رونوشت 🔗
00:00:00
Speaker 1: Welcome home, NLP fam.
00:00:02
Speaker 2: This is Angela Rye.
00:00:03
Speaker 1: You're about to hear an episode of Cite Your Source, a show produced and presented by Native Lamb Pod. On Cite Your Source, we fact-check the headlines and debunk viral news. We say we are your two-step verification on all the BS. New episodes drop Wednesday at 9 p.m. Eastern on Cite Your Source's YouTube channel. If you're listening and wondering what our sources are, I encourage you to check out the video where we cite our sources in real time and we have our sources in show notes.
00:00:30
Speaker 2: Thank you. Enjoy the episode. Welcome to Cite Your Source. I'm your host, Angela Rye.
00:00:37
Speaker 1: We are your two-step verification on all the BS, and there is plenty to go around, especially on the internet, where everybody has a voice, and that democratized access is great.
00:00:48
Speaker 2: But here's the question.
00:00:50
Speaker 1: Is it even real? Are the people you argue with real? They may not be. According to NPR, bots now outnumber humans online. and they also impact elections. According to CBS News, 2024 post-election analysis by independent researchers focused on how bot and spam accounts amplified intra-party divisions to depress voter enthusiasm. This year, we still see those tensions, but the outcome was a little different. United Airlines may have banned bots from booking flights last week, but it appears bots are still the new influencers. influencing what we see, what we believe, and even how we vote. While social media has given Black communities the power to build movements and tell our own stories, those same platforms have become breeding grounds for harassment, misinformation, manipulation, and yes, even bullying.
00:01:47
Speaker 2: These abuses don't just live online.
00:01:50
Speaker 1: Whether cyber or in-person, bullying has real-world consequences. Today, our panel will speak to the impact of spam accounts, bot farms, and cyberbullying, and how all of these impact our mental health. Plus, I'll be talking to Talib Kweli about his experience with cyber threats and bullying. Please welcome our panelists, Halil Kweli, hip-hop artist, author, activist, and podcast host. Nicole Polt-Bell, social justice advocate, author, and producer. Lindsey Song, the co-chair of New York City's Cyber Abuse Task Force and an attorney. Abiola Aguero, political educator, organizer, and creator.
00:02:46
Speaker 2: And Dr.
00:02:47
Speaker 1: Danielle Hairston, psychiatrist, from Howard University College of Medicine, who can attest to the fact that online drama is real and not manufactured. Thank you all for being here. Talib, I know you're on tour. I'm so glad that you could be with us today. My first question to you, good brother, is are you an online bully? Because that's what the streets say.
00:03:10
Speaker 3: Well, I don't know. I wouldn't say that the streets say that. Okay. But certain people online say that.
00:03:17
Speaker 4: I don't really hear that in the streets because I really do be outside in the supposed so-called streets. But yeah, in the YouTube streets, they might say that.
00:03:27
Speaker 3: In the Twitter streets, they might say that.
00:03:29
Speaker 4: And I feel like that's a gross, gross misrepresentation of who I am, what my legacy is, and what my purpose has been as an artist.
00:03:38
Speaker 2: Let me ask you this.
00:03:39
Speaker 1: If they are saying that in these mean Twitter streets, the Twitter thugs, can you respond on Twitter?
00:03:46
Speaker 3: I cannot respond on Twitter. I'm not allowed on Twitter.
00:03:49
Speaker 2: What happened?
00:03:50
Speaker 4: I wear that as a badge of honor, actually, because Twitter is legitimately.
00:03:56
Speaker 3: Owned by a Nazi.
00:03:58
Speaker 4: Before it was owned by a Nazi, it was sold to a Nazi. So who would sell something to a Nazi? But, you know, I digress. I'm a target of a lot of smear campaigns from all types of groups, whether it be MAGA or Zionist groups or, you know, sometimes it's Republicans or conservatives or libertarians. I've been a target of many smear campaigns because unlike a lot of people in my position, I actually will engage and I'll go back and forth and I'll respond. And that gives me endorphins, but it also gives a lot of other people endorphins. And I open up my platform for discussions that are uncomfortable.
00:04:37
Speaker 3: I don't debate people.
00:04:39
Speaker 4: I mean, I debate my peers and I debate people who are my alikes and people who I trust or people who, even if I disagree with you, I trust that you have a liberation at the forefront of your mind. But when I'm on Twitter or when I used to be on Twitter, you know, I'm, I'm exposing these people.
00:04:58
Speaker 3: I'm not debating them. And for me, it's fun.
00:05:00
Speaker 4: And it's a way for me to, it is absolutely fun.
00:05:04
Speaker 3: And, um, it's a way for me.
00:05:06
Speaker 4: To, to create safe spaces or try to help create safe spaces for people who are online.
00:05:12
Speaker 3: We spend all of our time online.
00:05:14
Speaker 4: We on door dash. I'm on zoom right now, you know, or whatever this is app that you got me on Riverside.
00:05:19
Speaker 5: Yeah.
00:05:19
Speaker 4: Riverside, um, childhood Riverside. And, um, You know, we order Ubers and all this, but people say that online hatred and online bigotry is not real. And we have a troll for president. Donald Trump is a Nazi. He is a person with actual rape charges. And he trolled his way to the presidency, in my opinion, in part because instead of people calling out all the racism that they see, which is what I've learned from my OGs, like.
00:05:49
Speaker 3: Angela Davis or Malcolm X, is that you call out all bigotry.
00:05:53
Speaker 4: Instead of doing that, people pat themselves on the back and act like they are above it and act like everything is a bot or act like everyone is just trolling and like that has no
Load full transcript
effect on society. And that's just something that I completely, completely disagree with. So I use my platform to put myself in front of people who don't have time, better privilege or the resources to go back and forth with these people to combat some of the misinformation.
00:06:18
Speaker 1: Now, Talib, I was so excited to get to this panel and this discussion. that I forgot to do some things, which are to say what our claims were for today, and also to let you know that I have to, or we all can, you can't, sadly, unless you have a buzzer over there, but we have a Cytresource buzzer. When I hit that, or when anybody hits that, that means that we're fact-checking. So you said that the president was an actual Nazi.
00:06:44
Speaker 3: Yes, absolutely.
00:06:45
Speaker 1: What documented evidence do you have that he was an actual Nazi? And this is not my defense of this president.
00:06:52
Speaker 2: I'm just wondering if you have actual evidence.
00:06:53
Speaker 3: Oh, I get it. I get it. Yes.
00:06:56
Speaker 4: Donald Trump is someone who is a eugenicist. Donald Trump is someone who has repeated great replacement theory. Donald Trump is someone who appeals to the far right. If you want to know whether or not Donald Trump is a Nazi, ask a Nazi. The Nazis support everything that he says politically. He is staunchly anti-communist. He's staunchly anti-socialist. He repeats white nationalist tropes. He defends white nationalist ideology. And I get that people who are politicians or journalists or have more quote-unquote respectable positions have to be really careful with their words and they have to parse the difference between someone who's a conservative or a white nationalist or is this a far-right person or is he just a.
00:07:41
Speaker 3: To me, that's all Nazi shit. They're just Nazis.
00:07:44
Speaker 4: I think it's important that we we are very honest with ourselves about what our response to fascism should be.
00:07:52
Speaker 3: And we just call it what it is.
00:07:54
Speaker 4: Like the Jewish people who went through the horrors of the Holocaust, the verbiage that comes out of.
00:08:00
Speaker 3: That community is never again.
00:08:02
Speaker 4: Not let's wait until they see if they're actual Nazis. Let's wait until they start holocausting and genociding people again.
00:08:09
Speaker 3: No, we call it out at the root.
00:08:11
Speaker 4: When you start talking about great replacement theory, when you start talking about white genocides, We start telling lies about black communities. We start attacking black women. Like, look at what Candace Owens is going through. That's a black woman that stood through Trump the whole time. Soon as she turned to him, now she got low IQ. Even the phrase low IQ, IQ testing as a measurement for intelligence, has been debunked by the scientific community in the way that we thought about it for years. But these Nazis lean into this. If you've ever been trolled by these Nazis online, they call you low IQ. They'd be like, I have a high IQ. Donald Trump says I have a high IQ all the time. Any black woman that challenges that man automatically has a low IQ. That's not a coincidence. These are Nazi dog whistles. And if we're not honest about it, we can't properly combat it.
00:08:56
Speaker 2: Yeah, that's fair.
00:08:57
Speaker 1: Okay, we have three claims today that we'll be addressing. The first is cyberbullying. Cyberbullying is a threat to mental health and public safety. The second claim is most people can differentiate human activity from bot activity. The third claim is bots and fake accounts exist to divide and manipulate people. This is a fact-checking show, so if any panelist stretches the truth or shares some data that sounds a little off, somebody will hit the buzzer and you will hear... this down, then they will have to cite their source. So now we're going to get a little more into claim one. Talib said he is not a bully online or any other place. He said he is still down with the beautiful struggle. But I do want to come to you, Lindsay, on what is cyberbullying.
00:09:42
Speaker 6: So cyberbullying, I often refer to as online harassment. I think cyberbullying, kind of the idea of bullying, kind of almost makes it sound like it's not as serious as it really is. So really any use of online social media services, applications, there's so many ways that we're connected, so many ways that we can message and contact each other, whether to threaten, harass, intimidate or harm, you know, cause fear to somebody using one of these social media or online services. And we see it often in the context of, for me, I'm an attorney that represents survivors of gender-based violence, intimate partner violence. And so we see it a lot as a form of gender based violence, which we know this form of abuse goes out of its way to impact women of color, indigenous people, Native American women, young women and other disenfranchised communities online.
00:10:34
Speaker 1: And I think that this is important, too, because there are some ways. that were impacted by cyberbullying and don't even know how to name it. Nicole, when you lost your fiancée at the time, Sean Bell, due to police violence, excessive force that resulted in his death the day before your wedding, I'm sure, one, you didn't anticipate becoming an activist in this space to ensure that there was no more Sean Bells, but certainly, not expecting to be dragged, harassed online.
00:11:05
Speaker 2: And at that time, as.
00:11:06
Speaker 1: You said earlier, it wasn't Twitter, Instagram, Facebook. It started on MySpace. Talk about your experience there.
00:11:15
Speaker 5: Yeah, so next week actually makes 20 years that we'll be remembering Sean. So as you said, Sean was celebrating his bachelor party and he was leaving his bachelor party And it was the early morning, so it was actually the day of my wedding, where police who were undercover vice squad detectives who were investigating the
nightclub that he was partying at followed him and his friends back to the car after they overheard an argument. And their claim was that they thought someone was getting a gun. Sean was celebrating his bachelor party.
00:11:56
Speaker 2: They didn't have a weapon.
00:11:57
Speaker 5: No one had a weapon.
00:11:58
Speaker 2: They fired 50 shots.
00:11:59
Speaker 5: Sean was killed and two other guys who were in the car were also shot, but they survived. They survived their injuries, obviously, but everyone's living with the scars of it. So I woke up that next morning and had heard the news that he had passed away and he was killed at the bachelor party.
00:12:20
Speaker 2: It was devastating.
00:12:20
Speaker 5: I was only 22 years old and Sean was 23. And right away, we just, Reverend Sharpton came and stood with the family. So we began to tell the public about what was happening, what happened that night. The police right away came out with their claims. They thought someone had a gun. They started digging up the sewers on Liverpool Street in Jamaica, Queens, where we grew up. They threw out claims that there was a fourth man and then later retracted it. So there were stories that came out. And right away, they said Sean tried to use his car to run over a police officer right away. And it took us a long time to really get down to what happened. And even still, there's so many questions even after the trial that they were acquitted from. But yeah, so MySpace was a thing back then. And I think Facebook was just coming around. So as a 22 year old, I didn't sign up for the tragedy. I didn't sign up to be an activist. I just got out there and defended Sean. and defended what he was doing. And really did it for, not only for me, but for my daughters too. Jada and Jordan at the time who were, they were only three and a half and Jordan was five months old. So, but right away, I mean, within weeks after Barry and Sean, I remember just opening up social media and think it was a nice space. And there was a Confederate flag. And the message said, you and your daughter should have been in the car too.
00:14:02
Speaker 2: And so.
00:14:05
Speaker 5: Someone, so I was grieving one, a mother, I was a mother and someone felt entitled to say that or wish death on my babies, you know, and it's not something, you know, like I said, that I've signed up for that anybody would sign up for. And this person who, you know, got on their phone or their laptop or computer at the time, decided that, you know, they had the right to say this about us. And I mean, it's very traumatic. You know, I don't know how anyone could ever say that. I didn't sign up for this.
00:14:48
Speaker 2: Sean didn't sign up for this.
00:14:49
Speaker 5: But we really just kind of pushed back and just continued to stay out there and... you know, continue to tell the story. And then it was, I mean, we can obviously go around the table, but then, then it was the police accounts, you know, that the families, just like they say about every family, that the families are doing this for money. This is what they say every single time. Every victim has gone through it, that we're doing this for money. And there's not a, there's no check. There's no amount of money that could ever replace Sean and could ever fill what my daughters have had to endure the last 20 years without having their dad around.
00:15:27
Speaker 2: Yeah.
00:15:28
Speaker 3: Dr.
00:15:29
Speaker 1: Harrison, I want you, as you hear what Nicole is talking about, the very real trauma of losing her fiance the day of her wedding to the racism, the fascism that Talib pointed to earlier. There's racialized trauma that exists in real life and online. There's the impact of the trauma that people push off being provocateurs online and in person. How does the convergence of that impact our mental health? And what do you say to people like Nicole who have experienced this in some instances on a lesser degree, but are traumatized no less?
00:16:07
Speaker 7: So for Nicole, I say, I'm sorry, right? Like I empathize with what she's going through. And we have to think about that was 20 years ago, right?
00:16:15
Speaker 8: So I'm an older millennial, right?
00:16:17
Speaker 7: So I was here. But now imagine the digital space is in your face. at all the time, like that was my space. But now there's Instagram, there's TikTok, there's threads, there's Twitter. I think I don't, I'm not on there anywhere either, but it's always in your face. It's always in your space. And I think like, what more can black people go through, right? Like first you have to experience it. Then you have to see other people experience it and go through it. And then in medicine and mental health and psychiatry, what I've been pushing for since I was a student is that looking at this stuff is traumatizing. Traditionally, we've said the definition is that you have to experience it yourself or that someone, you know, a first degree relative. But if I'm seeing George Floyd, if I'm seeing Sean Bell, if I'm seeing Philando Castile. And then I have my nephew in the car with me and we get pulled over real life.
00:17:09
Speaker 3: Right.
00:17:09
Speaker 7: We went to a workout in the park. I got pulled over for what? I think because I have a nice car and I shouldn't. But and he tensed up immediately.
00:17:17
Speaker 8: Right.
00:17:17
Speaker 7: Nothing's ever happened to him. or to my brother or to my sisters, but he knows what happens. And when you're saying that in your face, it's vicarious racism. And then there's also the element of people coming and attacking you for being a victim, for you just being alive, just your lived experience. I once made a tweet about, and I said that, you know, psychiatry and medicine needs to be accountable for the racism that they've passed down for years, for generations.
00:17:45
Speaker 8: People were coming at me.
00:17:47
Speaker 7: People were calling my department and telling them,
telling my chair, I need to watch what I say.
00:17:52
Speaker 8: I did. And I meant what I said.
00:17:54
Speaker 2: You know, what you mean?
00:17:57
Speaker 8: But I need to watch what I said.
00:18:00
Speaker 7: Don't talk about that.
00:18:02
Speaker 8: How are we going to ever be liberated if we don't talk about it?
00:18:05
Speaker 7: I'm supposed to not talk about what's happened to my family, what's happened to my neighborhood, what's happened generationally. And then it's thrown in your face. Remember at that time, we weren't even given trigger warnings, right?
00:18:15
Speaker 5: Yeah.
00:18:16
Speaker 7: Remember in the beginning with George Floyd? It was on your screen, in your face. They didn't even say, hey, you're about to see a black person be killed. You're about to see a knee on a black person's neck.
00:18:27
Speaker 8: Can I get prepared?
00:18:29
Speaker 3: Like, no.
00:18:30
Speaker 7: And now you have to go through that. Then somebody tells you, oh, that's not really trauma because the definition that was written by a predominantly white man's specialty says that. you looking at something isn't traumatizing enough. What more do I have to go through?
00:18:47
Speaker 1: How do you define that online trauma, whether it's racialized or not? How do you define it in a way that's different from that traditional definition that apparently doesn't really apply to us or even consider us?
00:19:00
Speaker 7: So what my colleagues and I are calling it now is vicarious trauma. race-based trauma, vicarious trauma. And there are studies, don't fact check me on this, but yes, there are studies. There are studies that looked at it with like 9-11 and saw that people who witnessed, just watching the news here in New York, watching the bombings, the crash, like they started experiencing trauma.
00:19:26
Speaker 8: So they looked at that.
00:19:27
Speaker 7: Why are we not looking at what's happening with, well, some of us are. But So vicarious trauma is a real thing. And we see it in children, especially. We see it in youth, but we can see it across generations.
00:19:38
Speaker 9: Yeah.
00:19:42
Speaker 1: Abiola, so for you, I think, one, I get so much joy from looking at your content.
00:19:48
Speaker 2: You show up happy.
00:19:49
Speaker 1: She look like Christmas decorations right now, okay? Like she just is always a light online. But you've also experienced online bullying, whether it's because people are jealous of your content, they don't understand. you know, your unique way of presenting, whatever it is, talk about some of your own experiences online.
00:20:07
Speaker 10: You know, I think that one of the worst parts sometimes about the online bullying, especially if I may bring in bots to some of this as well, is- That's claimed too, but we gonna get there. In the same way that we talk about the fact that race isn't real, right? We know race isn't real. The effects of racism are real. And I think the same things happen whenever you have a discourse being led by smaller accounts, by bot accounts. I know for me, especially 2024 during the election cycle was one of the worst time periods for online bullying.
00:20:37
Speaker 2: There were people that were saying.
00:20:40
Speaker 10: One of the things I get accused of randomly is not being from rural Texas. I don't know why it's something that happens a lot, but people will make videos.
00:20:47
Speaker 2: And be like, you don't know what you're talking about.
00:20:49
Speaker 10: You're just making stuff up. And I'm like, I live where there aren't streetlights. You drive down a 25 minute road with no streetlights. And so it seems like such an erroneous thing to claim, but it pops up a lot. I get accused of not being black American because my dad is Nigerian and because of my name. And so sometimes when you have some of those things, it ends up making you feel like you have to consistently prove something. And that you have to have justification for everything. I have to, there have been multiple times where I just put my mom on video and I let her go at people because, you know, it's like, you can say I'm not where I'm from, but I'm just going to let mama talk. And we'll, you know, we'll just let people handle it that way. But I think one of the biggest effects that it has is it allows for people to question credibility without any understanding of how it impacts folks. They are allowed to make a claim and some people will be like, well, you know what? I do think that maybe she's making something up. And they just run with it regardless. So I think that in my experience, it can be very frustrating. It can be very dehumanizing. And I've had to even remind people that I know in real life, when they get upset, I'm like, you do understand I'm a human too, right? Like, I'm not a random figure. There's a quote right now from a TV show, and I posted it yesterday because I thought it was really useful. And it says, you've put me on such a high pedestal, and not because you care for me, but to spare yourself the climb. And I think that's a really consistent issue that we have in these spaces.
00:22:11
Speaker 11: Yeah.
00:22:12
Speaker 1: We have with us also a content creator. He's a school leader, social worker, Dwight Thomas, who has direct experience with children being cyberbullied. And I want to come to you, Dwight. What do you think teachers and parents most often misunderstand about what a child might be going through online?
00:22:33
Speaker 11: I think one of the biggest misconceptions is that it only happens on social media, right? Cyberbullying spans across so many platforms. Text messages are platforms where bullying happens. And I think people are afraid to report it. Kids are afraid to report it. But what adults need to understand is that in order for kids to feel safe, you have to create a safe space, right? So cyberbullying from 2016 to 2025, has doubled to almost 60% of kids, teenagers, saying that they've
experienced some form of cyberbullying. And so it's just important that we as adults create safe spaces for kids to be able to report bullying, both anonymously and without anonymity if needed, but making it so that it doesn't feel like they're going to get crucified. Because the earlier you report it, the more likely it is that you can catch it before it goes viral, right? So some kids are just living with the trauma seeing it play out and don't have a trusted adult to tell, it goes viral and then it just continues to get worse. There's bots, there's other students, there's people from other schools. And we've seen kids get to a point where the trauma is just too much and attempt suicide and be hospitalized because the trauma from cyberbullying is really intense and impacts kids at a high level and adults too. But specifically in schools, we just have to be more intentional about providing pathways for kids to report it in a safe way with trusted adults.
00:24:04
Speaker 1: I want to go to this clip of our former Surgeon General Vivek Murtha, who called for a warning label to be placed on social media for children.
00:24:15
Speaker 2: Here's what he had to say.
00:24:18
Speaker 12: What we are living through right now is a youth mental health crisis, and social media has unfortunately emerged as one of the contributors to that crisis. Last year, when I issued an advisory on youth mental health and social media, I noted that when young people, adolescents in particular, are spending more than three hours a day on social media, that's associated with a doubling of risk of anxiety and depression symptoms.
00:24:43
Speaker 3: And what's the average use right now? It's 4.8 hours a day.
00:24:48
Speaker 2: So that I think is important.
00:24:49
Speaker 1: And Talib, I want to come back to you on this because this was for a warning label for children, for teenagers. Do you think we should have that same warning label for adults?
00:24:58
Speaker 3: I don't think it could hurt.
00:24:59
Speaker 4: It doesn't sound like something, you know, any type of like guardrails or parameters to limit the amount of time that you jump into that world, I think would be a net positive.
00:25:09
Speaker 2: Yeah, absolutely.
00:25:10
Speaker 3: Absolutely.
00:25:11
Speaker 1: The other thing is, you know, we talked a little bit about all of the people who have attacked you wrongfully, but we haven't necessarily talked about your.
00:25:20
Speaker 2: Pain in this.
00:25:21
Speaker 1: There have been people who look like us who have come at your status as a black man, completely erased, you know, as we would talked about your legacy in hip hop, all of the things that you've done culturally, communally to work towards our collective liberation. Have you felt any pain from that, from being so misunderstood from black folks online?
00:25:42
Speaker 12: Yeah.
00:25:43
Speaker 4: I mean, again, I'll point to the fact that most of the people that I run into who are not, this is
something, a phenomenon that exists online primarily for me. I'm very blessed and privileged to travel the world and perform in front of audiences that are very happy to see me. And so I count the blessings, not the problems as often as I can. Before I continue, I want to shout out and salute Nicole Bell. Definitely Sean Bell was someone who was very inspirational to me as an artist. Back then, Swiss Beats did a record, Stand Up, that I featured on. And Sean Bell's story is just very impactful in my life as an artist. So I'm happy to be on the panel with you. But what the sister was saying about being attacked online because they were saying she's not an American. That's something, you know, I'm someone whose, my family is very African-American.
00:26:33
Speaker 3: I'm from Brooklyn, New York. And because I'm from Brooklyn, New York, When the.
00:26:37
Speaker 4: ADOS thing popped off and the ADOS thing morphed into the FBA thing, ADOS was American Descendants of Slavery, and now it's Tariq Nasheed's thing, Foundation of Black Americans. It morphed into this really anti-immigrant movement, and a movement that was designed to divide Black Americans from Black people in the rest of the diaspora. And this was something, as a New Yorker, that I saw as extremely dangerous. Because, you know, we called each other names as kids, but when you're an adult, you put away childish things. For me to see these things, and it's not just, it didn't just stop at Black people.
00:27:17
Speaker 3: Or African-Americans versus Africans.
00:27:19
Speaker 4: It also went to Latinos, where you have like a large percentage of online, which, and a lot of that is bots, right? And I'm going to qualify what I'm going to say, because I know y'all want to get into the bots thing. But I think that, you know, just to add on to what I'm saying now, When people talk about bots in the way that they do, yes, there are bots. There are bots that attack me. There are bots in the ADOS thing. There are bots in the FBA thing. There are Zionist bots. There are MAGA bots. There are all these bots. But someone has programmed these bots. And the vast majority of attacks that happen to people is not just bots. People pat themselves on the back, really, like just a bot. But It's the same thing as the racism not being real, right? I mean, as race not being real, but racism having real consequences. These bots might not be real, but the misinformation they're spreading has very, very, very real consequences.
00:28:15
Speaker 3: It's very harmful.
00:28:16
Speaker 4: I get death threats all the time. I've had my mom threatened. I've had people set up fake interviews with my mom to get her information. I've had my daughter get death threats.
00:28:29
Speaker 3: All of that happens. This has been happening to me for years.
00:28:32
Speaker 4: In 2020, when I went through a severe smear campaign, I was getting, I'm not talking about online, I'm talking about to my cell phone. I was getting like really, really horrendous death threats and people talking about showing up at my family's.
00:28:46
Speaker 3: Places of business and stuff.
00:28:47
Speaker 4: And I know enough about my community to know that that's not black people. These are people who are purporting to be black people online, but that didn't feel like black people that was doing that. Because black people, we can tear each other down or we can gossip. that slander each other, all that, like, that threatening, that, like, I'm coming to get you, that lynch energy, that's not us.
00:29:10
Speaker 2: Well, it could be informed by white supremacy.
00:29:12
Speaker 1: And to that end, some white supremacists have bots too. We have claimed to most people can differentiate human activity from bot activity. And I actually want to pick up where Talib just left off because there is a part of this that is human informed, just like AI is human informed. Bot farms are normally triggered by a human being that comes up with an initial claim, an initial allegation, initial attack. So Lindsay, I want to come to you.
00:29:39
Speaker 3: What are bots?
00:29:40
Speaker 1: People are hearing us toss this term around at home. What's a bot?
00:29:44
Speaker 6: A bot is any kind of automated piece of software that performs a certain function. So bots predated AI but also can be informed by AI and can be advanced through AI. But we see it a lot in social media platforms of creating these, you know, what we call fake accounts. But I love the narrative of there's nothing fake about it, right? Even if it's not a authentic person, the harm is very real, regardless of whether the account is fake. There's nothing really fake about any of what we're experiencing. But these bots can perform, you know, massive amounts of harm. social media posting or even automated agents if they're informed by AI and kind of autonomous activities to a level that individual people just cannot. And so the overwhelming amount of hatred, of attacks, of content, it's not physically possible for a human to do, but it can be done because it's software.
00:30:34
Speaker 1: Okay, so let's go to the audience on this. We're going to do a little focus group poll, y'all. We want to see if you can tell the difference between a human account and a bot account.
00:30:44
Speaker 2: How many of y'all think you can do that?
00:30:47
Speaker 4: Maybe.
00:30:48
Speaker 2: We'll see.
00:30:49
Speaker 1: Okay, we're going to show you an account.
00:30:51
Speaker 11: That gives me bot vibes for sure.
00:30:54
Speaker 2: A bot, okay. And then what about this next account?
00:30:58
Speaker 9: Bot.
00:30:58
Speaker 2: Oh, okay. And then on this last one, human or bot? Human or bot?
00:31:05
Speaker 1: Human.
00:31:06
Speaker 2: That's good, Dwight, because it was your page. I'm just playing.
00:31:12
Speaker 1: But this is important for us to do because sometimes we can't tell. And sometimes the person or the thing that is aggravating us the most is
not even a real human being.
00:31:22
Speaker 2: Not saying to Lib.
00:31:23
Speaker 1: That it's not a real, doesn't cause real triggers or like real trauma, but we're responding to somebody that can't really do anything but be programmed to respond back and sometimes in the same exact way. So I think that's important. I want to hear from you all. When we think about this, the fact that most people can't tell the difference, even our own audience struggled a little bit. How do you respond if you can't tell the difference? How do you respond in this era?
00:31:51
Speaker 6: I think that I mean, like was that already the harm of a bot or a person giving you death threats? horrific comment, whatever it may be, the harm is still the same, right? And there are still venues and ways to report online with varying levels of success, depending on the social media account that you're talking about. But as an attorney who represents survivors in this space, there are resources like perth.org. It's a nonprofit that you can go to that has free case account creation, where if somebody is getting online harassment campaigns, they'll escalate it up for you. And they work with survivors of people who've experienced online harassment or going through the social media pages itself, using identity protection websites that can take off your personal identifying information. There's a lot of different services that unfortunately are paid. This is something that I believe very strongly should be free, particularly for people who are survivors or who have had an inordinate amount of focus put on them. But there are ways of people protecting themselves online. And I think a big thing is just investigating, you know, looking at the account, trying to do your best to identify what it's coming from. If it is a real person, then they could create a new account. But if it is a bot, then maybe reporting that account or blocking it could actually be, you know, a remedy that.
00:33:04
Speaker 8: Would be helpful.
00:33:05
Speaker 1: I will tell you all just recently I had a situation where and I still don't know if this person is real or not, but they didn't have very many followers, which is normally a sign about activity. And they said, you know, next time you come to this city, you're going to get your ass beat. Doesn't your mom have a chemo appointment to go to? Right. And so it is very triggering. I am very frustrated by that. But also, like it comes from a real place. People see online fractures, online dissension, and they figure out ways to pile on. Some of this is even foreign interference, you know, but they see opportunities. for people to kind of be triggered, be distracted by the nonsense. And this is on the other side of a historic election. For me, the work that I do, I don't need to be arguing with this random man that's talking about my mother's health condition.
00:34:00
Speaker 2: Maybe man, we don't even know. Maybe bot.
00:34:02
Speaker 1: But I shouldn't be focused on that when there's all these other very real things going on. An experiment by Science Advances put real tweets against OpenAI's post and found that people misqualified AI written posts as human 52% of the time.
00:34:17
Speaker 2: That's a lot.
00:34:17
Speaker 1: You might be wasting 52% of your energy. And I do want to say Tish James recently challenged Facebook and Meta. Several attorneys general have to your point about what should be the process for reporting online harassment, for resolving some of the challenges we're seeing online.
00:34:36
Speaker 2: I want to play this clip from Tish James.
00:34:39
Speaker 9: We reached an agreement with Meta, Facebook, and Instagram. because their business model was as follows. One, hook children. Two, keep them on your social platform as much as possible because that's how they make money. Three, harvest their data. And four, don't tell the general public anything about it. That was their business model. And as a result of the agreement today, a bipartisan agreement, we will receive, New York will receive almost $ 1. 13 billion to address the mental health harms and the mental health crisis that we are seeing amongst young people, not only in the state of New York, but all across this country.
00:35:20
Speaker 1: I think that this is so important because people do think like, oh, it's just, you know, you all are putting too much attention on it. Maybe you are spending too much time online.
00:35:30
Speaker 2: Dr.
00:35:30
Speaker 1: Hairston, is there something else that needs to happen? If it says bot account, like now you know how on Instagram in particular, it's like AI generated account or AI generated post.
00:35:41
Speaker 2: There's a disclaimer. Should there be a disclaimer?
00:35:44
Speaker 8: There should definitely be a disclaimer.
00:35:46
Speaker 7: But more than that, there should be some type of consequences like policy. Like we, okay, we're talking about like on the ground, like, yes, we're making them meta pay this and do this. But what about the people who are creating them? Because to tell you Kali's point, right? Yeah, it's fake. But who generated it? Who engineered it? Who manufactured it? Who informed this to create this? Like there's someone behind all of this, just like when they say it was the system. But the system is made of people, right? So the people, somebody informed this and did this. Now, we know that youth are saying they go to social media for mental health information. Over 67 percent of them are saying that. I feel like social media impacts my mental health, whether positively or negatively.
00:36:28
Speaker 8: Like, positively, yes.
00:36:31
Speaker 7: Community, finding people who are similar to me, who have lived experience, who are like me. So, yes, it's wonderful. I can get information. I can express myself. But then on the other side, I don't know whether it's a bot. They said they're afraid. They don't know if this is real or not. So they
don't know how to trust. Even if people give them compliments, they're worried, like, is this someone who's just going to catfish me and try to get me?
00:36:52
Speaker 8: So is it a bot? Is it fake?
00:36:54
Speaker 7: So there has to be some type of consequence. There has to be some type of policy, something that changes. Like people, remember when at first they didn't know like, oh, what's stalking? Okay, then they figured out how to have some policy and.
00:37:08
Speaker 8: Laws about stalking. Then it was, oh, what's cyber stalking? What's cyber bullying?
00:37:12
Speaker 7: Okay, we're at another level. Y'all need to make some policy changes. There have to be some consequences and something because we see that it's affecting the mental health, yes, especially of our youth. Every time I go on something, someone's like, Or look at the suicide attempt rate or suicide death rate of black youth. Okay, well, yes, y'all weren't looking at us before. But okay, fine, we'll take it. But what's the consequence? What's the answer? Because this is going on. It's not like you can say, oh, I don't care about social media. I'll just block my child from social media. Or my child doesn't need to know what AI is. And you over here talking to Siri, Alexa. Spotify is creating your playlist based on what.
00:37:47
Speaker 2: It's listening to.
00:37:49
Speaker 3: OK, I see you like this song.
00:37:51
Speaker 2: Exactly.
00:37:52
Speaker 7: So we can't say that, oh, it doesn't exist or we're not going to pay attention. I'm just going to block my child from looking at it. I'm just going to like, yes, boundaries are important. But what are the consequences? What are the next steps? Because we think in right here, that's great. But what's further upstream that we're going to make a difference?
00:38:07
Speaker 1: Talib, I like that Danielle is talking about this consequence for the people that actually deploy the bots. Here's a little twist on this. So it's not just bots that are used to create war and stoke division online. There are also the bots that are used to boost the downloads of some of the audience's favorite artists or singers. some of the favorite podcasts, right? What do you think about that? Because you're a purist. This is a real hip hopper, y'all. How do you feel about the folks? Now, I know he got something to say about this. How do you feel about the folks that are deploying bots to boost them download numbers, though?
00:38:41
Speaker 4: I mean, I think when it comes to the music business and the bots, you can't fight the technology. And if you are signed to a label, I mean, look, what's the point of being signed to a major label if they not going to be using the bots.
00:38:54
Speaker 3: You know what I'm saying?
00:38:54
Speaker 1: That's the whole reason. No, I did not think you were going to say this.
00:38:56
Speaker 11: What? Really?
00:38:59
Speaker 3: So this is like, this is making.
00:39:01
Speaker 2: It seem like people like you and they don't.
00:39:04
Speaker 4: No, what I'm saying is, what I'm saying is, is that if you play that.
00:39:07
Speaker 1: We fact-checking you on that.
00:39:09
Speaker 2: It ain't even no fact-check.
00:39:11
Speaker 1: We just don't even like that shit. We like, Talib, now we mad at you, Talib.
00:39:16
Speaker 2: You about to get bullied on here.
00:39:18
Speaker 1: Is this a good thing you got here?
00:39:19
Speaker 3: What I'm saying is, It's like this. It's like this. When Drake wants to sue his label.
00:39:24
Speaker 2: That's exactly who I was thinking about. Keep going.
00:39:26
Speaker 12: Right?
00:39:27
Speaker 4: And that's why I went right there, right? When Drake wants to sue his label... his label and say, Kendrick is using the bots. Y'all using the bots for Kendrick. Of course they using the bots for Kendrick. He's a priority on the label. Same way they was using the bots for you. Either you either you in the business or you're not.
00:39:43
Speaker 1: Do you know they were using the box for Kendrick?
00:39:46
Speaker 2: I don't know about that.
00:39:47
Speaker 1: I think I mean, listen, that was organic.
00:39:49
Speaker 4: Great, great, great, great loss. I don't know enough about the case to know the ins and outs of it. I know he lost the case, but I do know that Universal in their defense, the public statement they put out was what they said was the same things we've done for Kendrick. We've done for you. So we don't understand why you're suing us. To me, I read that as wrong.
00:40:12
Speaker 2: Okay, here's my question. Here's my question.
00:40:14
Speaker 1: And you got to break my heart today. Please tell me.
00:40:18
Speaker 4: I'm not signed to a major label. So I don't, that's not something.
00:40:21
Speaker 2: That I have to do.
00:40:22
Speaker 1: That ain't what I was about to ask.
00:40:23
Speaker 3: Yeah, I'm an independent artist. You know what I'm saying?
00:40:25
Speaker 1: Please tell me you are not using bots to support your downloads.
00:40:33
Speaker 4: No, my downloads, I don't even, I don't eat off of downloads like that. I don't eat off of streaming like that. I eat off of touring. I eat off of being who I am. That's a very minuscule amount of money that I'm making off of streaming. I make more money off of going on the road and selling things, physical copies of things. I'm more roots-based artists.
00:40:56
Speaker 3: Okay.
00:40:56
Speaker 1: Well, you're making me nervous. So if a major label- I'm.
00:41:00
Speaker 3: Saying the whole industry use the bots.
00:41:02
Speaker 4: And everybody online and all the podcasts, everybody's using them.
00:41:06
Speaker 3: Everybody's using AI. Should we do it?
00:41:08
Speaker 4: There's a moral case to be like, no, we shouldn't be doing it, but people are doing it.
00:41:12
Speaker 3: You know what I'm saying? Like if we talk to you, you asked about what the record industry does. Yes, they use bots.
00:41:16
Speaker 11: No, I know.
00:41:17
Speaker 1: But
I'm saying from like a moral standpoint, is that right?
00:41:20
Speaker 2: And should it be disclosed? Just like Dr.
00:41:21
Speaker 1: Harrison was saying, if you use a bot to attack, you should be exposed. If you use a bot to increase your downloads, should you also be like disclosing that?
00:41:31
Speaker 3: I absolutely think you should.
00:41:32
Speaker 11: Absolutely.
00:41:32
Speaker 3: Absolutely.
00:41:33
Speaker 2: Well, we at least got to. Me and him was about to be in a fight while he's on tour. I'm like, Talib, not you too.
00:41:41
Speaker 4: That's an ugly struggle, not a beautiful struggle.
00:41:46
Speaker 3: I do want to add this.
00:41:46
Speaker 4: I'm very glad that I'm on this show because of your fact check button. because of your site, your sources mantra, because I'm all about that, right? And I would encourage people like you stated earlier that there are pockets of the internet that see me as a cyber bully or see me as harassing people. And I would just encourage anybody who's watching this to cite your sources, do your research. This is something that you've been told. You've never seen me bully anybody. You don't see me leave my space to go on anybody else's page.
00:42:16
Speaker 3: I don't do that. I never do that.
00:42:18
Speaker 4: Anytime I have a conversation with someone It's someone who comes into my space. The person who got their name out there from saying that I cyberbullied this supposedly young woman, I don't know because I ain't never seen this person in public.
00:42:30
Speaker 3: I ain't never seen an interview done with this person. I've read print.
00:42:33
Speaker 4: Interviews done with, but anybody could do anything on the phone. I had Russian trolls call me pretending to be Bernie Sanders and Greta Thunberg, and I believe them. I thought I was on the phone with Bernie Sanders and Greta. They put the conversation online. It goes deep with me.
00:42:46
Speaker 3: You know what I'm saying? We need to play a clip of that. They put it on.
00:42:49
Speaker 4: I say what I have to say, like when it comes to me personally and I'm in this to let I don't want to make any of this about me.
00:42:55
Speaker 5: Right.
00:42:55
Speaker 4: Because it's a bigger conversation than me personally. But you I wanted to address it since you brought it up. All those claims about me being a bully. I'm not even going to stand. I don't even have to stand on business because my name and my reputation should.
00:43:09
Speaker 3: Should stand on its own.
00:43:11
Speaker 4: Go do your research. Read the articles they wrote about me. What are the sources of people who say this? There's no proof of any... I've never seen a tweet. I've never seen anything that you could point to that showed me bullying anybody.
00:43:25
Speaker 3: Now, do I stand up to systems?
00:43:28
Speaker 9: Yes.
00:43:28
Speaker 3: Do I stand up to fascism? Yes. Do I call people Nazis all the time? Yes, I do. If you come in my space and act like a Nazi, guess what? Guess what I'm going to do?
00:43:40
Speaker 11: Yeah.
00:43:40
Speaker 1: Well, I'm grateful for you and exactly how you stand up. I don't think you're a bully, but I wanted to make sure we address that at the top because, you know, they were going to come.
00:43:48
Speaker 3: I appreciate it.
00:43:48
Speaker 1: They were going to come back and say, well, she had the cyber bully on the show and didn't even ask.
00:43:53
Speaker 2: Him about it.
00:43:54
Speaker 3: Hey, guess what? They're going to say that anyway.
00:43:55
Speaker 2: They're going to say it. No, they're definitely going to say it anyway.
00:43:58
Speaker 1: And it might be coming from Greta and Bernie, but you'll know this time that.
00:44:01
Speaker 3: It's not them.
00:44:03
Speaker 1: So claim three is bots and fake accounts exist to divide and manipulate people. We've touched on some of this already, but I also think this is an important part, a piece for us to like double down on the misinformation. Nicole, you talked about some of your experience here, I think particularly with law enforcement or law enforcement supporters. What do you think is important for people to understand to ensure they're not manipulated by these bots that are deployed by real humans and these fake accounts that are, you know, people are using them as cover to say all the hateful things that they really want to say? What's important for our audience to know?
00:44:40
Speaker 5: Just as Lindsay said, it doesn't matter whether it's fake or not. It follows you to your bedroom at 2 a.m., Once it's said, it's harmful and it's not just a matter of logging off, right? Because this is something that, you know, tell that to your job or tell that to your family who's also seeing this and reading it, you know, like my daughters, you know, and you can't just simply shift the blame or shift the focus to the victim and just say, just log off. It just doesn't happen that way. You know, it's really important that people cite your source Because there's so much misinformation out there and there is a human on the other side of that. There are people on the other side of it. So there's lots of things you can do. Even if you're not on the side of policy and if you're just someone who's in the comments, report it. Or if you think that you have something because you have a screenshot or you have somebody's tea, you have nothing. Reach out to the person and see if they're okay before asking them, did you see what they said online? I've experienced that myself and my closest friends were the ones who reached out to me and said.
00:45:53
Speaker 3: Hey, are you OK?
00:45:55
Speaker 5: Everyone else, you know, if you're in the comments, I didn't consider you a friend, you know. And for me, yeah, it was a very long time ago. But the story's ongoing. Every time there's another person that goes through what my family goes through, we're all reliving it. And where I stay out of the comments, I've learned to.
00:46:13
Speaker 3: Like, disassociate.
00:46:14
Speaker 5: I don't go back and forth because I have to protect my peace. I've been traumatized. Like, really, I've had to see doctors like you to be able to help me get through some of the things I've gone through, not only from losing Sean, but from having to deal with the public scrutiny, having to deal with the smear campaigns for Sean, smear campaigns for myself, my family, and then having people that you trust and love also, you know, engaging in that. You feel betrayed, you know, but it leads to like losing sleep at night that follows you in your in your in your home. Like it's not just as simple as, you know, logging off. I can't say that enough because it follows you and it's it's in your day to day. It's, you know, how you show up. Depression, anxiety. I'm sure you can speak to that more than I can. But from a client standpoint, from a person who's actually been through it. I can tell you it's real. And if everyone can kind of do their part, you know, whether you have a big role or you're an attorney, if you're just someone who's an activist or you're someone who's just scrolling, like there's something that you can do. You can report it, do something, reach out to the person if you know them, reach out to them privately. But there's something that each one of us can do.
00:47:34
Speaker 1: Lindsay, on the solution side, even hearing Nicole, you know, there are people that create these fake accounts, amplify discord, attack people's personal reputation, discredit and work to destroy them. What are the legal remedies, if any, that are available? Nicole perked up like, yeah, tell me who I can sue. And how difficult it is to prove that there's an actor behind these things.
00:48:00
Speaker 2: What are the remedies that exist?
00:48:02
Speaker 6: It's a huge problem, and we've run into it a lot as an attorney. I've been representing survivors for almost 12 years in New York family and civil courts and also assist when they do want to go to the police. And the resistance that we face, the shaming, the dismissals, the gaslighting, the, well, you should just block them.
00:48:19
Speaker 3: Just get offline.
00:48:19
Speaker 6: Why don't you just get off of social media? And that is my number one concern. training role that we do now. I train law enforcement prosecutors and others. And that is one of the number one things we say is don't tell people to say, get offline. There is no offline, first of all. And second of all, you're limiting people's access to employment, to work, to society, to connections, to family members, to friends when they need it most, when they are under fire, when they are in vulnerable situations. So depending on who the person is, that is the harassing person, there are different remedies. Now, if it's a real person, you have more options, right? If it's like a family member and intimate partner violence, there's family courts, there's criminal court options, there's civil courts where you can sue for money damages if the level of harm, but it is very difficult. It's costly to sue. You have to pay for an attorney. Family and criminal court are free in certain circumstances, but can be difficult to access and also involves you being in court with that person and seeing them all the time. If it's not a real person, if it's a bot, it's really difficult, right? Because how can you file a police report and a bot? How can you file a civil claim against a bot? So a lot of that I focus on the safety planning aspect of using different, you know, websites like Perth, or we have a manual available for the Cyber Abuse Task Force.
00:49:31
Speaker 2: What is Perth?
00:49:32
Speaker 6: Perth, it's a Shout out to Perth. It is a nonprofit organization that was founded.
00:49:38
Speaker 1: Perth, you owe me a check.
00:49:42
Speaker 3: They're a nonprofit.
00:49:42
Speaker 6: They have free case services founded by Sherry Hakimi, who herself experienced an online harassment campaign years ago. And they can escalate up when there's massive amounts of online harassment there. for different social media accounts. So you can submit the accounts that are harassing and then they can basically help compile it and then report on your behalf.
00:50:02
Speaker 3: Because so much of it is retraumatizing, right?
00:50:04
Speaker 6: When you're asking people who are the victims experiencing this, oh, you go in and you report this account.
00:50:09
Speaker 3: You go to Twitter, you go to Facebook, you go to Reddit.
00:50:11
Speaker 6: You have to read these horrible things and then get them taken down one by one. It's a horrible thing to ask somebody who's experiencing it.
00:50:17
Speaker 1: I want to park here for just a minute. And I know we're close to overtime, but this is important to me because I'm traumatized, retraumatized. I've had stalkers. I've had them, you know, in my inbox for email. I had one. Speaking of it's not just online, they find you online, obsessed with you online and then come to your events. So you like I'm supposed to promote tell it knows better than me. I'm supposed to promote my events online to get people to come.
00:50:46
Speaker 2: I'm not talking to you, friend.
00:50:48
Speaker 11: Right.
00:50:48
Speaker 1: But this is you're seeing this as a personal invitation to go where I am. figured out where I lived because I did a YouTube video with this incredible, I shouldn't call him a plant guy. What is a plant guy called? What's the right word? Whatever a plant guy is.
00:51:05
Speaker 3: Botanist.
00:51:06
Speaker 2: Botanist. Thank you. Lifeline. Cite my story.
00:51:10
Speaker 1: I got to live all the way in London.
00:51:13
Speaker 2: Thank you so much. Not a bully after all. He's actually a lifeline. But Hilton Carter.
00:51:19
Speaker 1: And I was walking around my house showing him my plants for a podcast. Like, okay, what'd I do wrong with this plant?
00:51:24
Speaker 11: Right?
00:51:25
Speaker 1: I
went outside the house and there was an address number, not even the street number. They did a reverse lookup, figured out where I live. And this heifer started sending me books upon books of emails and letters and cards, like flooding my box. And then the day I was supposed to go to Ghana was outside my house and At my door and she had a license to carry. I had to file a temporary restraining order against this person and got her gun license stripped away. But the amount of evidence to your point that I had to produce to read like. Again, the person that they're describing, I don't know. The people who she's saying aren't my friends, I don't know. But like God told her something that he ain't never told me and I don't know what God she serves. But ultimately, like you go through these things where it starts online and then it trickles out into real life. The things that people are saying to you that are threatening in your DMs or online trickle.
00:52:25
Speaker 2: Down into what happens in real life.
00:52:27
Speaker 1: They feel divinely called by some, you know, gastro issue that is telling them to do something they shouldn't. So I just I am fascinated by how we keep telling people like you just leave it behind online because you really can't. Like I'm trying to live my everyday life. I don't know who this is. I wish her the best. I do not want you. You are not my calling. Like, please stay out of my my online DMs and please stay out of my mailbox.
00:52:56
Speaker 8: Yeah, maybe Lindsay can tell us.
00:52:58
Speaker 1: Sorry, I felt like I needed therapy.
00:53:01
Speaker 7: We all do therapy for all people, especially black people. But maybe Lindsay can tell us this because I also have had someone harassing me and I was advised well. why don't you just close or make your social media private? I'm like, no, that's how I, that's how I inform the masses. That's how I tell people what I'm doing. That's how I reach my youth. That's how I, that's what.
00:53:21
Speaker 8: I'm working on.
00:53:22
Speaker 7: And any of, even if I do, then they're emailing me and then there's fake texts and everything.
00:53:26
Speaker 8: So it's not, that can't be the answer.
00:53:28
Speaker 3: Right.
00:53:29
Speaker 7: And I think for me myself and like what I do with my own therapy, because I am a psychiatrist who has a therapist.
00:53:34
Speaker 8: Thank you. Um, boundaries were important.
00:53:38
Speaker 9: Right.
00:53:39
Speaker 8: Um, I have a.
00:53:40
Speaker 7: Nephew who was in a horrible situation and it was in the Bahamas and it was public and social media.
00:53:46
Speaker 8: Same last name as me.
00:53:47
Speaker 7: And people were just saying all types of stuff about him and the situation. And I'll be looking at it and then I'm like ready to comment.
00:53:54
Speaker 8: And then I like have to. relax myself like what is.
00:53:57
Speaker 7: That going to do and instead instead i would be like okay let me reach out to the police like hello what
have y'all done next and having just boundaries for myself like turning off my notifications on social media not letting my email notifications come on my phone anymore um things like that just to do your own self-protection because if the system isn't going to protect you you have to do things to protect yourself and then also we're a community collective healing for us like having people like you said check in on you Like, my friends be like, what are you doing?
00:54:27
Speaker 8: Are you soaking?
00:54:28
Speaker 7: Are you under the cover? Are you under the bed? Like, where are you today? Like, what's happening? Because all that's going on, right? We have to work together. We have to protect ourselves because no one's coming to save us.
00:54:38
Speaker 11: Nobody.
00:54:39
Speaker 12: Well, I am.
00:54:40
Speaker 2: Thank you. Thank you, doctor.
00:54:42
Speaker 1: Abiola, I got to ask you this because I think this is an important part, too.
00:54:45
Speaker 2: We're talking about mental health.
00:54:47
Speaker 1: There's another piece of this, and maybe this has to be a second part of another show, but there's addiction. The people that are addicted to the algorithm, addicted to the like, addicted to the consuming of content regardless of the cost to your neighbor, to the person who you want to cancel this week. Talk about what you're seeing in the creator space because you share a lot of space and have built spaces for content creators. It's a beautiful opportunity. It's democratized access to all kinds of people. And some of them aren't particularly healed. So how do you hold that?
00:55:22
Speaker 10: Ironically, this week I've dealt with a couple of attacks in two groups, one that's my own organization, one that's another organization. And at one point when I was trying to help defend somebody who we were worried about, we were worried about her health, she sent me a long email calling me a lot of things that I don't even think I would repeat.
00:55:44
Speaker 2: I actually felt better afterwards because.
00:55:46
Speaker 3: I looked up and I realized, this half are crazy.
00:55:50
Speaker 10: You know, I'm like, I got, there's three different people in this situation.
00:55:55
Speaker 8: But confirmed, right? Because people try to gaslight you, right? Yeah, they're all cursing me out. Maybe I didn't mean it like that.
00:56:00
Speaker 2: They're all sending me crazy emails.
00:56:02
Speaker 10: And I'm like, number one, to send an email in writing to say some of these things is wild. So it lets me know that you don't care about professionalism. You don't care about this or that. But it freed me because I realized some people, they are addicted to the chaos. I can provide you screenshots. I can say, hey, I didn't do this. I can show you over and over again, if you don't want to believe me, you're not going to. There's this thing that we talk about in philosophy, and it's called your credence value. And essentially what it is, or the way I like to explain it, is basically if you have an opening, it's like a water faucet. Depending on how open or closed it is, is how much water is going to come out. And people's credence value is how open or closed the faucet is. So the information is the water. And if they are closed off, nothing's going to get through. It doesn't matter what you do. It doesn't matter what you say. They're simply not going to listen to you. And so I think being able to learn that and experience that has been very freeing. I myself have been on the other end of a tax this week. And something that I always try and tell my followers and other folks is that context is everything, right? Like I'm a big contextualist. So if somebody says, hey, Abiola did this, why would I do that? If you look, why would I do that? What would my benefit be? And what's the harm in you believing that I did that? What's the effect of that? And I think that can help a lot amongst just trying to surround yourself with good people. I have some people that did reach out to me this week, they were like, listen, They're like, we know you tried your best. We know who you are.
00:57:19
Speaker 2: And we know that that is not the truth.
00:57:22
Speaker 10: And, you know, it doesn't really matter because as long as people know where you stand, you are able to really, I think, solidify your place and your spot and find a way to still build up light and be full of light as you navigate those things. So I always encourage people to just teach what you can, but sometimes you just got to laugh.
00:57:41
Speaker 3: Let it go.
00:57:42
Speaker 1: So I want to go close with you, Talib. And part of it is because you started this conversation today with liberation, which is a word that means every single thing to me, especially because I think for generations we fought for exactly that. How do we get free from this and use it for what it was intended for? But keep our peace, you know, use it to galvanize our folks. It's been a great equalizer around mobilization and and activism for us, but it feels like now it's starting to cause just as much harm.
00:58:15
Speaker 2: So, brother, how do we get free from this?
00:58:17
Speaker 4: Well, I don't know if we need to get free from this. I mean, you know, I don't want to sound like a fatalist at all, but, you know, all through human life, we can't beat the technology. And I'm not just talking about computers and science and science fiction. I'm talking about technology from the ancient world. You know, like what a song does to the spirit is also a form of technology. So things, you know, progress and things get better. You're not going to beat the technology. So you have to figure out how to work within it. It's sort of the same conversation around racism and bigotry and hatred.
00:58:52
Speaker 3: And all that.
00:58:53
Speaker 4: It's like, we're not going to solve these problems in our lifetime. So how do we just, how do we make it more comfortable? for
the people who are living in it.
00:59:00
Speaker 3: And I think for social media, it's a net positive.
00:59:04
Speaker 4: When you look at the Arab Spring, when you look at Occupy Wall Street, when you look at when Ferguson was on ground zero, when you look at what's happening with Palestine in our lifetime, it used to be demonized for mention of Palestine. Now it's like you can be demonized, not demonized, but people have heavy critiques for people who stand up for Israel. And when I was a child, you couldn't do that. So I think social media is added to that. I'm a person who was into forming community. And that was my biggest issue with what I went through personally on social media is that I felt, and I had to get over this, but I felt abandoned by my community. I felt gaslit and abandoned. I felt like I was telling people, I'm like, I'm getting death threats. They're saying I harass all these people. And a lot of people were like, man, it's just Twitter. it's just bots. It's just, don't get over it. And meanwhile, things were really happening that were having real effects. And so I, I want to end by just saying thank you to the wonderful women on this panel, because this has been a very healing conversation for me personally. Um, this has made me feel very, very heard or very seen. And, and, and the fact that I can, we can speak about these things. Like we're not shying away from anything. Um, but the opportunity to talk about social media, um, As.
01:00:23
Speaker 3: If it's a real thing, you know, because it is.
01:00:26
Speaker 4: Our enemies have used social media, weaponized social media to win elections and change policy. When Steve Bannon got hired by Donald Trump, when Steve Bannon is absolutely a Nazi. When he got hired by Donald Trump, the first thing he did was say, we don't have to.
01:00:40
Speaker 3: Go to CNN.
01:00:41
Speaker 4: We don't have to go to MSNBC. We don't have to talk to our opposition. We could just go to Twitter. And if Twitter's not good enough, we could start True Social. We could just talk to our base, and that's it. And they've been able to utilize social media to galvanize their base. I was in London when we started talking.
01:01:00
Speaker 3: I got on a plane. I'm actually in Scotland right now.
01:01:03
Speaker 4: But you see a rise of far-right extremism and fascism all over the world. And these people are connecting through social media. And if they're going to get aggressive with the nonsense, we got to get aggressive with the conscious.
01:01:15
Speaker 3: That's always what I've said.
01:01:17
Speaker 2: I love that. I like that.
01:01:18
Speaker 1: Please join me in thanking today's panelists, Talib Khali, Nicole Pope-Bell, Lindsay Song, Abiola Aguero, and Dr.
01:01:26
Speaker 2: Danielle Harrison.
01:01:29
Speaker 1: Today we discuss three claims. One, cyberbullying is a threat to mental health and public safety.
01:01:35
Speaker 2: Overwhelmingly, yes.
01:01:36
Speaker 1: Two, bots and fake accounts exist to divide and manipulate people.
01:01:41
Speaker 2: This also is mostly true.
01:01:43
Speaker 1: Some entities may argue that bots help to lift up products, some with increasing downloads for podcasts and music. Even Talib Khalid was not even that mad about it until later. Yep, even from some of your favorite artists. Their names won't be repeated here.
01:01:57
Speaker 10: Three.
01:01:58
Speaker 1: Most people can differentiate human activity from bot activity.
01:02:02
Speaker 2: Maybe a little bit true, but we.
01:02:04
Speaker 1: Saw our own audience struggle with this today, and I know I struggle with it regularly myself.
01:02:08
Speaker 2: And here's what else we know.
01:02:10
Speaker 1: The internet has given us unprecedented power to connect, organize, and speak truth to power. But it's also created new ways to intimidate people, manipulate conversations, and manufacture division. And here's what we can't forget. Not every disagreement is a conspiracy. Not every anonymous account is a bot. And not everything that goes viral is true. The challenge isn't just figuring out who's real online. It's making sure we're not surrendering our judgment, our safety, or our collective power to people and systems we cannot see. because a thousand comments don't necessarily mean a thousand people.
01:02:50
Speaker 2: And the loudest voice in the room isn't always.
01:02:53
Speaker 1: The accurate voice in the room, especially in cyberspace. Before you share it, believe it, or let it create any more division.
01:03:01
Speaker 2: Cite Your Source.
01:03:03
Speaker 1: Remember, knowledge is power. And on this show, we put that power back into the hands of the people. Please subscribe to Cite Your Source on YouTube. Engage with us on social media and share with somebody. Until next time, I'm your host, Angela Rye.
01:03:16
Speaker 2: This is Cite Your Source.