رونوشت 🔗
[0:01] Welcome to Family Law War Room with Brad LaMorgese.
[0:05] Hello, everyone.
[0:08] Welcome back to Family Law War Room with Brad LaMorgese
[0:13] Brad is a board-certified family law attorney in Texas
[0:16] and a shareholder at Coons Fuller PC.
[0:19] Specializing in high-stakes divorce,
[0:21] complex property division, jurisdiction disputes,
[0:24] and family law appeals.
[0:26] I'm Sean O'Connor and today Brad and I are talking about
[0:29] what happens when a divorce could potentially be filed in more than one state
[0:34] and how disputes over where the case belongs can shape the litigation
[0:39] right out of the gate.
[0:41] Brad, good to see you.
[0:42] Good to see you.
[0:43] So just set the stage here.
[0:45] I mean, this is the kind of thing where let's say I'm married and my,
[0:49] but where maybe kind of separated my spouses living in Oklahoma and I'm in Texas still
[0:55] and she files there or like just trying to ground this scenario in my mind.
[1:02] This answer can be more complex than you think.
[1:05] So the starting point is really residency for each state.
[1:09] Are you a resident in a domicile of that state?
[1:12] And it can be sometimes more than one.
[1:15] So if somebody recently moved or if they live in different states,
[1:20] it's conceivably possible that one's more than one state
[1:25] can be a valid place to file.
[1:27] And then we're looking really at where each spouse lives,
[1:32] how long they've lived there, where the marriage really operated,
[1:36] particularly if children are involved.
[1:39] And so that analysis can become surprisingly complex,
[1:43] especially given the example you made when two spouses legitimately live in different states.
[1:50] I don't know if that's more common these days or not.
[1:53] You know, I was sort of painting a picture of like,
[1:56] oh, there's obviously some marital issues and so they're chosen to live apart.
[2:01] But there's also people that legit, you know,
[2:04] she's pursuing her career, her corporate office is in the Southern state.
[2:09] And you know, like that's not so uncommon these days,
[2:12] these sort of hybrid scenarios with remote work and all that stuff.
[2:17] I agree, I think it's way more common with mobility and jobs and a variety of things
[2:24] where people are potentially even having multiple homes and then living apart.
[2:29] Particularly there's any kind of marital issues they may want to move and live apart.
[2:34] And so then you're maybe dealing with two jurisdictions.
[2:38] How do you decide which, you know, which of the, I mean,
[2:42] the scenario is what they're like, they've been filed concurrently, so to speak.
[2:46] I mean, you mentioned that, you know, where's the marital HQ or where the kids used to being like,
[2:52] that's going to dominate that decision, probably or influence it.
[2:56] Yeah, it's interesting because you have different kinds of jurisdiction to do different kinds of things.
[3:01] So in Rem jurisdiction, fancy Latin for,
[3:06] did you live in the state long enough, you can get a pronouncement of a divorce,
[3:11] even if the other spouse has nothing to do with the state.
[3:15] To divide property or to do anything with money, including child support,
[3:20] you have to have personal jurisdiction.
[3:22] So does one, does the other spouse have enough contacts?
[3:27] Do they own real estate?
[3:29] Have they been served in that state?
[3:31] And so that, you know, you may not be fair to divide property in one state,
[3:36] even if one spouse lives there.
[3:39] And then we've talked about this kind of on some of our other podcasts.
[3:43] But child custody jurisdiction, all bets are off.
[3:46] It generally will follow the child.
[3:48] And so, and believe it or not,
[3:50] you can actually have two states proceeding at the same time of both have jurisdiction.
[3:55] Speaking of jurisdiction, right?
[3:57] What's the difference between a court having jurisdiction over the divorce itself,
[4:02] versus I guess having authority to decide issues,
[4:05] you mentioned, you know, property, child support, custody, hesitation stuff.
[4:10] So the in-rem is just, for instance, in Texas,
[4:13] have you lived here six months in the county 90 days?
[4:17] The person could file for a declaration they want to be divorced.
[4:22] That's not enough just to divide the property,
[4:26] because if someone moved here and the other spouse had nothing to do with Texas,
[4:32] they're not going to have personal jurisdiction.
[4:34] And so it may be in the old state where they both lived,
[4:38] arguably would have personal jurisdiction to do that.
[4:41] Custody, child support, are governed even by different rules.
[4:45] And so, again, it can get very complex very quickly.
[4:49] Like there is, is first to file apply to this term I've heard in other conversations
[4:55] where like first to file, maybe in patent law or something, you know,
[4:59] where like the first to file has an advantage.
[5:02] Is that come into play here?
[5:04] You know, actually sometimes it can.
[5:07] Now filing first is not a guarantee of victory,
[5:10] but it can influence sort of where the battle begins,
[5:14] which court gets the first opportunity to evaluate jurisdiction and get moving.
[5:20] Sometimes first filed gains momentum and becomes a primary forum,
[5:25] particularly if arguably maybe either state would have jurisdiction.
[5:31] But that said, if the chosen forum doesn't have jurisdiction,
[5:36] filing first will not save a case.
[5:38] So speed does matter in my opinion,
[5:41] but proper jurisdiction matters even more.
[5:44] Got it.
[5:45] I could file a week ahead of you,
[5:47] but if I'm in a filing in a place where like there's no standing or what,
[5:51] like it's not going to matter.
[5:53] What about a scenario where the,
[6:00] or what is the reasoning behind,
[6:04] or the preference behind filing in one state versus another?
[6:08] I mean, I'm
Load full transcript
guessing I mean state laws vary.
[6:11] What are some of the scenarios or the factors there that drive someone's preference?
[6:18] Major, major scenarios and the differences can be absolutely enormous
[6:24] from division of property and how courts look at separate property versus divisible property,
[6:34] how they look at spousal support, business valuation, attorneys fees,
[6:40] and even custody disputes, but one spouse can view a particular state as beneficial.
[6:48] So historically, I've seen a lot of,
[6:51] oh, we live in California.
[6:53] Oh, we live in Texas fights.
[6:55] There's a very famous case in Texas between Minnesota and Texas.
[7:00] And it's frequently because it may result in more marital property being divided,
[7:06] depending on which state you're in or long term support laws,
[7:11] maybe more beneficial in one state rather than the other.
[7:15] So often there is a significant strategic reason to filing in a particular state.
[7:21] What do I, you just mentioned business, business issues,
[7:26] the division of marital assets and stuff.
[7:29] What are some of those complications, right?
[7:31] Maybe the couple loans of business together, right?
[7:34] Or certainly property or other as, you know, their own investment properties in other states.
[7:40] Like, well, how do you, how do you untangle all that?
[7:43] Most states will have a clause where it will potentially capture property
[7:49] from other states being divided, but there's, there are practical and legal challenges.
[7:54] So if you have real estate governed by one state's laws or business interests operating in several jurisdictions.
[8:02] At a minimum, you're going to have financial records potentially spread across the country.
[8:07] Different valuation principles and experts to devalue businesses in real estate.
[8:13] And value, valuation issues can become more complicated in enforcement of court orders may require a lot of coordination.
[8:22] So the larger and more geographic, geographically diverse the estate,
[8:27] the more important early jurisdictional planning becomes.
[8:31] And what we talked about before, that document gathering, that making sure you're doing your diligence.
[8:37] Maybe you covered this, but I'm think you just mentioned, you know, jurisdiction, you've got, you've got a jurisdiction versus venue.
[8:44] Is there a distinction there, right?
[8:46] In the multi-state divorce. And so, when does that matter?
[8:50] When you think jurisdiction, think state, which state?
[8:54] When you think venue, you think which county or which parish or which subset of that jurisdiction you involved in.
[9:02] And that gets very interesting in Texas too, because jurisdiction really asks a court, which court has legal power to hear the case, which state does.
[9:12] Then you ask which particular court within the proper jurisdiction is the appropriate location.
[9:19] And so you see this like in personal injury cases, but even divorces of what might be even the more favorable county.
[9:27] So there's cases out of Texas where if you own a vacation home or two or you own the ranch here, but you live in Dallas, you might get to pick.
[9:37] And in venue, first filed is everything, because it, it will lock your venue, unless the court of that county wants to give the case up, it's generally going to occur in that county.
[9:50] And so sometimes you may see people pick a rural judge or they want to pick a big city judge. And so it becomes very interesting with venue.
[10:01] Is this somewhat a function that Texas is just such a big state that there's these, you know, geographic, you know, great geographic swaths or is it just okay.
[10:14] It's a huge state. I'll pass those closer to California than to Dallas where I'm sitting in. So imagine you have a home there versus here, and it practically can make the litigation difficult of you live that far away from where the litigation is taking place.
[10:32] And I grew up in New England, right, where everything like, you know, all of that fits in Texas and then some, you know.
[10:40] What about, let's talk about like, I'm obviously no details or identifying details, but, you know, a multi-save divorce should deal with where, you know, the dispute over which court would hear the case, significantly impacted the litigation. Do you have a scenario there, a story.
[10:59] Yeah, I had a, I've had numerous that have acquired one where we litigated the property in the divorce and El Paso. We litigated the custody elements in Australia. So very, very different venues and jurisdictions. But I had one where we had dual litigation, neither state would shut it down between Georgia and between Texas.
[11:27] And eventually the case got settled, but it was interesting, the spouse that lived in Georgia wanted to litigate here, the spouse that lived here wanted to litigate in Georgia, because there were different property laws. And so it made a big difference.
[11:43] So it was pretty interesting and it just kept going in both states despite the request to dismiss in both states.
[11:51] So it could go, could it go all the way to sort of fruition or like have divorced degrees from both states or generally that's where it'll stop is that it's a very rare situation, but it's probably the one of the only times you can't have a race to the courthouse.
[12:08] Either states shutting them down, you want to get your case tried first, tried quickly and get a decree, because then the other state will have to honor that states judgment with full faith and credit.
[12:21] So it's a very interesting situation and pretty rare, I would say normally the states are going to talk and one of them is going to give it to the other one.
[12:34] But in that case, literally the first one to judgment will probably win, because they're going to be entitled to full faith and credit in the other state.
[12:46] What is the, and get a little behind the scenes here, but you're
talking about states giving up the case, you know, like okay, or wanting to keep it.
[12:58] What's the motivation there for those kinds of decisions?
[13:02] Sometimes the judge doesn't want to hear the case, okay, but practically speaking, but outside of that, I would say they're considering where is really the evidence going to be if there's a child case that's absolutely clearly in one state, because that's where the child lives there, there may be some consideration to that I've had them where like literally 90% of the properties in Texas, it would make no sense to do it in the other state.
[13:28] So they're looking at a lot of considerations or was there a sort of a person tricked into moving to one state, didn't quite cut all the ties with the other state, and you know, the the state they move to maybe disadvantageous to one of the spouses, they're going to they're going to look at all those kind of things.
[13:48] Interesting. Yeah, you know, I was thinking like, oh, calendar or whatever, but you know, we're busy, so yeah, we'll let it go, but they're actually kind of looking at the early fact pattern, so to speak, to see like, okay, doesn't make any sense for us to keep so it's sort of it's almost a preliminary ruling in a way.
[14:05] I mean, not not in a technical way, but it's sort of points it which way this case is going to go for sure.
[14:14] So a couple minutes left here, Brad, someone's listening out there, what should they consider before filing for divorce when you know that they may be in one of these scenarios where there's more than one state that could have jurisdiction or you know that that that's somewhere in the background of their relationship and life.
[14:35] For something particular like this, I do recommend going to somebody who has a history and background in this as far as lawyers go them because I think one of the most important things is seeking legal advice before acting because people frequently just assume jurisdictions obvious when it isn't and filing in the wrong state can create delays additional expense.
[15:00] Strategic disadvantages that we're talking about so before filing it's good to evaluate residency.
[15:09] Child custody jurisdiction, property issues, support issues, how the laws of those states might affect the outcomes and all those cases and then a little planning at the beginning can prevent problems later won't won't necessarily head them all off, but I think just really sitting down and understanding okay what would this look like and then.
[15:30] Do I want multiple litigations or are the states kind of similar where won't make a big difference yeah I think it's sort of a pre consult to I mean I imagine you'd be if I were the client potential client here the question might be well what are my goal what's the outcome i'm trying to achieve and then you know that could influence your advice obviously right I mean there's the laws the law and some you know in terms of you could do this you could do this but.
[16:00] You can't do that but you know between these two things that are options this one's going to more likely achieve your goals or you'd be able to tell me like good luck with that yeah 100% that's it that's kind of how it happens all right listen Brad super interesting thanks for sharing your expertise on this and always a pleasure and I look forward to connecting on on a future episode for sure thank you.
[16:26] Hey that's it for today's episode of family law war room with Brad the more just if you want to learn more about Brad and his work in complex family law matters visit the website coons fuller dot com as always thanks for listening and don't forget to like subscribe to the show maybe share this episode with someone in your world who is.
[16:48] Dealing with the pending divorce issues that we just discussed i'm shot all Connor I hope you have a great day thanks for watching be sure to hit that like and subscribe button and leave us a review in the comments.