رونوشت 🔗
1
00:00:05,008 --> 00:00:06,262
Claudia: I had like done bits and bobs.
2
00:00:06,347 --> 00:00:13,877
Like I would download the Headspace app and do 20 minutes a day and do breath focus and all that kind of stuff.
3
00:00:13,937 --> 00:00:21,246
And that was very much in that, you know, oh, meditation for stress reduction, that kind of thing.
4
00:00:22,648 --> 00:00:25,038
Oshan: This is Claudia, a health and science journalist.
5
00:00:25,558 --> 00:00:30,588
And like millions of Americans, she first picked up meditation for the practical benefits.
6
00:00:31,725 --> 00:00:34,905
Claudia: If I sit and meditate for 20 minutes, I'll feel better afterwards.
7
00:00:34,905 --> 00:00:36,105
Like, I'll feel calmer.
8
00:00:36,215 --> 00:00:40,955
I'll know my heart rate will have decreased, I'll probably sleep better, all these things.
9
00:00:40,955 --> 00:00:47,953
But it was very much like I have to go through the boring thing sitting and counting my breath, and it's dull.
10
00:00:49,216 --> 00:00:56,576
Oshan: The popularity of basic mindfulness over the past decade or two has spread this story of meditation as a tool for stress reduction.
11
00:00:57,605 --> 00:00:58,665
And that's all true.
12
00:00:58,665 --> 00:01:01,105
A little meditation can be a nice and relaxing thing.
13
00:01:02,564 --> 00:01:05,705
But for thousands of years across different traditions,
14
00:01:05,705 --> 00:01:12,754
the stories that have been told about what meditation can do have centered around claims of deep psychological transformation:
15
00:01:13,434 --> 00:01:21,304
Fundamental shifts in how we experience ourselves and the world, astounding insights into the nature of the mind, and huge boosts in wellbeing.
16
00:01:22,943 --> 00:01:28,493
In Claudia's case, she'd taken a course on Buddhism in college, so she was aware of these deeper claims,
17
00:01:28,893 --> 00:01:34,603
but they didn't feel relevant for her practice as a contemporary Western person with a career and a family.
18
00:01:35,065 --> 00:01:41,155
Claudia: I knew intellectually because I've been exposed to it, that there was this incredible richness of meditation outside of that.
19
00:01:41,155 --> 00:01:46,666
But I guess I thought, oh, that's for people who are willing to commit their lives to this stuff.
20
00:01:46,741 --> 00:01:47,176
You know?
21
00:01:47,176 --> 00:01:55,197
I kind of thought, this is for people who were gonna change their name to something from like the Pali language and,
22
00:01:55,197 --> 00:01:57,516
spend years and years and years in a monastery.
23
00:01:57,516 --> 00:02:00,496
And I knew that was never going to be me.
24
00:02:01,333 --> 00:02:03,753
Oshan: But it was, in fact, going to be her.
25
00:02:04,803 --> 00:02:07,597
Claudia did not change her name and go live in a monastery,
26
00:02:07,597 --> 00:02:13,563
but she did have a transformative meditation experience that led to things she never thought were possible for her,
27
00:02:13,823 --> 00:02:17,723
and completely blew open the kind of practice she understood meditation to be.
28
00:02:19,175 --> 00:02:22,595
Claudia: I get back home and I have a really, like challenging Christmas.
29
00:02:22,595 --> 00:02:26,345
It's the first one where my mom who had just died wasn't there.
30
00:02:26,425 --> 00:02:30,175
Me and my family were all just like feeling horrible.
31
00:02:30,775 --> 00:02:35,795
And I went back from my family home in the north of England, came back to London where I live.
32
00:02:36,575 --> 00:02:40,775
And I sat down and literally had the thought: I am gonna get somewhere with this.
33
00:02:40,805 --> 00:02:43,385
I was like, I am going to get somewhere today.
34
00:02:43,415 --> 00:02:44,825
Because I need something.
35
00:02:44,855 --> 00:02:48,371
Like, that was this awful experience and I'm gonna crack something today.
36
00:02:49,034 --> 00:02:53,634
Oshan: So Claudia goes to the citadel of contemporary meditation teachings, YouTube.
37
00:02:54,730 --> 00:02:57,165
Claudia: And I just typed in non-dual meditation.
38
00:02:57,215 --> 00:02:59,225
And I clicked on the first thing that came up.
39
00:03:00,125 --> 00:03:02,195
It was like a 15 minute meditation.
40
00:03:02,965 --> 00:03:10,915
And I just sat down and started following along, and then the guy narrating it just goes: How do you know you have a head?
41
00:03:13,045 --> 00:03:25,692
And something just, I had this intense experience of feeling what felt like the little person, the little me in my head,
42
00:03:25,692 --> 00:03:29,755
sitting behind my eyes and controlling everything.
43
00:03:30,700 --> 00:03:37,529
I had this incredible visual of that person just like going back and going down my neck
44
00:03:37,529 --> 00:03:42,689
And just like disappearing into the cavernous blackness of the inside of my body.
45
00:03:43,202 --> 00:03:47,282
And just joining the rest of my being.
46
00:03:48,585 --> 00:03:53,735
I just started to cry because I just had this feeling of oh my God, they're right.
47
00:03:54,465 --> 00:03:57,905
All these podcasts I'd listen to with people being like.
48
00:03:58,070 --> 00:04:06,193
You know who you really are is not this little gremlin in your head telling you to like, be better and do the things and,
49
00:04:06,193 --> 00:04:08,780
hey, do you remember when that girl was mean to you?
50
00:04:08,780 --> 00:04:11,780
And you were 10 and all this nonsense?
51
00:04:12,170 --> 00:04:14,900
And I was just like, oh my God, they're fucking right.
52
00:04:15,000 --> 00:04:21,970
And it was just the most incredible, revelatory experience.
53
00:04:22,060 --> 00:04:23,882
And I was like in shock.
54
00:04:23,928 --> 00:04:28,712
It was the first time I really understood missionary religion where I was like, I need to go and tell everyone.
55
00:04:32,359 --> 00:04:34,779
Oshan: Claudia's is not an isolated experience.
56
00:04:35,339 --> 00:04:43,879
Sometimes on purpose, sometimes by surprise, all kinds of
Load full transcript
meditators are discovering these experiences that completely change how they think about meditation.
57
00:04:44,529 --> 00:04:49,149
And more importantly, that completely change the ways they believe it's possible to feel.
58
00:04:49,949 --> 00:04:53,799
They change their understanding of how their minds work, or can work.
59
00:04:54,786 --> 00:04:57,666
Claudia: In my culture where I live, people don't know about this.
60
00:04:57,666 --> 00:05:02,166
People think of meditation in this head spacey, stress reduction way, but like.
61
00:05:02,781 --> 00:05:03,531
Oh my God.
62
00:05:03,531 --> 00:05:06,621
You can feel like you are on fantastic MDMA guys.
63
00:05:06,621 --> 00:05:07,401
Like, did you know?
64
00:05:11,452 --> 00:05:12,342
Oshan: I'm Oshan Jarow.
65
00:05:13,022 --> 00:05:14,272
I'm a writer and journalist.
66
00:05:14,732 --> 00:05:21,322
And this is episode one of Pivot Points, a podcast series about transformative meditation experiences.
67
00:05:26,941 --> 00:05:30,121
I've been around meditation one way or another for most of my life.
68
00:05:30,971 --> 00:05:34,781
My father was a professor of religion with a focus on Indian traditions.
69
00:05:35,041 --> 00:05:38,371
So growing up, our house was filled with meditators of all stripes.
70
00:05:39,321 --> 00:05:45,431
I've had my own meditation practice on and off for about 12 years now, and I've been all over the map.
71
00:05:46,251 --> 00:05:50,611
At times, I've thought of meditation as one of the most important practices of my life.
72
00:05:51,251 --> 00:05:55,591
I've also gone through phases of seeing it as mostly a navel-gazing waste of my time.
73
00:05:57,061 --> 00:06:02,091
As a journalist, I've spent years covering the science and growing culture of meditation in the West.
74
00:06:02,506 --> 00:06:10,151
And through that time, something I've seen over and over is that Claudia's discovery of this whole other world of meditation experience,
75
00:06:10,151 --> 00:06:16,516
one that goes well beyond anything that the popular story of mindfulness and stress relief covers, is surprisingly common.
76
00:06:17,556 --> 00:06:24,496
But at the same time, the popular stories our culture tells about what meditation is still haven't updated to reflect that.
77
00:06:25,523 --> 00:06:29,123
Instead, we have these two seemingly separate worlds of meditation.
78
00:06:29,703 --> 00:06:32,887
There's the world of beginner's mindfulness, which is in the cultural spotlight,
79
00:06:32,887 --> 00:06:38,603
and then there's this whole other obscure world of deep meditation or advanced meditation.
80
00:06:39,453 --> 00:06:45,383
And even though all the really interesting, exciting stuff happens in the latter world of deep meditation,
81
00:06:45,913 --> 00:06:49,253
most of our attention has gone to the former world of beginner's mindfulness.
82
00:06:49,871 --> 00:06:56,121
So as both a meditator and a journalist, I've spent a lot of time thinking about the boundaries between these two worlds.
83
00:06:56,901 --> 00:07:02,833
What is it that separates the hundreds of millions of Westerners who engage with meditation apps and mindfulness
84
00:07:02,833 --> 00:07:05,254
and think about it all as a form of stress relief,
85
00:07:05,254 --> 00:07:11,321
from the people who think about meditation as one of the most profound and transformative practices in their lives?
86
00:07:12,491 --> 00:07:15,771
Because it's not a matter of how much time you've spent meditating.
87
00:07:16,501 --> 00:07:20,650
You can launch into the deep end in your first 10 hours of practice ever,
88
00:07:20,650 --> 00:07:24,271
or it could take 10 years before anything remotely transformative happens.
89
00:07:25,609 --> 00:07:32,179
What does seem to separate the two worlds of meditation, and determine the kind of thing someone understands meditation to be,
90
00:07:32,179 --> 00:07:38,629
is whether they've had a direct experience that showed them, firsthand, how weird it can get.
91
00:07:39,289 --> 00:07:41,989
How fundamentally meditation can change your mind.
92
00:07:43,099 --> 00:07:52,889
And the more I've researched these kinds of experiences, or glimpses, the more they've coalesced into a single category, which I've started calling pivot points.
93
00:07:54,809 --> 00:08:01,759
You can think of pivot points as meditation experiences that people would describe not as relaxing, but transformative.
94
00:08:02,519 --> 00:08:07,107
And for this series, I'm specifically interested in the first pivot point,
95
00:08:07,107 --> 00:08:12,239
the first time that someone has a meditation experience that changes what they think is possible.
96
00:08:12,779 --> 00:08:16,259
Because that's where we get this jump between the two worlds of meditation.
97
00:08:18,002 --> 00:08:21,188
There's no single description for what these experiences are like.
98
00:08:21,888 --> 00:08:26,348
They might feel like insights into some obscure but fundamental aspect of the mind.
99
00:08:26,988 --> 00:08:31,338
They might feel like a sudden eruption of bliss across your entire field of awareness.
100
00:08:31,978 --> 00:08:39,118
They might involve the usual anchors of experience, like a sense of self or space or time, temporarily vanishing.
101
00:08:40,248 --> 00:08:48,348
And while the majority of these experiences tend to be positive, they can also be destabilizing, dissociative, or just generally terrible.
102
00:08:49,798 --> 00:08:55,638
But whatever the details of someone's particular experience, pivot points do have a few common threads.
103
00:08:57,108 --> 00:09:00,288
They're completely unlike anything we're used to experiencing.
104
00:09:00,998 --> 00:09:04,318
They're sharp breaks from our ordinary habits of perception.
105
00:09:05,298 --> 00:09:11,898
And because of that, they tend to feel anything from confusing and shocking, to exciting or compelling.
106
00:09:12,388 --> 00:09:14,858
They're often described as feeling like discoveries.
107
00:09:16,278 --> 00:09:24,378
And even though people will often describe these experiences as some of the most significant experiences in their lives, they're really difficult to talk about.
108
00:09:25,148 --> 00:09:29,718
And contemplative traditions have generally cautioned against putting too much focus on them.
109
00:09:30,778 --> 00:09:34,458
As a result, we in the West know surprisingly little about them.
110
00:09:36,415 --> 00:09:45,765
So this series is gonna focus directly on pivot points, which I think of as gateways from a beginner's meditation practice into the deep end.
111
00:09:49,308 --> 00:09:55,289
Last summer, I put out a survey across the internet to see if I could find meditators who've had these experiences
112
00:09:55,289 --> 00:09:58,198
and who'd be up for recording a conversation about them.
113
00:09:58,746 --> 00:10:03,206
Alex: And it feels like I am on literally the best super drug known to man.
114
00:10:03,386 --> 00:10:08,991
That was a life-changing moment for me, to recognize that, I didn't know that you could feel like that.
115
00:10:08,991 --> 00:10:12,561
Emily: And that was by far the most crazy.
116
00:10:12,651 --> 00:10:18,241
Like it just got so, really far beyond what I thought was possible.
117
00:10:18,494 --> 00:10:30,449
Charlie: Just a sense of my whole body having been almost like a fire hose had just been put up through my entire system and totally cleaned out.
118
00:10:30,449 --> 00:10:32,976
And I was left in shock amazement.
119
00:10:34,095 --> 00:10:36,848
Oshan: So the first step in this series, picking up in episode two,
120
00:10:36,848 --> 00:10:44,235
is gonna be hearing these stories directly from meditators to help answer the question: What does a pivot point feel like?
121
00:10:45,585 --> 00:10:49,135
But my goal isn't just to collect a bunch of weird meditation reports.
122
00:10:49,795 --> 00:10:55,289
If you've ever had the pleasure of listening to a friend excitedly tell you about the weird dream they had,
123
00:10:55,289 --> 00:10:59,655
you'll know that reports of other people's weird experiences can get boring very quickly.
124
00:11:00,324 --> 00:11:07,446
The reason I wanna focus on pivot points is that even though they may be most interesting and impactful to the people having them,
125
00:11:07,446 --> 00:11:09,834
I think they're informative for all of us.
126
00:11:10,556 --> 00:11:18,036
There's a lot we can learn from them about deepening a meditation practice, but also deepening our understanding of how the mind works.
127
00:11:19,076 --> 00:11:25,108
So to that end, I also interviewed scientists who study advanced meditation, who we'll hear from in episode three,
128
00:11:25,108 --> 00:11:30,526
and meditation teachers who've seen thousands of these experiences play out across their students.
129
00:11:31,026 --> 00:11:32,566
We'll hear from them in episode four.
130
00:11:33,506 --> 00:11:39,026
And in episode five, we'll take a step back to ask what
comes after a pivot point?
131
00:11:39,686 --> 00:11:41,516
Or as a meditator named Carla put it:
132
00:11:42,100 --> 00:11:45,430
Carla: So what, that's my big question all the time.
133
00:11:45,430 --> 00:11:45,940
So what.
134
00:11:46,490 --> 00:11:49,710
I had the explosive love experience, you know, so what.
135
00:11:51,125 --> 00:11:52,895
How does that change somebody's life?
136
00:11:54,104 --> 00:11:57,916
Oshan: Some contemplative traditions have concepts that are similar to pivot points.
137
00:11:58,391 --> 00:12:03,083
Theravada Buddhism has stream entry, which is the first of their four stages of awakening.
138
00:12:03,804 --> 00:12:12,641
It's traditionally defined as an experience that destroys three things: the meditator's belief in their existence as a separate self,
139
00:12:12,641 --> 00:12:21,092
their doubt in the Buddhist teachings, and the idea that rigid adherence to doctrinal rules and rituals will bring about awakening.
140
00:12:22,182 --> 00:12:27,825
Zen has kensho, which is a sudden falling away of your identification as a separate self,
141
00:12:27,825 --> 00:12:32,940
discovering an underlying unitary experience that Zen calls your original nature.
142
00:12:33,991 --> 00:12:39,084
So both stream entry and kensho refer to very particular kinds of experience.
143
00:12:39,545 --> 00:12:43,875
There's a set of criteria, and if your experience doesn't fit the profile, it doesn't count.
144
00:12:44,754 --> 00:12:47,436
Pivot points aren't as strict in their criteria.
145
00:12:47,814 --> 00:12:51,943
They're a much broader category that can include very different kinds of experience.
146
00:12:52,669 --> 00:13:00,905
Tibetan Buddhism talks about nyams or special meditation experiences, altered states that sometimes arise over the course of practice.
147
00:13:01,536 --> 00:13:06,355
These can be blissful and exciting, and a nyam could certainly be a pivot point.
148
00:13:06,936 --> 00:13:09,311
But a meditator can have any number of nyams.
149
00:13:09,338 --> 00:13:11,499
There's no distinction for the first one.
150
00:13:12,200 --> 00:13:19,500
So pivot points defined as someone's first transformative meditation experience, isn't really a well-established concept.
151
00:13:20,380 --> 00:13:24,270
Which is why I wanted to talk to meditators, scientists, and teachers.
152
00:13:24,760 --> 00:13:27,850
Because each perspective fills in a different part of the picture.
153
00:13:29,822 --> 00:13:34,253
The meditators tended to describe pivot points as these exciting moments
154
00:13:34,253 --> 00:13:40,342
where they discovered that there's actually something to all of this crazy stuff they might have heard about meditation.
155
00:13:41,827 --> 00:13:43,897
Sean: The sense of a pivot point.
156
00:13:45,052 --> 00:13:49,672
Was this moment of, holy crap, this is real.
157
00:13:50,332 --> 00:13:54,802
Because again, I knew that there was something there objectively.
158
00:13:55,462 --> 00:14:01,760
But I
was giving benefit of the doubts to all of these descriptions, which can sound quite,
159
00:14:01,760 --> 00:14:11,863
unscientific or extremely vulnerable to the entire list of psychological fallacies and, you know, self delusion and all of that confirmation bias.
160
00:14:12,373 --> 00:14:19,749
So I think regardless of trying to be open-minded and regardless of being motivated to find something that I logically knew was there,
161
00:14:19,749 --> 00:14:21,703
there was always this very strong skepticism.
162
00:14:22,693 --> 00:14:26,263
Until this moment of actually directly experiencing this.
163
00:14:26,997 --> 00:14:31,202
Max: The first pivot point is probably the one where, like me, people are gonna say, well,
164
00:14:31,202 --> 00:14:35,124
I've been using this car here for like 20 or 30 something years,
165
00:14:35,124 --> 00:14:39,222
and suddenly I push a button and there's like wings come out and I think, oh, it could do this.
166
00:14:40,281 --> 00:14:47,981
Oshan: Scientists describe pivot points as experiences that change how the mind constructs our experience of the world.
167
00:14:49,031 --> 00:14:55,861
For example, here's Ruben Laukkonen, a cognitive scientist and director of the Flourishing Intelligence Program at the University of Oxford.
168
00:14:56,632 --> 00:15:10,423
Ruben: I would describe a pivot point as a major restructuring in the models that underlie our understanding of the world, ourselves and experience.
169
00:15:11,673 --> 00:15:20,765
Oshan: Ruben described the mind as a house of cards and pivot points as experiences that reach down into those lower levels, pluck out a card,
170
00:15:20,765 --> 00:15:26,193
and force everything it was holding up to rebuild in a way that makes room for this new experience.
171
00:15:27,350 --> 00:15:30,950
Ruben: It's not such a big impact on that House of cards.
172
00:15:30,950 --> 00:15:36,871
If you take cards off the top of the deck and you replace them with new cards, you can gradually do that,
173
00:15:36,871 --> 00:15:38,850
and change the deck of cards that way.
174
00:15:39,330 --> 00:15:44,550
But it is a big deal if you pull out one of the cards at the bottom of that.
175
00:15:44,730 --> 00:15:46,350
That house that you've constructed.
176
00:15:46,980 --> 00:15:52,768
Because basically the whole thing comes, crashing down and when it reemerges,
177
00:15:52,768 --> 00:15:59,790
it doesn't reemerge in the same way that it was just a moment prior, to that important realization.
178
00:16:00,360 --> 00:16:11,645
And so I think a pivot point is when the meditation practice hits us somewhere deep enough that our understanding of reality has to change.
179
00:16:14,689 --> 00:16:19,859
Oshan: What was really fun about this project was hearing the echoes of the same ideas across perspectives.
180
00:16:20,549 --> 00:16:26,839
So when I asked the Zen meditation teacher Henry Shukman whether he's noticed any patterns across all of his students
181
00:16:26,839 --> 00:16:28,759
who've had these kinds of experiences.
182
00:16:29,343 --> 00:16:36,653
Henry: Yeah, I'd say there's a common theme, which is some variation of oh my gosh, I've been wrong.
183
00:16:38,033 --> 00:16:45,803
About whatever it is, about an emotion I thought I had to feel, or a thought pattern that I just couldn't shake off.
184
00:16:45,893 --> 00:16:51,653
Or, some discovery that the perspective I've had.
185
00:16:52,328 --> 00:16:54,788
Was not the only way of looking at life.
186
00:16:55,585 --> 00:17:03,095
Oshan: In other words, just like Ruben described, your understanding of what reality is, and what reality can be, changes.
187
00:17:08,018 --> 00:17:14,388
So to help demonstrate what a pivot point is, there's one more story I wanna tell you about a lawyer from Iowa.
188
00:17:15,537 --> 00:17:16,917
Matt: My name is Matt James.
189
00:17:17,017 --> 00:17:22,867
I am 50 years old and I am an attorney working in the realm of contracts.
190
00:17:23,551 --> 00:17:27,691
Oshan: Growing up, Matt read a few books on Buddhism, mostly out of curiosity.
191
00:17:27,701 --> 00:17:34,371
He didn't try to actually start meditating himself until well into adulthood when his job had started to grind him down.
192
00:17:34,936 --> 00:17:35,986
Matt: I was a prosecutor.
193
00:17:36,416 --> 00:17:40,016
In Illinois, and that was a very stressful job.
194
00:17:40,412 --> 00:17:44,502
Dealing with, criminals and putting people in jail potentially.
195
00:17:44,962 --> 00:17:49,312
And I dealt a lot with victims of crime, which made it even more stressful.
196
00:17:49,812 --> 00:17:55,398
So, you know, overall, I just started to get depressed, and feel down.
197
00:17:55,398 --> 00:17:56,538
I was drinking a lot.
198
00:17:56,678 --> 00:17:59,343
I was watching a lot of television and just trying to cope.
199
00:18:00,065 --> 00:18:04,505
And I remember just sitting down one day and I'm like, I just, I can't do this anymore.
200
00:18:04,505 --> 00:18:05,675
I gotta change something.
201
00:18:06,185 --> 00:18:12,630
And I remembered back to when I had read those books about meditation and I thought, well,
202
00:18:12,630 --> 00:18:15,535
why don't I give this a shot and see how it goes.
203
00:18:16,035 --> 00:18:22,255
Oshan: So Matt decides to try meditating, and he proceeds to have an incredibly common experience.
204
00:18:22,954 --> 00:18:23,734
Matt: It was terrible.
205
00:18:23,764 --> 00:18:24,394
It was awful.
206
00:18:24,394 --> 00:18:26,764
It was so boring.
207
00:18:26,874 --> 00:18:32,374
And all these thoughts in my head and I couldn't sit still, for more than a few minutes.
208
00:18:32,374 --> 00:18:36,289
And a lot of it was just me just sitting there checking the time.
209
00:18:36,569 --> 00:18:40,459
I think the first meditation I did, five minutes, I thought it was like five years.
210
00:18:40,459 --> 00:18:41,629
It seemed like an eternity.
211
00:18:42,089 --> 00:18:45,509
I did not have any
wonderful experiences.
212
00:18:45,509 --> 00:18:49,719
I had a lot of boredom, a lot of discomfort, and a lot of thinking.
213
00:18:50,898 --> 00:18:54,938
Oshan: But remember, Matt was not in a good place, so he stuck with it.
214
00:18:55,758 --> 00:19:02,878
And even in those early days when the practice itself was terrible and boring, he was finding just enough benefit to keep going.
215
00:19:03,205 --> 00:19:07,405
Matt: Even if you're not a very good meditator, your mind will start to calm and settle down.
216
00:19:07,865 --> 00:19:13,535
Just following through with the meditation and the instructions, and so on.
217
00:19:13,535 --> 00:19:20,065
So I saw that there was something there, that was worth pursuing a little bit more,
218
00:19:20,175 --> 00:19:22,678
Oshan: But even so, Matt was still a lawyer
219
00:19:22,678 --> 00:19:28,455
which meant he was skeptical of the claims Buddhism made about what deeper practice could actually do for him.
220
00:19:29,206 --> 00:19:32,146
Matt: I don't believe anything that I'm told.
221
00:19:32,446 --> 00:19:33,376
You know, period.
222
00:19:33,376 --> 00:19:36,616
I'm a lawyer too, so I always need to see, I always need to see it.
223
00:19:37,036 --> 00:19:39,491
For example, in Theravada they talk about the no self.
224
00:19:40,441 --> 00:19:46,511
And you know, how the self is an illusion, but my issue was well then, but what?
225
00:19:46,511 --> 00:19:47,651
What's seeing all this?
226
00:19:48,131 --> 00:19:52,871
You know, if there's no self, what am I like, am I like a rock or a sponge or something?
227
00:19:52,931 --> 00:19:54,071
It doesn't make any sense.
228
00:19:54,661 --> 00:19:59,858
Oshan: So Matt goes on in this pattern for years, with the meditation slightly calming his mind,
229
00:19:59,858 --> 00:20:07,831
but the bigger claims about the more transformative stuff just not making any sense, until he goes on a meditation retreat in West Virginia.
230
00:20:09,169 --> 00:20:17,839
The meditation center was in a quiet, rural setting, and while everyone was silently meditating indoors, a neighbor started doing yard work.
231
00:20:19,029 --> 00:20:24,044
Matt: There was a farmer next door who would occasionally bring out the chainsaw.
232
00:20:24,324 --> 00:20:26,124
Or had a dog barking.
233
00:20:26,554 --> 00:20:29,644
And I was listening to these things and I was getting aggravated.
234
00:20:29,914 --> 00:20:31,204
It's like I'm meditating.
235
00:20:31,254 --> 00:20:33,364
Can somebody go tell that person to be quiet?
236
00:20:33,404 --> 00:20:38,407
And the usual habit is this is a problem, but then what is, quote,
237
00:20:38,407 --> 00:20:46,204
the problem becomes the helper to boost you up, through whatever you're working with.
238
00:20:46,774 --> 00:20:55,744
And what I had realized was I was hearing sound, but the sound wasn't taking place at the location of my ears.
239
00:20:56,584 --> 00:20:58,774
And it, that's where your eardrum is, right?
240
00:20:58,774 --> 00:21:00,004
Like your ear is pumping.
241
00:21:01,044 --> 00:21:03,054
That's where the sound is entering the body.
242
00:21:03,864 --> 00:21:08,364
But I could hear the sound off in the distance over there.
243
00:21:08,574 --> 00:21:11,374
And I started switching between the two.
244
00:21:11,854 --> 00:21:12,754
It's like, how can this be?
245
00:21:12,754 --> 00:21:15,874
My ears are here and the sound is over there.
246
00:21:16,719 --> 00:21:20,059
It then just in a flash, everything reversed.
247
00:21:20,439 --> 00:21:27,864
So instead of becoming a person in space listening to external sounds coming in.
248
00:21:28,949 --> 00:21:30,129
It was like it flipped.
249
00:21:30,979 --> 00:21:36,619
It just happened spontaneously and it's kind of like, foreground background reversal.
250
00:21:36,979 --> 00:21:42,589
So the spacious awareness that was in the background was suddenly in the foreground.
251
00:21:42,949 --> 00:21:50,389
And the objects all seemed, rather than me looking at an object, it was like all these objects were just arising in this spaciousness.
252
00:21:51,079 --> 00:21:55,059
And at the middle of it there wasn't a person there.
253
00:21:55,989 --> 00:21:59,979
It was, well, this is no self.
254
00:22:00,009 --> 00:22:01,299
Oh, okay.
255
00:22:01,389 --> 00:22:03,249
So, you know,
256
00:22:05,572 --> 00:22:07,052
Oshan: This was Matt's pivot point.
257
00:22:07,732 --> 00:22:13,597
And like Claudia's, it completely changed pretty much on the spot what he understood meditation to be
258
00:22:13,597 --> 00:22:15,752
and the kind of stuff he believed it could do.
259
00:22:16,969 --> 00:22:18,960
Matt: But it, oh my gosh, it was amazing.
260
00:22:18,990 --> 00:22:22,770
Because you can have these concepts about what no self is.
261
00:22:23,415 --> 00:22:26,145
Or about what a meditation experience would be like.
262
00:22:26,145 --> 00:22:27,405
But those are just concepts.
263
00:22:27,405 --> 00:22:32,805
Those are just words on a page and mental images you're creating in your mind.
264
00:22:32,995 --> 00:22:38,095
When it arises, it's unlike everything that you've heard about.
265
00:22:38,385 --> 00:22:39,915
It's like waking up from the Matrix.
266
00:22:39,915 --> 00:22:42,465
It's like everything you've been told is not true.
267
00:22:42,805 --> 00:22:44,395
What you thought was real is a dream.
268
00:22:45,275 --> 00:22:50,925
My mind was so blown because I wasn't expecting it and it was so visceral,
269
00:22:50,925 --> 00:23:01,755
it was so vivid and it was so undeniable that I thought, how could I have ever existed in any other way?
270
00:23:03,850 --> 00:23:12,020
Oshan: Afterwards, Matt's experience of what meditating is like opened up into a far stranger palette of experiences than the calm of mindfulness.
271
00:23:12,611 --> 00:23:18,851
Matt: This is the retreat where I started to have a lot of involuntary movements, a lot of energetic sensations.
272
00:23:19,221 -->
00:23:27,051
A lot of what you would call the temporary meditation experiences that people, we often get addicted to, like the candy of meditation.
273
00:23:27,501 --> 00:23:32,648
And, this is when I saw really,
274
00:23:32,648 --> 00:23:41,781
that we were dealing with something very deep and very profound and very true that could be experienced directly.
275
00:23:42,574 --> 00:23:48,904
And strangely enough, looking back at my notes, 'cause I think back on this as a pivot in my meditation practice,
276
00:23:48,904 --> 00:23:55,358
this is where I went from a meditation hobbyist, a person who did this from time to time to like, oh my God,
277
00:23:55,358 --> 00:24:00,724
this is like something that people can actually dedicate their lives to.
278
00:24:01,178 --> 00:24:03,458
This is important and this is very serious.
279
00:24:07,513 --> 00:24:11,123
Oshan: Every one of my interviews were stories like Matt's or Claudia's,
280
00:24:11,483 --> 00:24:17,803
where people start out thinking that their meditation practice will never be anything other than mildly relaxing.
281
00:24:18,673 --> 00:24:26,343
Then they have a pivot point, and afterwards, they've flipped to thinking of their meditation practice as a much more profound one.
282
00:24:27,923 --> 00:24:32,291
To be transparent about my own interest in this project, as a meditator,
283
00:24:32,291 --> 00:24:42,112
I've always been fascinated by these experiences because of how they seem to dispel any doubt in the deep and transformative value of meditation practice.
284
00:24:42,874 --> 00:24:48,891
Because the longer that I've meditated, the more I've had that sense of doubt creep into my own practice.
285
00:24:49,844 --> 00:24:56,254
It's not that I'm unsure whether these experiences are real or if deep meditation can really transform one's mind.
286
00:24:56,724 --> 00:25:03,064
I think that becomes pretty clear when you spend time around meditation communities or these days just on the right subreddit.
287
00:25:03,964 --> 00:25:07,434
And some of the experiences we'll hear in this series are ones that I've had myself.
288
00:25:08,294 --> 00:25:16,914
But I've struggled with the question of whether these transformations of mind are really worth spending so much of my time meditating.
289
00:25:18,144 --> 00:25:23,704
Because in a sense, everything you do transforms your mind in ways small and occasionally large.
290
00:25:24,114 --> 00:25:29,894
So what's so special, so worthwhile about the kinds of changes that deep meditation offers?
291
00:25:31,020 --> 00:25:38,305
In a way, where you fall on this question, whether you're convinced of the particular value of the way that meditation can transform your mind,
292
00:25:38,305 --> 00:25:42,340
has always been a dividing line between the two worlds of meditation.
293
00:25:43,580 --> 00:25:51,050
In the Tibetan Buddhist Mahamudra tradition, there's a 16th century practice manual titled Clarifying the Natural State.
294
00:25:51,760 --> 00:25:57,780
And right at the outset, it addresses itself to, quote, "Those who have had the occasion to believe.
295
00:25:58,720 --> 00:26:02,580
That phrase has stuck with me through this whole project: occasions to believe.
296
00:26:03,540 --> 00:26:09,800
Contemplative traditions all have to deal with this question: How do you generate belief in the value of the practice?
297
00:26:10,930 --> 00:26:17,150
Contemporary Buddhist monks like Bhikkhu Bodhi have pointed out the role of faith in the Buddha's teachings.
298
00:26:17,920 --> 00:26:24,879
Bodhi writes that in Buddhist scripture, "The faculty of faith provides the element of inspiration and aspiration,
299
00:26:24,879 --> 00:26:28,210
which steers the mind away from the quagmire of doubt."
300
00:26:29,670 --> 00:26:37,590
And in predominantly Buddhist cultures, faith in the Buddha's teachings, in the value of deep meditation, is a widespread cultural practice.
301
00:26:38,452 --> 00:26:40,782
But in the West, we have a different situation.
302
00:26:42,402 --> 00:26:46,712
We lean on empirical evidence and science rather than religious traditions.
303
00:26:47,132 --> 00:26:50,342
Doubt and falsifiability are wired into our culture.
304
00:26:51,002 --> 00:26:57,042
And until very recently, the science of meditation has mostly focused on the world of beginner's mindfulness.
305
00:26:57,642 --> 00:27:02,452
So we don't have a bunch of research on which to base our belief in what deep meditation can do.
306
00:27:03,882 --> 00:27:10,472
So the question that I've been wrestling with in my own practice, maybe unsurprisingly, has become a question behind this whole series.
307
00:27:11,248 --> 00:27:16,068
How do people in the West become convinced of the value of deep meditation?
308
00:27:17,298 --> 00:27:20,428
If not faith, what are our occasions to believe?
309
00:27:21,842 --> 00:27:28,202
The most common, compelling, and yet neglected answer that I've come across is pivot points.
310
00:27:29,293 --> 00:27:37,563
And this series is a project of trying to learn everything we can about them, starting with, what do they feel like?
311
00:27:38,493 --> 00:27:45,313
When someone has an experience that completely changes what they think about meditation, what are they actually experiencing?
312
00:27:47,103 --> 00:27:50,373
In the next episode, we'll take that question to the meditators.
313
00:27:53,429 --> 00:27:57,849
If you wanna learn more about the series, head over to pivotpoints.xyz.
314
00:27:58,439 --> 00:28:02,649
There you can find transcripts, guest information, and links to more material.
315
00:28:03,399 --> 00:28:09,245
I'll be publishing bonus episodes and collections of short clips that didn't make it into the series through my newsletter,
316
00:28:09,245 --> 00:28:12,939
which you can subscribe to at heretodisappear.com.
317
00:28:13,859 --> 00:28:17,333
And if you'd like to support the series and more projects like this,
318
00:28:17,333 --> 00:28:21,799
you can become a paid subscriber of my newsletter or just share the series with a friend.
319
00:28:24,019 --> 00:28:26,959
Pivot Points is supported by the Waking Up meditation app.
320
00:28:27,569 --> 00:28:29,029
Edited by Amy Standen.
321
00:28:29,439 --> 00:28:31,453
Original theme music by Marcus Bagala.
322
00:28:31,878 --> 00:28:33,959
Cover art by Valero Doval.
323
00:28:33,959 --> 00:28:35,629
Mixed by Lucas Del Calvo.
324
00:28:36,029 --> 00:28:37,379
Created and hosted by Oshan Jarow.
325
00:28:38,769 --> 00:28:44,199
And made possible by the generous meditators willing to share their weird experiences for public listening.
326
00:28:44,949 --> 00:28:45,509
Thank you all.