رونوشت 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:00.100 --> 00:00:11.580
[upbeat music] Hey, everybody. In today's episode, Charter's finally about to swallow up Cox and make the nation's biggest cable broadband wireless company.
2
00:00:12.020 --> 00:00:22.760
Disney's D23 goes mid on cruise ships and big on interesting video game crossovers. Reed Hastings leaves his Netflix days behind while rehabbing a ski lodge?
3
00:00:23.540 --> 00:00:32.220
And Internet OG creator Hank Green gets crosswise with fans over hints of excessive AI reliance, even as the EU issues new laws on disclosure.
4
00:00:33.060 --> 00:00:42.340
In a special programming note, we are joined by Rick Ellis of All Your Screens as we talk all things technology, media, and telecom on next TMT Talks.
5
00:00:42.920 --> 00:00:57.790
Rick is joining us, uh, in a conversation specifically led by my co-founder, Daniel Frankel, about this little hundred and eleven, hundred and twelve, pick your number, $112 billion merger between Paramount Skydance and Warner Brothers Discovery.
6
00:00:57.880 --> 00:01:11.120
Rick has been one of the most interesting assessors of this gigantic disaster in the making, my perspective, and, uh, we wanna hear more about it from him. So Daniel, take it over.
7
00:01:11.960 --> 00:01:21.360
Well, I was hoping I could hear more about it from you too, David. I think that was the disconnect, but, uh- Well, you know how shy and retiring I am. Exactly. I never have an opinion on anything.
8
00:01:22.400 --> 00:01:33.950
No, I, I thought I'd have-- I'd invite Rick to this little, uh, thing we do on Sunday nights because I'd, I'd read some of the things he'd written about Paramount.
9
00:01:34.280 --> 00:01:45.460
Uh, unlike a lot of folks who know about media mergers who've talked about it ad nauseam lately, he had some wise things to say. Basically, don't believe everything you hear.
10
00:01:45.580 --> 00:01:55.600
Just because it's background information doesn't mean it's actually fact. Practice some judgment and some stridency on it. It was, it was manna from heaven because there's so much.
11
00:01:56.260 --> 00:02:06.080
I mean, uh, I, I was reading Sharon Waxman, my former boss at New York Times yesterday. "David Ellison's pretty serious about moving out of California." Seems like just leverage to me.
12
00:02:06.340 --> 00:02:17.829
Anyways, that's why I thought Rick would be an excellent guest. It, it, yeah, it seems like attempted leverage. There's some reasons for skepticism. I certainly share Rick's opinion about that, so go for it.
13
00:02:17.870 --> 00:02:30.180
But he's being lauded and celebrated by his, his user base, getting a lot of love mail, a lot of, uh, a lot of flowers. Talk about that, Rick. Well, I, first of all, people forget that Warner Bros.
14
00:02:30.300 --> 00:02:38.680
Discovery has been the corporate based in New York for a long time. Paramount was, was based in the East Coast until a year or two ago.
15
00:02:39.280 --> 00:02:46.060
I mean, it's-- Now, if you're, when these, you get these stories about, "Well, Paramount's gonna move out of Southern California." Well, what does that mean exactly?
16
00:02:46.120 --> 00:02:58.650
Is it the, the, the back end side, the, the executives? Or are you talking about all the production stuff? The Gulf+Western Company. Yeah. [chuckles] I mean, moving the executives, not a big deal. Now, moving production,
17
00:02:59.600 --> 00:03:11.840
I, I mean, Ellison's claiming that he doesn't have that much available money to begin with, right? Here's a guy who basically made this merger happen by, you know, pulling money out of the couch.
18
00:03:12.280 --> 00:03:23.920
Did, did everything to cover this thing, and now he's wanting to spend what? A-and Rick, let's be clear. It wasn't just his couch. He was pulling them out of couches in Saudi Arabia and Jared Kushner's couch.
19
00:03:24.000 --> 00:03:31.040
I mean, he was pulling them from all kinds of couches. I mean, there were- Oh, yeah... couches across, across the globe he was pulling couches out of, so.
20
00:03:31.240 --> 00:03:41.280
A-and, and we're supposed to believe that he's considering spending what? What, half a billion dollars to move the s- the studio productions, uh, at, at a minimum? Uh, no, it's not gonna happen.
21
00:03:41.320 --> 00:03:42.380
It's, it's a scare tactic.
22
00:03:42.620 --> 00:03:54.820
It's just one of those things because he knows that Hollywood is so fraught with nervousness right now because the industry's really struggling, a lot of people out of work, a lot of people underworking.
23
00:03:54.920 --> 00:04:05.000
And so he's made a point of stressing that he can turn things around without actually saying he can turn s- things around because honestly, he can't.
24
00:04:05.540 --> 00:04:12.900
But if, if he can keep stressing this or "I'm gonna pull stuff away from California," because he wants people scared. He wants people afraid.
25
00:04:13.400 --> 00:04:24.050
He wants people to write things like, you know, with respect, Daniel, your old boss saying, "We have to get Hollywood back to work. You know, we have to s- we have to close this merger." Okay, sure.
26
00:04:24.060 --> 00:04:34.500
Well, Ari, Ari Emanuel saying, "This merger can save Hollywood." That's literally the h- the headline also in the, I think the Wall Street Journal, maybe the New York Times, and they've done a full court press.
27
00:04:34.540 --> 00:04:50.380
There was a very thinly sourced story saying Gavin Newsom has made it known, and there was no, like, any comment from the governor's office about this more specifically other than just, "Oh, there was some word that he would think it would save jobs."
28
00:04:50.430 --> 00:05:02.590
It's like, how is it gonna save jobs, right? Well, exactly. Why? And as, as far as Ar-Ari Emanuel, his company is an investor w- in, in Paramount and in this deal. Yeah.
29
00:05:02.640 --> 00:05:09.330
So it's not- Right, seven point seven billion dollar, he's got a
Load full transcript
seven point seven billion dollar UFC deal, right? Yeah. So not nothing.
30
00:05:09.340 --> 00:05:17.000
So it's, it's not exactly like he's just some random guy who's in support of the, the merger, so. Right. [chuckles] Just walking down the street.
31
00:05:17.440 --> 00:05:25.700
Why or why is our, uh, DGA and IATSE, a couple of guilds have been operating this town and seen a few of these tie-ups before.
32
00:05:26.460 --> 00:05:37.240
Why do they view this closing as, as like the thing that needs to happen given, and you were saying this, Rick, uh, before we got on the air here, they're gonna lay off a bunch of people s- as soon as this thing closes.
33
00:05:37.660 --> 00:05:47.240
Why would they want this to close given the fact that you're, you represent jobs? The DGA has traditionally been a union that looks out for its own members, and that's it.
34
00:05:47.320 --> 00:06:00.180
And in this case- And, and, and Rick, the most, the most management friendly because- Yeah... the directors are really directing everything, and everybody else just works for them basically, right?
35
00:06:00.540 --> 00:06:12.764
So they've always been the most amenable to the studios in making deals Just generally Yeah. So, I mean, I'm not super surprised that DGA did that. It's the trades that I don't understand.
36
00:06:12.844 --> 00:06:27.384
I mean, that's a union that's just gotten slammed by the production slowdowns, the production cutbacks, and I don't know-- The statement that they sent out didn't explain why they thought that this would be a good deal to push the merger through.
37
00:06:27.704 --> 00:06:38.464
They somehow believe it's gonna help them. I, I, I'm at a, a loss to know how that works out, but Hmm. Yeah, it's a little opaque, and it feels like something...
38
00:06:39.404 --> 00:06:51.984
You know, in, in algebra they call it solving for X, like there's an unknown quantity. You got one plus two equals four. One plus two plus X equals four, solve for X. Like, what's the X equal to?
39
00:06:52.514 --> 00:07:04.704
It's like we just don't know what that is, but there's something out there that makes it make sense. But right now it doesn't make any sense. This idea that selling CNN will solve the f- the, the equation.
40
00:07:06.464 --> 00:07:12.784
There was, it, it was Reuters who jumped all over a comment made by their chief legal officer the other day at a conference.
41
00:07:13.284 --> 00:07:20.404
He said, you know, kind of exasperated, "Okay, yes," uh, he was pinned, "everything's on the table." And all of a sudden everybody runs with it.
42
00:07:20.424 --> 00:07:31.464
It was even on Drudge Report, big, you know, they don't do sirens anymore, but the next closest thing, big red type, you know. Ellison opened to selling CNN, and you said he is not.
43
00:07:32.544 --> 00:07:42.004
Why, uh, Rick, why don't you think he'll sell CNN? Well, I-I, part of it's my opinion, part of it's the fact that in a couple of days ago, he
44
00:07:43.324 --> 00:07:48.784
let people know at CNN that he had no interest in selling CNN, that that wasn't gonna happen.
45
00:07:48.824 --> 00:08:01.984
Now, he could just be telling them that, but yeah, uh, Brian Stelter and, and a couple other people at CNN reported that, look, the word is he's not interested in selling it. But the, the reality is he can't.
46
00:08:02.024 --> 00:08:07.794
He can't afford to sell it. His-- There's, there's really two rationales for this merger. Right.
47
00:08:07.824 --> 00:08:21.924
One of it's just combining the studio side and doing the efficiencies cuts, and the other side is combining the cable networks and using that large number of cable networks to force live TV platforms into paying more for them.
48
00:08:21.964 --> 00:08:37.804
You know, but if you're Comcast or Hulu Live or whoever you are, if, if this ki- combined company comes to you and says, you know, "You either agree to these increases or you lose half of your networks tomorrow," they're not really gonna be able to say no.
49
00:08:38.224 --> 00:08:44.104
Yeah. And part of their leverage in that is that CNN is by far the most valuable component that they have.
50
00:08:44.144 --> 00:08:54.924
A- and getting rid of CNN, I mean, uh, you know, if someone said, "Oh, you can't have Investigation Discovery anymore." Oh, no, what am I gonna do? You know, uh, CNN's a different story.
51
00:08:55.364 --> 00:09:05.724
Yeah, it's a totally different dynamic. I mean, it's fifty, fifty-nine percent of the cable viewership, I think is, would be controlled in the merger. Isn't that the num-- I think that's the number I recall.
52
00:09:06.004 --> 00:09:19.444
Fifty-nine percent. Yeah. Uh, that's crazy. There are still enough pay TV homes to justify this, th-uh, uh, that this revenue is still that important that you, or this is still foundational to the merger.
53
00:09:19.844 --> 00:09:32.624
That's not just- Well, the merger is depending on milking those cable networks and CBS until the bitter end. I mean, it is financed by cash flow being thrown off by those guys, right, Rick?
54
00:09:32.684 --> 00:09:45.424
I mean, that's the essential stuff. Now, worrisomely, at the last earnings call, Warner Brothers said, "Yeah, [chuckles] our, our revenues are down eleven percent year over year for this quarter,
55
00:09:46.424 --> 00:10:02.094
which is about eight percentage points more than the Street expected. Nothing to see here. Just keep moving along to that merger." But if you're down eleven percent, that is a free fall on your cash coming in, right?
56
00:10:02.094 --> 00:10:07.473
I mean- Well, I mean, the, it's one of those things of two things can be true at the same time. Uh, the cable- Right...
57
00:10:07.484 --> 00:10:20.724
business is really getting, it's fewer customers, fewer, m-much less revenue, but it's still incredibly profitable, and it is a business that doesn't require a lot of spending. You know, they license stuff.
58
00:10:20.784 -->
00:10:32.564
They, there's a l- a lot less original content than there used to be. And what original content- Yeah... they are creating gets ported over to the, the streaming platforms, whichever, you know, respective one.
59
00:10:32.964 --> 00:10:44.624
So that helps offset those costs. Uh, there really isn't another way for either Paramount or Warner Brothers to, to make a large amount of revenue that they can use to pay down their debt.
60
00:10:44.984 --> 00:11:03.734
That's how Warner Brothers has been paying down their debt, and when they were originally talking about selling off the studio part to Netflix, they were going to move a substantial amount of their debt to this spinoff company that had the cable networks because that was the division that could s- could pay, pay it off somehow.
61
00:11:04.444 --> 00:11:16.814
To both of you, so question. CNN, I mean, I've seen the ratings. Some of its daytime news segments do hundreds of thousands of viewers, just tiny little segments of audience. Mm-hmm.
62
00:11:16.844 --> 00:11:29.264
They still generate enough audience and advertising and licensing fees to be the flagship of a, of a, of a package of channels. It's not TNT or TBS.
63
00:11:29.324 --> 00:11:39.464
But, but, but the thing you-- But the other thing, Dan, is you're forgetting the transformation that CNN has gone through under Mark Thompson over the last, was it four years now?
64
00:11:39.524 --> 00:11:51.884
Where they don't care, I mean, they say they don't care. They mostly don't care about ratings because they're becoming a digital-first organization, news organization.
65
00:11:52.274 --> 00:12:02.884
And the cable thing, I mean, we're gonna see this a little bit with ESPN and a few of these other organizations that are bigger than the delivery method that they started out on.
66
00:12:03.464 --> 00:12:14.504
But they're trying to be all things news on the digital side, just as The New York Times did that under Thompson when he was GM over there. And that's the goal.
67
00:12:14.624 --> 00:12:21.224
Whether they'll get there enough to make the money make sense Particularly in a merger, is a whole nother question.
68
00:12:21.334 --> 00:12:31.264
And we haven't really checked in on that, 'cause you don't hear much from Thompson, but that's, that's what, you know, the ratings, you're right. The ratings are minuscule compared to Fox News.
69
00:12:31.324 --> 00:12:45.044
It's 600,000 versus three million, two and a half million, whatever Fox has. But part of this is they've kinda waved a white flag on cable ratings and said, "We're moving over here." Got it. So.
70
00:12:46.224 --> 00:13:00.364
So- What do you think about that, Rick? Well, I mean, I, I am skeptical that CNN can do the digital pivot they want to. Um- Right... when you look at what they're doing versus what the Now, MS Now is doing. Yeah.
71
00:13:00.524 --> 00:13:08.914
MS Now's, uh, YouTube channels, digital stuff, is pretty successful. Yep. And- And they keep buying things. Yeah. Yeah.
72
00:13:08.924 --> 00:13:23.203
And so I, I think they're better positioned, but s- w- CNN is still an incredibly profitable channel, and it's influential. Right. And being able to say, "I own CNN," has some value to a billionaire. Yeah.
73
00:13:23.944 --> 00:13:25.284
You know, the difference though, you're right.
74
00:13:25.444 --> 00:13:40.264
Versant, or Versant, as we like to say it here at Next TMT Talks, uh, Versant has, like, all these golf acquisit- uh, golf operations, like the Golf Channel, but now a bunch of other golf related things like Golf Pass and Golf Now, and this Full Swing thing.
75
00:13:40.644 --> 00:13:49.584
They've got CNBC doing all these pro versions and, you know, special groups and live events. MS Now is doing live events. You're right.
76
00:13:49.644 --> 00:13:59.864
So they're able to do a bunch of stuff with their different verticals that you don't see CNN doing or the rest of the Warner Brothers family in any way whatsoever.
77
00:13:59.884 --> 00:14:06.724
There's nothing unique about what they have, and they don't have their sports in quite the same way, though they still have a lot of live sports.
78
00:14:06.804 --> 00:14:12.744
But you're right, it's, MS Now is really interesting, right, with what they've done. Yeah.
79
00:14:12.804 --> 00:14:25.244
I, a- and I guess it, it also reminded me, I, I wanted to touch on this when we're talking about this merger just in general, one of the arguments I've been hearing the last few days is this has to get completed because otherwise Paramount's in financial trouble.
80
00:14:26.844 --> 00:14:33.884
Th- uh, to me, that doesn't, that says more about Paramount's business model and their- Yeah... decision making than it does about anything else.
81
00:14:34.124 --> 00:14:46.824
Basically, it's, it's almost like there's a really classic National Lampoon, uh, cov- magazine cover from the '70s where there's a picture of a dog and a gun up to it said, yeah, yeah, "Do, read this story or we'll shoot this dog."
82
00:14:47.084 --> 00:14:52.624
It's basically the- Yeah... the business equivalent of that. It's like, "Let this merger go through or you'll, we'll kill the company."
83
00:14:52.764 --> 00:15:01.164
[laughs] Well, and, and you know, uh, some of the, the, the analysts were saying it's not just Paramount that comes out of that.
84
00:15:01.264 --> 00:15:14.684
I mean, there was some, like, if we don't do this deal, Warner Brothers is gonna be, uh, a debt ridden struggling company. It's like, well, yeah, ever since David Zaslav worked his magic, right?
85
00:15:14.964 --> 00:15:25.864
I mean, it's kinda been a debt ridden struggling company without an obvious next step, despite all his bravado and- How much debt is still there?... you know, a good year at the box office last year. Yeah.
86
00:15:27.084 --> 00:15:35.754
He has to stay till December, I think, to cash out that $800 million. Yeah. So- So what- He's gotta stick around...
so is this gonna be like, uh, like,
87
00:15:37.264 --> 00:15:48.344
you know, World War I France, we're just gonna s- sit here and shoot at each other in trenches for the next 10 months or whatever till this trial starts? It, uh- Or until somebody surrenders. Yeah.
88
00:15:48.584 --> 00:16:00.564
I mean- It doesn't seem like that's-... unfortunately, World War I, you know, the Battle of the Somme was a bloody mess. 50,000 Brits and, uh, related empire troops died on the first day. Right.
89
00:16:00.664 --> 00:16:10.044
So this is gonna be kinda like that. The, the problem is that, you know, Daniel, you and I were talking about this, David Ellison has nowhere to move.
90
00:16:10.564 --> 00:16:20.284
He keeps talking about he wants to ne- negotiate with the state attorney generals, but what he wants to negotiate with is things like, "Oh, I'm gonna extend the theatrical window," or, "I'm gonna make X amount of movies."
91
00:16:20.624 --> 00:16:27.084
Well, that has nothing to do with the merger or, or any of the- No... the competition problems. Uh, but he doesn't have anything else to offer them.
92
00:16:27.424 --> 00:16:34.064
He can't spin off any of the parts of the company that matter, and the merger still make a, even remotely sense.
93
00:16:34.374 --> 00:16:49.384
Uh, so he's stuck and, and that's why you're seeing he and other people at Paramount doing all this spinning in public because at the end of the day, his only hope is that enough people can pressure the state AGs, uh, particularly in California, to basically say, "Oh, you know, you're right.
94
00:16:49.484 --> 00:17:01.844
We've been, we were bad. You know, our bad. We'll just let the merger go through." 'Cause he doesn't have any other option. So this is like, you know, like Trump rhetoric, "Open the strait you crazy bastards."
95
00:17:01.904 --> 00:17:14.124
He's just out there throwing rhetoric, trying to make public opinion change and buy some leverage. Yeah. Well, right. We're gonna bomb your civilization except for, oh, we really can't do that.
96
00:17:14.184 --> 00:17:25.864
It is a war crime technically that even he recognizes and, you know, you still can't change the control of the strait. You have to have fundamental shifts in our use of gasoline.
97
00:17:25.944 --> 00:17:36.304
Oh, wait, we, we already changed that and, uh, said we're not doing EVs, so you know, there's a whole bunch of stuff there. This is a tough one because it feels like they painted themselves in a corner.
98
00:17:36.424 --> 00:17:42.404
That's what it feels like to me, right? So what, what do you think, Rick? As a media news consumer, I can't accept that.
99
00:17:42.564 --> 00:17:51.104
I need daily dopamine of major incremental movements towards something, and this is, this is just- Well, boy, are you in the right business then.
100
00:17:51.524 --> 00:18:01.954
You, 'cause it's gonna be incremental and, I mean, I would be shocked if they settle this before it goes to court because the AGs have absolutely no incentive to do this. I mean, there's- Right...
101
00:18:01.984 --> 00:18:10.824
nothing that Ellison could offer them. The only hope, like I said, is that they can get pressured into it. Enough public pressure is on them, "Oh, you should settle this.
102
00:18:10.884 --> 00:18:19.964
Hollywood's gonna, you know, burst into flames and die if, uh, the merger doesn't go through." But there's nothing Ellison could offer them to make them feel better about it.
103
00:18:20.004 --> 00:18:28.156
They don't want the merger to go through, and they see this as their chance to, to, to stop it. And I don't think- I mean, I don't know.
104
00:18:28.216 --> 00:18:37.016
I've never talked to any of the AGs, but my sense from just what I've heard is that they don't believe at the end of the day either one of these companies is gonna go away if the merger doesn't happen.
105
00:18:37.286 --> 00:18:41.236
They could be wrong. I don't know that anyone can answer it, but I, I believe that's what they think.
106
00:18:42.196 --> 00:18:53.316
Well, you know, it's interesting because, uh, right, uh, uh, Warner Bro-- somebody will buy Warner Brothers [chuckles] 'cause apparently that's what you do every three years, you buy Warner Brothers, somebody does.
107
00:18:53.716 --> 00:19:03.316
But, um, to me, th- th- you're right, there's no federal ability to strong-arm the state AGs on this one.
108
00:19:05.396 --> 00:19:20.246
I suspect that any effort by the Trump administration will be severely limited after November, just guessing. But beyond that, they have no incentive to settle, and then the question becomes, how long can David wait?
109
00:19:20.816 --> 00:19:40.516
I think what we've seen, because there's some-- it feels to me, and I wanna bounce this off of you, Rick, it feels to me like this recent spate of op-eds in The Wall Street Journal and New York Times, you know, this thing with Sharon, uh, these feel a little desperate, uh, particularly when combined with these sorta hollow threats of, "Oh, I'll move it out of the state.
110
00:19:40.796 --> 00:19:44.416
I'll do it. I'll leave behind two fantastic, historic
111
00:19:45.316 --> 00:19:58.536
movie studios and their grounds that are worth, you know, hundreds of millions or billions of dollars, and I'll just leave, and I'll go somewhere that doesn't have that, then I'll have to spend another hundred or several hundred billion to do that.
112
00:19:58.916 --> 00:20:08.616
But I'll show you." Uh, you know, it just doesn't make sense. I mean, I think- I think the iron- the irony of this is that what Hollywood is asking- Mm...
113
00:20:08.676 --> 00:20:19.966
for, from Paramount is exactly what they would've got from Netflix. But people were so- Mm... wound up in this idea that Netflix hates theatrical business, and Netflix doesn't believe in theatrical window and stuff.
114
00:20:20.296 --> 00:20:25.966
Everyone was screaming like crazy. They were thrilled when Netflix was outbid for
this. And part of the reason that- Right...
115
00:20:25.996 --> 00:20:36.276
I think Netflix walked away was they saw that it was gonna be s- just such a pain in the ass to get the thing approved, and, and people were so unhappy. But all the things that they're wanting- Yeah...
116
00:20:36.336 --> 00:20:46.136
Paramount to do, Netflix was willing to do. And, and- Yeah... n- n- and when I hear people say, "Oh, well, y- if this falls apart, Netflix will buy the studio," I don't know.
117
00:20:46.456 --> 00:20:53.516
If you're Netflix, are you gonna jump back into this after seeing what Paramount's went through and, and what you know people already think of your company?
118
00:20:54.456 --> 00:21:12.156
I think what Netflix will do is just hope to God Ellison falls through, follows through, moves out of state, and they pick up the Paramount lot, which is just down the street from their headquarters in s- in, uh, uh, Hollywood, and 'cause they would love to have the Paramount lot and all those studio, uh, facilities and all the rest
119
00:21:13.136 --> 00:21:23.496
right there, six blocks away. Um, uh, they'd just swoop right in and maybe buy it for 20 cents on the dollar, 15 cents on the dollar, you know?
120
00:21:23.516 --> 00:21:33.376
Um- Yeah, didn't they already, they already made an offer to Paramount or there was sp- uh, they, they floated- There was speculation that they'd already floated something, but, you know, like, they don't want the cable operations.
121
00:21:33.436 --> 00:21:39.096
They don't want the broadcast operations. They don't need CNN. They don't need any of that stuff.
122
00:21:39.636 --> 00:21:50.996
They really like that whole marketing and distribution unit, which is incredibly valuable and incredibly talented and hard to build from scratch. They got a chance to kinda look at that and see what you could do with it.
123
00:21:51.996 --> 00:22:03.936
So sure, let's bolt that on, then we will do more theatrical because it makes sense. But, you know, building that from scratch is a very expensive and kinda hap- you know, hazardous process, so.
124
00:22:03.956 --> 00:22:12.386
Well, you see what happened with Apple. They tried to build that distribution arm, and it's expensive. There's a limited amount of people who know how to do it. It requires- Yep...
125
00:22:12.436 --> 00:22:15.886
a lot of time, a lot of money, and, uh- Yep...
126
00:22:15.886 --> 00:22:27.186
you know, it, a lot of it's relationships of getting the, into the theaters and getting this marketed and, and, uh, you know, Netflix would be looking at a five or 10-year process to build it from scratch, and I don't know that- Right...
127
00:22:27.186 --> 00:22:39.076
they're willing to do that. Well, and you'll see, and you notice that when, when Apple did a big movie, what did they do? They hired Warner Brothers- Yep... to distribute F1, and that was a big hit.
128
00:22:39.096 --> 00:22:42.895
And Warner Brothers collected a six percent distribution
fee.
129
00:22:42.936 --> 00:22:53.386
One of the most interesting things in this, uh, acquired podcast I've been listening to, it's a two-part, nine hours history of the Disney Corporation over the last, that they put out over the last six months,
130
00:22:55.256 --> 00:23:04.836
was when Walt decided we gotta have our own distribution unit. And you go, "Well, distribution's not a big deal." It's like, no, it's incredibly expensive 'cause you've gotta have, you gotta pay for all the prints.
131
00:23:04.876 --> 00:23:09.586
You've gotta upfront all this money. You've gotta do all this. You've gotta upfront all the marketing and, as you say, all these relationships.
132
00:23:09.996 --> 00:23:18.596
I worked at MGM long enough with a-- and the distribution people are different animals. They're the kind of people who scream in a phone all day, "Listen, you jerk.
133
00:23:19.016 --> 00:23:29.876
You're gonna put it on this screen, not that screen in that theater 'cause I know that screen sucks, and that one's, you know, got the right audio, and it deserves it, and you're gonna do it, or I'm gonna break your knees, and you'll never see another movie from us."
134
00:23:30.316 --> 00:23:42.196
That's, that's the day for a distribution guy, right? It could be somebody- You just owes me a cal- what a cal she bet on you referencing historical Disney more. I, I am so glad- Thank you...
135
00:23:42.226 --> 00:23:51.796
to finance your lifestyle- Yeah... Daniel. But go ahead. Because of, because of your, your input. But I, you know, look, uh, D23's going on. It's kinda interesting.
136
00:23:52.136 --> 00:23:58.656
But the point is, the distribution guys, it's expensive to do it. Uh, there's a lot of upfront cash. You can't do it. It, it's really important.
137
00:23:59.676 --> 00:24:07.336
One of the things that came out of D23 is Jon Favreau, the guy behind The Mandalorian, the live action, uh, Jungle Book, a bunch of other stuff,
138
00:24:08.556 --> 00:24:25.666
is doing a hybrid animation and, uh, live action show featuring Oswald the Lucky Rabbit. Do you guys know who Oswald the Lucky Rabbit is? Well, yeah, the, the w- the OG, uh, like, 1920s guy, uh, rabbit, yeah. Oswald?
139
00:24:25.666 --> 00:24:37.360
1927. 1927, he was the first Walt Disney as in Walt himself and Ub Iwerks hit. Unfortunately,
140
00:24:38.320 --> 00:24:52.500
they were doing it for Universal and Charles Mintz, a robber baron of the first water. They didn't own Oswald, and so they do this thing, it becomes a big hit,
141
00:24:53.840 --> 00:25:04.340
and Charlie Mintz decides, "You know, we don't really need these expensive Disney guys to do this stuff. I'll just hire away all their animators and do it myself." And he did.
142
00:25:04.680 --> 00:25:15.620
He hired away a bunch of people, including, I think, Ub Iwerks, who left. And so Disney is just, he's got nothing. And out of that, he has to say, "Well, okay, I gotta do something else." He comes up with Mickey Mouse.
143
00:25:16.880 --> 00:25:31.660
He never again doesn't own his IP, and he never again doesn't market the heck out of it in all the flywheel secondary outputs. The Mickey Mouse clubs start in the '30s, and movie theaters when Mickey becomes big.
144
00:25:32.860 --> 00:25:46.460
But the point being that Oswald is coming back. Universal owned it for eight decades. Uh, they got it, [chuckles] DC got it back when they traded Al Michaels to, to NBC.
145
00:25:46.960 --> 00:25:56.400
They got, they got Oswald, and Favreau's gonna do his live action on Oswald. It's the first big movie of Oswald from Disney since 1927.
146
00:25:56.460 --> 00:26:07.750
Oh, Gen Z and their parents, they, they, they've, they remember Oswald, and they'll just- I, yeah, I'm skeptical that- I think their great-grandparents remember it. Yeah, that, I mean- Like, I have boys...
147
00:26:07.760 --> 00:26:17.220
Disney has enough trouble convincing people to, to pay attention to Mickey Mouse nowadays, much less Oswald. Yeah. But, you know- Oh, yeah... Favreau's a talented guy, so who knows?
148
00:26:17.300 --> 00:26:23.340
Maybe it'll be a dark Oswald where he'll, you know, secretly be a serial killer who targets the president. Trained by Marines. Yeah.
149
00:26:23.370 --> 00:26:31.440
[chuckles] Well, you know what, what, so Rick, one of the concha- the challenges here for Disney, and not to, I mean, it's probably time we move on from Warner Brothers and Paramount at this point.
150
00:26:31.540 --> 00:26:42.500
Uh, yeah, one of the challenges for Disney, they threw out a bunch of announcements for all these different franchises they have, and things they're doing at the different, uh, parks, and, you know, new movies.
151
00:26:42.540 --> 00:26:54.330
But they haven't had a new franchise, which has been the flywheel builder, is new franchise that goes into the theme parks, and goes into the retail, and goes into the merch, and all that stuff.
152
00:26:54.900 --> 00:27:05.710
They haven't had a really new one. Everything's been an iteration of something that's existing, and you see that in that long list of stuff that was announced in a decade. Moana was the cow.
153
00:27:05.710 --> 00:27:17.320
Oswald is Moana's first, the first Moana came out more than a decade ago. Oh? So, like nothing new is coming down.
154
00:27:17.380 --> 00:27:26.200
It's hard to launch something new, so they're using a very old IP that they now once again own to try to get a new franchise, which is fascinating.
155
00:27:27.180 --> 00:27:37.100
But I'll be f- I don't know if they'll be able to generate stuff that creates like an Oswald Land or whatever, or an Oswald ride five years from now.
156
00:27:38.220 --> 00:27:47.120
I mean- Well, that's one of the interesting things about Netflix is they, well, two things. You know, a lot of the criticisms of Netflix is, oh, they don't launch franchises.
157
00:27:47.180 --> 00:27:56.460
But when you look at, back at it, and people, "Oh, there hasn't been a
new franchise there since the success of whatever, 'Squid Game- Right... or K-pop." But well, it's hard to do.
158
00:27:56.800 --> 00:28:06.200
There, none of these companies- Right... are launching a new franch- franchise every year, and one of the reasons that- And K- K-pop is, is actually a really good example of, of- Yeah... something that's new, right?
159
00:28:06.300 --> 00:28:13.800
And animated, so it doesn't die or get old or not show up. I mean, you're right though. I mean, nobody's doing it. Who's, who's doing it?
160
00:28:14.990 --> 00:28:26.000
That's sort of the case for Netflix instead of looking at Warner Brothers Discovery if it inc- ends up being available, going for Universal. Because- Yeah...
161
00:28:26.100 --> 00:28:36.240
Universal Studios, Universal has a, a decent theme park business. They have a lot of merchandising. They can plu- that's all stuff Netflix wants. They want those- Mm-hmm... experiences.
162
00:28:36.300 --> 00:28:41.480
They want all that stuff, and they could plug that in. And live sports. Yeah. Live sports out the wazoo. Yeah.
163
00:28:41.540 --> 00:28:53.790
So they got a great live sports portfolio, so that's also- Well, I mean, I think it, so can you create, that's the question you have to ask with the monoculture being what it is and now was. Uh- Is it?...
164
00:28:53.800 --> 00:29:10.180
can you create a franchise anymore? A kind of lasting, sticky thing that all, multiple age groups in, in quadrants, uh, you know, love. Is, has the terrain changed? If, if we're so fragmented, is it impossible?
165
00:29:10.240 --> 00:29:20.300
That's the question. I, I mean, it's not impossible. I, I, I think the reality, the, the problem that executives always run into is there's no guarantee. You know?
166
00:29:20.600 --> 00:29:27.340
Y- there's no way around throwing a bunch of stuff out there and seeing which one the audience gravitates to.
167
00:29:27.660 --> 00:29:40.480
I mean, I, I remember talking to, to people at Netflix before "Squid Game" came out because I, I liked a couple of people who were working on the show and tried to get screeners and was told, "Oh, no, this, this is not going anywhere.
168
00:29:40.540 --> 00:29:47.380
This is just like a little marginal thing that we've, we, we've worked out." You know? They, they were just, they were as shocked as anyone that it was a hit.
169
00:29:47.720 --> 00:29:55.440
I mean, and that's often the case is you give it your best shot, but you just don't know until the audience sees it, and they decide whether or not they want,
170
00:29:56.560 --> 00:30:01.520
you know, to, to, for this to be a big deal to them, which is why I always laugh when executives go, "Oh, you know what?
171
00:30:01.760 --> 00:30:13.690
We're gonna save money 'cause we're gonna put less stuff together into production, but it's gonna be a higher quality." You don't know that. [chuckles] Yeah, you just spend more money, but it doesn't make higher quality.
172
00:30:13.920 --> 00:30:26.840
You know, it's interesting 'cause both K-pop and s- K-pop, "Demon Hunters" and "Squid Games" are Korean. Yeah. Right? These are not coming out of Western content sources, so, uh- I wanna ask Rick something.
173
00:30:27.120 --> 00:30:42.848
You were on the "Squid Game" bandwagon prior to it catching fire here in the US or, uh, how did, uh- Well, you know, I, I had, I keep like really close track of stuff that's coming out- Right... internationally.
174
00:30:42.948 --> 00:30:53.427
That's sort of my, my, one of my things is I... And I had seen some stuff about it. I'd seen a, a mention of it on Netflix's press page.
175
00:30:54.048 --> 00:31:01.588
They had a little release, it went out like in Asia about it, and I just thought, "This sounds really interesting." I knew a couple of the actors, and I didn't think it was gonna...
176
00:31:01.788 --> 00:31:11.838
I'm not gonna claim I thought it was gonna be a global phenomena. Yeah. But I looked at it, that's kind of an interesting idea. I'd like to see this and see what it looks like. And they, they were just- Yeah...
177
00:31:11.838 --> 00:31:19.548
they had no clue. I mean, I cannot tell you how little interest they had in this thing. They talked about that in some of the earnings calls where they said, "You know,
178
00:31:20.468 --> 00:31:29.928
we thought it would do well in Korea, and that's kind of, you know, we, we had a s- some smart people in our Korean..." They have a big production operation- Yeah... s- in Seoul, I think.
179
00:31:30.398 --> 00:31:39.368
"And we thought it would do well there, and maybe beyond that in East Asia, but we didn't know [laughs] that it was gonna be this.
180
00:31:39.687 --> 00:31:49.728
We just thought it was gonna do pretty well there," and it just kept growing and became my- gigantic and one of their two or three biggest things of all time. So same thing with K-pop Demon Hunters.
181
00:31:50.248 --> 00:32:03.588
I mean, that's something that Disney does a lot of, uh, Asian productions, a lot of stuff in Europe. I- it doesn't- Yeah... do particularly well in the US because honestly, they do a terrible job of promoting it. Hmm.
182
00:32:03.888 --> 00:32:13.598
But that's... Behind Netflix, they're probably the, the second biggest. A- Amazon does a lot of international stuff, but they, they do it in certain areas.
183
00:32:13.648 --> 00:32:23.578
Like they have a big business in India, so they, they do a lot of Indian productions, a lot of Hindi productions. But, uh, Disney's been throwing a lot of money at it, uh, and they've had- Hmm...
184
00:32:23.598 --> 00:32:33.468
a couple of modest hits, but really nothing, I think, that's exploded the way they thought it was going to. I'm gonna be really interested to see how, how it works. You know, they- they've had a, a,
185
00:32:34.428 --> 00:32:48.888
a video game relationship with Square Enix, which is behind Final Fantasy and Dragon Quest and, uh, Star Ocean and a bunch of other
role-playing game, Japanese, very specific Japanese role-playing game,
186
00:32:50.108 --> 00:32:57.928
massive franchises. Like Final Fantasy sold over 200 million copies. Pretty good. You know, that's multiple billions of dollars.
187
00:32:58.668 --> 00:33:06.398
But, uh, they had one with Disney over the last 25 years, and they've had three copies, three, three versions come out of
188
00:33:07.828 --> 00:33:19.048
Kingdom Hearts, which takes Disney characters and all the Square Enix characters and some original ones that Disney gets to own that sit in the middle, and these video games have been incredibly successful.
189
00:33:19.168 --> 00:33:36.508
Now they're going to do, you know, Kingdom Hearts 4 for 2027 and an anime series, which is to me, like really smart and has some real potential to take this beyond the video game into a bigger world.
190
00:33:36.668 --> 00:33:49.188
So we'll see if that translates into a US market. But they- they've sold over a billion dollars' worth of, of Kingdom Hearts games, uh, 38 million units sold. So that's pretty good. You know, that's pretty good.
191
00:33:49.308 --> 00:33:54.958
I, I mean- So... they, video games sort of have struggled in that transition, but honestly- Yeah...
192
00:33:55.158 --> 00:34:08.098
it, it has to do, I, i- even in literature, I mean, a, a perfect example of that is when I was growing up, I loved Isaac Asimov's Foundation books. Read them a bunch of times. One of my favorite series of all time. Yeah.
193
00:34:08.108 --> 00:34:17.988
Apple TV show, eh. You know? I- Right... a- and I'm partly critical 'cause I know the books really well. Uh- Yeah... and I think the execution maybe is a little off with a couple of the characters.
194
00:34:18.368 --> 00:34:27.668
But that's the same thing with video games. If you're really familiar with the video game sometimes, even if it's a really good TV production, you look at it and say, "Yeah, but it's not what I was expecting."
195
00:34:27.708 --> 00:34:40.628
Well, I actually really liked the Foundation adaptation and have, uh, interviewed David Goyer, who did the adaptation. Yeah, for 50 years, that was an considered an untranslatable set of books.
196
00:34:40.668 --> 00:34:44.048
I mean, literally, you can't get this on screen. There's too much stuff.
197
00:34:44.568 --> 00:34:59.808
And I think, uh, they took some substantial liberties, but I think some of that was the reality of the difference between, uh, a long-running series based on a bunch of really provocative ideas from the 1960s and late '50s that- Yep...
198
00:34:59.818 --> 00:35:08.748
the wonderful Isaac Asimov came up with. And- Those are hard things to adapt, I think... and so I think they did what they could do. It's, I think- Yeah, they're hard. Yeah, they're hard. You have to be 100%.
199
00:35:09.088 --> 00:35:18.888
Um, I always marveled at- And then you get guys like Rick, who are just really difficult. Um- I, uh, well, honestly, that one's a biggie I don't know if you guys read or saw Three Body Problem. That was like a rare...
200
00:35:20.528 --> 00:35:32.898
I, I was astonished at how much I liked it. I thought Netflix did a wonderful job with it. Um- Honestly, the problem that I had with it, with Foundation was the emperor character. I had a really, I, I
201
00:35:33.868 --> 00:35:38.568
just- You know, meaning Lee? You didn't like- Yeah... Lee Pace or you didn't like, um, uh, Dusk and Dawn?
202
00:35:39.128 --> 00:35:50.788
I, I, I liked, I didn't like that whole, like every thing, every time it came on, it, it just was like a slapping me with a fish. I just, uh, for whatever reason, just did not, uh, like it.
203
00:35:50.868 --> 00:35:54.678
And you know how it is, sometimes something just strikes you that way- Yeah...
204
00:35:54.748 --> 00:36:05.388
and there's nothing you can do about it and, and that's sort of the way I am with that show, where it's just like, I like everything else sort of, uh, except about the emperor and the Dusk and Dawn. It, it just
205
00:36:06.448 --> 00:36:14.768
doesn't really do it for me. But, uh, whatever. It's [laughs] luckily, I'm not the only person in the world that watches things, so. But- Right.
206
00:36:14.878 --> 00:36:24.548
Well, I mean, I think it's done very well I'm a fan of, of Hawk, I, I, I read, Rick. I- I'm, I'm sorry, fan of what? Hawk, the Will, Will Ferrell series. It was funny. Oh, yeah.
207
00:36:25.058 --> 00:36:33.648
My wife-- It was a very nice-- My wife and I watched the first night of it, and I was like, "Well, that seems very derivative of, uh, the Owen Wilson show on Apple."
208
00:36:33.708 --> 00:36:40.060
I forget what, uh- Both, both about golf, but I was just- They both should've been called Hacks, but the name had already been taken.
209
00:36:40.120 --> 00:36:53.240
I was trying to decipher the aftertaste of it, which felt a little bitter at the time, and I forgot what you wrote about it, but you were, like, saying, "Yeah, I need a, a, I'm on my fifth palate cleanser for, for, for Hawk," or something to that effect.
210
00:36:53.260 --> 00:37:06.500
It, it, this surely had affected you badly. I thought that was int- Yeah, it, I mean, I will admit up front that I'm not a huge Will Ferrell fan. Yeah. Just that, that, his style of humor isn't my favorite.
211
00:37:06.820 --> 00:37:12.640
I've liked some of the stuff he's done, but I'm not one of these people who goes, "Oh my God, Will Ferrell. Whoo." Yeah.
212
00:37:12.700 --> 00:37:18.200
And this scene where- He is a beloved, he is a beloved USC Trojan, therefore, he can do no wrong in our eyes.
213
00:37:18.320 --> 00:37:28.150
And by all accounts from people who have known him and dealt with him, a decent human being, which is totally weird in Hollywood, so there's that. Well, I'd like to think I'm a, I'm a decent human being too, but I- No...
214
00:37:28.200 --> 00:37:40.040
would not wanna see me in a series. So- [laughs] Yeah... I just [laughs] Is there
anything else you've seen? What have you seen in the last 14 days that inspires you that you've really liked?
215
00:37:40.140 --> 00:37:48.860
Is there anything that stands to mind? Oh man, I'm, I've, I've sort of a fire hose of junk that I've watched. Um, you know, uh, in,
216
00:37:50.180 --> 00:38:03.600
an older series, and I say older, like six or eight months old, that, uh, I re-watched, which I hardly ever re-watch, is a, uh, show called Red Eye, which is on Hulu. It's a British show, two seasons.
217
00:38:04.250 --> 00:38:12.800
I was really skeptical about it because a lot of the premise of the first season is it takes place on an airplane, and I- Right... okay, what could possibly... We've seen this before.
218
00:38:13.280 --> 00:38:27.640
Incredibly action-packed, lots of twists, really enjoyed it, and I, the other night I was in the mood for something just mindlessly stupid, and, uh, I re-watched it again. Just really, really good.
219
00:38:28.820 --> 00:38:40.800
It's not related to the motion picture with, uh, I'm forgetting, uh, uh, Irish actor, Dave, help me out here. Colin Farrell? No. Wasn't him. No. It's, it's basically the, the- Sonny Bono. Bono, Houston.
220
00:38:41.000 --> 00:38:50.030
Amy Adams is in it. The, the whole premise is this guy's- Or no, A-Amy Adams... this guy's in China. There's an accident. A woman gets killed. Oh.
221
00:38:50.070 --> 00:39:03.380
He returns to the UK, and it turns out the, it's a daughter of a big Chinese party official. Okay. So they put him on this plane to ship him back to China, and during that flight, things happen on and off the plane.
222
00:39:03.420 --> 00:39:15.060
And it re- just, it's, it's not r- rocket science, but it was just a really fun, tightly written show, and it got absolutely no attention when it was on.
223
00:39:15.940 --> 00:39:28.060
I fell down a rabbit hole this week about Tom Segura's Bad Thoughts. I'd never seen it. [laughs] And I was like- I'm not sure that rabbit hole is quite the hole Tom Segura was talking about- [laughs]... but there you go.
224
00:39:28.640 --> 00:39:40.480
Uh, yeah. Just gonna leave it right there and walk away. I should say, don't mention orifices or holes or anything around that topic, but I was, uh, impressed. I don't know. It sort of blew my mind.
225
00:39:41.230 --> 00:39:51.520
But anyway, we, uh, y- we have John. We have to ask John. Once, once again. Like I said- Once again, the wrong verb, but we'll leave that alone too. All right. Uh, topic, Dave, what do we got?
226
00:39:51.580 --> 00:40:01.900
What else do we got to cover? What, what... Move that along. Okay, Charter's swallowing up Cox, uh, probably next week and creating the largest, you know, integrated communications company in the- There you go...
227
00:40:01.930 --> 00:40:15.420
United States. Fly o- to the, the ointment to, to David Ellison's fly. There, there you go. There I go again. Uh, uh, a, a s- a paid TV provider that has over 14 million subscribers. It's
the biggest one.
228
00:40:17.020 --> 00:40:26.100
I'm not sure it matches Paramount, Warner Brothers Discovery leverage, but, uh, it's an answer. Cumit with what we got. It's not, it's not levered. It's not levered.
229
00:40:26.160 --> 00:40:35.560
It, I mean, I think they're picking up some debt on this, but boy, this one, this one makes sense, right? Because cable operators all have their own areas, so there's not a lot of overlap.
230
00:40:35.600 --> 00:40:37.320
There's a little bit at the corporate level. Right.
231
00:40:37.660 --> 00:40:49.800
But all they're doing is getting probably some network benefits by having a bigger wireless operation and having a bigger broadband operation that can get some economies of scale.
232
00:40:51.140 --> 00:41:01.010
And as you say, those poor neglected Cox subscribers in Southern California are, A, gonna get, finally get access to the Dodgers.
233
00:41:01.060 --> 00:41:13.140
A million of them didn't have access, some of whom would really care, and B, they're gonna get it on gigabit, multi-gigabit connections, which all of us should care about. I want that, Charter.
234
00:41:13.150 --> 00:41:24.600
Uh- Yeah, there's certain markets, I think parts of New York and, and certainly Southern California where- Yeah... it creates a more cohesive cable product. You know, uh, Cox- Yeah... is never gonna upgrade that network.
235
00:41:24.620 --> 00:41:27.440
It doesn't have the resources to. So- Right... everybody...
236
00:41:27.469 --> 00:41:47.940
Well- You know, I mean, one of the things that, o- one of the things you shouldn't lose track of too is, you know, in California, Charter runs a very interesting local news operation now up and down the state from Sacramento and the, the Bay Area on down, and this plugs in the second-largest city in California, San Diego, right?
237
00:41:48.020 --> 00:41:58.060
As well as a bunch of sort of suburban Southern California areas. So that, that whole Southern California news operation gets that much bigger and more extensive.
238
00:41:58.420 --> 00:42:08.160
And again, you wanna talk about network effects, that actually becomes, I think, even more important. We saw them do really good work during the Palisades fire, uh, coverage.
239
00:42:08.280 --> 00:42:19.140
I think they did s- very solid stuff on a very fast-moving and scary set of stories in Eden Canyon and Palisades, so it'll be very interesting to see what happens with all of that. And you were gonna say, Rick?
240
00:42:20.000 --> 00:42:32.310
No, I was just gonna say that, you know, there is an argument to be made that this is a step towards that combined company walking away from the live TV business. Because that- Yeah...
241
00:42:32.320 --> 00:42:40.760
part of the business is the least important to them, and they'll have a lot of scale- And most annoying, right? Yeah. And, you know- It's the, it's the most annoying by far...
242
00:42:40.800 --> 00:42:56.236
they can cut the deals to get You know,
uh, their customers access to whatever Hulu or, or Discovery Plus or whatever, you know, that they can cut all sorts of networking deals and say to people, "Look, here's where you can go if you want live TV.
243
00:42:56.616 --> 00:43:03.186
We don't want anything to do with it." Because like you said, it's annoying, and their margins on that are increasingly thin. Yeah.
244
00:43:03.186 --> 00:43:15.736
And the broadband is just, people have no idea how, what kind of a margin is on broadband. I mean, it's just insane, and, uh, it will only be more with this consolidation. And you don't have carriage fees.
245
00:43:15.836 --> 00:43:20.596
You, you don't have to share your advertising. I mean, it'd be really interesting what happens.
246
00:43:20.656 --> 00:43:30.696
Like, here we're talking about Warner Brothers and Paramount merging and their dependence on their cable operations to continue going. If they said, "Okay, we're done.
247
00:43:31.296 --> 00:43:41.496
We're not doing, we're not gonna provide, uh, live TV. We've got broadband and wireless." Well, theoretically, that's what they told Disney three years ago. There was that- Yeah... big negotiation. We can walk away.
248
00:43:41.576 --> 00:43:52.596
Right. But if they actually finally did it, now that Winfrey's, Winfrey's retiring, right? He's stepping aside. I don't think so. And so, yeah, I, I thought he was heading toward, heading out.
249
00:43:52.706 --> 00:43:58.696
I mean, he's, he's had a great run. He said he was doing for one. Seve- about four years, I think. Some sort of young swan.
250
00:43:58.736 --> 00:44:06.696
Uh, but anyway, um, the, the, but the bigger point is they could follow through on that threat at some point, and, and Rick's right.
251
00:44:06.816 --> 00:44:17.136
I mean, it's, it's not that big a business, and the margins aren't great compared to, as you say, broadband. Pretty crazy when you get past, once you get that stuff in the ground, man, you just let her rip, right?
252
00:44:17.256 --> 00:44:28.166
Collect the money. You've been challenged for home broadband by wireless and fixed wireless access for several years. At the same time- Mm-hmm... they made big headway encroaching the other direction.
253
00:44:28.636 --> 00:44:37.016
You know, Cox has, even has a mobile service. So basically- Right... what that means is you're competing with the big wireless companies, the big three, and they're national, and you're not.
254
00:44:37.056 --> 00:44:48.356
You're a bunch of regional monopolies still. It makes sense for these two companies to link up, and I think eventually it'll make sense for Comcast to do it as well.
255
00:44:48.996 --> 00:44:57.196
I don't know if it'll have as, as easy a time in the regulatory sense as this merger just did, but I think, uh, you know, there's an argument for it.
256
00:44:57.256 --> 00:45:07.586
Well, I think the bigger question is Jo- does John Malone like Brian Roberts, and can they do this in a tax-advantaged way? I
kind of feel like that's the most important question there. Yeah, you know.
257
00:45:07.596 --> 00:45:22.226
Well, it's, it's hard to pick a, a w- uh, someone to, to root for on that duo, you know? Yeah. [laughs] Right? Boy, Brian Roberts over here, John Malone over here. It's like, "Go away." [laughs] Yeah. You know?
258
00:45:22.226 --> 00:45:28.426
[laughs] It's really a tough one to, to think you're, you're, uh, getting behind. Uh- Brian Roberts seems chill.
259
00:45:29.016 --> 00:45:36.196
I, I mean- Ro- I don't think chill is the term I would use, but he's certainly been a, a masterful chess player over the last years.
260
00:45:36.236 --> 00:45:42.536
If we're ranking our captains of cable industry, uh, he's not like Jim Dolan, that guy, uh, you know.
261
00:45:42.676 --> 00:45:56.516
Now, that is a low bar, but, but we all thank you for setting it low so every other human being on the planet can, can clear that. But anyway, uh, speaking of CEOs in transition,
262
00:45:57.416 --> 00:46:13.276
former Netflix co-founder and CEO and then co-CEO and chairman and now retired guy is doing the weirdest damn thing. He's rehabbing a ski lodge at a time when climate change means ski lodges don't have snow.
263
00:46:13.296 --> 00:46:20.396
What's he doing? It's like the cable industry, you know, the pay TV industry is all getting- You know, I heard it's all downhill from here... it still have value to it.
264
00:46:20.456 --> 00:46:27.986
It's wringing out the last vestiges of, uh, of power. The last snowflakes. But he does seem- The last snowflakes. This was a Semaphore- He can afford to,
265
00:46:28.916 --> 00:46:34.756
he can afford to just, you know, send the snow in, I mean, honestly. Yeah. But, uh- Yeah... I, he's a smart guy.
266
00:46:34.956 --> 00:46:43.456
I interviewed him when I was doing financial news back when Netflix was basically a, a one DVD warehouse in the Bay Area. Yeah. Yeah.
267
00:46:43.476 --> 00:46:52.656
And I remember having a conversation with him, and towards the end he starts, you know, we're talking about the future of the business, and he's like, "Well, you know, I think someday w- you're gonna be able to watch a movie on your computer.
268
00:46:53.136 --> 00:46:57.996
You know, you'll just be able just to go on and watch com- uh, a movie through us," and- Yep... he's going on.
269
00:46:58.116 --> 00:47:06.356
And this is a time where it's mostly dial-up, and I remember getting off the call with him and thinking, "This guy's insane." You know, "How is this gonna work?"
270
00:47:06.816 --> 00:47:13.556
You know, he didn't know what it was gonna look like, but he was already thinking that's where the business- Right...
271
00:47:13.656 --> 00:47:29.376
was headed, which I just- Yeah, I interviewed, I interview, I, I interviewed him back then a couple of times and, you know, uh, and I was actually i- in Southern California writing about, uh, visionary but completely impractical people trying to think about how to
get video on 56K dial-up
272
00:47:30.316 --> 00:47:39.776
connections. [laughs] Yeah. 56K boys, like, that's not happening, but good luck for that. You know, at least you got some startup capital from, oh, I don't know, some Disney or whatever.
273
00:47:40.796 --> 00:47:53.756
Uh, but so I was kind of aware that there were people hoping to try to do this, to shove enough bits down there that you weren't getting, you know, a postage stamp, black and white, 15 frames per second, 320 by, I don't know, 240 image.
274
00:47:54.596 --> 00:48:04.576
But he was already, you're right, this was like '98, '99. He came through a couple times, and I got the, I got what he was doing pretty quickly. I understood it pretty, it was, it was like, that's smart.
275
00:48:04.636 --> 00:48:16.136
You're using what the technology allows now, but down the road, when the technology gets better, 'cause it's Moore's law and it's gonna happen, he, he had that.
276
00:48:16.296 --> 00:48:30.986
Sarandos when, when he was, when, uh, Hastings was heading out the door, Sarandos in that sort of farewell earnings call, I mean, he mentioned it, like even then Reed had a clear vision, and I think that's really interesting.
277
00:48:31.356 --> 00:48:41.516
And as you say, he knew exactly what he wanted to do years before it was technologically feasible. Now I wanna know what he thinks he's gonna do with a damn ski lodge.
278
00:48:41.836 --> 00:48:50.036
Does he know how to turn around [laughs] climate change? Any word on that, guys? Well, let me, let me just quickly, let me give the context. He was talking to Semaphore.
279
00:48:50.076 --> 00:48:59.426
They were asking about what his life is like now, and he, you know, it's just sort of retirement hobbies, rehabbing a ski lodge. That's what he's doing. But the interesting things he said were
280
00:49:00.948 --> 00:49:10.418
Related to leading a company like Netflix with AI. It's doubled in the ch- the GPUs have doubled in speed and power every year or whatever it is.
281
00:49:10.568 --> 00:49:15.528
That it has, it's operating on its own Moore's law, or no laws at all according to Jensen Huang.
282
00:49:15.668 --> 00:49:31.688
And in the future, companies like Netflix, you, you gotta look at not only all these new opportunities with AI that you can sort of exploit in other markets that you didn't even think of before, you got people on your six or, or, are targeting your market, competitors you wouldn't even think of.
283
00:49:32.428 --> 00:49:43.568
And it's people with really sound judgment, those that can filter out the unlikely scenarios as opposed to those that might actually happen and matter, that are the ones that are gonna be the, the really good leaders.
284
00:49:44.108 --> 00:49:45.588
Right. Anyway. Right. Pardon me.
285
00:49:45.628 --> 00:50:00.068
Yeah, I mean, well, it, it, it's a good observation at a time when, where people are looking at creator content, creator economies taking off, and these, these barely pubescent, uh, YouTube creators coming up with, uh, YouTube
286
00:50:00.988 --> 00:50:02.608
ideas that have done very well there.
287
00:50:02.668 --> 00:50:12.308
They've made a bunch of stuff, and then they get a nice little, you know, million, $3 million budget, and then boom, it goes out to 30 million or 300 million, and Hollywood went, "Holy crap."
288
00:50:12.378 --> 00:50:20.588
And then the whole thing with the verticals and the, the vertical dramas. That's a huge business in China, and now they're trying to do it here, and it's very interesting stuff.
289
00:50:20.888 --> 00:50:34.868
Th- those are not things that Netflix was thinking about, or anybody else three years ago. They were not on the radar. Let me ask- Right?... quickly. Uh, w- when did you first start on a regular basis streaming video?
290
00:50:36.348 --> 00:50:46.898
When did what streaming video? Sorry. You got it. When did you first start streaming video that you experimented with or- Well, y- you know, I, I tell you how old I am. Um, I, I...
291
00:50:47.148 --> 00:50:57.608
My first journalism job online was for CompuServe. Oh. Yeah, so, uh, back when you were paying $6.99 an hour for the internet. Right.
292
00:50:58.108 --> 00:51:10.848
And, and I remember the, the company I was working for, they got the video, the full-length video for the, uh, that song, you know, If You Want to Be My Lover, that, that, um- Prince? Yeah.
293
00:51:11.128 --> 00:51:18.777
No, uh, the, the girl group from, from the UK, but whatever. Oh, Spice Girls. Spice Girls. Yeah, Spice Girls. Thank you. I just- Yeah... zoned out on it.
294
00:51:19.108 --> 00:51:26.608
So they posted that thing that you could download, and it would take people, like, four or five hours to download it, 'cause it was, you know- Right... dial-up then.
295
00:51:27.448 --> 00:51:39.418
Um, but I've always been interested in that stuff, and when I was in the late '90s, early aughts, I was working for a company which was doing all audio and video in the Bay Area, financial news,
296
00:51:41.068 --> 00:51:52.997
which was an interesting choice when it was dial-up. But they were betting that when the, the broadband rolled out, they would be in place. So I mean, I've been doing
297
00:51:53.948 --> 00:52:03.908
i- in the streaming business for on and off really for, oh my God, decades. You're, you're just saying you've been bleeding on the edge for a very long time. Well, definitely bleeding. Is that safe to say? I don't know.
298
00:52:04.018 --> 00:52:11.678
[laughs] Yeah. I don't know how to answer. Yeah. But the interesting, I tell you a little behind-the-scenes thing. The company I was working for back then, they, they were doing pretty well.
299
00:52:12.428 --> 00:52:21.988
Uh, weirdly, one of the things that was the most successful is I jokingly said to my boss one time, "Uh, we should just have a puppet come on and talk about these companies."
300
00:52:22.428 --> 00:52:28.628
And so he comes to me a
week later and goes, "Oh, you know, let's, let's..." So I was doing this sock puppet, and they had a guy for...
301
00:52:28.728 --> 00:52:40.288
He used to work at CNBC Asia, and he would interview me, give me straight questions, and the sock puppet would answer. And it was incredibly popular. Uh, [laughs] weirdly. The, the company was doing really well.
302
00:52:41.188 --> 00:52:52.288
We found out later that what happened- You're giving us ideas... was that the, uh, that CNBC came to our, our CEO and said, "We wanna buy you guys. We love what you do. We wanna buy you."
303
00:52:52.408 --> 00:53:02.497
And the CEO said, "No, no, I'm not interested." And the, the board found out and they dropped the funding and the company went away, so... Which is really the Silicon- You know, that's, that's-...
304
00:53:02.497 --> 00:53:15.348
Business in a, in a, a nutshell. Absolutely. That's, that's a little bit of what I went through at Red Herring, where Time Warner tried to buy Red Herring when it had just had a 600-page issue.
305
00:53:16.108 --> 00:53:27.028
[laughs] And we call it, we call it the widow maker because, you know, those poor, hapless postal carriers in the Silicon Valley delivering Red Herring to up and down Sand Hill Road had their backs broken.
306
00:53:27.608 --> 00:53:34.788
But, um, and they got a pitch for $200 million and they said, "No." The publisher, Tony Perkins, said no.
307
00:53:35.148 --> 00:53:48.588
And the weird thing was at the same time, Tony Perkins and his brother, who also worked for Red Herring, had overseen a big expansion of the company to 400 employees, and they had written a book called The Coming Internet Bubble.
308
00:53:49.528 --> 00:54:03.608
He did not read his own book. He said, "No, thanks." The bubble popped, and it popped for Red Herring, and a couple of years later they were selling the parts, like the subscription list and the name, for $5 million.
309
00:54:04.308 --> 00:54:12.228
And we were all unemployed. I don't, I don't know, further on in the newsletter, David, I don't know if you saw this, but the next shoe dropped last week. Uh, Wired reported it.
310
00:54:12.428 --> 00:54:20.948
It, Wired and a bunch of other tech press were at the annual Black Hat, uh, internet security conference. Oh, yeah, yeah. They're there every year, right.
311
00:54:20.958 --> 00:54:36.128
And there were a couple s- uh, safety security guys doing a technical presentation from OpenAI talking about how w- some of their agents broke loose from their containment barrier and, you know, were creating all sorts of mayhem, and they were on, in chat rooms- Right...
312
00:54:36.168 --> 00:54:49.968
talking about what they did. And, uh, Wired, e- every- Just to be clear. To, just to be clear, not the researchers talking on the chat rooms, the AI- Right. Yeah... in the chat rooms talking about what they did?
313
00:54:50.328 --> 00:55:01.168
So, it, so- So the AI is trying to get some roses- R-... some flowers- Right. Right. So-... for going rogue in a public way. So the reporters, Wired included, try to get the story out.
314
00:55:01.228 --> 00:55:10.458
There's this guy, a Austin, Texas-based entrepreneur, serial entrepreneur as it might be, Ryan Rickett, who runs this thing called RuntimeWire.
315
00:55:11.088 --> 00:55:18.748
He basically fed the, the live stream of the video of these two guys giving their presentation. I guess there was a transcript too.
316
00:55:19.308 --> 00:55:35.648
All components of the show get fed in real time to his own agents, and within six minutes of these guys describing this story, it surfaces on, uh, an X feed and a blog. So they beat everybody by three hours.
317
00:55:35.708 --> 00:55:45.608
Basically, uh, human, uh, AI journalists had their big scoop. Uh, it's, it's daunting and, and discouraging for folks like us anyway.
318
00:55:45.648 --> 00:55:57.608
It is daunting and discouraging for folks who, uh, don't necessarily work at the speed of light, though we think at the speed of light, right Rick? We think at the speed of light.
319
00:55:57.868 --> 00:56:09.348
I sort of have the opposite problem, but [laughs] Mm. I guess it's, I write really fast, don't really think so much as much as I should maybe sometimes, but [laughs] Right. Yeah, it's, it...
320
00:56:09.488 --> 00:56:20.988
Look, journalism's a, a tough, uh, a tough business to be in. I'm, I'm actually in the middle of completely redoing my business because of AI pressures and other stuff going on, and Google Zero- Yeah...
321
00:56:21.008 --> 00:56:29.728
yeah, it's, if you don't evolve, then you're, you're stuck. You don't, you don't have to be on the cutting edge, but you have to be able to respond to it to survive, so. Absolutely.
322
00:56:29.808 --> 00:56:40.008
Well, you know- So before we get out of it- Well, but I just wanted to segue from this, because Hank Green, who really helped create the creator economy as we know it with his brother, they were the Vlogbrothers.
323
00:56:40.488 --> 00:56:50.928
They created a lot of their own content. They started VidCon, which is the gathering place for the creators over the last 15 years. Now owned, I think, by Paramount. They sold it.
324
00:56:50.968 --> 00:56:54.128
But they've written, like, best-selling novels and other books.
325
00:56:55.288 --> 00:57:08.728
He got crosswise with his fans 'cause he, he, uh, he, he made some comment that people who are hypervig- vigilant about any AI slop, as they like to call it, creeping into their stuff, and thought, "Is Hank using AI?"
326
00:57:08.758 --> 00:57:22.268
And he said, "Well, I was using ChatGPT for research, and, you know, in retrospect, maybe I'm over-relying on the large language models and I... too much in, in these, these refined notes."
327
00:57:22.798 --> 00:57:25.927
And he, you know, he mea culpa and he was okay.
328
00:57:26.508 --> 00:57:47.508
But, but we're having these conversations now about what, what's acceptable in AI use for
content creation, particularly at a time when the EU just launched new EU, or new AI usage disclosure rules, particularly for content, particularly for sensitive consumer-facing content.
329
00:57:47.908 --> 00:57:53.528
So it's a really interesting time about, like, it's gonna be everywhere, right? Like, you're changing your business.
330
00:57:53.588 --> 00:58:02.428
We're gonna have to probably change ours and evolve to, uh, though, of course, our producer Vivian is the AI of our lives, so there is that as the animal test.
331
00:58:02.448 --> 00:58:06.888
Well let's, w- before we get out of here, let's talk about Rick's business a little bit. We've neglected to do it.
332
00:58:08.148 --> 00:58:20.248
You were, uh, as we learned a few months ago when we met you at Stream TV Denver, you were out at the forefront of, uh, self-publishing, the newsletter revolution. You've been doing this for a while.
333
00:58:20.308 --> 00:58:27.768
We're relative newcomers, so you've seen a few things as an independent operator, and your business is undergoing a transformation right now.
334
00:58:27.798 --> 00:58:39.568
Uh, give us the brief history, then tell us what you're doing right now to, to change it. So I have this website, allyourscreens.com, which I've had-- I've made a living on it for more than a decade.
335
00:58:40.368 --> 00:58:49.987
At the height, say a year and a half ago, I was getting two and a half million unique visitors a month, which is a lot. But Google Search has changed.
336
00:58:50.048 --> 00:59:00.628
It's, uh, at, at the low point in the beginning of the year, I was at maybe sixty thousand, which, you know, not only is that bad just for, for people seeing it, the revenue was, was terrible.
337
00:59:01.188 --> 00:59:07.028
Um, and then now I'm getting hit with AI bots wanting to answer questions based off of stuff on my website.
338
00:59:08.017 --> 00:59:18.228
At the same time, my newsletter went from something that I was putting out once a week just with links that were stuff that was on the website, to something that's now going out five or six times a week.
339
00:59:18.658 --> 00:59:31.168
It's got news in it, commentary, opinions. So I'm moving everything to a new domain. Toomuchtv.com went out and, and put on my big boy pants and bought that this week.
340
00:59:31.788 --> 00:59:40.268
Uh, and it's going to be basically a newsletter-centric website that will still have s- that archival stuff and some non-newsletter stuff.
341
00:59:40.568 --> 00:59:55.448
But it will be newsletter forward because that's the type of revenue I can control. Why, why, why do you think that that, in some fashion, gets you around the AI challenge for the content you create?
342
00:59:56.568 --> 01:00:08.268
Because as I'm launching this thing, I'm basically... I, I'm doing it through Beehiiv. Uh, that's, that's why I have the, uh, the, the newsletter now. And they have the ability to block a lot of the...
343
01:00:08.368 --> 01:00:17.148
I can basically say, "I don't want any- anyone scraping this stuff at all." And that's what I'll have. Right. I won't be concerned at all with search engine stuff.
344
01:00:17.668 --> 01:00:28.628
What will be for me is people reading the newsletter, people subscribing to the newsletter, you know, making it hopefully a, a really large community, because that's something I can control.
345
01:00:28.688 --> 01:00:32.788
That's something that I can protect. Uh, and there's no other way to do it.
346
01:00:32.868 --> 01:00:43.728
If you're a really, really big company, you can afford to invest in wizards to try and sell ads to AI and do all this other stuff, which I'm not convinced will work. For me, it's, uh, it's just me.
347
01:00:43.828 --> 01:00:56.018
I need something I can control. The newsletter has a good revenue that I'm gonna protect it this way. Well, you have something that is precious at this point, uh, a paying audience, a loyal paying audience. Yeah.
348
01:00:56.048 --> 01:01:06.388
A lot of readers have been with you a long time. Uh, they're really happy with what you do. And you churn out, I think you said something like sometimes seven newsletters a week? Yeah. I do this business.
349
01:01:06.448 --> 01:01:13.988
How the hell do you do that? I mean, that's... You don't have, like, a bunch of, like, minions inside an office. You've got... It's just you.
350
01:01:14.756 --> 01:01:22.876
Yeah, I, I figured out last year I wrote just short of a million words over the course of the year. It's a lot of words. Which is a lot.
351
01:01:22.996 --> 01:01:28.356
Uh, I mean, basically every newsletter's 1,600 to 2,200 words, depending on the day.
352
01:01:28.696 --> 01:01:37.536
And basically what I'll do is I'll start at the beginning of the day, blank template, and as I'm seeing stuff, I'm a- thinking of stuff, talking to people, I'm dumping it in the newsletter.
353
01:01:37.696 --> 01:01:48.736
This is what I think is interesting. It sort of evolves through the day, and at the end of the day, I got 2,000 words that, uh, you can't read anywhere else. I put a gun to David's head, that's how I get it done.
354
01:01:49.396 --> 01:02:02.926
[laughs] He says, "You're gonna write." Like, if you, if, if you don't read our newsletter, he's a goner. [laughs] So. 'Cause I have, 'cause I have puppy dog eyes. Uh, you know, I- Pretty much. That's the key...
355
01:02:03.046 --> 01:02:13.446
I, I, I get the newsletter. A- and that's the other... I, I read a lot of newsletters. I read, I don't know, probably 40 newsletters at least, maybe more regularly. Mm.
356
01:02:13.446 --> 01:02:23.316
And a lot of them just randomly, which helps give me... I d- that's why people will try and convince me to use AI to put my newsletter together, and it's like, I don't know what I'm looking for.
357
01:02:23.456 --> 01:02:33.546
I can't tell, can train an AI to look for it. I, I, half the time I'll write about something that I just ran across in a newsletter that has nothing to do with the media, and I think it's an interesting- Yeah...
358
01:02:33.596 --> 01:02:42.006
story, so. Right. Right. I'm an old school. I get it. That's, that's why I was talking about Oswald the Lucky Rabbit. Yeah. And see, I knew who- Because, see-...
359
01:02:42.006 --> 01:02:51.226
Oswald was, so, you know, my brain's, uh, I got all kinds of useless junk stuck in my head, so. Oswald's back, baby. [laughs] He's gonna be big. Well- Gonna be big.
360
01:02:51.256 --> 01:03:03.656
Oswald plushies and Lego sets are gonna be selling like hotcakes. Well, we're into overtime. We'll, uh, let you get, uh, to your next newsletter or to sleep. I think you're pro- a couple hours ahead of us.
361
01:03:03.676 --> 01:03:13.656
Probably more asleep. Thank you for doing this, Rick, and we hope to have you do it again. Uh, no, th- this was great. Anytime you guys want, just, uh, ha- have me on. I'm, I'm always willing to talk, so.
362
01:03:14.836 --> 01:03:23.025
We're, or write, as the case may be, so. Or write, yes. We appreciate it. We appreciate it. All right, take care. All right, thanks, man. Take care. Bye.
363
01:03:23.075 --> 01:03:35.596
All right, this has been David Bloom for Next TMT Talks with my co-founder, Daniel Frankel. We didn't lose Rick. Uh, we got uploaded and all that. We did. Couldn't walk. Yeah, he did-- I don't think he uploaded.
364
01:03:37.516 --> 01:03:46.696
Well, we'll see how that works. Okay. All right. All right.
365
01:03:47.296 --> 01:04:00.436
Thanks to Rick Ellis of, uh, All Your Screens and soon to have a new name and a new expression of his many, many, many, many newsletters per week, uh, talking all kinds of things, technology, media, and telecom.
366
01:04:00.476 --> 01:04:12.056
His is particularly about what shows up on your screen. We talk about many other things as well, my co-founder, Daniel Frankel, and I. Uh, you can get Next TMT at nexttmt.com.
367
01:04:12.116 --> 01:04:19.976
That's T as in technology, media, and telecom. TMT.com. You can get it for free twice a week in your email box.
368
01:04:20.616 --> 01:04:28.636
Uh, you can also subscribe to this podcast available on YouTube and in audio and visual form in Spotify and Apple Podcasts as well.
369
01:04:29.416 --> 01:04:41.436
Uh, please like, share, subscribe, follow, comment, all those great things that help give us a reason to exist in the ether, such as it is. Uh, in the meantime, thanks for everything.
370
01:04:41.496 --> 01:04:49.076
This is David Bloom with Daniel Frankel. Over and out. [outro music]