
00:32:43.679 --> 00:32:47.430
could get his clients to sometimes
00:32:47.440 --> 00:32:49.190
have the experience. I remember I think
00:32:49.200 --> 00:32:51.190
one I read was like he told the client
00:32:51.200 --> 00:32:52.470
when they were in a deep trance that
00:32:52.480 --> 00:32:55.110
there's a giant bag of marbles and
00:32:55.120 --> 00:32:57.509
you're going to pull a marble out and
00:32:57.519 --> 00:32:58.789
this is going to take you know it's
00:32:58.799 --> 00:33:00.870
going to take a long time. But he also
00:33:00.880 --> 00:33:04.230
then told them in his way you know
00:33:04.240 --> 00:33:06.630
there's only four minutes to do this.
00:33:06.640 --> 00:33:08.710
So, some of these clients when they come
00:33:08.720 --> 00:33:10.950
out of the trance and they're told to
00:33:10.960 --> 00:33:14.070
describe what happened, they're like, "I
00:33:14.080 --> 00:33:18.549
spent 5 hours pulling marbles out out of
00:33:18.559 --> 00:33:20.710
this bag." And then they can't believe
00:33:20.720 --> 00:33:22.149
that they were there for three minutes
00:33:22.159 --> 00:33:23.669
doing it. But, you know, there was no
00:33:23.679 --> 00:33:26.070
drugs involved. So, it just is a it's a
00:33:26.080 --> 00:33:28.230
sign that yeah, the mind is capable of
00:33:28.240 --> 00:33:30.870
phenomenal phenomenologies.
00:33:30.880 --> 00:33:34.070
Um, yeah.
00:33:34.080 --> 00:33:35.590
>> Yeah. It reminds me of dreams a little.
00:33:35.600 --> 00:33:38.070
I mean the dream time dilation thing I
00:33:38.080 --> 00:33:39.750
think at least from what I've read more
00:33:39.760 --> 00:33:42.630
recently isn't quite as people believed
00:33:42.640 --> 00:33:44.310
often if because there's a lot of
00:33:44.320 --> 00:33:45.750
jumping in dreams right you're in one
00:33:45.760 --> 00:33:47.110
place and another and then you saw oh
00:33:47.120 --> 00:33:48.789
that must have taken a while but in
00:33:48.799 --> 00:33:50.789
terms of actually how long have you been
00:33:50.799 --> 00:33:53.509
doing things about six seven hours okay
00:33:53.519 --> 00:33:55.029
that tracks
00:33:55.039 --> 00:33:57.750
>> but the notion at least that in a dream
00:33:57.760 --> 00:34:00.310
you can have sort of you know days or or
00:34:00.320 --> 00:34:03.029
weeks worth of mental experience yeah
00:34:03.039 --> 00:34:05.590
>> which then converts into you know 8 hour
00:34:05.600 --> 00:34:07.990
night in in several sections.
00:34:08.000 --> 00:34:09.349
>> Yeah. And what's interesting about that
00:34:09.359 --> 00:34:12.230
is I actually uh the first scientific
00:34:12.240 --> 00:34:14.069
science paper I had to write, you know,
00:34:14.079 --> 00:34:16.069
where we had to go to a library and pick
00:34:16.079 --> 00:34:19.270
out stuff was on lucid dreaming. Um and
00:34:19.280 --> 00:34:21.270
I was a third grader. Yeah. Right around
00:34:21.280 -->
00:34:23.750
the time of the tongue thing. I I I I
00:34:23.760 --> 00:34:25.829
read a bunch of stuff on lucid dreaming
00:34:25.839 --> 00:34:28.629
and I I had my first lucid dream just by
00:34:28.639 --> 00:34:30.629
reading the articles, you know, and I
00:34:30.639 --> 00:34:32.470
had my first like waking up in my dream
00:34:32.480 --> 00:34:35.270
that I was dreaming. And since then,
00:34:35.280 --> 00:34:36.869
about 10 years ago, I decided just to
00:34:36.879 --> 00:34:38.389
give myself two months of actually doing
00:34:38.399 --> 00:34:40.550
the practices for lucid dreaming. And
00:34:40.560 --> 00:34:44.869
that was an amazing year, you know, but
00:34:44.879 --> 00:34:46.629
the research shows in lucid dreams,
00:34:46.639 --> 00:34:48.869
people track time wonderfully. Like when
00:34:48.879 --> 00:34:51.109
you're in the dream and you're playing
00:34:51.119 --> 00:34:54.069
football and you you do it, you mostly
00:34:54.079 --> 00:34:55.829
can always report back exactly how long
00:34:55.839 --> 00:34:57.430
you were actually there. But in the
00:34:57.440 --> 00:35:01.109
normal REMM sleep, it's we don't guess
00:35:01.119 --> 00:35:03.589
it quite as well, but we're pretty good.
00:35:03.599 --> 00:35:05.109
It's very rare to have the thing you're
00:35:05.119 --> 00:35:06.550
talking about where someone just has a
00:35:06.560 --> 00:35:07.670
normal night of sleep and feels like
00:35:07.680 --> 00:35:10.550
their dream went on for uh a week or
00:35:10.560 --> 00:35:12.790
something, you know?
00:35:12.800 --> 00:35:14.230
>> Yeah. And while we're on the subject,
00:35:14.240 --> 00:35:15.910
just just interested in in lucid
00:35:15.920 --> 00:35:19.349
dreaming generally. Is is the hype real?
00:35:19.359 --> 00:35:21.430
Why isn't everyone doing it? Why aren't
00:35:21.440 --> 00:35:24.550
we a society based on going to sleep and
00:35:24.560 --> 00:35:27.030
and sort of floating around in the ether
00:35:27.040 --> 00:35:28.950
realms and then we wake up and just like
00:35:28.960 --> 00:35:31.430
subsistence drinking fluids. All right,
00:35:31.440 --> 00:35:34.069
back I'm back in bed. Why is this not
00:35:34.079 --> 00:35:35.109
happen? Because it
00:35:35.119 --> 00:35:37.190
>> Boon well was famously asked by a
00:35:37.200 --> 00:35:39.589
journalist uh you know if you knew you
00:35:39.599 --> 00:35:42.630
had uh um 30 years to live what would
00:35:42.640 --> 00:35:44.230
you do with them? And he said I'd spend
00:35:44.240 --> 00:35:47.990
29 years dreaming. Ah
00:35:48.000 --> 00:35:50.630
>> there we go. But that's a great question
00:35:50.640 --> 00:35:54.069
and I would say um have have you ever
00:35:54.079 --> 00:35:56.069
have you do you know the basic two
00:35:56.079 --> 00:35:57.990
practices to train yourself to lucid
00:35:58.000 --> 00:35:59.430
dream?
00:35:59.440 --> 00:36:00.790
>> You can tell audience
00:36:00.800 --> 00:36:03.430
>> the the sort of picking up I know the
00:36:03.440
--> 00:36:06.150
one about picking up certain habits like
00:36:06.160 --> 00:36:08.069
counting fingers or or if you have a
00:36:08.079 --> 00:36:09.510
watch always check the watch because
00:36:09.520 --> 00:36:11.270
these things are likely to be
00:36:11.280 --> 00:36:12.550
>> something like this.
00:36:12.560 --> 00:36:14.710
>> Yeah. The main one that can sometimes
00:36:14.720 --> 00:36:16.150
just hearing someone say this can
00:36:16.160 --> 00:36:18.470
sometimes like people I I'll talk about
00:36:18.480 --> 00:36:20.150
lucid dreams when I was at work at the
00:36:20.160 --> 00:36:21.990
Shakespeare festival and that just
00:36:22.000 --> 00:36:24.069
talking about it people would come back
00:36:24.079 --> 00:36:25.030
a few days [laughter] later and be like
00:36:25.040 --> 00:36:27.510
I had my first lucid dream. Um which
00:36:27.520 --> 00:36:29.349
again shows that like there's more going
00:36:29.359 --> 00:36:31.750
on in these conversations. But the
00:36:31.760 --> 00:36:34.230
practice that I think is pretty cool.
00:36:34.240 --> 00:36:35.910
It's first to realize this. It shocked
00:36:35.920 --> 00:36:37.990
me when I it's a simple sentence. When
00:36:38.000 --> 00:36:41.030
we're dreaming we believe we're awake.
00:36:41.040 --> 00:36:43.670
like that's simple. But for me, when I
00:36:43.680 --> 00:36:45.270
first actually thought about it, it kind
00:36:45.280 --> 00:36:47.030
of blew a circuit in me because it's
00:36:47.040 --> 00:36:49.270
like, yeah, there's actively the belief.
00:36:49.280 --> 00:36:51.510
There's actively the belief when I'm
00:36:51.520 --> 00:36:53.670
looking at the tiger in the dream that
00:36:53.680 --> 00:36:55.670
I'm awake and I'm seeing a tiger to some
00:36:55.680 --> 00:36:59.910
degree. So, the main practice in lucid
00:36:59.920 --> 00:37:02.150
dreaming that I think does something is
00:37:02.160 --> 00:37:04.950
you start going through your day and
00:37:04.960 --> 00:37:06.630
every time you see something a little
00:37:06.640 --> 00:37:08.870
bit weird, a woman walks by in a dress
00:37:08.880 --> 00:37:11.670
that's got stars on it or a dog, three
00:37:11.680 --> 00:37:13.109
dogs run across the street barking at
00:37:13.119 --> 00:37:14.550
each other, just anything that's like,
00:37:14.560 --> 00:37:18.390
whoa, you stop and you you convince
00:37:18.400 --> 00:37:19.670
yourself that this qu you're really
00:37:19.680 --> 00:37:22.310
asking this question. Hey, wait. Am I
00:37:22.320 --> 00:37:24.870
dreaming right now? And then after you
00:37:24.880 --> 00:37:26.310
ask yourself that question, you look at
00:37:26.320 --> 00:37:28.950
your hand, move it around, or some
00:37:28.960 --> 00:37:31.750
people poke it. And if something weird
00:37:31.760 --> 00:37:33.270
doesn't happen, if you just touch your
00:37:33.280 --> 00:37:35.829
hand or your fingers look normal, you
00:37:35.839 --> 00:37:39.430
go, "Oh no, I'm awake." You do that 12
00:37:39.440 --> 00:37:41.510
times a day. So you're building this
00:37:41.520 --> 00:37:44.550
habit of like, "Wait, am I dreaming?"
00:37:44.560 --> 00:37:46.630
And then you do this action and nothing
00:37:46.640 --> 00:37:49.270
weird happens. I'm awake. So then in
00:37:49.280 --> 00:37:50.550
your dream, if you're doing dream
00:37:50.560 --> 00:37:51.750
journaling and stuff, this, you know,
00:37:51.760 --> 00:37:53.910
you'll see a weird thing in your dream,
00:37:53.920 --> 00:37:55.670
you'll push your hand in front of your
00:37:55.680 --> 00:37:57.430
face and you'll say, "Am I dreaming?"
00:37:57.440 --> 00:38:00.069
And it's invariably you'll have six
00:38:00.079 --> 00:38:02.230
fingers or when you push your hand, your
00:38:02.240 --> 00:38:03.670
finger goes, you know, something weird
00:38:03.680 --> 00:38:06.550
happens. And then your mind goes, "Oh,
00:38:06.560 --> 00:38:10.069
I'm dreaming." And that's that's when I
00:38:10.079 --> 00:38:12.310
when I first had my first like system
00:38:12.320 --> 00:38:14.390
systematic lucid dream. It was that
00:38:14.400 --> 00:38:17.349
moment of going, "Oh, this is all a
00:38:17.359 --> 00:38:18.950
dream around me." And that was one of
00:38:18.960 --> 00:38:21.349
the I don't I don't do psychedelics. And
00:38:21.359 --> 00:38:23.829
that was one of the wildest experiences.
00:38:23.839 --> 00:38:25.349
And I just looked around at all these
00:38:25.359 --> 00:38:27.910
trees. It was a forest going up a
00:38:27.920 --> 00:38:31.190
mountain. And I just looked at them all
00:38:31.200 --> 00:38:34.230
and said, "My mind, that's my mind." And
00:38:34.240 --> 00:38:36.470
it it was very very startling. But then
00:38:36.480 --> 00:38:37.829
I stopped doing the practices after a
00:38:37.839 --> 00:38:39.829
while and now I just randomly have them.
00:38:39.839 --> 00:38:41.349
But for a while they were happening
00:38:41.359 --> 00:38:42.710
throughout the week.
00:38:42.720 --> 00:38:44.550
>> They're very exhausting if you continue
00:38:44.560 --> 00:38:46.310
having them for a prolonged period of
00:38:46.320 --> 00:38:48.150
time. That was an issue as well. Like I,
00:38:48.160 --> 00:38:49.589
you know, it's more important to feel
00:38:49.599 --> 00:38:50.870
well rested.
00:38:50.880 --> 00:38:52.550
>> And
00:38:52.560 --> 00:38:55.030
normal consciousness is also
00:38:55.040 --> 00:38:56.390
unbelievable.
00:38:56.400 --> 00:38:56.870
>> Yep.
00:38:56.880 --> 00:38:59.270
>> Like normal consciousness is completely
00:38:59.280 --> 00:39:01.670
insane. It's out of this world.
00:39:01.680 --> 00:39:03.750
>> I mean Yeah. But there's a there's
00:39:03.760 --> 00:39:05.750
another consciousness in inside you
00:39:05.760 --> 00:39:08.870
where you get to do everything. Is it as
00:39:08.880 --> 00:39:11.510
good as real? I don't know.
00:39:11.520 --> 00:39:13.190
>> I think it's nice. I think it's nice to
00:39:13.200 --> 00:39:14.870
taste it. But I'm with you. Like what I
00:39:14.880 --> 00:39:16.630
don't like is there's such a grift
00:39:16.640 --> 00:39:18.310
around lucid dreaming now. If you look
00:39:18.320 --> 00:39:20.310
it up online or something, it's always
00:39:20.320 --> 00:39:22.710
teachers telling you, you know, now that
00:39:22.720 --> 00:39:24.069
you can lucid dream, you're going to
00:39:24.079 --> 00:39:26.230
unlock your capac. It's it's it's just
00:39:26.240 --> 00:39:27.349
all [ __ ]
00:39:27.359 --> 00:39:30.550
>> Yeah. I just used it just for sex. That
00:39:30.560 --> 00:39:33.510
was my I was like immediately right. And
00:39:33.520 --> 00:39:35.829
often it's annoying cuz like [laughter]
00:39:35.839 --> 00:39:38.470
the it needs to be convincing. It needs
00:39:38.480 --> 00:39:40.550
to emerge convincingly from the
00:39:40.560 --> 00:39:44.150
situation. So often I'd be like, you
00:39:44.160 --> 00:39:46.230
know, in in the middle of the woods or
00:39:46.240 --> 00:39:48.550
something. And then the opportunities,
00:39:48.560 --> 00:39:51.109
they're they're kind of limited. And if
00:39:51.119 --> 00:39:53.670
you try and materialize if you try and
00:39:53.680 --> 00:39:56.230
materialize the sexual situation in the
00:39:56.240 --> 00:39:58.470
woods, the walls start breaking down.
00:39:58.480 --> 00:40:00.550
And it's like, oh no. And then it you
00:40:00.560 --> 00:40:02.470
sort of have to go with it a bit as
00:40:02.480 --> 00:40:05.109
well. You can't just completely mold the
00:40:05.119 --> 00:40:08.390
world and have these experiences. Um
00:40:08.400 --> 00:40:11.589
>> the first time I lucid dreamed was in a
00:40:11.599 --> 00:40:14.470
a a Harry Krishna ash ram in in
00:40:14.480 --> 00:40:18.790
Tuscanyany. Um which is a a large
00:40:18.800 --> 00:40:21.349
estate, a large house that was made out
00:40:21.359 --> 00:40:23.030
to the Harry Krishna by one of their
00:40:23.040 --> 00:40:26.230
many rich patrons. It was the villa in
00:40:26.240 --> 00:40:28.950
which Machiavelli wrote the prince which
00:40:28.960 --> 00:40:31.030
I found hilarious and I just kept
00:40:31.040 --> 00:40:32.550
telling everyone about that. None of
00:40:32.560 --> 00:40:35.109
them they were all you know it wasn't
00:40:35.119 --> 00:40:38.150
wasn't an important fact. And there was
00:40:38.160 --> 00:40:41.349
a a day when a a comet was going by. It
00:40:41.359 --> 00:40:42.550
was like in the middle of August like a
00:40:42.560 --> 00:40:45.829
a prominent comet across the sky. all
00:40:45.839 --> 00:40:48.790
this context ludicrous context for this
00:40:48.800 --> 00:40:51.349
first [laughter] and it was an eclipse
00:40:51.359 --> 00:40:54.550
of the sun and the whole day you know
00:40:54.560 --> 00:40:56.630
they'd been I' been you know they they
00:40:56.640 --> 00:40:59.910
chant Harry Krishna all day there it's
00:40:59.920 --> 00:41:02.150
not like you know it's it's it's round
00:41:02.160 --> 00:41:04.230
the clock they're chanting it and
00:41:04.240 --> 00:41:05.750
sometimes you can hear it just vaguely
00:41:05.760 --> 00:41:07.670
in the distance sometimes very clo you
00:41:07.680 --> 00:41:09.750
know um but it but it's always there
00:41:09.760 --> 00:41:11.750
around you and you start just naturally
00:41:11.760 --> 00:41:14.150
doing it yourself I was like helping out
00:41:14.160 --> 00:41:15.990
in the kitchen like washing dishes and
00:41:16.000 --> 00:41:18.550
stuff and you just start doing it do the
00:41:18.560 --> 00:41:20.870
Harry Krishna Harama thing and
00:41:20.880 --> 00:41:23.190
>> he's foreshadowing a very intense sexual
00:41:23.200 --> 00:41:27.430
encounter with [laughter]
00:41:27.440 --> 00:41:32.710
>> and and I um I went into the room and um
00:41:32.720 --> 00:41:35.750
I what's the word again? What was this
00:41:35.760 --> 00:41:37.910
word? I was asking an Italian man the
00:41:37.920 --> 00:41:40.150
word for because I was learning Italian
00:41:40.160 --> 00:41:43.190
at the time. I think it's clear. I said
00:41:43.200 --> 00:41:44.790
clear. What's the word for clear?
00:41:44.800 --> 00:41:46.150
Because I was talking about water or
00:41:46.160 --> 00:41:49.750
something and he said luchido.
00:41:49.760 --> 00:41:52.950
Luchido. The lucid. The same
00:41:52.960 --> 00:41:56.309
ethmological root as lucid.
00:41:56.319 --> 00:41:59.190
>> That night I have my first ever lucid
00:41:59.200 --> 00:42:01.109
dream.
00:42:01.119 --> 00:42:05.510
>> Zero sex alas. It was I was on a roof
00:42:05.520 --> 00:42:08.630
and it was it was like uh kind of China
00:42:08.640 --> 00:42:10.230
looking. It was kind of looked like
00:42:10.240 --> 00:42:12.230
ancient China, like Ming Dynasty China.
00:42:12.240 --> 00:42:14.150
And I was had the exact same experience
00:42:14.160 --> 00:42:17.910
as you. I was looking at um at a roof of
00:42:17.920 --> 00:42:21.270
another building uh like a a slate kind
00:42:21.280 --> 00:42:24.550
of roof, terra cotta roof, and I was
00:42:24.560 --> 00:42:26.470
amazed by the detail of it.
00:42:26.480 --> 00:42:28.309
>> I was looking I just going, "Oh my god."
00:42:28.319 --> 00:42:32.309
Like every single tile is
00:42:32.319 --> 00:42:37.030
>> is just like is 4K, is 10K, is IK. It's
00:42:37.040 --> 00:42:40.069
real. I'm looking at some real tiles on
00:42:40.079 --> 00:42:42.150
a roof. Amazing that my mind can do
00:42:42.160 --> 00:42:44.550
that. Wait a minute. That means I must
00:42:44.560 --> 00:42:46.550
be dreaming. That was the thought
00:42:46.560 --> 00:42:47.589
process.
00:42:47.599 --> 00:42:47.829
>> Yes.
00:42:47.839 --> 00:42:49.589
>> And then and then I tried flying and
00:42:49.599 --> 00:42:52.470
didn't do very far. I flew in a circle.
00:42:52.480 --> 00:42:53.190
Yeah.
00:42:53.200 --> 00:42:55.190
>> A guy said to me he was one time he was
00:42:55.200 --> 00:42:56.790
walking down the street in a dream and
00:42:56.800 --> 00:42:58.630
noticed something weird. Noticed a woman
00:42:58.640 -->
00:43:00.390
with a dress of stars or something and
00:43:00.400 --> 00:43:02.790
thought, "Oh, that's weird. I I must be
00:43:02.800 --> 00:43:06.230
dreaming." Runs up a wall, falls down
00:43:06.240 --> 00:43:09.750
again. He can't fly. He wanted to fly by
00:43:09.760 --> 00:43:11.510
running up the wall. He can't. He just
00:43:11.520 --> 00:43:13.829
fell down. Uh assumes, "Okay, I'm not
00:43:13.839 --> 00:43:15.349
dreaming then." Lives the rest of the
00:43:15.359 --> 00:43:17.109
dream.
00:43:17.119 --> 00:43:20.710
>> Yeah. Yeah. And you Oh, lives the rest
00:43:20.720 --> 00:43:21.510
of the dream.
00:43:21.520 --> 00:43:23.270
>> Lives the rest of the dream. Just lives
00:43:23.280 --> 00:43:25.349
it. Just lives it as a dreamer.
00:43:25.359 --> 00:43:26.309
>> Oh. Yeah.
00:43:26.319 --> 00:43:27.910
>> That's also a great pleasure as well,
00:43:27.920 --> 00:43:29.910
right? Just living as a dreamer. Not be
00:43:29.920 --> 00:43:32.390
not being the the god, the the the
00:43:32.400 --> 00:43:34.230
architect of the dream. It's lovely just
00:43:34.240 --> 00:43:35.829
being a dreamer,
00:43:35.839 --> 00:43:37.910
>> partaking in it, partaking in the nature
00:43:37.920 --> 00:43:39.030
of the dream.
00:43:39.040 --> 00:43:41.670
>> And one of the first, one of the coolest
00:43:41.680 --> 00:43:43.270
things I think that now in retrospect
00:43:43.280 --> 00:43:45.349
that can happen, it's it's something you
00:43:45.359 --> 00:43:46.790
have to be careful about lucid dreaming.
00:43:46.800 --> 00:43:48.950
It's called waking into your dream. And
00:43:48.960 --> 00:43:51.670
so I think it's because when the mind
00:43:51.680 --> 00:43:53.829
starts, you're in a lucid dream and then
00:43:53.839 --> 00:43:56.150
it's it kind of fizzles out and then
00:43:56.160 --> 00:43:58.069
your mind is getting close to actually
00:43:58.079 --> 00:44:01.109
waking up. What happens very often is
00:44:01.119 --> 00:44:04.390
you you wake up in your bed because I
00:44:04.400 --> 00:44:05.589
think your mind is actually starting to
00:44:05.599 --> 00:44:07.750
try to model and recreate I'm in my room
00:44:07.760 --> 00:44:10.150
and you're still in your lucid dream. So
00:44:10.160 --> 00:44:11.829
that happened to me a lot where I was
00:44:11.839 --> 00:44:15.190
like in my bed I think I'm up but then
00:44:15.200 --> 00:44:16.630
then it is one of those things you look
00:44:16.640 --> 00:44:19.750
into a mirror or because the mind for
00:44:19.760 --> 00:44:21.270
some reason the mind does not do a good
00:44:21.280 --> 00:44:24.230
job recreating an image in a mirror. So
00:44:24.240 --> 00:44:25.990
when you often in lucid dreams when you
00:44:26.000 --> 00:44:29.109
look in a mirror it's weird your I you
00:44:29.119 --> 00:44:31.190
look like your third uncle, you know,
00:44:31.200 --> 00:44:32.950
you just look very distorted mostly in
00:44:32.960 --> 00:44:34.150
mirrors or something. That's what would
00:44:34.160 --> 00:44:35.349
happen to me a lot. I'd go into the
00:44:35.359 --> 00:44:37.750
bathroom, I'm doing my normal morning
00:44:37.760 --> 00:44:39.750
routine and then I'd see myself in the
00:44:39.760 --> 00:44:41.030
mirror and I'd be like, "Oh, I'm still
00:44:41.040 --> 00:44:43.190
I'm still dreaming." And uh I think
00:44:43.200 --> 00:44:45.109
that's fascinating.
00:44:45.119 --> 00:44:46.550
>> Yeah. I think something interesting in
00:44:46.560 --> 00:44:48.390
in dreams just just to cut in there
00:44:48.400 --> 00:44:49.670
briefly and this this might be a
00:44:49.680 --> 00:44:51.510
somewhat limited point but it's
00:44:51.520 --> 00:44:53.109
interesting how technology and I'll
00:44:53.119 --> 00:44:55.270
count a mirror somewhat but often
00:44:55.280 --> 00:44:56.630
functions very poorly. One of the
00:44:56.640 --> 00:44:58.790
classic tells light switches phones
00:44:58.800 --> 00:45:00.470
which are sort of you know endemic in
00:45:00.480 --> 00:45:02.870
daily life those things if they're there
00:45:02.880 --> 00:45:05.109
at all completely non-functional. It's
00:45:05.119 --> 00:45:06.950
like our brain can simulate a river and
00:45:06.960 --> 00:45:09.589
a forest and a mountain and a gazelle
00:45:09.599 --> 00:45:11.430
but as soon as it has to do like a
00:45:11.440 --> 00:45:14.069
PlayStation cannot even not even the
00:45:14.079 --> 00:45:15.990
sort of like button to screen. It's like
00:45:16.000 --> 00:45:17.990
it has to simulate the circuitry and
00:45:18.000 --> 00:45:19.030
can't do it. Y
00:45:19.040 --> 00:45:21.910
>> but it's a in a world now which is um
00:45:21.920 --> 00:45:23.270
>> completely suffused with this
00:45:23.280 --> 00:45:25.670
technology. Everything you do everywhere
00:45:25.680 --> 00:45:28.150
um dreams maybe become more incoherent.
00:45:28.160 --> 00:45:30.390
Not in the kind of interesting meaning
00:45:30.400 --> 00:45:33.030
chaotic surreal way but just nothing
00:45:33.040 --> 00:45:36.230
works. you're walking around just EMP
00:45:36.240 --> 00:45:38.390
land. All the buttons, all the switches,
00:45:38.400 --> 00:45:40.710
all the touchcreens. So, yeah, it's it's
00:45:40.720 --> 00:45:42.630
a it's a strange I'm not sure what that
00:45:42.640 --> 00:45:44.550
has to do with anything, but maybe you
00:45:44.560 --> 00:45:46.150
have some insight there. No,
00:45:46.160 --> 00:45:48.550
>> I love it because I find first I find it
00:45:48.560 --> 00:45:49.829
fascinating as you were saying it. It
00:45:49.839 --> 00:45:51.270
made me wonder just if you know dreams
00:45:51.280 --> 00:45:53.750
are coming from a primal part of our,
00:45:53.760 --> 00:45:56.069
you know, we're bootstrapping up some
00:45:56.079 --> 00:45:58.950
some primal stuff that it just screens
00:45:58.960 --> 00:46:01.190
screens and digital watches weren't
00:46:01.200 --> 00:46:03.510
something that it had to replicate very
00:46:03.520 --> 00:46:05.270
much. It could replicate trees and
00:46:05.280 --> 00:46:07.190
landscapes, but then you look at your
00:46:07.200 --> 00:46:09.030
digital watch in a dream and the numbers
00:46:09.040 --> 00:46:10.870
are just like marshmallows, you know,
00:46:10.880 --> 00:46:12.230
they're just moving around. So I I think
00:46:12.240 --> 00:46:16.150
that's fascinating and
00:46:16.160 --> 00:46:18.069
kind of pivoting towards my journey is
00:46:18.079 --> 00:46:20.309
like
00:46:20.319 --> 00:46:22.150
I I went through it. So I go to college
00:46:22.160 --> 00:46:24.470
and I'm still in my little NLP mode
00:46:24.480 --> 00:46:26.309
where we're going to we're going to
00:46:26.319 --> 00:46:28.710
solve all of our suffering by just
00:46:28.720 --> 00:46:31.030
rearranging our thoughts, you know, just
00:46:31.040 --> 00:46:33.030
thinking the right thought and changing
00:46:33.040 --> 00:46:35.430
the images in your mind. But then in
00:46:35.440 --> 00:46:37.349
college just, you know, I started
00:46:37.359 --> 00:46:40.069
reading postmodernism. I started reading
00:46:40.079 --> 00:46:42.790
um Fuko. I even got into Carl Jung and
00:46:42.800 --> 00:46:44.790
um it was it was Carl Jung's work and
00:46:44.800 --> 00:46:46.870
his his main one of his main students,
00:46:46.880 --> 00:46:48.309
James Hillman. I don't know if you've
00:46:48.319 --> 00:46:50.630
read any James Hillman stuff, but he's
00:46:50.640 --> 00:46:52.470
so aggressively
00:46:52.480 --> 00:46:55.030
anti-interpreting dreams. James Hillman,
00:46:55.040 --> 00:46:58.069
he feels like when we interpret a dream,
00:46:58.079 --> 00:47:00.470
we're dragging the dream into our
00:47:00.480 --> 00:47:02.950
conscious logical world. And so he's
00:47:02.960 --> 00:47:04.710
much more about like, and I know this
00:47:04.720 --> 00:47:06.710
sounds so trivial, but you know, letting
00:47:06.720 --> 00:47:08.230
the dream interpret you, but he really
00:47:08.240 --> 00:47:09.829
wants us to not try to pull the dream
00:47:09.839 --> 00:47:11.109
in, but if we're working with our
00:47:11.119 --> 00:47:13.510
dreams, work with them. Don't understand
00:47:13.520 --> 00:47:15.510
them, but go into their textures and
00:47:15.520 --> 00:47:18.870
their qualities. And that became that
00:47:18.880 --> 00:47:21.430
made lucid dreaming for me then felt
00:47:21.440 --> 00:47:24.230
like sacrilegious because it's the worst
00:47:24.240 --> 00:47:25.910
version. It's what you were saying,
00:47:25.920 --> 00:47:30.150
Jack. Like it's it it's the worst trick
00:47:30.160 --> 00:47:32.710
to think that I can go into this amazing
00:47:32.720 --> 00:47:35.430
dream space that is mysterious and I can
00:47:35.440 --> 00:47:37.190
make it conscious and I can make it mine
00:47:37.200 --> 00:47:40.390
and I can do the things I want and I I
00:47:40.400 --> 00:47:42.150
you can tell there's some disdain in me
00:47:42.160 --> 00:47:43.670
now around it.
00:47:43.680 --> 00:47:46.390
>> Yeah. It's like vivid like vivisection a
00:47:46.400 --> 00:47:47.430
little bit
00:47:47.440 --> 00:47:49.270
>> to understand how the animal the
00:47:49.280 --> 00:47:51.109
beautiful wonderful animal works. We
00:47:51.119 --> 00:47:53.510
must cut it open while it is alive and
00:47:53.520 --> 00:47:56.950
observe all its pulsating organs.
00:47:56.960 --> 00:47:58.870
Sort of works in a way, but maybe
00:47:58.880 --> 00:47:59.670
missing the point.
00:47:59.680 --> 00:48:01.990
>> Yeah. That great line from Wdsworth, we
00:48:02.000 --> 00:48:03.670
murder to dissect.
00:48:03.680 --> 00:48:04.870
>> Yep.
00:48:04.880 --> 00:48:08.470
>> And oh gosh. To tell your viewers that
00:48:08.480 --> 00:48:11.349
you'll put this below later, but there's
00:48:11.359 --> 00:48:13.990
a Cridge quote that to me epitomizes
00:48:14.000 --> 00:48:15.670
what we're talking about. how the the
00:48:15.680 --> 00:48:18.230
the mind it's it's it's his version of
00:48:18.240 --> 00:48:19.990
the murder to dissect, but I think it
00:48:20.000 --> 00:48:21.990
captures it of like he's talking about
00:48:22.000 --> 00:48:24.309
we divide we um distinguish
00:48:24.319 --> 00:48:27.190
distinguishing to divide is the worst
00:48:27.200 --> 00:48:29.990
human mental sin. And he says a lazy
00:48:30.000 --> 00:48:31.829
version is to divide in order to
00:48:31.839 --> 00:48:33.349
distinguish. And I thought that was
00:48:33.359 --> 00:48:36.630
fascinating. Like we divide things up to
00:48:36.640 --> 00:48:38.309
make distinctions. And he's like that's
00:48:38.319 --> 00:48:39.910
good. I mean that's we have to kind of
00:48:39.920 --> 00:48:42.309
do that. But to distinguish things in
00:48:42.319 --> 00:48:44.150
order to divide them that starts to
00:48:44.160 --> 00:48:46.069
point towards the mechanical sciences
00:48:46.079 --> 00:48:48.069
that you know try to explain everything
00:48:48.079 --> 00:48:50.230
in a redundant like we understand the
00:48:50.240 --> 00:48:52.230
pieces now we understand the whole.
00:48:52.240 --> 00:48:53.670
>> Yeah. And there's a beautiful line in
00:48:53.680 --> 00:48:55.990
Keats somewhere about the Newtonian
00:48:56.000 --> 00:48:58.950
prism taking apart the the beam of light
00:48:58.960 --> 00:49:02.470
as um unweaving the rainbow.
00:49:02.480 --> 00:49:05.910
>> Um another beautiful line um
00:49:05.920 --> 00:49:08.150
>> from that. Yeah. that general suspicion
00:49:08.160 --> 00:49:10.069
towards the overly reductive, the overly
00:49:10.079 --> 00:49:11.670
categorical, I suppose in McGill
00:49:11.680 --> 00:49:13.670
Christian terms, the left brain, the
00:49:13.680 --> 00:49:16.790
overbearing left brain way of looking at
00:49:16.800 --> 00:49:17.589
things.
00:49:17.599 --> 00:49:21.990
>> Yeah. I'm I'm curious about um your like
00:49:22.000 --> 00:49:26.150
how exactly this um maybe slightly
00:49:26.160 --> 00:49:28.549
utopian view that you can fix all
00:49:28.559 --> 00:49:30.870
suffering in the world, you can fix all
00:49:30.880
--> 00:49:33.829
suffering from the inside. How exactly
00:49:33.839 --> 00:49:35.829
this broke down? And you say, you know,
00:49:35.839 --> 00:49:38.150
referencing specific thinkers, but what
00:49:38.160 --> 00:49:40.230
specific ideas, specific thoughts,
00:49:40.240 --> 00:49:43.190
specific books, um, broke down this
00:49:43.200 --> 00:49:45.589
utopian view that all suffering could be
00:49:45.599 --> 00:49:47.190
brought to an end.
00:49:47.200 --> 00:49:48.549
>> It's great. I mean, it's the perfect
00:49:48.559 --> 00:49:50.309
question because it takes me, okay, I
00:49:50.319 --> 00:49:52.390
can tell you the room it happened in.
00:49:52.400 --> 00:49:55.990
Um, okay. So, little Jeff, when I was
00:49:56.000 --> 00:49:57.510
13, I just started reading everything I
00:49:57.520 --> 00:49:59.030
could on psychology and blah blah blah
00:49:59.040 --> 00:50:01.990
blah. I go to college. I get a job in
00:50:02.000 --> 00:50:03.589
Santa Cruz, California. That's where I
00:50:03.599 --> 00:50:05.190
go to college at the university in Santa
00:50:05.200 --> 00:50:08.470
Cruz and it it's a wild university
00:50:08.480 --> 00:50:09.910
beautifully. It's up in the redwood
00:50:09.920 --> 00:50:12.950
forest and um they also that's where the
00:50:12.960 --> 00:50:15.990
main teachers at the time of neural
00:50:16.000 --> 00:50:17.910
linguistic programming did their summer
00:50:17.920 --> 00:50:20.470
workshops. They hired me to be their
00:50:20.480 --> 00:50:22.630
little audio recorder during the
00:50:22.640 --> 00:50:24.230
seminar. So I'd sit there and audio
00:50:24.240 --> 00:50:27.589
record and I was a little 19-year-old.
00:50:27.599 --> 00:50:30.390
Um, one day they brought in a guest
00:50:30.400 --> 00:50:33.829
teacher named Stephen Gilligan and he he
00:50:33.839 --> 00:50:35.190
was a buddy with these guys back when
00:50:35.200 --> 00:50:37.349
they were all in college, but he went in
00:50:37.359 --> 00:50:38.790
the direct when they were all getting
00:50:38.800 --> 00:50:41.270
hyped up about the mechanical fixing,
00:50:41.280 --> 00:50:44.390
solving all problems. He was drugged out
00:50:44.400 --> 00:50:45.829
dealing with his own, he says this in
00:50:45.839 --> 00:50:47.190
public, so I know he'd be comfortable
00:50:47.200 --> 00:50:48.549
with this. He was just dealing with his
00:50:48.559 --> 00:50:50.390
own [ __ ] at the time and he be he went
00:50:50.400 --> 00:50:52.309
off to that Milton Ericson guy who was
00:50:52.319 --> 00:50:54.470
about to die and he went and lived with
00:50:54.480 --> 00:50:57.430
him for a little bit and he Milton
00:50:57.440 --> 00:50:59.270
Ericson started seeing that this guy
00:50:59.280 --> 00:51:02.230
Steven could do some of the stuff he was
00:51:02.240 --> 00:51:05.349
doing hypnotically with people and
00:51:05.359 --> 00:51:07.190
Steven
00:51:07.200 --> 00:51:09.430
was more eastern inclined so he sort of
00:51:09.440 --> 00:51:10.790
he I think he was already
holding a
00:51:10.800 --> 00:51:13.589
Buddhist view of suffering
00:51:13.599 --> 00:51:16.390
and he incorporated his understandings
00:51:16.400 --> 00:51:18.390
of what's happening ing hypnotically
00:51:18.400 --> 00:51:20.710
with the Buddhist aspect. And I think he
00:51:20.720 --> 00:51:23.030
cleaned out some of the problems I have
00:51:23.040 --> 00:51:25.750
with the hypnotic stuff. And he he came
00:51:25.760 --> 00:51:28.230
into the room.
00:51:28.240 --> 00:51:29.910
Imagine a room full of 60 people from
00:51:29.920 --> 00:51:31.750
all over the world, mostly therapists or
00:51:31.760 --> 00:51:33.910
artists who are just infatuated with
00:51:33.920 --> 00:51:35.829
NLP. They just love knowing we're
00:51:35.839 --> 00:51:37.990
learning all the ways to control our
00:51:38.000 --> 00:51:40.230
minds to never suffer. Then this guy
00:51:40.240 --> 00:51:41.670
Steven Gilligan comes in. He's probably
00:51:41.680 --> 00:51:45.430
43 at the time. And he said he was
00:51:45.440 --> 00:51:47.270
talking and he said something like that
00:51:47.280 --> 00:51:48.710
people were asking him questions and he
00:51:48.720 --> 00:51:51.030
said you know life sucks but it's not a
00:51:51.040 --> 00:51:54.790
problem which doesn't sound deep but in
00:51:54.800 --> 00:51:57.270
that room full of people whose minds are
00:51:57.280 --> 00:52:00.150
trained on not thinking life sucks and
00:52:00.160 --> 00:52:03.430
he held that ground for two days where
00:52:03.440 --> 00:52:06.710
he would not budge from the suffering is
00:52:06.720 --> 00:52:08.470
the pain we're feeling isn't the problem
00:52:08.480 --> 00:52:10.230
and he also said I remember this he said
00:52:10.240 --> 00:52:12.950
the symptom is the solution
00:52:12.960 --> 00:52:15.589
And for me that really started to land.
00:52:15.599 --> 00:52:17.750
He wasn't about eliminating system
00:52:17.760 --> 00:52:19.190
symptoms. You come in with depression,
00:52:19.200 --> 00:52:21.349
you come in with anxiety. He was about
00:52:21.359 --> 00:52:23.589
learning to listen
00:52:23.599 --> 00:52:27.270
and be with those symptoms creatively,
00:52:27.280 --> 00:52:30.549
kindly, inwardly. And realize that
00:52:30.559 --> 00:52:32.870
there's some part of you that's really
00:52:32.880 --> 00:52:35.109
probably wanting to let go of a
00:52:35.119 --> 00:52:37.510
conscious fixation, an identity that
00:52:37.520 --> 00:52:39.349
you're you're trying to hold on to. And
00:52:39.359 --> 00:52:41.670
so his work was just the opposite of
00:52:41.680 --> 00:52:44.470
going inside and getting your goal. It
00:52:44.480 --> 00:52:45.829
was no, you're probably going to be
00:52:45.839 --> 00:52:47.910
letting go of a lot that you think you
00:52:47.920 --> 00:52:50.069
need. And that was my turning point.
00:52:50.079 --> 00:52:51.510
Meeting him and getting to know him
00:52:51.520 --> 00:52:53.349
personally a little bit was when I just
00:52:53.359 --> 00:52:55.510
started feeling
00:52:55.520 --> 00:52:59.430
everything crumbling beneath my feet.
00:52:59.440 --> 00:53:01.990
Also, if you marry that to have you
00:53:02.000 --> 00:53:04.390
heard of the um Stanford prison
00:53:04.400 --> 00:53:06.870
experiment?
00:53:06.880 --> 00:53:09.589
>> It's Yeah. the B the I had a teacher at
00:53:09.599 --> 00:53:12.790
UCSC who was one of the creators of that
00:53:12.800 --> 00:53:15.190
and he taught an entire class on it and
00:53:15.200 --> 00:53:17.349
that's the experiment briefly where they
00:53:17.359 --> 00:53:22.390
just randomly broke uh 20 men 10 of them
00:53:22.400 --> 00:53:24.950
became prisoners and 10 of them became
00:53:24.960 --> 00:53:26.870
guards and they did a bunch of tests to
00:53:26.880 --> 00:53:28.230
show that these were psychologically
00:53:28.240 --> 00:53:30.230
healthy people beforehand and they were
00:53:30.240 --> 00:53:32.150
going to they created a fake prison in
00:53:32.160 --> 00:53:34.790
Stanford that for the entire summer they
00:53:34.800 --> 00:53:37.109
were going to study behavior like what
00:53:37.119 --> 00:53:38.309
happens with the guards, what happens
00:53:38.319 --> 00:53:39.990
with the prisoners? And they wanted,
00:53:40.000 --> 00:53:41.589
these were social psychologists, so they
00:53:41.599 --> 00:53:42.790
believe we're going to learn a lot about
00:53:42.800 --> 00:53:47.030
just how social context affects people.
00:53:47.040 --> 00:53:49.430
They had to close the experiment down in
00:53:49.440 --> 00:53:51.829
3 days because you had guards beating
00:53:51.839 --> 00:53:53.750
prisoners. You had prisoners screaming
00:53:53.760 --> 00:53:55.430
they're going to kill themselves and
00:53:55.440 --> 00:53:59.190
going crazy. And my professor said he
00:53:59.200 --> 00:54:01.109
was at dinner with his wife one night
00:54:01.119 --> 00:54:02.950
after the first day of the second day of
00:54:02.960 --> 00:54:04.630
the experiment. And he was describing,
00:54:04.640 --> 00:54:06.309
he was just eating food, describing what
00:54:06.319 --> 00:54:08.710
happened that day at the experiment. And
00:54:08.720 --> 00:54:11.990
his wife said, "Honey, this is
00:54:12.000 --> 00:54:13.750
disgusting. Like, you guys have to stop
00:54:13.760 --> 00:54:15.829
this." And he said that's when he
00:54:15.839 --> 00:54:18.069
snapped out of this trance, to use our
00:54:18.079 --> 00:54:19.910
word of the day. He snapped out of and
00:54:19.920 --> 00:54:21.910
realized how awful what was happening in
00:54:21.920 --> 00:54:24.549
the experiment was. Like he he and the
00:54:24.559 --> 00:54:26.950
other professors that created it did not
00:54:26.960 --> 00:54:30.069
believe when the prisoners were saying
00:54:30.079 --> 00:54:31.750
they were suicidal. They just thought
00:54:31.760 --> 00:54:34.309
everything was a trick. And that that
00:54:34.319 --> 00:54:39.589
experiment when he taught that
00:54:39.599 --> 00:54:42.069
whatever notion I had that
there's this
00:54:42.079 --> 00:54:44.710
little what's it called the homunculus
00:54:44.720 --> 00:54:46.790
that there's this little part of me
00:54:46.800 --> 00:54:48.630
inside that's making the choices and
00:54:48.640 --> 00:54:50.710
deciding what to do it just like
00:54:50.720 --> 00:54:52.390
vanished and I was really it was almost
00:54:52.400 --> 00:54:54.150
a scary intellectual moment for me
00:54:54.160 --> 00:54:56.069
because everything in my life at that
00:54:56.079 --> 00:54:58.390
point had been about we can set a goal
00:54:58.400 --> 00:54:59.750
and we can figure out how to achieve it
00:54:59.760 --> 00:55:02.230
and this experiment made me think if
00:55:02.240 --> 00:55:03.670
somebody's suddenly beating another
00:55:03.680 --> 00:55:05.109
human being and they've never beat a
00:55:05.119 --> 00:55:06.630
human being before and it's two days
00:55:06.640 --> 00:55:07.910
into an experiment where they're
00:55:07.920 --> 00:55:10.950
pretending to be a guard. How does that
00:55:10.960 --> 00:55:13.750
happen? And so those two things, meeting
00:55:13.760 --> 00:55:17.270
Steven Gilligan and his thing about
00:55:17.280 --> 00:55:20.470
suffering and then my notion of identity
00:55:20.480 --> 00:55:23.430
falling apart, that was my
00:55:23.440 --> 00:55:25.829
second or third year of college. And
00:55:25.839 --> 00:55:27.829
that's when I would say I hit kind of a
00:55:27.839 --> 00:55:30.710
desert of not knowing kind of where to
00:55:30.720 --> 00:55:33.109
go.
00:55:33.119 --> 00:55:35.589
of those unethical psychology
00:55:35.599 --> 00:55:37.270
experiments. Just just while we're on
00:55:37.280 --> 00:55:39.190
the subject, are there any others that
00:55:39.200 --> 00:55:40.950
were very influential or or very
00:55:40.960 --> 00:55:42.390
interesting to you? Because I I think
00:55:42.400 --> 00:55:44.549
that is the most famous one, but it
00:55:44.559 --> 00:55:47.030
seemed before ethics had been invented
00:55:47.040 --> 00:55:49.030
later in the 20th century. It seemed you
00:55:49.040 --> 00:55:51.030
could do pretty much anything.
00:55:51.040 --> 00:55:54.710
>> Um yeah, share your your insight here,
00:55:54.720 --> 00:55:55.750
your knowledge.
00:55:55.760 --> 00:55:57.270
>> Well, the other one that sort of
00:55:57.280 --> 00:55:58.630
probably is even bigger than those are
00:55:58.640 --> 00:56:00.309
the here's the two. The second one that
00:56:00.319 --> 00:56:02.710
we learned in that class is called the
00:56:02.720 --> 00:56:06.150
Mgrim experiment. And that's the one
00:56:06.160 --> 00:56:08.950
where they
00:56:08.960 --> 00:56:11.030
it's you're right the ethics were so I
00:56:11.040 --> 00:56:12.630
mean part of me is grateful that we got
00:56:12.640 --> 00:56:14.549
to see this but I understand why they
00:56:14.559 --> 00:56:16.630
had to stop doing this stuff but they
00:56:16.640 --> 00:56:18.390
dress they dress a guy up in a nice
00:56:18.400 --> 00:56:21.109
scientific white lab coat and they would
00:56:21.119 --> 00:56:22.789
tell the the people would come in for an
00:56:22.799 --> 00:56:24.150
experiment. They didn't know what they
00:56:24.160 --> 00:56:26.470
were coming in for. And he'd say, "We're
00:56:26.480 --> 00:56:30.950
doing an experiment on um on learning
00:56:30.960 --> 00:56:32.789
and you're going to sit here and in that
00:56:32.799 --> 00:56:33.990
other room over there." And I think when
00:56:34.000 --> 00:56:35.270
they first did the experiment, you would
00:56:35.280 --> 00:56:37.109
see a person in the other room and
00:56:37.119 --> 00:56:38.549
they'd say, "He's going to be trying to
00:56:38.559 --> 00:56:41.990
memorize words." Now, your job when he
00:56:42.000 --> 00:56:43.829
gets a word wrong, you're going to press
00:56:43.839 --> 00:56:45.430
this button and it's going to shock
00:56:45.440 --> 00:56:46.789
them. Just a little shock. And they'd
00:56:46.799 --> 00:56:48.390
even give the person a little shock to
00:56:48.400 --> 00:56:50.789
feel like, "Oh, that doesn't feel good."
00:56:50.799 --> 00:56:53.910
And then he said, they say, every time
00:56:53.920 --> 00:56:56.789
he misses a question, you will you will
00:56:56.799 --> 00:56:58.069
press the button and it'll give them
00:56:58.079 --> 00:57:00.710
more of a shock. And then they show them
00:57:00.720 --> 00:57:01.910
the buttons or whatever. And they
00:57:01.920 --> 00:57:03.430
they're aware that like they even tell
00:57:03.440 --> 00:57:06.069
them like when you get to this level,
00:57:06.079 --> 00:57:08.069
it's, you know, this sends people
00:57:08.079 --> 00:57:10.309
unconscious or whatever. And then they
00:57:10.319 --> 00:57:11.510
start the experiment. And they have this
00:57:11.520 --> 00:57:12.789
on video. You could probably watch it on
00:57:12.799 --> 00:57:16.470
YouTube. And
00:57:16.480 --> 00:57:19.190
these people would just keep shocking
00:57:19.200 --> 00:57:21.670
the and the the actor. It was an actor
00:57:21.680 --> 00:57:23.190
being shocked of course in the other
00:57:23.200 --> 00:57:24.950
room. It was an actor and they would
00:57:24.960 --> 00:57:27.270
start screaming, "Please stop. Please
00:57:27.280 --> 00:57:28.950
don't press the button again." And then
00:57:28.960 --> 00:57:32.309
you'd get these the subjects would often
00:57:32.319 --> 00:57:35.109
fall into hysterical laughter, which is
00:57:35.119 --> 00:57:37.109
my first experience of seeing like, "Oh,
00:57:37.119 --> 00:57:38.950
laughter is a defense mechanism." And
00:57:38.960 --> 00:57:40.789
they just start laughing and kind of
00:57:40.799 --> 00:57:43.190
blushing. But then many of them many of
00:57:43.200 --> 00:57:46.069
them would keep pushing the buttons and
00:57:46.079 --> 00:57:47.589
of course this was in the context of us
00:57:47.599 --> 00:57:50.309
trying to understand how
00:57:50.319 --> 00:57:52.549
the the second world war you know the
00:57:52.559 --> 00:57:54.069
effects of second world war. So that was
00:57:54.079 --> 00:57:56.309
an experiment that at the same class I
00:57:56.319 --> 00:57:57.670
was learning that and it sort of
00:57:57.680 --> 00:57:59.430
devastated me as well. Yeah, I know.
00:57:59.440 --> 00:58:01.109
There's that that moment when there's
00:58:01.119 --> 00:58:03.829
the um they're running out of SS guys on
00:58:03.839 --> 00:58:06.710
the Eastern Front to go into like the
00:58:06.720 --> 00:58:09.589
Ukrainian and Polish villages and they
00:58:09.599 --> 00:58:11.349
um they recruited a bunch of like
00:58:11.359 --> 00:58:14.470
firemen from Hamburg. Um they they
00:58:14.480 --> 00:58:15.910
weren't soldiers, you know, they weren't
00:58:15.920 --> 00:58:19.030
like they they were kind of old firemen,
00:58:19.040 --> 00:58:22.069
normal guys, like really normal guys
00:58:22.079 --> 00:58:24.630
families. They were firefighters. and
00:58:24.640 --> 00:58:27.030
they said that, you know, there's these
00:58:27.040 --> 00:58:29.190
there's um this stuff we have to do on
00:58:29.200 --> 00:58:31.030
the Eastern Front and it's going to be
00:58:31.040 --> 00:58:33.589
nasty. You know, you have to we have to
00:58:33.599 --> 00:58:36.230
go through like ghettos and you just
00:58:36.240 --> 00:58:38.710
have to kill every single person in the
00:58:38.720 --> 00:58:43.750
building. And um and we understand like
00:58:43.760 --> 00:58:46.710
if if you don't if you don't feel you
00:58:46.720 --> 00:58:48.549
could do it, if you don't feel you could
00:58:48.559 --> 00:58:52.069
go through with it, then um you you
00:58:52.079 --> 00:58:53.750
don't need to. we've we've already got,
00:58:53.760 --> 00:58:54.870
you know, they and they presented them
00:58:54.880 --> 00:58:58.630
like a piece of paper like signed by
00:58:58.640 --> 00:59:01.910
um Guring or whoever it was saying they
00:59:01.920 --> 00:59:03.349
would be pardoned if they didn't take
00:59:03.359 --> 00:59:04.309
part.
00:59:04.319 --> 00:59:06.200
>> And every single one of them
00:59:06.210 --> 00:59:08.950
[clears throat] went and took part and
00:59:08.960 --> 00:59:10.069
because they weren't the train, you
00:59:10.079 --> 00:59:11.510
know, they weren't SS guys, so they
00:59:11.520 --> 00:59:12.789
weren't trained, they didn't do it
00:59:12.799 --> 00:59:14.710
efficiently, which made it even more
00:59:14.720 --> 00:59:15.750
horrible.
00:59:15.760 --> 00:59:17.109
>> You know, they they don't know how to
00:59:17.119 --> 00:59:18.870
kill someone quickly. They just fire the
00:59:18.880 --> 00:59:21.270
machine gun random. So, you know, it
00:59:21.280 --> 00:59:23.510
just, you know, complete completely
00:59:23.520 --> 00:59:26.710
horrible and um and they and they had
00:59:26.720 --> 00:59:30.870
the opportunity, but the looking looking
00:59:30.880 --> 00:59:33.510
important or looking appropriate in
00:59:33.520 --> 00:59:35.750
front of each other
00:59:35.760 --> 00:59:39.510
>> was ultimately a far far greater concern
00:59:39.520 --> 00:59:41.589
than any ethical one.
00:59:41.599 --> 00:59:43.430
>> Um God
00:59:43.440 --> 00:59:43.829
>> Yeah,
00:59:43.839 --> 00:59:45.589
>> that one I've never heard that. And
00:59:45.599 --> 00:59:47.510
that's that's
00:59:47.520 --> 00:59:49.670
in some ways obviously much worse. And
00:59:49.680 --> 00:59:52.630
also it's also a better it's an example
00:59:52.640 --> 00:59:53.910
of something happening in the real world
00:59:53.920 --> 00:59:56.230
that the Mgrim experiment was trying to
00:59:56.240 --> 00:59:58.069
>> of course yeah I think that there's a
00:59:58.079 --> 01:00:01.190
book about in in German it's gans no
01:00:01.200 --> 01:00:04.230
mala mena which is utterly normal men
01:00:04.240 --> 01:00:05.990
completely normal men I'm not sure if
01:00:06.000 --> 01:00:07.670
you can find it in English but yeah a
01:00:07.680 --> 01:00:09.829
very a very interesting story goes
01:00:09.839 --> 01:00:11.829
through each one of the firefighters
01:00:11.839 --> 01:00:13.190
just live stories
01:00:13.200 --> 01:00:14.870
>> I want to read it yeah I'll get that
01:00:14.880 --> 01:00:15.589
from you later
01:00:15.599 --> 01:00:18.069
>> yeah so I'm I'm how did what brought you
01:00:18.079 --> 01:00:19.990
out of the desert
01:00:20.000 --> 01:00:24.549
of of complete and utter like carpet
01:00:24.559 --> 01:00:25.990
from under the feet.
01:00:26.000 --> 01:00:29.829
>> Um everything is suffering. That's okay.
01:00:29.839 --> 01:00:33.829
But um you know like where did you where
01:00:33.839 --> 01:00:35.030
did you go from there?
01:00:35.040 --> 01:00:37.030
>> Yep. I will. Okay. Yeah. Cuz I think
01:00:37.040 --> 01:00:38.630
we're maybe two steps away from when I
01:00:38.640 --> 01:00:40.390
got into Eugene Janlin's work which
01:00:40.400 --> 01:00:42.230
which became sort of how I framed my
01:00:42.240 --> 01:00:44.230
work as a psychotherapist. So we're
01:00:44.240 --> 01:00:46.150
close and to get out of the desert.
01:00:46.160 --> 01:00:47.670
Okay. So just imagine there I am in my
01:00:47.680 --> 01:00:49.910
desert and I'm also starting my classes
01:00:49.920 --> 01:00:52.390
at UCSC which was a radically leftist
01:00:52.400 --> 01:00:54.549
school. Everything was postmodernism. I
01:00:54.559 --> 01:00:56.789
was reading Fuko. I was reading Dereda.
01:00:56.799 --> 01:00:58.870
Like everything I read or the stuff I
01:00:58.880 --> 01:01:01.190
was at loving was all the extreme
01:01:01.200 --> 01:01:03.990
postmodernist stuff which I loved. Like
01:01:04.000 --> 01:01:06.069
I I ate it up. I was applying its
01:01:06.079 --> 01:01:07.750
thinking to my love for music.
01:01:07.760 --> 01:01:09.670
Everything I would I was thinking of in
01:01:09.680 --> 01:01:14.309
terms of that. But at some point it's so
01:01:14.319 --> 01:01:16.549
unnutritious. like it's exciting and
01:01:16.559 --> 01:01:18.309
it's true. It's noticing something about
01:01:18.319 --> 01:01:20.549
the relativity of language and meaning.
01:01:20.559 --> 01:01:23.190
But I was just a little kid just in love
01:01:23.200 --> 01:01:25.990
with this new toy. And after a year and
01:01:26.000 --> 01:01:27.670
a half of that, so as I'm going into my
01:01:27.680 --> 01:01:30.390
last year, I was I didn't realize it,
01:01:30.400 --> 01:01:34.630
but I was uh pretty hollowed out. Um it
01:01:34.640 --> 01:01:36.630
was like a frenzy of excitement but with
01:01:36.640 --> 01:01:39.190
no meaning and because I couldn't I
01:01:39.200 --> 01:01:41.670
couldn't ground meaning anymore. Um, and
01:01:41.680 --> 01:01:43.829
I got into a form of there's a there's a
01:01:43.839 --> 01:01:45.349
pretty cool form of psychotherapy called
01:01:45.359 --> 01:01:47.510
narrative therapy which is grounded in
01:01:47.520 --> 01:01:51.109
Fuko's work and it's
01:01:51.119 --> 01:01:53.109
for all the things I don't agree with it
01:01:53.119 --> 01:01:55.430
in terms of meta in terms of its
01:01:55.440 --> 01:01:56.789
philosophy. It's really cool the
01:01:56.799 --> 01:01:59.990
practices um but that's for another day.
01:02:00.000 --> 01:02:02.950
I
01:02:02.960 --> 01:02:04.789
okay I'm going to lose some I'm going to
01:02:04.799 --> 01:02:06.870
lose some credibility here but it is how
01:02:06.880 --> 01:02:11.349
I shifted towards um the work
01:02:11.359 --> 01:02:13.990
before my senior at the end of my junior
01:02:14.000 --> 01:02:17.589
year I met a professor uh in a psycho
01:02:17.599 --> 01:02:21.910
linguistics context and um
01:02:21.920 --> 01:02:24.309
I had to turn a paper in late and it was
01:02:24.319 --> 01:02:27.190
the end of the year so I I was told she
01:02:27.200 --> 01:02:29.109
just said bring it bring it by the house
01:02:29.119 --> 01:02:30.710
drop it off I'll cleaning up the garage
01:02:30.720 --> 01:02:33.750
with my kids. I dropped it off, became
01:02:33.760 --> 01:02:35.589
friends with the family, and then later
01:02:35.599 --> 01:02:37.910
that summer.
01:02:37.920 --> 01:02:40.870
She had a dream that it made no sense
01:02:40.880 --> 01:02:43.910
what her dream had about my weekend. She
01:02:43.920 --> 01:02:45.430
was gone on the East Coast. She had a
01:02:45.440 --> 01:02:47.910
dream. It just I was the guy in Santa
01:02:47.920 --> 01:02:50.309
Cruz who anytime my woowoo friends
01:02:50.319 --> 01:02:52.710
shared their mystical experiences, I
01:02:52.720 --> 01:02:55.829
would very kindly explain how there's
01:02:55.839 --> 01:02:57.670
confirmation bias going on. You know, I
01:02:57.680 --> 01:02:59.510
always knew the filters and how that how
01:02:59.520 --> 01:03:01.670
to explain it away. And I wasn't an
01:03:01.680 --> 01:03:02.950
[ __ ] about it, but I think you do
01:03:02.960 --> 01:03:04.630
start to sound like, you know, an
01:03:04.640 --> 01:03:08.069
[ __ ] after a time. But this rocked me
01:03:08.079 --> 01:03:10.470
in a way that I couldn't at all
01:03:10.480 --> 01:03:12.150
understand how it happened. You know, I
01:03:12.160 --> 01:03:15.349
immediately emailed Daniel Dennett. He's
01:03:15.359 --> 01:03:17.270
the uh he was an American philosopher
01:03:17.280 --> 01:03:21.109
just died who wrote, you know, ex uh
01:03:21.119 --> 01:03:22.789
explaining consciousness or whatever. He
01:03:22.799 --> 01:03:24.470
was an a limitivist. So he he says
01:03:24.480 --> 01:03:25.990
consciousness is an illusion and all
01:03:26.000 --> 01:03:29.430
that. I emailed him and I told him, I
01:03:29.440 --> 01:03:30.630
just said, 'Look, I love your stuff.
01:03:30.640 --> 01:03:32.390
You're kind of one of my main
01:03:32.400 --> 01:03:34.549
philosophers. Uh, this just happened. I
01:03:34.559 --> 01:03:36.230
described the dream. I described how it
01:03:36.240 --> 01:03:39.349
corresponded. And I said, I just need to
01:03:39.359 --> 01:03:41.510
know from your point of view, like,
01:03:41.520 --> 01:03:44.470
what's going on? And he emailed me back.
01:03:44.480 --> 01:03:46.789
I have this email still. It's so sweet.
01:03:46.799 --> 01:03:50.870
He says something like, "Well, Jeff, uh,
01:03:50.880 --> 01:03:53.749
he goes, I think you're lying to me."
01:03:53.759 --> 01:03:55.430
[laughter] He said, he said, "I" He
01:03:55.440 --> 01:03:57.430
goes, "I either think it's a I think
01:03:57.440 --> 01:04:00.390
it's an incredible coincidence or I
01:04:00.400 --> 01:04:02.870
think you're lying to me." And got to
01:04:02.880 --> 01:04:04.230
run. [laughter] And then he thanked the
01:04:04.240 --> 01:04:05.510
professor that gave me his email because
01:04:05.520 --> 01:04:06.870
it was one of his friends who like I
01:04:06.880 --> 01:04:08.150
talked into getting his email and he
01:04:08.160 --> 01:04:09.670
said, "Tell Roger Hi." or something like
01:04:09.680 --> 01:04:12.870
that. And I was like, "So, [snorts]
01:04:12.880 --> 01:04:14.950
I remember walking away from my little
01:04:14.960 --> 01:04:17.589
computer reading Daniel Dennett's email
01:04:17.599 --> 01:04:18.789
saying,"Look, here's there's two
01:04:18.799 --> 01:04:20.630
options. it is a coincidence and it's
01:04:20.640 --> 01:04:22.789
just really bizarre or you're lying to
01:04:22.799 --> 01:04:25.349
me. And it was thrilling to me because I
01:04:25.359 --> 01:04:27.109
thought
01:04:27.119 --> 01:04:28.789
Go ahead, Jack. Say it.
01:04:28.799 --> 01:04:30.230
>> What's What's going on? What is this
01:04:30.240 --> 01:04:32.789
dream? What did I I missed a part? What
01:04:32.799 --> 01:04:33.829
What's happening here?
01:04:33.839 --> 01:04:35.270
>> I know I skipped it because I don't know
01:04:35.280 --> 01:04:37.029
how much I have to protect. Okay, just
01:04:37.039 --> 01:04:38.470
I'll come back to it right away.
01:04:38.480 --> 01:04:38.789
>> Sure.
01:04:38.799 --> 01:04:40.069
>> I'll describe the dream. I'll describe
01:04:40.079 --> 01:04:41.510
the dream. I'll describe it. I'm going
01:04:41.520 --> 01:04:43.670
to mask a couple things just because I
01:04:43.680 --> 01:04:46.309
have to. But
01:04:46.319 --> 01:04:49.910
I sat Okay, here's the dream.
01:04:49.920 --> 01:04:53.510
My friend goes away to the east coast to
01:04:53.520 --> 01:04:55.349
um teach a seminar or something. So,
01:04:55.359 --> 01:04:58.950
it's a Friday. She's flown away. I get
01:04:58.960 --> 01:05:01.589
on a bus in Santa Cruz to go downtown
01:05:01.599 --> 01:05:04.309
and I run into the girlfriend I had last
01:05:04.319 --> 01:05:06.549
year, the year before and then the in
01:05:06.559 --> 01:05:07.910
the summer we had broken up and it was
01:05:07.920 --> 01:05:09.750
kind of messy and there she is on the
01:05:09.760 --> 01:05:11.829
bus. I had kind of have to sit down next
01:05:11.839 --> 01:05:13.829
to her and by the time we get downtown
01:05:13.839 --> 01:05:17.510
we are back. we are like we're back and
01:05:17.520 --> 01:05:20.069
we had the whole weekend together. I
01:05:20.079 --> 01:05:22.230
knew I was going to eat on Sunday night
01:05:22.240 --> 01:05:23.670
my friend the professor was going to get
01:05:23.680 --> 01:05:25.349
back and we were going to have a meal
01:05:25.359 --> 01:05:27.349
and I was looking forward to that. we're
01:05:27.359 --> 01:05:29.430
we're cooking that meal and I'm about
01:05:29.440 --> 01:05:31.430
I'm excited to tell her like guess what
01:05:31.440 --> 01:05:34.309
on Friday I met back with this person
01:05:34.319 --> 01:05:35.990
and I wanted to tell her all about it
01:05:36.000 --> 01:05:38.309
and she she's pulling a lasagna out and
01:05:38.319 --> 01:05:40.630
she goes I had a I had the strangest
01:05:40.640 --> 01:05:43.829
dream last night and I go ahead and she
01:05:43.839 --> 01:05:45.750
goes okay
01:05:45.760 --> 01:05:49.190
you know you know that girl you told me
01:05:49.200 --> 01:05:50.950
you dated last year so in my dream
01:05:50.960 --> 01:05:53.349
there's a knock on my door and I come to
01:05:53.359 --> 01:05:55.589
the door and you and he she had never
01:05:55.599 --> 01:05:56.870
seen her she couldn't even remember her
01:05:56.880 --> 01:05:59.270
because you and that girl
01:05:59.280 --> 01:06:02.150
are like beaming with excitement to tell
01:06:02.160 --> 01:06:04.549
me that you're back together. And so
01:06:04.559 --> 01:06:05.990
she's telling me that and I'm already a
01:06:06.000 --> 01:06:07.430
little freaked out by that, but I could
01:06:07.440 --> 01:06:09.829
explain that by her unconscious mind
01:06:09.839 --> 01:06:11.430
remembering, you know, all that stuff.
01:06:11.440 --> 01:06:13.109
I'm already skeptical, but I'm like,
01:06:13.119 --> 01:06:15.589
that's weird. Then she goes, "So we I
01:06:15.599 --> 01:06:18.630
greet you. I I take you into the kitchen
01:06:18.640 --> 01:06:21.109
and we sit down
01:06:21.119 --> 01:06:24.069
and then right away you start pointing
01:06:24.079 --> 01:06:27.349
at her face. You're irritated and
you're
01:06:27.359 --> 01:06:29.510
saying, "Get a new laugh. Get a new
01:06:29.520 --> 01:06:31.349
laugh." Your friend is sticking out her
01:06:31.359 --> 01:06:32.789
tongue and you're pointing at her tongue
01:06:32.799 --> 01:06:36.549
saying, "Get a new laugh." So on the bus
01:06:36.559 --> 01:06:39.670
when I saw this person again on Friday,
01:06:39.680 --> 01:06:41.109
one of the things I noticed on the bus
01:06:41.119 --> 01:06:42.710
that at first I thought was charming,
01:06:42.720 --> 01:06:46.470
but then made me so annoyed, she started
01:06:46.480 --> 01:06:47.990
doing this laugh where she'd stick her
01:06:48.000 --> 01:06:49.510
tongue out and twirl it while she's
01:06:49.520 --> 01:06:50.789
laughing. And at first I was kind of
01:06:50.799 --> 01:06:53.029
sexy, but by the, you know, by the end
01:06:53.039 --> 01:06:55.990
of the weekend it was like it felt fake.
01:06:56.000 --> 01:06:57.190
And then I found out that she was
01:06:57.200 --> 01:06:59.116
imitating Jim Carrey from a movie.
01:06:59.126 --> 01:07:00.789
[laughter] And I never said get a new
01:07:00.799 --> 01:07:02.950
laugh. But all weekend when she would do
01:07:02.960 --> 01:07:05.349
that little tongue thing in her lap, I
01:07:05.359 --> 01:07:07.270
was so annoyed. And I was thinking like
01:07:07.280 --> 01:07:08.870
just I wasn't thinking literally get a
01:07:08.880 --> 01:07:10.150
new laugh, but I was thinking like it's
01:07:10.160 --> 01:07:13.349
so fake. It's so fake. So my friend says
01:07:13.359 --> 01:07:15.829
the thing about pointing at her tongue.
01:07:15.839 --> 01:07:17.670
Then she almost finished the dream. It
01:07:17.680 --> 01:07:18.710
wasn't a long dream at all. That's
01:07:18.720 --> 01:07:19.750
another thing. This was not a dream
01:07:19.760 --> 01:07:21.670
where she filled it with details and I'm
01:07:21.680 --> 01:07:23.109
pulling it out. It was like that. Maybe
01:07:23.119 --> 01:07:24.549
something else. And then she was almost
01:07:24.559 --> 01:07:27.430
done with the dream and she goes, "Oh
01:07:27.440 --> 01:07:28.870
yeah, there was this other thing." I'm
01:07:28.880 --> 01:07:30.549
like, I'm already freaked at this point
01:07:30.559 --> 01:07:32.150
cuz I could kind of understand the door,
01:07:32.160 --> 01:07:33.510
but I couldn't understand the tongue.
01:07:33.520 --> 01:07:35.589
And then she goes,
01:07:35.599 --> 01:07:37.510
"You guys are getting ready to go. You
01:07:37.520 --> 01:07:39.829
stand up and then
01:07:39.839 --> 01:07:41.829
she, the girlfriend, points at the
01:07:41.839 --> 01:07:43.430
middle of my kitchen table and there's
01:07:43.440 --> 01:07:45.589
this big thing of foam beer. Just like
01:07:45.599 --> 01:07:48.069
the foam from beer. And now she's
01:07:48.079 --> 01:07:51.670
laughing at you. The night before, so my
01:07:51.680 --> 01:07:54.470
final night, I'm at a restaurant, a
01:07:54.480 --> 01:07:56.470
fancy restaurant I've taken her out to.
01:07:56.480 --> 01:07:58.150
I was young. I didn't drink even in
01:07:58.160 --> 01:07:59.990
those days at all, but I she I was a
01:08:00.000 --> 01:08:00.950
little older than her and I could get a
01:08:00.960 --> 01:08:02.150
beer, so I thought it was cool to like
01:08:02.160 --> 01:08:05.109
get her a beer and pour it. And I I'm in
01:08:05.119 --> 01:08:06.390
this fancy restaurant. I'm a little bit
01:08:06.400 --> 01:08:07.829
of a clown. So when it happened, I
01:08:07.839 --> 01:08:09.990
poured it and it just went and you know,
01:08:10.000 --> 01:08:11.510
just all over the table. And then she
01:08:11.520 --> 01:08:13.430
was laughing at me and I sort of did a
01:08:13.440 --> 01:08:15.029
little performance for the people
01:08:15.039 --> 01:08:18.309
around. So my friend says that and I'm
01:08:18.319 --> 01:08:21.349
like I couldn't finish my dinner. I was
01:08:21.359 --> 01:08:23.030
like
01:08:23.040 --> 01:08:24.630
I only knew her. She's done like this
01:08:24.640 --> 01:08:27.669
this professor is known for research she
01:08:27.679 --> 01:08:29.910
did on language in the 70s at Stanford.
01:08:29.920 --> 01:08:32.229
Like she's she never indicated anything
01:08:32.239 --> 01:08:33.990
like this and she was she was as
01:08:34.000 --> 01:08:35.590
mesmerized as me as I was talking. But
01:08:35.600 --> 01:08:38.950
then we went into her living room and we
01:08:38.960 --> 01:08:40.390
were up until about 3:00 in the morning
01:08:40.400 --> 01:08:42.309
with her telling me her history since
01:08:42.319 --> 01:08:44.950
she was four years old of having this
01:08:44.960 --> 01:08:47.430
stuff. She doesn't try, she doesn't. But
01:08:47.440 --> 01:08:50.390
like since she was four and that was
01:08:50.400 --> 01:08:52.390
when I emailed the next day or soon
01:08:52.400 --> 01:08:55.669
thereafter I got Dennit's email and said
01:08:55.679 --> 01:08:58.550
like I described that dream and said
01:08:58.560 --> 01:09:01.030
what what do I do with that?
01:09:01.040 --> 01:09:03.590
And so that that now imagine little
01:09:03.600 --> 01:09:05.430
postmodern me who believes everything's
01:09:05.440 --> 01:09:07.510
relative. All meaning is in a flux
01:09:07.520 --> 01:09:09.669
that's just based on contingencies. like
01:09:09.679 --> 01:09:11.590
it suddenly brought me back to this
01:09:11.600 --> 01:09:13.669
notion
01:09:13.679 --> 01:09:15.430
there's a ground I don't know what it is
01:09:15.440 --> 01:09:17.030
the mind is more mysterious than I think
01:09:17.040 --> 01:09:20.309
and it gave me a new start um in terms
01:09:20.319 --> 01:09:23.110
of just trying to
01:09:23.120 --> 01:09:26.550
I had hope
01:09:26.560 --> 01:09:29.189
>> see this I you're the chosen one yeah
01:09:29.199 --> 01:09:29.590
this is
01:09:29.600 --> 01:09:31.749
>> no no I said this was going to discredit
01:09:31.759 --> 01:09:32.789
me
01:09:32.799 --> 01:09:34.070
>> I said this was going to discredit me
01:09:34.080 -->
01:09:35.910
because it kind of does but I will to
01:09:35.920 --> 01:09:38.630
get some credit back I was careful I
01:09:38.640 --> 01:09:40.390
tried to be very careful over the years
01:09:40.400 --> 01:09:42.550
of I didn't I wanted a model that could
01:09:42.560 --> 01:09:44.630
explain how that happened without going
01:09:44.640 --> 01:09:47.910
into woo woo land I did not want to go
01:09:47.920 --> 01:09:50.070
into you know I was in Santa Cruz so I
01:09:50.080 --> 01:09:53.590
had so much opportunity to go woo woo
01:09:53.600 --> 01:09:56.149
>> but I needed a model that at least said
01:09:56.159 --> 01:09:59.189
oh yeah that can happen and here's why
01:09:59.199 --> 01:10:00.950
and so that's that was the new start for
01:10:00.960 --> 01:10:03.750
me in terms of just like you know I
01:10:03.760 --> 01:10:06.709
wasn't depressed as depressed anymore
01:10:06.719 --> 01:10:12.229
>> goodness me Um, who is Eugene Gendlin?
01:10:12.239 --> 01:10:15.270
>> Okay, [laughter]
01:10:15.280 --> 01:10:16.950
>> let's go into this [snorts]
01:10:16.960 --> 01:10:19.910
>> good transition. So, okay. So, it wasn't
01:10:19.920 --> 01:10:22.229
long after I I I got my master's degree
01:10:22.239 --> 01:10:24.149
and I think I my master's degree was in
01:10:24.159 --> 01:10:26.470
existential psychology. I learned to
01:10:26.480 --> 01:10:27.590
become a counselor. I was going to
01:10:27.600 --> 01:10:30.310
become a counselor. And he's this
01:10:30.320 --> 01:10:33.270
amazing guy. I was in my second year of
01:10:33.280 --> 01:10:36.229
my master's degree out in New England.
01:10:36.239 --> 01:10:40.310
And um he was a guy who in the 50s Carl
01:10:40.320 --> 01:10:43.110
Rogers was the one of the big uh
01:10:43.120 --> 01:10:44.550
psychotherapists at the time because he
01:10:44.560 --> 01:10:46.630
was pushing against psychoanalysis and
01:10:46.640 --> 01:10:48.470
he was pushing against cognitive
01:10:48.480 --> 01:10:49.350
behaviorism.
01:10:49.360 --> 01:10:49.590
>> Yeah.
01:10:49.600 --> 01:10:51.350
>> Right. Client centered therapy.
01:10:51.360 --> 01:10:52.310
>> Yeah.
01:10:52.320 --> 01:10:54.470
>> And Carl Rogers was a big wig at the
01:10:54.480 --> 01:10:56.070
University of Chicago. So he had a lot
01:10:56.080 --> 01:10:58.630
of money to do experiments. So they put
01:10:58.640 --> 01:11:01.830
all this money into getting clients
01:11:01.840 --> 01:11:05.110
going to six or seven really good
01:11:05.120 --> 01:11:07.030
therapists from different models. So a
01:11:07.040 --> 01:11:09.030
psychoanalyst, a cognitive behavioralist
01:11:09.040 --> 01:11:11.910
and then they recorded all the sessions
01:11:11.920 --> 01:11:13.990
and it was like the first time they'd
01:11:14.000 --> 01:11:16.310
ever done this somewhat systematically,
01:11:16.320 --> 01:11:17.510
you know, where we have recordings of
01:11:17.520 --> 01:11:19.750
everyone and they they had some metrics
01:11:19.760 --> 01:11:22.870
to show change and growth. And then Carl
01:11:22.880 --> 01:11:24.630
Rogers had this young student named
01:11:24.640 --> 01:11:27.030
Eugene Genlin who was a philosopher, but
01:11:27.040 --> 01:11:29.750
he's young philosopher dude who also was
01:11:29.760 --> 01:11:32.950
interested in psychology. So he gave
01:11:32.960 --> 01:11:35.510
Eugene and a little team of people all
01:11:35.520 --> 01:11:37.590
the tapes and just said, "Now we need to
01:11:37.600 --> 01:11:38.790
start listening to these things and
01:11:38.800 --> 01:11:42.229
seeing if there's patterns." Right? M.
01:11:42.239 --> 01:11:44.470
>> So Eugene, they listen to all these
01:11:44.480 --> 01:11:45.910
tapes, hundreds, and hundreds of hours
01:11:45.920 --> 01:11:47.990
of tapes, and they finally end up
01:11:48.000 --> 01:11:50.310
getting to the point where they can
01:11:50.320 --> 01:11:53.750
basically predict from the first 20 to
01:11:53.760 --> 01:11:55.830
30 minutes of a session, regardless of
01:11:55.840 --> 01:11:58.310
the form of therapy. They could they
01:11:58.320 --> 01:11:59.830
could predict how well the client was
01:11:59.840 --> 01:12:01.590
going to do on the metrics they had of
01:12:01.600 --> 01:12:03.990
change. And there was one thing they
01:12:04.000 --> 01:12:06.149
they noticed they could listen for in
01:12:06.159 --> 01:12:08.390
those first 20 minutes that was the
01:12:08.400 --> 01:12:10.630
predictor.
01:12:10.640 --> 01:12:13.189
Any guesses?
01:12:13.199 --> 01:12:15.030
>> Um, uh,
01:12:15.040 --> 01:12:18.550
>> number of hamsters owned. [laughter]
01:12:18.560 --> 01:12:21.590
>> You, you, you already looked this up.
01:12:21.600 --> 01:12:24.310
>> I did. I have. I got a tab here.
01:12:24.320 --> 01:12:25.750
>> Yeah. So, there's all these theories of
01:12:25.760 --> 01:12:27.189
like why you would own this many
01:12:27.199 --> 01:12:32.470
hamsters. [laughter] So,
01:12:32.480 --> 01:12:34.630
>> keep keep doing the bit for like half an
01:12:34.640 --> 01:12:35.270
hour. [laughter]
01:12:35.280 --> 01:12:38.229
>> I know. found was like at a certain age
01:12:38.239 --> 01:12:40.070
you get attracted to certain kinds of
01:12:40.080 --> 01:12:43.030
mammals and [laughter]
01:12:43.040 --> 01:12:46.709
um so what they found was this they
01:12:46.719 --> 01:12:48.950
would listen for a pause in the person
01:12:48.960 --> 01:12:51.270
in the client speaking they listen for a
01:12:51.280 --> 01:12:53.510
certain kind of pause and that pause was
01:12:53.520 --> 01:12:55.030
the kind of pause we all know when we're
01:12:55.040 --> 01:12:57.110
like
01:12:57.120 --> 01:12:59.510
you know someone says so you're scared
01:12:59.520 --> 01:13:01.270
you can just somebody can say so you're
01:13:01.280 --> 01:13:03.110
scared and you can say yeah I'm scared
01:13:03.120 --> 01:13:05.270
like it's crazy because the person's
01:13:05.280 --> 01:13:06.470
always mean to me and I think they're
01:13:06.480 --> 01:13:07.990
strong and
they're going to hurt me. But
01:13:08.000 --> 01:13:09.510
there's a certain kind of client when
01:13:09.520 --> 01:13:12.229
you say, "So, you're scared?" They go,
01:13:12.239 --> 01:13:13.910
"Well,
01:13:13.920 --> 01:13:19.350
yeah, it's it's fear, but it's like um I
01:13:19.360 --> 01:13:21.430
don't it's kind of like a there's
01:13:21.440 --> 01:13:23.669
something exciting about it." You know,
01:13:23.679 --> 01:13:25.030
they're the people that are pausing to
01:13:25.040 --> 01:13:26.390
find their words, basically, or they're
01:13:26.400 --> 01:13:28.470
staying with an experience as opposed to
01:13:28.480 --> 01:13:30.950
just speaking from the explicated
01:13:30.960 --> 01:13:33.910
meaning of of [snorts] being scared. And
01:13:33.920 --> 01:13:36.149
so they noticed that people who just
01:13:36.159 --> 01:13:38.870
naturally for whatever reason tend to
01:13:38.880 --> 01:13:41.590
dwell a little bit in that funny place
01:13:41.600 --> 01:13:43.750
of meaning before it's articulated and
01:13:43.760 --> 01:13:45.830
explicated, they would be the clients
01:13:45.840 --> 01:13:47.350
that would always that would do much
01:13:47.360 --> 01:13:50.950
better than than that. And so Genlin
01:13:50.960 --> 01:13:53.910
Carl Rogers was ecstatic because he was
01:13:53.920 --> 01:13:56.070
finding um he didn't have much theory
01:13:56.080 --> 01:13:57.990
for what was happening with his clients
01:13:58.000 --> 01:13:59.990
in his process of client- centered
01:14:00.000 --> 01:14:02.790
therapist client centered therapy. So
01:14:02.800 --> 01:14:04.550
Eugene Genlin began to write
01:14:04.560 --> 01:14:06.229
philosophically a little bit more
01:14:06.239 --> 01:14:08.070
grounded about like what's you know how
01:14:08.080 --> 01:14:10.390
this works. Um and he became a
01:14:10.400 --> 01:14:12.550
psychoanalyst himself while still
01:14:12.560 --> 01:14:14.149
getting his degree in philosophy that
01:14:14.159 --> 01:14:17.030
his love was philosophy but he couldn't
01:14:17.040 --> 01:14:19.590
deny and he was a good person that he
01:14:19.600 --> 01:14:21.590
was finding ways to help. His question
01:14:21.600 --> 01:14:25.110
was this if this pause is really an
01:14:25.120 --> 01:14:27.350
important part of the process can we
01:14:27.360 --> 01:14:30.550
just teach clients to do that? like can
01:14:30.560 --> 01:14:32.070
we just teach people to spend a little
01:14:32.080 --> 01:14:35.030
bit more time in that weird zone of
01:14:35.040 --> 01:14:39.270
embodied meaning? And then he he he was
01:14:39.280 --> 01:14:40.630
people wanted him to write a book. He
01:14:40.640 --> 01:14:42.470
writes lots of intense philosophy and
01:14:42.480 --> 01:14:43.910
phenomenology, but people would say,
01:14:43.920 --> 01:14:45.270
"Can you just write a book for
01:14:45.280 --> 01:14:47.590
therapists that will be something a
01:14:47.600 --> 01:14:49.350
therapist could read and use with their
01:14:49.360 --> 01:14:50.630
clients?" And so then he wrote this book
01:14:50.640 --> 01:14:53.110
in the 70s called Focusing. And it's
01:14:53.120 --> 01:14:55.030
this it's what I first came across and I
01:14:55.040 --> 01:14:56.070
didn't really respect him because it
01:14:56.080 --> 01:14:57.590
seemed too simple, but it's where he
01:14:57.600 --> 01:14:59.669
first articulates for for therapists or
01:14:59.679 --> 01:15:02.790
people at home how you might learn to
01:15:02.800 --> 01:15:05.750
spend more time with that felt sense of
01:15:05.760 --> 01:15:09.110
meaning before you articulate it into um
01:15:09.120 --> 01:15:10.550
concepts
01:15:10.560 --> 01:15:12.229
>> or to at least notice when you're doing
01:15:12.239 --> 01:15:15.669
it. and that when I read about him and
01:15:15.679 --> 01:15:16.709
started learning about him in my
01:15:16.719 --> 01:15:18.709
master's degree program, at first I did
01:15:18.719 --> 01:15:20.149
discount him because that book just
01:15:20.159 --> 01:15:24.550
seemed a little too um simplistic. But
01:15:24.560 --> 01:15:26.550
then I started reading his philosophy
01:15:26.560 --> 01:15:28.950
papers and I got blown away. He he
01:15:28.960 --> 01:15:31.830
answered all he he began to speak to me
01:15:31.840 --> 01:15:34.070
most about what fascinates me about the
01:15:34.080 --> 01:15:36.070
mind and meaning, the creation of
01:15:36.080 --> 01:15:39.189
meaning.
01:15:39.199 --> 01:15:41.910
You gave us some sections from uh from
01:15:41.920 --> 01:15:46.390
Gendlin to to read. Well, um do do you
01:15:46.400 --> 01:15:47.990
fancy reading something, Milo? Do you
01:15:48.000 --> 01:15:48.870
fancy
01:15:48.880 --> 01:15:52.149
>> having a little Gendelin readathon?
01:15:52.159 --> 01:15:54.870
>> Hold on. That one from Jenlin was so
01:15:54.880 --> 01:15:57.430
long. Let me um or maybe not. I guess
01:15:57.440 --> 01:15:59.510
you guys do long form podcasts.
01:15:59.520 --> 01:16:00.229
>> Um
01:16:00.239 --> 01:16:02.070
>> yeah, we got our our audience have a lot
01:16:02.080 --> 01:16:03.669
of time.
01:16:03.679 --> 01:16:05.430
>> Yeah. Who [laughter]
01:16:05.440 --> 01:16:08.470
the ones still here? Yeah. No, no, no.
01:16:08.480 --> 01:16:12.597
Come on. They all watch on 0.25 speed.
01:16:12.607 --> 01:16:17.350
[laughter]
01:16:17.360 --> 01:16:21.590
>> Gentling.
01:16:21.600 --> 01:16:25.697
>> Now imagine that bit in two 0.25.
01:16:25.707 --> 01:16:28.229
[laughter]
01:16:28.239 --> 01:16:31.030
>> Okay, you can read the part. The thing
01:16:31.040 --> 01:16:32.790
for to have in the background of our
01:16:32.800 --> 01:16:34.709
minds as he's reading the Genlin thing
01:16:34.719 --> 01:16:39.270
is um he's basically trying to say that
01:16:39.280 --> 01:16:41.830
he's flipping the usual order in
01:16:41.840 --> 01:16:43.510
philosophy. Typically in phenomenology
01:16:43.520 --> 01:16:45.350
and philosophy, you think about
01:16:45.360 --> 01:16:47.030
experience, human experience, and then
01:16:47.040 --> 01:16:48.310
you come up with these logical
01:16:48.320 --> 01:16:49.910
connections and relationships and you
01:16:49.920 --> 01:16:52.070
lay those into the ground floor and you
01:16:52.080 --> 01:16:53.510
start building your model from those
01:16:53.520 --> 01:16:56.149
logical relations. And his point was we
01:16:56.159 --> 01:16:58.070
tend to forget that the creation of
01:16:58.080 --> 01:17:00.229
those logical the creations of those
01:17:00.239 --> 01:17:03.189
connections are embodied and felt. And
01:17:03.199 --> 01:17:05.510
so he wanted to try to stay with a
01:17:05.520 --> 01:17:09.110
philosophy that never forgets that the
01:17:09.120 --> 01:17:11.910
creation of the logical units is itself
01:17:11.920 --> 01:17:14.070
a creative moment. Very useful, very
01:17:14.080 --> 01:17:15.669
important and very helpful. But that you
01:17:15.679 --> 01:17:18.790
can always dip back into the embodied
01:17:18.800 --> 01:17:20.709
sense of meaning and create different
01:17:20.719 --> 01:17:23.110
units. So with that background this
01:17:23.120 --> 01:17:25.350
quote might make some sense.
01:17:25.360 --> 01:17:28.390
>> Yes. I will be the vessel Eugene will
01:17:28.400 --> 01:17:30.709
flow through me.
01:17:30.719 --> 01:17:32.470
Whatever the degree or kind of
01:17:32.480 --> 01:17:34.790
creativity involved in every case
01:17:34.800 --> 01:17:37.510
certain given felt meanings are directly
01:17:37.520 --> 01:17:39.830
referred to and function in the creation
01:17:39.840 --> 01:17:42.310
of new meaning. It is always just these
01:17:42.320 --> 01:17:45.189
given ones that so function. They are
01:17:45.199 --> 01:17:48.310
always directly referred to. Their
01:17:48.320 --> 01:17:50.310
functioning is both creative and
01:17:50.320 --> 01:17:52.709
determinative. We have inverted the
01:17:52.719 --> 01:17:54.870
usual philosophic procedure. Instead of
01:17:54.880 --> 01:17:56.310
seeking certain conceptual
01:17:56.320 --> 01:17:58.390
presuppositions that determine all
01:17:58.400 --> 01:18:00.630
experience and knowledge, we have sought
01:18:00.640 --> 01:18:03.189
to formulate the function of directly
01:18:03.199 --> 01:18:05.990
referred to experiencing in the creation
01:18:06.000 --> 01:18:08.310
of concepts. The usual philosophic
01:18:08.320 --> 01:18:10.550
procedure is to lay the conceptual into
01:18:10.560 --> 01:18:12.870
the preconceptual. The raw material of
01:18:12.880 --> 01:18:14.790
knowledge is controlled by conceptual
01:18:14.800 --> 01:18:17.270
rules. Conceptual relations thus
01:18:17.280 --> 01:18:19.669
determine concept formation before these
01:18:19.679 --> 01:18:21.910
conceptual relations are ever created or
01:18:21.920 --> 01:18:24.310
symbolized. We find instead that
01:18:24.320 --> 01:18:26.310
whenever logical relations are said to
01:18:26.320 --> 01:18:27.910
apply to an instance of concept
01:18:27.920 --> 01:18:30.950
formation, they really are
posterior to
01:18:30.960 --> 01:18:33.750
two experience creations. A the
01:18:33.760 --> 01:18:35.910
experience creation of the concepts to
01:18:35.920 --> 01:18:38.550
which they are said to apply. be the
01:18:38.560 --> 01:18:40.870
experience creation of certain further
01:18:40.880 --> 01:18:43.270
aspects of these concepts which are then
01:18:43.280 --> 01:18:45.669
formulated as these logical relations
01:18:45.679 --> 01:18:48.149
themselves. We have inverted the
01:18:48.159 --> 01:18:50.070
traditional philosophic procedure.
01:18:50.080 --> 01:18:52.229
Logical relations do not determine the
01:18:52.239 --> 01:18:54.470
creativity of new meaning and new
01:18:54.480 --> 01:18:57.270
symbiization. The preconceptual is not
01:18:57.280 --> 01:18:59.270
determined by the conceptual. We are
01:18:59.280 --> 01:19:01.430
inquiring into the functioning of the
01:19:01.440 --> 01:19:03.830
preconceptual itself. We can do so
01:19:03.840 --> 01:19:05.750
because the preconceptual when it
01:19:05.760 --> 01:19:07.990
functions in symbolization can be
01:19:08.000 --> 01:19:10.790
directly referred to.
01:19:10.800 --> 01:19:12.550
So says Eugene.
01:19:12.560 --> 01:19:15.430
>> So says Eugene. It kind of ends on the
01:19:15.440 --> 01:19:19.430
note of you know you can directly refer
01:19:19.440 --> 01:19:21.350
to the what he calls the preconceptual.
01:19:21.360 --> 01:19:23.830
He stopped calling it that later.
01:19:23.840 --> 01:19:25.830
>> The preconceptual just to clarify that's
01:19:25.840 --> 01:19:27.990
that space you enter when you when you
01:19:28.000 --> 01:19:28.950
pause.
01:19:28.960 --> 01:19:29.270
>> Yeah.
01:19:29.280 --> 01:19:31.350
>> It's like uh it's like fear. It's like
01:19:31.360 --> 01:19:34.310
the and and that stage that you're in
01:19:34.320 --> 01:19:37.189
before the concept is there when you're
01:19:37.199 --> 01:19:39.990
trying to invent it within yourself or
01:19:40.000 --> 01:19:42.070
find it within yourself or without of
01:19:42.080 --> 01:19:44.070
yourself or um
01:19:44.080 --> 01:19:47.350
>> that you can you can directly refer to
01:19:47.360 --> 01:19:49.350
that or symbolize it.
01:19:49.360 --> 01:19:51.830
>> Yes. And in directly referring to it if
01:19:51.840 --> 01:19:54.310
you what he wanted to do was to watch
01:19:54.320 --> 01:19:59.110
all the ways it functions. So and then
01:19:59.120 --> 01:20:00.790
he start in his first big philosophy
01:20:00.800 --> 01:20:02.390
book called experiencing and the
01:20:02.400 --> 01:20:05.669
creation of meaning he begins to try to
01:20:05.679 --> 01:20:07.189
talk about those different functions
01:20:07.199 --> 01:20:10.070
that that felt sense does and you know
01:20:10.080 --> 01:20:12.709
like I mean a good example is it's
01:20:12.719 --> 01:20:14.470
everybody knows when you know you know a
01:20:14.480 --> 01:20:16.390
name but you can't say it you can't get
01:20:16.400 --> 01:20:19.189
the name and you refer to this bodily
01:20:19.199 --> 01:20:21.110
sense that's very palpable I know the
01:20:21.120 --> 01:20:23.270
name you could even say like my chest
01:20:23.280 --> 01:20:26.149
it's like it's in me but I can't say it
01:20:26.159 --> 01:20:28.070
and
01:20:28.080 --> 01:20:30.709
That felt sense that can't say the name
01:20:30.719 --> 01:20:34.709
can reject any name instantly. So if I
01:20:34.719 --> 01:20:37.669
say Paul, you go, "No, it's not Paul.
01:20:37.679 --> 01:20:40.149
Cindy, it's not Cindy."
01:20:40.159 --> 01:20:42.070
So it's an interesting dynamic when you
01:20:42.080 --> 01:20:43.510
think about this thing that you can't
01:20:43.520 --> 01:20:46.229
say, this thing, you know, can still
01:20:46.239 --> 01:20:48.310
precisely
01:20:48.320 --> 01:20:49.990
reject something and then when when you
01:20:50.000 --> 01:20:51.510
get it, you go, "Oh, yeah, it's J or
01:20:51.520 --> 01:20:53.110
whatever you go." And it it carries
01:20:53.120 --> 01:20:55.189
forward. So
01:20:55.199 --> 01:20:56.310
>> that's one example. Well, the other
01:20:56.320 --> 01:20:57.830
would be you as a poet, you know what
01:20:57.840 --> 01:20:59.990
it's like when you you've you've put a
01:21:00.000 --> 01:21:03.350
phrase down and your body goes ick, but
01:21:03.360 --> 01:21:04.950
it's kind of good, it's kind of bad, but
01:21:04.960 --> 01:21:06.470
you you've put it in the poem just
01:21:06.480 --> 01:21:08.709
because maybe it's a placeholder. But
01:21:08.719 --> 01:21:10.229
then when you come back and you read the
01:21:10.239 --> 01:21:11.430
whole poem and you start from the
01:21:11.440 --> 01:21:13.030
beginning and you love the beginning of
01:21:13.040 --> 01:21:14.950
your poem, a felt sense starts to build
01:21:14.960 --> 01:21:16.870
up by all the units of meaning, the
01:21:16.880 --> 01:21:18.390
symbolizations,
01:21:18.400 --> 01:21:20.950
and that's what you use then to try to
01:21:20.960 --> 01:21:23.430
find what's going to be ah that's it.
01:21:23.440 --> 01:21:26.390
That's the phrase that does it.
01:21:26.400 --> 01:21:28.709
Yeah, I I suppose especially like
01:21:28.719 --> 01:21:31.830
writers who are more kind of picky and
01:21:31.840 --> 01:21:34.149
tasteful than me. I know like William
01:21:34.159 --> 01:21:36.550
Fork and I used to walk around the
01:21:36.560 --> 01:21:38.630
streets going, "I'm looking for a word
01:21:38.640 --> 01:21:41.750
like disaection or something." I'm like,
01:21:41.760 --> 01:21:43.510
he'd go around looking for words for
01:21:43.520 --> 01:21:46.390
days. I know James Joyce once he, you
01:21:46.400 --> 01:21:47.830
know, he said to someone, "I just got a
01:21:47.840 --> 01:21:49.510
good day's work done today." And someone
01:21:49.520 --> 01:21:51.270
said, "Oh, do you get a chapter done?"
01:21:51.280 --> 01:21:53.350
No. No. What about a paragraph? You get
01:21:53.360 --> 01:21:55.910
a paragraph done. No, not a paragraph, a
01:21:55.920 --> 01:21:59.990
sentence. No,
I I rearranged uh the
01:22:00.000 --> 01:22:02.390
words in a sentence written yesterday
01:22:02.400 --> 01:22:05.750
into the right order.
01:22:05.760 --> 01:22:08.870
>> Exactly. So, here it's preconceptual
01:22:08.880 --> 01:22:09.110
knowledge.
01:22:09.120 --> 01:22:11.590
>> It feels It feels right. It lands in the
01:22:11.600 --> 01:22:13.590
right way. It lands in the right place.
01:22:13.600 --> 01:22:14.070
Yeah.
01:22:14.080 --> 01:22:15.110
>> Yeah. Yeah.
01:22:15.120 --> 01:22:16.950
>> It's It's really interesting. Well, just
01:22:16.960 --> 01:22:19.270
it makes me think of Plato's
01:22:19.280 --> 01:22:21.030
epistemology and all the problems that
01:22:21.040 --> 01:22:22.390
he had trying. Well, do you know
01:22:22.400 --> 01:22:24.310
something or do you not know something?
01:22:24.320 --> 01:22:26.310
If you see someone you know from far
01:22:26.320 --> 01:22:28.790
away and you can't quite recognize them
01:22:28.800 --> 01:22:31.350
and you and you don't think it's them,
01:22:31.360 --> 01:22:33.990
do you not know it's them or you've made
01:22:34.000 --> 01:22:36.149
a mistake in knowing, but if you threw
01:22:36.159 --> 01:22:38.390
this at him, it would just sort of
01:22:38.400 --> 01:22:41.030
because in those in those dialogues, he
01:22:41.040 --> 01:22:42.870
never comes to any kind of real
01:22:42.880 --> 01:22:44.390
conclusion. He just sort of gets in a
01:22:44.400 --> 01:22:45.990
muddle and then leaves it. But this
01:22:46.000 --> 01:22:47.590
increases the muddle even more because
01:22:47.600 --> 01:22:49.030
okay, you have a knowledge that you
01:22:49.040 --> 01:22:51.510
can't access, but you're aware when it's
01:22:51.520 --> 01:22:54.629
not that you can delete the whole world
01:22:54.639 --> 01:22:57.590
around the thing you don't know and then
01:22:57.600 --> 01:22:59.990
somehow tease it up
01:23:00.000 --> 01:23:01.590
>> out of the skull.
01:23:01.600 --> 01:23:04.629
>> Right. Right. Exactly. And so Genlin in
01:23:04.639 --> 01:23:05.590
some ways you could say is an
01:23:05.600 --> 01:23:07.510
arisatilian and because he's pulling
01:23:07.520 --> 01:23:08.950
from this relationship between the
01:23:08.960 --> 01:23:10.950
potential and the actual. And you can
01:23:10.960 --> 01:23:12.550
even see that like there's something
01:23:12.560 --> 01:23:15.350
like the potential when you're you know
01:23:15.360 --> 01:23:17.590
sometimes you just see a certain uh
01:23:17.600 --> 01:23:19.669
moment a squirrel drops from a tree and
01:23:19.679 --> 01:23:21.030
you suddenly know there's a poem you
01:23:21.040 --> 01:23:22.870
have to write like you don't know what
01:23:22.880 --> 01:23:25.270
it is but you know exactly what it kind
01:23:25.280 --> 01:23:28.470
of feels like and that's kind of the I
01:23:28.480 --> 01:23:29.590
don't know there's an aristatilian
01:23:29.600 --> 01:23:32.229
aspect to that potentiality actualizing
01:23:32.239 --> 01:23:34.629
with each little
symbol you try to give
01:23:34.639 --> 01:23:36.790
to it keeps f in that relationship
01:23:36.800 --> 01:23:39.030
between the symbol and the potential or
01:23:39.040 --> 01:23:41.990
the the felt implying is what Jenlin was
01:23:42.000 --> 01:23:45.189
fascinated by. And I think it's part of
01:23:45.199 --> 01:23:46.390
what made him, and this is what I loved
01:23:46.400 --> 01:23:48.070
about him the most as I got to know I
01:23:48.080 --> 01:23:49.669
got I had some email correspondences
01:23:49.679 --> 01:23:51.990
with him in in in the later years, but
01:23:52.000 --> 01:23:55.110
he's the most generous thinker I've ever
01:23:55.120 --> 01:23:57.510
met. Like
01:23:57.520 --> 01:24:01.430
he loved every philosopher he read. He
01:24:01.440 --> 01:24:02.950
understood them deeply. And he would
01:24:02.960 --> 01:24:04.790
actually get upset. Jen would get upset
01:24:04.800 --> 01:24:07.110
at his students when they would um talk
01:24:07.120 --> 01:24:09.030
about Kant and they would say, "Well,
01:24:09.040 --> 01:24:10.550
Kant clearly didn't get this thing about
01:24:10.560 --> 01:24:11.590
your philosophy." You know, they would
01:24:11.600 --> 01:24:13.669
come to him with his philosophy. And he
01:24:13.679 --> 01:24:14.390
would say,
01:24:14.400 --> 01:24:16.229
>> "Stop."
01:24:16.239 --> 01:24:17.990
And he has this article called how to do
01:24:18.000 --> 01:24:19.830
phil or how to read philosophers in
01:24:19.840 --> 01:24:21.830
which he basically says when you're
01:24:21.840 --> 01:24:24.950
reading a philosopher
01:24:24.960 --> 01:24:26.870
you have to assume no matter what is
01:24:26.880 --> 01:24:27.910
going on in your body when you're
01:24:27.920 --> 01:24:30.470
reading you you start by assuming
01:24:30.480 --> 01:24:32.229
everything they said was perfectly
01:24:32.239 --> 01:24:33.750
figured out. And when you have a little
01:24:33.760 --> 01:24:36.149
counter example in your mind assume
01:24:36.159 --> 01:24:39.510
you're wrong. And um because most
01:24:39.520 --> 01:24:41.030
philosophers who spend so much time
01:24:41.040 --> 01:24:43.189
thinking they're they're they're aware
01:24:43.199 --> 01:24:44.950
of the objection you're about to make.
01:24:44.960 --> 01:24:47.590
So give them the credit of that. And he
01:24:47.600 --> 01:24:49.590
would be very scolding and like I'm not
01:24:49.600 --> 01:24:51.270
going to you're not going to say I
01:24:51.280 --> 01:24:53.669
outdid Kant. You have to first
01:24:53.679 --> 01:24:55.030
understand Kant to the best of your
01:24:55.040 --> 01:24:56.709
ability. And I always loved that about
01:24:56.719 --> 01:24:59.270
him. He he loved every and that's how he
01:24:59.280 --> 01:25:00.629
was as a psychotherapist. I think that's
01:25:00.639 --> 01:25:02.790
why he was good. He cared so much about
01:25:02.800 --> 01:25:06.550
where meaning comes from and the actual
01:25:06.560 --> 01:25:09.510
process of it and he and he he and
01:25:09.520
--> 01:25:11.430
that's what I try to do. So that became
01:25:11.440 --> 01:25:13.990
my model.
01:25:14.000 --> 01:25:15.430
It's kind of a meta model, but that
01:25:15.440 --> 01:25:18.390
became my model for what I love about
01:25:18.400 --> 01:25:20.390
what can happen in a therapeutic
01:25:20.400 --> 01:25:21.910
encounter.
01:25:21.920 --> 01:25:24.550
Became that like
01:25:24.560 --> 01:25:28.550
staying very very present to that edge
01:25:28.560 --> 01:25:30.790
of meaning that's happening for me as
01:25:30.800 --> 01:25:32.709
the therapist. You know, I have my own
01:25:32.719 --> 01:25:34.070
edges happening where I think I know
01:25:34.080 --> 01:25:35.189
what's going on with the client and I
01:25:35.199 --> 01:25:37.990
really try to notice that, honor it, but
01:25:38.000 --> 01:25:40.390
stay in the merc of meaning developing.
01:25:40.400 --> 01:25:44.629
And I I try to coach clients or at least
01:25:44.639 --> 01:25:46.390
guide them to noticing that they can do
01:25:46.400 --> 01:25:48.149
that in their own lives.
01:25:48.159 --> 01:25:49.990
>> It's kind of being comfortable with
01:25:50.000 --> 01:25:52.390
ambiguity and dissonance. Yeah.
01:25:52.400 --> 01:25:52.790
>> Yeah.
01:25:52.800 --> 01:25:54.629
>> Which is Yeah. Can be can be extremely
01:25:54.639 --> 01:25:56.950
uncomfortable. I mean often I find
01:25:56.960 --> 01:26:00.390
myself like someone asks how are you and
01:26:00.400 --> 01:26:03.110
like to prevent myself going into like a
01:26:03.120 --> 01:26:06.070
complete spiral like a half hour you
01:26:06.080 --> 01:26:07.350
know [laughter]
01:26:07.360 --> 01:26:10.149
sweating weeping in the corner like what
01:26:10.159 --> 01:26:12.950
on earth is I'll just have a pat answer
01:26:12.960 --> 01:26:15.189
often I find myself just saying things I
01:26:15.199 --> 01:26:18.629
don't believe just to make the to make
01:26:18.639 --> 01:26:21.590
social interactions and like ex you know
01:26:21.600 --> 01:26:23.669
just life move on
01:26:23.679 --> 01:26:25.510
>> you know lovely
01:26:25.520 --> 01:26:28.390
when it's objectively terrible weather
01:26:28.400 --> 01:26:31.669
>> and you know just I just need I don't
01:26:31.679 --> 01:26:35.270
care what I mean as much as I care about
01:26:35.280 --> 01:26:36.709
getting things moving along and I
01:26:36.719 --> 01:26:38.870
imagine in when you go to therapy that's
01:26:38.880 --> 01:26:43.370
a really uh a good way to derail things.
01:26:43.380 --> 01:26:43.910
[laughter]
01:26:43.920 --> 01:26:45.830
>> Yeah. Yeah.
01:26:45.840 --> 01:26:47.430
>> I was about to say I was about to say
01:26:47.440 --> 01:26:49.189
the same thing with the how are you
01:26:49.199 --> 01:26:51.189
thing. It is sometimes said to me and I
01:26:51.199 --> 01:26:53.430
will generally pause for a moment, muse
01:26:53.440 --> 01:26:55.430
and then typically I'm usually doing
01:26:55.440 --> 01:26:56.790
pretty well. So I think yeah I'm well
01:26:56.800 --> 01:26:58.229
and then they always say that wasn't
01:26:58.239 --> 01:27:01.270
very convincing. Well hold on I thought
01:27:01.280 --> 01:27:04.709
about it. Most people good in you. I and
01:27:04.719 --> 01:27:06.390
I get punished for thinking about it.
01:27:06.400 --> 01:27:08.310
But then I I wonder about, you know, I'm
01:27:08.320 --> 01:27:10.390
thinking about Glenn Gould, the man
01:27:10.400 --> 01:27:12.310
who's never paused in his life.
01:27:12.320 --> 01:27:15.990
Instantly paragraphs of deeply
01:27:16.000 --> 01:27:18.149
articulate response to is his
01:27:18.159 --> 01:27:20.629
preconceptual just like tiny
01:27:20.639 --> 01:27:22.870
microscopic, but still there. He's just
01:27:22.880 --> 01:27:25.590
running a thousand miles an hour
01:27:25.600 --> 01:27:27.430
>> or does just he doesn't need that. He
01:27:27.440 --> 01:27:28.229
doesn't have it.
01:27:28.239 --> 01:27:30.470
>> Worth saying that Glen Gould did write
01:27:30.480 --> 01:27:33.189
out almost all of his radio and TV
01:27:33.199 --> 01:27:34.709
interviews.
01:27:34.719 --> 01:27:35.270
Ah,
01:27:35.280 --> 01:27:38.310
>> we we have a a phone call between Glenn
01:27:38.320 --> 01:27:41.189
Gould and some students in New York, the
01:27:41.199 --> 01:27:43.669
Glen Gould Society. It's it's more like
01:27:43.679 --> 01:27:46.310
that. It is more it is more human. It's
01:27:46.320 --> 01:27:47.350
more
01:27:47.360 --> 01:27:48.790
>> Yeah. Uh but but these people who who
01:27:48.800 --> 01:27:50.629
grow up in front of uh cameras, in front
01:27:50.639 --> 01:27:53.189
of intercoms, who who have the I'm
01:27:53.199 --> 01:27:55.830
thinking people who are newscasters,
01:27:55.840 --> 01:27:58.629
streamers, like public intellectuals,
01:27:58.639 --> 01:28:00.550
debaters, these sorts of people who are
01:28:00.560 --> 01:28:04.390
just very very um articulate immediately
01:28:04.400 --> 01:28:06.070
and they have receipts for everything
01:28:06.080 --> 01:28:07.669
and they're good at making their point.
01:28:07.679 --> 01:28:10.470
I imagine these people are absolute hell
01:28:10.480 --> 01:28:11.910
in therapy
01:28:11.920 --> 01:28:13.350
>> just because they can they can talk
01:28:13.360 --> 01:28:14.950
their way out of anything or into
01:28:14.960 --> 01:28:17.590
anything and sound completely convincing
01:28:17.600 --> 01:28:19.430
>> and and um
01:28:19.440 --> 01:28:21.189
>> you know in what they're saying is
01:28:21.199 --> 01:28:23.110
probably true as well.
01:28:23.120 --> 01:28:23.830
>> Yeah.
01:28:23.840 --> 01:28:25.510
>> Well, that's actually you you said it. I
01:28:25.520 --> 01:28:27.270
remember Jen used to say and I've had
01:28:27.280 --> 01:28:28.629
this experience. Every therapist has had
01:28:28.639 --> 01:28:30.709
this experience in some way simplified.
01:28:30.719 --> 01:28:34.229
It's like this. the person comes in and
01:28:34.239 --> 01:28:35.669
they'll tell you the first time, hey, my
01:28:35.679 --> 01:28:38.870
problem is that uh um I don't trust my
01:28:38.880 --> 01:28:42.629
mom or something. And then 10 sessions
01:28:42.639 --> 01:28:46.229
later, they'll go
01:28:46.239 --> 01:28:48.149
and you you've built trust with them.
01:28:48.159 --> 01:28:49.669
You've you've 10 sessions like there's
01:28:49.679 --> 01:28:52.709
now a space for them to pause because
01:28:52.719 --> 01:28:54.470
their defense mechanism of just having
01:28:54.480 --> 01:28:56.070
an answer all the time. It's okay.
01:28:56.080 --> 01:28:57.590
They're safe here. They'll pause and
01:28:57.600 --> 01:28:59.030
they'll be and they might even tear up
01:28:59.040 --> 01:29:02.070
and say, "My problem is I don't trust my
01:29:02.080 --> 01:29:04.310
mom." And then they'll be tearing.
01:29:04.320 --> 01:29:05.990
They've just said the same symbols.
01:29:06.000 --> 01:29:07.669
Jenlin would point out that's the same
01:29:07.679 --> 01:29:09.590
symbolic sequence of words that they
01:29:09.600 --> 01:29:12.310
came into therapy with. But now it's
01:29:12.320 --> 01:29:14.870
carrying forward a completely different
01:29:14.880 --> 01:29:19.030
intricacy. So that knowing the problem
01:29:19.040 --> 01:29:21.990
does nothing. But that embodied knowing
01:29:22.000 --> 01:29:25.669
the problem is the beginning of of their
01:29:25.679 --> 01:29:27.270
healing or whatever it's going to be for
01:29:27.280 --> 01:29:31.030
them that allows them to shift and
01:29:31.040 --> 01:29:32.390
figure out what they're actually needing
01:29:32.400 --> 01:29:33.910
in their life, you know, and it's a
01:29:33.920 --> 01:29:35.910
beautiful moment because I what I love
01:29:35.920 --> 01:29:37.830
about Jenlin, his philosophy is so crazy
01:29:37.840 --> 01:29:39.189
and it can be hard to read and
01:29:39.199 --> 01:29:41.750
especially but then he can always boil
01:29:41.760 --> 01:29:44.470
it down to just everyday examples that
01:29:44.480 --> 01:29:47.270
that demonstrate his most complicated
01:29:47.280 --> 01:29:49.350
attempts to say what's going on. It's
01:29:49.360 --> 01:29:51.110
just like, yeah, what's it like when you
01:29:51.120 --> 01:29:52.550
find the right word? That's all I'm
01:29:52.560 --> 01:29:54.310
talking about.
01:29:54.320 --> 01:29:56.470
>> Jeff, have you ever read the short story
01:29:56.480 --> 01:29:59.590
Good Old Neon by David Foster Wallace?
01:29:59.600 --> 01:30:01.669
>> Yes. And here we get to play with my
01:30:01.679 --> 01:30:03.430
lack of memory. I love David Foster
01:30:03.440 --> 01:30:05.270
Wallace. Remind me of which one that is.
01:30:05.280 --> 01:30:05.990
That story.
01:30:06.000 --> 01:30:07.910
>> Yeah. So, so and and my own memories of
01:30:07.920 --> 01:30:10.149
it are are sort of faint. So, maybe
01:30:10.159 --> 01:30:11.990
together we can invent an all new story
01:30:12.000 --> 01:30:14.149
and discuss it.
01:30:14.159 --> 01:30:16.070
Sorry to all the the David Foster
01:30:16.080
--> 01:30:18.629
Wallace fans at home, but the the part
01:30:18.639 --> 01:30:20.310
of it I'm specifically referring to, so
01:30:20.320 --> 01:30:22.229
it is it's a it's a story about a
01:30:22.239 --> 01:30:24.229
suicidal man, which David Foster Wallace
01:30:24.239 --> 01:30:27.030
knew a thing or two about and he he does
01:30:27.040 --> 01:30:30.709
attempt recovery and he does enter
01:30:30.719 --> 01:30:32.790
therapy hoping and he get, you know, the
01:30:32.800 --> 01:30:34.629
best therapist in the game and he really
01:30:34.639 --> 01:30:36.629
wishes that someone can overmaster his
01:30:36.639 --> 01:30:38.870
own mind. That's his intention and he
01:30:38.880 --> 01:30:41.590
wants it to work. But equally, he he
01:30:41.600 --> 01:30:43.669
doesn't want this to be a kind of just a
01:30:43.679 --> 01:30:46.070
performance, just a show. And in in many
01:30:46.080 --> 01:30:47.510
ways, the the story is about
01:30:47.520 --> 01:30:49.669
performance. And so what he does is when
01:30:49.679 --> 01:30:52.229
he goes to this therapist, you know, in
01:30:52.239 --> 01:30:54.629
intensely intelligent, very qualified,
01:30:54.639 --> 01:30:56.629
he decides, okay, let's see if I feed
01:30:56.639 --> 01:30:58.709
this this therapist just some sort of
01:30:58.719 --> 01:31:01.430
pat nonsense about mom and dad, will
01:31:01.440 --> 01:31:03.830
they go for it or can they see through
01:31:03.840 --> 01:31:06.629
me, will they know this isn't in fact
01:31:06.639 --> 01:31:08.790
what you're saying? And and so he gives
01:31:08.800 --> 01:31:10.870
it a go. really hoping he'll be found
01:31:10.880 --> 01:31:13.110
out. Really hoping this person has such
01:31:13.120 --> 01:31:15.830
insight, but he does the thing Jack's
01:31:15.840 --> 01:31:17.430
talking about, extremely articulate,
01:31:17.440 --> 01:31:18.629
extremely fluid,
01:31:18.639 --> 01:31:20.390
>> and then the therapist just goes for it
01:31:20.400 --> 01:31:22.390
and goes down that lane and says all the
01:31:22.400 --> 01:31:23.669
things you say,
01:31:23.679 --> 01:31:25.830
>> and you know, he's completely
01:31:25.840 --> 01:31:29.030
heartbroken by this and and so the story
01:31:29.040 --> 01:31:32.149
goes to its predetermined end. But it
01:31:32.159 --> 01:31:34.070
but it made me think of just that
01:31:34.080 --> 01:31:35.910
problem. And I think it is an issue that
01:31:35.920 --> 01:31:37.990
many people have maybe with therapy in
01:31:38.000 --> 01:31:39.110
abstract.
01:31:39.120 --> 01:31:40.229
>> You know, if you give them what they
01:31:40.239 --> 01:31:41.910
want here, the therapist, they have
01:31:41.920 --> 01:31:44.149
these preset kind of notions
01:31:44.159 --> 01:31:45.990
>> and that and if they can't tell what
01:31:46.000 --> 01:31:48.229
you're saying is a performance, then how
01:31:48.239 --> 01:31:50.550
can anyone tell anything about anyone?
01:31:50.560 --> 01:31:52.229
Is this just all a show we're doing for
01:31:52.239 --> 01:31:53.669
each other? And we get somewhere,
01:31:53.679 --> 01:31:54.950
especially if you're not being so
01:31:54.960 --> 01:31:56.070
devious.
01:31:56.080 --> 01:31:58.629
>> But but have we just done this placebo
01:31:58.639 --> 01:32:01.189
magic hypnosis thing in a completely
01:32:01.199 --> 01:32:03.990
different way? Beautifully put.
01:32:04.000 --> 01:32:05.669
Beautifully put. Like you you're
01:32:05.679 --> 01:32:08.070
bringing me back to what I I'm shifting
01:32:08.080 --> 01:32:09.270
out of psychotherapy. I'm doing
01:32:09.280 --> 01:32:10.149
something a little bit different now.
01:32:10.159 --> 01:32:11.669
But you're taking me back to my favorite
01:32:11.679 --> 01:32:15.830
sessions were when um a lot of guys, at
01:32:15.840 --> 01:32:18.310
least in America, a lot of guys come in
01:32:18.320 --> 01:32:19.669
and they don't want therapy. They're
01:32:19.679 --> 01:32:22.550
typically seeing me because their spouse
01:32:22.560 --> 01:32:24.950
has said, "We're done if you don't get
01:32:24.960 --> 01:32:26.470
help, if you don't go to therapist." And
01:32:26.480 --> 01:32:28.950
so they come to me and I have a lot of
01:32:28.960 --> 01:32:30.950
things I don't do well, I think, as a
01:32:30.960 --> 01:32:32.790
therapist. But one of the things I do
01:32:32.800 --> 01:32:35.990
well is with the guy like that create a
01:32:36.000 --> 01:32:38.310
space where sometimes in the first
01:32:38.320 --> 01:32:40.950
session but by the fourth or fifth they
01:32:40.960 --> 01:32:43.830
on their own let go of that story
01:32:43.840 --> 01:32:45.189
they're telling me when they come into
01:32:45.199 --> 01:32:46.550
therapy you're talking about like they
01:32:46.560 --> 01:32:48.149
have a story they're going to tell me
01:32:48.159 --> 01:32:49.910
you know they're ready to be like I know
01:32:49.920 --> 01:32:51.669
my problem is you know I just need to be
01:32:51.679 --> 01:32:53.830
more patient and if I can listen better
01:32:53.840 --> 01:32:57.189
you know they have their story and in my
01:32:57.199 --> 01:32:58.629
olden days I would have wanted to like
01:32:58.639 --> 01:33:00.550
teach them skills to listen better you
01:33:00.560 --> 01:33:02.470
know which isn't bad. Actually, I I do
01:33:02.480 --> 01:33:05.030
some of that. But what I really love is
01:33:05.040 --> 01:33:06.470
when they get to that point where they
01:33:06.480 --> 01:33:08.390
pause, they crack open a little bit and
01:33:08.400 --> 01:33:10.950
they feel what's the implicit meaning
01:33:10.960 --> 01:33:12.870
underneath that they never pay attention
01:33:12.880 --> 01:33:15.270
to. And that's when they say they say
01:33:15.280 --> 01:33:16.790
something else. That's all I can say.
01:33:16.800 --> 01:33:18.149
They say something else. It has a
01:33:18.159 --> 01:33:19.750
totally different quality. And that's
01:33:19.760 --> 01:33:21.430
where the therapy starts in that
01:33:21.440 --> 01:33:23.590
something else. And I have to be very
01:33:23.600 --> 01:33:25.270
it's a sacred moment for me. It's a
01:33:25.280 --> 01:33:26.709
beautiful moment. And I have to be very
01:33:26.719 --> 01:33:28.149
careful because you can easily squash
01:33:28.159 --> 01:33:31.270
those moments as a therapist.
01:33:31.280 --> 01:33:33.510
you can scare them because my enth it's
01:33:33.520 --> 01:33:35.270
kind of like waking up in a lucid dream.
01:33:35.280 --> 01:33:37.189
Everyone the problem with lucid dreaming
01:33:37.199 --> 01:33:38.550
is when people start to have them they
01:33:38.560 --> 01:33:40.550
get so excited they wake up you know and
01:33:40.560 --> 01:33:42.229
as a therapist there's these really
01:33:42.239 --> 01:33:43.750
tender moments and you can get excited
01:33:43.760 --> 01:33:45.750
like oh my gosh we've and then you can
01:33:45.760 --> 01:33:47.510
like they run back into their shell
01:33:47.520 --> 01:33:49.430
because I get they even non-verbbally
01:33:49.440 --> 01:33:52.229
they sense me being like activated. So,
01:33:52.239 --> 01:33:53.910
I've had to learn to really just create
01:33:53.920 --> 01:33:56.790
a space and know that happened and I can
01:33:56.800 --> 01:33:58.550
refer back to it in my mind, but I don't
01:33:58.560 --> 01:34:01.510
have to like tamper with it right now.
01:34:01.520 --> 01:34:03.350
>> Yeah. No more aggressively scribbling in
01:34:03.360 --> 01:34:06.810
your notebook whenever they say, "Oh,
01:34:06.820 --> 01:34:10.229
[laughter]
01:34:10.239 --> 01:34:12.050
say that again. Say that again."
01:34:12.060 --> 01:34:12.870
[laughter]
01:34:12.880 --> 01:34:14.390
>> Yeah. Yeah. No, thanks for that. That's
01:34:14.400 --> 01:34:15.750
a That was a great description of
01:34:15.760 --> 01:34:17.350
something that's very real. And it
01:34:17.360 --> 01:34:18.870
reminded me of David Foster Wallace, who
01:34:18.880 --> 01:34:20.950
you mentioned in one of your talks. Uh
01:34:20.960 --> 01:34:23.430
oh, you put Infinite Jest on your list.
01:34:23.440 --> 01:34:23.830
Yeah.
01:34:23.840 --> 01:34:25.030
>> And um
01:34:25.040 --> 01:34:27.990
>> it it was a big book for me. I when I
01:34:28.000 --> 01:34:30.390
when I read it, it really really blew me
01:34:30.400 --> 01:34:32.709
away. And um there's a quote we might
01:34:32.719 --> 01:34:34.470
not get to, but I put a quote from Evan
01:34:34.480 --> 01:34:37.030
Dar who's a synonym
01:34:37.040 --> 01:34:39.189
pseudon. How do you say a writer who we
01:34:39.199 --> 01:34:41.430
don't pseudonmous?
01:34:41.440 --> 01:34:43.669
>> Yeah, synonymous writer who is my
01:34:43.679 --> 01:34:46.470
probably my favorite novelist. Um, and I
01:34:46.480 --> 01:34:48.470
I found out shortly after David Foster
01:34:48.480 --> 01:34:50.950
Wallace died that he had that book on a
01:34:50.960 --> 01:34:52.310
list.
01:34:52.320 --> 01:34:54.950
>> Um, and I always I have that pain of
01:34:54.960 --> 01:34:57.110
just wondering did he read it? Did he
01:34:57.120 --> 01:34:58.870
get to it or what would he have said?
01:34:58.880 --> 01:35:00.550
Because it's just a it's it's a
01:35:00.560 --> 01:35:01.270
beautiful novel.
01:35:01.280 --> 01:35:02.709
>> Yeah, I find the therapy sections of
01:35:02.719 --> 01:35:04.310
Infinite Jess the strongest. I got to
01:35:04.320 --> 01:35:06.229
say the bits with Gaitly in the in the
01:35:06.239 --> 01:35:08.390
AA meetings where it basically just
01:35:08.400 --> 01:35:10.550
becomes an essay. I mean, very thinly
01:35:10.560 --> 01:35:12.870
shrouded. this is his own experience
01:35:12.880 --> 01:35:14.950
going to Alcoholics Anonymous. That's
01:35:14.960 --> 01:35:17.189
just um that's my favorite stuff in
01:35:17.199 --> 01:35:19.590
there to be honest. Yeah, I was thinking
01:35:19.600 --> 01:35:23.270
like Infinite Jest. Um uh thinking about
01:35:23.280 --> 01:35:25.830
um uh the character of Hamlet being
01:35:25.840 --> 01:35:27.910
really good at doing the bullshitty
01:35:27.920 --> 01:35:29.750
immediate words coming to your mouth
01:35:29.760 --> 01:35:31.990
thing whenever he's with other people.
01:35:32.000 --> 01:35:33.750
>> Yes. When we when we get to the
01:35:33.760 --> 01:35:36.310
siloquiz, he starts to do more of this
01:35:36.320 --> 01:35:38.470
embodied meaning finding, finding out
01:35:38.480 --> 01:35:40.550
exactly what he means by things, you
01:35:40.560 --> 01:35:42.310
know, and to in to be or not to be. Most
01:35:42.320 --> 01:35:45.669
famously, you know, he he he defines to
01:35:45.679 --> 01:35:48.310
die in so many different ways.
01:35:48.320 --> 01:35:54.229
>> Not to be to um to to uh what is it? To
01:35:54.239 --> 01:35:57.350
oppose the sea of tide to end them, to
01:35:57.360 --> 01:36:00.390
die, to sleep. um no more and by asleep
01:36:00.400 --> 01:36:01.910
to say we end the heartache and the
01:36:01.920 --> 01:36:05.350
thousand natural shocks constant
01:36:05.360 --> 01:36:08.390
um re redefinition trying to figure out
01:36:08.400 --> 01:36:10.229
what he means exactly trying to actually
01:36:10.239 --> 01:36:12.070
construct a meaning as soon as Prince
01:36:12.080 --> 01:36:14.149
Hamlet's back with [laughter] all the
01:36:14.159 --> 01:36:16.070
idiots around him. He immediately gives
01:36:16.080 --> 01:36:18.149
the pat answers. He immediately gives
01:36:18.159 --> 01:36:20.790
super witty, super eloquent answers that
01:36:20.800 --> 01:36:22.470
explain things beautifully that are
01:36:22.480 --> 01:36:24.950
honest but just don't um
01:36:24.960 --> 01:36:28.149
>> don't go to the heart of the matter. Um
01:36:28.159 --> 01:36:31.510
>> yeah. Do you find that like um the the
01:36:31.520 --> 01:36:35.430
eloquent people um are may are maybe the
01:36:35.440 --> 01:36:39.350
people who find it hardest to to be in a
01:36:39.360 --> 01:36:41.750
in an ambiguous situation? Do do you
01:36:41.760 --> 01:36:44.870
think like the more um eloquent you are,
01:36:44.880 --> 01:36:48.310
the more um gifted you are with with
01:36:48.320 --> 01:36:50.709
language, with words, the more you you
01:36:50.719 --> 01:36:52.550
can hide from meaning?
01:36:52.560 --> 01:36:54.149
>> Mhm.
01:36:54.159 --> 01:36:56.629
On the level of
01:36:56.639 --> 01:36:58.550
the suffering that would bring a person
01:36:58.560 --> 01:37:00.470
into therapy or that doesn't bring them
01:37:00.480 --> 01:37:02.070
in but it is their suffering. I would
01:37:02.080 --> 01:37:04.470
say yes. I would say those people often
01:37:04.480 --> 01:37:07.830
love ambiguity on the level of seeing a
01:37:07.840 --> 01:37:09.270
movie and then talking and thinking
01:37:09.280 --> 01:37:11.270
about it afterward. They love not
01:37:11.280 --> 01:37:13.109
knowing if he meant that or that. But
01:37:13.119 --> 01:37:16.229
yeah, at the level of like their deepest
01:37:16.239 --> 01:37:18.149
pain that they're trying not to feel all
01:37:18.159 --> 01:37:20.470
day long and they have all these defense
01:37:20.480 --> 01:37:22.149
mechanisms built up to make sure they
01:37:22.159 --> 01:37:23.910
don't feel it. Yeah. I'd say their their
01:37:23.920 --> 01:37:27.590
their capacity to create meaning becomes
01:37:27.600 --> 01:37:30.390
their defense mechanism and they talk.
01:37:30.400 --> 01:37:31.590
Some of my friends who are the most
01:37:31.600 --> 01:37:33.430
poetic and the most, you know, they're
01:37:33.440 --> 01:37:36.550
like it's so hard to feel like you get
01:37:36.560 --> 01:37:38.310
to that moment where, you know, they're
01:37:38.320 --> 01:37:39.910
just feeling kind of raw, vulnerable,
01:37:39.920 --> 01:37:43.510
stupid, and a little scared.
01:37:43.520 --> 01:37:46.629
>> Yeah. I I wonder um what brought you to
01:37:46.639 --> 01:37:50.709
memorize every single Shakespeare set.
01:37:50.719 --> 01:37:54.870
>> Good. Good. Um,
01:37:54.880 --> 01:37:58.629
it was I think I can boil it down to and
01:37:58.639 --> 01:38:00.870
um we'll we'll put the quote down below.
01:38:00.880 --> 01:38:03.990
Look down below. But I read a quote from
01:38:04.000 --> 01:38:05.750
Nabokov
01:38:05.760 --> 01:38:08.470
and he said something like this. Nobody
01:38:08.480 --> 01:38:10.550
has ever paid closer attention to the
01:38:10.560 --> 01:38:12.629
texture of the English language as
01:38:12.639 --> 01:38:14.390
Shakespeare did in his sonnetss.
01:38:14.400 --> 01:38:16.149
Something like that.
01:38:16.159 --> 01:38:18.229
And I was working at the Shakespeare
01:38:18.239 --> 01:38:20.390
Festival, splitting my time there kind
01:38:20.400 --> 01:38:22.709
of in the development box office to and
01:38:22.719 --> 01:38:25.510
then I go out and be a therapist. And I
01:38:25.520 --> 01:38:26.550
didn't go into working at the
01:38:26.560 --> 01:38:27.910
Shakespeare Festival really loving
01:38:27.920 --> 01:38:29.189
Shakespeare. It was hard for me to
01:38:29.199 --> 01:38:31.430
understand all that stuff. It was
just
01:38:31.440 --> 01:38:33.270
too much for me. But you start to fall
01:38:33.280 --> 01:38:34.550
in love with it when you're going to the
01:38:34.560 --> 01:38:36.149
plays for free and you start to get to
01:38:36.159 --> 01:38:38.550
see Hamlet three different ways by three
01:38:38.560 --> 01:38:39.750
different actor. It just starts to
01:38:39.760 --> 01:38:42.310
become a very delightful experience. But
01:38:42.320 --> 01:38:45.830
the sonnetss, I'd crack them open. I
01:38:45.840 --> 01:38:47.669
knew nothing about the sonnet tradition,
01:38:47.679 --> 01:38:49.189
the sequences. I didn't know Philip
01:38:49.199 --> 01:38:50.470
Sydney. I didn't know Petrarch,
01:38:50.480 --> 01:38:52.149
anything. And I'd crack open his
01:38:52.159 --> 01:38:54.790
sonnetss and I'd be disgusted. Like,
01:38:54.800 --> 01:38:57.109
they weren't lovely to me. They were
01:38:57.119 --> 01:38:59.030
hard to figure out what was going on.
01:38:59.040 --> 01:39:01.109
And I didn't like them. And then I read
01:39:01.119 --> 01:39:03.030
that I I was going through a summer of
01:39:03.040 --> 01:39:05.350
trying to read all of Nabokov's novels,
01:39:05.360 --> 01:39:07.830
and I was up I was falling in love with
01:39:07.840 --> 01:39:10.070
his sentences and just the the texture,
01:39:10.080 --> 01:39:12.229
you could say. So when he said that, I
01:39:12.239 --> 01:39:15.109
was like, I need to I need to understand
01:39:15.119 --> 01:39:17.510
I need to feel that in the sonnetss. So
01:39:17.520 --> 01:39:20.149
that was what tipped me off towards
01:39:20.159 --> 01:39:23.669
picking up the sonnetss and wanting to
01:39:23.679 --> 01:39:25.430
have a different experience with them.
01:39:25.440 --> 01:39:27.510
And then that I started doing that and I
01:39:27.520 --> 01:39:29.109
started feeling I stopped trying to
01:39:29.119 --> 01:39:30.550
understand them. This goes back to our
01:39:30.560 --> 01:39:33.510
genian conversation. I stopped trying to
01:39:33.520 --> 01:39:36.070
like have something in the explicit
01:39:36.080 --> 01:39:38.229
meaning of them which I thought I had to
01:39:38.239 --> 01:39:40.550
do to enjoy the sonnet and I started
01:39:40.560 --> 01:39:43.430
just noticing the sound structures and
01:39:43.440 --> 01:39:46.310
the the way it felt to say it and I was
01:39:46.320 --> 01:39:47.750
then I was starting to feel that's what
01:39:47.760 --> 01:39:49.510
he's talking about. Navacov is not
01:39:49.520 --> 01:39:51.990
talking about how
01:39:52.000 --> 01:39:53.990
you learn about love through these signs
01:39:54.000 --> 01:39:56.470
or anything. So that was the first step
01:39:56.480 --> 01:39:58.629
and then I came across this guy Steven
01:39:58.639 --> 01:40:01.590
Booth. [clears throat] He's a critic and
01:40:01.600 --> 01:40:05.030
uh his his his all you have to take is
01:40:05.040 --> 01:40:07.189
Nabokov and Steven Booth put them
01:40:07.199 --> 01:40:09.910
together and then I one day I decided
I
01:40:09.920 --> 01:40:13.109
was going to memorize every sonnet not
01:40:13.119 --> 01:40:16.470
having a memory [laughter]
01:40:16.480 --> 01:40:18.950
>> and um uh you've given us some booth
01:40:18.960 --> 01:40:21.590
booth bits to read. Should I should I do
01:40:21.600 --> 01:40:24.310
which should I do the second booth quote
01:40:24.320 --> 01:40:25.510
perhaps?
01:40:25.520 --> 01:40:26.070
>> Yeah. Yeah.
01:40:26.080 --> 01:40:27.590
>> Yeah. Because it feels like it overlaps
01:40:27.600 --> 01:40:28.790
a lot with what we've been talking
01:40:28.800 --> 01:40:30.709
about. Um
01:40:30.719 --> 01:40:33.990
>> uh art comforts the spirit by presenting
01:40:34.000 --> 01:40:35.990
experience selected and organized in
01:40:36.000 --> 01:40:38.470
such a way as to exhibit the sense of
01:40:38.480 --> 01:40:41.430
pattern that the human mind tries always
01:40:41.440 --> 01:40:44.070
to perceive. In all experience the
01:40:44.080 --> 01:40:46.709
experience of nature so-called everyday
01:40:46.719 --> 01:40:49.750
experience is haphazard. It never quite
01:40:49.760 --> 01:40:52.629
conforms to the patterns imposed upon it
01:40:52.639 --> 01:40:55.189
by its participants who must think about
01:40:55.199 --> 01:40:58.070
it, talk about it, remember it, and
01:40:58.080 --> 01:41:00.550
predict it. From moment to moment, a
01:41:00.560 --> 01:41:03.430
person engaged in such experience must
01:41:03.440 --> 01:41:05.750
relate sensations and ideas to one
01:41:05.760 --> 01:41:08.070
another. He is not thinking hard, but he
01:41:08.080 --> 01:41:10.870
is actively and totally engaged. In the
01:41:10.880 --> 01:41:13.189
sets, Shakespeare does not achieve and
01:41:13.199 --> 01:41:15.910
surely wouldn't want the effect of
01:41:15.920 --> 01:41:17.910
natural experience whose randomness
01:41:17.920 --> 01:41:19.990
prompts the imposition of artistic order
01:41:20.000 --> 01:41:22.149
in the first place. Shakespeare does
01:41:22.159 --> 01:41:24.070
however evoke in his reader the
01:41:24.080 --> 01:41:26.629
incessant intellectual motion which the
01:41:26.639 --> 01:41:28.950
controlled experience of art ordinarily
01:41:28.960 --> 01:41:30.709
precludes. There is nothing in
01:41:30.719 --> 01:41:33.270
Shakespeare's sonet that does not
01:41:33.280 --> 01:41:36.950
pattern. But there are so many patterns
01:41:36.960 --> 01:41:38.950
that in moving from one system to
01:41:38.960 --> 01:41:40.950
another, the reader's mind operates
01:41:40.960 --> 01:41:43.750
similarly to the way it operates upon
01:41:43.760 --> 01:41:46.470
unstructured experience. Shakespeare
01:41:46.480 --> 01:41:49.030
approaches the popular impossibility of
01:41:49.040 --> 01:41:51.990
having his cake and eating it too.
01:41:52.000 --> 01:41:52.310
>> Right?
01:41:52.320 --> 01:41:55.510
>> I like Shakespeare recreates the world
01:41:55.520 --> 01:41:57.030
in order to [laughter]
01:41:57.040 --> 01:41:59.270
create the experience of being in
the
01:41:59.280 --> 01:42:01.590
world. It's not like you you you create
01:42:01.600 --> 01:42:03.990
the experience of natural experience by
01:42:04.000 --> 01:42:07.109
writing about it, but by being nature
01:42:07.119 --> 01:42:09.990
again in this artificial realm
01:42:10.000 --> 01:42:13.030
>> and um yeah creating all these patterns
01:42:13.040 --> 01:42:15.910
that that force you to apply meaning.
01:42:15.920 --> 01:42:18.310
They force the mind to go into that
01:42:18.320 --> 01:42:20.629
ambiguous meaning state and apply it.
01:42:20.639 --> 01:42:21.030
Yeah.
01:42:21.040 --> 01:42:23.109
>> Yes. And what perfectly said and what
01:42:23.119 --> 01:42:25.350
Booth what I've learned that Booth is
01:42:25.360 --> 01:42:28.070
pointing to is he's pointing to in our
01:42:28.080 --> 01:42:29.990
genine language he's pointing to all the
01:42:30.000 --> 01:42:32.709
acrobatics that Shakespeare is allowing
01:42:32.719 --> 01:42:35.750
your preconceptual experience to have
01:42:35.760 --> 01:42:38.310
and that's what Booth found the little
01:42:38.320 --> 01:42:40.390
miracles that he did because he's not
01:42:40.400 --> 01:42:43.189
Booth would say when we talk about why
01:42:43.199 --> 01:42:45.830
we love um love's labors lost or a
01:42:45.840 --> 01:42:47.990
sonnet well our mind will just say like
01:42:48.000 --> 01:42:49.990
I love that line or it's so good how he
01:42:50.000 --> 01:42:51.830
does this but What Booth's claim is that
01:42:51.840 --> 01:42:54.870
Shakespeare is doing this um behind the
01:42:54.880 --> 01:42:56.629
scenes whether it's conscious or not on
01:42:56.639 --> 01:42:58.229
Shakespeare's part. He's playing with
01:42:58.239 --> 01:43:02.550
patterns in a way that are so
01:43:02.560 --> 01:43:04.310
ephemerally they they they just shoot
01:43:04.320 --> 01:43:06.709
across the mind and they're enjoyable
01:43:06.719 --> 01:43:08.629
because he's changing a pattern. It
01:43:08.639 --> 01:43:10.070
could be like what's that rhetorical
01:43:10.080 --> 01:43:12.310
anaclast when a word is changing
01:43:12.320 --> 01:43:12.790
throughout
01:43:12.800 --> 01:43:15.030
>> kaya kaastic or something like that.
01:43:15.040 --> 01:43:16.310
>> Yeah, that's when they do that. But
01:43:16.320 --> 01:43:18.070
there's one where a word changes its
01:43:18.080 --> 01:43:21.109
meaning as it moves through
01:43:21.119 --> 01:43:22.790
Yeah. He does it with his own name quite
01:43:22.800 --> 01:43:24.390
a lot, Will.
01:43:24.400 --> 01:43:27.030
>> Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So, and and and what
01:43:27.040 --> 01:43:28.709
Booth would say is where other poets
01:43:28.719 --> 01:43:30.950
like Sydney and stuff,
01:43:30.960 --> 01:43:32.790
>> that was the thing they were showing the
01:43:32.800 --> 01:43:34.790
writer like the reader. They wanted you
01:43:34.800 --> 01:43:37.430
to notice that Booth thinks that
01:43:37.440 --> 01:43:39.510
Shakespeare is doing it in these subtle
01:43:39.520 --> 01:43:41.510
ways that you do experience, but they
01:43:41.520 --> 01:43:43.590
aren't um they aren't what you talk
01:43:43.600 --> 01:43:44.870
about later when you talk about that
01:43:44.880 --> 01:43:46.790
poem. Um
01:43:46.800 --> 01:43:49.430
>> anyway, so he has that. Now, if you read
01:43:49.440 --> 01:43:51.189
there's a shorter paragraph that starts
01:43:51.199 --> 01:43:52.950
with perhaps the happiest moment. I can
01:43:52.960 --> 01:43:53.910
read it, I guess, if you want.
01:43:53.920 --> 01:43:55.350
>> Yeah, go for it. Yeah, please.
01:43:55.360 --> 01:43:55.830
>> Yeah,
01:43:55.840 --> 01:43:57.030
>> this one cuz this one I [clears throat]
01:43:57.040 --> 01:43:59.189
think Go ahead.
01:43:59.199 --> 01:44:01.189
>> Oh, I just said the trifecta. We've all
01:44:01.199 --> 01:44:04.390
done our bit for the glory of mankind.
01:44:04.400 --> 01:44:08.629
>> Yeah. So, I will uh this one relates to
01:44:08.639 --> 01:44:10.390
a lot of what we were saying earlier, I
01:44:10.400 --> 01:44:12.550
think, in a weird interesting way.
01:44:12.560 --> 01:44:14.629
Perhaps the happiest moment the human
01:44:14.639 --> 01:44:17.270
mind ever knows is the moment when it
01:44:17.280 --> 01:44:19.189
senses the presence of order and
01:44:19.199 --> 01:44:22.870
coherence and before it realizes the
01:44:22.880 --> 01:44:25.910
particular nature and so the particular
01:44:25.920 --> 01:44:29.350
limits of the perception at the moment
01:44:29.360 --> 01:44:32.950
of unpart unparticularized perception.
01:44:32.960 --> 01:44:35.669
The mind is unlimited. It seems capable
01:44:35.679 --> 01:44:38.070
of grasping and about to grasp a
01:44:38.080 --> 01:44:40.629
coherence beyond its capacity. As he
01:44:40.639 --> 01:44:42.950
reads through the609 sonnetss, the
01:44:42.960 --> 01:44:44.790
source of that pleasurable sense of
01:44:44.800 --> 01:44:47.590
increased mental range is the same
01:44:47.600 --> 01:44:49.669
multitude of frames of reference that
01:44:49.679 --> 01:44:52.470
frustrate him when he looks for a single
01:44:52.480 --> 01:44:55.189
label or formula by which his mind may
01:44:55.199 --> 01:44:56.390
take personal possession of the
01:44:56.400 --> 01:44:58.310
sonnetss.
01:44:58.320 --> 01:44:59.350
>> Um, that's very nice.
01:44:59.360 --> 01:45:01.590
>> And so that moment, you know, I think he
01:45:01.600 --> 01:45:03.830
captures well that there's a moment of
01:45:03.840 --> 01:45:05.189
experience before it becomes
01:45:05.199 --> 01:45:07.270
particularized that's still very
01:45:07.280 --> 01:45:10.790
intricate. And that's because I don't
01:45:10.800 --> 01:45:13.830
have a good memory. Uh when I'm going
01:45:13.840 --> 01:45:15.109
through the sonnetss every day, I have
01:45:15.119 --> 01:45:17.669
to say 22 just mumble them to myself
01:45:17.679 --> 01:45:19.270
while I'm doing the dishes or whatever.
01:45:19.280 --> 01:45:21.910
As long as I say 22 a day, they stay in
01:45:21.920 --> 01:45:24.229
my mind. Um but that's what I'm paying
01:45:24.239 --> 01:45:26.310
attention. I'm just feeling and
01:45:26.320 --> 01:45:27.669
sometimes I have ideas. Sometimes I'm
01:45:27.679 --> 01:45:29.030
smart enough to write them down when I
01:45:29.040 --> 01:45:30.709
notice one of the patterns that I think.
01:45:30.719 --> 01:45:32.629
But I just typically I'm doing other
01:45:32.639 --> 01:45:34.149
things, you know.
01:45:34.159 --> 01:45:36.149
>> Yeah. And the the ending of that first
01:45:36.159 --> 01:45:37.750
quote, Shakespeare approaches the
01:45:37.760 --> 01:45:39.270
popular impossibility of having his cake
01:45:39.280 --> 01:45:41.350
and eating it too, I think is the great
01:45:41.360 --> 01:45:43.270
quality and also the great defect of
01:45:43.280 --> 01:45:45.669
Shakespeare. Defect when it doesn't play
01:45:45.679 --> 01:45:47.669
well. I think the taming of the shrew,
01:45:47.679 --> 01:45:49.510
which which is my least favorite of
01:45:49.520 --> 01:45:51.830
them. That the defect there is he he
01:45:51.840 --> 01:45:55.109
creates this sort of a runabout fast
01:45:55.119 --> 01:45:57.430
where we have to tame the shrew and that
01:45:57.440 --> 01:45:59.189
can be enjoyable if you play it
01:45:59.199 --> 01:46:01.270
straight, but he can't help but not play
01:46:01.280 --> 01:46:03.030
it straight. He has to make her a real
01:46:03.040 --> 01:46:05.510
woman who feels things for whom it is
01:46:05.520 --> 01:46:06.950
tragic. And then when she says, you
01:46:06.960 --> 01:46:08.629
know, the night is day or the moon is
01:46:08.639 --> 01:46:11.669
the sun, I feel terrible because he's
01:46:11.679 --> 01:46:13.750
he's created a real human only to
01:46:13.760 --> 01:46:16.550
completely humiliate her and he's living
01:46:16.560 --> 01:46:18.149
in two worlds at once.
01:46:18.159 --> 01:46:21.189
>> Shillock as well, you know, if he could
01:46:21.199 --> 01:46:23.910
just like go full on like let's just
01:46:23.920 --> 01:46:26.550
hate the Jews together for a while, but
01:46:26.560 --> 01:46:28.629
he can't just commit to it.
01:46:28.639 --> 01:46:31.109
>> He has to humanize them, damn it. ruins
01:46:31.119 --> 01:46:31.510
the
01:46:31.520 --> 01:46:32.709
>> whereas [laughter]
01:46:32.719 --> 01:46:36.470
whereas a fellow works because of this
01:46:36.480 --> 01:46:38.629
constant complication of itself. It's
01:46:38.639 --> 01:46:40.709
always has to be twisted another level.
01:46:40.719 --> 01:46:43.350
Coralenus is just a massive spiral of
01:46:43.360 --> 01:46:46.070
what is this play? On the page I think
01:46:46.080 --> 01:46:47.910
it's uninterpretable. It could be
01:46:47.920 --> 01:46:49.750
anything. Once you produce it, you've
01:46:49.760 --> 01:46:51.830
got to say I am a fascist or or maybe
01:46:51.840 --> 01:46:53.669
I'm not a fascist. But on the page,
01:46:53.679 --> 01:46:55.750
you're both simultaneously
01:46:55.760 --> 01:46:57.669
>> and the sonets I'm thinking
particularly
01:46:57.679 --> 01:47:00.870
of the the young man sequence. wonderful
01:47:00.880 --> 01:47:03.189
example of this because it sort of plays
01:47:03.199 --> 01:47:04.629
as a narrative. I don't know if this is
01:47:04.639 --> 01:47:07.350
a hot take, but reading one to what is
01:47:07.360 --> 01:47:08.629
it 127
01:47:08.639 --> 01:47:10.470
>> 17 I think the
01:47:10.480 --> 01:47:12.550
>> 126
01:47:12.560 --> 01:47:14.550
the breeding ones.
01:47:14.560 --> 01:47:16.790
>> No, no, I'm saying one from breeding all
01:47:16.800 --> 01:47:19.350
the way to 126.
01:47:19.360 --> 01:47:21.350
>> I'm sure all the young man stuff. All
01:47:21.360 --> 01:47:21.750
right.
01:47:21.760 --> 01:47:24.229
>> Exactly. Yeah. It's you can read it as a
01:47:24.239 --> 01:47:28.229
a narrative of an extensive relationship
01:47:28.239 --> 01:47:30.709
which has its es and flows. They are
01:47:30.719 --> 01:47:32.709
thematically linked. They often one
01:47:32.719 --> 01:47:35.189
responds to the one before it. And you
01:47:35.199 --> 01:47:36.870
can see you can paint it and there's the
01:47:36.880 --> 01:47:39.189
last maybe 20. It's like there's been a
01:47:39.199 --> 01:47:41.590
big gap and he's looking back and he's
01:47:41.600 --> 01:47:42.790
thinking, "Oh, you've aged three
01:47:42.800 --> 01:47:44.629
summers." And but you can build it into
01:47:44.639 --> 01:47:46.709
this. But in doing this, in painting
01:47:46.719 --> 01:47:49.109
this whole tapestry of a lifestyle, he
01:47:49.119 --> 01:47:51.590
can therefore put in that every possible
01:47:51.600 --> 01:47:54.070
relationship dynamic. We've done it all.
01:47:54.080 --> 01:47:56.709
I wanted you to breed. Then I then I
01:47:56.719 --> 01:47:58.470
loved you a lot. Then you cheated on me
01:47:58.480 --> 01:48:00.870
and I hated you. And then I took you
01:48:00.880 --> 01:48:02.629
back. And then I realized that writing
01:48:02.639 --> 01:48:04.390
is greater than beauty. And then I
01:48:04.400 --> 01:48:05.990
realized that beauty is greater than
01:48:06.000 --> 01:48:08.070
writing. Then I told you I can't write
01:48:08.080 --> 01:48:09.830
about you because silence is more
01:48:09.840 --> 01:48:11.430
powerful. Then I said you will be
01:48:11.440 --> 01:48:13.350
preserved unto the ending of the world.
01:48:13.360 --> 01:48:15.430
And then you grew old, but I loved you
01:48:15.440 --> 01:48:17.590
still because time cannot touch you. And
01:48:17.600 --> 01:48:19.350
time cannot touch you is the exact
01:48:19.360 --> 01:48:21.270
opposite of the breeder poems at the
01:48:21.280 --> 01:48:22.550
beginning. The whole point is time's
01:48:22.560 --> 01:48:25.350
touching you. Avoid it. By the end, you
01:48:25.360 --> 01:48:28.470
are fully immortal. Time sickle cannot
01:48:28.480 --> 01:48:30.310
move through you. And it's astounding.
01:48:30.320 --> 01:48:33.990
You get this one story, the 126 poems
01:48:34.000 --> 01:48:35.669
that seem to weave their way through the
01:48:35.679 --> 01:48:38.950
entirety of of this premise of I have I
01:48:38.960 --> 01:48:42.229
have a lover or I love this man.
01:48:42.239 --> 01:48:45.510
>> Yes. I [snorts] love that. And um per
01:48:45.520 --> 01:48:48.070
perfectly put. And I think he gives you
01:48:48.080 --> 01:48:50.790
so much like in the 17, they call them
01:48:50.800 --> 01:48:53.350
the 17 procreation sets. Those first 17
01:48:53.360 --> 01:48:54.470
where it's like have a baby, have a
01:48:54.480 --> 01:48:55.910
baby, have a baby, have a baby. And then
01:48:55.920 --> 01:48:57.430
on 18, he says, "Shall they compare thee
01:48:57.440 --> 01:48:58.790
to a summer's day, thy eternal summer
01:48:58.800 --> 01:49:00.709
shall not fade." You know, like that's
01:49:00.719 --> 01:49:02.550
the one where he says, but you can go
01:49:02.560 --> 01:49:04.149
back. At first, when I first started
01:49:04.159 --> 01:49:05.270
reading the sonnetss, I really thought
01:49:05.280 --> 01:49:07.189
of those first 17 as a little boring, a
01:49:07.199 --> 01:49:08.870
little mechanical. Now, I think he did
01:49:08.880 --> 01:49:11.030
that on purpose because you start to see
01:49:11.040 --> 01:49:13.109
even in the third sonnet, he's
01:49:13.119 --> 01:49:15.109
manipulating this. He's manipulating
01:49:15.119 --> 01:49:16.950
this kid. He's saying, "You need to have
01:49:16.960 --> 01:49:18.470
a baby. You're beautiful. You got to
01:49:18.480 --> 01:49:20.070
keep your legacy going and your keep
01:49:20.080 --> 01:49:20.629
your
01:49:20.639 --> 01:49:22.709
>> jeans. Good jeans. Keep them."
01:49:22.719 --> 01:49:24.229
>> There you go. I know you get I knew that
01:49:24.239 --> 01:49:26.950
would get you, Jack. [laughter]
01:49:26.960 --> 01:49:28.870
There was There was Oh, no. It was your
01:49:28.880 --> 01:49:31.669
uh Harry Potter your Harry Potter.
01:49:31.679 --> 01:49:33.910
>> Yeah. The Sydney Sweeney advert, you
01:49:33.920 --> 01:49:34.709
know.
01:49:34.719 --> 01:49:36.550
>> Yeah. Yeah. [laughter]
01:49:36.560 --> 01:49:38.310
But anyway, you start to see that even
01:49:38.320 --> 01:49:40.070
in those early kind of more
01:49:40.080 --> 01:49:41.750
mechanicalized
01:49:41.760 --> 01:49:45.590
sonnetss, he's so burying little digs at
01:49:45.600 --> 01:49:48.070
the narcissism of the fair youth and
01:49:48.080 --> 01:49:51.750
he's basically saying, "You need me to
01:49:51.760 --> 01:49:54.629
eternalize you through my art." And then
01:49:54.639 --> 01:49:55.990
he slowly gets up to where he says,
01:49:56.000 --> 01:49:57.350
"Okay, I'm gonna do it. I'm gonna do
01:49:57.360 --> 01:49:59.270
it." and um and there's so much
01:49:59.280 --> 01:50:02.629
playfulness in the in in in the ways he
01:50:02.639 --> 01:50:04.229
articulates going back and forth and
01:50:04.239 --> 01:50:06.709
manipulating the youth and also
01:50:06.719 --> 01:50:09.990
bearing his soul. But what I loved was
01:50:10.000 -->
01:50:13.430
when I found out that sonet sequences
01:50:13.440 --> 01:50:16.390
were never Yes, they create a persona of
01:50:16.400 --> 01:50:18.229
themselves. Sydney created a persona of
01:50:18.239 --> 01:50:20.790
himself. Yes, Petra created a persona of
01:50:20.800 --> 01:50:22.870
himself. But they were not wanting you
01:50:22.880 --> 01:50:26.950
to read them thinking um oh she won't
01:50:26.960 --> 01:50:29.189
[ __ ] me, oh she doesn't love me. Like
01:50:29.199 --> 01:50:32.550
they are making fun of they're using the
01:50:32.560 --> 01:50:34.310
narcissistic
01:50:34.320 --> 01:50:37.910
uh plays of love to comment on whatever
01:50:37.920 --> 01:50:40.709
their theological or social bigger
01:50:40.719 --> 01:50:43.350
structure is. And it's that play between
01:50:43.360 --> 01:50:45.590
making fun of themselves and the speaker
01:50:45.600 --> 01:50:47.350
and these other structures, the more
01:50:47.360 --> 01:50:49.669
architectural aspects of the sonnets or
01:50:49.679 --> 01:50:51.750
of the sequences that becomes really
01:50:51.760 --> 01:50:54.390
interesting for me. The both levels.
01:50:54.400 --> 01:50:56.550
>> Do you have like a gateway a gateway
01:50:56.560 --> 01:50:58.709
sonnet? The first one that you like
01:50:58.719 --> 01:51:00.870
really liked.
01:51:00.880 --> 01:51:08.870
>> That's good.
01:51:08.880 --> 01:51:12.390
I mean, 53 is fun. It's the one that
01:51:12.400 --> 01:51:15.990
First of all, I can't We can try, but I
01:51:16.000 --> 01:51:18.470
typically in public do not get through a
01:51:18.480 --> 01:51:21.990
sonnet, but let's see if I do.
01:51:22.000 --> 01:51:22.709
>> You want me to try?
01:51:22.719 --> 01:51:24.550
>> Sure. Go for it. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Let's
01:51:24.560 --> 01:51:25.910
Let's Wow.
01:51:25.920 --> 01:51:29.990
>> Okay. It 53. What is your substance?
01:51:30.000 --> 01:51:31.750
Wherever are you made the millions of
01:51:31.760 --> 01:51:34.229
strange shadows on you tend like
01:51:34.239 --> 01:51:36.310
everyone see I couldn't do it I couldn't
01:51:36.320 --> 01:51:37.350
do it do you have the sonnets in front
01:51:37.360 --> 01:51:37.669
of you
01:51:37.679 --> 01:51:39.510
>> I think it's since everyone have
01:51:39.520 --> 01:51:40.470
>> since everyone
01:51:40.480 --> 01:51:42.070
>> have everyone a shade or something like
01:51:42.080 --> 01:51:42.390
that
01:51:42.400 --> 01:51:43.750
>> yeah yeah yeah but see this is what
01:51:43.760 --> 01:51:45.750
happens I get a little too social but
01:51:45.760 --> 01:51:48.070
that sonnet was the f that's a sonnet
01:51:48.080 --> 01:51:49.350
where he's playing so much with the
01:51:49.360 --> 01:51:50.470
platonic form
01:51:50.480 --> 01:51:53.510
>> millions of strange shadows on you this
01:51:53.520 --> 01:51:55.127
guy
01:51:55.137 --> 01:51:55.669
[laughter]
01:51:55.679 --> 01:51:57.830
>> yeah and then he's he's equating him
01:51:57.840 --> 01:52:00.229
with Adonis he's saying you're the
01:52:00.239 --> 01:52:03.109
you're not you're not an instance of the
01:52:03.119 --> 01:52:05.910
platonic form. You are the form. And
01:52:05.920 --> 01:52:07.510
that was he was doing that in a way that
01:52:07.520 --> 01:52:09.270
a lot of the other sonnet sonnet people
01:52:09.280 --> 01:52:10.709
weren't quite doing. Shakespeare does it
01:52:10.719 --> 01:52:12.229
a few times in his sequence where he's
01:52:12.239 --> 01:52:13.910
basically saying you are the platonic
01:52:13.920 --> 01:52:16.742
form of that. Um and he also
01:52:16.752 --> 01:52:17.750
[clears throat] promises he'll never do
01:52:17.760 --> 01:52:20.229
that earlier in the sequence. So backs
01:52:20.239 --> 01:52:21.830
on it was the first was one that got
01:52:21.840 --> 01:52:22.790
stuck.
01:52:22.800 --> 01:52:25.350
>> Yeah. And it's it's like the Bloom idea
01:52:25.360 --> 01:52:29.109
when the uh thing that influenced then
01:52:29.119 --> 01:52:31.510
begins to look like it was influenced by
01:52:31.520 --> 01:52:34.790
the thing. So sort of reverse you read
01:52:34.800 --> 01:52:37.030
the like Seinfeld did. You look at the
01:52:37.040 --> 01:52:38.310
influence later. It's like oh you've
01:52:38.320 --> 01:52:40.390
done this in the style of me.
01:52:40.400 --> 01:52:42.550
>> I don't think so. But it's it's yeah
01:52:42.560 --> 01:52:45.030
this idea is being expressed
01:52:45.040 --> 01:52:47.030
>> in a romantic form.
01:52:47.040 --> 01:52:48.790
>> Yeah. And it's interesting because
01:52:48.800 --> 01:52:50.550
Stanley Wells, like some of the some of
01:52:50.560 --> 01:52:52.709
the big wig Shakespearean, they they
01:52:52.719 --> 01:52:54.629
think when they they talk about the
01:52:54.639 --> 01:52:56.310
sonnetss, they talk about them as if
01:52:56.320 --> 01:52:57.830
Shakespeare wrote a bunch of sonnets,
01:52:57.840 --> 01:52:59.109
somebody found them and threw them all
01:52:59.119 --> 01:53:01.270
together and tried to organize them, you
01:53:01.280 --> 01:53:03.750
know, and I just can't believe that. I
01:53:03.760 --> 01:53:04.950
can't believe it. And the more you get
01:53:04.960 --> 01:53:07.030
to know the sonnetss and you see the
01:53:07.040 --> 01:53:10.149
architectural the relationship between u
01:53:10.159 --> 01:53:11.669
it's like walking in a cathedral and
01:53:11.679 --> 01:53:13.589
looking up and you see the domes over
01:53:13.599 --> 01:53:15.430
there and their symmetry with the domes
01:53:15.440 --> 01:53:16.870
over there and there's
01:53:16.880 --> 01:53:18.550
>> you you start to see that the sonnetss
01:53:18.560 --> 01:53:21.189
aren't about a narrative they're about
01:53:21.199 --> 01:53:23.750
um relationships of structure and that
01:53:23.760 --> 01:53:25.189
becomes just that's part of the stuff
01:53:25.199 --> 01:53:26.870
that right now I'm like looking the most
01:53:26.880 --> 01:53:29.510
at is just how thoughtful and I think he
01:53:29.520 --> 01:53:31.270
had more time
01:53:31.280 --> 01:53:34.070
>> I think probably if he started thinking
01:53:34.080 --> 01:53:37.669
of his sequence in the midifs
01:53:37.679 --> 01:53:39.350
>> um when you know when the craze was
01:53:39.360 --> 01:53:42.470
bubbling up. I think he had
01:53:42.480 --> 01:53:46.310
at least 10 years to fiddle with them
01:53:46.320 --> 01:53:47.830
and really think about how he was going
01:53:47.840 --> 01:53:50.470
to outdo Sydney and all the others.
01:53:50.480 --> 01:53:53.189
>> 150 feels very Psalms. Feels very
01:53:53.199 --> 01:53:55.109
Psalms. Feels like you're doing a Psalms
01:53:55.119 --> 01:53:58.070
thing. I'm I'm see I see you there. I
01:53:58.080 --> 01:54:01.189
know what that number means. I Yeah.
01:54:01.199 --> 01:54:02.390
>> Well, yeah.
01:54:02.400 --> 01:54:05.189
>> Yeah. I I my my first was um that I
01:54:05.199 --> 01:54:07.830
really loved was was 55.
01:54:07.840 --> 01:54:08.790
Um
01:54:08.800 --> 01:54:10.709
>> not marble nor the gold. Yeah.
01:54:10.719 --> 01:54:13.109
>> Not no Yeah. Not marble nor the gilded
01:54:13.119 --> 01:54:15.270
monuments of princes shall outlive this
01:54:15.280 --> 01:54:17.910
powerful rhyme. But you shall shine more
01:54:17.920 --> 01:54:20.709
bright in these contents than unswept
01:54:20.719 --> 01:54:23.990
stone besmeared with slutish time.
01:54:24.000 --> 01:54:24.790
>> Yes.
01:54:24.800 --> 01:54:27.189
>> When wasteful war shall statues overturn
01:54:27.199 --> 01:54:29.430
and broils root out the work of masonry.
01:54:29.440 --> 01:54:31.990
Not Mars, his sword, nor wars, quick
01:54:32.000 --> 01:54:33.830
fires shall burn the living record of
01:54:33.840 --> 01:54:35.830
your memory. Against death and all
01:54:35.840 --> 01:54:38.470
oblivious emnity shall you pace forth.
01:54:38.480 --> 01:54:40.629
Your praise shall still find room even
01:54:40.639 --> 01:54:42.790
in the eyes of all posterity that wear
01:54:42.800 --> 01:54:45.270
this world out to the ending doom. So
01:54:45.280 --> 01:54:47.189
till the judgment that yourself arise,
01:54:47.199 --> 01:54:49.270
you live in this and dwell in lover's
01:54:49.280 --> 01:54:50.470
eyes.
01:54:50.480 --> 01:54:52.550
>> I learned that off by heart when I think
01:54:52.560 --> 01:54:54.550
I was 17 or something. And I remember
01:54:54.560 --> 01:54:57.589
just sitting on the bed in kind of the
01:54:57.599 --> 01:55:00.310
the downstairs, the kind of basement of
01:55:00.320 --> 01:55:03.430
my dad's house and just repeating it
01:55:03.440 --> 01:55:08.310
over and over and over again. Um uh just
01:55:08.320 --> 01:55:11.350
and it wasn't even an experience of of
01:55:11.360 --> 01:55:13.189
pleasure. It was something it was
01:55:13.199 --> 01:55:15.510
something beyond it. It was something it
01:55:15.520 --> 01:55:16.390
was
01:55:16.400 --> 01:55:18.310
>> coming into contact with something that
01:55:18.320 --> 01:55:22.229
felt authentically kind of kind of holy.
01:55:22.239 --> 01:55:25.510
There's a kind of a a a sacred geometry
01:55:25.520 --> 01:55:26.950
going on there.
01:55:26.960 --> 01:55:28.870
>> Um
01:55:28.880 --> 01:55:31.510
>> yeah, patterns,
01:55:31.520 --> 01:55:36.390
um feelings, um vague sensations that
01:55:36.400 --> 01:55:40.229
were just outside the character of um
01:55:40.239 --> 01:55:42.950
anything I'd really had in felt in
01:55:42.960 --> 01:55:45.589
language before, actually. Yeah,
01:55:45.599 --> 01:55:46.629
>> I love that.
01:55:46.639 --> 01:55:48.629
>> And and I've continued to, you know, I
01:55:48.639 --> 01:55:50.709
love them. I love them a lot. I've not
01:55:50.719 --> 01:55:52.870
memorized all of them, but I've um
01:55:52.880 --> 01:55:53.750
>> Oh, you're good.
01:55:53.760 --> 01:55:56.870
>> remembered a few over time. And and um
01:55:56.880 --> 01:55:59.669
it's amazing how uh how they don't they
01:55:59.679 --> 01:56:02.550
don't fade. Um I can have I can have a
01:56:02.560 --> 01:56:04.310
Shakespeare set that I've not thought
01:56:04.320 --> 01:56:07.990
about for two three years and it's it's
01:56:08.000 --> 01:56:10.629
much more in there than a Yates poem or
01:56:10.639 --> 01:56:12.870
a Blake poem or a Milton poem that I've
01:56:12.880 --> 01:56:14.310
not read for two or three years. I
01:56:14.320 --> 01:56:16.709
really think there is something um
01:56:16.719 --> 01:56:21.030
pretatural about Shakespeare's um
01:56:21.040 --> 01:56:23.910
ability to put words in an order,
01:56:23.920 --> 01:56:26.390
particularly words next to each other
01:56:26.400 --> 01:56:29.830
>> and um yeah and just so so many specific
01:56:29.840 --> 01:56:34.229
lines in amic pentameter that just um
01:56:34.239 --> 01:56:37.910
that that I find myself thinking when I
01:56:37.920 --> 01:56:41.270
let my mind fall asleep when I when I'm
01:56:41.280 --> 01:56:44.149
no longer there. Just a random line from
01:56:44.159 --> 01:56:46.310
sonet 30 or whatever will
01:56:46.320 --> 01:56:48.070
>> will um pop in.
01:56:48.080 --> 01:56:50.070
>> That's a beautiful one. Yeah, that's one
01:56:50.080 --> 01:56:51.270
of the most beautiful
01:56:51.280 --> 01:56:55.270
>> 30 is off the chain. Yeah. The proof
01:56:55.280 --> 01:56:57.109
sweet silent thought I summon up
01:56:57.119 --> 01:56:59.589
remembrance of things past I sigh the
01:56:59.599 --> 01:57:01.430
lack of many a thing I saw it and with
01:57:01.440 --> 01:57:04.070
old with new whale old whale my dear
01:57:04.080 --> 01:57:07.589
times waste. I I just conflated too.
01:57:07.599 --> 01:57:10.149
Then can then the the best bits the
01:57:10.159 --> 01:57:11.910
third the second quatt train. Then I
01:57:11.920 --> 01:57:15.189
then can I drown an eye unused to flow.
01:57:15.199 --> 01:57:17.589
For precious friends hid in death's
01:57:17.599 --> 01:57:19.669
dateless night.
01:57:19.679 --> 01:57:21.430
>> For precious friends hidden death's
01:57:21.440 --> 01:57:24.229
dateless night. Get is there a
line in
01:57:24.239 --> 01:57:26.070
amic pentameter better than that?
01:57:26.080 --> 01:57:27.109
>> No. There you go.
01:57:27.119 --> 01:57:27.430
>> Yeah.
01:57:27.440 --> 01:57:28.790
>> It's beautiful. I love hearing you
01:57:28.800 --> 01:57:30.870
should read the sonnet. I have I'm so I
01:57:30.880 --> 01:57:32.470
I have so many problems with how people
01:57:32.480 --> 01:57:35.589
read the sonnetss out loud and you avoid
01:57:35.599 --> 01:57:38.149
what drives me crazy. So I I we have to
01:57:38.159 --> 01:57:41.189
do an audio book because you don't I I
01:57:41.199 --> 01:57:43.030
was at the festival and a lot of times
01:57:43.040 --> 01:57:44.550
when people read sonnetss they'll be
01:57:44.560 --> 01:57:46.470
like they try to make it a character
01:57:46.480 --> 01:57:48.149
talking to another character on stage
01:57:48.159 --> 01:57:51.189
like shall I compare thee to a summer's
01:57:51.199 --> 01:57:52.229
day
01:57:52.239 --> 01:57:54.090
>> that more lovely you know as if
01:57:54.100 --> 01:57:55.189
[laughter] they're trying to find the
01:57:55.199 --> 01:57:57.430
words as they go and I'm like no just
01:57:57.440 --> 01:57:59.750
kind of don't mumble them but just let
01:57:59.760 --> 01:58:01.669
the words just let the words and the
01:58:01.679 --> 01:58:03.109
sounds come out of your mouth. And I
01:58:03.119 --> 01:58:04.709
love how you do that because I can feel
01:58:04.719 --> 01:58:06.629
that you like the sounds.
01:58:06.639 --> 01:58:07.189
>> Yeah.
01:58:07.199 --> 01:58:09.030
>> And there's there's it's deliberate in a
01:58:09.040 --> 01:58:10.629
way. I recently saw a production
01:58:10.639 --> 01:58:12.709
midsummer Night's Eve because it's that
01:58:12.719 --> 01:58:15.750
time of the year and uh you know it was
01:58:15.760 --> 01:58:18.870
a very entertaining production. Fine.
01:58:18.880 --> 01:58:21.109
But there are certain passages in that
01:58:21.119 --> 01:58:23.350
play which are just so beautiful in
01:58:23.360 --> 01:58:25.030
their language. I mean it's one of those
01:58:25.040 --> 01:58:28.070
lyrical plays and it was almost all lost
01:58:28.080 --> 01:58:30.229
to make them characters to make them say
01:58:30.239 --> 01:58:31.430
things to each other like they're
01:58:31.440 --> 01:58:33.109
people. And I get the impulse and I
01:58:33.119 --> 01:58:34.870
understand if everyone's stuck still
01:58:34.880 --> 01:58:37.430
reciting their amic and you lose a
01:58:37.440 --> 01:58:39.669
little bit of the dramatic energy. But I
01:58:39.679 --> 01:58:42.629
think at times it is worth morphing into
01:58:42.639 --> 01:58:45.030
the bard and just declaiming some of
01:58:45.040 --> 01:58:47.189
this stuff with the rhythm in there a
01:58:47.199 --> 01:58:48.390
little bit. You don't have to stop at
01:58:48.400 --> 01:58:50.870
the line endings and make it completely
01:58:50.880 --> 01:58:52.629
uh you know architectural like like a
01:58:52.639 --> 01:58:55.430
mansion
but let the poetry do a bit of
01:58:55.440 --> 01:58:57.030
the speaking. You don't have to fully
01:58:57.040 --> 01:58:59.750
immerse it in humanity. It it contains
01:58:59.760 --> 01:59:01.990
something in itself.
01:59:02.000 --> 01:59:04.470
Yes. And that's something the one of the
01:59:04.480 --> 01:59:05.910
joys of working at the Shakespeare
01:59:05.920 --> 01:59:08.470
Festival was you would see the young
01:59:08.480 --> 01:59:11.189
modern actors when they got hired there.
01:59:11.199 --> 01:59:13.270
They were great actors, but they just
01:59:13.280 --> 01:59:15.669
did so much muscular work to say the
01:59:15.679 --> 01:59:17.830
lines. And then you get the the older
01:59:17.840 --> 01:59:19.510
actors that have been at the festival
01:59:19.520 --> 01:59:21.589
for 20 years and they had found the way
01:59:21.599 --> 01:59:23.510
that you yes, you're acting, but there's
01:59:23.520 --> 01:59:25.350
also a way that the words are doing the
01:59:25.360 --> 01:59:27.350
work for you. and to feel and you and
01:59:27.360 --> 01:59:29.750
you get I worked there for 15 years so I
01:59:29.760 --> 01:59:31.589
would get to watch these young 22 year
01:59:31.599 --> 01:59:34.790
olds start to embody Shakespeare in new
01:59:34.800 --> 01:59:36.790
ways and it was just so precious and
01:59:36.800 --> 01:59:38.950
then they're doing like Hamlet their
01:59:38.960 --> 01:59:40.870
seventh year there and it's it's it's
01:59:40.880 --> 01:59:41.830
such a joy.
01:59:41.840 --> 01:59:44.629
>> Yeah. I I remember like Rafe Fines
01:59:44.639 --> 01:59:47.669
famous for sort of speed running Hamlet.
01:59:47.679 --> 01:59:49.990
He would like do everything as fast as
01:59:50.000 --> 01:59:51.990
fast as pos. Apparently, it was amazing.
01:59:52.000 --> 01:59:53.430
Apparently, it was brilliant. But he
01:59:53.440 --> 01:59:56.149
just like, you know, just absolutely uh
01:59:56.159 --> 01:59:58.550
storm stormed through. It just it
01:59:58.560 --> 02:00:00.550
sounded like someone it sounded like a
02:00:00.560 --> 02:00:03.109
fast-talking person talking fast.
02:00:03.119 --> 02:00:06.470
>> Oh, maybe if you're as good as Ray Fines
02:00:06.480 --> 02:00:10.629
at kind of every role, uh then yeah, you
02:00:10.639 --> 02:00:12.310
you pull it off.
02:00:12.320 --> 02:00:14.229
>> Yeah. I've heard that that Shakespeare
02:00:14.239 --> 02:00:16.310
used to be performed faster and it
02:00:16.320 --> 02:00:19.109
explains why some of the plays are seem
02:00:19.119 --> 02:00:21.189
absurdly long because if you do them at
02:00:21.199 --> 02:00:23.030
a clip and they did used to be faster
02:00:23.040 --> 02:00:25.270
for sure in terms of set and character
02:00:25.280 --> 02:00:27.109
changing because when the Victorians
02:00:27.119 --> 02:00:29.030
brought in these enormous sets and took
02:00:29.040 --> 02:00:31.109
20 minutes to change the scene whereas
02:00:31.119 --> 02:00:33.030
I've seen some sort of you know
02:00:33.040 -->
02:00:34.709
traditional productions where they're
02:00:34.719 --> 02:00:36.550
just running back and forth they exit
02:00:36.560 --> 02:00:38.550
and enter immediately straight into the
02:00:38.560 --> 02:00:39.589
next line
02:00:39.599 --> 02:00:41.430
>> and and the plays they take on a
02:00:41.440 --> 02:00:43.510
different aspect not always superior.
02:00:43.520 --> 02:00:46.629
It's like when you hear Elgar conducting
02:00:46.639 --> 02:00:48.550
Elgar and he does an Nimrod and it's
02:00:48.560 --> 02:00:50.310
like bam bam bam. It's like all right
02:00:50.320 --> 02:00:52.070
great. Sometimes it's good to go slow
02:00:52.080 --> 02:00:55.430
motion or Dusi's piano rolls of Cla
02:00:55.440 --> 02:00:57.830
Deoon where he's ripping through it and
02:00:57.840 --> 02:01:00.390
it's something.
02:01:00.400 --> 02:01:02.550
Yeah, it's mental.
02:01:02.560 --> 02:01:04.229
>> I just did one of my fake knots, but
02:01:04.239 --> 02:01:05.430
that's good. Yeah. Yeah.
02:01:05.440 --> 02:01:06.629
>> Yeah. [laughter]
02:01:06.639 --> 02:01:07.910
>> We'll get it on the scorecard.
02:01:07.920 --> 02:01:08.790
>> Yeah, get it on the score.
02:01:08.800 --> 02:01:10.229
>> Put it on the score. I did. You'll see
02:01:10.239 --> 02:01:11.990
it. I did a subtle like as if I knew
02:01:12.000 --> 02:01:14.070
your but I do the first it was the first
02:01:14.080 --> 02:01:17.270
one I faked the the dubc I have some
02:01:17.280 --> 02:01:18.550
reference to but what was the first
02:01:18.560 --> 02:01:19.109
thing you said
02:01:19.119 --> 02:01:21.669
>> the Elgar Enigma variations the
02:01:21.679 --> 02:01:23.830
variation it's it's kind of a Britain
02:01:23.840 --> 02:01:25.669
core thing [laughter]
02:01:25.679 --> 02:01:27.510
>> there's a very famous recording by
02:01:27.520 --> 02:01:29.510
Leonard Bernstein where he goes
02:01:29.520 --> 02:01:31.030
extremely
02:01:31.040 --> 02:01:33.189
slowly for Nimrod and the London
02:01:33.199 --> 02:01:35.109
Symphony Orchestra really hated him for
02:01:35.119 --> 02:01:36.790
it so apparently they're playing it kind
02:01:36.800 --> 02:01:38.709
of begrudgingly which made them go even
02:01:38.719 --> 02:01:40.310
slower I don't
02:01:40.320 --> 02:01:41.830
What's the Shakespeare sonet? I've been
02:01:41.840 --> 02:01:43.589
trying to remember. It's like it's
02:01:43.599 --> 02:01:46.229
there's a there's a um it's one of the
02:01:46.239 --> 02:01:49.270
great platonic love ones where he's
02:01:49.280 --> 02:01:52.550
saying all my previous lovers are you or
02:01:52.560 --> 02:01:55.669
all my loves from the past like buried
02:01:55.679 --> 02:01:57.430
in
02:01:57.440 --> 02:01:59.430
Exactly. And it's it's a great it's a
02:01:59.440 --> 02:02:01.350
sentiment it's a sentiment I love. It's
02:02:01.360 --> 02:02:03.990
a sentiment I love in all poetry. Like
02:02:04.000 --> 02:02:06.390
John Dunn has that you know um if ever
02:02:06.400 --> 02:02:08.550
any beauty I did see which I desired and
02:02:08.560 --> 02:02:10.950
got. just but a dream of thee. I love
02:02:10.960 --> 02:02:12.629
this as a sentiment. I've been looking
02:02:12.639 --> 02:02:14.550
for you my entire life through various
02:02:14.560 --> 02:02:16.229
different I think it works well no
02:02:16.239 --> 02:02:18.390
matter what you do. The Beatles song in
02:02:18.400 --> 02:02:21.510
my life. Um but uh yeah. Yeah. The
02:02:21.520 --> 02:02:22.229
buried
02:02:22.239 --> 02:02:24.790
>> 31. It's 31.
02:02:24.800 --> 02:02:27.990
>> Which which think about it like those
02:02:28.000 --> 02:02:29.830
people that say there's no coherence to
02:02:29.840 --> 02:02:31.669
the sequence. Like we just talked about
02:02:31.679 --> 02:02:33.510
30 and what is what was the line you
02:02:33.520 --> 02:02:36.229
brought up? Friends buried in death
02:02:36.239 --> 02:02:38.149
stateless night. And then he takes this
02:02:38.159 --> 02:02:41.350
image of burial again beautifully in 31,
02:02:41.360 --> 02:02:43.430
but he uses it in a in a different way
02:02:43.440 --> 02:02:46.149
for a different purp. Anyway, I love 31
02:02:46.159 --> 02:02:47.350
too. Yeah, it's
02:02:47.360 --> 02:02:50.229
>> Yeah. 31. Wow. Thy bosom is endeared
02:02:50.239 --> 02:02:52.709
with all hearts which I by lacking have
02:02:52.719 --> 02:02:55.109
supposed dead. And there reigns love and
02:02:55.119 --> 02:02:57.189
all love's loving parts and all those
02:02:57.199 --> 02:02:59.830
friends which I thought buried. How many
02:02:59.840 --> 02:03:02.550
a holy and obsequious tear hath dear
02:03:02.560 --> 02:03:04.870
religious love stolen from mine eye as
02:03:04.880 --> 02:03:07.510
interest of the dead which now appear
02:03:07.520 --> 02:03:10.390
but things removed that hidden in thee
02:03:10.400 --> 02:03:13.910
lie. Thou art the ba the god what a lie.
02:03:13.920 --> 02:03:16.470
Thou art the grave where buried love
02:03:16.480 --> 02:03:19.109
doth live hung with the trophies of my
02:03:19.119 --> 02:03:23.109
lovers gone who all their parts of me to
02:03:23.119 --> 02:03:26.390
thee did give that dw of many now is
02:03:26.400 --> 02:03:29.109
thine alone. Their images I loved I view
02:03:29.119 --> 02:03:32.390
in thee and thou all they has all the
02:03:32.400 --> 02:03:33.270
all of me.
02:03:33.280 --> 02:03:34.149
>> That's so good.
02:03:34.159 --> 02:03:36.709
>> What a poem. What a friend. Oh my god.
02:03:36.719 --> 02:03:39.430
It's so and the em and the emotion as
02:03:39.440 --> 02:03:41.430
well. They're very t like they they move
02:03:41.440 --> 02:03:45.109
me. I was I that pause there was a pause
02:03:45.119 --> 02:03:47.775
because I was moved reading about
02:03:47.785 --> 02:03:48.709
[laughter]
02:03:48.719 --> 02:03:49.750
that, you know.
02:03:49.760 --> 02:03:52.870
>> Yeah, I think that 29 to early 30s is a
02:03:52.880 --> 02:03:55.109
really good cluster.
02:03:55.119 --> 02:03:57.750
>> 29 off the chart. Yeah, that one's
the
02:03:57.760 --> 02:03:59.510
uh when in disgrace with fortune and
02:03:59.520 --> 02:04:02.390
men's eyes. Oh my god,
02:04:02.400 --> 02:04:04.790
>> this is great because one of the games
02:04:04.800 --> 02:04:06.310
that I play with other people who know
02:04:06.320 --> 02:04:09.189
the sequence is again the aliens come
02:04:09.199 --> 02:04:11.589
down and you have to pick seven sonnetss
02:04:11.599 --> 02:04:14.310
in a row uh to give to them. And it's so
02:04:14.320 --> 02:04:15.910
fun to think like what are those seven
02:04:15.920 --> 02:04:17.910
where's the segment of seven and I often
02:04:17.920 --> 02:04:21.830
think of that that from like 29 to 36
02:04:21.840 --> 02:04:23.830
because 36 is one of my favorite like
02:04:23.840 --> 02:04:27.076
but it's great. You guys are fun.
02:04:27.086 --> 02:04:28.550
[laughter]
02:04:28.560 --> 02:04:29.910
Well, one thing I just wanted to
02:04:29.920 --> 02:04:31.830
bookmark for, we're going to have a
02:04:31.840 --> 02:04:33.750
future conversation in a year. I believe
02:04:33.760 --> 02:04:35.510
your thing about you said sacred
02:04:35.520 --> 02:04:37.750
geometry when you mentioned 55.
02:04:37.760 --> 02:04:38.470
>> Yeah.
02:04:38.480 --> 02:04:40.310
>> And there is an interesting structural
02:04:40.320 --> 02:04:42.229
thing in the sequence that I find I look
02:04:42.239 --> 02:04:45.350
at sometimes and I
02:04:45.360 --> 02:04:48.070
108. Okay. So, Philip Sydney's sequence
02:04:48.080 --> 02:04:51.109
had 108 sonnetss in it and it kicked off
02:04:51.119 --> 02:04:53.350
the sonnet craze in England. you know,
02:04:53.360 --> 02:04:54.870
that's when Fletcher and Daniel,
02:04:54.880 --> 02:04:56.950
everybody had to write a sequence.
02:04:56.960 --> 02:04:59.669
>> There's a bunch of great relatively new
02:04:59.679 --> 02:05:02.310
scholarship showing that like these
02:05:02.320 --> 02:05:04.229
people were all referring to Sydney's
02:05:04.239 --> 02:05:06.229
patterning of 108 in different ways
02:05:06.239 --> 02:05:08.870
because he was using the harmonic scales
02:05:08.880 --> 02:05:10.709
and he was using what can what you can
02:05:10.719 --> 02:05:12.310
pull out of 108 in these fascinating
02:05:12.320 --> 02:05:13.830
ways. And the other poets, Daniel, they
02:05:13.840 --> 02:05:16.629
were all doing it. Shakespeare in his
02:05:16.639 --> 02:05:20.070
sequence. If you read Sydney's first
02:05:20.080 --> 02:05:23.830
sonnet and you read Shakespeare's 108, I
02:05:23.840 --> 02:05:25.589
just think you can't and Kathern Duncan
02:05:25.599 --> 02:05:27.189
Jones like many people have pointed this
02:05:27.199 --> 02:05:28.790
out, but I think it's you just see that
02:05:28.800 --> 02:05:31.589
in 108 Shakespeare is is nodding to
02:05:31.599 --> 02:05:33.910
Sydney. Now, that goes back to 55
02:05:33.920 --> 02:05:35.830
because
02:05:35.840 --> 02:05:39.589
55 there's three sonnets that say the
02:05:39.599 --> 02:05:43.910
word monument. 55, 81, which is
02:05:43.920 --> 02:05:47.510
fascinating, and 107.
02:05:47.520 --> 02:05:49.350
Now, those are the only three that say
02:05:49.360 --> 02:05:51.270
monument. They're 27 apart. They're
02:05:51.280 --> 02:05:53.109
perfectly structured. And there's more
02:05:53.119 --> 02:05:55.030
parallels I could talk about later that
02:05:55.040 --> 02:05:57.990
show how he he's definitely put this in
02:05:58.000 --> 02:05:59.750
there. And it comes right up against
02:05:59.760 --> 02:06:01.510
108. When I think Shakespeare is
02:06:01.520 --> 02:06:05.189
lovingly saying, it's like hiphop in the
02:06:05.199 --> 02:06:07.910
'9s. He's lovingly saying to Sydney,
02:06:07.920 --> 02:06:11.030
"You're awesome and you did 108 sonnetss
02:06:11.040 --> 02:06:12.950
and that's really cool. I love you, but
02:06:12.960 --> 02:06:16.149
watch. I've got like 50 more to go." But
02:06:16.159 --> 02:06:18.070
anyway, the fact that those three
02:06:18.080 --> 02:06:20.390
monument sonnets bounce up right against
02:06:20.400 --> 02:06:22.470
Sydney there is really interesting to
02:06:22.480 --> 02:06:24.390
me. And there's also, and I know this is
02:06:24.400 --> 02:06:25.750
when you don't know if you're reading
02:06:25.760 --> 02:06:28.950
things into it, but he uses monument in
02:06:28.960 --> 02:06:31.990
the first stanza of 55, the second
02:06:32.000 --> 02:06:34.790
stanza of uh 81, and then the third
02:06:34.800 --> 02:06:37.910
stanza of 107. And and there's other
02:06:37.920 --> 02:06:40.069
patterns of declination like that, like
02:06:40.079 --> 02:06:44.229
at the end 23, 24, 25, and 26, those
02:06:44.239 --> 02:06:46.470
final sonnetss of the fair youth
02:06:46.480 --> 02:06:49.270
sequence. 23 is when he stops talking to
02:06:49.280 --> 02:06:51.430
the fair youth and he addresses time and
02:06:51.440 --> 02:06:53.189
he starts with the word no. He says, "No
02:06:53.199 --> 02:06:54.550
time." And then
02:06:54.560 --> 02:06:55.990
>> Yeah. Isn't it one of the only
02:06:56.000 --> 02:06:58.149
exclamation marks in the quattro? Just
02:06:58.159 --> 02:06:59.189
just y
02:06:59.199 --> 02:07:00.470
>> bam
02:07:00.480 --> 02:07:04.310
>> boom. And then in [clears throat] 124 he
02:07:04.320 --> 02:07:07.189
starts no in the second stanza. And it's
02:07:07.199 --> 02:07:08.550
again he's not addressing the fair
02:07:08.560 --> 02:07:10.310
youth. He's addressing more time. And
02:07:10.320 --> 02:07:13.270
then in 125 he starts the third stanza
02:07:13.280 --> 02:07:16.790
with no. And then in 126 this is what I
02:07:16.800 --> 02:07:18.790
think is amazing. It's like you have
02:07:18.800 --> 02:07:20.629
this compression of nos, right? The no
02:07:20.639 --> 02:07:23.109
is going down down down. Then in 126,
02:07:23.119 --> 02:07:26.310
what's he do? He chops off the couplet
02:07:26.320 --> 02:07:28.950
and he turns every other line into
02:07:28.960 --> 02:07:31.189
couplets. So he turns every line into
02:07:31.199 --> 02:07:33.510
these ending points and then he chops
02:07:33.520 --> 02:07:35.030
off the couplet. And that's a structural
02:07:35.040 --> 02:07:36.709
thing that I don't know if that was
02:07:36.719 --> 02:07:38.470
intentional, but when you see more
02:07:38.480 --> 02:07:39.830
structure in the sus, you start to
02:07:39.840 --> 02:07:40.790
think,
02:07:40.800 --> 02:07:43.030
>> you know, he was seeing things too.
02:07:43.040 --> 02:07:45.270
>> That has the well, in the copy we have,
02:07:45.280 --> 02:07:46.550
which some people say it might be
02:07:46.560 --> 02:07:47.910
compositional, like just for the
02:07:47.920 --> 02:07:50.149
compositives, but we have these brackets
02:07:50.159 --> 02:07:52.310
for the missing lines. So there's just
02:07:52.320 --> 02:07:55.270
this emptiness on the page distinctly
02:07:55.280 --> 02:07:57.430
there. So it's not just oh it end it's a
02:07:57.440 --> 02:08:01.030
short sonnet. It's a set that has actual
02:08:01.040 --> 02:08:03.430
on the page nothing. You have to read it
02:08:03.440 --> 02:08:05.830
out. You have to read nothing for two
02:08:05.840 --> 02:08:08.390
lines. And it's it astounds me because
02:08:08.400 --> 02:08:11.109
if if we do take the position that
02:08:11.119 --> 02:08:13.750
Shakespeare did not arrange these on
02:08:13.760 --> 02:08:15.430
purpose, if we take the position that it
02:08:15.440 --> 02:08:16.790
is a compositor, we have to then
02:08:16.800 --> 02:08:18.870
introduce the second genius, the
02:08:18.880 --> 02:08:21.669
compositor. Because whoever got 150
02:08:21.679 --> 02:08:24.229
random old poems and managed to string
02:08:24.239 --> 02:08:26.229
them into this. It's likely the
02:08:26.239 --> 02:08:28.470
re-editing of the conversation, just a
02:08:28.480 --> 02:08:30.709
real left-wing reference, but that uh
02:08:30.719 --> 02:08:32.950
left field I should say, but that film
02:08:32.960 --> 02:08:35.830
unfinished, loads of missing scenes, and
02:08:35.840 --> 02:08:37.830
then they get Walter Merch on it, and he
02:08:37.840 --> 02:08:40.310
completely rearranges Coppers sort of
02:08:40.320 --> 02:08:42.069
very well shot, very interesting, but
02:08:42.079 --> 02:08:43.830
but ultimately unfinished film into one
02:08:43.840 --> 02:08:46.229
of the great kind of 1970s.
02:08:46.239 --> 02:08:47.830
>> I've seen it. I didn't know that.
02:08:47.840 --> 02:08:49.270
>> Yeah. No, nor did I. You would never
02:08:49.280 --> 02:08:50.629
guess.
02:08:50.639 --> 02:08:51.430
out of order.
02:08:51.440 --> 02:08:53.589
>> Yeah, Milo can send you the the
02:08:53.599 --> 02:08:56.709
conversation re-editing breakdown. It's
02:08:56.719 --> 02:08:58.904
the most crazy thing. It's the
02:08:58.914 --> 02:08:59.430
[laughter]
02:08:59.440 --> 02:09:02.229
like like it's like I'll take the 27th
02:09:02.239 --> 02:09:04.310
scene and that's scene one and then the
02:09:04.320 --> 02:09:07.030
49th scene and that scene two and then
02:09:07.040 --> 02:09:08.950
the 13th scene and that scene three.
02:09:08.960 --> 02:09:10.709
It's the ma It's the maddest edit
02:09:10.719 --> 02:09:12.709
anyone's ever done. Yeah,
02:09:12.719 --> 02:09:13.430
>> that's great.
02:09:13.440 --> 02:09:15.669
>> And like the hip-hop, we're back in the
02:09:15.679 --> 02:09:17.350
' 90s hip-hop putting things together,
02:09:17.360 --> 02:09:18.069
putting Yeah.
02:09:18.079 --> 02:09:19.750
>> Yep. Yep.
02:09:19.760 --> 02:09:20.629
each other.
02:09:20.639 --> 02:09:22.950
>> So either Shakespeare the great genius
02:09:22.960 --> 02:09:25.189
or another unnamed man who we can call
02:09:25.199 --> 02:09:28.310
Shakespeare also is the great G but
02:09:28.320 --> 02:09:29.669
either way there is one of them is
02:09:29.679 --> 02:09:31.830
operating here. We are observing
02:09:31.840 --> 02:09:34.390
something remarkable in this line and I
02:09:34.400 --> 02:09:36.390
I'm much less familiar with the dark
02:09:36.400 --> 02:09:38.790
lady stuff after young man but I can
02:09:38.800 --> 02:09:40.709
imagine there's a similar amount of sort
02:09:40.719 --> 02:09:43.430
of design in that structure.
02:09:43.440 --> 02:09:45.109
>> Totally is. And do you guys have time
02:09:45.119 --> 02:09:46.390
for one more little Shakespeare
02:09:46.400 --> 02:09:47.270
structural thing?
02:09:47.280 --> 02:09:49.910
>> Yeah. No, I I'm very free with time.
02:09:49.920 --> 02:09:50.629
Yeah. Okay.
02:09:50.639 --> 02:09:52.229
>> I'm going to get a glass of water if
02:09:52.239 --> 02:09:54.229
that's all right due to the enormous
02:09:54.239 --> 02:09:55.109
heat.
02:09:55.119 --> 02:09:58.069
>> Yep. Okay. So, a structural thing that's
02:09:58.079 --> 02:09:59.990
fascinating and you Jack made me think
02:10:00.000 --> 02:10:03.430
of it is that u Okay, when you look at
02:10:03.440 --> 02:10:06.069
the sequence, he numbers every sonnet
02:10:06.079 --> 02:10:09.030
all the way up to 154.
02:10:09.040 --> 02:10:10.950
But he does something a little it's a
02:10:10.960 --> 02:10:14.550
little different in that 153 and 154 are
02:10:14.560 --> 02:10:17.910
the cupid sonnetss and they're called I
02:10:17.920 --> 02:10:21.030
think the fancy word is anacriics.
02:10:21.040 --> 02:10:22.709
They're these sonnetss at the end of
02:10:22.719 --> 02:10:24.870
sequences there would often be these two
02:10:24.880 --> 02:10:27.990
like epigraph like playing with a Greek
02:10:28.000 --> 02:10:29.990
story of Cupid or something. But
02:10:30.000 --> 02:10:31.510
Shakespeare's
02:10:31.520 --> 02:10:34.709
numbered his and um people have always
02:10:34.719 --> 02:10:36.470
wondered was that the compositor like
02:10:36.480 --> 02:10:37.830
why are those numbered? They should just
02:10:37.840 --> 02:10:39.669
be set off aside and they should sort of
02:10:39.679 --> 02:10:42.229
introduce the complaint, the lover's
02:10:42.239 --> 02:10:45.270
complaint that comes after the sonnetss.
02:10:45.280 --> 02:10:46.629
Well, what's really interesting
02:10:46.639 --> 02:10:49.910
structurally speaking is that if you do
02:10:49.920 --> 02:10:53.109
put those two aside, you have 152
02:10:53.119 --> 02:10:55.270
sonnetss and all of those sonnets deal
02:10:55.280 --> 02:10:57.109
with the fair youth and the dark lady in
02:10:57.119 --> 02:10:59.910
some way or one way or other.
02:10:59.920 --> 02:11:02.870
in the middle
02:11:02.880 --> 02:11:07.990
from 27 to 126. That's 100 sonnets with
02:11:08.000 --> 02:11:12.950
26 on one wing and 26 on the other wing.
02:11:12.960 --> 02:11:17.109
And 20 sonnet 26 is this fascinating
02:11:17.119 --> 02:11:19.830
little sonnet, very witty sonnet that is
02:11:19.840 --> 02:11:24.709
basically copying the um dedication
02:11:24.719 --> 02:11:27.589
of Venus Adonis and Rape of Lree. the
02:11:27.599 --> 02:11:29.350
little dedication that Shakespeare makes
02:11:29.360 --> 02:11:32.709
to Southampton. Um 26 is one of these
02:11:32.719 --> 02:11:34.470
that's just it sounds like a dedication
02:11:34.480 --> 02:11:36.310
and he's saying I don't have any wit.
02:11:36.320 --> 02:11:38.709
This is just my love, you know, uh it's
02:11:38.719 --> 02:11:40.390
terrible. I'm not a good poet, but if
02:11:40.400 --> 02:11:41.910
you like this someday, you know, I'll
02:11:41.920 --> 02:11:43.830
show my head to you. So, it seems like
02:11:43.840 --> 02:11:45.589
suddenly you go through the procreation
02:11:45.599 --> 02:11:48.790
sonnetss, you you get the weird sonnet
02:11:48.800 --> 02:11:50.629
20 about the master mistress of my
02:11:50.639 --> 02:11:52.790
passion, which we could talk forever
02:11:52.800 --> 02:11:55.589
about, and then you get up to the next
02:11:55.599 --> 02:11:58.069
sonnetss. I see them as him giving you
02:11:58.079 --> 02:12:00.629
clues on how to read the structure from
02:12:00.639 --> 02:12:04.310
20 21 22 23 24 and then 26 he does this
02:12:04.320 --> 02:12:06.310
preface like almost like he's saying hey
02:12:06.320 --> 02:12:08.870
the rest of these poems here here you go
02:12:08.880 --> 02:12:10.470
and then you get this hundred sonnetss
02:12:10.480 --> 02:12:12.470
that are just uh to the fair youth and
02:12:12.480 --> 02:12:14.229
then you get the dark lady so there's a
02:12:14.239 --> 02:12:15.750
beautiful structure if you get rid of
02:12:15.760 --> 02:12:19.830
the cupids of a hundred framed by 26
02:12:19.840 --> 02:12:21.750
that um
02:12:21.760 --> 02:12:23.430
>> now that I say it I can't go further but
02:12:23.440 --> 02:12:25.270
there's more ways that reinforce the
02:12:25.280 --> 02:12:27.589
notion that he wanted you to have he
02:12:27.599 --> 02:12:29.669
wanted the cubid sonnetss to function so
02:12:29.679 --> 02:12:31.430
that you could either count them and
02:12:31.440 --> 02:12:35.189
then 77 is the middle or take them off
02:12:35.199 --> 02:12:37.270
and you get this other structure and one
02:12:37.280 --> 02:12:38.870
thing that I definitely
have loved
02:12:38.880 --> 02:12:42.149
learning I knew nothing about I knew
02:12:42.159 --> 02:12:43.510
nothing and I still don't know anything
02:12:43.520 --> 02:12:45.270
about the writing from that time period
02:12:45.280 --> 02:12:47.990
but you do learn that these artists were
02:12:48.000 --> 02:12:51.430
obsessed with structure in what they
02:12:51.440 --> 02:12:52.870
were writing and they were obsessed with
02:12:52.880 --> 02:12:54.870
putting things in the middle of things
02:12:54.880 --> 02:12:57.589
like the middle Petrarch did it uh
02:12:57.599 --> 02:13:00.470
Philip Sydney like the middle of works
02:13:00.480 --> 02:13:03.910
was a very important place to play games
02:13:03.920 --> 02:13:06.629
and anyway someday I'm going to say more
02:13:06.639 --> 02:13:08.310
about what I think the games that
02:13:08.320 --> 02:13:09.669
Shakespeare was playing
02:13:09.679 --> 02:13:12.629
>> yeah like you hear you get it a lot in
02:13:12.639 --> 02:13:14.870
in composition maybe I'm I'm more
02:13:14.880 --> 02:13:17.189
familiar with it in classical music uh
02:13:17.199 --> 02:13:21.270
these sorts of games especially uh um
02:13:21.280 --> 02:13:24.390
cognizance of the the opus number
02:13:24.400 --> 02:13:26.550
playing with that sort of thing. Number
02:13:26.560 --> 02:13:29.189
games with opus numbers. Mozart's
02:13:29.199 --> 02:13:31.430
marriage of Figaro famously starts with
02:13:31.440 --> 02:13:34.310
a man just announcing Italian numbers.
02:13:34.320 --> 02:13:37.750
It's like venti shinqu and he cuz he's
02:13:37.760 --> 02:13:40.310
mar he's measuring for his wedding bed
02:13:40.320 --> 02:13:42.550
on the floor with a ruler. He's taking
02:13:42.560 --> 02:13:45.990
measurements and they they function kind
02:13:46.000 --> 02:13:48.470
of as as arbitrary uh numbers as
02:13:48.480 --> 02:13:52.870
arbitrary just numeric units but Mozar
02:13:52.880 --> 02:13:55.270
uses them constantly throughout
02:13:55.280 --> 02:13:57.750
>> numbers of bars of things number of note
02:13:57.760 --> 02:13:59.750
not notes in melodies always in this
02:13:59.760 --> 02:14:02.709
specific sequence that the guy uses at
02:14:02.719 --> 02:14:05.030
the start and um although I don't think
02:14:05.040 --> 02:14:07.589
Shakespeare is
02:14:07.599 --> 02:14:10.149
has as much of this Nabacopian game side
02:14:10.159 --> 02:14:13.669
to him I I I don't register him as this
02:14:13.679 --> 02:14:16.069
kind of artist. I think of him as being
02:14:16.079 --> 02:14:20.870
much more um kind of impulsive slightly
02:14:20.880 --> 02:14:23.430
on on the moment. Like not that there
02:14:23.440 --> 02:14:26.069
aren't uh grand structures that emerge,
02:14:26.079 --> 02:14:27.830
but I think they are very much emergent
02:14:27.840 --> 02:14:29.109
structures.
02:14:29.119 --> 02:14:30.550
>> I don't think there's that much
02:14:30.560 --> 02:14:33.189
architectural uh top- down stuff in
02:14:33.199 --> 02:14:35.910
Shakespeare. I think it's one of um one
02:14:35.920 --> 02:14:37.990
of the interesting areas of writing he
02:14:38.000 --> 02:14:40.229
doesn't deal with very much. Yeah.
02:14:40.239 --> 02:14:42.470
formatting, looking at things from above
02:14:42.480 --> 02:14:46.629
that all the plays um the the the
02:14:46.639 --> 02:14:48.229
structure imposed on them through the
02:14:48.239 --> 02:14:50.310
acts feels just very much a cutout and
02:14:50.320 --> 02:14:53.669
he likes playing with with extended acts
02:14:53.679 --> 02:14:56.629
and shortening acts and action slowing
02:14:56.639 --> 02:15:00.550
out the acts. Um for for me Shakespeare
02:15:00.560 --> 02:15:04.709
is the kind of artist who's who's always
02:15:04.719 --> 02:15:07.109
budging against the constraints rather
02:15:07.119 --> 02:15:10.310
than placing them on this chaos.
02:15:10.320 --> 02:15:14.870
>> He is just like this this um like chaos
02:15:14.880 --> 02:15:16.790
contained by architecture rather than
02:15:16.800 --> 02:15:18.310
the other way around.
02:15:18.320 --> 02:15:19.510
>> Um
02:15:19.520 --> 02:15:21.830
>> beautiful. I mean, it's unbelievable
02:15:21.840 --> 02:15:24.629
when you think of there's 36 plays and
02:15:24.639 --> 02:15:26.229
the amount of time those are written in
02:15:26.239 --> 02:15:28.470
and the purpose of a play versus the
02:15:28.480 --> 02:15:30.069
purpose of a sonnet sequence. Like, they
02:15:30.079 --> 02:15:31.990
couldn't be more different. Like, the
02:15:32.000 --> 02:15:34.229
play has to it's telling a story. You're
02:15:34.239 --> 02:15:36.069
moving characters around. You're you're
02:15:36.079 --> 02:15:38.149
hitting those beats in terms of a plot.
02:15:38.159 --> 02:15:39.750
And the sonnetss really are much more
02:15:39.760 --> 02:15:42.229
like a cathedral. They're much more like
02:15:42.239 --> 02:15:45.270
the structure is externalized pointing
02:15:45.280 --> 02:15:47.510
architecturally. And that's why you you
02:15:47.520 --> 02:15:48.870
they're boring if you try to read them
02:15:48.880 --> 02:15:50.229
just as a story through, but they're not
02:15:50.239 --> 02:15:51.910
when you see that there's there's
02:15:51.920 --> 02:15:53.830
symmetrical relationships in the
02:15:53.840 --> 02:15:56.470
sequence touching each other. Um I think
02:15:56.480 --> 02:15:58.629
that's why Shakespeare probably loved
02:15:58.639 --> 02:16:00.870
working on the like he's busy writing
02:16:00.880 --> 02:16:03.109
plays all the time for various purposes
02:16:03.119 --> 02:16:04.870
and then he always has his little
02:16:04.880 --> 02:16:06.870
sequence to fiddle around with when he's
02:16:06.880 --> 02:16:08.790
tired of that form. You know, he gets to
02:16:08.800 --> 02:16:10.149
really think architect.
02:16:10.159 --> 02:16:12.149
>> Yeah. Yeah. It's it's it's interesting
02:16:12.159 --> 02:16:15.430
to consider it his almost like another
02:16:15.440 --> 02:16:18.709
art form because theater is is
clearly
02:16:18.719 --> 02:16:22.229
and always his primary occupation
02:16:22.239 --> 02:16:24.390
perhaps passion. I mean we have these
02:16:24.400 --> 02:16:26.149
long narrative poems that came out when
02:16:26.159 --> 02:16:29.350
the theaters were closed and um I forget
02:16:29.360 --> 02:16:30.550
who mentioned it. One of our former
02:16:30.560 --> 02:16:31.830
guests mentioned the fact that he could
02:16:31.840 --> 02:16:33.349
have gone gone on doing those. They sold
02:16:33.359 --> 02:16:35.349
very well. They were they were popular
02:16:35.359 --> 02:16:37.190
but clearly soon as the theaters back
02:16:37.200 --> 02:16:40.070
open he's back. playwright, actor,
02:16:40.080 --> 02:16:41.750
producer, the whole the whole affair.
02:16:41.760 --> 02:16:43.110
It's just what he does. And and it's
02:16:43.120 --> 02:16:46.150
fascinating when you find um trace the
02:16:46.160 --> 02:16:47.910
textual history of some of his plays
02:16:47.920 --> 02:16:50.070
like we know or at least we presume from
02:16:50.080 --> 02:16:52.870
the quattro and folio of Hamlet that at
02:16:52.880 --> 02:16:55.030
least one great speech you know capital
02:16:55.040 --> 02:16:58.629
G great speech was cut for time and to
02:16:58.639 --> 02:17:01.030
imagine anyone now obviously Shakespeare
02:17:01.040 --> 02:17:03.030
cutting in production is normal but the
02:17:03.040 --> 02:17:04.309
notion of anyone writing one of the
02:17:04.319 --> 02:17:06.709
great Hamlet speeches and going ah bit
02:17:06.719 --> 02:17:07.589
much
02:17:07.599 --> 02:17:09.830
>> and just deleting it is astounding and
02:17:09.840 --> 02:17:11.750
again we we we we therefore have to
02:17:11.760 --> 02:17:13.830
struggle Well, was every line perfect?
02:17:13.840 --> 02:17:16.230
Did every line have a purpose? Oh, the
02:17:16.240 --> 02:17:17.830
clown scene in a fellow. Well, he had a
02:17:17.840 --> 02:17:19.349
clown in his outfit. Had to write in
02:17:19.359 --> 02:17:21.429
some lines. But then with the sonets, we
02:17:21.439 --> 02:17:23.509
don't need to have these practical
02:17:23.519 --> 02:17:25.669
considerations. And perhaps, as you say,
02:17:25.679 --> 02:17:28.870
it was him able to practice another kind
02:17:28.880 --> 02:17:30.870
of art. And perhaps the the outflowing
02:17:30.880 --> 02:17:32.549
of it was similar
02:17:32.559 --> 02:17:34.230
>> to [clears throat] to the theater in the
02:17:34.240 --> 02:17:36.150
way that he composed his lines, but
02:17:36.160 --> 02:17:38.469
equally, you know, everyone except two
02:17:38.479 --> 02:17:40.389
have the same number of lines, strict
02:17:40.399 --> 02:17:42.790
rhyme scheme. He's pretty on the amic
02:17:42.800 --> 02:17:44.790
pentameter. So some of the late plays
02:17:44.800 --> 02:17:46.230
which don't date that differently from
02:17:46.240 --> 02:17:48.950
the late sets the meter is a lot rougher
02:17:48.960 --> 02:17:50.709
and a lot more free. You know you read
02:17:50.719 --> 02:17:52.950
King Le and it doesn't have that dancing
02:17:52.960 --> 02:17:55.349
of Richard II Romeo and Juliet Midsummer
02:17:55.359 --> 02:17:56.629
Night. You know it's
02:17:56.639 --> 02:17:58.389
>> it's freer and open. Yet you look at all
02:17:58.399 --> 02:18:00.790
the sonnetss and the early to the late
02:18:00.800 --> 02:18:04.230
they all have this very measured
02:18:04.240 --> 02:18:05.830
>> uh meter. There's the one with with an
02:18:05.840 --> 02:18:07.110
extra line. Don't know what's going on
02:18:07.120 --> 02:18:08.709
there. And then of course the one
02:18:08.719 --> 02:18:10.469
missing lines
02:18:10.479 --> 02:18:12.709
>> which is which which we've discussed.
02:18:12.719 --> 02:18:14.950
But it is interesting to see him in a
02:18:14.960 --> 02:18:17.349
format where he does resist maybe the
02:18:17.359 --> 02:18:20.549
the impulse as the late artist to oh we
02:18:20.559 --> 02:18:21.990
don't need the meter. We are free from
02:18:22.000 --> 02:18:24.070
the meter. We can play with it but he
02:18:24.080 --> 02:18:25.830
doesn't so much in the sonets. when he
02:18:25.840 --> 02:18:27.509
does, as in those two examples, we
02:18:27.519 --> 02:18:28.309
notice
02:18:28.319 --> 02:18:30.549
>> and and this is what Booth loves
02:18:30.559 --> 02:18:32.950
pointing out and others before him, when
02:18:32.960 --> 02:18:35.110
you count when you start just doing a
02:18:35.120 --> 02:18:38.230
statistical statistical analysis on like
02:18:38.240 --> 02:18:41.190
the use of enjamment in in Shakespeare,
02:18:41.200 --> 02:18:45.110
he it's so much more than any of the
02:18:45.120 --> 02:18:47.270
other sonnet guys are writing. Like he's
02:18:47.280 --> 02:18:49.110
allowing lines to flow into each other
02:18:49.120 --> 02:18:51.429
more. He also like more than other
02:18:51.439 --> 02:18:53.509
people like he won't always he won't
02:18:53.519 --> 02:18:55.270
always force a couplet to be its own
02:18:55.280 --> 02:18:56.709
contained thing. he'll let the line
02:18:56.719 --> 02:18:59.349
before the couplet go in. And he was um
02:18:59.359 --> 02:19:01.270
so yes, I think he loved this is at
02:19:01.280 --> 02:19:03.429
least what Booth is saying. There's so
02:19:03.439 --> 02:19:06.230
many slightly imperceptible things that
02:19:06.240 --> 02:19:08.790
he's enjoying what happens to the mind
02:19:08.800 --> 02:19:11.429
when it has to shift patterns in mid
02:19:11.439 --> 02:19:13.830
gear. And that that sensation of
02:19:13.840 --> 02:19:15.669
shifting a pattern in mid gear, even if
02:19:15.679 --> 02:19:17.190
it's preconceptual and it's not the
02:19:17.200 --> 02:19:19.429
thing that's flashy, is very satisfying.
02:19:19.439 --> 02:19:22.070
might be why actors and and Jack, you
02:19:22.080 --> 02:19:25.270
said this, they do tend to say the
02:19:25.280 --> 02:19:27.190
Shakespeare stuff sticks with them
02:19:27.200 --> 02:19:29.349
better than any other of the writing
02:19:29.359 -->
02:19:31.509
they have to memorize, you know, and
02:19:31.519 --> 02:19:32.790
some of that's because of the rhythms,
02:19:32.800 --> 02:19:34.790
but I think that it the mind is also
02:19:34.800 --> 02:19:36.230
tickled in ways that are hard to
02:19:36.240 --> 02:19:38.870
describe with Shakespeare. uh Nabokov
02:19:38.880 --> 02:19:40.870
and he gives this line to Charles Kimbo
02:19:40.880 --> 02:19:43.589
in pale fire but he used to it's it's
02:19:43.599 --> 02:19:45.110
literally taken from one of his own
02:19:45.120 --> 02:19:48.309
lectures used to encourage his students
02:19:48.319 --> 02:19:51.750
um just to get drunk on the language of
02:19:51.760 --> 02:19:54.950
Shakespeare just revel in it just just
02:19:54.960 --> 02:19:58.630
have an orastic just bask in it just
02:19:58.640 --> 02:20:01.670
just enjoy it he didn't like that was
02:20:01.680 --> 02:20:04.150
the primary that's the primary goal
02:20:04.160 --> 02:20:05.910
that's from the thing from which
02:20:05.920 --> 02:20:09.270
everything else um emerges.
02:20:09.280 --> 02:20:10.070
>> That's beautiful. [clears throat]
02:20:10.080 --> 02:20:11.590
>> Before we finish, I I think I should
02:20:11.600 --> 02:20:13.270
read a Shakespeare set because I'm the
02:20:13.280 --> 02:20:15.510
only one who hasn't yet. Sadly, my my
02:20:15.520 --> 02:20:18.309
civike brain has not Well, there is sort
02:20:18.319 --> 02:20:19.670
of one, but I don't want to stumble
02:20:19.680 --> 02:20:22.389
through it. I'll pretend at fluency by
02:20:22.399 --> 02:20:25.190
staring directly at the words on a page
02:20:25.200 --> 02:20:27.030
>> and and this has no real relevance to
02:20:27.040 --> 02:20:28.950
the end of the conversation other than
02:20:28.960 --> 02:20:32.389
it is one that I like.
02:20:32.399 --> 02:20:34.070
106.
02:20:34.080 --> 02:20:36.469
When in the chronicle of wasted time I
02:20:36.479 --> 02:20:38.790
see descriptions of the fairest whites
02:20:38.800 --> 02:20:41.830
and beauty making beautiful old rhyme in
02:20:41.840 --> 02:20:44.389
praise of ladies dead and lovely nights.
02:20:44.399 --> 02:20:47.510
Then in the blasm of sweet beauty's best
02:20:47.520 --> 02:20:51.110
of hand of foot of lip of eye of brow I
02:20:51.120 --> 02:20:52.870
see their antique pen would have
02:20:52.880 --> 02:20:55.349
expressed even such a beauty as you
02:20:55.359 --> 02:20:58.230
master now. So all their praises are but
02:20:58.240 --> 02:21:00.870
prophecies of this our time all you
02:21:00.880 --> 02:21:03.110
prefiguring. And for they looked but
02:21:03.120 --> 02:21:05.830
with divining eyes. They had not skill
02:21:05.840 --> 02:21:08.790
enough your worth to sing. For we which
02:21:08.800 --> 02:21:11.910
now behold these present days have eyes
02:21:11.920 --> 02:21:17.270
to wonder but lack tongues to praise.
02:21:17.280 --> 02:21:19.670
>> Tongues keep coming into this
02:21:19.680 --> 02:21:21.429
conversation from all sorts of
02:21:21.439 --> 02:21:24.550
directions. What is going on? This has
02:21:24.560 --> 02:21:26.950
been mad. I knew it was coming as soon
02:21:26.960 --> 02:21:28.950
as my like halfway through I was like
02:21:28.960 --> 02:21:30.790
how does this one oh my god it ends with
02:21:30.800 --> 02:21:33.510
the this is absurd my poem had the
02:21:33.520 --> 02:21:35.190
tongue I believe that's the first one
02:21:35.200 --> 02:21:38.870
then you you first as a 13 as a third
02:21:38.880 --> 02:21:41.030
grader you realize phenomenology exists
02:21:41.040 --> 02:21:43.349
because of a picture of a tongue then we
02:21:43.359 --> 02:21:46.389
have the dream of the tongue which is
02:21:46.399 --> 02:21:49.510
when which destroyed postmodernism
02:21:49.520 --> 02:21:51.429
through through magic and Daniel Dennett
02:21:51.439 --> 02:21:54.070
could not explain it and
02:21:54.080 --> 02:21:54.870
>> thank
02:21:54.880 --> 02:21:57.349
This is this is this is
02:21:57.359 --> 02:21:58.710
>> this is dark magic.
02:21:58.720 --> 02:21:59.429
>> Yeah.
02:21:59.439 --> 02:22:03.110
>> Okay. Wait. Before we go, can I can we
02:22:03.120 --> 02:22:05.830
just end on an enigmatic note of a
02:22:05.840 --> 02:22:08.070
prophecy? But you it'll give you both of
02:22:08.080 --> 02:22:10.230
you some homework between now and our
02:22:10.240 --> 02:22:11.910
next conversation in a year and three
02:22:11.920 --> 02:22:15.910
days from now. Um are you ready?
02:22:15.920 --> 02:22:19.030
>> I had this made. This is a die that I
02:22:19.040 --> 02:22:24.870
had made. It's 154sided die. After
02:22:24.880 --> 02:22:27.110
I memorized all the sonnetss, I had to
02:22:27.120 --> 02:22:29.270
get myself a gift, right? Like I got
02:22:29.280 --> 02:22:32.469
them all in me. So on January 16th, that
02:22:32.479 --> 02:22:33.830
was the day I memorized the final.
02:22:33.840 --> 02:22:36.353
>> That's my birthday. Just throw another
02:22:36.363 --> 02:22:37.750
[laughter] freaking
02:22:37.760 --> 02:22:39.670
>> Yes. I'm going to put that on my
02:22:39.680 --> 02:22:41.030
calendar because my calendar is also
02:22:41.040 --> 02:22:42.710
this weird synchronicity thing that I
02:22:42.720 --> 02:22:47.190
love. Uh so on January 16th, I ordered
02:22:47.200 --> 02:22:49.590
myself I found this custommade die.
02:22:49.600 --> 02:22:50.950
they'll make dye. And I said, "Can you
02:22:50.960 --> 02:22:53.670
make 154-sided die?" And the guy was
02:22:53.680 --> 02:22:55.990
like, "First of it, cost you a lot of
02:22:56.000 --> 02:22:57.510
money. Second, it won't be
02:22:57.520 --> 02:22:59.590
mathematically perfect if you roll it."
02:22:59.600 --> 02:23:00.950
And I said, "I don't care. I just want
02:23:00.960 --> 02:23:03.830
154s eye." So, I got this. Couple people
02:23:03.840 --> 02:23:05.830
have ordered them since. What I want to
02:23:05.840 --> 02:23:08.150
do is the way we use this as sort of a
02:23:08.160 --> 02:23:10.950
tarot thing. I'll put it up. First,
02:23:10.960 --> 02:23:12.309
we're going to do you Jackson since I
02:23:12.319 --> 02:23:13.830
see you right now on my screen. I'm
02:23:13.840 --> 02:23:15.349
going to put it up as close as I can to
02:23:15.359 --> 02:23:17.030
the camera and you have to just see
02:23:17.040 --> 02:23:21.030
which number is closest to the center of
02:23:21.040 --> 02:23:22.230
your vision. Okay.
02:23:22.240 --> 02:23:23.110
>> Okay.
02:23:23.120 --> 02:23:26.550
>> We're going to say that's your secret
02:23:26.560 --> 02:23:28.790
sonnet number that we'll we'll unpack
02:23:28.800 --> 02:23:30.870
over the years. Okay.
02:23:30.880 --> 02:23:31.910
>> Yeah.
02:23:31.920 --> 02:23:34.070
>> You ready? Oh, wait. Let me roll it
02:23:34.080 --> 02:23:36.710
around. Tell me when to stop.
02:23:36.720 --> 02:23:38.790
>> Stop.
02:23:38.800 --> 02:23:40.550
>> Tell me if you see a number. If you need
02:23:40.560 --> 02:23:43.349
me to move it back, forward.
02:23:43.359 --> 02:23:44.870
>> I see a number.
02:23:44.880 --> 02:23:46.389
>> What is it?
02:23:46.399 --> 02:23:47.830
>> 138.
02:23:47.840 --> 02:23:49.590
>> Write it down.
02:23:49.600 --> 02:23:51.429
>> It's a fascinating number. It's a I
02:23:51.439 --> 02:23:53.349
already It explains you so much better
02:23:53.359 --> 02:23:55.349
now. [laughter]
02:23:55.359 --> 02:23:59.670
>> Okay. Milo, tell me when you're ready.
02:23:59.680 --> 02:24:00.630
>> Yeah.
02:24:00.640 --> 02:24:02.790
>> I'll remember, Jack. I'll remember.
02:24:02.800 --> 02:24:03.990
>> I'm I'm ready.
02:24:04.000 --> 02:24:04.870
>> Jack,
02:24:04.880 --> 02:24:05.349
>> I'm ready.
02:24:05.359 --> 02:24:07.510
>> Okay. You're frozen on my screen. Here
02:24:07.520 --> 02:24:09.670
we go.
02:24:09.680 --> 02:24:13.110
Oh,
02:24:13.120 --> 02:24:17.030
keep it there. Oh. Oh, it's 70, I think.
02:24:17.040 --> 02:24:18.950
Yeah. 70. 70.
02:24:18.960 --> 02:24:22.550
>> 70. Write it down. Um, and just read
02:24:22.560 --> 02:24:24.790
that poem, I'd say once a week. I'm a
02:24:24.800 --> 02:24:25.910
therapist, so I give homework
02:24:25.920 --> 02:24:27.510
assignments to my clients. I'd say read
02:24:27.520 --> 02:24:29.750
that poem once every, you know, 7 to 10
02:24:29.760 --> 02:24:33.349
days and get back to me.
02:24:33.359 --> 02:24:35.670
>> Jeff, absolute pleasure. Wonderful
02:24:35.680 --> 02:24:38.150
guest. Thank you so much for your time.
02:24:38.160 --> 02:24:39.990
So fun. Great to meet you guys.
02:24:40.000 --> 02:24:42.309
>> Yeah. Have a lovely rest of your day.
02:24:42.319 --> 02:24:43.270
>> You too. Take care.
02:24:43.280 --> 02:24:46.240
>> See you next year.