رونوشت 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:00.172 --> 00:00:08.896
Local climate leadership is really about driving the community action and not just leading by example.
00:00:09.429 --> 00:00:20.643
Because we've spent the last 25 years leading by example, and if that hasn't trickled into your community, then you're not really leading, you're just giving an example, right?
00:00:20.647 --> 00:00:29.902
So the leading has to be where the local government recognises and leverages its role as a catalyst to drive community action
00:00:40.203 --> 00:00:51.902
A council can reduce emissions from its own operations and still miss its climate targets if households and businesses aren't making the changes needed across the wider community.
00:00:52.832 --> 00:01:04.927
Good morning, good afternoon, or good evening, where everywhere in the world, this is Climate Confident Stories and Strategies that Cut Emissions Episode 303, and I'm your host, Tom Raftery.
00:01:06.006 --> 00:01:11.192
My guest today is Kim Lundgren, founder and CEO of Kim Lundgren Associates.
00:01:11.673 --> 00:01:19.983
She works with local governments on the difficult part of climate action, turning plans into decisions that actually reduce emissions.
00:01:20.703 --> 00:01:35.972
We explore how targeted outreach can encourage heat pump adoption, what a threefold increase in rebate participation really tells us and why the people responsible for delivering climate plans often lack the authority to make them happen.
00:01:36.912 --> 00:01:38.621
Kim, welcome to the podcast.
00:01:38.652 --> 00:01:40.121
Would you like to introduce yourself?
00:01:40.796 --> 00:01:41.106
Sure.
00:01:41.125 --> 00:01:41.817
Thanks, Tom.
00:01:41.819 --> 00:01:43.021
I appreciate you having me.
00:01:43.036 --> 00:01:44.100
My name's Kim Lundgren.
00:01:44.121 --> 00:01:53.975
I'm the founder and CEO of Kim Lundgren Associates, also known as KLA, and we partner with local governments to take action on the climate crisis
00:01:55.040 --> 00:01:59.659
Nice, and what drew you to local government as a place to do climate work?
00:02:01.045 --> 00:02:02.061
It's interesting.
00:02:02.081 --> 00:02:06.679
I really just got a job there in the early days.
00:02:06.798 --> 00:02:12.673
So I'd studied environmental science as an undergrad, decided to go back to graduate school.
00:02:12.699 --> 00:02:20.641
And as a environmental scientist, I had started working in hazardous waste, 'cause this was, like, the late '90s, early 2000s.
00:02:20.646 --> 00:02:23.717
And so I was doing that, and I really did not enjoy it.
00:02:24.467 --> 00:02:41.980
It was kind of, not satisfying, mostly because I was early in the process, and so, wow, I'd do all this assessment and soil sampling and water sampling and you're like, "Wow, this site's contaminated." And then, "Oh, okay, now I just hand it off and hope somebody's doing something about it." So that didn't really align well with who I am.
00:02:41.981 --> 00:02:44.478
I'm not the person who finds a problem and hands it off.
00:02:44.478 --> 00:02:47.578
It's more of I wanna help create the solution.
00:02:48.272 --> 00:02:49.689
I went back to graduate school.
00:02:49.729 --> 00:02:55.610
I still was working for the money, and I remember going into my advisor's office one day.
00:02:55.656 --> 00:03:00.663
It was, I mean, I was probably only a couple months into graduate school, and I'm like, "I hate working in hazardous waste.
00:03:00.683 --> 00:03:04.528
I need something else to do." And he was like, "Oh, that's so funny.
00:03:04.528 --> 00:03:12.171
I just got off the call with an alum from the program who said the city of Medford," which I was at Tufts University in Medford, Massachusetts.
00:03:13.239 --> 00:03:22.825
They said, "Oh, the city of Medford needs a climate action plan." First off, this was the year 2000, so I didn't know what a climate action plan was, but I was like, "That sounds good.
00:03:22.844 --> 00:03:26.824
I'll do that." And I literally called them, got an interview.
00:03:26.854 --> 00:03:28.953
I thought they were, like, posting this position.
00:03:29.243 --> 00:03:29.991
They were not.
00:03:30.372 --> 00:03:35.519
I just called them out of the blue and showed up, interviewed them, and they hired me on the spot.
00:03:35.549 --> 00:03:38.139
So it wasn't intentional, Tom.
00:03:38.141 --> 00:03:43.282
I kind of ended up there, and honestly, I loved it, and I still love it.
00:03:43.872 --> 00:03:55.697
For, for me, local government is the place to be because it really is a place where you can have change happen on a reasonable scale, as opposed to the national or international level
00:03:56.695 --> 00:04:03.402
Okay, and municipal operations can be under 5% of community emissions.
00:04:03.402 --> 00:04:05.473
So why do cities keep focusing there?
00:04:06.426 --> 00:04:10.932
Well, that's something I constantly am pushing them to not focus on, and especially now.
00:04:11.326 --> 00:04:18.629
What I like about working with local governments is that they have the ability to influence their community members, right?
00:04:18.630 --> 00:04:25.687
So when you think about what's required to ignite behavior change, you've got to get your information from a trusted source.
00:04:25.706 --> 00:04:27.759
You can see your mayor at the grocery store.
00:04:27.762 --> 00:04:29.398
These folks are in your community.
00:04:29.399 --> 00:04:31.055
They're, they're living among you.
00:04:31.588 --> 00:04:36.427
And then local governments also, they have a way to get to everyone in the community.
00:04:36.427 --> 00:04:37.591
They can send mailers out.
00:04:37.591 --> 00:04:38.702
They can knock on your door.
00:04:39.148 --> 00:04:44.134
And then finally, they can create the enabling environments that lead to the behavior you want to see.
00:04:44.136 --> 00:04:50.019
So if you want people to get out of their cars, well, then make it safe to ride bikes or make sure they have good transit options.
00:04:50.290 -->
Load full transcript
00:04:56.552
And so for me, it's that catalyst role that local governments play that makes me the most excited about working there.
00:04:56.928 --> 00:04:58.168
They want to lead by example.
00:04:58.629 --> 00:05:02.295
They can control their operations way better than they can control the community.
00:05:02.589 --> 00:05:16.045
But one of the things my organisation is really pushing with local governments now and over the last three to five years has been, great, you've been leading by example, but now we have to really tackle where the emissions are or your targets will mean nothing.
00:05:16.954 --> 00:05:27.365
And speaking of targets, I mean, we're not that far away now from 2030, so how can you tell if a city is implementing or just updating its plan?
00:05:28.391 --> 00:05:34.336
The local governments are actively implementing actions in their plan, but we're not reducing emissions.
00:05:34.358 --> 00:05:38.692
And so a few years ago, I'm like, "This isn't working.
00:05:38.706 --> 00:05:55.696
We're not doing the thing that is supposed to be." And for me, yeah, sure, I make money doing climate action plans, but I'm mission-driven, and I don't wanna just do a plan that isn't going to yield the results that we're trying to get, which is reducing emissions and enhancing our resilience to the impacts.
00:05:56.293 --> 00:06:15.185
So we actually created a new program called Action Ready, and I am actively pushing this now with my clients, and I encourage everyone at this point, any local government who, if you haven't even started thinking about climate change, you don't have a greenhouse gas inventory, you don't have a climate action plan, I'm telling you, between now and 2030, don't waste your time and money on those things.
00:06:15.560 --> 00:06:16.786
You don't need them.
00:06:17.129 --> 00:06:18.521
We know where your emissions are.
00:06:18.629 --> 00:06:19.973
Buildings and transportation.
00:06:20.853 --> 00:06:21.680
I can tell you that.
00:06:21.685 --> 00:06:22.997
I don't have to look at your data.
00:06:23.117 --> 00:06:29.411
That's where they are, and we know what the solutions are to address those areas, so we want to do that.
00:06:29.791 --> 00:06:31.382
I'd make one distinction here.
00:06:32.072 --> 00:06:37.172
Skipping another strategy document may be sensible, but skipping measurement is different.
00:06:37.831 --> 00:06:46.442
Without a baseline and follow-up data, a council can't know whether emissions are actually falling or whether it's simply counting activities.
00:06:47.235 --> 00:06:52.502
So for example, obviously a, great solution is to electrify your home.
00:06:52.608 --> 00:06:53.896
Let's get electric heat pumps.
00:06:53.958 --> 00:06:55.067
Let's get solar panels.
00:06:55.084 --> 00:06:56.528
Let's get electric vehicles.
00:06:57.055 --> 00:07:03.555
Those are three huge and highly impactful solutions that are also tens of thousands of dollars.
00:07:04.319 --> 00:07:13.113
And yet we blanket, "Well, go get solar.""Oh, oh, oh yeah. You know what, honey? Today why don't we go get solar panels?" These are not decisions that we make on the fly.
00:07:13.137 --> 00:07:26.446
These are serious investments, and I think we're forgetting that a lot of the time 'cause we're just so like,"Hey, we have a solution. Let's do something." So we're trying to help folks to rethink this and focus in on certain people at certain times.
00:07:26.490 --> 00:07:29.990
We have the information about our building stock at the local level.
00:07:29.994 --> 00:07:33.021
We know this neighborhood are homes of this age.
00:07:33.494 --> 00:07:36.425
They could be due for a heating and cooling system upgrade.
00:07:36.713 --> 00:07:39.730
And you'd be surprised how many homeowners actually don't know that.
00:07:39.764 --> 00:07:44.805
They don't know that their heating and cooling system maybe is only gonna last 15 to 20 years.
00:07:45.274 --> 00:07:46.767
Some only last 12.
00:07:46.786 --> 00:07:49.601
I know for me, we bought a brand-new house.
00:07:50.192 --> 00:07:54.966
By year 12, it's every piece of equipment just started slowly dying on us.
00:07:54.970 --> 00:07:58.910
And we're like, "Ah, what's happening here?" People aren't expecting that.
00:07:58.913 --> 00:08:09.627
And so if you can kind of get folks I think a year, two years before the system goes or is about to go, then they can work it into their plan.
00:08:09.649 --> 00:08:11.872
They're gonna have to save for that upgrade.
00:08:11.872 --> 00:08:14.458
They're gonna pay tens of thousands for that upgrade.
00:08:14.464 --> 00:08:19.168
It could be 10,000, it could be 20,000, depending on their home and the system, but you're gonna be paying that.
00:08:19.180 --> 00:08:26.045
So now when I say go to a heat pump at, say, 30,000, well, it's not zero to 30, it's 15 to 30.
00:08:26.154 --> 00:08:32.726
So now that delta is 15, and we've got rebates in there, so it's not as much of a jump as we might have thought.
00:08:32.741 --> 00:08:43.549
And then when you factor in the fact that it's more efficient and your monthly utility bills will be less because of that, well, now it's a different story, and it's a totally different conversation.
00:08:44.157 --> 00:08:49.397
And the other big piece of this program is that we do not lead with any climate communication.
00:08:49.966 --> 00:08:53.166
That doesn't have to be the reason people do it, right?
00:08:53.240 --> 00:08:56.684
If the outcome is the same, I don't care what we call it.
00:08:57.384 --> 00:09:04.086
It's getting to the outcomes that we need, and it's reaching people in a way that's more comfortable for them, rather than fighting it.
00:09:04.359 --> 00:09:06.075
Climate change shouldn't be politicized.
00:09:06.130 --> 00:09:06.903
No, it shouldn't.
00:09:07.038 --> 00:09:10.594
But is that the argument I wanna have when I'm trying to get someone to install a heat pump?
00:09:10.839 --> 00:09:12.513
Mm, not really
00:09:13.162 -->
00:09:15.397
Get your bills down rather than reduce your emissions.
00:09:15.982 --> 00:09:16.307
Right.
00:09:16.479 --> 00:09:22.347
And if emissions are, like a, a reduction in emissions are a co-benefit, most people are pretty happy about that.
00:09:22.640 --> 00:09:35.503
I do believe the majority of people want to do the right thing, but it's gotta be in alignment with what they care about and what they have the capacity to move forward on, and not just, "Well, you should do this because it's the right thing to do."
00:09:36.895 --> 00:09:37.166
Hmm.
00:09:37.225 --> 00:09:41.576
And can you take us inside a community where targeted outreach changed a real decision?
00:09:42.129 --> 00:09:42.474
Yeah.
00:09:42.474 --> 00:09:46.037
So we worked in a community not too far from me, actually.
00:09:46.038 --> 00:09:47.316
I'm in the Boston area.
00:09:48.076 --> 00:09:49.272
Danvers, Massachusetts.
00:09:49.357 --> 00:09:51.797
Funny enough, I just, I happened to go to high school there.
00:09:51.798 --> 00:09:52.873
My parents live there.
00:09:53.081 --> 00:09:55.250
They reached out to me about doing some work.
00:09:55.279 --> 00:09:59.273
And they're a municipal utility, so there is a benefit to that.
00:09:59.799 --> 00:10:08.559
It doesn't mean this program doesn't work in investor-owned utility communities, but the municipal utility, I could just get the data faster, so we could see the results of what was happening.
00:10:08.897 --> 00:10:13.599
And so we went in and we identified a couple of key neighborhoods.
00:10:14.147 --> 00:10:16.433
We brought a few criterion in.
00:10:16.436 --> 00:10:19.422
One, we looked at the age of the home, looking at age ranges.
00:10:19.660 --> 00:10:27.625
We looked at whether or not they had ductwork, 'cause that, as you know, is much easier to do a replacement if they already have some ductwork.
00:10:28.280 --> 00:10:35.602
And then in this case, because we have a municipal utility, it's an electric utility, but we have an investor-owned natural gas utility.
00:10:36.063 --> 00:10:38.666
And in Massachusetts, we have a program called Mass Saves.
00:10:38.913 --> 00:10:44.905
Long story short, in Danvers, not everywhere, you can double-dip in the rebates.
00:10:44.979 --> 00:10:51.758
So you could get a rebate from Danvers Electric, as well, if you're replacing natural gas, you could get a rebate from Mass Save.
00:10:52.202 --> 00:10:56.768
And so that was kind of like, whoa, here's a great opportunity.
00:10:56.783 --> 00:10:57.727
And nobody knew this.
00:10:57.745 --> 00:11:03.113
And so we sent the basic messaging,"Hey, your home's of this age.
00:11:03.145 --> 00:11:04.625
It could be due for an upgrade.
00:11:04.644 --> 00:11:05.452
Are you aware?
00:11:05.452 --> 00:11:08.697
Like, have you been looking at this?" We had a little… So it's a postcard.
00:11:08.751 --> 00:11:09.754
We had a QR code.
00:11:10.097 --> 00:11:21.048
They go to a landing page, some information on heat pumps, a calculator to figure out how much could you save every month based on your specific electric utility rates, and some general information.
00:11:21.969 --> 00:11:23.635
And then you gotta let the program go.
00:11:23.668 --> 00:11:29.294
The other piece is, you watch that traction, and then we send out door knockers with some door hangers.
00:11:29.294 --> 00:11:36.514
So two communication pieces very light touch, three X increase in the heat pump rebate participation.
00:11:37.991 --> 00:11:38.354
Yeah.
00:11:38.988 --> 00:11:40.859
And that was our very first little pilot.
00:11:40.861 --> 00:11:47.479
So I was like, whoa, just from postcards and a door hanger, a three X increase?
00:11:48.125 --> 00:11:55.986
So that's what really made me think there might be something here, and it was that pilot… I mean, that pilot program, I was just doing it as part of a regular climate action plan.
00:11:56.673 --> 00:12:00.020
I just said to them, "Hey, do you mind if I try something here?
00:12:00.020 --> 00:12:12.825
I just wanna test something out and see if we can implement an action that will be in your plan that we haven't written yet." And they were like, "Sure, let's figure it out." And so it was great, and we're actually about to do another round of it in Danvers because… So it's interesting.
00:12:12.881 --> 00:12:14.731
So that was '22 to '23.
00:12:14.732 --> 00:12:16.582
So we did it in, the program in '22.
00:12:16.616 --> 00:12:22.432
2023, they saw that increase between those two years, and it stayed pretty steady.
00:12:22.450 --> 00:12:27.296
It start to slowly decline just a bit, still not even close to where it was in '22.
00:12:27.530 --> 00:12:30.619
We're gonna do another campaign, see if we can get those numbers even higher.
00:12:31.402 --> 00:12:39.981
Three times more rebate participation is encouraging, although it doesn't tell us on its own how many upgrades the campaign caused.
00:12:40.822 --> 00:12:46.761
How do you target people who are ready to act without leaving lower income households behind?
00:12:47.850 --> 00:12:48.649
Great question.
00:12:48.649 --> 00:12:53.586
I should have mentioned that income was another criteria that we looked at in Danvers in particular.
00:12:53.604 --> 00:13:03.519
We want to reach out to folks that are of a certain level income single family or just owner occupied is more the, the piece, so they have the control.
00:13:03.519 --> 00:13:09.943
We're trying to minimise all the other barriers so we could figure out if our messaging and, tactics worked.
00:13:10.878 --> 00:13:15.648
The low income area is a little bit different because there's a lot more programs for them.
00:13:15.664 --> 00:13:18.909
There's a lot more rebate opportunities and different grant programs.
00:13:18.910 --> 00:13:25.051
And actually right now, not to date the podcast, but we have a New England heat pump accelerator program.
00:13:25.051 --> 00:13:32.501
So all New England states are participating in this
massive program to get millions of heat pumps out throughout New England.
00:13:32.994 --> 00:13:38.817
That's a new funding source, but there's also a lot of others that go with it with low income programs.
00:13:38.822 --> 00:13:49.869
So the way that I've approached it for my business is we can hit those areas if folks want, mostly through landlords, but I feel like there's a lot of other programs that are already focused on those groups.
00:13:50.283 --> 00:13:55.816
And typically they're gonna be smaller homes and, it's a smaller emissions footprint.
00:13:55.817 --> 00:14:11.341
So for me, really targeted on that 2030 year let's go for the biggest homes with the biggest footprint that have the money to make the change, and by the way, happen to be due for one anyways, so that we don't lock in another 20 years or more of fossil fuels.
00:14:11.640 --> 00:14:17.880
The fastest emissions cuts and the fairest access don't always come from the same campaign.
00:14:18.931 --> 00:14:29.221
Targeting larger owner occupied homes may speed up reductions, but renters and lower income households need their own route into the transition.
00:14:29.445 --> 00:14:38.705
And talk to me about the dashboard because, a public dashboard can help, change decisions and sometimes it's just a, a prettier report.
00:14:39.549 --> 00:14:40.625
Yeah, fair question.
00:14:40.638 --> 00:14:43.460
And so our landing pages are part of our dashboard.
00:14:44.224 --> 00:14:54.725
I will say I've been wanting to come up with a different name for this tool for a long time because I think people have a very particular idea of what a dashboard should be.
00:14:54.730 --> 00:15:02.690
And they, especially if you're an energy manager in a city, right, you just wanna see charts and graphs and all kinds of data flowing at you.
00:15:02.706 --> 00:15:07.168
But the average person does not connect with that information that way at all.
00:15:07.440 --> 00:15:15.307
I think a lot of communities are like, "Here's your real time data on how the high school's using energy." Nobody cares about 15-minute intervals except the energy manager.
00:15:15.369 --> 00:15:18.693
That's just not a thing for the general citizen.
00:15:19.029 --> 00:15:22.590
So for us, our dashboard is really a communications platform.
00:15:22.620 --> 00:15:40.609
We want more people to feel comfortable enough to participate in conversations around climate action so that, a lot of times what happens is you go to one of these dashboards, it's all technical jargon, it's acronyms, it's units people don't know.
00:15:40.629 --> 00:15:43.683
It's a crazy line graph with some other thing happening.
00:15:43.684 --> 00:15:47.124
And I'm like, "Does anyone know what this means?" And it makes people feel stupid.
00:15:47.802 --> 00:15:49.500
And who wants to do that?
00:15:49.509 --> 00:16:00.801
Who's gonna participate in something if you're basically saying, "Look how smart I am, and you're not understanding it, so now I'm making you feel like you're not smart enough to engage in this conversation"?
00:16:00.820 --> 00:16:02.596
And that's the last thing we wanna do.
00:16:02.893 --> 00:16:07.719
Everybody knows their, daily usage, how they operate, right?
00:16:07.893 --> 00:16:11.381
People are more than smart enough to participate in these conversations.
00:16:11.688 --> 00:16:22.802
And I think, our space has done a little bit of a disservice when we feel that we need to put out, ridiculously long words that aren't necessary to use, charts that don't mean anything.
00:16:22.894 --> 00:16:25.967
What we do on our dashboard is start with images.
00:16:26.254 --> 00:16:28.288
Here's a picture of your community park.
00:16:28.311 --> 00:16:29.350
You know that place.
00:16:29.350 --> 00:16:31.514
We want people to connect with what they're looking at.
00:16:31.903 --> 00:16:40.432
We write everything at about an eighth-grade level, which in America, that's the average reading level, which a lot of people are shocked to learn about.
00:16:40.496 --> 00:16:40.778
Yeah.
00:16:41.255 --> 00:16:44.053
we can have a different conversation about the education system here, Tom.
00:16:46.167 --> 00:16:48.846
So that also allows more accessibility.
00:16:48.846 --> 00:16:50.552
We like data visualizations.
00:16:50.562 --> 00:16:51.702
I like icons.
00:16:51.730 --> 00:16:54.413
I like to give equivalencies so folks can understand.
00:16:54.538 --> 00:17:08.161
It doesn't mean I shy away from helping folks learn what a metric ton of carbon dioxide equivalent is and why it matters, but it's not the first thing I'm leading with, and we're explaining it in a way that a middle schooler could understand
00:17:09.414 --> 00:17:14.279
If it's not the first thing that people will connect with what metric has actually triggered action?
00:17:15.647 --> 00:17:24.811
I feel like generically speaking, a metric will trigger action when you can have an equivalency that folks can understand.
00:17:25.241 --> 00:17:28.128
I think water is something people can relate to, right?
00:17:28.130 --> 00:17:34.622
So when, when we think about how much water we're using or we're saving, well, that's 80 Olympic-sized pools.
00:17:34.631 --> 00:17:36.881
Like, people can picture that.
00:17:36.978 --> 00:17:42.012
And I know there's a lot of organisations out there that have the big ball always at the climate conferences.
00:17:42.013 --> 00:17:52.231
"This is a metric ton of carbon dioxide." I love that because it gives folks a size thing to put on, but I think generally speaking humans have a hard time envisioning invisible things.
00:17:53.048 --> 00:17:53.348
Yeah.
00:17:53.363 --> 00:17:55.424
Things we, we can't ever see.
00:17:55.688 --> 00:17:57.989
So I do love water examples.
00:17:58.009 --> 00:18:07.087
I do love forest examples, like trees, people can connect with that, and say, oh, one street tree versus an entire forest in Yosemite National Park.
00:18:07.678 --> 00:18:09.801
You
can understand that scale.
00:18:10.095 --> 00:18:12.221
So I do think scale matters a lot.
00:18:12.567 --> 00:18:17.962
On the metric tonne of CO2 thing, what I often say to people is a metric tonne that's about equivalent to a Mini Cooper.
00:18:18.973 --> 00:18:20.250
I love that.
00:18:20.488 --> 00:18:22.103
I love that.
00:18:22.846 --> 00:18:24.890
And that's one people can picture in their mind immediately.
00:18:25.260 --> 00:18:26.138
Exactly.
00:18:26.161 --> 00:18:30.944
That's what you need to be able to do, connect with things that people can immediately put context around
00:18:31.637 --> 00:18:31.847
Yeah.
00:18:32.268 --> 00:18:32.448
Yeah.
00:18:32.718 --> 00:18:34.643
And what's been harder than expected?
00:18:35.924 --> 00:18:37.160
Working with humans.
00:18:39.244 --> 00:18:51.375
I always, I always use this phrase cause people even my husband back in the day used to say, "Oh, well, Kim saves the world and I pay for it." And I've really gotten folks to rethink that statement.
00:18:51.425 --> 00:18:53.239
I'm not saving the planet.
00:18:53.803 --> 00:18:59.290
I'm trying to save humanity from extinction, which I'm part of that group, so I have a vested interest.
00:18:59.290 --> 00:19:00.825
I would think you all do, too.
00:19:01.423 --> 00:19:09.865
But I think it's important for people… Every time I say that you get this like aha moment from folks because they don't think of it that way.
00:19:09.909 --> 00:19:12.611
You feel like you're banging your head against the wall sometimes.
00:19:12.612 --> 00:19:19.403
But to me that's just like you gotta just keep recrafting and rethinking how you're communicating to reach the right people.
00:19:19.871 --> 00:19:24.873
And I think a lot of societal things of, you can't talk about that, right?
00:19:25.127 --> 00:19:26.528
Anything's oh, you can't talk about that.
00:19:26.549 --> 00:19:27.554
You can't talk about politics.
00:19:27.582 --> 00:19:28.592
You can't talk about religion.
00:19:28.680 --> 00:19:29.707
You can't talk about climate change.
00:19:29.763 --> 00:19:31.849
You can't talk about these things at Thanksgiving dinner.
00:19:31.851 --> 00:19:33.631
It's like that's your family.
00:19:34.192 --> 00:19:35.786
Those are like your closest people.
00:19:36.045 --> 00:19:37.753
I grew up in an Italian family.
00:19:37.832 --> 00:19:40.309
We talk and yell at each other about everything.
00:19:40.799 --> 00:19:47.811
And we get over it in like 10… Like you yell and then you're done and you're like,"Okay, now we move on." I've learned that most families aren't quite like mine.
00:19:48.281 --> 00:19:58.660
But I think that piece of not being able to talk about the things that matter most, I, I feel like that's what fossil fuel industry and other folks like want us to do.
00:19:58.689 --> 00:20:12.490
"Oh, yeah, no, we don't want you talking about that because if you're talking to trusted sources then you'll realise, well, we've been feeding you a load of crap." N- we as in the fossil fuel companies, to be clear.
00:20:14.203 --> 00:20:19.394
And is there anywhere that you've changed your mind about climate communication or engagement in the last 10, 15 years?
00:20:48.963 --> 00:20:49.696
I, yeah.
00:20:49.798 --> 00:20:51.044
Constant learner here.
00:20:51.102 --> 00:20:53.662
I, I'm always evolving and adjusting.
00:20:54.077 --> 00:21:05.122
I think the biggest thing I've been changing, and this is just the last year or so, kind of came to this, what now feels like a very obvious conclusion.
00:21:06.260 --> 00:21:13.064
Working with local governments, we tend to work with a sustainability director or some department.
00:21:13.318 --> 00:21:26.787
It could be in like, a city manager's office, could be at a high level, but it's a sustainability office that has no money and even less authority over anything.
00:21:26.860 --> 00:21:28.176
Now, there are some exceptions.
00:21:28.981 --> 00:21:37.311
Ann Arbor, Michigan, Dr. Missy Stoltz in Ann Arbor, she has money and authority, and she's knocking it out of the park over there.
00:21:37.931 --> 00:21:51.095
So there are definitely some exceptions, but the majority of sustainability offices or directors in local governments, p- and frankly, from what I've seen in the corporate world, have no authority over things.
00:21:51.114 --> 00:22:17.063
And so when you think about it from the standpoint of, okay, if we're thinking and saying that climate change is a pretty important thing, and at a local level, when the impacts are all there, and this is about public safety, public health, your economy thriving, some of the most important things for a local government, you put this great plan together, and then you put the person with the least money and the least authority in charge of it.
00:22:19.335 --> 00:22:20.722
Feels like a disconnect to me.
00:22:20.750 --> 00:22:28.346
And so, what I've been trying to do more and more lately is find connections more to more leadership.
00:22:28.376 --> 00:22:45.634
I mean, I have some in our communities, but really trying to get senior leaders more engaged to understand that this can't be something that just falls on a well-meaning person, but who really can't move the needle.
00:22:45.788 --> 00:22:59.259
Their number one job, and this is I think what a lot of folks don't think about, is"Oh, I'm a sustainability director. I've gotta know about energy, and electric cars, and composting, and everything under the sun, green infrastructure." No.
00:22:59.268 --> 00:23:10.183
What you really have to know is how to build relationships and get the people that are responsible for those things in your community, because you probably are not.
00:23:10.511 --> 00:23:13.990
You've gotta get them to move the needle, and that takes a lot.
00:23:14.258 --> 00:23:25.053
Takes a lot of time with them, communicating with them, understanding what their current burdens are, being willing to give more to them before you get anything from
them.
00:23:25.477 --> 00:23:26.593
That's how this works.
00:23:26.605 --> 00:23:34.900
It's relationship building, and I don't think all of the sustainability directors that we have out there are equipped to do those kinds of things
00:23:35.668 --> 00:23:37.918
That raises a governance question.
00:23:38.788 --> 00:23:44.668
The sustainability director may own the target, but someone else approves the developments that affect it.
00:23:45.538 --> 00:23:48.057
AI data centres are a case in point.
00:23:48.807 --> 00:24:00.327
If a proposed facility offers jobs and tax revenue, but strains electricity and water supplies, what conditions should a council insist on before granting approval?
00:24:00.948 --> 00:24:04.690
They should demand that they generate all their energy on site.
00:24:05.980 --> 00:24:07.926
That's really the thing, right?
00:24:07.974 --> 00:24:13.880
Most of the data centers going in are being funded by pretty wealthy organisations.
00:24:14.506 --> 00:24:18.528
Most of them could pull cash out of their back pocket to fund these things.
00:24:18.823 --> 00:24:34.588
And so, mm, then you should have solar, battery backup, create your own little virtual, or not, your actual grid there, and cover the all, if not the majority of your energy use.
00:24:35.239 --> 00:24:39.048
Onsite generation is not the same as run the clock supply.
00:24:39.889 --> 00:24:49.699
If a data centre needs continuous power, solar and batteries have to be assessed against that entire demand, not just the amount of capacity installed.
00:24:50.209 --> 00:24:51.409
That's a critical test before approval.
00:24:52.674 --> 00:25:03.361
Also, thinking about the need, and I don't know, I haven't dug deep into this, but everything I've seen so far is suggesting that there's no reason that data centers need fresh water.
00:25:04.317 --> 00:25:06.621
Why aren't they using more recycled water?
00:25:06.629 --> 00:25:16.907
Why aren't we putting in things like that where there's a constant reuse of water and not just using our fresh water that could be used for drinking water?
00:25:17.355 --> 00:25:18.355
There's a lot here.
00:25:18.361 --> 00:25:23.457
I do think for me, this is feeling like a huge challenge in many ways.
00:25:23.547 --> 00:25:34.190
And for local governments, I s- we saw this with EVs coming in because the industry gets ahead of government, no surprise, right?
00:25:34.213 --> 00:25:42.923
And so back in the day, the cities would get these requests like, "Well, we wanna install EV charging stations." And they're like we don't have a policy for that.
00:25:42.933 --> 00:25:44.542
We don't have zoning for that.
00:25:44.542 --> 00:25:51.076
We don't know what to do." So the cities became reactive, and it's literally the same thing we're seeing with data centers.
00:25:51.299 --> 00:26:10.109
It's really hard for local governments to stay on top of how fast technology and different industries are moving when they've got billions and billions of dollars getting poured into it, and you don't have that same level of funding for your governments to protect your community and your citizens.
00:26:10.611 --> 00:26:15.660
And I mean, sure, there may be some revenue and whatnot, but at what expense?
00:26:15.690 --> 00:26:24.337
That short-term gain for what long-term impact, that they could then reap all of the bad part of basically.
00:26:24.760 --> 00:26:29.365
All the negative effects are left for that community and its community members.
00:26:29.602 --> 00:26:35.734
And I will say, on a personal level, ugh, this AI thing is really a struggle.
00:26:36.364 --> 00:26:48.144
Man, as a business owner, a small business owner up against big multinationals with way more money, it is really hard right now to keep pace if I'm only using humans.
00:26:48.174 --> 00:27:02.018
It's a real struggle of values, of getting some efficiency and some sanity to stay doing good work while not going backwards on all the things we've done.
00:27:02.022 --> 00:27:11.020
I mean, we've already seen in some communities one data center coming in wipes out years of climate action as it relates to greenhouse gas emissions.
00:27:12.135 --> 00:27:16.634
So, this is gonna be the big thing to wrestle with over the next couple of years.
00:27:16.666 --> 00:27:24.000
As we're heading towards 2030, do I get some community to actually hit their 2030 targets by this targeted marketing?
00:27:24.076 --> 00:27:28.571
And then a data center goes up, and boom, that's all wiped out almost instantly
00:27:29.461 --> 00:27:29.672
Hmm.
00:27:29.731 --> 00:27:34.711
I, I think the issue there, it's a bit like energy use or electricity use.
00:27:34.892 --> 00:27:42.511
I mean, you absolutely need it for your work, but sometimes it's generated using fossil fuels.
00:27:42.991 --> 00:27:53.064
So if it's mandated that the AI companies can only build data centres that are powered by renewables, then it becomes, and, and it has to be
00:27:53.658 --> 00:27:53.948
new
00:27:53.952 --> 00:27:55.103
build additional
00:27:55.179 --> 00:27:56.865
Yes, that's the key
00:27:57.241 --> 00:28:03.751
then it isn't as big an issue because a lot of them are, what they're doing is they're putting these big gas turbines on site,
00:28:03.981 --> 00:28:04.484
Yep
00:28:04.584 --> 00:28:05.634
which are blowing up
00:28:05.740 --> 00:28:07.230
emissions and pumping
00:28:07.238 --> 00:28:11.251
CO2 and other noxious gases into the local atmosphere.
00:28:12.557 --> 00:28:12.905
Yep.
00:28:12.962 --> 00:28:34.321
And so you do have organisations like Climate Mayors and others ICLEI, Local Governments for Sustainability, that are bringing resources to local governments, leaders, and staff to understand here are policies you can put in place, here are things that you can do, so that they have the knowledge and the resources to make some decisions.
00:28:34.909 --> 00:28:39.949
There's a gap between being able to impose conditions and having resources to
enforce them.
00:28:40.759 --> 00:28:50.179
If a council can't scrutinise energy and water commitments, a development agreement, may look impressive on paper without delivering in practise.
00:28:50.615 --> 00:29:00.601
Since I've left local government about 20 years ago, I have seen an exponential increase in the amount of responsibility that sits at the local level.
00:29:00.789 --> 00:29:18.566
So your local government staff and leaders are now required to be experts in so many things and be prepared even trying to get ahead of what industry's doing with less staff, salaries that can't compete with the private sector, and I don't know how they do that.
00:29:18.607 --> 00:29:21.195
And, and I don't think most people realise how much is on them.
00:29:21.254 --> 00:29:25.697
They're not getting more resources to do it because nobody wants their property taxes to go up, right?
00:29:26.169 --> 00:29:29.549
But it's like, how do we find that balance?
00:29:30.285 --> 00:29:32.168
Yeah, sure, Time.
00:29:32.168 --> 00:29:39.309
Now, Kim, for the lightning round, I've got six quick questions, one sentence answers if possible.
00:29:39.610 --> 00:29:41.198
Yes, I will be succinct
00:29:42.077 --> 00:29:42.587
Okay.
00:29:43.278 --> 00:29:47.868
So first one, one big project or hundreds of household upgrades?
00:29:52.124 --> 00:29:53.413
Depends on the project.
00:29:57.798 --> 00:29:58.758
All right, we'll go onto the next one.
00:29:58.758 --> 00:30:02.087
So more public input or faster delivery?
00:30:03.826 --> 00:30:04.812
Faster delivery
00:30:05.976 --> 00:30:06.246
Okay.
00:30:07.026 --> 00:30:09.520
Which climate number do you trust least?
00:30:11.576 --> 00:30:12.952
Vehicle miles traveled
00:30:14.577 --> 00:30:19.343
Okay, plan first or act on obvious wins now?
00:30:20.121 --> 00:30:21.216
Act now
00:30:22.559 --> 00:30:22.860
Okay.
00:30:23.910 --> 00:30:26.279
What should every city stop funding?
00:30:27.745 --> 00:30:30.250
I feel like I'm gonna get in trouble for my answer
00:30:32.111 --> 00:30:32.471
Good.
00:30:32.605 --> 00:30:33.785
So I'll caveat it.
00:30:34.776 --> 00:30:40.022
Every community should stop funding as a climate strategy community gardens
00:30:41.386 --> 00:30:41.687
Ooh.
00:30:41.807 --> 00:30:42.287
Interesting.
00:30:43.366 --> 00:30:47.957
And last one, what makes people act savings, comfort, or climate?
00:30:50.159 --> 00:30:52.965
Depends on the people, but I say comfort
00:30:53.776 --> 00:30:54.016
Great.
00:30:54.661 --> 00:30:55.104
So,
00:30:55.220 --> 00:30:57.005
left field question for you now.
00:30:58.384 --> 00:31:00.845
If you could have any person or
00:31:00.855 --> 00:31:01.586
character,
00:31:02.203 --> 00:31:03.265
alive or dead
00:31:03.818 --> 00:31:04.471
real
00:31:04.585 --> 00:31:12.725
or fictional as a champion for turning local climate plans into real world action, who would it be and why?
00:31:13.927 --> 00:31:14.878
Oh my goodness.
00:31:14.905 --> 00:31:16.510
I love this question.
00:31:17.610 --> 00:31:21.834
I mean, is it crazy to think about Like Wonder Woman,
00:31:22.900 --> 00:31:23.140
Brilliant.
00:31:23.209 --> 00:31:23.440
know?
00:31:23.871 --> 00:31:24.250
Yeah.
00:31:24.549 --> 00:31:24.850
Yeah.
00:31:25.150 --> 00:31:27.658
first off, both men and women love her.
00:31:28.381 --> 00:31:29.187
How can you not?
00:31:29.205 --> 00:31:30.048
She's gorgeous.
00:31:30.109 --> 00:31:31.761
She's super strong and smart.
00:31:32.186 --> 00:31:42.717
And she's so calm, I think she brings power without the negative energy and brings people together.
00:31:43.600 --> 00:31:45.428
I'm obviously a big Wonder Woman fan.
00:31:45.477 --> 00:31:48.654
That's the ca- full transparency.
00:31:48.789 --> 00:31:55.657
But I feel like some- someone that people can connect with and trust that they're doing it for the right reasons
00:31:56.549 --> 00:31:57.090
Fantastic.
00:31:57.420 --> 00:32:03.674
And after this conversation, how should we think differently about what local climate leadership really is?
00:32:04.821 --> 00:32:13.544
Local climate leadership is really about driving the community action and not just leading by example.
00:32:14.077 --> 00:32:25.292
Because we've spent the last 25 years leading by example, and if that hasn't trickled into your community, then you're not really leading, you're just giving an example, right?
00:32:25.296 --> 00:32:34.551
So the leading has to be where the local government recognises and leverages its role as a catalyst to drive community action
00:32:36.873 --> 00:32:36.993
Okay.
00:32:37.353 --> 00:32:39.423
We're coming towards the end of the podcast now, Kim.
00:32:39.423 --> 00:32:43.100
Is there any question that I didn't ask that you wish I had or
00:32:43.683 --> 00:32:43.900
any
00:32:43.900 --> 00:32:47.008
aspect of this we haven't covered that you think it's important for people to be aware of?
00:32:49.794 --> 00:32:50.622
I don't think so.
00:32:50.632 --> 00:32:52.366
I feel like we covered a lot.
00:32:52.427 --> 00:33:03.864
I, definitely wanna reemphasize the, invite everyone to steal it when people talk about we're saving the planet, or when we talk about this being an environmental issue.
00:33:04.441 --> 00:33:05.222
It's not.
00:33:05.330 --> 00:33:10.043
It's a human issue, and it's a real one that affects everything we do.
00:33:10.331 --> 00:33:11.668
It affects our health.
00:33:11.682 --> 00:33:13.548
It affects our livelihood.
00:33:13.558 --> 00:33:15.498
It affects our economy.
00:33:15.509 --> 00:33:18.465
It affects our natural resources, our children.
00:33:18.932 --> 00:33:25.623
Everything that we say we care about and that are priorities, it affects, and mostly not in a good way.
00:33:25.967 --> 00:33:34.984
So it is important that we stop, stop siloing this, and that's why I really do encourage the, you don't have to lead with climate communication.
00:33:35.713 --> 00:33:43.778
You can lead with benefits that people will get and things that they can do that they need to do anyways.
00:33:44.178 --> 00:33:51.923
I feel like that's where we, we really get the win, when we stop feeling like everybody has to do this because climate change is our greatest challenge.
00:33:52.548 --> 00:33:53.779
The why doesn't matter.
00:33:53.791 --> 00:33:56.778
It's, it's the solution that they implement that matters
00:33:58.259 --> 00:33:59.917
I'm reminded of a cartoon
00:34:00.419 --> 00:34:00.615
of
00:34:00.615 --> 00:34:08.469
a, a lecture theatre where there's a guy at the front giving a lecture about climate change and he is got a screen behind him with, the various different things you can do.
00:34:08.710 --> 00:34:16.090
And you have two people at the back and one is turning to the other saying, you know what, if it's all a big scam and we improve the world for no good reason?
00:34:17.389 --> 00:34:20.563
Oh yeah, that was a popular comic strip for a while there.
00:34:21.000 --> 00:34:22.844
It is, and it's a perfect one, right?
00:34:23.009 --> 00:34:23.398
Yeah.
00:34:23.487 --> 00:34:24.538
I love that message.
00:34:24.538 --> 00:34:25.663
We should bring it back, Tom
00:34:26.288 --> 00:34:26.858
Absolutely.
00:34:27.308 --> 00:34:33.398
Kim, if people would like to know more about yourself or any of the things we discussed on the podcast today, where would you have me direct them?
00:34:34.346 --> 00:34:39.230
They can go to our website, kimlundgrenassociates.com, or I'm on LinkedIn, Kim Lundgren.
00:34:39.394 --> 00:34:41.375
I think that's my LinkedIn, is just Kim Lundgren.
00:34:41.380 --> 00:34:42.869
I must've gotten there first.
00:34:43.722 --> 00:34:44.382
Fantastic.
00:34:44.532 --> 00:34:47.322
I'll put those links in the show notes as well, Kim, so everyone can find them.
00:34:47.811 --> 00:34:48.905
Thank you, Tom
00:34:49.242 --> 00:34:49.871
Super.
00:34:49.871 --> 00:34:51.192
It's been really fascinating, Kim.
00:34:51.192 --> 00:34:52.961
Thanks a million for coming on the podcast today.
00:34:53.152 --> 00:34:54.016
Thank you so much.
00:34:54.016 --> 00:34:55.258
It's been a real pleasure