رونوشت 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:46.100
What if you've worked really hard to support a pupil back into school, their attendance figures are improving, but their parents tell you that they're becoming more upset at home than ever? After nearly two decades working with schools on behaviour and SEMH, I've learned that getting a pupil back into the classroom or school doesn't necessarily mean that they're coping with being there. So in this episode, we'll look at how to judge whether a pupil's reintegration plan is genuinely working for them, what other information we should be looking at alongside raw attendance figures, and when it might be time to change the support and offer to them so it's genuinely successful. Welcome to the School Behaviour Secrets podcast.
00:00:46.380 --> 00:01:34.579
I'm your host Simon Currigan, my co-host is Emma Shackleton, and we're obsessed with helping teachers, school leaders, parents and of course students when classroom behaviour gets in the way of success. We're going to share the tried and tested secrets to classroom management, behavioural special needs, whole school strategy and more, all with the aim of helping your students reach their true potential. Plus, we'll be letting you eavesdrop on our conversations with thought leaders from around the world, so you'll get to hear the latest evidence-based strategies before anyone else. This is the School Behaviour Secrets podcast. Hi there, my name's Simon Currigan and I'm broadcasting from Behaviour Towers, where the grass isn't green, the air isn't clear, and you'll definitely want to wash your hands after touching the whiteboard markers.
00:01:34.739 --> 00:02:24.199
In today's episode, we're going to be looking at school attendance, specifically how we decide whether the support that we're putting in place for pupils who've struggled to attend school is actually working, like genuinely working, because there's a danger that we can become so focused on getting children back through the school gates and hitting arbitrary attendance figures that we forget to ask what happens to them once they're back in the classroom. And that's important because people might be attending more regularly but still struggling to cope with the school day. So we're going to look at how school leaders and SENCOs can review integration plans, how to recognise when a pupil is making genuine progress and when we might need to adapt what we're doing to support them better.
00:02:24.460 --> 00:02:33.219
But before we go any further, if you're finding these episodes useful, please take just one moment to subscribe to School Behaviour Secrets in your podcast app of choice.
00:02:33.759 --> 00:03:35.979
I don't judge how you listen, you do you. Unless, of course, you're listening on the website, in which case I am very much judging you. You know what you're doing and you know what you do, which is listen on a podcast app because it's way more convenient. And if you know a colleague who's responsible for, say, attendance or supporting pupils with EBSA, emotionally based school avoidance, why not share this episode with them? Because the more people we can reach with practical strategies about behaviour and SEMH, the more students we can help. And possibly, with enough subscribers, I'll be able to afford a window that opens here at Behaviour Towers to let some of the atmosphere out because the plumbing here is terrible. There's no airflow, but I'm not promising anything. So if you want to make of that what you will, if you want to imagine we've got a pupil called Ella, she's in year nine. She's been struggling with anxiety about coming into school and over the last few months her attendance has dropped significantly.
00:03:36.199 --> 00:03:57.280
Some weeks she's only managed two or three mornings and another week she's barely attended at all. Her parents are exhausted by the daily battles to get her out of the house and the school's worried about the amount of learning she's missing. So the SENCO and Attendance Lead sit down with Ella and her family and they agree a plan to help her return to school.
00:03:57.439 --> 00:04:22.019
And the plan involves Ella going to a named adult that she trusts, someone who'll meet her when she arrives in the morning. She can come in through a quieter entrance rather than having to walk through that noisy busy playground and she has access to a quiet space when she becomes overwhelmed. The school also agrees to make some temporary adjustments to her timetable with the aim of gradually increasing the amount of time she spends in lessons.
00:04:22.620 --> 00:04:31.600
None of this is particularly revolutionary by the way. It's the kind of sensible individualised support plan that lots of schools are already putting into place.
00:04:31.779 --> 00:04:41.199
So after six weeks the results are looking promising. Ella's attendance has improved dramatically. She's coming into school every day and she's spending much more time in lessons.
00:04:41.699 --> 00:04:46.300
The Attendance Lead can show the headteacher a nice graph with a lovely upward line on it.
00:04:46.379 --> 00:04:52.459
The school's pleased with progress and everyone in school feels the work they've put in is paying off.
00:04:52.540 --> 00:05:34.889
But there's just one problem. Although Ella is attending lessons, some of her teachers say that she's just sitting there and not doing very much work. She looks tired, she's struggling to concentrate and she doesn't seem to be making much academic progress. Meanwhile her parents are reporting that she's becoming increasingly unhappy, more upset at home. She's crying about school in the evening, struggling to sleep and getting upset on Sunday afternoons because she's already worried about going back to school on Monday. And when someone actually sits down with Ella in school and how she's finding school, she says that she's proud that she's managing to attend.
00:05:35.449 --> 00:07:19.329
She
Load full transcript
knows that's important to all of the adults in her life but she's still finding the experience really hard, really overwhelming. So what do we make of that? Has the integration plan been successful? Well yes, in one important respect Ella's attending much more regularly and that's a genuine achievement and I don't want to dismiss that. You get one shot at education when you're young and if you miss it, you miss it and if you have to go back, it's very expensive. But if we only look at her attendance figures, we might think that her attendance problem's been solved when actually there's still quite a lot of work to do. And just to be clear, Ella's a fictional pupil I've created to illustrate the problem, okay? But the situation itself is one that will be familiar to loads of SENCOs and teachers and attendance leads. I'm sure if you're working in school you can relate to an Ella right now. We all work hard to get the child back into school and then we have to decide whether the support we're providing is sufficient, whether we should be asking the student to do more in class to crank up the academic demands or whether they're already struggling with the demands that we're placing on them. So navigating that is a bit of a tightrope. This is particularly relevant right now because the Department for Education has been placing a strong emphasis on providing support to improve attendance in schools. Its statutory guidance, Working Together to Improve School Attendance, was updated in July and there's also guidance from August about how schools should be communicating with parents about their child's attendance. Both are worth reading and if you're involved in attendance in schools, you definitely should if you haven't already.
00:07:19.329 --> 00:07:42.670
One of the important principles in that guidance is that we should work with pupils and their families to understand the barriers that are preventing children from attending school and provide support to help them overcome those barriers. The guidance doesn't suggest that attendance is optional or that school should simply accept persistent absence. Far from it.
00:07:42.689 --> 00:08:49.610
The expectation is that children should attend school and school should work with families to make that possible and I think that's a sensible, reasonable approach because if a child isn't attending school because they're being bullied or they're overwhelmed by the sensory environment or they're experiencing significant anxiety or whatever it is, we need to understand those issues and unpick them so we can deal with them. Simply telling the family in these cases that their child needs to attend more regularly doesn't really solve the underlying problem that's stopping them from attending in the first place. So to take our example in this case, there was a reason underlying why Ella was struggling getting into school in the first place while she was avoiding school and unless we dealt with that, that kind of anxiety was going to persist in the long term. But here's something I think we need to consider. If we've spent weeks working with a pupil and their family to understand what's stopping them from attending school, why should we stop listening to them the moment their attendance figures start improving?
00:08:49.750 --> 00:09:29.230
Because surely the purpose of all that support we put in place wasn't simply to get a tick in the register, it was to help the child get back into education in a way that's sustainable and isn't going to go off the boil further down the track. And that means we need to look at more than attendance figures when we're reviewing the success of a reintegration plan, when we're deciding whether it's working or not. And I'm not suggesting that school should throw out their attendance data, it's important data. We know that regular school attendance is associated with better educational outcomes and children do benefit from the opportunities that being in school provides.
00:09:29.429 --> 00:11:16.921
But the attendance register tells us whether a pupil was present for a session or whether they were absent. It doesn't tell us how they were engaging with the teaching, whether they're managing to participate in learning or whether they're becoming increasingly distressed or overwhelmed as the day goes on. So when we're reviewing ELLA's progress I'd suggest looking at four different areas and these aren't for new sets of paperwork I think you should be introducing into your school by the way. I can practically hear the photocopier groaning in your school at the thought. They're just four simple questions that can help us make a more informed judgment about whether the support we're providing is being effective when it comes to big picture success for the child. So the first is obviously attendance. Is Ella coming to school more regularly? Is she arriving on time? Is she managing to stay for the agreed sessions in class? And is that improvement being sustained over several weeks? In Ella's case, we know the answer to most of these questions is yes. So that's one part of the picture. It's an important part and it's a positive part. The second area is access to learning because Ella might be sitting in her lessons, but is she able to focus on and concentrate on and engage with what's being taught? Is she starting her work, completing more activities and becoming more independent as time moves on? Or is she spending the lesson staring at the page, unable to concentrate or becoming increasingly overwhelmed by the expectations being placed on her? And actually, the answer might be different depending on which lesson we're talking about.
00:11:16.921 --> 00:11:52.980
There's some complexity there. So for example, Ella might be doing quite well in English because she has a good relationship with her teacher. She knows what to expect and she feels comfortable asking for help. But in science, perhaps she's struggling with the noise and
the unpredictability of practical activities. So rather than concluding that Ella can't cope with lessons generally, we've identified a specific part of her school day that's causing her difficulty and that's information we can actually do something useful with. The third area is relationships and belonging.
00:11:54.000 --> 00:13:45.041
Does Ella feel comfortable being part of the school community? Does she have friends she can spend her time with? Is there an adult she trusts who she can speak to when she's worried about something? Because one of the reasons school attendance matters is that children have opportunities to develop relationships and feel part of the group. But simply being present physically in a classroom doesn't mean that those things are happening. You can be quite alone in a classroom and physically be surrounded by other students. And the fourth area is emotional well-being. How is Ella actually feeling about school? What are her teachers noticing about her during the day? What do her parents see when she gets home? Now we need to be careful here because we can't assume that a child who becomes upset after school is necessarily experiencing something harmful during the school day. There could be several reasons for that behaviour. But equally we shouldn't ignore what parents are telling us simply because the child appears to be managing in school from our perspective. And I think that last point is especially important. Sometimes we can end up with two completely different accounts of the same child. The school says they're doing brilliantly because they're coming in every day, they're polite, they're following instructions and they're not causing any difficulties in class. Meanwhile the parents are saying that the student is falling to pieces at home. And both accounts might be accurate. The child might be working incredibly hard on the inside to manage the demands of school and then they struggle once they get somewhere they feel safe enough to express how they're really feeling when they're with their parents. Which brings us to what I think is the most difficult part of this whole issue.
00:13:45.400 --> 00:16:09.341
Because even when we have all that information we still have to make a judgment about how successful the plan is and what to do next. Let's go back to Ella. She tells us that she's feeling anxious about coming to school. Her parents say she's upset in the evenings. So should we reduce the we're placing on her? Should we maintain her current timetable? Or should we encourage her to keep going even though she's finding it tough? That is a hard question and I don't think we can answer it simply by knowing that Ella is experiencing anxiety. Because experiencing anxiety isn't always a sign that something is going wrong. Sometimes when we're doing something difficult or unfamiliar we are going to feel uncomfortable and if we avoid every situation that makes us anxious as a child then we end up with fewer and fewer
opportunities to build our confidence and grow our coping skills. So for instance imagine Ella's worried about attending a particular lesson because she hasn't been there for several months. She's frightened that she won't understand the work that she's got behind or that the teacher might ask her a question that she simply can't but with some reassurance, a bit of preparation and appropriate support during the lesson she manages to take part and then the next time she attends she's still nervous but perhaps not quite as nervous as before and over time she's able to do that more independently. Being in the situation that she finds uncomfortable has helped her develop the coping skills to actually do well in that situation. It's given her evidence that she can manage her anxiety successfully and succeed and that is a positive direction of travel. She's experiencing manageable discomfort but she's also learning that she can cope with that situation. If we had jumped in and automatically removed every lesson that made her feel anxious we might then actually counter-intuitively make it harder for her to develop that confidence in the future and just thinking about it I think the most important word I just used back there was the word manageable. Manageable discomfort. It's like the plumbing in behaviour towers isn't great, it's leading to some smells and gases but the atmosphere is copable with. It's unpleasant, yeah it's definitely unpleasant but it's copable with.
00:16:09.520 --> 00:17:08.920
Now let's imagine a different scenario. Ella's anxiety is becoming more intense as the week goes by. She's sleeping less, she's increasingly exhausted, she's struggling to complete work in lessons and she's beginning to withdraw from her friends. She's attending school, yes, but there's little evidence that she's becoming more able to cope with the experience. In that situation I'd be concerned that the demands we're placing on her might be too much and that we need to review the rather than simply asking her to keep pushing through. To bring it back to my behaviour terrace example, now the gases from the plumbing are toxic and staying in that atmosphere is going to be damaging to my health rather than, you know, shutting the door and saying I'd give it five minutes and then all the smells and gases will go. Okay so now I know I've made those two examples sound quite different but in the real world of course things are rarely that straightforward.
00:17:08.920 --> 00:19:59.780
They're not black and white. People might be making progress in one lesson but then struggling in another. Their anxiety might reduce for a few weeks and then increase again. That's because anxiety is complex. It does recede and then return. There could be setbacks along the way that don't mean the whole plan is failing and that's when we need to look at how things are over time and not make big decisions based on one difficult day or one good week. And there's another point here. Supporting a pupil with anxiety doesn't mean we should remove every expectation they find difficult but maintaining expectations doesn't mean we also have to ignore the distress they're experiencing either. We can hold on to the goal of regular attendance while sensible adjustments to help the child achieve it. I don't want to go too deep into this because I did a podcast episode that already looked at this topic just a few weeks ago called why some pupils avoid work and what to do about it that's related to stress and distress and I don't want to repeat it here but you get the point and if you want to know more about that just go back a couple of reintegration plans. Well I've got three practical suggestions. First off when you're reviewing a pupil's attendance make sure you're discussing more than their percentage in class or in school on the register. You don't necessarily need another formal assessment. It might involve a quick conversation with the student's teachers, checking in with the adult who's supporting them and finding out what the family is finding at home. The purpose of all that is to build a fuller picture of whether the pupil is becoming more able to manage school rather than simply attending more sessions rather than just getting through the gate in the morning. Secondly make sure you're listening to the pupil themselves and I don't just mean asking whether they're happy at school because that is such a broad question the LS answer might not tell us very much. We could ask something more specific like which part of the school day is getting easier for you and which bits do you find challenging still or is there a lesson that you're finding particularly difficult or what's helping you manage school at the moment that you didn't have in the past. Those sorts of questions can help us identify where our support program is working and where we might need to make some changes and adaptations. Obviously we'll need to adapt how we ask those questions depending on the child's age, their communication needs, their ability to reflect on their experiences, the reason why they're finding it difficult to get into school in the first place and there may not be.
00:19:59.980 --> 00:20:05.400
A single set of questions in school that you use repeatedly across all reintegration cases.
00:20:05.579 --> 00:21:05.359
You might want to, and you probably will, want to adapt them to each individual pupil and their circumstances. And then thirdly, use what you've learned to agree the next realistic, achievable, doable step. Because once a student's attendance improves, there's a temptation then to keep increasing the demands, or perhaps start withdrawing the support that's been put in place already. And sometimes that will be the right thing to do. And sometimes that might be jumping the gun. So we need to make those decisions based on how well the pupil is actually coping, rather than making assumptions about them being okay because they're attending
regularly and thinking they no longer need the extra adjustments that help them get through the gates in the first place. So in Ella's case, perhaps we decide to maintain her current attendance arrangements for another few weeks, but focus on helping her participate more successfully in science.
00:21:05.539 --> 00:21:35.299
Maybe that means giving her some advanced information about what the practical activities will be, making sure she understands what she'll be expected to do, and agreeing how she can ask for help if she's becoming overwhelmed. And then we review how she goes, rather than changing several parts of a timetable at once and hoping for the best. And notice that we're not necessarily making the curriculum easier for Ella here, or letting her avoid everything she finds difficult.
00:21:35.779 --> 00:22:40.319
We're identifying what's getting in the way of her accessing the learning, and making adjustments to help her participate. That's the same sort of thinking we'd use if her pupil was struggling academically. We'd work out which part of the task they couldn't manage, provide the right support, and then gradually help them become more independent. If you need some support with this, if you need help understanding why children might struggle in school, and how that might show up in terms of their behaviour and SEMH needs, I've got a free download that can help. It's called the SEND Behaviour Handbook. You can get it from our website beaconschoolsupport.co.uk. To access it, you go to the website and you click on the free resources tab at the top of the screen, and you'll see the SEND Handbook at the top of the page in the downloadable resources section. That's the SEND Handbook at beaconschoolsupport.co.uk. And I'll also, if you're using a podcast app, I'll put a link in the show notes, the episode description, so you can tap straight through and get that.
00:22:40.319 --> 00:22:55.279
It's been downloaded over 100,000 times around the world. Obviously, in the real world, schools don't have unlimited time and resources to provide bespoke support for every pupil, pupils like Ella.
00:22:55.779 --> 00:24:14.140
And I know that's not the kind of reality that you're working with day to day, but I do think there's a danger of putting in lots of time and effort into a reintegration plan, and then getting the pupil back into school, and then withdrawing the support that made Ella's improvement possible before we've worked out whether she can manage successfully without it. So let's bring all this together. Improving a pupil's attendance is important, and when a reintegration plan starts working, that's something we should recognise and definitely celebrate. It does indicate success, but if we want those improvements to last, we need to understand what's happening beyond the child's attendance figures. Are they increasingly able to engage with their learning? Are they building relationships? Do they feel part of the school community? And is their emotional well-being improving, or are there signs now that they're starting to struggle with the demands of attending and learning? We also need to recognise and get parents on board with that some discomfort can be part of the process of returning to school. That's to be expected, and that our job as adults is to distinguish between manageable emotional challenges that help a pupil ultimately build confidence and resilience, and demands that are overwhelming to the students and their current ability to cope.
00:24:14.240 --> 00:25:04.500
And that's not always an easy judgment, and two thoughtful professionals might actually reasonably interpret the same information differently and come to two completely different conclusions, but we're more likely to make good decisions when we're looking at the whole picture rather than a single attendance percentage. Because the ultimate aim isn't simply to get a pupil to walk through the school gates, it's to help them to return to education in a way that works for them, where they can increasingly participate and learn, and build the confidence to attend regularly so they can meet their potential in school. Our aim shouldn't be just for the student to survive school, but to get the most out of it. And that brings me to the end of this week's episode of School Behaviour Secrets. If you found it useful, please make sure you've subscribed, and if you've got a spare moment, please leave me a review in your podcast app.
00:25:04.740 --> 00:25:43.740
It really does help other teachers and school leaders discover the show, and oh, and a quick update. Just had a message from the plumber here at Behaviour Towers. That unusual smell in the upstairs in the podcast studio I've been complaining about, I say studio, the tiny cupboard next to the bathroom. Turns out there was something living in the ventilation system, and the plumber says it's getting bigger, and he's not coming back. Hmm, tricky one. Anyway, I hope you have a brilliant week, that you don't have anything living in your ventilation system, and if that presence doesn't overwhelm Behaviour Towers, I can't wait to see you on the next episode of School Behaviour Secrets.
00:25:43.740 --> 00:25:45.819
Thank you for listening, bye now.