رونوشت 🔗
00:00:00
Speaker 1: Morning to you welcome to this thursday hope we find you well this 12th day of november much to talk about today i'd love to hear from you if you have any views on what we're talking about or subjects that you'd like to introduce to the show the adelaide city council and the state government seem to be at loggerheads we'll talk about that shortly um something that speaking about loggerheads The COP31 conference in Turkey, it seems to be more notable for who's not there than who is. Major world leaders are absent, sparking concerns about climate advocates. And most glaringly, the heads of the world's three largest carbon-emitting nations, US President Donald Trump, Chinese President Xi Jinping, and Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi, are skipping the event. Among the G7 nations, British Prime Minister Andy Burnham was the only starter, as Canada's Mark Carney, Japan's Sanya Takachi, France's Emmanuel Macron, Germany's Friedrich Merz and Italy's Giorgio Maloney all stayed away. Many European leaders, including Spain's Pedro Sanchez, opted instead to attend an artificial intelligence summit in Dublin. Critics warn these empty chairs highlight wealthy nations aren't committed to tackling global warming. And is it surprising that COP isn't regarded as having any real impact? The first COP conference was in 1995. They aim to stabilise greenhouse gas levels to prevent dangerous human-caused climate change, mainly by limiting global warming to well below 2 degrees, ideally 1.5 degrees Celsius. 31 years on, how successful has COP been? Well, global greenhouse gas levels have continued rising overall, temperatures are accelerating, and the core goal of stabilising concentrations to limit warming to the Paris targets remain unmet. And the cost of it all? Well, global investment in clean energy reached a record $ 2. 2 trillion in 2025. The total or future price tag of the global transition? Well, United Nations estimates that about $ 4. 5 trillion per year must be invested in renewable energy and infrastructure through 2020-30 to reach the net zero emissions by 2050. And what is the cost of the COP talk fest themselves? Well, while no official figures exist, Best estimates for host organisational costs have alone likely totalled in the many billions of US dollars, and that doesn't include what individual countries attending COP have spent. Individual nations often spend millions per COP on delegations and pavilions. Australia has the biggest delegation in Turkey, by the way. The cost? Reportedly over $ 1. 5 million in travel for public servants, $ 1 million per pavilion in recent years. Canada reportedly $ 1. spent nearly $ 3 million for COP28 attendance. So over 30 years, we're talking about many, many billions of dollars invested for no positive return. Anthony Albanese addressed COP yesterday, came under fire for delivering a climate change speech without once mentioning fossil fuels. The Prime Minister told world leaders, Australia had a responsibility to act on climate change, spruiking the country's rapid growth in renewable energy, rooftop solar and household batteries. But his conspicuous silence on coal, oil and gas raised eyebrows, particularly given Australia remains a major exporter of fossil fuels. And the timing couldn't have been more awkward for the conference. Just a day earlier, Turkish President Erdogan celebrated the discovery of two new oil fields in the country's Gabar region, potentially containing 135 million barrels of crude oil. He described it as good news. with production expected to exceed 100,000 barrels a day by the second half of 2027. All this at a conference where the focus is reducing the use of fossil fuel around the world. So while one leader talks for renewables, another celebrates finding more oil. Climate campaigners say Australia's credibility is taking a hit. Mind you, at least you can get a free coffee at the Australian Pavilion. What are your thoughts? Love to hear them. 8223 0000 is the number to ring. I mentioned it at the start. about the state government versus the adelaide city council what's what's happening in this ongoing battle the premier has accused the city council of complete madness and stifling the city after it tightened rules for events on the village green at adelaide oval number two now at its heart this is a disagreement about how much freedom adelaide oval should have to stage major events on the parklands and who gets to make the decisions the state government or adelaide city council So what's the argument? Well, the Premier and the Adelaide Oval Stadium Management Authority want greater flexibility to stage concerts and other major events. They argue the Council's restrictions will discourage promoters from bringing events to Adelaide because they can't be certain they will get approval. Joining us now is Adelaide City Councillor Phil Martin. Councillor, good morning. Thanks for your time today.
00:04:55
Speaker 2: Yeah, good morning, Graeme.
00:04:57
Speaker 3: How are you?
00:04:57
Speaker 1: Yeah, good, thanks. The Premier says you're stifling state opportunities.
00:05:03
Speaker 2: Well, look, I heard your comments leading up to this discussion, and I have to say what actually occurred at Council is that we didn't tighten restrictions, we loosened them. We made it possible for the government to have what it asked for. which is events at Adelaide Oval 2 and in Stella Bowen Park and Pennington Gardens, which they currently use as car parks during events at Adelaide Oval, we enabled the conduct of events there on multiple days. So where previously the Stadium Management Authority agreed to a system whereby there were six events a year at that precinct, we've now said, well, we don't care how many events you have, Of those six days, you can run, say, for example, a three-day or two three-days or three two-days, which is exactly what they asked for. We gave it to them. Now, the Premier's confusion in all of
Load full transcript
this, I think, is he thinks the Stadium Management Authority asked for council approval for six events of three days each. The Stadium Management Authority didn't do that. And in fact, because of the government regulations, we went to a very lengthy consultation with the people of Adelaide and more broadly South Australia, explaining what the government wanted. And the answer came back to us, look, that's okay.
00:06:33
Speaker 4: That's okay.
00:06:34
Speaker 5: Do it.
00:06:35
Speaker 1: And so we've done it.
00:06:36
Speaker 2: Now, the goalposts have shifted and the Premier seems to be under the mistaken apprehension that we haven't approved what he asked for. We gave him everything he wanted. If you want something else, we say to the Premier, please articulate that so that we can give you what you want.
00:06:54
Speaker 1: There seems to be a whole area of confusion here. I mean, SMA Chair Jamie Briggs has called the extra restrictions surprising and frustrating. warnings that they could deter promoters who need certainty. You're saying that no such restrictions exist.
00:07:08
Speaker 2: Well, and moreover, the restrictions that apply are the ones that the Stadium Management Authority agreed to many years ago when events were first discussed. Moreover, the Stadium Management Authority has sent counsel a letter and it's on the public record. It's attached to the agenda papers for the committee at which this matter was discussed a week ago. The Stadium Management Authority has sent a letter to council saying, good on you, we're very happy at what you're proposing as changes. Now, I'll leave it to your listeners to work out what's happened between last week when they sent council a letter copied to all councillors and available publicly still saying, good on you, to what happened yesterday.
00:07:58
Speaker 1: Are you suggesting the Premier and the SMA have totally misread the situation?
00:08:03
Speaker 2: I think there's a very good chance that's what's occurred. There's a very good chance that's what's occurred. You know, look, the city of Adelaide is as keen on events as the state government is. They bring vibrancy. They bring activity to the city.
00:08:21
Speaker 1: We love them. There is nothing like.
00:08:24
Speaker 2: The city of Adelaide, particularly during February and March, when there are events in.
00:08:29
Speaker 1: Every corner of the city. We get that. We love it.
00:08:33
Speaker 2: Now, if they want to do that more often at Adelaide Oval, then let us know, we'll help. Now, I've heard the Premier talk about how there have only been two events at Adelaide Oval because there have been restrictions applied by Council under the terms of this agreement, and you would have heard him mention the Midnight Oil Concert and Ice House, the only ones in about eight years. Well, let me tell you, I've been on council for eight years. I don't know of any other matter that was brought to us for a concert that we knocked back. I don't even
remember seeing an application at all. And it seems to me that the Stadium Management Authority and the government have a problem. If the authority, with the capacity to have events at Adelaide Oval, as it did with Ice House and with Midnight Oil, has not been arranging concerts, there's a problem. I think the Premier needs to ask the Stadium Management Authority, what have you guys been doing?
00:09:36
Speaker 1: Why have you not had more concerts? So let's be unequivocal about this. The Adelaide City Council is not limiting the whole area to six events a year. Is that right?
00:09:47
Speaker 6: No.
00:09:49
Speaker 2: The agreement that was put in place, and don't trust my memory in this, but I think it was 2018, 2019, the Stadium Management Authority, came to us and said, we would like to hold events at Adelaide Oval 2 Precinct, which includes Adelaide Oval, Stella Bowen Park and Pennington Gardens. We would like to do that six times a year on non-consecutive days. The council said at that time, yes, of course, you can do that. And we agreed the circumstances under which that would happen. Late last year and again early this year, the minister representing the Stadium Management Authority, that's Nick Champion, came to council and said, look, we want to change the rules.
00:10:37
Speaker 1: What we want to do is to.
00:10:39
Speaker 2: Change those six days into to accommodate consecutive days of concerts so that we can have, for example, on those six days, three consecutive days of, say, a rock festival or two consecutive days of some particular performance. Neither the minister... nor the Stadium Management Authority said to Council, we want to increase the number of days from six to 10 to 20 or whatever. Had they done so, then that would have been something we would have considered and which we would have put out to public consultation. And moreover, you would think in the letter that came to us from the Stadium Management Authority saying, good on you, we're really happy with what you're doing, you would have thought they'd have said, hang on a minute, guys, we want 20 days, not six days. At no point did they say that. Did the Minister say that? The only time this has come up is in the last 24 hours when the Premier has complained that he didn't get what he wanted. Well, he didn't ask for what he claims he wants.
00:11:52
Speaker 1: Now, the Premier continues to butt heads with the Adelaide City Council. Is there a bigger agenda? I mean, the proposed MotoGP street circuit, the North Adelaide golf course redevelopment. Do you think he's building a dossier here so he can at a later stage take some formal action and dismiss the council?
00:12:08
Speaker 2: Well, look, I've said previously, I mean, I think it is troubling. in circumstances like this where we have a Premier criticising the Council for not giving him what he wanted, which he hasn't yet articulated to Council, it is in those circumstances troubling and I am worried that there's another agenda. Now, I take at face value the Premier's assurances to media yesterday that he has no intention of dismissing the City of Adelaide. But look, Graeme, There's no question there is a strained relationship. I understand that the Premier is very angry and I've been in meetings with the Premier where he's expressed this anger. He is very angry with two or three Adelaide City Councillors who he sees as having frustrated in some way his plans for Live Golf and for MotoGP.
00:13:07
Speaker 1: I get that.
00:13:08
Speaker 2: But we are talking about a few members of council who are entitled to their point of view, but who do not represent the council opinion on a range of issues, including cooperating with the state government in any way we can to help bring events to Adelaide.
00:13:26
Speaker 1: We love them. They are so important. Phil Martin, thanks for your time today. Councillor Phil Martin. on the ongoing battle between the Adelaide City Council and the state government. This is what the Premier had to say in the last 24 hours.
00:13:39
Speaker 7: It beggars belief that the Adelaide City Council seem to be so utterly determined in repelling people coming to our city.
00:13:48
Speaker 1: It is complete madness. So the battle goes on and what has the Lord Mayor had to say?
00:13:54
Speaker 8: What's this?
00:13:55
Speaker 6: What's this?
00:13:58
Speaker 9: Mally blasts Adelaide City Council over absurd Adelaide Oval restrictions.
00:14:04
Speaker 8: I'm really confused. So, let me get this right.
00:14:10
Speaker 9: The stadium authority made a request to the council to change the management plan around the Oval. We did what the legislation asked us to do.
00:14:23
Speaker 8: We consulted. And then we agreed. And we did what they asked.
00:14:30
Speaker 9: In fact, they said the stadium authority welcomes the direction of council's proposed amendments and acknowledges the constructive response to the matters previously discussed. I sometimes think I'm in a parallel universe. We just got a shellacking for doing what we were asked to do.
00:14:57
Speaker 8: What are they going to settle us with next?
00:14:59
Speaker 1: That's Lord Mayor Jane Lomax-Smith taking to social media to address the issue. So what are your thoughts, folks? Where do you stand on the matter? The Adelaide City Council has been accused of being obstructionist. If we are to believe what Phil Martin has said, what the Lord Mayor has said, they have acceded, agreed to what was asked of them, and now they're being attacked. I'd like to know what you think. 8223 0000.
00:15:27
Speaker 10: 5AA Mornings with Graham Goodings.
00:15:30
Speaker 1: Do your calls in a moment on 8223 0000. Frank says, Morning, Gigi. Did you see Chris Bowen conference when he was talking? They panned around the room. Two-thirds were asleep or on the phone. Waste of money. Good morning, Gigi. I've heard that they are renaming COP31 to change their position for the 31st time. A little unkind. Can
you confirm that Albo and Bowen traveled to COP 31 in separate jets? Well, they did because, uh, Chris Bowen has been there for some time. The prime minister only arrived yesterday and flew out soon after, I believe, uh, 196 Australian representatives attended at the expense of the taxpayer. I can confirm, I can't confirm the number, but I know Australia's is the largest delegation at COP 31 and the coffee is free. Eight double two three double O double O. Um, When are Australians going to wake up to the biggest con in world history, that is, that we can control climate change? Three-quarters of the world are doing nothing, while Australia enjoys the world's highest energy prices, our standard of living going backwards, and companies going broke, all for less than 1% of global emissions. Thank you for that, Steve. Brenton, good morning.
00:16:44
Speaker 11: Morning, Graeme.
00:16:45
Speaker 12: How are things?
00:16:46
Speaker 1: Yeah, good, thanks.
00:16:48
Speaker 11: Graeme, while this federal government's determined to destroy... Our society, as we know it, with respect to energy, they are decimating our industry, decimating manufacturing, crippling small business. We are seeing ever-increasing rises in energy as a consequence of their ideologically driven energy policy. But this COP31 conference, just a couple of points, Chris Bowen stated earlier Swapping fossil fuels for clean power helps us better shield households from volatile bills and price shocks. Well, I don't know about you and me, but since they've come to power, the ABS is telling me that it's about 32% to 40% increase in power prices since then. And secondly, we've got our Prime Minister urging, again, urgent action on climate crisis. hoping for an 82% renewable energy goal by 2030. And then Reinstadt Energy just yesterday said, if we continue down the path we are, power prices will double by 2029.
00:18:04
Speaker 1: Yeah, wholesale power prices, yep.
00:18:07
Speaker 11: Yes, I know. And we never pay the wholesale.
00:18:09
Speaker 13: It's always retail.
00:18:10
Speaker 1: Well, that to me means wholesale prices will be that. Then you put the retail on.
00:18:14
Speaker 13: Top of that.
00:18:15
Speaker 11: That's right.
00:18:16
Speaker 10: That's right.
00:18:16
Speaker 11: So it's going to be much higher than two times. Solar and wind can't keep pace. It was stated, rice, dead energy was stated. Solar and wind can't keep pace with coal power station closures. And to reach 82%, and I hate the word renewable, the intermittent weather-driven unreliable energy system, solar and wind, Solar wind can't keep pace, and to do that, to reach 82% by 2030, we need three times the amount of solar wind we've got now. So, I mean, it's just absolute ideological craziness to pursue this path of unreliable, intermittent, weather-driven energy as our main source of power in society. We can all see the effects of it. We can all see a rise in our energy bills where 1% of the global problem and still we're trying to set the way for the rest of the world to follow as we go down this ridiculous ideological path.
00:19:13
Speaker 1: Brenton, well said. Tony says, fossil fuels, not the enemy. It's the poor efficiency and the use of fossil fuels. For example, new housing builds with no roofs or no roof eaves or green space, substandard insulation, the research in petrol-driven engine combustion changes that minimise loss of heat. Science tells us energy is not lost, only transferred. Hence, if the engine is not lost through heat, it stays within the engine and hence less fuel is used. And, oh my God, Phil Martin, what a voice. Give the man his own radio show. Interesting you say that. I used to work with Phil Martin in Tasmania. He was a journalist at TNT9 in Launceston. And, yeah, I lost contact with him, met up with him again. Well, I haven't met up with him, spoken to him on the phone since he came to Adelaide.
00:19:58
Speaker 10: But, yeah, he does have a voice. 5AA Mornings with Graham Goodings.
00:20:04
Speaker 1: 27 minutes to 10, 5AA, this Thursday morning. Let's take a call. Ed, good morning.
00:20:10
Speaker 14: Oh, Graeme, good morning.
00:20:13
Speaker 5: Firstly, an observation.
00:20:15
Speaker 14: When all looking solemn and humble and giving a talk to the Australian public, I noticed that the Prime Minister did not wear a poppy on his suit when laying a wreath at the Changi Chapel. So, you know, one might have their own ideas about that. Mine comes to be critical. The second thing is we're looking at solar panels, government subsidies. Why on earth 2015, when all the new developments here in South Australia, friends of mine have bought a house out at Trinity Gardens, out near Trinity College, do they have solar panels?
00:20:52
Speaker 15: No, they don't.
00:20:53
Speaker 14: Every house that's been developed since 2015 possibly should have had incorporated into their build solar panels as a compulsory addition. And then we start to come good with this clean energy, et cetera. Anyway, they are my two observations.
00:21:13
Speaker 5: Have a great day.
00:21:13
Speaker 1: Yeah, thanks for making them for us. Maybe Albo not wearing a poppy was an oversight. Let's hope it was. I don't think it would be any sort of political statement. But as for putting solar panels on way back in 2015 when the new bills were going up, yeah, I agree. A little bit of foresight because, you know, when you retrofit something, it's always way more expensive than in the original deal. Well, the controversial billion-dollar-ton-kilo data center proposal has hit a pause. It follows the backlash from local residents. Developer Quantum DC has announced it will not lodge a development application or seek Crown sponsorship this year, admitting it underestimated the strength of community opposition. Well, yesterday in Parliament, Rob Sims, Greens MLC, presented a motion. Rob, thanks for joining us this morning. What was the motion that you moved on?
00:22:04
Speaker 16: Good morning, Graeme. So, yeah, yesterday I moved a motion in Parliament calling on the state government to oppose... the proposal for a data centre up at Tunkillo, but also to impose a moratorium on any new data centres across the state. You know, these things are energy vampires. They're water vampires. They use a huge amount of our natural resources. And so we need to hit the pause button across the state so that we can work out whether the community want them and also what this means for our natural resources.
00:22:35
Speaker 1: So I guess you're across what happened this morning with the proposed developers. at Tangkilo holding fire.
00:22:43
Speaker 16: I am across that news and I welcome the news that the proposer is going back to the drawing board, the proponents going back to the drawing board. I think it demonstrates the power of community action. But the fight's not over yet. We want to see this project abandoned entirely and there shouldn't be any data centre up at Tangkilo. And so we've got to keep the pressure up to ensure that it's dumped. And of course, we need to see a moratorium on all new data centres, because we heard just yesterday that there's potential, apparently there's at least five expressions of interest at the moment, there's potential for more of these things to pop up around the state.
00:23:21
Speaker 13: And that's why we need to see a moratorium.
00:23:24
Speaker 1: The government is very keen to have data centres. They say that, you know, lots of employment, lots of economic benefit for the state. Do you see it that way?
00:23:33
Speaker 17: Oh, look, I don't.
00:23:35
Speaker 16: I think there's lots of questions that we've got to work through. I mean, the government says it opens up opportunities for economic development. But I mean, we know, of course, that data centres enable the AI revolution. And long term, I think that's going to displace a lot of jobs. And so I'm really concerned about that. But also, what about the economic costs in terms of what this means for our energy use? and our water. And if this puts prime agricultural land at risk, well, that's hardly a boon for our economy. So there are lots of serious questions to be worked through here.
00:24:08
Speaker 13: And while I.
00:24:08
Speaker 16: Welcome the pause button being hit on the Tangkilo proposal, we need to see a pause on these proposals right across the state so that we can work through what this new, this evolving technology really means.
00:24:22
Speaker 1: I mean, it seems to me that this move to attract data centres here is done within decent haste. How many data centres do we need? Could there be a situation where a Tangkilo data centre or a Tangkilo data centre somewhere else could be a white elephant in five or ten years' time? We have too many data centres.
00:24:42
Speaker 16: Well, that's exactly my concern, Graeme, and the government will say, well, we've got to rush ahead with this, and they'll say they
want to regulate it. Well, of course I agree we need to regulate data centres, there's no question, but we don't need to rush ahead here, and I think what we should be doing is imposing a moratorium, give ourselves a year or 18 months to work through what the implications are, and really there should be some leadership from the federal government in Canberra rather than us having a patchwork quilt of different laws and regulations in every state. Let's leave it to the federal government to work through those issues and ensure there's a nationally consistent framework rather than South Australia sticking our neck out and being ahead of the pack and potentially just opening ourselves up to be a playground for big tech.
00:25:27
Speaker 1: Do you think there are the economic developments or the benefits that the government seem to say there is? I mean, is it that likely that we're going to make money out of it? I mean, These data centres will end up being owned and controlled and managed by overseas companies. What ongoing benefits are there for Australia and South Australia?
00:25:46
Speaker 16: Well, that's the fundamental question, isn't it? I'm not convinced that there's going to be a long-term return to South Australians. I'm really concerned about that. I'm concerned about the impact this has on our water supply, on our energy supply. And I think you're right that, you know, what happens if the AI boom goes bust? I mean, we've actually seen over the last few days that shares are significantly dipping in that area. We could find ourselves with a bunch of empty warehouses on our prime agricultural land. And I'm not sure what the rush is here. I mean, the Malinakis government seems to love to bend over backwards to accommodate big business. But, you know, let's just cool our jets. And I welcome what's happened in Tanguilo. There's a go slow there. That's great. But the Premier needs to slam on the brakes across the board. Let's have a statewide moratorium on these new centres.
00:26:37
Speaker 1: Are there any other data centres pending at the moment?
00:26:41
Speaker 16: So, interestingly, the Treasurer yesterday revealed on radio that he'd heard that there were five proposals for new data centres popping up. And, again, that concerns me because at the moment we don't really have any regulation in place yet. And the government has talked about, you know, wanting to move to regulating this area. Well, we're running out of time really to do so. Let's actually hit a pause and let's buy ourselves the time to make sure we get this right.
00:27:11
Speaker 1: Is there any suggestion that there is taxpayer money involved in attracting data centres to South Australia?
00:27:17
Speaker 16: I would hope not. I mean, knowing this government, though, if they were, we know what they'd say, Graeme.
00:27:24
Speaker 1: Commercial incompetence.
00:27:25
Speaker 16: Commercial incompetence. That's their mantra. So we wouldn't be able to actually get to the bottom
of it. But I certainly hope that there isn't, because I think the economics of this really don't stack up.
00:27:40
Speaker 1: Well, final word, victory for the little people. Tung Kilo has had a small victory, which might ripple across the state and make people realise that they can have a say and make a difference.
00:27:53
Speaker 13: Absolutely.
00:27:54
Speaker 16: I agree, it is a win for people power, but we can't take the pressure off just yet because, you know, there is still the prospect that this development will be progressed and I'll be bringing my motion to a vote in Parliament, urging the government to oppose any data centre in Tunkillo and also, of course, for this statewide moratorium.
00:28:12
Speaker 1: Rob Sims, good to chat. Greens MLC on the motion that he introduced regarding... a statewide moratorium on data centres. What are your thoughts, folks? The Tunkillo people have received a reprieve. There's no question about that, how long it will last. We're going to speak with local Magdalene Lippert after, in short, about five minutes or so. I believe they've called for a rally to protest about the Tunkillo data centre. Will that rally go ahead with news that the people that want to build the data centre are hitting the pause button. What are your thoughts? Love to hear them, 8223 0000. Back shortly. 5AA Mornings with Graeme Goodings. 14 to 10, 5AA. Thanks for tuning in. Hope you can stick around for a while. Let's take some calls. Ken, good morning.
00:29:02
Speaker 12: Good morning, Graeme. I'd like to talk about this new Women's and Children's Hospital.
00:29:07
Speaker 13: Yeah.
00:29:09
Speaker 12: Well, first, I certainly hope it's not going to land up like the rural Adelaide where we gave land and billions of dollars and it was nearly finished in construction and someone came out with, oh, the computer system's going to cost more than the whole construction of the hospital. Now we don't own it and we pay a million dollars a day to lease it for its entirety. However, this Women's and Children's Hospital We've got a prime situation right now that they built a car park. Instead of a Women's and Children's Hospital, they put in a massive aged care hospital, which takes all the pressure off the other hospitals. And we've got a prime situation where we can do it.
00:29:58
Speaker 12: Prefabricated. So every story that goes up is exactly the same as each other and built in factories and then delivered and placed like a big Meccano set. Bang, bang, bang, bang, bang. And then if the Women's and Children's Hospital they're coping extremely well now and there's hardly any ramping. But the thing is they could build an extension of in the parklands across the road and have a walkway sound from the second storey across.
00:30:33
Speaker 1: This is from the existing Women's and Children's, you're saying?
00:30:36
Speaker 12: Yes, and they extend the existing Women's and Children's Hospital there with the new extension.
00:30:42
Speaker 1: Well, you know that's not going to happen, don't you?
00:30:46
Speaker 12: Well, that wouldn't surprise me at all. Mind you, I went for the first time in my life to the... What's it called?
00:30:54
Speaker 18: The.
00:30:55
Speaker 12: the viewing deck at the Parliament House.
00:31:00
Speaker 6: Yeah.
00:31:00
Speaker 12: The other day, it runs from two till three, Tuesday, Wednesday, and Thursdays, per fortnight. So, it's three hours a fortnight, or let's whack it down to weekly, one and a half hours a week. But mind you, half of that was in, someone had died, and they were giving eulogies and this and that, and then they had a, and they had a three-minute break with their heads standing up and their heads dropped down, and then they had.
00:31:31
Speaker 1: So this is to watch parliamentary procedure, it is? It's sort of.
00:31:33
Speaker 19: A public gallery.
00:31:34
Speaker 12: Well, I forgot about the thumping machine, the big mace there to go through all that too. And in the end, that one hour, well, it was only a half an hour. And they then all of a sudden had a smoke-out, or maybe they were having their wake for the person that died, because up in the viewing section, maybe that's why they call it the viewing section, because you can't hear a damn thing.
00:32:00
Speaker 1: Nothing at all. Not much point being there if you can't hear what's being said.
00:32:04
Speaker 12: Exactly right.
00:32:05
Speaker 1: They've got no speakers up in the seats.
00:32:08
Speaker 15: Big button?
00:32:09
Speaker 1: No, they've got no speakers in the seats. No, it doesn't sound like it.
00:32:12
Speaker 12: Well, actually, I rang the maintenance guy this morning, the manager of the maintenance, and he said, well, there are speakers up there. Because I said, well, why don't you put wireless speakers in?
00:32:20
Speaker 5: Yeah.
00:32:21
Speaker 12: And... He goes, well, there is speakers there. I said, well, they're not working.
00:32:26
Speaker 1: Yeah, maybe they need to turn them up. Good on you, Ken. Thanks for your call. Susie, good morning.
00:32:30
Speaker 20: Good morning.
00:32:32
Speaker 21: I've got two main things with the data centres.
00:32:35
Speaker 1: Yeah, what's that?
00:32:37
Speaker 21: First of all, the Chinese government a year or more ago made rules that AI cannot take over people's jobs. It is there to help people not to take the jobs away. Why has our federal government not even brought that up or mentioned a thing about it?
00:32:58
Speaker 1: This is the first I've heard of it. So in China, they've legislated so AI can't take people's jobs. Is that what you're saying?
00:33:04
Speaker 21: Yes, and we do exactly the same thing here. I mean, I'm old enough.
00:33:11
Speaker 11: That it's not going to affect me, but how.
00:33:13
Speaker 21: Are the young ones going to get a job when thousands of jobs won't exist anymore?
00:33:18
Speaker 1: Yeah, look, it's a fair point, Susie. There's no question about that, that
any business that's struggling at the moment, how are they going to save money? And they can see they've got X number of employees. Some of those jobs could be done by artificial intelligence and you don't have to pay, you know, leave loading, holiday pay. You don't have to pay for sick leave, superannuation and the like if a machine can do the job. I'm not saying it's right, but it's just the way businesses will go. They will go that way. What happens to people? What happens to the unemployment level? A scary thought, I know. Let's take a look at the stock market. The All Ords is down by 0.4%. ASX 200 down by 0.5%. Dow Jones up by 0.5%. The NASDAQ up by 1.6%. Brent Crude, 92 US dollars a barrel. West Texas, 86 US dollars. And Gold, 3,987 US dollars an ounce. The Aussie dollar currently buying 68 US cents. Well, it was certainly a win for local residents with the news that developer Quantum DC has hit the pause button on its proposed data centre, Tunkillo. Local resident Magda Lippert has been a prime mover in stopping the data centre development. She joins us now. Magda, thanks for your time today.
00:34:32
Speaker 19: Hi.
00:34:34
Speaker 1: So you see this is a win for the locals?
00:34:37
Speaker 22: Look, we welcomed the pause, but it certainly isn't over yet.
00:34:42
Speaker 4: No. We look at it.
00:34:45
Speaker 22: As in there are many, many issues. I understand that Mr Tomasi has said that he has read, read, misunderstood the community backlash.
00:34:57
Speaker 4: I think he's still misunderstanding it.
00:34:59
Speaker 22: We've done our own community consultation with experts in many different areas now, and the hills just isn't the right place for their data centre.
00:35:11
Speaker 1: So what... What are your major grievances?
00:35:17
Speaker 4: There are many.
00:35:17
Speaker 22: So the community has put together, before their first cancelled meeting, 432 questions that are all valid.
00:35:25
Speaker 4: We've put them together with subheadings.
00:35:28
Speaker 22: The concerns include things like water, light pollution, noise pollution, the impact on the Dark Sky Reserve, roads, livestock, endangered species, Indigenous... culture there it just the list goes on and on and as we start to break down those issues there's many more issues that are underneath those subheadings as well.
00:35:52
Speaker 1: Yeah well there are a lot of issues to address but I believe Mr Tomasi did address one of those on breakfast on 5AA this morning when he said you know water is no longer an issue it's it's recycled water so they're not going to be using any great quantities of water so does that appease you in any way?
00:36:09
Speaker 22: I mean, they're saying that they're going to capture water off 120 hectares of rooftop that would normally go into the underground systems and the streams that we all share. So I'm unsure what he means by water won't be an issue.
00:36:23
Speaker 1: So it won't be an issue for them, but it will be an issue for you is what you're saying.
00:36:26
Speaker 4: It will be for everyone else, yeah, definitely.
00:36:30
Speaker 1: Now, Magda, Steve on our text line has posed a question that you might be able to answer. It says, read data centres. Over 450 questions from local residents sounds a bit ridiculous to me. Do people genuinely want to know the impacts of data centres or do they have their minds made up already and are just looking for as many reasons as they can find to oppose data centres? How would you respond to that?
00:36:53
Speaker 22: I think that's a really good question. Up here in the hills, we're certainly not opposed to development. In fact, we do have a couple of large-scale projects on the go around this area, but we are very sensitive to making sure that those projects.
00:37:06
Speaker 4: Fit within the community and saying that because.
00:37:09
Speaker 22: People have 450 questions, it must mean that they're just creating issues. I mean, I think that they maybe need to look at the questions that are available on our website, which is www.stopthehillsdatacenter.com, and go through those questions and have a look for themselves.
00:37:25
Speaker 4: You know, the people up here aren't just angry people.
00:37:28
Speaker 22: Pitchfork-wielding hicks up in the hills. We're people that are educated and intelligent and generations who have lived up here for a really, really long time. And when we say that this isn't the right place for a data centre, we mean that.
00:37:42
Speaker 1: Now, the company says it will introduce a longer-term community consultation process. How do you feel about that?
00:37:49
Speaker 22: Well, I mean, if I can speak quite plainly about it, it really feels like Quantum DC is the creepy bloke at the pub that just can't take.
00:37:58
Speaker 4: The hint when we're saying no. And now they're waiting outside in the car park.
00:38:02
Speaker 1: So you're virtually saying that there is no argument that they can present, no evidence that they can present to you that would change your mind?
00:38:09
Speaker 22: Look, they've cancelled now five community engagement sessions, including these ones in November. The community has made every effort to engage. We've compiled questions. We've contacted them. None of us have had any personal engagement. And in that process, we've reached out to experts in all of the areas that we're concerned about, And the hills is not the right place for this project.
00:38:29
Speaker 4: It is just not the right place.
00:38:30
Speaker 1: Do you concede that there would be some economic benefit for the region?
00:38:35
Speaker 4: Everything comes with a trade-off. Everything.
00:38:38
Speaker 22: So there is economic benefit in this region already. There are many primary producers. We have a huge economy of that here in the hills. And this project will not benefit any of that.
00:38:51
Speaker 1: Now, you've called for a rally at the weekend. Will you put that off now that... Nope.
00:38:56
Speaker 22: No way, the rally is going ahead. We'll be there at 10.30am at the steps of Parliament. Come along and join us if you're available.
00:39:05
Speaker 4: It will be respectful, it will be peaceful, but we will be there.
00:39:08
Speaker 1: Would you welcome people from Quantum DC taking part?
00:39:12
Speaker 4: Absolutely, if they'd like to come along.
00:39:15
Speaker 22: I don't think that they will, considering how many community engagement meetings they've already cancelled, but we did invite them to all of our others, and once again, the invitation's there if they'd like to come along.
00:39:26
Speaker 4: On Sunday.
00:39:27
Speaker 1: So give us the detail. When is the rally? and what time?
00:39:31
Speaker 5: Sure.
00:39:31
Speaker 22: 10.30am Sunday on the steps of Parliament in Adelaide, North Terrace.
00:39:35
Speaker 1: Magda, thanks so much for your time today. Thank you. Well done for your local community. And it's great. I mean, in this day and age where we feel overwhelmed and having little say and our politicians aren't speaking for us and our councils aren't speaking for us, or they're answering the wrong questions, or they're not putting the right questions or answers in the world of AI and data centers. Here we have a group of people at Tunkillo who have spoken up loud and long. And well, it's not to say the developer will not eventually go ahead, but it would seem that they've hit the pause button on the proposed data center at Tunkillo. And regardless of what they want to do into the future, they're going to have long-term community consultation, according to Magda Lippert, it won't have any impact. So maybe that's plus one for the local community. Danny, good morning.
00:40:28
Speaker 12: Good morning, Graeme.
00:40:30
Speaker 18: Just on the subject of data centres and AI, all these companies that are taking on AI and displacing their employees, it's a bit of a false economy because the companies don't own the AI.
00:40:44
Speaker 15: They have to subscribe.
00:40:46
Speaker 23: So they're actually paying.
00:40:47
Speaker 24: to use the AI rather than using a human.
00:40:52
Speaker 5: So they're paying anyway.
00:40:54
Speaker 23: And the other thing I wanted to say is why, whether it be data centres or renewable energies, why, why, why are they putting it on our arable farmland?
00:41:03
Speaker 18: Do these people.
00:41:04
Speaker 24: Are they that sick in the city that they think that.
00:41:07
Speaker 23: Everything comes from the shop? And believe me, I've heard it even.
00:41:11
Speaker 24: You had a politician, not you, Graham, but one morning on David and Will's show, there was a politician who didn't know that milk came from cows.
00:41:21
Speaker 1: Oh, come on. You're putting me on, Danny.
00:41:22
Speaker 6: No, seriously.
00:41:23
Speaker 1: Oh, no, I'm serious. No, that's BS, surely.
00:41:26
Speaker 23: No, he actually said he was surprised, but then he backtracked and went, oh, well, I was only
joking.
00:41:34
Speaker 1: Can you name him?
00:41:36
Speaker 25: I can't remember who it was.
00:41:37
Speaker 18: It was years ago.
00:41:38
Speaker 15: It was a few years ago.
00:41:41
Speaker 1: If someone was listening and knows, I'd love to hear it. Good on you, Danny. Thanks for putting this in the picture. A politician who didn't know where milk came from. Yeah, look, I have expressed my concern over and over again when we have major wind farms and solar farms and artificial intelligence, digital centres and the like being built on arable land. Now, when you look at Australia, how much desolate land there is and arable land, we don't have a whole lot of it.
00:42:09
Speaker 13: Not a whole lot.
00:42:10
Speaker 1: So every acre, every hectare we use of arable land is food that can't be grown. So Sam has just said to me, doesn't chocolate milk come from brown cars? Sam, thank you very much for that. You can get back to sleep now.
00:42:25
Speaker 6: Ah, yes.
00:42:25
Speaker 1: So, no, look, if these centres are needed, let's build them in places where the land is reclaimed land. It can't be used for anything else. But to put them on arable farming land is an absolute no-no. Five AA mornings with Graham Goodings. Nine past ten on this Thursday morning, and being a Thursday at 10.30 this morning, we'll have our legal experts from Johnston with us to answer your legal questions on 8223 0000. That is the number to ring. Well, David Jones stores in five states will be closed by the end of the year, and the latest move to save the struggling retailer, Westlakes and Marion Face the Chop, Let's get some close-up analysis from Barry Urquhart, Consumer Behaviour Analyst. Barry, good morning. Thanks for joining us today.
00:43:11
Speaker 5: My pleasure.
00:43:13
Speaker 1: We've talked about this and we talked about only a week or so back being in the hands of the administrator, but is this advance quicker than you thought?
00:43:21
Speaker 5: Not really. I think that it's indicative and it's actually symbolic, isn't it, that they were waiting for tomorrow to have the expressions of interest declared. And here we are 48 hours before. The administrators of the estate are saying, well, hold on, we're going to close. half of our stores. Now, that indicates to me that there has been some negotiations behind the scenes. There is little interest in the acquisition in the whole, and so they're making rational decisions very, very quickly. The declaration tomorrow is going to be almost an afterthought of saying, well, is there anyone genuinely interested in buying? And more importantly, is there anything to buy? At what price? In 2018, the network was sold for $ 2. 1 billion, and then in 2022, eight years later, it was sold for $ 100 million. There's since been something like $ 200 million spent upgrading it and making it more attractive as a network. And reportedly, in the financial years ending 2024-25, they lost over $ 180 million in those two years collectively, and reportedly another $ 200 million this financial year, which has not been reported to us at the moment. So it's the sort of thing where you'd say, well, if you were an intending buyer, the proposition would be to the current owners, what do you want to pay me to take over this network? Because it has very little, if any, value at all.
00:44:51
Speaker 1: Well, many of the regional and suburban centres are going. I guess it makes sense that the flagship stores in the capital cities are remaining open. Well, it's not.
00:45:02
Speaker 5: That's the problem. The High Street Mall store in Perth, Western Australia, is closing down. Now, let me just focus on Western Australia. Western Australia occupies 2.3 million square kilometres, or in the old imperial measure, a million square miles. It's one-third of the land mass of Australia, which is 3 million square miles, or 7.3 million square kilometres. You've got a population of 3.2 million in Western Australia. Now you're going to have two stores of David Jones trying to satisfy and service that area. It's not possible. So what we've seen is from 38 stores down to 19, it is not half the business that it was a couple of days ago because its ability to be able to be a network of convenient, compelling, destination-type stores has really been marginalized completely. You will find that David Jones, as of next year, will become a cluster of small niche stores. What does that mean? There will be less of them. They will be smaller. There will be a narrower product range. They will be not having the brands that they are recognized for. And for that reason, will they be a destination, a generator for precincts and shopping centers? Clearly not. They're going to be a collection of smaller outlets. And coming back to the four most important things for consumers, convenience and accessibility is singularly the most important determinant of where people buy and why they prefer to go to those outlets. you cannot in South Australia say we're going to close two major shopping centre outlets and say, well, hold on, we're still convenient, we're still the destination. It is simply not the case because many people don't go to the CBD, to the Rundle Street Mall.
00:46:47
Speaker 1: And that's right. There's no question about that. And there's the effect that's likely to play a major role too. But with these major department stores in regional shopping centres, I mean, they're usually the major tenant. What impact is that going to have on on the regional centres themselves?
00:47:06
Speaker 5: Huge, but in reality, since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic in February 2020, it has not been the influence that it was. And so consequently, yes, it will be significant, it will be important. More important, not so much that they're not there, it will be vacant premises. And vacant premises visually and pictorially are just appallingly sort of situations. I think one of the worst things that we've got at the
moment is what has been indelibly imprinted in the minds of consumers is that all the television news bulletins have shown vacant stores, empty shelves, and people are going to sit back and say, well, hold on, I now know what to expect because management, marketing, customer service and the like is all about managing expectations. with the optics that have been evident in the news bulletins on television and on tablets right around the world and throughout South Australia, is that people say, well, what's the point of going there? There's no products for those ladies in black who I love and look for. I can't see any there. Therefore, what's the point of going?
00:48:10
Speaker 1: And you've got to feel for the staff. I mean, couldn't it be a worse time of year to be on the verge of losing your job? Do you know of sort of, will a lot of people be picked up in other areas? I mean, I know it's, coming up to the silly season, the busy season. So there'll be thousands of people around Australia working for David Jones who could be looking for a job in the next four to six weeks.
00:48:32
Speaker 5: Well, there's 6,000 in the workforce. I'm told immediately there's a threat for 800 jobs. So that's a kind of a significant amount. But if you lost half the stores, you're probably going to say that there's going to be 3,000 people who are very, very nervous. Let's put that into perspective. I have the great pleasure of bringing into Australia, for his only ever Australian appearance, Alvin Toffler. Alvin Toffler was the world's first futurist. He died about four years ago at 96 years of age, and he was advising all the forward thinking about, you know, for the United States of America. Now, Alvin Toffler wrote a book, Future Shock. He shocked the people in the 1970s. He said, think about this and put it into context. In the 1970s, he said, the people entering the workforce now in 1970 have got to expect that there's going to be seven career changes in in their life. Now, post-World War II, we were thinking about going into the police force, going into the public service, insurance companies, and you'd join at 15, you'd get a watch at 65, retire and off you would go. Single employment. Today, the average person, particularly in the retail sector, is looking to have, if they enter the workforce at 18 years of age, up to 17 and possibly 23 career changes. There is no career path in employment generally in Australia, retailer in particular. And the point that we were being analysed now is, Whereas the jobs is going to be back to jobbing side of the situation. So they're going to be an Uber delivery worker. They don't want that. That's not an appealing sort of proposition. So these people would not be overwhelmed with offers. They are well-renowned. They will be respected because of their product knowledge. But then there is a problem. A lot of them are older females. And we sell best to people aged seven years, either side our own age. So businesses attracting
and wanting to service people under 45 years of age will be very selective in who they choose from those people who will be thrown onto, sorry, but figuratively, the job heap of unemployment.
00:50:34
Speaker 1: Yeah, we're coming up to the perfect storm, aren't we? Actually, with AI doing people out of jobs. And businesses like David Jones shutting down, it doesn't look good for unemployment figures.
00:50:45
Speaker 5: Very sad. Very sad. Very emotional. And if you think about this, the people will be going into David Jones between now and Christmas. confronted with people who are nervous, anxious, high anxiety, and 70% of the reasons why you buy from them is the emotional interaction between two. When one person in that interaction is in a state of anxiety, that is not necessarily going to be a positive interaction, and so it's going to be a very sad reflection, and it's going to have a chained reaction.
00:51:13
Speaker 1: Now, Barry, on the text line, Helen has said in the wake of what's happening with David Jones, Maya would be feeling very insecure.
00:51:22
Speaker 5: I'm suffering from the same problem. They've got 54 stores. When they relisted, their share price is $ 4.
00:51:28
Speaker 25: 10.
00:51:28
Speaker 5: It's currently about $ 0. 20 to $ 0.
00:51:31
Speaker 25: 24.
00:51:31
Speaker 5: So they've lost 93%, 94% of their value. It's not the sort of thing where they will be looking to say, well, hold on, we can buy some of their stores. We'll grow our business naturally. The one person, and it is a person rather than a company, who's going to be the beneficiary of all of this is Solomon Liu. Solomon Liu is the major shareholder of Maya. He's got a representative on the board. He is a manufacturer and distributor. He recently sold six brands on his fashion outlet from Premier Investments into Maya. So he's going to be able to have a vertically integrated supply chain where he'll be distributing and giving products and services to the Maya group. and expand it almost, almost, I'm saying, emphasizing it, almost with exclusivity in a supply chain to a customer base that is going to be starved of a lot of options, choices, and preferences.
00:52:21
Speaker 1: Barry, final question. Would you expect a buyer to come forward for DJs?
00:52:26
Speaker 5: Look, I can't visualize who it would be. They will be very selective, and it's not going to be like it's going to be Q. and say, oh, well, we can rebirth it and that sort of thing. Rebirthing an apartment store is not because the simple answer is to your question, The business model for department stores is obsolete and redundant. Therefore, it's not compellingly attractive for funds managers, retailers or global retail monoliths who say, well, we can now get a footprint into Australia. No, it's not an attractive proposition. So the chances, I think it will be a slow, progressive attrition.
00:53:03
Speaker 1: Barry, thanks so much for your insight. Always great to chat. Barry Urquhart, Consumer Behaviour Analyst. for Media Focus.
00:53:09
Speaker 13: What are your thoughts, folks?
00:53:10
Speaker 1: Have you got any comments? Love to hear them. 8223 0000. Call shortly.
00:53:13
Speaker 10: 5AA Mornings with Graham Goodings.
00:53:17
Speaker 1: 24 past 10, 5AA, this Thursday morning. A reminder that after 10.30 headlines, your chance to have your legal questions answered when we have the experts from Johnston Withers Lawyers, Tim Downey and Caitlin Walkington, will be in the studio. On the text slide, Great Show Graham, as usual, I agree on using Wasteland for data centres. The land set aside for the multifunction polis at Gilman would suit. Power infrastructure near water cooling near. That has been good enough for power stations for decades. Thank you for that, Don. Graham, I've never protested. I will certainly go on Sunday. This is regarding the Tunkillo protest. Did anyone watch 60 Minutes last week about AI? Damning. I didn't see it, Helen. I'd like to know more. So if you want to share it with us or anyone that did see it, what was revealed about data centres? Graham, regarding the water consumption in data centres, the gent this morning said the water is in a closed-loop system which refrigerates and recycles the same water or glycol solution, just as is done in multi-storey buildings and hotel beer fonts. Thank you for that, Glenn.
00:54:23
Speaker 10: Hi, Graham.
00:54:24
Speaker 1: When baristas, shop assistants and jobs which require no university degree, and this includes public service jobs, are being paid $ 39 per hour plus penalties and entitlements, you can understand why employers are opting for AI to replace jobs, which can be done by a non-human. Although one person is not employed at that full-time rate, the job requires a 40-hour week, so it is spread between two, three or four people. The employer still has to pay the same. As wages increase, so does the cost of living. Apart from government financial mismanagement, that's another story. Employers have to look for better options. Thank you for that, Bill. Yeah, I think we still have to work out a way that these... jobs that are replaced by artificial intelligence are treated to some level of taxation. Because a job is lost, that means somebody is not earning money, that means somebody is not paying tax. And if it goes the way, it's like replacing all petrol-driven cars by EVs. People are paying the fuel excise, which goes into the government coffers, which equates to billions of dollars if we have fewer and fewer employees paying tax we have fewer and fewer amounts of millions and billions of dollars going into the federal government coffers where are they going to get the money from so maybe they should be considering how do we tax the ai machines every time a job is replaced by ai a level of taxation has to be paid what are your thoughts well i was watching tv news last night and i saw former prime minister malcolm turnbull uh pop up at COP. He's at the
COP conference. He wasn't in line for a coffee, but he had some thoughts about it.
00:56:02
Speaker 20: Mr Trimble, do you drink coffee?
00:56:04
Speaker 26: The taxpayers are paying $ 32, 000 for.
00:56:06
Speaker 27: This coffee stand just here. Will you be having a coffee and is it a good spend of money?
00:56:11
Speaker 28: Well, I don't actually drink a lot of coffee, so I probably won't be having a coffee. But can I say to you, I think this is one of the smartest things the Australian government does at COPS because everyone knows Australian coffee is the best. and it gets people to the pavilion. That is the best of all the dollars that are.
00:56:32
Speaker 1: Spent on marketing here.
00:56:34
Speaker 28: That is probably the best dollar spent because it gets people to come to the Aussie pavilion.
00:56:40
Speaker 20: And do you think that taxpayers at home will be happy.
00:56:42
Speaker 4: To hear that?
00:56:45
Speaker 28: Taxpayers want their money well spent. If you're going to be at the COP, if you're going to have a pavilion for the COP, you want people to come to it, right? Having good coffee is a pretty cost-effective way of doing it.
00:56:59
Speaker 1: Former Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull. So what are your thoughts? It's cost us $ 32, 000. I saw the pictures last night. People queuing up for, you know, all around the building. But are they there to see the Australian pavilion and take in what Australia has to offer? Or are they there just for a free coffee? Line up, get the coffee and move on. Look, I can appreciate that it is a good promotional gimmick, a good promotional idea, but... Is that the best way to spend our money? I don't know. 8223 0000. Phil says, you could build a brand new hospital the size of the RAH, but it wouldn't fix ramping because there isn't the staff available to fill it. Get used to ramping because it's here forever. And Steve says, the controversies surrounding Malinowskis and his government appear never ending. Algol Bloom, Wyler, Live Golf, MotoGP, hospitals and ramping, biker infiltration into the Torrance to Darlington project, And now the fallout with the Adelaide City Council. In my 40 plus years of voting history, I've never witnessed such a divisive, secretive and contemptuous state government. And Mark says, the interview this morning showed the developers were looking at bypassing the local community. This is regarding the Tonkilo data center development. The interview this morning showed the developers were looking at bypassing local government community, or the local community, and were looking to place the application directly to state, federal government to bypass pushback from local residents. Thank you for that, Mark. Well, the local residents haven't had their final say. They're holding another meeting at the weekend. Ah, yes, one of the most popular segments of the whole week. Caitlin, Tim, welcome.
00:58:42
Speaker 26: Thanks, Graeme.
00:58:42
Speaker 1: Johnson Withers Lawyers legal segment. If you have any legal questions, get in. We always say get in early. We were just talking about it before. We've lots of things to talk about and nobody's ringing. You're obviously all fascinated by what you guys have got to say.
00:58:54
Speaker 17: That's right.
00:58:54
Speaker 1: And then the last 10 minutes of the show, oh, I better ring up. I've got a question about a will or tree hanging over the fence or angry neighbours, loud neighbours. So get in early.
00:59:05
Speaker 6: Yes.
00:59:06
Speaker 1: And we welcome. Beat the rush.
00:59:07
Speaker 27: It doesn't matter what we are going on about or talking about.
00:59:10
Speaker 5: About.
00:59:10
Speaker 27: They should just ring in.
00:59:13
Speaker 20: Test us. We love.
00:59:14
Speaker 26: We love to test out our brains and see how on fire we are.
00:59:18
Speaker 1: Folks, you should see the look on their faces when some of your questions come in. Where do we go with this one?
00:59:25
Speaker 26: Well, we're not afraid to let people know when we don't know the answer because we can't possibly know everything about law. You don't know.
00:59:31
Speaker 27: That's my enthusiastic face.
00:59:34
Speaker 1: All right. See if anyone's got any legal twisters this morning. But before we do that.
00:59:41
Speaker 1: I've seen New South Wales pass laws allowing human bodies to be turned into compost after death, which I think presents for most, it's a subject that we sort of don't want to talk about. We have to face the reality that we're all shuffling towards the same end in life. But where we end up after death, you know, what sort of rights do we have to, you know, what happens to us after we die?
01:00:02
Speaker 20: Yeah, it's a good question.
01:00:04
Speaker 26: My mum was actually horrified when I told her this topic, which I was going to talk about. She said, Caitlin, can't you talk about something other than death? Well, that's a big part of my job. And to be honest, it's a big part of the conversations that I have with everyday people because a lot of people, it is actually concerning with what happens with their body after they pass away.
01:00:22
Speaker 20: It's a very important.
01:00:23
Speaker 26: Decision and whether that is for religious reasons or just personal preferences, there is a lot of discussions and we hear some absolute strange requests, but this is not.
01:00:37
Speaker 20: An unfamiliar one that I have come out.
01:00:40
Speaker 26: I think In today's society, people are moving towards a more environmentally conscious options available, which is where this human compost has come about. So in New South Wales, it's the first of the states and it's not available here yet in South Australia.
01:00:58
Speaker 20: But it allows for.
01:00:59
Speaker 26: Human bodies to be turned into compost after passing. It's where there's like a natural organic reduction of human remains and it turns into nutrient-rich soil. And it's meant to be considered
environmentally friendly opposed to burial or cremation.
01:01:15
Speaker 1: So if you haven't made much of a contribution during your lifetime, maybe you can... In the afterlife.
01:01:21
Speaker 23: Yeah.
01:01:22
Speaker 26: I mean, it's a thing that comes up quite often is that you hear people say, oh, I want to be cremated and then please just spread my ashes at the beach or spread my ashes over a rose garden or something like that.
01:01:34
Speaker 20: And there are.
01:01:36
Speaker 26: A lot of restrictions about where ashes can be spread.
01:01:38
Speaker 20: So they can't just be spread in the ocean.
01:01:41
Speaker 26: And you can put them on your rose garden, but I can almost assure you that your roses.
01:01:46
Speaker 20: Will die shortly after. Is that right?
01:01:49
Speaker 26: Yeah, just with the makeup. I'm not a horticulturalist or anything like that, but it might be the acidity or whatever in the ashes actually does tend to cause.
01:02:00
Speaker 1: Parts to pass away. We might get Michael Keelan on to explain to us why you shouldn't.
01:02:02
Speaker 10: Put ashes on.
01:02:04
Speaker 20: It's a good idea because it's a common request to have.
01:02:06
Speaker 1: Yeah, I can understand that.
01:02:07
Speaker 20: Spread them in my garden or plant a tree in my honour or anything like this.
01:02:12
Speaker 26: And I guess human composting is a way forward that could allow for that to occur. So even in New South Wales, the law has passed. But it hasn't come into effect as of yet. So we're hoping that other states will follow. Because in South Australia, the options really are burial cremation at the moment. And people might say, well, what other alternatives are there? Well, there is human body compost, which we've just talked about. But there's also hydro cremation, which is available in other states and not here. And that is where instead of like, you know... turning your your body to ashes through flame it uses you know water and some alkaline solutions and things like that it gets ultimately the same effect but that is also meant to be considered more environmentally friendly than cremation is and I guess for people who don't like the idea of being burnt, that's another option that might give them some peace of mind.
01:03:10
Speaker 27: How do you record this stuff in your will? Like if you really want this to happen and also for the family that's left, they might feel a bit, you know, uneasy and think, oh, granddad's had a moment here.
01:03:27
Speaker 3: Yeah.
01:03:28
Speaker 27: How do you ensure that this is actually going to happen once you pass?
01:03:32
Speaker 26: Well, the key thing is that you've already said is it has to be recorded in your will. It comes up a lot of the time where people want to put it in their advance care directives. that's for medical and lifestyle decisions, why you're still alive. And once you die, that document's irrelevant. So it does get recorded in your will. You can record a direction as to whether you want to be buried or cremated. But ultimately, the person who has to make those arrangements when you pass away is your executor. So you need to make sure, and that's why it's such an important role, because other than managing all your you know, financial affairs and paying money to beneficiaries, they also are in charge of your disposal of your body and that's a job that goes to them. So making sure that you pick the right person, you can record a direction as to whether you want to be buried or cremated in your will and then you can put expressions of wishes about whether or not you want to have a service or you want a memorial plaque in your honour, etc.
01:04:28
Speaker 20: Those, however, are only expressions of wishes.
01:04:31
Speaker 1: What about if there are any disputes concerning disposal of bodily remains?
01:04:35
Speaker 20: That happens all the time, unfortunately. You would be.
01:04:37
Speaker 27: Surprised how many of those disputes, and they go straight to the Supreme Court, and you can get them heard very urgently for obvious reasons.
01:04:46
Speaker 1: Yeah.
01:04:48
Speaker 27: And they're really challenging because you're dealing with such a highly emotional issue, but you will have someone contesting because they might say, That person definitely wanted to be buried here. In my view, that's the land they're associated with or whatever it might be. And the executive thinking, no, the will stipulates this. So those matters go before the court and the judge has to make that decision based on the evidence before the judge at the time.
01:05:24
Speaker 26: I've actually been involved in a successful burial dispute, so I might have a chat and explain what that all went and what the court considered after. But I know we've got a few calls on the issue, so maybe we'll answer those questions and then I can tell everyone about our experience.
01:05:38
Speaker 1: Excellent.
01:05:38
Speaker 13: Mike, go ahead.
01:05:40
Speaker 11: Hello there.
01:05:41
Speaker 17: A lot of loved ones actually that are born overseas want to.
01:05:44
Speaker 5: Get their ashes returned.
01:05:45
Speaker 17: Back to their home country, and it's a bit of an issue when it goes to the airlines. You have to notify them, and I'm thinking Singapore, whoever they are, they're all individual rules and regulations.
01:05:55
Speaker 5: Is that how it works?
01:05:57
Speaker 26: Yeah, there are overall just some, I guess, federal requirements in respect to dealing with getting... ashes to different states, which would deal with, you know, the bio hazards and things like that of different countries. But yes, then you've also got to notify the airline's I think if you do feel passionately about putting, you know, like having that direction, it should also be recorded in your will. The reason that I say that is that an executive can incur reasonable expenses to carry out your wishes in respect to your burial or cremation. And what is
reasonable will depend on the circumstances at the time. if you have said that you want your executor or this particular family member to take your ashes overseas and scatter them in a home country, for example, recording that in your will would be the best opportunity that that beneficiary or executor has to be reimbursed for their expenses in doing so, because in of its face, an overseas holiday to take someone's ashes somewhere wouldn't, I don't think, be considered a reasonable expense by the court. So I think setting the expectation up that that's what your wishes are and you feel very passionately about it so that it can be seen reasonable in the circumstances that those expenses get met because they can be significant.
01:07:23
Speaker 27: Well, you've got to have you know, containers that will go through the X-ray machine. They've got to have certain biosecurity markers. You know, you can't, for instance, have soil in there that might, that would be contra what the biosecurity laws are of that country or our country. But you also need a whole lot of official documentation. You need certificates of cremation, official death certificates. You need the approval of the country you're going to. So it would incur serious expense, I.
01:07:56
Speaker 1: Would have thought.
01:07:57
Speaker 26: Yeah, so I think that if that's something that you wanted, putting that in your will to make that really clear, even though it's an expression of a wish, you can't make it legally binding, it would be really important to do that.
01:08:07
Speaker 1: Mike, thanks for your call. Let's move on. Amber, good morning.
01:08:11
Speaker 29: Yes, good morning. This is a subject close to my heart. I used to work for the Port Adelaide Football Club and many moons ago, but we get often, so often requests that people wanted their ashes spread on Alberton Oval.
01:08:32
Speaker 20: I've seen some of those myself.
01:08:34
Speaker 6: Yes.
01:08:35
Speaker 29: And it was actually, it was very well organised. It was actually organised through Port Adelaide Council. And you booked a time and a date and everything else.
01:08:48
Speaker 6: And I just thought.
01:08:50
Speaker 29: That, you know, So many people from way back, the Magpies, and so it was a common.
01:09:00
Speaker 30: thing.
01:09:00
Speaker 29: We'd see them spreading them, and I just thought that, I just sort of threw that in.
01:09:07
Speaker 26: Yeah, I think it's a good point, is that, you don't just get to say where you want your ashes spread because there are particular rules and regulations, whether that be because it's on private property or council regulations at common ground that need to be considered. So that's why I said before, ashes in of itself just can't be spread in the ocean. You actually need a permit to allow you to do that. So I think a lot of the time when you are making these inquiries, and if you feel really passionately about it to the point that you want to put it in your will, you probably need to do some further research to make sure that that is an option available to you.
01:09:47
Speaker 27: But, Anna, what was your thinking from the Port Adelaide Football Club? Did they welcome it? They sort of encouraged it?
01:09:56
Speaker 12: Absolutely.
01:09:57
Speaker 6: Yeah.
01:09:58
Speaker 5: Look, being.
01:09:59
Speaker 29: I'm 70. I was born and bred on Lefevre Peninsula. My dad, bless his soul.
01:10:04
Speaker 6: He's long gone.
01:10:06
Speaker 29: You know, it was... In those days, you were on the Fever Peninsula. You were a Maggie supporter. You flew the black and white. Mum made Dad a magpie flag that he used to fly every Saturday. And it was just, I think it's beautiful.
01:10:26
Speaker 12: Yeah, it's good.
01:10:28
Speaker 29: These men and women just loved then the Maggie's. And it was beautiful. I used to look out of the window and you could see them. And it was beautiful. I have a tear in my eye. I just think it's beautiful because those men that loved, well, then, the Magpies, Their ashes were on the sacred ground.
01:10:57
Speaker 23: Yeah.
01:10:57
Speaker 29: I don't know what it cost them or what it was. I just know, because I had to forward calls, that it was arranged through Port Adelaide Council. But I think it's a beautiful thing.
01:11:08
Speaker 10: Yeah.
01:11:08
Speaker 1: Good on you, Amber. Thanks for sharing that with us. 8223 0000 is the number if you have a legal question. Back shortly.
01:11:15
Speaker 10: 5AA Mornings with Graeme Goodings.
01:11:18
Speaker 1: We're on air for Johnston with his lawyers, Caitlin and Tim in the studio, to answer your questions. Philip, good morning.
01:11:26
Speaker 3: Good morning, Grant, and good morning to your lawyers as well.
01:11:30
Speaker 5: I enjoy your show.
01:11:31
Speaker 27: Thank you.
01:11:32
Speaker 3: I live in a modern house with a small backyard, and my neighbour at the rear has a significant gum tree, and I think it's designated as a significant tree so it can't be cut down. with some significant branches overhanging my yard and the rear.
01:11:54
Speaker 12: Of my house, to be honest.
01:11:56
Speaker 3: My question is, if a branch did fall down and damage my house, firstly, is that claimable? And secondly, am I obligated to notify my insurance company of this potential risk?
01:12:10
Speaker 26: First question is if your property is damaged because of a neighbor's tree then yes you they could be liable for any damage caused that would obviously be you know your insurance taking that issue up with them but I guess there's two parts to it if your house got damaged by a neighbor's tree that could be through the cause of action negligence you know that there was a risk and as a consequence of that risk and they're in action you know you've suffered a loss um the other common one that i see with neighbor trees particularly gum trees is um nuisance so if for example gum nuts leaves you know smaller branches are constantly falling in your
yard and affecting your rights and enjoyment of your property then at that time you can also write to them um and say you know this is the issue that we're having and, you know, you're responsible.
01:13:09
Speaker 20: With the cause of action.
01:13:10
Speaker 26: Either option is going to require you to get an arborist report to say, you know, that damage or that risk is coming about by virtue of that tree and whether that's ongoing.
01:13:23
Speaker 20: In terms of your insurance, it really depends on what.
01:13:27
Speaker 26: The policy says and what your particular requirements are. But, you know, I think having disclosure and having that conversation with them up front is preferred because they might want to get involved.
01:13:40
Speaker 1: But there's no.
01:13:41
Speaker 27: There wouldn't be, Philip, any necessarily positive duty for you to notify the insurer in so much as they're the one that takes the risk and they would be well aware of a house insured in any inner suburb in Adelaide of the nature of that type of risk. The other issue is whether you... put your neighbor on what we call notice um before even you went to the arborist to say look i've got significant concerns about this tree um it's overhanging if it fell if this tree fell it's going to do significant damage i want to use an arborist um and then from that get permission to obviously you know trim the tree or what remove the hazard just simply by doing that the the neighbour is then on notice of the risk and you've sort of put a positive duty on him to do something. If then the worst happens, you can, in theory, point to that letter to say, well, it was negligent. I gave this guy or the neighbour's notice of this risk and they didn't do anything about it. So that's a few ideas for you, Philip.
01:14:53
Speaker 1: I hope it helps.
01:14:55
Speaker 3: OK, thanks very much for that.
01:14:56
Speaker 13: So....
01:14:58
Speaker 3: My limited knowledge of hanging trees and so on, it would be at my cost if I wanted to remove some of the branches.
01:15:06
Speaker 17: Is that correct?
01:15:08
Speaker 26: Unless you can write to them and say that, yeah, those branches are causing negligence or nuisance and that you would obviously need to do that or preferably do it before you incur the cost of removing the branches.
01:15:20
Speaker 1: Philip, thanks for your call. Just before our next call, on the text line, Dave wants to know, is a codicil a good idea to make minor changes to a will?
01:15:28
Speaker 20: Always a bad idea.
01:15:30
Speaker 26: I think in my whole career I might have done one or two, and there was very, very certain and specific circumstances in which I did it for, but.
01:15:40
Speaker 20: Most always people in my team don't do them.
01:15:43
Speaker 26: And the reason why is that they've got to be done in a very, very specific manner that you're only making the alterations that you need to without otherwise causing revoking or changing any of the other terms. You're also then dealing with two testamentary documents. So if you, for example, lose the codicil or misplace the will, that's when you can get in really dangerous and complicated territory with the probate registry. You still need to do for the codicil to be done properly, go through the same process in any event where you're talking to a lawyer about your family, your assets and liabilities, what your wishes are so that they can talk to you about you know, and give evidence about capacity or, you know, wishes and making sure your affairs are structured properly. So in my opinion, there is absolutely really no benefit in doing a codicil and you may as well just update your will.
01:16:31
Speaker 27: You're not going to save any money.
01:16:32
Speaker 20: No, no.
01:16:34
Speaker 1: Okay, next call. Adrian, good morning.
01:16:36
Speaker 15: Yes, good morning. I have a question about the Fences Act, if I could, please.
01:16:42
Speaker 20: Try us, Adrian.
01:16:44
Speaker 4: We love it, Adrian.
01:16:46
Speaker 15: I can only imagine.
01:16:47
Speaker 8: If you could get everyone in.
01:16:48
Speaker 27: Your neighbourhood to ring as well on that topic.
01:16:51
Speaker 15: Sorry. My question is the neighbour has advised us that they will be putting up a new fence because they're putting up a new house and putting up a new fence. And they've advised us that we need to pay half of the bill for the fence. Can they do that and have we got any rights? Because all we want to do is just mind our own business.
01:17:14
Speaker 20: Yeah, so they can.
01:17:15
Speaker 26: So obviously you've identified the Fencing Act. There is a process that they need to go through. So if they are wanting a contribution towards 50% of the costs of changing a fence, they need to send you a notice and that gives you a period of, off the top of my head, it's 28 days.
01:17:33
Speaker 20: It's either 21 or 28 days to respond to that notice.
01:17:37
Speaker 19: Notice?
01:17:37
Speaker 2: 28.
01:17:37
Speaker 15: We've got the notice.
01:17:39
Speaker 6: Yeah.
01:17:40
Speaker 26: If you don't respond to the notice, it will be acknowledgement that you accept that. And if you've got any objections, you need to respond and set out what those objections are. If the parties can't agree to deal with the issue of the fence, then the recourse for the neighbour will be to take you to the minor civil section of the Magistrates' Court.
01:18:01
Speaker 15: So if we do want to object, we would need to go through that process anyway, which would probably cost us a similar amount of money.
01:18:09
Speaker 5: As the fence.
01:18:10
Speaker 27: Yeah, but I think the first thing is, is there already a sufficient fence? This is the issue. Like, what's there now?
01:18:20
Speaker 15: A good fence.
01:18:23
Speaker 6: Yeah.
01:18:24
Speaker 15: It's not the height that they want to go. It's just the old regulation height that they want to go to, the nearly seven-foot height.
01:18:31
Speaker 6: Yeah.
01:18:31
Speaker 27: No, I– well, don't quote me on this. I'd have to really look into it. I just think if yours is at the current regulatory height and it is a good fence, I would go back to them. I mean, the whole thing about this is just putting stuff in right. right because what you're trying to do is show to them that um you're not you're not going to be silly you're not going to ignore it all because if you ignore it all you're going to end up in court and the risk with that is that you know well it's civil it's minus civil so there's probably no legal cost but It just gets more difficult.
01:19:10
Speaker 26: And Jill, your time, your effort to deal with the court process as well, like that can't be discounted as to what toll it will take.
01:19:18
Speaker 27: So you're better off, I think you should, you're better off writing to them, emailing them or just having a chat to start up with and just say, look, we don't understand it. The fence is reasonable. It's adequate. There's no problem with the fence. It's at the regulatory height, which I'd check and look up. And we're really sorry, but we're not going to contribute.
01:19:38
Speaker 26: To the extent that you do need advice as well, the Legal Services Commission do give free legal advice on these type of issues. So it might sound like Tim and I aren't giving the clearest direction and we.
01:19:51
Speaker 20: Apologise for that.
01:19:52
Speaker 26: But that is because as lawyers, we don't get involved in fencing disputes. disputes usually because the cost, like you've correctly identified, Adrian, involving a lawyer will usually outweigh the cost of getting a fence. So to the extent that you're having issues, I would recommend contacting the Legal Services Commission as well.
01:20:11
Speaker 27: The other factor is if there is some deficiency in the fence, even a minor one, what you could then say is, look, we'll throw in, you know, 500 bucks because we acknowledge there's, you know, an issue with the fence that could be fixed, but that's a good way of doing it.
01:20:26
Speaker 1: Let's take one final call. Wayne, go ahead.
01:20:30
Speaker 30: Yes, good morning. I have an issue about a family member. I won't go into all the details. I have recently learned that he has reportedly had a stroke and dementia, and there's two properties that's been in the family for 70 years, one nearly 100 years, the other one, and I'm the only nephew of his left. And apparently he's been doing this for years. He hasn't made a will and he won't do a will. And apparently he wasn't going to leave me anything, but I'm still entitled to the stuff that's on the property there. And it's in the dealings with the public trustee and all that sort of thing. And I can't find out any information whatsoever. I know that he's been put into the Elliston Hospital of all places, mind you. and he's from Port, well, Port Lake, and our property is, and I'm living from here, from Adelaide, and I've been having trouble trying to get some legal advice and all, and trying to get a lawyer involved to help with some letters and different things, because I'm on disability pension, and I'm finding this very, very difficult to, it's been really upsetting to me, because my uncle's been a, like a father figure, he's been family, my grandmother left him.
01:21:48
Speaker 1: Okay, Wayne, look, can we.
01:21:49
Speaker 5: Leave it there?
01:21:49
Speaker 1: We're just almost out of time, uh, We'll get an answer from Tim and Caitlin for you.
01:21:55
Speaker 26: Yeah, Wayne, if you would like to give me a call off air, I can give you some specific advice and I can help out in that situation, okay?
01:22:03
Speaker 1: Go on, Wayne.
01:22:03
Speaker 13: Hold the line.
01:22:04
Speaker 1: I'll put you back to Sam. That's it. Tim, Caitlin, thanks for coming by.
01:22:07
Speaker 20: Goes quickly, doesn't it?
01:22:08
Speaker 1: It certainly does. When experience matters, trust Johnston Withers Lawyers. With over 75 years legal experience, johnstonwithers.com.au. I'll be back next week. 9 past 11, 5AA. Lots to talk about. We've talked about a lot this morning. In the red corner, the Malinowskis government. The white corner, Jane Lamack-Smith and the Adelaide City Council. What is going on there? The latest battle lines have been drawn over the Adelaide Oval No. 2 and the use of it. If you have any thoughts, love to hear them. 8223 0000 is the number to ring. And the controversial billion-dollar Tonkilo data centre proposal has hit the pause button. largely due to the reaction of locals. And that will go on, and we'll no doubt hear more about that too. 8223 0000 is the number to ring. Well, there's no question death is inevitable, pretty much like taxes. But the way we deal with death is changing dramatically, and South Australia's cemeteries may need to change with it. Joining me now is Andrew Hoyne, the Zinnia founder. Andrew, good morning. Thanks for your time today.
01:23:13
Speaker 17: Good morning.
01:23:14
Speaker 12: Great to chat with you.
01:23:16
Speaker 1: You're calling for a rethink on how we look at cemeteries.
01:23:19
Speaker 17: Yeah, I think cemeteries are spaces that are critical to the kind of infrastructure and the running of a city. But really, the problem that we have is they have a very serious space crisis. Either we need to build new cemeteries or we need to use the existing ones in a far more sensible manner.
01:23:38
Speaker 1: I see that New South Wales is legalising human composting. Is that the direction we're heading?
01:23:43
Speaker 17: Well, it's one of the new innovative options. And while when you hear those words put together, they can be quite confronting, it's actually a really interesting and innovative solution from overseas. And it's incredibly environmental. It's one of the many things that can be done differently. However, that's burial. And the reality of Australia.
01:24:04
Speaker 11: is that.
01:24:04
Speaker 17: We
are very fast moving towards predominantly cremation. And so burial is a traditional option for memorialisation, but it's very expensive, whereas cremation is a more cost-efficient way to memorialise the loved one.
01:24:20
Speaker 1: What percentage of people would be cremated these days?
01:24:24
Speaker 17: In an urban area like Adelaide, I'd say 80%, 20% buried. And in a more rural regional area, it's a far greater number of people being buried. And it really does predominantly come down to cost.
01:24:38
Speaker 1: So when it gets specifically to the issues of cemeteries and the fact of space is a critical factor, what should we be looking at?
01:24:48
Speaker 17: Well, we need to think about how to utilise the cemeteries we have. We need to think about how we make them more dense, more flexible, more sustainable, and actually more engaging as well. I mean, there are some wonderful cemeteries in Adelaide. I know people don't think about cemeteries as a place to go, but Centennial Park is a great example of a cemetery that has a very.
01:25:09
Speaker 17: You know, great cafe, you know.
01:25:12
Speaker 12: It has events there.
01:25:13
Speaker 17: They invite people in for all sorts of activities beyond just memorialisation. And there are other great cemeteries in Adelaide like West Terrace and Enfield and very progressive cemeteries like Smithfield, particularly in terms of First Nations and.
01:25:29
Speaker 1: Sustainability.
01:25:31
Speaker 17: But what we need to start doing is using space better and our solution is... This Australia, or Global First, Australia-designed patent, which is a vertical pillar which puts ash internments into this very beautiful architectural design pillar. So instead of in a certain location, a very small space where you might have, say, one cremation, our solution has either 10 for a single-sided pillar or for the five-sided pillar, it has 50. So you have just a simple pole where the ash internments for the plug into it, incredibly beautiful, but all of a sudden you are amplifying a space that normally might fit one interment into.
01:26:15
Speaker 4: 10 or 50.
01:26:17
Speaker 17: And so that completely changes the way you think about the utilisation of spaces in cemeteries and how long you can actually think about that space being valid in an urban environment.
01:26:29
Speaker 1: I think a lot of people would appreciate that and think it is the way to go, but what about the people that push back, the the traditionalists that say that, you know, we've always seen a cemetery and burial the way it's been and that's the way we want it to continue to be.
01:26:42
Speaker 17: Yeah, I've I think people should have options. I think that if they want to be memorialised through burial, absolutely, that's their choice. And it's still a very valid option in Australia. It is not a valid option for much of the world. In fact, in Asia, it doesn't actually exist. Asia is almost entirely cremation. They just don't have the space. And while we think of Australia as a big, open country with lots of space... It's really about the urban areas where people want to have the ability to commemorate, visit, and be connected to a loved one who has passed away. And if you put those cemeteries, you know, two hours away from where people live, no one's ever going to go there. They need to be within proximity to where people actually run their lives and not create a level of inconvenience.
01:27:34
Speaker 1: Now, you've suggested a number of cemeteries are becoming quite progressive, like Centennial Park. But does there need to be government action?
01:27:43
Speaker 17: Look, I actually think South Australian government is probably the most progressive of anywhere in Australia. They've done a lot to look at bringing more sustainable initiatives to fruition. They're actually thinking about how to engage the community to think about cemeteries, not just as places of memorialisation. But, you know, you can go running through, you can walk your dog. These are really wonderful parks. So we almost have to reverse engineer our thinking as these are not places that are out of bounds unless we are celebrating.
01:28:14
Speaker 31: Somebody's life as they've passed away.
01:28:16
Speaker 17: But they're actually places that we should see as having value in terms of the flora and fauna that exist in these spaces. And I heard you a moment ago, you were talking about data centers. Now, the relevance of that to me is that Right now, the community is up in arms. They do not want to live next to a data centre. They don't want to live next to a prison. They don't want to live next to a garbage dump. If you look at the way people talk about cemeteries, they assume that I don't want to live next to a cemetery either. However, the reality is when you speak to anyone who lives near a cemetery, they think they've hit the jackpot.
01:28:50
Speaker 12: They live near the.
01:28:51
Speaker 17: Nicest, quietest, most tranquil neighbour with mature trees and calmness. But it's only the people who live there actually who understand that. So I actually think we need to kind of rethink the way that we value cemeteries in our society. And then we need to rethink about the way that we use the space intelligently to not only ensure that we are getting as much value and decades ahead of use in these spaces, but also that we need more modern solutions. We need different memorial solutions so people do have a greater range of choice.
01:29:25
Speaker 1: So tell us a little more about Memoria.
01:29:29
Speaker 17: So it's a 2.4 high pillar made of stainless steel and granite, and different ethnicities and cultures choose colours based on their connection to their faith. The Asian community love a red granite.
01:29:43
Speaker 6: The Catholic.
01:29:45
Speaker 17: Community are probably more inclined to a black or a dark blue granite. We've had Irish people want to choose a green granite. And so granite comes
in such a big range of colours that some families are choosing.
01:29:59
Speaker 5: A like a vertical mausoleum.
01:30:02
Speaker 17: So it has these 10 spots. So like, well, that's rather than spending a huge, you know, hundreds of thousands of dollars on a mausoleum, they'll say, no, I want all of my family to be together, not spread broadly across the cemetery. So by having a pillar for one family, you're pretty much guaranteeing that that family can memorialize together for decades to come and for generations to come.
01:30:25
Speaker 13: Yeah.
01:30:26
Speaker 1: Andrew, so much. Thank you so much for your time today. That's Andrew. Owen, senior founder, is calling for a rethink on how we look at cemeteries. What are your thoughts, folks? Have you thought much of the afterlife, how you would like your body disposed of, and the ever-changing cemeteries? What are your thoughts? Give us a call. 8223 0000, the number. 5AA Mornings with Graeme Goodings. 21 past 11, 5AA.
01:30:47
Speaker 10: You'll call shortly on 8223 0000.
01:30:58
Speaker 1: Look, I don't know really what to make about this battle between the state government and the Adelaide City Council. I know that the council have been intransigent on a number of issues and they've really arced up against the redevelopment of the Adelaide parklands. But in this most recent kerfuffle over the village green, Adelaide Oval No. 2, the premiers accused the city council of complete madness, stifling the city after, they say, council rules were tightened. At its heart, It's a disagreement about how much freedom Adelaide Oval should have to stage major events on the parklands and who gets to make the decisions, the state government or the Adelaide City Council. This is part of what the Premier had to say.
01:31:38
Speaker 7: It beggars belief that the Adelaide City Council seem to be so utterly determined in repelling people coming to our city.
01:31:47
Speaker 5: It is complete madness.
01:31:50
Speaker 1: That's part of what the Premier had to say. Well, the Lord Mayor has taken to social media and... She just can't quite understand what he's going on about.
01:31:59
Speaker 8: What's this?
01:32:00
Speaker 22: What's this?
01:32:03
Speaker 9: Mally blasts Adelaide City Council over absurd Adelaide Oval restrictions.
01:32:09
Speaker 8: I'm really confused. So, let me get this right.
01:32:15
Speaker 9: The stadium authority made a request to the council to change the management plan around the oval. We did what the legislation asked us to do. We consulted and then we agreed and we did what they asked. In fact, they said the stadium authority welcomes the direction of council's proposed amendments and acknowledges the constructive response to the matters previously discussed. I sometimes think I'm in a parallel universe. We just got a shellacking for doing what we were asked to do.
01:33:00
Speaker 8: What are they going to saddle us with next?
01:33:04
Speaker 1: I don't understand. Am I missing
something here? Am I missing something? The Adelaide City Council said they've acceded to what was asked of them, And yet the Premier has set out to say that they're blocking it. We had Councillor Phil Martin on earlier. He says the state government has never previously asked to host more than six days of events at Adelaide Oval No. 2. And to quote him, he said, if the government wants more than six days, ask and you shall receive. He says it's a council that actually loves events. We can't understand what the Premier is on about. What's really at stake? What am I missing here, folks? Trevor, good morning.
01:33:42
Speaker 25: Yeah, g'day, Graeme.
01:33:43
Speaker 15: How are you?
01:33:43
Speaker 1: Good, thanks.
01:33:44
Speaker 25: Yeah, look, just regarding the cemetery thing, a lot of people are going more for cremations, I suppose, and the ashes get put in tour bars and they keep them at home. Now, that saves on, obviously, the burial sites and everything where you don't have to put on marble or granite and make it all fancy. But that's only personal for people who do it. But the other thing that I understand is that people are putting on QR codes.
01:34:16
Speaker 9: Right.
01:34:17
Speaker 15: Cemetery.
01:34:18
Speaker 1: Yeah, on the cemetery plot, yeah.
01:34:20
Speaker 6: Yeah.
01:34:21
Speaker 25: Now, you don't necessarily have to have a burial site, but just have a plaque and a wall with your QR code on it, and people can scan it and just see who you are.
01:34:31
Speaker 14: Oh, right.
01:34:32
Speaker 1: And I guess that could have any sort of information at all.
01:34:34
Speaker 30: Yeah.
01:34:35
Speaker 1: It could lead you to a website. It could lead you to audio or video grabs or anything.
01:34:40
Speaker 25: Well, that's correct. And it's up to you what you want to put on it. And I don't know how it's going to be regulated, but that seems to be the way they're going.
01:34:47
Speaker 1: Oh, that is interesting, Trevor. I mean, there's no doubt it's an area that needs to be looked at and expanded. I mean, the area and space that cemeteries take up is vast. And as our last... guest suggested that you can't move cemeteries two hours away from the city because people won't visit them. It is literally too far away. So we need to keep cemeteries where they are, but they need to be repurposed. And more and more people are being cremated these days, but there's still a lot of space taken up. Thanks for that, Trevor. John says, we should get rid of councillors and only have a mayor. Keep the council districts and the administration, let the administration run them. Nick says, Hi, Gigi. So Turnbull thinks it's a great idea to have a coffee stand costing us $ 32, 000. I'm wondering if he understands that he has contributed to the rainforest decline, making way for more coffee plantations for world demand. I guess that's another way of looking at it. And Bell says, Hi, Graham. Plenty of workers available to be retrained for hospitals,
aged care facilities, into carers, nursing and silvery staff from David Jones, if the staff and government really want to work. Thank you for that, Bill. Yeah, so I would wonder if someone who's worked in retail at David Jones would consider working in aged care. Not a logical progression, but I mean, if you want to work, you want a job. Paul says, if people knew how much water, gas and resources are used in farming chickens, then they want to shut the chicken farms down. These farms use massive amounts of water in summer in the evaporative cooling for each shed. They also use huge amounts of electricity to run the sheds. and a massive amount of gas to heat the sheds during winter. Is that right, Paul? I was not aware of that. Thanks for letting us know. Andrew says, if you're going to give free coffee at the Australian Pavilion, I reckon they should make it like IKEA so people can't have a quick exit. Andrew, I know exactly what you're saying. Haven't been to IKEA a lot over the years, but any time I've gone there, once you're in, it's like a maze. There's no easy exit. And yeah, once you're there, you sort of go around and around and up and down and so forth, and you eventually get out. But yeah, that's a good point. Because at the moment, there's no question that the pavilion at COP 31, people are queuing up, you know, there's meters and meters of people, you know, they're up and around the corner and so forth, queuing up for a free coffee. They get their coffee and walk straight out of the pavilion and go elsewhere. Because there's nothing stopping them. There's nothing obstructing them. So, Andrew, good thinking. If you're going to spend that sort of money, design it like IKEA so people can't get out so readily. Hi, Gigi. I agree with Barry Urquhart that DJs should be selling the CBD store. People have preferred to shop at shopping centres for years. Retail, retail. That's a fair point. And if only people power existed in relation to solar and wind farms on agricultural land, not unusual for the Greens to advocate more laws and regulations. So says Webby. And Colin says, regarding the Greens' stance on data centres, never thought I'd say this, 100% agree with Rob Sims. Did I just say that? And re the data centres, we need a reality check. I agree, very thorough analysis of data centres and their impacts on people and the environment is absolutely necessary. However, AI will go ahead regardless of what Australia says and does. There are huge economic benefits. I'm sure if we do our due diligence on the data centres. Steve, I agree. There's money to be made, but we have to make sure that money that's made is staying here in Australia and that the data centres are here for us. benefit and not for the multinationals. 5AA Mornings with Graeme Goodings. 28 to 12, 5AA, the final 30 minutes of the show. Lee Forrest will join us a little later on to tell us what he's got on this afternoon. Well, I think we tend to think of pneumonia as something that's associated with coughs and colds and winter. but it's apparently a year-round risk. Joining us now is Dr Rod Pearce, GP and Chairman of the Immunisation Coalition. Doctor, good morning to you and thanks for your time today.
01:38:59
Speaker 19: Hi, Graeme.
01:39:02
Speaker 1: Yeah, and I think that it's fair that most people would think that, wouldn't they, that it's winter, maybe pneumonia. Summer, we don't have to worry so much.
01:39:09
Speaker 19: Yeah, there's a couple of points there is that I guess we used to think of it and we know that respiratory infections and transmission is more common in winter, but.
01:39:20
Speaker 19: Climate change, COVID and the ongoing presence of upper respiratory infections, we're getting more of them and we're getting them all year round. So it's been a real shift. And our thinking about respiratory infections is early diagnosis, possibly treatment because we've got antivirals. or is there something we could have done to prevent it? So prevention, early treatment, early diagnosis, rather than the old story, it's like, oh, it's just a respiratory infection. Wait for a while and see what happens. It's a lot more aggressive and a lot more nuanced than it used to be.
01:39:51
Speaker 1: Yeah, so just how serious a health threat is pneumonia in Australia?
01:39:55
Speaker 19: Well, the commonest cause of pneumonia is a pneumococcal infection. So pneumococcus lives in our gut normally, just like we have skin flora, we have lungs. bacteria and when they go rogue they can be lethal there's some 80 odd strains and our vaccines and prevention have not been that good but over the last 20 years we've been gradually getting better and better vaccines covering more of the regular infections and now we're pretty happy we've got a way of providing some protection for those secondary infections and jumping on with antibiotics is sort of treating it once the infection is going. But if we can decrease the risk of getting a secondary bacterial infection, we're happy. We've got a few things up our sleeve now. So the whole approach to respiratory infections has changed. COVID's put it in limelight. We know we can stop transmission with social distancing. and all that sort of stuff. And we're seeing some simple viruses making a worse comeback because we had five years without anything. When COVID came, we were all isolated. Now they're all coming back. So a simple rhinovirus is just a cold, can end up leading to secondary infections that can be lethal. So, yeah, it's a slightly nuanced and different approach than it was maybe four or five years ago.
01:41:10
Speaker 1: So how is pneumococcal disease diagnosed?
01:41:14
Speaker 19: Well, that's a bit of a challenge. You can get sputum and then confirm it on a sputum. There's some tests they use in the laboratory, but they're not very reliable because we carry these bacteria with us. Saying you've got the bacteria, that doesn't mean it's what's causing the infection for you.
And not all infections actually end up being pneumonia or being life-threatening. So if a chest X-ray shows pneumonia, then that's probably a pneumococcal that shows a particular distribution. Um, but yeah, um, there's a whole lot of ways of doing it, but, uh, um, often when we're diagnosing it with a chest X-ray or a CAT scan that says he's got pneumonia, often it's pretty late and pretty serious and we're struggling to manage it.
01:42:01
Speaker 1: I mean, there's so many bugs, as we say, going out there at the moment and, you know, is it RSV?
01:42:05
Speaker 13: Is it COVID?
01:42:06
Speaker 1: Is it some form of flu? Um, the symptoms for all these seem to be pretty much the same.
01:42:14
Speaker 19: Yeah, and 10 years ago, we would have said, just hold off for a while, see what's happening, and then if it continues, come and hand it over. Now we say, get an early diagnosis. We can do the point-of-care testing, the rats, rabbit engine, and if it's COVID, if it's flu, we've actually got specific virus treatments for them. If it's RSV, we can make a prediction of what the course might be, and particularly in children. and who it might spread to. If you want a formal testing, there's about a dozen that we do as standard.
01:42:45
Speaker 5: So it could be whooping cough.
01:42:46
Speaker 19: Could be metanumous, rhinovirus, all of which we can make some predictions. So these days, early diagnosis tells us what you've got. Then we can make some predictions and then we can follow it up. Sometimes early intervention is needed because antivirals work. But if it's not, then we can monitor it. And then if you get a secondary infection, then we can get on top of that. And it depends on your background, your illness, other things. So it's a lot more aggressive and nuanced than it was a decade ago.
01:43:12
Speaker 1: Are the number of cases of pneumococcal getting worse?
01:43:17
Speaker 19: They've been steady and they've been killing people for a long time, but the newer vaccines have actually made a difference to how that happens. So once upon a time we were only covering a few of the different types. Now we're covering 21 in our latest vaccine. So we've now probably got 80% of the infections covered with our vaccines, whereas before we were maybe... getting a third of them or half of them. So the changes have put us on the mat with some good options.
01:43:45
Speaker 1: I take it older people are particularly vulnerable?
01:43:49
Speaker 19: Yeah, the immune system, immune senescence is.
01:43:54
Speaker 13: The way we describe it.
01:43:55
Speaker 19: So your immune system is only maybe two-thirds, half as effective as it used to be. So it's not just that our body grows old, our immune system grows old and isn't quite as targeted, isn't quite as effective, which makes you more vulnerable. Even if you look after yourself and keep fit, the immune response is slow. And if it's slow, the infection can become overwhelming before your immune system mounts a response so that it can be lethal, whereas maybe at 20 it may not be. So, yeah, immune senescence is an issue, and that's why older people are more prone to it.
01:44:26
Speaker 1: Now, on the text line, Christine says, it would be okay if you could actually get the pneumonia vaccine. I am 65 and have been on the waiting list in my medical centre where I see my GP for months. I was told last week I only get a few vaccines in every fortnight, and there are still 40 people on the list in front of me. Is there a waiting list? Is that the way it works?
01:44:48
Speaker 6: No.
01:44:50
Speaker 19: I was staying away from that, being careful. But I totally agree. What's been really exciting is that a new vaccine has been made available. It's a great thing for Australia to have the vaccine available. The federal government has looked at everyone who's eligible and checked if they've had it and written to them and said, please go and get this vaccine. But it doesn't matter whether it's a pharmacy, the GP, the amount of vaccine that's in our fridges just isn't there. And we're all disappointed to say to people, sorry, we haven't got the vaccine. So that is a specific issue. We had the same thing with the shingles vaccine when it was first announced. It wasn't in the fridges when this new vaccine is here ready to go. It's not in our fridges. So the doctors will be feeling the same as the lady who's just rung in because we're all saying, why can't we have the vaccine? So we appreciate the awareness, but this vaccine availability, it's a national issue. Certainly aware of that and certainly spoken to the state and the national authorities and the providers to maybe.
01:45:47
Speaker 5: Have a look at that.
01:45:47
Speaker 19: But excited that it's being an awareness, but disappointed that we can't deliver.
01:45:53
Speaker 1: How quickly can pneumonia develop into something life-threatening?
01:45:57
Speaker 19: Oh, it can be three to four days once it gets established.
01:46:00
Speaker 5: So the pneumonia is the.
01:46:04
Speaker 19: Lung tissue actually having an infection. When we talk about tonsillitis, we're talking about infection there. If we're talking about laryngitis, it's further down the throat. Bronchitis in the bronchial tubes. And then when it's actually in the lungs, that's the pneumonia. So it's actually blocking off the air exchange. So it becomes life-threatening. One is because you're fighting an infection. Two, because you're not getting air into your lungs. So pneumonia is basically when the actual... Lung tissue is actually swamped with infections full of pus and swelling and fluid, meaning you can't exchange oxygen.
01:46:39
Speaker 1: So what are the early warning signs that we should be looking out for?
01:46:43
Speaker 19: So what you would say is just a common cold going on longer and you're deteriorating. These days people can check their oxygen if they see your oxygen levels dropping or you are concerned about ongoing
infections. It may not be pneumococcal, it may be one of the other ones, but getting it checked rather than delaying it. And like I said, with a slightly nuanced response to say, don't just sit back and wait until you really sit. It may be something you can get on the front foot and do. Or if you do think you have an infection, test for it early to know specifically what you can be treated with and what the follow-up should be.
01:47:21
Speaker 1: Are there any other chronic health conditions that can worsen the situation regarding pneumonia?
01:47:28
Speaker 19: The thing that we all talk about is decreased immune response, which occurs with age, but it also occurs with diabetes. It's more vulnerable with previous heart disease, and some of these infections can actually precipitate a heart attack because you lower your oxygen levels. And there's a whole lot of immunotherapy, which is a standard thing for cancers these days, cancer therapies, leukemias, lymphomas, so a whole range of medical conditions that we specifically look at. So advice is check to see whether you're eligible, like the lady who's 65 and eligible. Make sure someone's aware and as soon as we get.
01:48:07
Speaker 15: A vaccine, get it.
01:48:09
Speaker 19: But look at the other conditions that might make you vulnerable for either a different vaccine or maybe some other treatment that controls your diabetes or manages your heart or your blood pressure better. So all of that stuff with good control lessens your risk. Make sure you're vaccinated with as many things that stop you getting primary infections that could lead on to secondary pneumonia.
01:48:30
Speaker 5: All of that is good.
01:48:31
Speaker 19: And then the pneumococcal vaccine might be the one for you because it's probably the best in the world and it's probably as good as coverage we're ever.
01:48:38
Speaker 6: Going to get.
01:48:39
Speaker 3: Yeah.
01:48:40
Speaker 1: Doctor, on this World Pneumonia Day, a final bit of advice?
01:48:46
Speaker 19: It's a little bit different approach than we used to. Look at any infection early, use the rapid antigen test or get advice really quickly. Don't just wait until it's nasty and end up with a pneumonia.
01:48:58
Speaker 1: Great advice. Dr Rod Pierce, thanks so much for your time today. Chair of Immunisation Coalition on this World Pneumonia Day. And we look outside, the sun is shining, warm day. Don't associate that sort of weather with pneumonia. But as Dr. Peer said, it is an all-year-round condition. 14 to 12, 5AA, this Thursday morning, the 12th of November. All being well, we'll have the Health Minister, Mark Butler, in the studio next Friday. He's agreed to it at this stage, as long as nothing intercedes or upsets the plan. But no doubt you'll have plenty of questions for him. I know I have. So be prepared for that next Friday on 5AA. Calls in a moment on 8223 0000. John says, Graham, you just allowed Albo on your news service to talk absolute garbage about climate change. That lying fool should not be allowed to be heard. Why do you facilitate him? Well, John, this is a democracy. Freedom of speech. Heard of that? Now, just because you don't agree with it, and maybe I don't agree with it, does that mean we should silence him? Does that mean we should silence you? If I was sitting here and disagreed totally with your view, should I silence you?
01:50:11
Speaker 15: No.
01:50:12
Speaker 1: And that's what we're here for, and that's the beauty of a democracy. Lots of things are said that I don't agree with, and lots of people listening don't agree with me, and that's fine, but that's the basis of what a democratic society is all about. So, yeah, and we let people like the Prime Minister have their say because you, our intelligent listeners, go, hang on, I agree or I disagree. but we allow you to make up your own mind, we are not going to sanitise the news. Graeme, good morning.
01:50:42
Speaker 31: Hey, Graeme, how are you?
01:50:43
Speaker 1: Good, thanks.
01:50:45
Speaker 31: Sorry to bother you, mate, but one thing about, you know, Arbo and Chris Bone travelling the world, sprouting our green credentials and how well Australia are doing and how we're on a test to be like us.
01:50:56
Speaker 6: Yeah.
01:50:57
Speaker 31: And, you know, that's never going to happen as much as they will continue to To sprout that, what concerns me, and I've got nothing against people protesting about trees going down north of Adelaide or trees having to come down for the MotoGP. So we're talking 400 or 500, maybe 600 trees between the two projects, I would imagine. I'm not 100% sure on it. And you constantly have Robert Sims coming on telling us that green energy is the way to go and you can't chop down trees. But what concerns me is the total lack of regard for the amount of trees being cut down for Bowen's Green Dream. I mean, you can't build a wind farm without chopping down thousands of trees. You can't build a solar farm without taking trees down. You can't build... transmission lines without taking trees down. And I can guarantee you there are thousands and thousands of trees being cut down for that, not 600 here in Adelaide. But the people that promote not wanting trees cut down never talk about it. They never talk about how much collateral damage is being done to the environment with trees going down for our green dream. And I'm just wondering because Trees are a natural carbon dioxide soaker-upper. What they do is they suck in carbon dioxide and they produce oxygen.
01:52:23
Speaker 6: Yep.
01:52:24
Speaker 31: So they clean the atmosphere in a natural way. Now, if I had a choice, I'd rather have trees, more trees planted sucking up carbon dioxide than a stack of wind farms and wind turbines.
01:52:38
Speaker 10: Yeah, look, I take it.
01:52:40
Speaker 31: You know what I mean?
01:52:41
Speaker 1: Yeah, I mean... emphasise the hypocrisy that the last COP conference in Brazil, the Amazon rainforest, they
ploughed through hundreds of kilometres of the rainforest to build a highway from the airport to where the conference was being held, all in the name of saving the planet. I mean, the hypocrisy is absolutely amazing. How they get away with it, I don't know. And maybe it's because The demonstration against the trees in the city is because it's close by. We can see it. When they bulldoze trees out in the Donga, we don't know. We're not so aware of it. And to be fair, where they put a lot of the solar panels and the wind farms, there are not a lot of trees there. Not so much here, but certainly on the east coast, there are a lot of trees. How many they've removed, I don't know. Remains to be seen. But yeah, you made a good point, Graeme. Thanks for your call. Roy, good morning.
01:53:38
Speaker 6: Yeah, how are you doing, Brian?
01:53:39
Speaker 1: Good, thanks.
01:53:40
Speaker 6: You seem to be fairly fair on both sides of the subject and stuff like that. And earlier on it was brought up about changing history, right? I know this is a delicate subject, but how can they say Adolf Hitler didn't exist and it's against the law or anything? They had the Vikings and the Longboats, so they raped and pillaged all their lives and things like that.
01:54:12
Speaker 10: So.
01:54:13
Speaker 17: Yeah.
01:54:14
Speaker 6: Yeah, I just... It's part of history, whether you like it or not. I'm not saying to advertise it. Like, they've done the thing with the swastika and got rid of all that. Yes, I understand all that. But it's just part of history, mate. You know what I mean? And I'd like your opinion, because you seem not... You don't... You sit on the fence and you understand both sides when you just give your explanation.
01:54:40
Speaker 1: I'm not quite sure what point of view you're making there, Roy. Are we trying to deny history? Yes.
01:54:52
Speaker 6: You brought it up where you're not allowed to talk about it. It didn't exist.
01:54:56
Speaker 1: Who said this?
01:54:58
Speaker 6: It's been said on the radio before. I've rang up a couple of times.
01:55:03
Speaker 1: I'm told you couldn't say something. What were you told you couldn't say?
01:55:10
Speaker 6: That part of history has been erased.
01:55:14
Speaker 1: Which part of history?
01:55:16
Speaker 6: Hitler.
01:55:17
Speaker 1: Well, not to my knowledge. I mean, you get certain groups that might try and rewrite history, but I think most sane people would realise that Hitler did exist. and he exterminated millions of Jews and ravaged one of the most horrendous periods in world history. So, you know, who's denying that?
01:55:40
Speaker 6: No, it's just on the radio in general, it's brought up, at least you're listening, most people say, no, we can't talk about that.
01:55:50
Speaker 3: Oh, okay.
01:55:50
Speaker 14: Thanks, Roy.
01:55:51
Speaker 6: I don't know who would be denying that.
01:55:56
Speaker 1: Denying history and denying facts, but, you know, five double A's in an open forum. As
long as you don't speak profanity or fame people, we're happy to hear your opinion. We might not agree with it, but we're happy to take it into account. G'day, Graham. Graham from Harry. I'm into John's opinion.
01:56:18
Speaker 8: Sorry.
01:56:19
Speaker 1: Sorry, Harry. I can't quite discern what you've said there. I might need to take another look at that.
01:56:23
Speaker 26: Gigi.
01:56:25
Speaker 1: That gentleman, Graham, hit the nail on the head. How can wrecking the environment by clearing hundreds of acres of forest for renewable energy be saving the environment? Not one supporter of renewables has been able to explain this to me. Thank you for that, Nat. Andrew says, I'm absolutely opposed to the Adelaide City Council needing to be consulted on any adjustment to the frequency of usage of village green. That area is for public use at events and should not have to be approved by them. Well, Andrew, I'll take you to task to some degree. The Adelaide City Council need to provide amenities. If there is a major event, they need to provide toilets, they need to provide parking, they need to provide rubbish disposal and the like. So if it is within their territory, the Adelaide City Council, I think the City Council have every right to be aware of it. And as the Lord Mayor said, and as Councillor Phil Martin said, the government only have to ask and they'll get what they want. It's just that they're not asking. So I am confused. I don't quite know what the Premier wants in this case. After one o'clock this afternoon, it's Lee Forrest. G'day, Lee.
01:57:31
Speaker 13: It's a bit petty, don't you think, the whole government council? Well, I think there's an agenda here. Look, I'm no big fan of the Adelaide City Council by any means. I've been super critical on a whole range of issues. But I think the Premier has an agenda, and he's lining them up in his sights. Oh, yeah.
01:57:52
Speaker 1: And if he can get enough... I mean, he does have within his power to sack the council. And yeah, he's lining things up. But I think on this one, by my observation, I think he's got it a little wrong. Okay.
01:58:05
Speaker 13: So I don't understand then. I don't know why the Adelaide City Council would say three days. You know, the test goes for five. It seems petty to me.
01:58:14
Speaker 1: Well, it's not petty in that. All they're saying is they've agreed to everything the SMA has asked.
01:58:21
Speaker 26: Yes.
01:58:22
Speaker 1: And the SMA, according to the Lord Mayor, responded saying, thank you very much. That's what we asked for.
01:58:27
Speaker 15: Yep.
01:58:27
Speaker 1: And within a week. Jamie Briggs, is it, from the SMA, said, oh, we're not happy. You're stifling opportunities.
01:58:35
Speaker 5: Right.
01:58:36
Speaker 1: And the Premier has come out.
01:58:38
Speaker 13: It just seems weird three days when you know the test is five.
01:58:41
Speaker 1: Yeah, but have they ever stopped anything in the past?
01:58:42
Speaker 23: No.
01:58:42
Speaker 13: They're not going to stop this either. Yeah, no, that's why I wonder why it's even an issue. Because it seems like both sides, you know the old adage of pick your battles? Now they're looking to fight each other on various things.
01:58:53
Speaker 15: Yeah.
01:58:53
Speaker 13: So it's advertising for fossil fuel, it's parklands, it's... The MotoGP. It's the car and the bike. They just want to fight now. I agree. They're nitpicking both of them to try and find a fight.
01:59:07
Speaker 1: And instead of getting on the state government running the state and the Adelaide City Council doing its best for the city, they're at loggerheads.
01:59:13
Speaker 13: You're in public service. Service the public.
01:59:16
Speaker 1: And we're the ones suffering.
01:59:17
Speaker 13: That's it. Do your job.
01:59:18
Speaker 1: Yeah, focus on your job. It's annoying.
01:59:20
Speaker 13: It is interesting, though, isn't it? I mean, we do like a stout from time to time.
01:59:24
Speaker 1: Oh, look, it's in our business. It gives us something to talk about.
01:59:27
Speaker 13: But it's like bickering children. At some stage, enough.
01:59:30
Speaker 6: Yeah.
01:59:30
Speaker 13: There needs to be an adult in the room to go, okay, this is how things are going to roll. Maybe the Premier needs to, he loves calling roundtables. Call a roundtable with the Adelaide City Council.
01:59:40
Speaker 1: Thrash it out.
01:59:40
Speaker 13: Get on the same page.
01:59:41
Speaker 1: Sort it out.
01:59:42
Speaker 13: So we had a member from the council on the show yesterday. Is it good that they never agree? He was suggesting that it's democracy, which is true to some point. But at some stage, it'd be nice if the Adelaide City Council all agreed on something. Or is that just a pipe dream that can't happen? The council is like a board, a company board. And being on the board of the Adelaide Crows, matters come up before the board and you'll have a roundtable discussion. And you might get several directors not agreeing. And this foments discussion and out of it comes a good policy.
02:00:17
Speaker 17: Yes.
02:00:18
Speaker 1: And at the end of the day, you walk out of the boardroom With a unified voice.
02:00:22
Speaker 13: But I don't think the Adelaide Crows Board has divisions like the Adelaide City Council has historically.
02:00:28
Speaker 1: Probably not.
02:00:28
Speaker 13: And it feels like it still continues.
02:00:30
Speaker 27: Yeah.
02:00:31
Speaker 13: It's like this is, it's almost part of your MO if you want to be in the Adelaide City Council. Be, you know, about the state and want to do good, but it doesn't hurt if you're a troublemaker or you like to sort of mix things up a little bit.
02:00:44
Speaker 1: It gives you a profile. And I think some of these people run for council just wanting to get a profile and notoriety. It's weird, isn't it?
02:00:52
Speaker 15: Yeah.
02:00:52
Speaker 1: And when you think how few people elect the city councillors, I mean, it's just a handful. But look at everything under their watch. That's the thing.
02:01:00
Speaker 13: It's the biggest, most important council by far, by far, by far.
02:01:05
Speaker 19: Yeah.
02:01:06
Speaker 1: So, I mean, it's interesting. As I say, it's great fodder for us. It gives us something to talk about. But the bottom line is we want the state to be the best it can. And this is the hub of the state, Adelaide. city, yes, we want it to be the best it can possibly be. So, you know, if they could work in harmony, we'd all be better off.
02:01:24
Speaker 13: And it'd be nice.
02:01:25
Speaker 15: Yeah.
02:01:25
Speaker 13: Let's hope so.
02:01:26
Speaker 1: So we'll hold hands around the campfire.
02:01:28
Speaker 13: And sing Kumbaya together. Kumbaya. Have you had a manager's role at any stage during your career? Have you been?
02:01:34
Speaker 15: No.
02:01:35
Speaker 3: No?
02:01:35
Speaker 13: No.
02:01:35
Speaker 10: Often.
02:01:36
Speaker 1: Once or twice, but no.
02:01:38
Speaker 13: If I came to you and said, Graeme, could I possibly have a day off work because I want to play a computer game. Are you going to give me the day off?
02:01:48
Speaker 1: Get out of my office.
02:01:49
Speaker 13: Okay. I thought so. What about your producer, Sam? Is he allowed to take a day off next week when GTA Grand Theft Auto, this new popular computer game is released because they're expecting an influx of Australian ciggies like never before.
02:02:04
Speaker 1: Well, Sam's my boss, so he doesn't ask me if he wants anything. He tells me.
02:02:08
Speaker 13: Oh, well, you can just make the call then. Unilateral decision. On the one hand, everyone's going, it's ridiculous, it's a computer game. On the other hand, people are going, well, it's the great Australian tradition. You're taking a sick day. So we'll talk about that on the show today. People are more excited about that than the midterms. Everyone's saying, oh, what about November? What about November? Oh, what, the midterms?
02:02:27
Speaker 12: No, no, no.
02:02:28
Speaker 13: GTA, the new release.
02:02:30
Speaker 6: Beautiful.
02:02:30
Speaker 13: So we're going to talk about that on the show today, plus many more after one o'clock.
02:02:33
Speaker 1: Good on you, Lee. Lee Forrest coming up this afternoon. As we go, we say goodbye. Have a great day. And Kendall in the newsroom. Happy birthday, Kendall.
02:02:41
Speaker 13: She's 21, Kenny.
02:02:42
Speaker 1: Oh, she couldn't be that old, surely.
02:02:44
Speaker 13: Well done, Kendall. 18.
02:02:45
Speaker 1: Have a great day.