رونوشت 🔗
[0:01] Welcome to courtroom quarterback the experiences and thoughts of a court-martial defense attorney
[0:07] Hey, everyone. Welcome back to an all-new episode of courtroom quarterback the experiences and thoughts of a court-martial defense attorney
[0:15] With attorney Joseph Jordan the founder over at the Jordan
[0:19] UCMJ law group. I'm your host Mike Leon. You know, Joseph here's a former army jag and worldwide court-martial defense attorney
[0:25] Who's tried more than 240 court-martials to verdict and thousands of military cases all across
[0:32] the US Europe Middle East and the Pacific today's episode
[0:36] We're gonna be stepping into one of the most serious and complex areas of military criminal defense
[0:42] And that's the eye-cack the internet crimes against children cases
[0:47] Joseph's gonna explain what that is why these cases are uniquely difficult to defend and how some shims form early on in the case
[0:55] And what it actually takes to evaluate them with discipline and care
[0:59] Joseph, it's good to see you. I gave the acronym here of eye-cack
[1:02] So I would love for you to explain a little bit of what this is and what these cases kind of involve
[1:07] But also when one of these cases kind of comes to your desk
[1:11] What are you kind of a paying attention to early on before you even start thinking about you know your trial strategy?
[1:17] Yeah, afternoon Mike
[1:19] so first of all
[1:22] Eye-cack cases are more commonly known as to catch a predator cases
[1:26] So these are as you mentioned earlier this you know these crimes usually occur over the internet and so what am I paying attention to?
[1:36] first well first of all
[1:40] You're looking at the ad so at the end we get we get a whole list
[1:45] Yeah, you have an accused and then you get a whole bunch of chats
[1:49] Well, how did the chat start in the first place usually it starts with some sort of an advertisement
[1:54] Some sort of ad on a social media platform. Okay, and so
[2:00] Where is the ad ad? Where is it located?
[2:03] Is it required to be an adult to even set up the ad in the first place?
[2:08] What is the content of the ad? What photographs are shown on the ad?
[2:12] What is being requested? What questions are being asked of the ad?
[2:17] Why is all this important because you're looking for elements of entrapment?
[2:22] So Joseph, let me ask you when you kind of look back at these cases that
[2:27] Let's say went sideways a little early on
[2:30] What what were some of the assumptions because I mentioned in the intro right assumptions tend to form like what were some of the assumptions that tend to get baked in before anyone kind of slows down and says
[2:38] Hey, let's let's evaluate the evidence here. Well first, I think you're you're looking at the assumption that the
[2:46] Person the accused if they're charged with the crime that the accused is
[2:52] Has specific knowledge and knows that he's talking to a minor that that's the number one and really intruded the only assumption that that is made
[3:02] Let me ask you because you mentioned a second ago and there was like text messages and things like that
[3:07] And a lot of the evidence in these iKat cases and you tell me if I'm wrong. They're like they're digital, right?
[3:12] It's like it's text messages chats things like that
[3:14] What makes assessing that kind of evidence a little bit different from other cases you handle first and foremost
[3:21] It's in the black and white. So I think one of the reasons why I'm uniquely
[3:29] uniquely qualified more than most to
[3:32] Look at these types of cases is because I read a lot
[3:36] I read a lot which allows me to what
[3:39] Formulate pictures in my mind think about and when I'm formulating pictures in my mind as I'm reading a story
[3:45] I'm thinking about
[3:47] Tone inflection setting all of those sorts of things. So when you get these chats you have to read them and
[3:57] I think when I look through these things. I'm trying to understand
[4:02] What's being said? What's the information being conveyed?
[4:06] What leads to the next part of the conversations? Conversations are like
[4:12] It's like a pathway, you know
[4:15] And depending on where you're going down the path what signs you come up against will determine if you turn right left or what have you?
[4:23] And so these cases are digitally centric and there's a lot of other data that you're also looking at because first you start with the chats
[4:32] And you're looking at the black and white conversation, but then you're also looking at
[4:36] All right, what else is in this person's digital footprint, right? What kind of searches do they have?
[4:42] Were they chatting with anybody else at the same time?
[4:45] Were they engaging any phone calls at the same time?
[4:48] Those things matter because it helps determine whether or not this was distracted chatting or focused chatting
[4:54] And that matters because can you definitively say that this person had this specific intent to have these conversations if they're chatting with four or five people at the same time?
[5:04] Well, I was gonna ask you along those lines because I'm sure when you handle these type of cases, I mean, they're gonna get naturally strong reactions
[5:11] Right because of the assumptions that are formed. How do you kind of keep the analysis and discipline part of this from getting you know drowned out once momentum starts building in the case like how do you separate that?
[5:24] So I think I take a three-pronged approach
[5:28] So first I kind of take a 30,000-foot view
[5:32] You know, let's just take a look at this from the 30,000-foot
[5:35] um
[5:36] venue for angle and think about this holistically
[5:41] Then I place myself in the shoes of the client and think through okay, what is the client experiencing at their level?
[5:51] Right and then I go to the client themselves and I say okay
[5:55] Walk me through your
Load full transcript
experience, right?
[5:58] Um, it's easy if the chats are only happened in a few hours space and time
[6:05] Uh, it's much much more difficult when you're dealing with chats that are weeks in some cases month's law
[6:12] um and
[6:14] You know, but you have to break it down at that level and I I think taking that three-pronged approach the 30,000-foot view
[6:21] Putting myself in the place of my client and then asking my client, okay
[6:25] Walk me through your experience
[6:28] um allows me to test
[6:31] A variety of different assumptions
[6:33] To
[6:34] Destroy confirmation bias if indeed my client is innocent staying on that front
[6:40] Can we talk a little bit more about like the investigative process that you do like what like that could shape the entire case
[6:46] I mean what kind of early choices in that investigative process
[6:50] tend to have like the biggest impact downstream or later on well first
[6:55] It's mastering the chats read the chats understand the rhythm of the chats and then
[7:01] Next it's getting the right digital forensic expert on your team to verify
[7:07] A variety of different things because sometimes the chats are with a real person
[7:11] Most of the time these cases are you're dealing with an agent, you know, someone is playing a kid
[7:17] So then what are we looking at we're looking at the training of the agent
[7:21] We're looking at the way the agent presented themselves online
[7:26] We're looking at the ad as I mentioned before. How was that thing placed? How does it draw you in?
[7:32] So you're trying to establish
[7:35] known factors of entrapment to determine if you have them or not
[7:39] um in order to present at the fence
[7:42] so
[7:43] The training and education of the agent
[7:46] There's a whole series of analysis that you do on the chats themselves from the agents perspective
[7:51] And how they go through the chat process and the things that they're supposed to do do they
[7:57] um
[7:58] You know for instance
[8:00] Do they actually confirm that the person they're chatting with has verified the age?
[8:06] Do they provide what's known as quote unquote an off-ramp meaning?
[8:10] Hey, we don't have to continue this you know, I got a you know those sorts of things right
[8:16] How do they react to
[8:19] You know the stimulus of what the client is saying are they trying to draw them into much or they're trying to lead them down the road too much
[8:25] So those things matter so you you focus on the reality of the situation
[8:30] You know, because that's what the panel is going to be focused on as well
[8:33] Um, they're not going to be thinking about all of the intricacies behind the scenes in terms of the digital footprint
[8:39] But again, I mentioned earlier
[8:40] What else is the client doing during the chat and does the client have a propensity for this
[8:45] When they when you're looking at the evidence is there is there a
[8:49] Child pornography on there on the on the devices that they were chatting with
[8:53] Or do they have those types of internet searches that would lead you to believe that they're interested in child
[8:58] You know children in the first place that stuff matters too. Well stay on the uh defense perspective there
[9:04] You just said it so like take us inside now
[9:06] You're presenting this these cases are especially difficult to kind of explain like how do you do it without
[9:12] oversimplifying it or or
[9:15] provoking these you know
[9:16] Or listening emotion from folks like how are you putting this on you keep it real um and depending on the case
[9:24] Uh, you see what facts you have available to work with you so
[9:29] If it's an agent which nine times out of 10 the cases that we take to trial you're dealing with an agent who's on the other side chatting
[9:35] With the uh with your client
[9:38] It's a it's an easier sell to the panel right one
[9:42] The breath comes out of the room at this point or you can you can you can put the oxygen back in the room as it were because
[9:49] Uh, we're not dealing with a real child
[9:51] All right, so no child to worry about let's just look at the facts here and see what we have to work with and did the agents actually
[9:59] And trap your client right so keep it focused. What's the ballgame right
[10:05] What's the alamo where are we going with this if you're actually dealing with a child though and we've done that too
[10:12] In those scenarios now you're looking at
[10:16] Okay, well, what's the background of the child? Why would the child be involved in something like this in first place
[10:23] What gives them
[10:25] You know access what gives them the knowledge what gives them the interest right um and so in those cases
[10:35] Most of the time the child if they're communicating with your client they're not identifying that they're actually a child
[10:40] It's a situation where the parents have identified you're talking to an adult but then you look at the chats and there's no indication that
[10:48] That they're actually a child they presented themselves to be older than who they are
[10:52] Um, but then there's an indication that maybe they're not so where do the where do you get where do you get caught?
[10:57] Well, maybe if they show up for the me or whatever right so it depends on the scenario in terms
[11:05] Of what you're working with
[11:07] um and
[11:08] With if it is found out to be a child that you're communicating with it does make the defense perspective much much more difficult to deal with
[11:16] Well, let's talk about like a specific case because you gave two examples there were sometimes it's an agent sometimes not a kid can you kind of share a case where
[11:24] the analysis
[11:26] Rather than you know a quick conclusion
[11:29] Fundamentally kind of changed how the allegation was understood and what what kind of stood out in in the process?
[11:35] So in my last um, I can't case. I was at a fourth drum
[11:41] For
the life of me. I don't understand why they thought we had to catch a predator problems on
[11:47] Post on fourth drum, but they decided to set up a stain at some cabins in a little park area on fourth drum
[11:57] um and
[11:59] They started they started and when I say they I mean the New York state police
[12:05] So the New York state police partnered with RBC ID on fourth drum and set up this stain operation
[12:12] And so they put out these ads
[12:14] um and the ads were on an adult only website
[12:18] uh is actually a website there was known to
[12:21] uh traffic and prostitutes
[12:24] And so my client uh
[12:28] As it turned out was an individual who was a known
[12:32] Well, he was a very experienced
[12:35] user of these online services for prostitution purposes um and so when we looked at his chat
[12:44] In particular, it was a very short chat. It started like early in the day. Hi. How are you and that was it?
[12:50] And then in the afternoon it was a very compressed time frame
[12:54] And so I started to understand breakdown what happened in that compressed time frame
[12:59] And one of the things that we found through looking at the digital forensic evidence was that
[13:04] He's got a bunch of chats going on
[13:07] And so I had to sit down with him. I'm like, hey, this is what the evidence is show on me man
[13:10] Who else were you talking to?
[13:12] And he was talking like three other girls like, you know, one of them might have had you know that sex with them
[13:18] You know, I've paid her for it your prostitute
[13:21] and
[13:22] We started looking at the gaps of time
[13:26] Where he's answering a question and then like five or ten minutes or past and then well, what's happening here
[13:32] We could plug in that he was messaging someone else and so what it turned out was he was supposed to go on the on the day in question
[13:39] He was supposed to meet with the with one individual
[13:42] She said she wasn't going to be available for like another hour. So he was like, well, I want to go check this thing out
[13:47] And you could tell through the chats that it was distracted chatting
[13:52] He didn't ask for a photo didn't send the photo himself didn't acknowledge the age of the person he was chatting with completely ignored that
[14:00] Just like hey, were you going to meet what time you want to meet that was it
[14:05] Um, and it wasn't the type of chats that I see in these cases where they're getting really nasty
[14:11] Where they're used it where they're sexting for lack of a better term, you know, things of that nature
[14:15] You know, no exchange of photographs
[14:17] Um, and it was just a matter of
[14:20] Hate thought he was just going to go meet someone and pay for sex and that's what we were able to present
[14:26] Um, not to mention the fact that we were able to show that he was indeed in trapped
[14:31] He found this person on own
[14:34] You know prostitution website and we did the digging on that too.
It's it was it surprised me that there was actually
[14:40] Websites that the public has access to where you can meet someone
[14:47] For sex and it it's pretty clear. You're paying them for it, right? So
[14:52] Um, we put it all together
[14:54] Uh, I had probably mentioned in a previous episode um
[15:00] Two episodes ago uh, where I talk about cross-examining the agent to like do you speak english that was that agent he was a very obstructionist
[15:09] Um, you know, he thought he was the biggest the best things since sliced bread
[15:14] Um, and we were able to uh, what we but I was able to eviscerate him on the stand because he very clearly violated
[15:21] Many of the basic tenets of how to do these chats properly. I won't go into the bloody gory details of that but
[15:28] Um, suffice it to say he didn't do it correctly. We were able to show
[15:33] Um, the panel that our client was indeed in trapped and it was a full acquittal
[15:38] And it was a quick verdict too
[15:40] which um
[15:42] Is a pretty strong signal that this was a case that should have never walked into the courtroom
[15:47] Well, Joseph as we wrap here, you know, this is courtroom quarterback, right? So for the folks out there that are watching this that
[15:55] Maybe they're with deciding whether or not they should handle an i-cat case
[16:00] But let's use this as an example. What are some qualities or approaches that
[16:04] You would tell them matter the most in these cases
[16:07] They're maybe they're they're rarely talked about openly
[16:11] First listen to your client
[16:13] First and foremost what?
[16:16] Find out what the client's thoughts were
[16:19] You need a red team that you need to question that you need to apply common sense to what they're telling you
[16:26] But what is the client's perspective on this and you in what you have to do is you have to coach them
[16:33] Through this
[16:34] Process wherein you want them to be objective
[16:39] Take the emotion out of it. I know you're scared shitless. I get that. Okay. Take the emotion out of it
[16:44] Let's just tell me what you were thinking as you were going through this as you were having this chat, right
[16:50] That really helped me gain perspective on my client because my client was use a third country national um
[16:58] And he
[16:59] You know English was not necessarily his first language
[17:03] um
[17:05] And he was timid
[17:07] Which surprised me given his occupation um and his size he was a had some
[17:14] Big fella of fit
[17:17] Um, he was very timid and so I really needed to understand what was going through his head. So
[17:23] You know
[17:24] Understand from the client's perspective
[17:26] And are they being reasonable and you only get there through doing a lot of case?
[17:30] You know that you experience
[17:33] Breeds judgment and then with that judgment you're able to make really good calls
[17:38] So uh reps is what you need you got to stack them
[17:43] But as you're doing these cases
[17:45] Understand what the client's perspective is
[17:48] Make sure you dig into the digital evidence
[17:51] Um, and look for what's not there right where you can get and you can you can see what's there and big and get caught up in the emotion
[17:59] For what's there, but what what people forget to do is look for what's not there
[18:04] And in my client's case that I just talked to you about there was no child pornography there was no searches for
[18:10] Anything of a nature that had to do with child sex um, he didn't have a history of chatting with other people for this
[18:17] So that's a big indicator that um, he has no interest in it did not intend to meet or talk with a minor and was indeed entrapped
[18:28] Yeah
[18:29] Well, Joseph appreciate the time the insights explaining all this to the audience. Thanks as always
[18:34] Thank you Mike have a good one and thank you to everyone out there for listening to this installment of courtroom quarterback with attorney Joseph Jordan
[18:41] If you want to learn more about Joseph's worldwide court martial uh defense practice do me a favor right now visit Jordan
[18:47] UCMjlaw dot com and as always one more favor hit like hit subscribe leave a review comment share it with someone who needs to hear it
[18:56] I'm Mike Leon. We will see you next time
[19:02] Thanks for watching be sure to hit that like and subscribe button and leave us a review in the comments