رونوشت 🔗
speaker-0: You're challenging the false dichotomy of either you're born this way or you choose your sexuality.
speaker-1: I would call it a trichotomy. Born that way, choose it, or it's a symptom of mental illness. The same-sex attraction is just something you know how to do. I don't think people are born gay, but they're not born straight either.
speaker-0: Yeah, I think that's the contention, that's the issue. So they're reinforcing the underlying assumption
speaker-1: I would say the the church is strong on we don't know.
speaker-0: Yes. How is this different than then choosing, right? It doesn't go after us, so we choose to do it.
speaker-1: So it's very different than choosing as far as agentative choice. Just because it's something I doing does not mean it's something I'm choosing.
speaker-0: I was with you until this part. Now I'm now I'm I'm wavering here.
speaker-2: Bless it
speaker-1: Are your eyes, or they see.
speaker-0: Well, today I'm very excited to welcome the show Andrew Robinson and his father, Jeff Robinson. welcome. And you're calling from Arizona and Oram. Is that right? Yep. Right on. Right on. Well, I'd love for you guys to introduce yourselves. Our topic today is helping youth and young adults address LGBT issues in the classroom by examining some common cultural assumptions. And that's a mouthful because it's based on a paper that you guys have been working on. so give us a little intro as to who you are and then I've got lots of questions about this. I'm I just teach a seminary down in Mace, Arizona. And I just work with teenagers, so I this is just something in fact actually today in class this was this came up. So it's it's not like it's not uncommon, right? So Sure. That was kind of my interest in it.
speaker-1: I'm a psychotherapist in private practice in Provo. And for the last 30 years, the majority of my clients overall have been Latter day Saints who deal with same-sex attraction issues. When I was when I was a graduate student at BYU did my doctoral dissertation on the topic of change, whether change is possible with same sex attraction.
speaker-0: Okay, well since you're a psychotherapist, I my first question is, how confident are you in the the therapy industry right now? Do you have concerns? 'Cause if so, we'll have to do another episode about this one. I love meeting amazing based therapists, so you're you're a rare dying breed.
speaker-1: good therapists and there's not great therapists. Therapy therapy can be a useful tool, it makes a terrible religion.
speaker-0: Yeah, there we go. That's
speaker-1: And some pe and some people use it as their religion and it's a horrible religion. It's got the i the the values that it is based on, the the world view that it is based on is not a worldview that's always friendly to the restored gospel of Jesus Christ. And so I think people have to be very careful about what they're hearing and and it's sometimes it's subtle. So I have concerns.
speaker-0: Jeff passes the sniff test on that one. That's great. No. I I okay, cool. Well, let's dive into our topic here. So what made you decide to write this paper? why did it come about? And and and then we'll dive into what your claims are, what your thesis are and and how you're helping. I can start with that part. I'm I'm not an expert by any means. I've My dad's way more knowledgeable than I am, but I it just came 'cause I noticed with seminary teachers that there was just you you could go to any classroom and they'd be all over the board. They're approaching it different ways. And there was they weren't always in line with the brethren. Like a and they wouldn't but they might not know that they were unal unaligned. be just 'cause there was a little bit of a lack of training. This is the most common thing that I would see a seminary teacher. If a student asks, Why would God allow someone to be born that way when it comes to like LGBT, you get one of two responses from a seminary teacher. Either a well-meaning seminary teacher will say, Well, we don't know. It's really complicated. We don't know all the answers, but we have faith, right, and grace. We don't know why God would allow someone to be born that way. Or the they would try to come up with some Well, maybe it's ether twelve twenty seven and God gives us weaknesses so we can be humble and strength. But the problem is no matter how a seminary teacher was responding to that, they were not identifying the underlying assumption in the question, and that is that we know that people are born that way. And the church does have a stance on cause. And its stance is that we don't know cause and that it's com complicated. And so if we when a teacher unintentionally reinforces the assumption that people are born that way, they've actually just gone against the brethren because the brethren are not saying that we're born that way. They're not saying there's that it's determined by genetics. But we've just reinforced that assumption by the students saying, Well, we don't know why they're born that way. And that's very common amongst among teachers. I see that. pretty often. Does that make sense? Let me let me see if I understand. So so right now you're saying the churches the what the brethren have said is that we don't know what causes it, but it's not have they said that it's not at birth? It's more of a timeline question and then the seminary teachers going saying we don't know why they're born that way, agreeing with the premise that it's at birth. Is that the the contention? It's the timeline thing? yeah. I think that's that's the the contention, that's that's the issue. So they're reinforcing the underlying assumption.
speaker-1: I w I would say that the church is strong on we don't know.
speaker-0: Yes.
speaker-1: And when a student when the student says, Why would God allow somebody to be born that way? And they try to answer that without saying, Well how what do you mean? How do we know they're born that the
Load full transcript
church? We don't know that they're born that way that then they're reinforcing the assumption that what they're going against is we don't know.
speaker-0: The problem with this is it it's that's one question. There's probably so many questions surrounding this topic that when someone asks the question, we we sometimes just go ahead and answer agreeing with not just that premise, but many of the other premises that sometimes come with these loaded questions when we should be very hesitant and careful that everyone knows like there's a lot of question marks here. So let's watch how we're framing questions. Is that is that kind of a an approach? Yeah. The seminary program has a really good training on how to help students I it's called doctoral mastery. They help students identify assumptions and reframe those assumptions using doctrines. But that one assumption about cause, well, my dad could get into that better, but that one assumption about cause, what you think causes this will determine how you respond to this and whether or not you think the church is fair or or that the church's doctrine is is even feasible in someone's life, right? So cause is actually really important, but we're we're dancing around it and and reinforcing false assumptions, which the church hasn't the church has not said that. It's genetically determined. So but my dad can do a way better job at explaining that. That that resonates with me. I mean we on my channel specifically I talk a lot about worldview. And you can have the same people watch the same piece of media, for example, and then get something totally different out of it, depending on if they resonate with the worldview or if it's you know and and so what we value in terms of what what saves us, what what the good life looks like, all these things that are kind of baked into our worldview are going to change how we feel about doctrines and things too. So that totally resonates with me. so Jeff, why why is this such a big deal though? Because it seems like seminary teachers are just and and other people just just being helpful and answering questions and is ri is there really that much of a distinction between I don't know and challenging the questions saying I d i help help me understand this because I right now I'm I am still struggling to see why it's so important.
speaker-1: Okay, so when I when I sit down with a client, and the great majority of my clients are faithful Latter-day Saints who believe in the restored gospel and want to live the restored gospel. That's the majority of people that I sit down and talk with. And I always start by saying, if you could get an answer to any question about this issue, what would it be? And the question is always, why? Why do I have those feelings? Why? Why matters a lot? Why matters a lot? And so There are there are f there are five bas basic approaches to cause of this. One, if people are born that way, it's genetic. It's genetic. You used to hear that a lot more than
you hear it now because science has not been kind to that thesis. It it has clobbered it pretty good. Even the American Psychological Association doesn't even begin to say people are born that way. And so you stop sort of saying that, but it's sort of like, we were cheating at this game for fifty years. We're gonna stop c cheating, but we're gonna keep all the points we scored while we were cheating. And so so the majority of people still in the back of their mind have this un unexamined assumption that that it's innate, that people just are that, that they're just born that way.
speaker-0: Real quick on that, I mean that's that's true of a lot of things. It's true of a l a lot of things in the medical space. For two years I was the cre the creative director for a psychiatrist and he he taught me so much about how medication works and and and whatnot. But one thing that we all believe, I mean we were all raised believing is that you i if you're depressed, it's because of a chemical imbalance in your brain. Right. And that's not true. It's been it did proven time and time and time and time and time again, and yet that's what ever how everyone explains medication for depression. And i it's just unbelievable how untrue it is, and yet how prevalent that is.
speaker-1: Yeah. That that's a great that's a great parallel. That's a great parallel. Next approach to cause would be that people chose it. So you used to hear all the time, Well, people born that way or did they choose it? Born that way or they choose it, you know? And nobody nobody has any any feeling of having chosen it. You know. So this dichotomy for many years was the driving dichotomy. And it's a false dichotomy. Born that way or chose it, and I always say to clients, Well, were you born speaking English or did you choose it? Now, this is a this is a huge part of your life. I mean, this is how you make sense out of the world, this is how you think in English, this is how you form relationships, this is how you understand the world, is in English. Were you born that way or did you choose it? Well, you didn't choose it, you weren't born that way. You were born with a strong predisposition to learn a language. Strong. But which one you learn depends on what you were exposed to. And you did participate in learning English. Not in any way that somebody would have said was a choice. So born that way and shows it. A third approach was that it is a mental illness. That there's something in your past, that it's a symptom of past traumas or past difficulties. I'm not saying that could never be the case, but I've had lots of clients who I think were more mentally healthy than I was. I think that it's n it's that there's that's far from always the case, or even predominantly the case. Do people who struggle with issues of same sex attraction have mental health issues? Sure, because most people do. Most people do to some degree. So born that way chose it.
speaker-0: Now is real quick as we're p going through these five, is this specifically just with same sex attraction? Do you also apply these five to gender dysphoria?
speaker-1: that's a whole nother thing. Gender dysphoria is more complex. but and and I think people are coming around to understand the the role of social contagion in gender dysphoria. I think they're a long way from understanding s social contagion and same sex attraction.
speaker-0: So so so probably different issues right now. You're these five are what you typically talk about with with same sex attraction.
speaker-1: Yeah, and and gender dysphoria people aren't even asking the questions. You know? Yeah. Yeah. So a a a fourth approach to cause is the cause doesn't matter. It it often goes with it's so complex that we'll never really know, so what really matters is how you respond to it.
speaker-0: Okay, so just throwing out any so interesting
speaker-1: Yep. So you're just gonna live with it and maybe in the next life it'll be taken away or something like that. You can just hold on a white knucklet for seventy or eighty years, things will be good. You know, kind of thing. And so so but all of those affect how somebody responds. If I if every time I find myself attracted to the same gender, I I think, boy, this is a an indication of my biological base reality, that will affect how I respond to it. If I think, man, I have chosen this, I'm just an evil person. If I was just repent thoroughly enough, I could make this go away because I'm clearly it choosing it. Boy, that's gonna respond ch change how you respond to it. If you think, boy, I'm broken inside, man, I'm I have deep mental health issues because they have got the symptoms, so I must have the disease. That's gonna respond how you change how you respond to it. So it matters. It matters a lot.
speaker-0: What was number five?
speaker-1: Number five is the one I want to sell people on.
speaker-0: this is the g this is the so there's four bad ones and there's a fifth one that you're proposing here.
speaker-1: I might not use that language exactly, but yeah. So the
speaker-0: So here we go.
speaker-1: fifth one, and this is the one I w I tell clients, I'm gonna try to sell you on this idea. That same sex attraction is just something you know how to do. It is only something you know how to do. It is simply something you know how to do. It is nothing but something you know how to do. I don't think people are born gay, but they're not born straight either. All sexuality, I think, is learned and is something we know how to do. And if you look cross-culturally at how cultures affect people in their sexuality, that seems pretty apparent. Something you know how to do. Now there's good news and bad news about that. And when I talk to clients And and things go really well for them, they say that idea was the most powerful and important idea that we talked about. That it is something you know how to do. When they have a thought come into mind, a fantasy, they have a dream, they
have something else. That's something I know how to do. It's not a symptom of something else. It's not a symptom of biology or psychology or wickedness. It's something I know how to do.
speaker-0: So that is this right powerful because it's removing shame around it and it's just like, No, this is just a thing. We're just kind of being aware of it at this point. Or
speaker-1: I think there's some I think there's something about res removing shame, but it is also dealing with it truthfully. See there's good news and bad news. If it's something I know how to do, I'm not gonna get amnesia. I'll always know how to do it. But it doesn't matter all that much. It is something that I'm doing, and I can learn more and more ways to not do that. It's again, we go back to the language acquisition idea. I don't have a lot of choice in what language I speak, but I could choose to learn another language. I could choose to be I could choose to live my whole life in another language. So I I tell people if I if I wanted to learn Spanish because somebody offered me a huge job in Spain. And so I go and I just immerse myself in Spanish. I've been there for a couple of years. Now I'm speaking Spanish, I'm I'm I'm I I'm making friends in Spanish, I'm employed in Spanish. And I'll ask them these questions. How long before I forget how to speak English? Well never. How long before English words or phrases never pop into my mind? Never. How long before my Spanish is every bit as good or better than my English ever was? Probably never. Probably never. In my quest to learn Spanish, how important are those three questions? When will I forget English? When will English phrases and words never puff into my mind? When will my Spanish be as good or better than my English? Those aren't important. The only important question is how long before my Spanish is good enough? For me to get on with my life and do what I need to do and want to do in Spanish. So I talk to return missionaries all the time who say they were speaking in their mission language. Not speaking, they were thinking. Dreaming. They were thinking. They were dreaming and thinking in their mission language. And I said, Did you forget how to speak English? No. What do you speak better? Spanish or English? English. But I was living my life in Spanish. Living my life in Spanish. So when you tell somebody it's something you know how to do, then they know what to expect. If they think I'm going to get cured of this, it's incurable because it's biology. Or I'm going to repent of it and it'll go away. Or boy, I'm broken inside with enough psychotherapy, I'll be fixed. Right. They have they have expectations that are not going to be fulfilled and they're gonna f again, shame, hopelessness, despair. But if they understand what this is, then they understand steps in how to deal with it. How to deal with it.
speaker-0: It still seems like this solution and I understand why it's effective, but it still seems like we're we're we're
not there's question marks. We still don't know why th someone might experience this.
speaker-1: I can just
speaker-0: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
speaker-1: So that's more that's more than we've got time for right now. There are different ways people acquire this. There's patterns.
speaker-0: Would a little
speaker-1: There's clear patterns. And so I'll just mention first of all, this doesn't spread itself randomly through the population. The the traits that guys who are more so sensitive to subsep susceptible to same sex attraction, they tend to be unusually emotionally sensitive. They tell me I always got my feelings hurt more easily, I cried more easily, I was more tenderhearted, I had more sympathy or empathy for people or animals that are suffering. They're just sensitive. Second, they're unusually introspective or self-analytical. They say, people tell me I think too much. I think myself into circles, I think myself into knots. I'm constantly trying to figure myself out. And they have an unusually strong sense of right and wrong and a desire to be right. And I use that very broadly to to be good, to be right, to be righteous, to be talented, to be worthy, to be helpful, to get things right. It's broader than what we generally think of as perfectionism.
speaker-0: Okay.
speaker-1: Very, very broad, and it might be different with different guys, but but but sensitivity, introspection, and wanting to be good. Those three things, which are positive traits. set someone up. Because first of all, they hear about chastity when they're young. Eight, nine, ten years old, and they say, I'm not going think thoughts about not going to think sexual thoughts about girls. Where most of us were going, why? Why not? W why? What's going on? Actually, and so but they go, okay, I'm not going to think that way. That's one pattern. But another pattern is when I was young I felt different from or rejected by other men. And as a result of that, I was very focused on other men. I was envious of them. I longed for a connection with them. I was curious about them. I hit puberty. I'm starting to get aroused really easily. And I'm super focused on these other guys. And this arousal is highly programmable. And and pretty soon I find myself that I'm starting to get aroused by men. When that happens, five things happen over focus and overinterpretation. Becomes the biggest thing in my life. I worry about it, I wonder about it. I I I wonder how bad I've got it. I wonder if people can tell, I wonder if it's going to go away. I wonder if I'm evil. I wonder if God says I wonder and think and wonder until finally you could say, over here's the fact I get aroused by guys, here's everything else in my life. As far as the amount of worry or concern I have about things, this one thing outweighs every other thing in my life combined. Second thing, self-loathing. I wanted to be perfect. I want to have my calling election made sure before I left on my mission just to get that taken care of. And now I've got the worst thing you can have. This is disgusting. I am disgusting. Third thing, isolation and secrecy. No one must know about this. I've got to hide it. I can't tell anyone. Some guys look a little withdrawn. Most guys become what I call world-class fakers. They're walking down the hall of school giving high fives to people and laughing and joking with people, and you ask their bishop. How's that kid doing? Ugh We wish we had a dozen kids like him. Why can't other kids be like this kid? And no one knows the hell that this kid is walking around with in his life every every day. Fourth thing that happens, compulsive sexual behaviors. Now that's not exclusive to guys with same-sex attraction. Most guys dabble in some sexual addiction. Most men really do growing up. But for this guy who's really sensitive And self-analytical, these emotional pains are very painful and he wants them to go away. And he knows if I just fantasize it will medicate this pain. So I practice and practice and practice. So I ask clients all the time, if you'd spent as much time practicing the piano as you spent thinking sexual thoughts about other guys in the last ten years, how good a pianist would you be? They just laugh. I'd be performing all over the world. So I say So we practice and practice and practice and practice and then say, Where are these feelings coming from? Well you've been practicing, you've been practicing, you know. And the fifth thing that happens is spiritual and religious turmoil. Some people become uber religious. If I'm just righteous enough I will bind the Lord and he will have to answer my prayers. Some people become cynical and doubt, some people vacillate back and forth, but it's painful. Spiritual and religiously is painful. So those five things over focus, overinterpretation, self loathing, isolation secrecy, compulsive sexuality, and spiritual and religious turmoil. Now when I say those to clients, the great majority of them are saying, You just described my life. You just destroyed my life. Now, how specifically that that winds up happening, it might be different for different people. That's kind of an overarching pattern. Sure. It's it's different for different guys in different ways, but those those elements seem to be fairly universal. Fairly universal.
speaker-0: It it seems as though many of those though can apply across the board to someone who's straight but also struggling with just perfectionism or mental health, is that right?
speaker-1: Absolutely, absolutely. No no doubt. This isn't vastly different than any other thing people deal with. Absolutely it came. And and does. So certainly those kinds of feelings and those kinds of things are not completely unique to some of the things like Christian. But I will say with those personality characteristics, it tends to be more intense. Intense and more difficult.
speaker-0: Guys, I interrupt real quickly because this channel, it's small, it's self-funded, but you can help
us make a bigger impact. The biggest thing you can do, it's free. You click that subscribe button down below, and that'll show this channel to more people. But after that, if you'd like to support further, you can visit our link in the description where you'll find LDS kids books, gifts, resources, music, and the other projects that we're involved in. Thanks so much for watching. Back to the video. Andrew, going back to you here, are you a fan of the office? Seen the office? You know, I the first three seasons came out before my mission. So I seen
speaker-1: Okay.
speaker-0: those, but then after my mission, I didn't really there's a scene where Michael says, Okay, explain it to me like I'm five. Okay, explain it to like I'm three. And he just keeps counting down, right? he's he's younger and younger. So I I'm curious. as a as a seminary teacher, you you're someone interacting with people who have questions on this all the time as well. some of them might be gay, but they're not in your office, you know, seeking treatment. Some of them might just be people who are in a worldview that is much more open to LGBTQ questions, discussions, issues. So so my question is how does this method or this understanding, how does this help you answer those questions? Honestly, like we have really good tools, which is the doctoral mastery, the Almost weekly I'm giving kids scenarios where they have to like go to a whiteboard and identify, okay, here's someone's question. I want you to identify their assumptions in the scenario. What are their underlying assumptions? So I'm training them some critical thinking. And then I want you to reframe those assumptions using like doctrines, truths that you know that would that would help in that scenario. so hopefully I've trained them by the time we get to this, we can go, they have some some scaffolding to to go, okay. We're identify some assumptions here. And there's assumptions about how do people belong, how do they fit into the church? There's assumptions about cause. And I think that when you help them see that we don't know and the church does not teach, Elder Holland was really big on it, like President Oakes has has talked about. We don't we do not know what causes this. President Oakes said it'd be more helpful to consider it as a what he he called it a it's an adjective that describes something you do or you feel, not something that you are. President Oak said that back in two thousand six. I'm paraphrasing. Say that again. Say that again. That's good. Well, he gave a press interview in two thousand six and he said I'm paraphrasing because it's better it'd be more helpful to think of it as something that you as as an adjective, something that you feel or something you do and not something that you are. Okay. And when you combine that with President Nelson who talked about Yeah. Identity, yeah. Yeah. And so can we do can we do the pen thing or you wanna does that help or
speaker-1: Well one thing I I'd say is Yeah, go ahead notice a contrast between Andrew and my thing. I just described how I think it happens.
speaker-0: I can't do that in seminary.
speaker-1: He can't he can't do that in seminary. So he he's pulling weeds. I can pull weeds and plant a few vegetables. He's clearing ground. He's taking away s let's question these assumptions. Do we really know this much? I'm happy.
speaker-0: Because because Andrew Andrew is teaching from this is kind of church doctrine what we know, and you're teaching from as that plus maybe what we know in the in the studies and things. Is that correct?
speaker-1: Yeah, much of what I'm saying developed from my doctoral dissertation.
speaker-0: Okay. And thirty years of practice and
speaker-1: 30 years of practice and and and and saying, okay, my my doctoral dissertation was the question of can people change? And so I interviewed seven guys who said they had changed, did an analysis of the interview transcripts. But what was striking, and all those things I just described to you came from that and from from practice. But what was striking is all of them said, I could still do it. I could still do it. And at first I was disappointed, like, well, you can still do it. I thought you'd changed. You know, no, I can still do it. I just don't need to anymore. I just don't do it anymore. Like I still could. And and it dawned on me, okay. This isn't this isn't something that that's a symptom of some underlying thing that gets fixed. It's just something you know how to do. And that's all it is. It's something you know how to
speaker-0: Same.
speaker-1: do. And a lot of what you do springs from that.
speaker-0: So it's not an identity thing, it's not something you're tied to forever. It's not something to be guilty of because you've done something wrong. It's just something that you've learned how to do, something you know how to do. And that means you can change. But it also means you'll ne you may never forget how to do it. Is that is that kind of the approach?
speaker-1: Absolutely. Okay. You'll never forget how to do it, but that's okay. So what I know I know how to do lots of stupid things that don't make me happy or that don't fit with my values, that aren't who I want to be, but I still know how to do Okay. So but that in sensitive, introspective, sort of perfectionistic person is relieved like, okay. All right. It's not just a matter I haven't repented enough. Okay, it's not just a matter that that my biology is unalterable. It's not just a matter you know, that that I I was I was traumatized as a kid. It's just something I know how to do. And that's a great relief to them.
speaker-0: Now I imagine anything surrounding LGBT issues get y you're gonna have a lot of pushback whenever you have a stance on anything. what's your biggest pushback from inside the church that you've noticed as you teach this way? Are you talking to me or I'm sorry, I was talking to Jeff, but but I do do you get people who are like, Well, that's
wrong because you know, d do you get members with pushback?
speaker-1: not a lot. Okay not a lot because because it makes sense to them. If I if I was gonna get pushback I've had I've had various institute teachers or seminary teachers want to invite me to speak and the directors say, No way. We're not touching this.
speaker-0: No way. Because they see this as a solution because they get these questions all the time and it makes sense to them.
speaker-1: N no, th they w don't want anything to do with me.
speaker-0: Well the d and then the directors say, No, we can't. We can't.
speaker-1: Not really touch that. They will have they will have people who openly declare that they are gay and have written books and had books published by Deseret Book give devotionals and speak on campus all they want. And many of them wind up saying the church is wrong or implying that the church is wrong. But but because of where they're published, and because at the time they're sort of kind of supportive of I'm gonna keep the commandments, I guess, for as long as I can. Come give a come give a a firesight for us. But somebody comes along and says, I got a different way of looking at this that that might be a solution. my no, we can't touch that. We can't wait into that. So if that was gonna be
speaker-0: How many with how many years of clinical practice and and service lifelong service in the church?
speaker-1: That's that's probably where I that's probably where I get pushback.
speaker-0: Wow. And then okay, well tell me about the the other side. So people who are not religious, what what's the pushback you get?
speaker-1: I generally don't see people who are not religious.
speaker-0: Okay. Okay. Because and because the I mean y this isn't something that that you've published far and wide and necessarily contended too much with on that. Okay. No.
speaker-1: I haven't I haven't no. And and so mostly I think I get some grumbling online. I'd never look at it. I've people have told me I get some grumbling online, but mostly people want to just leave me alone. What and that's fine. I want to be left alone.
speaker-0: But the non religious part, your your academic the the academic LGBT sphere is in like like the Lisa Diamond TED Talk. L Lisa Diamond is what you wanna go ahead.
speaker-1: So so what I'm saying here falls in academically it falls into this a social constructionist perspective. And there are there are strong, strong in fact, queer theory and gay theory leans heavily social constructionist. So a lot of the chief theorists in the gay world are are saying, No, people aren't born that way. This is but but it's okay for them to be whatever they choose to be, whatever they want to be. And so they're actually ahead of the general population. in looking at start with you know Michael Foucault and and others. So I'm not I'm not way out in in in la la land academically. but it it's never been applied for, okay, so you don't want this to be your life, what can you do?
It's generally applied to, well, since everything is socially constructed, you you get to choose anything you want and people have to respect it. Okay, fair enough. Fair enough. I I would I would say this. C. S. Lewis talked about people who say that we're the world is progressing morally, that we're becoming more and more moral. And the example they give is that five hundred years ago we used to burn witches at the stake. And Lewis answers and says, Isn't that 'cause we don't believe in witches? Is it really moral progress or understanding? If we really felt like there were people in league with the devil and the only way to save their souls and the souls of all the people they captured was the brim of the sea, we might still do that. We just don't believe that anymore. As far as ethical or moral arguments go, I don't have I don't have an issue with the ethical or moral arguments with people who say we should respect people who who get said I I have I have a factual disagreement. If there really are an entire category of people that are innately born with same sex attraction and it's and it's it it can never be changed or altered in any way, nothing else could be learned, and the only way they'll ever have happiness in this life is bonding with a same sex sexual partner. If that really was the truth, it would be really hard to defend the church's position. Really hard. I'm not saying it couldn't be done, but man it would be an uphill battle. It'll be an uphill battle. I just don't think that's true. I just don't think that's the truth.
speaker-0: There's yeah, I mean there's plenty of people who this this is their biggest struggle. They grapple with this for years. and and in thinking that they're defending the church's or that they're they're trying to reconcile the church's stance when maybe they just have the church's stance wrong because we don't know. Is that is that fair to say? Like we we're we're looking at the the problem wrong?
speaker-1: I I think we are. I don't think the church the church wisely avoids waiting into these debates because it's a good place to get burned. I think the church in in years past has sided with various factions in various kinds of controversial issues and have wound up getting a bloody nose. So I have clients who say, Why doesn't the church teach this? Why doesn't the church teach this? And I say, That's not my their job. That's my job. It's not their job. It's not what they're supposed to be doing. It's my job. And so if what I'm saying is helpful to you, great. I'm glad that it's helpful to you. But I'm not going to blame the church for not wading in and taking sides on this very controversial and difficult subject. I can do that. I can do it's kind of like podcasters. You any podcasters?
speaker-0: Yeah.
speaker-1: They can they can wade in and really draw a sword and go to battle in ways that the church cannot and should not do. But I'm guessing that many people in the church are appreciative of that. Of
the of the backup that they're getting, you know? So
speaker-0: So so Andrew, do you got yeah, I mean anything to say here just for ideas. Do you mean the Michael Scott version? If I gotta say it's really Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Dumb it down. So just the sexual fluidity, the idea which is what which is what the academic LGBT community is pushing, can't happen if there's genetic predetermin if s if sexuality is fluid, i is one argument. But but then we're saying no, it's fixed, you're born that way. Well then that the those two cannot be true at the same time. Does that make sense? So that would that's how I would how how does how does like what my dad is saying fit into the academic sphere, the secular sphere? It's fixed genetic. Right. Versus if you really believe sexual flu fluidity Which is what the academics are are pushing. The pro LGBT yeah.
speaker-1: I think I think fewer and fewer academics are ever saying born that way. Yeah. They don't that there's really not a a that's really not a firm ground to stand on anymore. Okay. There's been so many studies and so many, you know, studies that just show being the like I said, even the American Psychological Association would which would I think love to be able to say that, won't won't say that. So I don't think born that way is but in j in the general popul again it's back to we've been cheating for fifty years
speaker-0: We're gonna start cheering.
speaker-1: Cheating but we're gonna keep all the points we're in while we were cheating. Everyone knows that
speaker-0: Here we go.
speaker-1: people are are that's who they are, that's the way made God made them, that's who they really truly are. And and so it it's an implication that sort of hangs there.
speaker-0: You're challenging the false dichotomy of of those to either you're born this way or you choose your sexuality.
speaker-1: I would call it a trichotomy, born that way, choose it, or it's a symptom of mental illness.
speaker-0: Yeah. And that's that's I unfortunately I think that one was strong in the church for a very long time. It's either
speaker-1: Yes.
speaker-0: sin that you're choosing or you're mentally ill.
speaker-1: And you need treatment.
speaker-0: And you need treatment. Yeah.
speaker-1: And so that's one of the places I was talking about. The church in the past has taken a stance or leaned towards something and gotten burned by it. So I don't blame them for leaving alone now. I would too if I was the church.
speaker-0: Sure. Well and from from my experience, I I I don't know history well enough for the the to talk about the church proper in this, but I'm just saying in congregations growing up, leader, friends, family, like that that's the message I would hear from the the lay member.
speaker-1: were those two. Mental illness had its heyday. All of these had their heyday. Yeah. Yeah. All of these had their time when they were the most popular they all float around in various degrees in various ways now. But there were times when it was, you know, i that's just wicked people who have to repent. no they were born that way. no it's a mental illness. no they were b you know all this that's floating around. And they all influence people without them knowing. Worldviews are very subtle, right? World views we don't know we have them. It's it's the water we swim in, the fish doesn't know he's wet. You know? Let me let me give you one example that I think you'd find interesting. So I'll I'll ask I ask all my clients this question at some point. I'll say, imagine you grew up in the same world that you did grow up in. You had the same parents, same siblings, same church, same school, same friends, same neighborhood. You're the same person. Everything in your world is exactly the same, except one thing. One thing is different. That one thing is that in the world you grew up in there was no such thing as same sex attraction. You had never heard the word homosexual. The word gay only meant happy. Nobody got teased or made fun of or called gay or fag or queer when they were growing up. I've lost count on how many clients said so many people told me I was, I wondered if I was. You know? Nobody got made fun of. Nobody whispered a gossip about who's gay and who's not. Nobody came out of the closet and declared they were gay. There were no gay characters in television shows or movies. There was no same sex marriage debate, no discussion about it at church. Just didn't exist. Didn't exist. Any sexual fantasy you had about another person, you'd have to invent it entirely on your own. Never having seen it in pornography or heard it discussed in any way, shape, or form. So I'll say if you grew up in that kind of world, how much of a problem would you have with this issue with same sex attraction? I want to ask them that over two thirds of them will say think for a minute, I'll say, I don't think I'd have any problem. A f around a third, less than a third, would say, I still might, but it would be seventy, eighty, ninety percent less than it was. And I'll say the degree to which that is true is a degree to which this is a cultural phenomenon more than an individual psychological phenomenon. It's
speaker-0: Yeah.
speaker-1: more like being a Democrat or Republican than it is like being black or white. It is
speaker-0: Admitting to the social contagion part of it.
speaker-1: I wouldn't say they're admitting we don't use the phraseology, but as they sit and think about because as I go down that long list of ways that they're exposed to that idea, in their minds they're going, check, check, check, check, check, check, check, check. I got made fun of, I was told this, I saw these characters, I ran into the people who said they were gay, they became my friends, I I this and this and this. I started looking online to check it out and see if I was. I got aroused by that. I I you know On and on and on. They can see how this built up in their life, how they learned how to do this. And now that
they know how to do it, the bad news is you're not going get amnesia. You're not going to get amnesia. It's something that you know how to do. Something you know how to do. And that's okay. if something you know how to do implies that The idea is sexuality, whether it's homosexuality or heterosexuality or any form, is it something that comes after us? Or is it something we go after? There are certain things in your life that come after you. Hunger. If you stop eating, you get hungry enough, people will eat anything. They'll eat shoe leather, they'll eat each other. Thirst, fatigue, being tired. You you cannot put these things off indefinitely. They will come after you and clobber you. Is sex one of those things? Or is it something we go after? Well, I think it's something we know how to do, therefore the implication is we're doing it. We're doing it. It can be so easy to go after that it feels like it's coming after us. My my biggest piece of evidence that it's something that we go after is and that it's not. some innate need that comes after us is that it can be distracted from indefinitely. Without negative effect. Guys go on missions, not all of us who went on missions, but many people on missions hardly dabble into sexuality at all for two years during the prime of their sexual arousability. And for two years they're distracted from it largely. Completely some more than others. But if it was really this this innate appetite that was necessary, it could not be distracted from. Like these other things like hunger and thirst and fatigue, it would come after you.
speaker-0: How is this different than than choosing? Right? It's something we it doesn't go after us, so we choose to do it.
speaker-1: Well, okay, that that opens a huge can of worms that that gets into theology and agency and all kinds of things that we don't have time to go into right now, but but it goes th that that's a great question. That's a great question. Everything we do is not something we chose to do. Every thought we have isn't something we chose to have. It just because we're doing it doesn't mean we're choosing fully, agentatively choosing to do it. And it's an actual it's a conversation. I have a good hour or longer conversation I have with every client about the limitations of agency, because if they believe that they are completely morally responsible for every thought, feeling, and action they've had since noon on their eighth birthday. That's overwhelming. And these are guys who are sensitive, self analytical, and would like to be really, really good. And to give them a little bit of relief and say, Come on, man, y you didn't choose this, and you can't choose to just never do it again. You've tried that, remember? You've tried that again and again, it didn't work, right? So sorry that's not gonna work. So it's very different than choosing as far as agentative choice. Just because it's something I doing does not mean it's something I'm choosing.
speaker-0: Well c just
Michael Scott for a second. Yep, help me out. I was with you until this part. Now I'm now I'm I'm wavering here. That's what
speaker-1: Well you see that's an hour long discussion.
speaker-0: Well you're talking about a need versus an appetite. Well, you have appetites for food. What appetites you have are totally a result of your culture. So y y if I go I d I'm not big into I I developed a better taste for seafood when I went on my mission in Brazil and I got served fish all the time. I developed a taste for fish. But that's but I have a there's a difference between appetite and the need, right? So food is just an example. 'Cause we I think your question was like We're we're merging on where is where does agency factor in? It seems as though you're you're tr talking in language that sounds like, well, it's not a need that chases after you, it's something we choose to do instead. and then it's like, wait, I thought we were against that one. Well, we are because it's not something that you you don't choose everything. Some things are needs that chase after you. And so I'm I'm I'm now grappling with
speaker-1: With that part. I didn't put it. You
speaker-0: You didn't put it. You didn't I added it back in, but that's it's that's what it sounded like to me. It sounded like the same discussion, just a different word. You heard it wrong. Okay.
speaker-1: 'Cause just something I'm doing doesn't mean something I've chosen to do. People have people don't have unlimited agency. You know, it's interesting, I hear Elder Bednar is always careful when he says, you know, we we are we are things that act, not simply things that are acted upon. Now he's careful in his language. That means we are things that are acted upon. We're not just things that act. So So when it comes to agency, if you get if you get a really good solid atheist, really you know, one of the one of the n one of the the four horsemen of the placards, the new atheists that now old, you know, Sam Harris will say there is no free will. There's no free will. If you get an old school Latter day Saint, which there aren't a lot left, but he'll they'll say there's no nature and nurture, it's all agency. Well, neither one of those are true. Neither one of those are true. So we all learn in psychology, you know, about nature and nurture. And in psychology, nature, our bodies, our genetics, and nurture our environment are supposed to explain everything. Then religious people will will add in free will. Free will. So they have a third variable. But none of them are domin c completely dominant. None of them certainly, certainly our biology affects our range. So the doctrine of covenants, the Lord says All truth is free to act in that sphere in which God has placed it. Our sphere includes our biology, our environment. We're not free to act outside the sphere in which we're placed. We're not free to think thoughts that we've never learned to think. We're not free to view things in ways that we've never learned to view them. We're not free to have any mood we want, any time we want. We're not free to have a hundred percent control over our thinking. And so there are such things as OCD and addictions and cultural norms and assumptions and all kinds of things that shove us around all over the place. So it's very important to say if it's something you're doing, it's not something you necessarily chose, but if it's something you're doing, you we might be able to help you learn how to do other things that fit better for your values and your beliefs.
speaker-0: Right. Okay. Okay. I think you walked me off a ledge there. No, I I think I get what you're saying here. It it it is difficult because even I, as we're talking and we've spent, you know, forty minutes talking about it, I start to see is it back in that false dichotomy? It's either this or this.
speaker-1: Yeah, we drift into that so easily.
speaker-0: That's so interesting.
speaker-1: Which is why, like e every client I talk with, we have to sit down and have several discussions about agency. Because they overestimate their agency. They want to take complete responsibility for everything they like I said, they've thought, felt, or done since they were noon on their eighth birthday was their fault. Because now I'm accountable. Well, accountability progresses slowly. It doesn't happen all at once. You know, it progresses slowly. And so that's very important for them to know because i again, if they're if they're assuming that I'm responsible for everything I think, feel or f or do, man. Now, well we get into sin transcription as we get into that.
speaker-0: All right, Andrew. Well, take us home here. if there are if there are parents, church leaders, people with with questions on this, and they want to know more about the the this way of viewing it, how do you recommend they they put it into words? How do you recommend they learn more? Well, I think I mean as far as resources, you can link the paper in the in the Footnote show notes if you want. You can you're welcome to link the paper, link my dad's Fair Mormon talk. I think does a really good job. as far as what I if I'm having a conversation with a kid, I want them to identify their assumptions. Stephen Harper gave a great BYU devotional and we talked about being metacognizant about your how how you know your your epistemology. and and he just The idea is just I if kiss says why are they born that way? And like how do you know that they're born that way? Well everybody knows that. Well, how do you know? Someone's born right? And and getting them just to question the assumption. I don't do I can't do all the things in a seminary classroom that my dad does, obviously, because I will only teach what's like purely in the script I have to be able to cite it in the scriptures or with the brethren. If I if I can't do that, I'm not pointing patterns out to kids and things like that. I'm strictly w what with what they've said, but they haven't So my
job is, my dad mentioned this before, is I'm just assumptions are like weeds. And a kid w might think, well, the come to the conclusion the church is not fair, the church because well, how how could they expect this of somebody? And if I can I help them identify their assumptions and pull those weeds, that gives possibility for other things to grow there. because that's all I'm doing is try to clear that ground and and plant some seeds of faith. Talk about Your identity and as a child of God, child of the covenant, a disciple of Jesus Christ and and things like that. There's we get I in fact today we were in Isaiah and and we were talking about LGBT questions came up and we used Isaiah to Isaiah does a that's a whole nother episode, but you you can use the scriptures and the words of the prophets to help reframe those those assumptions. But identifying them as assumptions is half the battle. So awesome. Okay. and Jeff, anything any last thoughts here as we close up here?
speaker-1: well as far as resources go, I think that that that Fair Mormon presentation from four or five years ago is a good one. That
speaker-0: We'll link we'll link both of these in the description for sure. It's up to the paper.
speaker-1: That article that article has already been watered down significantly over the last few years. There was a earlier version that had a lot of what I've just been describing in it and slowly through edit you know, reviews and edits you gotta take this out, you gotta take that out, you gotta take this out until probably
speaker-0: With who who's who's who's the editor here?
speaker-1: Well, don't want to talk about that, do we?
speaker-0: okay. All right. All right. Because he's a power the powers
speaker-1: Yeah.
speaker-0: that be
speaker-1: The po the po the powers of me. And there are good people who are working under a lot of constraints and a lot of difficulties trying to trying to satisfy a lot of people and not
speaker-0: A lot of bureaucracy, we might say. Okay.
speaker-1: Yeah. So so a lot of there are a lot of good people. I'm not blaming anyone for for for not being ab we just finally reached an impasse where no any further any further editing is there's gonna be so little left of it. I also have a website called the Guardrail, theguardrail dot com. And it it it has a I think eighteen page paper that I wrote about this many years ago.
speaker-0: That's the uncensored version.
speaker-1: s sort of. It make it make a good companion piece to the to the Fair Mormon article. The Fair Mormon talk. It give a bit overview, yeah.
speaker-0: Great. Yep. Well, thank you. I'm glad you guys reached out to me. I think this will be interesting to the audience. you're welcome to come back on too, as we we might have audience questions or or further when the paper gets published. Let's let's have you back. This is this is helpful. So appreciate what you're doing. Cool,
speaker-1: Thanks Austin. Thanks Austin.
speaker-0: cool. Thanks so much for watching. And I have an exciting announcement. I have a new kid show called Brother Sunbeam on YouTube, and soon to be YouTube for kids. In this show, it's gonna be like Latter day Saint. Singing time in in a way that kids can understand and feel. We're being very true with doctrine, bold about doctrine, but think of it as a mix between maybe a Mr. Rogers, a Steve from Blues Clues, maybe a blippy. It shouldn't be too much dopamine overload, but the most important thing is that we are teaching doctrine to kids and just trying to provide a clean, happy, healthy, Latter-day Saints source for media. For young kids. So feel free to follow along over at Brother Sunbing and thank you so much for your support.
speaker-2: you