رونوشت 🔗
1
00:00:00,240 --> 00:00:03,060
- Eugene, we haven't really
talked about privacy much.
2
00:00:03,060 --> 00:00:05,190
- That's 'cause it's none of our business.
3
00:00:05,190 --> 00:00:07,260
- Well, today it's gonna be our business.
4
00:00:07,260 --> 00:00:09,750
- Well, yeah, actually it
should be our business.
5
00:00:09,750 --> 00:00:12,450
It is in many ways free
speech scholars business
6
00:00:12,450 --> 00:00:14,100
to also think about privacy.
7
00:00:14,100 --> 00:00:15,120
Sometimes free speech
8
00:00:15,120 --> 00:00:17,310
and privacy pull in the same direction.
9
00:00:17,310 --> 00:00:19,740
Sometimes you have Right.
10
00:00:19,740 --> 00:00:23,250
Speak free of government,
figuring out whom you're speaking
11
00:00:23,250 --> 00:00:26,400
with, let's say, or what your
identity is and the like.
12
00:00:26,400 --> 00:00:29,190
But a lot of the time, free speech
13
00:00:29,190 --> 00:00:30,930
and privacy pull in opposite directions.
14
00:00:30,930 --> 00:00:33,780
Sometimes privacy rights are rights
15
00:00:33,780 --> 00:00:35,910
to stop people from speaking about you.
16
00:00:35,910 --> 00:00:38,070
That so what's, that's what
we're gonna explore today.
17
00:00:45,300 --> 00:00:47,490
Hello, my name is Eugene Volokh.
18
00:00:47,490 --> 00:00:50,070
I'm a senior fellow at the
Hoover Institution at Stanford
19
00:00:50,070 --> 00:00:51,630
University, and for 30 years,
20
00:00:51,630 --> 00:00:53,790
that was at UCLA law professor,
21
00:00:53,790 --> 00:00:55,950
still Professor emeritus there.
22
00:00:55,950 --> 00:00:58,710
My co-host is Jane Bambauer, the University
23
00:00:58,710 --> 00:00:59,760
of Florida Law School.
24
00:01:00,780 --> 00:01:03,870
We've also studied free
speech and we study privacy.
25
00:01:03,870 --> 00:01:05,280
And we're gonna talk about that today.
26
00:01:06,360 --> 00:01:08,070
Let's, let's start talk.
27
00:01:08,070 --> 00:01:09,870
Let le let's break this
up into two categories.
28
00:01:09,870 --> 00:01:14,870
One is, when does free speech
give you a right to speak
29
00:01:15,480 --> 00:01:16,740
with privacy?
30
00:01:16,740 --> 00:01:18,780
In some sense, that's what free speech
31
00:01:18,780 --> 00:01:21,990
and privacy pull together often
when it's privacy from the
32
00:01:21,990 --> 00:01:23,850
government that you are seeking.
33
00:01:23,850 --> 00:01:26,370
And then maybe you can tell us
34
00:01:26,370 --> 00:01:29,400
after we talk about that, when free speech
35
00:01:29,400 --> 00:01:31,200
and privacy might pull
in opposite direction.
36
00:01:31,200 --> 00:01:33,720
Now, how various privacy
laws in the so-called privacy
37
00:01:33,720 --> 00:01:37,770
torts, how they interact with
the free speech provisions.
38
00:01:37,770 --> 00:01:40,380
- Yeah. Okay. Well, so, so free speech
39
00:01:40,380 --> 00:01:43,380
and privacy go hand in hand
40
00:01:43,380 --> 00:01:45,720
most comfortably when,
41
00:01:46,650 --> 00:01:51,330
when privacy gives people
some relief from governments,
42
00:01:51,330 --> 00:01:55,890
I don't know, prying or
intimidation of some sort that might
43
00:01:55,890 --> 00:01:58,440
otherwise prevent people
from partici fully
44
00:01:58,440 --> 00:01:59,670
participating politically.
45
00:01:59,670 --> 00:02:02,790
So, so for example, you know, the founding
46
00:02:02,790 --> 00:02:07,790
of this country was enabled to some degree
47
00:02:07,830 --> 00:02:10,140
through anonymous pamphlets.
48
00:02:10,140 --> 00:02:11,880
And the people who produced them
49
00:02:11,880 --> 00:02:15,300
and wrote them were taking
on some personal risk
50
00:02:15,300 --> 00:02:16,980
by, by writing them.
51
00:02:16,980 --> 00:02:20,670
And, and, and so today, I mean in part
52
00:02:20,670 --> 00:02:21,720
because of that history,
53
00:02:21,720 --> 00:02:23,160
but in part, just speak for other sort
54
00:02:23,160 --> 00:02:24,810
of theoretical reasons.
55
00:02:24,810 --> 00:02:29,580
The First Amendment provides
a source of privacy from
56
00:02:29,580 --> 00:02:31,170
laws where the government might
57
00:02:31,170 --> 00:02:32,340
otherwise force people
58
00:02:32,340 --> 00:02:34,560
to identify themselves
when they're speaking.
59
00:02:35,580 --> 00:02:37,680
- That's absolutely right.
So here's one example.
60
00:02:39,930 --> 00:02:42,240
There used to be laws that
say, if you wanna hand out
61
00:02:43,230 --> 00:02:45,870
leaflets related to, to politics
62
00:02:45,870 --> 00:02:49,230
or sometimes related to a,
to an elect an election,
63
00:02:49,230 --> 00:02:50,460
you have to sign them.
64
00:02:50,460 --> 00:02:52,800
You have to indicate who you are.
65
00:02:52,800 --> 00:02:54,180
And as a general matter,
66
00:02:54,180 --> 00:02:55,950
the Supreme Court said
that's unconstitutional.
67
00:02:55,950 --> 00:02:58,860
Your right to speak includes
the right to speak anonymous.
68
00:02:58,860 --> 00:03:00,220
And that's for two related reasons.
69
00:03:00,220 --> 00:03:03,310
One is you get to choose what
you write on your pamphlet.
70
00:03:03,310 --> 00:03:05,200
You get to choose what arguments you make,
71
00:03:05,200 --> 00:03:07,150
what arguments you don't
make, what facts you include,
72
00:03:07,150 --> 00:03:08,410
what facts you don't include.
73
00:03:08,410 --> 00:03:11,530
And one such fact is
your name that if they,
74
00:03:11,530 --> 00:03:13,960
that if you want to output to,
75
00:03:13,960 --> 00:03:15,700
to distribute this particular pamphlet
76
00:03:15,700 --> 00:03:17,710
with just these words and
none of them is your name.
77
00:03:17,710 --> 00:03:18,850
Well, you have the right to do that.
78
00:03:18,850 --> 00:03:20,290
Just like you have the
right to say other things.
79
00:03:20,290 --> 00:03:21,850
That's sort of a formal argument
80
00:03:21,850 --> 00:03:23,830
and then a functional
argument that if you have
81
00:03:23,830 --> 00:03:26,860
to identify yourself, you
might not always, of course,
82
00:03:26,860 --> 00:03:29,410
Load full transcript
but you might be deterred
from saying things
83
00:03:29,410 --> 00:03:31,960
that are unpopular that may
lead to government retaliation
84
00:03:31,960 --> 00:03:33,790
or to private retaliation and the like.
85
00:03:34,750 --> 00:03:35,860
Likewise, relatedly,
86
00:03:35,860 --> 00:03:39,280
the Supreme Court held in a
famous case in the late 1950s
87
00:03:39,280 --> 00:03:40,510
involving NAACP
88
00:03:40,510 --> 00:03:43,960
and Alabama, that Alabama
couldn't just say, well, you have
89
00:03:43,960 --> 00:03:46,420
to turn over your membership list to
90
00:03:46,420 --> 00:03:47,420
- Us.
91
00:03:47,420 --> 00:03:48,850
- Right? If you are going
to operate in the state,
92
00:03:48,850 --> 00:03:49,930
including if you're operating
93
00:03:49,930 --> 00:03:51,460
as a non-profit advocacy group,
94
00:03:52,480 --> 00:03:55,600
because in 1950s Alabama, it
would've been pretty risky
95
00:03:55,600 --> 00:03:58,720
for many people to be
identified as NAACP supporters
96
00:03:58,720 --> 00:04:02,170
and they would be deterred by
the presence of this law from,
97
00:04:02,170 --> 00:04:04,450
from supporting the naacp.
98
00:04:04,450 --> 00:04:06,550
So, so that's the general,
99
00:04:06,550 --> 00:04:08,200
but there are, there
are exceptions to that.
100
00:04:08,200 --> 00:04:09,280
Right. Especially when it comes
101
00:04:09,280 --> 00:04:11,470
to election related speech
and Spanish. Yeah, I
102
00:04:11,470 --> 00:04:13,960
- Was just gonna say, people
are probably thinking right now
103
00:04:13,960 --> 00:04:16,450
about the various FEC rules
104
00:04:16,450 --> 00:04:18,880
that require disclosing certain types
105
00:04:18,880 --> 00:04:20,170
of political donations,
106
00:04:20,170 --> 00:04:21,170
- Right?
107
00:04:21,170 --> 00:04:22,003
That's the Federal Election Commission.
108
00:04:22,003 --> 00:04:25,240
And of course it's state analogs as well.
109
00:04:26,260 --> 00:04:28,660
So what have the courts
generally said about such rules
110
00:04:30,730 --> 00:04:34,660
- Generally that they pass
some, some scrutiny given the,
111
00:04:34,660 --> 00:04:38,080
the public interest in
understanding the election system
112
00:04:38,080 --> 00:04:42,100
and making sure that, that
we, under that it's only sort
113
00:04:42,100 --> 00:04:44,920
of legitimate stakeholders,
you know, Americans basically,
114
00:04:44,920 --> 00:04:47,680
that are participating in
the, in funding the elections.
115
00:04:47,680 --> 00:04:49,000
- Right? Right. So there are a
116
00:04:49,000 --> 00:04:50,110
couple of things going on there.
117
00:04:50,110 --> 00:04:52,300
One is there are requirements,
for example, when it comes
118
00:04:52,300 --> 00:04:55,120
to spending with regard to, to
119
00:04:55,120 --> 00:04:57,940
federal election spending
really any money with regard
120
00:04:57,940 --> 00:05:01,120
to federal elections, you
have to be an American citizen
121
00:05:01,120 --> 00:05:03,190
or I believe also a lawful
permanent
president.
122
00:05:03,190 --> 00:05:05,650
But it's illegal for,
for somebody even who,
123
00:05:05,650 --> 00:05:07,960
who perfectly legally here
124
00:05:07,960 --> 00:05:09,310
and maybe legally here for a long time,
125
00:05:09,310 --> 00:05:10,990
if they're not a lawful permanent resident
126
00:05:10,990 --> 00:05:12,970
or a citizen, they
can't, they can't speak.
127
00:05:12,970 --> 00:05:14,320
That's just a general prohibition.
128
00:05:14,320 --> 00:05:17,470
But also everybody,
including including citizens,
129
00:05:17,470 --> 00:05:20,200
if they spend, if they contribute
130
00:05:20,200 --> 00:05:22,600
or often even independently
spend more than a certain
131
00:05:22,600 --> 00:05:25,570
amount, they have to
disclose this to various
132
00:05:25,570 --> 00:05:27,550
election related bodies.
133
00:05:27,550 --> 00:05:29,350
And that may actually end up being
134
00:05:29,350 --> 00:05:31,690
publicized on the website.
135
00:05:31,690 --> 00:05:35,050
The theory there being that
people should be able to know
136
00:05:35,050 --> 00:05:37,210
who it is, who's funding elections.
137
00:05:37,210 --> 00:05:39,160
So the general sense is
138
00:05:39,160 --> 00:05:43,870
that is an limitation on
anonymous speech, on your ability
139
00:05:43,870 --> 00:05:47,170
to either engage in independent
spending anonymously
140
00:05:47,170 --> 00:05:51,160
or contribute so to a candidate
associated with a candidate
141
00:05:51,160 --> 00:05:53,380
by sharing your resources
with a candidate.
142
00:05:53,380 --> 00:05:56,590
So the candidate can, can speak.
143
00:05:56,590 --> 00:05:59,540
It's a, on your ability to
do that anonymously too.
144
00:05:59,540 --> 00:06:01,550
But the sense is that's a,
145
00:06:01,550 --> 00:06:04,640
there's a strong enough
reason supporting those kinds
146
00:06:04,640 --> 00:06:07,610
of restrictions having to do
with maintaining the integrity
147
00:06:07,610 --> 00:06:11,180
of elections and possibly sort
of deterring, for example,
148
00:06:11,180 --> 00:06:13,370
bribery, making it easier
to identify bribery,
149
00:06:13,370 --> 00:06:15,710
making it easier to identify a illegal
150
00:06:15,710 --> 00:06:17,180
spending like foreigner spending.
151
00:06:17,180 --> 00:06:20,750
But also possibly there's
some controversy about whether
152
00:06:20,750 --> 00:06:23,300
this is a sufficient reason, possibly just
153
00:06:23,300 --> 00:06:24,710
to inform the public of
154
00:06:24,710 --> 00:06:26,840
who is spending related to elections.
155
00:06:26,840 --> 00:06:30,710
So the courts say, yes, there
is a presumptive right of it,
156
00:06:30,710 --> 00:06:35,300
of privacy in your, your
who you are as a speaker
157
00:06:35,300 --> 00:06:38,750
and in your associations, but
it's overcome by compelling
158
00:06:38,750 --> 00:06:40,850
or at least important enough interests
159
00:06:40,850 --> 00:06:41,900
in election integrity.
160
00:06:41,900 --> 00:06:43,790
So that's an important, important point
161
00:06:43,790 --> 00:06:46,670
to realize there is a right of privacy
162
00:06:46,670 --> 00:06:49,370
for your speech against the government.
163
00:06:49,370 --> 00:06:52,430
There is a presumption that the
government can't require you
164
00:06:52,430 --> 00:06:55,130
to identify yourself
as the, as the speaker
165
00:06:55,130 --> 00:06:58,010
or to identify yourself as a contributor
166
00:06:58,010 --> 00:07:00,860
of money towards the production of speech.
167
00:07:00,860 --> 00:07:03,770
- But that, and of course
there's also overcome also. Yeah.
168
00:07:03,770 --> 00:07:05,660
And of course there's also
the fourth amendment right
169
00:07:05,660 --> 00:07:08,600
to privacy that I think does not interfere
170
00:07:08,600 --> 00:07:10,640
with the First Amendment
interest in speech and,
171
00:07:10,640 --> 00:07:13,310
and may even facilitate
them to the extent that
172
00:07:14,540 --> 00:07:17,420
if people are worried
about, you know, overzealous
173
00:07:18,290 --> 00:07:20,870
surveillance by the government, generally,
174
00:07:20,870 --> 00:07:22,310
that's usually it's the fourth
175
00:07:22,310 --> 00:07:24,170
amendment that people think about.
176
00:07:24,170 --> 00:07:28,610
And, and if one of the
potential problems from,
177
00:07:28,610 --> 00:07:30,530
from over surveillance is,
178
00:07:31,370 --> 00:07:34,040
is deterring people from
participating in protests or,
179
00:07:34,040 --> 00:07:36,375
or from, you know, using their voice,
180
00:07:36,375 --> 00:07:38,210
then you could see the fourth amendment
181
00:07:38,210 --> 00:07:39,950
and the first amendment as right.
182
00:07:39,950 --> 00:07:41,150
As, as
183
00:07:41,150 --> 00:07:42,150
- Right.
184
00:07:42,150 --> 00:07:42,983
- Working together.
- Yeah.
185
00:07:42,983 --> 00:07:44,750
And historically, historically,
186
00:07:44,750 --> 00:07:46,250
the freedom from unreasonable searches
187
00:07:46,250 --> 00:07:49,580
and seizures has been recognized in,
188
00:07:49,580 --> 00:07:52,940
in part in England it was
recognized in, in important cases,
189
00:07:52,940 --> 00:07:56,480
having to do with, with
searches for alleged libels,
190
00:07:56,480 --> 00:07:59,270
alleged seditious libels
against the government.
191
00:07:59,270 --> 00:08:01,490
Hmm. So yeah, one important
protection we have
192
00:08:01,490 --> 00:08:05,780
for the privacy of our speech is that
193
00:08:05,780 --> 00:08:08,630
the government suspects
that we are, that we are
194
00:08:09,890 --> 00:08:14,600
organizing some, some
political movement or,
195
00:08:14,600 --> 00:08:17,720
or preparing some, some
materials to publish it.
196
00:08:17,720 --> 00:08:18,980
Can't just sort of say, okay, fine,
197
00:08:18,980 --> 00:08:21,680
we're just gonna search your
home, search your computer,
198
00:08:21,680 --> 00:08:23,210
search your yourself phone for that.
199
00:08:23,210 --> 00:08:25,640
It generally needs probable
cause and a warrant
200
00:08:25,640 --> 00:08:27,050
and other such protections.
201
00:08:27,050 --> 00:08:29,270
As for other things, of course
the Fourth Amendment protects
202
00:08:29,270 --> 00:08:31,370
a lot more than just privacy and speech.
203
00:08:31,370 --> 00:08:33,350
But it has historically
204
00:08:33,350 --> 00:08:35,870
and continues to be useful
for protecting that.
205
00:08:35,870 --> 00:08:38,635
Of course, when it comes to such searches
206
00:08:38,635 --> 00:08:40,280
and the related subpoenas,
207
00:08:40,280 --> 00:08:43,100
the protections are necessarily limited.
208
00:08:43,100 --> 00:08:46,100
So if the government does have
probable cause in a warrant
209
00:08:47,090 --> 00:08:49,220
to believe that, for example, that you are
210
00:08:50,240 --> 00:08:52,820
composing death threats
on your computer, you,
211
00:08:52,820 --> 00:08:55,950
they think you're the one who
sent out a constitutionally
212
00:08:55,950 --> 00:08:57,030
death threat, they may be able
213
00:08:57,030 --> 00:08:58,770
to search your, your computer for that.
214
00:08:58,770 --> 00:09:02,550
Likewise, in the civil
justice context, if somebody,
215
00:09:02,550 --> 00:09:07,140
let's say Alan Sues Jane
Doe, turns out it's Betty,
216
00:09:07,140 --> 00:09:08,280
but he doesn't know it's Betty.
217
00:09:09,390 --> 00:09:13,740
Alan Sues Jane Doe saying, she defamed me.
218
00:09:13,740 --> 00:09:17,250
He can then get subpoenas essentially
219
00:09:17,250 --> 00:09:19,410
to simplify here something
that could be backed
220
00:09:19,410 --> 00:09:23,490
by a court order to a, let's say,
221
00:09:23,490 --> 00:09:25,215
interest service provider and right.
222
00:09:25,215 --> 00:09:28,980
And o and other such companies
to try to unmask Betty.
223
00:09:28,980 --> 00:09:31,710
Now courts in the interest
of protecting privacy
224
00:09:31,710 --> 00:09:33,960
of speakers will do some,
225
00:09:33,960 --> 00:09:36,720
some checks beforehand
at least can be asked
226
00:09:36,720 --> 00:09:39,000
by someone representing Jane Doe,
227
00:09:39,000 --> 00:09:41,940
who turns out is secretly Betty to,
228
00:09:41,940 --> 00:09:44,130
to quash the subpoena.
229
00:09:44,130 --> 00:09:47,250
Because let's say Alan
has no legal basis at all.
230
00:09:47,250 --> 00:09:49,950
He is suing over something
that's clearly an opinion,
231
00:09:49,950 --> 00:09:52,920
let's say, so that that too allows
232
00:09:52,920 --> 00:09:54,180
for some protection of privacy.
233
00:09:54,180 --> 00:09:57,570
But if Alan says, look,
Betty accused me of
234
00:09:59,250 --> 00:10:03,420
stealing from her, it's
a factual allegation,
235
00:10:03,420 --> 00:10:04,470
or let's say not stealing from
236
00:10:04,470 --> 00:10:07,020
her, stealing from someone,
right? I stealing from
237
00:10:07,020 --> 00:10:08,070
- Your work or something.
238
00:10:08,070 --> 00:10:10,380
- Right? It's a factual allegation.
239
00:10:10,380 --> 00:10:13,140
I'm denying it, it's certainly something
240
00:10:13,140 --> 00:10:16,410
that would be defamatory if it's false,
241
00:10:16,410 --> 00:10:19,230
and I should be able to argue
to a jury that it's false.
242
00:10:19,230 --> 00:10:22,710
But I can't do that until
I can identify who Betty
243
00:10:22,710 --> 00:10:25,800
or who Jane Doe is again,
turns out that it's Betty
244
00:10:25,800 --> 00:10:28,200
and I can use subpoenas
in order to do that.
245
00:10:28,200 --> 00:10:31,230
So again, there is protection
for privacy for speakers,
246
00:10:31,230 --> 00:10:33,570
but it's not unlimited among other things
247
00:10:33,570 --> 00:10:36,330
because if it were unlimited,
248
00:10:36,330 --> 00:10:39,600
then anybody could anonymously
defame anybody else
249
00:10:39,600 --> 00:10:41,970
or anonymously threaten anybody else.
250
00:10:41,970 --> 00:10:45,240
And then, and then there'd
be no way of unmasking them.
251
00:10:45,240 --> 00:10:46,710
There are ways of unmasking them,
252
00:10:46,710 --> 00:10:48,600
although with some limitations
253
00:10:48,600 --> 00:10:50,550
and some protections
aimed at protecting the
254
00:10:50,550 --> 00:10:52,410
really innocent speakers.
255
00:10:52,410 --> 00:10:57,180
- Okay. So, so far we've
talked about mechanisms
256
00:10:57,180 --> 00:10:58,980
for protecting ourselves, you know,
257
00:10:58,980 --> 00:11:02,370
protecting our privacy
from government compulsion
258
00:11:02,370 --> 00:11:05,010
or government, you
know, revelation or, or,
259
00:11:05,010 --> 00:11:07,560
or acquisition of information.
260
00:11:07,560 --> 00:11:11,820
And that's true even for these
subpoenas, these, you know,
261
00:11:11,820 --> 00:11:15,630
Jane Doe sorts of cases
where ultimately it's a court
262
00:11:15,630 --> 00:11:19,770
that is ordering another
company to provide information
263
00:11:19,770 --> 00:11:22,350
to another, to a party, to a litigant.
264
00:11:22,350 --> 00:11:24,450
But I think first, the first amendment
265
00:11:24,450 --> 00:11:27,360
and privacy get in
266
00:11:27,360 --> 00:11:32,010
the most tension when there
is a private individual
267
00:11:32,010 --> 00:11:34,710
who wants to acquire
268
00:11:34,710 --> 00:11:37,890
or to share information about
another private individual.
269
00:11:37,890 --> 00:11:40,260
- Right. Private in the sense
here of a non-governmental,
270
00:11:40,260 --> 00:11:41,280
- Non-government,
- Right.
271
00:11:41,280 --> 00:11:42,420
Maybe famous, maybe not,
272
00:11:42,420 --> 00:11:44,670
but somebody other than
the government, right?
273
00:11:44,670 --> 00:11:46,140
- Someone other than the
government. That's what that very,
274
00:11:46,140 --> 00:11:47,700
very, yeah, very good clarification.
275
00:11:48,840 --> 00:11:53,770
Because in that case,
the private individual
276
00:11:53,770 --> 00:11:55,570
who wants, you know,
the, the person who wants
277
00:11:55,570 --> 00:12:00,310
to keep their privacy intact,
can't say it's the government
278
00:12:00,310 --> 00:12:02,980
that's causing me some kind of grief.
279
00:12:02,980 --> 00:12:05,350
You know, there's no
state action necessarily.
280
00:12:06,250 --> 00:12:10,690
Instead, their claim has to be,
well, you know, this person,
281
00:12:10,690 --> 00:12:14,620
this defendant wants, wanted
to know something about me
282
00:12:14,620 --> 00:12:16,180
and I just didn't want them to.
283
00:12:16,180 --> 00:12:17,320
And so it is more
284
00:12:17,320 --> 00:12:20,530
of a information interest
versus privacy interest clash,
285
00:12:20,530 --> 00:12:21,760
- Right?
286
00:12:21,760 --> 00:12:25,990
- So that the, the origin
of legal protection that,
287
00:12:25,990 --> 00:12:27,347
- I'm sorry, if I could
just give a, a give a
288
00:12:28,240 --> 00:12:30,070
concrete illustration for our listeners
289
00:12:30,940 --> 00:12:32,740
of the kind of thing that might happen.
290
00:12:32,740 --> 00:12:36,640
So let's say that I am about
291
00:12:36,640 --> 00:12:38,290
to write something on my blog.
292
00:12:38,290 --> 00:12:41,380
I have a blog, it's
hosted by Reason Magazine,
293
00:12:41,380 --> 00:12:45,370
and I am writing a story on, on
294
00:12:45,370 --> 00:12:47,110
that blog about some person,
295
00:12:47,110 --> 00:12:48,970
and I'm about to, to publish about them,
296
00:12:48,970 --> 00:12:51,130
and they say, wait a minute, I don't
297
00:12:51,130 --> 00:12:52,900
want you to write about me.
298
00:12:52,900 --> 00:12:54,250
What about my privacy?
299
00:12:54,250 --> 00:12:58,330
You are disclosing something
I may have filed in court,
300
00:12:58,330 --> 00:12:59,920
or I may have tried to file in court
301
00:12:59,920 --> 00:13:03,100
or something completely
unrelated to court.
302
00:13:03,100 --> 00:13:05,170
I think it should remain private,
303
00:13:05,170 --> 00:13:07,750
or I think my name should remain private.
304
00:13:07,750 --> 00:13:10,720
And I said, but wait a minute,
what about my right to speak?
305
00:13:10,720 --> 00:13:13,870
Why isn't, doesn't my right
to speak, including the right,
306
00:13:13,870 --> 00:13:16,060
include the right to speak your name
307
00:13:16,060 --> 00:13:19,030
and right to speak information about you.
308
00:13:19,030 --> 00:13:21,430
That's the tension between
free speech and privacy.
309
00:13:21,430 --> 00:13:23,740
Often when people assert
privacy against this
310
00:13:23,740 --> 00:13:28,360
non-governmental entity, could
be an individual, could be a,
311
00:13:28,360 --> 00:13:30,075
a newspaper company, could be a,
312
00:13:30,075 --> 00:13:31,870
it could be a nonprofit advocacy
313
00:13:31,870 --> 00:13:33,670
organization, could be whatever else.
314
00:13:33,670 --> 00:13:37,450
They're essentially saying,
stop talking about me,
315
00:13:37,450 --> 00:13:39,370
or at least when you talk about me,
316
00:13:39,370 --> 00:13:42,340
don't disclose certain
information about me.
317
00:13:42,340 --> 00:13:43,510
That's a speech restriction,
318
00:13:43,510 --> 00:13:45,400
maybe a
constitutionally
permissible speech
319
00:13:45,400 --> 00:13:46,720
restriction in some situations.
320
00:13:46,720 --> 00:13:48,550
But it is a speech restriction.
321
00:13:48,550 --> 00:13:50,770
And that's where the, the real tension
322
00:13:50,770 --> 00:13:52,600
between the first amendment and privacy.
323
00:13:52,600 --> 00:13:54,010
That's one example.
324
00:13:54,010 --> 00:13:56,200
Not the only, but one of the
examples where it arises.
325
00:13:56,200 --> 00:13:58,030
Yeah. So Jane, back to you.
326
00:13:58,030 --> 00:14:02,050
- Yeah. Well, so, so one of
the kind of ironies of, of,
327
00:14:02,050 --> 00:14:06,490
of privacy American privacy
law is that its origin story is
328
00:14:06,490 --> 00:14:07,930
sort of surprising and confusing.
329
00:14:07,930 --> 00:14:12,700
So, so the original civil
330
00:14:12,700 --> 00:14:13,810
claims, you know, claims
331
00:14:13,810 --> 00:14:15,970
that people could bring
against each other for privacy,
332
00:14:17,230 --> 00:14:20,950
were inspired by this old
law review article written
333
00:14:20,950 --> 00:14:23,320
by Samuel Warren and,
334
00:14:23,320 --> 00:14:25,570
and Louis Brandeis called
the Right to Privacy,
335
00:14:25,570 --> 00:14:27,160
where they were conceptualizing
336
00:14:27,160 --> 00:14:31,930
how a common law tort claim might work
337
00:14:31,930 --> 00:14:34,930
if someone's pri if someone
felt like they were harmed
338
00:14:34,930 --> 00:14:36,640
by a privacy violation.
339
00:14:36,640 --> 00:14:41,200
And the context, by the way, was that the,
340
00:14:42,070 --> 00:14:45,220
the handheld camera had
recently been invented,
341
00:14:45,220 --> 00:14:47,950
and Samuel Warren, at
least I'm not, I don't,
342
00:14:47,950 --> 00:14:49,840
I don't think this is so true of Brandeis,
343
00:14:49,840 --> 00:14:53,480
but Warren at least used to
have these kind of, you know,
344
00:14:53,480 --> 00:14:56,480
elegant parties sort of, and,
345
00:14:56,480 --> 00:14:59,510
and the, the early versions
346
00:14:59,510 --> 00:15:01,400
of the paparazzi would sometimes show up
347
00:15:01,400 --> 00:15:02,900
and, and take pictures.
348
00:15:02,900 --> 00:15:05,600
And, and so then people's not just names,
349
00:15:05,600 --> 00:15:07,160
but images would be in the tabloids.
350
00:15:07,160 --> 00:15:10,760
And so, so Warren
351
00:15:10,760 --> 00:15:13,790
and Brandeis argued that there ought
352
00:15:13,790 --> 00:15:18,790
to be some relief from
overzealous attempts to
353
00:15:19,070 --> 00:15:21,320
gather information and
share, disclose, you know,
354
00:15:21,320 --> 00:15:25,010
publish information that
would otherwise ordinarily
355
00:15:25,010 --> 00:15:27,680
before the invention of the
camera, at least be private.
356
00:15:28,880 --> 00:15:30,200
And I, I find this ironic
357
00:15:30,200 --> 00:15:33,560
because, you know, Louis
Brandeis at least went on
358
00:15:33,560 --> 00:15:36,500
to become one of the fiercest free speech
359
00:15:38,390 --> 00:15:39,650
kind of advocates.
360
00:15:40,520 --> 00:15:44,210
Many, you know, the, the
strength of the First Amendment
361
00:15:44,210 --> 00:15:47,780
to today is, you know,
362
00:15:47,780 --> 00:15:52,340
is is is greatly affected by
the period when Brandeis and,
363
00:15:52,340 --> 00:15:56,480
and Oliver Wendell Holmes were
writing their famous descent
364
00:15:56,480 --> 00:16:00,200
and sort of expanding the, the reach of,
365
00:16:00,200 --> 00:16:01,730
of First Amendment coverage.
366
00:16:01,730 --> 00:16:05,480
And, and so, so sort of
interesting to imagine
367
00:16:05,480 --> 00:16:09,140
that at least, you know, at least in 1890,
368
00:16:09,140 --> 00:16:11,210
Brandeis felt comfortable arguing
369
00:16:11,210 --> 00:16:13,850
that basically somebody
should be able to have,
370
00:16:13,850 --> 00:16:15,350
he compared it to like an intellectual
371
00:16:15,350 --> 00:16:16,550
property style, right?
372
00:16:16,550 --> 00:16:20,330
To say, Hey, no, this is my information.
373
00:16:20,330 --> 00:16:23,330
You cannot, you cannot use it.
374
00:16:23,330 --> 00:16:25,130
You, you know, you can't
sort of steal it from me.
375
00:16:26,180 --> 00:16:27,740
- Right? And it's interesting, by the way,
376
00:16:28,730 --> 00:16:31,490
it's an interesting
feature of our language.
377
00:16:31,490 --> 00:16:35,060
And by the way, our, our
shared language, English,
378
00:16:35,060 --> 00:16:36,140
the one other language
379
00:16:36,140 --> 00:16:38,780
that I know Russian also has this feature,
380
00:16:38,780 --> 00:16:40,790
maybe it's most languages, maybe in fact
381
00:16:40,790 --> 00:16:45,790
therefore it's suggest,
it's a feature of, of just
382
00:16:45,860 --> 00:16:50,860
human, human mental processes
that we use the same word my,
383
00:16:50,990 --> 00:16:55,340
to refer to things that
belong to me, my house,
384
00:16:57,320 --> 00:17:00,290
and things that are about me, my name,
385
00:17:01,670 --> 00:17:03,530
my life story.
386
00:17:03,530 --> 00:17:06,710
And so it does become the, in some ways,
387
00:17:06,710 --> 00:17:11,450
at least some people intuitive that, well,
388
00:17:11,450 --> 00:17:14,720
just as I'm entitled to
stop you from using my house
389
00:17:14,720 --> 00:17:17,390
to speak, it can't just
barge into my house
390
00:17:17,390 --> 00:17:22,010
or even onto my lawn to
speak as it's mine, my lawn.
391
00:17:22,010 --> 00:17:25,340
I should be able to let
you excuse, excuse me,
392
00:17:25,340 --> 00:17:28,790
I should be able to stop
you from using my name
393
00:17:28,790 --> 00:17:33,770
or my life story because it's mine, right?
394
00:17:33,770 --> 00:17:35,180
So that, that's something intuitive
395
00:17:35,180 --> 00:17:36,470
to many people, to other people.
396
00:17:36,470 --> 00:17:38,210
It's equally intuitive in the other way.
397
00:17:38,210 --> 00:17:42,110
Like, well, of course, if I'm
entitled to talk about things,
398
00:17:42,110 -->
00:17:43,700
one of those things is people.
399
00:17:43,700 --> 00:17:46,430
And that may include people who
don't wanna be talked about.
400
00:17:47,270 --> 00:17:51,720
And that's especially
true if I've grown up in,
401
00:17:51,720 --> 00:17:55,410
in a, a culture with lots
of mass media where all
402
00:17:55,410 --> 00:17:58,590
of these newspaper stories,
stories in television,
403
00:17:58,590 --> 00:18:00,300
stories on the web about people
404
00:18:00,300 --> 00:18:02,820
who may not wanna be written
about criminal defendants,
405
00:18:02,820 --> 00:18:05,370
let's say, or even somebody who hasn't
406
00:18:05,370 --> 00:18:06,690
yet been formally accused
407
00:18:06,690 --> 00:18:08,670
but is suspected of a crime, of course,
408
00:18:08,670 --> 00:18:11,070
they don't want their name
409
00:18:11,070 --> 00:18:13,680
and claims about their lives
410
00:18:13,680 --> 00:18:16,110
and their actions to
be used in a newspaper.
411
00:18:16,110 --> 00:18:18,570
We could say, well, of course
a newspaper is perfectly free
412
00:18:18,570 --> 00:18:20,100
to talk about such thing, right?
413
00:18:20,100 --> 00:18:23,520
Just like it's free to talk
about ideas and about policies.
414
00:18:23,520 --> 00:18:27,630
It's free to talk about
people because people first,
415
00:18:27,630 --> 00:18:29,670
because sometimes
important debates are about
416
00:18:29,670 --> 00:18:31,260
what people allegedly did.
417
00:18:31,260 --> 00:18:35,580
And sometimes because it's hard
to understand abstract ideas
418
00:18:35,580 --> 00:18:39,360
or abstract policy arguments
without seeing real stories.
419
00:18:39,360 --> 00:18:43,620
So that's, I think, one reason
why there is a lot of tension
420
00:18:43,620 --> 00:18:48,150
among, between many people's
understanding of free speech
421
00:18:48,150 --> 00:18:50,910
and privacy and between many people's,
422
00:18:50,910 --> 00:18:53,490
between some people's
understanding of a very broad scope
423
00:18:53,490 --> 00:18:55,740
of privacy rights and others understanding
424
00:18:55,740 --> 00:18:57,330
of a very limited scope,
425
00:18:57,330 --> 00:18:58,680
especially when they're up against other
426
00:18:58,680 --> 00:19:00,630
people's free speech rights.
427
00:19:00,630 --> 00:19:03,060
- Yeah. Well, I mean it to, to illustrate
428
00:19:03,060 --> 00:19:05,160
that there are a lot of,
there are surprising number
429
00:19:05,160 --> 00:19:09,330
of cases that involve a
situation where someone wants
430
00:19:09,330 --> 00:19:11,070
to tell their own story
431
00:19:11,070 --> 00:19:14,430
but must inevitably disclose
something about somebody else.
432
00:19:14,430 --> 00:19:15,750
And so then it's, you know,
433
00:19:15,750 --> 00:19:17,730
one person is legitimately saying, Hey,
434
00:19:17,730 --> 00:19:19,140
that's my life story.
435
00:19:19,140 --> 00:19:21,210
You can't tell my life
story and the other,
436
00:19:21,210 --> 00:19:22,800
and whereas the defendant was say, no,
437
00:19:22,800 --> 00:19:25,680
I'm not telling your story,
I'm telling my story.
438
00:19:25,680 --> 00:19:28,440
You know, so cases that involve, you know,
439
00:19:28,440 --> 00:19:29,730
ex Yeah, go ahead.
440
00:19:30,810 --> 00:19:32,610
- No, no, I'm sorry, go on.
I just wanted to make sure
441
00:19:32,610 --> 00:19:34,980
that we give credit to
one particular scholar
442
00:19:34,980 --> 00:19:36,630
who has written, I think
very interesting stuff
443
00:19:36,630 --> 00:19:37,860
about this, about this.
444
00:19:37,860 --> 00:19:40,080
- Oh, okay. Yeah. So, so ca ca cases
445
00:19:40,080 --> 00:19:43,650
and often involve like,
for example, memoirs
446
00:19:43,650 --> 00:19:48,600
detailing the detailing,
you know, incidents,
447
00:19:48,600 --> 00:19:51,720
sensitive incidents that happen
during a relationship or,
448
00:19:51,720 --> 00:19:53,400
or family drama
449
00:19:53,400 --> 00:19:57,240
that spills out into the Maury
Po show or some stuff like that.
450
00:19:57,240 --> 00:19:59,700
- Right? Right. So that's,
that's absolutely right.
451
00:19:59,700 --> 00:20:03,090
So Sonya West, who is a
professor of the University
452
00:20:03,090 --> 00:20:05,760
of Georgia, had a couple
of articles about,
453
00:20:05,760 --> 00:20:09,450
about free speech and auto
autobiographical speech.
454
00:20:10,290 --> 00:20:15,290
And the first one published
in 2006 is the story of me,
455
00:20:15,570 --> 00:20:18,330
the under protection of,
of autobiographical speech.
456
00:20:18,330 --> 00:20:22,860
And it focuses on kind of
autobiography as protected,
457
00:20:22,860 --> 00:20:26,010
you know, the First Amendment
does protect it very broadly.
458
00:20:26,010 --> 00:20:28,140
Her argument was that
in some ways it's not
459
00:20:28,140 --> 00:20:29,550
as protected as it should be.
460
00:20:29,550 --> 00:20:32,310
And then four years later she
wrote a follow up called The
461
00:20:32,310 --> 00:20:34,950
Story of Us Resolving the Face off
462
00:20:34,950 --> 00:20:37,740
between Autobiographical
speech and Privacy.
463
00:20:37,740 --> 00:20:41,850
And that's because basically almost no
464
00:20:41,850 --> 00:20:45,510
autobiography is really just
auto self biography, right?
465
00:20:45,510 --> 00:20:46,900
That's right. That would be a,
466
00:20:46,900 --> 00:20:48,310
that would be usually a boring
467
00:20:48,310 --> 00:20:52,150
and certainly an extraordinarily
self-absorbed memo.
468
00:20:52,150 --> 00:20:54,040
Let me tell you about everything I did.
469
00:20:54,040 --> 00:20:55,750
And I won't even mention
mention about anybody else.
470
00:20:55,750 --> 00:20:56,980
Mention anyone else. Yes. Right.
471
00:20:58,030 --> 00:21:00,170
So, so, so yeah, yeah, Jen, you,
472
00:21:00,170 --> 00:21:01,180
you, you're absolutely right.
473
00:21:01,180 --> 00:21:04,390
This is actually autobiography.
474
00:21:04,390 --> 00:21:07,690
Well that is an area where
there's a lot of tension here.
475
00:21:07,690 -->
00:21:09,820
But of course, biography even more so,
476
00:21:09,820 --> 00:21:12,160
like there are all these
unauthorized biographies.
477
00:21:12,160 --> 00:21:13,840
Why can't someone say, wait a minute,
478
00:21:13,840 --> 00:21:18,340
you can't make money off of my life story.
479
00:21:18,340 --> 00:21:21,970
Well, because the Lord does
generally protect people's right
480
00:21:21,970 --> 00:21:25,510
to speak about other people,
not withstanding claims
481
00:21:25,510 --> 00:21:27,460
of privacy, but only generally.
482
00:21:27,460 --> 00:21:31,180
So famously, this privacy
tort that you mentioned,
483
00:21:33,100 --> 00:21:35,770
the one that was originally
pioneered in this law journal
484
00:21:35,770 --> 00:21:39,340
article for historical reasons,
485
00:21:39,340 --> 00:21:42,850
legal academics call articles
in learned journals about law.
486
00:21:43,810 --> 00:21:46,120
Excuse me. They're called
learn journalism about law
487
00:21:46,120 --> 00:21:48,010
Law reviews.
488
00:21:48,010 --> 00:21:50,230
It's not necessarily like a book review
489
00:21:50,230 --> 00:21:53,650
or a review essay that's
necessarily derivative of,
490
00:21:54,610 --> 00:21:57,160
of other people's ar articles or books.
491
00:21:57,160 --> 00:21:59,440
That's just what we, what
we call learn a journal.
492
00:21:59,440 --> 00:22:02,230
So this is a famous article
in the Harvard Law Review,
493
00:22:04,900 --> 00:22:09,820
which was written by then
two prominent Boston lawyers,
494
00:22:11,410 --> 00:22:12,400
Louis Brandeis, and I believe
495
00:22:12,400 --> 00:22:13,690
Samuel Warren. I think that was
496
00:22:13,690 --> 00:22:15,010
- Samuel Warren. Yep.
497
00:22:15,010 --> 00:22:19,750
- And it was then adopted,
498
00:22:19,750 --> 00:22:21,820
its ideas were adopted in some measure
499
00:22:21,820 --> 00:22:25,150
by courts throughout the
20th century in the US
500
00:22:25,150 --> 00:22:28,540
and then a,
501
00:22:28,540 --> 00:22:31,750
a famous tort scholar who's
known as Dean Prosser,
502
00:22:31,750 --> 00:22:33,280
'cause he's also a dean,
503
00:22:34,240 --> 00:22:36,970
but I think he was William Pross William,
504
00:22:36,970 --> 00:22:37,970
- Yeah.
505
00:22:39,850 --> 00:22:43,330
- Summarized those cases that had emerged
506
00:22:43,330 --> 00:22:47,200
and as basically forming
four different strands,
507
00:22:47,200 --> 00:22:49,510
basically four privacy torts.
508
00:22:49,510 --> 00:22:51,850
So it's not like there's one tort law rule
509
00:22:51,850 --> 00:22:53,290
of invasion of privacy.
510
00:22:53,290 --> 00:22:57,760
It's four of them. Public
disclosure of private facts,
511
00:22:57,760 --> 00:23:02,620
intrusion upon seclusion,
placing someone in a false light,
512
00:23:02,620 --> 00:23:06,220
and then misappropriation of name
513
00:23:06,220 --> 00:23:09,430
or likeness, also sometimes
known as right of publicity.
514
00:23:10,510 --> 00:23:12,160
So let's start out at least
515
00:23:12,160 --> 00:23:14,320
by talking about these four torts.
516
00:23:14,320 --> 00:23:15,790
Jane, you wanna take maybe the first two,
517
00:23:15,790 --> 00:23:18,640
and I'll take, take the,
the, the last two. Well,
518
00:23:18,640 --> 00:23:20,710
- I'll do intrusion and public disclosure
519
00:23:20,710 --> 00:23:22,510
'cause those I think are the mo I'll do
520
00:23:22,510 --> 00:23:23,510
- Intrusion.
521
00:23:23,510 --> 00:23:24,343
- Sounds
- Good. Okay. Exactly. Those are
522
00:23:24,343 --> 00:23:25,335
the ones I was giving you.
523
00:23:25,335 --> 00:23:28,155
- Oh, okay. See, I know
you right, I do. You do.
524
00:23:29,020 --> 00:23:31,060
Although if we were gonna go in
525
00:23:31,060 --> 00:23:32,350
histor historically accurate order,
526
00:23:32,350 --> 00:23:33,790
we'd start with misappropriation.
527
00:23:33,790 --> 00:23:36,978
Actually, the very first case,
well, I'll let you, I let you
528
00:23:36,978 --> 00:23:37,978
- Mystery.
529
00:23:37,978 --> 00:23:40,120
- Okay, so let's, with intrusion,
530
00:23:40,120 --> 00:23:43,030
intrusion is the privacy tort that,
531
00:23:44,110 --> 00:23:47,840
that addresses efforts by a defendant
532
00:23:47,840 --> 00:23:49,430
to observe
533
00:23:49,430 --> 00:23:53,210
or record information about,
534
00:23:53,210 --> 00:23:55,370
about their target.
535
00:23:55,370 --> 00:23:58,130
So, so if you think of like the lifecycle
536
00:23:58,130 --> 00:24:00,620
of personal information,
at some point it has
537
00:24:00,620 --> 00:24:02,210
to be noticed, right?
538
00:24:02,210 --> 00:24:04,160
At some point someone,
there has to be some fact
539
00:24:04,160 --> 00:24:05,810
that some other person notices
540
00:24:05,810 --> 00:24:09,410
and then later that, that
noticing might lead to a recording
541
00:24:09,410 --> 00:24:11,210
and then that might lead
to a publication, you know,
542
00:24:11,210 --> 00:24:13,490
it's a dissemination and, and whatnot.
543
00:24:13,490 --> 00:24:15,620
But intrusion, I, I like
think, I like starting with it
544
00:24:15,620 --> 00:24:18,680
because in order for anyone other than you
545
00:24:18,680 --> 00:24:21,920
to know something about yourself,
they have to observe you.
546
00:24:21,920 --> 00:24:25,370
So the restatement, the
second restatement of torts,
547
00:24:25,370 --> 00:24:28,640
which also, so in addition to
the law review article that,
548
00:24:28,640 --> 00:24:33,200
that Dean Prosser wrote
that, that Eugene mentioned,
549
00:24:33,200 --> 00:24:37,400
he also was the, what do you,
550
00:24:37,400 --> 00:24:39,110
what does the a LI call that the, the
551
00:24:39,110 --> 00:24:40,110
- Reporter
- Author, the
552
00:24:40,110 --> 00:24:42,110
- Reporter, again, another strange
553
00:24:42,110 --> 00:24:45,590
and somewhat confusing term
reporters law reviews reporter.
554
00:24:45,590 --> 00:24:48,350
- Yes, - Yes. He was the, we
just used the English language
555
00:24:48,350 --> 00:24:50,690
we lawyers in, in a strange
way.
556
00:24:50,690 --> 00:24:54,140
- Yes, yes. To show that we
have secret codes, I guess.
557
00:24:54,140 --> 00:24:57,710
So he was the reporter for the
second restatement of torts.
558
00:24:57,710 --> 00:25:02,000
And, and the, the definition of an intru
559
00:25:02,000 --> 00:25:04,850
of intrusion upon
seclusion is the following.
560
00:25:04,850 --> 00:25:07,910
One who intentionally
intrudes physically or
561
00:25:07,910 --> 00:25:11,750
otherwise upon the solitude
or seclusion of another,
562
00:25:11,750 --> 00:25:15,140
or his private affairs or
concerns is subject to liability
563
00:25:15,140 --> 00:25:16,160
to the other for invasion
564
00:25:16,160 --> 00:25:19,130
of his privacy if the intrusion
would be highly offensive
565
00:25:19,130 --> 00:25:20,930
to a reasonable person.
566
00:25:20,930 --> 00:25:25,280
So when I teach this tort, I, you know,
567
00:25:25,280 --> 00:25:26,720
students often see it
568
00:25:26,720 --> 00:25:29,960
as maybe co co constituting four elements.
569
00:25:29,960 --> 00:25:31,790
You need to intentionally,
570
00:25:31,790 --> 00:25:33,680
so there's a mental state you need
571
00:25:33,680 --> 00:25:36,500
to intrude upon the seclusion.
572
00:25:36,500 --> 00:25:39,470
So you know that you
could think of that maybe
573
00:25:39,470 --> 00:25:41,900
as two elements, or maybe
it's just one thing.
574
00:25:41,900 --> 00:25:46,370
It's like there needs to be
some sort of pri private orbit
575
00:25:46,370 --> 00:25:48,950
or private space
576
00:25:48,950 --> 00:25:52,700
or, you know, kind of circumstance
577
00:25:52,700 --> 00:25:55,130
that then the defendant
needs to intrude into it.
578
00:25:56,570 --> 00:25:59,090
And that observation
579
00:25:59,090 --> 00:26:01,610
or that, you know, that
kind of penetration into
580
00:26:01,610 --> 00:26:04,400
that private space needs to
have been highly offensive.
581
00:26:04,400 --> 00:26:05,540
So it's not enough for it
582
00:26:05,540 --> 00:26:07,400
to have been seclusion in the first place.
583
00:26:07,400 --> 00:26:10,190
It needs to also be a highly
offensive sec intrusion.
584
00:26:11,600 --> 00:26:15,920
The types of cases that are
textbook intrusion are things
585
00:26:15,920 --> 00:26:19,310
that nobody, I think
would object to having
586
00:26:19,310 --> 00:26:21,500
tort liability to protect.
587
00:26:21,500 --> 00:26:26,500
So peeping Tom cases are
classic intrusion cases,
588
00:26:26,510 --> 00:26:28,130
secret recording devices.
589
00:26:28,130 --> 00:26:32,630
Like if a landlord puts
a, a secret, you know,
590
00:26:32,630 --> 00:26:36,950
video camera in in their, in
their tenant's living room
591
00:26:36,950 --> 00:26:39,980
or even bedroom or something
that, that, or wiretaps.
592
00:26:39,980 --> 00:26:44,850
Those are easy cases.
There are also some that,
593
00:26:44,850 --> 00:26:45,810
- By the way, I'm sorry, if I could
594
00:26:45,810 --> 00:26:47,040
just interrupt for a moment.
595
00:26:47,040 --> 00:26:49,170
I think we all know what you
mean by peeping Tom cases.
596
00:26:49,170 --> 00:26:53,970
Someone walks like up to someone's house
597
00:26:53,970 --> 00:26:57,900
and peers through maybe moves
the blinds a little peers
598
00:26:57,900 --> 00:27:00,240
through, maybe they're not
trespassing, maybe for example,
599
00:27:00,240 --> 00:27:04,110
they're standing the outside
of, of an apartment building,
600
00:27:04,980 --> 00:27:07,050
but, but they're, they're
looking in someplace.
601
00:27:07,050 --> 00:27:10,050
They're not really that that,
602
00:27:10,050 --> 00:27:12,540
that under social convention
we accept they're,
603
00:27:12,540 --> 00:27:14,820
they're not really allowed to look into.
604
00:27:14,820 --> 00:27:18,420
Of course, the original peeping
Thomas, as I understand it,
605
00:27:18,420 --> 00:27:20,070
the story is supposedly the one
606
00:27:20,070 --> 00:27:22,410
who spied on Lady Godiva's naked ride.
607
00:27:23,340 --> 00:27:24,600
Right. And
608
00:27:24,600 --> 00:27:26,610
- Oh, well that that would
not be a good case, would it?
609
00:27:26,610 --> 00:27:29,460
- That would not, because
the interesting thing is
610
00:27:29,460 --> 00:27:31,680
that you can't have
intrusion upon seclusion,
611
00:27:31,680 --> 00:27:34,770
generally speaking for
things you observe in public.
612
00:27:34,770 --> 00:27:35,940
Likewise, we're gonna get to some
613
00:27:35,940 --> 00:27:37,650
of the other torts as well.
614
00:27:37,650 --> 00:27:40,170
Generally speaking, people
have the right to observe
615
00:27:40,170 --> 00:27:42,210
and record things in public.
616
00:27:42,210 --> 00:27:45,630
Maybe not in weird
parts, like weird parts,
617
00:27:45,630 --> 00:27:47,820
maybe not from weird
places like for example,
618
00:27:47,820 --> 00:27:50,790
so-called outskirt photography
would be another example
619
00:27:50,790 --> 00:27:52,260
of intrusion upon seclusion.
620
00:27:52,260 --> 00:27:55,620
Even if this is done in public
621
00:27:55,620 --> 00:28:00,330
and someone puts like a, a
camera on a, some rolly thing
622
00:28:00,330 --> 00:28:02,220
and looks up a woman's skirt.
623
00:28:02,220 --> 00:28:05,340
But the actual peeping Tom,
who was just not supposed
624
00:28:05,340 --> 00:28:08,400
to be looking at Lady
Godiva riding naked through,
625
00:28:08,400 --> 00:28:09,630
through town, but actually did,
626
00:28:10,500 --> 00:28:11,670
there wouldn't be torque liability.
627
00:28:13,410 --> 00:28:15,090
So the story he was published in other way
628
00:28:15,090 --> 00:28:17,340
punished in another ways
than torque. But the day
629
00:28:17,340 --> 00:28:18,340
- Yes, that's right.
630
00:28:18,340 --> 00:28:21,030
- Today I would defend that
man against a tor lamp.
631
00:28:21,030 --> 00:28:22,410
- Yeah, I I agree.
632
00:28:22,410 --> 00:28:25,080
We shouldn't all have to avert
our eyes in public. Come on.
633
00:28:25,080 --> 00:28:28,110
Exactly. Exactly. Well one,
one of my favorite cases
634
00:28:28,110 --> 00:28:31,320
for really illustrating how
the tort works, involves,
635
00:28:32,370 --> 00:28:34,980
involves a, a public bathroom
636
00:28:34,980 --> 00:28:37,380
because everyone has had the
experience where as you walk
637
00:28:37,380 --> 00:28:39,720
by a stall, especially if
it's an older one where
638
00:28:39,720 --> 00:28:40,920
that's kind of gappy,
639
00:28:40,920 --> 00:28:44,130
you can sometimes see the
people who are using them.
640
00:28:45,180 --> 00:28:47,070
But, and that's sort of,
641
00:28:47,070 --> 00:28:49,170
so there could be
unintentional observation,
642
00:28:49,170 --> 00:28:50,400
maybe you don't see anything important,
643
00:28:50,400 --> 00:28:52,830
but, you know, that type
644
00:28:52,830 --> 00:28:55,800
of unintentional observation
would be the sort of thing
645
00:28:55,800 --> 00:28:59,640
where even if you did
accidentally learn, you know, sort
646
00:28:59,640 --> 00:29:02,070
of intruder learn something
private about somebody,
647
00:29:03,030 --> 00:29:04,410
the tort wouldn't apply.
648
00:29:04,410 --> 00:29:07,380
But on the other hand, if you
go walk into a public restroom
649
00:29:07,380 --> 00:29:12,380
and you, you know, take effort
to peer between the slats,
650
00:29:12,390 --> 00:29:14,850
that would, that would be
a good case of intrusion.
651
00:29:14,850 --> 00:29:16,800
And indeed there are those cases.
652
00:29:16,800 --> 00:29:19,050
So, but I,
653
00:29:19,050 --> 00:29:23,580
there are harder cases within
the intrusion tort harder in
654
00:29:23,580 --> 00:29:25,710
terms for me at least, of squaring
655
00:29:25,710 --> 00:29:29,310
with First Amendment norms
that involve instances
656
00:29:29,310 --> 00:29:33,420
where people are in a situation where
657
00:29:34,290 --> 00:29:36,090
they are allowed to observe.
658
00:29:36,090 --> 00:29:37,440
Either they're in public
659
00:29:37,440 --> 00:29:39,870
or they're a social guest or something.
660
00:29:39,870 --> 00:29:43,720
They're, they're there, the,
the, the, the, you know,
661
00:29:43,720 --> 00:29:46,960
the subject of of interest
knows that they are there,
662
00:29:48,340 --> 00:29:52,330
but the defendant Vince
secretly records what happens.
663
00:29:52,330 --> 00:29:56,950
Mm. So there are successful cases finding
664
00:29:56,950 --> 00:29:59,380
that a, that that a plaintiff can sue
665
00:29:59,380 --> 00:30:01,090
and say, yes, I know that you were there,
666
00:30:01,090 --> 00:30:02,890
I know you heard everything I did,
667
00:30:02,890 --> 00:30:05,620
I know you saw everything
I did in my living room,
668
00:30:05,620 --> 00:30:09,550
but I didn't give you
permission to record that.
669
00:30:10,600 --> 00:30:15,130
And, and so that means that the nature
670
00:30:15,130 --> 00:30:19,480
of the privacy violation isn't
acquiring the information in
671
00:30:19,480 --> 00:30:21,790
the first place, but it's
getting it into a medium
672
00:30:21,790 --> 00:30:26,080
that can then be shared later
or preserved for memory sake.
673
00:30:28,090 --> 00:30:31,480
And so, so for a long
time, courts, I'd say they,
674
00:30:31,480 --> 00:30:33,280
they did not really recognize much
675
00:30:33,280 --> 00:30:35,710
of a first amendment in issue.
676
00:30:36,850 --> 00:30:40,660
The, you know, they, I think
they thought once there's a new
677
00:30:40,660 --> 00:30:43,750
recording technology that hasn't
been specifically consented
678
00:30:43,750 --> 00:30:46,690
to and you're in an
otherwise seclusion type of
679
00:30:48,160 --> 00:30:51,010
situation, those cases can proceed.
680
00:30:51,010 --> 00:30:55,000
But, but things I think
have taken a turn in part
681
00:30:55,000 --> 00:30:59,560
because of states that have
all party wiretap acts.
682
00:30:59,560 --> 00:31:01,360
And so I think I have to
explain what that is in order
683
00:31:01,360 --> 00:31:03,040
- To say Yeah, especially
since they're not really
684
00:31:03,040 --> 00:31:04,120
about wiretaps anymore.
685
00:31:05,170 --> 00:31:07,330
- Yeah, no, they're not. Right. Okay.
686
00:31:07,330 --> 00:31:11,080
So, so federal wiretap,
actually, I dunno, we can talk,
687
00:31:11,080 --> 00:31:12,250
maybe we'll go straight to the states.
688
00:31:12,250 --> 00:31:15,880
So every, you know, every state
has some kind of wiretap law
689
00:31:15,880 --> 00:31:18,100
that prevents recording conversations
690
00:31:18,100 --> 00:31:19,630
to which you are not a party.
691
00:31:21,220 --> 00:31:23,860
Private conversations to
which you are not a party.
692
00:31:23,860 --> 00:31:26,590
But some states they have wiretap laws
693
00:31:26,590 --> 00:31:30,040
that not only prevent you
from secretly recording con
694
00:31:30,040 --> 00:31:31,810
private conversations to
which you aren't a party,
695
00:31:31,810 --> 00:31:34,210
but also secretly recording conversations
696
00:31:34,210 --> 00:31:35,410
to which you are a party
697
00:31:35,410 --> 00:31:37,450
unless you have everybody else's consent.
698
00:31:38,560 --> 00:31:43,090
And these state wiretap statutes
have occasionally been used
699
00:31:43,090 --> 00:31:46,480
or have attempted to be
used by police officers
700
00:31:46,480 --> 00:31:51,190
who are recorded while doing their public,
701
00:31:51,190 --> 00:31:54,280
you know, public job in
public while arresting
702
00:31:54,280 --> 00:31:55,330
somebody, for example.
703
00:31:56,350 --> 00:32:00,520
And so, and so in these cases,
704
00:32:00,520 --> 00:32:02,530
at this point now, every circuit that
705
00:32:02,530 --> 00:32:04,300
that has considered them has found
706
00:32:04,300 --> 00:32:07,750
that the police cannot use a wiretap,
707
00:32:07,750 --> 00:32:10,660
a state wiretap statute to sue
708
00:32:10,660 --> 00:32:15,660
for civil damages against
somebody who has recorded their,
709
00:32:15,790 --> 00:32:18,165
their con their conduct in, in public.
710
00:32:18,165 --> 00:32:19,965
- At least in a public place. Yes.
711
00:32:19,965
--> 00:32:21,250
- At least in a public place. Yeah.
712
00:32:22,660 --> 00:32:25,060
But then that raises the
question, well, so why it does
713
00:32:25,060 --> 00:32:26,950
so is there first amendment coverage
714
00:32:26,950 --> 00:32:30,610
or isn't there, so do we have
a right to record or not?
715
00:32:30,610 --> 00:32:33,040
And so I, I think by recognizing
716
00:32:33,040 --> 00:32:37,570
that we have an interest in
not just acquiring knowledge,
717
00:32:37,570 --> 00:32:39,890
but preserving it in a
form where we, we can,
718
00:32:39,890 --> 00:32:42,500
in a highly credible way,
tell others what happened.
719
00:32:43,550 --> 00:32:45,620
The courts are basically admitting
720
00:32:45,620 --> 00:32:47,090
that there is some tension
721
00:32:47,090 --> 00:32:50,960
between the intrusion tort
722
00:32:50,960 --> 00:32:54,260
or the, the con, you know,
the, the, like the, the concept
723
00:32:54,260 --> 00:32:57,560
of, of a acquire of, of recording and,
724
00:32:57,560 --> 00:32:59,210
and first amendment address,
725
00:32:59,210 --> 00:33:00,210
- Right?
726
00:33:00,210 --> 00:33:02,600
So that, that's right. So
there are the, these states,
727
00:33:02,600 --> 00:33:04,220
the so-called two party consent states,
728
00:33:04,220 --> 00:33:06,020
I believe there are about a dozen of them.
729
00:33:06,020 --> 00:33:08,510
So it's, it's a, it's a
minority of states, but
730
00:33:08,510 --> 00:33:12,350
but substantial number
including Mount La Ponia,
731
00:33:12,350 --> 00:33:15,830
which is the big state which
do say essentially that
732
00:33:19,580 --> 00:33:24,110
in order to to, to record
a conversation, you need
733
00:33:24,110 --> 00:33:25,550
to have the permission of everybody,
734
00:33:25,550 --> 00:33:27,410
or at least the knowledge of everybody.
735
00:33:27,410 --> 00:33:30,200
So may most of these
state laws are limited
736
00:33:30,200 --> 00:33:32,630
to surreptitious recording,
although not, not all.
737
00:33:33,535 --> 00:33:36,260
And everybody's a party
to the conversation.
738
00:33:36,260 --> 00:33:37,700
So that affects, for example,
739
00:33:37,700 --> 00:33:39,560
people's ability to record the police.
740
00:33:39,560 --> 00:33:42,260
It also affects a traditional,
741
00:33:42,260 --> 00:33:46,310
although always I think a
little, a little dicey, but,
742
00:33:46,310 --> 00:33:50,000
but in some measure,
long established practice
743
00:33:50,000 --> 00:33:51,980
of the hidden camera being used
744
00:33:51,980 --> 00:33:55,970
to capture people admitting
doing something really bad.
745
00:33:55,970 --> 00:33:57,440
That was something that,
746
00:33:57,440 --> 00:34:00,290
that historically major
news organizations had
747
00:34:00,290 --> 00:34:01,580
routinely done.
748
00:34:01,580 --> 00:34:03,770
They had an interview with someone or,
749
00:34:03,770 --> 00:34:05,810
or they didn't frame it as an interview
750
00:34:05,810 --> 00:34:08,720
that just looked like somebody
is going to some business
751
00:34:08,720 --> 00:34:11,900
or to some person and
asking them about something.
752
00:34:11,900 --> 00:34:15,470
They, that person would never
have admitted it if they knew
753
00:34:15,470 --> 00:34:17,330
that it would be reported and broadcasted
754
00:34:18,980 --> 00:34:20,300
on national television,
755
00:34:20,300 --> 00:34:23,150
but not realizing they do
admit it, then they say, well,
756
00:34:23,150 --> 00:34:25,850
you are on, I guess there's,
you are on Candid camera.
757
00:34:25,850 --> 00:34:28,550
That's a line from an old show.
I don't remember. I get the
758
00:34:28,550 --> 00:34:29,660
- Reference. But
759
00:34:29,660 --> 00:34:31,010
- Yeah, so,
760
00:34:31,010 --> 00:34:33,530
so I'm not sure whether they
then got the permission.
761
00:34:33,530 --> 00:34:34,910
'cause I don't think this was sort
762
00:34:34,910 --> 00:34:37,910
of investigative journalism,
the camera show, but there,
763
00:34:37,910 --> 00:34:40,340
but there were such, I believe
60 Minutes for example, used
764
00:34:40,340 --> 00:34:42,200
to do that pretty, pretty regularly.
765
00:34:43,040 --> 00:34:47,300
And generally it's, it's
understood that that is,
766
00:34:47,300 --> 00:34:49,880
that there's, this is at
least an established part
767
00:34:49,880 --> 00:34:53,660
of news gathering, but an
interesting question is
768
00:34:53,660 --> 00:34:56,480
if is can that in fact be made illegal?
769
00:34:56,480 --> 00:35:00,980
And of course if you make it
illegal for ordinary folk,
770
00:35:00,980 --> 00:35:02,930
you know, I suppose you
could have a statute
771
00:35:02,930 --> 00:35:05,390
that exempts established
news organizations,
772
00:35:05,390 --> 00:35:07,580
but the First Amendment doesn't
draw a distinction in an
773
00:35:07,580 --> 00:35:10,100
established news
organization and an upstart,
774
00:35:10,100 --> 00:35:13,250
or just one person who styles
himself a citizen journalist.
775
00:35:13,250 --> 00:35:17,150
So yeah, there is still this
tension there, both with regard
776
00:35:17,150 --> 00:35:18,800
to the intrusion upon seclusion tort
777
00:35:18,800 --> 00:35:22,460
and with regard to these
laws, which are state statutes
778
00:35:22,460 --> 00:35:26,150
that sort of operate on
similar about that, that deal
779
00:35:26,150 --> 00:35:27,260
with similar concerns
780
00:35:27,260 --> 00:35:29,630
to the intrusion upon seclusion
toward often there are
781
00:35:29,630 --> 00:35:31,910
clearer or more precise, narrower,
782
00:35:31,910 --> 00:35:33,830
but often more forceful in po
783
00:35:33,830 --> 00:35:35,540
potentially post criminal
liability. Criminal
784
00:35:35,540 --> 00:35:36,540
- Li yeah,
- Exactly.
785
00:35:36,540 --> 00:35:37,590
Foreign statute sometimes.
786
00:35:37,590 --> 00:35:40,800
So that's intrusion upon
seclusion generally not that much
787
00:35:40,800 --> 00:35:42,300
of a First Amendment problem is to many
788
00:35:42,300 --> 00:35:44,010
of its applications in part
789
00:35:44,010 --> 00:35:48,240
because the focus is on
intruding physical intrusion into
790
00:35:48,240 --> 00:35:51,030
certain places, or at least
sensory intrusion in certain
791
00:35:51,030 --> 00:35:54,600
places as opposed to the
communication of particular things.
792
00:35:54,600 --> 00:35:57,720
But the disclosure of private
facts to really is a law
793
00:35:57,720 --> 00:35:58,920
that limits the ability
794
00:35:58,920 --> 00:36:01,680
to speak about people.
So tell us about that.
795
00:36:01,680 --> 00:36:05,520
- Yep. Okay. So the second
restatement defines public
796
00:36:05,520 --> 00:36:07,620
disclosure of private
facts as the following.
797
00:36:07,620 --> 00:36:10,260
One who gives publicity to a matter
798
00:36:10,260 --> 00:36:13,050
concerning the private
life of another is subject
799
00:36:13,050 --> 00:36:15,420
to liability to the other
for invasion of privacy.
800
00:36:15,420 --> 00:36:20,100
If the matter publicized is a kind that a,
801
00:36:20,100 --> 00:36:22,290
would be highly offensive
to a reasonable person.
802
00:36:22,290 --> 00:36:24,960
So there's that highly
offensive language again,
803
00:36:24,960 --> 00:36:29,220
and b is not of legitimate
concern to the public.
804
00:36:29,220 --> 00:36:31,530
So the idea is you need to have some sort
805
00:36:31,530 --> 00:36:33,750
of fact about somebody that is private.
806
00:36:33,750 --> 00:36:38,580
Anything that's generally
known to a broad enough
807
00:36:39,510 --> 00:36:43,200
community would, would
not be a private fact.
808
00:36:44,430 --> 00:36:46,920
You as a defendant have to
have given publicity to that.
809
00:36:46,920 --> 00:36:51,920
So that's, that is a, a narrower
810
00:36:52,290 --> 00:36:57,120
concept than the defamation
publication standards.
811
00:36:57,120 --> 00:36:59,610
So last, in our last show we
talked about the publication
812
00:36:59,610 --> 00:37:02,160
requirement where you can just
tell one other person who's
813
00:37:02,160 --> 00:37:03,540
not the plaintiff and
814
00:37:03,540 --> 00:37:06,270
that satisfies publication
publicity requires
815
00:37:06,270 --> 00:37:07,530
something broader than that.
816
00:37:07,530 --> 00:37:10,110
It's, you know, broad distribution,
817
00:37:10,110 --> 00:37:13,800
or at least the abil, you know,
the, the potential to, to,
818
00:37:13,800 --> 00:37:17,010
for the fact to reach a broad audience.
819
00:37:18,930 --> 00:37:21,390
And, and of course the tort,
though you might notice,
820
00:37:21,390 --> 00:37:24,480
has a little bit of a first amendment
821
00:37:24,480 --> 00:37:29,250
release valve built into it,
which is that also, even if
822
00:37:29,250 --> 00:37:33,120
that private fact is
given publicity, it needs
823
00:37:33,120 --> 00:37:37,020
to both be highly offensive
and not of legitimate concern.
824
00:37:37,020 --> 00:37:40,770
So, so those,
825
00:37:41,760 --> 00:37:45,990
those requirements are
quite hard arduous for,
826
00:37:45,990 --> 00:37:50,370
for plaintiffs to meet, especially
827
00:37:50,370 --> 00:37:52,980
because, or at least, you
know, there, there are a lot
828
00:37:52,980 --> 00:37:56,580
of the courts are, are pretty
willing to, to acknowledge
829
00:37:56,580 --> 00:38:01,560
that, that if generally speaking
people are interested in a
830
00:38:01,560 --> 00:38:06,090
fact about somebody, then it
would be, it would require,
831
00:38:06,990 --> 00:38:09,120
you know, it would put courts
in a difficult position
832
00:38:09,120 --> 00:38:13,020
to say, okay, it might
be interesting to you
833
00:38:13,020 --> 00:38:14,610
that this politician is gay,
834
00:38:14,610 --> 00:38:16,080
but we're just gonna say you shouldn't,
835
00:38:16,080 --> 00:38:18,270
you shouldn't be interested
in that, for example.
836
00:38:20,460 --> 00:38:25,380
And, and so as a result,
the cases I, I tell you
837
00:38:25,380 --> 00:38:29,190
that there are still some easy
cases, easy cases have, are,
838
00:38:29,190 --> 00:38:31,740
are, are tend to have to
do with sex and death.
839
00:38:31,740 --> 00:38:36,740
So revenge porn, even though
lots of states now have
840
00:38:37,210 --> 00:38:40,660
revenge porn statutes, they
in a way maybe didn't really,
841
00:38:40,660 --> 00:38:42,970
you know, many of them wouldn't
have needed it in the sense
842
00:38:42,970 --> 00:38:45,760
that there was that, that that this,
843
00:38:45,760 --> 00:38:48,280
this tort would cover the circumstances
844
00:38:48,280 --> 00:38:49,780
of revenge porn pretty easily.
845
00:38:51,580 --> 00:38:55,900
And, and then gruesome
photographs taken of, of
846
00:38:56,920 --> 00:39:00,640
of, you know, basically
family members who passed away
847
00:39:00,640 --> 00:39:05,620
and then are passed around
as, for example, for example,
848
00:39:05,620 --> 00:39:08,320
Halloween cards, people,
849
00:39:08,320 --> 00:39:09,670
people are really disgusting sometimes.
850
00:39:09,670 --> 00:39:13,180
Anyway, those types of
cases also are easy cases
851
00:39:13,180 --> 00:39:14,230
of public disclosure.
852
00:39:15,580 --> 00:39:17,290
Many, you know, but,
853
00:39:17,290 --> 00:39:19,450
but it, that
854
00:39:20,560 --> 00:39:22,690
tho I I'd say those are
the only two categories
855
00:39:22,690 --> 00:39:26,145
that I find routinely,
you know, satisfy the,
856
00:39:26,145 --> 00:39:29,560
the court's concern about having no
857
00:39:29,560 --> 00:39:31,870
valid public interest.
858
00:39:31,870 --> 00:39:34,360
Eugene, am I missing
some category of cases?
859
00:39:34,360 --> 00:39:36,520
- No, no, I, I think,
I think that's right.
860
00:39:36,520 --> 00:39:39,640
I think that this is the
part, one of the privacy torts
861
00:39:39,640 --> 00:39:44,530
that seems to most butt up
against the First Amendment.
862
00:39:44,530 --> 00:39:46,810
And in the battle between free speech
863
00:39:46,810 --> 00:39:49,930
and privacy in this area, free
speech is largely prevailed.
864
00:39:51,370 -->
00:39:53,380
Again, part of it,
because historically a lot
865
00:39:53,380 --> 00:39:55,900
of the lawsuits were brought
against media organizations.
866
00:39:55,900 --> 00:39:57,910
And it's hard to say to
the newspaper, well, yeah,
867
00:39:57,910 --> 00:40:00,220
this is not a matter of
legitimate or public concern.
868
00:40:00,220 --> 00:40:03,460
True. You are in the business
of, of informing the public.
869
00:40:03,460 --> 00:40:06,820
You think it's a public concern,
your readers snap it up.
870
00:40:06,820 --> 00:40:08,680
But we, the judges say it's not a matter
871
00:40:08,680 --> 00:40:09,820
of legitimate public concern,
872
00:40:09,820 --> 00:40:10,820
- Right?
873
00:40:10,820 --> 00:40:12,550
- The judges are reluctant to
do then of course these days,
874
00:40:12,550 --> 00:40:15,250
a lot of things that are
posted on the internet and we,
875
00:40:15,250 --> 00:40:18,190
and reach a wide audience
876
00:40:18,190 --> 00:40:20,230
are not from established
media organization.
877
00:40:20,230 --> 00:40:22,870
So maybe a judge could
say, well, yeah, you,
878
00:40:22,870 --> 00:40:27,130
you Joe Schmo who's posting
something on this on,
879
00:40:27,130 --> 00:40:30,370
on social media, you might
think it's important,
880
00:40:30,370 --> 00:40:31,450
but we, we don't agree.
881
00:40:32,350 --> 00:40:34,420
You couldn't even get some
newspaper interested in it
882
00:40:34,420 --> 00:40:36,070
or some such, so, yeah, so, so one
883
00:40:36,070 --> 00:40:38,410
- Example of that might be
the Gawker case, the case
884
00:40:38,410 --> 00:40:39,880
that brought down Gawker by Bolio.
885
00:40:39,880 --> 00:40:42,250
- Right. Although there
it was a media outlet
886
00:40:42,250 --> 00:40:44,380
and this was sex, this was a sex tape.
887
00:40:44,380 --> 00:40:47,545
- Yeah. But, okay, you're
considering Gawker.
888
00:40:47,545 --> 00:40:49,330
I I thought new media,
I thought you said post
889
00:40:49,330 --> 00:40:50,330
- It on the internet.
890
00:40:50,330 --> 00:40:51,455
No, I'm talking about new
media in the sense like,
891
00:40:51,455 --> 00:40:52,720
like like social media.
892
00:40:52,720 --> 00:40:54,190
A little guy who
893
00:40:54,190 --> 00:40:55,190
- Yeah.
894
00:40:55,190 --> 00:40:57,100
- Who po post post things just
895
00:40:57,100 --> 00:40:59,320
because he's interested it may not really.
896
00:40:59,320 --> 00:41:00,850
- Okay, I see, I see, I see.
897
00:41:00,850 --> 00:41:02,985
Gawker at least has to maintain
an audience. I gotcha's
898
00:41:02,985 --> 00:41:03,985
- Hard to know.
899
00:41:03,985 --> 00:41:06,700
I think the Gawker case, the
one the bankrupted guer, yeah.
900
00:41:06,700 --> 00:41:09,460
Having to do with the, I
believe Hulk Hogan sex tape.
901
00:41:09,460 --> 00:41:11,080
Correct. There,
902
00:41:11,080 --> 00:41:14,290
I think it fit pretty neatly
into the the traditional,
903
00:41:16,300 --> 00:41:18,010
traditional, oh that principle
904
00:41:18,010 --> 00:41:21,370
that there's not really a ma
much legitimate public concern.
905
00:41:21,370 --> 00:41:24,010
Oversimplify here, the case
was more complicated than that.
906
00:41:24,010 --> 00:41:26,140
There's not really much in
legitimate public concern about
907
00:41:26,140 --> 00:41:28,720
in how a person looks
while they're having sex.
908
00:41:30,100 --> 00:41:33,950
So, so in any case, so
as a general matter,
909
00:41:33,950 --> 00:41:36,080
courts historically have
read it pretty narrowly
910
00:41:36,080 --> 00:41:39,590
and the Supreme Court has nudged
in that direction as well.
911
00:41:39,590 --> 00:41:43,850
So the most famous case on
this is Florida Star, VBJF.
912
00:41:44,750 --> 00:41:47,930
And that involved the
publication of the name of a,
913
00:41:47,930 --> 00:41:50,120
of a rape victim.
914
00:41:51,290 --> 00:41:54,080
This woman tells the p
police she's been raped.
915
00:41:55,070 --> 00:41:57,410
The police department has a policy
916
00:41:57,410 --> 00:41:59,330
of not including the names
917
00:41:59,330 --> 00:42:01,880
of rape victims in the crime report
918
00:42:01,880 --> 00:42:05,900
that is then passed along
to local media outlets,
919
00:42:05,900 --> 00:42:07,490
the reporters in the newsroom
920
00:42:07,490 --> 00:42:10,250
or such as it is of the
local police station.
921
00:42:10,250 --> 00:42:12,680
But this policy wasn't
followed in that instance,
922
00:42:12,680 --> 00:42:14,750
just there was a school
on, it was an accident.
923
00:42:14,750 --> 00:42:17,360
- Yeah.
- And then Florida Star,
924
00:42:17,360 --> 00:42:20,840
a weekly newspaper in Jacksonville
publishes in its police
925
00:42:20,840 --> 00:42:25,700
reports section the,
something about this incident,
926
00:42:25,700 --> 00:42:27,920
including this woman's name.
927
00:42:27,920 --> 00:42:31,220
So she then sues under a Florida statute
928
00:42:31,220 --> 00:42:34,040
that specifically prohibits
the publication of the,
929
00:42:34,040 --> 00:42:35,180
of the names of rape victims
930
00:42:35,180 --> 00:42:37,665
or even just of alleged rape victims.
931
00:42:37,665 --> 00:42:42,665
Adam. And in particular
the Supreme Court said
932
00:42:42,890 --> 00:42:44,810
that generally speaking,
933
00:42:44,810 --> 00:42:47,600
there can't be privacy claims
based on information drawn
934
00:42:47,600 --> 00:42:49,520
from government records.
935
00:42:49,520 --> 00:42:52,940
Classic example is a court
record Filing in court,
936
00:42:52,940 --> 00:42:56,450
which often in a, in a
various cases has a lot
937
00:42:56,450 --> 00:43:00,110
of personal details about
people or a police report
938
00:43:00,110 --> 00:43:02,150
or something else
released by the government
939
00:43:02,150 --> 00:43:03,980
that people should be able to say, look,
940
00:43:03,980 --> 00:43:07,010
if the government releases
it, we are entitled
941
00:43:07,010 --> 00:43:10,250
to publish it without then
having to worry about whether,
942
00:43:10,250 -->
00:43:12,590
well, is this something that
might be seen as private,
943
00:43:12,590 --> 00:43:15,110
is it might violate some, some state law.
944
00:43:17,210 --> 00:43:21,470
And that's a very important
protection. It's of course not.
945
00:43:21,470 --> 00:43:25,310
Categorical protection
doesn't invalidate the dis the
946
00:43:25,310 --> 00:43:28,460
disclosure torts and the
Supreme Court made clear,
947
00:43:28,460 --> 00:43:31,610
it wasn't categorically
saying you can never have any
948
00:43:31,610 --> 00:43:34,550
privacy claims, but at
least generally speaking,
949
00:43:34,550 --> 00:43:36,530
it can't have such claims with regard
950
00:43:36,530 --> 00:43:38,510
to information drawn
from government records,
951
00:43:38,510 --> 00:43:40,070
even when it is something that a lot
952
00:43:40,070 --> 00:43:42,830
of people would fight
extremely private and sensitive
953
00:43:42,830 --> 00:43:45,410
and offensive when, when
published to the world, such
954
00:43:45,410 --> 00:43:46,730
as the name of a, of a,
955
00:43:46,730 --> 00:43:49,610
of somebody who's alleging
that she'd been raped.
956
00:43:50,690 --> 00:43:53,930
So, so that's just a reminder
that the disclosure tort
957
00:43:55,220 --> 00:43:56,450
has been narrowed.
958
00:43:56,450 --> 00:43:58,370
Again, that's not quite
a disclosure tort case,
959
00:43:58,370 --> 00:44:00,110
but its logic would apply
960
00:44:00,110 --> 00:44:04,010
to disclosure tort claim brought
on the same facts as well.
961
00:44:04,010 --> 00:44:06,110
It hasn't been eliminated.
962
00:44:06,110 --> 00:44:07,760
Most states, almost all states
963
00:44:07,760 --> 00:44:09,110
that have considered it have accepted it.
964
00:44:09,110 --> 00:44:11,840
A handful, I wanna say four
or five have rejected it.
965
00:44:11,840 --> 00:44:14,570
But almost all states have
ha that have considered it,
966
00:44:14,570 --> 00:44:17,720
have accepted it, but
it does look like it's
967
00:44:17,720 --> 00:44:19,400
pretty narrow in scope.
968
00:44:19,400 --> 00:44:22,820
So that leaves the last two, two torts,
969
00:44:23,930 --> 00:44:25,040
two privacy torts.
970
00:44:25,040 --> 00:44:26,960
And by the way, Jane, you talked about,
971
00:44:26,960 --> 00:44:29,030
you gave the restatement
of torts definitions.
972
00:44:29,030 --> 00:44:30,800
That's absolutely correct.
973
00:44:30,800 --> 00:44:33,120
Again, for the benefit
of a non-lawyer readers,
974
00:44:33,120 --> 00:44:37,260
the restatements are a, are an
interesting, interesting kind
975
00:44:37,260 --> 00:44:38,820
of of work.
976
00:44:38,820 --> 00:44:40,770
They're not statutes,
they were never enacted
977
00:44:40,770 --> 00:44:44,550
by a legislature, but neither
are they, like a treatise,
978
00:44:44,550 --> 00:44:47,490
which would be written
by one legal academic,
979
00:44:47,490 --> 00:44:50,280
let's say usually, or sometimes
historically, one lawyer,
980
00:44:50,280 --> 00:44:52,830
sometimes historically judges
have written treatises,
981
00:44:52,830 --> 00:44:54,540
which is just the view of one person,
982
00:44:54,540 --> 00:44:56,730
although sometimes it's
extremely influential.
983
00:44:58,890 --> 00:45:00,900
For example, the Nier treatise pioneered
984
00:45:00,900 --> 00:45:03,450
by UCLA professor Mel Nier and,
985
00:45:03,450 --> 00:45:06,120
and now published by his son David Nier,
986
00:45:06,120 --> 00:45:08,040
who's a very prominent copyright lawyer
987
00:45:08,040 --> 00:45:10,890
and scholar is a very
influential criticism.
988
00:45:10,890 --> 00:45:14,250
Copyright. But that's
just one person speaking
989
00:45:14,250 --> 00:45:16,710
or maybe a couple of co-authors speaking.
990
00:45:16,710 --> 00:45:19,530
The restatement is
something almost in between.
991
00:45:19,530 --> 00:45:22,710
There's an organization called
the American Law Institute,
992
00:45:22,710 --> 00:45:27,710
and it is a organization of judges,
993
00:45:27,750 --> 00:45:30,090
lawyers, and legal academics.
994
00:45:30,090 --> 00:45:32,850
And they take on, it's,
it's over a century old.
995
00:45:33,915 --> 00:45:37,950
They, they take on the,
996
00:45:37,950 --> 00:45:41,130
these projects of restating the law,
997
00:45:41,130 --> 00:45:42,720
which is usually not always,
998
00:45:42,720 --> 00:45:45,390
but usually it is summarizing
999
00:45:47,500 --> 00:45:52,080
it is summarizing the, the common law
1000
00:45:52,080 --> 00:45:54,390
in, in certain areas.
1001
00:45:54,390 --> 00:45:57,900
And one, one of their
signature publications,
1002
00:45:57,900 --> 00:45:59,430
the restatement of torts.
1003
00:45:59,430 --> 00:46:01,650
We're now getting to the
restatement third of torts,
1004
00:46:01,650 --> 00:46:05,340
which is being worked
on by ris, by Ris Ky,
1005
00:46:05,340 --> 00:46:06,780
who's a colleague of yours, Jane
1006
00:46:06,780 --> 00:46:08,220
- And former guest of ours.
1007
00:46:08,220 --> 00:46:10,200
- Exactly. And former
guest and former Dean
1008
00:46:10,200 --> 00:46:12,580
and Robert Post, who's also a,
1009
00:46:12,580 --> 00:46:14,220
a prominent First Amendment scholar,
1010
00:46:14,220 --> 00:46:16,500
also former dean, former dean.
1011
00:46:16,500 --> 00:46:19,560
He's a, he is a professor and
former dean at Yale. Yale.
1012
00:46:19,560 --> 00:46:21,510
So they're working on
restatement third of torts,
1013
00:46:21,510 --> 00:46:23,070
defamation and privacy.
1014
00:46:23,070 --> 00:46:26,670
And the way it works is you
have these reporters, again,
1015
00:46:26,670 --> 00:46:29,970
kind of a weird, weird usage special
1016
00:46:29,970 --> 00:46:31,500
specific to American law.
1017
00:46:31,500 --> 00:46:34,800
They're the reporters who draft something
1018
00:46:35,940 --> 00:46:38,520
with input from the members consultative
1019
00:46:38,520 --> 00:46:39,930
group for that project.
1020
00:46:39,930 --> 00:46:41,220
And then eventually it has
1021
00:46:41,220 --> 00:46:45,120
to be approved at the
annual
meeting of the a LI
1022
00:46:45,120 --> 00:46:47,640
often it's approved somewhat piecemeal.
1023
00:46:47,640 --> 00:46:51,840
And, and then it becomes this
thing called a restatement.
1024
00:46:51,840 --> 00:46:53,310
That's still not the law,
1025
00:46:53,310 --> 00:46:55,110
but many courts will say,
1026
00:46:55,110 --> 00:46:57,150
we adopt the restatement formulation.
1027
00:46:57,150 --> 00:47:00,690
They almost never say we adopt
formulation from a treatise
1028
00:47:00,690 --> 00:47:02,130
or we adopt a professor's
1029
00:47:02,130 --> 00:47:03,690
formulation from a journal article.
1030
00:47:03,690 --> 00:47:05,190
But they will sometimes say,
1031
00:47:05,190 --> 00:47:07,350
we adopt the restatement formulation.
1032
00:47:07,350 --> 00:47:10,800
And at that point it becomes
incorporated into the law,
1033
00:47:10,800 --> 00:47:12,000
into the law of that state.
1034
00:47:12,000 --> 00:47:14,250
Because courts say yes, you know,
1035
00:47:14,250 --> 00:47:17,760
we think a LI is a very
respectable organization.
1036
00:47:17,760 --> 00:47:20,070
We think they did a really
good job summarizing this.
1037
00:47:20,070 --> 00:47:24,150
So the a LI is acceptance of
the proser for torques model
1038
00:47:25,560 --> 00:47:26,580
gave it extra heft.
1039
00:47:26,580 --> 00:47:28,200
So the, so a third one
1040
00:47:28,200 --> 00:47:31,030
of these torts is a
so-called false like tort.
1041
00:47:31,030 --> 00:47:33,070
So here's the
1042
00:47:33,070 --> 00:47:35,920
how the restatement articulates
the false like tort one
1043
00:47:35,920 --> 00:47:37,540
who gives publicity.
1044
00:47:37,540 --> 00:47:40,360
So again, Jane, as you pointed out,
1045
00:47:40,360 --> 00:47:44,320
this doesn't extend a kind of
personal gossip to friends.
1046
00:47:44,320 --> 00:47:46,720
It requires giving publicity like putting,
1047
00:47:46,720 --> 00:47:50,260
putting on the internet or
in a newspaper to a matter
1048
00:47:50,260 --> 00:47:52,270
concerning another that places the other
1049
00:47:52,270 --> 00:47:56,650
before the public in a false
light is subject to liability
1050
00:47:56,650 --> 00:47:59,020
for the other, I'm sorry to the other,
1051
00:47:59,020 --> 00:48:01,510
if the false light would
be highly offensive
1052
00:48:01,510 --> 00:48:02,860
to a reasonable person
1053
00:48:02,860 --> 00:48:07,390
and the actor knew the
statement was, was false
1054
00:48:07,390 --> 00:48:09,370
or was reckless about that possibility.
1055
00:48:10,330 --> 00:48:12,250
So it's a false slight.
1056
00:48:12,250 --> 00:48:14,890
Now why do we need a false light tort?
1057
00:48:14,890 --> 00:48:17,500
Don't we already have a,
we don't just, we don't,
1058
00:48:17,500 --> 00:48:22,120
I have tend to agree, but
don't we already have a tort
1059
00:48:22,120 --> 00:48:24,340
that deals with false
statements about other
1060
00:48:24,340 --> 00:48:25,600
people called defamation?
1061
00:48:26,590 --> 00:48:27,820
And for that reason,
1062
00:48:27,820 --> 00:48:29,800
some courts have rejected
the false light tort.
1063
00:48:32,230 --> 00:48:35,110
But the main difference
between false light
1064
00:48:35,110 --> 00:48:38,200
and defamation is defamation
is usually limited
1065
00:48:38,200 --> 00:48:42,730
to statements that are the
damage a person's reputation,
1066
00:48:42,730 --> 00:48:44,920
that's the real harm, reputational harm.
1067
00:48:45,940 --> 00:48:47,020
There are some statements
1068
00:48:47,020 --> 00:48:50,020
that are false about another
person that generally
1069
00:48:51,400 --> 00:48:54,460
wouldn't damage a person's reputation,
1070
00:48:56,320 --> 00:49:00,310
but might still be so offensive
that that person ought
1071
00:49:00,310 --> 00:49:02,830
to be able to recover for the injury
1072
00:49:02,830 --> 00:49:05,770
to his feelings without
concern. Injury to reputation
1073
00:49:05,770 --> 00:49:08,440
- Splitting hairs, in my
opinion. Maybe, maybe,
1074
00:49:08,440 --> 00:49:09,790
- But so for example,
1075
00:49:09,790 --> 00:49:12,520
dam damaged reputation is
generally seen as potentially
1076
00:49:12,520 --> 00:49:15,160
so serious that setting
aside public officials
1077
00:49:15,160 --> 00:49:17,440
and public figures, people can recover
1078
00:49:17,440 --> 00:49:20,260
for even negligent falsehoods about,
1079
00:49:20,260 --> 00:49:22,720
especially if the damaged reputation will
1080
00:49:22,720 --> 00:49:24,070
be evident on the face.
1081
00:49:24,070 --> 00:49:25,990
The theory being, look,
if you're say a newspaper
1082
00:49:25,990 --> 00:49:27,250
and you're publishing someone
1083
00:49:27,250 --> 00:49:30,820
and you know it's an accusation
of some serious offense,
1084
00:49:30,820 --> 00:49:32,530
you really need to take good care
1085
00:49:32,530 --> 00:49:35,620
to make sure you don't
accidentally ruin this person's
1086
00:49:35,620 --> 00:49:38,620
career or business or even personal life.
1087
00:49:38,620 --> 00:49:40,690
But in a situation where, you know,
1088
00:49:40,690 --> 00:49:43,060
it's something about their age,
maybe about their religion,
1089
00:49:43,060 --> 00:49:45,160
about some other things which
doesn't seem on its face
1090
00:49:45,160 --> 00:49:47,020
likely to damage reputation.
1091
00:49:47,020 --> 00:49:50,170
We don't wanna, we don't
want, we still would like you
1092
00:49:50,170 --> 00:49:51,730
to limit yourself to the truth, of course,
1093
00:49:51,730 --> 00:49:56,500
but we don't wanna to unduly
chill your ability to,
1094
00:49:56,500 --> 00:49:59,320
to report about people by,
1095
00:49:59,320 --> 00:50:01,750
by holding a liable on
a negligent standard.
1096
00:50:01,750 --> 00:50:06,160
So that's why, for example,
even for private figures,
1097
00:50:06,160 --> 00:50:08,350
the standard of the false light door is
1098
00:50:08,350 --> 00:50:09,880
recklessness or knowledge.
1099
00:50:09,880 --> 00:50:14,080
So here's an illustration from,
1100
00:50:14,080 -->
00:50:15,550
from the, from the restatement.
1101
00:50:17,290 --> 00:50:21,850
So a is a war hero
1102
00:50:21,850 --> 00:50:24,130
distinguished for bravery
in a famous battle.
1103
00:50:25,120 --> 00:50:28,520
B makes a movie about a's
life in which he includes
1104
00:50:28,520 --> 00:50:32,990
some narrative of fictitious
details of this person's life.
1105
00:50:32,990 --> 00:50:36,800
But those, those narratives,
those facts aren't,
1106
00:50:36,800 --> 00:50:39,320
don't reflect badly on the subject.
1107
00:50:39,320 --> 00:50:43,010
They may in fact place the
person in a better light
1108
00:50:43,010 --> 00:50:44,240
than than he otherwise would've.
1109
00:50:44,240 --> 00:50:46,280
It may unduly false, false positive
1110
00:50:46,280 --> 00:50:47,840
- Light
- Pardon
1111
00:50:47,840 --> 00:50:49,400
- False positive light,
- Right?
1112
00:50:49,400 --> 00:50:51,680
May, may inflate this person's reputation.
1113
00:50:51,680 --> 00:50:53,030
It's not defamatory
1114
00:50:53,030 --> 00:50:55,520
'cause it doesn't damage
this person's reputation,
1115
00:50:55,520 --> 00:50:58,370
but it may make this
person feel quite offended.
1116
00:50:58,370 --> 00:50:59,480
Like, here you're purport
1117
00:50:59,480 --> 00:51:03,500
to be telling my life this is
not a fictionalization this
1118
00:51:03,500 --> 00:51:08,030
this claims to be articul
de describing a real story.
1119
00:51:08,030 --> 00:51:12,170
And, and, but, but you've,
you've made this stuff up
1120
00:51:12,170 --> 00:51:15,410
and that makes me feel understandably bad.
1121
00:51:16,610 --> 00:51:21,610
And courts do allow liability
in that, that is in fact drawn
1122
00:51:21,650 --> 00:51:25,010
from, from, there's a set of
such cases, the most famous
1123
00:51:25,010 --> 00:51:27,500
of which is the Warren Spawn case.
1124
00:51:27,500 --> 00:51:32,300
Warren Spawn was a, a great
1125
00:51:32,300 --> 00:51:33,800
baseball player and I know
1126
00:51:33,800 --> 00:51:35,930
that he was a great baseball player
1127
00:51:35,930 --> 00:51:38,600
because I have no interest in baseball.
1128
00:51:39,710 --> 00:51:44,120
And, and he played well before,
1129
00:51:44,120 --> 00:51:47,870
before I had my very brief time
interested in baseball back
1130
00:51:47,870 --> 00:51:51,560
when I was in my, like
when I was 10 to 12.
1131
00:51:51,560 --> 00:51:54,170
And even so I remembered
I had heard his name.
1132
00:51:54,170 --> 00:51:58,520
He was a great pitcher
1133
00:52:00,050 --> 00:52:04,220
apparently for the Boston Braves
1134
00:52:04,220 --> 00:52:05,510
and Milwaukee Braves.
1135
00:52:05,510 --> 00:52:08,420
In any case, this was, by the
way, you can tell it's old
1136
00:52:08,420 --> 00:52:10,100
because there are no more Boston Braves in
1137
00:52:10,100 --> 00:52:11,210
Milwaukee Braves right now.
1138
00:52:11,210 --> 00:52:14,420
Right. And he fought in World War ii
1139
00:52:14,420 --> 00:52:18,260
and there was a, there
was a children's book
1140
00:52:18,260 --> 00:52:20,900
about the little biography of him
1141
00:52:20,900 --> 00:52:23,060
that portrayed him as this great war hero.
1142
00:52:24,020 --> 00:52:25,250
And he said, that's offensive.
1143
00:52:25,250 --> 00:52:26,840
I was not a great war hero,
1144
00:52:26,840 --> 00:52:28,610
I was just a soldier like everybody else.
1145
00:52:28,610 --> 00:52:31,430
I do not want to claim heroism
that I'm not entitled to.
1146
00:52:33,020 --> 00:52:36,500
And he sued and the court
was at least open to,
1147
00:52:36,500 --> 00:52:39,080
to allowing this claim on the theory
1148
00:52:39,080 --> 00:52:40,580
that it put him in a false light.
1149
00:52:40,580 --> 00:52:43,220
Again, if it was just
carelessness, well then there,
1150
00:52:43,220 --> 00:52:44,660
at least in the restatement formulation,
1151
00:52:44,660 --> 00:52:45,770
there wouldn't be liability.
1152
00:52:46,670 --> 00:52:49,370
You could have liability
knew for carelessness,
1153
00:52:49,370 --> 00:52:50,420
for defamation
1154
00:52:50,420 --> 00:52:52,820
because it's so important
to protect reputation,
1155
00:52:52,820 --> 00:52:55,700
but not for careless putting
someone in a false light.
1156
00:52:55,700 --> 00:52:58,430
But when it comes to
1157
00:53:00,440 --> 00:53:04,220
WW I'm sorry when it comes to knowing
1158
00:53:04,220 --> 00:53:06,260
or reckless false splits,
if they knew, you know,
1159
00:53:06,260 --> 00:53:08,930
this didn't happen, but we
just wanna sell more books.
1160
00:53:08,930 --> 00:53:12,140
Well that's just not
something you should be doing.
1161
00:53:13,400 --> 00:53:14,930
Interestingly, by the way,
1162
00:53:16,280 --> 00:53:18,230
well it's still sometimes
called false light
1163
00:53:18,230 --> 00:53:19,430
invasion of privacy.
1164
00:53:20,630 --> 00:53:22,280
It, I think to most of us today,
1165
00:53:22,280 --> 00:53:25,080
it doesn't even sound
like privacy much, right?
1166
00:53:25,080 --> 00:53:28,680
It's, it's about a person
who is very well known.
1167
00:53:28,680 --> 00:53:31,110
It is about incidents in his life
1168
00:53:31,110 --> 00:53:33,870
that if true would not have
been viewed as private.
1169
00:53:33,870 --> 00:53:35,160
And the claim was he got medals,
1170
00:53:35,160 --> 00:53:36,630
which would've been, would be record.
1171
00:53:37,505 --> 00:53:39,510
- And usually think
people think of privacy
1172
00:53:39,510 --> 00:53:41,790
as being about some true fact about you.
1173
00:53:41,790 --> 00:53:45,180
That you want to be, you
know, just to keep out
1174
00:53:45,180 --> 00:53:48,390
of the public of the public
domain or public light, so,
1175
00:53:48,390 --> 00:53:49,390
- Right.
1176
00:53:50,760 --> 00:53:51,870
Yeah, exactly.
1177
00:53:51,870 --> 00:53:54,840
So, so you could have a kind of a
1178
00:53:55,770 --> 00:54:00,000
factual assertion about someone
that would, that if true,
1179
00:54:00,000 --> 00:54:02,250
would never be seen as, as disclosure
1180
00:54:02,250 -->
00:54:03,330
of private facts simply
1181
00:54:03,330 --> 00:54:05,580
because it's not something
that's really embarrassing
1182
00:54:05,580 --> 00:54:07,530
to have to have revealed about you.
1183
00:54:07,530 --> 00:54:10,740
But if false could lead
to false light liability,
1184
00:54:10,740 --> 00:54:13,980
because the real harm in
false light is not that, it's
1185
00:54:13,980 --> 00:54:16,710
that it invades some super
private space about you.
1186
00:54:16,710 --> 00:54:18,600
It's that it's a combination of falsehood.
1187
00:54:18,600 --> 00:54:22,530
So that lacks value and it's about you.
1188
00:54:22,530 --> 00:54:24,600
And people should be entitled not
1189
00:54:24,600 --> 00:54:28,110
to have sports about certain
facets of their lives.
1190
00:54:28,110 --> 00:54:31,530
Said not because of a concern
about privacy as such,
1191
00:54:31,530 --> 00:54:34,380
but more of a sense that it is my life
1192
00:54:34,380 --> 00:54:37,710
and you shouldn't be making
enough stuff about my life like
1193
00:54:37,710 --> 00:54:40,740
it's private property in that
respect, even as the things
1194
00:54:40,740 --> 00:54:42,000
that we, that we think would be
1195
00:54:42,000 --> 00:54:45,390
of legitimate public concern
wouldn't be really kind of seen
1196
00:54:45,390 --> 00:54:47,430
as traditional intrusions in privacy.
1197
00:54:47,430 --> 00:54:49,290
That's why I don't like to
talk about the false light
1198
00:54:49,290 --> 00:54:51,360
invasion of privacy tort, I call it,
1199
00:54:51,360 --> 00:54:53,250
and other others do the same.
1200
00:54:53,250 --> 00:54:55,560
Call it the false light tort.
1201
00:54:55,560 --> 00:54:57,060
By the way, some people
think one difference
1202
00:54:57,060 --> 00:54:59,700
between false light and
defamation is the defamation
1203
00:54:59,700 --> 00:55:02,040
requires false statements,
1204
00:55:02,040 --> 00:55:04,530
whereas false light sounds
like it includes things
1205
00:55:04,530 --> 00:55:07,350
that are nearly misleading,
that are literally true.
1206
00:55:07,350 --> 00:55:09,720
But put someone in a
false light occasionally,
1207
00:55:09,720 --> 00:55:11,070
you see this distinction drawn.
1208
00:55:11,070 --> 00:55:12,565
That's not really much of a difference.
1209
00:55:12,565 --> 00:55:14,460
Here's not among other
things, because it, as you,
1210
00:55:14,460 --> 00:55:17,130
we talked about in the
last episode about libel,
1211
00:55:17,130 --> 00:55:21,060
if something is misleading
enough about someone, then
1212
00:55:21,060 --> 00:55:22,710
it's viewed as tantamount to false
1213
00:55:22,710 --> 00:55:25,800
because everybody would
be misled led into this
1214
00:55:25,800 --> 00:55:28,680
misunderstanding of, of this person
1215
00:55:28,680 --> 00:55:30,690
that it would be a false understanding
1216
00:55:30,690 --> 00:55:32,130
of, of what's supposedly happen.
1217
00:55:32,130 --> 00:55:34,350
- Right? Like the case where
it sounded like the guy shot
1218
00:55:34,350 --> 00:55:35,850
his, his wife's lover,
1219
00:55:35,850 --> 00:55:38,610
even though it was just a
party in the living room that
1220
00:55:38,610 --> 00:55:39,610
- You told us about.
1221
00:55:39,610 --> 00:55:42,240
Right? Right. I believe it was
the woman who shot someone,
1222
00:55:42,240 --> 00:55:44,400
she, her husband's lover.
1223
00:55:44,400 --> 00:55:46,325
- Oh, okay. So, pardon me. Alright.
1224
00:55:48,360 --> 00:55:49,350
- Usually, okay, usually it is the guy who
1225
00:55:49,350 --> 00:55:51,245
does the shooting. But
in this, I guess I was
1226
00:55:51,245 --> 00:55:53,370
- Apparently must I, I
was using some gender
1227
00:55:53,370 --> 00:55:54,810
stereotypes, I must
1228
00:55:54,810 --> 00:55:55,810
- Admit.
1229
00:55:55,810 --> 00:55:56,820
Right, right, right.
Like many stereotypes,
1230
00:55:56,820 --> 00:55:59,130
they're generally active,
but sometimes not.
1231
00:55:59,130 --> 00:56:04,130
So that's the false, like
tot And then that brings us
1232
00:56:04,650 --> 00:56:08,790
to the last of these, which
is sometimes called the right
1233
00:56:08,790 --> 00:56:10,350
of publicity, which
1234
00:56:10,350 --> 00:56:12,450
by the way is almost a subtle dig at the
1235
00:56:12,450 --> 00:56:13,920
privacy formulation.
1236
00:56:13,920 --> 00:56:14,880
It's like saying, you know, we're
1237
00:56:14,880 --> 00:56:16,560
actually gotta acknowledge it.
1238
00:56:16,560 --> 00:56:21,270
It's really almost the opposite of, of
1239
00:56:22,320 --> 00:56:24,430
a invasion of privacy.
1240
00:56:26,620 --> 00:56:28,990
And sometimes it's
called perhaps more act,
1241
00:56:28,990 --> 00:56:32,770
more descriptively misappropriation
1242
00:56:32,770 --> 00:56:34,570
of name or likeness.
1243
00:56:35,980 --> 00:56:37,510
So here's by the way,
1244
00:56:37,510 --> 00:56:39,910
the way the restatement articulates it,
1245
00:56:39,910 --> 00:56:44,110
and this is a reminder that
sometimes the one line summary
1246
00:56:44,110 --> 00:56:48,610
of a legal rule is much more misleading,
1247
00:56:48,610 --> 00:56:51,790
misleading, misleading than
leading in the right direction.
1248
00:56:51,790 --> 00:56:53,980
So the rest statement
says, one who appropriates
1249
00:56:53,980 --> 00:56:56,230
to his own user benefit, the name
1250
00:56:56,230 --> 00:57:00,250
or likeness of another is
subject to liability to the other
1251
00:57:00,250 --> 00:57:02,350
for the invasion of his privacy.
1252
00:57:02,350 --> 00:57:06,550
So it sounds like a categorical
rule, like if it's your name
1253
00:57:06,550 --> 00:57:09,940
or likeness and I use it
for my benefit, by the way,
1254
00:57:09,940 --> 00:57:12,730
it doesn't even say commercial
benefit, my benefit,
1255
00:57:12,730 --> 00:57:14,620
Then I'm liable.
1256
00:57:14,620 --> 00:57:17,200
So what's an, what would
be the clearest example
1257
00:57:17,200 --> 00:57:21,970
of my appropriating and the name
1258
00:57:21,970 --> 00:57:25,210
or likeness
of another
for my own user benefit?
1259
00:57:25,210 --> 00:57:28,960
Let's say I write an
unauthorized biography of,
1260
00:57:28,960 --> 00:57:32,590
of some person Jane Bamb Bauer, right?
1261
00:57:32,590 --> 00:57:34,180
The untold story.
1262
00:57:34,180 --> 00:57:35,440
And then I have a big picture
1263
00:57:35,440 --> 00:57:38,320
of Jane Bamb Bauer on the cover because
1264
00:57:38,320 --> 00:57:41,800
after all that, what, that's
what what needs to sell books.
1265
00:57:41,800 --> 00:57:45,520
And also I think people will
better, better see that it,
1266
00:57:45,520 --> 00:57:47,650
that it's indeed about, about you.
1267
00:57:47,650 --> 00:57:49,180
You might be quite upset.
1268
00:57:49,180 --> 00:57:50,560
I think you, if you are upset,
1269
00:57:50,560 --> 00:57:52,030
probably that'll be the
end of this podcast.
1270
00:57:52,030 --> 00:57:54,190
So I'm not gonna do it
because I, I respect you
1271
00:57:54,190 --> 00:57:56,710
and I want our fruitful
partnership to continue.
1272
00:57:56,710 --> 00:57:59,290
But if I were to do that,
you couldn't sue me for that.
1273
00:58:00,220 --> 00:58:02,230
Unauthorized biographies
are fully protected
1274
00:58:02,230 --> 00:58:04,420
by the First amendment
and generally speaking,
1275
00:58:04,420 --> 00:58:05,860
Tola doesn't even purport to go
1276
00:58:05,860 --> 00:58:07,330
after them, even though that is something
1277
00:58:07,330 --> 00:58:11,560
where the entire book would be,
wouldn't exist if it weren't
1278
00:58:11,560 --> 00:58:13,270
for its subject.
1279
00:58:13,270 --> 00:58:15,370
And it often draws the great bulk
1280
00:58:15,370 --> 00:58:17,710
of its sales just from the
interest in the subject.
1281
00:58:17,710 --> 00:58:21,435
Occasionally there are biographies
that that bring back or,
1282
00:58:21,435 --> 00:58:23,500
or that talk about someone unknown
1283
00:58:23,500 --> 00:58:25,270
because their life is so interesting.
1284
00:58:25,270 --> 00:58:26,590
Well, there you might say,
1285
00:58:26,590 --> 00:58:28,600
doesn't really turn on this person's fame,
1286
00:58:28,600 --> 00:58:30,640
although it's still are
using their name a likeness.
1287
00:58:30,640 --> 00:58:33,160
But sometimes if it's
somebody super duper famous,
1288
00:58:33,160 --> 00:58:34,720
if somebody were write Taylor Swift,
1289
00:58:34,720 --> 00:58:36,340
the unauthorized biography,
1290
00:58:36,340 --> 00:58:37,990
probably most people would buy it
1291
00:58:37,990 --> 00:58:39,490
because they know of Taylor Swift
1292
00:58:39,490 --> 00:58:40,870
and they're interested
in her life already.
1293
00:58:42,280 --> 00:58:44,530
Or another example, how about newspapers?
1294
00:58:45,640 --> 00:58:49,180
Newspapers are commercial
enterprises, at least they seek
1295
00:58:49,180 --> 00:58:51,370
to be profit making enterprises.
1296
00:58:51,370 --> 00:58:54,400
Sometimes they fail increasingly, but,
1297
00:58:55,540 --> 00:59:00,430
but they are writing
stories that routinely use
1298
00:59:01,450 --> 00:59:04,870
another person's incidents of
their lives, including name
1299
00:59:04,870 --> 00:59:06,550
or likeness to sell newspapers.
1300
00:59:07,630 --> 00:59:09,850
That's particularly true
for magazines which may be,
1301
00:59:09,850 --> 00:59:11,560
let's say People magazine
1302
00:59:11,560 --> 00:59:13,900
or other such magazines are
really about people, right?
1303
00:59:13,900 --> 00:59:15,940
It's, they're on, they're in the title
1304
00:59:15,940 --> 00:59:18,430
and will will write
stories about this person.
1305
00:59:18,430 --> 00:59:22,070
My guess is that very often
the, the person is quite eager
1306
00:59:22,070 --> 00:59:23,300
to have the story written about them,
1307
00:59:23,300 --> 00:59:25,850
but they're entitled to write
this about the person and,
1308
00:59:25,850 --> 00:59:26,960
and people will buy it
1309
00:59:26,960 --> 00:59:29,210
because they see their favorite celebrity
1310
00:59:29,210 --> 00:59:30,980
or maybe they're the celebrity they left
1311
00:59:30,980 --> 00:59:32,780
to hate on the cover.
1312
00:59:32,780 --> 00:59:34,670
But even a newspaper
might have a big banner
1313
00:59:34,670 --> 00:59:36,770
or headline about somebody
accused of some crime
1314
00:59:36,770 --> 00:59:38,900
and they're using against
this person's name
1315
00:59:38,900 --> 00:59:40,940
or like likeness to, so, so
1316
00:59:40,940 --> 00:59:45,500
what has really emerged in
the context of this rite
1317
00:59:45,500 --> 00:59:47,840
of publicity or appropriation of name
1318
00:59:47,840 --> 00:59:49,700
or likeness is that
1319
00:59:51,500 --> 00:59:53,690
it has been limited
1320
00:59:53,690 --> 00:59:56,665
to mostly three categories.
1321
00:59:56,665 --> 01:00:01,370
And I oversimplify one
is commercial advertise
1322
01:00:01,370 --> 01:00:04,520
if I appropriate somebody else's name
1323
01:00:04,520 --> 01:00:07,940
or likeness in commercial
advertising for soap
1324
01:00:08,780 --> 01:00:13,700
or a TV set for pretty
much anything other than
1325
01:00:13,700 --> 01:00:15,080
for a book about it.
1326
01:00:16,820 --> 01:00:19,820
But basically for commercial
advertising, for some product,
1327
01:00:19,820 --> 01:00:23,215
that's something that would lead to to
1328
01:00:23,215 --> 01:00:25,040
to very strong generally speaking
1329
01:00:26,810 --> 01:00:28,970
misappropriation claim. Yeah.
1330
01:00:28,970 --> 01:00:30,890
- And that's true even if
you're not, that's true, even
1331
01:00:30,890 --> 01:00:32,420
for the plaintiff who's not a celebrity,
1332
01:00:32,420 --> 01:00:34,910
it's not even like their it's
name recognition or anything.
1333
01:00:34,910 --> 01:00:36,530
Exactly. But they're trading on. Exactly.
1334
01:00:36,530 --> 01:00:38,420
But this was like, this
was the, so this goes back
1335
01:00:38,420 --> 01:00:41,060
to the very first privacy claim exactly.
1336
01:00:41,060 --> 01:00:43,250
Filed where a woman Rob Ms.
1337
01:00:43,250 --> 01:00:46,340
Robeson suddenly discovered
1338
01:00:46,340 --> 01:00:48,200
that her face was on a bag of flour.
1339
01:00:48,200 --> 01:00:50,630
Right, right. Or a flower
advertisement. So yeah,
1340
01:00:50,630 --> 01:00:51,630
- Right.
1341
01:00:51,630 --> 01:00:54,530
So, so those claims will generally,
1342
01:00:54,530 --> 01:00:56,630
these days, these days prevail.
1343
01:00:56,630 --> 01:00:57,950
Again, note this is not the kind
1344
01:00:57,950 --> 01:00:59,420
of privacy we're talking about in
1345
01:00:59,420 --> 01:01:01,280
disclosure of private facts.
1346
01:01:01,280 --> 01:01:03,080
The name and likeness may
not be a private fact.
1347
01:01:03,080 --> 01:01:06,860
In fact, if it, it is a,
if it is using the name
1348
01:01:06,860 --> 01:01:09,140
and likeness of celebrity,
it may be the least private
1349
01:01:09,140 --> 01:01:11,660
facts out there, right?
1350
01:01:11,660 --> 01:01:13,670
The Tom Cruise's name
1351
01:01:13,670 --> 01:01:16,700
and likeness are about, as
unprivate a fact as possible.
1352
01:01:16,700 --> 01:01:21,560
But that doesn't mean that
I can use Tom Cruise's name
1353
01:01:21,560 --> 01:01:23,840
to, to advertise, I dunno, whatever,
1354
01:01:23,840 --> 01:01:26,450
whatever one might want an airline right.
1355
01:01:26,450 --> 01:01:28,490
Top Gun, although actually if I were
1356
01:01:28,490 --> 01:01:31,130
to fly in an on an air
airline, I would not want them
1357
01:01:31,130 --> 01:01:32,510
to do the maneuvers from Top Gun.
1358
01:01:32,510 --> 01:01:33,890
So I'm not sure, but it,
1359
01:01:33,890 --> 01:01:36,620
but whatever I want to
use to Tom Cruise's name
1360
01:01:36,620 --> 01:01:38,420
or likeness to sell, I
better get his permission.
1361
01:01:39,590 --> 01:01:42,410
A second category is what we
might loosely call merchandise,
1362
01:01:43,400 --> 01:01:46,970
t-shirts, coffee mugs,
1363
01:01:47,870 --> 01:01:50,720
maybe also prints to hang on the wall,
1364
01:01:50,720 --> 01:01:52,700
although that's actually more borderline.
1365
01:01:53,870 --> 01:01:55,220
We'll explain what's on the other
1366
01:01:55,220 --> 01:01:56,300
side of the border shortly.
1367
01:01:57,230 --> 01:02:00,470
But those are things that
generally, the sense is
1368
01:02:00,470 --> 01:02:02,480
that's not advertising, right?
1369
01:02:02,480 --> 01:02:07,400
It is itself fully protected
speech in some respects.
1370
01:02:07,400 --> 01:02:10,550
But still, if all I'm doing
is if I'm just presenting this
1371
01:02:10,550 --> 01:02:13,340
person's, this person's name
1372
01:02:13,340 --> 01:02:16,160
and likeness, really that's
just all that's going on.
1373
01:02:16,160 --> 01:02:18,140
There is a t-shirt with a picture of
1374
01:02:19,230 --> 01:02:23,010
Taylor Swift Le let's
say then in that case,
1375
01:02:23,010 --> 01:02:25,590
that is probably an
infringement of her rights.
1376
01:02:25,590 --> 01:02:27,120
And a third category.
1377
01:02:27,120 --> 01:02:28,740
The only one that actually went up
1378
01:02:28,740 --> 01:02:31,350
to the US Supreme Court is
when basically you produced
1379
01:02:31,350 --> 01:02:32,580
someone's entire act.
1380
01:02:32,580 --> 01:02:33,810
There was this famous case,
1381
01:02:33,810 --> 01:02:37,530
zucchini involving Hugo
Zucchini, the human cannonball,
1382
01:02:37,530 --> 01:02:40,110
where he, his act was being shot out
1383
01:02:40,110 --> 01:02:43,500
of a cannon at various
circuses and similar events
1384
01:02:43,500 --> 01:02:45,900
and some television station broadcast.
1385
01:02:45,900 --> 01:02:48,660
The whole act in a very positive way.
1386
01:02:48,660 --> 01:02:50,250
But, but he sued
1387
01:02:50,250 --> 01:02:53,970
and the court said,
yeah, he's got, it's kind
1388
01:02:53,970 --> 01:02:55,440
of like a property, right?
1389
01:02:55,440 --> 01:02:58,380
In his performance, it's not
quite copyright infringement
1390
01:02:58,380 --> 01:03:00,690
because it's because those
acts are not protected
1391
01:03:00,690 --> 01:03:02,910
by copyright, generally speaking.
1392
01:03:02,910 --> 01:03:07,320
What? No, basically people
should be able to, to, to,
1393
01:03:07,320 --> 01:03:10,020
to stop other people from broadcasting
1394
01:03:10,020 --> 01:03:11,340
their whole, their whole acts.
1395
01:03:11,340 --> 01:03:13,530
There's a, there's a
subset of that having to do
1396
01:03:13,530 --> 01:03:15,120
with Elvis impersonators.
1397
01:03:15,120 --> 01:03:17,220
There's a whole body of
case law involving Elvis
1398
01:03:17,220 --> 01:03:20,040
impersonators and others
who basically just kind
1399
01:03:20,040 --> 01:03:21,450
of take somebody else's act.
1400
01:03:21,450 --> 01:03:23,820
So all of these involve
using someone's name
1401
01:03:23,820 --> 01:03:26,280
or likeness for commercial purposes.
1402
01:03:26,280 --> 01:03:28,740
There are few situations
where it might be liability
1403
01:03:28,740 --> 01:03:30,660
for non-commercial use,
but really very rare.
1404
01:03:32,070 --> 01:03:33,150
So what's in the other side?
1405
01:03:33,150 --> 01:03:35,790
Well, anything that is seen,
1406
01:03:35,790 --> 01:03:38,010
and there are all these
categories that are listed.
1407
01:03:38,010 --> 01:03:41,220
News, entertainment,
1408
01:03:42,090 --> 01:03:46,680
nonfiction accounts,
fictionalized accounts, right?
1409
01:03:46,680 --> 01:03:48,750
What about Forrest Gump
or Midnight in Paris
1410
01:03:48,750 --> 01:03:51,330
or other movies which have real people
1411
01:03:51,330 --> 01:03:52,620
supposedly as characters?
1412
01:03:52,620 --> 01:03:54,060
Clearly it's fiction.
1413
01:03:54,060 --> 01:03:55,200
So there's no false slight claim
1414
01:03:55,200 --> 01:03:57,510
because everybody would
understand It's just fiction.
1415
01:03:57,510 --> 01:03:59,670
It doesn't really display
anything private about them.
1416
01:03:59,670 --> 01:04:02,430
Doesn't display nude photos
of them or some such.
1417
01:04:02,430 --> 01:04:05,730
It does use their name and
likeness for commercial reasons,
1418
01:04:05,730 --> 01:04:09,090
but the courts say no, no,
that, that just doesn't count.
1419
01:04:09,090 --> 01:04:12,990
That's not an improper kind of
use that once. Well, because
1420
01:04:12,990 --> 01:04:16,110
- Part of, yeah, I, I mean it, it's,
1421
01:04:16,110 --> 01:04:17,340
it's not improper in part
1422
01:04:17,340 --> 01:04:20,400
because it is its own
creative work, right?
1423
01:04:20,400 --> 01:04:22,770
Like it, it, I guess the,
the term maybe you're getting
1424
01:04:22,770 --> 01:04:24,960
to this, the term that courts often look
1425
01:04:24,960 --> 01:04:26,370
for is transformative.
1426
01:04:26,370 --> 01:04:27,870
- Like well, sometimes they look for look
1427
01:04:27,870 --> 01:04:28,950
for, for transformative.
1428
01:04:28,950 --> 01:04:31,530
That's right. Yeah.
Borrowing it from some,
1429
01:04:31,530 --> 01:04:33,450
some aspects of copyright law.
1430
01:04:33,450 --> 01:04:36,000
Right. But yeah, the sense is
if it's something that is kind
1431
01:04:36,000 --> 01:04:37,020
of a full fledged,
1432
01:04:37,020 --> 01:04:40,410
respectable first amendment
protected work, a book,
1433
01:04:40,410 --> 01:04:42,540
a movie, a song.
1434
01:04:42,540 --> 01:04:45,330
I remember Mrs. Robinson
1435
01:04:45,330 --> 01:04:48,780
or mentions Jodi Maggio,
this is the Paul Simon song.
1436
01:04:48,780 --> 01:04:51,090
Well, I don't know how many
of our listeners remember,
1437
01:04:51,090 --> 01:04:52,650
but some of them are probably our age.
1438
01:04:52,650 --> 01:04:54,810
They, they know used to
be, used to be very big.
1439
01:04:54,810 --> 01:04:55,860
Apparently I'm told
1440
01:04:55,860 --> 01:04:57,720
that Joe Diaggio was
kind of upset at the use.
1441
01:04:57,720 --> 01:05:01,740
I don't know if he was ever
contemplating suing until, until
1442
01:05:01,740 --> 01:05:04,920
I think it was made clear
that this was a favorable use.
1443
01:05:04,920 --> 01:05:06,000
Like where have you gone?
1444
01:05:06,000 --> 01:05:09,090
Joe Diaggio or Nation
Turns It's Lonely Ice.
1445
01:05:09,090 --> 01:05:13,470
You sort of using him as
an icon of, of, of, of,
1446
01:05:13,470 --> 01:05:17,410
of kind of, of not maybe heroism,
1447
01:05:17,410 --> 01:05:19,270
but kind of, of, of American greatness.
1448
01:05:20,620 --> 01:05:25,270
So, so in any event, songs,
1449
01:05:25,270 --> 01:05:29,380
movies, books, biographies
1450
01:05:29,380 --> 01:05:31,540
and such, clearly fully protected
1451
01:05:31,540 --> 01:05:33,250
by the First Amendment
in part, I think as,
1452
01:05:33,250 --> 01:05:37,060
as you point out, because they
actually, they do add a lot
1453
01:05:37,060 --> 01:05:38,290
beyond just the name, a likeness.
1454
01:05:38,290 --> 01:05:40,750
They're not just like
the T-shirt. Of course.
1455
01:05:40,750 --> 01:05:41,710
Then you ask, well,
1456
01:05:41,710 --> 01:05:42,790
what about things that are in the middle?
1457
01:05:42,790 --> 01:05:46,810
Like what about a painting?
Is that like a t-shirt?
1458
01:05:46,810 --> 01:05:47,950
It's just maybe a painting
1459
01:05:47,950 --> 01:05:50,410
of this one person, maybe
a few people. And you know,
1460
01:05:50,410 --> 01:05:51,490
- Or I thought you were going to say,
1461
01:05:51,490 --> 01:05:52,720
what about a video game
1462
01:05:52,720 --> 01:05:53,830
- Depict? Oh, I was gonna say one.
1463
01:05:53,830 --> 01:05:57,130
- Okay. An athlete doing,
playing his sport. Right,
1464
01:05:57,130 --> 01:05:58,130
- Exactly.
1465
01:05:58,130 --> 01:06:01,030
And there are some courts
that say, yes, you know,
1466
01:06:01,870 --> 01:06:05,170
painting is fully protected
by the First Amendment.
1467
01:06:05,170 --> 01:06:06,910
Not right of publicity infringements.
1468
01:06:06,910 --> 01:06:11,080
Others say, well, a
print of just the image
1469
01:06:11,080 --> 01:06:14,050
of the three stitches,
well, that is not protected
1470
01:06:14,050 --> 01:06:16,240
'cause it's not transformative
enough. There's a case
1471
01:06:16,240 --> 01:06:21,100
- Involving - A Hallmark card
with Paris Hilton's image
1472
01:06:21,100 --> 01:06:22,690
and kind of what used to be for a while
1473
01:06:22,690 --> 01:06:25,210
for a signature joke
from, from our TV show.
1474
01:06:26,050 --> 01:06:28,870
And the court allowed that to go forward,
1475
01:06:28,870 --> 01:06:31,780
even though you'd think like
if it were a comedian doing
1476
01:06:31,780 --> 01:06:33,580
impersonations even of someone
1477
01:06:33,580 --> 01:06:35,830
or jokes about someone on Saturday Ad Live
1478
01:06:35,830 --> 01:06:38,560
or some such, you'd think,
well, no, isn't that protected?
1479
01:06:38,560 --> 01:06:40,570
So there are these vague lines and,
1480
01:06:40,570 --> 01:06:42,910
- And
- Especially when it comes to video games,
1481
01:06:42,910 --> 01:06:46,630
that indeed there are
some cases that say, well,
1482
01:06:46,630 --> 01:06:50,170
a video game, essentially,
essentially a sports video game,
1483
01:06:50,170 --> 01:06:54,310
a fantasy game where you
can put together teams from,
1484
01:06:54,310 --> 01:06:57,700
from various sports greats that infringes
1485
01:06:58,660 --> 01:07:01,540
the sports greats, right.
1486
01:07:01,540 --> 01:07:03,460
Of publicity right against
Bib Circle creation,
1487
01:07:03,460 --> 01:07:05,650
even if they don't actually
use this person's name or like,
1488
01:07:05,650 --> 01:07:08,620
but just identify them
clearly by say, number
1489
01:07:08,620 --> 01:07:11,140
and general body type and such.
1490
01:07:11,140 --> 01:07:13,960
That's say Jersey number and
the name of the team, right?
1491
01:07:13,960 --> 01:07:15,640
So, so fans would understand,
1492
01:07:17,200 --> 01:07:19,660
but on the other hand, there
are other courts that say,
1493
01:07:19,660 --> 01:07:21,610
well, first of all, the
Supreme Court has said in a
1494
01:07:21,610
--> 01:07:22,930
non-white publicity context,
1495
01:07:22,930 --> 01:07:25,360
the video games are fully
protected by the First Amendment,
1496
01:07:25,360 --> 01:07:28,870
and sometimes the courts
do allow some protection
1497
01:07:28,870 --> 01:07:31,300
for, for video games.
1498
01:07:31,300 --> 01:07:35,050
So there's a good deal of
uncertainty among, excuse me,
1499
01:07:35,050 --> 01:07:39,580
along this, this vague line
1500
01:07:39,580 --> 01:07:42,070
between fully protected media
1501
01:07:42,070 --> 01:07:44,770
and ones that are viewed
as mere merchandising.
1502
01:07:44,770 --> 01:07:46,630
But at the same time, there's
also a lot of certainty.
1503
01:07:46,630 --> 01:07:48,970
One is that commercial advertising,
1504
01:07:48,970 --> 01:07:51,280
you can't use somebody
else's name or likeness.
1505
01:07:51,280 --> 01:07:53,950
Again, not because it's
private in the sense of being
1506
01:07:53,950 --> 01:07:57,220
embarrassing or kind of
like it's an invasion
1507
01:07:57,220 --> 01:07:58,690
of privacy in the normal sense, just
1508
01:07:58,690 --> 01:08:00,340
to mention the person's name or likeness.
1509
01:08:00,340 --> 01:08:02,560
But it's private in
the sense of belonging.
1510
01:08:02,560 --> 01:08:04,240
Like the name and
likeness belongs to them.
1511
01:08:04,240 --> 01:08:06,040
You can't use it. Internet
1512
01:08:06,040 --> 01:08:09,310
likewise for t-shirts pretty
well established that you,
1513
01:08:09,310 --> 01:08:12,310
that you can't print a t-shirt
1514
01:08:12,310 --> 01:08:13,930
and sell it with someone's name
1515
01:08:13,930 --> 01:08:15,200
and likeness without their permission,
1516
01:08:15,200 --> 01:08:17,570
unless it's really a
parody or something else.
1517
01:08:17,570 --> 01:08:19,185
Highly transformative like that.
1518
01:08:19,185 --> 01:08:21,980
On the other side is books,
movies, and the like.
1519
01:08:21,980 --> 01:08:25,550
Yeah, absolutely. You could
sell unauthorized biographies.
1520
01:08:26,660 --> 01:08:29,990
And then there's this
vague area about prints,
1521
01:08:29,990 --> 01:08:34,990
about greeting cards, about
paintings, about video games
1522
01:08:35,090 --> 01:08:36,170
where the law is uncertain.
1523
01:08:36,170 --> 01:08:38,450
You'd think since it's
the First Amendment issue,
1524
01:08:38,450 --> 01:08:39,980
Supreme Court would've stepped in.
1525
01:08:39,980 --> 01:08:41,900
Really basically in all these areas,
1526
01:08:41,900 --> 01:08:44,450
it hasn't much stepped in except
in unusual situations like
1527
01:08:44,450 --> 01:08:47,630
zucchini, which involved
this very specific right
1528
01:08:47,630 --> 01:08:50,180
of publicity as a right to
control one's entire act
1529
01:08:50,180 --> 01:08:51,590
or Florida Star VBJF,
1530
01:08:51,590 --> 01:08:53,870
which include all the
very specific statute
1531
01:08:55,580 --> 01:08:59,570
focused on a very, with a very
particular fact pattern of
1532
01:08:59,570 --> 01:09:02,240
where it's
the, the person
got the information, the name
1533
01:09:02,240 --> 01:09:05,480
of the rape victim from,
from government records.
1534
01:09:05,480 --> 01:09:08,000
So I'd like to see the
Supreme Court step in
1535
01:09:08,000 --> 01:09:09,110
and just clear things up a bit,
1536
01:09:09,110 --> 01:09:10,280
although sometimes it steps in
1537
01:09:10,280 --> 01:09:12,680
and muddies the waters further,
1538
01:09:12,680 --> 01:09:14,540
but it has, neither of
those have happened yet.
1539
01:09:15,830 --> 01:09:17,420
- Yeah. Although, although so, so we,
1540
01:09:17,420 --> 01:09:21,200
we've been focusing on
this episode on the torts.
1541
01:09:21,200 --> 01:09:24,065
There are now lots of
privacy statutes and the
1542
01:09:24,065 --> 01:09:26,090
- Supreme Supreme Court has
taken are one of the people
1543
01:09:26,090 --> 01:09:27,291
who has most written about this.
1544
01:09:28,370 --> 01:09:30,715
- Well, I guess that that might be right.
1545
01:09:30,715 --> 01:09:33,680
And, but the Supreme
Court also has taken up
1546
01:09:33,680 --> 01:09:37,250
privacy statutes a little more
frequently and more recently.
1547
01:09:37,250 --> 01:09:39,410
So, but, but maybe, I mean, but, but,
1548
01:09:39,410 --> 01:09:42,830
but in many ways what the
statutes do are, you know,
1549
01:09:42,830 --> 01:09:45,470
there's sort of variants
on some of the themes
1550
01:09:45,470 --> 01:09:48,440
that have come up and
been kind of explored
1551
01:09:48,440 --> 01:09:49,910
through tort law anyways.
1552
01:09:51,320 --> 01:09:53,540
And so ultimately the
statutes are still trying
1553
01:09:53,540 --> 01:09:56,900
to control either who gets
to collect data initially
1554
01:09:56,900 --> 01:09:58,190
or who gets to disclose it.
1555
01:09:58,190 --> 01:10:00,440
I mean, you can kind of see
it in, you know, in, in the,
1556
01:10:00,440 --> 01:10:05,030
in those two stages and it
covers most of the field,
1557
01:10:05,030 --> 01:10:09,560
but I think we probably
would try our audience's
1558
01:10:09,560 --> 01:10:13,310
patients if we went into
privacy statutes right now.
1559
01:10:13,310 --> 01:10:15,170
So maybe we'll have to
come back and talk about
1560
01:10:15,170 --> 01:10:16,820
- Maybe, so
- HIPA and FERPA
1561
01:10:16,820 --> 01:10:21,110
and all sorts of other privacy
laws like biometric privacy
1562
01:10:21,110 --> 01:10:25,130
rights, and there are a lot
of fun, you know, high tech,
1563
01:10:26,810 --> 01:10:31,100
high tech problems that have
been treated through statute
1564
01:10:31,100 --> 01:10:34,765
or, or, you know, digital
advertising and, and Right.
1565
01:10:34,765 --> 01:10:38,990
DDPR or style of laws that we
can come back and talk about.
1566
01:10:38,990 --> 01:10:40,280
But, but I think,
1567
01:10:41,930 --> 01:10:44,660
but I think some of the problems explored
1568
01:10:44,660 --> 01:10:45,740
that we explore today
1569
01:10:47,120 --> 01:10:50,690
where there are legitimate
interests in sharing information
1570
01:10:50,690 --> 01:10:53,570
and they run up against
legitimate interests in keeping
1571
01:10:53,570 --> 01:10:57,680
information controlled
are, you know, the, the,
1572
01:10:57,680 --> 01:10:59,180
those themes are, are, are going
1573
01:10:59,180 --> 01:11:01,280
to be very similar in
the statute of context
1574
01:11:01,280 --> 01:11:02,280
- In many ways.
1575
01:11:02,280 --> 01:11:04,670
And yeah, so, so this is
already quite long for one
1576
01:11:04,670 --> 01:11:06,170
of our episodes and,
1577
01:11:07,220 --> 01:11:09,260
and that just reflects what a complicated
1578
01:11:09,260 --> 01:11:12,110
and just the one, the,
1579
01:11:12,110 --> 01:11:15,180
the one thing you might away
a multifaceted question,
1580
01:11:15,180 --> 01:11:18,990
this is, this isn't like even free speech
1581
01:11:18,990 --> 01:11:21,450
and I don't know fighting words,
1582
01:11:21,450 --> 01:11:22,920
I don't think we've had
an episode just on that,
1583
01:11:22,920 --> 01:11:25,920
but it's basically about just
face-to-face personal insults.
1584
01:11:25,920 --> 01:11:27,720
We can cover that
quickly. Even free speech
1585
01:11:27,720 --> 01:11:30,360
and libel, there are a lot
of complications there,
1586
01:11:30,360 --> 01:11:32,130
but it is basically about false statements
1587
01:11:32,130 --> 01:11:33,615
that damage someone's reputation.
1588
01:11:33,615 --> 01:11:35,670
Here. There isn't even
innovation of privacy.
1589
01:11:35,670 --> 01:11:38,100
One invasion of privacy
torque. Really to make it
1590
01:11:38,100 --> 01:11:40,050
- Make - Sense, you have to
split it up into at least four
1591
01:11:40,050 --> 01:11:42,780
categories and that's just
focusing on the tor part.
1592
01:11:42,780 --> 01:11:44,880
So yeah, free speech and
privacy. Interesting thing.
1593
01:11:44,880 --> 01:11:48,450
I think a lot of the people
who like free speech also,
1594
01:11:48,450 --> 01:11:51,150
like privacy, at least from the government
1595
01:11:51,150 --> 01:11:53,340
and a lot of people like
privacy, like free speech,
1596
01:11:54,780 --> 01:11:56,430
and I think that's good.
1597
01:11:57,270 --> 01:12:00,360
But I do think we have to
acknowledge that it is complicated
1598
01:12:00,360 --> 01:12:01,650
because sometimes the two are in
1599
01:12:01,650 --> 01:12:02,730
real tension with each other.
1600
01:12:04,260 --> 01:12:07,890
- Yep.
- Well, Jane, great pleasure as always.
1601
01:12:07,890 --> 01:12:10,260
- Great to see you Eugene.
- Talk to you again soon.
1602
01:12:12,750 --> 01:12:15,990
- This podcast is a production
of the Hoover Institution,
1603
01:12:15,990 --> 01:12:19,770
where we generate and promote
ideas advancing freedom.
1604
01:12:19,770 --> 01:12:22,170
For more information about
our work, to hear more
1605
01:12:22,170 --> 01:12:23,400
of our podcasts
1606
01:12:23,400 --> 01:12:26,880
or view our video content,
please visit hoover.org.