رونوشت 🔗
1
00:00:52,659 --> 00:00:56,839
Hey there, another great episode on in store today.
2
00:00:56,839 --> 00:00:58,142
Who do we have Jennifer?
3
00:00:58,142 --> 00:00:58,652
We do.
4
00:00:58,652 --> 00:01:08,337
Today we have Dan Stein, who is a long, long time former president of the Federation for
American Immigration Reform, also known as FAIR.
5
00:01:08,337 --> 00:01:14,400
He has been one of the most influential voices in the national immigration debate for over
four decades.
6
00:01:14,400 --> 00:01:24,885
Dan joined FAIR back in 1982, led the organization for over 20 years and has testified
before Congress more than 50 times.
7
00:01:24,885 --> 00:01:28,126
His work focuses on the legal, economic, and social impact
8
00:01:28,126 --> 00:01:32,309
of immigration, especially what happens when it's not well regulated.
9
00:01:32,309 --> 00:01:38,394
FAIR pushes for policies that prioritize national interest, secure borders, and
sustainable growth.
10
00:01:38,394 --> 00:01:41,416
So let's welcome Dan to the show.
11
00:01:42,666 --> 00:01:43,738
Hello, Dan.
12
00:01:43,738 --> 00:01:46,380
Thank you so much for joining us today.
13
00:01:48,106 --> 00:01:55,727
So one of the questions that we found interesting when we asked it from our other guest
was, how did you get into immigration?
14
00:01:56,940 --> 00:02:08,119
Back in the 1970s, I was working for Congress on international drug control policy and
became very interested in international development programs in Latin America, crop
15
00:02:08,119 --> 00:02:14,865
substitution programs, eradication programs for coca crops and marijuana.
16
00:02:15,426 --> 00:02:25,684
And over time, it became clear to me that a lot of these petty despots in Latin America
were using out migration as a way of avoiding internal political and economic reform.
17
00:02:26,134 --> 00:02:35,577
And so it became clear that border security was a key part of advancing US foreign policy
in terms of bringing about positive political change back in the home countries.
18
00:02:35,677 --> 00:02:44,119
So I went to work for FAIR to work on what I thought would be one of the most important
issues over the next 40 years, as it turned out to be, immigration.
19
00:02:44,659 --> 00:02:54,592
And all this time, nothing has changed my mind about A, the importance of the issue, and
B, the fact that the way we practice immigration policy often runs contrary.
20
00:02:54,776 --> 00:02:57,608
to our US foreign policy interests globally.
21
00:02:57,849 --> 00:03:05,555
And so after about 43 years at fair, I decided about two months, well, three weeks ago to
retire.
22
00:03:05,996 --> 00:03:13,882
But you know me, I'm always gonna be in the mix on this thing because immigration is gonna
be a major part of the political debate for the next hundred years.
23
00:03:14,836 --> 00:03:15,677
That makes sense.
24
00:03:15,677 --> 00:03:20,963
My dad's wife retired in December and she's still working.
25
00:03:20,963 --> 00:03:27,811
So hopefully you're actually retiring and going to enjoy life a little bit without
working.
26
00:03:28,818 --> 00:03:29,536
Right, that-
27
00:03:29,536 --> 00:03:31,264
at this maybe kind of a swan.
28
00:03:33,597 --> 00:03:38,249
Well, you know, so we have a list of questions for you, but we're happy to go in any
direction.
29
00:03:38,249 --> 00:03:42,651
But I really am interested in kind of you.
30
00:03:42,651 --> 00:03:43,751
have a unique perspective.
31
00:03:43,751 --> 00:03:47,673
You're the fourth person we've had in a four part series.
32
00:03:47,673 --> 00:03:53,725
We may add a fifth, which would be our local sheriff and how immigration is impacting us
here in Sarasota County.
33
00:03:53,725 --> 00:04:03,109
But from a national stage, you're the fourth person and you kind of have a unique
perspective of helping others versus protecting.
34
00:04:03,109 --> 00:04:04,460
ourselves.
35
00:04:04,721 --> 00:04:10,468
And so there's a lot of people trying to escape dangerous places around the world.
36
00:04:10,669 --> 00:04:18,479
And how do we help those folks without putting our own country at risk or for us becoming
stretched too thin?
37
00:04:20,014 --> 00:04:20,674
Well, the U.S.
38
00:04:20,674 --> 00:04:24,816
can't be the home of last resort for all the world's displeased and dispossessed.
39
00:04:25,457 --> 00:04:35,462
And the fact is that there's an international obligation of all community of nations to
try to provide sucker and support for people who are in truly life-threatening situations.
40
00:04:36,203 --> 00:04:37,333
And because the U.S.
41
00:04:37,333 --> 00:04:47,059
has advanced several concepts of freedom and market capitalism and other things, we've
seen a tremendous advance in the average incomes of people all over the world beyond
42
00:04:47,059 --> 00:04:50,090
anything that was ever anticipated 50 years ago.
43
00:04:50,446 --> 00:05:01,272
50 years ago, there was enormous catastrophizing about worldwide famine and about die-offs
and everything else because of projections about agricultural production and things like
44
00:05:01,272 --> 00:05:10,197
that, as well as the success of market capitalism has been able to produce standards of
living that far exceeded anybody's projections back then.
45
00:05:10,497 --> 00:05:19,102
But the reality is there's still about three billion more people, three billion more
people on the planet now than when I started working on the issue.
46
00:05:19,350 --> 00:05:29,014
And so there are hundreds of millions of people who have everything to gain and nothing to
lose by trying to get into a handful of countries that have a strong social safety net and
47
00:05:29,014 --> 00:05:38,478
have essentially an actuarial income stream because of that social safety net that dwarfs
anything like their standard of living back in the home country.
48
00:05:38,899 --> 00:05:46,902
So trying to find those people who are truly,
Load full transcript
you know, political refugees, people who are
fearing for their lives for political reasons.
49
00:05:47,234 --> 00:05:57,377
or people whose lives are in some kind of danger because of those activities versus people
who simply want to improve themselves economically by making a move is like finding a
50
00:05:57,377 --> 00:05:59,017
needle in a haystack.
51
00:05:59,397 --> 00:06:10,961
And our country, like all other countries that enjoy Western democratic traditions, an
effort to try to provide the procedural process that's due to make sure we get the facts
52
00:06:10,961 --> 00:06:14,202
to figure out who's entitled to protection and who isn't.
53
00:06:14,202 --> 00:06:16,302
And then once you get that protection,
54
00:06:16,492 --> 00:06:19,455
then you ultimately have to make sure it's temporary, right?
55
00:06:19,455 --> 00:06:29,254
Not permanent, because there's so many who would theoretically qualify, while ensuring
there's a fair share responsibility globally, while at the same time realizing that not
56
00:06:29,254 --> 00:06:37,881
everybody's gonna be able to move, and that the ultimate solutions of course would be
temporary resettlement near the home country with ultimate repatriation when it's safe to
57
00:06:37,881 --> 00:06:43,192
do so, while advancing ideas that bring about democratic.
58
00:06:43,192 --> 00:06:51,526
capitalism, market capitalism under a democracy, self-governing republic that has proven
to be so successful so far in this country.
59
00:06:53,836 --> 00:06:58,670
In other words, it's like a global rule, a golden rule for the global village.
60
00:06:59,071 --> 00:06:59,571
Right?
61
00:06:59,571 --> 00:07:05,146
We would want to treat people who come to our shores the way we would want our people
treated elsewhere.
62
00:07:05,146 --> 00:07:06,036
Right?
63
00:07:06,337 --> 00:07:10,189
And the fact of the matter is the vast majority of countries are not so hospitable.
64
00:07:10,189 --> 00:07:18,566
The U S over the last 50, 60 years can take its place next to anybody for its generosity
and tradition.
65
00:07:18,727 --> 00:07:22,740
Think about the numbers of people this country has absorbed and assimilated.
66
00:07:22,816 --> 00:07:26,548
over the last 50, 100 years from all over the world.
67
00:07:26,649 --> 00:07:38,536
One of this engine of assimilation that somehow digested as Israel's Zangwill said 100
years ago to create a nation of immigrants, somehow a melting pot out of so many different
68
00:07:38,536 --> 00:07:42,779
traditions to assimilate them into one common language and cultural tradition.
69
00:07:42,779 --> 00:07:44,139
Quite amazing.
70
00:07:46,076 --> 00:07:55,120
Well, and I think what you said is, and that's kind of the first time that I've heard that
is where, actually vetting people before they come in.
71
00:07:55,120 --> 00:08:03,724
So, are you in a situation where you're not safe or whatever it is, then we can make that
determination and bring you
in.
72
00:08:03,724 --> 00:08:15,670
But obviously that is not what has happened, especially over the past four years with how
many people that have crossed the border and not for those reasons, I'm sure.
73
00:08:16,110 --> 00:08:26,483
I think that's a great idea to, okay, let's talk about it and tell us why you need to be
here and let us make that decision, I guess.
74
00:08:27,630 --> 00:08:28,280
Well, right.
75
00:08:28,280 --> 00:08:35,613
mean, you know, in the end, a successful immigration system allows in the people who
should be here and keeps out the ones who don't.
76
00:08:36,154 --> 00:08:42,036
And unfortunately, you know, the politics of this country are pretty much broken at this
point.
77
00:08:42,036 --> 00:08:50,260
You see this hardened polarization that we've hardly ever seen before, not since before
the civil war, really.
78
00:08:50,960 --> 00:08:53,711
Why it is, is of course a big topic of discussion.
79
00:08:53,711 --> 00:08:55,372
It's beyond the scope here.
80
00:08:55,790 --> 00:09:04,930
But in the course of working on one issue for so many years and working with so many
amazing and intelligent, bright people who had a lot of foresight, people who founded FAIR
81
00:09:04,930 --> 00:09:17,210
back in 1979, 78, they were amazing men and women who were thinking about the issue going
on 40, 50 years from now, recognizing that there was a strong bipartisan consensus that
82
00:09:17,210 --> 00:09:24,166
the rule of law was a cornerstone of citizenship and that secure borders are the
definition of modern nationhood.
83
00:09:24,460 --> 00:09:28,411
And then if you lose control of your borders, as Ronald Reagan said, you're not a country.
84
00:09:28,852 --> 00:09:35,975
And most other countries around the world understand basically that if you lose control of
your borders, you know, you're not a country.
85
00:09:36,055 --> 00:09:45,899
Well, the Democratic party throughout most of the 20th century was anchored by a strong
commitment to organize labor from Sam Gompers, founder of Organized Labor all the way
86
00:09:45,899 --> 00:09:47,900
through about 1995.
87
00:09:47,900 --> 00:09:53,152
The Democratic party was wedded to this strong unionized labor tradition.
88
00:09:53,248 --> 00:09:55,899
and stood for very strong border security.
89
00:09:55,999 --> 00:10:02,351
Everybody in the 1960s, 70s, illegal means, hey, illegal, right?
90
00:10:02,351 --> 00:10:05,802
You cross the border illegally, you're jumping in line.
91
00:10:06,262 --> 00:10:08,623
That's contrary to the American value system.
92
00:10:08,623 --> 00:10:10,263
Cheaters don't prosper.
93
00:10:10,263 --> 00:10:13,244
You don't break the law to get ahead of the line.
94
00:10:13,244 --> 00:10:14,654
That's not the American way.
95
00:10:14,654 --> 00:10:18,446
Fairness is still very much an American concept.
96
00:10:18,446 --> 00:10:20,456
And we basically believe in that.
97
00:10:20,704 --> 00:10:31,370
So when Ronald Reagan signed the 1986 bill that had an amnesty, everybody from Chuck
Schumer, I know Chuck's lying when his mouth is moving, all the way to Ronald Reagan.
98
00:10:31,370 --> 00:10:34,001
This is the last amnesty we're going to do, right?
99
00:10:34,001 --> 00:10:38,194
Because in the end, as I say, respect for law is what matters.
100
00:10:38,194 --> 00:10:40,125
That bill was supposed to get control of the borders.
101
00:10:40,125 --> 00:10:41,675
And of course it did not.
102
00:10:41,675 --> 00:10:50,350
And there's a lot of reasons why, but the immigration issue is ultimately motivated by
greed, intolerance.
103
00:10:50,452 --> 00:10:51,943
exploitation.
104
00:10:52,263 --> 00:11:02,229
mean, much of the debates about everything from slavery all the way through modern labor
contracting and guest worker programs is about the conditions under which labor is brought
105
00:11:02,229 --> 00:11:04,369
into this country from other countries.
106
00:11:04,690 --> 00:11:08,282
And this is ultimately, you know, getting a little far afield here.
107
00:11:08,282 --> 00:11:19,438
But the bottom line is for the average American here, you don't see the consensus about
the rule of law animating the discussion because the Democrats
108
00:11:19,438 --> 00:11:20,639
And I'm not just picking on them.
109
00:11:20,639 --> 00:11:28,065
The Republicans have issues too, but the Democrats abandoned their commitment to the
treatment of the average American worker.
110
00:11:28,065 --> 00:11:39,154
When Bill Clinton and others signed these trade agreements that outsourced all this
manufacturing, the Democrats lost this manufacturing base, blue collar Democrats became
111
00:11:39,154 --> 00:11:43,997
Reagan Democrats, and they had to find a new constituency.
112
00:11:44,218 --> 00:11:49,420
And then a great book by David Horowitz called the shadow party 2005 described.
113
00:11:49,420 --> 00:11:53,193
how George Soros and the radical left were taking over the Democratic Party.
114
00:11:53,193 --> 00:11:59,397
And the Democratic Party had to create a new constituency, which turned out to be this
mosaic of identity politics.
115
00:11:59,397 --> 00:12:09,645
And they decided that immigrants represented this emerging minority that they could
exploit, started really under Obama, second term, but then Bill Joe Biden took it downtown
116
00:12:09,645 --> 00:12:13,107
with this complete destruction of American border control.
117
00:12:13,107 --> 00:12:17,440
And now, even now you see it with Chris Von Houghton, my Senator.
118
00:12:17,618 --> 00:12:21,739
Ugh, and Jamie Raskin, my representative, I'm going to kill myself.
119
00:12:21,819 --> 00:12:32,582
Basically, they're flying down there to bring back an MS-13 gangbanger because they feel
he was wrongly deported even though he'd had his day in court twice, thumbed his nose at
120
00:12:32,582 --> 00:12:35,843
our legal system, and had absolutely no right to be here.
121
00:12:35,863
--> 00:12:39,424
So, I mean, the Democrats have gone full on crazy, lunatic.
122
00:12:39,424 --> 00:12:42,465
And suddenly it's like illegal doesn't mean anything.
123
00:12:42,465 --> 00:12:44,176
Citizenship doesn't mean anything.
124
00:12:44,176 --> 00:12:46,206
There's no longer any sort of
125
00:12:46,530 --> 00:12:50,472
consensus about what the rule of law matters in immigration policy.
126
00:12:50,472 --> 00:12:55,896
And you wonder, it all started with Obama under the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals
program.
127
00:12:55,896 --> 00:13:06,223
No legislation is going to get through Congress when the Democratic Party doesn't see any
value, if you will, in working to restore a functioning immigration system.
128
00:13:06,223 --> 00:13:08,004
They want chaos.
129
00:13:08,185 --> 00:13:16,620
The organizations that have attacked FAIR over the last 30 years, like the SPLC you
mentioned, Jennifer, are basically
130
00:13:16,800 --> 00:13:18,671
And the ACLU look at what they want.
131
00:13:18,671 --> 00:13:24,194
If you want to know what those organizations want, it is what you saw under Joe Biden.
132
00:13:24,194 --> 00:13:30,418
Chaos, anarchy, collapse of the rule of law, millions and millions of aliens bust into the
country.
133
00:13:30,418 --> 00:13:34,820
No vetting, terrorists, terrorist watch lists, murderers, criminals.
134
00:13:34,820 --> 00:13:35,491
They don't care.
135
00:13:35,491 --> 00:13:40,563
They don't care what the costs are to taxpayers, education, housing, healthcare.
136
00:13:40,563 --> 00:13:41,194
They don't care.
137
00:13:41,194 --> 00:13:42,144
Okay.
138
00:13:42,144 --> 00:13:45,430
All they want to do is re-engineer the American electorate.
139
00:13:45,430 --> 00:13:48,458
as Elon Musk said, to their political advantage.
140
00:13:48,458 --> 00:13:52,085
So now that we've all seen it, nobody supports it.
141
00:13:52,928 --> 00:13:57,624
So, and that's the point we're trying to understand.
142
00:13:57,624 --> 00:14:00,156
So is it about votes?
143
00:14:00,317 --> 00:14:02,299
Is it about cheap labor?
144
00:14:02,299 --> 00:14:05,063
Is it about just the whole thing?
145
00:14:05,063 --> 00:14:05,447
Yeah.
146
00:14:05,447 --> 00:14:14,311
I mean, a great environmental writer, Edward Abbey said, conservatives have their cheap
labor, liberals have their cheap votes.
147
00:14:14,532 --> 00:14:20,994
The business community, in particular, big agriculture has been the raspberry seed in our
wisdom tooth for decades.
148
00:14:20,994 --> 00:14:29,248
They always want some kind of snap your fingers and Jose and a bunch of guys in the back
of a pickup show up to pick strawberries.
149
00:14:29,548 --> 00:14:34,639
Of course, the Japanese and the Netherlands, they would have automated this stuff a long
time ago.
150
00:14:34,739 --> 00:14:40,021
But every time we talk about border security, they come to Congress and go, we got to have
a guest worker program.
151
00:14:40,021 --> 00:14:43,222
The guest worker program that they're demanding is totally unworkable.
152
00:14:43,222 --> 00:14:48,813
So what they really want is a continued flow of illegal labor, which is very costly
because they work in the fields for a while.
153
00:14:48,813 --> 00:14:58,382
Then they go to the cities and they bring their families and then they have to be replaced
with more and this is continuing streams like a stepping stone, but they're very powerful.
154
00:14:58,382 --> 00:15:01,042
in the Republican party, but also in the Democratic party.
155
00:15:01,042 --> 00:15:05,302
And then on the left, yes, there are books who can read.
156
00:15:05,302 --> 00:15:11,522
mean, the democratic operatives have written that are flat out saying, oh, you know, we
have a lock on people of color.
157
00:15:11,522 --> 00:15:22,702
want to replicate with the Hispanic community, the kind of political loyalty we've seen
from the African-American community and just basically run rough shot over the pre 1970
158
00:15:22,702 --> 00:15:28,366
American post, you know, descendant of immigrant stock that's here because
159
00:15:28,366 --> 00:15:29,366
They're so loyal.
160
00:15:29,366 --> 00:15:33,806
Well, Donald Trump has demonstrated there's a few flaws in the theory.
161
00:15:34,246 --> 00:15:37,466
And in fact, Biden was so irresponsible.
162
00:15:37,606 --> 00:15:41,606
I mean, I think the country would have been better off if Biden had been alive while he
was president.
163
00:15:41,606 --> 00:15:45,306
But anyway, I'm just kidding around here.
164
00:15:45,326 --> 00:15:57,086
But the point is, the point is that Trump took advantage of the incredible colossal
political mistakes that frankly, Hillary Clinton made in 2016 too, which is somewhere
165
00:15:57,086 --> 00:15:58,178
along the way.
166
00:15:58,178 --> 00:16:09,229
Barack Obama has not been able to convince his so-called successors that abolishing
borders is something neither party, neither party's base really supports.
167
00:16:09,369 --> 00:16:12,592
But it gave Trump an enormous opportunity.
168
00:16:12,678 --> 00:16:20,861
it's some, and what the most interesting thing about it is the Democrats seem to have
learned absolutely nothing from the mistakes that they're making.
169
00:16:20,861 --> 00:16:22,452
They're just doubling down.
170
00:16:22,749 --> 00:16:31,136
Well, and it seems like an issue where, you know, they're cutting off their nose to spite
their face because what we're seeing, you know, in a diverse state like Florida,
171
00:16:31,136 --> 00:16:41,195
especially down in Miami and Southeast Florida, you know, prior to Barack Obama, we
started to see this generational shift of African Americans to the Republican Party.
172
00:16:41,195 --> 00:16:45,959
Barack Obama certainly stopped that and for that period of time.
173
00:16:45,959 --> 00:16:48,762
But now we're starting to see that shift again.
174
00:16:48,762 --> 00:16:50,515
And certainly in
175
00:16:50,515 --> 00:17:01,075
You know, for instance, the Cuban community has been Republican, but you started looking
at other South American, Central American communities where they came and voted Democrat.
176
00:17:01,075 --> 00:17:03,095
The Puerto Rican community voted Democrat.
177
00:17:03,095 --> 00:17:09,235
And now we're seeing as they're here generationally, they're voting more and more
Republican.
178
00:17:09,455 --> 00:17:19,715
And, you know, so it's one of these things that where Democrats are really short sighted,
not only are they put it compromising the safety and integrity of the very fabric of our
179
00:17:19,715 --> 00:17:20,515
country.
180
00:17:20,679 --> 00:17:29,413
But they are, you know, the long-term is these folks aren't gonna vote for them anyway,
because once they become economically involved in America, they know that their only
181
00:17:29,413 --> 00:17:34,135
chance for true economic freedom is what Republicans stand for, not what Democrats stand
for.
182
00:17:34,135 --> 00:17:38,377
And so it's just, you know, I just keep going.
183
00:17:38,377 --> 00:17:46,631
It's just a frustrating hypocrisy that the Democrats continue to portray.
184
00:17:47,107 --> 00:17:49,148
But it starts with our children in a way.
185
00:17:49,148 --> 00:17:55,651
And so a lot of this impacts, you know, people starting out in their careers and jobs for
young Americans.
186
00:17:55,712 --> 00:18:07,368
you know, so how, what kind of information have you seen where this is truly impacting,
you know, kind of starting, people starting out in their careers, starting out in life, or
187
00:18:07,368 --> 00:18:09,619
even teenagers looking for jobs?
188
00:18:11,130 --> 00:18:11,570
wow.
189
00:18:11,570 --> 00:18:24,144
I mean, this is a huge topic, but you you have to, you have to go back to the, to the late
1980s and the dawn of the computer industry with mass production of laptops and things
190
00:18:24,144 --> 00:18:24,544
like that.
191
00:18:24,544 --> 00:18:32,976
And they went to Congress and they said, you know, we need temporary skilled workers
because there aren't enough Americans to do this job.
192
00:18:32,976 --> 00:18:36,497
they pushed Congress to create the H1B program.
193
00:18:37,457 --> 00:18:39,758
And this thing is now going on for like,
194
00:18:39,758 --> 00:18:48,761
Now the so-called shortage has gone on for decades because once they get addicted to a
foreign labor flow, it drives out American workers.
195
00:18:48,981 --> 00:18:58,424
mean, de Tocqueville, when he was writing Democracy in America, pointed out that slave
labor and free labor can't coexist in the same labor market for the same basic reason.
196
00:18:58,424 --> 00:19:06,766
Guest workers drive out American workers because their expectations are skewed in the
whole bunch of ways, including their exploitable status.
197
00:19:07,224 --> 00:19:13,499
But then we signed all these agreements where we outsourced millions and millions of
manufacturing jobs.
198
00:19:13,940 --> 00:19:19,065
And the reason, the theory was back then that we were going to be the knowledge dominant
society.
199
00:19:19,065 --> 00:19:28,073
And JD Vance made this really important speech to the innovation society a few weeks ago,
explaining how these assumptions turned out to be wrong.
200
00:19:28,114 --> 00:19:33,038
The belief was back then that we could send manufacturing overseas, but retain.
201
00:19:33,330 --> 00:19:40,553
R &D research and development and design, computer aided design manufacturing, high value
added manufacturing here.
202
00:19:41,153 --> 00:19:48,737
And the problem was that none of them anticipated the advent of the internet and its
utility worldwide in moving knowledge work around the world.
203
00:19:49,197 --> 00:19:53,359
At the same time, country lost control of its borders.
204
00:19:53,759 --> 00:20:01,152
And so all the assumptions that were in play in the early 1990s about what kind of economy
we were going to have,
205
00:20:01,272 --> 00:20:04,964
high value added manufacturing, knowledge work, service work.
206
00:20:04,965 --> 00:20:14,781
Americans were going to be trained in all this knowledge work, great education, relatively
few people in schools because the birth rate had declined in the 70s, not taking any
207
00:20:14,781 --> 00:20:17,463
factor of immigration into account.
208
00:20:17,463 --> 00:20:28,040
that for those jobs that were in the non-export competing sector, like janitorial work,
service work, hotel, restaurant, they would be well-paid unionized jobs.
209
00:20:28,681 --> 00:20:31,362
And that was what the American people were sold.
210
00:20:31,850 --> 00:20:33,310
None of that happened.
211
00:20:33,450 --> 00:20:36,311
Instead, know, foreign workers were brought in.
212
00:20:36,331 --> 00:20:40,382
They started basically stealing technology, taking it back home.
213
00:20:40,382 --> 00:20:45,334
The company started outsourcing smart work, knowledge work overseas.
214
00:20:45,794 --> 00:20:51,235
And now Americans are suddenly competing in a worldwide labor force.
215
00:20:51,915 --> 00:21:00,958
And naturally there are all these, I mean, if you at least look at manufacturing, Trump
thinks we're going to be able to compete in manufacturing with countries like China, but
216
00:21:00,958 --> 00:21:01,432
they're
217
00:21:01,432 --> 00:21:03,463
The pay scale is so dramatically different.
218
00:21:03,463 --> 00:21:05,843
It's going to be kind of a challenge to do that.
219
00:21:06,003 --> 00:21:11,425
Well, young Americans today basically are being told, well, you're not good enough to do
any job in your own country.
220
00:21:11,425 --> 00:21:15,406
There are always foreign workers out there who are going to bring in these skills and do
them better.
221
00:21:15,686 --> 00:21:25,988
So between that and the population growth that's resulted from immigration, crowding out
housing, bidding up housing costs, supply stock isn't there.
222
00:21:26,109 --> 00:21:30,370
mean, young people today can't get a leg up.
223
00:21:30,370 --> 00:21:31,562
They can't achieve.
224
00:21:31,562 --> 00:21:34,223
economic security for family formation.
225
00:21:34,423 --> 00:21:38,184
And as a result, they don't have the economic security to even start families.
226
00:21:38,444 --> 00:21:44,965
know, and yeah, women want to be in the workforce, but at the same time, they can't
function on one income.
227
00:21:45,426 --> 00:21:50,687
And to be able to step out of the labor force with young children is not affordable for
families.
228
00:21:50,687 --> 00:21:52,498
So the women are waiting longer and longer.
229
00:21:52,498 --> 00:21:55,809
And then by the time they're ready to have kids, it's much more difficult.
230
00:21:55,809 --> 00:22:01,600
Maybe they'll have one or two, but you see the decline in fertility where it's sub
replacement fertility now.
231
00:22:01,666 --> 00:22:10,091
And all these factors play into the fact that there's this congestion effect of both
massive immigration and outsourcing at the same time.
232
00:22:10,351 --> 00:22:21,698
So you wonder why there's like at a time when there should be a strong economic future for
our young people today, they don't A, see anything being actually built in this country.
233
00:22:21,698 --> 00:22:23,979
There's no real manufacturing going on.
234
00:22:23,979 --> 00:22:29,462
It doesn't fire their imaginations and B, the conventional path toward college.
235
00:22:29,582 --> 00:22:36,542
with this enormous debt isn't really producing, guaranteeing the skills to do the kinds of
jobs that needed to be done in this country in the future.
236
00:22:36,542 --> 00:22:39,042
I mean, I got a grandson, he's smart as a whip.
237
00:22:39,342 --> 00:22:40,762
I don't see any effort.
238
00:22:40,762 --> 00:22:42,462
He's in what, sixth, seventh grade?
239
00:22:42,462 --> 00:22:51,842
I don't see any effort by these tech companies to go out there and recruit people like him
and get him channeled into the right path forward to the jobs that are needed tomorrow
240
00:22:51,842 --> 00:22:55,642
because they still believe they can rake off people from India and China.
241
00:22:55,884 --> 00:22:56,675
to do these works.
242
00:22:56,675 --> 00:23:00,318
And then they go to Congress and go, we can't get Americans to do the job.
243
00:23:00,318 --> 00:23:05,814
Well, you you told us there was a labor shortage in 1980, 88, 89.
244
00:23:05,882 --> 00:23:08,945
You've had plenty of time to train Americans to do the job.
245
00:23:08,945 --> 00:23:15,150
Why would they care about the quality of public education if they think they can just keep
bringing in these folks from overseas?
246
00:23:15,150 --> 00:23:22,956
So, I mean, and then when you get to the lower end of the economic, I know you've talked
to a number of folks on this issue, so I don't want to repeat what they've already told
247
00:23:22,956 --> 00:23:25,228
you, but the data are clear here.
248
00:23:25,390 --> 00:23:34,635
When it comes to people with a high school degree or less, this massive inflow of people
with less education, a high school degree or less, fifth grade education, illiterate in
249
00:23:34,635 --> 00:23:39,618
any language, we're a post-industrial superpower information society.
250
00:23:39,718 --> 00:23:45,441
Last thing we need to be doing is bringing in people who are more appropriate for the age
of the buggy whip and the Model T.
251
00:23:45,602 --> 00:23:51,845
We don't need this massive surfeit of unskilled labor, but we're bringing it in either
illegally or not.
252
00:23:52,025 --> 00:23:53,526
And then you wonder why...
253
00:23:53,526 --> 00:24:01,030
wages have been stagnant and why American men, born men, native born American men are all
dropping out of the labor force.
254
00:24:01,331 --> 00:24:03,491
And they've been crowded out of everything.
255
00:24:03,512 --> 00:24:08,455
these wages that they're paying under the table, the aliens, whatever, you can't survive
on them.
256
00:24:08,455 --> 00:24:11,876
mean, just this stuff is like basic common sense, supply and demand.
257
00:24:11,876 --> 00:24:15,258
You keep increasing the supply, employers like it.
258
00:24:15,258 --> 00:24:16,059
They love it.
259
00:24:16,059 --> 00:24:19,801
And I'm sure in Florida, Governor DeSantis is doing a great job down there.
260
00:24:19,801 --> 00:24:22,142
He's got the legislature whipped into shape.
261
00:24:22,424 --> 00:24:30,979
But there's always going to be these businesses down in Florida going, we got to raise
wages, you know, know, if you're a marginal employer and, and the problem is if you're an
262
00:24:30,979 --> 00:24:35,231
employer who's trying to do the right thing, pay competitive wages.
263
00:24:35,932 --> 00:24:41,165
the guy who's using the illegal labor is going to be able to undercut you cause he's
shortchanging on the labor costs, right?
264
00:24:41,165 --> 00:24:48,489
It's called privatizing the profits of low wage labor while you commonize the costs on the
community for education, all that kind of stuff.
265
00:24:48,489 --> 00:24:50,790
So it's, it's,
266
00:24:51,062 --> 00:24:55,294
complicated issue, but it's killing the job prospects for young people.
267
00:24:55,975 --> 00:24:56,748
Well, I
268
00:24:56,748 --> 00:25:11,738
guess I just don't understand how, how do the Democrats like not number one, see this as
an act of slavery and not see what it is doing to our country or like, how are they
269
00:25:11,738 --> 00:25:13,539
benefiting enough to...
270
00:25:14,960 --> 00:25:19,422
make this a reality that could essentially ruin our country.
271
00:25:19,422 --> 00:25:21,043
Like I just, don't understand that.
272
00:25:21,043 --> 00:25:25,926
And that's my, you I'm not the high level thought process on the political side of it.
273
00:25:25,926 --> 00:25:30,540
So me being a regular Americans, like I don't get it.
274
00:25:31,342 --> 00:25:44,162
If you're willing to sacrifice the productivity for the labor cost, mean, if you've given
me three slaves and all I have to do is give them a room and three meals a day, I'll make
275
00:25:44,162 --> 00:25:47,002
money if they're at all productive.
276
00:25:47,982 --> 00:25:52,982
It's apparently a preferred alternative to automation, robotics, things like that.
277
00:25:53,022 --> 00:25:59,942
I mean, the best thing we could do for our economy would be to shut off the supply of less
skilled labor for a sustained period of time.
278
00:26:00,110 --> 00:26:08,550
And we would see the introduction of all this labor saving technology right across the
board, agriculture, all the way up to like home health care and everything else.
279
00:26:08,650 --> 00:26:16,070
But if the alternative is being able to bring people in who are willing to work all day
for a bucket of fish heads, employers would prefer that.
280
00:26:16,430 --> 00:26:28,370
That's, you know, this is part of the debate that went on a hundred and some years ago,
led to the very first immigration restrictions in 19 at the federal level, 1916, 1920,
281
00:26:28,370 --> 00:26:29,430
1922.
282
00:26:29,986 --> 00:26:32,367
But those restrictions were hard fought.
283
00:26:32,507 --> 00:26:42,270
And the only reason that American business actually finally agreed to support the
restrictions that brought down the huge Ellis Island wave was because of fear of the
284
00:26:42,270 --> 00:26:44,770
contagion from the Bolshevik revolution.
285
00:26:45,210 --> 00:26:52,072
And evidence that too many of the immigrants who were coming in to work in the sweatshops
were sympathetic to what was happening in Russia.
286
00:26:52,673 --> 00:26:55,734
Now, I don't know what it would take.
287
00:26:55,734 --> 00:26:57,964
I maybe Trump's election.
288
00:26:58,030 --> 00:27:08,510
vindicates the idea that some of these tech company gurus who've been so, you know,
adamant about foreign labor, I Elon Musk is basically talking at two levels.
289
00:27:08,510 --> 00:27:13,390
He's talking one about if you don't give him his H1B workers, he's going to kill you.
290
00:27:13,390 --> 00:27:18,690
But on the other hand, he's saying we're bringing in so many immigrants that it's
destroying our civilization.
291
00:27:19,050 --> 00:27:21,410
So, I mean, it's kind of, you got to kind of thread the needle.
292
00:27:21,410 --> 00:27:27,410
But the point is that's a tectonic shift in the tech company reception of this.
293
00:27:27,438 --> 00:27:35,183
And maybe they're beginning to realize that there is a level at which you can destabilize
this wonderful American experiment.
294
00:27:35,183 --> 00:27:39,046
Remember, sorry about my cold.
295
00:27:39,807 --> 00:27:42,839
It used to be called the immigration and naturalization service.
296
00:27:42,839 --> 00:27:45,510
That's what it was called, the INS for decades.
297
00:27:45,731 --> 00:27:47,852
Immigration was the first step.
298
00:27:47,933 --> 00:27:50,674
Naturalization, oath of allegiance.
299
00:27:51,215 --> 00:27:52,756
That was the last.
300
00:27:52,916 --> 00:27:55,726
When you immigrate, you had to wait a five years or so.
301
00:27:55,726 --> 00:27:57,027
before you took the oath of allegiance.
302
00:27:57,027 --> 00:27:59,648
Now, what did you learn in that period of time?
303
00:27:59,989 --> 00:28:05,392
Well, what does it mean to live in a self-governing Republic, a democracy?
304
00:28:05,546 --> 00:28:14,318
And what it means is you're not loyal to a potentate, a thug, a dictator, a tribal chief,
a strong man, you know, a murderer, whatever.
305
00:28:14,479 --> 00:28:17,991
You basically are a citizen in a self-governing democracy.
306
00:28:17,991 --> 00:28:25,696
You're an office holder as a citizen participating in that process, selecting your
government, selecting your governor.
307
00:28:25,804 --> 00:28:29,855
And that's a big change from historically what was done, right?
308
00:28:29,875 --> 00:28:39,558
Kind of like the equivalent would be Adam Smith's invisible hand that somehow things go
better when people are able to do what they want to do instead of centrally directed
309
00:28:39,558 --> 00:28:42,739
conduct in a communist or fascist regime.
310
00:28:42,739 --> 00:28:43,579
Right?
311
00:28:43,639 --> 00:28:50,240
So you're teaching them something about what it means to be an American politically,
historically, what have you.
312
00:28:50,561 --> 00:28:56,052
And ideally you're teaching people about what market capitalism is and why it's an
efficient.
313
00:28:56,098 --> 00:28:59,160
done properly allocation of resources, right?
314
00:28:59,961 --> 00:29:09,349
If you don't teach people those fundamental lessons about what it means to be an American,
you bring people in at a level where they're basically bringing bad ideas into the country
315
00:29:09,349 --> 00:29:21,339
to the point where, you know, they're met here right off the boat by left-wing AOC types
who are trying to convince them, you know, the problem is there's, or Bernie Sanders.
316
00:29:21,380 --> 00:29:22,931
I mean, look at Bernie Sanders.
317
00:29:22,931 --> 00:29:24,750
He hasn't changed his tune in what?
318
00:29:24,750 --> 00:29:34,863
50 years, he still, but he goes to find these young audiences who were still gullible
enough to listen to his nonsense about, you know, income inequality is somehow a bad thing
319
00:29:34,863 --> 00:29:40,784
because, you know, people, some people work harder than others and some people have better
capability or skills than others.
320
00:29:40,784 --> 00:29:49,377
But in any case, that process of molding people into being an American is the key to
assimilation for large numbers of people.
321
00:29:49,377 --> 00:29:52,686
The level of immigration has to be guided by
322
00:29:52,686
--> 00:30:03,206
factors that include the assimilability, think that's the right word, of the people coming
in, the volume, the velocity, how fast they're coming in and what they're meeting when
323
00:30:03,206 --> 00:30:04,366
they get here, right?
324
00:30:04,366 --> 00:30:15,826
Do we as a nation have the confidence to stand up for what we ultimately have, this great
tradition, the glory of the English language, which is a fabulous creation, rich, diverse
325
00:30:15,826 --> 00:30:22,742
from so many sources that came into Great Britain and brought it, came here, our sort of
Anglo-American system.
326
00:30:22,742 --> 00:30:33,597
of governance, understanding of property rights and its role in freedom and building a
society and all these things that go along with what makes democratic freedom possible in
327
00:30:33,597 --> 00:30:37,428
the allocation of political power and votes.
328
00:30:38,249 --> 00:30:44,652
Immigration tends to corrupt the process because some people make a lot of money off
immigration, Jennifer.
329
00:30:44,652 --> 00:30:48,293
Your question is really about why is it so hard to get right?
330
00:30:48,293 --> 00:30:50,674
Because immigration is
331
00:30:50,944 --> 00:31:00,059
about exploitation and about greed and about making money using marginal labor instead of
innovation and in productivity advances.
332
00:31:00,239 --> 00:31:04,962
And so because in both sides of the spectrum, it serves certain people's interests.
333
00:31:05,142 --> 00:31:09,765
It becomes hard for our two party system to find the center.
334
00:31:09,765 --> 00:31:13,867
Now there used to be a center back in the eighties and nineties.
335
00:31:13,867 --> 00:31:16,589
As I said earlier, there was a political center.
336
00:31:16,589 --> 00:31:18,860
You had Rockefeller Republicans.
337
00:31:18,862 --> 00:31:28,088
But people who believed fundamentally in the rule of law, cultural conservatives who liked
to the stability of the American culture and the, in the cultural community.
338
00:31:28,088 --> 00:31:37,414
And then you had people who were big government liberals, Eugene McCarthy, governor Dick
Lamb, who understood that if you don't know how many people you're going to be serving in
339
00:31:37,414 --> 00:31:39,816
the country, you can't deliver good government services.
340
00:31:39,816 --> 00:31:40,417
Right?
341
00:31:40,417 --> 00:31:48,982
You issue a bond, you build a school, but the school's overcrowded suddenly because people
have come in illegally and they put their kids in the school.
342
00:31:49,102 --> 00:31:50,762
Our kids are getting hurt, right?
343
00:31:50,762 --> 00:32:01,342
I think about what Biden did to public education, overloading our public schools, because
the Supreme Court demanded in 1982, we provide education at taxpayer expense.
344
00:32:01,342 --> 00:32:03,582
They call it free public education.
345
00:32:03,582 --> 00:32:05,142
Like something's free, right?
346
00:32:05,142 --> 00:32:15,842
Anyway, and the point is here you have unaccountable Supreme Court justices putting this
mandate on taxpayers to provide education for anybody coming in, putting 10 kids in public
347
00:32:15,842 --> 00:32:16,722
school.
348
00:32:16,822 --> 00:32:18,732
What do think that did to public education?
349
00:32:18,732 --> 00:32:20,203
Right?
350
00:32:20,203 --> 00:32:22,584
the Supreme Court, I think it was Potter.
351
00:32:22,584 --> 00:32:25,355
No, was Brennan who wrote the decision.
352
00:32:25,355 --> 00:32:28,956
we don't see any economic burden of kids going into public schools.
353
00:32:28,956 --> 00:32:29,887
Well, that was 1982.
354
00:32:29,887 --> 00:32:31,828
You should look at it now.
355
00:32:31,828 --> 00:32:36,099
And that kind of unfunded mandate is part of the problem.
356
00:32:36,099 --> 00:32:43,913
And that's the last problem, which is that the state and local taxpayers are the ones who
pay most of the cost for this uncontrolled immigration.
357
00:32:43,913 --> 00:32:47,170
the federal level, you have lawyers and the Judiciary Committee.
358
00:32:47,170 --> 00:32:51,952
People like that who basically go, yeah, we'll let another couple hundred million in.
359
00:32:52,113 --> 00:32:52,783
No problem.
360
00:32:52,783 --> 00:32:55,475
We'll let the state and local taxpayers deal with it.
361
00:32:55,475 --> 00:32:58,096
And you you have this disconnect.
362
00:32:58,096 --> 00:33:05,080
So I mean, there are all these structural reasons why immigration policy is so hard to get
solved.
363
00:33:05,080 --> 00:33:10,404
You know, as Mark Korkorian, I think may have said to you, there are winners and losers,
right?
364
00:33:10,404 --> 00:33:15,106
Okay, well, right now, what Donald Trump has done,
365
00:33:15,446 --> 00:33:19,688
Is vindicate the interests of the populist wing of the Republican party.
366
00:33:19,808 --> 00:33:31,223
He's basically kicked out the Bush entrenched, you know, wing of the party, the elites,
the country club guys, you know, all those, and basically said the populist party part of
367
00:33:31,223 --> 00:33:33,374
the party is going to rule for awhile.
368
00:33:33,374 --> 00:33:35,115
Now the Bush wing, they don't like that.
369
00:33:35,115 --> 00:33:35,815
They're upset.
370
00:33:35,815 --> 00:33:41,707
We heard them on the never Trumpers, but you know, as I believe somebody said, who was it
here?
371
00:33:41,707 --> 00:33:43,508
The people rule, right?
372
00:33:43,750 --> 00:33:47,679
And in the case of what we see with Donald Trump, that's what we're seeing.
373
00:33:47,679 --> 00:33:49,672
So maybe something will get done.
374
00:33:51,505 --> 00:33:59,275
Well, you certainly have, you know, packed a lot in there, you know, as far as, you know,
housing and education.
375
00:33:59,275 --> 00:34:04,183
And the one thing that I don't know that you touched on is public health.
376
00:34:04,404 --> 00:34:10,408
And, you know, what
kind of impact does this have on our health system?
377
00:34:10,408 --> 00:34:20,539
Like here in Sarasota, we have, you know, a public, supported hospital and, know, a
portion of our property taxes go to support that hospital and into do the care, which.
378
00:34:20,539 --> 00:34:25,903
Of course, includes a lot of emergency room care for illegal immigrants.
379
00:34:25,903 --> 00:34:32,528
But from your global or national perspective, what's that this influx?
380
00:34:32,528 --> 00:34:39,694
mean, we're not importing nurses and doctors for the most part, or Biden didn't import
nurses and doctors that came across the southern border.
381
00:34:39,694 --> 00:34:42,045
It's people who need nurses and doctors.
382
00:34:42,045 --> 00:34:47,119
So what are your thoughts and what are you seeing from the national perspective on that?
383
00:34:48,142 --> 00:34:51,962
Well, healthcare is one of the major costs, education, healthcare, housing.
384
00:34:51,962 --> 00:34:55,402
I mean, these are some of the major costs of immigration.
385
00:34:55,762 --> 00:35:02,642
You know, the people who come in who are doctors, very small number of percentage, we're
talking about the overall immigration level.
386
00:35:03,242 --> 00:35:12,702
No, what the world is supplying is people who, as I say, are illiterate in any language
and have fifth grade education and they don't have health insurance and naturally, you
387
00:35:12,702 --> 00:35:16,760
know, there's a Hippocratic oath, public institutions are supposed to try to help people.
388
00:35:16,760 --> 00:35:18,531
whether they can pay or not.
389
00:35:18,531 --> 00:35:31,538
But in the end, know, Barack Obama stood up at his State of the Union and Joe Thomas set
up, Obama said, illegal aliens are not going to get access to Obamacare.
390
00:35:32,019 --> 00:35:34,490
And Joe said, you lie.
391
00:35:34,490 --> 00:35:35,611
It was a big scandal.
392
00:35:35,611 --> 00:35:43,626
my God, you know, as if somehow the Democrats are models of decorum when it comes to
Republicans giving a State of the Union.
393
00:35:43,626 --> 00:35:44,826
In any case,
394
00:35:45,446 --> 00:35:50,909
Naturally, Obama, Biden just said, yeah, we're by the way, we're going to give illegal
aliens Obamacare.
395
00:35:51,229 --> 00:35:59,934
And, by the way, and of course Gavin Newsom struggling with a two plus billion dollar
deficit in California is busy giving illegal aliens healthcare.
396
00:36:00,114 --> 00:36:08,478
I mean, you know, when it goes beyond just the cost of healthcare, you also have this
absurd interpretation of the 14th amendment.
397
00:36:08,979 --> 00:36:15,282
A woman comes in El Paso hospital 45 minutes before delivering a baby and the baby's a US
citizen.
398
00:36:15,973 --> 00:36:18,334
And entitled to the rights and privileges of U.S.
399
00:36:18,334 --> 00:36:19,274
citizen.
400
00:36:20,074 --> 00:36:24,294
And of course, we're responsible for the health care of the the child, citizen child too.
401
00:36:24,574 --> 00:36:30,354
you know, the way this again is privatizing profits, commonizing costs.
402
00:36:30,534 --> 00:36:34,874
No way the framers of the 14th Amendment ever anticipated this kind of stuff going on.
403
00:36:34,894 --> 00:36:40,634
In 1867, most people didn't go more than 30 miles from their place of birth their entire
lives.
404
00:36:41,334 --> 00:36:43,174
And you didn't have birth certificates.
405
00:36:43,174 --> 00:36:44,174
Everybody knew who you were.
406
00:36:44,174 --> 00:36:47,354
You know, you're either the town drunk or the sheriff.
407
00:36:47,934 --> 00:36:52,374
And, uh, you know, we have these antiquated ideas.
408
00:36:52,374 --> 00:37:02,454
And so, you know, part of the healthcare costs is ultimately like some absurd number,
like, you know, 40 % of mothers giving birth to children in our house, public hospitals
409
00:37:02,454 --> 00:37:03,594
are here illegally.
410
00:37:03,594 --> 00:37:06,794
We have birth tourism, same thing there.
411
00:37:06,794 --> 00:37:13,164
Um, I mean, the cost of healthcare is already very high and certainly trying to provide
emergency public healthcare.
412
00:37:13,164 --> 00:37:20,416
which is mandated for all these people is a massive burden on our health care system.
413
00:37:20,416 --> 00:37:27,068
Then you get into the problem of unvetted people coming into the country, resurgence of
things like tuberculosis, right?
414
00:37:27,068 --> 00:37:33,180
We had COVID come in, we had lots of things like that, resurfacing of measles, things like
that.
415
00:37:33,180 --> 00:37:37,574
have polio is now back, unvetted.
416
00:37:37,574 --> 00:37:38,862
Are we supposed to...
417
00:37:40,182 --> 00:37:48,550
support the Chinese government and assuming that they're going to protect us from Chinese
visitors coming in and it's a great job with COVID, my goodness.
418
00:37:48,591 --> 00:37:52,894
I mean, all kinds of reasons why you have to have strict vetting.
419
00:37:52,975 --> 00:38:00,282
And it's so funny that Biden would have let the borders get so bad out of control after
having just gone through a pandemic.
420
00:38:01,932 --> 00:38:04,474
Yeah, that seems crazy.
421
00:38:06,111 --> 00:38:07,217
Yeah, please.
422
00:38:07,217 --> 00:38:15,546
So, and this is gonna be a weird question, but what does it look like actually coming in
through the border?
423
00:38:15,546 --> 00:38:17,929
Like, it like a turnstile?
424
00:38:17,929 --> 00:38:20,632
Is it like an amusement park?
425
00:38:20,632 --> 00:38:22,234
Is it like customs?
426
00:38:22,234 --> 00:38:23,775
What does it look like?
427
00:38:24,728 --> 00:38:28,296
Well, it's kind of like a line at Disney World in a way.
428
00:38:28,296 --> 00:38:31,513
I mean, you got to wait at the port of entry and you get screened by an officer.
429
00:38:31,513 --> 00:38:34,368
If you have a passport, examines it for you.
430
00:38:34,654 --> 00:38:36,239
of
everybody coming in?
431
00:38:36,426 --> 00:38:42,409
No, I mean, they take biometrics of certain people who are non-citizens.
432
00:38:42,409 --> 00:38:52,063
They, particularly if you come in and make a humanitarian claim for asylum or what have
you, if you're released on recognizance and given an order to show cause or an order to
433
00:38:52,063 --> 00:38:55,794
report on a certain date, they're doing biometric identification.
434
00:38:56,115 --> 00:38:59,896
The port of entries are relatively orderly, but they're overwhelmed.
435
00:38:59,896 --> 00:39:03,818
You go to the San Ysidro port of entry down there near San Diego.
436
00:39:03,982 --> 00:39:09,042
And you'll see lines and lines of traffic most days as people wait in line to go through.
437
00:39:09,042 --> 00:39:13,122
In most cases, you know, if you're a US citizen, it's fairly obvious.
438
00:39:13,122 --> 00:39:15,822
They ask you a few questions and you wave you through.
439
00:39:16,402 --> 00:39:22,202
But if you're from another country, they inspect your passport and you don't have proper
documentation.
440
00:39:22,202 --> 00:39:23,762
They don't let you come in.
441
00:39:23,762 --> 00:39:32,982
If you try to make a humanitarian claim or you're in one of these crazy parole programs
that Biden put over, know, they, they, they take down your information, take the biometric
442
00:39:32,982 --> 00:39:34,158
fingerprints and
443
00:39:34,158 --> 00:39:41,478
and maybe they believe you're a flight risk, they'll give you an ankle bracelet and send
you on your way.
444
00:39:41,478 --> 00:39:45,518
Or if they think you're a flight risk, they'll put you in detention.
445
00:39:47,198 --> 00:39:48,592
But where?
446
00:39:48,592 --> 00:39:51,014
Yeah, where would they be a flight risk to?
447
00:39:51,382 --> 00:39:55,893
Well, I mean, if they're not going to show up for their court hearing, but they've made an
asylum claim.
448
00:39:55,893 --> 00:39:59,575
In fact, Congress has mandated asylum claimants be detained.
449
00:39:59,575 --> 00:40:04,126
of course, administration has always claimed they don't have the space.
450
00:40:04,126 --> 00:40:10,798
I mean, one of the reasons why the Trump administration is trying to send folks to
Guantanamo is there's only so much detention space.
451
00:40:10,798 --> 00:40:14,509
And Biden did everything he could under, with Secretary Mayorkas.
452
00:40:15,009 --> 00:40:17,460
Guy ought to be tried for treason, for God's sake.
453
00:40:17,950 --> 00:40:24,813
you know, closed all these detention centers and the, and the Democrat states don't want
private detention facilities in their states.
454
00:40:25,153 --> 00:40:34,477
I mean, I mean, you have to realize Jennifer that we're dealing with one entire political
party that wants to sabotage all immigration enforcement.
455
00:40:34,677 --> 00:40:44,241
You know, once somebody gets into the, what you notice in this whole problem is that
getting into the country is a lot easier than removing them.
456
00:40:44,381 --> 00:40:46,574
It's like they, you know,
457
00:40:46,574 --> 00:40:54,754
All kinds of ways people can get into the country without inspection, overstay a visa, lie
their way through a port of entry, fraud, whatever.
458
00:40:54,974 --> 00:41:02,474
But like the Democrats and their allies all know that the removal process requires this
kind of immigration court proceeding.
459
00:41:02,474 --> 00:41:03,634
It's elaborate.
460
00:41:03,734 --> 00:41:12,434
Trump has tried to short-circuit that with some folks with the, with the Alien Act from
1797, 98.
461
00:41:12,514 --> 00:41:14,926
And, uh, you know, he's, of he's getting.
462
00:41:14,926 --> 00:41:18,106
blow back from some of the courts about using such an old law.
463
00:41:18,106 --> 00:41:30,186
But in the end, you know, the procedural process is due in a removal proceeding is
cumbersome enough to take, you know, if you want to deport a million illegal aliens in one
464
00:41:30,186 --> 00:41:40,166
year, it's pretty hard to do with the court backlogs that we have now in the court system
itself is a whole different topic set up because the advocates did not like the fact that
465
00:41:40,166 --> 00:41:43,094
hearing officers back in the 1980s were
466
00:41:43,094 --> 00:41:46,355
immigration officers that were part of the enforcement division.
467
00:41:46,575 --> 00:41:48,175
mean, immigration is a civil matter.
468
00:41:48,175 --> 00:41:49,616
It's not a criminal matter.
469
00:41:49,616 --> 00:41:53,977
If you remove somebody back to the home country, you're not putting them in jail.
470
00:41:53,977 --> 00:41:55,657
You're sending them home.
471
00:41:56,038 --> 00:41:57,158
Very different.
472
00:41:57,158 --> 00:42:02,479
Chris Van Hollen is saying, this guy we want to bring back from El Salvador is a Maryland
man.
473
00:42:02,499 --> 00:42:04,780
Stephen Miller said, no, he's not a Maryland man.
474
00:42:04,780 --> 00:42:08,421
He's an El Salvadoran citizen.
475
00:42:08,421 --> 00:42:10,582
doesn't belong here at all.
476
00:42:10,582 --> 00:42:12,354
But I mean, that's where the Democrats came
477
00:42:12,354 --> 00:42:15,515
blurring citizenship and all these other statuses.
478
00:42:15,515 --> 00:42:24,099
Well, I mean, when you have one entire political party that opposes state and local
cooperation, sheriffs, because they're elected officials, are one of the few local
479
00:42:24,099 --> 00:42:33,983
officers who are able to really speak out in opposition to the Democrats' opposition, if
you will, to these state and local cooperation agreements with federal immigration
480
00:42:33,983 --> 00:42:42,016
authorities, which are critical to actually identifying and removing these overstayers,
people here illegally generally.
481
00:42:42,370 --> 00:42:50,382
mean, the Democrats and their allies have put up these walls between the federal
government and the state government,
isolated the enforcement authorities at the federal
482
00:42:50,382 --> 00:42:51,214
level.
483
00:42:51,214 --> 00:42:53,735
And that's why there's no interior enforcement.
484
00:42:54,335 --> 00:42:56,470
And this has to be turned around.
485
00:42:56,470 --> 00:43:02,849
I mean, we're not going to be sustained as a country if we don't find a way to
reinvigorate interior immigration law enforcement.
486
00:43:02,849 --> 00:43:05,455
And that's what Trump is desperately trying to do.
487
00:43:05,455 --> 00:43:11,262
And he's got some good folks there in Miller, Tom Homan, good friend, doing a really great
job.
488
00:43:12,209 --> 00:43:15,771
Well, and you mentioned, you know, kind of your congressman and your senator.
489
00:43:15,771 --> 00:43:26,597
And, know, it's frustrating to me when we hear people use the term, you know, long-term
legal resident instead of green card holder, you know, just crazy terminology to make them
490
00:43:26,597 --> 00:43:35,101
sound more legal and more permanent and more, you know, like a citizen when they're simply
not citizens.
491
00:43:35,101 --> 00:43:37,113
You know, they're, green card holders.
492
00:43:37,113 --> 00:43:41,959
We may be, it be allowed them here, but it goes back to what you said at the beginning of
the show, which is
493
00:43:41,959 --> 00:43:51,074
you know, hey, if you're here as a guest, act like a guest and you'll get treated like
one, you know, but if you're going to come down and, you know, try to, you know, exert
494
00:43:51,074 --> 00:43:57,168
your non-existent First Amendment right by burning down buildings, that's not acting like
a guest.
495
00:43:57,328 --> 00:44:00,130
And you should be deported if you do that if you're not a citizen.
496
00:44:00,130 --> 00:44:03,231
And quite frankly, the citizens who do that should be in jail.
497
00:44:03,352 --> 00:44:09,595
And, you know, I just wrote a newsletter on subsac that went out this morning that was
talking about
498
00:44:09,855 --> 00:44:22,546
Abrego Garcia and how, how convoluted the press has screwed up, you know, John Roberts
order and, know, and, and how they, you know, John Roberts didn't mandate that we go get
499
00:44:22,546 --> 00:44:23,517
him and bring him back.
500
00:44:23,517 --> 00:44:32,975
They're like, he kind of shrugs a little bit and says, Hey, do what you can, you know, and
keep the lower court updated, you know, type of thing.
501
00:44:32,975 --> 00:44:37,669
And so, you know, if I'm allowed to take a two page letter and turn it into eight words,
502
00:44:37,671 --> 00:44:40,793
But that's a frustrating thing.
503
00:44:41,291 --> 00:44:48,218
I think we kind of covered most of the points we had, but we wanted to have just kind of a
fun question.
504
00:44:48,218 --> 00:45:00,167
If you were talking to a group of high school students, college students, what do you
think is the number one thing that those young people misunderstand about legal or illegal
505
00:45:00,167 --> 00:45:01,197
immigration?
506
00:45:03,346 --> 00:45:09,709
Well, is ultimately about who we are, we the people.
507
00:45:09,709 --> 00:45:13,850
It's about who we are, who we become, what kind of nation we're going to be.
508
00:45:14,286 --> 00:45:16,571
A country should really do its own work.
509
00:45:17,352 --> 00:45:28,356
And in the end, if you allow the forces of greed and exploitation and power to take
control of immigration policy, they will destroy not only your futures, but our national
510
00:45:28,356 --> 00:45:29,437
destiny.
511
00:45:29,517 --> 00:45:32,524
Immigration implicates every public concern.
512
00:45:32,524 --> 00:45:35,856
you as a young person will ever be concerned about the rest of your life.
513
00:45:35,856 --> 00:45:51,936
It touches everything from entitlements, fiscal sanity, labor force equity, environmental
concerns, pollution, resource usage, resource allocation, certainly issues like traffic
514
00:45:51,936 --> 00:45:57,469
congestion, housing availability, cultural cohesion, quality of education.
515
00:45:57,469 --> 00:45:59,220
It goes on and on and on.
516
00:45:59,510 --> 00:46:04,477
immigration policy touches on everything you will be concerned about for the rest of your
life.
517
00:46:04,578 --> 00:46:15,414
And therefore you better go about the business of understanding who comes in, how many,
and most importantly, how a nation like ours should enforce the rules.
518
00:46:16,079 --> 00:46:27,167
And it looked like you were going to say something to Jennifer, but if you had a magic
wand and you could make a law or let's keep it to two laws, you know, what do you think,
519
00:46:27,167 --> 00:46:31,653
what would be the magic wand you would wave and say, this fixes it?
520
00:46:33,378 --> 00:46:36,820
If you don't play by the rules, you don't play the game.
521
00:46:38,899 --> 00:46:40,381
But you made that simple.
522
00:46:40,381 --> 00:46:41,132
I like it.
523
00:46:41,132 --> 00:46:42,003
So.
524
00:46:44,101 --> 00:46:45,001
That's right though.
525
00:46:45,001 --> 00:46:47,223
I mean, it's that simple.
526
00:46:48,104 --> 00:46:49,084
You know?
527
00:46:49,900 --> 00:46:51,727
I mean, I think it's that simple.
528
00:46:51,727 --> 00:46:54,079
just, this is just amazing to me.
529
00:46:54,079 --> 00:46:56,837
Just all of this is crazy.
530
00:46:56,837 --> 00:46:59,469
And we both have learned so much through this entire series.
531
00:46:59,469 --> 00:47:06,912
And you would be surprised, Dan, how much the four of you did not talk about the same
topics.
532
00:47:06,973 --> 00:47:09,234
You know, it's complete.
533
00:47:09,234 --> 00:47:11,307
These were, you know, because we kind of worried about it.
534
00:47:11,307 --> 00:47:15,437
It's like, these could kind of run into being the very same show.
535
00:47:15,437 --> 00:47:19,459
And every show was so unique.
536
00:47:19,679 --> 00:47:26,563
And you all brought every single one
of you brought such a breadth of knowledge to.
537
00:47:26,611 --> 00:47:32,511
to our viewers and our listeners that just incredible knowledge.
538
00:47:32,511 --> 00:47:43,411
know that, you I like to think that I'm up to date on most things, you know, maybe an inch
deep and a mile wide, but I've learned an incredible amount.
539
00:47:43,411 --> 00:47:46,031
You shared, you know, you're sharing your knowledge today.
540
00:47:46,031 --> 00:47:50,011
Do you want to ask the final closing bonus closer question, Jennifer?
541
00:47:51,021 --> 00:47:53,714
So let's say that nothing changes, right?
542
00:47:53,714 --> 00:47:55,947
It stays the way that it is.
543
00:47:55,968 --> 00:48:00,994
And what is the real risk to America if we keep doing what we're doing now?
544
00:48:02,178 --> 00:48:12,106
That's an excellent question, Jennifer, because what we saw under Joe Biden exposes
something that we have been concerned about from the very beginning of fair and we're the
545
00:48:12,106 --> 00:48:13,447
granddaddy organization.
546
00:48:13,447 --> 00:48:16,099
And I am of course, the best of the guests.
547
00:48:16,099 --> 00:48:21,813
And I know that's probably axiomatic, but the truth is, I'm just kidding.
548
00:48:21,813 --> 00:48:22,833
The truth is.
549
00:48:22,833 --> 00:48:25,900
No, it's absolutely true, but we've said that to all of them.
550
00:48:25,900 --> 00:48:27,110
Yeah, thank you.
551
00:48:27,851 --> 00:48:29,111
I'll take it.
552
00:48:29,111 --> 00:48:42,136
The truth is, there's always been this concern that an unprincipled executive president
would take advantage of the asymmetry in how the courts are willing to hear complaints on
553
00:48:42,136 --> 00:48:48,699
immigration by allowing in millions and millions of aliens without any legal authority.
554
00:48:49,160 --> 00:48:55,292
In other words, if the ACLU thinks that somebody's been wrongly excluded like this clown
from El Salvador.
555
00:48:55,810 --> 00:48:58,112
They can litigate it to the Supreme court.
556
00:48:58,392 --> 00:49:05,799
But if Joe Biden lets in two, three million people here who have no right to be here,
courts go, you don't have any standing.
557
00:49:05,799 --> 00:49:08,020
You can't show direct injury.
558
00:49:08,041 --> 00:49:11,543
And so the courts are basically almost silent about it.
559
00:49:11,704 --> 00:49:22,774
Well, we always knew that unless Congress steps up and closes these loopholes, which
they've tried to do in so-called HR two from last Congress and creates a standing
560
00:49:22,774 --> 00:49:23,764
provision.
561
00:49:23,874 --> 00:49:35,271
which they did do in the Lake and Riley bill, to allow Americans and states affected by
improvidently admitted, illegally admitted aliens by an unprincipled president, they can
562
00:49:35,271 --> 00:49:37,061
go to court to stop it.
563
00:49:37,642 --> 00:49:38,853
And that has to happen.
564
00:49:38,853 --> 00:49:49,829
Congress has to do this because otherwise, as you saw under Trump 1.0, the minute Biden
comes in, he's reversing all these executive orders and all these good policies.
565
00:49:49,849 --> 00:49:51,840
So then all of a sudden,
566
00:49:52,416 --> 00:49:54,647
AOC gets elected president.
567
00:49:55,548 --> 00:49:57,889
I know we're all going to Canada.
568
00:49:58,550 --> 00:50:02,193
And she just does everything and starts this nonsense again.
569
00:50:02,193 --> 00:50:05,755
So this is, this is the great danger this country faces.
570
00:50:05,935 --> 00:50:12,919
An unprincipled president for partisan purposes, power politics, vote packing, whatever
you want to call it.
571
00:50:13,440 --> 00:50:20,045
Let's the borders get out of control on purpose purely for vanity, partisan gain, whatever
reason.
572
00:50:20,045 --> 00:50:22,496
And nobody can stop it.
573
00:50:22,690 --> 00:50:24,810
This is the great danger.
574
00:50:24,810 --> 00:50:27,434
We will cease to be a functioning nation.
575
00:50:27,434 --> 00:50:39,103
Everything we care about that we like about this country or used to like will be gone
because no nation can sustain massive uncontrolled immigration on an unending basis
576
00:50:39,103 --> 00:50:40,170
because you know what?
577
00:50:40,170 --> 00:50:42,886
There's more of them than there are of us.
578
00:50:42,886 --> 00:50:43,996
Very simple.
579
00:50:44,960 --> 00:50:52,206
So this just brings, because I'm a big conspiracy theory person and let's go to the auto
pen.
580
00:50:52,206 --> 00:50:53,367
if we get.
581
00:50:54,468 --> 00:50:55,468
I know.
582
00:50:58,972 --> 00:51:05,717
So we find out that the person, that the immigration, everything was signed by the auto
pen.
583
00:51:05,717 --> 00:51:10,180
And then we maybe find out who was in charge of the auto pen one day.
584
00:51:10,180 --> 00:51:13,263
I mean, is that even possible?
585
00:51:14,670 --> 00:51:17,050
Well, the auto pen was wielded by Barack Obama.
586
00:51:17,050 --> 00:51:18,190
Everybody knows that.
587
00:51:18,190 --> 00:51:29,030
I contrary to the American tradition, Obama didn't leave Washington afterward and go back
to, you know, chop wood and cut bush or whatever.
588
00:51:29,030 --> 00:51:30,710
What did Reagan do on his ranch?
589
00:51:30,710 --> 00:51:31,890
Clear brush.
590
00:51:32,610 --> 00:51:35,630
Or like Harry Truman, go back and be a country lawyer.
591
00:51:35,630 --> 00:51:36,228
mean, he did.
592
00:51:36,228 --> 00:51:37,241
became a painter.
593
00:51:37,241 --> 00:51:39,735
Yeah.
594
00:51:39,735 --> 00:51:41,756
with Michelle Obama, apparently.
595
00:51:42,217 --> 00:51:44,399
Let's hope Hunter Biden becomes a good painter too.
596
00:51:44,399 --> 00:51:48,528
But no, Obama stayed here and he said what he wanted.
597
00:51:48,528 --> 00:51:49,633
mean, everybody knows this.
598
00:51:49,633 --> 00:51:51,705
I mean, he had his buddies in this all this.
599
00:51:51,705 --> 00:51:53,446
He
directed who the staff were.
600
00:51:53,446 --> 00:51:57,910
I mean, the beautiful thing about the whole thing was that Obama had this whole thing
orchestrated.
601
00:51:57,910 --> 00:51:59,531
He directed the White House staff.
602
00:51:59,531 --> 00:52:01,172
He met with them all the time.
603
00:52:01,172 --> 00:52:03,174
Everybody knows what was going on here.
604
00:52:03,174 --> 00:52:08,398
Had a nice big mansion in Kalorama, know, a nice place in Hawaii and his place in the
vineyard.
605
00:52:08,398 --> 00:52:09,598
That was great stuff.
606
00:52:09,598 --> 00:52:10,918
He had a good time.
607
00:52:10,918 --> 00:52:15,158
The only thing that went wrong was that Biden broke the deal.
608
00:52:15,658 --> 00:52:22,738
Biden was supposed to be a one-term president and he turned around and went, you know,
hey, Jill and I, man, we're digging this, you know, and basically our whole family's
609
00:52:22,738 --> 00:52:26,238
corrupt and we want to make sure they don't get prosecuted, Joe needs another term.
610
00:52:26,338 --> 00:52:28,858
And Biden and Barack's like, hey man, that wasn't the deal.
611
00:52:28,858 --> 00:52:31,318
It's like, hey, you what are you going to do about it?
612
00:52:31,698 --> 00:52:34,018
Anyway, that blew up in his face.
613
00:52:34,370 --> 00:52:35,674
That was the beauty of the whole thing.
614
00:52:35,674 --> 00:52:41,813
But yeah, was clearly Obama and his apparatchiks, Susan Rice and all those crazies that
were in the White House.
615
00:52:42,173 --> 00:52:46,211
So no conspiracy at all, Jennifer, just Barack Obama.
616
00:52:47,669 --> 00:52:52,037
That's a conspiracy in itself, so I'm going to stick with that.
617
00:52:52,182 --> 00:52:57,777
Well, you're new to politics, Jennifer, but sooner or later you're going to learn you're
getting lied to every minute.
618
00:52:57,777 --> 00:53:04,952
So the fact that the legacy media is desperately trying to hang on using whatever
techniques they are.
619
00:53:04,952 --> 00:53:09,186
mean, it's kind of interesting to behold.
620
00:53:09,186 --> 00:53:17,292
I I was actually trained years ago by a Pulitzer Prize winner with Newsday, which was
really a great newspaper in Long Island for many, many years.
621
00:53:17,716 --> 00:53:25,201
And I remember when we used to be able to go on TV and have policy debates on different
sides and people could make up their minds.
622
00:53:25,201 --> 00:53:29,995
And the big thing that's collapsed in our society is debate.
623
00:53:30,295 --> 00:53:31,997
mean, the left doesn't want to debate.
624
00:53:31,997 --> 00:53:32,917
There's no debate.
625
00:53:32,917 --> 00:53:45,576
So I don't know why people would want to cable news, so-called news, because I find
one-sided panels where everyone's agreeing with each other is boring.
626
00:53:46,130 --> 00:53:48,371
and doesn't illuminate anything.
627
00:53:48,472 --> 00:53:55,997
They pitch these softball questions to their buddies and of
course they're working off
talking points from either the White House or the Democrat, whatever.
628
00:53:56,097 --> 00:53:58,359
And it's like, this is not interesting at all.
629
00:53:58,359 --> 00:54:01,701
You want to hear a debate, a real debate by policy experts.
630
00:54:01,701 --> 00:54:11,918
The four or five people you had on immigration, every one of those folks, I know all of
them, I'm sure, could have been, probably hired some of them and probably fired some of
631
00:54:11,918 --> 00:54:14,402
them, could have been, you know.
632
00:54:14,402 --> 00:54:18,386
fabulous on a national debate stage, but you can ask every one of them.
633
00:54:18,386 --> 00:54:25,073
How many times have you been involved in a strong, good forensic debate on immigration in
the last 10 years?
634
00:54:25,073 --> 00:54:27,805
I think Mark Krikorian's been on a few, but very few.
635
00:54:27,805 --> 00:54:31,689
mean, in the old days, it was like every week back in the 80s and 90s.
636
00:54:31,689 --> 00:54:33,041
The debate has disappeared.
637
00:54:33,041 --> 00:54:35,142
Terrible loss for the American people.
638
00:54:35,592 --> 00:54:42,714
doesn't even seem like people can have conversations today about politics and exactly.
639
00:54:42,714 --> 00:54:44,265
Yeah.
640
00:54:44,265 --> 00:54:45,269
reflexes.
641
00:54:45,269 --> 00:54:47,412
We need honest, reasonable arguments.
642
00:54:47,412 --> 00:54:48,554
How about that?
643
00:54:48,554 --> 00:54:49,515
Honest.
644
00:54:49,515 --> 00:54:52,276
And I appreciate the public service you all are doing.
645
00:54:52,276 --> 00:54:53,357
Thank you.
646
00:54:53,357 --> 00:54:53,807
Thank you.
647
00:54:53,807 --> 00:55:00,598
Is there anything that we did not cover that you would like to say before we sign off?
648
00:55:00,598 --> 00:55:01,993
No, out of respect for your time.
649
00:55:01,993 --> 00:55:03,499
I can talk about this for three days.
650
00:55:03,499 --> 00:55:06,220
There's almost nothing about the topic.
651
00:55:06,220 --> 00:55:07,221
I don't know.
652
00:55:07,368 --> 00:55:09,281
if there's something that, yeah.
653
00:55:09,281 --> 00:55:16,449
if you went for three days, you would beat Cory Booker's new Filibuster record, right?
654
00:55:16,892 --> 00:55:23,487
Yeah, I wonder if he had a tent like Edward Everett did at the Gettysburg Address, you
know, and I admire his bladder.
655
00:55:23,559 --> 00:55:31,263
Yeah, I always say that, you know, ending a filibuster on April 1st may not have been your
best timing.
656
00:55:32,144 --> 00:55:34,365
Like, who cared?
657
00:55:34,365 --> 00:55:35,585
Who cared?
658
00:55:35,846 --> 00:55:37,927
Jennifer, do you have any other questions?
659
00:55:39,148 --> 00:55:41,129
Dan, thank you so much for your time.
660
00:55:41,129 --> 00:55:43,650
We really appreciate your time and knowledge.
661
00:55:43,690 --> 00:55:45,081
It's been incredible.
662
00:55:45,081 --> 00:55:46,021
Thank you.
663
00:55:46,104 --> 00:55:47,580
My pleasure, anytime.
664
00:55:47,580 --> 00:55:48,328
Good luck.
665
00:55:48,328 --> 00:55:50,671
hold still for one second and we'll be right back.
666
00:55:55,597 --> 00:55:56,519
Yeah.