رونوشت 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:10.825 --> 00:00:16.359
Hello, and welcome to Conversations with Great Historians, the podcast brought
00:00:16.359 --> 00:00:19.132
to you from the Gilder Lehrman Institute of American History.
00:00:19.597 --> 00:00:23.109
I'm Jim Basker, president and CEO of the Gilder Lehrman Institute,
00:00:23.109 --> 00:00:25.193
and I'm delighted to have you join us.
00:00:25.804 --> 00:00:29.859
For years, our program, Book Breaks, has brought together thousands of history
00:00:29.859 --> 00:00:34.379
lovers, teachers, students, and lifelong learners for conversations with leading
00:00:34.379 --> 00:00:35.603
historians and writers.
00:00:36.189 --> 00:00:40.859
Each week, we explore important books that deepen our understanding of the people,
00:00:40.859 --> 00:00:43.834
events, and ideas that have shaped our past.
00:00:44.451 --> 00:00:49.084
Now we're bringing those conversations directly to you in podcast form.
00:00:49.648 --> 00:00:53.919
In each episode, you'll hear an engaging conversation with an author about their
00:00:53.919 --> 00:00:57.554
latest work, followed by thoughtful questions from our audience.
00:00:58.135 --> 00:01:03.029
We hope these conversations inform and inspire you, and most of all,
00:01:03.029 --> 00:01:05.379
spark your curiosity about history.
00:01:06.016 --> 00:01:10.654
Thank you for listening, and welcome again to Conversations with Great Historians.
00:01:11.467 --> 00:01:15.309
Hi, everybody, and welcome to Book Breaks. We're so thrilled to have you here
00:01:15.309 --> 00:01:19.839
today as we welcome our friend John Meacham and his introduction to the Declaration
00:01:19.839 --> 00:01:22.741
of Independence and Constitution of the United States.
00:01:23.263 --> 00:01:25.949
If you'd like to ask a question, you can use the Q&A feature,
00:01:25.949 --> 00:01:29.027
and Ryan will be asking your questions in the second half of the program.
00:01:29.672 --> 00:01:33.137
And we'd like to thank viewers like you for making book breaks possible.
00:01:33.901 --> 00:01:36.979
And I'm your host, Gina Oppenheim, and I'm joined by my friend Ryan,
00:01:36.979 --> 00:01:38.969
who will be taking your questions later on.
00:01:39.649 --> 00:01:43.059
And without further ado, we are so thrilled today to welcome John,
00:01:43.059 --> 00:01:47.032
who is a winner of the Poulter Prize and the Gilder Lerman Lincoln Prize.
00:01:47.346 --> 00:01:52.269
He is also the Carolyn T. and Robert M. Rogers Chair in American Presidency
00:01:52.530 --> 00:01:55.264
and Professor of Political Science at Vanderbilt University,
00:01:55.531 --> 00:02:00.012
as well as co-chair of the Vanderbilt Project on Unity and American Democracy.
00:02:00.384 --> 00:02:03.384
John, we're so thrilled to have you here today. Thanks so much.
00:02:03.944 --> 00:02:07.919
So just wondering if you can just give us an overview of this work and how you
00:02:07.919 --> 00:02:09.656
are asked to write this introduction.
00:02:10.492 --> 00:02:15.848
Well, it came from my editor, Andy War at Random House, who I think,
00:02:15.848 --> 00:02:21.369
like a lot of people in this, how to put it, tumultuous time politically,
00:02:21.816 --> 00:02:24.747
has been trying to find ways to,
00:02:25.513 --> 00:02:30.968
illuminate as opposed to scorch in the public dialogue, which I'm a big believer in.
00:02:31.491 --> 00:02:37.018
And Modern Library, which I've always been obsessed with, is a great line of
00:02:37.018 --> 00:02:42.063
classics where you can put out these kinds of volumes,
00:02:42.585 --> 00:02:46.698
in a way that, you know, has a chance of almost, I don't want to say sneak up
00:02:46.698 --> 00:02:48.638
on you, but I kind of mean that.
00:02:49.081 --> 00:02:53.641
It's a sense of, is there going to be,
00:02:54.368 --> 00:03:04.809
a re-engagement with these critical documents at a time when so many of us believe that we are,
00:03:05.564 --> 00:03:12.216
falling away from working on realizing the promise of the declaration and clearly realizing.
00:03:13.031 --> 00:03:18.967
How to put it, are taking the Constitution out for a very, very rough ride.
00:03:19.263 --> 00:03:24.255
And so let's go back to first principles. Let's see why these things were written,
00:03:24.719 --> 00:03:27.274
what they said, and what they should mean to us.
00:03:27.755 --> 00:03:31.276
Yeah. And speaking of just sort of this idea of division, you open the book
00:03:31.276 --> 00:03:34.936
with correspondence between Abraham Lincoln and somebody surprising,
00:03:35.197 --> 00:03:40.213
Alexander Stevens, the future vice president of the Confederacy.
00:03:40.544 --> 00:03:43.696
Can you tell us about that correspondence? Because It's so fascinating.
00:03:44.009 --> 00:03:48.787
It was fascinating. So Stevens and Lincoln served together in the House in the 1840s.
00:03:48.897 --> 00:03:53.786
And Stevens, of course, is the articulator of the cornerstone speech,
00:03:53.786 --> 00:03:58.195
the clearest document that shows what the Confederacy was about.
00:03:58.532 --> 00:04:02.826
He writes that we were the we were the we the Confederacy are the first government
00:04:03.081 --> 00:04:08.936
ever fully founded on the principle that the white man is superior to the black man.
00:04:09.396 --> 00:04:11.911
Rough paraphrase, but but essentially there.
00:04:12.499 --> 00:04:21.016
And Stevens was writing, really looking for reassurance and trying to feel out
00:04:21.016 --> 00:04:23.543
where Lincoln as president-elect was.
00:04:24.019 --> 00:04:28.426
And one of the things which everyone here knows, but we all need to tell the
00:04:28.426 --> 00:04:35.549
story as much as possible, is Lincoln was not a radical figure in the winter of 6061.
00:04:35.950 --> 00:04:39.473
He was very much a constitutionalist.
00:04:39.874 --> 00:04:44.776
He did not believe the Constitution as written gave him the power to abolish
00:04:44.776 --> 00:04:46.595
slavery where it existed.
Load full transcript
00:04:47.257 --> 00:04:52.783
He was about, as we all as we know, he was about containing its spread.
00:04:53.149 --> 00:04:56.411
And that's where he believed the federal government had authority.
00:04:57.096 --> 00:05:03.969
And in trying to describe why he believed this and why he believed that it could not spread,
00:05:04.544 --> 00:05:08.724
he got to the apple of gold and the frame of silver, that the Declaration of
00:05:08.724 --> 00:05:12.978
Independence, which is from Proverbs, the Declaration of Independence is the apple of gold.
00:05:13.182 --> 00:05:20.844
That's the principle we were, as a nation, we founded ourselves in an attempt to recognize,
00:05:21.304 --> 00:05:26.580
that central truth, that all are created equal, a diametrically opposed truth,
00:05:26.968 --> 00:05:30.353
alleged truth, to the one that Stevens wrote.
00:05:31.428 --> 00:05:36.513
And the Constitution, then, was the frame of silver that enabled that journey to unfold.
00:05:37.018 --> 00:05:42.014
And one of the things, and to talk about Abraham Lincoln with Gilder Lehrman
00:05:42.014 --> 00:05:44.524
is like Coles to Newcastle and all that.
00:05:45.427 --> 00:05:47.411
But, you know, Lincoln...
00:05:48.235 --> 00:05:54.585
To me, what absolutely redeems Abraham Lincoln is that he is the fullest illustration
00:05:54.585 --> 00:05:59.105
that I can think of, of the necessity of sending someone to the pinnacle of
00:05:59.105 --> 00:06:01.586
power with a moral commitment,
00:06:02.155 --> 00:06:05.023
with a moral compass of some kind.
00:06:05.406 --> 00:06:08.320
Just be devoted to something larger than yourself.
00:06:08.819 --> 00:06:11.826
And his anti-slavery commitment was persistent.
00:06:12.370 --> 00:06:16.676
He didn't move as fast as Garrison and others wanted him to do,
00:06:16.967 --> 00:06:21.169
and he moved far faster than Stevens and others ever thought he should.
00:06:21.895 --> 00:06:27.335
That's not to say the middle way is always the right way, but Lincoln in the
00:06:27.335 --> 00:06:32.335
maelstrom of history found a way to defend that principle, articulate in the
00:06:32.335 --> 00:06:36.044
Declaration, and basically save the constitutional structure.
00:06:36.607 --> 00:06:41.058
Yeah, and I love the way you contextualize the Constitution in your introduction,
00:06:41.354 --> 00:06:44.025
and you bring in a lot of different people's thoughts on it.
00:06:44.454 --> 00:06:48.115
Frederick Douglass said the Constitution of the United States is not a pro-slavery
00:06:48.115 --> 00:06:50.242
document. Can you expand on that?
00:06:50.578 --> 00:06:55.725
So I think, Fred, more and more, I find, and David Blight, of course,
00:06:55.725 --> 00:07:03.654
loves this, I find that Douglass is one of the handful of truly remarkable Americans.
00:07:03.990 --> 00:07:08.115
This is the wrong thing to bring up in this particular era, but I really want
00:07:08.115 --> 00:07:10.585
there to be a Douglass memorial on them all.
00:07:11.009 --> 00:07:13.064
I think he's one of the vital figures.
00:07:13.691 --> 00:07:20.721
Imagine what it takes for a man born into enslavement, who escaped enslavement,
00:07:21.413 --> 00:07:27.428
to say that the Constitution of the United States is a glorious liberty document.
00:07:28.148 --> 00:07:33.515
Imagine what it takes for him to have faith in the principles when folks who
00:07:33.535 --> 00:07:39.369
looked like me, did all we could to violate those principles in practice.
00:07:40.033 --> 00:07:46.814
And I just find that a remarkably generous-spirited and brave thing to believe.
00:07:47.568 --> 00:07:52.917
And if Douglass argued that,
00:07:53.584 --> 00:07:57.990
the constitutional structure was the way to move forward,
00:07:58.489 --> 00:08:02.266
I think, and this is just me talking, I think partly it's because if you break
00:08:02.266 --> 00:08:06.706
up the country at that point, if you say the Constitution, if you're an abolitionist
00:08:06.706 --> 00:08:11.522
and you say the Constitution is too pro-slavery, the Wendell Phillips garrison argument,
00:08:12.236 --> 00:08:16.351
then what do you do with the four million people who are enslaved?
00:08:17.001 --> 00:08:24.940
Are consigned forever, right? So it's a much more complicated question than is often presented.
00:08:25.445 --> 00:08:30.728
Absolutely. Now, in writing this, what were some of your favorite discoveries that you came upon?
00:08:31.006 --> 00:08:37.566
You know, I had forgotten that Gladstone said the Constitution was the greatest
00:08:37.566 --> 00:08:40.015
act of genius struck off by the hand of man.
00:08:40.525 --> 00:08:45.053
And boy, you know, those white guys in Philadelphia would have loved that.
00:08:45.448 --> 00:08:49.766
That's a blurb they would have used. They would have made a needlepoint pillow
00:08:49.766 --> 00:08:51.513
with it and sold it in the gift shop.
00:08:52.556 --> 00:08:59.236
And re-engaging with Douglas, because it is so resonant, right?
00:08:59.236 --> 00:09:03.436
There are people, and we shouldn't tiptoe around this, there are people who
00:09:03.756 --> 00:09:10.317
believe that given the authoritarian trend in the country,
00:09:10.926 --> 00:09:17.246
that perhaps the Constitution and this system is not commensurate anymore to
00:09:17.246 --> 00:09:19.872
the pursuit of fulfilling the Declaration.
00:09:20.530 --> 00:09:27.787
And that's not unlike what Garrison and Wendell Phillips believed in the 19th century.
00:09:28.503 --> 00:09:35.136
And then you have Douglas and Lincoln say, no, that this is the way we have to do it.
00:09:35.975 --> 00:09:40.659
And just because it worked in the past doesn't mean it's going to work now,
00:09:41.329 --> 00:09:45.079
but it is the most vivid example of.
00:09:45.945 --> 00:09:52.737
Faith. The book of Hebrews says that faith is the substance of things hoped
00:09:52.737 --> 00:09:55.328
for and the evidence of things not seen.
00:09:55.711 -->
00:10:02.507
It is this so much of our republic, and I use this advisedly,
00:10:03.007 --> 00:10:08.831
it's kind of a make-believe, right? I mean, we sort of decide we're going to obey laws.
00:10:09.331 --> 00:10:13.237
One of the ways I like to think about it is if you have in your neighborhood,
00:10:14.047 --> 00:10:17.817
if you drive around, there's probably a stop sign where there's almost never
00:10:17.817 --> 00:10:20.575
oncoming traffic, right? But do you stop?
00:10:21.335 --> 00:10:25.087
Do you slow down a little bit when you know at three o'clock in the morning,
00:10:25.547 --> 00:10:27.418
going to the airport or something, that no one's there?
00:10:28.028 --> 00:10:33.027
Most people do because it's part of the covenant. And the Constitution is the
00:10:33.027 --> 00:10:37.688
most important manifestation of the covenant that binds us together,
00:10:38.222 --> 00:10:40.027
should bind us together. Should, yeah.
00:10:40.490 --> 00:10:44.106
Now, for our students on the call who might not be aware, can you tell us about
00:10:44.245 --> 00:10:49.307
the parts of Jefferson's draft that didn't make it into the final version? Sure.
00:10:49.847 --> 00:10:53.957
So, first of all, for those who, and there are lots of writers,
00:10:53.957 --> 00:10:56.257
I'm sure, who are listening to this.
00:10:57.354 --> 00:11:00.814
Nobody loves being edited, and Jefferson hated it.
00:11:01.093 --> 00:11:05.712
There's a marvelous scene where poor Benjamin Franklin has to reach over and
00:11:05.712 --> 00:11:11.978
sort of keep Jefferson from leaping up to say, no, you're butchering this brilliant prose.
00:11:12.407 --> 00:11:17.080
There was a strong denunciation of, a much stronger denunciation of slavery
00:11:17.469 --> 00:11:20.423
in the declaration that was taken out. That's the most important thing.
00:11:21.364 --> 00:11:26.312
And, you know, the young Thomas Jefferson is an interesting figure on this.
00:11:26.312 --> 00:11:29.555
As a young lawyer, he had an anti-slavery position.
00:11:30.019 --> 00:11:33.052
He drafted this in 1776.
00:11:33.528 --> 00:11:40.661
He became more tragically accepting of slavery as he went on.
00:11:41.305 --> 00:11:42.982
But it's a reminder.
00:11:43.722 --> 00:11:47.511
I found the whole project, as I'm sure everybody here does.
00:11:49.130 --> 00:11:58.213
It's always remarkable to read something you thought you knew because we don't always.
00:11:58.608 --> 00:12:05.972
And so much of these founding documents, which can be turned into totems,
00:12:05.972 --> 00:12:09.372
you know, we shouldn't be worshiping these documents, right?
00:12:09.372 --> 00:12:13.432
These are the product, as Gladstone said, of human hands.
00:12:14.548 --> 00:12:16.272
They did not come on tablets.
00:12:17.650 --> 00:12:26.560
But they were, I believe, forged in a sensibility that I think is really,
00:12:26.560 --> 00:12:32.528
really important at this particular moment, which is, it's essentially a theological one.
00:12:33.900 --> 00:12:40.287
The founders saw us as flawed, frail, and fallible people.
00:12:41.103 --> 00:12:46.920
They saw us as folks who would be driven by appetite and ambition And that most
00:12:46.920 --> 00:12:51.350
of what we would want to do would be self-serving and probably wrong We have
00:12:51.350 --> 00:12:55.151
now done everything we can in 250 years to prove them right,
00:12:55.947 --> 00:12:59.964
But therefore they made it hard they made it hard to do things and.
00:13:01.149 --> 00:13:04.750
One of the things that I think is really important to remember right now And
00:13:04.750 --> 00:13:10.578
I say this to my conservative friends all the time is be very careful about,
00:13:11.366 --> 00:13:13.909
the rule of the strong over the weak.
00:13:14.702 --> 00:13:20.420
Because the point of the United States was to level that field a bit.
00:13:21.029 --> 00:13:27.950
Not entirely in practice, but in principle, that it would not simply be the
00:13:27.950 --> 00:13:32.262
strong or those in office who would have ultimate power.
00:13:32.889 --> 00:13:36.395
It would be diffuse. There would be divided sovereignty.
00:13:37.322 --> 00:13:44.057
Not least because one thing that history tells us again and again is that if
00:13:44.057 --> 00:13:49.348
you're strong in this season, you're going to probably going to become weak in a different one.
00:13:49.795 --> 00:13:55.042
And the way to protect yourself is when you are strong, don't be a bully.
00:13:55.772 --> 00:13:58.267
Wield the strength within the
00:13:58.267 --> 00:14:04.350
spirit and the substance of the laws so that you don't set up a pendulum.
00:14:04.669 --> 00:14:09.070
Pendulums, when they swing this way, don't just stop here. They go like this.
00:14:09.737 --> 00:14:15.321
And part of the argument of the founders was, let's try to keep it here. Yeah.
00:14:16.745 --> 00:14:20.927
And so another turn of phrase about Jefferson you use that I love is that he
00:14:20.927 --> 00:14:23.421
was able to turn the ordinary sacred.
00:14:23.729 --> 00:14:26.037
Can you tell us that? So I love that.
00:14:27.589 --> 00:14:36.688
So Jefferson, for a man who claimed not to be religious, he was much more complicated in his views.
00:14:37.048 --> 00:14:39.649
He did decide that his desk was a relic.
00:14:41.297 --> 00:14:48.607
So he the desk on which he wrote at Jacob Graff's house on Market Street in
00:14:48.607 --> 00:14:55.436
Philadelphia, the desk on which he wrote the draft of the declaration, he later said, will now,
00:14:56.079 --> 00:15:03.067
come to be seen as a relic linked to this theological sociology of the founding.
00:15:03.746 --> 00:15:09.939
And it is scriptural, as Pauline Mayer wrote in her marvelous book, American Scripture.
00:15:10.534 --> 00:15:15.207
I've always read, parenthetically, so Pauline Mayer, as you know,
00:15:15.207 --> 00:15:19.006
did American Scripture and ratification.
00:15:19.813 --> 00:15:26.037
And I
was desperate for and made myself very annoying suggesting it,
00:15:26.637 --> 00:15:31.026
that she do secession, that the different states and why they did it.
00:15:32.337 --> 00:15:36.147
So somebody out there should do that. So take that for free and run with it.
00:15:39.238 --> 00:15:45.614
That sentence is scriptural. Our friend Walter Isonson's done a book called
00:15:45.614 --> 00:15:46.971
The Greatest Sentence Ever Written.
00:15:47.905 --> 00:15:53.774
I've sometimes referred to it as the most important sentence ever originally
00:15:53.774 --> 00:15:59.157
rendered in English because it gives us, it's an apple of gold.
00:16:00.146 --> 00:16:04.038
It gives us a principle. It gives us, and this is Lincoln again,
00:16:04.931 --> 00:16:11.564
who is, of course, the standard bearer of a party founded against essentially
00:16:11.564 --> 00:16:15.230
the party that Jefferson and Jackson had been leaders of.
00:16:16.233 --> 00:16:21.444
Lincoln said in 1959, all honor to Jefferson, to the man who in the midst of
00:16:21.444 --> 00:16:26.682
a revolutionary struggle had the coolness, forecast, and capacity,
00:16:27.246 --> 00:16:33.094
to enshrine in that document, a never failing truth. That's a slight paraphrase.
00:16:33.901 --> 00:16:39.524
But this is not. So that it will be forever a stumbling block to reappearing
00:16:39.524 --> 00:16:40.848
tyranny and oppression.
00:16:42.124 --> 00:16:47.151
And, you know, if that's what Abraham Lincoln thinks about it, I'm signing on.
00:16:48.509 --> 00:16:53.619
Yes. Now, before I give you back to Ryan for audience questions in a few minutes,
00:16:53.834 --> 00:16:57.144
just want to know in what ways we can chart our national progress through the
00:16:57.144 --> 00:16:58.974
understanding of these documents.
00:16:59.734 --> 00:17:03.056
Well, that's it. You answered your own question, which is great.
00:17:03.434 --> 00:17:08.324
I think that's how we do it. I think that every generation can be and should
00:17:08.324 --> 00:17:15.024
be judged by the degree to which we live into that sentence and the degree to
00:17:15.024 --> 00:17:16.158
which we fall away from it.
00:17:17.192 --> 00:17:23.553
I'm a Southerner. I was born after the height of the freedom struggle of the post-war era.
00:17:24.270 --> 00:17:32.240
But what happened in 1965 on the Edmund Pettus Bridge is in its way as important
00:17:32.240 --> 00:17:33.816
as Lexington and Concord,
00:17:34.482 --> 00:17:40.350
which of course is what Lyndon Johnson, reading that great speech that Richard Goodwin wrote, said.
00:17:41.063 --> 00:17:45.110
There are moments when at Lexington and Concord, Appomattox and Selma,
00:17:45.110 --> 00:17:51.287
Alabama, where history and fate meet and form a turning point in man's unending search for freedom.
00:17:53.970 --> 00:18:00.620
And that's, you know, it's, it is because we voluntarily, right?
00:18:00.620 --> 00:18:03.400
This was not just a press release, right?
00:18:03.643
--> 00:18:08.240
It was, if it had just been a press release, I mean, some people,
00:18:08.240 --> 00:18:11.551
I think Adams sort of thought it was going to be that, which is why he didn't want to write it.
00:18:12.790 --> 00:18:17.720
And that's not fair. That's complicated. I know what the complicated reasons
00:18:17.720 --> 00:18:19.352
are about Massachusetts and Virginia.
00:18:21.007 --> 00:18:25.890
Nobody yell at me about that. But I do like Jefferson. Adams is great.
00:18:26.410 --> 00:18:30.769
Jefferson ran away with the glory of it. There wasn't anything original about this idea.
00:18:31.326 --> 00:18:37.280
And that's great, right? I think Adams was doing it to kind of throw some shade,
00:18:37.280 --> 00:18:40.407
as the kids would say, if they still say that, on Jefferson.
00:18:40.639 --> 00:18:45.974
But what it really was, by saying what I take from Adams' remark,
00:18:46.607 --> 00:18:55.480
is that if this was the ambient atmosphere, then in fact, we were doing something
00:18:55.480 --> 00:18:57.346
not simply to protect our property.
00:18:57.880 --> 00:19:00.318
Charles Beer, you know, to the contrary.
00:19:01.618 --> 00:19:10.100
You know, that there was an intellectual and philosophical impetus behind this.
00:19:10.343 --> 00:19:14.545
Now, we'll debate this forever, and we should.
00:19:15.260 --> 00:19:21.056
History, it drives me a little crazy when certain political figures say,
00:19:21.516 --> 00:19:25.284
you know, we don't want history to be so argumentative or controversial.
00:19:25.557 --> 00:19:27.916
Well, what on earth do you think history is?
00:19:28.516 --> 00:19:32.506
Be out of a job, that's true. Right. It's just, it's, you know,
00:19:32.506 --> 00:19:34.767
it's not, it's not a fable.
00:19:35.404 --> 00:19:38.531
It's not, you know, quick bedtime story.
00:19:39.257 --> 00:19:42.298
It's the story of struggle.
00:19:43.089 --> 00:19:48.516
And what these documents remind us is that at our best, we have struggled in
00:19:48.516 --> 00:19:51.773
the service of a vital idea.
00:19:52.260 --> 00:19:56.846
Yeah. Is there a part of the document that speaks to you the most or maybe a
00:19:56.846 --> 00:20:00.927
lesser known part that really moved you that sort of might have surprised you?
00:20:01.618 --> 00:20:03.487
Of the declaration? Yes. Yeah.
00:20:05.593 --> 00:20:11.181
I think Jefferson's sense of a moment interested me.
00:20:11.478 --> 00:20:16.936
I trained as a journalist, so I sort of I sort of feel why he was doing it.
00:20:16.976 --> 00:20:21.616
And, you know, when he talks about how we're trying to take our stand among
00:20:21.616 --> 00:20:25.454
the powers of the earth, our place among the powers of the earth,
00:20:26.125 --> 00:20:31.646
and he was – what I love about that is he wasn't just –.
00:20:33.754 --> 00:20:38.184
Writing for the heart. He was writing for the heart, he was writing for the
00:20:38.184 --> 00:20:41.391
head, and he was writing for the muscle.
00:20:42.314 --> 00:20:48.378
He needed to inspire people to want to shed blood for this idea.
00:20:49.055 --> 00:20:55.458
And I was struck anew by that. I think we tend to think of the inspirational
00:20:55.777 --> 00:21:02.952
men-to-arms sort of ethos, really more from Thomas Paine from earlier in the year, common sense.
00:21:03.534 --> 00:21:09.529
But Jefferson is on that, right? He's saying there is a national pride here.
00:21:09.744 --> 00:21:11.727
I do want to say one thing, if I may.
00:21:13.060 --> 00:21:19.074
I'm currently obsessed with this idea, and I offer it to everybody to fight about it,
00:21:20.269 --> 00:21:23.456
that there's a difference between nationalism and patriotism,
00:21:24.155 --> 00:21:28.307
and that nationalism is very oiling a lot of stuff down.
00:21:28.626 --> 00:21:34.589
But nationalism, roughly put, is an allegiance to our own kind,
00:21:35.234 --> 00:21:39.476
to people who look like us, already believe like us, blood and soil.
00:21:41.060 --> 00:21:48.304
Patriotism is different. Patriotism is rooted in the ascent to an idea.
00:21:48.867 --> 00:21:53.059
And it doesn't matter where you came from or what you look like.
00:21:53.838 --> 00:22:02.128
If you confess the same creed, you become a fully empowered member of the congregation.
00:22:02.703 --> 00:22:08.251
I'm back on theology. Sorry. It's Sunday. It's Sunday. Exactly. Perfect. There you go.
00:22:09.002 --> 00:22:13.345
And I think that's I think we're in a nationalist moment. And I think part of
00:22:13.345 --> 00:22:15.475
the answer is a patriotic reply.
00:22:16.446 --> 00:22:20.445
Oh, that's beautiful. And just ask before I pass you to Ryan,
00:22:20.445 --> 00:22:24.075
what's next? What are you working on currently? I am deep, deep,
00:22:24.075 --> 00:22:26.249
deep in a life of Eisenhower.
00:22:26.627 --> 00:22:34.045
And when I say deep, I mean, there are trees that have not been born yet that
00:22:34.045 --> 00:22:38.425
may have to give their lives for the it's very long.
00:22:38.425 --> 00:22:43.531
I mean, I'm at that point in the process where I've written everything I know,
00:22:44.182 --> 00:22:48.879
and it's it's it's not very good yet, but we're working on it.
00:22:49.117 --> 00:22:53.137
So chugging away at that. I'm doing it because.
00:22:54.546 --> 00:23:03.413
I think that one way to consider 1932 to 2017 in American life is that we had
00:23:03.413 --> 00:23:09.461
a kind of figurative debate between FDR and Reagan, those rough positions,
00:23:10.130 --> 00:23:14.370
and every American president basically governed on that spectrum.
00:23:16.016 --> 00:23:21.163
Without Eisenhower, you don't have that consensus. I don't think the consensus
00:23:21.163 --> 00:23:25.844
leading into our current moment was a liberal one or a conservative one.
00:23:26.204 --> 00:23:35.094
I think it was this constitutionally based give and take along a fairly accepted range of options.
00:23:35.793 --> 00:23:42.683
And
without Eisenhower winning in 1952 and deciding that he was not going to
00:23:42.683 --> 00:23:49.464
uproot Social Security and a good bit of what had come in the new and fair deals,
00:23:51.072 --> 00:23:52.918
and if he had not supported NATO.
00:23:54.923 --> 00:24:00.033
I think we would not have been able to project the kind of force we projected
00:24:00.033 --> 00:24:03.731
in the 50s and 60s on behalf of liberty abroad.
00:24:04.323 --> 00:24:13.835
And I think that, you know, this man from Abilene, who wasn't famous until he was 50, 52,
00:24:14.531 --> 00:24:19.686
is this extraordinary figure standing at the center of the American century,
00:24:20.011 --> 00:24:21.886
at the center of the American experience.
00:24:22.147 --> 00:24:27.442
And he hated, hated extremism, hated it, believed it, believed,
00:24:27.697 --> 00:24:30.054
partly because of his own, you're going to be sorry you asked this,
00:24:30.362 --> 00:24:34.146
partly because of his own personality. Now, he had a terrible temper.
00:24:34.588 --> 00:24:39.673
You would not have wanted to work for him. He had these veins in his head that
00:24:39.673 --> 00:24:42.233
would bulge, you know, and he got mad all the time.
00:24:43.195 --> 00:24:47.946
But he knew he had to control it. And I think he projected that,
00:24:48.751 --> 00:24:52.152
that everybody wants to just throw a temper tantrum.
00:24:52.832 --> 00:24:58.451
And what a mature person and what a mature country do is they don't.
00:24:59.261 --> 00:25:03.322
Well, we look forward to welcoming you on that book. It'll be a long time.
00:25:04.922 --> 00:25:06.022
I'll be dead and you'll be.
00:25:08.402 --> 00:25:12.102
I have faith. And with that, I'm going to pass you over to Ryan. Yes.
00:25:13.008 --> 00:25:16.322
Thank you so much, Gina, for that awesome back and forth Okay,
00:25:16.322 --> 00:25:19.160
this is your opportunity Can we go ahead and tell everyone what you're really doing?
00:25:20.362 --> 00:25:26.372
Sure He's watching football Well, I do have the Giants and Saints game in the
00:25:26.372 --> 00:25:27.879
background I just want to be clear,
00:25:28.662 --> 00:25:34.562
He's really paying a lot of attention to our Estonian philosophy 14-13 for Giants
00:25:34.562 --> 00:25:35.936
fans out there One point lead,
00:25:36.742 --> 00:25:42.372
But to the founding era Which football wasn't invented just yet But so many questions.
00:25:42.372 --> 00:25:46.662
This is your opportunity to get your questions in for the great John Meacham.
00:25:46.662 --> 00:25:50.860
We always begin this part of the program with our History Scholar Question of the Week.
00:25:51.080 --> 00:25:54.612
And I just want to shout out that this is a weekly competition in which students
00:25:54.612 --> 00:25:57.973
have the opportunity to ask a question of our great guests.
00:25:58.176 --> 00:26:03.412
They can have their question read aloud, but also have an opportunity to win
00:26:03.412 --> 00:26:05.682
a $50 gift card to our gift shop.
00:26:05.682 --> 00:26:10.182
And this week we received over 100 questions, submissions. They were all outstanding.
00:26:10.182 --> 00:26:15.101
So our winner, D-Rong, I hope I'm saying that right. Really, that is a true honor.
00:26:15.403 --> 00:26:20.033
He attends Stuyvesant High School in Manhattan, not too far from me, maybe a Giants fan.
00:26:20.289 --> 00:26:24.632
And the question is this, what lessons from the founding era do you think are
00:26:24.632 --> 00:26:29.802
most relevant to today's debate over the balance, particularly between individual
00:26:29.802 --> 00:26:32.119
rights and collective responsibility?
00:26:33.114 --> 00:26:38.432
I can see why the question won. And again, I think as one of Gina's questions
00:26:38.432 --> 00:26:40.331
was, I think it kind of answers itself.
00:26:41.658 --> 00:26:48.308
The Constitution is a covenant. We are granted rights in exchange for responsibilities.
00:26:49.045 --> 00:26:59.236
And if you only focus on what you get out of a covenant, it ceases to be a covenant.
00:27:01.307 --> 00:27:03.199
Inherent in.
00:27:05.641 --> 00:27:10.163
A democratic republic like ours is that we have to be comfortable with.
00:27:11.240 --> 00:27:14.868
Giving as well as taking. And that's counterintuitive.
00:27:15.235 --> 00:27:19.410
Democracy is, I think, the most counterintuitive form of government you can
00:27:19.410 --> 00:27:22.955
imagine because it requires us,
00:27:23.647 --> 00:27:30.426
it requires me to want to pay taxes so that you can have a bridge in your neighborhood,
00:27:30.914 --> 00:27:34.234
to get over a river that I'll never cross over.
00:27:34.958 --> 00:27:39.808
And I do that because I figure that at some point I might need one too.
00:27:40.592 --> 00:27:49.325
And so I think the lesson for us is what does history tell us?
00:27:49.731 --> 00:27:56.570
What does the history of competing governmental structures tell us about what
00:27:56.570 --> 00:28:01.834
works and what doesn't for the greatest good for the greatest number?
00:28:02.508 --> 00:28:09.288
And do we still believe that a journey toward a more perfect union,
00:28:10.126 --> 00:28:18.453
is achieved by the degree to which we live into the declaration using the Constitution.
00:28:19.022 --> 00:28:21.058
And there are people who don't think so.
00:28:21.816 --> 00:28:25.630
And I hate the phrase both sides. I do everything I can to avoid it.
00:28:26.286 --> 00:28:32.030
But there are people, broadly put, on one side of the political...
00:28:32.030 --> 00:28:34.831
I'm not using right left anymore. I don't think that means anything.
00:28:35.690 --> 00:28:44.590
But on one side of the political spectrum, who believe the Constitution is not
00:28:44.590 --> 00:28:48.356
about patriotism, as I define it, but about nationalism,
00:28:49.027 --> 00:28:51.558
that is to protect Americans.
00:28:51.686 --> 00:28:55.260
And then you get into, well, who's an American? Well, an
American is someone
00:28:55.260 --> 00:29:00.080
born here, except maybe not because of the 14th Amendment debate,
00:29:00.080 --> 00:29:04.460
right? So, and then, but there are also folks who say, look,
00:29:04.460 --> 00:29:06.020
the Electoral College is crazy.
00:29:06.500 --> 00:29:12.613
The, you know, Article 2 is too strong. Article 1 needs to assert itself.
00:29:13.719 --> 00:29:21.956
And they're more in proximity to where, again, Wendell Phillips and William
00:29:21.956 --> 00:29:24.216
Lloyd Garrison were in the 19th century.
00:29:24.596 --> 00:29:32.128
And I'm where Frederick Douglass was, which is, this isn't perfect, but it's what we've got.
00:29:32.995 --> 00:29:39.816
I also believe firmly that what we're living through is not so much a constitutional
00:29:39.816 --> 00:29:41.693
crisis as a moral crisis.
00:29:42.496 --> 00:29:45.956
The Constitution is only as good as we are because we have to,
00:29:45.956 --> 00:29:50.116
again, we have to choose to obey laws. And.
00:29:52.148 --> 00:29:55.992
When people who have amassed temporary strength,
00:29:56.957 --> 00:30:02.906
ride over those laws for their own purposes, they are inviting chaos and putting
00:30:02.906 --> 00:30:09.796
an extraordinary burden on the next wave of the other team, what are they going to do?
00:30:10.589 --> 00:30:16.166
And to me, that's one of the great, as Donald Rumsfeld would say,
00:30:16.166 --> 00:30:21.611
known unknowns, is what does this look like in five to seven years?
00:30:22.345 --> 00:30:26.456
Absolutely. Well, fantastic question from our student and a great answer.
00:30:26.758 --> 00:30:30.656
Okay. So many questions. I'll try to get to as many as I can in the next 15
00:30:30.656 --> 00:30:32.836
minutes or so. Lightning round. Yes.
00:30:34.763 --> 00:30:38.876
Justine asks, how do you think Jefferson's personal contradictions,
00:30:38.876 --> 00:30:43.006
mainly owning slaves and his personal views on liberty of the people,
00:30:43.006 --> 00:30:48.226
kind of shape our modern interpretation of the Declaration of Independence, if it does at all?
00:30:48.226 --> 00:30:51.036
Sort of the contradictions within Jefferson, I guess, is the thrust.
00:30:51.036 --> 00:30:55.312
It's a great question. I wrote a biography of Jefferson. I always saw him as a.
00:30:56.666 --> 00:31:00.826
I tended to make sense of, not make sense of, but explain his contradictions,
00:31:01.360 --> 00:31:04.596
by seeing him as something that he didn't like to be seen as,
00:31:04.596 --> 00:31:07.013
but which I believe he was, which is a politician.
00:31:07.743 --> 00:31:12.006
Thomas Jefferson was desperate to be seen as a philosopher. He was a politician
00:31:12.006 --> 00:31:13.362
who wrote philosophically.
00:31:13.885 --> 00:31:17.796
For 40 years, he was either seeking office or holding office.
00:31:17.796 --> 00:31:19.713
There was one little period where he wasn't.
00:31:20.381 --> 00:31:25.055
And I believe, and I've written about Jefferson, I've written Scott Jackson,
00:31:25.758 --> 00:31:33.950
I believe his contradictions, his hypocrisies, his failings are representative of the countries.
00:31:34.635 --> 00:31:40.386
And I don't think that, and the questioner is not suggesting this,
00:31:40.386 --> 00:31:45.909
but I think sometimes people say, well, then, you know, let's remove this person from the conversation.
00:31:46.402 --> 00:31:51.702
I think that might make us feel better, but it lets the rest of us off the hook.
00:31:52.539 --> 00:32:00.491
Like, you know, Thomas Jefferson was not solely responsible for the evils of human enslavement.
00:32:01.518 --> 00:32:07.624
He could have done more to move in the right direction. He didn't.
00:32:08.408 --> 00:32:13.011
But as my colleague and our friend Annette Gordon-Reed likes to say is,
00:32:13.690 --> 00:32:16.134
all right, the guy wrote the Declaration of Independence.
00:32:16.425 --> 00:32:18.120
What more do you want from one person?
00:32:18.809 --> 00:32:21.009
Right. I mean, it's sort of...
00:32:22.116 --> 00:32:27.706
Again, not saying, therefore, he's beyond reproach.
00:32:27.706 --> 00:32:32.788
We have to reproach the past, but we have to reproach it, I believe,
00:32:33.663 --> 00:32:41.326
unselfrighteously, because I believe the moral utility of history is not to
00:32:41.326 --> 00:32:43.169
feel superior to the past,
00:32:44.010 --> 00:32:51.526
But to recognize that if even the best people of a given generation could fail
00:32:51.526 --> 00:32:58.280
so signally, as Jefferson did on slavery, as Jackson did on slavery and Native American removal,
00:32:59.322 --> 00:33:04.454
If the best of the past could get something so horribly wrong,
00:33:05.096 --> 00:33:06.210
what are we getting wrong?
00:33:06.942 --> 00:33:08.410
And let's project forward.
00:33:09.462 --> 00:33:13.101
Let's work backwards a little bit, right? How do we want to be seen?
00:33:13.737 --> 00:33:21.772
And let's act in a way that means that somebody doing this in 50 years will
00:33:21.772 --> 00:33:25.121
say of this generation, you know what? They got it right.
00:33:25.870 --> 00:33:29.326
Absolutely. Yes. Another question from Catherine.
00:33:29.523 --> 00:33:36.142
What advice might the founding fathers give on kind of the state of immigration over the past 50 years?
00:33:36.142 --> 00:33:40.392
This is something that's changed, you know, obviously, becoming increasingly
00:33:40.392 --> 00:33:43.962
politicized. What role did immigration have during the time of the founding
00:33:43.962 --> 00:33:47.372
era? You know, any insights or thoughts that you might have there from Catherine?
00:33:47.372 --> 00:33:48.792
It's a marvelous question.
00:33:49.007 --> 00:33:51.364
And they were, like all of us, all over the map.
00:33:52.702 --> 00:33:58.932
Right. They were, you know, Washington has a great quotation about we should
00:33:58.932 --> 00:34:01.571
welcome everyone into the bosom of the country.
00:34:02.301 --> 00:34:08.984
And then there are some Hamilton lines about restriction, even though he was an immigrant.
00:34:09.286 --> 00:34:17.282
The Alien and Sedition Act, obviously, of 1798, is a perennial source of political
00:34:17.282 --> 00:34:23.846
anxiety, policy strife, but I would argue of American strength, immigration.
00:34:24.199 --> 00:34:30.863
And it is absolutely the case, I think the 50-year number is now almost 60 years, exactly, that...
00:34:31.847 --> 00:34:37.982
I would argue, and this is one just to go to Thanksgiving and annoy people with,
00:34:38.571 --> 00:34:44.805
we're about to commemorate the 250th based on Philadelphia in 1776.
00:34:46.339 --> 00:34:53.432
What if we were really founded as a multiracial, multiethnic democracy 60 years ago?
00:34:54.166 --> 00:34:58.386
What if this is a country that actually, as the country we live in,
00:34:59.072 --> 00:35:01.847
did not really take political shape?
00:35:01.847 --> 00:35:11.413
The polity, the enfranchised polity that currently exists was not possible before 1965.
00:35:12.195 --> 00:35:15.731
And in that case, we are very much a developing democracy.
00:35:16.780 --> 00:35:20.428
Yes, absolutely. Great question and great answer, of course.
00:35:20.735 --> 00:35:25.857
Kimberly asked the question that's been kind of in our chat for a little bit.
00:35:25.857 --> 00:35:29.357
Other people have asked similar questions, so giving it to Kimberly,
00:35:29.357 --> 00:35:31.770
although others in the chat have asked something similar.
00:35:32.071 --> 00:35:35.430
Kimberly says, I'm a high school AP government teacher in Michigan.
00:35:36.899 --> 00:35:42.025
And I feel at times the overwhelming responsibility to do my job exceptionally well.
00:35:42.391 --> 00:35:46.267
Do you have any advice? If you were in my position, what would you be sure to
00:35:46.267 --> 00:35:48.196
do? Also, I love the soul of America.
00:35:48.457 --> 00:35:51.717
I've used so many classroom discussions based around fear versus hope,
00:35:51.717 --> 00:35:53.380
and thank you so much for appearing today.
00:35:53.641 --> 00:35:59.527
Oh, thank you. And thank you. I believe the reason I'm here is not just because
00:35:59.527 --> 00:36:03.794
Ryan is a persuasive guy, but I believe that.
00:36:05.012 --> 00:36:11.248
APUSH, APGUM. I believe you are the civics education in the country.
00:36:11.892 --> 00:36:16.867
My children, two out of three have taken all of it. One is in the middle of APUSH.
00:36:17.897 --> 00:36:23.882
One of the great, actually the only thing I've ever done that made my daughters
00:36:23.882 --> 00:36:30.232
impressed with me was they were making a promotional video for the high school
00:36:30.232 --> 00:36:32.396
prom a couple of years ago.
00:36:33.023 --> 00:36:37.290
And my daughter came to me and said, is there any chance, you know, Eric Foner?
00:36:37.952 --> 00:36:41.722
And I said, yeah. She said, we really would like him to say,
00:36:41.722 --> 00:36:44.092
send a video saying, enjoy the prom.
00:36:46.352 --> 00:36:52.668
So I called Eric and you, Eric has never done a video, but wonderfully he said,
00:36:53.480 --> 00:36:58.452
enjoy the prom, but don't forget your study of history. It was if you'd made
00:36:58.452 --> 00:37:00.690
it up, you got, you couldn't have scripted it better.
00:37:02.509 --> 00:37:09.356
Here's what I think, and I feel this obligation as well, teaching at Vanderbilt.
00:37:10.637 --> 00:37:19.789
I think if those of us who have made the study and contemplation of the past
00:37:19.789 --> 00:37:21.873
such a huge part of the work of our days,
00:37:22.668 --> 00:37:29.932
I think we can assume that we have a belief that the past is prologue.
00:37:30.777 --> 00:37:37.540
And I would say, in terms of keeping yourself going,
00:37:39.098 --> 00:37:43.121
is imagine, if I'm right about the 1965 thing,
00:37:44.166 --> 00:37:52.769
imagine all these generations of people who were teaching in a country that
00:37:52.769 --> 00:37:56.084
had huge illiberal elements.
00:37:56.906 --> 00:38:02.409
Again, thinking about the South, but elsewhere. And, you know.
00:38:05.975 --> 00:38:13.948
Without a conviction that we do have the capacity to get things right.
00:38:15.572 --> 00:38:19.912
I would probably have to do something else. And I base the fact that we have
00:38:19.912 --> 00:38:25.872
the capacity to get things right on the fact that we have barely gotten them right in the past.
00:38:26.796 --> 00:38:34.272
And so one of my favorite examples of this is I will sometimes ask in classrooms or in speeches,
00:38:34.947 --> 00:38:42.602
what is the thing that the United States did that is largely uncontroversial and immense?
00:38:42.602 --> 00:38:44.586
What is our greatest tower.
00:38:45.236 --> 00:38:48.649
And I think most people can agree that World War II was that.
00:38:49.642 --> 00:38:53.312
Tom Hanks once said that he kept making movies about World War II because it
00:38:53.312 --> 00:38:56.069
was good versus evil and Grandpa won.
00:38:56.992 --> 00:38:58.471
So it's this immense thing.
00:38:59.478 --> 00:39:05.897
But we didn't get into World War II until we were dragged into it kicking and screaming.
00:39:06.593 --> 00:39:13.461
And we didn't declare war on Germany until Germany declared war on us five days after Pearl Harbor.
00:39:13.757 --> 00:39:19.117
So the greatest thing we did, we did everything we could to screw up.
00:39:20.009 --> 00:39:30.565
And so I believe that that's, I believe that the tension there and yet the result is what gives me hope.
00:39:31.516 --> 00:39:34.052
And the other thing that gives me hope, again, I go back to John Lewis.
00:39:34.412 --> 00:39:41.045
I go back to those remarkable people who learned how to practice nonviolence,
00:39:41.812 --> 00:39:44.929
and insisted that the Declaration of Independence mattered.
00:39:45.760 --> 00:39:46.892
And so I think.
00:39:48.286 --> 00:39:53.600
I would say to teachers, what are the stories that got you into this?
00:39:54.267 --> 00:39:57.635
What are the stories that put you in this classroom?
00:39:58.496 --> 00:40:03.366
And how do you tell them? Because clearly they were so important to you that
00:40:03.366 --> 00:40:07.535
they have shaped the work of your days. This is what you do.
00:40:08.260 --> 00:40:11.046
And so in the same way, in a way that, you know, I went back and looked at the
00:40:11.046 --> 00:40:14.425
Declaration of Constitution. Go back and think about why are you doing this?
00:40:14.959 --> 00:40:16.428
Why are you teaching U.S. government?
00:40:17.354 --> 00:40:21.609
And draw strength and story from that.
00:40:22.539 --> 00:40:26.766
Absolutely. Okay, I'm going to try to get to one or two more questions.
00:40:26.766 --> 00:40:31.604
Jim says, can the declaration or what can the declaration and the founding documents
00:40:31.906 --> 00:40:36.696
and also those who wrote and drafted them teach us about some of the populist
00:40:36.696 --> 00:40:39.766
tendencies that seem to be ubiquitous in the U.S.
00:40:39.766 --> 00:40:42.090
Today? Would the founders have any thoughts on that?
00:40:42.705 --> 00:40:46.994
But the whole, the constitution was built to manage these things,
00:40:47.720 --> 00:40:49.531
right? They knew this was coming.
00:40:50.217 --> 00:40:53.706
I think they'd be surprised it took, it didn't take longer. Do you read the
00:40:53.706 --> 00:40:55.790
Federalist Papers? You know, that's what you got.
00:40:56.423 --> 00:41:00.283
I'll be brief because I've been going on and on. But the reason,
00:41:00.968 --> 00:41:03.592
populism was one of the reasons for the constitution.
00:41:04.284 --> 00:41:06.287
And so it is a.
00:41:07.389 --> 00:41:12.125
It's a literary rebuke to inordinate bashing.
00:41:13.154 --> 00:41:18.379
Yes, absolutely. Darla asks, who I have to say is a seventh grader,
00:41:18.379 --> 00:41:23.221
so I love getting our younger students on. It's a simple one.
00:41:23.645 --> 00:41:26.569
Darla is a seventh grader in Alabama. Yes.
00:41:27.609 --> 00:41:32.828
They beat Vanderbilt yesterday. Yeah, must be happy. It was a good Saturday.
00:41:33.238 --> 00:41:34.624
Although they're used to a lot of winning there.
00:41:35.256 --> 00:41:38.917
What is, it's a simple question, but a good one What's your personal favorite
00:41:39.101 --> 00:41:41.973
article piece from the Constitution and why?
00:41:42.798 --> 00:41:48.244
I, obviously, the great first paragraph that Jefferson wrote about in the course of human events.
00:41:49.335 --> 00:41:55.789
But I think that what Gouverneur Morris wrote The preamble to the Constitution Which says that,
00:41:56.589 --> 00:42:02.169
we are doing this in order to form a more perfect union And what I love about
00:42:02.169 --> 00:42:05.570
that is it doesn't say we're going to be perfect.
00:42:06.383 --> 00:42:08.177
It says we're just going to be more perfect.
00:42:09.117
--> 00:42:15.632
And I believe that that recognition of the possibility and yet the limitation,
00:42:16.260 --> 00:42:19.632
of what we can do should give us strength.
00:42:20.218 --> 00:42:28.497
Winston Churchill once said that the future is unknowable, but the past should give us hope.
00:42:29.379 --> 00:42:32.439
Future is unknowable, the past should give us hope. And the past should give
00:42:32.439 --> 00:42:39.722
us hope, I think, because the people who wrote the Constitution were not gods.
00:42:40.423 --> 00:42:47.099
They weren't even saints, right? They were politicians and planters and merchants,
00:42:47.616 --> 00:42:52.779
and they had good days and bad days, and they made history.
00:42:53.035 --> 00:42:56.988
We can, you, Darla, can make history. You don't have to be perfect.
00:42:57.831 --> 00:43:02.926
Your parents probably won't like it that I said that, but try to be perfect, but.
00:43:04.705 --> 00:43:10.717
And history should give us a sense of proportion. And the fact that at the end
00:43:10.717 --> 00:43:16.458
of the 18th century, this group of flawed and complicated people,
00:43:17.090 --> 00:43:20.867
created a system that has shaped the world that we're now talking about on what
00:43:20.867 --> 00:43:22.431
they could not have imagined,
00:43:23.239 --> 00:43:24.203
tells us that.
00:43:25.447 --> 00:43:27.244
Since we're flawed and imperfect.
00:43:28.072 --> 00:43:29.105
Maybe we can too.
00:43:29.897 --> 00:43:34.397
Absolutely. And perhaps accumulating question, final question for John.
00:43:34.397 --> 00:43:38.117
We do have to say goodbye to John after this, as everybody in our audience can
00:43:38.117 --> 00:43:41.495
imagine. He's very overcommitted today, and we appreciate so much his time.
00:43:41.693 --> 00:43:45.577
But stay on a little bit longer for some programming notes from Gina and I,
00:43:45.577 --> 00:43:47.609
but I think this is a good last question from John.
00:43:48.027 --> 00:43:52.647
Do you believe that education's de-emphasizing civics and citizenship in these
00:43:52.647 --> 00:43:58.527
documents has hindered the majority of Americans in their lives and added to
00:43:58.527 --> 00:44:02.817
some kind of malaise or indifference about these documents today?
00:44:02.817 --> 00:44:07.747
Sort of the de-emphasis of civics and citizenship being taught today from John. Yeah, absolutely.
00:44:08.127 --> 00:44:15.384
I think that citizenship, the art of citizenship is the air we should breathe. And it is hard.
00:44:15.656 --> 00:44:20.787
And I wouldn't want, oh my Lord, if someone asked me to draft a civics curriculum,
00:44:21.107 --> 00:44:25.831
I would run as far as possible, right? Because it would be so politicized.
00:44:26.261 --> 00:44:28.170
It's why we have to teach it through history.
00:44:28.849 --> 00:44:34.985
And it's why history teaches, why government, we have to tell these stories.
00:44:35.316 --> 00:44:40.192
And the way to do civics, I believe, is to show civics in action.
00:44:40.987 --> 00:44:47.007
And so, yes, I mean, the reason to shine a light on these documents,
00:44:47.007 --> 00:44:49.927
the reason to remind people about
00:44:49.927 --> 00:44:54.990
Jefferson and Madison and Hamilton and Douglas and Lincoln, you know.
00:44:56.479 --> 00:45:03.463
And the suffragists, the folks on the Pettus Bridge, you know.
00:45:05.007 --> 00:45:08.949
The heroic people whose names we don't know, male and female,
00:45:08.949 --> 00:45:12.135
of all colors and everything.
00:45:12.675 --> 00:45:17.787
The whole panoply of human experience is, I believe,
00:45:19.019 --> 00:45:27.839
the inspiration to do better while also providing the context to show that we
00:45:27.839 --> 00:45:33.024
probably won't get the best, but we can't let the perfect be the enemy of the good.
00:45:33.610 --> 00:45:39.096
And what history teachers do at their best, I believe that my teachers did,
00:45:39.753 --> 00:45:43.595
is they told a story that could have turned out the other way.
00:45:44.470 --> 00:45:48.997
And so can ours. And that's what we have to guard against and,
00:45:49.673 --> 00:45:51.984
on the other side of the coin, build toward.
00:45:52.689 --> 00:45:56.360
Absolutely. Well, I'm going to throw things back to Gina for some final thoughts
00:45:56.360 --> 00:45:57.890
and a look ahead to next week.
00:45:58.314 --> 00:46:03.660
John, thank you so much. We were breaking all types of questions from our audience.
00:46:03.660 --> 00:46:04.854
We so appreciate the time.
00:46:05.231 --> 00:46:08.070
And it was a pleasure. Again, thank you so much. I'm delighted.
00:46:08.070 --> 00:46:09.083
Thank you all for what you're doing.
00:46:09.714 --> 00:46:12.658
Thank you, John. Gina, over to you for some final thoughts and a look ahead to next week.
00:46:13.231 --> 00:46:16.594
Yes, thank you so much, John. It was such an honor having you.
00:46:16.890 --> 00:46:21.650
And if today's session piqued your interest about the Declaration of Independence,
00:46:21.650 --> 00:46:25.382
we have so much more programming coming up for the Declaration at 250.
00:46:25.637 --> 00:46:29.841
We have an upcoming workshop with our friend Manisha Sinha at the University of Connecticut.
00:46:30.108 --> 00:46:33.649
And all teachers who participate will receive a $50 stipend.
00:46:33.944 --> 00:46:38.640
And we have the annotated Declaration of Independence. And the Declaration Justifies
00:46:38.640 --> 00:46:42.900
Revolution, an interactive exhibit. it. And you can find these all at gilderlerman.org
00:46:42.900 --> 00:46:45.734
slash Declaration Independence right there.
00:46:46.124 --> 00:46:50.210
And we also want to let you know about our National Teacher of the Year,
00:46:50.210 --> 00:46:53.480
History Teacher of the Year award ceremony that's coming up.
00:46:53.480 --> 00:46:54.789
And everybody is welcome.
00:46:55.046 --> 00:47:00.340
If you're interested, you can email events at gilderlerman.org for more event
00:47:00.340 --> 00:47:03.450
information. But we would love to see you there. And it's always a great time
00:47:03.450 --> 00:47:05.907
to honor our favorite people, teachers.
00:47:06.220 --> 00:47:09.450
And we hope that you'll join us next week. We have Jared Cohen,
00:47:09.450 --> 00:47:14.305
the author of Life After Power, Seven Presidents and Their Search for Purpose Beyond the White House.
00:47:14.642 --> 00:47:18.050
And if you enjoyed today and you didn't get your question answered,
00:47:18.050 --> 00:47:21.585
a great remedy for that is to purchase the book at bookshop.org.
00:47:21.910 --> 00:47:26.114
And the affiliate commission we receive supports our programming for history teachers and students.
00:47:26.432 --> 00:47:32.240
And you can watch this and a presentation of over 250 other scholars at gilderlerman.org
00:47:32.240 --> 00:47:36.997
slash book breaks. And you can also go to our website for that deck 250 information,
00:47:37.171 --> 00:47:40.190
as well as the Hamilton education program and so much more.
00:47:40.625 --> 00:47:44.631
Ryan, always good to see you here. Thank you, everybody, for joining us.
00:47:44.961 --> 00:47:48.061
Have a great rest of your day. Thank you, everyone. Take care.
00:47:49.106 --> 00:47:52.436
Thank you for listening to Conversations with Great Historians,
00:47:52.436 --> 00:47:56.094
the podcast from the Gilder Lehrman Institute of American History.
00:47:56.745 --> 00:48:00.446
We hope today's conversation gave you a new perspective on the history of our
00:48:00.446 --> 00:48:05.120
country and sparked some ideas you can take with you, whether into the classroom,
00:48:05.358 --> 00:48:09.004
into your family conversations, or into the life of your community.
00:48:09.633 --> 00:48:13.006
To explore more conversations with leading historians, authors,
00:48:13.006 --> 00:48:18.081
and scholars, visit the Gilder Lehrman Institute at gilderlehrman.org.
00:48:18.800 --> 00:48:22.996
And be sure to subscribe wherever you listen to podcasts So you never miss a
00:48:22.996 --> 00:48:25.386
new episode Thanks again for joining
00:48:25.386 --> 00:48:29.737
us And we'll see you next time on Conversations with Great Historians.