رونوشت 🔗
Monopolies are Very Bad, Except Big Education – Part II
January 2020
I left off my previous podcast by noting that onetime presidential candidate Amy Klobuchar used the term “Big” Technology. If a Minnesota police officer, Derek Chauvin, had not been implicated in the death of African American George Floyd, touching off a series of protests throughout the United States, Klobuchar would have been the choice of Joe Biden as running mate. Additionally, given Biden’s precarious health, she could have been the first female president of the United States. As it stands, that notation will go to Kamala Harris. This missed opportunity partly explains why Klobuchar has been issuing especially virulent statements, including this gem about the Facebook antitrust suit. “Numerous reports have brought Facebook’s long history of anti-competitive behavior to light. The company’s acquisitions of Instagram and WhatsApp have made the social media landscape less competitive and worse for users. Big technology companies like Facebook should not have free reign to impose their will on the market, and they must be held accountable when they attempt to do so. I’m glad the FTC and state enforcers are taking action to stop Facebook’s anti-competitive behavior.”
Both sides of the aisle talk about the dangers and imminent threats posed by “Big Technology,” but imagine where we would be in this pandemic without it. No personal computing. No WiFi, Zoom, Online Search, Online information, or even the ability to communicate with friends over social media. Even allowing for the use of private data, the net benefits brought by Big Tech far outweigh the bad stuff.
Additionally, could a vaccine have been produced in less than a year, with all the necessary coordination, without Big Tech? I find making a case for the benefits of Big Tech easy. I would invite someone to argue that Big Education, in the form of public schools and unionized teachers, performs half so well. Yet where there has been an appetite to regulate, break up, and reorganize Big Tech, there is far less with Big Education.
There are three anti-competitive behavior areas that Klobuchar will not comment on, at least in the negative. One is those government-sanctioned monopolies, such as utilities, where real trusts can be found. One organization, Mission:Data, describes itself as “advocates for customer-friendly energy data access policies throughout the country to deliver benefits for consumers and enable an innovative, vibrant market for energy management services.” In an article posted in 2018 on the Mission Data website, author Michael Murry writes, “Looking at the railroads or telecommunication industries throughout history; regulated monopolies have rarely, if ever, adapted to new conditions. Electric utilities will tend to exert their power over anything that touches the electricity system, whether that serves the public interest or not.”
Two, the more highly regulated industries such as steel, automobiles, and airlines, is where the United States has fallen behind. In my previous podcast, I noted that in technology, where the United States is still a recognized leader, the antitrust crusaders spend much of their time. It is as though they wish to do to those industries what has been to the older ones where the United States is now a laggard.
Writing for The Hill in 2017, Jonathan Hauenschild states, “Regulations have unintended consequences. Occasionally, those consequences arise from a regulatory agency not understanding technology or the agency’s structure as defined by Congress. Agencies created in the 1930s, 1950s, or similar decades were created long before the technologies they seek to regulate today were developed. Many regulatory agencies are ill-suited to regulate technology. Their approaches are steeped in bureaucratic history and based on laws that could not anticipate technological advances. Innovation looks to the future, and more often than not, disrupts existing interests. As governments, federal and state, wrestle with regulating disruptive technologies,”
A report from the Heritage Foundation found that “Unnecessary and inefficient regulation at the federal, state and local levels now costs the American people somewhere between $810 billion and $1.7 trillion per year -- even after taking account of the benefits of regulation -- or between $8,400 and $17,100 per year per household.” This is the type of regulation that the antitrust laws would put on Microsoft, but today on Facebook.
Three there is one overriding monopoly that affects nearly every American that no government entity wishes to touch, Big Education. There are currently 53 million students enrolled in K through 12 education; 94% are in public education. Writing in 2006 for the Center for Education Reform, author Michael J. O’Neal penned a piece called “Teachers’ Unions as Monopoly.” In this piece, O’Neal notes, “the teachers’ union cartel is a larcenous monopoly. Now, like nineteenth-century robber barons, they’re compounding their larceny by trying to enlist the state to force consumers of their product to fund their monopoly.” His comparison is not quite apples to apples. At its peak, Standard Oil controlled 90% of refining capacity in the United States, but that figure was down to 64% by the 1911 breakup of the company. We can only wish that 36% of American students were enrolled in private education.
O’Neal goes onto to write about one of the many areas where public teacher’s union use both their considerable financial might and the coercive power of government to crush a potential rival; charter schools, “For years the teachers’ unions have sustained a PR campaign that should be the envy of corporate CEOs everywhere. Take the issue of charter schools. Charters expose the cost bloat and inefficiency of the typical school system by doing a better job for about a third less money. They do so primarily by reining in administrative costs,
Load full transcript
in contrast to school systems generally. In 1960 American public schools limped along with one administrator for every 13.6 students; by 2002, they needed one for every 8.1 students. The unions, predictably, maintain ongoing jihad against charters, wanting the public to believe they siphon money away from “real” public schools—though maybe it’s the “real” schools that are siphoning money away from charters and other alternatives that would provide taxpayers and kids better results for less money. Yet in 2005, the National Education Association, the nation’s largest teachers union, donated $500,000 to a Washington State anti-charter group called Protect Our Public Schools—an Orwellian name, given that charters are public schools.”
Milton Friedman also understood the nature of Big Education’s stranglehold on the schools, especially judging whether one teacher or one school is superior to another. Writing in 1983, Friedman states, “Someone must judge merit, determine who is meritorious and who not, and by how much the one is more meritorious than the other. In a competitive market economy, consumers render that judgment. Every private school must satisfy its customers — parents paying tuition and benefactors who contribute funds to the school. Every private school now pays its teachers according to their merit. If it did not, its “better” teachers would be hired away by its competitors, and it would be left with the poorer ones. Its customers would sooner or later discover what is happening and desert it. The situation is wholly different with a socialist enterprise like the public school system, or, for that matter, a private monopoly. The true customers of the public schools — parents and children — have come to exercise less and less influence over the schools as the schools have become more and more centralized and bureaucratic. When school districts were numerous and small, parents could exercise considerable influence. A superintendent or principal who misjudged the “merit” of teachers — in the eyes of consumers — would not have remained in these positions for long. The situation has changed drastically in the past half-century. The number of school districts declined from 130,000 to 16,000.” Friedman’s view, expressed 39 years ago, has only gotten worse.
The National Right to Work Committee states, “In a recent policy analysis for the Washington, D.C.-based Cato Institute, University of Texas (UT) economist Stan Liebowitz and UT research fellow Matthew Kelly quantitatively demonstrate that union monopolists make schools less effective and more costly.”
One of the favorite tactics of trustbusters ranging from Ida Tarbell and her war on Standard Oil to Klobuchar is to assign a villain. For Tarbell, it was Standard Oil founder John D. Rockefeller, “John D. Rockefeller didn’t care about anyone. He did anything to be rich and be the only company standing without any competition. He destroyed anyone else.” This was not the stuff of a sober
and objective assessment of monopoly. For Tarbell, whose father’s business lost in competition with Standard, it was always personal. And given her vitriol, the reticent Rockefeller provided an excellent target.
This is a pattern with these antitrust suits. In the case against Microsoft, Bill Gates was portrayed as the villain. In a piece in The Ringer, it is noted that “On the first day of the trial, famed lead prosecutor David Boies made a videotaped deposition of Bill Gates the centerpiece of his opening arguments.” In a piece in Wired Magazine penned by John Heilman, the writer states, “The slavish fealty accorded Gates at Microsoft draws gales of derision from critics and competitors. Netscape’s former counsel, Roberta Katz, says it was the “blind obedience, the willingness to suspend all judgment and follow the party line, all this zombielike devotion to the Maximum Leader” that led Microsoft inexorably to its fate in the courts.”
Regarding the Facebook antitrust suit, the government was handed a villain on a silver platter ten years ago when The Social Network was released. There was also a movie called Antitrust in Gates’s case, but the Gatesean character is called Gary Winston is fiction, and Winston is not even the star. Not so with The Social Network. The movie portrays the beginning of Facebook, and Jesse Eisenberg, who plays real life Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg, is described by the great movie reviewer Roger Ebert in the following passage, “Erica gets fed up, calls him (Zuckerberg) an asshole and walks out. Erica is right.”
Writing for the Washington Post about the real-life Zuckerberg, Technology writers Craig Timberg and Drew Harwell go even further than the movie’s devious character.
In their description, Zuckerberg goes from infuriating to terrifying, “In calling for the breakup of his $800 billion company, federal and state officials portray a Zuckerberg who could more easily star in a Silicon Valley update to “The Godfather.” Rivals cower at the thought of “the wrath of Mark” as he schemes to “eliminate” competitors, who face being “snuffed out” if they defy him, according to the 123-page complaint from state officials. One anecdote central to the cases depicts Instagram co-founder Kevin Systrom seeking advice from a company investor while considering a $1 billion offer to sell his company to Facebook in 2012: “Will he go into destroy mode if I say no?” The answer: “Probably.” Systrom soon decided to sell, making an offer that, in the telling of the state and federal officials, he couldn’t really refuse.” Forget Vito Corleone or Tony Soprano whacking some mob rat; the real victim of a mafia don is the guy looking to get a billion dollars from some Don Zuckerberg. Where can I go to run afoul of this guy?
Are these portrayals of Rockefeller, Gates, and Zuckerberg accurate? Almost certainly not, but antitrust is about politics, and in this milieu, optics matter. Optics matter in the perpetual monopoly maintained over education by a host of interested parties, but most of all by the two uber-powerful teacher’s unions; the National Education Association and the American Federation of Teachers. The NEA and AFT are beyond cunning because, aside from lobbying, their presidents often maintain a low profile. Quick, who is Becky Pringle? No, she is not an heiress to a potato chip fortune. Whereas 5 of 10 Americans can name Bill Gates, not one hundred outside teachers would know who she is. Of course, she has not been on the job that long because the NEA cleverly rotates leaders. Not so with the American Federation of Teachers. Randi Weingarten has been the leader of this union for twelve years. But could two out of ten Americans identify her?
There are two unions with overlapping missions that make it hard to pin down our mediocrity in education on one overall organization. With more than 1.7 million members, affiliated with the AFL-CIO (American Federation of Labor and Congress of Industrial Organizations) and having 43 state and 3,000 state affiliates, the AFT (American Federation of Teachers) is a union organization representing classroom teachers. The NEA has approximately 3 million members, headquartered in Washington D.C., and has affiliates in every state. More than 14,000 local affiliates, The National Education Association’s history dates back to 1857. Historically, one of the NEA’s primary goals has been to nationalize the American school system. In the 1960s, school directors, officers, and university professors predominantly carried out the NEA’s work. These leaders would take the discussed proposals to their respective local communities for possible implementation. Requests were mostly concentrated on collective bargaining for teachers’ rights protection and lobbying for educational issues.
Note NEA’s 14,000 local affiliates. Another clever design. This decentralized structure means that the organization’s face is not the bureaucrats in Washington but a local teacher. Consider Becky Pringle’s description. Becky (note the use of a first name, which is considered misogynistic in some circles but is just fine here) is a middle school science teacher with 31 years of classroom experience.
And this is what is insidious. There is always that teacher who reached out and made a positive impact on your child. The one who became a model and mentor to that child and that teacher is an NEA member. Because of their positions within our children’s lives, teachers are often right outside the orbit of the family in terms of meaningful relationships. It is one thing to blame Zuckerberg for your privacy being monetized or Rockefeller because your business was ruined, but how can one blame the NEA when Mrs. Jones, the best teacher your child ever had, was a member. Yet play a simple word game. Count how many teachers your child encountered over their 12-year span in public education, then divide the number by truly exceptional and impactful teachers. Assume
an average of one teacher for grades one through five and five for grades 6-12. Add in some specialists in music, PE, and drama. That is around 40 teachers throughout non-secondary education. Now how many fit into that particular category? Was it 10? Was it 5? Less? If the number is less than 15, the numbers bear out the prevailing mediocrity of too many teachers.
According to the left-wing magazine, The Atlantic, in a 2013 article written by Julia Ryan, “The U.S. education system is mediocre compared to the rest of the world, according to an international ranking of OECD countries. More than half a million 15-year-olds around the world took the Program for International Student Assessment in 2012. The test, which is administered every three years and focuses largely on math, but includes minor sections in science and reading, is often used as a snapshot of the global state of education. The results, published today, show the U.S. trailing behind educational powerhouses like Korea and Finland. Not much had changed since 2000 when the U.S. scored along with the OECD average in every subject: This year, the U.S. scores below average in math and ranks 17th among the 34 OECD countries. It scores close to the OECD average in science and reading and ranks 21st in science and 17th in reading.”
The NEA and AFT will tell you that it is money or the lack thereof that is the problem. “The only way to make sure all learners have the tools and schools they need to succeed is to properly fund every aspect of public education.” Every Aspect? The U.S. ranks fifth in spending per student. Only Austria, Luxembourg, Norway, and Switzerland spend more. The United States spends far more per student than Japan, China, South Korea, and the United Kingdom, which all did better on international tests.
The next explanation is that U.S. tests are brought down by the disadvantaged, such as African American minorities. If this is the case, why do District of Columbia students, which are primarily African Americans, and where the average spend per student is $22,000, $9,000 higher than the U.S. average and $12,000 higher than the global average, fare so poorly? In a 2019 article in the NPR about D.C. schools, writer Debbie Truong notes, “just 37% of D.C. students were prepared for college English, and only 31% were prepared for college math in the 2018-2019 school year.”
In 1960, annual spending on public education nationwide was about $3,000 per student. In the years since 1960, that amount has swollen to over $9,400 per student. Those are inflation-adjusted dollars, so spending on public education in real terms has more than tripled, with dubious results.
Per the paper by Liebowitz and Kelly, the work states, “no significant relationship is found between spending and student performance, either in magnitude or statistical significance. This does not necessarily imply that spending overall does not affect outcomes (assuming causality), but merely that most states have reached a sufficient level of spending such that additional spending does not appear to be related to achievement as measured by these test scores.”
Teachers earn extra money in two different ways. The first is through seniority, and the second is through achieving certifications.
This is the synergy between education colleges (the same ones that “Dr.” Jill Biden works at) and teachers. Teachers take classes and spend money on these colleges to obtain degrees. The colleges offer easy (I have taken some of these classes, elementary) courses and generous grading to fashion the degrees that boost teacher pay. The one thing you will not see is a better teacher getting more money through merit pay. If a principle could decide which salaries would negate the union’s power to dictate wage scale and drive collective bargaining, which is one of the reasons that unions fight merit pay, and by extension Charter schools, so vigorously.
Another consistent argument from the unions is that smaller class sizes equate to more excellent student performance. Again, Kelly and Liebowitz, “Though having more students per teacher are theorized to be negatively related to student performance, the empirical literature largely fails to find consistent effects of student-teacher ratios and class size on student performance.” What is certain is that to achieve smaller class sizes, school districts would have to hire more teachers, which equates to more union dues and greater union power.
The authors finalize their thoughts with the following, “Certain southern and western states, such as Florida and Texas, have much better student performances than appears to be the case when student heterogeneity is not taken into account. Other states, such as Maine and Rhode Island in New England, fall substantially. These results run counter to the conventional wisdom that the best education is found in northern and eastern states with powerful unions and high expenditures.”
The stated primary focus of the unions is on the students, or so they say, “All students deserve schools with the resources, programs, and curriculum to nurture their curiosity, imagination, spirit, talents, and desire to learn.” Yet make one or two clicks, and the real story emerges, “Our schools have a qualified, caring, diverse, and stable workforce. Safe and affirming schools are a core element of student success. When students feel that they are not welcome, their ability to learn and thrive is diminished. We can create schools where every student can learn, regardless of their skin color, religion, sexual orientation, gender identity, or ability.” This is where teachers focused. Per Pringle, her description leads with her being a teacher, which then serves as a shield against this descriptor, “distinguished herself as a fierce social justice warrior and defender of educator rights.” The leader of 3 million teachers is self-described as part of the SJW crowd. Of course, none of that
ideology would ever permeate the classroom, except the one she maintained. And what, exactly, is educator “rights.” “An education is a civil right, and any child who does not feel safe coming to school is being denied their civil right. We are working tirelessly to dismantle systems of oppression that prevent children from accessing a great public education because of their race, gender, sexual orientation, culture, or nationality.”
Note how little discussion on the core NEA web site talks about reading, writing, math, science, or physical education. Instead, it is all ideology. It would be hard to swap a civil rights website such as Black Lives Matter for this page.
It is not that many of these things are unnecessary, but rather with the public unions, this is just one of three things that REALLY matter; social justice wars, more money per teacher, and more teachers. They talk of the students but focus on other things. If nothing else made their real priorities more transparent, it was the COVID Pandemic. Writing in the Wall Street Journal, author David R Henderson notes, “If you have school-age children, you may be wondering if they’ll ever get an education. On Tuesday the American Federation of Teachers, the second-largest education union, threatened “safety strikes” if reopening plans aren’t to its liking. Some state and local governments are insisting that public K-12 schooling this fall be conducted online three to five days a week and imposing stringent conditions on those students who make it to the classroom.” The Federalist’s John Daniel Davidson adds, “Then there are teachers unions. More than any other group during this pandemic, teachers’ unions have shown themselves to be abjectly selfish, hyper-political, and intransigent about teaching during the pandemic. They are willing to lie about the science behind COVID-19 transmission and shamelessly stoke fear to advance their partisan agenda. Just about the last thing these unions seem to care about is educating children or helping the country get back on its feet.”
So given their monopolistic power, what is to be done? There are two simple solutions. First, provide each parent with a voucher for students and enable them to choose their school.
This would force actual competition (the same thing that the FTC continues to espouse) beyond zip codes. Initially, there would be confusion as parents opt for better-performing schools. But this would force the lesser schools to compete for the students by trying real reform, including hiring better teachers.
This works exceptionally well during the pandemic. Davidson notes, “issue vouchers to families and let them decide how best to educate their children this fall. Specifically, they could create education savings accounts, which give parents a savings account dedicated to their kids’ education. The state deposits the child’s public education dollars into the account, and parents can use it for various things like online classes, a private tutor, private school tuition, whatever. Especially during the pandemic, it’s a handy way to help people fit their child’s education to specific local circumstances.”
The second reform is to enable principles to have the same hiring and firing power similar to that in the private sector. Good teachers in, bad teachers out, and having once been a teacher, I guarantee that the principles know the wheat and the chafe. These seem like such simple reforms, but both would destroy the power of the unions.
Additionally, teachers like the unions’ protection and the simple fact that an organization’s size can make or break local politicians who may try to attempt these reforms. Consider California and this gem from the CalSTRS website, “You can retire at age 55 with at least five years of service credit. Members under CalSTRS 2% at 60 also have the option to retire at age 50 with at least 30 years of service credit.” So, a teacher who retires at 50, after 30 years of service, and lives to the average age of 81, will have been retired longer than they worked. That is why reform will not begin with the teachers.
There are two primary impediments to these reforms. The obvious is the leviathan that is Big Education. The second is the parents themselves. My mother, a sagacious woman, once said that “parents are not rational about their children.” People want choices with cars, houses, and (yes, Senator Warren) in healthcare. But as noted above, parents are just not that rational when coming to education. The simple solution is (for those who can afford it) to move to a better district. Those who cannot merely endure the monopoly because they have a misplaced adoration of the few teachers who have made a positive difference in their children’s lives. It is time for American parents to sober up and look at education as they do everything else. Is a choice of schools better? Is a monopoly the best use of their hard-earned tax dollars? Does an excellent teacher do better with 25 or 30 kids than a mediocrity does with 20?
When Ida Tarbell began writing her biased, damning portraits of Standard Oil in 1904, it was only seven years later that the company was broken up. In 1977 Senator Daniel Patrick Moynihan stated, “Our private schools embody these values. They provide diversity to the society, choices to students and their parents, and a rich array of distinctive educational offerings that even the finest of public institutions may find difficult to supply, not least because they are public and must embody generalized values. There is something larger involved here. It is time liberalism redefined its purposes in the area of education. State monopoly is no more appropriate to liberal beliefin this field than in any other.”
Forty-three years later, our education system falls further behind, and the public union monopoly is more powerful than ever.