رونوشت 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:37.270 --> 00:00:39.358
And the first is will cat and survive?
00:00:39.358 --> 00:00:42.219
And to me it is the driving question of the story.
00:00:42.219 --> 00:00:49.715
So when you have a question like that, will cat and survive as the main stakes of the story, the physical stakes, you know you're in action territory.
00:00:49.715 --> 00:00:59.097
In addition to action, super strong subplot in the story is society and we're dealing with the idea of eventually, towards the end of the trilogy, building towards a revolution.
00:00:59.097 --> 00:01:09.296
We have rebellion in moments here, Even in chapter two, we can kind of see little bits of a desire to rebel against the capital and how we're dealing with a power source.
00:01:12.396 --> 00:01:14.782
Welcome] to the fiction writing made easy podcast.
00:01:14.782 --> 00:01:18.575
My name is Savannah Gilbo and I'm here to help you write a story that works.
00:01:18.575 --> 00:01:30.718
I want to prove to you that writing a novel doesn't have to be overwhelming, so each week, I'll bring you a brand new episode with simple, actionable and step-by-step strategies that you can implement in your writing right away.
00:01:30.718 --> 00:01:36.414
So whether you're brand new to writing or more of a seasoned author looking to improve your craft, this podcast is for you.
00:01:36.414 --> 00:01:38.716
So pick up a pen and let's get started.
00:01:41.770 --> 00:02:00.056
In today's episode, abigail Kay Perry and I are diving deep into the first chapter of the Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins, and we're both super excited to dig into this opening chapter, not only because it's a really great example of an opening chapter that works, but also because it's one of our favorite stories and one of our favorite series.
00:02:00.056 --> 00:02:06.359
So we are planning to do the three books in the Hunger Games series, and today we're diving into that first one.
00:02:06.359 --> 00:02:10.036
Now, just in case you're new here, I want to introduce my co-host.
00:02:10.036 --> 00:02:11.856
Her name is Abigail Kay Perry.
00:02:11.856 --> 00:02:20.097
She's a developmental editor and the host of an amazing podcast called Lit Match, where she helps writers find the best literary agent for their writing and publishing careers.
00:02:20.097 --> 00:02:32.099
I will link to her podcast in the show notes as well as where you can find Abigail around the internet if you want to get in touch with her and if you are new here or if you need a reminder of what we do in these first chapter episodes.
00:02:32.330 --> 00:02:45.498
Abigail and I like to pick apart the opening chapters of stories to see how the author hooks our attention and pulls us into the story, and we analyze these opening chapters on both the macro big picture level and the smaller micro level as well.
00:02:45.498 --> 00:02:51.713
So basically, we're asking why does this chapter work and how does it set up the reader's expectation for the rest of the story?
00:02:51.713 --> 00:03:00.338
We also dig into the scene structure, so we want to find out how many scenes are in this chapter and if there are multiple scenes, how do those work together to create an awesome first chapter.
00:03:00.338 --> 00:03:04.056
So that's a very quick overview of what we're going to dig into today.
00:03:04.056 --> 00:03:07.796
You will hear more explanation for everything once we get inside the episode.
00:03:07.796 --> 00:03:13.893
So without further ado, let's dive right into the conversation where we discuss the Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins.
00:03:17.221 --> 00:03:31.876
Hi everyone, Savannah and I are back with another first chapter deep dive analysis and we are going to analyze the first chapter of the Hunger Games, which is one of my favorite books and series of all time.
00:03:31.876 --> 00:03:37.397
I wanted to do this forever with someone, and who better to do this with than Savannah?
00:03:37.397 --> 00:03:38.722
So thanks, Savannah.
00:03:38.722 --> 00:03:40.635
I'm so excited to tackle this with you.
00:03:41.117 --> 00:03:46.277
Of course and I'm excited too we are definitely going to nerd out today, so hopefully listeners are ready for that.
00:03:46.277 --> 00:03:47.713
But it was funny.
00:03:47.713 --> 00:03:57.218
In the past few episodes I feel like we've been trying to pick well, not a few episodes, but I feel like we've been trying to pick newer things and then when we were like, why have we never done the Hunger Games?
00:03:57.218 --> 00:03:59.959
It's one of both of our favorite books A Lightbulb Went Off.
00:03:59.959 --> 00:04:06.356
So not only do we love it, but we think the opening chapter and the opening pages is an excellent example for writers.
00:04:06.930 --> 00:04:12.781
So we are very excited to dig in and we have to do two and three, of course, after we do one.
00:04:12.781 --> 00:04:16.860
So look forward to another series of first chapter episodes.
00:04:16.860 --> 00:04:18.711
Yes, definitely so.
00:04:18.711 --> 00:04:24.961
For your usual with these episodes, we are going to do a big picture expectations analysis with the first chapter.
00:04:24.961 --> 00:04:34.716
So we'll use the seven key first chapter questions from Paul and Muniz, the writer's guide to beginnings Love that resource Look for that in the show notes if you want to check out that book.
00:04:35.110 --> 00:04:37.918
And then also we're going to go into a micro analysis.
00:04:37.918 --> 00:04:47.360
So we'll look at what makes this chapter a well-structured scene and to do that we use Story Grid's five commandments of storytelling or Robert McKee's five commandments.
00:04:47.360 --> 00:04:59.774
And of course, before all of that, let's give you a quick summary of what happens in chapter one so that if you don't have time to read it before, you know what we're talking about and how to dissect it and you can go check it out later.
00:04:59.774 --> 00:05:04.557
And if you want to go read it before this
Load full transcript
episode, pause and come back to it, because it's going to be quite fun.
00:05:05.169 --> 00:05:07.858
Yeah, we're going to get into a lot of stuff.
00:05:07.858 --> 00:05:14.695
So we have a lot of stuff to talk about about the scene analysis and a lot to talk about how Suzanne Collins set up big picture expectations.
00:05:14.695 --> 00:05:16.697
So it's going to be a jam-packed episode.
00:05:16.697 --> 00:05:19.238
But let me give you guys a summary to kick us off.
00:05:19.238 --> 00:05:21.778
So in chapter one we meet Katniss.
00:05:21.778 --> 00:05:28.897
She's waking up, she's looking next to her in bed, she's expecting to see her sister Prim there, but quickly realizes Prim is not there.
00:05:28.897 --> 00:05:30.034
She's in bed with her mother.
00:05:30.034 --> 00:05:34.695
And then she kind of mentions probably because it's reaping day and she's having nightmares.
00:05:34.695 --> 00:05:36.354
We don't know what that means yet.
00:05:36.750 --> 00:05:44.394
But then we see Katniss leave, set out to hunt with her best friend, gail, even though hunting is illegal and they kind of have to do it on the sly.
00:05:44.394 --> 00:05:53.579
They meet in the woods and they share what they consider to be a delectable meal of warm bread and goat cheese before setting off to hunt and fish.
00:05:53.579 --> 00:06:01.399
And so while they're doing all this they talk about their reaping and just the hunger games and things like that, without giving us too much detail yet.
00:06:01.399 --> 00:06:05.834
And then Gail suggests they run away together in an effort to avoid the reaping.
00:06:05.834 --> 00:06:09.038
But Katniss cannot even fathom the idea of leaving Prim.
00:06:09.038 --> 00:06:13.534
After all, who would provide for Prim and her mother now that their father is gone?
00:06:13.534 --> 00:06:17.159
And so shortly after that we get some context about her father.
00:06:17.159 --> 00:06:23.117
He died in a mining accident when she was very young and she's been the sole provider ever since.
00:06:23.117 --> 00:06:39.092
So this is why we're here hunting in the first place, and then, after a day of hunting and fishing and all that, katniss and Gail go to the market and the mayor's house to exchange what they hunted and gathered for other things, and then they kind of part ways to each get ready for the reaping.
00:06:39.649 --> 00:06:45.938
And so, still in chapter one, once they're back at Katniss's house, or once Katniss is home, she jumps in the bath.
00:06:45.938 --> 00:06:47.373
She gets ready for the reaping.
00:06:47.373 --> 00:06:48.938
Prim is also ready.
00:06:48.938 --> 00:06:57.674
She tries to soothe Prim, because Prim's very nervous about the reaping, and then as a family they head out to the square where the reaping's going to happen.
00:06:57.674 --> 00:07:07.141
So we start to get some more context about the hunger games, what's at stake, why the games were put into existence and things like that.
00:07:07.141 --> 00:07:14.241
And then at the very end of the chapter, prim's name is chosen as the female tribute from District 12.
00:07:14.241 --> 00:07:18.320
So a whole lot happens and we get a big ending to that chapter.
00:07:18.832 --> 00:07:36.320
Yeah, I love that breakdown, Savannah, and I love that you included all the big details, including when we go see Match, because that is not in the film, and I think that the hunger games, in my opinion, is one of the strongest adaptations of any story.
00:07:36.850 --> 00:07:45.389
I think that they do a wonderful job at preserving the emotions and the plot points in the story, but it is interesting to see there are differences.
00:07:45.389 --> 00:07:53.775
So, just if you are more familiar with the film versus the book, it's worth returning to look at the text in order to see what we're talking about.
00:07:53.775 --> 00:08:33.590
And I do think that there is a no sentence wasted type of feel to these sample pages, these, well, not sample pages, but these first pages, and I've highlighted a bunch in there to even talk about how she does such a great job of executing or setting up what feels like really, really special connections, I guess, even to the point of when you talk about when she is with Gail and they're eating bread and there's the whole thing with the boy with the bread and he tosses her a blackberry and it's not, but it's definitely significant that we're eating with dairy.
00:08:33.590 --> 00:08:40.455
So there are just little details here that I think if you are a super nerd with these books you'd catch and it's fun to look at that.
00:08:40.889 --> 00:08:41.150
Yeah.
00:08:41.150 --> 00:08:46.759
So even the things that on first glance could seem random, they're definitely not their setups for things that come later.
00:08:46.759 --> 00:09:13.603
And Abigail and I use this a lot as an example of an opening chapter that's done well, but also an example of how to get in backstory in a way that counts and that's impactful, how to show what certain events of the actual external plot mean to the character and things like that, and we'll get into that a little bit more later, but it's an excellent example of a chapter Definitely worth studying, definitely.
00:09:14.261 --> 00:09:30.091
Okay, so why don't we go ahead and move into the first chapter the seven key first chapter questions that we like to use when we are looking at stories, and how these first chapter questions set up those big picture expectations?
00:09:30.091 --> 00:09:34.330
Yes, okay, so I'll go ahead and just walk us through those.
00:09:34.330 --> 00:09:44.530
The first question deals with genre and, again, if you haven't listened to an episode before, then what we focus on here is the idea of content genre.
00:09:44.530 --> 00:09:47.080
So commercial genre is how it's marketed.
00:09:47.080 --> 00:09:51.298
Commercial genre for this would be YA sci-fi, right.
00:09:51.579 --> 00:09:51.740
Savannah.
00:09:51.740 --> 00:09:53.043
Yeah, YA,
dystopian.
00:09:53.245 --> 00:09:54.649
YA, sci-fi, yep.
00:09:54.649 --> 00:10:00.625
And then the content genre we're looking at is to how is the story, what is this?
00:10:00.625 --> 00:10:02.120
How does the story really unfold?
00:10:02.120 --> 00:10:06.543
One of the key concepts in the story that make the story what it is, yeah, so what do you think?
00:10:06.543 --> 00:10:07.948
What kind of story is this?
00:10:08.562 --> 00:10:16.352
We're definitely in action territory because even from page one we get that sense that lives are at stake and this is not a friendly world to live in.
00:10:16.352 --> 00:10:18.143
So definitely action.
00:10:18.143 --> 00:10:20.269
That just ramps up as we get further into the book.
00:10:20.610 --> 00:10:20.931
Mm-hmm.
00:10:20.931 --> 00:10:23.685
Yeah, I definitely agree the life and death stakes.
00:10:23.685 --> 00:10:27.258
Survival is the main question that drives the story.
00:10:27.258 --> 00:10:31.009
Yeah, I don't know if anyone follows Gabriella Pereira DOIMFA.
00:10:31.009 --> 00:10:32.982
I love her she.
00:10:32.982 --> 00:10:36.235
I remember back in 2015, my Redo Stygianos conference.
00:10:36.235 --> 00:10:43.333
I went to her, I went to one of her presentations and she talked about how hunger games really breaks up.
00:10:43.333 --> 00:10:54.360
It really does a great job at presenting three big questions right away, I think the story, and the first is we'll can't survive, right, and to me it is the driving question of the story.
00:10:54.360 --> 00:10:57.312
So when you have a question like that, we'll can't survive.
00:10:57.674 --> 00:11:02.210
As the main stakes of the story the physical stakes you know you're in action territory, right.
00:11:02.210 --> 00:11:11.330
In addition to action, a super strong subplot in the story is society and we're dealing with the idea of eventually, towards the end of the trilogy, building towards a revolution.
00:11:11.330 --> 00:11:14.540
We have rebellion in moments here.
00:11:14.540 --> 00:11:35.927
Even in chapter two, we can kind of see little bits of a desire to rebel against the capital and how we're dealing with a power source and controlling people with power and people who are in have impotence and basically have no power in the situation, and we see that a lot in thematic questions that we're going to get into details a little bit with how, what Katniss and Gail talked about.
00:11:35.927 --> 00:11:40.494
So I do think that society is a really, really strong.
00:11:40.494 --> 00:11:42.120
Just the story doesn't work.
00:11:42.120 --> 00:11:46.511
It's so important to this story, but we're dealing with main stakes, physical stakes.
00:11:46.912 --> 00:11:54.493
Right, and there's the kind of a love subplot right, at first with her and Gail, later with her and Pita, later even with them kind of mixed together.
00:11:54.493 --> 00:12:00.504
So, yeah, definitely a lot going on here, which is really cool because we get flavors of all of that
in this first chapter.
00:12:01.040 --> 00:12:03.168
Who doesn't love the love story in this?
00:12:03.168 --> 00:12:04.985
I know I love the love story in this.
00:12:05.561 --> 00:12:15.886
And it's so fun too to think about like a love story, despite what's going on, like there's 25 kids in an arena fighting to their death you know, and there's still some kind of connection happening.
00:12:16.180 --> 00:12:20.891
Of course, and even we even see that in chapter two, with her thinking about the boy with the bread.
00:12:20.891 --> 00:12:23.400
So right, we'll talk about that, okay?
00:12:23.400 --> 00:12:29.551
The second question deals with plot and the question is what is the story really about?
00:12:29.551 --> 00:12:33.418
So what is the big picture story really about or the main story really about?
00:12:33.437 --> 00:12:38.886
Yeah, and I think you hit on this earlier that it's about whether or not Katniss is going to win the Hunger Games and survive.
00:12:38.886 --> 00:12:52.629
So you know, before we even get into that question, because we kind of get there in this first chapter, but it's, you know, katniss's whole deal is I want to protect Prim, I want to provide for my family so that collectively we can survive.
00:12:52.629 --> 00:12:55.311
So we're, even though we're not quite into that.
00:12:55.311 --> 00:12:57.160
Am I going to survive or not survive?
00:12:57.160 --> 00:12:58.605
The Hunger Games are not questioned.
00:12:58.605 --> 00:13:01.388
It's about, you know, survival.
00:13:02.100 --> 00:13:06.852
And I think that within that question, will she or will she not survive?
00:13:06.852 --> 00:13:17.293
That's how, when we get into the details of how she moves through the story, we start to understand that her idea of how she's going to survive is not what she expected, right?
00:13:17.293 --> 00:13:24.786
So very much in this first chapter we can see that it feels like a very black and white view of what survival is to her.
00:13:24.786 --> 00:13:39.105
And even this idea of conversation with Gail and the idea of will they run or not, it's just so instinctive, like when you said she can't even fathom the idea of leaving because she has to protect Prim.
00:13:39.105 --> 00:13:42.389
I think another question in there is will I survive?
00:13:42.389 --> 00:13:47.603
Another question is how do I protect Prim, or can I protect Prim or will she?
00:13:47.603 --> 00:13:48.706
Will she protect Prim?
00:13:48.706 --> 00:13:56.334
Right, and when she volunteers we see that she her knee jerk reaction is just I have to save her.
00:13:56.721 --> 00:14:10.600
So I think that there's a really good line in chapter two where it talks about how, in district, like in other districts, volunteering is almost a pride movement and they wait their chance to volunteer.
00:14:10.600 --> 00:14:18.729
But in district 12, when the word volunteer or when the word tribute is synonymous with chorus, it's not so much something that happens.
00:14:18.729
--> 00:14:29.109
So you can see all that, but I think, within that, I guess to look at the internal arc, because I think that the external arc is pretty clearly an action story.
00:14:29.109 --> 00:14:31.557
The internal arc, Savannah.
00:14:31.557 --> 00:14:32.700
What do you think is going on there?
00:14:32.700 --> 00:14:45.674
Because to me it's about her challenging that worldview of what does it take to survive, which goes against a lot of these hard shells that she's used to protect herself and survive up to this moment in her life.
00:14:46.179 --> 00:14:46.280
Yeah.
00:14:46.280 --> 00:14:54.360
So I want to pause and I'll answer that in a second and I want to go back to and just kind of put a disclaimer that she doesn't volunteer's tribute in chapter one.
00:14:54.360 --> 00:14:58.379
So that does come in chapter two, just for anybody that's listening.
00:14:58.379 --> 00:15:09.990
So what's kind of cool and this is why I wanted to go into that before I answer your question is because a lot of the internal arc is set up so that when we get to her, volunteering is tribute in chapter two.
00:15:09.990 --> 00:15:11.980
We know a lot of what's at stake.
00:15:11.980 --> 00:15:19.560
We also know how emotionally and intellectually she's kind of equipped to deal with what just happened and volunteering is tribute and things like that.
00:15:20.846 --> 00:15:37.720
But there's a couple of places in the text let me find them when Katniss is kind of showing us how she feels about things in the capital, about their world and things like that, because we see her like in the beginning her primary focus is on providing for her family, making sure Prem's okay and things like that.
00:15:37.720 --> 00:15:49.398
We see that Gail is kind of pulling her out of her comfort zone with the questions he's asking and, like Abigail said, it's something that Katniss can't even fathom.
00:15:49.398 --> 00:15:53.100
Like thinking through, what would it mean to leave, because so many people rely on us.
00:15:53.100 --> 00:16:00.067
So also, like Abigail said, that thought process of what does it mean to survive, how am I going to survive?
00:16:00.067 --> 00:16:02.360
That gets challenged the further she goes into the story.
00:16:03.509 --> 00:16:04.680
But we have that society element there too.
00:16:04.680 --> 00:16:20.620
So Gail gets upset when they go and talk to Madge because he's in the fish bowl, his name's in the fish bowl like 40-something times and Madges might only be in there once and it's unfair and things like that and he's really passionate about it and Katniss is just kind of like what's the point?
00:16:20.620 --> 00:16:22.620
What are we going to do here in District 12?
00:16:22.620 --> 00:16:32.715
So throughout the book and throughout the series it becomes what does survival mean if we're the disenfranchised and if we don't even have what's a fair life?
00:16:32.715 --> 00:16:35.816
So a lot to unpack there.
00:16:38.008 --> 00:16:49.179
Yeah, that's a really interesting point that you bring up, savannah, because I think a lot in stories that feel society dominant, often that question comes up as what does it mean Like, is survival even worth it if you don't have freedom?
00:16:50.363 --> 00:16:50.564
Yeah.
00:16:51.105 --> 00:16:58.365
I'm thinking of 12 Years a Slave I don't know if anyone has seen that movie but that there's even a line like that where it's like what is it so?
00:16:58.365 --> 00:17:00.532
Basically, that the point of it is that's it doesn't.
00:17:00.532 --> 00:17:02.557
It's not worth surviving if you're not free.
00:17:02.557 --> 00:17:11.230
And that means towards more of that arc of we were building towards a revolution, where Katniss is.
00:17:11.230 --> 00:17:18.290
A lot of what she has to challenge is that is she going to find it in her to Do rebel against the Capitol?
00:17:18.751 --> 00:17:27.167
I have a line here I'm looking at the Kindle version so it's a handful of pages in but she says when I was younger I steered my mother to death.
00:17:27.167 --> 00:17:33.311
The things I would gloar it out about district 12, about the people who rule our country, pnm From the far off city called the Capitol.
00:17:33.311 --> 00:17:36.734
Eventually I understood this would only lead us to more trouble.
00:17:36.734 --> 00:17:47.616
So I learned to hold my tongue and to turn my features into an indifferent mask so that no one could ever read my thoughts Right, which I think is so interesting, because that's the opposite of what she's going to learn to do.
00:17:47.616 --> 00:17:56.016
But she is Placed right now and how she reacts into Her, her light, her everyday life is just about get through the day, survive through the day.
00:17:56.526 --> 00:17:57.047
Well, let me.
00:17:57.047 --> 00:18:06.278
Let me read this part, because it says this is after Gail gets upset with Maj and Katniss is thinking she's thinking but what good is yelling about the Capitol in the middle of the woods?
00:18:06.278 --> 00:18:10.605
It doesn't change anything, it doesn't make things fair, it doesn't fill our stomachs.
00:18:10.605 --> 00:18:13.238
In fact it scares off the nearby game.
00:18:13.238 --> 00:18:16.732
I let him yell, though better he does it in the woods than in the district.
00:18:16.732 --> 00:18:21.697
So she's kind of just like you know, she's so focused on that on the ground survival.
00:18:21.697 --> 00:18:24.314
Because of course she is right, she's young.
00:18:24.314 --> 00:18:30.739
Also, she has this kind of like Abigail, the quote she read was this indifference mask right?
00:18:30.739 --> 00:18:33.754
Why would she think she could do anything major at this point?
00:18:34.204 --> 00:18:40.046
Exactly, and I think that's where I'm going back to that big question of what is the story really about, how?
00:18:40.046 --> 00:18:42.592
I think it is about, well, katniss survive.
00:18:42.592 --> 00:18:45.438
And then it's about how is she going to survive?
00:18:45.438 --> 00:18:47.789
What, what will it take to survive?
00:18:48.331 --> 00:18:50.075
and when we get survival going to change her.
00:18:50.276 --> 00:18:52.046
Yeah, exactly yeah.
00:18:52.046 --> 00:18:56.376
And and which is so interesting is, you know, fast-forwarding outside of the first chapter.
00:18:56.376 --> 00:19:01.008
But that is the big thing about and why pita Needs to be her person.
00:19:01.008 --> 00:19:05.429
Because pita is about I don't want the games to change me, right?
00:19:05.429 --> 00:19:08.285
The response to that is I can't afford to think like that.
00:19:08.786 --> 00:19:41.535
Yeah so we can see how she is grounded in this misbelief of the only way to survive Is to kind of basically like keep your head down right Right and kill when you need to kill, right Like, even like it's interesting to use hunting in chapter one that talks so much in detail about how she hunts and why she's have to good hunter and she even she goes into this, this kind of Backstory about a links that used to follow her and she actually really liked the links and kind of felt like it was company, but eventually she had to kill the links because it was chasing away her gain.
00:19:41.535 --> 00:19:44.831
And Then she says something like but you know, meat is meat.
00:19:44.831 --> 00:20:01.136
So it's so interesting she is really Maybe I'm just also you, you and I being huge animal people Savannah, that was hard to swallow over me I like don't kill the links, but I think that that's where it's so crucial to her character and we can talk about that more in her character question.
00:20:01.136 --> 00:20:03.805
But it is showing us this first chapter.
00:20:03.805 --> 00:20:18.335
When I look at this, I always use this one as an interesting example, because the one of the first pieces of advice I ever got on writing first chapters was do not start with someone waking up and going through their day, and that is exactly what happens here.
00:20:18.496 --> 00:20:20.584
Katniss wakes up and we go through her day.
00:20:20.584 --> 00:20:28.204
Now she wakes up and it's the day of the reaping, so it's a much bigger day than just I'm going to my job and it's the monotonous routine.
00:20:28.204 --> 00:20:34.437
But and we ground the details in here of her hunting is very exciting, like her day is very interesting.
00:20:34.437 --> 00:20:41.100
Things are happening, but I think that all of this is grounded in this intense fear.
00:20:41.100 --> 00:20:47.136
We are moving towards danger, we are moving towards death, and how are you going to face that?
00:20:47.605 --> 00:20:56.831
And so two things that I want to say to that is one about the animal thing, because you kind of have to laugh at the cat part in the beginning where prams cat Cat thinks that the cat hates her.
00:20:56.831 --> 00:21:00.221
So it says he hates me or at least distrust me.
00:21:00.221 --> 00:21:08.771
Even though it was years ago I I think he still remembers how I tried to drown him in a bucket when prim brought him home Scrawny kitten, belly swollen with worms, crawling with fleas.
00:21:08.771 --> 00:21:11.478
The last thing I needed was another mouth to feed.
00:21:11.478 --> 00:21:17.229
So it's like everything is through that lens of how am I going to survive and provide for my family and keep prim happy?
00:21:17.229 --> 00:21:21.644
Because the very next sentence is prim begged me so hard cried even I had to let him stay.
00:21:21.644 --> 00:21:26.629
So it's like everything about survival is number one, but so is prim.
00:21:26.629 --> 00:21:27.874
So she kind of lets prim.
00:21:27.874 --> 00:21:32.733
We get to see, like, what that Weakness is, what that vulnerability is and things like that.
00:21:33.325 --> 00:21:38.225
But the second thing I want to say is, even though we're going through the day, like you said, we have questions.
00:21:38.225 --> 00:21:42.557
So we're being led through this text with questions of like, what is the reaping?
00:21:42.557 --> 00:21:57.456
So in the beginning all we get is it says this is the day of the reaping, and then we kind of go through some days right or some of the rest of the day and I'm scrolling to see where we get the next thing, because every time she mentions it we just get a little bit more information.
00:21:57.456 --> 00:22:05.215
So we keep reading to find out like what does this mean and how does this, you know, how does this have to do with her getting into the hunger games and things like that?
00:22:05.215 --> 00:22:07.883
Let's see I'm looking for the text.
00:22:08.625 --> 00:22:12.856
I know just while you look for the text I can kind of list off some, some details that stood out to me.
00:22:12.856 --> 00:22:24.798
Talking about the woods, right, yeah, there's a place in the fence is usually electric, but it the electricity isn't worked in, like for a couple hours at night maybe, but otherwise it's usually down.
00:22:24.798 --> 00:22:26.087
It used to the.
00:22:26.087 --> 00:22:44.545
It sounds like the district actually had built the fence to keep the animals, the dangerous animals like Hoogers and things like that, out of the district, but it hasn't worked in a long time and some people will Go underneath the vents and venture through it in order to Get food, like Katniss and Gail, who are skilled at hunting.
00:22:44.545 --> 00:22:50.465
Otherwise their families would perish because starving is not uncommon in district 12, right.
00:22:50.826 --> 00:22:52.711
And then you know how she.
00:22:52.711 --> 00:22:53.735
What does she do with that game?
00:22:53.735 --> 00:23:08.336
Usually she's trading out with peacekeepers and she talks about how the peacekeepers technically work for the capital but are actually their greatest, uh, customers, because they have money and Also they're kind of looking the other way because they want to eat.
00:23:08.336 --> 00:23:10.684
Sounds like they're not treated super awesome by the capital.
00:23:10.684 --> 00:23:21.471
So you kind of get that we interact with the black market, which is something that is, I think, given more Intention in the book than in the film.
00:23:21.471 --> 00:23:25.514
But you have the black market and what she does and where she works with.
00:23:25.514 --> 00:23:38.590
And then, of course, like you talk, you have the conversation with manged, the mayor's daughter, and understanding that there does seem to be a hierarchy of privilege in the district, but it sounds like in general like everyone still is Basically screwed in district 12.
00:23:38.590 --> 00:23:42.317
It's into very, a very underprivileged district out of all of the districts.
00:23:42.805 --> 00:23:47.184
Yeah, and so kind of on that note, like we, we get this information dripped out to us.
00:23:47.184 --> 00:23:52.758
It's not like there's a giant prologue with here's the history of, but you know, district 12 and the capital and all this.
00:23:52.758 --> 00:23:55.673
But back on that note of the the rape.
00:23:55.673 --> 00:23:58.312
No, at first she just says, like today is the day of the reaping.
00:23:58.312 --> 00:24:03.065
Right then, when she gets to gail Gail's like happy hunger games and they're kind of making fun of it.
00:24:03.065 --> 00:24:06.895
So we get a little more information like what is, what is this?
00:24:06.895 --> 00:24:08.568
Why do they feel this way about it?
00:24:08.568 --> 00:24:12.357
Later on it says after the reaping, everyone is supposed to celebrate.
00:24:12.357 --> 00:24:16.655
A lot of people do out of relief their children have been spared for another year.
00:24:16.655 --> 00:24:21.537
So we get more information uh, two families will pull their shutters, we don't know why yet.
00:24:21.537 --> 00:24:27.374
So she's really leading us through with this like central question of what's going on here.
00:24:27.374 --> 00:24:28.704
Like this place seems terrible.
00:24:28.704 --> 00:24:32.114
But then there's this additional element of the reaping and the hunger games.
00:24:32.114 --> 00:24:34.866
I hope everyone's going to be okay, yeah definitely.
00:24:35.146 --> 00:24:36.169
It's really scuffly done.
00:24:36.169 --> 00:24:39.035
Okay, so let's go look at question number three.
00:24:39.035 --> 00:24:43.150
Question number three deals with point of view, and the question is who is telling the story?
00:24:43.652 --> 00:24:46.178
So we are in Katniss's perspective.
00:24:46.365 --> 00:25:11.058
We have a first person narrator, which I think is appropriate for a young adult book and in a book where we want to be so close to Our protagonist, yes, and this is one of the examples that I use About how important the point of view is, because it's also in present tense yeah and it's, so it's first person present tense, and that adds to the tension of story because we don't know if Katniss is going to survive or not.
00:25:11.058 --> 00:25:17.921
Right happening in real time as you read, and that question of
is she gonna die or not, we don't know.
00:25:17.921 --> 00:25:23.596
And if it was yeah, or telling the story back on when she went into the hunger games, that would take out that tension.
00:25:24.565 --> 00:25:26.650
Yeah, and as a reader, how do you like present tense?
00:25:27.171 --> 00:25:27.872
me in general.
00:25:27.872 --> 00:25:30.899
Yep, I think I gravitate towards past over present.
00:25:30.899 --> 00:25:39.131
I think that Present can when I at least, like when I'm working with writers sometimes it can feel Like the voice doesn't come out as strong.
00:25:39.131 --> 00:25:40.375
Yeah, whatever reason.
00:25:40.375 --> 00:25:43.031
But I love this book in present tense.
00:25:43.031 --> 00:25:46.765
But I think, yeah, I tend to feel like I gravitate towards past.
00:25:46.785 --> 00:25:48.019
Yeah me too, and it's.
00:25:48.019 --> 00:25:59.991
It's funny because it, like you said, it adds to the immediacy and at first, whenever I dip back into this it's a little jarring for me because I read a lot of past tense, but I think it's the right call for this book.
00:25:59.991 --> 00:26:00.693
Yeah.
00:26:00.713 --> 00:26:01.355
I agree with that.
00:26:01.355 --> 00:26:03.568
Okay, this is a big question.
00:26:03.568 --> 00:26:05.134
Is this a really important question?
00:26:05.134 --> 00:26:07.329
And it deals with characters.
00:26:07.329 --> 00:26:08.173
Question number four.
00:26:08.173 --> 00:26:11.884
And the question is which character should the readers care about the most?
00:26:12.487 --> 00:26:12.668
Yeah.
00:26:12.668 --> 00:26:25.308
So I actually want to back up for a second and I want to talk a little bit more about point of view, because I work with a lot of writers who are writing sci-fi or fantasy and they want to have multiple points of view For that kind of bigger scope.
00:26:25.308 --> 00:26:30.439
So I think it's worth talking about, like, why is pita not a point of view character?
00:26:30.439 --> 00:26:32.391
Why is gale not a point of view character?
00:26:32.913 --> 00:26:33.936
That's a great question.
00:26:33.936 --> 00:26:48.496
Well, for I think gale is pretty easy for this book because he's not that, not where the action is, yeah, and we don't even really get the sense that they're a romantic pair Until I think the end of the story are fat or more like chapter.
00:26:48.496 --> 00:26:48.905
I think.
00:26:48.905 --> 00:26:52.875
More book two, the romance, romance with gale and cat, this feels like it picks up a bit.
00:26:52.875 --> 00:26:53.177
For me.
00:26:53.177 --> 00:27:01.115
They feel more like a she and she encourages the idea that they're more of a brother, sister for relationship in this first book.
00:27:01.557 --> 00:27:12.192
If you're watching the movie you don't get that sense at all Because the movie has the advantage of doing what the book does not, because it is Omniscient in its point of view telling versus the.
00:27:12.192 --> 00:27:20.097
The book is first person present and
we can go away from the games to go see gale watching catness kissing pita and things like that.
00:27:20.097 --> 00:27:25.336
So that's where it's like again, like the difference between what you're doing with the film, what you're doing with the book.
00:27:25.336 --> 00:27:33.895
But so that's where you know in the book I don't think gale would be worth a point of view and at least you know, definitely in this first book, because he's just at home taking care of the family.
00:27:33.895 --> 00:27:37.132
There's no arc really there he's just walking with catness.
00:27:37.553 --> 00:27:39.257
So he'd be an observer, pita.
00:27:39.257 --> 00:27:41.270
I think he'd be giving answers away.
00:27:41.270 --> 00:27:42.014
Totally.
00:27:42.014 --> 00:27:47.827
The plot the whole is pita or catness or against catness Would go out the.
00:27:47.827 --> 00:27:58.505
Would, you know, go out the door If you had pita's point of view, because I don't think that you could or be very challenging to hide pita's true intentions for why he took up with the careers.
00:27:59.247 --> 00:28:11.031
And that's exactly why I wanted to ask you, because Certain writers would say well, I want to show someone like pita's point of view so that the reader knows right, the reader knows what his true intentions are, but then that spoils the tension.
00:28:11.031 --> 00:28:23.619
From catness's point of view, like we don't need to let our reader know everything, I think in a lot of cases it's better that we Filter it through the protagonist's point of view and have them guess wrong sometimes and have them doubt and wonder and things like that.
00:28:23.619 --> 00:28:25.656
You know that's what builds that tension.
00:28:26.121 --> 00:28:26.704
Yeah, I agree.
00:28:26.704 --> 00:28:37.365
I also think that, pita I'm going to see if I can phrase this in the way that I want to phrase this Katniss has a lot to gain and lose and she changes a lot.
00:28:37.365 --> 00:28:38.026
In this story.
00:28:38.026 --> 00:28:45.066
Peter doesn't really change, you know so he does, and that the games make him less naive.
00:28:45.066 --> 00:28:51.813
I guess you would say Like there is like a worldview arc in there, but as has it like a in his core.
00:28:52.074 --> 00:28:56.944
I don't think he really changes and it's almost what Katniss loves most about him.
00:28:56.944 --> 00:29:19.642
You know that he is this innately good human being and he's really like everything that Katniss lacks or that she undervalues in herself, that she can't see herself being, but he pulls out of her and I think that that's something like when Peter says to her you know, outside of chapter one, but when he says to her I don't want the games to change me.
00:29:19.642 --> 00:29:25.759
And immediately you think the games have changed him, because you have Katniss's point of view and you're just seeing what she's seeing.
00:29:25.759 --> 00:29:39.463
That really throws us right, because we got to know this, this sweet boy with the bread who just innately seems good and it will be hard for him to kill others, but then we can see that he can step up and do that if it's to protect Katniss.
00:29:39.985 --> 00:29:43.324
Right, yeah, and it's really interesting because she brings to him what he lacks as well.
00:29:43.324 --> 00:29:45.021
Like he's not that confident in the beginning.
00:29:45.021 --> 00:29:51.718
He thinks, you know, might as well focus our attention on you, because you're the one that's going to survive, you know, so he does.
00:29:51.718 --> 00:29:56.488
I do agree that he has like the less interesting arc, but he does change In that way.
00:29:56.488 --> 00:30:01.865
Yeah, I mean he changes, but it's not as impactful as Katniss's growth, Right, right.
00:30:02.306 --> 00:30:06.304
Yeah, so ultimately, on point of view, everything Peter does is for Katniss.
00:30:06.304 --> 00:30:10.105
So if you had his point of view, we'd be giving all those spoilers away.
00:30:10.516 --> 00:30:14.624
Yes, definitely, and so you were asking what character should we care about the most?
00:30:14.624 --> 00:30:18.265
Well, I mean, I think obviously Katniss, because she's our protagonist.
00:30:18.265 --> 00:30:24.067
We care about what she cares about because of how her introduction to us was set up.
00:30:24.067 --> 00:30:26.402
We also, of course, care about Prim.
00:30:26.402 --> 00:30:33.562
We care about, you know, the families of Gail and Katniss and people in District 12, but primarily we're with Katniss?
00:30:34.136 --> 00:30:35.201
Yeah, I 100% agree.
00:30:35.201 --> 00:30:42.201
I think that you made a really good point and that this is a really great example about how you, of course, care about your protagonist.
00:30:42.201 --> 00:30:59.863
You must care about your protagonist in opening pages in order for us to care about the story, and we care about what Katniss cares about, and that's part of what I think makes the stakes so high or so early in the story, because it's not Katniss' name that's drawn, it's Prim's.
00:31:00.816 --> 00:31:25.741
Well, I love once we get into chapter two more and we have seen where they're talking about, how they exchange food for, like the names that get put in the bowl, how Katniss has done everything she can do to not let Prim's name be chosen and then it is, so it's like she gets put in, I think one of the best, worst decisions ever, where it's like either her or me right and it's literally the worst decision she could face in her life.
00:31:26.303 --> 00:31:26.765
Absolutely.
00:31:26.765 --> 00:31:28.698
And then later this is chapter two.
00:31:28.698 --> 00:31:42.454
But later in chapter two then Pita is drawn and she comments about how Pita has two older brothers and one is unable to volunteer because he's above 18, but one could volunteer and he doesn't right.
00:31:42.454 --> 00:31:47.625
It's like you know what me volunteering would be the abnormality versus the norm.
00:31:47.625 --> 00:32:02.365
I wanted to look up something real quick in chapter two that I think, and I guess, like you know, when Savannah and I go into the scene structure, we're going to talk about some chapter one, some of chapter two a little bit and what we decided to do there.
00:32:02.365 --> 00:32:21.004
But I think that talking about character and talking about like why we care so much, there's this area where normally people don't get overexcited when someone volunteers, like I've talked about earlier about the districts and how they're different to volunteer in District 12 versus volunteer in District one or something like that.
00:32:21.004 --> 00:32:43.776
But I have this piece right here where she starts to walk up and she talks about how the crowd is really upset when Prim's name is drawn and there's kind of this like tisking, because people are usually upset when a 12 year old gets drawn because it's not fair, like when a and of course, like Rue is going to be a foil character for Prim, who is also 12.
00:32:43.776 --> 00:32:47.563
But then it says but a shift occurred.
00:32:47.563 --> 00:32:55.200
So she volunteers and she says but a shift has occurred since I stepped up to take Prim's place and now it seems I have become someone precious.
00:32:55.200 --> 00:33:02.767
At first one, then another, then almost every member of the crowd touches the three middle fingers to their left hand, their lips, and holds it out to me.
00:33:02.767 --> 00:33:06.844
It is an old and rarely used gesture of our district, occasionally seen at funerals.
00:33:06.844 --> 00:33:11.421
It means thanks, it means admiration, it means goodbye to someone you love.
00:33:11.421 --> 00:33:14.143
So that's chapter two versus chapter one.
00:33:14.375 --> 00:33:37.870
But I think that that is just so interesting to see how we are really drawn to care about Katniss because we see her as really kind of the martyr of this family, before she's even the martyr of the whole entire district and she has done everything in her power to care for her family at the cost of her I don't want to say humanity, because she is a she.
00:33:37.870 --> 00:33:40.139
There's definitely like tenderness to her, but she is.
00:33:40.139 --> 00:33:59.449
She is hard, there's a hard shell around and that shell has been layered and layered over years of loss and forced hands to survive, from her father being killed to her mother going ghost like and failing to take care of the family.
00:33:59.449 --> 00:34:08.983
So she had to step up to take care of the family and by, like you said, age 12, she was already putting her name in for for Tesserae, right, did you say that?
00:34:08.983 --> 00:34:09.944
Is that my pronounce?
00:34:09.944 --> 00:34:10.645
I think so.
00:34:10.766 --> 00:34:13.148
Yeah, yeah, for Tesserae, so she would.
00:34:13.148 --> 00:34:17.942
Her name ends so then she'd have more names and, like you said, she's done this every year to 16.
00:34:17.942 --> 00:34:22.853
So her name is in there 20
times instead of the minimal amount of times.
00:34:22.853 --> 00:34:26.362
Everything she can to make sure that Prim did not have extra names in.
00:34:26.362 --> 00:34:28.779
Yeah, so you care about that character.
00:34:28.779 --> 00:34:32.744
You care about someone who cares about someone more than herself, right?
00:34:33.215 --> 00:34:37.520
And it's like you can't blame her for her hardness, like you're saying, because it's been built up over time.
00:34:37.520 --> 00:34:46.278
And then when we get to the question of what is going to happen when you actually survive, like, is it, is it really worth going back to the world you're from and it you know?
00:34:46.278 --> 00:34:47.987
Who knows what she would say if you asked her.
00:34:47.987 --> 00:34:51.382
But she wants to go back because she wants to keep caring for Prim.
00:34:51.382 --> 00:34:55.784
So she's very steady in that the whole time, which makes her admirable, absolutely.
00:34:55.784 --> 00:34:56.264
Yeah.
00:34:57.315 --> 00:34:57.596
So we, we do.
00:34:57.596 --> 00:35:07.123
We care about Kennis, we care about Prim, we care about really like, if you get to chapter two, I care about Peter, because everyone feels bad for anyone whose name is being drawn.
00:35:07.123 --> 00:35:28.965
You really care about Peter because then you learn that he's the boy with the bread, right, you know that's kind of going into chapter two, but we are understanding why these characters matter so much to us so early on, which means that, as you go forward, even though this story is so plot driven, this is plot driven in the way that we care first and foremost about characters.
00:35:28.965 --> 00:35:33.905
So why the plot is so intense is because if characters die it's upsetting.
00:35:34.367 --> 00:35:36.420
Right and just like to bring that home.
00:35:36.420 --> 00:35:38.271
Imagine it from Kato's perspective.
00:35:38.271 --> 00:35:39.999
We probably wouldn't care as much, right?
00:35:39.999 --> 00:35:45.896
The plot would not sustain I mean, who knows what Kato's backstory really is, but the Kato that we know.
00:35:45.896 --> 00:35:52.981
The plot itself would probably not be enough to sustain a story about him where he's just kind of like being a bruiser through this whole hunger games.
00:35:54.264 --> 00:35:55.927
Yeah, absolutely Okay.
00:35:55.927 --> 00:35:58.181
So question number five is setting.
00:35:58.181 --> 00:36:01.461
Deals with setting, and the question is where and when does the story take place?
00:36:01.822 --> 00:36:01.963
Yep.
00:36:01.963 --> 00:36:08.346
So specifically, we are in Penem, which this is a dystopian future, and we are in district 12 with Kennis.
00:36:08.646 --> 00:36:08.847
Yeah.
00:36:08.847 --> 00:36:29.384
So with a lot of great details, you could really just peel through these pages and, as Savannah mentioned this earlier, we are learning about the setting through the action, so we're not getting just a big bunch of info dump that explains the districts and explains why they're so poor and starving.
00:36:29.384 --> 00:36:41.697
We see this because of how Kennis is going about through her day and there are external events happening around her that trigger reason for us to learn more about this world, and that's where it's like.
00:36:41.697 --> 00:36:55.762
You know, savannah did the word count and it's a longer first chapter, but it grounds us in world, which, of course, is very important for something that's dystopian, because when you've done it and it's not like.
00:36:56.063 --> 00:36:57.626
here's my textbook of Penem.
00:36:57.626 --> 00:37:02.684
It's great we're going to learn this because of what Kennis is interacting with.
00:37:03.155 --> 00:37:05.804
Yeah, and there's a lot that's not said in this opening chapter.
00:37:05.804 --> 00:37:10.333
So you know about the world and a lot of the sci-fi fantasy writers I work with.
00:37:10.333 --> 00:37:13.862
They tend to either want to put like a prologue.
00:37:13.862 --> 00:37:19.925
That's like Abigail said, here's the history, start to finish and here's everything you need to know before you read page one.
00:37:19.925 --> 00:37:26.079
We don't want to do that, but what we do include in this opening chapter is it's always triggered by something in the present moment.
00:37:26.079 --> 00:37:33.195
So you know, she sees the minors and she thinks about her dad and you know, because he was a minor and things like that, and it doesn't.
00:37:33.195 --> 00:37:44.443
There's nothing extra that's not triggered by something in the moment, which means there's going to be a lot that we don't know yet, which is another reason why we want to keep moving forward and reading to find out more about the world.
00:37:44.903 --> 00:37:46.588
Yes, definitely Okay.
00:37:46.588 --> 00:37:53.364
So question number six deals with the core motion and we kind of paired this one with question number seven, the stakes, because they go hand in hand.
00:37:53.364 --> 00:37:56.923
So the two questions are how should the readers feel about what's happening?
00:37:56.923 --> 00:38:01.985
That's dealing with emotion, and the stakes question is why should the readers care about what happens next?
00:38:01.985 --> 00:38:04.021
Yeah, I think that's right too right.
00:38:04.463 --> 00:38:09.985
Yeah, and I feel like the three areas I kind of go to are like concern, curiosity and wonder.
00:38:09.985 --> 00:38:16.503
And we don't really have a lot of wonder here because we're, you know, this is a pretty sad, sad state of life.
00:38:16.503 --> 00:38:30.606
We start out with some curiosity because we don't know, we don't know why we should be concerned until we know, but I would say, primarily, I walk away feeling concerned for Katniss, like we said, prim, you know, gail's family and all of District 12.
00:38:30.606 --> 00:38:40.887
So I think this is a nice job, balancing it and also transitioning from that feeling of curiosity initially to uh-oh now we're, you
know, concerned, yeah.
00:38:41.155 --> 00:38:46.641
I would throw in the word unease yeah, it's for me in here too, because I'm not quite.
00:38:46.641 --> 00:38:56.635
I was going to say the word fear and I don't think I was ready to say fear until we are in the reaping and Prim's name is drawn and, yes, that's the end of chapter one.
00:38:56.635 --> 00:39:03.467
But so much of this is based in hunting conversation with Gail black market getting ready for the reaping.
00:39:03.467 --> 00:39:11.684
The closer you get to the reaping, the more afraid I became, because I cared about the characters and I obviously one of these characters is going to be in danger.
00:39:11.684 --> 00:39:14.603
If you read the back cover you know it's Katniss, is going into the games.
00:39:14.603 --> 00:39:18.105
So you, uh, I do feel hopeful for that.
00:39:18.105 --> 00:39:37.663
I feel unease, I think for the majority of this chapter, because we're trying to have a normal day, knowing that it's not going to be a normal day and no matter what these characters, no matter how normal these characters try to make this day, everything ends with the reaping, yeah, and the unease of whose name is going to be drawn.
00:39:38.043 --> 00:39:44.081
Yeah, and to that point I think it's fun that, like they actually did succeed hunting, they had a good hunting and gathering day.
00:39:44.081 --> 00:39:52.538
You know, the blue skies are out, like it feels good, but there's a layer of unease and then it's like boom, it's Prim Rose Everdeen that gets chosen.
00:39:52.538 --> 00:39:53.179
Yeah.
00:39:53.775 --> 00:39:58.271
And she even talks about how they saved strawberries and bread, yeah, to eat that night.
00:39:58.271 --> 00:39:59.293
So they're trying.
00:39:59.293 --> 00:40:05.271
It's almost like they have to push it out of their minds, like the possibility is there, but they have to push it out of their mind in order to get through the day.
00:40:05.271 --> 00:40:12.010
Yes, that's that their names can be drawn, but then, of course, like I'll help Briggs lose when the name is drawn.
00:40:12.072 --> 00:40:19.253
You know, yeah, ok, so that's a good summary of the seven key for shifter questions that set up big picture expectations.
00:40:19.253 --> 00:40:22.494
Now let's go take a micro lens and look at the same structure.
00:40:22.494 --> 00:40:29.675
Before we get into the same structure, we're going to chat about why we broke down the scene the way that we did.
00:40:29.675 --> 00:40:36.416
First, vanna, let's talk about did we pick multiple scenes or one scene, and let's talk about the goal for the scene.
00:40:36.798 --> 00:40:37.000
Yeah.
00:40:37.000 --> 00:40:43.090
So this was a hard one for us to analyze and we kind of came into it thinking we were going to do one thing.
00:40:43.090 --> 00:40:45.612
And then we kind of changed our mood last minute.
00:40:45.612 --> 00:40:47.135
We'll explain why.
00:40:47.135 --> 00:40:53.474
So at first we were like maybe this is one scene centering around Katniss volunteering to take Prim's place.
00:40:53.474 --> 00:41:05.436
And then we were thinking, ok, well, that means this goes into chapter two, which means the scene, if we do it as one scene, would be over 6,000 plus maybe even more than that words.
00:41:05.436 --> 00:41:07.068
How do we feel about that?
00:41:07.068 --> 00:41:11.871
So word count isn't something that has to be like the end all be all.
00:41:11.871 --> 00:41:15.592
If you're over a certain amount, that means your scene's wrong or your scene's broken.
00:41:15.592 --> 00:41:20.329
But it is a good indicator that maybe it's worth looking at things a little more closely.
00:41:20.329 --> 00:41:23.728
So long story short, that's what we did and we landed at.
00:41:23.728 --> 00:41:29.954
We believe this first chapter has two scenes, or one full scene and a part of the second scene.
00:41:29.954 --> 00:41:32.572
So we'll go into that in more detail.
00:41:32.572 --> 00:41:34.851
But you wanted to talk about goals, right, abigail?
00:41:35.333 --> 00:41:45.371
Yes, because I think that in order to understand how commandments work, we need to figure out what is the goal first, because what throws that goal off, or why is that goal so hard to accomplish?
00:41:45.894 --> 00:41:46.074
Yep.
00:41:46.074 --> 00:41:50.670
And so, right up front, there's a few things Katniss is concerned about.
00:41:50.670 --> 00:41:54.454
So we know she's heading out to hunt so that her family can eat.
00:41:54.454 --> 00:42:01.914
We know she's concerned about Prim and this being Prim's first reaping and she's probably had nightmares and things like that.
00:42:01.914 --> 00:42:10.668
So we could say part of her goal is keep Prim safe, keep her in good spirits, keep her unafraid, whatever, however, you want to word that.
00:42:11.144 --> 00:42:45.347
I agree with that, which is now helping us figure out why we do a scene and then kind of a second scene that leads into chapter two, right, yeah, so when we're looking at that, when we break down the commandments and when writers can be confused about this, I think that's the main thing is, if you're feeling stuck on how you want to make an argument and I just like to practice this, saying that the way I see the commandments might be different than how you see the commandments, so it's not necessarily the way that I analyze the scene or the way Savannah analyzes the scene is the only way to analyze the scene.
00:42:45.347 --> 00:43:05.653
Right, these are tools that help us understand where we feel confident that there is scene structure in order to determine when something brings value to the story versus when something might be taking too long or is going too fast or is extra baggage that isn't really adding to the plot, movement or the character development, Right?
00:43:05.653 --> 00:43:24.554
So why Savannah and I had a tricky time deciding what we wanted to do, breaking this down as one scene that leads into
chapter two, or two scenes with a little carryover into chapter two with the second scene, is because the first scene, when we look at the command and it doesn't feel nearly as loud as the second scene.
00:43:24.554 --> 00:43:31.550
Now the second scene's turning point, which we'll get to in a second, is one of the most important scenes in the entire novel.
00:43:31.550 --> 00:43:36.974
So of course that scene's intensity is going to be astronomically higher than this first scene.
00:43:37.565 --> 00:43:39.413
But we're also looking at word count.
00:43:39.413 --> 00:43:47.172
Not that a scene has to be determined by word count, but typically a scene's average length the potato chip length is around the 2,000 words.
00:43:47.172 --> 00:43:48.711
This is going to be over that regardless.
00:43:48.711 --> 00:43:55.894
But I think that's this idea of can we figure out how to tighten and when is it going to be a scene versus a beat?
00:43:55.894 --> 00:43:56.708
Right, savannah.
00:43:57.224 --> 00:44:04.652
And one thing, if I can add to what you said right before is people ask me all the time like, do you and Abigail ever disagree on things?
00:44:04.652 --> 00:44:07.750
And I'm always like, yeah, we disagree on things a lot and we have to talk through them.
00:44:07.750 --> 00:44:11.135
And it's never about like I like that you said.
00:44:11.135 --> 00:44:15.954
It's not about who's right or who's wrong, it's more do we get to the same point in the same takeaway?
00:44:15.954 --> 00:44:20.572
And I would say, off the top of my head, I can't ever think of a time where we didn't.
00:44:20.572 --> 00:44:26.771
So we might disagree on the details or we might see something slightly different, but we usually get to the same takeaway.
00:44:28.208 --> 00:44:39.088
So because I also hear from people a lot like I'm getting so stuck, I'm getting so bogged down in the weeds, it's not always about the small details, it's about what's this doing for the bigger story, like Abigail was saying.
00:44:39.088 --> 00:44:48.514
The second thing I want to say is that what we're talking about in scene one is basically the part with Gail where they go hunting, and then scene two is basically Prim and the reaping.
00:44:48.514 --> 00:44:52.376
So just to kind of give some big picture perspective on that.
00:44:52.376 --> 00:44:55.612
And yeah, do you want to dig into the analysis, abigail?
00:44:56.115 --> 00:44:56.836
Yes, yeah.
00:44:56.836 --> 00:45:00.411
So ultimately we decided and we both did come to agreement with this.
00:45:00.411 --> 00:45:06.148
We talked a little bit off podcast before we hopped on, but, yes, it's that reiterating way you said, savannah, we disagree all the time.
00:45:06.148 --> 00:45:13.175
That's what makes discussion so interesting, because it's not about who's right and who's wrong.
00:45:13.175 --> 00:45:25.552
It's about seeing each other's viewpoints and often I'll end up changing my opinion to what Savannah has, or sometimes Savannah might change her opinion to what I had, or we stay disagreeing, but we have, like you said, the same conclusion.
00:45:25.552 --> 00:45:27.030
Like, did we get to the same place?
00:45:27.030 --> 00:45:29.271
And that's ultimately what the goal is.
00:45:29.271 --> 00:45:31.873
It's also why these are such great editing tools.
00:45:32.045 --> 00:45:45.894
When I've had writers not that they're right or wrong for this, but when I've had writers try to plan out the command and suit, for they actually write the scene they can almost stiffen what they're trying to do and I like to say write your scene first and then use them as editing tools.
00:45:45.894 --> 00:45:47.612
But again, that's your own process.
00:45:47.612 --> 00:45:48.668
Whatever works for you better.
00:45:48.668 --> 00:46:07.911
Anyway, to answer your question, to go to this conversation, we chose this as the first scene because I think it does and, savannah, I think you agree with this it sets up so many big components about her character development, about her misbelief about what's really at stake.
00:46:08.505 --> 00:46:24.693
It happens quickly and I think that that was why we debated about it, because her decision in this scale breakdown almost felt instinctive, like there wasn't really even much debate about how she answers her crisis question which we'll talk about in a second which felt like is that enough?
00:46:24.693 --> 00:46:26.911
Is that enough to work as a scene?
00:46:26.911 --> 00:46:39.755
I think ultimately, because there's so much packed into this quick conversation, we argue that there is enough, but I can see how a first-time reader, and especially someone who's not even analyzing the scene, would just go through it.
00:46:39.755 --> 00:46:40.847
It's just so nice.
00:46:40.847 --> 00:46:43.110
So it's like the scene structure.
00:46:43.110 --> 00:46:57.132
You want stories to feel natural, you don't want it to feel stiff and you're bringing so much attention onto something that it's preaching and I don't think that this does this at all.
00:46:57.132 --> 00:47:04.414
But when you really look at the line level, what's happening in this conversation, you can see how important this conversation is.
00:47:04.914 --> 00:47:10.492
Yeah, so let's dig into it, because I think if people haven't read it in a while they might be like what conversation, abigail?
00:47:10.492 --> 00:47:10.972
Right?
00:47:10.972 --> 00:47:21.849
So I think if we just kind of zoomed into this one scene where it's her and Gail hunting, the goal is very simple it's to go out and get stuff for their families so that they can eat food.
00:47:21.849 --> 00:47:23.628
That's a simple goal.
00:47:23.628 --> 00:47:26.233
Then there's conflict that gets in the way of that.
00:47:26.233 --> 00:47:35.536
So there's the inciting incident, which is that first blip of conflict, and then there's the turning point, which is kind of like conflict has reached its peak.
00:47:35.536 -->
00:47:36.750
What are you going to do about it?
00:47:36.750 --> 00:47:41.233
And what's interesting about this scene is that by the end, they do accomplish their goal.
00:47:41.233 --> 00:47:45.135
So they do hunt and they hunt successfully.
00:47:45.135 --> 00:47:49.896
But there's also like a and something else has now happened.
00:47:49.896 --> 00:47:52.771
So, abigail, what did you see as the inciting incident?
00:47:53.233 --> 00:47:58.816
OK, so the inciting incident was the goal is to go hunting.
00:47:58.816 --> 00:48:07.630
So with the inciting incident, I guess this is where the inciting incident and this group of commandments feel softer to me.
00:48:07.630 --> 00:48:14.514
But I think that you could just, if it's to create the goal, it could just be that they meet up and go hunting.
00:48:14.514 --> 00:48:23.432
It could be that Gail has some bread and they're going to sit down and have a meal and talk about this conversation that they're going to have before.
00:48:23.432 --> 00:48:28.333
I guess the inciting incident for me feels a little bit fluffier than the turning point.
00:48:28.333 --> 00:48:30.112
What did you see as the inciting incident?
00:48:30.385 --> 00:48:45.831
Well, and to that point no pun intended we should probably talk about the turning point and maybe back out, because I see that turning point is like there's something around that part where they talk to Maj and so this makes me want to maybe reevaluate our goal or maybe add something to it.
00:48:45.831 --> 00:49:02.152
So Maj upsets Gail, gail's upset and wants to fly off the handle about the capital and things like that, and Katniss is kind of like she stood up for Maj and she also doesn't really want to make it as big of a deal about things as Gail does.
00:49:02.152 --> 00:49:24.806
So if we said something like that is the turning point and there's a couple options here, so just hang in there with me If something like that's the turning point, what's kind of the first thing that is on the same path of Gail and Katniss kind of being upset with each other, it's probably Gail saying we could just run away together and she's like what the heck which?
00:49:24.806 --> 00:49:27.534
If we kind of back that out to their goal?
00:49:27.534 --> 00:49:32.092
Their goal is to just go through kind of the normal day of hunting so they can provide for their family.
00:49:32.704 --> 00:49:37.532
When Gail speaks up about running away together, that interrupts Katniss's idea of this.
00:49:37.532 --> 00:49:44.952
Is my buddy slash brother figure that I didn't think we were talking about kids and dating and things like that together.
00:49:44.952 --> 00:49:46.548
So that's option one.
00:49:46.548 --> 00:49:53.255
Option two is that the turning point is when Gail says, do you want to run away together?
00:49:53.255 --> 00:49:54.711
And she's like I can't fathom that.
00:49:54.711 --> 00:49:56.349
What are your thoughts on that, abigail?
00:49:56.905 --> 00:50:00.693
Yeah, well, I'm glad you backed out because this is a simpler conversation now.
00:50:00.693 --> 00:50:04.231
It's definitely getting in the weeds, yeah, so it's good to back out.
00:50:04.231 --> 00:50:10.414
To me, I think that this conversation is what controls the same structure, more than the managed conversation.
00:50:10.414 --> 00:50:18.010
I think that for the turning point there that is, the clear turning point is the question of will you run away or not?
00:50:18.010 --> 00:50:30.028
So that leads to this crisis of do I listen to him and we run, because life in the districts is not way less than ideal, or do you?
00:50:30.028 --> 00:50:37.559
But to run would mean leaving behind Prim and her mom, who she provides for, or do I stay?
00:50:37.559 --> 00:50:45.219
And that means facing the tragedy of every day, of what this you know really struggling through life to survive.
00:50:45.219 --> 00:50:54.179
Days are in District 12, as well as the upcoming reaping, which means that if she got her name pulled, then she would have to go into the games and face that fate right.
00:50:54.179 --> 00:50:58.003
So that's where I sit with it.
00:50:59.175 --> 00:51:07.740
I think that then her crisis you know that her climax is then acting on the crisis, which her immediate reaction is I can't run.
00:51:07.740 --> 00:51:09.626
You know I'm not running away.
00:51:09.626 --> 00:51:11.623
What about all these people that we provide for?
00:51:11.623 --> 00:51:14.045
And then the resolution is actually them talking about.
00:51:14.045 --> 00:51:20.786
You know her reflecting more on like who they provide for, and the idea of the idea of children to me happens more.
00:51:20.786 --> 00:51:37.106
I mean that maybe could even be the idea of in the setting incident is something like that, and I do think that actually would maybe work as I talk this out, because I think that that point of this is these are the lines I never want to have kids, Katniss says right.
00:51:37.275 --> 00:51:38.922
So she says I never want to have kids.
00:51:38.922 --> 00:51:41.202
I might have if I didn't live here, says Gail.
00:51:41.202 --> 00:51:42.135
But you do?
00:51:42.135 --> 00:51:43.501
I say irritated, forget it.
00:51:43.501 --> 00:51:46.661
He snaps back the conversation feels all wrong, leave.
00:51:46.661 --> 00:51:52.800
How could I leave Prim, who is the only person in the world I'm certain I love, yeah, and Gail's devoted to his family.
00:51:52.800 --> 00:52:08.121
So what's interesting is that it does kind of turn into this conversation about kids, which I think speaks to the theme of the story, because it is Katniss's idea of there is no hope in this world and I can't leave the only person who I really love.
00:52:08.121 --> 00:52:14.242
So it's interesting like we see a little bit of heat there, with Gail suggesting about kids and you forget it.
00:52:14.755 --> 00:52:16.260
He snaps back from his perspective.
00:52:16.260 --> 00:52:18.503
There's some chemistry
from Katniss.
00:52:18.503 --> 00:52:20.320
She's too focused on protecting Prim.
00:52:20.320 --> 00:52:28.324
You can even see romance as an option, right, yeah, so it does kind of throw her off and I can see that working into third debate.
00:52:28.324 --> 00:52:36.943
But ultimately the idea of running or not running feels so easy for Katniss to make because the leading, Prim, is unfathomable.
00:52:36.943 --> 00:52:39.815
So that's why I debated like is this even a scene?
00:52:39.815 --> 00:52:48.204
Is that allowed enough to be a scene compared to the second scene, which deals along the lines of her volunteering as tribute, which most people probably do remember.
00:52:48.204 --> 00:52:50.682
But I think we can argue that it is right.
00:52:50.682 --> 00:52:52.942
There is some debate there that moves us forward.
00:52:53.282 --> 00:53:01.885
Yeah, and so, just for a fun exercise, I'm going to go a different way than you and we're going to see if we get to the same point of this first chapter, or this first scene.
00:53:02.775 --> 00:53:04.699
So I think that what Abigail is talking about.
00:53:04.699 --> 00:53:14.704
In my view of the scene, the inciting incident is that, gail, there's this kind of disruption in there, the way that Katniss views the relationship and potentially the ability to comfortably hunt together.
00:53:14.704 --> 00:53:22.362
Like she says at some point, there's nothing better than finding a great hunting partner or something so like you know, whatever.
00:53:22.362 --> 00:53:26.753
So then I think that they go through the day they're at the market or whatever.
00:53:26.753 --> 00:53:28.662
Then they go to the mayor's house and match.
00:53:28.662 --> 00:53:33.601
The mayor's daughter is upsetting Gail just with what she's saying, because life is unfair.
00:53:33.601 --> 00:53:39.496
And so in that scenario it's kind of like you know, gail snaps at her and he says what do you have?
00:53:39.496 --> 00:53:42.521
Five entries, I had six when I was just 12 years old.
00:53:42.521 --> 00:53:45.322
And Katniss stands up to her and says that's not her fault.
00:53:45.322 --> 00:53:47.702
Gail agrees it's just the way things are.
00:53:47.702 --> 00:53:51.043
So then it's like they walk toward the seam in silence.
00:53:51.514 --> 00:53:53.119
Katniss is thinking about I don't like that.
00:53:53.119 --> 00:53:55.505
Gail took a dig at Maj, blah, blah, blah.
00:53:55.505 --> 00:53:57.077
Things are unfair.
00:53:57.077 --> 00:54:08.664
And then by the end of kind of this little section it's you know she says Gail knows his anger is misdirected and she talks about how he continuously rants about the Capitol.
00:54:08.664 --> 00:54:13.365
She glances at him and she's thinking what good is it yelling about the Capitol?
00:54:13.365 --> 00:54:15.742
Like his rage seems pointless.
00:54:15.742 --> 00:54:21.342
Even though I never say so it's not that I don't agree with him, I do what good is yelling about the Capitol in the middle of the woods?
00:54:21.342 --> 00:54:22.398
It doesn't change anything.
00:54:22.398 --> 00:54:31.845
So I can see a decision here to like say something and kind of agree with him even though I don't see a point, or remain silent and take no action.
00:54:32.574 --> 00:54:41.246
So like, with something like that being said, if we were to look at what Abigail's analysis was and what my analysis was, where are we getting to by the end of this first scene?
00:54:41.246 --> 00:54:43.940
And Abigail jump in, I'll say kind of what I think.
00:54:43.940 --> 00:54:44.382
But it's.
00:54:44.382 --> 00:54:48.382
You know, they don't end the day on good terms, even though they were successful.
00:54:48.382 --> 00:54:52.625
So it says at the end she says see you in the square.
00:54:52.625 --> 00:54:54.682
I say wear something pretty.
00:54:54.682 --> 00:54:55.739
He says flatly.
00:54:55.739 --> 00:55:01.407
So it's kind of like they're just at this, it's just uncomfortable between them by the end of the day.
00:55:01.407 --> 00:55:05.784
So they were successful, but now they're going into the reaping, not totally on the same page.
00:55:06.146 --> 00:55:11.666
Yeah, I think not totally being on the same page is the key, because Gale seems in a worse mood than Katniss, right?
00:55:11.666 --> 00:55:13.778
So I think that it's.
00:55:13.778 --> 00:55:18.941
It's like anything like the more things don't go your way, the worse mood we get in, right?
00:55:18.941 --> 00:55:31.461
And both of these events Katniss not responding the way Gale hopes, with the brints, with the kid conversation, and then her not defending him with the match part it just adds fuel to the fire.
00:55:32.074 --> 00:55:45.858
The point is kind of like does it really matter what exactly we call out Not necessarily because we're saying the same thing that this opening scene is established a lot in terms of the stakes of the overall story, what Katniss values, her friendship with Gale.
00:55:45.858 --> 00:55:51.579
And then we're also like, because I said earlier, it's kind of, yeah, they succeed, but also this stuff happens.
00:55:51.579 --> 00:56:07.485
So, yeah, they succeed, but now Katniss and Gale are going into the reaping, feeling a little disconnected, which could create consequences later Cause imagine that if they went in on the same page and they were like you know, go team, and then there would be no weirdness when she leaves district 12.
00:56:08.155 --> 00:56:11.068
And I do think that the weirdness are the you know.
00:56:11.068 --> 00:56:17.318
You know in a worse place than they were with their friendship when they're going into the reaping, that's reinforced when it hits her.
00:56:17.318 --> 00:56:26.108
She looks at Gale's face during the reaping Right and it hits her that his name is in there 42 times and it makes her feel nauseous.
00:56:26.309 --> 00:56:28.304
Yeah, and he looks away and she makes her feel nauseous.
00:56:28.304 --> 00:56:30.662
So I think
that reinforces the sometimes.
00:56:30.662 --> 00:56:32.025
Katniss is very common account.
00:56:32.025 --> 00:56:34.057
This is character, her focus is.
00:56:34.057 --> 00:56:41.342
So she is such a laser focus on the angle of what it takes to survive that she can forget about other things that matter.
00:56:41.443 --> 00:56:47.516
Yeah, relationship matter to her, and we see that in the beginning of her relationship with Pita too, cause it's kind of like I'm focused.
00:56:47.516 --> 00:56:48.059
I'm focused.
00:56:48.059 --> 00:56:49.922
Now he's doing this thing where he's including me.
00:56:49.922 --> 00:56:53.019
I don't know what to do, but you know, that's later in the story.
00:56:53.019 --> 00:56:58.067
So I think, like key point is that you know, feel free to vote with whoever you want.
00:56:58.067 --> 00:57:03.943
I think, either way, we're saying the same thing and what you know, like we've been saying the whole time, it sets up so much stuff.
00:57:03.943 --> 00:57:07.505
The conflict is escalating even through their conversation.
00:57:07.505 --> 00:57:10.644
So it's the conversation about the kids and running away.
00:57:10.644 --> 00:57:15.376
It's the conversation with Madge, right, it's just pulling them further and further apart.
00:57:15.376 --> 00:57:19.782
On this day that it's not ideal for them to be pulled further apart, exactly, yeah.
00:57:20.284 --> 00:57:20.463
Okay.
00:57:21.795 --> 00:57:25.260
So that's where we landed with scene one and we think it's worth calling out cause.
00:57:25.260 --> 00:57:37.405
You can also take the third route and disagree with us that there's a scene here and you could say that the first chapter into the second chapter is one big scene, and I don't think Abigail and I would necessarily argue with you either, you know.
00:57:37.405 --> 00:57:47.954
But anyway, we thought it was enough worth talking about because it does so much stuff and because it really sets up Katniss's you know, from the perspective I argued.
00:57:47.954 --> 00:57:54.126
It sets up her inaction based on her misbelief, and same with from the perspective Abigail argued.
00:57:54.597 --> 00:57:55.387
Yes, exactly.
00:57:55.387 --> 00:57:57.920
So let's go look at that second scene.
00:57:57.920 --> 00:58:07.974
So the second scene spills into capture shoot and with the second scene that means that we're having the whole getting ready for the reaping, right?
00:58:07.974 --> 00:58:09.878
Yep, so we see some.
00:58:09.878 --> 00:58:38.295
There are details like I'm getting ready, katniss admiring you know, I'm just admiring Prim in general, but there's a really important detail about her mother has light, has laid out one of her more beautiful blue dresses for Katniss to wear and and that is surprising to Katniss because her mother Cherishes her clothes and I think that you know Katniss and her mother obviously don't have an awesome relationship to Katniss presents her a lot.
00:58:38.295 --> 00:58:43.275
And Then
it's getting her ready scene that the clothes are Big for her.
00:58:43.275 --> 00:58:49.815
There's a big thing with the duck tail that she has to tuck in the duck tail and her outfit before they go into the reaping.
00:58:49.815 --> 00:58:51.378
Then they go into the reaping.
00:58:51.458 --> 00:58:55.628
There's a lot of important pieces with backstory where the mayor talks about why we think it's this.
00:58:55.628 --> 00:59:09.655
We see Heymitch, we and how he is, you know, bledger and drunk on stage and how he tries to hug Effie and how Effie kind of shoes him away and obviously she's horrified to even be representing this district.
00:59:09.655 --> 00:59:12.043
She's just waiting for motion to get a better district.
00:59:12.043 --> 00:59:18.641
And you know her in the beginning, very obnoxious, cheering us over the hunger games.
00:59:18.641 --> 00:59:23.510
Yeah, her character evolves but ultimately then you have the reaping itself.
00:59:23.771 --> 00:59:24.414
I'm just name is drawn.
00:59:24.414 --> 00:59:35.179
So at the end of chapter one we know that trims name is drawn and then you move into chapter two and this moves into Katniss being Basically in shock.
00:59:35.179 --> 00:59:50.635
She freezes for a while when Prim is escorted up to the stage and then she sees the detail of the duck tail hanging out again and that brings her back to reality and she volunteers and then she's brought up on stage as the volunteer.
00:59:50.635 --> 01:00:06.375
And then chapter two continues into Pete as being name being drawn for the boys and she has a long backstory about why, of all boys being drawn, he will be the most difficult to have next to her because he is the boy with the bread.
01:00:06.375 --> 01:00:07.521
We understand what?
01:00:07.561 --> 01:00:10.255
that is right and so okay.
01:00:10.255 --> 01:00:16.072
So her goal, if we were to back out the goal, is like survive the reaping, help prim.
01:00:16.072 --> 01:00:17.436
Survive the reaping, would you say.
01:00:17.436 --> 01:00:18.561
The goal would be that?
01:00:18.601 --> 01:00:22.434
yes, I mean it's interesting as like, um, almost like get through.
01:00:22.434 --> 01:00:23.499
I don't know if it's true.
01:00:23.499 --> 01:00:23.900
Yeah.
01:00:24.141 --> 01:00:24.663
Yeah, I get.
01:00:24.663 --> 01:00:29.197
I think it's get through the raping because you can also be survive emotionally, you know, however, you want to word it.
01:00:29.858 --> 01:00:31.802
Yeah, I think it's probably survive emotionally.
01:00:31.802 --> 01:00:39.900
More so because I think she's so shocked when prim's name is drawn Right, so I think at her mind she's already done everything that she can to protect prim.
01:00:39.900 --> 01:00:44.606
So then when her, when prim's name is drawn, it's like oh my gosh, how is this happening?
01:00:44.606 --> 01:00:46.150
I did everything I could this.
01:00:46.150 --> 01:00:48.155
This is not supposed to happen, right.
01:00:48.155 --> 01:01:04.095
So that's where I almost argue that that's what first upsets the goal, and I think that's why the inciting incident shifts a bit, because I think the in the goal becomes the goal becomes protect crime right and so inciting incident.
01:01:04.836 --> 01:01:07.322
I feel like this one's pretty loud and clear.
01:01:07.322 --> 01:01:08.485
What would you say?
01:01:08.485 --> 01:01:09.248
That is Abigail.
01:01:09.876 --> 01:01:11.061
Yeah, the inciting incident.
01:01:11.061 --> 01:01:14.443
Well, so the inciting incident, I think, is when prim's name is drawn.
01:01:14.443 --> 01:01:27.775
The turning point, if we really zero in on the details, I think is when Katniss sees the ducktail sticking out on prim's dress, because that is what pulls her back into the crisis of do I volunteer or not?
01:01:27.775 --> 01:01:33.972
How do I look at my new goal now and how do I protect from now that she's already?
01:01:34.012 --> 01:01:43.106
volunteered, right, you said, it kind of pulls her out of her thoughts and into action, because Prim is in front of her, you know now, and she only has so long to volunteer.
01:01:43.106 --> 01:01:51.940
So also, you know, and it's, I think, prim, she's like sobbing or something too, so it kind of just jolts her back into reality, which so, which I agree.
01:01:51.940 --> 01:01:54.469
The inciting incident is prim's name gets chosen.
01:01:54.469 --> 01:02:01.184
Katniss is just kind of frozen until she sees prim ahead of her with little ducktail out, and then she.
01:02:01.184 --> 01:02:11.219
You know, the crisis doesn't necessarily happen after the ducktail, it's more like it's been happening when she was frozen and she volunteers.
01:02:11.219 --> 01:02:23.606
That's the climax, and then the resolution is basically everything that happens, you know, peta getting chosen and then essentially getting carted off to this room where they're gonna say goodbye, which is what starts the next scene.
01:02:24.150 --> 01:02:32.536
Yeah, and if you look at that I don't know the word kind into the word count, but a great deal of chef to is the backstory of PETA being the boy with the Bread.
01:02:32.536 --> 01:02:36.175
Uh-huh, yeah, that's where I would just throw this in there.
01:02:36.175 --> 01:02:43.048
I, that's all resolution for me in this scene, because the climax is the volunteering, the direct action.
01:02:43.048 --> 01:02:43.797
I agree.
01:02:43.797 --> 01:02:55.195
And then the resolution then deals with her kind of aggressive, you know, kind of in Meaner than she would normally treat Prim to get prim off of her because she can't cry.
01:02:55.195 --> 01:02:57.999
She immediately is going into survival mode already.
01:02:57.999 --> 01:03:07.025
She's already aware of the cameras and, right, she cannot cry on camera because she'll be seen as a weakling and she needs to, you know, get people to bet on her.
01:03:07.065 --> 01:03:17.760
Essentially, and Then the whole rest of it, after PETA's name is drawn, is this
long backstory about how she Recognizes him as the boy with the bread, and it's in great detail.
01:03:17.760 --> 01:03:35.887
And I think that it's worth having the backstory in such detail because it is the whole entire development of who PETA is in his core and why he is so Challenging to have, as I mean in, why a relationship with PETA is so challenging for Katniss.
01:03:35.887 --> 01:03:40.675
Yeah, so it drastically raises the stakes and introduces the love story at the same time.
01:03:40.675 --> 01:03:47.389
But I would say that this is a great example of backstory that is a beat within the scene.
01:03:47.389 --> 01:03:49.074
Yeah, it's got its own structure.
01:03:49.074 --> 01:03:54.684
Yeah, it's got its own structure, but there's nothing necessarily that changes, because she's reflecting on it right.
01:03:54.684 --> 01:04:01.465
The change has happened in the sense of her Moving towards death because she is volunteer to distribute, and that's the change that we're looking for.
01:04:01.485 --> 01:04:01.907
In the scene.
01:04:01.907 --> 01:04:03.581
There is a layout.
01:04:03.581 --> 01:04:08.280
If you were to really zero in, you could do five commandments with the boy with the bread, but it's told through backstory.
01:04:08.280 --> 01:04:09.465
Yeah, that's what I'd say.
01:04:09.465 --> 01:04:12.054
That's more like a beat breakdown versus a scene break.
01:04:12.175 --> 01:04:17.485
Yeah, and also this is in chapter two, so we're not saying that all this backstory is coming in chapter one.
01:04:17.485 --> 01:04:30.787
It's after we've introduced that central conflict, got Katniss really involved with it and, like Abigail mentioned earlier, she's her focus has to shift now from just protecting Prim and her family to, oh you know, holy cow.
01:04:30.787 --> 01:04:32.112
Now I have to survive this thing.
01:04:32.112 --> 01:04:39.639
So you know, just whenever I'm looking at something like that because I I know that as writers we all like to look and say, well, they did it.
01:04:39.639 --> 01:04:45.898
Why can't I just look at things like this backstory example and think, why is this Okay, why did this work?
01:04:45.898 --> 01:04:49.246
I think asking why is one of the best questions you can ever ask.
01:04:49.715 --> 01:04:49.936
Always.
01:04:49.936 --> 01:04:53.887
There's no harm in ever asking why you're only going to do yourself a favor when you ask.
01:04:54.898 --> 01:05:16.947
Yeah, and so, like Abigail said, just to kind of quickly bring this to a close, this, this opening chapter and the first two scenes that go into chapter two, we've brought Katniss like closer to that danger death edge of the spectrum, because now she's on this path to participating in the Hunger Games and it's only gonna get more dangerous from here on out.
01:05:16.947 --> 01:05:30.721
So does what a first chapter should do definitely sets us up with, I think, the right amount of Context in terms of the world, the backstory, katniss's character and a central plot problem and then actually getting Katniss involved with it.
01:05:30.721 --> 01:05:33.228
So I think it's a really, really great example.
01:05:33.695 --> 01:05:35.021
Definitely a great example.
01:05:35.021 --> 01:05:44.947
Like I mentioned the beginning of this one of my all-time favorites, I just there's so much to learn from this book in general and helping yourself look at start.
01:05:44.947 --> 01:05:53.407
Start that analysis by looking at the first pages and seeing what out of this Did they do that you could do well in yours, especially when you have big worlds like a dystopian.
01:05:53.838 --> 01:05:58.081
Yeah, and if you want to get a head start on us, we said we were going to do book two and book three.
01:05:58.081 --> 01:06:09.809
So if you want to try your hand at pulling out the commandments and those big picture elements before we Record them, do it and we will meet you back in a future episode to talk through the first chapter of the next two books.
01:06:10.255 --> 01:06:14.327
Right, thanks to Vanna for doing this with me Such fun, and I can't wait for books two and three.
01:06:17.735 --> 01:06:19.469
So that's it for today's episode.
01:06:19.469 --> 01:06:23.300
As always, thank you so much for tuning in and for showing your support.
01:06:23.300 --> 01:06:35.567
If you want to check out any of the links I mentioned in this episode, you can find them in the show notes listed in the description of each episode Inside your podcast player or at savannah gilbocom forward slash podcast.
01:06:35.567 --> 01:06:41.028
If you're an apple user, I'd really appreciate it if you took a few seconds to leave a rating and a review.
01:06:41.028 --> 01:06:50.284
Your ratings and reviews tell apple that this is a podcast that's worth listening to and, in turn, your reviews will help this podcast Get in front of more fiction writers just like you.
01:06:50.284 --> 01:07:00.534
And while you're there, go ahead and hit that follow button, because there's going to be another brand new episode next week, full of actionable tips, tools and strategies to help you become a better writer.
01:07:00.534 --> 01:07:03.845
So I'll see you next week and until then, happy writing.