رونوشت 🔗
George: All right. We are back on Boreas Podcast and as per many of you were request we are keeping up with the Jones. I mean of course Doctor E. Michael Jones. Doctor Jones, welcome back.
E. Michael Jones: George, good to be here.
George: I counted it. this is our seventh episode. It's turning into a mini-series. pr yeah. so for those of you still need introduction, Dr. Jones is a prolific Catholic writer. You can find his books and order them on FidelityPress dot org or is it dot com.
E. Michael Jones: FidelityPress dot org or the magazine Culture Wars at CultureWars dot com.
George: There you have it. the magazine is a monthly subscription. I have it, a lot of very informative stuff. So previously we've done we kind of make each episode centered around one of Dr. Jones' books. this latest one that I want to talk about that I read through is called Degenerate Moderns: Modernity as Rationalized Sexual Misbehavior. Believe it was published in 1993. So one of the Earlier works, perhaps. anyway, the unifying argument, which I take it from the book is that intellectuals, this is a quote from Dr. Jones from book, the unifying or the the argument or that intellectuals face a fundamental choice, conform their desires to truth, or conform truth to their desires. So Dr. Jones argues that many defining theories of modernity. exemplify the latter, conforming truth to desires. there are I think about nine chapters. I think each one of them can be a book. even though it's kind of a short book. And I don't know how far we're gonna go into, but let's get into them one by one, Dr. Jones. The first one is Samoa Lost and it's about Margaret Mead. I believe this is anthropologist who went to Samoa to debunk the sexual morse of the West to show us how people in quote unquote noble savage societies are liberated from all the oppressive sexual rules that we that we have. And things didn't turn out quite as she imagined, even though she duped a lot of people, didn't she?
E. Michael Jones: She was so she w she came from a the the anthropology school founded by Franz Boas, and this was the environmental school, and it was at odds with the racial school, which was probably the predominant psych predominant school of anthropology at that point. So it comes down to is it nurture or nature? Is it Are you bound by your genes or are you bound by your environment? This is the conflict that she entered in. And so other part another part of it is this whole as you said, the noble savage story, the story of what is man and the state of nature. that had created created by Rousseau in the French during the French Revolution. The idea that Freud was saying that basically civilization represses your desires your desires, talking about guilt. Is guilt natural? Does it is is there an objective reality to guilt, or is it just something psychological that's based on conditioning that you've had as a child? All this type of stuff enters into this discussion that Margaret Mead created. Now, the book became a kind of bestseller, and it it was very popular when I was a student in In the nineteen sixties. I was in college during the nineteen sixties in in America. And it it tried to give a basically a scientific veneer to something that was basically a fantasy. A fantasy that was actually sh a shared cultural fantasy that a lot of people subscribe to because they had read Rousseau. Rousseau was a good example of it, you know. May man is free. You're born free, but everywhere man is in chains. that was kind of the premise. And if you went to Tahiti, you would be free. So he's not the only guy. Gauguin did it. Gauguin went there and shacked up with this young Polynesian girl. And this is going to be the paradise of sexual liberation. And he's there one moment there, and the girl is looking out the window, and all the Polynesian girls are going to church. Ha ha! And they all have white dresses on. And so his teenage mistress turns to him with Gogan and says, Can you get me a white dress so that I can go to church? So it kind of blew up the whole idea. So there was a what happened, Margaret Meade became famous as a kind of guru for the sexually liberated. And then there was a
George: Mm-hmm.
E. Michael Jones: an Australian anthropologist by the name of I think it was Derek Freeman. Is that the right name? anyway, yeah, whatever
George: maybe. Yeah.
E. Michael Jones: it was, he decided that he knew something about Polynesia. He's living down in that neck of the woods, and he decided to go there. And it turns out that everything she said was was false. Everything. She made it up, basically. She didn't speak the language. She stayed in one compound the entire time. She just made it up. so as I said, or as you said, You have two options. You either subordinate your desires to the truth, or you subordinate the truth to your desires. And what we found now is, well, what was Margaret Mead doing at this time? Well, she had just committed adultery. She was having an affair with Edward Saper, another anthropologist, famous anthropologist. And then when she went to Samoa, she dragged her guilty conscience with her. You can't escape the conscience. You know, it's inside of you. so she dragged it there and she projected it onto the Samoans and said that, you know, basically it's there was a movie, famous movie called Blue Lagoon. so it was like Blue Lagoon Lagoon anthropology, where you kind of your airplane crashes and you end up on the island and you're free of all these inhibitions. It happened to a number of people. It happened to Nathaniel Hawthorne, who was on a whaling ship. In the Pacific, and he jumped ship and he he spent some time in the Marquises. And he had his own little paradise there where you don't have to really work much. And had a little native girl that became his mistress, and he suddenly got tired of it. So that was a different story. but Margaret Mead said, Well, you know, in the state of nature, there's no such thing as
Load full transcript
guilt. And these people have sexual relations and they don't feel guilty about them if they're not married. Well, was completely false. They are what Freeman said is that the man there, if their sister is seen sitting under a palm tree with some a guy that they don't know, he will go over and beat the guy up because you're not allowed to sit with my sister under a palm tree unless you have the approval of my parents. So it's completely different. and it caused a shock to Academia because Margaret Mead was one of the heroines of of Academ, along with Ruth Benedict, who was her friend. And Ruth Benedict was a lesbian. And so she had some type of investment in this whole thing. And it was a shock. And basically what Academ did was pretend that it never happened. I don't think they they just pretended, that's some crazy Australian. And then they just kept on promoting Margaret Mead as if nothing happened.
George: Right. Yeah, th th there's I think well the tourism industry still runs on this, still sells this idea that if you escape the tropical beach you're gonna enter a sex sexual paradise. white people, right, Europeans, maybe North Americans to a lesser extent, but the Europeans, Michelle Walbeck writes about it, you know, they work like slaves and then they can't wait to hop on that airplane and fly off to some exotic island. And the whole thing is sold as well, sexual paradise and l there's a lot of sex tourism. Sex tourism too, yeah.
E. Michael Jones: Sex tourism. There's sex t sex tourism. Yeah, Bangkok.
George: Yeah. right. So you know, this this idea of trying to invent some exotic society where sexual mores no longer apply has a long history. I want to read you a quote from James Fraser, Golden Bow, right? you're familiar with this book, I think you reference it a lot. this book was written in the eighteen nineties, and to me this book's project was to It was the first book of what's called later a comparative religion. We're gonna compare all these archaic religions. And Frasier's goal was basically to at least side goal was to discredit Christianity or to show that Christianity is just another Dionysus myth. I think Renier Gerard d the does an amazing job of discrediting Frasier, but that's maybe another topic. But there's one quote from Fraser that I think is really relevant here, and I'll read it to you. It says The old notion that the savage is the freest of mankind is the reverse of the truth. He is a slave, not indeed to a visible master, but to the past, to the spirits of his dead forefathers who haunt his steps from birth to death and rule him with a rod of iron. So Frasier's basically saying the truth about how these societies are even more oppressive. You write in your book how, in fact, adultery or sexual transgressions in Samoa are much more severely punished punished. And somebody like Girard would trace that to actually something he calls non-policed archaic states. The idea that these societies they did not have a strong rule of law or a police force or judiciary who can adjudicate these sort of transgressions. So if things kinda go go off the rail, if rivalry or conflict happens, society tends to descend into this chaos of endless blood feud and so on. And this is why these societies are paranoid about people breaking even smallest rules and and everything sort of delegated and prescribed. Because they're even afraid of people imitating each other's gestures. He traces all of this to the idea that you know, even a smallest offense can lead to an escalation that we as a non-police society with low technology can't stop. So and and then he traces that, that's clearly traced to Christianity, you know, through something like Beatitudes and so on, getting rid of that. would you how would you say that squares with your analysis here? the James Fraser quote and And generally the sexual revolution.
E. Michael Jones: Yeah, sure, sure. a guy named Unwin wrote a book about the sexual mores of primitive people, and he said, the thing that destroys culture is the having sex too too too young. I I think there's something to that. I think we have a the black population in America has a serious, serious problems, illegitimacy, for example. is eighty percent of the so the the children are growing up without fathers. but they also have a very early sexual initiation. And I think if there's sexual i initiation early, you don't have it it it stunts your intellectual development because you unleash the passions at a time when you really haven't formed your personality. And that will stunt the development of of your mind, the ability to have what should I say? enough philosophical distance to to create the right categories. I think causality is a big issue here. I think what you're talking about with taboo is a failure to understand causality. You're not quite sure what's going to cause anything. And you see it in well even in the Greeks who were not I would not say primitive by any any stretch of the imagination. But the story of Iphigenia where
George: Yeah.
E. Michael Jones: the where who who is it is it who is the who is it is it Achilles is someone's who is sailing? They gotta get the the the winds right. Is it Ulysses? I forget now who who's who's the fat Agamemnon. Agamemnon is the father of Iphigenia. And Agamemnon is becomed on an island he has to get to Troy and so he sacrifices his own daughter.
George: All right.
E. Michael Jones: to to to get favorable wins. And he gets favorable wins, but he's committed some type of offense, even though he did it to get the pleasure of the gods. He's done something that he know is wrong. And you got this conflict here between is is my moral state, is my moral consciousness a f a category of the mind or a category of reality? Which is it? I have to do this in y in the Greek tragedy You're damned if you do, and you're damned if you don't. So you have a
George: Right.
E. Michael Jones: an another example would be Hippolytus, where he he
understands that sexuality is a very powerful force. it's like riding a horse. It's like being on a horse. And you have to have control of the horse. that's what his name means. His name is a pun in Greek. So it's to To mount the horse or to be undone by the horse. Luo is comes, we have the word analysis, coming from that can break something down. Which is it? And so Hippolytus spurns the sexual advances of the his mother and his stepmother. She's outraged by being spurned, and she calls the gods down upon him. Well, you're damned if you do. If you had sex with your stepmother, you would offend one God. If you don't have sex, you're gonna offend another God. There's no clear sense of moral causality. And this is a very sophisticated society. Well, I I wouldn't call it primitive, by comparison to to other groups, like the the Yano Mammo in the Brazilian in the Amazon rainforest. Now that's a primitive
George: Yeah.
E. Michael Jones: tribe, okay? And they have a peculiar problem because the government of Brazil doesn't want anybody going near them. It's like similar to do you remember? Do you where Sentinel Island is? You heard about Sentinel Island? Well, don't go there
George: Yeah, yeah. Right.
E. Michael Jones: because they'll kill you. They'll kill you and eat you. And this is exactly so the Yanomamo are very similar. The government has simply said, you're not allowed to go there. And the government is there, sent there to protect them. And the guy who is sent there as the police gets killed and eaten by these people, but they're still not gonna do anything about them. So they're preserving these people in a state of barbarism in which they will never reach maturity. That's not been the Christian attitude. But what I'm saying here is in these primitive cultures, you don't have a a sense of causality and you're not gonna have freedom. I mean Hegel said something very similar to what you just said from Sir James Frazier. You don't have freedom in the state of nature. You're you have bondage to all sorts of forces that you can't control. The only place you can approximate freedom is in civilization. You need the state to have freedom because that will allow you to conform your will to an accurate understanding of necessity, which is. What God's will is.
George: Right. th Greeks, I I think that one of the the mistakes of causation is the idea of scapegoating. So what ties a lot of these pre Christian societies together is that when things go wrong, somebody is to blame and sort of by extension somebody needs to die. So I think that would tie in something like some kind of a cake sacrifice or Agamemnon sacrificing daughter. It's well attested in pr European paganism as well as paganism all over the world that you know no big no big let's say project or adventure or venture can succeed unless you sat pease the gods with some kind of blood blood sacrifice, right? And kind of the more expensive the blood sacrifice is the more these gods may be pleased. So sacrificing one's daughter is pretty high on that list. another thing that these people do, I would the kind of like ritualistic societies is they didn't they tend to have these rituals where they break the taboos. So one of the big mistakes, well, according to Girard at least, is that these the the moderns, right, they would go to some tribe. pre-Christian tribe and they would watch a ritual where people would enjoy where people would engage in breaking the taboos. the most basic one being excessive drinking or any sort of intoxication, also breaking of sexual taboos. And the purpose, the real purpose of that rituals was some sort of a catharsis. Like everybody just does what's forbidden within the ritual setting. So they kind of get it out of their system and and and then they go back to the very strict tribal laws. But somebody like some precursor Margaret Mead might have observed these rituals and said, Whoa, these guys love having orgies and getting wasted. that's just they're just liberated like that. So ironically the liberal the modern liberal society basically becomes this constant orgy or like they're trying to promote a state in Europe in West they're trying to pre promote a set a state of constant well orgy, constant ritual, where which was in archaic society something you only do temporarily because you don't have, as you mentioned, the pathway of penance and confession to get rid of your sins. So you kinda have to like act them out. But you have to go back to normal. You have to go back to obeying those
E. Michael Jones: Yeah.
George: natural rules. Whereas in liberalism, they're just trying to get rid of the rules altogether.
E. Michael Jones: You I think you see this in Protestantism as well. so the beginning of Protestantism, you break with the church, and you think that, well, I can get together and create my own church. and then they have the three principles, sola scriptura, sola grazia, and sola fide. Sola grazia means by fa by grace alone. Now, what you did here was as soon as you declare that principle, you cut the people off from the source of grace. Which is the sacraments of the Catholic Church, specifically confession. This had a tremendous effect on Protestantism, especially in America, because they didn't have the custom. They er when you come to America, let's say in the eighteenth century, if you're there then, you make up your own culture. It's you're you're beginning the thing from the beginning. You decide what the culture is, because there's no one else to tell you that. Well,
George: Hm.
E. Michael Jones: what happens is The lack of the ability to confess your sins eventually drives you crazy. And so you have a massive outbreak of this in the Great Awakening in the middle of the 18th century, which is, I think it's a function of the break with sacramental confession. So you can't
George: Yeah.
E. Michael Jones: go to the priest. You're burdened by guilt. The man who was the genius in this regard was
Nathaniel Hawthorne
George: Right.
E. Michael Jones: and his great book, The Scarlet Letter. And the premise of the Scarlet Letter is in order to be a Puritan minister, you have to be one of the visible elect on earth, which means you're saved. That's the term they use now. So what happens when you're saved and then you commit adultery? What happens then? What do you do? Well, you go crazy. And what
George: Tough situation, yeah.
E. Michael Jones: Either either so there are two options. Either it's not a sin, which is the antinomian position, or you're not saved, which is not a happy position either. So which is it? You got two completely re repugnant alternatives. And so when the pressure got so great, they would just have these revivals, and the Great Awakening was a a massive revival. John Wesley showed up, preached all the way from Maine, from Maine down to Georgia, pre season revivalists, and they had this need, and they still have the need. It was even something as late as Promise Keepers, which you probably don't remember because you weren't here when it happened, but it was basically a football coach who would get people together in football stadiums, like 80,000 people, and they'd all confess their sins because they found that this was after the sexual revolution. It's like in the 1970s, it begins. You had all of the the charismatic movement was a big movement in the 1970s. And I think it was a direct reaction to the sexual, so-called sexual liberation of the of the 1960s because it became intolerable. How do you deal with it this pressure of guilt? You just tell us, it's not there. Well, that Margaret Mead tried that. She, in other
George: Mm.
E. Michael Jones: words, she was reacting to the pressure of her own guilty conscience. So you did have to do something. It was a big deal. And the fact that you wrote coming of age in Samoa is proof that you thought it was a big deal. Why didn't you just ignore it? Just just have sex. No, she couldn't do that. And I'm saying that's talks about the it brings you up to the objective nature of good and evil. It's not simply some type of fantasy that was created by society to keep you oppressed. There is an objective reality there because you were created by God. As a rational creature. And practical reason is another word for morality, and it's written on your heart. That's how you pursue the good. because of the fact you're a rational creature, that something's good and something's not good. Because that's how you have to act. You have to be able to choose the good. That's you have to get through life that way. You can't get around saying, well, I can't make a decision because I don't know what's good and what's bad. No, it's been programmed into you. And to try and get away from it is a fantasy, but it's a collective fantasy. It has a lot of power in the West.
George: Right. It just struck me as fascinating as you talk about these revivals. They do seem to be this Protestant equivalent of rituals,
cathartic rituals. in some sense, these primitive societies they were were they were less just, but they had the outlet of blood sacrifice. Basically means like if you live in a primitive society, the same thing happens. Guilt builds up, which I totally agree is universal to human nature. And how did they deal with it? They don't have the concept of confessing your personal sin. So it all gets, you know, there's this demonic force, there's this devil that's amongst us that's tormenting us, and what ends up happening is you end up sacrificing, lynching a human being, later you substitute it for animals. But in in primitive societies, you would have this ritual, maybe even seasonal thing, where the guilt gets channeled onto s violently and On to even tr even through war, maybe on a on an outsider or on slaves. I don't know. But with the Protestants, because they have the or are at least these charismatic ones. I don't know. There's so many Protestants, right? But with these charismatic movements, because of their Christian heritage, they can't just blame it on on some person and lynch them unless we want to talk about, I don't know, Salem witch trials or something. That's all controversial. But the point is they don't have the primitive catharsis of blood sacrifice. So they're just stuck in that limbo that you're talking about. they don't want to confess through like a sacramental church, I guess, but they want to be saved. So it's just the thing where everything just explodes in this old revival, which I guess is like they're renewing their faith. Or do they kind of like what is the logic when they go to these revivals? Do they confess they they've been guilty? so they weren't saved before,
E. Michael Jones: Yeah, they do a lot.
George: but now they're saved. Like they kind of reset the clock
E. Michael Jones: Mm-hmm.
George: on when they were saved.
E. Michael Jones: Yeah, you have to engage in absurdities like that, but what it's it's in a po if you have a power what is being saved? What do you mean by you're saved? How do you know you're saved? Well, I had a powerful emotional experience. That's all they're saying. There's no guarantee, there's nothing objective about this. I had a powerful emotional experience, and that's proof that I'm saved. Well, now I committed a sin. So now what do I do? Well, I guess I need another powerful emotional experience. So they go seeking for these. That's what the revival provides you with. you can you the music gets you all in in ma involved and it it it it fires up your emotions and then you move toward the stage and you testify to the Lord and sometimes you pass out, sometimes you speak in tongues, but that's proof. I had a powerful emotional experience. Well, that's not logical and it's it doesn't last forever and you gotta keep renewing it and it t after a while it doesn't make sense. And it leads to despair, apostasy, it leads to rationalism. That's what it leads to. So what you saw
George: Mm.
E. Michael
Jones: in America was the Great Awakening led to the Age of Enlightenment, the American Enlightenment. And a classic figure in that guard regard would be Benjamin Franklin. And so he he was there when John Wesley was preaching. He wasn't Whitfield, I think, was the most famous preacher at the time. Had a powerful voice. And so Ben Franklin there goes there and starts measuring off how far he can be from where the preacher is saying, speaking, and how loud his voice is and how many it's like a scientific experiment. It is in many ways
George: Hm.
E. Michael Jones: a mockery of the emotional experience that all these people are having, because he doesn't believe any of it. And what that's exactly what you saw, the reaction. That came about in New England, the rationalist reaction that came about as the result of Calvinism. Hawthorne was part of it. Melville was part of it. All of the great American thinkers of the 19th century were all part of this anti-Calvinist reaction because it wasn't rational. And it was not only it not only that, i i i Hawthorne again is the genius here. The the little short story he wrote is called Young Goodman Brown. About the Puritan who goes off into the forest. Nobody went into the forest. That was where the devil lived. So why are you going into the forest? Well, it's to meet the devil. But why do you want to meet the devil? Well, the devil tells you, Welcome to the communion of your race. This is the minister preaching, who's really the devil. And he says, Evil is the nature of mankind. Well, that's Calvinism. It's total depravity. So he find that well, if evil is the nature of mankind, you worship the devil. This shows you Hawthorne's profound understanding of the psychological implications of Calvinism and why it led to a rationalist reaction. That so you went from pendulum swinging from faith alone to reason alone. And you can't do without either one. You have to have. You're a rational creature. That's the way God made you. And Orestes Brownson is a man who went through this. He said, Well, wait a minute, if if it's faith alone, why are you telling me to read the scripture? I have to I have to have a rational mind to read the scripture, don't I? So doesn't that mean that reason is okay? It w in other words, it didn't last. It could not last. And America was a place where it just kind of broke down completely.
George: Alright, yeah, that's that's brilliant. That makes a lot of sense. Yeah, it's also uncanny how it just starts to resemble more and more the archaic ritual. And even the the devil, right? I it ends in the devil. I mean, you know, what does the Bible say? The the gods of the nations are demons, right? So every time you have this demonic influence, it's you got the ritual, you have the ecstasy, and you have it going in a cycle. I would you know it ha it has been remarked lately that people say these trances, charismatic quote unquote church trances are are fake. d you know, I think they might be real, but it's not the Holy Spirit that's moving them, right? It might be other some other kind of spirit that's moving them there. And maybe it has to do with some th maybe those spirits have something to do with the devil that that character means in the forest.
E. Michael Jones: You're playing with fire. You're playing with fire if you do this. How do you know that when you offer yourself up, how do you know it's going to be a good spirit coming into you and not a bad spirit? How do you know that?
George: I think unless you're repenting, you're not getting the good spirit, okay? Unless like
E. Michael Jones: Well that
George: a tr the true Christian penance, you know, and I don't think that's yeah. It's I mean I agree, I'm with you. I'm with you. I'm just saying generally it's gonna be a bad spirit if you do that.
E. Michael Jones: Well, I can give you an example of that. I see Medjugoria, you're this is from your neck of the woods, okay? It's Bosnia. I don't know whether you heard about it, okay?
George: Yeah. Yes. We talked about it. No, no, we had an episode. We talked about it. You told me about what, demons walking through walls or something like that?
E. Michael Jones: Yeah, right. Well, this is Saint John of the Cross said the devil rejoices when people seek private revelations. That's why Medigory is infested with demons. Because the people are receptive to these spirits. It's a charismatic openness and the demons love it.
George: All right, I wanna move on here because we're getting really let's let's cut a break here. I wanna go to another chapter that I think we have time here to discuss. The one about homosexual as subver subversive, the double life of Sir Anthony Blunt. And you also had a pretty long one about Maynard Keynes, the economist, which is also my neck of the wood since I teach economics and I read his biography and I was fascinated to see what you have to say about that. Can you can you walk us through that? either Anthony Blunt, what is it, Bloomsbury Group? What was that all about? And how's homosexuality linked to sedition, if at all?
E. Michael Jones: That's good question, isn't it? so what are we talking about? We're talking about let's say start with Leslie Stevens, who was the father of Virginia Wolf. So he said that he studied Darwin, he said, I lost my faith. But I'll always be a gentleman. That's like classic English. Okay. you lost your yeah.
George: Nietzsche talked about that. Nietzsche talked about how the English kinda gave up the Christian God and all the more they insist on Christian morality. I remember
E. Michael Jones: Yeah.
George: that from back in the day and I saw it again in your book and I'm like, okay, this makes sense.
E. Michael Jones: Yeah, he ridicules George Elliott for this. But this is what this is what Leslie Stevens said. I I don't I'm not a Christian, but I'll always be a gentleman. Well, how long do you think that's gonna last? Okay. Newman said, you know, if think you can control human
passion all by yourself, try to moor an ocean liner with silk threads. That'll be easier. You cannot control these passions by yourself. And so that proof of that was the Bloomsbury crowd. Who immediately
George: Okay.
E. Michael Jones: Lytton Strachey gave the term. What is Bloomsbury? He said it was the higher sodomy. So it was homosexuals. It happened like that, like that. Like overnight. You went from being, I'll always be a gentleman, to you've got Lytton Straity talking about higher strategy, and Virginia Wolf is the same type of situation. So w at that point, you've got A situation, okay, if it's a higher sodomy, you got a lot of people at Cambridge who feel that way. they're the those English boarding schools were notorious for homosexual activity. So you got people who are acting out because now they're liberated from Christianity, because nobody believes in that anymore because of Darwin. And now they're acting on their impulses at a time when it's still criminal behavior. And the man who found that's out the hard way was Oscar Wilde, who was stupid enough to s he was having all these sexual affairs with boys, and one of them was the son of a former famous aristocrat, and he sued him for libel and he lost. And he God, by the grace of God, he was punished in this life, and it brought about his conversion to Catholicism and he confessed his sins and probably gotta spend a line of time in purgatory. But you got a situation where You have to be if you're a homosexual, you are automatically part of a secret society. And if you're part of a secret society that you have an attitude toward nature that you're you're like a born revolutionary. And I
George: Right.
E. Michael Jones: I bring this out in E. Forster's novel, Morris. I think every Englishman was a homosexual and some of them grew out of it. Simply because they were they they They they were no longer in boarding school and they decided sex
George: Yeah.
E. Michael Jones: with girls is better. Or something but they put some people didn't grow out of it. And that became part of Forster's identity, and he became a subversive. He hated the king. Why are you full of violence? Because you are at war with nature. Your act your the act the sexual act that you perform is contra natura. And so you become a natural subversive. You have to be part of a hidden group. And of course, this fits in perfectly with with communism. And so there seems to be a kind of natural shift at that time. This is the next generation. After d the the this is the generation after Virginia Wolf, after Lytton Strachey. We're now in the 30s generation. Where the world has fallen apart and communism ceased to be answered. And the the the Cambridge traders were that generation, and Sir Anthony Blunt was one of them. Guy Burgess, all of these people l led double lives. If you're a communist, you have to lead a double life, you're a subversive. If you're a homosexual, you have to lead a double life. And that they so they naturally fit together.
George: All right. you write about I guess I'm gonna go back to Keynes again because I'm more familiar with him. Sir Anthony Blunt's kinda new to me. I think he's been portrayed in some movies lately. Not that I watched them, but I think Colin Firth, there was a movie recently where where they portray I just remember it was some some guy he gets shot eventually because he ended up being a spy for communists and he was homosexual but For Keene specifically, you write about how his economics is maybe predicated or well influenced by his childlessness, right? there's a lot of critique of Kenjian economics, which is basically about government spending and government inter intervention in the economy. And it's it's it comes from the part of the Ayn Rand types, you know, people who are just like private property absolutists. I don't like that camp either, so I'm not really dedicated to either side of this battle. But it is an interesting question of how this Kenjian idea that, you know, in the long run we're all dead and we can all spend money and you know, fiat currency is a good thing. How that might tie in with the fact that he was childless. He also grew out of homosexuality eventually, right? Mary the ballerina, but
E. Michael Jones: Yeah, married a ballerina Russia a Russian ballerina.
George: So yeah, tell tell us about that. Is his economics about that or like how do you stand on that this economics? I don't know if you've read about his like theory, but was was he a good guy? Because okay, let me tell you before you get into it, just to warn you, I don't wanna do it at the end, but you know that Keynes was trying to save Germany after World War One, right? You're aware of his his book economic consequences of the peace and how he was the lone
E. Michael Jones: Yeah. Yeah.
George: voice saying that burdening yeah. All right. Go. What was he say? Is he see he's a good he's a good guy there, right?
E. Michael Jones: So yeah, that ba base I I'm not in the business of certifying whether people are good guys or bad guys. I'm just here trying to describe the thing. So on the one hand, he did say, I mean, my com my statement about him was based on his statement that in the long run we're all dead, as someone who doesn't have children. So in other words, you're focusing this on a very short temporal horizon by the fact that you don't have children. If you're willfully avoiding children. which is what homosexual behavior is, then it makes it it makes it even worse. But what what what's he com what is he complaining about? It's the gold standard. Keynes was a a a ferocious opponent of the gold standard, and that's a good thing. I am a ferocious opponent of the gold standard, which is to say that there is an objective value in a piece of metal. If there's anything that gold has, it has an objective value, okay? And everybody recognizes this objective value. Okay. Is that a fetish? What Marx would call a fetish? Does that make you
believe that, as Shylock said, that his ducats could multiply faster than Laban's Laban's ewes and rams? Or is what Keynes was proposing, in other words, Fiat not fiat currency, okay, but the government will issue currency based on the needs of the of the marketplace rather than concentrating in in a piece of metal that would is automatically deflationary and causes all sorts of suffering to the people who have to work for a living. I think that I would agree with Keynes, okay, that gold standard is a bad thing. It only makes the rich richer. Everyone else is punished because of the gold standard. But you can't generalize
George: Yeah.
E. Michael Jones: that from to say that, well, all morality is subjective too. Which is what the posi that's the position he wanted to s have true because he was operating, at least in his younger life, in total rebellion against the objective moral law, which says there is a logos to sexuality. And it is not fulfilled by homosexual activity. So what they're saying is well, it's like fiat money. We decide the size of the economy based on our needs, which is the opposite of the gold standard. So it's good in economics, but don't generalize from economics to all of existence. This people do this all the time. And Rand's classic example of that, you know, if Newman. Cardinal Newman said the main danger to the university right now is that economics has replaced theology as the queen of the sciences. So it had a very bad effect on England. But Changes. Keynes's alternative to the gold standard was a good thing, but I don't think he should have generalized it to morality in general, which is something that the homosexual would do because he's knows he's at odds with the moral law. He's at odds, you're at odds with nature. You don't want there to be a nature. You want your
George: All right.
E. Michael Jones: will to be the nature. And in a sense, that's what fiat currency is. The will, it's it's a will it it at least it seems that way. This is precisely
George: Mm.
E. Michael Jones: the problem that John Law got involved in when he did bring about paper money, which was a tremendous liberation for the economy of France. But how do you stop it? Well, there are limits.
George: Right.
E. Michael Jones: There are objective limits to the amount of currency you can issue as a fiat currency. And the limit is the labor force of the country you're in. You can't exceed the labor. that your country can produce because labor is the source of value. If you go beyond that, which is what every politician does, United States, exactly that same situation right now. You're gonna inflate the currency and ruin everything.
George: Yeah. No, I'm with you. Yeah, exactly. it's a good thing, but it's very easy to to abuse that power to print money, right? if we lived in a moral society it would be linked to the reality of
E. Michael Jones: That's exactly the point. That's exactly the point. And that's exactly the point that Americans understood,
John Adams understood, when he said, We have no constitution that functions in the absence of a moral people. You cannot control the currency unless you can control your behavior according to the moral law. You cannot have democracy. If you have democracy without morality, it leads immediately to chaos and then the tyrant comes in and takes it over.
George: Has it occurred to you how the fiat currency is basically the alt chemical project just succeeding? for for hundreds of years these guys try to make gold out of lead and then they realize we don't even need lead. We can just like make gold from paper.
E. Michael Jones: Yeah. That's so it's in yeah, of course it is. Of course it is. so George Soros said finance is alchemy. Newton is an example of this. He was an alchemist, he was involved in the coinage, he was a usurer, he was involved and this is the problem with Newton is that economics became pseudophysics in England. Once Adam Smith wrote his book, he changed gravity and inertia to self-interest and competition. It's the same type of system that's supposed to regulate itself. And by the way, the gold standard is supposed to regulate itself too. So we we have everything figured out and then it all went bust because it's not it's not the same it's not not that simple.
George: Things derail very easily. All right, let's go. We we got some time here. I want to go to the next chapter. Again, we're still under the theme of passions taking over our reason. And the next chapter is Stanley and Jane's excellent adventure, Stanley Fish. And I think you have some personal anecdotes here. I gotta say, when I was reading this, I was feeling compassion for you, Dr. Jones, because I went through engineering and business undergrad and and I barely survived. I don't know how I maybe I didn't actually make it. Who knows how it affected me dealing with all the like crazies in academia. But you actually studied what, liberal arts in undergrad and you had to deal with these characters. I I'm just very glad you made it and you're still with us. I mean, I don't know how you how you
E. Michael Jones: Thank you.
George: kept your sanity.
E. Michael Jones: By the grace of God. That's how I did it. By the grace of God. Yeah, so what
George: Right.
E. Michael Jones: so what you saw here was the this could be a chapter in the Jewish Revolutionary Spirit, too. Stanley Fish is a Jew. at this point the Jews took over literary criticism. So when I was a teenager in high school and as an undergraduate, there there was called the new criticism, and it was a kind of formalism. which basically you didn't take all talk at all about the biography of the poet. All you talked about was the form of the of the poem. And it's for some, it's some poems are really intric intricate. So John Dunn is really complicated. It's like a really complicated watch that you can take apart and you can just marvel at how all these parts work together. But for the most part, it's inadequate. Formalism is sterile. It's just a sterile exercise. You usually always come up with the same thing. And there was a ca a sense of dissatisfaction with the artificial limits. Now, I'm saying s new criticism was Protestant. It was basically sola scriptura. democratic Yeah, the formal the formula the formalism that I I was talking about, that was the orthodoxy.
George: Wha what was new criticism? Was that formalism? okay, it was. Okay. I see. Gotcha. All right.
E. Michael Jones: It was Protestant. It was solely scriptural. All you needed was the poem. You just sat down there and you analyzed the poem. You need any other information. Well, I think that's kind of sterile, okay? And it led to a reaction. And the reaction took place in an attack on Ezra Pound. The Jews did not like Ezra Pound because he made propaganda broadcast for Mussolini during the war and talked about the kikes are doing this and the kikes are doing that. Classic Ezra Pound. And so they organized an uprising against Ezra Pound, which succeeded when I was in graduate school. and they changed the terms of the discussion. So before, if TS, if you asked T.S. Elliott or Ezra Pound, he'd say, well, the life of the poet is really not that important. What is important is the beauty of the object. This is one of the texts was called a well-wrought urn. So this is a well-wrought error. Who cares about the biography? Well, the Jews come in and they flip the narrative completely. And they say, we don't care how beautiful this is. Is T. S. Eliot an anti-Semite? That's what we have to figure out first of all. And then we we deduce everything from that. And so you come up with a lot of justification for crappy poetry because their heart is in the right place. Okay, they're both wrong. They're both
George: I see. Right.
E. Michael Jones: wrong. But what I did was I had to bring these two things together in a way that no one so I created my own literary criticism. And Degenerate Moderns is the example of what I'm talking about. Where you have to bring the biography in. So as I said, if you subordinate your desires to the truth, then all that matters is the truth, and your biography is not really that important. On the other hand, if you subordinate the truth to your desires. Your desires are the most important thing I need to know about the poem, because it's an ex so biography becomes very important. That's the shift that I made. In other words, I avoided both of the errors of the new criticism and the Jewish well, what what was the Jewish thing afterward? Deconstruction with Derrida, reader response criticism of Stanley Fisher. It's all incoherent, all stupid and and the whole English profession went down the drain because of that.
George: Was it not a deconstruction as in undermining or taking apart the Western civilization, or Christian civilization? That's what it seemed to me. I mean, not that it was
E. Michael Jones: That's why.
George: deliberate, but maybe at least in some psychological
level, there's this revolutionary spirit, right? Trying to take things down, break things down.
E. Michael Jones: Deconstruction is Jewish. The main proponent was Jacques Derrida, who was a an Algerian Jew whose ancestors were rabbis. And he's that was a war on being. That's a sophisticated, that was an anti-metaphysical text that was pretty much incomprehensible, very difficult to understand, but it was an attack on being. And it goes back to when when did everything become discourse? The lack of real presence. It's suddenly you realize he's getting theological. There is no real presence. The real presence for Christians is in the Eucharist. There's no real presence. There's no being. There's no ultimate reality. It's just projection. It's just the language thinking itself. The language is thinking itself.
George: No substance. it's crazy to me how they're saying, well, it's it it's it's hard to keep track. So, to me, it sounds almost like if you're saying don't look at the person's biography, almost like saying like you're investigating a crime scene and you're saying, Well, that let's not look at any fingerprints here. isn't it obvious that somebody's like philosophy is gonna be informed by their life and that that's gonna be
E. Michael Jones: Yeah, I agree with you. But that was the premise of the new criticism was you never look at the person the writer's biography. That that's what that's what I was raised as. it's good in a sense it trains you to have a close pay close attention to the text. You can't have any type of decent literary criticism unless you play close pay close attention to the text. Okay, but that's not just biography, that's history, that's philosophy. You have to bring all of these things to bear. in order to understand the what you're talking about. So Paradise Lost didn't really come alive to me until I realized that every man who signed the Declaration of of Independence was reading Satan's speech in Paradise Lost. Suddenly I could was able to situate thiself in its in its historical context and the meaning arose from that that meeting.
George: Okay, so while some of them are saying I'm just trying to clear this up. Some of them are saying you can't look at the biography or you shouldn't unless the person is an anti Semite. so so which one is it? Do we look or we do not look, or who's saying what?
E. Michael Jones: The the new criticism says do not look at the biography, just look at the work.
George: Even for Ezra Pound.
E. Michael Jones: For anyone, or anyone,
George: Okay.
E. Michael Jones: anyway. Ezra Pound was part of the new criticism movement. the
George: okay.
E. Michael Jones: he was part of that. He and T. S. Elliott were part of that movement who basically said, it's the work that is important and not the the writer. Well, the Jews reverse that and say, Well, first of all, I gotta find out if you're an anti Semite or not. And then I will judge everything you wrote according to the absolutely external criteria, criterion of anti Semitism. Well that's that's ridiculous. Why do you need why do you need to ha write a po read a poem then? You already know what the answer is gonna be. Both of them were in their way avoiding the real issue. And one of the one of the great casualties In this regard, was Shelley. Percy Shelley was basically a a revolutionary. Absolutely no question. A sexual revolutionary. He ran off with Mary Godwin, the famous William Godwin's daughter, abandoned his teenage wife, ran off with her, came back, and his wife committed suicide, and Mary Godwin is completely obsessed with guilt. She can't get over the guilt. She can't you go to Godwin. Godwin said that marriage is the most odious of all monopolies. So my father said that. Well, then what's wrong? Why do I feel guilty? I don't understand this. Where's the guilt coming from? My father absolved me for this type of thing. And so, in order to resolve that, she wrote Frankenstein. Where
George: Mm.
E. Michael Jones: the the monster, she projects the guilt or onto the monster, tries to externalize the guilt by projecting it on the monster. Okay?
George: I see.
E. Michael Jones: You can't understand Shelley. So what she did then was create the the a false Shelley to absolve herself of guilt and turn Shelley into some type of angel. this was the age of angelism, late 19th century, where they loved angels. I don't know why it is, but they just loved angels. I wrote in my doctoral dissertation, it's called The Angel and the
George: Hm.
E. Michael Jones: Machine. These were the two dominant metaphors at the end of the 19th century, corresponding to idealism and materialism, if you wanted to be philosophical. But anyway, she turned
George: That's cool.
E. Michael Jones: him into an angel because she didn't want to admit her guilt and she covered over the real Shelley, which was the revolutionary. You can't understand Shelley's poetry unless you understand that Shelley was a revolutionary and not a Victorian angel.
George: Right. I I really enjoy your literary criticism because it's so historically informative and it is the opposite of what you call new criticism. You you definitely look into people's biographies biographies and connect them, except of course you're not trying to figure out well, you might be also trying to figure out if they're anti Semite, but you're mostly looking at their like we said at the beginning, right, how their desires might inform or deform their work. Is that fair to say?
E. Michael Jones: Yes, absolutely. Absolutely.
George: Yeah. all right. How do we go as a kind of last thing here? sticking with the Stanley Fish. There were some funny episodes there. The the funniest one to me was helping a feminist with the kickstand of her motorcycle. that's so symbolic, yeah. Yeah. But but how
E. Michael Jones: Yeah. she wore
George: do you get from that to the whole of how how do you get to these whatever literary criticism to the thing where like you're not
allowed to say what you think in the classroom like you weren't and and you know the woke speech police and stuff like that. How did that come about?
E. Michael Jones: Largely because of feminism. So feminism, all all these ladies went to literary, they wanted to get degrees in literature. So I was kind of alone there with all these women. men, it's not a manly thing to do, I have to admit that. If you're a man, you go out and become a lawyer and make a lot of money. And here I am because I like poetry, here with all these women. And well, I love being with women, but they all turned into feminists. And so what you had was a kind of it was it was Marxism. Basically, feminism was Marxism applied to the gender rather than means of production. And so it became so stealthifying. all we t all we looking for sexism in kindergarten text or something. This is ridiculous. What you were doing was in effect projecting your n 20th century feminism onto something where it didn't apply. what's that got to do with Shakespeare? What was the fundamental issue in Shakespeare? Obviously he talked about sex a lot. What was the fundamental issue that Shakespeare had to deal with?
George: Shakespeare? Well rivalry, sexual obsession. I wasn't tracking there.
E. Michael Jones: The Reformation
George: yeah, okay, well in political plane, sure.
E. Michael Jones: He had to deal with the Reformation, which was a form of censorship. Elizabeth created the first secret police agency. You had to get plays approved. And so whenever he wanted to say something about England, he would set it in ancient Greece. And there are absolutely brilliant set like in Troilus and Crescida, brilliant passages that are directly related to the Reformation. If you don't understand that, you don't understand you're not in a position to talk about Shakespeare. And that's precisely the situation in graduate school. That's what it was like. So you had a Marxist analysis of Shakespeare, and then you had a Freudian analysis of Shakespeare, and then you had a feminist analysis of Shakespeare, and then you had a deconstruction. It didn't they were all pointless. You're barking up the wrong tree. It's like it's like the race. Th I there are white boys out there who say that race explains everything. Ibn Ignatieev said race explained the Reformation. Well, wait a minute. Are the Irish white or are the English white? Are the Catholics white? This is stupid. It's like saying, Well, what about the Balkans? How does race explain the conflict between Serbs and Croats? Which guy or are you the white guy or is the Croat? This is preposterous. It's a pu an idea of pu that is purely provincial American. They're projecting their own worldview onto the rest of the world where it doesn't make any sense. You have to allow this is what I'm saying, this is what I did, you have to allow essence, the categories, to emerge from existence. The category has to emerge from the existence of the work of art. You can't impose it a
priori like Marxism. Hamlet's about Marxism. It's about the working class rising up. Macbeth is about feminism because Lady Macbeth was a real h strong woman. This is preposterous. You have to allow the category the category to emerge. From the existence. And I'm saying if you look at Shakespeare long enough, the thing that emerges is the Reformation. The fundamental distorting episode that wrecked English it wrecked English philosophy, but it it created some great English literature. Very similar to Persia after the Arabic conquest. The the Persians couldn't do philosophy anymore. It's too dangerous. You get your head chopped off. And so they did poetry instead because it was oblique. Same thing happened in England. They're not their thinking is a worth they it died with William of Ockham. Their music's terrible. but their poetry is beautiful. It's great. it's part of it's the best part of English culture.
George: Yeah. At the very least your theory is something at the very least your theory has this on its side, which is that Shakespeare knew what Reformation was. But whereas he had no idea what feminism or Marxism were. So unless you wanna make some so you're basically essentially saying Shakespeare didn't know what he was writing, but you, now that we know the truth of whatever feminism and Marxism were imposing on Shakespeare.
E. Michael Jones: Yeah. That
George: which just s so so
E. Michael Jones: that wrecked literature. That wrecked literary criticism. And the main agent of that wrecking was the feminist composition teacher. You show up as a freshman and this chick is going to teach you composition, and we're just going to teach you ideas. And if you say something she doesn't like about contraception, you get an F. It's like Marxism. You know, it's exactly the same thing. It killed literary studies.
George: Yeah. I've had those kind of teachers, some of them in high school, so it probably wasn't that bad. But yeah, I remember getting some yeah, Fs for for some kind of statements. It also reminded me you mentioned I was watching when I was watching you talk to Jim Goad and Jim Goad claiming that you know Cromwell was basically a white boy and it was just like it's just like he he had no idea what that is.
E. Michael Jones: And he should have known better. He was a Catholic until his brain got screwed up by sexual liberation. Don't, don't, this is very serious stuff. It ended up killing Jim Goad. Whiteness killed Jim Gode. He killed himself.
George: Yeah. So again we see this desire to project our unrepentant desires on history and leading to historical revisionism a lot. Marxism, feminism, all of these are things like historical revisionism and just trying to rewrite history and I think that's serious matter. That's getting into like some serious brainwashing, isn't it?
E. Michael Jones: Yeah. Well look at I think the Soviet Union suffered from that b were you raised under communism or to are you too young to did you ha were you t
George:
I was too young. I was born in socialist Yugoslavia, right? It was kinda I guess in the eighties it was already falling apart. But yeah. But yeah, no.
E. Michael Jones: Yeah. No, you weren't there. Look, I I have a d a Russian daughter in law who studied music and she said it was you had more freedom of speech in the Soviet Union when she was a girl, right around the time of Brezhnev's death than you had at the university here in in in America.
George: I'm I I I don't doubt it anymore. Yeah.
E. Michael Jones: she was talking about music. I am certain that that was the case. I am certain that that was the case. If you read my book, The Dangers of Beauty, you'll see what a a disaster American music was after the after the Jews took it over. The Soviets came here for the Congress of Cultural Freedom. No, they came here with their own Congress in Manhattan, bold Soviets. And they they wanted to prove that Soviet culture was more congenial to production of great art than the West was. Well that's a bold claim. So when they came up with music, who'd they show up with? Shostakovich, Brokofiev, and our f the guy who the the Armenian, Kachaturian. And who did we show up with? Who did the Americans show up? Leonard Bernstein? Aaron Copeland? And then the weird, all this crappy t twelve tone stuff. it was obvious that the Soviets did have better music than we had. It was better because they wouldn't touch it. They they under they they would not in a sense they did not have a cultural revolution there in the way that we had over here. Like
George: Well, music doesn't in in involve wars, so it can't be like to overtly critical of the government. But wouldn't you also say that some of these musical talents developed and were nurtured prior to the Russian Revolution?
E. Michael Jones: Yes, you're right. You're at that's right. So god God bless Stalin. Okay, he saved Shostakovich from himself. If you let Shostakovich alone, it would be Our Lady Macbeth of Minsk or something awful stuff because he was doing twelve-tone music because he was imitating what he saw from the West. Stalin came in and basically said, one more one more piece like that and you're gonna end up in the gulag. And so Shostakovich Shostakovich wrote the Fifth Symphony. I don't know where I think this Fifth Symphony is a stirring piece of music. the Ninth Symphony. I this is great music. Nothing in the West com comes close to Shostakovich's achievement in these symphonies.
George: Stalin was also sexual prude, ironically. I think you right about that. They had kinda a fling with sexual revolution and it it derailed. And then Stalin was like, No, we're not doing that. Who was saying how sex is like drinking a cup of water or something, glass of water?
E. Michael Jones: Yeah, I'll Alexandra Cole and Ty.
George: Yeah. So he did straighten some things out. All right, Dr. Jones, it's been an hour, over an hour. So thank you again for coming on. good discussion. dangers of beauty might be the next thing I look at. So let's keep in touch. I also wanted to get on Picasso,
E. Michael Jones: Yeah, I think we'd have a really good discussion.
George: we didn't get to that. That was a good episode. I commend you guys again get
E. Michael Jones: Yeah.
George: the general moderns, Picasso critique, criticism is very good.
E. Michael Jones: Yeah, go to FidelityPress dot org. Buy the book. Buy the book. The books are the vectors of ideas in this world and the podcast exists to lead you to the book.
George: One hundred percent. Thank you, Doctor Jones.
E. Michael Jones: Thank you, George. Pleasure to be with you.