رونوشت 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:00.320 --> 00:00:03.770
The spirit of the zeitgeist that I saw was on
2
00:00:03.830 --> 00:00:06.009
Reddit and it was a post using.
3
00:00:07.549 --> 00:00:08.410
It's so perfect.
4
00:00:09.369 --> 00:00:12.980
Using Sam's speech from Lord of the Rings when he goes,
5
00:00:13.560 --> 00:00:15.080
and it was so dark, Mr.
6
00:00:15.140 --> 00:00:15.480
Frodo.
7
00:00:16.109 --> 00:00:18.850
And there was so much, there was so much bad.
8
00:00:19.269 --> 00:00:22.030
There was so much bad that happened. We never thought
9
00:00:22.129 --> 00:00:24.510
anything that would good would happen again. And it's like
10
00:00:24.609 --> 00:00:30.570
over scenes of January 6th. And then it shows Abdul
11
00:00:30.629 --> 00:00:33.929
El-Sayed and it's like, and there's.
12
00:00:33.259 --> 00:00:34.939
Some good in this world, Mr.
13
00:00:35.020 --> 00:00:35.479
Frodo.
14
00:00:35.640 --> 00:00:37.119
And it's worth fighting for.
15
00:00:37.140 --> 00:00:41.079
Oh, you know it by heart. You're a true millennial.
16
00:00:41.119 --> 00:00:43.000
You know the Sam speech by heart.
17
00:00:44.990 --> 00:00:50.149
It's the answer that led those who've been told for
18
00:00:50.210 --> 00:00:54.479
so long by so many to be cynical and fearful
19
00:00:55.219 --> 00:00:58.859
and doubtful about what we could achieve to put their
20
00:00:58.899 --> 00:01:02.359
hands on the arc of history and bend it once
21
00:01:02.460 --> 00:01:06.700
more toward the hope of a better day. It's been
22
00:01:06.719 --> 00:01:11.390
a long time coming, but tonight, because of what we
23
00:01:11.430 --> 00:01:16.269
did on this day, in this election, At this defining moment,
24
00:01:17.189 --> 00:01:18.689
change has come to America.
25
00:01:21.390 --> 00:01:24.769
We don't need to be great again. We need to
26
00:01:24.829 --> 00:01:27.969
embrace that thing about us that has always made us great.
27
00:01:29.469 --> 00:01:31.780
The will to be more perfect.
28
00:01:31.939 --> 00:01:43.620
I guess this marks an important moment in the history
29
00:01:44.239 --> 00:01:50.280
of geopolitics, which is the end of Trumpism.
30
00:01:51.140 --> 00:01:52.739
The end of MAGA, maybe, perhaps.
31
00:01:53.379 --> 00:01:57.340
The end of the MAGA movement until it's reconstituted as
32
00:01:57.900 --> 00:02:02.549
something different in two years. But for now... I.
33
00:02:02.530 --> 00:02:04.849
Heard people calling this the Blue Cockay.
34
00:02:05.969 --> 00:02:07.010
The Blue Cockay?
35
00:02:07.790 --> 00:02:09.909
Yeah.
36
00:02:10.210 --> 00:02:11.789
Is that like a derivative of caucus?
37
00:02:12.759 --> 00:02:15.349
No, no, it's a joke on bukkake.
38
00:02:16.610 --> 00:02:19.930
Oh, I see the blue kake.
39
00:02:20.210 --> 00:02:20.729
Oh, shit.
40
00:02:21.330 --> 00:02:23.590
I missed that. Wow.
41
00:02:24.509 --> 00:02:26.599
I guess my mind is just not in the gutter
42
00:02:26.620 --> 00:02:28.159
right now. I'm going to get it there.
43
00:02:28.780 --> 00:02:35.159
A virgin having never taken place in a bukkake scenario.
44
00:02:35.300 --> 00:02:37.310
I don't know anyone who hasn't done bukkake.
45
00:02:38.599 --> 00:02:38.919
Wow.
46
00:02:39.099 --> 00:02:40.900
I almost want you to cut that out. I should
47
00:02:40.939 --> 00:02:44.300
have recognized that right away. I had my mind on
48
00:02:44.360 --> 00:02:46.000
caucus for some reason.
49
00:02:47.099 --> 00:02:50.389
There's a, there's a Blue Nami. Yeah.
50
00:02:50.969 --> 00:02:54.870
Today we're talking about the, the paradox of representation in
51
00:02:55.889 --> 00:02:59.430
that in order to represent, there has to be a
52
00:02:59.490 --> 00:03:04.310
death on behalf of both the representative and the represent
53
00:03:04.590 --> 00:03:07.930
T and why the, Yeah, I don't want to be
54
00:03:07.939 --> 00:03:11.650
the one dumping cold water because everyone's really excited about this.
55
00:03:12.169 --> 00:03:17.550
Does anyone else want to do the cold water intro here?
56
00:03:17.569 --> 00:03:19.569
The cold water dump.
57
00:03:19.590 --> 00:03:23.289
I mean, it's the honeymoon phase like anything else, right?
58
00:03:23.930 --> 00:03:25.550
It's not going to last.
59
00:03:25.569 --> 00:03:31.229
Well, I mean, I'll say that it's better than the alternative,
60
00:03:31.530 --> 00:03:33.229
but it doesn't really matter.
61
00:03:34.840 --> 00:03:40.710
To its credit, it is definitely, I think, a much-needed
62
00:03:41.310 --> 00:03:47.370
psychic release of energy from one and a half terms
63
00:03:47.430 --> 00:03:55.629
of Trump divided up by the Crypt Keeper, Biden. But basically, yeah,
64
00:03:55.810 --> 00:04:00.759
six years it's been. So catharsis, fine.
65
00:04:01.580 --> 00:04:01.860
Yeah.
66
00:04:01.939 --> 00:04:03.060
Maybe it was needed.
67
00:04:03.080 --> 00:04:03.180
Yeah.
68
00:04:04.979 --> 00:04:08.949
It's kind of a classic case of just, like, I
69
00:04:08.939 --> 00:04:12.090
don't know, I always find that when these things, that
70
00:04:12.650 --> 00:04:20.990
political pundits, they're so short-sighted, you know? Like, when Trumpism
71
00:04:21.029 --> 00:04:25.430
was winning, it's like, you know, lefties are like, oh,
72
00:04:25.449 --> 00:04:27.949
we're going to fascism, it's going to be like this forever, like,
73
00:04:28.009 --> 00:04:33.100
you know? And then, of course, the, like, self-congratulating mega
74
00:04:33.139 --> 00:04:34.899
people were like, we keep winning. We're going to be
75
00:04:34.939 --> 00:04:37.300
winning forever. And they got, but it's like, you just,
76
00:04:37.519 --> 00:04:40.779
all you need to do is think about 10 years ago. Right.
77
00:04:40.899 --> 00:04:44.439
And it's like completely shifted in the other direction. And again,
78
00:04:44.500 --> 00:04:46.350
it's just the same thing that always happens. It just
79
00:04:46.370 --> 00:04:48.829
goes back and forth. But, and, and right now it's
80
00:04:48.870 --> 00:04:52.170
Load full transcript
just funny seeing, uh, right wingers being like, our country's
81
00:04:52.230 --> 00:04:55.230
about to become socialism. We're about to like, our country's
82
00:04:55.290 --> 00:04:56.050
dead forever.
83
00:04:56.649 --> 00:04:56.810
Right.
84
00:04:56.850 --> 00:04:58.649
And like the same thing was happening on the left
85
00:04:58.670 --> 00:05:00.269
where they're like, our country's dead. We're about to be
86
00:05:00.310 --> 00:05:02.930
a fascist country. forever. And it's like, no, these things
87
00:05:02.990 --> 00:05:07.129
just shift back and forth when you have an electoral democracy,
88
00:05:07.170 --> 00:05:09.569
because ultimately nothing is going to change that much. That's
89
00:05:09.629 --> 00:05:13.449
sort of the upshot, right? Nothing is really going to
90
00:05:13.490 --> 00:05:15.850
change that much. And it's like, look at this right now.
91
00:05:15.870 --> 00:05:20.810
We have Texas, which is, for the Democrat, it's 1
92
00:05:20.810 --> 00:05:23.250
by 12 points, 13 points. It's the first time we've
93
00:05:23.300 --> 00:05:27.300
ever seen anything like that happen. I mean, so it's,
94
00:05:27.379 --> 00:05:29.259
I think, what it's showing you is.
95
00:05:30.839 --> 00:05:35.120
The kind of energy of the public the fatigue with
96
00:05:35.220 --> 00:05:37.819
what has been happening and you know whatever we don't
97
00:05:37.839 --> 00:05:39.959
have to go into details of what pundits have been
98
00:05:40.000 --> 00:05:41.430
talking about but i would assume a lot of it
99
00:05:41.470 --> 00:05:43.709
has to do with the iran war and whatever these
100
00:05:43.750 --> 00:05:46.170
other things that people are just tired and they just
101
00:05:46.230 --> 00:05:48.550
want to kick the bums out right it's not because
102
00:05:49.149 --> 00:05:52.250
people have all of a sudden found some new commitment
103
00:05:53.029 --> 00:05:55.930
to what the democrats have to offer or have all
104
00:05:55.949 --> 00:05:58.670
of a sudden found you know, that, oh, actually, like,
105
00:05:58.709 --> 00:06:02.040
we care more about left-wing or more left-leaning values. It's just,
106
00:06:02.100 --> 00:06:04.120
they just want to kick the bums out. They just
107
00:06:04.180 --> 00:06:07.439
want to kick Texans or probably, like, these people fucking suck.
108
00:06:08.019 --> 00:06:10.060
You know, and in Texas, you can look at it
109
00:06:10.220 --> 00:06:12.360
at a more granular level. It kind of makes sense.
110
00:06:12.420 --> 00:06:17.189
I would, like, there's been a huge shift back among
111
00:06:17.230 --> 00:06:20.970
Latino voters, right, where, like, last time they kind of
112
00:06:21.050 --> 00:06:23.649
shockingly went for Trump just to see what would happen,
113
00:06:23.689 --> 00:06:27.110
and now they're, All these border counties in Texas have
114
00:06:27.120 --> 00:06:31.189
gone hard back against Trump. But it's not just a
115
00:06:31.250 --> 00:06:34.550
story of Latino voters. I mean,
you know, it's interesting.
116
00:06:34.569 --> 00:06:38.240
I was looking at every demographic group. The Democrats won
117
00:06:38.339 --> 00:06:41.959
every single demographic group except white men. The amazing thing
118
00:06:42.000 --> 00:06:44.759
is that they almost won white men. Like they almost
119
00:06:44.800 --> 00:06:47.550
like they were close. It was like 48 to 52.
120
00:06:47.550 --> 00:06:49.029
which is very tough.
121
00:06:49.089 --> 00:06:51.269
Like suburban and rural whites?
122
00:06:51.430 --> 00:06:55.310
Even 48% of white men went for Democrats. That's just
123
00:06:55.509 --> 00:06:59.050
people being tired of Omega and stuff.
124
00:06:59.209 --> 00:07:03.980
Well, maybe they voted outside of their interest because things
125
00:07:04.040 --> 00:07:08.680
like gas prices and war fatigue and all these other
126
00:07:08.699 --> 00:07:14.160
things were so high that it just pushed the pendulum
127
00:07:14.319 --> 00:07:16.980
so hard in the other direction that I mean, you
128
00:07:17.019 --> 00:07:19.180
just gave us, you didn't just dump cold water there.
129
00:07:19.230 --> 00:07:22.129
That was a whole cold shower, but fine. There are
130
00:07:22.230 --> 00:07:25.490
some historical things here. Like I did hear this was
131
00:07:25.550 --> 00:07:27.110
the biggest win.
132
00:07:27.230 --> 00:07:28.629
It's good. It's better.
133
00:07:28.649 --> 00:07:32.259
Since like the Watergate backlash.
134
00:07:32.279 --> 00:07:32.540
Yes.
135
00:07:33.180 --> 00:07:35.480
Like there are some historical.
136
00:07:35.500 --> 00:07:37.240
Based on what metric?
137
00:07:38.420 --> 00:07:41.870
I mean, like how much the Democrats won.
138
00:07:42.310 --> 00:07:45.310
The margin of popular vote. Similar to Watergate.
139
00:07:45.329 --> 00:07:50.110
Not the House seats. The seats swing was like only
140
00:07:50.170 --> 00:07:54.089
the most since Obama. The flip.
141
00:07:54.170 --> 00:07:57.540
Was it? The Senate, the House, and the governorships. I
142
00:07:57.560 --> 00:07:58.720
didn't look at the numbers.
143
00:07:58.800 --> 00:08:01.959
The House is going to end up being a pretty
144
00:08:01.980 --> 00:08:03.660
big swing. I think the Democrats are going to have
145
00:08:03.699 --> 00:08:05.079
up to 260 seats when all is said and done,
146
00:08:05.100 --> 00:08:07.939
which is huge. And only 35 Senate seats are up.
147
00:08:11.970 --> 00:08:15.009
At any given time anyway, so that you can't win
148
00:08:15.069 --> 00:08:15.430
them all.
149
00:08:15.449 --> 00:08:17.649
I think they're going to win the popular vote by
150
00:08:17.740 --> 00:08:19.740
more than 10 points. So I think it's, I think.
151
00:08:20.389 --> 00:08:23.680
And then like, basically then, then I heard the governorships,
152
00:08:24.240 --> 00:08:27.500
which governors are basically just like mini presidents of the
153
00:08:27.540 --> 00:08:32.580
state are like, there's so many blue ones in, in
154
00:08:32.639 --> 00:08:37.519
places where there were almost never blue governors, they went blue.
155
00:08:37.840 --> 00:08:43.019
Like when, When economic circumstances are getting worse and cost
156
00:08:43.039 --> 00:08:48.269
of living is skyrocketing, that old divisive sort of identity politics,
157
00:08:48.350 --> 00:08:51.870
hatred message doesn't play. When people are doing all right
158
00:08:52.129 --> 00:08:55.850
and gas prices are relatively low and stable and food
159
00:08:55.909 --> 00:08:59.070
prices are fine, then yeah, you can play the fucking
160
00:08:59.309 --> 00:09:03.740
anti-trans people in sports game and then that's going to
161
00:09:03.759 --> 00:09:07.179
win you votes. But in this situation, it's not going to.
162
00:09:07.840 --> 00:09:12.039
And I'm annoyed that it works in any situation, but
163
00:09:12.080 --> 00:09:14.299
it definitely doesn't work in this one.
164
00:09:14.820 --> 00:09:16.360
No, I will say, to pour a little bit more
165
00:09:16.440 --> 00:09:23.230
cold water, too, for those more inclined to more socialist candidates,
166
00:09:23.309 --> 00:09:27.190
which includes myself. I prefer DSA candidates. It's kind of
167
00:09:27.230 --> 00:09:30.389
interesting that I would say that the Michigan guy who
168
00:09:30.450 --> 00:09:35.539
is a DSA member, he won very easily. But I
169
00:09:35.559 --> 00:09:40.129
would say he kind of underperformed. given the polls and
170
00:09:40.230 --> 00:09:42.720
the more like, and then in the red States, the
171
00:09:42.759 --> 00:09:47.600
Democrats who won were like pretty centristy Democrats and they
172
00:09:47.720 --> 00:09:52.100
overperformed like, like in Texas and Kansas and Iowa and in,
173
00:09:52.220 --> 00:09:55.090
and in Michigan where, you know, they're more comfortable, I
174
00:09:55.110 --> 00:09:59.350
think putting forward a more left-wing democratic social candidate, you know,
175
00:09:59.409 --> 00:10:01.960
he did worse. than the governor who also won.
176
00:10:02.360 --> 00:10:02.580
Right.
177
00:10:02.659 --> 00:10:05.320
Like, so, and he's also got that, that, that Arab
178
00:10:05.360 --> 00:10:07.519
last name too, which I think, again, that's just good
179
00:10:07.559 --> 00:10:10.340
old fashioned racism may be playing in where people are like,
180
00:10:10.399 --> 00:10:12.039
I'm not going to vote for an El Saeed. Uh,
181
00:10:13.340 --> 00:10:15.179
I really like him by the way. I'm, uh, I mean,
182
00:10:15.220 --> 00:10:17.730
in terms, as far as someone can like, uh, An
183
00:10:17.750 --> 00:10:18.490
elected politician.
184
00:10:18.549 --> 00:10:19.129
If you look at.
185
00:10:19.289 --> 00:10:23.190
I compared his policies. Basically, if you're in Canada, he'd
186
00:10:23.230 --> 00:10:26.289
be a moderate, maybe a little bit left of the
187
00:10:26.350 --> 00:10:27.029
Liberal Party.
188
00:10:27.850 --> 00:10:30.990
He'd be like an NDP. He'd be like an NDP. No, no.
189
00:10:31.429 --> 00:10:31.950
You don't
think so?
190
00:10:32.669 --> 00:10:35.580
I don't think so. The only thing that even puts him.
191
00:10:35.620 --> 00:10:36.840
That's how bad things are.
192
00:10:37.240 --> 00:10:40.440
The only thing that even puts him to the left
193
00:10:40.500 --> 00:10:44.039
of the Liberal Party is that he's proposing a capital
194
00:10:44.059 --> 00:10:45.940
gains tax over a million dollars.
195
00:10:46.549 --> 00:10:49.590
That's how bad things are right now, that that looks
196
00:10:49.690 --> 00:10:52.830
left and radical when it really just looks like that
197
00:10:52.889 --> 00:10:54.649
against a background of austerity.
198
00:10:55.269 --> 00:10:58.419
This took me so long to find because Google is
199
00:10:58.480 --> 00:11:01.399
completely unusable when it comes to this.
200
00:11:01.419 --> 00:11:02.580
Oh, the AI search?
201
00:11:03.659 --> 00:11:06.960
Well, even it's all like NBC and I can't find
202
00:11:07.059 --> 00:11:09.259
any historical data, but this is what I was looking for.
203
00:11:09.279 --> 00:11:14.649
The house was, I think, 32 flips so far, right?
204
00:11:15.590 --> 00:11:17.110
Yeah, but it's going to be quite a bit more.
205
00:11:17.129 --> 00:11:22.669
Okay, so that puts it fourth in the last 20
206
00:11:22.669 --> 00:11:26.519
years in terms of flips. It's not a huge flip.
207
00:11:26.580 --> 00:11:31.220
That was my point. The largest flip was the 2010 midterm,
208
00:11:31.960 --> 00:11:35.200
which was Obama. There were 69 flips.
209
00:11:36.200 --> 00:11:38.399
Okay, I mean, I think this might end up being...
210
00:11:38.080 --> 00:11:41.870
Because right now there's, I don't know how many, but
211
00:11:41.889 --> 00:11:46.350
for example, NBC is projecting... NBC is projecting that the
212
00:11:46.379 --> 00:11:49.710
Democrats will probably end up winning 259. And I think
213
00:11:49.750 --> 00:11:54.309
before they had 206 or something. So that'll be like 60.
214
00:11:54.309 --> 00:11:56.649
That'll be like 60 seats flipped.
215
00:11:56.929 --> 00:12:00.360
I think there's no doubt that with control of the House,
216
00:12:00.559 --> 00:12:04.600
control of the Senate, and control of all the governorships
217
00:12:05.240 --> 00:12:13.470
shifting blue, is basically going to paralyze the Trump's agendas towards...
218
00:12:13.950 --> 00:12:17.919
Canada can expect movement on the trade war. I'm sure
219
00:12:17.960 --> 00:12:22.240
the Ukraine policy will change. I don't know about the
220
00:12:22.379 --> 00:12:27.889
Israel-Palestine conflict, how American policy is going to shift towards
221
00:12:27.929 --> 00:12:33.769
that or towards supporting the war against Iran. But it's
222
00:12:33.830 --> 00:12:38.600
at least going to paralyze certain things in those directions.
223
00:12:38.620 --> 00:12:38.740
Yeah.
224
00:12:39.279 --> 00:12:42.519
Rather than maybe doing anything concrete because the president does
225
00:12:42.559 --> 00:12:44.899
have veto power after all. It'll just be a war
226
00:12:44.950 --> 00:12:46.450
of legislation and vetoes.
227
00:12:47.210 --> 00:12:48.470
Yeah, I was going to say he's just going to
228
00:12:48.490 --> 00:12:50.610
veto everything, so it doesn't actually really make much of
229
00:12:50.629 --> 00:12:51.009
a difference.
230
00:12:51.809 --> 00:12:54.330
Which is going to look bad, but then is.
231
00:12:54.570 --> 00:12:55.049
He doesn't care.
232
00:12:55.090 --> 00:12:59.649
Will this momentum carry for two more years now to have...
233
00:13:00.470 --> 00:13:03.950
Will the blue wave continue on in two years to
234
00:13:03.990 --> 00:13:05.870
an actual presidential election?
235
00:13:06.309 --> 00:13:06.809
Who knows?
236
00:13:06.830 --> 00:13:10.559
Because you're going to have Vance... sort of reconstituting the
237
00:13:10.600 --> 00:13:14.879
Republican Party around him in two years. And that's an
238
00:13:14.940 --> 00:13:20.059
interesting point that, as a hard pivot, that Bourdieu makes
239
00:13:22.580 --> 00:13:29.490
about political organizations in general, is that they reconstitute themselves
240
00:13:29.750 --> 00:13:35.870
from within. If you want to criticize the established political party,
241
00:13:36.730 --> 00:13:39.970
you have to form a movement within it. which always happens, right?
242
00:13:39.990 --> 00:13:43.090
You get like the Tea Party movement, you get these
243
00:13:43.169 --> 00:13:46.549
breakaway groups. And like the MAGA movement started off as
244
00:13:46.610 --> 00:13:49.610
this too, right? Like it was a little breakaway fringe movement.
245
00:13:50.090 --> 00:13:53.269
It gained momentum and then it completely took over and
246
00:13:53.320 --> 00:13:58.259
redefined how the party worked. And the Democrats tried to
247
00:13:58.299 --> 00:14:00.559
do that too. You had like the squad, you have
248
00:14:00.580 --> 00:14:03.019
like the DSA, but like, I don't know, things are more,
249
00:14:04.259 --> 00:14:06.860
don't move in that direction for some reason and for
250
00:14:06.879 --> 00:14:13.629
the Democrats. But what Bordia says about how changes occur
251
00:14:13.710 --> 00:14:18.669
within party bureaucracies is what we're going to see now
252
00:14:18.769 --> 00:14:22.889
over the next two years. As everyone, already Trump's name
253
00:14:23.429 --> 00:14:26.889
was dropped off the ballot and he wasn't being mentioned.
254
00:14:26.970 --> 00:14:31.070
The people who mentioned Trump the most were the Democrats
255
00:14:31.149 --> 00:14:34.960
trying to remind everybody of him. Whereas the Republicans dropped
256
00:14:35.000 --> 00:14:38.340
his name out of almost every political ad they ran
257
00:14:38.379 --> 00:14:41.019
in all their speeches. They didn't name him because they're
258
00:14:41.039 --> 00:14:44.279
distancing himself there and they're going to reconstitute a new
259
00:14:44.340 --> 00:14:47.639
movement from within the Republican party. And it's going to completely,
260
00:14:47.659 -->
00:14:52.779
whether or not it's going to completely erase this defeat
261
00:14:53.759 --> 00:14:57.279
and halt the blue sort of swinging of the pendulum
262
00:14:57.360 --> 00:15:00.559
or like, you know, that'll be, that's to be seen,
263
00:15:00.899 --> 00:15:03.710
but that's, likely what's going to happen. They're not going
264
00:15:03.730 --> 00:15:05.789
to rehabilitate MAGA, I'm sure.
265
00:15:06.070 --> 00:15:08.809
No, I think, I think JD Vance's chances of being
266
00:15:08.830 --> 00:15:12.149
the nominee have are pretty close to zero now.
267
00:15:12.850 --> 00:15:16.230
I was trying to find a way to pivot into, uh, the,
268
00:15:17.509 --> 00:15:20.200
from this conversation. Cause he kind of, you kind of
269
00:15:20.240 --> 00:15:24.820
have to like reverse engineer politics, like more broadly to
270
00:15:24.840 --> 00:15:27.440
get to like, okay, how does the midterm fit into
271
00:15:27.500 --> 00:15:28.679
what Bordeaux is saying?
272
00:15:29.679 --> 00:15:29.799
Yeah.
273
00:15:29.820 --> 00:15:30.700
What were your thoughts, Pills?
274
00:15:31.240 --> 00:15:34.220
We've read a lot of theories of how to create groups,
275
00:15:34.340 --> 00:15:37.480
and especially Gerard is fresh on the mind. Gerard's got
276
00:15:37.500 --> 00:15:39.960
a very Schmidt type of view of how to make
277
00:15:40.000 --> 00:15:43.389
a group, and that's rivalry with another group. The only
278
00:15:43.450 --> 00:15:47.149
way to make a group is rivalry with the tribe
279
00:15:47.210 --> 00:15:51.669
next door, and that's how you get our team versus
280
00:15:51.740 --> 00:15:54.419
their team. And you get a lot of people who
281
00:15:55.120 --> 00:15:59.730
endorse that desire. And this is a different kind of
282
00:16:01.049 --> 00:16:04.830
theory about that. He references Durkheim, Durkheim who we've read
283
00:16:04.850 --> 00:16:07.529
on the podcast before. Durkheim says you kind of just,
284
00:16:08.250 --> 00:16:11.970
by living around people and by having common goals, there's
285
00:16:12.070 --> 00:16:19.019
almost a magical feeling, a coherence that's eventually formed.
286
00:16:20.460 --> 00:16:21.299
Unconsciously.
287
00:16:22.259 --> 00:16:25.259
And Bourdieu says, oh, I always liked Bourdieu. We always
288
00:16:25.320 --> 00:16:28.470
come back to him. And it's like, that's, That's a
289
00:16:28.950 --> 00:16:29.759
nice way to put it.
290
00:16:30.269 --> 00:16:31.429
Yeah, I thought that too.
291
00:16:32.610 --> 00:16:38.529
The representative retroactively creates the group that he represents. Because
292
00:16:38.590 --> 00:16:41.190
now we have a guy and we go, okay, that
293
00:16:41.230 --> 00:16:45.740
guy is part of that team. But until you have
294
00:16:45.779 --> 00:16:48.779
a representative, you don't really know what the team is.
295
00:16:48.879 --> 00:16:52.480
It's once you get the representative, then it becomes identifiable
296
00:16:52.580 --> 00:16:55.320
with a bunch of the terms we
just used. So
297
00:16:55.360 --> 00:17:01.620
that's a far right representative. That's a DSA lefty type
298
00:17:01.659 --> 00:17:05.650
of representative. That's a centrist representative. And, you know, more
299
00:17:05.710 --> 00:17:08.309
often than not, we put a media face on it. Like,
300
00:17:09.430 --> 00:17:14.849
I don't know, Ezra Klein is a nice centrist. I
301
00:17:14.890 --> 00:17:18.069
really don't like what Ezra Klein did with his cheating
302
00:17:18.109 --> 00:17:19.329
on his wife. That's really not.
303
00:17:20.170 --> 00:17:20.549
Wait, what?
304
00:17:20.730 --> 00:17:24.579
Really not cool. Ezra Klein cheated on his wife.
305
00:17:24.599 --> 00:17:26.640
No, no, you're thinking about Ethan Klein, bro.
306
00:17:27.599 --> 00:17:28.799
Destroyed his podcast.
307
00:17:29.819 --> 00:17:34.450
No, I saw, I know I saw, uh, Ezra Klein
308
00:17:34.470 --> 00:17:36.450
was talking this morning, how nice it is to have
309
00:17:36.569 --> 00:17:39.230
leftist Christians back in politics or something.
310
00:17:39.250 --> 00:17:46.170
I'm like, you are such a toad politics of pure surface. Anyway, anyway.
311
00:17:46.210 --> 00:17:49.720
Yeah. Yeah. Once you, once you get a person that
312
00:17:49.819 --> 00:17:52.799
speaks in the language of the group, then there's a
313
00:17:52.900 --> 00:17:54.440
retroactive cycle.
314
00:17:54.500 --> 00:17:56.420
Kind of like Eric said, there's a cycle that goes
315
00:17:56.480 --> 00:17:57.079
back and forth.
316
00:17:57.759 --> 00:18:01.660
Where that person dies as an individual in order to
317
00:18:01.740 --> 00:18:04.779
embody the group, but then it becomes increasingly hard to
318
00:18:04.819 --> 00:18:10.819
hold the representative to account. Because if you speak against
319
00:18:10.900 --> 00:18:13.779
the person who represents your team, then you're kind of
320
00:18:13.980 --> 00:18:17.099
taking yourself off the team. So all that's to say,
321
00:18:17.779 --> 00:18:21.990
it's a different theory of group formation where you have
322
00:18:22.029 --> 00:18:27.170
a metonymic relationship between an individual who kind of becomes.
323
00:18:28.710 --> 00:18:33.569
The part becomes representative of the whole, the spokesperson stands
324
00:18:33.690 --> 00:18:37.599
in for the group and thereby speaks for them. He
325
00:18:37.630 --> 00:18:41.220
calls this, he brings up the, he calls it the
326
00:18:41.339 --> 00:18:46.559
oracle effect where the spokesperson gives voice to the group
327
00:18:47.339 --> 00:18:51.099
in whose name he speaks. So he speaks in the
328
00:18:51.160 --> 00:18:54.640
name of the group and he substitutes for the group.
329
00:18:55.500 --> 00:18:59.700
And that's really the way that your voice gets heard
330
00:18:59.789 --> 00:19:03.130
in politics. But he seems to call it a sort
331
00:19:03.170 --> 00:19:07.509
of fetishism, a political fetishism. If you look at it,
332
00:19:08.549 --> 00:19:12.029
I mean, this is almost like Marx's idea of fetishism,
333
00:19:12.589 --> 00:19:14.769
where we look at a commodity and we think it
334
00:19:14.829 --> 00:19:19.519
has inherent value, when really what's going on is that
335
00:19:20.960 --> 00:19:24.859
this commodity is standing in for a social relation between people.
336
00:19:25.640 --> 00:19:32.779
But It becomes fetishized, and it's externalized, and it takes
337
00:19:32.960 --> 00:19:39.019
on the relationship between things. And that relationship between things
338
00:19:39.099 --> 00:19:43.509
replaces the relation between people. That's fetishism. And political fetishism
339
00:19:43.750 --> 00:19:47.990
is sort of a– he notes that it's not exactly
340
00:19:48.329 --> 00:19:52.829
what Marx is analyzing. but it's useful because we think
341
00:19:52.970 --> 00:19:55.710
that the leader we elect we elect them on the
342
00:19:55.759 --> 00:20:00.599
basis of their their views and their interests align with
343
00:20:00.660 --> 00:20:05.160
ours their charisma it's like they inherently possess some charismatic
344
00:20:05.279 --> 00:20:08.940
leadership quality and we elect them on that basis and
345
00:20:09.970 --> 00:20:13.950
But that's not really the case, he says. Because the
346
00:20:14.029 --> 00:20:16.599
only way we get a voice in politics is, yeah,
347
00:20:16.630 --> 00:20:20.099
by doing that. But at the same time, it's that
348
00:20:20.480 --> 00:20:24.700
representative who creates the group. That's why I said it's
349
00:20:24.740 --> 00:20:27.519
a kind of a chicken and the egg problem. Where
350
00:20:27.539 --> 00:20:31.220
it's like, is it the group who creates the leader?
351
00:20:31.440 --> 00:20:35.000
Or is it the leader who creates the group? He
352
00:20:35.039 --> 00:20:39.019
says it's just as true to say that in reality...
353
00:20:39.440 --> 00:20:42.369
It is the leader who creates the group. They become
354
00:20:42.589 --> 00:20:49.890
recognized within the political field. Just as Protestantism, I guess,
355
00:20:49.970 --> 00:20:52.089
I don't know if this is the analogy he's thinking
356
00:20:52.130 --> 00:20:58.420
of too, but just as in religion, how Lutheranism, right?
357
00:20:58.460 --> 00:21:01.640
If you're a Protestant and you're a Lutheran, you are
358
00:21:01.720 --> 00:21:05.519
created by Martin Luther, just as if you're some other
359
00:21:06.039 --> 00:21:10.529
denomination of Protestantism. Anglicanism, you're created by the King of England,
360
00:21:11.829 --> 00:21:16.410
or whatever Calvinism, you're created by John Calvin. Who's to
361
00:21:16.450 --> 00:21:22.319
say which way around it goes? But these political people
362
00:21:22.460 --> 00:21:28.440
vying for our vote for them, I guess, vying to
363
00:21:28.480 --> 00:21:33.140
be our delegates are like oracles. They're trying to speak.
364
00:21:34.059 --> 00:21:35.819
They're trying to give voice to people.
365
00:21:37.509 --> 00:21:39.569
He also calls it like a form of bad faith
366
00:21:39.730 --> 00:21:43.609
that whenever you speak on behalf of people, there's an
367
00:21:43.750 --> 00:21:48.789
aspect of bad faith about that because you end up reducing, well,
368
00:21:48.809 --> 00:21:51.670
you end up eliminating obviously like a whole bunch of differences.
369
00:21:51.710 --> 00:21:53.410
I mean, it's kind of a fiction. Every time you
370
00:21:53.430 --> 00:21:56.650
speak on behalf of a group, there's some aspect that's
371
00:21:56.690 --> 00:21:59.390
being lost. Like it's kind of impossible to avoid. And
372
00:21:59.410 --> 00:22:02.420
actually that's another paradox. I think he mentions that in
373
00:22:02.460 --> 00:22:05.220
a way it's sort of impossible to avoid. doing it
374
00:22:05.480 --> 00:22:07.789
from time to time right because you're always going to
375
00:22:07.849 --> 00:22:12.269
speak about groups which will kind of reduce and eliminate
376
00:22:12.329 --> 00:22:16.170
differences that actually exist in that group uh like and
377
00:22:16.250 --> 00:22:18.829
even that that group is unified so you know even
378
00:22:19.009 --> 00:22:20.990
i think he uses the example he's like if i
379
00:22:21.009 --> 00:22:24.549
appear aboard you talk about like sociology or like he's
380
00:22:24.589 --> 00:22:26.650
like i'm going to be committing the oracle effect in
381
00:22:26.670 --> 00:22:28.289
a way because it's like how can i talk about
382
00:22:28.329 --> 00:22:30.990
that thing as like a thing like so it's like
383
00:22:31.009 --> 00:22:32.839
it's like it's in a way like an unavoidable there's
384
00:22:32.859 --> 00:22:36.940
like a paradox because it's It serves a function. And
385
00:22:36.960 --> 00:22:40.599
then obviously he's talking about it more specifically to political organizations.
386
00:22:42.319 --> 00:22:45.380
But in a way, it's also unavoidable. Yeah.
387
00:22:45.400 --> 00:22:47.960
To be a leader, you almost have to stop believing
388
00:22:48.000 --> 00:22:52.160
in yourself as an individual. And sort of, I think
389
00:22:52.220 --> 00:22:54.849
that's part of the bad faith is that you don't
390
00:22:54.930 --> 00:22:58.029
believe it. You sort of deny that you're an individual.
391
00:22:58.230 --> 00:23:00.930
That like, I'm not speaking on behalf of myself anymore.
392
00:23:01.170 --> 00:23:04.400
I'm speaking on behalf of the people. And that's the,
393
00:23:04.619 --> 00:23:06.680
you have to sort of believe that in order to
394
00:23:06.740 --> 00:23:09.660
put yourself forward and you become an Oracle. Like the
395
00:23:09.759 --> 00:23:12.819
Oracle effect is a splitting of personality. He calls it
396
00:23:13.359 --> 00:23:17.910
the individual personality. The ego abolishes itself in favor of
397
00:23:17.970 --> 00:23:24.130
a transcendent moral person. I give myself to France. You
398
00:23:24.170 --> 00:23:26.490
have to believe in this, in this almost this, this
399
00:23:27.210 --> 00:23:31.940
religious fiction of self-sacrifice and it, And
there's a lot
400
00:23:31.980 --> 00:23:35.430
of parallels between religion and politics in this way. But
401
00:23:35.470 --> 00:23:39.829
politics constitutes itself as its own field with its own rules.
402
00:23:40.809 --> 00:23:44.690
Isn't there also a kind of three-step process if I,
403
00:23:44.990 --> 00:23:48.150
you know, where, because first you have to, the group
404
00:23:49.009 --> 00:23:54.170
has to be constituted as representing something, right? So like, whatever,
405
00:23:54.259 --> 00:23:57.920
like the Communist Party like becomes constituted as representing the
406
00:23:57.980 --> 00:24:01.319
working class, right? For example, which itself is like bit
407
00:24:01.359 --> 00:24:05.680
of a fiction and then within that party organization then
408
00:24:05.700 --> 00:24:09.119
a representative will become like a spokesperson or a delegate
409
00:24:09.200 --> 00:24:11.380
for that so it's like you have this weird step
410
00:24:11.420 --> 00:24:14.500
where it's like the group gets constituted to represent a
411
00:24:14.559 --> 00:24:17.589
people and then a member of that group then becomes
412
00:24:17.880 --> 00:24:20.549
chosen to represent that group which is supposed to represent
413
00:24:20.660 --> 00:24:23.009
that so there's like a weird and i think he
414
00:24:23.049 --> 00:24:25.509
talks about that with the church i think that it's
415
00:24:25.549 --> 00:24:29.140
like the that you you you you like give yourself
416
00:24:29.160 --> 00:24:31.809
to this group that's constituted, that's supposed to also represent
417
00:24:31.869 --> 00:24:35.269
humanity or whatever. And then, and then, and then it
418
00:24:35.309 --> 00:24:37.789
all gets put into one person, for example, or like,
419
00:24:37.890 --> 00:24:41.490
or like a person like the archbishop in whatever, you know,
420
00:24:41.559 --> 00:24:45.339
Boston is representing the Catholic church. And of course all
421
00:24:45.359 --> 00:24:49.039
of the Catholic church is represented by the Pope. But
422
00:24:49.059 --> 00:24:54.089
then the Catholic church itself is supposed to represent God. And, and, and, and,
423
00:24:54.130 --> 00:24:57.359
you know, so there's, there's all these kind of, interrelations
424
00:24:57.430 --> 00:25:02.339
and steps of representation and kind of this delegation and
425
00:25:02.440 --> 00:25:05.700
constitution of groups that is all based on some aspect
426
00:25:05.740 --> 00:25:09.880
of fiction, but serves also obviously a useful function because
427
00:25:09.920 --> 00:25:14.009
it keeps happening. And it even happens in language. Even
428
00:25:14.069 --> 00:25:17.630
earlier when I was talking about, you know, even when
429
00:25:17.650 --> 00:25:20.150
I'm talking about something that's rooted in statistics, right? I
430
00:25:20.190 --> 00:25:23.309
was talking about, I don't know, Latino voters in South Texas, right?
431
00:25:23.329 --> 00:25:27.940
It's like right there. I am using doing some Oracle
432
00:25:28.000 --> 00:25:30.000
affecting here where I'm talking about a group as if
433
00:25:30.039 --> 00:25:32.099
it's as if it's like a stable thing.
434
00:25:33.000 --> 00:25:37.819
And this is his term for for this is symbolic violence,
435
00:25:38.960 --> 00:25:42.220
not which is not how we've been using violence on
436
00:25:42.259 --> 00:25:45.799
the last several episodes. His his sort of violence is OK.
437
00:25:46.599 --> 00:25:50.880
As soon as someone can't speak, there's violence being done. Yeah,
438
00:25:51.039 --> 00:25:53.900
but it's but it's true in that there's no there's
439
00:25:53.960 --> 00:25:59.000
no alternative because if you want a voice, you need
440
00:25:59.019 --> 00:26:03.170
a representative for you and your team. But as soon
441
00:26:03.210 --> 00:26:06.069
as you have a representative, now your voice is no
442
00:26:06.109 --> 00:26:12.079
longer anything. Even if you are the representative, your individual voice,
443
00:26:12.099 --> 00:26:16.140
in theory, is taken from you so that you speak
444
00:26:16.859 --> 00:26:21.619
by the group's voice rather than your own. There's actually
445
00:26:22.119 --> 00:26:25.869
it's like no one is speaking. It's it's the unconscious
446
00:26:25.970 --> 00:26:30.690
of a group that becomes the voice and everyone has
447
00:26:30.730 --> 00:26:34.809
to go along with this fiction. But there's no alternative
448
00:26:34.829 --> 00:26:39.130
to the fiction. There's no real representation. And that's kind
449
00:26:39.150 --> 00:26:41.160
of what he goes through with all these with all
450
00:26:41.180 --> 00:26:43.980
these steps. You know, the first you got the people
451
00:26:44.440 --> 00:26:46.240
who's going to be represented by the people while the
452
00:26:46.259 --> 00:26:50.420
Communist Party represents the people. And now we need representatives
453
00:26:50.480 --> 00:26:54.160
of the Communist Party. So we need little apparatchiks. Now
454
00:26:54.200 --> 00:26:56.529
who's going to represent all the apparatchiks? Now we need
455
00:26:57.390 --> 00:27:03.230
the chairman or the leader. And at each level of abstraction,
456
00:27:03.549 --> 00:27:06.509
he says there's symbolic violence. When he says symbolic violence,
457
00:27:06.529 --> 00:27:11.019
he's not saying it's morally wrong, because he's also said
458
00:27:11.700 --> 00:27:14.880
there's no alternative. We're only in symbolic violence. And the
459
00:27:15.420 --> 00:27:19.269
The violence increases as the abstraction increases where you have
460
00:27:20.190 --> 00:27:23.589
one guy who all of a sudden represents the entire nation.
461
00:27:24.690 --> 00:27:29.029
The paradox is if you want a voice, you need
462
00:27:29.250 --> 00:27:34.079
a representative, and the representative also steals your voice, and
463
00:27:34.680 --> 00:27:35.400
you're fucked.
464
00:27:35.960 --> 00:27:36.599
Yeah, I like that.
465
00:27:37.259 --> 00:27:41.099
Usurpetory ventriloquism, he calls
it.
466
00:27:41.380 --> 00:27:43.720
That's the good word for it. Usurpetory ventriloquism.
467
00:27:46.430 --> 00:27:51.829
In the realm of politics, I would say that, yeah,
468
00:27:51.849 --> 00:27:55.630
it's unavoidable. But I guess one reason why I think
469
00:27:55.789 --> 00:28:02.180
something like sortition would be better on this basis is because,
470
00:28:03.619 --> 00:28:08.259
you know, there's less... I think there's fewer layers in
471
00:28:08.299 --> 00:28:12.000
a body that is supposed to represent the population... when
472
00:28:12.039 --> 00:28:14.529
it's just selected by lottery and there's no elections, there's
473
00:28:14.569 --> 00:28:17.569
no political parties, you kind of like reduce the number
474
00:28:17.589 --> 00:28:19.450
of layers, but it's still, you're still having like a
475
00:28:19.490 --> 00:28:22.309
random selection of the population is supposed to represent the people. Right.
476
00:28:22.329 --> 00:28:24.269
And there's, you're going to have all kinds of fictions
477
00:28:24.309 --> 00:28:26.460
with that. But I guess I would claim that, you know,
478
00:28:26.500 --> 00:28:29.640
this is a very embryonic thought, if you will. But
479
00:28:29.660 --> 00:28:30.920
just when I was reading this, I was like, well,
480
00:28:31.160 --> 00:28:34.299
in a way this would reduce these like layers of
481
00:28:34.380 --> 00:28:36.589
abstraction because you, you know, you don't need this party
482
00:28:36.619 --> 00:28:41.779
apparatus anymore to like, to consider its platform. And, you know,
483
00:28:41.819 --> 00:28:43.779
and then you have all this bargaining going on behind
484
00:28:43.819 --> 00:28:45.880
that creates all these extra layers of like, well, who
485
00:28:45.900 --> 00:28:49.299
are we representing? We have to worry about all these donors. And,
486
00:28:49.500 --> 00:28:51.460
you know, I'm speaking for this party as if it's
487
00:28:51.500 --> 00:28:53.839
this entity itself. And, you know, if you just have
488
00:28:53.859 --> 00:28:58.509
a randomly selected portion of the population, maybe it would
489
00:28:58.569 --> 00:29:01.450
reduce those layers. There's obviously another question about whether or
490
00:29:01.490 --> 00:29:02.869
not that would be a good thing or not, but
491
00:29:02.890 --> 00:29:04.869
I guess I think it potentially could be.
492
00:29:05.650 --> 00:29:09.210
I think Sortition might sort out some of those problems
493
00:29:09.250 --> 00:29:13.589
you were talking about. But I think Bordeaux's logic here
494
00:29:13.930 --> 00:29:15.430
would hold pretty good.
495
00:29:15.450 --> 00:29:15.670
Of course.
496
00:29:16.289 --> 00:29:19.849
Because all that stuff, there's two major, when you put
497
00:29:19.890 --> 00:29:24.349
the delegate in the center of your analysis, there's two
498
00:29:24.589 --> 00:29:28.150
big relations to think about. One is the relation between
499
00:29:28.190 --> 00:29:32.230
the delegate and the mandators, the ones who give the
500
00:29:32.299 --> 00:29:36.680
delegate the mandate. So like the politician and the people
501
00:29:37.160 --> 00:29:41.099
or the priest. and the flock, right? That they, that
502
00:29:41.140 --> 00:29:43.900
they serve and serve.
503
00:29:45.180 --> 00:29:45.400
Yeah.
504
00:29:45.440 --> 00:29:49.359
Then there's the other relationship between the delegate and the apparatus,
505
00:29:49.819 --> 00:29:53.160
the priests and the priesthood, the body of priests, the
506
00:29:53.200 --> 00:29:57.980
politician and the party. And that has its own sort
507
00:29:58.019 --> 00:30:01.519
of rigid logic. And sortition would sort of solve in
508
00:30:01.559 --> 00:30:06.289
a way how delegates get delegated, but it wouldn't solve
509
00:30:06.849 --> 00:30:10.569
the demands that the party then puts on the delegate.
510
00:30:11.069 --> 00:30:16.710
Because he says these interesting things about how a party's
511
00:30:17.029 --> 00:30:20.589
type of organization works. Like you have to have, you
512
00:30:20.609 --> 00:30:22.609
have to give up, you do in a literal way
513
00:30:22.670 --> 00:30:26.349
have to give up everything for the party. You have
514
00:30:26.369 --> 00:30:33.250
to sacrifice everything because party structures, priestly bodies, party structures,
515
00:30:34.589 --> 00:30:38.740
and even like he kind of uses, I guess, the
516
00:30:38.859 --> 00:30:44.059
Bolshevik kind of Stalinist party as an example, but I
517
00:30:44.099 --> 00:30:46.640
think it holds everywhere, is that you have to have
518
00:30:46.700 --> 00:30:51.369
nothing outside of that. The only way that you are
519
00:30:51.490 --> 00:30:54.369
reliable in the eyes of the party as a party
520
00:30:54.430 --> 00:30:58.470
member is is that you have no value outside of
521
00:30:58.509 --> 00:31:01.329
that party and the party is the only thing that
522
00:31:01.390 --> 00:31:04.670
gives you the value. So sortition would sort of introduce
523
00:31:04.710 --> 00:31:09.059
this problem where they may have outside commitments and motivations
524
00:31:09.119 --> 00:31:15.359
that aren't connected to the party. And the party over
525
00:31:15.400 --> 00:31:20.660
time flips into that logic of the organization, right? Where
526
00:31:21.730 --> 00:31:28.359
the sort of apparatus itself dictates what the delegates can
527
00:31:28.400 --> 00:31:31.839
and can't do. And that's why I was saying the
528
00:31:31.920 --> 00:31:35.250
only way you can go against the party is to
529
00:31:35.289 --> 00:31:37.930
sort of break off and form another party within that
530
00:31:37.990 --> 00:31:42.529
party that then flips into its own logic. And that's
531
00:31:42.549 --> 00:31:47.710
why the MAGA movement, right? Like when Trump sues news organizations,
532
00:31:47.849 --> 00:31:52.430
when he chews out Republicans for not towing his line,
533
00:31:52.490 --> 00:31:56.259
how sensitive he is. for towards any kind of criticism
534
00:31:57.039 -->
00:32:00.220
from others. Yeah. But also from within the party, they're
535
00:32:00.599 --> 00:32:04.599
afraid to criticize him. And even the polls this time,
536
00:32:04.619 --> 00:32:10.109
the polling agencies are even afraid to, uh, like overestimate
537
00:32:10.150 --> 00:32:12.890
in favor of the Democrats, right? If they're going to
538
00:32:12.970 --> 00:32:18.730
overestimate anybody's performance, they'll overestimate the Republicans because Trump sued
539
00:32:18.809 --> 00:32:22.839
one of the polling agencies because it overestimated the Democrats,
540
00:32:22.859 --> 00:32:27.089
which is crazy. But that's the logic, I think, of
541
00:32:27.289 --> 00:32:32.000
the MAGA movement starting to dictate the motivations of the
542
00:32:32.039 --> 00:32:38.279
party members themselves. Trump included, I guess, right? Again, we
543
00:32:38.319 --> 00:32:43.519
don't want to commit the sort of political fetishism is
544
00:32:43.579 --> 00:32:45.839
that he was elected because of who he is and
545
00:32:45.900 --> 00:32:51.059
his own charisma and personality. That's political fetishism. What he's
546
00:32:51.099 --> 00:32:51.869
really doing is.
547
00:32:54.319 --> 00:32:56.440
I don't know, sort of that, I guess he's still
548
00:32:56.480 --> 00:33:00.609
doing that sort of self-sacrificial, make America great again, I
549
00:33:00.630 --> 00:33:03.230
give myself to the country, I'm not really me, I
550
00:33:03.269 --> 00:33:05.589
speak for the people kind of thing as well.
551
00:33:06.630 --> 00:33:10.720
And then the analysis of this comes from the analogy
552
00:33:10.759 --> 00:33:15.240
of the church. And all the church officials, they're all
553
00:33:15.299 --> 00:33:22.250
called ministers, right? And similar to how our representatives, they're
554
00:33:22.289 --> 00:33:25.819
called public servants. So the name makes it sound like
555
00:33:25.859 --> 00:33:28.259
they're low. It makes it sound like they're the bottom.
556
00:33:28.759 --> 00:33:32.960
And this is the, it's a conceit. It's a hallucination
557
00:33:33.029 --> 00:33:34.509
that we all agree to.
558
00:33:34.589 --> 00:33:37.369
We're like, oh yeah, they're serving us.
559
00:33:38.009 --> 00:33:38.789
They work for me.
560
00:33:39.910 --> 00:33:40.349
Exactly.
561
00:33:40.390 --> 00:33:43.730
They are dying to themselves in a sort of political baptism.
562
00:33:44.130 --> 00:33:45.130
Even Trump says this.
563
00:33:45.190 --> 00:33:45.869
Trump says, I.
564
00:33:48.049 --> 00:33:51.589
Could have been a happy billionaire, but instead of being
565
00:33:51.609 --> 00:33:54.339
a happy billionaire, I have given it all up because
566
00:33:54.460 --> 00:33:57.940
I care about the people, I care about you. And
567
00:33:57.980 --> 00:34:01.430
at a certain point, I mean, this is not his
568
00:34:01.549 --> 00:34:05.470
problem specifically. This is the problem of becoming a leader
569
00:34:05.509 --> 00:34:10.230
that is then an oracle, is you
have to conceal
570
00:34:10.489 --> 00:34:15.949
the fact that you have usurped them, but then being
571
00:34:16.730 --> 00:34:20.929
given authority. Like you're never really allowed to say out loud, yes,
572
00:34:21.030 --> 00:34:23.739
I have now authority and I've taken it. And now
573
00:34:23.840 --> 00:34:27.300
I have this salary. Now I have these business relationships.
574
00:34:27.760 --> 00:34:33.320
I am privately profiting off of the office. That stuff
575
00:34:33.380 --> 00:34:36.780
is never supposed to come to light because all of
576
00:34:36.820 --> 00:34:40.159
that stuff, we call it corruption, it's exterior to the
577
00:34:40.320 --> 00:34:45.139
office that you've been given. So it's not supposed to
578
00:34:45.179 --> 00:34:47.730
be a part of the job that you get all
579
00:34:47.769 --> 00:34:49.789
these private benefits on the side.
580
00:34:49.849 --> 00:34:50.969
So it has to.
581
00:34:50.929 --> 00:34:54.699
Be for your cult, we could say, for your cult
582
00:34:54.920 --> 00:34:58.139
as a Catholic priest, for your cult as a Trump member,
583
00:34:58.159 --> 00:35:00.699
for your cult as a, I don't know, a fan
584
00:35:00.780 --> 00:35:04.889
of some celebrity, you have to turn away from the
585
00:35:04.929 --> 00:35:08.309
fact that they are personally benefiting from their office. Because
586
00:35:08.329 --> 00:35:10.650
as soon as you say they're personally benefiting, then they
587
00:35:10.690 --> 00:35:13.630
are no longer your voice, or they can no longer
588
00:35:13.690 --> 00:35:16.150
function adequately as your voice.
589
00:35:16.769 --> 00:35:18.650
Now they're split. So you have to ignore the fact
590
00:35:18.670 --> 00:35:19.309
that they're split.
591
00:35:19.969 --> 00:35:20.449
But he does.
592
00:35:21.800 --> 00:35:26.880
He does say, though, that he kind of blows up
593
00:35:27.360 --> 00:35:30.460
this idea that the representative has to be this sort
594
00:35:30.500 --> 00:35:37.849
of ideologically disinterested person who isn't benefiting, though. There are
595
00:35:37.969 --> 00:35:42.590
real interests at play on both the side of the electors,
596
00:35:42.769 --> 00:35:46.710
the mandators, and the one who is mandated. And he
597
00:35:46.769 --> 00:35:50.039
says the interests of the delegate and the interests of
598
00:35:50.099 --> 00:35:54.099
the mandators are of those he represents coincide to a
599
00:35:54.139 --> 00:35:57.699
large extent so that the delegate can believe and get
600
00:35:57.860 --> 00:36:01.380
others to believe that he has no interests outside of
601
00:36:01.440 --> 00:36:05.400
those mandators, that the appearance that they have no interest
602
00:36:05.619 --> 00:36:09.239
is just because of a perfect coincidence of interest. And
603
00:36:09.280 --> 00:36:13.530
the moment that we start saying that Trump is personally
604
00:36:13.670 --> 00:36:17.329
benefiting from this or that whatever his son is using
605
00:36:17.369 --> 00:36:21.510
his political power to further his own private interests, That's
606
00:36:21.550 --> 00:36:24.750
been going on the whole time. That's the flaw of
607
00:36:24.809 --> 00:36:29.210
that reasoning. What is really happening is that their private
608
00:36:29.250 --> 00:36:33.840
interests now are obviously not in line with the interests
609
00:36:34.039 --> 00:36:36.719
of the mandators, the ones who put them there. That's
610
00:36:36.780 --> 00:36:40.019
just what's happening. It's a splitting off of the interests.
611
00:36:41.079 --> 00:36:44.360
That their interests did align before, that's what drives this
612
00:36:44.409 --> 00:36:49.679
whole thing. That's why that like kind of voters do
613
00:36:49.800 --> 00:36:52.920
kind of vote with their own personal interests in mind.
614
00:36:53.599 --> 00:36:56.179
I think that's what he seems to be saying here
615
00:36:56.730 --> 00:37:01.369
is that like the coincidence of interests is what drives
616
00:37:01.429 --> 00:37:05.650
this whole thing. It's not this like idea that like
617
00:37:05.690 --> 00:37:10.409
we do talk, we were talking about this appearance of self-sacrificial. Oh,
618
00:37:10.610 --> 00:37:13.599
I am nothing. I give myself to the country. I'm
619
00:37:13.639 --> 00:37:16.880
in the service of God, whatever. That's just the appearance of,
620
00:37:17.980 --> 00:37:19.159
But the reality is.
621
00:37:19.280 --> 00:37:23.920
It's never true, but it's in principle, the representative is
622
00:37:24.000 --> 00:37:25.880
not pursuing their own interests.
623
00:37:26.019 --> 00:37:28.139
Otherwise, they would not be a representative.
624
00:37:28.579 --> 00:37:32.760
Now, a representative is never- Yeah, the representative is never
625
00:37:33.440 --> 00:37:35.320
actually a representative.
626
00:37:35.360 --> 00:37:37.280
That's the whole paradox.
627
00:37:38.139 --> 00:37:41.519
I mean, Bordia doesn't sort of say how party politics
628
00:37:41.599 --> 00:37:44.179
and electing works, but I think that's what it is.
629
00:37:44.219 --> 00:37:47.710
You're The oracles are out there with their discourse of
630
00:37:47.789 --> 00:37:51.369
interests and who they're serving. And the people have their
631
00:37:51.449 --> 00:37:54.389
own interests that they want to get expressed by the oracles.
632
00:37:54.889 --> 00:37:58.320
And so they choose their oracle. And they seem to
633
00:37:58.360 --> 00:38:01.380
be electing their oracle. And so there is this game
634
00:38:01.420 --> 00:38:05.019
of interests, I think. He calls it a structural coincidence
635
00:38:05.059 --> 00:38:08.659
of specific interests between delegates and mandators.
636
00:38:09.619 --> 00:38:15.130
But like the mandate from MAGA, no MAGA... cultist is
637
00:38:15.190 --> 00:38:19.630
saying i'm voting for trump because i want trump to
638
00:38:19.670 --> 00:38:21.360
get rich because i think he's a good guy and
639
00:38:21.380 --> 00:38:22.130
he deserved.
640
00:38:21.860 --> 00:38:24.409
No it was drain the swamp and stop the forever
641
00:38:24.449 --> 00:38:25.260
wars that's.
642
00:38:25.139 --> 00:38:28.059
Right i am i am voting for trump because he
643
00:38:28.119 --> 00:38:29.480
pisses the people that i.
644
00:38:29.460 --> 00:38:31.960
Don't like about corruption in politics.
645
00:38:31.519 --> 00:38:34.059
I'm voting for trump because he talks about america i
646
00:38:34.320 --> 00:38:37.320
am voting for trump because i don't want my my grandchildren.
647
00:38:36.880 --> 00:38:40.099
I don't like trans people I don't want my grandchildren
648
00:38:40.119 --> 00:38:41.550
to be gay and trans. I don't like the border.
649
00:38:41.699 --> 00:38:44.090
I don't like immigrants coming into the country. Yeah.
650
00:38:44.269 --> 00:38:47.690
So no one is voting for Trump to be their
651
00:38:47.849 --> 00:38:51.809
oracle because they care about Trump the guy getting rich.
652
00:38:52.070 --> 00:38:53.750
And if he does get rich, they're going to turn
653
00:38:53.789 --> 00:38:56.809
a blind eye to that fact because it's in contrast
654
00:38:56.849 --> 00:39:00.309
to his function as oracle for him to get rich.
655
00:39:00.409 --> 00:39:03.389
But then if it happens too much, if he alienates,
656
00:39:03.449 --> 00:39:07.829
there's a... Bourdieu kind of changes the... the tenor of
657
00:39:07.869 --> 00:39:13.869
this word alienation. Political alienation is when your representative does
658
00:39:13.949 --> 00:39:16.579
not represent you in a way that you can no
659
00:39:16.639 --> 00:39:17.579
longer overlook.
660
00:39:18.260 --> 00:39:20.900
So you take off the blinders.
661
00:39:22.880 --> 00:39:28.909
The symbolic violence is simply the way that this goes
662
00:39:29.110 --> 00:39:34.800
on and continues to reproduce the power structures that keep
663
00:39:34.880 --> 00:39:40.880
the dominators and the dominated in different groups and continuously
664
00:39:40.940 --> 00:39:45.440
reproduce the sort of hierarchical structure of society by this
665
00:39:47.159 --> 00:39:51.869
symbolic game of communication and discourse. So I thought his
666
00:39:51.929 --> 00:39:54.010
analysis was really cool in this chapter.
667
00:39:54.750 --> 00:39:57.309
And the basis of it is semiotics, where he says
668
00:39:57.650 --> 00:40:02.679
the leader is the signifier, and the signifier reverse creates
669
00:40:03.010 --> 00:40:03.860
the signifieds.
670
00:40:05.480 --> 00:40:09.719
Yeah, the signifier creates the people, which is the signified,
671
00:40:10.119 --> 00:40:11.000
is it not? Yeah.
672
00:40:11.960 --> 00:40:17.190
So the person becomes, yeah, or the leader, the representative
673
00:40:17.670 --> 00:40:20.769
becomes the, well, it's a signifier, it's a sign. It's
674
00:40:20.789 --> 00:40:24.269
a sign of the people's will until he's not anymore,
675
00:40:24.289 --> 00:40:25.650
until he fucks up too bad.
676
00:40:26.730 --> 00:40:29.750
And it's a sign to the people of their
own existence,
677
00:40:30.170 --> 00:40:33.250
because if they're not acknowledged in the political discourse, then
678
00:40:33.289 --> 00:40:38.110
they have no existence. Almost in reality, not just in
679
00:40:38.150 --> 00:40:44.650
a discursive sort of symbolic sense, but the oracle becomes
680
00:40:44.710 --> 00:40:48.050
the sign of the existence of the people who they're
681
00:40:48.070 --> 00:40:51.679
speaking for, to those people. Those people look And they
682
00:40:51.719 --> 00:40:55.449
look at that sign of themselves and say, aha, I exist.
683
00:40:56.269 --> 00:40:58.130
And in a way, it is in reality because that
684
00:40:58.190 --> 00:41:03.329
group is composed around that leader. And the group wouldn't
685
00:41:03.369 --> 00:41:06.809
exist without that leader. So there is a more than
686
00:41:06.889 --> 00:41:11.739
symbolic effect of the symbolic game going on here.
687
00:41:12.719 --> 00:41:15.039
So then I guess the conclusion of this whole thing
688
00:41:15.139 --> 00:41:17.840
is basically what you'd expect. Insofar as you.
689
00:41:20.900 --> 00:41:26.409
There's no good situation for either leaders or either representatives
690
00:41:26.670 --> 00:41:32.750
or the represented because they're both erasing each other, right?
691
00:41:33.210 --> 00:41:38.639
They're both getting erased and the representative has to continue
692
00:41:38.659 --> 00:41:43.780
to sacrifice himself and the people need him to sacrifice himself.
693
00:41:43.840 --> 00:41:47.000
So both are losing. I guess if there's a good
694
00:41:47.099 --> 00:41:52.019
way to represent... it would be to stay in very
695
00:41:52.980 --> 00:41:57.639
close contact with your people, right? You see so often
696
00:41:57.679 --> 00:42:02.380
in politics that the goal becomes fundraising or the goal
697
00:42:02.420 --> 00:42:06.489
becomes climbing the ladder in the party. As soon as
698
00:42:06.530 --> 00:42:13.329
the communication with your representatives starts to erode and you
699
00:42:13.369 --> 00:42:16.550
become a functionary of a different sort of role, then
700
00:42:16.630 --> 00:42:22.070
abstraction creeps in and then you're you're increasingly illegitimate depending
701
00:42:22.130 --> 00:42:24.230
on how much abstraction is in your relationship to the
702
00:42:24.269 --> 00:42:28.769
people you represent. So when you call politicians out of touch, say,
703
00:42:29.090 --> 00:42:34.920
it's because it's clear to everyone, including themselves, that they
704
00:42:34.940 --> 00:42:39.440
are no longer seeking to represent. Now they're seeking some
705
00:42:39.500 --> 00:42:45.969
other goal to kowtow for a foreign government, kowtow to
706
00:42:45.989 --> 00:42:48.449
the party leadership so that they get their spot.
707
00:42:49.449 --> 00:42:53.809
I mean, some of it could also be, well, not
708
00:42:54.050 --> 00:42:57.679
quite benign, but it's just because of the way competitive
709
00:42:57.719 --> 00:43:02.880
elections work. It's like you need resources to compete. And
710
00:43:02.920 --> 00:43:05.139
I just feel like that need for resources to be
711
00:43:05.179 --> 00:43:08.980
able to campaign just creates this incentive where it's like,
712
00:43:09.159 --> 00:43:12.059
you know, nominally they're not doing anything wrong in the
713
00:43:12.099 --> 00:43:15.650
sense of like purposely being like, oh, I'm only caring
714
00:43:15.670 --> 00:43:18.690
about my interests now. But it's more like, wait, for
715
00:43:18.730 --> 00:43:21.130
me to even do anything for the people that I represent,
716
00:43:21.449 --> 00:43:23.750
I have to get reelected. But then it's like because
717
00:43:23.809 --> 00:43:30.019
the resource competition is so all-encompassing, just the time that
718
00:43:30.039 --> 00:43:32.300
you have to actually be in contact with the people
719
00:43:32.320 --> 00:43:38.019
you're supposed to represent becomes smaller and smaller. So it's
720
00:43:38.059 --> 00:43:41.480
almost like an unconscious effect of just the nature of
721
00:43:41.519 --> 00:43:41.840
the game.
722
00:43:41.880 --> 00:43:45.099
You start paying more attention to the donors than anything else.
723
00:43:45.820 --> 00:43:47.940
We should have mentioned that. He's pretty clear.
724
00:43:47.960 --> 00:43:51.139
He describes this in conscious terms as if people are
725
00:43:51.179 --> 00:43:53.300
in on the game, but no one is in on
726
00:43:53.340 --> 00:43:53.679
the game.
727
00:43:54.159 --> 00:43:54.780
Yeah, exactly.
728
00:43:55.380 --> 00:43:58.260
Everyone's doing it unconsciously. So I think what you just
729
00:43:58.300 --> 00:44:02.199
described there is you become a representative of the people,
730
00:44:02.900 --> 00:44:06.889
then the incentive structure makes it so you are now
731
00:44:06.969 --> 00:44:09.670
representing just the money people.
732
00:44:10.510 --> 00:44:12.769
Yeah. And even if you don't want to, like even
733
00:44:12.809 --> 00:44:14.889
if like you don't want to, like you're just like, well,
734
00:44:14.909 --> 00:44:16.610
it's like I have to get reelected. Otherwise, I'm going
735
00:44:16.630 --> 00:44:18.230
to be able to do nothing. So it's like, well,
736
00:44:18.269 --> 00:44:21.329
of course, I have to like spend my time competing
737
00:44:21.369 --> 00:44:24.070
for resources. And if I don't play this game, then
738
00:44:24.110 --> 00:44:26.480
my competitor is going to win and they're going to
739
00:44:26.579 --> 00:44:28.900
and they're worse than me. So I need to win.
740
00:44:29.139 --> 00:44:31.840
So I need to like, you know, play this game
741
00:44:32.579 --> 00:44:33.119
for the people.
742
00:44:34.079 --> 00:44:34.199
Yeah.
743
00:44:34.219 --> 00:44:35.840
You have to be a you have to be a
744
00:44:36.280 --> 00:44:40.349
complete egomaniac, really. You have to, you have to not
745
00:44:40.449 --> 00:44:43.510
believe in yourself. Wait, you have to believe in yourself
746
00:44:43.630
--> 00:44:47.849
so much that you actually believe this fiction to be
747
00:44:47.909 --> 00:44:48.630
successful at it.
748
00:44:48.650 --> 00:44:49.300
Yeah.
749
00:44:49.610 --> 00:44:52.380
I think you see that in Obama as an egomaniac.
750
00:44:52.400 --> 00:44:53.239
It's self-deception.
751
00:44:53.260 --> 00:44:53.780
Yeah.
752
00:44:53.800 --> 00:44:56.780
But something interesting can happen though, where people, where politicians
753
00:44:56.820 --> 00:44:59.920
will often, but they'll often even agree. They'll do this
754
00:44:59.960 --> 00:45:02.280
thing where they'll like, they'll have this kind of faux,
755
00:45:02.360 --> 00:45:05.929
but not faux consciousness about it. Right. They'll, but kind
756
00:45:05.969 --> 00:45:07.579
of be like, oh, I know this is horrible. Like,
757
00:45:07.619 --> 00:45:10.340
I don't have time. They will say that it's really bad,
758
00:45:10.659 --> 00:45:13.440
that they have to worry about campaign financing.
759
00:45:13.980 --> 00:45:19.300
Both Ted Cruz and J.D. Vance wrote just fucking essays.
760
00:45:19.380 --> 00:45:21.880
And I'm sorry to admit that I read all of them,
761
00:45:21.940 --> 00:45:25.559
but it was like, oh, yes, we've realized we were
762
00:45:25.639 --> 00:45:31.500
out of touch. It's this faux self-reflection on the difficulties
763
00:45:31.559 --> 00:45:35.750
of representing in office. And I know you're speaking... specifically
764
00:45:35.769 --> 00:45:38.429
about campaign finance. But this is like, yes, we grew
765
00:45:38.550 --> 00:45:41.309
out of touch. We were aware that this was the
766
00:45:41.349 --> 00:45:43.889
biggest issue. Now I see that these are the four
767
00:45:43.929 --> 00:45:45.750
biggest issues. They didn't want us to go to war.
768
00:45:45.789 --> 00:45:49.119
They didn't want us to increase inflation. They didn't want
769
00:45:49.179 --> 00:45:54.420
us to push AI data center policies in Texas.
770
00:45:56.059 --> 00:45:56.699
Now I see.
771
00:45:56.800 --> 00:46:00.679
So they're pretending like, oh yeah, we're having this back
772
00:46:00.739 --> 00:46:03.949
and forth relationship. Now that we've lost, I've heard you.
773
00:46:04.340 --> 00:46:06.519
Because I want to get elected in two years.
774
00:46:07.510 --> 00:46:11.769
It's also funny that the defenders of kind of the
775
00:46:11.929 --> 00:46:16.269
electoral systems, they always say that it is the incentive
776
00:46:16.309 --> 00:46:19.659
for re-election that should produce the responsiveness to citizens. Because
777
00:46:19.679 --> 00:46:22.480
they're like, well, if they need to get re-elected, then
778
00:46:22.519 --> 00:46:25.920
the voters are going to hold them accountable. And that's
779
00:46:25.940 --> 00:46:28.659
going to force them to be responsive. But the problem
780
00:46:28.679 --> 00:46:31.199
with that argument is that every politician is playing the
781
00:46:31.239 --> 00:46:34.380
same game. So it's like, even if you hold one accountable,
782
00:46:34.400 --> 00:46:36.360
you're holding them accountable for someone else who's doing the
783
00:46:36.380 --> 00:46:36.739
same thing.
784
00:46:37.199 --> 00:46:41.130
It's just like, and there's structural reasons that can't be done.
785
00:46:41.190 --> 00:46:43.989
Like you said, there's reasons that that can't always be
786
00:46:44.030 --> 00:46:49.269
the case. Competition for resources, donors, and media attention.
787
00:46:49.530 --> 00:46:51.650
Like you're competing for attention to like all.
788
00:46:51.550 --> 00:46:54.550
The party itself and its own sort of logic that
789
00:46:54.679 --> 00:46:57.599
sort of dictates how you have to be in relation
790
00:46:57.699 --> 00:47:02.159
to all your other party members and the, and the,
791
00:47:02.460 --> 00:47:07.190
party apparatus itself. That's why as the logic of the
792
00:47:07.250 --> 00:47:13.849
Democratic party apparatus begins to start displacing now the logic
793
00:47:13.889 --> 00:47:19.400
of the Republican party apparatus, such as it is, there's
794
00:47:19.420 --> 00:47:23.000
going to be an interesting game going on between the
795
00:47:23.059 --> 00:47:27.989
Democrats who were just put in power through the midterms
796
00:47:29.190 --> 00:47:34.329
playing those games with the donors, with the resources, with
797
00:47:34.369 --> 00:47:38.730
their party, and drawing those party lines, but at the
798
00:47:38.789 --> 00:47:43.429
same time, being able to deliver on all the interests
799
00:47:44.340 --> 00:47:50.019
that they're supposedly now aligned with throughout the people at large,
800
00:47:50.699 --> 00:47:54.820
I guess, which involves, again, just those basic issues, stopping
801
00:47:54.860 --> 00:47:57.719
the war with Iran, getting rid of the stupid trade
802
00:47:57.760 --> 00:48:00.960
war with Canada, bringing down the prices of things and
803
00:48:00.980 --> 00:48:05.760
the cost of living. I'm a little bit doubtful that
804
00:48:05.780 --> 00:48:08.460
they're going to be able to really do all that meaningfully.
805
00:48:09.860 --> 00:48:12.699
Even in two years, I doubt they'll be able, if
806
00:48:12.739 --> 00:48:16.550
they get elected, if a president comes from the Democratic Party,
807
00:48:17.110 --> 00:48:19.510
I still doubt they'll be able to make any meaningful
808
00:48:19.550 --> 00:48:21.030
movement on those sorts of things.
809
00:48:22.380 --> 00:48:22.940
Yeah, totally.
810
00:48:22.960 --> 00:48:25.719
I think that's the interesting game. The interesting part is,
811
00:48:25.840 --> 00:48:28.599
are they going to just sort of constitute their old,
812
00:48:29.159 --> 00:48:36.150
like woke public or what's is the democratic party and
813
00:48:36.190 --> 00:48:38.670
their Oracle is going to constitute new publics?
814
00:48:39.570 --> 00:48:44.230
Well, can I also mention internally in parties also think another, I've,
815
00:48:44.250 --> 00:48:45.849
so I was, I've been researching this a
little bit
816
00:48:45.869 --> 00:48:47.429
cause I had, I have a paper I'm working on
817
00:48:47.469 --> 00:48:50.889
that's sort of about this, these dynamics and, and, So
818
00:48:51.650 --> 00:48:54.329
even when you look internally at party structures, some of
819
00:48:54.369 --> 00:48:57.639
what you're just mentioning, Eric, the incentives there are also
820
00:48:57.739 --> 00:49:01.000
worse than we realize, because especially from the perspective of
821
00:49:01.159 --> 00:49:05.699
changing and internal party democracy in the sense of, well,
822
00:49:05.780 --> 00:49:09.219
in these parties, there's supposed to be these idealist places
823
00:49:09.280 --> 00:49:11.780
where ideas about how to serve the interests of the
824
00:49:11.820 --> 00:49:14.980
citizens should be discussed and debated, and you know, there
825
00:49:15.000 --> 00:49:17.440
should be like a vibrancy to it. But what happens
826
00:49:17.500 --> 00:49:19.119
is like, think about how parties work. It's like they
827
00:49:19.179 --> 00:49:22.579
hire people. It's like to be staffers, right? And staffers,
828
00:49:22.599 --> 00:49:24.460
what are they worried about? They want to keep their job.
829
00:49:24.949 --> 00:49:27.469
And they also want to have opportunities to advance in
830
00:49:27.510 --> 00:49:29.969
the party. And they don't, and crucially, they don't want
831
00:49:30.010 --> 00:49:33.289
to ruin their opportunity to advance in the party. So
832
00:49:33.329 --> 00:49:36.469
that creates also, I think, a pretty bad incentive where
833
00:49:36.550 --> 00:49:39.369
nobody wants to really upset anyone else. Like nobody, nobody
834
00:49:39.409 --> 00:49:42.449
wants to take a risk and come and say out loud,
835
00:49:42.849 --> 00:49:45.530
what we're doing here is wrong, right? This is a bad,
836
00:49:45.570 --> 00:49:47.349
because they don't want to ruffle feathers. Like, I mean,
837
00:49:47.409 --> 00:49:50.050
some really courageous people will, but generally the incentive is
838
00:49:50.110 --> 00:49:52.110
to not do that, is to go along with how
839
00:49:52.170 --> 00:49:54.389
things have been going because they're like, well, I don't
840
00:49:54.409 --> 00:49:56.250
want to ruin my chances of getting a promotion. I
841
00:49:56.769 --> 00:49:58.329
don't want to get fired. I don't want to ruin
842
00:49:58.369 --> 00:50:00.670
my chances of like ruffling the feathers of that person
843
00:50:00.690 --> 00:50:02.989
who's above me. And everyone is kind of thinking the
844
00:50:03.030 --> 00:50:06.539
same thing, this kind of cowardly, Risk aversion to do
845
00:50:06.719 --> 00:50:10.480
anything internally in the party. So that disincentivizes internal party
846
00:50:10.579 --> 00:50:13.739
debate and democracy. And it's just that's why like, no,
847
00:50:13.780 --> 00:50:16.679
that's why I think we watch how slow it is
848
00:50:16.739 --> 00:50:20.079
for the Democratic Party to pivot, for example, on their messaging,
849
00:50:20.659 --> 00:50:23.469
because everybody is afraid to come out. So it's just
850
00:50:23.489 --> 00:50:26.130
a horrible thing. It's just a horrible, horrible system all
851
00:50:26.150 --> 00:50:26.530
the way down.
852
00:50:26.610 --> 00:50:28.889
There's a whole role for that, isn't there? They call
853
00:50:28.929 --> 00:50:31.230
them party whips. Those are the people who go around
854
00:50:31.269 --> 00:50:34.530
making sure that everybody's on message and on brand and
855
00:50:34.650 --> 00:50:34.929
on the points.
856
00:50:34.949 --> 00:50:36.250
Yeah, and they whip them if they don't.
857
00:50:36.869 --> 00:50:41.449
Yeah, they're called the party whips. I think what you're
858
00:50:41.489 --> 00:50:45.469
talking about, this paradox, he expresses it really well here,
859
00:50:45.860 --> 00:50:50.179
saying that the fundamental law of bureaucratic apparatuses is that
860
00:50:50.219 --> 00:50:51.619
their apparatus gives everything.
861
00:50:54.170 --> 00:50:58.809
To those who give it everything and expect everything from it.
862
00:50:59.960 --> 00:51:03.400
Or more simply, the apparatus depends most on those who
863
00:51:03.440 --> 00:51:06.559
most depend on it because they are the ones it
864
00:51:06.619 --> 00:51:11.559
holds most tightly in its clutches. So it expects every
865
00:51:11.619 --> 00:51:17.190
member to depend on it. And the party apparatus depends
866
00:51:17.269 --> 00:51:23.070
for its existence on the people depending completely on it
867
00:51:23.289 --> 00:51:27.219
and having no outside, nothing outside of it. They have
868
00:51:27.320 --> 00:51:33.420
nothing outside the apparatus. All their value comes from that.
869
00:51:33.699 --> 00:51:36.280
So then there becomes this tricky situation. So yeah, then
870
00:51:36.360 --> 00:51:40.909
how do you disagree with the party in a way
871
00:51:41.489 --> 00:51:47.030
that doesn't immediately get you exiled? You can't really do it.
872
00:51:48.289 --> 00:51:50.909
It's a paradox there. You have to have your own
873
00:51:50.989 --> 00:51:53.389
views and serve the interests of the people. But at
874
00:51:53.429 --> 00:51:56.369
the same time, your interests have to be tightly aligned
875
00:51:57.030 --> 00:52:02.170
with the other bureaucrats that you are constituting an apparatus with.
876
00:52:02.989 --> 00:52:06.159
And you can see that most clearly in like really
877
00:52:06.239 --> 00:52:11.519
tight organizations like the French Communist Party and like China
878
00:52:11.579 --> 00:52:14.980
and stuff like that, right? Like, yeah, everybody's free to
879
00:52:15.019 --> 00:52:17.900
think whatever they want as long as they think exactly
880
00:52:18.019 --> 00:52:20.969
what it is the party wants them to think. And
881
00:52:21.010 --> 00:52:24.050
you get this weird situation of like, then where does
882
00:52:24.090 --> 00:52:26.150
the direction of the party come from even in the
883
00:52:26.190 --> 00:52:30.260
first
place? I think he calls this, he calls this
884
00:52:30.280 --> 00:52:38.699
the organization effect, how people spontaneously coming together to organize
885
00:52:38.739 --> 00:52:43.070
a party sort of then flips into the party, calling
886
00:52:43.090 --> 00:52:46.510
the people together to, to the organization and the party
887
00:52:46.570 --> 00:52:49.469
taking the lead. It sort of flips into it. Like,
888
00:52:49.860 --> 00:52:53.480
If the Bolshevik Revolution and the formation of the Soviets
889
00:52:54.039 --> 00:52:57.300
and all of those things were people coming together spontaneously
890
00:52:58.360 --> 00:53:04.130
to organize and have collective action and form a revolution,
891
00:53:04.489 --> 00:53:07.769
once the organization is in place, the logic completely flips.
892
00:53:08.530 --> 00:53:12.389
And the party then becomes the be-all, end-all and demands
893
00:53:12.510 --> 00:53:16.380
everything from its members. And then he says, once it flips,
894
00:53:16.739 --> 00:53:19.920
it is the organization which calls meetings and And the
895
00:53:19.960 --> 00:53:25.710
participants serve, on the one hand, to demonstrate the representativeness
896
00:53:26.510 --> 00:53:29.050
of their representatives, and on the other hand, to ratify
897
00:53:29.090 --> 00:53:29.789
their decisions.
898
00:53:31.349 --> 00:53:40.289
When the party sort of takes over, especially because every
899
00:53:40.630 --> 00:53:44.739
system will tend towards a binary opposition, because now it's...
900
00:53:46.199 --> 00:53:48.860
at the long end point of a two-party system, or
901
00:53:48.920 --> 00:53:51.860
even a three-party system like we had prior.
902
00:53:51.980 --> 00:53:54.260
Like a parliamentary, coalition-based system.
903
00:53:54.739 --> 00:53:56.559
Yeah, but it's going to come down.
904
00:53:57.000 --> 00:54:01.219
You are going to be filtered by basically your two
905
00:54:01.300 --> 00:54:02.059
or three issues.
906
00:54:03.199 --> 00:54:07.989
Like what? Abortion and immigration? Is that?
907
00:54:08.349 --> 00:54:11.510
Immigration's big. Is that how you predict? The economy, whatever
908
00:54:11.550 --> 00:54:11.929
that means.
909
00:54:12.820 --> 00:54:13.360
Taxes.
910
00:54:13.730 --> 00:54:18.750
That's basically how you predict a Democrat or a Republican.
911
00:54:18.789 --> 00:54:21.909
Just ask them abortion and immigration.
912
00:54:21.929 --> 00:54:26.860
You'll be right 90% of the time because it's now
913
00:54:26.909 --> 00:54:31.960
the party's choosing the representatives. These are not institutions. I
914
00:54:32.000 --> 00:54:35.960
guess one of the things that's breaking is the Israel.
915
00:54:37.380 --> 00:54:40.500
That's one of the developments is that broke. If you
916
00:54:40.539 --> 00:54:47.320
have one organization that's dumping between 200 and 500 million
917
00:54:47.840 --> 00:54:52.260
into campaigns per election, then no one's going to want
918
00:54:52.300 --> 00:54:53.920
to be the hero. No one's going to want to
919
00:54:53.960 --> 00:54:56.659
be the brave one that says, hey, we shouldn't be
920
00:54:56.699 --> 00:55:00.179
doing this. So it takes sort of a dam breaking.
921
00:55:01.030 --> 00:55:02.050
Do you guys see that meme?
922
00:55:02.110 --> 00:55:07.170
It's like when we're saying that Abdul just wants Canada
923
00:55:07.389 --> 00:55:12.030
and Michigan. They spent, what, like 40 million? AIPAC spent
924
00:55:12.030 --> 00:55:17.389
40 million against him between the primary? If you compare
925
00:55:17.429 --> 00:55:20.550
that to Canada, I don't want to toot our horn
926
00:55:20.690 --> 00:55:24.980
so much, but the reason Canadian politics is so boring, relatively,
927
00:55:25.000 --> 00:55:30.800
is because the amount that AIPAC spent against Abdul El-Sayed
928
00:55:31.199 --> 00:55:33.679
is the max amount that a party can spend on
929
00:55:33.719 --> 00:55:34.780
an election.
930
00:55:35.519 --> 00:55:36.820
For the entire cycle.
931
00:55:37.519 --> 00:55:40.869
It's like 30, it's like, $ 40 million is what you're
932
00:55:40.889 --> 00:55:43.719
allowed to spend as a national party if you have
933
00:55:45.800 --> 00:55:47.760
a rep in every single riding.
934
00:55:48.119 --> 00:55:50.599
And our campaigns are obviously a lot shorter, which is nice, too.
935
00:55:50.639 --> 00:55:52.159
I mean, the fact that they last, like, I don't know,
936
00:55:52.159 --> 00:55:55.300
80 days max. Like, max. That's like a high end.
937
00:55:56.639 --> 00:55:58.829
That demonstrates, like, the.
938
00:56:00.090 --> 00:56:07.449
I think it's probably the efficacy of controlling finance, political spending,
939
00:56:07.690 --> 00:56:07.989
I guess.
940
00:56:08.460 --> 00:56:10.239
We still have a lot of the same problems in
941
00:56:10.280 --> 00:56:13.769
terms of lack of inspirational ideas and the same old,
942
00:56:13.780 --> 00:56:15.360
same old. Just on a smaller scale. But yeah.
943
00:56:16.079 --> 00:56:19.050
We have a mono party that's run by mining banks
944
00:56:19.119 --> 00:56:21.199
and the Rogers family.
945
00:56:21.219 --> 00:56:23.789
By the way, yeah. Yeah.
946
00:56:25.130 --> 00:56:27.530
It's not worse. I can tell you that. It's not worse.
947
00:56:27.550 --> 00:56:30.250
Did you guys see this meme that was right before
948
00:56:30.309 --> 00:56:32.269
the midterms? And it's like, I don't know if you
949
00:56:32.289 --> 00:56:35.389
know that cartoon guy who's sweating and he has two
950
00:56:35.429 --> 00:56:37.289
buttons in front of him of what to pick?
951
00:56:37.690 --> 00:56:37.809
Yeah.
952
00:56:38.440 --> 00:56:42.539
And one of them was like the Republican elephant. And
953
00:56:42.559 --> 00:56:45.900
then it said like openly Zionist, secretly gay. And then
954
00:56:45.940 --> 00:56:48.929
the other one, the donkey, it's like openly gay, secretly Zionist.
955
00:56:51.309 --> 00:56:54.630
I don't know how secret it is, but yeah.
956
00:56:54.650 --> 00:56:55.869
I'll just put it in the chat.
957
00:56:55.989 --> 00:56:59.309
That's another layer of like both the parties are the same.
958
00:57:00.750 --> 00:57:11.699
That's the hyper-reality of American politics is you filter into abortion... Anti-abortion, pro-immigration, anti-immigration, pro-abortion.
959
00:57:11.719 --> 00:57:13.320
I hope I said that right.
960
00:57:13.920 --> 00:57:16.320
And then if your team's not doing what you want,
961
00:57:16.360 --> 00:57:18.199
then you just don't hit the button that year. Then
962
00:57:18.239 --> 00:57:22.570
you just go out for dinner at the Cheesecake Factory
963
00:57:22.869 --> 00:57:23.530
on election day.
964
00:57:23.550 --> 00:57:25.269
Exactly.
965
00:57:25.949 --> 00:57:29.449
And then the needle just will bounce back and forth forever.
966
00:57:29.530 --> 00:57:32.639
It feels a little good. It feels a little bit better.
967
00:57:32.659 --> 00:57:34.139
I was just going to say, we should feel good
968
00:57:34.159 --> 00:57:37.639
about the catharsis and the and punishing people who suck
969
00:57:37.860 --> 00:57:39.860
a little bit. That should feel a little bit good.
970
00:57:39.889 --> 00:57:43.510
I like J.D. Vance being upset.
971
00:57:44.250 --> 00:57:47.210
Yes, I like that. I like people losing. It looks like,
972
00:57:47.230 --> 00:57:48.969
I don't know if you guys know who Lauren Boebert is,
973
00:57:49.010 --> 00:57:53.110
but she's a really annoying Republican congressman, and it looks
974
00:57:53.150 --> 00:57:55.940
like she's going to lose her seat in Colorado. So
975
00:57:55.980 --> 00:57:58.260
that's just little wins like that. It's like people who
976
00:57:58.300 --> 00:58:01.960
are really annoying losing is fun, right? And in a way,
977
00:58:01.980 --> 00:58:02.739
that's really all that matters.
978
00:58:03.840 --> 00:58:07.989
Speaking of Meltdown, you should check out Nick Land's Twitter feed.
979
00:58:08.010 --> 00:58:09.030
Oh, really?
980
00:58:09.050 --> 00:58:12.989
He's very upset, despite being a Brit.
981
00:58:13.429 --> 00:58:14.309
That's so weird.
982
00:58:15.570 --> 00:58:19.389
But he's a Brit living in China, I think?
983
00:58:19.530 --> 00:58:22.210
I didn't think that he would care. That's kind of weird.
984
00:58:22.670 --> 00:58:25.570
He says this is proof that the remnants of the
985
00:58:25.739 --> 00:58:28.300
Anglo race should go live in space.
986
00:58:28.440 --> 00:58:32.039
That's very cool. Very cool response.
987
00:58:32.679 --> 00:58:33.039
Yeah.
988
00:58:33.059 --> 00:58:37.519
That's so bizarre. That's extremely bizarre. Well, I can see,
989
00:58:37.599 --> 00:58:38.280
you know, yeah.
990
00:58:38.300 --> 00:58:40.440
Try and put data centers up there anyway.
991
00:58:40.940 --> 00:58:45.150
Stay off the speed, kids. Oh, big question.
992
00:58:45.210 --> 00:58:47.630
I would really like to know if we got some
993
00:58:47.670 --> 00:58:52.170
little smarties in the comment section. There was the
smallest
994
00:58:52.269 --> 00:58:56.389
dip ever on hyperscalers when it looked like the election
995
00:58:56.429 --> 00:58:59.139
was turning the other way, when it was showing.
996
00:58:58.929 --> 00:59:01.590
How hard it was going. And then the next morning,
997
00:59:01.670 --> 00:59:03.760
all the hyperscaler stocks are back up.
998
00:59:03.820 --> 00:59:05.539
But now they're back down again, I think, today.
999
00:59:05.960 --> 00:59:06.239
Are they?
1000
00:59:06.260 --> 00:59:09.110
I haven't checked today. I was too busy reading Bordeaux.
1001
00:59:10.239 --> 00:59:12.860
I think we got to read a little more of.
1002
00:59:13.260 --> 00:59:15.579
Yeah, I like him. I like him. I kind of knew.
1003
00:59:15.659 --> 00:59:18.400
I've always known that I would like him based on
1004
00:59:18.420 --> 00:59:21.199
what people told me. But I've never had the opportunity
1005
00:59:21.219 --> 00:59:21.579
to really.
1006
00:59:21.739 --> 00:59:24.880
I was just thinking he's got to be my favorite
1007
00:59:24.940 --> 00:59:25.840
French theorist.
1008
00:59:27.030 --> 00:59:27.309
Really?
1009
00:59:27.730 --> 00:59:29.730
Boring. I think so.
1010
00:59:31.360 --> 00:59:35.159
He's, no, he's, well, I don't know. Yeah, maybe it's
1011
00:59:35.199 --> 00:59:37.880
kind of lib of me. He does quote Marx enough, though,
1012
00:59:37.920 --> 00:59:40.079
for me to be happy and other people.
1013
00:59:41.139 --> 00:59:45.449
I think he's called the compatible left by the really serious.
1014
00:59:45.869 --> 00:59:46.789
By the communists.
1015
00:59:46.849 --> 00:59:48.130
The serious Marxists.
1016
00:59:48.829 --> 00:59:54.860
Yeah, he might be. I mean, his symbolic stance might
1017
00:59:54.900 --> 01:00:01.030
be interpreted as culturalist. and that things aren't really determined
1018
01:00:01.110 --> 01:00:05.050
by their material base, but actually through ideas and cultures
1019
01:00:05.090 --> 01:00:08.070
and worldviews, that might get a bit of a hit.
1020
01:00:09.070 --> 01:00:13.329
Wow, apparently. Yeah. On a lighter note, I'm just noticing
1021
01:00:13.349 --> 01:00:15.570
in my feed here that the Best Buy at the
1022
01:00:15.670 --> 01:00:18.929
Eden Center in downtown Toronto, there's apparently giant lineups for
1023
01:00:18.949 --> 01:00:23.130
the launch of the Zelda Ocarina of Time remake for
1024
01:00:23.170 --> 01:00:24.909
the Nintendo Switch 2.
1025
01:00:24.909 --> 01:00:26.550
Can you guys get some taste?
1026
01:00:27.389 --> 01:00:27.710
Amazing.
1027
01:00:27.750 --> 01:00:30.800
I mean, I love that game as much as anyone
1028
01:00:30.840 --> 01:00:33.599
who was eight years old when it came out.
1029
01:00:33.780 --> 01:00:34.460
But come on.
1030
01:00:34.739 --> 01:00:37.039
That'll take some of the focus off the launch of
1031
01:00:37.059 --> 01:00:37.599
the new.
1032
01:00:37.449 --> 01:00:40.610
World of Warcraft. They're just trying to recapture their childhood.
1033
01:00:40.750 --> 01:00:42.110
That's nostalgia.
1034
01:00:42.650 --> 01:00:43.050
Totally.
1035
01:00:43.389 --> 01:00:48.230
World of Warcraft just relaunched vanilla, basically, today, called World
1036
01:00:48.269 --> 01:00:50.630
of Warcraft Forever. Well, yesterday.
1037
01:00:51.329 --> 01:00:53.250
What's vanilla at the time of recording?
1038
01:00:53.570 --> 01:00:56.440
That was when World of Warcraft came out in the mid-2000s, 2000s.
1039
01:00:58.539 --> 01:01:01.239
I thought that one was still going.
1040
01:01:02.239 --> 01:01:06.630
Yeah, but it's had like 50 expansions and the level
1041
01:01:06.690 --> 01:01:10.269
cap has been raised. It's a completely different game. And
1042
01:01:10.309 --> 01:01:15.050
then they kept sort of vanilla going, like the 2000s
1043
01:01:15.090 --> 01:01:18.289
version in like a time capsule. And now they've sort
1044
01:01:18.349 --> 01:01:23.469
of cut the difference and made a new one. So whatever.
1045
01:01:25.010 --> 01:01:27.429
So the old one's still out.
1046
01:01:29.300 --> 01:01:32.519
Oh, and Dragon Ball Z is airing on TV again?
1047
01:01:32.719 --> 01:01:34.440
It's like the 2000s.
1048
01:01:36.179 --> 01:01:39.119
You pay for the new one that has less levels,
1049
01:01:39.760 --> 01:01:41.179
even though you can just play the old.
1050
01:01:41.519 --> 01:01:45.280
Oh, okay. I'm a boomer. I'm sorry. Yes, I am
1051
01:01:45.340 --> 01:01:46.230
seeing the stocks.
1052
01:01:46.969 --> 01:01:51.510
NVIDIA down 8% in the last five days. So we
1053
01:01:51.530 --> 01:01:57.230
see Microsoft, NVIDIA, Apple, Amazon all down as of this recording.
1054
01:01:58.059 --> 01:01:58.500
Interesting.
1055
01:01:59.219 --> 01:02:02.800
That's is, I wonder if that's the, uh, pushback against
1056
01:02:02.900 --> 01:02:06.079
the data centers causing that because video wants.
1057
01:02:05.920 --> 01:02:06.780
To sell the chips.
1058
01:02:08.099 --> 01:02:13.039
There was a peak yesterday on the fourth and then
1059
01:02:13.079 --> 01:02:16.780
a dip again on the fifth. Who knows the rational market.
1060
01:02:17.440 --> 01:02:20.780
Yeah. Rational market. Yeah, exactly. Um, yeah, it's a bit
1061
01:02:20.800 --> 01:02:24.400
of a fantasy. Uh, also, uh, just a quick little
1062
01:02:24.519 --> 01:02:26.159
funny tidbit too. Do you guys know that in the
1063
01:02:26.219 --> 01:02:30.679
Alaska Senate race? the democrats like kind of funded this
1064
01:02:30.739 --> 01:02:33.679
guy with the same name as the republican dan sullivan
1065
01:02:33.699 --> 01:02:34.900
to also be on the.
1066
01:02:35.320 --> 01:02:38.239
Ballot and uh so and then it's like 3 000
1067
01:02:38.239 --> 01:02:39.400
votes or something.
1068
01:02:39.079 --> 01:02:41.730
Yeah i got like 3 000 votes like so it's
1069
01:02:41.750 --> 01:02:44.489
pretty funny i think uh i saw some people saying
1070
01:02:44.510 --> 01:02:47.690
well good it's like a nice iq test for republicans.
1071
01:02:48.010 --> 01:02:49.710
See if they
could tell the difference.
1072
01:02:51.289 --> 01:02:54.619
On the well doesn't it say like incumbent like right
1073
01:02:54.639 --> 01:02:58.260
behind it yes yes it does but people are stupid.
1074
01:02:57.619 --> 01:03:01.750
Also clearly it'll clearly mark it yeah hey you gotta
1075
01:03:01.769 --> 01:03:02.750
play dirty.
1076
01:03:02.929 --> 01:03:04.809
You gotta play a bit dirty especially i mean the
1077
01:03:04.889 --> 01:03:07.949
the republicans will play dirty every single opportunity that they
1078
01:03:07.969 --> 01:03:08.710
can so.
1079
01:03:08.789 --> 01:03:11.530
Yeah isn't a lot of this was as a result
1080
01:03:11.690 --> 01:03:15.710
of of uh they gerrymandered too hard.
1081
01:03:15.760 --> 01:03:19.260
Right yeah exactly yeah people were upset about that supposedly
1082
01:03:19.300 --> 01:03:20.239
too but who knows.
1083
01:03:20.079 --> 01:03:24.840
Well they gerrymandered so hard that they're that their gerrymandered
1084
01:03:24.980 --> 01:03:28.519
districts then flipped because they made them less strong in
1085
01:03:28.539 --> 01:03:33.059
order to get other districts. Good job, Democrats. Try not
1086
01:03:33.099 --> 01:03:35.260
to suck balls this time.
1087
01:03:35.280 --> 01:03:38.260
Yeah, try not to disappoint us right away.
1088
01:03:38.989 --> 01:03:40.969
Who's the new speaker?
1089
01:03:40.989 --> 01:03:46.690
It'll be Hakeem Jeffries. Hakeem Jeffries, and it'll be in
1090
01:03:46.730 --> 01:03:47.190
the Senate.
1091
01:03:47.690 --> 01:03:49.889
Is he from Jersey or New York?
1092
01:03:50.610 --> 01:03:53.599
I think New York. And then, of course, in the Senate,
1093
01:03:53.619 --> 01:03:58.099
it's going to be boring, boring, stinky old. What's his name?
1094
01:03:58.159 --> 01:04:00.739
The Senate majority leader. I hate that guy. Schumer.
1095
01:04:00.760 --> 01:04:01.860
Chuck Schumer.
1096
01:04:02.059 --> 01:04:05.860
Chuck Schumer. Hopefully they change him.
1097
01:04:06.360 --> 01:04:07.679
Yeah. I don't think he's very well.
1098
01:04:07.840 --> 01:04:10.139
I think everyone hates him, and that'll be horrible to
1099
01:04:10.179 --> 01:04:10.739
keep around.
1100
01:04:11.079 --> 01:04:14.500
I mean, it's got to be said. The Republicans don't
1101
01:04:14.519 --> 01:04:18.760
want power. They want to complain about governing. Then they
1102
01:04:18.800 --> 01:04:23.099
caught the car. It was the worst thing for them.
1103
01:04:23.639 --> 01:04:26.039
Well, it's the same for everyone. Once they catch the car,
1104
01:04:26.079 --> 01:04:32.090
they all suck. But the difference is that Republicans are
1105
01:04:32.110 --> 01:04:34.530
better at complaining than Democrats, I feel like.
1106
01:04:35.210 --> 01:04:40.269
Yeah. Oh, definitely. I mean, everybody listen to the right-wing
1107
01:04:40.329 --> 01:04:45.570
pundits and just drink in the cope. It's going to
1108
01:04:45.639 --> 01:04:50.159
be massive. I think I was watching the Young Turks...
1109
01:04:50.869 --> 01:04:54.449
which is basically just a left-wing news organization, but they
1110
01:04:54.489 --> 01:04:55.829
yell everything at you instead.
1111
01:04:55.849 --> 01:04:57.710
Yeah, because of Cenk.
1112
01:04:59.489 --> 01:05:01.170
Because of the what?
1113
01:05:01.190 --> 01:05:01.710
Cenk Uygur.
1114
01:05:02.030 --> 01:05:04.670
He's like the main guy who yells. Oh, right.
1115
01:05:05.250 --> 01:05:07.409
Oh, I was going to say Anna does too, but yeah.
1116
01:05:07.449 --> 01:05:09.530
They talk about it.
1117
01:05:09.679 --> 01:05:13.840
They give you nice little sips of all the cope
1118
01:05:14.679 --> 01:05:15.239
from all the.
1119
01:05:16.159 --> 01:05:17.659
Have you guys checked what Tucker was saying?
1120
01:05:20.300 --> 01:05:27.360
They blame Tucker. Some of the right-wing pundits blame Tucker
1121
01:05:27.510 --> 01:05:30.829
and those sort of breakaway people who started opposing the
1122
01:05:30.889 --> 01:05:35.750
Israel war for demoralizing the right and causing them to
1123
01:05:35.829 --> 01:05:39.809
lose to the Democrats. That's one of the cope things,
1124
01:05:40.110 --> 01:05:41.610
is that it's all Tucker's fault.
1125
01:05:42.510 --> 01:05:43.130
Well, he's got to.
1126
01:05:43.110 --> 01:05:46.659
Be coming out of this with a smile, at least
1127
01:05:46.679 --> 01:05:49.809
while the camera's off, because he He turned early.
1128
01:05:49.869 --> 01:05:50.610
He turned first.
1129
01:05:52.329 --> 01:05:56.309
Yeah, he saw the way the wind was blowing, and
1130
01:05:56.369 --> 01:06:01.480
now the loyal ones are blaming him for changing the
1131
01:06:01.539 --> 01:06:06.860
way the wind is blowing. So that's interesting. It wasn't
1132
01:06:07.500 --> 01:06:13.050
Trump absolutely shitting on everybody. It was Tucker Carlson's fault, so.
1133
01:06:13.789 --> 01:06:15.000
Stay tuned for that kind of.
1134
01:06:15.449 --> 01:06:18.650
Tucker's got a nose, so it would be interesting if
1135
01:06:18.710 --> 01:06:21.750
with his nose he still backs J.D.
1136
01:06:21.949 --> 01:06:22.429
After this.
1137
01:06:23.070 --> 01:06:24.079
Yeah, he might hop on.
1138
01:06:25.400 --> 01:06:28.719
He's already there, I think, but I don't think he
1139
01:06:28.739 --> 01:06:30.719
can stay there if he wants to survive.
1140
01:06:31.420 --> 01:06:34.300
Get rid of Trump. Get rid of Trump.
1141
01:06:34.679 --> 01:06:37.130
Dumber things have happened. Trump doesn't give a shit, by
1142
01:06:37.170 --> 01:06:39.949
the way. Trump's just like, have you seen the marble
1143
01:06:39.989 --> 01:06:40.530
floors here?
1144
01:06:40.590 --> 01:06:43.260
Have you seen... No one, no one could get a
1145
01:06:43.280 --> 01:06:45.440
price for the marble like this. He just doesn't even
1146
01:06:45.460 --> 01:06:47.400
give a shit because he can't run next time.
1147
01:06:47.739 --> 01:06:50.159
He just puts a hat on that says Vito and
1148
01:06:50.280 --> 01:06:51.460
moves on. That's all.
1149
01:06:51.480 --> 01:06:52.519
He's the best.
1150
01:06:52.559 --> 01:06:53.840
Great job, Democrats.
1151
01:06:54.840 --> 01:06:57.619
Good job. Congrats. Have you seen these floors though? I
1152
01:06:57.619 --> 01:06:58.820
hope we can work together.
1153
01:07:00.199 --> 01:07:00.519
Yeah.
1154
01:07:01.940 --> 01:07:05.340
Wears his Vito hat and comments on what was he making?
1155
01:07:06.019 --> 01:07:09.219
That stuff that was doing the rounds before the midterms
1156
01:07:09.280 --> 01:07:14.889
when he commented on some guy's ass? Did you catch that?
1157
01:07:15.989 --> 01:07:16.159
No.
1158
01:07:17.179 --> 01:07:19.760
I've been reading the Desert Fathers, so I haven't had
1159
01:07:20.199 --> 01:07:23.099
the NBC tab open for very long. But anyway.
1160
01:07:23.460 --> 01:07:26.820
It's just an example of how poor their messaging was.
1161
01:07:27.639 --> 01:07:29.480
All right.
1162
01:07:29.559 --> 01:07:32.389
He doesn't give a shit about the party.
1163
01:07:32.409 --> 01:07:32.690
All right.
1164
01:07:32.710 --> 01:07:33.030
Cheers, guys.
1165
01:07:33.050 --> 01:07:35.550
Thanks for listening. Later. Later.