رونوشت 🔗
[00:00:00] Dawn Hawkins: I've always been more in the policy and advocacy realm, and the survivors I work with are usually five, ten or longer years out of the life. But because their abuse was filmed and recorded and uploaded online, used as advertisements, used to rate them, used to humiliate and control them, ten years out of the life those images continue to still show up.
[00:00:23] So that's how I got into this space was walking the halls of Congress with these really powerful leaders and leaving to learn that they were being humiliated because of content that was created ten years before and surfacing again. And the answer that I've had to tell people for ten, fifteen years is once an image is online there's really not much we can do about it and I refuse to accept that as reality. And so we're building the technology now to make sure that it doesn't have to stay online forever.
[00:01:01] Elisha: A photo from a church picnic can be turned into fake pornography, and for years, survivors are told that once it's online, there's not much anyone can do. But that's no longer true. It's happening to far more people than most of us realize, including today's guest, who has been targeted with deepfakes herself.
[00:01:16] Hi, I'm Elisha. I'm a student here at Vanguard University, and I help produce the show. Today, Sandie talks with Dawn Hawkins, founder and CEO of Protect Privacy AI. After 14 years leading the National Center on Sexual Exploitation, Dawn now uses AI to help find these images and get them taken down. And now, here's their conversation.
[00:01:38] Sandie Morgan: Hey, Dawn Hawkins. It's so good to have you here on the Ending Human Trafficking Podcast.
[00:01:45] Dawn Hawkins: Dr. Sandie, it's been so long since I got to sit with you.
[00:01:50] Sandie Morgan: Oh my goodness, and you have been so busy. I can hardly wait to ask all the questions I have. But I know that this was a really big year for you because you're the founder and CEO of Protect Privacy AI, and I'm really eager to talk about that. But I know you, and our listeners know you from years of leadership at NCOSE and your involvement, advocacy.
[00:02:27] I lost track of how many times you have testified for Congress. So in our work here at the Global Center for Women and Justice, we often talk about our model of REACH, which is research, education, advocacy, collaboration, and hope. And when we talk about advocacy, we always preface it with study the issues before you try to be a voice, because you might say the wrong thing.
[00:03:07] So when I champion your advocacy, I know it is based on research that you have done. You've been an amazing, stellar clarion call for the rights of victims, and I'm so excited to have you here today.
[00:03:27] Dawn Hawkins: I'm grateful to be here and grateful for all you've done.
[00:03:31] Sandie Morgan: Well, this is our 15-year anniversary of doing the "Ending Human Trafficking" podcast, and we have listeners in 173 countries. And now, because of a recent case in the South Pacific, we have an unusual number of listeners on the island of Tonga. And so I love that we get to use this platform to spread good information and strong strategies for how we end the exploitation of people.
[00:04:15] So let's dive right in. What I noticed in your change as now you are the CEO and founder, and I have to look at it every time 'cause it's new for me, of Protect Privacy AI. And you're helping survivors of image-based sexual abuse. So let's talk about what listeners probably recognize the phrase revenge porn, but not this new phrase of image-based sexual abuse.
[00:05:01] What is that? What does it cover?
[00:05:04] Dawn Hawkins: Well, we're trying to get at the actual root of what's happening to individuals when this type of activity happens, and it really is sexual abuse, and so we want to call it that. It's also called non-consensual intimate imagery or NCII in legal terms. I hate that term intimate because if you were raped, if you were trafficked, if you're a victim of domestic violence, I would argue it's not intimacy that was recorded.
[00:05:32] It was violence. But image-based sexual abuse is more of an umbrella term for multiple types of abuse that happens and is leveraged online. That would include the revenge pornography idea of maybe you created and shared something with a past partner and then they have tried to control you, humiliate you and share that.
[00:05:57] But there's also instances of voyeurism like the hidden camera type abuse. There's instances of sextortion, "Hey, send me this and if you don't, I'm going to send more sexually explicit content out into the world to people that you care about," et cetera. It also includes the forged pornography or in the AI space, deepfaked pornography, sexually explicit deepfakes, which now it could happen to anybody.
[00:06:29] This has happened to me multiple times, where they just take an innocent photo of you, a headshot of you, and then they edit it in a way that looks like sexually explicit material that you were involved in. So there's lots of different forms of image-based sexual abuse. In my instance, Sandie, and this is probably similar to you, many, many of the advocates I work with who are survivors, for me, I'm not in the direct service space.
[00:06:59] I've always been more in the policy and advocacy realm, and the survivors I work with are usually five, ten or longer years out of the life. But because their abuse was filmed and recorded and uploaded online, used as advertisements, used to rate them, used to humiliate and control them, ten years out of the life those images continue to still show up.
[00:07:24] So that's how I got into this space was walking the halls of Congress with these really powerful leaders and leaving to learn that they were being humiliated because of content that was created ten years before and surfacing again. And the answer that I've had to tell people for ten,
Load full transcript
fifteen years is once an image is online there's really not much we can do about it and I refuse to accept that as reality.
[00:07:54] And so we're building the technology now to make sure that it doesn't have to stay online forever.
[00:08:00] Sandie Morgan: So let's talk just a little more about this revenge porn deepfake. They can take your picture that was at a church picnic and put it on another image. I don't understand how that works. Explain that.
[00:08:26] Dawn Hawkins: It's so atrocious, and it's happening to so many individuals, and mostly to women. Right before I left NCOSE, I was doing research on nudifying apps that are in the Apple and Google App Stores, and we found 127 nudifying apps together with our partners out of Australia.
[00:08:49] Sandie Morgan: We better define what is a nudifying app. You're bringing in all these new concepts.
[00:08:58] Dawn Hawkins: Oh, I'm glad I get to help you understand how bad the world is. It's so bad. So the nudifying technology now is an additional deepfake technology where it allows you to take a photo of anybody and nudify them and turn them naked and often put them in sexually explicit content, have them depicted in committing sex acts that they never did.
[00:09:24] And the problem is that it looks so real, and in the tech today, it's hard to identify that this is fake, that it's not real. And so it's really super affecting women in particular. It's used to humiliate them. They're losing scholarships, losing jobs. They're not even trying for jobs or scholarships because they're afraid that this kind of stuff will surface.
[00:09:47] When I was at NCOSE, at the end, I was fighting for the Kids Online Safety Act, such a super critical piece of legislation that still has not passed. But as I was fighting for KOSA, we're walking the halls with parents of sixty kids, sixty kids who died from sextortion, and many of them it was fake, or they were coerced into creating a nude image and sending it.
[00:10:14] But they thought that if they didn't do what their predator abuser said, then it was gonna get out and their lives were gonna get ruined. And these children died by suicide as a result of this type of pressure. And so when I found that there's over a hundred and twenty nudifying apps in the Apple App Store that were rated, Sandie, for four-year-olds and nine-year-olds, which means if you have the parental controls turned on, it doesn't keep those from your kids, that's when I realized we have to do something so much more because anyone can be a victim.
[00:10:49] Sandie Morgan: Let's start right there. Anyone can be a victim. So you shared that you were targeted by a deepfake. What did you learn as you became a survivor, and how did you apply what you learned to the work you're doing now?
[00:11:08] Dawn Hawkins: I'm gonna get emotional. I don't know why I... Okay, so in my case, the deepfake pornography has been made of me for many years. It's happened since my earliest years in advocacy. And it was used to try to stop me from fighting for women and children and against pornography industry.
[00:11:30] And so in my case, what happened is they made deepfakes over the years of many times. They would send it to my family, to my parents, to my baby sister. Once we were hacked and they uploaded it all over the NCOSE, it was before we were NCOSE, we had changed our name, but all over our YouTube and it felt humiliating to me, right?
[00:11:52] I can talk about the feelings I felt, but ultimately, what I hate is that I just gave up. I gave up trying to get it all down because it was hopeless. I also can see in my advocacy, I still was able to speak publicly and fight for good, but I totally changed after that. I was more reserved.
[00:12:16] I did a lot less publicly. You'll be like, "I see you everywhere," but I was terrified, and I did hold back significantly because of those types of threats. And I would go through phases where I'd be like, "I'm not doing anything." And so for six months, I wouldn't make videos or speak publicly, really.
[00:12:34] And then I would get the courage again to do it. And then I would be... an onslaught of this type of harassment again and get scared and things like that. But the problem is that I just gave up and accepted it, and that's what almost every survivor has done and does, and that's what we can't allow anymore.
[00:12:53] And the fact that you give up... One of the biggest problems, Sandie, is until now, you've had to hunt for your own sexual abuse. You've had to be the one to go find it. And if you wanna pay someone else to do it, it's astronomically expensive, thousands of dollars. And then the platforms, there was no reason for them to remove the material.
[00:13:17] They could just ignore you. But the TAKE IT DOWN Act, which just passed, went into full effect this year, now gives teeth. It requires platforms to remove this material within forty-eight hours, and that's what's changed. So the tech has to change now.
[00:13:32] Sandie Morgan: So let's talk about the TAKE IT DOWN Act. We all celebrated that, but how does it work and how does that impact the launch of your new role?
[00:13:45] Dawn Hawkins: So I fought for that law for years before it had that name. But the reality is, until the TAKE IT DOWN Act passed, it wasn't against the law for someone federally, some states had stuff, but federally, for someone to create and distribute non-consensual, sexually explicit material of you.
[00:14:05] Now it's a felony because of the TAKE IT DOWN Act. But also in that statute, it requires platforms, so like Instagram or Pornhub or Reddit or X, they now have to remove this material within forty-eight hours of being notified that it's there, and they have to stop it from being re-uploaded, the exact content from being re-uploaded again.
[00:14:28] This is amazing because I can tell you so many stories of when we've gone in on behalf of survivors and asked for takedowns and
removals, ignored, just the hoops we had to jump through to get to that place. And so now if they don't, under the law, they face penalties from the Federal Trade Commission of about fifty-three thousand dollars a day per image.
[00:14:53] And that starts to add up significantly. Yeah.
[00:14:56] Sandie Morgan: 53,000 a day. Okay. So there's also a little confusion with the Take It Down tool in NCMEC. We've done a lot of work with the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children, and in our schools, we promote that tool. What's the difference?
[00:15:23] Dawn Hawkins: Okay, I'm gonna explain a couple things. One, the Take It Down tool with NCMEC is focused on minors, and there's an equivalent focus on adults called StopNCII. Both of these tools rely only on hash of the image. A hash is like a fingerprint of the image. So you as the survivor, the victim, you have to have a copy of your abuse, and then you can hash it through the Take It Down or StopNCII tools, and then it goes into a database that they host.
[00:15:56] And they've partnered with a number of large tech platforms who compare against that database to make sure that that content isn't uploaded to their platforms. It's massively helpful for preventing the upload and the further distribution of content. But the problems are if you don't already have a copy of it, if you don't know where it is, then those do not help you.
[00:16:22] Those tools also do not help you remove existing content. They don't submit take down requests for you. And so that's where we step in, is we look for you, and then we also manage the process of asking for removals, and we escalate, if needed, when they ignore you. And we also hide your identity for them.
[00:16:44] Now, I wanna tell you something, Sandie, because for minors, very critically, there's two tools that you really need to know. The Take It Down app, the Take It Down portal is critical for stopping the spread. But if you want help getting content down, if you're a minor, you need to go to NCMEC's CyberTipline and support and report it there.
[00:17:06] So you'd have to report it in both places.
[00:17:09] Sandie Morgan: Okay, two reports for minors. So let's go back to adults. And one of the things that in my conversations with survivors, the idea that they can't get their images offline, and they go to all kinds of lengths and sometimes even change their names to avoid the problem that it keeps popping up.
[00:17:41] So for an adult now, what are the options?
[00:17:46] Dawn Hawkins: So now you can use our technology. We're in beta testing just right now. It's free for everyone to try. But if you know where a link is, if you know where content is, you can submit a link, and then we do the takedown processes for you and escalation. If you don't know, with us, you would build a digital identity, and then we scan the open web for that.
[00:18:08] If anything is found, you're notified, and then you approve it moving forward, and we can request removal and takedowns. So that's the option now that has never existed before, with Protect Privacy AI.
[00:18:24] Sandie Morgan: So we just go to protectprivacy.com
[00:18:28] Dawn Hawkins: .ai. Mm-hmm.
[00:18:30] Sandie Morgan: .ai.
[00:18:31] Dawn Hawkins: Protectprivacy.ai. Yeah. So we detect, we scan for you, we look for you, we help with the removal process, we escalate, and we monitor to make sure it's not uploaded again. And then all the while, we also track and document everything that's happening so that if you wanna pursue criminal or civil accountability later, you can do that and you've got the evidence to back you up.
[00:18:57] Sandie Morgan: Okay. So when did you launch this app?
[00:19:03] Dawn Hawkins: We've been live in beta testing for now about six weeks.
[00:19:07] Sandie Morgan: Okay. So tell us what happens after you are able to get things taken down, and what happens if you aren't able to? The 53,000 a day just keeps adding up?
[00:19:27] Dawn Hawkins: It does in theory. So if content is removed, you are notified of that. You know when we know if content is removed or not, so you've got that peace of mind. Now, if it's not removed, we check back every 48 hours, and then every day after that, and we submit a complaint to the FTC on your behalf automatically that the content is still removed.
[00:19:55] We also escalate now to their infrastructure, to folks like their registrars, their hosts, their advertisers, their CDN. So exciting, Sandie. It's like what we were doing at NCOSE with Pornhub, but against all of the sex industry, automated.
[00:20:14] Sandie Morgan: You have like 1,000 people working for you?
[00:20:17] Dawn Hawkins: No, Sandie, it's all automated.
[00:20:19] It's so amazing. With the tech in the world today, I am just... That's what changed for me, was realizing that the technology is here to solve what felt impossible to solve a few years ago. And we can do so without having to look at the sexually explicit content, and we can do so in ways that are so privacy-preserving to the individual.
[00:20:43] I'm so proud of what we've been able to build in that regard. But just today, Sandie, literally, I just saw this before I got on the phone with you. The Department of Justice just announced that they shut down, with France, a website. I won't say the name because the words are so disgusting.
[00:21:03] But it's a site that was hosting, a network of sites hosting non-consensual sexually explicit content, and they shut it down. And I was just looking, and I was like... And they used the TAKE IT DOWN Act as a reason for shutting the site down, and we had submitted complaints against that site. So I don't know that we were that super helpful, but it's working to tell on them.
[00:21:30] It's working, and today, I saw it for the
[00:21:33] Sandie Morgan: Oh. Bravo, bravo. So that raises two parts that I want to talk about. First of all, what is the international reach of this?
[00:21:48] Dawn Hawkins: We can help survivors anywhere in the world. In the United States we have the TAKE IT DOWN Act, which has the 48-hour rule and penalties. The UK and the EU have passed similar legislation. It's a little bit complicated of how to report and who to tell on them. But we are submitting take down requests on behalf of anyone anywhere in the world.
[00:22:15] It's just that the requirements for the platforms differ. So they could remove it, and they might not. We're babies still though, Sandie, so we've actually only served two or three people who are outside of the United States so far. So folks, if you're listening and you need some help, come test it out.
[00:22:31] Sandie Morgan: Okay. I love how open-handed you are with what you've learned. So this other question around this is about AI generally, because I think it cuts both ways. There are those who say shut it all down, but you found a way to use it for good.
[00:22:55] Dawn Hawkins: Yeah, I know. I know. I'm on that everyday fence. I'm still fighting for online child safety in my free time. And I'm like, "Ah, AI is causing so much harm," but also, oh my gosh, it's causing so much good. And in this instance, for example, we've been able to solve, or we're close to solving, this human rights crisis that had no solution in sight even five years ago.
[00:23:24] And AI is really a big reason why that's possible.
[00:23:28] Sandie Morgan: So that's so counterintuitive for us. We've been in this movement for a long time, and even yesterday I was at a prevention conference and educators and school leaders, child welfare people discussing prevention and where we have to put limits around AI. And so the absolute get rid of all of it also comes at the price of getting rid of the good.
[00:24:07] Can you speak to how we might moderate that?
[00:24:11] Dawn Hawkins: Well, I think it's a different story when we're talking about kids and minors and AI for education. And I don't know all the answers to that, Sandie, because I literally took a sabbatical and a break from my advocacy in that space to solve this problem. That feels very hard. What is the right solution?
[00:24:34] All I can say is, we obviously did it very wrong with the internet. We did it very wrong with social media, and we cannot afford to get it so wrong again with AI. We need guardrails and we need to be very careful and aware. And I think we need to be looking at the research from social media's impacts on youth as we're trying to assess what the guardrail should be with AI.
[00:25:01] It's not exact, but it's the closest we have, and we can't wait another twenty years to finally have research on the AI impacts. I will say to you though, something that's just really changed for me in the last year and a half, which, Sandie, in all honesty and for all of you listening, this work is hard.
[00:25:21] And I feel like I was struggling a lot with burnout and just a little bit of hopelessness, fighting this for
so many years. And even though we were having so much success, the problem still seems to grow and escalate, you know? I imagine you feel the same. So I stepped down from NCOSE as CEO, and I took a sabbatical, but what has me excited again and feeling full of hope is AI and is that we can really ten-x solutions in this fight for human dignity in ways we couldn't imagine before.
[00:25:57] And I just wanna shake all the leaders in this space and say, "Hey, lean into it. Think about how we can ten-x what we've learned over these twenty years of fighting in order to solve these problems." And likewise to you, I was at a conference recently, but that conference was, "How do we use AI for good?"
[00:26:19] And I saw just so many applications that are making a massive difference on behalf of survivors and children. So I'm optimistic again.
[00:26:28] Sandie Morgan: And how about in Congress? Because I'm sure you're not going to stay away from the Hill, and you faced down lots of objections. People called the bill a slippery slope that was ripe for abuse, and civil liberties raised free expression concerns. But we keep wanting to bring both sides of the aisle into this conversation to see moving these issues forward for adults as well as children.
[00:27:12] I had this conversation yesterday that kids turn 18, and then they stay adults a lot longer. So if we only focus our attention on under 18, then what happens? And what happens to the mental health? And we have a mental health crisis for young adults that they put in a category from 18 to 25. So I think I'm almost asking you to make a prediction for how... Because you took this up on behalf of adults, and how does that figure in bringing the rest of the movement?
[00:28:05] Because we've all pretty much been able to say what we think because everybody has to be concerned about children. But what about adults? How did you decide to do this for adults?
[00:28:21] Dawn Hawkins: Well, I fight for both adults and children in my advocacy over the years and at the National Center on Sexual Exploitation. But when I was at NCOSE in particular, we realized very few were standing up for adults in this space. Survivors of sex trafficking, prostitution, pornography, child sexual abuse who then become adults.
[00:28:46] It was like there was nothing for them anymore. So while I was at NCOSE, it was such a critical part of our DNA to be doing what we can also for adults. Like you said, it doesn't just change when you have a birthday and you're eighteen years old. That being said, Congress hasn't even passed legislation in twenty-seven years now for protecting kids online.
[00:29:13] There's just so many problems. But in my space, NCMEC is doing a lot for minors and for kids in trying to get content down. But for adults, there has been no solutions. And when you talk, Sandie, about that eighteen to twenty-five-year-old range, the first thing that comes to my mind is two different studies that say forty-six percent of them are also survivors of image-based sexual abuse.
[00:29:40] And when you start to talk about the impacts of either your private intimate moments or your most horrific moments of violence that you've experienced being filmed and uploaded and distributed online, is that also contributing, if fifty percent of our young people are victims of that, to their mental health?
[00:30:01] Of course it is.
[00:30:02] Sandie Morgan: Mm-hmm. Wow. Wow. We've got to get that stat and put a footnote in the show notes. Okay, so some of the first people around a person who might know that something happened like this is a parent, a youth pastor, a close personal work friend. And if someone finds an image today, what should they do in the first hour?
[00:30:37] Dawn Hawkins: If it's you, really critically it's helpful for you to document what's happened. So if there are threats or where it was posted and things like that, take screenshots of that. Our first is try to delete it as fast as we can. But you really want to document that it happened, and then save that in a very private, personal place that only you have access to.
[00:31:01] And then you can request for it to be taken down. If you're worried that there might be more out there, we can look for you. If you're a loved one of somebody who this has happened to, that's a hard place to be, because you wanna solve this problem for them. But my biggest advice is to not go looking for their abuse material for them, even though you're trying to help get it taken down.
[00:31:28] It just adds to the trauma, and many times the survivor can handle a stranger seeing and knowing and getting it down, but the people they love the most being those people, it really, for many, is very difficult. So really if you're the loved one, my advice is to really just listen, do not be judgmental, don't blame them for this happening, and then to just ask them what is most useful.
[00:31:56] If they want your help finding and removing, that's when you do it. But don't step in to do that for them.
[00:32:02] Sandie Morgan: If someone is listening to this and they know someone, who should they send them to for next steps? Do they call, email?
[00:32:18] Dawn Hawkins: Our tech is really good and is meant to help with that. So if someone comes to us, for example, I commented on trying to save document that it was up, we do that for you along the way. So sending them to us is a great first step. Also, it's all about time.
[00:32:40] You wanna get that content down as fast as you can, because the longer it's up, the more views it has, the more potential downloads or shares that it has, and then the farther the spread is. So getting it down as fast as you can is also critical, and that's what we can help with.
[00:32:57] Sandie Morgan: So this is a lot of new material for me, and so what didn't I ask that our listeners need to hear?
[00:33:06] Dawn Hawkins: I think that part of it that I want you to understand and the listeners to understand is that this is very widespread, and this is affecting so many. The research is showing 22% of adults are victims of image-based sexual abuse, 46% if you're in that younger adult age range. And those statistics do not take into account the AI deepfake technology that's exploding.
[00:33:32] If you just look at January of this year, in eleven-day span, because Grok, which was associated with X or Twitter, they toggled on a thing that allowed you to undress anybody. And so in eleven days, there were over three million sexually explicit images created of just women online, mostly women on the X platform.
[00:34:00] This is so widespread. Telegram, there were over a hundred and fifty million accounts with deepfakers, the forged pornography made of them. So what I want you to understand listening is that this is a very common and very prevalent problem, and we all feel like we're alone in it when this has happened to you. You're not alone. It's happening to lots of people. And also, don't judge everyone else. Don't be like, "Why did you send that picture? How could you let this happen?" The world that we're living in now, literally one bad actor can do this to thousands of women at a time.
[00:34:37] So really trying to have empathy for them and helping them find resources.
[00:34:44] Sandie Morgan: Dawn, I'm so glad I talked to you today. This is heavy, and at the same time, you leave me with hope because AI for good, if Dawn Hawkins believes this and has been an advocate in this space, I'm gonna follow you on social media. I'm gonna read your Substack. Tell us the name of both of your Substacks.
[00:35:14] Dawn Hawkins: Just find Dawn Hawkins on Substack and you'll see both of them.
[00:35:18] Yeah. So one I'm talking about IBSA and one I'm talking about child online safety.
[00:35:24] Sandie Morgan: Okay, and we'll put everything in the show notes. This has been a wonderfully invigorating conversation. I feel like it's been up and down, up and down, but it ends on hope and there is a way forward for us. Thank you so much, Dawn.
[00:35:45] Dawn Hawkins: Good to see you, Sandie.
[00:35:48] Elisha: Thank you, Dawn Hawkins, for your honesty about your own experience and for leaving listeners with this: If it's happened to you, you're not alone, and those images don't have to stay online forever. Listeners, if you enjoyed this conversation, make sure you check out our website at endinghumantrafficking.org for tons of in-depth show notes and other resources.
[00:36:07] If you'd love to help us grow this podcast, you can start by sharing this episode with someone and connecting with us on Facebook, Instagram, or LinkedIn. And as always, thank you for listening.