رونوشت 🔗
Aaron (00:15)
Guys, it's our hundredth episode. We we did it.
Chris (00:18)
Finally.
pri (00:19)
Officially.
Chris (00:20)
A after head heaven and holland delaying here.
derek edws (00:23)
I appre I appreciate
pri (00:24)
We're here, we're doing
Aaron (00:24)
It's a
derek edws (00:24)
you guys sa sandbagging the episodes for me there. I think I saw a ninety nine and a quarter,
Aaron (00:28)
Yeah, we didn't even know what to do, Derek.
derek edws (00:30)
a ninety nine and two quarters, so thank you guys.
Aaron (00:33)
Well, it
Chris (00:34)
It wouldn't be a hundredth episode without you.
derek edws (00:36)
I appreciate that, guys.
Aaron (00:36)
Yeah, completely.
pri (00:38)
Yeah.
Aaron (00:39)
So we're back from Marfa. great I mean it's more than a weekend, but great week at Marfa. What were thoughts, guys?
derek edws (00:45)
I'd love to
pri (00:46)
That was fine.
derek edws (00:46)
hear I'd love to hear how it went. I'd love to hear what you like some of the the standout experiences, like what worked well, what what could work better next year. I'm I'm always curious to get your guys' take.
Aaron (00:58)
I don't want to glaze glaze you guys too much or glaze you, Derek and Maddie and the rest of the glitch crew, Steve, too much, Zach. but I thought the MP Cause show was kind of the highlight. I thought it was great. super impressive work. I think it was very innovative, like I think it fit fits nicely into like a a cannon of s stained glass and I'm s I don't know the exact process of how we generated the you know
Aaron (01:24)
I guess the windows, I don't know exactly how to describe them, but I'm assuming there was like a generative aspect to it. really cool stuff. That was the highlight for me.
Chris (01:33)
Aaron, I think you actually do need to glaze it and go full AI slop and reframe this as not since the construction of the Notre Dame Cathedral have we seen such
derek edws (01:42)
Ha ha
Chris (01:43)
a transcendent display of illuminescent radiance shine through from the heavens, revealing an entire world within the walls of glitch.
derek edws (01:56)
Wow.
pri (01:57)
Chris, are you
Aaron (01:57)
Yeah.
pri (01:57)
are you pulling from the performance art script of that priest?
Chris (02:02)
I I'm just channeling. I'm tapping in.
pri (02:04)
You're channeling.
Aaron (02:05)
Well, I loved it. There was just MP
Chris (02:06)
I'm I'm elevating through slop discourse.
Aaron (02:09)
Yeah, you could tell that MP cause put a lot of thought into it. there was the Last Supper like ovations to it. there was like a whole performance if you weren't there, where I guess the the pastor priest kind of let everybody in. There was two confession booths that you had to kind of confess into to establish whether or not you were human or machine. and the the pastor
Aaron (02:32)
sitting in West Texas had a scream above a a massive train that never seemed to end. So he was good on his feet
pri (02:38)
That was really funny.
Aaron (02:39)
too. yeah, I don't know. I felt I felt like kind of bad for him, but also he like didn't break out of character, which I really appreciated.
derek edws (02:47)
really appreciate you guys noticing all the details. it's so when Mike kind of approached us with the idea, like the I think it you know, Maddie's very good at at kind of like bringing kind of the concepts behind the kind of the creative process and the work to kind of bear in physical form. And I think we knew pretty quickly that we wanted to land on a ceremony of some kind. And you know, and and then as the work was being made and the twelve, you know, there
derek edws (03:14)
They're actually like a very, very thin type of acrylic. They actually look like stained glass, but it's it's carbon fiber and acrylic and photy photopolymer resin. and they're I mean, they're incredibly detailed and and they give the appearance of stained glass. the as the work was coming together, it was I think we started to be really affected by, you know, Mike comes from a Catholic background. We wanted to to, you know.
derek edws (03:40)
him and I both went to an all-boys private Catholic school. We started to think about this ceremony that was from the future while also having this religious connotation connotation to the past and being kind of flanked by these stained glasses like you would in a church. And yeah, it it it, you know, I think Maddie did an amazing job with just with the the space and the layout and the the Last Supper motif that you picked up on Aaron. yeah, I I am really
derek edws (04:08)
I'm really proud of that one. I'm really proud of how it all came together. It's like a it's a three month process to get the details right and while while Mike is actually making the work and he was building these pieces painstakingly for fourteen hours a day for the last couple of months. I will say we had some interest to acquire a few of the pieces at the show and Mike was so inspired by the work as it was being hung that he decided to he wants to
derek edws (04:36)
reve he th so these the physicals were made with code originally and he's excited about kind of putting together the the code based digital to pair with each of these works. And so I think given the given the response he got and given how excited he was about yeah going deeper into kind of the the digital process to pair with these, I think he's gonna come up with something and we're gonna show that out here in the next couple of months. So I appreciate you guys saying that. It was
derek edws (05:02)
Another another one of my favorites to work on for sure and I'm glad it resonated.
Aaron (05:07)
I really like the the summer video too. I'm blanking a little bit on her last name, but I thought that that was pretty interesting and compelling. Yeah.
derek edws (05:14)
Summer Wagner. She she
derek edws (05:16)
is a v so Summer's interesting. I've been yeah, I've been following her work for the last few years. She's
Load full transcript
actually out in Los Angeles with with Madison and I. And so I've gotten to know her a bit better over the last year and have had a chance to do a couple studio visits and see her work at a couple shows in LA. And there's such a spiritual, mystical
derek edws (05:41)
piece to her practice that usually will come out in in the in the work, but like it I think what drew Maddie Malta and I to it was that there was this whole component around the work that we felt like could be really explored. And this show was like a a first touch at starting to do that. I'm I'm curious without giving away too much, because there is a another piece to the work that's coming out early next year. What did you guys think
derek edws (06:10)
think of it. I'm maybe one of you guys could describe your experience in there and and share a little bit about what what
Aaron (06:16)
Yeah. it was like
Aaron (06:17)
it was haunting, interesting. So the the the piece was a series of videos interviewing some people that were gonna have kind of what's it a UAP experience in the Mojave Desert and it showed them kinda before they had the experience and then after the experience. I just thought it was shot really well and it just had a unique perspective and kinda
Aaron (06:39)
felt like the aesthetic that probably will come to video over the next couple of years. She just felt like ahead of the curve. so I wouldn't be surprised to see know, movies or you know, begin to kind of adopt kind of the quick cut, like a lot of close up type approaches that that she was exploring there. But it just was, you know, it was interesting. It was a little bit thought provoking. It was awesome.
derek edws (07:03)
And you and you got a chance to talk to her about her experience with the UAPs too, right?
Aaron (07:07)
Yeah.
Aaron (07:08)
Yeah, exactly. Yeah. there's just some constraints. I think there's some follow up work that she may be r releasing related to it, which he's still working on. So I think it could be kind of a series. But I thought it was interesting, you know, like commenting on the American berserker that we all kind of live through and just all the weird, you know, substories that exist here, and the odd mix of people that America seems to produce and or attract. So
pri (07:32)
Actually
pri (07:32)
I was curious, I wasn't there on Saturday, but was any of that AI generated or was it all like I looked at the shots after
Aaron (07:38)
I don't think so.
derek edws (07:39)
No, those are those
Aaron (07:39)
No.
derek edws (07:40)
were all real people, real stories, real real work. And she's
pri (07:45)
nice.
derek edws (07:45)
doing an amazing job capturing that, you know, this event that happened and and really trying to narrate it and bring it to life.
Aaron (07:54)
Yeah, I also like the, jewels who I am not I don't didn't know their work that well, but I thought that they had kind of an event where they displayed the work kind of s with the setback of the desert. that's
that's West Texas or, you know, kind of high desert. I thought that was great. I just think that that kind of contrast is was really cool. it was kind of fun to just see everybody get together and and enjoy that kind of as a backdrop.
Aaron (08:18)
Obviously loved seeing the new adjacent space that that Steve put together. and yeah,
pri (08:24)
Yeah. One four one one forty. Yeah.
derek edws (08:24)
One one four. Yeah.
Aaron (08:28)
I couldn't remember the numbers, but I thought that was great. Awesome screens. Highlight for me, not to glaze you, Chris, was just seeing all the progress Chris has been making on world building. so that was super fun and impressive. and then I
derek edws (08:40)
I I'd love to hear about that.
derek edws (08:42)
W w w
pri (08:42)
Yeah, damn.
derek edws (08:43)
what's the what's the latest, Chris?
Chris (08:45)
What's the latest? Well, for starters, yeah, the the projector at one fourteen, holy cow, like when Steve was showing that off, I was like, I gotta get up on this man. Like I know you're running like a million things. You got a little empty space, you know, so I can I can do a demo for folks. And so that that was super cool just to see it on on such a big high death projector. But right now
Chris (09:13)
Yeah, I'm I'm deep across a couple things and I felt like I both never really arrived in Marfa, never really left Marfa, and I left my stomach in Alpine. But I am working on a simulation at the moment that's a lot of my my time right now and it was quite unexpected. I I really this is not something that was on my my bingo card for the month, but
Chris (09:41)
Well, I built out a like a procedurally constructed metaverse so that, you know, as you're talking to my world in the background it's creating and minting what I'm calling burbland. And so every single turn you have talking to the world, builds a little set, then as the next turn goes over, it preserves that set and it puts it on a plot with a house.
Chris (10:09)
sitting in this procedural suburb and then it spawns a resident who lives there and that resident will go out, will wander around, we'll meet, we'll talk with other other people in the simulation. And so that's been that's been one big effort for me right now. And it's it's amazing how far it's come along.
Chris (10:32)
every single day there's something else that pops up where you're like, my God, I can throw this in, I can add to it. And so, you know, over the last couple of days, I've been really pulling in a lot of Nvidia's avatar control systems. so they've got something called motion and Komodo. And what that whole system is is basically they provide an avatar body that I think has 32 joints in it.
Chris (11:00)
And then it's got a a movement library that goes along with it. It's all it's a model that you can install, train, download all the clips. And then, you know, I I've kind of like attached that to a whole control system. So as these guys are talking, there's I've got like Jeb sitting on sitting, you know, in the in the avatar shell.
Chris (11:23)
reading the conversation and figuring out, hey, is there an appropriate motion to add to this? Should you know, should they give them a hug? Should they touch someone's shoulders? Should they clap? should and so they're they're very expressive and reactive little guys who are just getting together, wandering around their their bird and and chatting to each other.
Aaron (11:43)
Yeah, it was super cool. And I the last thing, you I you have to mention it. And I think what was interesting about this Morpha is just you see the different kind of tribes of the NFT community coming together. there was an super impressive drone show that Adam Weitzman put together, kind of honoring some of the the more, you know, collectible parts of the ecosystem. So that was fun to see. definitely thought that I've I thought about that as as prenos. I think that that's like an interesting way to kinda
Aaron (12:11)
show the, the digital nature of the artwork. It can be in any form, right? It can be really big on beautiful screens. It can be really small, like in your pocket. it could hang in museums. It could even be kind of translated into a drone show, you know, like and shown in the sky. So I think the scale of digital art is always something that is interesting to me. So nice job there.
pri (12:33)
I agree. I I
pri (12:34)
yeah, just one shout out on on one fourteen as we talking about it. And Chris, I'm like I have so many questions on how you even found about these like NVIDIA like hums that you're incorporating. It like I don't even know how you found that, but it's really cool. but I I love that one space 'cause I know we were talking about it. I I thought the G Wa stuff actually really resonated too. I like loved the look of that. Like I actually really like that P that like body of work by G Wa. thought that was pretty good.
pri (13:00)
the one thing to your point though, Erin, on like it being kind of a more melting pot of different tribes or different like aesthetics, I would say. it it felt less trying to frame this in the right way. It felt less like generative focused and like less on the digital as a medium to me than normal.
pri (13:23)
I also I I don't know if I thought the quality of the work was as high this year as I have seen historically in Marfa. maybe I'm just like hating, but that's just kind of my POV. But I can't tell if that's because it's like opened up the tent for things that are like collectibles and not things that I maybe would consider like art artistic.
Aaron (13:45)
Yeah, I don't know if I agree with that, Bray. I think the I think I Yeah,
pri (13:47)
Yeah. I thought the drone show is Okay, thank you.
Chris (13:49)
Sorry, free, I'll agree with you.
Aaron (13:51)
I'll take the counter on this one. I think it's good to build a big tent and if people love any part of the space, like I'm I'm completely on board for that. I think you
pri (14:02)
I guess.
Aaron (14:03)
kinda got the whole range of it.
derek edws (14:04)
So I can I I I did a lot of work planning in anticipation for our our event there, but I haven't heard a ton of feedback on how the weekend went and I'm maybe just trying to understand a little bit more. Can you guys unpack this a bit for me?
Chris (14:20)
Alright, I'll say this. I didn't get out and about all that much. I didn't circulate. And so I'm not necessarily like in a place to judge all of this. And part of the reason why I wasn't out and about that much was I found what I'm working on to be far more compelling and interesting to me than
Chris (14:41)
just you know seeing what was what was gonna be down there and being familiar with like you know people's work and whatnot felt felt like it was gonna be more of the same. And you know me, I I like really biased towards new and novel experiences. I really, you know, like case my own interests. And so in a lot of this, you know, my my judgment or my like decision making was always like, okay, well, do I wanna spend
Chris (15:06)
10 minutes looking at work that's gonna be familiar to me and then milling around and making small talk with a great group of people, but people have already made small talk with. Or, do I wanna slip back to my place and get into like, you know, trying to crack this 3D per stage real set building stuff that's driving
pri (15:23)
What?
Chris (15:25)
me crazy? And so that's really what like the point of view I'm coming from is that you know, even in a battle.
Chris (15:32)
Or even down there, you know, it's still like MARFA versus the internet, Marfa vers the machines, Marfa vers like what what is getting me out of bed and what I'm obsessed about. And more often than not, like my my own obsessions went out.
derek edws (15:47)
is another way of saying this, you'd rather be working on your own stuff than see what other people are working on?
Chris (15:53)
I saw enough of what everyone else was working on and some of it was great. it's also like I can absorb that very quickly.
derek edws (16:00)
Mm.
Chris (16:01)
And the things I'm trying to crack really require like a lot, a lot of like involvement, persistence, stick intuitiveness. And that was just, you know, yeah, I I'm like very self driven, self motivated these days. And so it it was a it's a tough bar to overcome on any number of fronts.
Chris (16:21)
and I certainly gave Marfa its time. But I often I just view Marfa as a place to more so than like
derek edws (16:27)
Yeah, one thing I
pri (16:28)
Yeah, it's great.
derek edws (16:29)
one thing I love about you, Chris, is no matter where you are, even if you're two hours from the airport in this art destination, it's like, nope, it's time to pipe back into the matrix, sit back in my room. It's
pri (16:38)
Ha ha ha
derek edws (16:39)
like back to the back to the digital salt mines, baby.
pri (16:42)
Yeah.
Chris (16:44)
It look, I'm a man on a mission at the moment. There's been other times of my life,
pri (16:47)
Ha ha ha.
Chris (16:48)
But like I can I can see hyper reality now. Like I like I can really feel like we've turned a corner and I can see it and I know how to get there. And like, you know, it's
Aaron (16:59)
Running towards it.
Chris (17:01)
yeah, no, it it it's kind of what I needed because I'm like fifteen months into this right now. You know, and so to have these unlocks, to have like this second stage to the rocket.
Chris (17:11)
is is kind of necessary.
Aaron (17:14)
think the there was a lot of quality work. I think it w just was in a lot of side events. there was was the Lumbyard, there was a bunch of folks, including Glimmerdao, that put some stuff together.
pri (17:22)
I like the lumber yard a lot. Yeah.
Aaron (17:24)
There was a really cool, kind of like arcade. I don't ac I didn't get to speak to its creator, but I thought it was really novel and interesting. Derek could kind of remind me a little bit of I think it was last year, with those orbs. I forgot the name of it. So apologies for that. But it kind of had like a a little bit of that aesthetic, but was like a
Aaron (17:43)
like a maze that was really difficult to kind of win. I thought it was cool pushing on that.
derek edws (17:46)
The the artists, yeah, the artist
derek edws (17:49)
the artist is pack. It's actually the same artist as the one we featured last year with the Plints. where are are you talking about the dance
Aaron (17:53)
that was the same artist? Yeah.
derek edws (17:56)
same artist? Yeah, he's he's awesome. He's actually in Los Angeles with me as well, and I got a chance to look at the work before he brought it out to Marfa. I I am a huge Pac-Man fan. Pac-Man Scoop is his name on Twitter. He's yeah, he's just incredible at bridging hardware and software and and
derek edws (18:16)
great design to embody the the work. So I'm really happy to hear that the the arcade experiences that he brought out there resonated with folks.
Aaron (18:23)
Yeah, I think I thought that was cool. there was even stuff that I missed, I didn't realize some of Kevin McCoy's work was being displayed. That was really my bad, but I was bummed to kinda not you know, not be able to see that. I there was some I think pretty impressive and very aesthetically pleasing new generative work, I think, in the lumber house too.
pri (18:43)
Yeah.
Aaron (18:44)
lumber yard. so I thought that was great.
pri (18:46)
Nori's work there was great. Yeah.
Aaron (18:48)
Yeah, I mean it it definitely felt like
Aaron (18:50)
the artists from Japan and just some other kind of pockets of the planet are are still pushing the frontier when it comes to aesthetics. so I thought that was cool. you know, another highlight I guess for me would would have would be watching Tony H Herrera kinda like cook up tacos and and give them to everybody.
pri (19:07)
I love him.
Aaron (19:08)
You could kind of see that that was like a big passion of his. He just looks so
happy. And obviously they were like out outstandingly good too. so I thought that that piece was was was pretty good.
pri (19:17)
So
derek edws (19:17)
I think
derek edws (19:17)
the I think that I think it's nice to hear. I think I ex I think all that feedback all makes sense from everyone. I maybe one thing I'll just say is the event to we have all been going since the very beginning, since that that very first ArtBlox weekend. I will say like the event is evolving, right? It is changing. It is you know, there was a I think a lot of heavy lifting that like the ArtBlox House and Glitch did those first three years.
derek edws (19:43)
And over the last couple years, it is spreading out. Like more people want to rent and or like lease spaces for the weekend. More people want to do pop ups. More people want to bust folks out into the desert to do kind of like one off one off shows. And I I actually I think that I think that's a good trend. I think the event only grows and and more people come into into it if that happens. and so it it's been
derek edws (20:10)
I think there's I think I have kind of mixed feelings about what that actually looks like, but it's kind of like a blockchain, right? It's like you you have your opinion of what you want people to do on this global database, but ultimately it's public and permissionless and anybody can come and build whatever they want. And some of those experiences may be a little bit different than the ones that you enjoy, but in the you know, it the everyone's kinda guided. Like the through line is like we're all making this trek out to the desert and
derek edws (20:39)
It's fun and and interesting and people will do different things. I think the thing that pre-s flagging is an interesting note, which is I ultimately you don't want the identity of the week to turn into something else than I maybe what like the original ethos or spirit of it was. And I'm not by no means am I saying that that's happened here or is happening. It's more just like I think one of the you you look at any a lot of like these decentralized organizations. I I mean went to Burning Man ten years ago and I think that event has
derek edws (21:08)
very clearly changed for anyone that's going in the last year or two. But the y there there are these things that happen with time and with more people coming to things where the the goal of the the project just starts to morph into something new and different. And it's for some people that might not be as interesting. For others it's way more interesting. And so yeah, I don't I don't know what happens here, but it is cool to see the event growing in size. I I guess both both land like the size of folks that are
derek edws (21:39)
joining the event and the types of things that people want to showcase at the event.
Chris (21:43)
No, Derek, I think that's a a it's a really good point and it kinda matches up to how I th I've been thinking about it for the last three years or so. I don't really view Art Art Blogs Weekend as as Art Blocks anymore. I I I consider it more of a homecoming in which like you can approach it on your own terms. And
Chris (22:04)
Whatever your mood is that year, whatever happens to be around, who happens to be around, there's a certain consistency to it. you're always going to know there's a critical mass of people you like in the space there. There's always gonna be good artists doing interesting things. Marfa now, you're very familiar with how to get around, what the vibe of the place is, what the weather's gonna be.
Chris (22:28)
And so I no longer view it as I don't even register t at our blocks. I don't I don't sign up for any of the official events. I just show up and I I roam around and you know, I think there's some years where I'm gonna be like more about okay, what are people showing, you know, and engaging with it. And there's there's gonna be other years where it's just like, I you know, I'm looking forward to having a few good really good conversations, but like I really just wanna be out in Martha. And, you know, for me this year it was just like,
Chris (22:57)
I really want to, be in a good environment, you know, kinda have like space to myself to, you know, focus on my work. But then like, you know, there's only so much you can do and then the machines need to like turn for hours and then you're like, well, great. I mean this is you know, I'll just cue this up, I'll give it a really hard problem, then I'll head in town for like five hours and I'll come back, you know, for a couple hours, switch switch the shifts out at the mines and then head in for dinner.
Aaron (23:22)
Yeah. I think it's definitely like a vibe, which is which is great. yeah, it's such an amazing place.
pri (23:26)
Yeah. I love it there. But it was more just the commentary
pri (23:31)
on on like it it evolving, I think. It's just you know, is more what I was saying, I guess.
derek edws (23:37)
I think it's a fair I think
derek edws (23:38)
these are fair points you're bringing up, Brie, for sure. I think
Chris (23:41)
I I think we have
Chris (23:42)
to ask the most important question. Pre was the Elizabeth Holmes movie worth leaving a day early for?
pri (23:47)
I so I planned that after I was planning on leaving on Saturday. But yes, it was fantastic. You guys should all watch it if you have it. It's like really thought provoking.
derek edws (23:56)
I s I saw it. I saw
derek edws (23:58)
I saw it and I loved it. I
Chris (24:00)
I I I
Chris (24:01)
can't do awkwardness, I'm sorry. I'll I'll just take your word for it.
Aaron (24:04)
Yeah.
Aaron (24:05)
Yeah, I think I'm gonna unkear Chris. I can't tell if he's kinda like the Steve Martin of millennials. he's just like a a
derek edws (24:11)
Here's the thing I'll say about Nathan Fielder.
derek edws (24:13)
as somebody who's been I was a a very big fan for Nathan for you on Comedy Central, I don't even 15 years ago. This work, the documentary that he did
with Elizabeth Holmes, is very different than anything he's done before. And I think a lot I think
Aaron (24:26)
that's good to know.
derek edws (24:27)
a lot of people saw the trailer and were like, okay, he's running Nathan for You on Elizabeth Holmes. And that's just not the case. It is, I I would say it
derek edws (24:38)
is a the the the I th maybe the thing that I will flag for you guys without kind of like sharing about the the mystery or the story as it evolves is he approaches the medium very differently than he approached his other work. And I think yeah I would say it it really there was a point about halfway through where I was like I don't know if I've ever s quite seen a film like this before. And that is that was a surprising feeling for me.
derek edws (25:06)
to feel like the expectations as they were being presented were flipped on its head. And anyway anyway, I agree with Bree. I thought it was a it's it's worth watching if for nothing else than to see someone who's an expert at his craft approach a material that's very different and just do it with a creativity that leaves you just like I guess just like surprised and interested in following
pri (25:33)
Yeah.
derek edws (25:33)
along it with every word.
pri (25:35)
There's a lot of meta moments. I thought it was I thought yes, he's awkward, but the the substance is is so rich and the way he approaches it, I think is very unique. 'Cause he's not a an investigative journalist or a documentarian by any means. So having that figure approach that I think is really interesting. And I will say, like it was just a good piece of art art in the sense that like
pri (25:58)
After watching it, I think I wavered on my opinion of, Nathan's role, her, the way that, you know, there's some other things I don't want to give away, but like the way that it was shot. I'm like, who's the manipulator? Is it Nathan? Is it Elizabeth? Is it Billy, her husband? Like, I think that there's a lot of perspectives you could like dissect this movie and like there's a million think pieces. There's like a million
pri (26:21)
things written about it already from all these variant perspectives. But I think the fact that there's even that much discussion on what is the actual truth is just frames the fact that it's a good piece of art. it's just important.
derek edws (26:34)
I I saw I
derek edws (26:36)
saw it with to that point, Pri. I saw it with my wife and her best friend and the three of us got out of the movie and we n all three of us had landed in completely different spots. And I can't
pri (26:46)
Right.
derek edws (26:46)
remember a piece of work, whether it's like a film or art or or or a performance, where I've ever had that feeling, which was also like to your point a really interesting I I'm very rarely surprised.
derek edws (27:00)
And I felt like even walking out of this, I felt surprised with its impact.
pri (27:04)
Yeah, and I think that to me is a unique thing. Cause I I watched it with three other people too, and we all landed on different places and also were like still digesting it. and then I ended up on Reddit and Twitter and all the social media reading about it after. I thought it was really good. But anyways, we don't need to we don't need to bore the ungst.
Aaron (27:21)
Well so so pre
Aaron (27:24)
pre wants that type of quality of art to to hit Marfa, you
pri (27:28)
Yeah.
Aaron (27:29)
know. Things again ninety nine, ninety eight percent on Rotten Tomatoes. So thanks for keeping the standards the or being you know, somebody calling for high standards. Can I can I mention one other thing that I thought was interesting in in Marfa? Chris kinda touched on it before.
derek edws (27:44)
Definitely.
Aaron (27:46)
We took a little side quest to Alpine, which is kind of the neighboring town.
Aaron (27:49)
And I was super surprised just to see the pushback on data centers. So that part of the country is just super energy rich, right? Like Midland, Texas is not that far away. It's kind of like at the edges of the Permian Basin. I learned from conversations with some other folks it has a lot of access to water in some aquifers that are kind of running below the land.
Aaron (28:12)
and so it seems like you know, one of the ground zeros for big data center build outs and at least in the neighboring towns, there was, you know, signs on every store, you know, on people's houses just really pushing back on the the data center build out, which I thought was pretty pretty fascinating. You know, just kind of reading about it on Twitter, it's kinda hard to know is this some like psyop campaign by some nefarious actor or is this organic? But it it looked pretty organic. So that
Aaron (28:39)
That was something that helped me adjust some of my priors there. So I thought that was pretty interesting.
derek edws (28:45)
It is interesting. Yeah, thanks for sharing that.
pri (28:48)
I'm kinda bummed I didn't go to the Alpine trip. I did go to the I finally went to Moonlight Gemstones, by the way, Derek. I don't know if you've ever been there while you've been in Marfa, but it's sick.
derek edws (28:57)
It is sick. Yeah.
pri (28:59)
There's not much to say. It's just like an amazing little shop and this guy collects like rocks and gems from all over the world and Texas, obviously. And he's just and I actually bought a little fossil that is from the Cambrian period, like literally 450 million years old. It's pretty common. It's like the first, it's like what's it called? The terobyte or something. a trilobite.
pri (29:24)
but it looked really good and I don't know, I just thought it was a really like fun little quirky store. but yeah, I was a fan.
derek edws (29:31)
We like the rocks.
pri (29:32)
We like the rocks. I had never been there in my sixth times of going to Marf I'd never been to Moonlight Gemstones. But it was cool.
derek edws (29:39)
Should we talk about the internet melting
Aaron (29:39)
Well, it seems like
derek edws (29:41)
down?
pri (29:41)
Yeah. We did a little last movie.
Aaron (29:42)
it's yeah. it definitely it's tr
Aaron (29:46)
it was it's treacherous times on on the internet. I'm sure everybody saw that Binance got hacked for what I think initially people thought was like two ish billion dollars. I think it's been updated to about six billion dollars, which is obviously a tremendous amount of of capital. super fascinating.
Aaron (30:06)
super interesting to see the digital asset industry kind of digest that. I wonder if we get like some new centralized exchanges. I I'm curious what what you guys think is the kind of the fallout from this.
derek edws (30:18)
I I've looked at some of the post mortem stuff that Binance has put out and it just feels really fishy. Like I I'm not quite sure what the takeaway is. Let me I think
pri (30:28)
What was the
pri (30:29)
post mortem actually? 'Cause I haven't even I obviously I've seen the h hack and there's more leaf coming and now the FBI and C FTC is like cooperating in it, but and everyone's joking that it was Korea, but what's the actual post mortem of it? they just had everything in households?
derek edws (30:42)
So the post the po
derek edws (30:44)
the post mortem is there was a compromised laptop from an engineer and that compromised laptop I mean they didn't go totally into detail for security reasons, but one compromised laptop from an employee led to a six billion dollar hack, which I find to be quite
pri (31:03)
Insane.
derek edws (31:04)
unrealistic. I mean, like I don't I'm not exactly sure what the
derek edws (31:10)
the the security breakdown was and I don't know if they've published anything in more detail, but
derek edws (31:14)
Listen, I do know that these models are getting incredibly good. And it's not just the model performance anymore, it's the fact that you can we're we're moving from single player inference into a gendech inference. So you can have you can, you know, select a payload to reverse engineer. So like, you know, book me a dinner at the hottest restaurant in town over the next thirty days. And you've got you agents that can help
derek edws (31:41)
work and iterate and improve themselves and try new things until that job is done. And I think when you pair really performant models with y let's call it agentic swarm inference, and you point it towards kind of malicious things, what we're finding is the way humans wrote code over the last 30, 40 years is like very fragile when applied to like, you know, thousands of intelligent you know,
derek edws (32:08)
computers that are trying to find holes or places to shake the tree or look for backdoors or do second, third, fourth order, consequences to single events that humans might not see. And we're l it's leading to kind of a lot of outcomes like this. And and I would say like everything is at risk, right? It's like any database architecture that was written by humans is you needs to be looked at.
derek edws (32:35)
and secured in a way that takes into account this new paradigm that we're moving into. With that being said, this this feels different to me. Like something about this does isn't quite mapping. And I don't know I just it's har it's hard for me to understand
Aaron (32:49)
I guess
derek edws (32:50)
exactly what happened.
Aaron (32:52)
Yeah, I guess we'll get the autopsy reports, right? There's so much so much value at stake, that I imagine that that we'll probably learn more like as the story kind of develops. I you know, I saw somebody give a take which I thought was interesting. It was kinda like I'm gonna butcher it a little bit, but here was the sentiment. It was kinda like crypto's like a heat shield, almost like when you're, you know, going, I guess or coming back from outer space. It like burns off.
Aaron (33:18)
It's a good place for some of the unsavory parts of the internet to focus on first. so it doesn't impact kind of the rest of the economy. but I think the end point of this is just we're gonna rewrite all software. I actually think it's a bull case for a lot of the large
pri (33:32)
Really?
Aaron (33:33)
hyperscalers. Yeah, I just think that there's a bunch of developers, many of which like started their careers are still in and around crypto, that are trying to quote unquote formally verify code.
Aaron (33:45)
And by doing that, you can really narrow or potentially eliminate the attack surface. And I think crypto's gonna be one of the first industries to kind of move in that en masse. And then that will probably bleed out to other critical parts of the internet, governments, et cetera. just feel like that this is just more incentive for that to happen and for it to happen faster. but if we have to rewrite all the code that existed in the past,
Aaron (34:10)
Which it seems like we're gonna probably have to do that at least over the next couple of months to years. it just means that there's gonna be a lot of tokens consumed. So like the demand for tokens, the bid for tokens, I don't think that's going down. I think all this stuff is just indicates the bid for it is gonna continue to be pretty high.
Chris (34:26)
The bid for it will be high. The cost will fall. Is this our segue into the commanding heights of techno capitalism, which I've only gotten halfway
Aaron (34:34)
Yeah, I thought
Chris (34:35)
through?
Aaron (34:36)
yeah, I got about you know, I have it kind of bookmarked for when I ha Yeah.
derek edws (34:38)
I I'm halfway through too. I think I think we're all
derek edws (34:41)
about halfway through.
Aaron (34:43)
Yeah, there was definitely some good memes about it. I always appreciate these epic tomes that people are trying to trying to write. I I thought it was thought provoking. just 'cause you guys are a little bit further along than me, do you guys wanna give the the the T L D R of it? If for folks that may not have read it yet.
derek edws (34:58)
I'll I'll yeah,
derek edws (34:59)
I I think
I'm still waiting for him to kind of land the plane on a bunch of this stuff, but I would say he uses fiction as a way to insert kind of where we're currently at from this agentic inference era into the economy and how it's going to diffuse in the second and third and fourth order fourth order effects of that for how money moves around, how work gets built, who's the winners, who's the losers, where does wealth aggregate, where does it disaggregate.
derek edws (35:28)
And yeah, it uses kind of like storytelling and prose to like it to flush that out. It's I got I you know, was reading it with my eyes at first and I was like I can't I can't read this right now. this is just like the the I'm so used to more direct language these days when with like this point making. So I just put it on in the background and they thankfully they have like an audio feature too so you can listen to it, which is which is what I ended up doing. I'm about halfway through it
Aaron (35:53)
I thought that was cool. That was smart.
pri (35:55)
Yeah, I like that too. I started listening
derek edws (35:55)
is cool. Yeah.
pri (35:57)
to it.
derek edws (35:57)
which makes it a little easier to get through. just because he is like it is very flowery language. but yeah, I would say it's like it's insightful in the sense that it's really difficult, I think, for people to hold in the in the balance all of the different things that are kind of competing right now with one another and what the effects will be on right. It's kind of like a a butterfly effect. It's like, you know, something that happens with this Fortune five hundred company could affect, you know.
derek edws (36:26)
Are you eating potatoes tomorrow or are you in you know looking wandering around trying to find water to like survive? that's an extreme example, obviously. But like the point I'm making is there's so much complexity to trying to predict or understand the future that I think what he does or he's attempting to do, is kind of like, let's just try and bring all these competing ideas together and use storytelling and prose to kind of
derek edws (36:52)
figure out the web of how they all connect to one another. So I'm only halfway through. I haven't really seen him laying the plane on this stuff yet, but I would say it's a good I kudos to anyone that takes the time to try and
Aaron (37:03)
Makes it all the way through. Yeah.
derek edws (37:05)
dude
Chris (37:05)
No, but to to construct
derek edws (37:06)
yeah
Chris (37:07)
something like this. Yeah, I hear ya, Derek.
Aaron (37:08)
Completely.
Chris (37:10)
Yeah, I think the thing is if you're around this space, you know, a piece like this isn't revelatory at all. You know, like you're familiar with these ideas, they've been circulating, you've had had these thoughts yourself. but you know, I I think what Will does Will Mandis does well, right, is he's very supplemental around that. And he provides like more color, more cover, like he paints the scene.
Chris (37:36)
from a perspective that maybe you yourself really weren't looking at and just creates more room for your thoughts or fills in gaps or allows you to see things a slightly different way. the pros, I find it a little tough in in that like I don't think he's actually narratively strong enough. you know, in a way like
Chris (38:00)
Like a Michael Lewis, let's just take one of the all-time greats, around something like this. it it it it has a flow, it has a drive to it. He you know, is maybe a little more like Guns German steel you know, style, like popular popular nonfiction, and can get a little wonkish at times. And, you know, I think
derek edws (38:21)
Exactly.
Chris (38:22)
that's why like the listening aspect of this is probably good. Cause, you know, like I'm multi-screening as I'm reading this and
Chris (38:28)
I'm jumping over to cursor and I'm I'm in this very dense techno jargon. And, to jump back over, it's not a breath of fresh air for me. it's just now we're gonna do this in a slightly denser style. And so, but it is, I think, you know, worthwhile. And I do think like we all need to inhabit and take take a long sweeping view around things every once in a while, just you know, as a
Chris (38:56)
a way of anchoring ourselves to what this moment in time means and whether certain assumptions, are being maintained, whether they're changing, or as, you know, every six months, I think it's good to to engage with one of these pieces, you know, just as a way of resetting and reframing your own your own worldview, you know, within like this giant moment.
Aaron (39:23)
Yeah, I agree with that. I think the from what I kind of gleaned from it already, and what I've seen some people just summarizing it, I read a couple summaries. I think the the headline is right that they're predicting that the ultimate value for all this new intelligence will not necessarily root back to the hyperscalers or those that are producing tokens. they may just root back to the financial system.
Aaron (39:49)
or things adjacent to it, which I took as actually being incredibly bullish for legacy companies that may be involved in that flow. that could be, places like Visa or MasterCard. But I think increasingly
pri (40:02)
Right.
Aaron (40:03)
that also be yeah, Stripe and blockchains, right? I think it also kind of fits neatly. I don't think this was touched in it into just this notion of exocapital where just capital is probably increasingly important as kind of intelligence turns labor.
Aaron (40:18)
Or makes labor or changes the way we perform labor. So I kind of viewed it as
Chris (40:23)
Yeah.
Aaron (40:24)
like a net net bullish for this space that we spend so much time with. And you know, and I think that that's like the meta trend and what makes digital assets crypto feel so difficult right now. We're like in we're like a awkward teenager, like kind of growing up. Like we're getting real utility assets on chain.
Aaron (40:44)
We're
being embedded in more and more important systems in the background, and the transaction volumes are just gonna explode. and I think people really haven't wrapped their heads around like how many transactions there's gonna be running through blockchains and related services. it's not gonna be like a one X change, it's not gonna be a two X change or even a ten or twenty five X, it's gonna be, thousand X plus, if not more. and you know, one interesting
Aaron (41:12)
piece that kinda kinda came out of the Binance hack was just what the hackers did afterwards. we can include this in the show notes, but you know, they sent, you know, scores of transactions in like a very complicated web in order to kind of move the proceeds. And I think it's kind of a glimmer into like what a gentic finance is gonna look like and it's gonna be tons of transactions at a minimum.
Chris (41:38)
There's gonna be a lot of blocks. Blocks gonna be made all over the place. you know, Will Mandis works for team capital, right? Like his heart is in capital markets, that's the jersey he wears, the the colors he flies. And so his piece is gonna skew very strongly as like capital is in the driver's seat, even
Chris (41:58)
Even if there's this earth-shattering technology, around AI, ultimately money is going to control its flows because mo money is its oxygen. And and that's a perfectly good position to take. And if you stay within that worldview and you think about it from the perspective of crypto, in a way, crypto, it could be in that transitionary phase where,
Chris (42:23)
it is no longer its own independent domain and that it's ultimately gonna have to bend the knee and merge and integrate, you know, into this you know, larger agentic finance stack in ways that's gonna change it. And so like, you know, we really like could be looking at crypto's last days as an independent sovereign, as its own, you know, sort of domain. And and in those final days we're seeing all sorts of, you know, both like
Chris (42:52)
moments of integration and you know joining up become you know no longer being mercia but like fusing with you know wessex and northumberland to become england but also like the outlaw days of it are s are in its like prime you know in its like full heyday with with the Binance hack and you know like all of these things. And so you know just like the from will from a Will Mandis stand
Chris (43:18)
colored glasses, that's one way to think about what's happening right now.
Aaron (43:23)
Yeah, let me let me zoom zoom you out to twenty thirty five, Chris. we have fully formally verified code. I think that's coming in the next, you know, one to three years, let's say. gonna be deployed in crypto first. So there's no more security risks or the aperture for that is much, much less. number two, we have incredible amounts of of tokenization that's happening from traditional Wall Street. whether that's you know
Aaron (43:51)
Dollars, stocks. I think there's just gonna be a
whole host of assets that have actual value that have fundamentals. you could see an increasing crackdown on the casino parts of crypto just because because they're a little unsavory, they're not socially beneficial. you hear people kind of pushing back on just gambling in general, and I think that's gonna continue to gain steam. And crypto is the safest place for value. and if you graph that
Aaron (44:18)
onto, you know, Will's argument. you know, maybe that's kind of the end point. where, you know, crypto and AI are really two sides of the same coin. a little bit like what, you know, Reed Hoffman and Peter Thiel kind of famously argued, you know, half a decade plus ago. which we can also include that in the show notes if folks haven't absorbed that one.
Chris (44:38)
Well, all right, let's let's just say in like the the real worldview mode, right? Really crypto could become the merchant class of this new society that's forming and that, you know, AI might be taking a more dominant role in society, like i.e. that of the church or that of the sovereign. But yes, like they're all gonna like start to fuse and integrate and come under one tent rather than like consider themselves, you know, their own separate thing.
Aaron (45:06)
Yeah, I think that merging is happening. I think the knee has already been bent. and I think it's gonna be a net benefit for everybody. but then the net net of all that, you know, possibly with, you know, identity and reputation systems sitting at the edges, just 'cause it's it probably makes sense for that to happen. You have kind of the actual expression of the future of finance. You have the, you know, actual new rails that is where, you know, the good guys are really playing.
Aaron (45:35)
And if you want to be, outside of that system, it may be that just the traditional systems are more equipped for that. we we've seen headlines where some of the big banks and other institutions have really struggled they've really struggled to to make sure that their customers are are good actors, or at least that's what's alleged.
Chris (45:54)
Is anyone a good actor these days? I know I know there are plenty of of good actors out
Aaron (45:58)
Yeah, come on.
Chris (45:59)
there, but it it it's an er Well
pri (46:00)
There are a lot of not great actors though.
Chris (46:04)
It it's a good time to be a bad guy right now.
pri (46:06)
Yeah.
pri (46:06)
It's like peak bad guy. I think
Aaron (46:08)
Yeah, I'm gonna take the under on that. I
Aaron (46:10)
think we're almost done with this I think we got a couple more years of this age of chaos and we're moving towards the great moderation. maybe it's guided in part by these AI systems that intermediate. Maybe it's aided in part by, some weird impact from peptides. I just feel like
pri (46:26)
That's
Aaron (46:28)
we're we're we're moving back and congealing again. hopefully in a a positive way. So I'll I'll wear that Optimus hat today while you guys
Aaron (46:38)
Doom scroll through it.
pri (46:40)
I will say the Will Manis thing is interesting because it's like I do think science fiction is popping off more, I would say in the last two years. I don't know if it's like the SpaceX IPO or what, but it does feel like there's more interest around science fiction, even the books. I feel like I'll talk to people and they're like recommending more sci-fi. I think it's like this weird thing where it's almost easier to read about the future and like, you know, potential
pri (47:06)
outcomes through fiction and then rooted into these like parts of parts of the world we're living in and like kind of predict it's more predictive than anything else so I think that's part of the reason why we're like seeing people even take this format like even Scott Alexander and that AI whatever
pri (47:23)
twenty forty one or what I forgot the actual year. he also takes a little bit of fiction to try to make these predictions. It also kinda reminded me, frankly, Chris, of like hyper-real hospitality where you're trying to make sense of all these different technologies and how they weave in together. It was like VR, AR, metaverse, like crypto, AI, obviously, and and I don't know, and like and thinking about the
pri (47:47)
the exocapitalism and like what society looks like. I I think it was like very much in that vein. And I wouldn't be surprised if like that's the medium to which people want to communicate the next like ten, twenty years of this like I wanna say fourth turning, but this like trans transition period. Yeah.
Chris (48:06)
You can say foreturning. It's not a dirty word.
pri (48:08)
Yeah, I don't know. It it is it you know, I mean Bill Gates says it's gonna last twenty years, but
pri (48:13)
whatever, the next five, ten years. I I I I actually have accelerando. I wanna start that this weekend. I've been reading Diamond Age. It's and it's more just trying to like get a grasp of what's to come. very tough
Chris (48:27)
Storytelling
Chris (48:28)
is is the vehicle in which we do that, right? It's a vehicle in which we can both get a we can scale things down into personal relationships, we can, you know, entertain ourselves through like the power of a good storyline, but then that that can also carry like the scaffolding for much, much larger issues. And I I do think when you're dealing with
Chris (48:51)
this level of complexity, this velocity of change, and you know, like every everyone who tries to predict the future ends up looking foolish in some some way, shape, or form or another. And, you know, using using narrative and using storytelling is a great cover to give yourself like, you know, enough sort of safe space to to ruminate and not get called out. Like you're certainly not, you know, an analyst on
Chris (49:17)
on a an investment bank saying the stock's gonna be this number this month, right? Or you're not doing procurement or, trying to build a hyperscaler in which, if you get your bets wrong, you you
destroy the trajectory of a company for decades to come or, more likely permanently. And so yeah, I do think stories are a really good place to do this in. And it's also like
Chris (49:43)
at least in my own journey right now, it's dovetailing very, very well to what is just unlocking in the last month or so. just in terms of what Opus Five Five and that generation, like our, you know, this model class is capable of, the their ability to do math, their ability to visualize things, their ability to like manipulate digital physics.
Chris (50:08)
in environments like 3JS, right? Or Splats or world models, is just so damn strong. And like the unlocks are coming so fast and furious over there. And it's such a wide open space. You know, it's I think all of that is is converging. You know, like I've been sitting on this book for a long time now because I just don't want to release it as a book. I want to release it as an experience and as an immersive environment. And you know, that's really kind of what I've been
Chris (50:37)
been chasing after and for the longest time it just it's it's not something I could see how it could actually come together or what like a timetable was to actually be able to deliver that experience. And I just feel within this month that I can see how to do it. I know what the the pathway and the through lines are and that there's almost enough material there. There's almost enough agentic assistance to be able to pull it off. And so
Chris (51:05)
I do think
Chris (51:08)
It's just it's that moment in time and we all like a good story. We all, want to get carried along. And, you know, so like you could be mainlining your situation reports and your P Doom and and you know, crypto hacks and and doom scrolling, all of that, but like you can also be filled with a sense of wonder and adventure and like joy at being alive and just, you know, as you were talking about last week on the pod.
Chris (51:34)
just that overwhelming sense of gratitude and the sheer impossibility of finding yourself, A here, but B at this moment in time. And
pri (51:45)
Yeah.
Chris (51:45)
so I think that's a very compelling side of this as well.
pri (51:49)
Yeah. and I think you've you've done a really good job of articulating that. And honestly, even when you're talking about crypto and all these hacks being like the last I don't want to say the last gasp of it being like a singular industry before it gets absorbed reminds me a lot of what you were writing about in in hyper real hospitality as well is like it just gets folded into the infrastructure of life as opposed to being this separate industry. And we might be almost there, but yeah, I think I think, to your point.
pri (52:19)
reflecting on the world, you know, internally as, you know, being alive in this moment, but even just where we're going is I think it's well communicated by fiction, right now. Fiction.
Chris (52:29)
Yeah,
Chris (52:29)
no for sure. It it's interesting 'cause my book
club for like this year we've just been doing books about New York. That's been the theme for the year. And to close out the year we've decided we're gonna do New York Twenty One Forty by Kim Stanley Robinson, which I I knew nothing about. I I still have it. It's like showing up in the mail. what I can tell is it's a it's a climate dystopia and it was put out in twenty seventeen and Goodreads is
Chris (52:57)
Giving it a three point six out of five, which, you know.
pri (53:00)
That's pretty not great.
Chris (53:02)
Well, Goodreads is a tough crowd. and so I'm really curious now because like to have written, you know, like I was writing fiction in in 2017, and like your worldview, you know, like I was doing speculative fiction back then, your worldview from in 2017 versus 2026 is completely upended. And so it
Aaron (53:21)
That's true.
Chris (53:22)
I'm I'm kinda on guard to see how dated this is this is gonna be.
Aaron (53:28)
Yeah, I I think makes makes sense to me that science fiction also will or that people are exploring it more 'cause I think it's really hard to stare into the into the exponential, right? Like it you really have to bend your brain. it may even be like a kind of futile process. You know, I I know Sean McGuire, who who's a partner at Sequoia, the kind of epic like the epic venture fund.
Aaron (53:55)
He noted something. I think he's a trained or has a PhD in in physics. And he's he said the only way to make sense of the world right now is to understand we're approaching the singularity. Space-time is becoming more curved and relative times are disturbed in the sense that we're getting pulled basically into a almost like a black hole. and it's gonna be hard to kinda understand what the rules and physics are related to it. Like as we get
pri (54:21)
Fourth turning.
Aaron (54:22)
As we get deeper into the singularity. And then he mused on that again yesterday, basically saying that he thinks that quantum effects will will save us, which I I thought was a or quantum entangle entanglement may save us, which I thought was a a good a good coda to to what he was saying before. But I think, I think the net net is like it's just a moderation. Like I I increasingly just think that that's what's gonna happen.
Aaron (54:49)
you you already had Reddit did you guys see Reddit yesterday? They basically said that they they were getting no traffic from AI and their stock kinda got hammered because of it, unfortunately. Did you guys see this?
Chris (55:00)
It's a good good week for your stock to get hammered. No, I did see that. And coupled with Discord being like, hey, we're just gonna throw all your shit on Google unless you start opting out. Well, I mean,
Aaron (55:09)
Yeah, why? Yeah. I was like
Chris (55:12)
Discord's business. I mean, remember looking at this. Discord only does like a hundred million a year in revenue. It's shocking how little revenue a platformer that
Aaron (55:22)
Really? Wow.
Chris (55:23)
size does. I mean, that was from a couple of years back, but I remember looking at that and going, my God.
Chris (55:29)
that's tiny.
Aaron (55:31)
Yeah. Well th I think they'll f they'll figure it out. But it it just really like AI is the the new middleman, right? it's it's replacing everything and middlemen take a lot of value from that. And I just think there's some negative side effects to that. Clearly, if your business was dependent on other middlemen, whether that was social media or search, but you know, AI is the alpha predator of everything right now, including those platforms. And I just think
Aaron (55:57)
the negative effects of those platforms which are pretty well worn, whether that's, information bubbles, what's the right way to describe it? Kind of sensation sensationalism that kind of cuts through the attention economy. I just feel like the physics of that is just changing at this point. and it's probably not going to be as effective. Like the more and more people are kind of viewing the world through the lens of an AI system, just the
Aaron (56:23)
It's not gonna feel the same as it it did when we were viewing the world through through a search box or or through social media feeds.
Chris (56:31)
A hundred percent. No, this is the Route 66 moment for web two. they're just gonna
Aaron (56:37)
Yeah.
Chris (56:37)
get left behind, their side of the road, it's roadside attractions for nostalgia now. Cause AI is so much closer to your mind, right? It's so like it's a step. you know, like web pages, there's a dis
Chris (56:52)
I don't even know how to explain it, right? but AI like alm it feels like another appendage versus you and a screen.
Aaron (56:59)
Yeah, it's like it's like the customization that we knew was coming from the internet and computers. It just it's there, right? It's in your pocket, it's talking to you increasingly, it's on your your desktop, it's on all your devices, it's in your it's in your home, and it's just gonna be the middleman to all these different businesses. Stack Overflow, which I think a lot of the developers will know, it was iconic, right? if you wanted to solve a really hard programming problem.
Aaron (57:27)
you went there to post a question or or learn from others that solved a problem you may have. the numbers are kind of shocking to this the situator, Chris. Like in September twenty twenty one there was a hundred and twenty thousand questions asked that month. In twenty twenty four it was twenty four thousand like almost twenty five thousand and it was a thousand questions this past September. It just like fell off a c
Chris (57:50)
Wow.
Aaron (57:51)
a cliff completely. So to your route sixty six point,
Aaron (57:55)
it feels like that's increasingly happening and probably will happen to more and more platforms. I imagine like something will kind of spring up in its like once the shift happens, but it does feel like the attention economy, which was super exciting and interesting, but probably
net net negative for everybody. maybe maybe in its last couple innings.
Chris (58:15)
Yeah, well it's not only that, but it's also it's no longer about solving a problem, it's about conceptualizing the problem.
Aaron (58:22)
Like a system.
Chris (58:23)
And
Chris (58:23)
and yeah, or just like having having the right mindset or or knowing to ask for interesting things or wanting to materialize something in a novel way is is really now where where value is gonna come from. It's no longer going to be, well, we all we all kind of know like this is this is how things happen and we just need a better, faster, more efficient way to do it.
Chris (58:51)
program programming team, go go take a crack at, breaking this nut. It's no longer that. It's really about like all the known things can easily be optimized. But it's also we're opening up this whole new aperture of discovery that the map itself, you know, we've we now need to fill in all these these empty lands. Let's go, let's go about solving for that.
Chris (59:17)
it it's really
Aaron (59:17)
Yeah.
Chris (59:18)
w but let's go back to England. It's no longer about how do we put roads and, you know, turnpikes and how do we get goods to market. Like it's let's get our ass beyond England. Let's see what's, you know, on the other side of the sea.
Aaron (59:32)
Let's see if we can we can get all the way through continental Europe now. Something like that. It's the n it's in the Napoleon era.
Chris (59:41)
I mean I there there is a lot of like Napoleonic conquests going on out there right now. You know. the continental
Aaron (59:47)
Yeah. I don't I don't know what I
Chris (59:50)
wars are are fully raging, but at the same time, you know, there's there's plenty of of places beyond the reach beyond being contested and, you know, to open up, you know.
Aaron (59:59)
Yeah. I'm trying to I think you're starting to see hyper reality, but I think that that may be where things are going, Chris. I mean, I I'm assuming you agree with that, but you know, another notable news from this week was Google came out one with some models that are now state of the art, which is not surprising to me. I just feel like Google has such a, you know, gold mine of data. And they obviously were pioneers, were acquired the pioneers that
Aaron (01:00:29)
That kicked this all off. So they've caught up. It looks like it feels like they've cooked up something a little bit different than what Anthropic and OpenAI have. wouldn't be surprised if they're hitting their inflection point where they become the alpha predator here. and same thing, I feel like Grox's still gonna continue to do that. But they also had a model that they call Genie, Genie 4, which is super interesting, and it's definitely like world building simulation.
Aaron (01:00:54)
based. And I wonder if that's a bigger piece of the media landscape, less feeds and more worlds. so that's that's kind of one thing I've been thinking a little bit about here and there this past week.
Chris (01:01:05)
Yeah, to me that is potentially the emergent dominant media, you know, the next twenty, thirty years is choose your own adventure, create your own world, live without scripts, and really drive yourself in like immersive multimedia situations. The I think the hard part or the thing to figure out is really
Chris (01:01:28)
what that form factor is going to be and what the stack sitting underneath it is. And I'm increasingly bearish or narrowing around what world models are actually going to be good at. It it's quite possible that they just end up being supercars. You know, they're the McLaren's and Lamborghinis of this of this class. And that, you know, it's it's three JS. you know, it's control patch like,
Chris (01:01:55)
Type script systems integrated into like a whole suite of, you know, like a dozen different models. you know, just building like, you know, that's the Jeep Cherokees of the era. And that's where a lot of the actual I think immersive experiences are going to live. Cause I just I don't know, it's it's it's hard.
Chris (01:02:19)
my sense, and I don't spend too much time with world models, largely because, they're very expensive. The the best in class you don't have access to. Most of it's still real time video and the level of control and influence you can have in terms of the the payloads you send to them are very limited. You know, or it's
Chris (01:02:43)
I'm using World Labs. I'm I'm in the the beta for their Atlas product. And what it actually is, it's not necessarily a world model, it's a it's a camera control system in which you know you can take reference images and then shoot all the angles around them, and then you build your depth maps. And so like I'm using Atlas a lot right now, but I'm using it for like pose capture, and then I'm bringing all that into my own my own stack and I'm
Chris (01:03:12)
baking procedural scenes out of it or I'm building building slats using other models. And so it's kind of interesting to seeing like, you know, one of the very, very hyped up and you know, front-of-the-pack world model companies and, you know, if they lay there, that what they have on the market right now is actually really more of a a better set of tooling and so that you can create the necessary
Chris (01:03:40)
precursors to then go and build more immersive things that actually live in three.
Aaron (01:03:46)
Yeah, I could see that. I think that's a good way to describe it. I had a odd thought last night and then I I circled back to it this morning. Like I wonder if the reason there's a push to world models is to begin to, you know, simulate basically like economic activity. like that's the end point of a world model, right? like you can begin to kind of build a simulation, that simulation black patterns. You could probably build like a
Aaron (01:04:11)
almost like an economic model on top of that that could better predict those patterns. We're kinda covering that. And and that's
probably the ultimate endpoint of world models is we get a model where we can actually predict the economy. I don't think that that's gonna happen tomorrow, but if if that happened in twenty, thirty years, like I would I don't think I'd be surprised. So just pretty pretty interesting. It's kinda like foundation series, Isaac Asimov stuff. I know everybody's like compl
Chris (01:04:39)
Yeah.
Aaron (01:04:41)
completely geek Daniel Stevenson and and some of his futuristic visions. But I wonder if really the endpoint's a little bit more as a Mafian.
Chris (01:04:50)
You you're you're a Harry Selden Maxie in this one?
Aaron (01:04:53)
Maybe, yeah. super influential books for me at least.
Chris (01:04:56)
Yeah. I to me like I can't see that far out with vermo world models. What I can see is that they're definitely going to be your your training training ground for embodied robotics and automation and like things that need enough training data such that like they can move in physical space. Like that to me is I think what world model what people are gonna like really
Chris (01:05:24)
deploy their capital on the world model side. and if they continue to stay expensive, you know, Genie like does end up, you know, the sort of McLaren class of the group. That like that the only people who are gonna be willing to pay for that are, know, people who get the the economic benefits of that API cost. Like it's it's
Chris (01:05:47)
I'd love it to be readily accessible for entertainment purposes. I just don't see that happening for another five years. And what I do see coming in the brew your own 3GS type world is gonna be able to like be probably better than what word models can do for the next five years.
Aaron (01:06:07)
Yeah. Yeah, I think it's just peering into the exponential, right? what what's the endpoint? That's where I'm trying to trying to push myself to maybe get some some thoughts or opinions related to that. Just I think that's helpful to kind of navigate these these treacherous waters. But maybe maybe we
Chris (01:06:25)
Yeah.
Aaron (01:06:26)
call it there.
Chris (01:06:27)
I I think it is a good time to to call it there because I need to ground myself and figure out how to unclog my dishwasher. I I hope it's just a clog. So
Aaron (01:06:35)
I hope so too. well what
Chris (01:06:37)
L let's step down
Chris (01:06:38)
from the commanding heights of techno capital and and get into the the mendanity of everyday life.
Aaron (01:06:43)
Of
Aaron (01:06:44)
yeah, which is important. well welcome to Net Society. Thanks for everybody that's that's listening and made it this far. we really appreciate your attention, your thoughts. it means a lot to us. you know, you had Derek, Pree, Chris, and me today on the show. just a quick reminder that nothing here is investment advice. nothing here also reflects the opinions.
Aaron (01:07:10)
of our parent organizations and let's go.
Chris (01:07:15)
Yeah, thanks everyone and a special shout out to two to the hundred episode club, to whomever out there is listening to every single episode, but also everyone who's listened to any episode. we really appreciate you guys.