رونوشت 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:00.530 --> 00:00:04.410
Inside Olympia podcast is brought to you by the Washington
2
00:00:04.450 --> 00:00:09.349
State Association of Counties and the Washington Indian Gaming Association
3
00:00:10.269 --> 00:00:18.140
and by Pemco Insurance, Boeing Employees Credit Union, AARP Washington,
4
00:00:19.260 --> 00:00:25.879
Washington State Skills Center Association, Western States Petroleum Association, and
5
00:00:26.199 --> 00:00:27.339
Puget Sound Energy.
6
00:00:28.370 --> 00:00:31.820
This week on Inside Olympia, electricity and natural gas rates
7
00:00:31.899 --> 00:00:35.100
are on the rise in Washington and ratepayers are feeling
8
00:00:35.119 --> 00:00:37.619
the pinch. How much of a factor are the state's
9
00:00:37.740 --> 00:00:41.240
climate policies? What will it take to build an affordable,
10
00:00:41.490 --> 00:00:45.229
reliable and green grid for the future? On the program,
11
00:00:45.409 --> 00:00:49.090
former State Senator Reuven Carlyle and Todd Myers of the
12
00:00:49.109 --> 00:00:50.229
Washington Policy Center.
13
00:00:57.179 --> 00:01:03.939
From the TVW studio, it's Inside Olympia with host Austin Jenkins.
14
00:01:05.620 --> 00:01:09.129
Welcome to Inside Olympia. Washington State residents have long enjoyed
15
00:01:09.290 --> 00:01:12.049
low electricity and natural gas rates compared to the rest
16
00:01:12.090 --> 00:01:15.890
of the country. We've benefited from clean, cheap hydropower and
17
00:01:15.950 --> 00:01:19.519
proximity to gas pipelines in Western Canada. But recently, it
18
00:01:19.719 --> 00:01:22.819
started to feel like the era of cheap power is ending.
19
00:01:23.340 --> 00:01:27.260
Utilities across the state are raising rates, and ratepayers are
20
00:01:27.359 --> 00:01:30.140
feeling the pinch. So much so, they turned out in
21
00:01:30.260 --> 00:01:33.540
force for a recent rate-setting hearing for Puget Sound Energy,
22
00:01:33.680 --> 00:01:37.420
which is seeking double-digit electricity and natural gas rate hikes.
23
00:01:38.120 --> 00:01:40.920
Utilities point to multiple factors for a need to raise rates,
24
00:01:41.359 --> 00:01:44.219
but a leading factor, they say, is state policies passed
25
00:01:44.250 --> 00:01:48.370
by majority Democrats that require a transition away from fossil fuels.
26
00:01:49.109 --> 00:01:51.569
This hour, we're going to dig into the disruption in
27
00:01:51.629 --> 00:01:55.840
Washington's energy market What's driving it? What can policymakers do?
28
00:01:56.280 --> 00:01:59.760
And as demand for electricity increases, where will the region
29
00:01:59.799 --> 00:02:02.310
get the energy it needs and will it be affordable?
30
00:02:02.689 --> 00:02:04.810
This is part of our ongoing look at the region's
31
00:02:04.890 --> 00:02:08.270
energy future. Last April, we spoke with Arnie Olson, a
32
00:02:08.310 --> 00:02:12.069
San Francisco-based energy consultant whose firm wrote a report on
33
00:02:12.090 --> 00:02:16.590
Load full transcript
behalf of utilities highlighting the gap between projected energy needs
34
00:02:17.180 --> 00:02:17.759
and supply.
35
00:02:18.819 --> 00:02:22.180
We see a looming shortfall of electric power with the
36
00:02:22.199 --> 00:02:26.060
need to construct significant amount of new resources to fill
37
00:02:26.099 --> 00:02:28.419
that gap. And as you said, the need is now.
38
00:02:28.520 --> 00:02:30.879
It's not 10 years from now. So there's a lot
39
00:02:30.919 --> 00:02:33.860
of action that needs to happen in order to develop
40
00:02:33.879 --> 00:02:36.150
those resources and ensure that we can have a reliable
41
00:02:36.169 --> 00:02:36.810
electric system.
42
00:02:37.710 --> 00:02:40.569
Next month, we will interview Brian Rybarik, who is the
43
00:02:40.629 --> 00:02:43.629
chair of the Utilities and Transportation Commission, which has the
44
00:02:43.669 --> 00:02:47.750
final say over rate increases for investor-owned utilities like Avista
45
00:02:47.789 --> 00:02:51.159
and Puget Sound Energy. This week, we examine the impact
46
00:02:51.199 --> 00:02:55.680
of two major environmental laws on Washington's energy future, the
47
00:02:55.680 --> 00:03:00.479
2019 Clean Energy Transition Act and the 2021 Climate Commitment Act.
48
00:03:01.039 --> 00:03:03.500
In our second half, we'll talk with Todd Myers, Vice
49
00:03:03.539 --> 00:03:07.090
President of Research at the Free Market Washington Policy Center.
50
00:03:07.909 --> 00:03:11.729
But joining me first is former Democratic State Senator, Reuven Carlisle,
51
00:03:11.849 --> 00:03:16.710
the lead sponsor and architect of those two landmark environmental laws. Welcome.
52
00:03:17.069 --> 00:03:18.490
Back to Inside Olympia. Welcome back to Olympia.
53
00:03:18.550 --> 00:03:19.569
Thank you. It's good to be back.
54
00:03:19.629 --> 00:03:21.750
Appreciate you doing this. Just in terms of setting the
55
00:03:21.770 --> 00:03:23.289
stage for the conversation, we're about to have a little
56
00:03:23.310 --> 00:03:26.629
bit of background on former Senator Carlyle and the two
57
00:03:26.669 --> 00:03:31.270
signature environmental laws he authored. First off, Carlyle served in
58
00:03:31.289 --> 00:03:35.330
the Washington legislature from 2009 to 2020-23, beginning in the
59
00:03:35.349 --> 00:03:37.389
House and then moved over to the Senate where he
60
00:03:37.449 --> 00:03:41.889
chaired the Environment, Energy, and Technology Committee. After leaving the legislature,
61
00:03:41.930 --> 00:03:45.750
he founded Earth Finances, a global climate strategy and technology
62
00:03:45.810 --> 00:03:50.129
firm that helps companies transition to clean energy sources. In 2019,
63
00:03:50.110 --> 00:03:53.569
Carlyle successfully shepherded to passage the Clean Energy Transition Act,
64
00:03:53.949 --> 00:03:56.889
which requires utilities to transition away from fossil fuel energy
65
00:03:56.930 --> 00:04:01.090
sources by 2045 with key benchmarks along the way, phasing
66
00:04:01.150 --> 00:04:04.729
out coal by 2025, that has passed, and becoming carbon
67
00:04:04.750 --> 00:04:07.789
neutral by 2030. Carlyle was also the lead sponsor of
68
00:04:07.810 --> 00:04:11.810
the 2021 Climate Commitment Act, a cap-and-invest program designed to
69
00:04:11.909 --> 00:04:15.259
force the state's largest greenhouse gas emitters to ramp down
70
00:04:15.280 --> 00:04:18.670
their emissions over time with the goal of helping Washington
71
00:04:18.709 --> 00:04:21.709
achieve its goal of reducing greenhouse gas emissions by 95%
72
00:04:21.709 --> 00:04:25.889
by 2050. Washington is in the process of linking its
73
00:04:25.949 --> 00:04:31.040
carbon market with California and with Quebec. I should also
74
00:04:31.069 --> 00:04:33.540
note that Washington lawmakers under former Governor Jay Inslee also
75
00:04:33.579 --> 00:04:36.660
adopted a Clean Buildings Act in 2019 and a Clean
76
00:04:36.720 --> 00:04:40.399
Fuel Standard in 2021. The Washington Supreme Court last month
77
00:04:40.800 --> 00:04:43.899
struck down a voter-approved initiative that sought to protect natural
78
00:04:43.939 --> 00:04:47.589
gas as a source of energy. So there's about a
79
00:04:47.649 --> 00:04:50.990
decade's worth of background on state environmental and energy policy.
80
00:04:51.449 --> 00:04:53.790
I think just before we begin, I should ask you,
81
00:04:53.810 --> 00:04:56.189
in the context of the work you're doing now in
82
00:04:56.209 --> 00:04:59.790
the private sector, is there any, sort of in the
83
00:04:59.889 --> 00:05:04.189
interest of full disclosure, any work you're doing around these
84
00:05:04.269 --> 00:05:08.139
laws that you passed any conflict of interest? Absolutely.
85
00:05:08.139 --> 00:05:11.660
100% transparency, proud to support all of that legislation over
86
00:05:11.699 --> 00:05:13.899
the years. No, I don't have any clients that have
87
00:05:13.920 --> 00:05:19.139
a direct interest in seeking resources from the Climate Commitment
88
00:05:19.240 --> 00:05:23.939
Act or any implementation issues around the 100% clean energy.
89
00:05:25.160 --> 00:05:28.699
Big picture, and I alluded to this in my intro,
90
00:05:28.879 --> 00:05:30.800
it seems like we are speaking kind of at a
91
00:05:30.860 --> 00:05:34.209
moment of reckoning. The halcyon days of cheap Hydropower seemed
92
00:05:34.240 --> 00:05:36.129
to be fading. I see you have a Henry M.
93
00:05:36.160 --> 00:05:42.160
Jackson biography on the table here. Demand for electricity is
94
00:05:42.240 --> 00:05:47.019
rising after years of stability. AI and data centers promised
95
00:05:47.040 --> 00:05:49.720
to put a lot more pressure on the grid. The
96
00:05:49.740 --> 00:05:53.810
grid really hasn't been modernized, and we haven't figured out
97
00:05:53.850 --> 00:05:57.230
a one-to-one replacement for fossil fuels yet. And now we've
98
00:05:57.269 --> 00:05:59.209
got environmental laws like the ones you wrote that
are
99
00:05:59.310 --> 00:06:01.389
forcing the hands of utilities to get off of coal,
100
00:06:01.449 --> 00:06:03.629
get off of gas with real deadlines that are approaching
101
00:06:03.670 --> 00:06:06.399
really quickly. So big picture, I just want to start
102
00:06:06.439 --> 00:06:09.339
with kind of your acknowledgement of this moment.
103
00:06:09.759 --> 00:06:12.639
Absolutely. And you really nailed it. And that is why
104
00:06:12.699 --> 00:06:15.480
I brought this biography of Henry M. Jackson, Scoop Jackson.
105
00:06:15.839 --> 00:06:18.379
You know, you work for Scoop. I was a congressional
106
00:06:18.430 --> 00:06:20.430
page for him when I was 15 years old.
107
00:06:20.490 --> 00:06:20.949
Exactly.
108
00:06:21.029 --> 00:06:24.769
But Ultimately, we're living in a time of just historic
109
00:06:24.870 --> 00:06:27.779
global transformation in energy. And as you said, the era—
110
00:06:27.850 --> 00:06:28.089
And the.
111
00:06:28.029 --> 00:06:29.910
Reason we'd be talking about Scoop Jackson is because of
112
00:06:30.529 --> 00:06:32.889
the dams and hydropower and sort of the history. Exactly.
113
00:06:32.930 --> 00:06:37.209
So we're living on the— we' re standing on the shoulders of giants. FDR,
114
00:06:37.529 --> 00:06:42.629
Warren Magnuson, Henry M. Jackson, senators from Washington, the FDR,
115
00:06:42.980 --> 00:06:47.560
the— the World War II construction boom relative to the
116
00:06:47.620 --> 00:06:50.279
New Deal. And if you look at all the dams,
117
00:06:50.319 --> 00:06:53.500
the hydro, 32% of the entire hydro in the United
118
00:06:53.550 --> 00:06:56.790
States comes from Washington State. I mean, we are standing
119
00:06:56.870 --> 00:06:59.970
on the shoulders of giants. And we are now in
120
00:07:00.009 --> 00:07:04.129
this moment, a generational moment, where we're transitioning from a
121
00:07:04.250 --> 00:07:08.759
highly concentrated, primarily fossil fuel-based system in the United States
122
00:07:09.199 --> 00:07:14.939
to a highly decentralized, distributed system Renewable based system so
123
00:07:14.980 --> 00:07:19.720
that that structural shift is profound and that's really what
124
00:07:19.759 --> 00:07:22.060
we're in the middle of and so the implications of
125
00:07:22.120 --> 00:07:25.689
that our policy, but they're also about markets and finance
126
00:07:26.370 --> 00:07:29.610
and About climate so all of these issues are converging
127
00:07:29.790 --> 00:07:30.829
in this moment.
128
00:07:31.389 --> 00:07:33.850
Before we talk policy Let's talk people, you know the
129
00:07:33.889 --> 00:07:36.600
ratepayers are starting to kind of pick up their pitchforks
130
00:07:36.800 --> 00:07:40.589
and they're frustrated over rising rates and The Washington State
131
00:07:40.610 --> 00:07:43.889
Standard reported last month that PSE, which serves about 2
132
00:07:43.889 --> 00:07:47.370
million power and gas customers in western Washington, has doubled
133
00:07:47.410 --> 00:07:50.689
its prices since 2020 and is now asking for another
134
00:07:50.689 --> 00:07:54.899
30% increase over the next three years. Vista in eastern
135
00:07:54.939 --> 00:07:59.259
Washington is also pursuing double-digit rate hikes. Can you appreciate
136
00:07:59.800 --> 00:08:02.019
the frustration maybe now bordering on anger?
137
00:08:02.519 --> 00:08:03.410
Absolutely.
138
00:08:03.430 --> 00:08:04.370
I mean, of course.
139
00:08:04.470 --> 00:08:06.810
We know that people in this country are suffering. People
140
00:08:06.850 --> 00:08:09.910
in the state are suffering. Affordability is is very real
141
00:08:10.069 --> 00:08:15.279
on every aspect of it. At the same time, we're
142
00:08:15.339 --> 00:08:19.560
living in a system where we've had among the lowest
143
00:08:19.639 --> 00:08:22.600
energy costs of any region in the nation, really in
144
00:08:22.639 --> 00:08:25.319
the world. And that is not just hydro, but we've
145
00:08:25.399 --> 00:08:28.610
also had wind and solar. We also have nuclear. We
146
00:08:28.649 --> 00:08:33.090
have just a wonderful tapestry system. As we move away
147
00:08:33.149 --> 00:08:36.470
from coal, the economics just don't make sense of coal.
148
00:08:36.840 --> 00:08:40.139
It's not just about policy. It's also about markets and
149
00:08:40.220 --> 00:08:43.340
finance and the cost model of coal as well. So
150
00:08:43.500 --> 00:08:47.019
those concerns about affordability are very real. But what we
151
00:08:47.120 --> 00:08:52.399
have is a responsibility to deconstruct what is the real driver.
152
00:08:52.940 --> 00:08:56.899
Is it just state climate policy? Or is it much
153
00:08:56.980 --> 00:09:01.779
more expansive relative to a fundamental change in demand? For example,
154
00:09:01.919 --> 00:09:04.879
AI and data centers. That's one element of it. There's
155
00:09:05.029 --> 00:09:08.820
lots of other reasons for a transformational change that is
156
00:09:08.879 --> 00:09:12.360
affecting affordability. But nobody should minimize that there is a
157
00:09:12.419 --> 00:09:14.940
real effect that we're seeing in the state.
158
00:09:15.240 --> 00:09:18.860
Before we get to your sort of diagnosis of the problem,
159
00:09:19.779 --> 00:09:23.269
the investor-owned utilities like Avista and PSC point to a
160
00:09:23.309 --> 00:09:26.070
number of factors that are driving up costs. Fire safety
161
00:09:26.090 --> 00:09:27.830
is one. I mean, they're having to invest a lot
162
00:09:27.909 --> 00:09:32.110
to reduce the chance that their systems will set the
163
00:09:32.129 --> 00:09:36.820
wild lands on fire. Infrastructure investments, growing demand, but they
164
00:09:36.940 --> 00:09:40.080
also point to, and the data point to, compliance with
165
00:09:40.120 --> 00:09:43.720
Washington State's clean energy requirements. They are pointing directly at
166
00:09:43.740 --> 00:09:48.720
policies where they are protected. Do you have any regrets?
167
00:09:49.259 --> 00:09:51.190
If you had to do it over again, would you
168
00:09:51.210 --> 00:09:53.490
do it differently? Were these policies too much too fast?
169
00:09:53.970 --> 00:09:54.649
You know what? Tell you what.
170
00:09:55.029 --> 00:09:58.169
This pen is the pen that Jay Inslee used to
171
00:09:58.210 --> 00:09:59.090
sign the 100% clean energy.
172
00:09:59.110 --> 00:09:59.950
They got to hold it up for him.
173
00:10:01.000 --> 00:10:05.679
Clean Energy Transformation Act. So that was CETA in 2019.
174
00:10:05.679 --> 00:10:09.279
So if I had the magic wand, the ability to
175
00:10:09.909 --> 00:10:13.610
write that law today, there is no question that what
176
00:10:13.669 --> 00:10:17.470
we would do is lean into the fundamental problem of
177
00:10:17.549 --> 00:10:21.480
permitting and building. the inability to build anything in this state.
178
00:10:21.679 --> 00:10:25.039
I'm a huge believer in the book by Derek Thompson
179
00:10:25.240 --> 00:10:28.669
and Ezra Klein called Abundance, which is just about leaning
180
00:10:28.830 --> 00:10:31.769
into the fact that blue states struggle to show that
181
00:10:31.809 --> 00:10:35.629
they can govern. And Washington is a symbolic representation of
182
00:10:35.669 --> 00:10:38.610
this problem when it comes to energy. It is so
183
00:10:38.669 --> 00:10:41.269
difficult to build anything in this state. It is so
184
00:10:41.370 --> 00:10:45.269
profoundly cumbersome. And it isn't just about one bureaucracy. It's
185
00:10:45.320 --> 00:10:49.159
a systems issue. We have levels of opposition in terms
186
00:10:49.200 --> 00:10:52.990
of permitting. We have a grid that's very old and
187
00:10:53.070 --> 00:10:57.190
very brittle and very difficult to interconnect with. The Bonneville
188
00:10:57.230 --> 00:11:00.570
Power Administration controls the essence of much of the grid,
189
00:11:01.190 --> 00:11:05.409
and connecting to them is incredibly difficult, years and years
190
00:11:05.470 --> 00:11:07.730
and years. So if I had that ability to redo
191
00:11:07.789 --> 00:11:11.169
that law with Governor Jay Inslee and Representative Joe Fitzgibbon
192
00:11:11.190 --> 00:11:13.929
and others and Representative Gail Tarleton and all the folks
193
00:11:13.970 --> 00:11:16.850
who we worked on it, there's no question that we
194
00:11:16.889 --> 00:11:20.529
should lean into the fundamental problem statement that we did
195
00:11:20.750 --> 00:11:23.870
not clear the pathway to make it easy and accessible
196
00:11:23.929 --> 00:11:27.549
to actually build the energy. So in fairness to the
197
00:11:27.600 --> 00:11:32.659
investor-owned utilities like PSE and Avista and Pacificor, it is
198
00:11:33.120 --> 00:11:37.480
central to acknowledge that they are building in cost models
199
00:11:37.940 --> 00:11:41.070
that assume the status quo, that assume that it takes
200
00:11:41.250 --> 00:11:44.269
years to build anything in terms of renewable energy. And
201
00:11:44.389 --> 00:11:48.820
that's the fundamental problem. We're failing to clear the pathway
202
00:11:48.879 --> 00:11:51.299
to be able to build renewable energy.
203
00:11:52.590 --> 00:11:56.049
But no regrets on the forcing mechanism to say to
204
00:11:56.090 --> 00:11:59.090
these utilities, by a date certain, you have to get
205
00:11:59.149 --> 00:11:59.850
off fossil fuels.
206
00:12:00.169 --> 00:12:03.110
I think it's a hugely constructive forcing function. There's no
207
00:12:03.169 --> 00:12:07.139
question that state climate policy is absolutely critical. We're seeing
208
00:12:07.440 --> 00:12:10.779
reduced snow packs in our hydro systems. We see the
209
00:12:10.840 --> 00:12:14.549
effects of climate change every day. And the essence... of
210
00:12:14.610 --> 00:12:18.149
those bills and that legislation is to show states that
211
00:12:19.149 --> 00:12:24.789
substantive climate policy that's market-oriented is possible. So yes, there's implications.
212
00:12:25.470 --> 00:12:29.179
But the affordability issue is spread across a variety of
213
00:12:29.240 --> 00:12:33.480
problems we'll get into. But ultimately, the ability to make
214
00:12:33.539 --> 00:12:36.039
the kind of progress that would lower the cost is
215
00:12:36.139 --> 00:12:40.639
driven by the inability to easily and affordably build additional
216
00:12:40.679 --> 00:12:41.419
renewable energy.
217
00:12:41.879 --> 00:12:46.039
Well, let's get at these... eight factors you've identified. We
218
00:12:46.059 --> 00:12:48.059
actually can put them on the screen. You've mentioned and
219
00:12:48.179 --> 00:12:51.620
alluded to a couple of them already. They are demand
220
00:12:51.700 --> 00:12:57.240
growth that wasn't priced in, aging infrastructure, low-income subsidies, which
221
00:12:57.259 --> 00:13:01.419
you're going to have to explain, inadequate efficiency efforts, a
222
00:13:01.490 --> 00:13:06.889
difficult regulatory environment, which you've just discussed, federal headwinds, reduced
223
00:13:06.929 --> 00:13:10.570
snowpack and the impacts that that has on hydropower, and
224
00:13:11.470 --> 00:13:14.169
not to be forgotten, the state's clean energy policies. I
225
00:13:14.200 --> 00:13:16.620
don't think we have time to walk through each one briefly,
226
00:13:17.440 --> 00:13:21.399
but what is the story you're trying to tell by
227
00:13:21.440 --> 00:13:24.320
having identified these eight factors? Absolutely.
228
00:13:24.379 --> 00:13:28.580
So I think the narrative of value for this journey,
229
00:13:28.639 --> 00:13:31.519
this really troubling time that we're living in, is that
230
00:13:32.340 --> 00:13:36.009
we have a hundred-year-old infrastructure. And we are so used
231
00:13:36.029 --> 00:13:38.070
to flipping the light switch and the power going on,
232
00:13:38.090 --> 00:13:40.610
we don't even think about it. It's a fundamental human
233
00:13:40.649 --> 00:13:43.149
right in our mindset. But that's of course not the
234
00:13:43.190 --> 00:13:46.230
case around the world. And so as we look at
235
00:13:46.269 --> 00:13:49.000
the fact that our aging infrastructure is 100 years old,
236
00:13:49.080 --> 00:13:52.179
the life cycle is simply at its end in many ways.
237
00:13:52.639 --> 00:13:56.779
So modernizing our infrastructure. You have the factor of inflation.
238
00:13:56.820 --> 00:13:59.899
The cost of a wood pole has doubled in five
239
00:13:59.940 --> 00:14:03.639
or six years. The cost of grid modernization. Then there's
240
00:14:03.700 --> 00:14:08.440
another problem statement around battery storage. In my opinion, every
241
00:14:08.519 --> 00:14:13.250
single big box store, every commercial building, every single office
242
00:14:13.279 --> 00:14:16.100
building ought to have battery storage right next to it.
243
00:14:16.169 --> 00:14:20.610
That should be automatic permitting. Today, they're in many ways
244
00:14:20.690 --> 00:14:23.870
associated in some of the public's mind with data centers.
245
00:14:23.929 --> 00:14:27.970
And so there's some resistance to them. Distributed battery storage
246
00:14:28.250 --> 00:14:33.149
should be widely available, easily and accessible. That's another example
247
00:14:33.330 --> 00:14:35.309
of our tough permitting environment.
248
00:14:35.850 --> 00:14:37.470
What is the low-income subsidies piece?
249
00:14:37.509 --> 00:14:42.509
So low-income is we have very generous requirements that low-income
250
00:14:42.570 --> 00:14:47.149
folks on their bill have access to reduced or eliminated bills.
251
00:14:47.210 --> 00:14:49.700
And so basically we sort of have a policy model
252
00:14:50.080 --> 00:14:53.740
where the middle class in many ways subsidizes very low-income individuals.
253
00:14:54.490 --> 00:14:57.049
And that's an important part of the money that the
254
00:14:57.090 --> 00:15:00.470
investor-owned utilities get. A lot of it has to be pushed,
255
00:15:00.789 --> 00:15:06.210
reinvested back into low-income rebates and subsidies. And that's just
256
00:15:06.250 --> 00:15:10.009
an element of the larger tapestry. But you, again, you
257
00:15:10.049 --> 00:15:15.250
have this radical acceleration of demand with the aging infrastructure,
258
00:15:15.750 --> 00:15:19.600
with the lack of permitting and building ability, with the
259
00:15:19.659 --> 00:15:23.179
lack of battery storage, all of these factors together. And
260
00:15:23.220 --> 00:15:26.990
then finally, you have a 60-plus percent reduction in the
261
00:15:27.039 --> 00:15:30.490
tax benefits that renewable energy used to have prior to
262
00:15:30.509 --> 00:15:31.409
the Trump administration.
263
00:15:31.610 --> 00:15:33.409
And so that's the federal headwinds you're talking about. Correct.
264
00:15:33.429 --> 00:15:37.169
So President Trump came in and completely wiped out and
265
00:15:37.509 --> 00:15:40.350
fiercely opposed every aspect of renewable energy.
266
00:15:40.860 --> 00:15:41.980
Including offshore wind.
267
00:15:42.340 --> 00:15:45.159
Including offshore wind. We're one of the best areas in
268
00:15:45.200 --> 00:15:49.240
the world for offshore wind, and it's completely eviscerated.
269
00:15:51.019 --> 00:15:51.159
So.
270
00:15:51.830 --> 00:15:53.909
Let's talk about the cost of going green. So you've
271
00:15:53.950 --> 00:15:55.970
identified sort of all these factors, and as I hear
272
00:15:55.990 --> 00:15:59.610
you saying it, it's not just the environmental policies that
273
00:15:59.649 --> 00:16:01.629
are driving this challenge.
274
00:16:01.750 --> 00:16:03.850
And I'm saying that's a part of it, right? But
275
00:16:04.090 --> 00:16:07.840
is it 5%, 20%? It's very difficult to know. There's
276
00:16:07.879 --> 00:16:10.759
a complexity to this. But the essence of it is
277
00:16:10.940 --> 00:16:15.840
really this explosion in demand with this inability to build
278
00:16:15.879 --> 00:16:20.320
renewable energy, combined with state policy, combined with inflation, combined
279
00:16:20.360 --> 00:16:24.259
with the Trump administration, all of these factors together are
280
00:16:24.360 --> 00:16:25.899
drivers of our costs.
281
00:16:26.720 --> 00:16:29.039
So here's what the utilities say. On the one hand,
282
00:16:29.100 --> 00:16:31.840
it does seem like CETA is having its intended effect.
283
00:16:32.139 --> 00:16:37.799
PSE reports that clean energy resources supplied 50.6% of its
284
00:16:37.860 --> 00:16:41.429
customer electric load, up nearly 20 points from 31% average
285
00:16:41.450 --> 00:16:47.590
between 2018 and 2021. So that's That's progress towards meeting CETA.
286
00:16:48.250 --> 00:16:50.809
On the other hand, PSE says its power supply costs
287
00:16:50.850 --> 00:16:53.649
have tripled since the law was passed. This is according
288
00:16:53.669 --> 00:16:57.029
to reporting by the Washington State Standard. PSE's most recent
289
00:16:57.190 --> 00:17:01.529
clean energy compliance report calculates the incremental cost of complying
290
00:17:01.570 --> 00:17:04.950
with Washington's clean energy requirements during 2022 to 2025 period
291
00:17:05.009 --> 00:17:13.019
was approximately $ 820 million. When UTC approved their 12%, electricity
292
00:17:13.220 --> 00:17:16.829
rate increase last December, the largest chunk of that increase
293
00:17:16.930 --> 00:17:20.549
was attributed to power costs, including CCA and CETA compliance.
294
00:17:21.269 --> 00:17:26.509
So is this an intended or an unintended consequence of
295
00:17:26.529 --> 00:17:26.680
the law?
296
00:17:27.099 --> 00:17:30.579
So the challenge with that modeling, which I take at
297
00:17:30.619 --> 00:17:33.220
face value, and I know they've worked very hard, and
298
00:17:33.240 --> 00:17:35.839
I think next week with the UTC, you can have
299
00:17:35.880 --> 00:17:38.680
a really substantive conversation about their analysis.
300
00:17:38.759 --> 00:17:39.619
Yeah, a few weeks from now.
301
00:17:39.619 --> 00:17:40.049
A few weeks.
302
00:17:40.470 --> 00:17:43.930
But I think what's interesting is that That assumes a
303
00:17:43.990 --> 00:17:49.670
status quo plan. That assumes virtually no additional efficiencies whatsoever.
304
00:17:50.410 --> 00:17:53.190
And the chair of the UTC, Brian, he has a
305
00:17:53.230 --> 00:17:57.869
very interesting statement, which is utilize before you capitalize, which
306
00:17:57.930 --> 00:18:02.509
means grid efficiency. We only use less than 50% of
307
00:18:02.569 --> 00:18:05.349
our grid. And so we're one of the most inefficient
308
00:18:05.390 --> 00:18:08.609
grids in the nation. And our region is incredibly ineffective.
309
00:18:08.630 --> 00:18:12.930
So what that means is We're building this massive capital
310
00:18:13.029 --> 00:18:17.380
infrastructure to deal with these peak days, these peak weeks occasionally.
311
00:18:17.799 --> 00:18:20.460
And we're not being really thoughtful about the issue of
312
00:18:20.519 --> 00:18:24.160
grid efficiency. And that's hundreds of millions of dollars of
313
00:18:24.220 --> 00:18:28.930
capital infrastructure. The second status quo element of their proposal,
314
00:18:29.630 --> 00:18:34.009
in fairness to them as utilities, is they're assuming it
315
00:18:34.069 --> 00:18:37.670
takes years, if not decades, to build additional renewable energy.
316
00:18:37.920 --> 00:18:40.779
And so that's where I'm saying the public policy failure
317
00:18:41.240 --> 00:18:45.710
is that we didn't, while asking our utilities to transition
318
00:18:45.750 --> 00:18:48.950
to a lower carbon economy, we didn't also give them
319
00:18:48.990 --> 00:18:54.250
the tools to accelerate the permitting and the regulatory environment
320
00:18:54.569 --> 00:18:59.029
so that you can build renewables, including geothermal. And I
321
00:18:59.359 --> 00:19:03.319
also would add SMR, small module nuclear, is an essential
322
00:19:03.359 --> 00:19:04.140
part of our future.
323
00:19:04.680 --> 00:19:06.930
So maybe what I hear you saying is, if we
324
00:19:06.950 --> 00:19:10.710
could figure out a way to speed these projects that
325
00:19:10.750 --> 00:19:13.509
are part of the transition and maybe not build as
326
00:19:13.650 --> 00:19:17.849
much capacity as the utilities think they need at this
327
00:19:17.930 --> 00:19:22.170
point and derive more efficiency out of the existing system
328
00:19:22.259 --> 00:19:24.900
or whatever will be the new system that that's, that
329
00:19:24.980 --> 00:19:26.819
might be a way out of this.
330
00:19:26.920 --> 00:19:29.759
I'm saying that those two factors alone are not trivial.
331
00:19:30.059 --> 00:19:33.960
They would account for hundreds of millions of dollars. And again,
332
00:19:34.420 --> 00:19:36.900
Puget Sound Energy, in all fairness to them, they're writing
333
00:19:36.940 --> 00:19:41.079
a status quo plan that assumes basically modest levels of
334
00:19:41.160 --> 00:19:44.410
improvements in efficiency and assumes that it still takes a
335
00:19:44.450 --> 00:19:48.470
decade to build anything. And I'm saying that's the policy failure.
336
00:19:49.150 --> 00:19:51.589
You did build in some, I think they're called off-ramps,
337
00:19:51.670 --> 00:19:56.109
into CETA, essentially cost caps that allow utilities to seek
338
00:19:56.150 --> 00:20:00.710
some relief from greenhouse gas neutrality if the incremental cost
339
00:20:00.769 --> 00:20:03.430
of CETA compliance exceeds a certain threshold. How do these
340
00:20:04.339 --> 00:20:06.519
off-ramps work, and are they being triggered yet, or are
341
00:20:06.559 --> 00:20:07.140
they about to be?
342
00:20:07.579 --> 00:20:10.490
You know, I think that's where the UTC— we gave— the
343
00:20:11.009 --> 00:20:14.450
UTC a lot of authority in the legislation. I mean
344
00:20:14.490 --> 00:20:18.430
a lot. And I think in fairness to Republican opponents
345
00:20:18.490 --> 00:20:21.890
of both of the bills, they argued that it was
346
00:20:21.930 --> 00:20:25.599
a very substantial delegation of authority to the regulatory agency
347
00:20:26.000 --> 00:20:28.700
to be able to assess that very question. And I
348
00:20:28.740 --> 00:20:30.579
think in fairness to them, it's true. We did give
349
00:20:31.099 --> 00:20:32.980
them a lot of authority. So we gave it in
350
00:20:33.019 --> 00:20:37.359
sort of two-year increments. So the UTC has the authority
351
00:20:37.480 --> 00:20:39.960
to look very clearly at where we are today and
352
00:20:40.559 --> 00:20:43.819
where we need to be 2030 or beyond in terms
353
00:20:43.859 --> 00:20:47.460
of the legislation, and to really look at how real
354
00:20:47.500 --> 00:20:50.259
those off ramps are. The two off ramps, one is
355
00:20:50.319 --> 00:20:54.619
about cost, if the incremental cost is material, and two
356
00:20:54.720 --> 00:20:58.829
is reliability, if there's a serious issue relative to negative
357
00:20:58.869 --> 00:21:02.150
effects on reliability of the grid. So we gave them
358
00:21:02.210 --> 00:21:05.430
the tools, and I think it's in fairness to the UTC,
359
00:21:06.009 --> 00:21:09.490
they're the ones who really need to deconstruct to determine
360
00:21:10.049 --> 00:21:12.470
whether those thresholds have been met. And that's why we
361
00:21:12.509 --> 00:21:13.250
gave them the tools.
362
00:21:13.329 --> 00:21:16.190
But my understanding is that utilities have also determined that
363
00:21:16.210 --> 00:21:21.259
it doesn't let them off of meeting the mark, meeting
364
00:21:21.299 --> 00:21:23.460
the standard. So even if they take the off ramp,
365
00:21:23.480 --> 00:21:27.720
they're still ultimately responsible for meeting the deadline.
366
00:21:27.740 --> 00:21:31.339
You know, it's true. Look, in fairness, as much as
367
00:21:31.400 --> 00:21:34.839
we all in the legislative arena like to pretend like
368
00:21:35.039 --> 00:21:38.960
our work is... you know, carried down on tablets by
369
00:21:39.029 --> 00:21:42.529
Moses on Mount Sinai. It's just not true, right? This
370
00:21:42.589 --> 00:21:45.829
legislation needs to live and it needs to breathe and
371
00:21:45.849 --> 00:21:48.589
it needs to be modernized and updated. There's so many
372
00:21:48.630 --> 00:21:55.640
new legislators from since between 2019 and today and 2021
373
00:21:55.640 --> 00:21:58.440
when we passed CCA. It is important for it to
374
00:21:58.480 --> 00:22:01.160
be a living and breathing document. Now, I am not
375
00:22:01.220 --> 00:22:06.160
opposed to pressure relief valves that make good economic sense.
376
00:22:07.519 --> 00:22:10.259
the spirit of the law is to transition to a
377
00:22:10.299 --> 00:22:13.339
lower carbon economy. It's not about the letter of law
378
00:22:13.400 --> 00:22:17.720
of exactly X percent on Y date in and of itself.
379
00:22:17.960 --> 00:22:21.859
It's about helping the economy. And I think the fact
380
00:22:21.940 --> 00:22:25.460
that we as a region have had the lowest levels
381
00:22:25.539 --> 00:22:30.690
of energy prices, costs for generations, we're feeling it in
382
00:22:30.730 --> 00:22:34.009
a disproportionate way. But I'll tell you, compared to other states,
383
00:22:34.089 --> 00:22:37.869
we know that we're still at a really strong advantage.
384
00:22:37.910 --> 00:22:39.049
And so we want to maintain that.
385
00:22:39.730 --> 00:22:42.490
Speaking of relief valves, Arnie Olson, when he was on
386
00:22:42.509 --> 00:22:46.410
the program, talked about the potential need to have natural
387
00:22:46.450 --> 00:22:52.079
gas peaking plants to address gaps at those peak demand times.
388
00:22:52.579 --> 00:22:55.059
But of course that would, and my understanding is that
389
00:22:55.119 --> 00:22:58.779
the TransAlta plant down in Centralia is being transitioned from
390
00:22:58.839 --> 00:23:01.299
coal to natural gas. PSE is doing that and that
391
00:23:01.420 --> 00:23:04.220
will be for a period of time. But what is
392
00:23:04.279 --> 00:23:09.420
your position on allowing some natural, even new natural gas
393
00:23:09.960 --> 00:23:10.579
to come online?
394
00:23:10.980 --> 00:23:13.680
I'm super unenthusiastic about it, but I don't think it's
395
00:23:13.720 --> 00:23:14.740
an irrational argument.
396
00:23:15.259 --> 00:23:16.279
Not an irrational.
397
00:23:16.460 --> 00:23:17.680
Not an irrational.
398
00:23:17.720 --> 00:23:18.000
Correct.
399
00:23:18.039 --> 00:23:20.319
Thank you. I think if it were up to me,
400
00:23:20.759 --> 00:23:24.400
I would triple down on small module nuclear. I would
401
00:23:24.440 --> 00:23:27.769
rather see nuclear be part of our baseload because it's
402
00:23:28.069 --> 00:23:31.490
not only clean, but we have the workforce. We have
403
00:23:31.509 --> 00:23:35.509
the interconnection. We have the permitting ability in the Tri-Cities area.
404
00:23:35.549 --> 00:23:38.230
We have all of the attributes. I
would like to
405
00:23:38.289 --> 00:23:41.819
see in five, 10 years, five or 10 small modular
406
00:23:41.859 --> 00:23:46.779
nuclear SMR systems robustly deployed throughout our state. So to me,
407
00:23:46.839 --> 00:23:50.339
that's the kind of systems change that makes the most sense.
408
00:23:50.839 --> 00:23:55.420
I'm not religiously opposed to an additional natural gas peaker
409
00:23:55.740 --> 00:23:58.880
as if it's truly used for peaker, but I'd like
410
00:23:58.920 --> 00:24:02.599
to see SMR instead. And geothermal.
411
00:24:02.680 --> 00:24:04.720
We'll talk with Todd Myers in the second half from
412
00:24:04.740 --> 00:24:08.430
Washington Policy Center about the costs involved in moving to
413
00:24:08.730 --> 00:24:13.130
wind and solar, small modular nuclear. But one of the
414
00:24:13.170 --> 00:24:16.970
issues that has come up has been friction with Washington
415
00:24:17.029 --> 00:24:20.660
tribes over some of these projects, whether it's large wind farms,
416
00:24:21.180 --> 00:24:27.279
large solar farms. How are you assessing that friction and
417
00:24:27.339 --> 00:24:30.970
tension and And it is a potential barrier to building
418
00:24:30.990 --> 00:24:31.809
some of these projects.
419
00:24:32.230 --> 00:24:34.910
It absolutely is. And I think it's a very fair,
420
00:24:36.289 --> 00:24:39.250
very thoughtful and fair question for us all from a
421
00:24:39.309 --> 00:24:41.210
policy point of view and a political point of view
422
00:24:41.269 --> 00:24:44.019
to consider. I had the great honor of working with
423
00:24:44.039 --> 00:24:47.079
our 29 federally recognized tribes, both in my role in
424
00:24:47.099 --> 00:24:49.440
the Senate and my role in the House. And I
425
00:24:49.519 --> 00:24:52.920
think the learning, of course, is that there's not a
426
00:24:52.940 --> 00:24:56.259
monolith and there's a uniqueness to each area of the state.
427
00:24:56.900 --> 00:25:00.200
I also think there's opportunities that we have not seized
428
00:25:00.420 --> 00:25:03.900
to partner with tribes on the energy front in a
429
00:25:03.940 --> 00:25:07.039
way that we just haven't taken to the next level.
430
00:25:07.519 --> 00:25:10.130
You know, there are some exciting projects. The Yakima Nation
431
00:25:10.410 --> 00:25:15.230
is enthusiastic about solar panels over irrigation canals, as an
432
00:25:15.269 --> 00:25:16.069
example of something.
433
00:25:16.109 --> 00:25:19.990
Which could potentially help, I guess, with also evaporation. Exactly.
434
00:25:20.009 --> 00:25:23.609
So a lot of multi-levels of benefits. I think we
435
00:25:23.650 --> 00:25:25.680
need to be a lot more creative about that. But
436
00:25:25.720 --> 00:25:29.460
I do feel like the ability to have accelerated permitting
437
00:25:29.480 --> 00:25:34.329
that has cultural sensitivity is an imperative element of the
438
00:25:34.369 --> 00:25:38.809
government-to-government negotiations that the governor needs to lead with tribes
439
00:25:39.130 --> 00:25:41.809
to get to a place where we can have accelerated
440
00:25:41.849 --> 00:25:45.730
permitting for renewable energy that is real and is achievable.
441
00:25:45.890 --> 00:25:50.099
Because that is, in essence, just the core driver of
442
00:25:50.180 --> 00:25:50.960
our system failure.
443
00:25:52.240 --> 00:25:54.109
We have about four minutes left, and I want to
444
00:25:54.200 --> 00:25:58.329
talk about potential legislative changes to these laws and what,
445
00:25:59.690 --> 00:26:02.210
as you're a former lawmaker, but the architect of these laws,
446
00:26:02.750 --> 00:26:04.670
from where you sit now, what your advice to the
447
00:26:04.789 --> 00:26:08.900
legislature and to the governor and to the commerce, which is,
448
00:26:09.740 --> 00:26:12.720
I guess, actually monitoring and supposed to put out a
449
00:26:12.759 --> 00:26:17.089
report on CETA next year, or 2028, actually. So let's
450
00:26:17.109 --> 00:26:20.559
start with lawmakers. Coming into session in January, Are there
451
00:26:20.880 --> 00:26:25.200
particular legislative changes or fixes that you would recommend that
452
00:26:25.240 --> 00:26:25.819
they consider?
453
00:26:27.940 --> 00:26:31.480
It's obviously a tapestry of a question. You know, there's
454
00:26:31.500 --> 00:26:32.400
all kinds of issues.
455
00:26:32.480 --> 00:26:35.240
I think one is... Well, one example would be that
456
00:26:35.279 --> 00:26:38.339
Washington Policy Center helped write a bipartisan bill that would
457
00:26:38.359 --> 00:26:41.650
have allowed utilities to default to natural gas power production
458
00:26:41.710 --> 00:26:45.009
for an additional 30 years if the risk of blackouts...
459
00:26:45.089 --> 00:26:45.990
triggers certain thresholds.
460
00:26:46.210 --> 00:26:49.589
Yeah, I understand. I think it's really an affirmative question
461
00:26:49.609 --> 00:26:51.549
of how do we move forward to deal with the
462
00:26:51.769 --> 00:26:54.690
real systems issues that are on the table. So to me,
463
00:26:55.730 --> 00:26:59.200
one is accelerated permitting of renewable energy projects, and that
464
00:26:59.259 --> 00:27:04.240
means real systems reform. It also includes automatic permitting, elimination
465
00:27:04.259 --> 00:27:07.420
of SEPA for things like battery storage, which is critical
466
00:27:07.500 --> 00:27:10.930
to a distributed system. It also means, I think, resources
467
00:27:11.009 --> 00:27:15.450
under CCA and others for grid modernization, And recognizing that
468
00:27:15.549 --> 00:27:21.509
interconnection to Bonneville and other entities is extremely difficult.
469
00:27:21.589 --> 00:27:26.470
You mentioned that basically taking a new power source and
470
00:27:26.509 --> 00:27:30.710
plugging that into BPA's system can take years, if not decades.
471
00:27:30.730 --> 00:27:35.059
Ten years, yeah. It's just staggering. So I think acceleration
472
00:27:35.420 --> 00:27:39.559
of
the ability to build renewable energy is the ultimate
473
00:27:39.720 --> 00:27:41.539
systems problem that we.
474
00:27:41.480 --> 00:27:42.200
Have to fix.
475
00:27:42.240 --> 00:27:43.599
Can we learn something from California?
476
00:27:43.619 --> 00:27:43.700
Yeah.
477
00:27:44.309 --> 00:27:44.789
Absolutely.
478
00:27:44.829 --> 00:27:47.690
I mean, they particularly very recently through my good friend,
479
00:27:47.849 --> 00:27:50.250
Senator Josh Becker, who's the chair of the committee down there,
480
00:27:50.910 --> 00:27:54.849
passed legislation on this question of grid efficiency to really
481
00:27:55.789 --> 00:27:58.509
stress test all of the aspects of how to use
482
00:27:58.849 --> 00:28:01.890
the full grid to much more capacity instead of the
483
00:28:01.930 --> 00:28:04.789
type of underutilization that we have. So I think efficiency
484
00:28:04.809 --> 00:28:08.369
is another opportunity, battery storage, permitting, a number of those
485
00:28:08.430 --> 00:28:10.950
issues really go to the core of the systems issue.
486
00:28:11.119 --> 00:28:14.440
And as you said, including the types of partnerships with
487
00:28:14.650 --> 00:28:18.250
our tribal partners that is just critical to move forward.
488
00:28:18.430 --> 00:28:20.009
Let me sneak in two last questions here. One is
489
00:28:20.049 --> 00:28:21.589
about what you'd like to see from the governor in
490
00:28:21.630 --> 00:28:24.390
terms of leadership on energy policy and our energy future.
491
00:28:24.589 --> 00:28:24.769
Yeah.
492
00:28:25.150 --> 00:28:28.650
I mean, look, climate change is affecting us every day.
493
00:28:28.829 --> 00:28:30.849
It's not a department down the hall, as we all know.
494
00:28:30.970 --> 00:28:33.809
It's incredibly real. I think just like the governor has
495
00:28:33.849 --> 00:28:36.029
been very bold on the issue of economic development and
496
00:28:36.089 --> 00:28:39.970
looking seriously about SWAT team task force, I'd like to
497
00:28:40.029 --> 00:28:42.230
see that same kind of leadership on the issue of energy.
498
00:28:42.650 --> 00:28:46.400
What does a modern 21st century energy system look like?
499
00:28:46.839 --> 00:28:49.539
How do you move from a highly concentrated to a
500
00:28:49.619 --> 00:28:55.140
highly decentralized renewable energy system? It takes all of the
501
00:28:55.180 --> 00:28:56.019
issues we've talked about.
502
00:28:57.440 --> 00:28:59.430
Something that may come up before the legislature will be
503
00:28:59.490 --> 00:29:04.470
proposals for a data center moratorium. There are those who argue, though,
504
00:29:04.490 --> 00:29:08.740
that data center developers could be potentially part of the
505
00:29:08.759 --> 00:29:11.200
solution if they're forced to not only find the energy
506
00:29:11.240 --> 00:29:14.880
to power their data center, but plus some to then
507
00:29:15.279 --> 00:29:19.849
provide electricity to rate payers. If you were in the
508
00:29:19.890
--> 00:29:21.990
legislature or if you were advising legislators, what do you
509
00:29:22.009 --> 00:29:24.970
think they ought to do in data centers?
510
00:29:25.490 --> 00:29:28.250
Data centers can't be net neutral. They have to be
511
00:29:28.410 --> 00:29:31.339
net positive. They have to be contributors of the solution.
512
00:29:31.690 --> 00:29:34.259
As you can imagine, their business model is to purchase
513
00:29:34.359 --> 00:29:37.079
energy over the long haul. So they get the benefits.
514
00:29:37.099 --> 00:29:39.470
I mean, Grant County, our number one producer of energy
515
00:29:39.490 --> 00:29:42.920
in our state used to, like 37 or 35 or
516
00:29:42.980 --> 00:29:45.900
so percent of its energy is used for data centers today.
517
00:29:46.140 --> 00:29:48.740
That used to go to Western Washington homes and businesses
518
00:29:49.259 --> 00:29:52.619
and statewide. So you can see that this change is
519
00:29:52.680 --> 00:29:55.759
really substantive. I think data centers can be a part
520
00:29:55.779 --> 00:29:58.420
of the solution. But they absolutely have to be a
521
00:29:58.460 --> 00:30:02.460
net positive as it relates to interconnection, distributed energy systems,
522
00:30:02.529 --> 00:30:06.490
backup power, and other types of solutions.
523
00:30:07.450 --> 00:30:08.690
Final thought you want to leave us with?
524
00:30:09.430 --> 00:30:15.910
You know, this transformation is, it's just, it's based upon generations, right?
525
00:30:15.990 --> 00:30:19.680
We are coming at the end of 1940s-based hydro system.
526
00:30:20.019 --> 00:30:23.519
We have less snowpack. We have more wildfires. We have
527
00:30:23.559 --> 00:30:26.910
to value energy. the externalities on a positive and a
528
00:30:26.970 --> 00:30:29.049
negative sense of climate change. We've got to make this
529
00:30:29.150 --> 00:30:32.880
kind of investment in the next generation of our entire
530
00:30:32.940 --> 00:30:36.759
energy system. Energy is life. The era of guaranteed power
531
00:30:37.099 --> 00:30:37.599
is over.
532
00:30:38.859 --> 00:30:41.119
Former State Senator Reuven Carlyle, thanks for coming in. Thanks
533
00:30:41.140 --> 00:30:41.779
for making the trip down.
534
00:30:41.940 --> 00:30:42.319
My pleasure.
535
00:30:42.359 --> 00:30:44.059
Good to see you again. When we return, we get
536
00:30:44.079 --> 00:30:46.779
a different perspective on rising energy costs from Todd Myers
537
00:30:46.839 --> 00:30:49.380
at the Washington Policy Center. Back right after this.
538
00:30:52.859 --> 00:30:56.619
Part of whether you're going to succeed is understanding human nature,
539
00:30:56.960 --> 00:31:00.400
not just generally, but of the people that are involved.
540
00:31:00.880 --> 00:31:04.730
Remembering that the process has to take them as they are,
541
00:31:05.329 --> 00:31:07.730
as opposed to how you would like everybody to be.
542
00:31:07.750 --> 00:31:11.549
At every moment, you can never give up. That's
what
543
00:31:11.589 --> 00:31:14.640
this process is about. You give up, you get nothing.
544
00:31:21.819 --> 00:31:27.960
Watch all of TVW's award-winning shows on your time at tvw.org.
545
00:31:30.289 --> 00:31:32.569
Welcome back to Inside Olympia. My next guest has been
546
00:31:32.609 --> 00:31:36.450
a vocal critic of Washington's climate policies and attributes rising
547
00:31:36.490 --> 00:31:39.589
consumer costs in large part to the requirement to transition
548
00:31:39.630 --> 00:31:42.940
to clean energy sources. Joining me now is Todd Myers,
549
00:31:43.240 --> 00:31:46.259
vice president of research at at the Washington Policy Center.
550
00:31:46.630 --> 00:31:47.640
Welcome to the program. Good to see you.
551
00:31:47.799 --> 00:31:48.559
Yeah, good to see you.
552
00:31:48.819 --> 00:31:50.880
Reuven Carlyle came down from Seattle. You came over from
553
00:31:50.940 --> 00:31:51.380
Cle Elum.
554
00:31:51.400 --> 00:31:51.660
That's right.
555
00:31:51.680 --> 00:31:53.700
We appreciate you making the trip. A note about the
556
00:31:53.740 --> 00:31:57.400
Washington Policy Center. It describes itself as a nonprofit, free
557
00:31:57.440 --> 00:32:03.539
market-oriented research and advocacy organization that publishes analysis of taxation, regulation, energy,
558
00:32:03.599 --> 00:32:07.700
and other policy topics. WPC is funded by businesses, foundations,
559
00:32:08.180 --> 00:32:11.819
and individuals. Many of its 31 board of directors members
560
00:32:11.940 --> 00:32:15.069
are drawn from Washington's business community. Let me just start
561
00:32:15.089 --> 00:32:17.150
with a kind of obvious question. If you could wave
562
00:32:17.210 --> 00:32:21.140
a wand and repeal CCA and CETA tomorrow, would you
563
00:32:21.160 --> 00:32:21.960
do it? And if so, why?
564
00:32:22.400 --> 00:32:30.450
Yeah. First, fundamentally, CCA has not been effective at reducing
565
00:32:30.490 --> 00:32:33.630
CO2 emissions. It's been very expensive. I mean, I think
566
00:32:33.670 --> 00:32:36.589
the statistic that sort of stands out most is that
567
00:32:36.750 --> 00:32:38.970
Washington is now, we're going to join California.
568
00:32:39.289 --> 00:32:40.109
And Quebec, yeah.
569
00:32:40.190 --> 00:32:43.049
And Quebec, which I actually support. But the reason I
570
00:32:43.089 --> 00:32:47.509
support it is that California, which is very restrictive on
571
00:32:47.670 --> 00:32:51.970
climate emissions, their costs are half of what Washington states
572
00:32:52.210 --> 00:32:55.640
are per metric ton of CO2. When you have a
573
00:32:55.680 --> 00:33:00.839
climate policy that is double the cost of California and
574
00:33:00.940 --> 00:33:04.200
not meeting its goal, I mean, it's clearly failed. For
575
00:33:04.299 --> 00:33:07.299
us to meet our climate goals for 2030, the targets
576
00:33:07.380 --> 00:33:09.880
of the state has said, we would have to reduce
577
00:33:09.920 --> 00:33:15.589
CO2 emissions by the equivalent of three COVID-level reductions, cumulatively,
578
00:33:16.200 --> 00:33:18.430
in four more years. We're never going to meet that.
579
00:33:18.930 --> 00:33:21.230
So I think that's the problem is, is that, look,
580
00:33:21.430 --> 00:33:24.450
we need to do things to reduce the risk of
581
00:33:24.490 --> 00:33:26.930
climate change. I have been supportive of that. But we
582
00:33:26.970 --> 00:33:29.299
have to do things that are effective and are cost-effective.
583
00:33:31.190 --> 00:33:35.049
I asked Reuven Carlisle, if not repeal, which doesn't seem
584
00:33:35.089 --> 00:33:38.630
like that's going to be politically palatable, what changes should
585
00:33:38.690 --> 00:33:42.089
the legislature, and he seems like he's open to, you know,
586
00:33:42.109 --> 00:33:47.869
this is not written in stone tablets. What would be
587
00:33:47.910 --> 00:33:53.769
your prescription for legislators coming into the 2026, sorry, 2027 session,
588
00:33:54.369 --> 00:33:59.130
knowing that there is this pain point right now around
589
00:34:00.069 --> 00:34:03.950
electricity and natural gas prices that consumers are feeling, and
590
00:34:04.220 --> 00:34:06.359
probably state legislators are starting to hear from some of
591
00:34:06.380 --> 00:34:09.380
those consumers. What could they do, short of repeal?
592
00:34:10.119 --> 00:34:12.059
The first thing I think is that while people have
593
00:34:12.099 --> 00:34:16.260
focused on PSE, understandably, and Avista, Seattle City Light is
594
00:34:16.340 --> 00:34:19.300
also raising their rates 10% a year over the next
595
00:34:19.340 --> 00:34:23.039
three years. So it's not just the investor-owned utilities. Even
596
00:34:23.119 --> 00:34:26.800
public utilities who have access to low-cost BPA power are
597
00:34:26.840 --> 00:34:30.130
starting to see these costs go up, in order to
598
00:34:30.170 --> 00:34:33.920
meet these restrictions. I think fundamentally, the thing that you
599
00:34:33.960 --> 00:34:36.460
have to do, at the very least, is change the targets.
600
00:34:37.099 --> 00:34:42.360
The 2030 target, net neutral by 2030, is a political goal, right?
601
00:34:43.059 --> 00:34:46.090
It's exactly at the end of a decade, it's easy
602
00:34:46.110 --> 00:34:48.809
to sort of say, but it was never based on
603
00:34:48.949 --> 00:34:52.150
is it feasible on cost, things like that. It was
604
00:34:52.190 --> 00:34:54.909
a political goal. And so first I think you need
605
00:34:54.929 --> 00:34:57.030
to do is change the targets.
606
00:34:57.050 --> 00:34:58.130
You push the targets out.
607
00:34:58.510 --> 00:35:03.059
Absolutely. And then second, if you're saying I can't repeal it, right?
608
00:35:03.079 --> 00:35:04.360
I'm saying you can't repeal it, yes.
609
00:35:04.699 --> 00:35:07.639
Push the targets out. And then second, you mentioned the
610
00:35:07.980 --> 00:35:13.559
legislation that we proposed, which is to give more flexibility.
611
00:35:13.579 --> 00:35:17.360
There are standards, the Northwest Power and Conservation Council and
612
00:35:17.420 --> 00:35:21.400
others have standards for energy reliability to make sure that
613
00:35:21.440 --> 00:35:25.500
the lights stay on. If we break those targets, like
614
00:35:26.420 --> 00:35:29.289
utilities should be able to say, all right, we're still
615
00:35:29.309 --> 00:35:32.750
going to meet the CETA targets in this area, but
616
00:35:32.809 --> 00:35:36.829
give us some flexibility to add some natural gas, especially
617
00:35:37.369 --> 00:35:41.159
for the most times when demand is highest, in the winter,
618
00:35:41.179 --> 00:35:45.519
on those cold days, when the wind isn't blowing, typically,
619
00:35:45.639 --> 00:35:49.880
and there's very little sun. So to meet those high
620
00:35:49.940 --> 00:35:53.679
periods of demand is very expensive. You mentioned Arnie Olson's report.
621
00:35:54.239 --> 00:35:57.780
That's exactly what his report found was, in order to
622
00:35:57.860 --> 00:36:02.440
meet the demand when Washington is most stressed, which is
623
00:36:02.480 --> 00:36:06.860
in the winter, like wind and solar just won't do it.
624
00:36:06.949 --> 00:36:09.429
So I think you need to add flexibility, both in
625
00:36:09.449 --> 00:36:12.429
terms of the deadlines and both in terms of the fuels.
626
00:36:13.090 --> 00:36:15.650
Adding a little bit of natural gas is not going to,
627
00:36:15.869 --> 00:36:18.800
you know, bust our, that's not why we're failing to
628
00:36:18.840 --> 00:36:21.599
meet our targets. It'll add a little bit of CO2,
629
00:36:22.019 --> 00:36:24.460
but it's not, I mean, it will do a tremendous
630
00:36:24.500 --> 00:36:25.840
amount to reduce costs.
631
00:36:26.460 --> 00:36:29.280
You just mentioned Arne Olson's report, and one of the
632
00:36:29.320 --> 00:36:32.559
things he told us in the spring was that even
633
00:36:32.639 --> 00:36:38.840
the least cost resource portfolios require substantial rate increases as
634
00:36:38.880 --> 00:36:43.760
the Northwest replaces aging generation and expands capacity, estimating at
635
00:36:43.800 --> 00:36:47.699
approximately a 50% increase over 20 years in terms of need.
636
00:36:48.880 --> 00:36:51.639
Is the real issue here that our region was sort
637
00:36:51.659 --> 00:36:53.920
of lulled into this idea that we should get our
638
00:36:53.960 --> 00:36:58.030
power for cheap, and we've haven't really invested and upgraded
639
00:36:58.170 --> 00:37:01.449
our system for decades, and now it's time to sort
640
00:37:01.489 --> 00:37:02.389
of pay the piper.
641
00:37:03.210 --> 00:37:05.349
Yeah, I think that there's a number of pieces of
642
00:37:05.409 --> 00:37:08.789
evidence of that. I think, you know, Reuven talked about
643
00:37:08.849 --> 00:37:12.929
the difficulty in building things. I think that we decided
644
00:37:13.010 --> 00:37:18.650
that a lot of environmental and bureaucratic analysis was acceptable because, like,
645
00:37:18.809 --> 00:37:22.989
we're not seeing very high costs. That now has to change. Although,
646
00:37:23.010 --> 00:37:25.940
I mean, like, we... We did see some of that, right?
647
00:37:26.099 --> 00:37:28.860
FSEC was given tremendous amount of power.
648
00:37:29.019 --> 00:37:30.500
That's the energy siting entity.
649
00:37:30.599 --> 00:37:33.900
That's right. To override local concerns, to site.
650
00:37:34.719 --> 00:37:36.219
To try to move these projects along.
651
00:37:36.260 --> 00:37:36.769
Exactly.
652
00:37:36.829 --> 00:37:38.949
So that they could say, okay, local governments, you can't
653
00:37:38.989 --> 00:37:41.489
just block all these sorts of things. And even they
654
00:37:41.530 --> 00:37:46.989
have had a difficulty overcoming that. So one other issue is,
655
00:37:47.030 --> 00:37:50.420
is that I think that people have blamed or there
656
00:37:50.480 --> 00:37:52.960
is a tendency to blame. And I understand it. on
657
00:37:53.360 --> 00:37:56.139
increased rates on data centers. We actually haven't seen an
658
00:37:56.159 --> 00:37:59.719
increase in demand in Washington State due to data centers.
659
00:38:01.300 --> 00:38:04.699
I think people would be surprised that Puget Sound Energy's
660
00:38:05.179 --> 00:38:08.619
demand is almost the same as it was a decade ago,
661
00:38:09.599 --> 00:38:12.780
as is Washington State. We don't see that in Oregon. Oregon,
662
00:38:12.800 --> 00:38:15.929
they have seen an increase due to data centers, and
663
00:38:15.949 --> 00:38:18.429
they're part of the region. But really, that's not what's
664
00:38:18.489 --> 00:38:20.150
driving these increases.
665
00:38:20.269 --> 00:38:22.150
At least not yet. That's correct.
666
00:38:22.389 --> 00:38:24.429
And they do have to plan for the future. And
667
00:38:24.469 --> 00:38:27.349
there is some of that increase that is projected. But
668
00:38:27.889 --> 00:38:32.070
that's really what PSE and others are having to do
669
00:38:32.659 --> 00:38:38.179
is to replace existing capacity with less reliable, more expensive capacity.
670
00:38:38.599 --> 00:38:42.840
The capacity that is available and reliable in those moments
671
00:38:43.519 --> 00:38:45.599
in the winter when demand is high and things like that,
672
00:38:46.440 --> 00:38:49.000
doing wind is much more expensive to meet that than
673
00:38:49.039 --> 00:38:49.639
natural gas.
674
00:38:50.320 --> 00:38:54.019
What is your thought about what the state's data center
675
00:38:54.059 --> 00:38:57.000
policy should be. And going back to the question I
676
00:38:57.119 --> 00:39:02.000
asked Reuven Carlyle, could data centers actually be part of
677
00:39:02.079 --> 00:39:07.900
the solution towards accelerating development of new and perhaps renewable
678
00:39:07.920 --> 00:39:10.559
energy sources that don't just power the data centers but
679
00:39:10.639 --> 00:39:12.280
help lift the entire grid?
680
00:39:12.840 -->
00:39:14.780
This is, in fact, what we're seeing elsewhere, where they
681
00:39:14.820 --> 00:39:20.139
do have more data centers. This is that the money
682
00:39:20.199 --> 00:39:25.099
that is in data centers is investing in new energy sources.
683
00:39:25.719 --> 00:39:29.429
Reuven mentioned small modular reactors. It's a really cool technology
684
00:39:31.480 --> 00:39:35.840
It's more flexible than existing nuclear. It uses nuclear waste, right?
685
00:39:35.860 --> 00:39:38.489
So it does all sorts of really cool things. Where
686
00:39:38.510 --> 00:39:39.619
are you going to get the money to do that?
687
00:39:40.150 --> 00:39:42.219
The federal government doesn't have it. The state doesn't have it.
688
00:39:43.309 --> 00:39:45.010
The people who are looking at that, frankly, are the
689
00:39:45.030 --> 00:39:48.269
people who want to build those data centers. So that
690
00:39:48.369 --> 00:39:51.090
can be a source of capital for to invest in
691
00:39:51.150 --> 00:39:55.590
these new types of more flexible, more reliable sources of energy.
692
00:39:56.139 --> 00:40:01.480
People focus on the increase in demand, but data centers also,
693
00:40:01.840 --> 00:40:05.460
they want reliability, right? They don't wanna be reliant on
694
00:40:05.500 --> 00:40:09.219
the grid. They wanna make sure that they have control
695
00:40:09.239 --> 00:40:12.420
of their electricity. So I think that the concern is
696
00:40:12.579 --> 00:40:15.639
all about, oh, what will it do to demand and
697
00:40:16.059 --> 00:40:17.769
rates And.
698
00:40:17.809 --> 00:40:19.230
Water usage is another concern.
699
00:40:19.349 --> 00:40:22.250
Although, I mean, water usage, I think, as somebody who
700
00:40:22.329 --> 00:40:24.309
has worked on salmon issues for a very long time,
701
00:40:24.349 --> 00:40:26.829
I think water usage is the funniest one because water
702
00:40:26.889 --> 00:40:30.409
is so regulated. They can't, you know, there's this notion
703
00:40:30.429 --> 00:40:32.860
that they can just start grabbing water. They can't do
704
00:40:32.900 --> 00:40:35.260
that at all. They can't grab a drop of water without,
705
00:40:35.619 --> 00:40:39.039
you know, it being, you know, allocated to them. But
706
00:40:39.159 --> 00:40:41.980
in terms of, I understand the concern, but I also
707
00:40:42.039 --> 00:40:43.699
think that if you just simply do something like a
708
00:40:43.739 --> 00:40:47.030
data center moratorium... then you are losing a lot of
709
00:40:47.070 --> 00:40:50.630
opportunity to build exactly the capacity that we need in
710
00:40:50.670 --> 00:40:52.809
terms of energy demand, or energy supply, rather.
711
00:40:53.070 --> 00:40:55.489
Let me raise a data point with you that I
712
00:40:55.530 --> 00:40:58.289
think surprises everybody when they hear it, especially given the
713
00:40:58.349 --> 00:41:00.670
laws on the books that are supposed to be driving
714
00:41:00.710 --> 00:41:04.630
this move to fossil fuel energy. According to reporting last
715
00:41:04.670 --> 00:41:08.690
year by Oregon Public Broadcasting and ProPublico, Washington state is
716
00:41:08.690 --> 00:41:11.829
50 out of the 50 states in terms of bringing
717
00:41:12.030 --> 00:41:16.369
new renewables onto the grid. What is going on there?
718
00:41:17.030 --> 00:41:23.619
Is it BPA? Is it the permitting that we require?
719
00:41:24.099 --> 00:41:27.719
How is it possible that after... We had the climate
720
00:41:27.760 --> 00:41:30.500
governor for 12 years who was leading on this idea
721
00:41:30.519 --> 00:41:33.420
of a renewable future, and we're 50 out of 50.
722
00:41:33.420 --> 00:41:34.239
How does that compute?
723
00:41:34.300 --> 00:41:37.530
Yes, I like to say self-proclaimed climate governor, but I
724
00:41:37.570 --> 00:41:40.449
take your point that it was his focus, and yet
725
00:41:40.510 --> 00:41:42.530
here we are so far behind. I think that there's
726
00:41:42.570 --> 00:41:46.340
a number of factors, which is One, permitting, and we're
727
00:41:46.380 --> 00:41:50.199
seeing that in lots of different areas. The difficulty in
728
00:41:50.219 --> 00:41:53.099
getting things built. I mentioned, you know, FSEC, that the
729
00:41:53.159 --> 00:41:56.260
changes to the FSEC rules were designed to build more
730
00:41:56.300 --> 00:41:59.139
of those. But then, you know, in Yakima, they end
731
00:41:59.179 --> 00:42:02.500
up cutting the size in half because of concerns from
732
00:42:02.539 --> 00:42:05.940
the Yakima tribe, concerns about the Friginus Hawk, other things
733
00:42:06.000 --> 00:42:09.699
like that. It's very difficult. But we have gotten ourselves
734
00:42:09.719 --> 00:42:12.590
into a position where permitting is very difficult. I also
735
00:42:12.610 --> 00:42:15.170
think that the business climate is simply not great in
736
00:42:15.230 --> 00:42:20.969
Washington state. The Biden administration had a webpage that it
737
00:42:21.030 --> 00:42:24.010
showed all the investments from the Inflation Reduction Act, which
738
00:42:24.030 --> 00:42:26.429
were a lot of green investments. And it said, look
739
00:42:26.469 --> 00:42:28.769
at where this is going. And it was going a
740
00:42:28.909 --> 00:42:32.469
lot to red states in the southeast. Now, it wasn't
741
00:42:32.510 --> 00:42:35.320
because those red states in the southeast had great climate policies.
742
00:42:35.590 --> 00:42:38.159
They don't compared to us. What they had was a
743
00:42:38.199 --> 00:42:38.900
good business environment.
744
00:42:38.940 --> 00:42:39.940
They could get stuff built.
745
00:42:40.019 --> 00:42:44.050
They could get stuff built. It was good for business.
746
00:42:44.530 --> 00:42:46.690
That's what you want to do. You want to build more.
747
00:42:46.710 --> 00:42:49.949
You want to have more businesses in this area. Then
748
00:42:50.030 --> 00:42:52.789
make the business environment good generally.
749
00:42:53.510 -->
00:42:56.110
I want to refer you to something that Jensen Huang,
750
00:42:56.219 --> 00:43:00.400
who is the president and CEO of NVIDIA, said recently
751
00:43:00.539 --> 00:43:03.119
in an interview with Ezra Klein with the New York Times.
752
00:43:03.139 --> 00:43:06.110
It was a podcast interview, and he said, the market
753
00:43:06.179 --> 00:43:09.119
demand for energy is so incredible that this is the
754
00:43:09.199 --> 00:43:12.019
best time in 100 years to improve our power grid,
755
00:43:12.440 --> 00:43:15.059
to make our power grid more sustainable, to lower the
756
00:43:15.099 --> 00:43:18.940
cost of energy, also investing in our sustainable future. He said,
757
00:43:18.960 --> 00:43:21.260
there's no question that in four or five years' time,
758
00:43:21.320 --> 00:43:24.039
we're going to use a lot more fossil fuel, but
759
00:43:24.079 --> 00:43:26.119
also in the next decade in front of us, at
760
00:43:26.159 --> 00:43:28.239
no time in history are we better prepared to move
761
00:43:28.260 --> 00:43:31.019
to sustainable energy. And because the cost of these data
762
00:43:31.039 --> 00:43:33.519
centers is so high, now we're starting to talk about
763
00:43:33.559 --> 00:43:35.710
putting them out in space. We'll see if we start
764
00:43:35.730 --> 00:43:41.159
particularizing space. But this idea that a moment maybe has arrived.
765
00:43:41.380 --> 00:43:44.659
Do you agree with that assessment? I do.
766
00:43:44.699 --> 00:43:48.239
And I think you see, again, because the amount of
767
00:43:48.320 --> 00:43:51.110
capital that is going in, you're seeing lots of innovation.
768
00:43:51.119 --> 00:43:53.869
You're seeing lots of people try different things. And that's
769
00:43:53.909 --> 00:43:57.670
what we need. The other thing that I think that
770
00:43:57.690 --> 00:44:02.489
we have the opportunity, because of data availability, is to
771
00:44:02.550 --> 00:44:05.260
engage the consumer in a way that we have never
772
00:44:05.320 --> 00:44:10.480
engaged them before. Our tariff system for electricity rates was
773
00:44:10.519 --> 00:44:16.809
essentially set in 1890. That same sort of regulated monopoly
774
00:44:17.989 --> 00:44:24.210
structure was created almost 150 years ago because residential consumers
775
00:44:24.250 --> 00:44:27.440
simply didn't have the access to information to make decisions
776
00:44:27.519 --> 00:44:30.039
about their own use. That is simply not true anymore.
777
00:44:30.420 --> 00:44:32.500
I can tell you on my phone right now exactly
778
00:44:32.559 --> 00:44:35.010
how much my home in Cle Elum is using right
779
00:44:35.070 --> 00:44:38.909
now and what utilities are, you know, what appliances rather
780
00:44:39.389 --> 00:44:43.010
are on. Now, I'm a nerd. Not everybody can do that.
781
00:44:43.469 --> 00:44:46.949
But that information is now available. And what you see
782
00:44:47.369 --> 00:44:51.019
at the Utilities Commission is an example of the stress
783
00:44:51.300 --> 00:44:54.760
of that old system where it is, you know, the
784
00:44:54.820 --> 00:44:59.400
Utility Commission talking to the utilities and following laws. And
785
00:44:59.420 --> 00:45:01.199
what happens when the public comes in, they don't know
786
00:45:01.219 --> 00:45:03.639
what to do other than to sort of scream. We
787
00:45:03.679 --> 00:45:07.369
now have an opportunity to give consumers actual power, actual
788
00:45:07.409 --> 00:45:10.949
control over how they use electricity, what it costs, those
789
00:45:10.969 --> 00:45:13.829
other things. I think that's the biggest change that we need.
790
00:45:14.010 --> 00:45:14.769
What would that look like?
791
00:45:15.489 --> 00:45:18.570
Well, it looks like, I think we do need to
792
00:45:18.969 --> 00:45:22.800
give people incentives by saying time of use pricing. People
793
00:45:22.840 --> 00:45:25.639
don't realize that when you use electricity between 4 and
794
00:45:25.639 --> 00:45:29.130
7 p.m., it's much more expensive. And if you simply said, look,
795
00:45:29.610 --> 00:45:32.010
don't wash your dishes, don't dry your clothes, don't do
796
00:45:32.050 --> 00:45:34.309
a few simple things that you don't need to do.
797
00:45:34.449 --> 00:45:35.719
Or charge your car if you happen to have an EV.
798
00:45:35.719 --> 00:45:38.679
Or charge your car, right? Still cook your dinner. Great, right?
799
00:45:38.880 --> 00:45:39.480
That's something you.
800
00:45:39.440 --> 00:45:40.820
Need to do. Save some of those other things for
801
00:45:40.840 --> 00:45:41.659
the overnight hours.
802
00:45:41.780 --> 00:45:42.260
Exactly.
803
00:45:42.300 --> 00:45:42.840
Morning hours.
804
00:45:42.860 --> 00:45:45.139
But because people don't have those signals, they don't pay
805
00:45:45.219 --> 00:45:48.210
for them, they don't understand right now. The best example
806
00:45:48.289 --> 00:45:50.530
that I like to give is when California was looking
807
00:45:50.570 --> 00:45:53.190
at an energy shortage and potential blackouts a couple years ago,
808
00:45:53.570 --> 00:45:55.090
all they did was they sent out a text saying,
809
00:45:55.449 --> 00:45:58.369
to people that said, we're facing shortages, please conserve where
810
00:45:58.389 --> 00:46:01.900
you can. And you can see the curve drop instantly.
811
00:46:02.420 --> 00:46:04.579
So is this, are you agreeing with Reuven Carlisle that
812
00:46:04.599 --> 00:46:06.679
we're not, and I think Arnie Olson also said this,
813
00:46:06.699 --> 00:46:10.480
that we're not doing enough from a conservation standpoint?
814
00:46:13.090 --> 00:46:18.849
Yes, but I think that the standpoint, the conservation approach
815
00:46:18.969 --> 00:46:21.900
so far has been the state saying, you must meet
816
00:46:21.940 --> 00:46:26.739
these arbitrary conservation targets, right? Figure out how, Puget Sound Energy,
817
00:46:26.820 --> 00:46:29.630
figure out how. I think we need to engage consumers
818
00:46:29.690 --> 00:46:32.969
more because the consumers are ultimately the ones who know
819
00:46:33.150 --> 00:46:35.769
best where they can save electricity. And if you give
820
00:46:35.789 --> 00:46:38.909
them a reward for doing so, and just tell them,
821
00:46:39.170 --> 00:46:42.150
make some few simple changes, that changes a lot. But
822
00:46:42.190 --> 00:46:46.130
they're the ones who know, not necessarily, certainly not government,
823
00:46:46.369 --> 00:46:47.650
and maybe not even the utilities.
824
00:46:49.360 --> 00:46:53.679
Attorney General Brown has challenged Avista and PSE on their
825
00:46:53.719 --> 00:46:58.699
rate increase requests, calling them excessive and not justified. He
826
00:46:58.739 --> 00:47:02.239
says that utilities should be prioritizing affordability for consumers, not
827
00:47:02.400 --> 00:47:06.369
increased dividends for wealthy investors, his words. He said that
828
00:47:06.429 --> 00:47:09.610
utility rates should reflect the actual cost of providing these services,
829
00:47:09.650 --> 00:47:11.789
which are far lower than the requests that the companies
830
00:47:11.829 --> 00:47:14.289
are making. And he said that 9% of consumer bills
831
00:47:14.309 --> 00:47:17.019
are going to pay investors less. and that rate payers
832
00:47:17.059 --> 00:47:19.800
are footing the bill for higher executive pay, marketing, and lobbying,
833
00:47:20.400 --> 00:47:22.659
and that that money should come out of the pot
834
00:47:22.679 --> 00:47:27.380
of money that's paying shareholder dividends. He's asking the UTC
835
00:47:27.420 --> 00:47:31.739
to not approve the, I believe, the profit margin increase
836
00:47:31.760 --> 00:47:34.139
that they're requesting. What is your view of this sort
837
00:47:34.159 --> 00:47:38.650
of analysis as a piece of the pricing problem or
838
00:47:38.690 --> 00:47:39.550
the cost issue?
839
00:47:39.809 --> 00:47:42.280
So I have asked about that. this, the utilities, I've
840
00:47:42.340 --> 00:47:44.760
asked them, and they say that for many of the
841
00:47:44.800 --> 00:47:47.460
things that the Attorney General is citing, they don't use
842
00:47:48.579 --> 00:47:52.010
rate money. They do take it out of the rate
843
00:47:52.030 --> 00:47:55.510
of return. I think it's ironic to have a heavily
844
00:47:55.570 --> 00:48:00.170
regulated system with all of these rules. Every year, Olympia
845
00:48:00.210 --> 00:48:02.429
is changing the rules. You have the Utilities Commission, and
846
00:48:02.449 --> 00:48:04.469
then tell them, oh, by the way, you have to
847
00:48:04.510 --> 00:48:07.280
pay for lobbyists on your own time, right? We have
848
00:48:07.429 --> 00:48:11.829
created a highly politicized system And so, yes, they're going
849
00:48:11.869 --> 00:48:14.650
to be, the utilities are going to respond in a
850
00:48:14.670 --> 00:48:17.309
politicized way. I don't think you should be surprised about that.
851
00:48:17.969 --> 00:48:21.389
But even if we do like what the Attorney General says,
852
00:48:21.429 --> 00:48:25.090
which I think was take the rate from just over
853
00:48:25.090 --> 00:48:26.880
10% to just about 8-something percent.
854
00:48:26.889 --> 00:48:27.739
That seems about right.
855
00:48:28.860 --> 00:48:32.780
That's not going to fundamentally change how much people are paying.
856
00:48:33.699 --> 00:48:36.980
And what we have seen from the Attorney General's office
857
00:48:37.039 --> 00:48:41.219
previously is and from legislators is, well, look, this isn't
858
00:48:41.239 --> 00:48:43.980
gonna cost much. We have programs to help the poor.
859
00:48:44.320 --> 00:48:46.900
Don't worry about this. But then when the costs go
860
00:48:47.019 --> 00:48:50.260
up higher than they want, they're like, hey, wait a minute, utilities,
861
00:48:50.320 --> 00:48:53.809
why are you doing this? So they promised this wouldn't happen,
862
00:48:53.829 --> 00:48:55.769
and now that it does, they're trying to point the
863
00:48:55.809 --> 00:48:58.230
finger of blame on someone else. And what I don't
864
00:48:58.289 --> 00:49:01.840
want is pointing that finger of blame to distract from
865
00:49:01.880 --> 00:49:05.159
the more fundamental problems that are driving rates that are
866
00:49:05.280 --> 00:49:08.739
increasing the cost to average folks and addressing that problem.
867
00:49:08.780 --> 00:49:09.949
This can't be a distraction.
868
00:49:10.090 --> 00:49:14.449
When you think about Reuven Carlisle's eight factors, do you
869
00:49:14.489 --> 00:49:16.670
agree with them? Are there any you take off the list?
870
00:49:16.769 --> 00:49:19.170
Would you reorder that list? I don't think he was
871
00:49:19.190 --> 00:49:22.880
giving it to me. necessarily in order, but what's your
872
00:49:22.920 --> 00:49:24.980
response to those eight?
873
00:49:25.340 --> 00:49:30.150
Yeah, I think some of them are wrong. I think that, look,
874
00:49:30.309 --> 00:49:36.590
as I said, I think that the problem we're not seeing,
875
00:49:36.630 --> 00:49:40.630
we're actually not seeing a big reduction in snowpack. We've
876
00:49:40.650 --> 00:49:43.190
seen a fairly, this is kind of surprising, but we've
877
00:49:43.210 --> 00:49:45.570
seen fairly level snowpack. But what does that mean? That
878
00:49:45.630 --> 00:49:48.469
means that we're getting about the same amount of hydro.
879
00:49:48.769 --> 00:49:51.250
And what's interesting is we're actually going to get more hydro.
880
00:49:51.309 --> 00:49:57.449
Both the Pacific Northwest National Labs and the Northwest Power
881
00:49:57.469 --> 00:50:00.670
and Conservation Council say that hydro will go up under
882
00:50:00.730 --> 00:50:05.230
climate change because there's actually more precipitation. Less snowpack, but
883
00:50:05.289 --> 00:50:09.719
more precipitation. So I think I think that people grab
884
00:50:09.800 --> 00:50:12.539
for sort of simple things that seem to make sense.
885
00:50:13.360 -->
00:50:16.360
This is a very complex system. And I think fundamentally,
886
00:50:16.840 --> 00:50:19.820
that I think is one of the major challenges of
887
00:50:20.260 --> 00:50:24.219
CETA and CCA is that they are inflexible systems. They're
888
00:50:24.239 --> 00:50:28.230
very rigid systems. And to deal with the dynamism that
889
00:50:28.269 --> 00:50:32.570
we're seeing with data centers, with changing climate or all
890
00:50:32.590 --> 00:50:35.170
those other things, is you need more flexibility, not less.
891
00:50:35.769 --> 00:50:37.590
And what we have right now is a system that
892
00:50:37.650 --> 00:50:40.550
is very inflexible, that has arbitrary deadlines, and I think
893
00:50:40.590 --> 00:50:42.429
that's causing much of this problem.
894
00:50:42.949 --> 00:50:46.710
The Seattle Times editorial board recently opined on this issue
895
00:50:46.789 --> 00:50:51.150
of CEDA and costs to consumers and noted that the
896
00:50:51.190 --> 00:50:54.469
portfolios of Seattle City Light, Tacoma Power, and the Snohomish
897
00:50:54.570 --> 00:50:58.019
Public Utilities District already hover around 90% for green energy.
898
00:51:01.320 --> 00:51:05.260
and pointed out that it's the investor-owned utilities, Avista and PSE,
899
00:51:05.280 --> 00:51:10.320
that have the furthest to go. Are we really talking
900
00:51:10.400 --> 00:51:15.199
about these? And remind me of the third investor, Pacificor?
901
00:51:15.219 --> 00:51:21.099
It serves Southwest Washington. But I suppose that somebody who's
902
00:51:21.139 --> 00:51:23.300
a proponent of these laws would say, look, the issue
903
00:51:23.489 --> 00:51:27.389
isn't the requirement to go green. Most of these utilities
904
00:51:27.429 --> 00:51:31.250
are already 90% of the way there. This is a
905
00:51:31.329 --> 00:51:34.570
forcing mechanism for the investor-owned utilities, and they can't just
906
00:51:34.610 --> 00:51:37.469
gouge the customers on their way to doing it. How
907
00:51:37.489 --> 00:51:38.030
would you respond?
908
00:51:38.369 --> 00:51:41.349
Well, I do hear that. It's like, well, they're just
909
00:51:41.369 --> 00:51:44.099
gouging the customers. It's like they're literally just trying to
910
00:51:44.179 --> 00:51:47.960
follow the law that you wrote. I think this is
911
00:51:48.800 --> 00:51:50.679
one of the biggest frustrations that I have about our
912
00:51:50.719 --> 00:51:51.480
climate policy.
913
00:51:51.500 --> 00:51:52.780
And by the way, that wasn't the point of the
914
00:51:52.820 --> 00:51:54.960
editorial board. The editorial board said it's up to the
915
00:51:55.000 --> 00:51:56.920
governor and state lawmakers to find a way through this problem.
916
00:51:56.980 --> 00:51:59.769
Yeah, I understand that. one of my frustrations is that
917
00:51:59.809 --> 00:52:02.349
we get all these promises about climate policy. Oh, it
918
00:52:02.389 --> 00:52:04.030
won't increase prices. Oh, it won't do this. Oh, it
919
00:52:04.050 -->
00:52:06.610
won't do that. And then what happens, they say, hey,
920
00:52:06.760 --> 00:52:09.619
this is everybody's fault but ours. It's like, well, no,
921
00:52:10.059 --> 00:52:12.260
you were the one who promised that this wouldn't happen
922
00:52:12.300 --> 00:52:15.639
and you have an obligation to deal with it now
923
00:52:16.239 --> 00:52:20.719
that it is. And so I think that that's, we
924
00:52:20.780 --> 00:52:25.239
have to focus on where the real problems are. You
925
00:52:25.280 --> 00:52:26.920
can't just sort of wave them off.
926
00:52:27.239 --> 00:52:30.079
What about the off-ramps that we discussed and that are
927
00:52:30.159 --> 00:52:33.119
written into CETA? Yeah, it's interesting.
928
00:52:33.159 --> 00:52:38.099
I talked to somebody recently about those off-ramps and who
929
00:52:38.139 --> 00:52:42.260
determines if we have hit those triggers. I think, as
930
00:52:42.539 --> 00:52:45.489
you rightly pointed out, we still have to meet the
931
00:52:45.530 --> 00:52:49.289
targets one way or another. I do think that 2066,
932
00:52:49.269 --> 00:52:55.980
which was the natural gas ban, was an attempt to
933
00:52:56.539 --> 00:53:00.570
help Puget Sound Energy cover its increased costs, but those
934
00:53:00.610 --> 00:53:06.150
costs are ultimately passed on to the consumers. The reality
935
00:53:06.269 --> 00:53:09.269
is that I think that the Utilities Commission has done
936
00:53:09.349 --> 00:53:13.380
a good job recently of recognizing that there are increased costs,
937
00:53:13.480 --> 00:53:16.760
both on CETA and on CCA. And I think as
938
00:53:16.880 --> 00:53:20.199
long as we are in denial about those costs, then
939
00:53:20.219 --> 00:53:22.719
we're going to continue to see them go up. Second,
940
00:53:23.309 --> 00:53:25.679
it's going to make it harder for us to meet
941
00:53:25.820 --> 00:53:29.320
our reliability targets. I think the biggest takeaway from Arne
942
00:53:29.380 --> 00:53:34.380
Olson's study is that we're already behind the curve in
943
00:53:34.420 --> 00:53:38.079
terms of having enough reliable energy to keep the lights on.
944
00:53:38.440 --> 00:53:41.750
Not in a big way, but that grows rapidly over
945
00:53:41.809 --> 00:53:44.909
the next five years. And so we could be, unless
946
00:53:44.949 --> 00:53:47.010
we start catching up and we are not catching up,
947
00:53:47.630 --> 00:53:49.570
we could be in a situation in 2030 where we
948
00:53:49.610 --> 00:53:52.880
are in big trouble, both in terms of costs We
949
00:53:52.920 --> 00:53:55.440
have high costs and low reliability, which is sort of
950
00:53:55.460 --> 00:53:58.940
the worst of both worlds. That's not because Puget Sound
951
00:53:58.980 --> 00:54:01.960
Energy is gouging its customers. That's because the laws are
952
00:54:02.019 --> 00:54:04.860
forcing us to limit how we meet that demand.
953
00:54:05.039 --> 00:54:06.840
I'll just quote back to you what he said. He said,
954
00:54:06.860 --> 00:54:09.079
the most important thing that we can do is weatherize
955
00:54:09.119 --> 00:54:11.480
our homes, ensure that we buy efficient appliances and a
956
00:54:11.519 --> 00:54:13.719
variety of those things, charge our electric vehicles at the
957
00:54:13.760 --> 00:54:16.519
right times, and engage with smart thermostats and other programs
958
00:54:16.539 --> 00:54:18.760
to reduce load, especially during the peak periods.
959
00:54:20.320 --> 00:54:23.780
Yeah, that's exactly right. But it's more than just conservation.
960
00:54:23.860 --> 00:54:25.360
Just briefly, because we have about 20 seconds.
961
00:54:25.639 --> 00:54:27.820
Yeah, it is empowerment of the individual. And I think
962
00:54:27.880 --> 00:54:30.059
this is the key thing that we need to do
963
00:54:30.360 --> 00:54:32.389
is that people for so long, and I think Reuven
964
00:54:32.469 --> 00:54:34.070
said this and I agree with it, that you're used
965
00:54:34.090 --> 00:54:35.829
to just turning on the lights and knowing the lights
966
00:54:35.869 --> 00:54:38.530
will be there. What we need to do now is
967
00:54:38.590 --> 00:54:41.989
engage consumers so they can have more control, both on
968
00:54:42.090 --> 00:54:45.179
costs and on reliability. We have the technology, we have
969
00:54:45.199 --> 00:54:47.500
the ability. We need to make a commitment to do it.
970
00:54:48.110 --> 00:54:48.349
Okay.
971
00:54:48.489 --> 00:54:50.530
Todd Myers with the Washington Policy Center. Thanks again for
972
00:54:50.550 --> 00:54:51.369
coming in. Appreciate it very much.
973
00:54:51.389 --> 00:54:51.849
Thanks for having me.
974
00:54:51.889 --> 00:54:53.829
Good to see you. Thank you for watching Inside Olympia.
975
00:54:53.869 --> 00:54:56.469
We'll continue this conversation in the weeks ahead, and we
976
00:54:56.510 --> 00:54:57.429
will see you again next week.