رونوشت 🔗
Susie: Imagine running over a thousand auto body and glass repair shops across North America, pulling in over a billion dollars in quarterly revenue, and somehow walking away with eighty-one thousand dollars in GAAP net income. Like, basically the price of one really nice pickup truck. Welcome to Earnings Unscripted. It's November eleventh, twenty twenty-six, and we're looking at third-quarter results for Boyd Group Services, ticker BGSI. Miro, where did the money go?
Miro: Well, it didn't disappear from the actual body shops, which is the bizarre part. If you look at the store level, they're growing revenue fast, same-store sales are ticking up while industry claims are actually shrinking, and their adjusted EBITDA jumped by over a third compared to last year. The actual collision business is humming.
Susie: Okay, yet the bottom line is a rounding error. And the market clearly didn't love the print, right? The stock gapped down hard at the open, dropped double digits compared to yesterday's close before it kind of flatlined for the rest of the morning. And before we go any further, remember nothing we say here is financial advice, just our own personal opinions on the tape. So what spooked everyone? Is it that GAAP profit, or sorry, lack of profit?
Miro: It's the weight of how they bought that growth. Remember, they closed that massive Joe Hudson's acquisition earlier this year, and to do it, they issued a ton of shares in their US IPO last fall, took on debt, took on massive lease liabilities, and booked a mountain of intangible assets for customer relationships. So now, below the operating line, you've got gigantic depreciation, amortization, and interest charges just eating the GAAP earnings alive. Plus, because of all those new shares, even their adjusted earnings per share actually went down year over year.
Susie: Right, because the pie got bigger, uh, slightly bigger, but you're slicing it into way more pieces.
Miro: Exactly. And there's a bit of a seasonal optical illusion in the sequential numbers too. On paper, revenue and margins dipped slightly from the second quarter, which looks like stalling if you don't know the business.
Susie: Which is just summer glass and Southern US seasonality, right? People aren't sliding on ice in July.
Miro: Pretty much. In fact, their margin dip from Q2 was actually milder than what they normally see in the third quarter. Because under the hood, they're squeezing a lot more margin out of paint rebates and doing their own high-tech sensor calibrations in-house instead of outsourcing them.
Susie: Speaking of under the hood, the detail from the call that completely broke my brain was CEO Brian Kaner talking about what their shop employees actually do all day. He said almost half of the people in their stores are just moving a claim from the front desk to the back of the shop.
Miro: Yeah, think about that. You run a massive repair network, and nearly half your store headcount is basically administrative relay runners. So now they're rolling out agentic AI to answer phones after hours, schedule the repairs, and do the follow-ups automatically.
Susie: Which makes total sense for cutting costs, though getting an AI voice agent right after you've wrapped your bumper around a pole sounds like a test of human patience. But before we get to the robots, there was something else on the call about insurance companies and why people are suddenly getting their cars repaired instead of totaled. You mentioned earlier there's a wild stat from J.D. Power driving all of that?Miro: Yeah, this was actually my favorite moment on the whole call. So for a while now, a big headwind for collision shops has been insurance companies just declaring damaged cars a total loss instead of paying to fix them. But Kaner pointed out that state regulators in places like Rhode Island and Oklahoma are actually raising the damage thresholds required before you're allowed to total a car. And the insurers and automakers are weirdly aligned with this.
Susie: Wait, why would an insurance company want to pay for a super expensive repair instead of just cutting a check and walking away?
Miro: Customer churn. Kaner cited data from CCC and J.D. Power showing that "40% of people after a total loss event switch insurance carriers. The attrition after a total loss event versus a repair event that's 7% is super high."
Susie: Oh, wow. Okay, so if they total your car, you basically fire them right after you cash the check. Is that just because people get annoyed fighting over what the used car was worth?
Miro: It's actually worse than that. Think about the auto loan market over the last few years. A huge number of drivers right now are upside down on their car loans. So if your car gets totaled, the insurance payout goes to the lender, it doesn't even cover the full loan balance, and suddenly you don't have a car AND you have to write a check out of pocket just to exit the loan on a wrecked vehicle.
Susie: Oh, that's brutal. Yeah, if I have to pay money to not have a car anymore, I'm blaming my insurance company, I'm blaming the automaker, I'm blaming everyone in sight.
Miro: Exactly. You lose the policyholder, and the car brand loses a repeat buyer. So suddenly everybody in the ecosystem has a massive incentive to get borderline cars fixed rather than totaled. Which flows directly into Boyd's bays and helps push up what they call TCOR, the average repair ticket.
Susie: Okay, so that's a great tailwind for getting cars into the shops. What about when they actually try to expand the network? Because if the unit economics are getting better with the paint rebates and the sensor stuff we talked about, they must be buying up every regional chain they can find.
Miro: Well, that's the second curveball in this report. They basically went on strike when it comes to buying regional multi-shop operators. Kaner flat out said on the call, "We're not a buyer in that environment," until sellers bring their
Load full transcript
valuation expectations down.
Susie: Hold on. Didn't they just do that massive US IPO last fall specifically to be a consolidator?
Miro: That was to fund the Joe Hudson's deal. And here's the irony. Since they issued all that stock last November, Boyd's own trading multiple has contracted. So when they look at the math today, regional shop owners still want peak multiples, while Boyd's own stock is sitting right there on sale. So instead of buying regional chains, they launched a buyback program in September and spent about fourteen million dollars buying back their own shares.
Susie: Which is rational capital allocation, I guess, if your stock is cheaper than the private market. Though wait, if they aren't buying regional chains, they're just relying on single shops and building their own locations from scratch, right?
Miro: In theory, yes. Except in the third quarter, they guided to opening three new start-up locations, and they opened zero.
Susie: Zero? Like, none at all?
Miro: Not a single one. They bought ten individual shops, which is fine, they look for specific footprints in markets where they want to be number one or two. As Kaner joked, he's not just taking a shotgun approach to buy random shops in Wyoming or Montana. But on the organic development side, where they build greenfield or convert brownfield buildings, everything got pushed back. Now they're promising eleven of those start-up openings in the fourth quarter, and thirty-four over the next twelve months.
Susie: Going from zero in Q3 to eleven in Q4 feels like a pretty steep ramp if you're dealing with construction or permitting delays. And at the same time they're still digesting Joe Hudson's, right? How is that integration actually going behind the scenes?
Miro: It was a little bumpy out of the gate. Kaner admitted that between announcing the deal last fall and actually getting the keys in January, the Joe Hudson's business eroded a bit. And when they got inside, they realized Joe Hudson's didn't have the data visibility or operational tools Boyd uses. They've converted all the stores over to Boyd's systems now, which caused some first-week chaos at the shops, and they're bringing the leverage down nicely. But then management did one more thing on this call that always makes my ears perk up. They announced they're permanently stopping their intra-quarter monthly same-store sales updates.
Susie: Right when the stock is getting hammered and start-up openings hit a wall, they decide to turn off one of the main headlights analysts use to see how the quarter is going?Miro: Look, whenever a company pulls back on a disclosure metric, Wall Street's knee-jerk reaction is always that they're hiding a slowdown. Though in fairness to Kaner, they didn't pull the curtain while trends were tanking. They actually confirmed October same-store sales were positive and repair tickets were climbing before shutting the window. His argument is basically that monthly collision volume is super noisy, and giving play-by-play updates just makes analysts obsess over thirty-day weather patterns instead of the multi-year transformation.
Susie: Okay, I can buy that logic on paper, even if the timing feels a little convenient. Because if you're asking investors to ignore the monthly noise and stomach all that acquisition accounting we talked about earlier, you really need the fourth quarter to look clean. What are they actually telling us to expect for the rest of the year?
Miro: They're guiding for fourth-quarter gross margins to stay pretty stable sequentially, since winter glass seasonality tends to balance out the heavier collision work. And on their big cost-saving plan, they're expecting another fifteen million dollars in savings next quarter, which puts them well over two-thirds of the way to their multi-year target before that AI phase really kicks in.
Susie: So the cost story is actually ahead of schedule. It really comes down to whether they can get those delayed start-up shops open in the fourth quarter, and honestly, whether they get Joe Hudson's fully wired into their internal financial controls on time early next year.
Miro: Exactly. Fix the cars, open the doors, and let the accounting dust settle. It's a classic heavy-indigestion year after a mega-deal, but the underlying shop mechanics actually look pretty healthy.
Susie: And if all else fails, at least their AI receptionist won't get mad at us when we call after hours. Alright, Miro, we'll leave it right there.
Miro: Sounds good. Catch you next time.Susie: If you want these breakdowns waiting in your feed right as earnings season unfolds, go ahead and tap follow wherever you're listening. And speaking of AI receptionists, Miro and I are actually synthetic ourselves, with this whole conversation written and voiced by AI to turn Boyd's filings and call transcript into a same-day show. If there's a ticker you want us to tackle next, or you just want to tell us what you think, drop a note at earningsunscripted@datamadness.ca or check the X link in the show notes.
Miro: Take care, everyone.