رونوشت 🔗
WEBVTT
00:01.094 --> 00:12.794
[SPEAKER_02]: Hi, I'm Lara Land, an integrative clinical mental health counselor, author of my bliss book and the essential guide to trauma-sensitive yoga and trauma-sensisivity consultant.
00:12.814 --> 00:15.439
[SPEAKER_02]: And this is The Beyond Trauma Podcast.
00:16.040 --> 00:17.803
[SPEAKER_02]: Here we explore healing.
00:17.783 --> 00:20.706
[SPEAKER_02]: growth and what it means to truly thrive.
00:21.167 --> 00:33.981
[SPEAKER_02]: You'll hear from therapists of different approaches, wellness coaches, and people with lived experience who talk about how to build resilience and connection, shift habitual responses and live in your values.
00:34.542 --> 00:36.183
[SPEAKER_02]: Your time is valuable to me.
00:36.584 --> 00:47.436
[SPEAKER_02]: My goal is for you to walk away from each episode with an insight or practice you can put into action to build more ease and clarity in your life.
00:47.416 --> 00:48.017
[SPEAKER_02]: Here we go.
00:52.205 --> 00:56.332
[SPEAKER_02]: Beyond trauma listeners, did you know you can always start over?
00:56.413 --> 01:06.210
[SPEAKER_02]: Giving myself permission to begin again at any moment has allowed me to constantly evolve and it's a tool I use with all of my coaching clients.
01:06.852 --> 01:10.318
[SPEAKER_02]: It's also the premise of my first book, my bliss book.
01:10.298 --> 01:23.191
[SPEAKER_02]: Myblis book is an undeaded, life-purpose planner that comes with an automated coaching program sent directly to your inbox by weekly when you enroll using the secret URL found inside the book.
01:23.211 --> 01:38.567
[SPEAKER_02]: You will receive my creative visualization meditation, encouraging you to move beyond social programming and self-imposed limitations and into visualizing your truest, most honest vision for your own unique life.
01:38.547 --> 01:47.173
[SPEAKER_02]: Then, using my Blisk book, you will work backwards to develop actionable steps to meet goals throughout the year that take you towards your big vision.
01:47.626 --> 01:51.872
[SPEAKER_02]: have a habit of buying pretty planners and putting them down before they're finished?
01:52.433 --> 01:53.154
[SPEAKER_02]: Not a problem.
01:53.494 --> 01:57.961
[SPEAKER_02]: My bi-weekly emails provide just the nudge needed to pick up your planner again.
01:58.001 --> 02:01.766
[SPEAKER_02]: And if you miss a few days, you don't waste your book.
02:01.786 --> 02:04.810
[SPEAKER_02]: The book is undated, so you can always start again.
02:04.870 --> 02:17.548
[SPEAKER_02]: My book is available off my site lariland.us and is now 20% off for my podcast listeners with code start again.
02:18.102 --> 02:21.006
[SPEAKER_02]: Welcome back, the on-channel listeners.
02:21.606 --> 02:24.610
[SPEAKER_02]: Well, I have something very special for you today.
02:24.630 --> 02:34.102
[SPEAKER_02]: I'm a little beyond my scope of knowledge, but I'm leaning in because I really feel like with this series, you know, I don't
Load full transcript
want us to just talk about problems.
02:34.483 --> 02:43.634
[SPEAKER_02]: I want to talk to people who are in the ring, right, who are really in it, working on solutions, doing the work, you know, daring to, right?
02:43.875 --> 02:46.438
[SPEAKER_02]: And today, I have on for you someone in
02:46.756 --> 02:47.818
[SPEAKER_02]: relatively special.
02:47.838 --> 02:58.317
[SPEAKER_02]: It's going to give you a lot of ideas about new ways of thinking about negotiation, mediation, and I'm talking about a cross so many different scopes, right?
02:58.778 --> 03:06.773
[SPEAKER_02]: Conflict between neighbors, conflict with, and we talk especially about renewable projects, and land conflicts,
03:06.753 --> 03:09.498
[SPEAKER_02]: conflict in partnership and business building teams.
03:10.079 --> 03:13.124
[SPEAKER_02]: This is such a special guest I have for you on today.
03:13.204 --> 03:23.863
[SPEAKER_02]: Professor Lawrence Susskind, he is the Ford professor of urban and environmental planning at MIT and head of MIT's Science Impact Collaborative.
03:24.163 --> 03:29.773
[SPEAKER_02]: He's also an experienced mediator and negotiation trainer who's worked in more than 30 countries.
03:29.753 --> 03:40.338
[SPEAKER_02]: He's co-founder of the Interior University Program on Negotiation at Harvard Law School, where it's worked for three decades to improve the theory and practice of negotiation and dispute resolution.
03:40.398 --> 03:47.796
[SPEAKER_02]: He's vice chair of instruction at PANPO and Director of the MIT Harvard Public Disputes Program.
03:47.776 --> 03:58.199
[SPEAKER_02]: More than 25 years ago, he founded the Consensus Building Institute to help provide mediation services in some of the most difficult resource management disputes around the world.
03:58.219 --> 03:59.802
[SPEAKER_02]: You're going to hear about some of those today.
03:59.862 --> 04:07.118
[SPEAKER_02]: Larry provides facilitation mediation and dispute systems design services along with advanced negotiation.
04:07.098 --> 04:28.043
[SPEAKER_02]: and mediation training to both public and private sector clients, his areas of expertise include the management of transboundary waters, renewable energy, facility sighting, the management of common pool resources like the Arctic and the ocean, the use of serious games as public engagement tools, innovation and the use of online tools and techniques for joint
04:28.023 --> 04:40.280
[SPEAKER_02]: fact-finding the rights of indigenous peoples, entrepreneur, negotiation, socially responsible, real estate development, public private partnerships for urban development and cybersecurity for critical urban infrastructure.
04:40.320 --> 04:45.448
[SPEAKER_02]: He's been involved in some extraordinary projects that you will hear about today.
04:45.468 --> 04:49.874
[SPEAKER_02]: I am so honored to bring Larry to the podcast.
04:50.234 --> 04:50.655
[SPEAKER_02]: Here we go.
04:52.424 --> 04:55.089
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm teaching at MIT for
a very long time.
04:55.109 --> 05:02.121
[SPEAKER_01]: I have worked with a number of other institutions and organizations, indeed, helped to create them.
05:02.722 --> 05:03.964
[SPEAKER_01]: And I just added them.
05:04.645 --> 05:06.729
[SPEAKER_01]: So I'm always been at MIT.
05:07.751 --> 05:12.559
[SPEAKER_01]: But I've started the program on negotiation at Harvard Law School with Roger Fisher.
05:12.691 --> 05:14.813
[SPEAKER_02]: So what was your first love?
05:14.833 --> 05:16.595
[SPEAKER_02]: Was your first love negotiation?
05:16.615 --> 05:16.675
[SPEAKER_02]: No.
05:17.156 --> 05:17.937
[SPEAKER_02]: No.
05:18.337 --> 05:19.418
[SPEAKER_01]: You're okay.
05:20.239 --> 05:23.182
[SPEAKER_01]: I was trained as an urban planner.
05:24.103 --> 05:24.303
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
05:24.624 --> 05:26.506
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm interested in that field.
05:27.307 --> 05:37.838
[SPEAKER_01]: And I was studied in urban planning professionally and then academically and then joined the faculty at MIT to teach in urban planning.
05:38.324 --> 05:51.541
[SPEAKER_01]: and I was approached by some people in Harvard Law School who said we're trying to bring together people who do mediation in very different contexts to see if we can build a new field together.
05:51.582 --> 06:02.356
[SPEAKER_01]: And so people from three universities and 20 different fields came together and created the program on negotiation at Harvard Law School.
06:02.836 --> 06:04.078
[SPEAKER_02]: And when was this?
06:04.244 --> 06:05.045
[SPEAKER_01]: 40 years ago.
06:05.065 --> 06:06.066
[SPEAKER_02]: 40 years ago.
06:06.146 --> 06:16.998
[SPEAKER_02]: So I'm assuming they were seeing starting to see some issues and getting things done, it specifically in the field of urban planning.
06:17.018 --> 06:17.919
[SPEAKER_01]: No, no.
06:18.780 --> 06:28.531
[SPEAKER_01]: They included people in labor relations, international relations, a law, business, family law, all kinds of things.
06:28.971 --> 06:34.217
[SPEAKER_01]: And they said, oh, this is curious.
06:34.383 --> 06:37.547
[SPEAKER_01]: facilitators to help in complex situations.
06:37.687 --> 06:39.869
[SPEAKER_01]: Let's see what's common.
06:40.390 --> 06:40.810
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
06:41.451 --> 06:46.237
[SPEAKER_01]: We started meeting once a month for dinner with 20 people.
06:47.278 --> 06:49.120
[SPEAKER_01]: We continued that for 20 years.
06:49.620 --> 06:56.849
[SPEAKER_02]: What new skills did you need to learn at that time to add mediation to what you were doing?
06:57.329 --> 06:58.771
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, that was the strange thing.
06:58.871 --> 07:04.137
[SPEAKER_01]: When Roger Fisher called and said,
07:04.690 --> 07:06.012
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know what mediation is.
07:06.894 --> 07:19.053
[SPEAKER_01]: And they said, well, we've read about this work you're doing, including in Boston, of bringing large groups together where there's public policy disagreements, and you facilitate this.
07:19.073 --> 07:21.517
[SPEAKER_01]: You don't come in as an expert planner.
07:21.558 --> 07:26.766
[SPEAKER_01]: You come in as someone who knows this environment and wants to help.
07:26.932 --> 07:30.959
[SPEAKER_01]: these different stakeholders work together reach some agreement.
07:31.580 --> 07:32.461
[SPEAKER_01]: That's mediation.
07:32.501 --> 07:33.523
[SPEAKER_01]: I said, okay, fine.
07:33.703 --> 07:34.505
[SPEAKER_01]: Then I'll join you.
07:34.945 --> 07:36.648
[SPEAKER_02]: So you were doing that organically.
07:36.688 --> 07:44.822
[SPEAKER_02]: You were already able to see the various parties with different interests and to bring them together to get things done.
07:45.123 --> 07:48.549
[SPEAKER_01]: And that came out of what was happening in urban planning.
07:49.230 --> 08:02.551
[SPEAKER_01]: I started my work in urban planning in the late 1960s when everybody was fighting about everything on campus and fighting in reaction to the Vietnam War or fighting with regard to racial integration.
08:03.152 --> 08:12.227
[SPEAKER_01]: And all of these public disputes weren't getting anywhere when people just engaged this advocate.
08:12.443 --> 08:21.664
[SPEAKER_01]: And so it had been planning what we were learning and then teaching was you want to help deal with issues in the city, it's not an issue of expertise.
08:22.847 --> 08:29.001
[SPEAKER_01]: We need people to bring other people together because they all have a right to participate in the decision.
08:29.318 --> 08:37.129
[SPEAKER_01]: So that's what we began experimenting with more self-consciously and more systematically.
08:37.149 --> 08:49.386
[SPEAKER_01]: I written a lot of books and they're all about different kinds of conflict and different contexts and how the process of collaborative problem solving.
08:49.737 --> 09:00.831
[SPEAKER_01]: informed by joint fact-finding works when there's a commitment to consensus and powers everybody, everyone is a veto.
09:01.712 --> 09:10.783
[SPEAKER_01]: So you have empowered the less powerful when they're at the table to engage in a conversation where there's an agreement, there's no agreement and there's an agreement.
09:11.270 --> 09:12.592
[SPEAKER_01]: and everybody's involved.
09:13.093 --> 09:19.723
[SPEAKER_01]: And so I spent a lot of time trying to make such things happen.
09:20.324 --> 09:38.492
[SPEAKER_01]: And then the program on negotiation or neither the program on negotiation nor the university provided a setting in which I could work as a practitioner to do these things without being hamstrung by the bureaucracies of these other institutions.
09:39.215 --> 09:40.337
[SPEAKER_01]: your faculty member.
09:40.878 --> 09:43.282
[SPEAKER_01]: You can only spend this much time doing this.
09:43.362 --> 09:49.692
[SPEAKER_01]: You can't have students working with you outside because that violates the responsibility you have.
09:49.732 --> 09:51.775
[SPEAKER_01]: Everybody had rules.
09:52.356 --> 09:56.683
[SPEAKER_01]: So I ended up not
for profit called the consensus building Institute.
09:56.663 --> 10:02.050
[SPEAKER_01]: And it was just my wife, myself, and a couple of students in the beginning.
10:02.770 --> 10:07.997
[SPEAKER_01]: Now it's four countries and it's got 45 full-time people in the Cambridge office.
10:08.698 --> 10:15.066
[SPEAKER_01]: And it's a $10 million dollar year or not for profit operation that works on fee for services.
10:15.126 --> 10:16.948
[SPEAKER_01]: We don't live on grants.
10:17.889 --> 10:22.755
[SPEAKER_01]: And CBI became a way for me to practice.
10:22.735 --> 10:35.249
[SPEAKER_01]: And so I will teach in the university, I do research at the program on negotiation, and I practice through CBI, and I've never let go of any of my institutional connections.
10:35.890 --> 10:46.161
[SPEAKER_02]: It's so exciting because, you know, you typically see people that are in research doing the research, but then maybe not necessarily getting to see how it's.
10:46.141 --> 10:47.463
[SPEAKER_02]: played out in the real world.
10:48.064 --> 10:53.652
[SPEAKER_02]: And you're actually taking your research and you're putting it into action and you're getting that feedback loop.
10:54.293 --> 10:54.513
[SPEAKER_01]: Yes.
10:55.014 --> 11:02.945
[SPEAKER_01]: And I made up a word, at least I claim I'm the one who invented it, to describe this kind of a life.
11:03.506 --> 11:10.536
[SPEAKER_01]: And I describe myself in many publications going back almost 40 years as a academic.
11:11.457 --> 11:12.098
[SPEAKER_01]: Love it.
11:12.314 --> 11:19.583
[SPEAKER_01]: and I have younger students who want to do the same thing and they want to know which do I do first?
11:19.603 --> 11:21.466
[SPEAKER_01]: Do I first become an academic?
11:21.826 --> 11:23.569
[SPEAKER_01]: And then I learned about practice.
11:23.669 --> 11:26.572
[SPEAKER_01]: I said, no, you do them together all the way through.
11:26.612 --> 11:34.002
[SPEAKER_01]: And they said well, but the university says, if I'm a faculty member, I'm judged on my scholarship.
11:34.268 --> 11:45.462
[SPEAKER_01]: and I said, well, you have to be in a place and negotiate a relationship which says that part of getting promoted in the university is about practice.
11:46.002 --> 11:51.509
[SPEAKER_01]: And yeah, I mean, you got to pick a right field, you got to pick a university where they believe that.
11:52.110 --> 11:54.954
[SPEAKER_01]: MIT is unique in that regard.
11:55.674 --> 12:01.862
[SPEAKER_01]: And so I have any problem staying in the university as I increased my engagement
12:02.112 --> 12:03.355
[SPEAKER_01]: in the world at large.
12:03.475 --> 12:18.906
[SPEAKER_01]: And then as I internationalized that engagement, I needed another institution to see PI to contain all of that activity, because the university, it operates by a set of rules,
12:18.886 --> 12:25.578
[SPEAKER_01]: And I don't mean to be getting into the latest this week between the Trump administration and the university.
12:25.598 --> 12:27.561
[SPEAKER_01]: He's nothing about any of that.
12:28.062 --> 12:38.941
[SPEAKER_01]: It's the university has ways of operating that make it very hard to be responsive and flexible in the context of particular places where there's fighting going on.
12:39.562 --> 12:41.626
[SPEAKER_01]: And then you go and get involved.
12:41.906 --> 12:42.227
[SPEAKER_01]: And
12:42.730 --> 12:48.659
[SPEAKER_01]: If you try to do that in the name of the university, it will take you most of the year to get permission to go.
12:48.679 --> 13:08.248
[SPEAKER_02]: So can you explain to folks your basic structure and research-based structure for helping people come to consensus, the different parts, how you get the right people at the table and how it all works, and then how you apply that maybe in a few different settings or conflicts,
13:08.515 --> 13:08.835
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
13:09.496 --> 13:18.608
[SPEAKER_01]: For the first, it took me five years to get 50 people that do this work in the public arena to agree on what we know.
13:19.169 --> 13:29.623
[SPEAKER_01]: And there's a thing called the consensus building and book, which is the doorstopper of a book published by Sage in 1999.
13:30.163 --> 13:33.628
[SPEAKER_01]: And it has all the things
13:33.608 --> 13:35.050
[SPEAKER_01]: in written form.
13:35.371 --> 13:49.571
[SPEAKER_01]: I'll say them quickly, but we have been very careful to document what works, what doesn't work, could only use full case studies together and continue to evolve the practice.
13:50.052 --> 13:54.739
[SPEAKER_01]: But basically an answer to your first question, a community calls,
13:55.158 --> 14:01.185
[SPEAKER_01]: or a person in a community called and says, there's this fighting going on and it's terrible.
14:01.205 --> 14:05.250
[SPEAKER_01]: And we don't know what to do and people stop talking to each other and nobody trusts anybody.
14:05.830 --> 14:06.571
[SPEAKER_01]: What can we do?
14:06.631 --> 14:08.754
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, you need a neutral party.
14:08.794 --> 14:10.796
[SPEAKER_01]: It's not a stakeholder.
14:11.177 --> 14:18.925
[SPEAKER_01]: It doesn't have an axe to grind about what the outcome should be to help structure a collaborative problem-solving process.
14:19.366 --> 14:21.148
[SPEAKER_01]: And the way I begin,
14:21.128 --> 14:38.192
[SPEAKER_01]: is we come into that place, we being the team, whether it's students that MIT or CBI professionals, and we interview privately and confidently and not for attribution, as many different people and as people tell us to talk to.
14:38.773 --> 14:40.275
[SPEAKER_01]: So it's a snowball process.
14:40.896 --> 14:41.517
[SPEAKER_01]: Bye.
14:41.497 --> 15:02.160
[SPEAKER_01]: was asked to help with the battle going on in the Arctic about who should have access to fish as the ice melts and huge boats can come from all the different countries how they wanted to talk about sharing those resources and having some rules and there's no governing
body for the Arctic.
15:02.180 --> 15:07.065
[SPEAKER_01]: There's just six or seven major countries that think they should be able to do
15:07.602 --> 15:24.970
[SPEAKER_01]: including the United States and so it took a squad of six people, six months to interview almost 400 individuals privately and confidently before I could produce what I call a stakeholder assessment.
15:26.198 --> 15:28.361
[SPEAKER_01]: And this is the point of the stakeholder assessment.
15:28.381 --> 15:30.905
[SPEAKER_01]: It's a process and it produces a product.
15:31.306 --> 15:33.509
[SPEAKER_01]: And the product is very straightforward.
15:33.830 --> 15:36.033
[SPEAKER_01]: It's a matrix on a piece of paper.
15:36.594 --> 15:39.759
[SPEAKER_01]: Down the side categories of stakeholders.
15:40.299 --> 15:49.814
[SPEAKER_01]: Of course, the top issues that they're concerned about in each cell, how real people in those categories speak about that issue.
15:49.854 --> 15:51.597
[SPEAKER_01]: What are they most want to have happen?
15:52.157 --> 15:53.339
[SPEAKER_01]: Not have happened.
15:53.359 --> 15:55.142
[SPEAKER_01]: What are they still want to know?
15:55.628 --> 16:25.146
[SPEAKER_01]: I can fill all that out and then I can flip that to an agenda, say it's going to take us this many months to take up these six issues and this is how I suggest we order that and we're going to need technical resource people agreed to buy the group that's coming together to do this, nobody's favorite technical person.
16:25.649 --> 16:27.512
[SPEAKER_01]: which usually has a budget with it.
16:28.373 --> 16:33.460
[SPEAKER_01]: I can't take any money from the participants and be neutral.
16:34.201 --> 16:47.959
[SPEAKER_01]: Last, typically we need to find philanthropic resources at the point in which everyone has participated in the draft design of what the process is going to be in detail.
16:47.999 --> 16:55.369
[SPEAKER_01]: They all get a draft of that matrix and my pros discussion of it and my suggested budget.
16:55.805 --> 17:01.150
[SPEAKER_01]: I said, if you have a problem with it, you've got to call me, you know, don't tell me you don't want to participate.
17:01.211 --> 17:05.395
[SPEAKER_01]: Just call me and let's talk about how to get a better reflection of what you said.
17:05.435 --> 17:15.565
[SPEAKER_01]: Nobody's names mentioned, but they have to see in the agenda and the work plan and the timetable and the ground rules that we tripped that what they said was heard.
17:15.605 --> 17:21.171
[SPEAKER_01]: And then
17:21.151 --> 17:35.494
[SPEAKER_01]: prescription for what we should do includes here's the groups that we think can best represent this category of stakeholders, but we'll have to convene those people because they are not an organization.
17:36.516 --> 17:46.872
[SPEAKER_01]: You'll have to get them to choose to represent it as for this work that's described just specifically in this stakeholder assessment.
17:46.953 --> 17:49.878
[SPEAKER_01]: And
when we get all the way through that, we can start.
17:50.839 --> 18:04.540
[SPEAKER_01]: So if you don't have time and energy and expertise in the process and some money, you can't get to the point where I then say, okay, everyone's around the table.
18:05.021 --> 18:05.502
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
18:05.522 --> 18:10.770
[SPEAKER_01]: Instead of ground rules, you have to sign a piece of paper and say, I'm going to live with these ground rules.
18:10.930 --> 18:14.175
[SPEAKER_01]: One of them is no odd hominem attacks.
18:14.459 --> 18:19.005
[SPEAKER_01]: Another one is, nothing's decided to let everything's decided.
18:20.186 --> 18:35.826
[SPEAKER_01]: Another one is, we're going to seek unanimity, but settle for overwhelming agreement as the whole group has made an effort to respond to any outliers at the end by modifying whatever the package or the proposal is.
18:36.683 --> 18:59.097
[SPEAKER_01]: and we will have weekly communications summarizing the content of the conversations that the neutral will mean, pain in order for all the constituents, so to speak, of all the people who are in the process can hear what's going on from a neutral source.
18:59.768 --> 19:08.935
[SPEAKER_01]: And as we move towards some point where this agreement on action, the neutral becomes the spokesperson for the process.
19:10.417 --> 19:20.269
[SPEAKER_01]: and I've done this, you know, 50, 60 times in the United States at all different scales, very small neighborhood scale up to national.
19:21.070 --> 19:23.113
[SPEAKER_02]: Now you said something earlier on.
19:23.133 --> 19:26.557
[SPEAKER_02]: I wanted to hear that whole way through that process of price.
19:26.697 --> 19:31.243
[SPEAKER_02]: I do you said something early on which is you have to have people that want to come to a consensus.
19:31.595 --> 19:51.510
[SPEAKER_02]: So, like, for instance, and I'm thinking about the length of this process, and it was so interesting because as I was about to open up my computer to do some research on you, I did my normal little look at my Instagram, and that day I saw this real from this young woman who was very mad because some
19:51.490 --> 20:01.347
[SPEAKER_02]: I forget it was wind or solar energy project to be built on land in New York State that's supposed to be saved for very rare bird wildlife.
20:01.387 --> 20:05.875
[SPEAKER_02]: And I feel like this is a case that a kind of a case that you're probably familiar with.
20:06.276 --> 20:08.740
[SPEAKER_02]: You have two kind of
20:08.720 --> 20:31.627
[SPEAKER_02]: what I would say like good interests like we need to move we need more renewable energy, but then you have people that don't want that on that land because it's protecting very rare birds or their special ecosystem there and you have the development the developers who want to move fast to push this through.
20:31.647 --> 20:32.888
[SPEAKER_01]: Yes.
20:33.138 --> 20:35.324
[SPEAKER_02]: And their agenda is just get it done.
20:36.126 --> 20:39.494
[SPEAKER_02]: So how do you get those kind of parties to work together?
20:39.534 --> 20:41.740
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, well, partly it has to do.
20:42.462 --> 20:49.780
[SPEAKER_01]: And we are working specifically on that question in a number of places because I run a renewable energy.
20:50.030 --> 21:03.868
[SPEAKER_01]: facility, citing clinic at MIT, where my students are learning how to do this work by doing this work for particular communities that want no cost assistance.
21:04.569 --> 21:11.638
[SPEAKER_01]: I've got to send you this case here for I have worked on the Hudson on renewable energy already.
21:11.859 --> 21:14.622
[SPEAKER_01]: There are plenty of cases and so many places.
21:15.083 --> 21:18.147
[SPEAKER_01]: The first thing is you have to reframe the question.
21:18.920 --> 21:20.183
[SPEAKER_01]: It's not who's right.
21:20.223 --> 21:22.969
[SPEAKER_01]: It's not who's going to get everything they want.
21:23.711 --> 21:30.246
[SPEAKER_01]: It's well, if we agree that there's a need for new renewable energy.
21:30.833 --> 21:45.741
[SPEAKER_01]: And if we agree, it should not be built in a way that threatens endangered species, then let's bring a set of people together and say, what are our options for how to achieve those two objectives?
21:46.382 --> 21:49.348
[SPEAKER_02]: I guess I'm wondering if there's a party that
21:49.328 --> 22:01.797
[SPEAKER_02]: Is there any convincing of a party that doesn't have to let's say one party has more power and they don't have to listen to to this adverse party if they have the power the money to go ahead.
22:01.817 --> 22:05.245
[SPEAKER_02]: Do they need more convincing?
22:05.933 --> 22:12.140
[SPEAKER_01]: When I teach negotiation, separate course and negotiation, and students are asked this question a lot.
22:12.200 --> 22:19.088
[SPEAKER_01]: They want to know about spoilers and how you negotiate with spoilers, as a party and how mediators deal with spoilers.
22:19.689 --> 22:35.147
[SPEAKER_01]: And my senses, I just take a very small scenario and say, okay, I'm the less powerful person and I'm talking to the more powerful person in one-on-one conversation.
22:36.089 --> 22:37.331
[SPEAKER_01]: And I say, you sure?
22:37.371 --> 22:41.137
[SPEAKER_01]: Yes, we demand a hundred, or they'll be nothing.
22:41.157 --> 22:46.124
[SPEAKER_01]: We say, so you wouldn't want me to get you something worth more than a hundred.
22:47.126 --> 22:47.646
[SPEAKER_01]: What do you mean?
22:47.667 --> 22:49.930
[SPEAKER_01]: So you only want a hundred.
22:50.691 --> 22:53.956
[SPEAKER_01]: What if I could figure out a way to get you to a hundred?
22:55.318 --> 22:56.921
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, how would you do that?
22:57.181 --> 22:58.783
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, we have to sit and talk.
22:59.745 --> 23:03.210
[SPEAKER_01]: And I need to understand more about why you want a hundred.
23:03.730 --> 23:07.736
[SPEAKER_01]: And then we need to inventory possible ways of getting you more than
100.
23:08.777 --> 23:12.162
[SPEAKER_01]: And I need to understand what's valuable to you in what ways.
23:13.003 --> 23:18.251
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, okay, if you're really going to get me 200, I'll join the conversation.
23:18.311 --> 23:24.280
[SPEAKER_01]: I can't promise, but we'll try that will make that the objective to get you 200.
23:24.300 --> 23:32.792
[SPEAKER_01]: And the problem is reframing.
23:33.278 --> 23:54.350
[SPEAKER_01]: It's open-ended at the outset, and so in the renewable energy stories, especially those that involve birds, which is quite an issue, because I work on offshore wind too, or I did until Trump shut all of them down, the question is, the birds are not flying in front of the blades of turbines all the time.
23:55.051 --> 23:59.337
[SPEAKER_01]: It's only a question during migration when there's an intensity of birds.
24:00.177 --> 24:08.233
[SPEAKER_01]: And we've learned how to change the speed of the turbine, and even that it needs to be shut down for several weeks.
24:09.495 --> 24:12.602
[SPEAKER_01]: And we'll offer compensation if we're wrong.
24:13.724 --> 24:14.906
[SPEAKER_01]: Now can we please try?
24:14.926 --> 24:16.690
[SPEAKER_01]: It's not.
24:17.491 --> 24:19.335
[SPEAKER_01]: I promise you it won't hurt the birds.
24:19.415 --> 24:20.397
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't believe you.
24:21.035 --> 24:33.014
[SPEAKER_01]: You can't hurt any birds that are replaceable, I said, okay, what if I might have to move this to a slightly different location.
24:34.016 --> 24:36.740
[SPEAKER_01]: The developers, but I already bought this land yet.
24:36.920 --> 24:38.944
[SPEAKER_01]: You want to go ahead and you don't want to go ahead.
24:39.545 --> 24:47.397
[SPEAKER_01]: If I can get you an invitation to do what you want to do a half a mile away, you don't want to.
24:47.815 --> 24:53.761
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, how are you going to get it, and they're going to know I want the land, and they're going to raise the price.
24:54.181 --> 25:02.330
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm just asking you if you could do what you want to do slightly different location and no additional cost.
25:03.351 --> 25:04.432
[SPEAKER_01]: Yes, I want that.
25:04.792 --> 25:06.734
[SPEAKER_01]: Will you come into the conversation?
25:08.095 --> 25:17.805
[SPEAKER_01]: And so it's constantly a question of how do you create value through the negotiation?
25:18.123 --> 25:30.781
[SPEAKER_01]: It's problem solving and the problem is how do you create sufficient value to achieve a new version of what people thought they were fighting about?
25:31.382 --> 25:34.106
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, like it's not an awesome win loose.
25:34.246 --> 25:38.953
[SPEAKER_02]: We actually really opening up that binary and looking for solutions.
25:38.993 --> 25:42.798
[SPEAKER_02]: We haven't thought of looking for people to win in ways that they never imagined.
25:43.599 --> 25:43.860
[SPEAKER_01]: Right.
25:44.060 --> 25:46.223
[SPEAKER_01]: And so one book I wrote.
25:46.827 --> 25:49.471
[SPEAKER_01]: as the title, good for you, great for me.
25:50.152 --> 25:50.572
[SPEAKER_01]: A lot of it.
25:51.273 --> 25:58.463
[SPEAKER_01]: Because I have to convince people who are entering into this, this is not about negotiating how much loss as you're going to take.
25:59.525 --> 26:04.432
[SPEAKER_01]: It's not about getting together and teaching people to be reasonable and to compromise.
26:05.413 --> 26:06.034
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
26:06.054 --> 26:07.176
[SPEAKER_01]: It's just not that.
26:07.576 --> 26:11.822
[SPEAKER_01]: And some people can imagine an alternative to that.
26:11.954 --> 26:18.463
[SPEAKER_02]: Did you always think this way or did you learn this through practice or did how did you develop these skills?
26:18.564 --> 26:22.309
[SPEAKER_02]: Because these are very specific skills.
26:22.910 --> 26:39.514
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm very self-conscious about how I teach them and I teach them from practice and I take the practice and I convert it into video and role play simulation and other teaching tools because I know it works.
26:39.865 --> 26:42.572
[SPEAKER_01]: Now, how did I learn it in the beginning?
26:43.214 --> 26:55.748
[SPEAKER_01]: I think it was really a very fortunate to have some great inspiring teachers who didn't know that's what they were teaching me, but who's optimism?
26:55.829 --> 27:15.651
[SPEAKER_01]: and whose openness and whose capacity to function impromptu and whose ability to listen to people and whose ingenious or unconstrained ability to redesign and not be so wedded to the last thing that they thought was perfect.
27:16.372 --> 27:20.436
[SPEAKER_01]: That just a lucky to have a set of people.
27:20.737 --> 27:24.621
[SPEAKER_01]: who added that set of perspectives to my learning.
27:24.661 --> 27:31.167
[SPEAKER_01]: And then when people told me I was mediating, I said, well, what's all the things you do?
27:31.708 --> 27:42.998
[SPEAKER_01]: And then I saw the parallels between things I had fallen into and things that other people spent their life learning how to do as professionals.
27:43.879 --> 27:48.904
[SPEAKER_01]: And then that's what I packaged and started to teach and write about.
27:49.340 --> 28:07.905
[SPEAKER_02]: You talked about when you started it was the 60s and it was a contentious time and universities, but I feel like we're in a kind of parallel time now, and especially like the instance, the example that I mentioned to you, where one person can get on social media,
28:07.885 --> 28:10.127
[SPEAKER_02]: and get everyone up in arms.
28:10.167 --> 28:14.791
[SPEAKER_02]: Like I felt my nervous system started to go and I was ready to write my letters.
28:15.011 --> 28:19.475
[SPEAKER_02]: And so I'm wondering, I guess a couple questions are wrapped in there.
28:19.556 --> 28:21.918
[SPEAKER_02]: Like how have things changed through the decades?
28:22.198 --> 28:23.299
[SPEAKER_02]: Are you noticing that?
28:23.459 --> 28:25.961
[SPEAKER_02]: And how does those like
very special interest groups?
28:26.021 --> 28:30.686
[SPEAKER_02]: And the use of social media and polarization play into your techniques?
28:31.647 --> 28:35.530
[SPEAKER_02]: Any kind of like those changes or what you're noticing that specific to these times?
28:36.269 --> 28:38.954
[SPEAKER_01]: the changes you listed in the question are all there.
28:38.994 --> 28:44.443
[SPEAKER_01]: You cannot work the same way that I worked 20 years ago.
28:44.463 --> 28:50.473
[SPEAKER_01]: I would always prefer to be doing this work face-to-face, but you can't.
28:51.595 --> 28:56.704
[SPEAKER_01]: And so I learned to facilitate these conversations online.
28:57.065 --> 29:01.332
[SPEAKER_01]: And once you're in the digital world, you're in the social media world,
29:01.936 --> 29:09.904
[SPEAKER_01]: And one of the things we ask in terms of people signing unique ground rule.
29:10.728 --> 29:12.450
[SPEAKER_01]: for that occasion.
29:13.151 --> 29:14.513
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm not saying here's a book.
29:14.533 --> 29:15.914
[SPEAKER_01]: We're going to follow Robert's rules.
29:16.355 --> 29:18.297
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm saying here's the ground rules.
29:18.437 --> 29:20.880
[SPEAKER_01]: One of them is no odd hominum attacks.
29:21.421 --> 29:40.144
[SPEAKER_01]: Another is you need to let us use centralized communication to keep everybody updated and we don't say anyone's name next to our efforts to summarize what's happened and we don't prepare minutes
29:40.124 --> 29:56.743
[SPEAKER_01]: We put a narrative story that anybody read and because it's written by the neutral, it doesn't serve as a second wave for people to get another bite at the apple for the point of view by concluding it.
29:56.823 --> 29:59.185
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, I really almost came out the way I wanted.
29:59.225 --> 30:00.227
[SPEAKER_01]: It's nothing like that.
30:00.847 --> 30:09.557
[SPEAKER_02]: Can you say a little more about the difference between minutes and a narrative and
30:10.246 --> 30:27.264
[SPEAKER_01]: I do not believe that groups, especially groups with shared interests like church groups or religious associations or university departments, where people have shared, I don't believe they should operate by Robert's rules, motions and second motions.
30:27.845 --> 30:34.212
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, I'm actually quite a skilled parliamentarian, so I know when they tell me I can't.
30:34.192 --> 30:55.626
[SPEAKER_01]: revoke Robert rules like I know exactly how to do it by using Robert's rules to revoke Robert But the particular meetings that we want to have and in this little book breaking Robert's rules I describe What the alternative set of agreements look like procedurally that you need people to commit to
30:56.602 --> 30:57.984
[SPEAKER_01]: if they're going to work together.
30:58.425 --> 31:04.934
[SPEAKER_01]: Now, they don't know each other in many cases that they think they have to be against some bodies.
31:04.954 --> 31:09.100
[SPEAKER_01]: They are for something they said or wrote or did a decade ago.
31:09.140 --> 31:22.980
[SPEAKER_01]: And the neutral has to intervene between those folks and put a stop to those kinds of die tribes that make it impossible for people to go forward.
31:23.264 --> 31:27.713
[SPEAKER_01]: We don't, in the present day, we're not using neutrals.
31:28.594 --> 31:38.353
[SPEAKER_01]: Even in Gaza, the so-called neutrals were not professional mediators, Qatar, and each of, we're not neutral.
31:38.738 --> 31:58.182
[SPEAKER_01]: And the reason I think the head as much struggle as I did, reaching a final set of steps, and they're going to have a lot more trouble over the next several stages, is they don't have neutrals who've won the trust of the parties in generating the terms of the agreement.
31:58.543 --> 31:58.823
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah.
31:59.225 --> 32:05.841
[SPEAKER_01]: And so I have been trying to institutionalize the use of neutrals.
32:05.922 --> 32:15.445
[SPEAKER_01]: So California, which was so worried about building renewable energy facilities, then it decided that it needed to stop.
32:15.425 --> 32:20.855
[SPEAKER_01]: local engagement in those decisions because it was slowing everything down.
32:20.915 --> 32:26.084
[SPEAKER_01]: The state passed a law saying there won't be any local hearing local discussion.
32:26.205 --> 32:32.556
[SPEAKER_01]: Only the state will have one state level review wants the proposal comes from the developer.
32:32.840 --> 32:45.820
[SPEAKER_01]: I told them it was a terrible idea and they went ahead and then they were just in court fighting about whether the state could preempt local decision making and I said the alternative is the process I'm describing.
32:46.020 --> 32:54.814
[SPEAKER_01]: When the developer thinks they want to explore the idea, they should be able to come to the state, signing agency and say,
32:54.794 --> 32:58.319
[SPEAKER_01]: I need a neutral from a panel of professional neutrals.
32:58.620 --> 33:05.410
[SPEAKER_01]: And I need a state to pay for the neutral, because I can't pay for them, because nobody will believe the neutral if I'm paying for them.
33:05.670 --> 33:12.440
[SPEAKER_01]: And California set up that system, because everything was stopped to rush things forward.
33:13.561 --> 33:13.662
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
33:13.682 --> 33:17.147
[SPEAKER_01]: And Massachusetts just passed new sighting regulations.
33:17.267 --> 33:24.177
[SPEAKER_01]: And I'd like to think we have something to do with the fact that they didn't copy California and New York and preempt.
33:24.157 --> 33:39.124
[SPEAKER_01]: local participation, they created the need for the to be a negotiation between the developer, the officials and the stakeholders over what we're calling a community benefits agreement.
33:39.805 --> 33:41.508
[SPEAKER_01]: That's what's being negotiated.
33:42.129 --> 33:48.561
[SPEAKER_01]: If this thing goes forward the way the developer is proposing, what are the benefits?
33:48.743 -->
33:53.093
[SPEAKER_01]: that the developer is promising to deliver to all the different groups.
33:53.895 --> 33:57.062
[SPEAKER_01]: And that's all negotiated with the help of a mediator.
33:57.102 --> 34:04.178
[SPEAKER_01]: And it gets added to the permit request by the developer, which means it's enforced by the state.
34:04.740 --> 34:05.301
[SPEAKER_01]: Uh-huh.
34:05.585 --> 34:08.709
[SPEAKER_01]: because it's now part of the terms of what they, what was agreed.
34:09.109 --> 34:09.430
[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah.
34:10.251 --> 34:17.980
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm the key thing we need to do now that we're not doing is add an N plus one's party.
34:18.380 --> 34:28.092
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't care how many participants you have to have somebody to manage a problem solving process, not just a discussion.
34:28.152 --> 34:33.178
[SPEAKER_01]: We don't want a discussion leader, which means they better know a lot,
34:33.158 --> 34:43.918
[SPEAKER_01]: about the substance in order to help them reframe the potential new versions of things that create more value, which means that that neutral needs a team.
34:44.298 --> 34:47.965
[SPEAKER_01]: It's a job that facilitates these big processes.
34:48.025 --> 34:49.428
[SPEAKER_01]: That's why I have CBI.
34:51.171 --> 34:52.012
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, wow.
34:52.373 --> 34:54.036
[SPEAKER_02]: I'm just thinking about
34:54.910 --> 35:07.038
[SPEAKER_02]: someone that's neutral, they have to be able to do, I guess, the process, like you said, they have to interview all the people figure out who the stakeholders are, who's important to be there.
35:07.078 --> 35:13.493
[SPEAKER_02]: The whole process you took us through, what are the main questions concerns?
35:13.473 --> 35:14.174
[SPEAKER_01]: Draft it.
35:14.654 --> 35:15.535
[SPEAKER_01]: Trusted.
35:15.556 --> 35:17.518
[SPEAKER_01]: Everyone you talk to and draft.
35:17.538 --> 35:18.219
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah.
35:18.239 --> 35:23.986
[SPEAKER_01]: Get everybody to have a chance to be out to own the process you're then going to follow.
35:24.266 --> 35:24.827
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah.
35:24.847 --> 35:32.856
[SPEAKER_02]: And I know a little bit about some of the issues that you're talking about as far as these renewable projects.
35:32.997 --> 35:39.745
[SPEAKER_02]: I mean, I know that things got stopped by so much regulation in California that people couldn't get anything done.
35:39.945 --> 35:41.607
[SPEAKER_02]: And so I think.
35:42.194 --> 35:46.521
[SPEAKER_02]: as a tendency and the U.S. we tend to go one way to the next.
35:47.242 --> 35:49.946
[SPEAKER_02]: So they said, you know, then they said, well, nothing's getting built.
35:50.647 --> 35:56.216
[SPEAKER_02]: So dysregulate everything and your voice is for a different way, not all or nothing way.
35:56.296 --> 36:05.411
[SPEAKER_02]: What do you say about your process as far as timing when someone says they want to be a part of this, but when are we going to have a solution?
36:05.471 --> 36:06.052
[SPEAKER_02]: Is it one year?
36:06.072 --> 36:06.793
[SPEAKER_02]: Is it five years?
36:06.833 --> 36:08.556
[SPEAKER_02]: It seems like a long process.
36:08.890 --> 36:12.879
[SPEAKER_01]: My motto, all of this, got to go slow to go fast.
36:12.899 --> 36:13.440
[SPEAKER_02]: I love it.
36:13.600 --> 36:16.506
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, I do, you're going to say, and it's so true, it's so true.
36:16.947 --> 36:23.541
[SPEAKER_01]: And if someone says, we have to have a decision in two years, I say, okay, that's what the group has to accept.
36:24.744 --> 36:25.466
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah.
36:25.486 --> 36:28.452
[SPEAKER_01]: If we say one year, then that's what the group has to,
36:28.752 --> 36:34.159
[SPEAKER_01]: Except, and we have to write the agenda, and if we can't do it, we just don't start.
36:34.800 --> 36:58.371
[SPEAKER_02]: So have you ever found that the problems, the issues, the stakeholders actually change during the time, or is there some agreement that once we decide these are the issues, we don't add more, because I guess if you're working on something that's long term a few years, there could suddenly
36:58.351 --> 36:59.674
[SPEAKER_02]: know about it at the beginning.
37:00.275 --> 37:01.097
[SPEAKER_01]: Absolutely right.
37:01.899 --> 37:17.153
[SPEAKER_01]: Which is why in the ground rules we say if the group decides the whole group to add someone during then that person has to come before the group.
37:18.179 --> 37:28.695
[SPEAKER_01]: The group needs to stay, we will invite you, but you have to accept the ground rules, not everything we've said so far, but the ground rules about how we're going to work by consensus.
37:28.996 --> 37:33.060
[SPEAKER_01]: We're going to have joint fact finding help from neutral parties and so on and so forth.
37:33.740 --> 37:45.291
[SPEAKER_01]: And I also require every group to have a representative and alternate because things happen in people's lives during that time.
37:46.051 --> 37:46.372
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
37:46.392 --> 37:50.635
[SPEAKER_01]: I can't really educate a brand new person about everything that's come before.
37:51.036 --> 37:58.142
[SPEAKER_01]: And the relationships that have evolved are lost.
37:58.966 --> 38:04.529
[SPEAKER_01]: but to switch chairs during, but new people can be at it.
38:04.549 --> 38:08.385
[SPEAKER_01]: And we make that provision at the outset just the reasons you match.
38:08.990 --> 38:32.230
[SPEAKER_02]: This is so interesting, one thing that came to my mind is you're saying that is, I'm guessing you're making sure that the person who's there is the person that can agree to things, like I'm just thinking about if a company or someone sends someone that's not actually in any power to say, okay, and then they agree to something, and there's someone else at the company that says, actually no.
38:32.513 --> 38:34.435
[SPEAKER_01]: You have all the right questions on your list.
38:34.936 --> 38:36.157
[SPEAKER_01]: Laura, I mean, absolutely.
38:36.337
--> 38:47.110
[SPEAKER_01]: And the way we accommodate that is a little bit more subtle than saying, oh, we only want people who have the power to decide, because in some organizations, that's not possible.
38:48.151 --> 38:52.576
[SPEAKER_01]: And so what we do is we work toward a draft agreement.
38:53.737 --> 39:00.445
[SPEAKER_01]: And when we have that draft, everyone is responsible
39:01.454 --> 39:04.957
[SPEAKER_01]: Finding out whether that's okay with the membership.
39:05.077 --> 39:08.461
[SPEAKER_01]: And if that membership is just a CEO, that's your business.
39:09.041 --> 39:12.024
[SPEAKER_01]: And then you come back to the table with the full group.
39:12.545 --> 39:20.352
[SPEAKER_01]: And everyone speaks and says, this is how I went to get authority to now formally sign this.
39:21.253 --> 39:21.753
[SPEAKER_02]: Beautiful.
39:22.254 --> 39:23.215
[SPEAKER_01]: Because it's different.
39:24.216 --> 39:27.799
[SPEAKER_01]: And you can't, and many, or again,
39:28.336 --> 39:41.046
[SPEAKER_01]: has in its constitution and its charter that nobody can speak for or upon when they go to something and they're called or upon even the president has to be by a vote of the membership.
39:41.414 --> 39:41.955
[SPEAKER_01]: period.
39:42.455 --> 39:52.406
[SPEAKER_01]: So we want a lot of on to be one of the environmental representatives, the person's coming, and everyone needs to understand the constraints that each person faces.
39:52.466 --> 40:00.254
[SPEAKER_01]: So up until the end, they're speaking like not speaking for a particular constituency.
40:01.015 --> 40:06.561
[SPEAKER_01]: Until we jointly reach a proposal
40:06.980 --> 40:23.298
[SPEAKER_01]: something that everyone can accept, then everyone takes that penultimate version back to get permission, however it is required in their context, then we come back together and we produce the agreement.
40:23.959 --> 40:31.047
[SPEAKER_01]: In most instances, the final thing we produce is a proposal, not a decision.
40:31.415 --> 40:43.254
[SPEAKER_01]: because an elected body and appointed body cannot delegate away the authority to give a permit or allow development or allocate public funds.
40:44.236 --> 40:51.388
[SPEAKER_01]: So all we're producing is the proposal to whoever has that final legal authority.
40:52.049 --> 40:54.553
[SPEAKER_01]: But what we're giving them is
40:55.580 --> 40:59.104
[SPEAKER_01]: If you do this, everyone's going to think you're great.
41:00.145 --> 41:03.970
[SPEAKER_01]: Everyone's going to vote for you because everyone is agreed to this.
41:04.370 --> 41:05.151
[SPEAKER_02]: That's a nice feeling.
41:05.912 --> 41:07.654
[SPEAKER_01]: It's an incentive.
41:07.714 --> 41:24.574
[SPEAKER_01]: We don't usually have somebody showing up at the end saying, well, I wasn't consulted, and I'm the mayor, and so we're not going to do this.
41:24.925 --> 41:27.250
[SPEAKER_01]: but there's a lot of votes here.
41:27.290 --> 41:32.421
[SPEAKER_01]: Look at the list of all the categories of groups that were involved.
41:32.441 --> 41:38.914
[SPEAKER_01]: You sure you want to go against all of these groups that reached agreement amongst themselves.
41:39.556 --> 41:44.065
[SPEAKER_01]: And that's useful enough to get the implementation to happen.
41:45.361 --> 42:05.767
[SPEAKER_02]: that's beautiful and you mentioned that often it's this because I was going to ask you like who makes sure that the follow-through happens after and I think you mentioned just a little while ago that often the state makes sure that the follow-through is there or it's is it different depending on what the project is.
42:05.787 --> 42:15.199
[SPEAKER_01]: It is often necessary to invent the summer arrangement that's
42:15.584 --> 42:41.963
[SPEAKER_01]: 60 parties negotiate something about whether housing should be built here or this open land should be preserved and it took us six months and there was a plan to have part of the land for preservation and part of the land for housing and the housing developers agreed that they would buy the rights to the other land even though the city had responsibility for it didn't have the money
42:41.943 --> 42:52.510
[SPEAKER_01]: So the developers part of the cost of building my housing is preserving this portion of the site and I'm preserving it better because I'm going to buy it and turn it over to a land trust.
42:52.861 --> 42:57.067
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm preserving it better than it was going to be preserved if I didn't do this.
42:57.988 --> 43:04.877
[SPEAKER_01]: So that's why they let me take 25% of the land to build housing, but we agreed on the design of the housing.
43:05.218 --> 43:08.282
[SPEAKER_01]: And we agreed on how many units might be subsidized.
43:08.522 --> 43:13.329
[SPEAKER_01]: And we agreed on how many units might be for young families from that place.
43:13.369 --> 43:22.581
[SPEAKER_01]: And all of that was negotiation, which never would have been required of the developer to get the zoning permit
43:22.831 --> 43:28.228
[SPEAKER_01]: and the land to be preserved is now really preserved with a fun to maintain it.
43:28.248 --> 43:36.975
[SPEAKER_01]: That all part of the invention of the added value that comes from collective or creative problems,
43:37.225 --> 43:38.186
[SPEAKER_02]: It's incredible.
43:38.506 --> 43:53.422
[SPEAKER_02]: I hope you feel so proud of what you've done and what you're doing here, especially right now when things can get so heated so fast to have a system for bringing down the temperature and actually coming to new solutions.
43:53.502 --> 43:56.085
[SPEAKER_02]: It's just, it's really something special.
43:56.986 --> 44:01.731
[SPEAKER_01]: Some days I feel very pleased that we're doing this.
44:02.015 --> 44:08.742
[SPEAKER_01]: And other days, I feel depressed that where they should be doing it, they haven't yet seen that.
44:09.423 --> 44:10.143
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
44:10.163 --> 44:20.073
[SPEAKER_01]: Nobody's suggested it
to them or they, somebody has got in their mind that you can't possibly involve other people in it who disagree with you.
44:21.595 --> 44:29.423
[SPEAKER_01]: And so when I can, the folk, the federal energy regulatory commission,
44:29.909 --> 44:33.874
[SPEAKER_01]: has to give a permit to put a dam in or to take a dam out.
44:34.434 --> 44:44.806
[SPEAKER_01]: There's all kinds of indigenous communities trying to have long-standing dams taken down so that the water can run free so that the salmon can breathe again and it's all on.
44:46.729 --> 44:52.255
[SPEAKER_01]: It took me many years and FERC amended the law that
44:52.707 --> 44:57.758
[SPEAKER_01]: dictates how it works and says we have two options.
44:57.798 --> 45:07.480
[SPEAKER_01]: We have the normal regulatory process and we have a negotiated regulatory process and it's up to the applicant to say which you want.
45:08.101 --> 45:11.509
[SPEAKER_01]: By the way, the normal process takes at least five years.
45:12.940 --> 45:18.291
[SPEAKER_01]: The negotiated process could take five months, could take five years might not work.
45:18.912 --> 45:21.056
[SPEAKER_01]: But here's how it functions.
45:21.938 --> 45:32.439
[SPEAKER_01]: And it allows for groups that would otherwise not be able to interact with regulators because we don't like regulators interacting with the people seeking permits.
45:32.459 --> 45:33.902
[SPEAKER_01]: It's against the law.
45:34.220 --> 45:39.026
[SPEAKER_01]: but when they say, no, this is going to be a negotiated regulation.
45:40.187 --> 45:44.232
[SPEAKER_01]: They can also together work together and come up with a proposal to the commission.
45:45.194 --> 46:00.092
[SPEAKER_01]: It took years to get that commission's authorizing legislation changed, but now it's always available, and nobody has to think of it, design it, and fund it, nothing, it's all there.
46:00.460 --> 46:10.869
[SPEAKER_01]: And if we could get in every regulatory process, local, federal, an option, I wouldn't make anyone do it.
46:10.889 --> 46:18.735
[SPEAKER_02]: Right, there'd be a lot, it'd be a lot more effective than having one by one a case come to you or someone recommend you.
46:18.875 --> 46:23.760
[SPEAKER_02]: If it was, it's like, it's kind of like the opt-in opt-out research.
46:23.780 --> 46:30.265
[SPEAKER_02]: Right, if you're automatically, yeah, if it's automatically there,
46:30.616 --> 46:34.179
[SPEAKER_01]: And I have argued this at the UN.
46:34.620 --> 46:40.685
[SPEAKER_01]: I said that we have all kinds of situations where the UN is asked to intervene.
46:40.705 --> 46:44.228
[SPEAKER_01]: It doesn't know how to get in the middle.
46:44.929 --> 46:47.571
[SPEAKER_01]: It just assumes that needs to be meetings.
46:49.573 --> 46:49.673
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
46:49.693 --> 46:52.336
[SPEAKER_01]: There's no theory behind what the thing.
46:53.016 --> 46:59.442
[SPEAKER_01]: And I've tried to get the mediation professionals
46:59.776 --> 47:11.107
[SPEAKER_01]: to get the U.N. to amend its charter to say when asked, this is how the U.N. will intervene in a dispute amongst countries.
47:11.767 --> 47:28.163
[SPEAKER_01]: It's already been thought through, it does a model, independent media enters that and it's been impossible when Jimmy Carter was a YP organized a meeting at the Carter Center for the heads of all of the major international entities.
47:28.649 --> 47:41.002
[SPEAKER_01]: like the United Nations, he even had been UNDP and World Bank, and I had a chance to present all of this and Carter was completely consistent with his view of the world.
47:41.443 --> 47:47.870
[SPEAKER_01]: And he served as a mediator, after he was president in lots of disputes, he really understood it.
47:47.890 --> 47:52.935
[SPEAKER_01]: And we tried to get the heads of all these agencies to say,
47:53.557 --> 48:22.382
[SPEAKER_01]: you should have it as a regular option yeah it was too hard in two days to answer all their anxieties but I'm in charge you saying this is how we should do it I'm one who should run this process of meeting them up between the fighting countries right this is why President Trump is not going to be able to do anything when Hamas
48:23.088 --> 48:24.650
[SPEAKER_01]: I know I was in the agreement.
48:24.670 --> 48:33.320
[SPEAKER_01]: It was 0.16 in the agreement and I know you think you had signatures because you had discussions with people.
48:33.901 --> 48:42.591
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, no relationships have been built where anybody who could help at that moment has the trust of all sides.
48:43.412 --> 48:52.082
[SPEAKER_01]: And so it's a paper thin agreement
48:52.687 --> 49:02.687
[SPEAKER_01]: And it's just, you have to promote the institutional reforms ahead of the particular crisis in the middle of the crisis, thank you.
49:03.829 --> 49:06.855
[SPEAKER_01]: And she said, well, who you, what do you want?
49:06.955 --> 49:08.839
[SPEAKER_01]: Why are you telling us what to do?
49:09.511 --> 49:19.302
[SPEAKER_02]: Right, people, they, you know, it's the same thing in a couple scenarios, they, they wait till the, they're at full crisis to, to try to bring in help.
49:19.342 --> 49:21.564
[SPEAKER_02]: And by that time, you know, so it's a little late.
49:21.764 --> 49:22.505
[SPEAKER_02]: So a lot harder.
49:22.525 --> 49:24.487
[SPEAKER_02]: So you should get in early.
49:24.527 --> 49:31.275
[SPEAKER_02]: And it's like they say, you know, when you're putting a business together, you decide at that time, what's going to happen if we get in a fight?
49:32.296 --> 49:33.337
[SPEAKER_02]: How will we resolve it?
49:33.357 --> 49:35.219
[SPEAKER_02]: What's going to happen if one of us wants to leave?
49:35.579 --> 49:37.982
[SPEAKER_02]: And you
49:38.603 --> 49:46.572
[SPEAKER_01]: Yep, my most recent book is about a Canadian experiment, which is truly wonderful in Alberta.
49:46.892 --> 50:02.530
[SPEAKER_01]: The court system offers the parties in a case that's coming
before the court, the option of having the judge instead of adjudicating the case turn into a mediator and mediated.
50:02.990 --> 50:04.392
[SPEAKER_01]: All they have to do is ask,
50:05.452 --> 50:06.954
[SPEAKER_01]: They're still there with their lawyers.
50:07.575 --> 50:13.724
[SPEAKER_01]: Judge comes down from the day us sits around the table and knows how to mediate.
50:14.646 --> 50:23.359
[SPEAKER_01]: And if they reach an agreement that the judge then issues a binding statement implementing the agreement that the parties worked out.
50:23.896 --> 50:26.680
[SPEAKER_01]: and two other provinces have copied that.
50:27.181 --> 50:28.924
[SPEAKER_01]: There is no such thing in the US.
50:29.505 --> 50:35.294
[SPEAKER_01]: The US, a judge can say, don't you waste in my time, go try to mediate this out of court.
50:35.354 --> 50:38.178
[SPEAKER_01]: And when you fail, come back and see me.
50:38.398 --> 50:38.679
[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah.
50:38.779 --> 50:42.124
[SPEAKER_01]: But it's called judicial dispute resolution.
50:42.986 --> 50:46.812
[SPEAKER_01]: I have the access to the, for the first time, they're all confidential.
50:47.653 --> 50:48.674
[SPEAKER_01]: So there's no records.
50:49.456 --> 50:52.300
[SPEAKER_01]: So I have 10, 10, nine cases.
50:52.617 --> 51:06.848
[SPEAKER_01]: where I interviewed everybody before during an after and out about this wonderful innovation and the book is out and I have judges in the US saying, how come they're allowed to do that in Canada?
51:07.209 --> 51:09.293
[SPEAKER_01]: I say you're allowed to do that too.
51:10.032 --> 51:14.397
[SPEAKER_01]: They said, oh, no, but I ever told me I could do that, no, you were allowed to do that.
51:14.738 --> 51:26.732
[SPEAKER_01]: And then I have to tell them in the state that they're in what the federal and state code is that actually permits them to do this, even though it's not ever been what judges have done in the America.
51:27.373 --> 51:31.618
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, it's like it's not brought to their attention, so they're not using it.
51:31.919 --> 51:44.494
[SPEAKER_02]: So this system that you created, this model, it works really with across environmental, across disputes with couples, across disputes between countries.
51:45.155 --> 51:45.416
[SPEAKER_01]: Yes.
51:46.597 --> 51:53.526
[SPEAKER_01]: If you look at this CBI.org website, you'll see 10, 15 case studies.
51:54.206 --> 51:57.150
[SPEAKER_01]: If you look at our website called Renewable,
51:57.586 --> 52:07.854
[SPEAKER_01]: hyphenenergy.mit.edu, you'll see we did 53 case studies of places where projects were stopped.
52:08.335 --> 52:11.123
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, because we want to understand why.
52:11.238 --> 52:13.261
[SPEAKER_01]: so that we can show what the answer is.
52:13.681 --> 52:15.944
[SPEAKER_02]: We talked a good amount about renewable energy.
52:16.065 --> 52:40.097
[SPEAKER_02]: Could you share maybe, and this was so interesting about the disputes with couples, can you share maybe one more case, either conflict between nations or the water getting clean water that you sent me, one more success story for our listeners?
52:40.820 --> 52:58.356
[SPEAKER_01]: across the United States, all kinds of battles between neighboring homeowners, housing informal organizations, they're, I don't know what legal power homeowner associations really have.
52:58.673 --> 53:06.324
[SPEAKER_01]: people live in a community, a gated community, there's a homeowner's association, and two people are fighting with each other.
53:06.364 --> 53:13.876
[SPEAKER_01]: Neighbors, one says, you cut down my part of the tree, you do added the width of your driveway.
53:13.936 --> 53:15.698
[SPEAKER_01]: That's my land, you're sure.
53:15.718 --> 53:22.909
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh yeah, a whole long list, and there's even landlord rent or versions of these battles.
53:23.412 --> 53:42.535
[SPEAKER_01]: And we have across the country created housing mediation services they're in place and so instead of somebody going next door and screaming at someone or throwing exit their house or whatever it is that we're going to do or filing a lawsuit.
53:43.190 --> 53:49.578
[SPEAKER_01]: day, go online, put the problem in a digital form.
53:50.158 --> 53:57.487
[SPEAKER_01]: And some immediate accomplishments says, I can come to you, you can come to me, but let's get sitting a room.
53:58.328 --> 54:03.595
[SPEAKER_01]: And then both you guys tell me what you think happened and what you think is the problem.
54:04.116 --> 54:11.104
[SPEAKER_01]: And let's see if we can't work something out.
54:11.438 --> 54:16.724
[SPEAKER_01]: there are housing, tenant landlord, housing mediation services.
54:17.125 --> 54:23.872
[SPEAKER_01]: One more surprising example, started in Hawaii, it's all the way across to Philadelphia now.
54:25.394 --> 54:28.317
[SPEAKER_01]: Peer mediation in middle schools.
54:30.240 --> 54:34.965
[SPEAKER_01]: The teachers don't know, but the kids know,
54:35.435 --> 54:41.804
[SPEAKER_01]: who ought to be the mediator in their class who will help to kids fighting about something.
54:42.085 --> 54:45.269
[SPEAKER_01]: It's not going to deal with discipline between the school system and a kid.
54:46.391 --> 54:59.350
[SPEAKER_01]: When the kids are fighting on the playground, instead of sending them both to speed the team to have their school from making a problem, they say, we want pit mediation.
54:59.532 --> 55:08.464
[SPEAKER_01]: And there's kids lined up, scheduled each week, who have been trained at the school in this package of things on peer mediation.
55:08.985 --> 55:19.199
[SPEAKER_01]: There are kids from the class, but who took this training, and they sit with the kids who were fighting, and they have a set of routines that they've learned.
55:20.200 --> 55:25.067
[SPEAKER_01]: And the teacher is sitting in the back of the room, but doesn't get to say anything.
55:25.503 --> 55:28.840
[SPEAKER_01]: And to the extent, something is agreed
and approved.
55:28.980 --> 55:30.066
[SPEAKER_01]: It's agreed and approved.
55:30.086 --> 55:30.709
[SPEAKER_01]: That's the end.
55:30.729 --> 55:33.201
[SPEAKER_01]: If the work, it doesn't work.
55:33.637 --> 55:48.194
[SPEAKER_01]: But there were every class of kids knows, it's not the kids with the highest grades, it's not the kids who most popular, it's not the kids who are the best athletes, it's not the kids that teachers are sure to name.
55:48.214 --> 55:52.840
[SPEAKER_01]: As long as you ask the kids, yeah, thank you.
55:52.860 --> 56:01.770
[SPEAKER_01]: Various here, they know, and it turns out a lot of the time, it's kids that come from more religious households.
56:03.421 --> 56:23.180
[SPEAKER_01]: And, you know, not all the kids want to be mediators, not all the kids are able at the end of this short training program, but it's called peer mediation and it started in one school in Hawaii and it just went to the west coast and then it all crossed the country.
56:23.220 --> 56:29.546
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm sad to say mostly at the beginning for a decade in private schools.
56:30.527 --> 56:30.627
[SPEAKER_03]: Okay.
56:31.147 --> 56:40.341
[SPEAKER_01]: but especially friends that society of friend schools, that schools that live by friends principles, fit right in, wasn't an issue.
56:41.182 --> 56:47.511
[SPEAKER_01]: Getting public schools, you can just imagine the debate about, well, what is this?
56:48.332 --> 56:51.577
[SPEAKER_01]: What the teachers are not taking responsibility for discipline anymore?
56:51.597 --> 56:54.441
[SPEAKER_01]: You're gonna let kids discipline other kids?
56:55.122 --> 57:00.310
[SPEAKER_01]: No, it's about settling the dispute
57:01.724 --> 57:08.133
[SPEAKER_01]: and it was very hard to get some public schools and any never agreed to it.
57:08.613 --> 57:25.697
[SPEAKER_01]: But I'm trying to follow your cue to say, all these areas of realms of public conflict where mediation, collect collaborative problem solving can work.
57:25.957 --> 57:30.043
[SPEAKER_01]: And it's not wildly different applications.
57:30.462 --> 57:31.824
[SPEAKER_02]: That's what's so interesting.
57:32.245 --> 57:39.596
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, that is what is so interesting that you can take that model and really replicate it in so many different places.
57:39.616 --> 57:45.165
[SPEAKER_02]: Do you have any trainings online for people who want to become mediators?
57:46.887 --> 57:48.069
[SPEAKER_01]: And yes, I do.
57:48.910 --> 57:58.545
[SPEAKER_01]: And the program on negotiation offers many times a year, three day, four day, five day mediation trainings, but they charge money.
57:58.795 --> 58:00.036
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't get any part of it.
58:00.257 --> 58:08.326
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't want any part of the money, but my colleagues have institutionalized the training and made it a business.
58:09.687 --> 58:13.892
[SPEAKER_01]: So yes, there is mediation training available.
58:14.352 --> 58:16.755
[SPEAKER_01]: A lot of it they prefer to do it in person.
58:18.397 --> 58:21.260
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm sure there are online mediation trainings.
58:21.420 --> 58:28.448
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't do them.
58:28.883 --> 58:29.544
[SPEAKER_01]: Great.
58:30.165 --> 58:33.549
[SPEAKER_01]: Through MIT, Expro, that's MIT's online courses.
58:34.190 --> 58:38.656
[SPEAKER_01]: Our Harvard Business School has a negotiation training online.
58:38.676 --> 58:42.281
[SPEAKER_01]: It's just $5,000 for each person to take training.
58:42.581 --> 58:43.823
[SPEAKER_02]: Just to start $5,000.
58:43.903 --> 58:49.751
[SPEAKER_01]: I've done a lot of training around the world in my life.
58:50.452 --> 58:54.157
[SPEAKER_01]: And a lot of this kind of training is best done in person.
58:54.578 --> 58:54.958
[SPEAKER_02]: OK.
58:55.462 --> 58:59.768
[SPEAKER_01]: people can spontaneously say, well, I don't get this or I don't get that.
59:00.369 --> 59:08.099
[SPEAKER_01]: Or they're really dealing with other people in practice situations face-to-face and the emotions are more real.
59:09.821 --> 59:15.529
[SPEAKER_01]: So yes, there is online training, I'm not a huge fan of it, but it's there.
59:16.471 --> 59:30.044
[SPEAKER_02]: Before, and I wanted you to tell us other ways to get involved to support your work, is there anything I missed that I didn't ask you that's important to just bring into this conversation, to tie it up or add to it?
59:33.547 --> 59:41.294
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm particularly concerned about cross-cultural communication in this kind of work.
59:43.476 --> 59:45.398
[SPEAKER_01]: You can be really, really good.
59:45.935 --> 59:57.889
[SPEAKER_01]: at doing this, but if you don't understand what people in the room are saying to you and they don't understand what you're saying back, I don't care that you're really good at it.
59:58.049 --> 01:00:00.111
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't even care if you're doing all the right things.
01:00:00.612 --> 01:00:02.714
[SPEAKER_01]: It's not going to work.
01:00:02.734 --> 01:00:15.469
[SPEAKER_01]: And so there is a kind of cross-cultural communication overlay, which we don't know how to teach, we don't teach.
01:00:15.685 --> 01:00:45.405
[SPEAKER_01]: 40 years teaching a group of Bedouin professionals in Israel, how to mediate, and then I paired them up with Israeli mediators, and we had teams, many, many, many Bedouin settlements throughout Israel, particularly in the south and in the desert, that have been there
01:00:45.723 --> 01:00:46.464
[SPEAKER_01]: That's it.
01:00:46.484 --> 01:00:54.975
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, if they are often sometimes Muslim, they are not Palestinian, they're better when and they can trace their ancestry usually to Jordan.
01:00:55.856 --> 01:01:05.368
[SPEAKER_01]: But they've been living in Israel in the same places, not wandering around with their sheep, but living in the same places, and Israel has never recognized.
01:01:05.821 --> 01:01:09.148
[SPEAKER_01]: their rights to own land or to be in those
places.
01:01:09.830 --> 01:01:25.804
[SPEAKER_01]: And so I spent some years encouraging mediation between the state of Israel, the Bedouin tribes, and the surrounding Jewish community about some sort of
01:01:25.784 --> 01:01:29.728
[SPEAKER_01]: stability to the ownership of the better-win community.
01:01:29.768 --> 01:01:43.242
[SPEAKER_01]: And I took those teams to Turkey because nobody on the better-win side wanted to be seen going to joint training with his drill and before the current war.
01:01:43.862 --> 01:01:48.487
[SPEAKER_01]: And we trained them jointly for multiple years.
01:01:48.547 --> 01:01:52.551
[SPEAKER_01]: We could take
01:01:52.987 --> 01:02:04.505
[SPEAKER_01]: that were mediation teams to deal with the fact that the room was gonna have both groups and nobody was gonna be trusted to be neutral in that context.
01:02:05.208 --> 01:02:05.308
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
01:02:05.812 --> 01:02:09.255
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm just saying this is one response.
01:02:09.956 --> 01:02:11.898
[SPEAKER_02]: No, you brought up such a good point.
01:02:12.178 --> 01:02:18.405
[SPEAKER_02]: Oh, I want to like slap myself for not thinking to ask that because the cultural component is so important, right?
01:02:18.425 --> 01:02:22.088
[SPEAKER_02]: Because you have different cultures even within families.
01:02:22.108 --> 01:02:29.436
[SPEAKER_02]: And you can have someone that feels that looking in the eye, take a very kind of simple example, is a sign of respect.
01:02:29.896 --> 01:02:34.941
[SPEAKER_02]: And you can have someone that's, as it's a sign of aggression.
01:02:34.921 --> 01:02:41.030
[SPEAKER_02]: I mean, there are many, many, many of those examples happening in communication in one room.
01:02:41.832 --> 01:02:58.397
[SPEAKER_01]: And we have produced at the program on negotiation several webinars on cross cultural communication and dispute resolution, people that do its study and they exist to alert people.
01:02:58.782 --> 01:03:08.421
[SPEAKER_01]: to the issues and to highlight some ideas, but it's very much an unknown realm part of practice.
01:03:09.142 --> 01:03:12.328
[SPEAKER_01]: And it's often the reason that mediation doesn't work.
01:03:12.889 --> 01:03:18.360
[SPEAKER_01]: It's not that the mediation process
01:03:18.931 --> 01:03:23.978
[SPEAKER_01]: it's just that the gap between the people isn't just about their interest being in odds.
01:03:24.579 --> 01:03:26.742
[SPEAKER_01]: They cannot understand each other.
01:03:26.782 --> 01:03:35.996
[SPEAKER_01]: You can't problem solve without being able to listen to and understand the other person.
01:03:36.056 --> 01:03:38.239
[SPEAKER_01]: And that includes not just hearing the words.
01:03:38.540 --> 01:03:41.442
[SPEAKER_01]: It's just looking someone in the eye, is an issue.
01:03:41.482 --> 01:03:49.589
[SPEAKER_01]: If you can't interpret the non-spoken signals, yeah, all-chirled difference, you will fail.
01:03:49.649 --> 01:04:08.125
[SPEAKER_01]: So one thing is
about matching the mediators to the culture, which often means you need a pair of mediators or team of mediators so that all the participants can see
01:04:09.117 --> 01:04:10.279
[SPEAKER_01]: that let's like them.
01:04:10.899 --> 01:04:13.563
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, and maybe can translate some of that, you know?
01:04:14.204 --> 01:04:21.795
[SPEAKER_02]: And I think at minimum, at least saying, they're going to be things about each other that we might not get, we may not understand.
01:04:21.815 --> 01:04:28.304
[SPEAKER_02]: At least bringing it into the room that that's happening all the time, bringing some awareness around it.
01:04:29.305 --> 01:04:37.757
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, so for a period of time, I worked a lot for large corporations, particularly those that needed teams,
01:04:38.142 --> 01:04:42.449
[SPEAKER_01]: to do complex work engineering companies, so construction companies.
01:04:43.511 --> 01:04:55.932
[SPEAKER_01]: And they did not understand that the company needed to train its people to participate effectively in teams or the teams weren't going to work.
01:04:56.165 --> 01:05:00.670
[SPEAKER_01]: It was just that you took one from here with me and went from here to talk and had a great leader.
01:05:00.690 --> 01:05:00.750
[SPEAKER_01]: No.
01:05:02.131 --> 01:05:02.471
[SPEAKER_01]: No.
01:05:02.511 --> 01:05:03.613
[SPEAKER_01]: It wasn't going to work.
01:05:04.253 --> 01:05:20.630
[SPEAKER_01]: And I've written a book called Built To Win, which is just about how corporations committed to becoming learning organizations with regard to how to manage conflict and how to build teams.
01:05:20.650 --> 01:05:23.893
[SPEAKER_01]: And I have lots of teaching materials that
01:05:24.278 --> 01:05:28.967
[SPEAKER_01]: companies use to a role play problems and teams.
01:05:29.588 --> 01:05:32.133
[SPEAKER_01]: Same ideas, but it's not mediation.
01:05:32.875 --> 01:05:36.782
[SPEAKER_01]: It's not just two parties negotiating.
01:05:36.842 --> 01:05:41.331
[SPEAKER_01]: It's a special thing when you have people with different expertise.
01:05:41.411 --> 01:05:43.114
[SPEAKER_01]: It's almost like different cultures.
01:05:43.395 --> 01:05:46.000
[SPEAKER_01]: That's why I'm raising it on the heels of the cross cultural.
01:05:46.334 --> 01:05:53.603
[SPEAKER_01]: conversation, you have parts of the company where people are scientists and parts of the company where people are managers.
01:05:54.023 --> 01:05:54.424
[SPEAKER_01]: Yes.
01:05:55.064 --> 01:05:57.848
[SPEAKER_01]: They have to work together and it's like two cultures.
01:05:58.068 --> 01:05:59.710
[SPEAKER_01]: Yes.
01:05:59.730 --> 01:06:04.375
[SPEAKER_02]: They can't understand each other often and just say, you know, why is this the priority?
01:06:04.555 --> 01:06:04.836
[SPEAKER_02]: Why?
01:06:05.036 --> 01:06:07.399
[SPEAKER_02]: Why are you so stuck on this one thing?
01:06:07.439 --> 01:06:09.802
[SPEAKER_02]: You know, and that's so interesting.
01:06:09.822
--> 01:06:14.367
[SPEAKER_01]: So, so interesting.
01:06:14.768 --> 01:06:30.145
[SPEAKER_01]: I've avoided raising the question that I wanted to ask you earlier, and I don't have a lot of time, but I know you have an interest in trauma, and there are mediators within my profession.
01:06:30.445 --> 01:06:42.218
[SPEAKER_01]: who think that mediating in a post-traumatic situation requires an additional layer of site understanding and training.
01:06:42.238 --> 01:06:43.900
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't have that.
01:06:44.080 --> 01:06:58.275
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know what that is, but I can certainly accept the idea that you're trying to deal with people where there's a conflict that is the
01:06:58.407 --> 01:07:07.943
[SPEAKER_02]: I really appreciate you bringing that into the conversation and one of the things that I do is teach trauma sensitivity to different groups.
01:07:09.145 --> 01:07:24.111
[SPEAKER_02]: So how to look for those things that, yeah, if you're not trained in trauma sensitivity, you might not realize are in the room hyper vigilance or people who are
01:07:24.091 --> 01:07:27.798
[SPEAKER_02]: And it's a little bit probably what comes up in those groups you were talking about.
01:07:28.139 --> 01:07:37.436
[SPEAKER_02]: Some people will pretend they're happy because they don't feel safe to share, to reveal themselves for a trauma survivor could be a fear of death.
01:07:38.098 --> 01:07:43.568
[SPEAKER_02]: And there are people that have been trained through trauma to say yes.
01:07:43.548 --> 01:08:06.298
[SPEAKER_02]: And so, trauma sensitivity has to do with, you know, training the group or the facilitator to look for those things, to use language which is more invitational to consider a power dynamics in the room, body language, even like the way people are positioned in a room that affects their sense of safety.
01:08:06.278 --> 01:08:09.001
[SPEAKER_02]: And, I mean, it sounds like you're doing a lot of that.
01:08:09.021 --> 01:08:29.383
[SPEAKER_02]: There might be a little extra layer that's, you know, very specific to trauma, but we want to create safety, feeling of safety as much as possible, no one can, you know, promise you this room is 100% safe, but as much as possible, so that the nervous system can relax, we're not just,
01:08:29.363 --> 01:08:31.225
[SPEAKER_02]: hyper-vigilant on edge.
01:08:31.665 --> 01:08:33.988
[SPEAKER_02]: We're also not zoning out, right?
01:08:34.008 --> 01:08:39.633
[SPEAKER_02]: We're able to be responsive because when things are too much, we can also just totally tune out.
01:08:40.054 --> 01:08:41.155
[SPEAKER_02]: We can just go away.
01:08:41.175 --> 01:08:46.580
[SPEAKER_01]: There's a moment in lots of mediation, all the different kinds that's talking about.
01:08:47.301 --> 01:08:54.088
[SPEAKER_01]: Where a mediator will feel they have to assist
01:08:55.368 --> 01:09:04.228
[SPEAKER_01]: one or some parties because those folks are too upset to listen carefully.
01:09:04.268 --> 01:09:10.622
[SPEAKER_01]: They're too overwrought to them to think about their own best interest clearly.
01:09:10.662 --> 01:09:12.887
[SPEAKER_01]: And they
01:09:13.255 --> 01:09:28.564
[SPEAKER_01]: There's this group of mediators who feel that what they're really having to learn about in order to do that are social worker type skills or social psychological skills.
01:09:29.388 --> 01:09:39.941
[SPEAKER_01]: I think they're effort to put themselves into a counseling mode with some of the participants in the process is problematic.
01:09:41.103 --> 01:09:41.664
[SPEAKER_01]: Yes.
01:09:41.684 --> 01:09:46.530
[SPEAKER_01]: I think it's going to undermine the potentially the relationship with the other.
01:09:46.570 --> 01:09:47.631
[SPEAKER_01]: Sure.
01:09:47.651 --> 01:09:48.432
[SPEAKER_01]: It's a thing.
01:09:48.693 --> 01:09:56.863
[SPEAKER_01]: But I understand their desire to address and what they see as an underlying obstacle that's
01:09:57.097 --> 01:09:59.662
[SPEAKER_01]: And I view that as the lemma.
01:10:00.604 --> 01:10:12.388
[SPEAKER_02]: Yeah, that's an interesting line and that has that there's something there about the group guidelines that are set up in advance, you know, about how we talk about what might happen in the room.
01:10:12.368 --> 01:10:39.507
[SPEAKER_02]: this could be emotional and what will happen if it gets emotional so that that's what is going to happen is predictable and then it because I could see that it could be seen like all this person cries and so they get the attention of this supposedly neutral party and of course that that person is comforting them and and you have you know certain type of people that don't cry when they feel attacked they feel upset they get angry
01:10:39.487 --> 01:10:47.098
[SPEAKER_02]: And typically, you know, they're the ones that are pushed to the side or told to like control of your anger before you talk.
01:10:47.118 --> 01:10:55.009
[SPEAKER_02]: And instead of having that nurturing where the softer motion can come out, because the anger is covering up a fear.
01:10:55.069 --> 01:10:58.254
[SPEAKER_02]: So it does take a certain training to see all that.
01:10:58.514 --> 01:11:06.726
[SPEAKER_02]: And part of that I think what could be helped in what you're describing is just naming what could come up and how it's going to be dealt with in advance.
01:11:06.706 --> 01:11:28.650
[SPEAKER_02]: And it is true that, you know, Dan Seagull really is the one who came up with this research that, you know, we can really only work within a certain window of tolerance in our nervous system and when we're, when we're outside of that, I mean, we're just not using our prefrontal cortex where no longer, you know, able to make really good decisions.
01:11:28.770 --> 01:11:35.818
[SPEAKER_02]: So when people are
01:11:35.798 --> 01:11:36.879
[SPEAKER_02]: what to expect.
01:11:37.040 --> 01:11:46.391
[SPEAKER_02]: And I think that's a small maybe small change or a denim I
could add that could happen in the room that the predictability is a big thing for safety.
01:11:46.431 --> 01:11:48.774
[SPEAKER_01]: Thank you for for sharing that.
01:11:49.515 --> 01:11:59.747
[SPEAKER_01]: I have a colleague named Michael Wheeler who wrote a book on this improvisation and dispute resolution.
01:12:00.014 --> 01:12:04.681
[SPEAKER_01]: And he studied improvisation and music quite a bit.
01:12:05.382 --> 01:12:18.643
[SPEAKER_01]: And he did some interesting experiments, bringing people who are all jazz performers from four corners of a room who've never met each other, right individually to a stage.
01:12:19.203 --> 01:12:27.456
[SPEAKER_01]: And the music stands were up, and their fake books were open to the same song and just had a record progression.
01:12:28.246 --> 01:12:32.090
[SPEAKER_01]: And nobody knew each other, nobody was in charge.
01:12:32.791 --> 01:12:49.391
[SPEAKER_01]: And he watched as these professionals in unspoken ways, figured out what would be the pace that they would play at, who would solo first, how long would the solo go?
01:12:50.212 --> 01:12:50.592
[SPEAKER_01]: And,
01:12:51.989 --> 01:13:07.443
[SPEAKER_01]: people improvised and yet they could detect messages and send code because they've been jazz musicians for their whole lives and they were used to playing with all kinds of people.
01:13:07.503 --> 01:13:10.470
[SPEAKER_01]: But we were watching
01:13:11.328 --> 01:13:14.472
[SPEAKER_01]: And we saw nothing except the performance.
01:13:15.093 --> 01:13:16.054
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
01:13:16.074 --> 01:13:17.015
[SPEAKER_01]: They had no rehearsal.
01:13:17.055 --> 01:13:18.897
[SPEAKER_01]: There's nothing, no communication.
01:13:19.698 --> 01:13:28.429
[SPEAKER_01]: And so we're interested in improvisation and how improvisation can cut against, making sure everybody knows what's gonna happen.
01:13:29.130 --> 01:13:32.914
[SPEAKER_01]: We want everyone to feel comfortable by knowing what's gonna happen.
01:13:33.295 --> 01:13:33.515
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
01:13:33.815 --> 01:13:35.918
[SPEAKER_01]: Also know that success,
01:13:38.142 --> 01:13:45.577
[SPEAKER_01]: depends on suddenly picking up an opportunity, an idea, reacting to a challenge in a new way.
01:13:45.617 --> 01:13:46.579
[SPEAKER_01]: Absolutely.
01:13:46.599 --> 01:13:46.940
[SPEAKER_01]: Absolutely.
01:13:47.240 --> 01:13:48.322
[SPEAKER_01]: That's improvisation.
01:13:48.723 --> 01:13:49.926
[SPEAKER_01]: Yes.
01:13:50.166 --> 01:13:57.180
[SPEAKER_01]: I see attention between making sure people feel comfortable by knowing what's going to happen.
01:13:57.548 --> 01:14:02.097
[SPEAKER_01]: being open to improvisation, which may be the key to resolve it.
01:14:02.117 --> 01:14:06.986
[SPEAKER_02]: And that is something that can even go into the group agreements in the beginning.
01:14:07.166 --> 01:14:13.478
[SPEAKER_02]: You know, there's even a way to let that be known and kind of predictable.
01:14:13.498 --> 01:14:18.628
[SPEAKER_02]: Like, you know, we might tell people, you know, you will be asked to go into breakout groups.
01:14:18.608 --> 01:14:23.253
[SPEAKER_02]: you know, so, you know, that something that might happen, things might go off script.
01:14:23.273 --> 01:14:31.503
[SPEAKER_02]: So even just that little bit of letting people know, even that things like go off script, I think that's beautiful what you're what you're saying.
01:14:31.523 --> 01:14:36.228
[SPEAKER_02]: We have to leave room for the unknown, so much of what you've spoken about.
01:14:36.288 --> 01:14:47.721
[SPEAKER_02]: Today Larry is about that, is about the answers that we
01:14:47.701 --> 01:14:58.540
[SPEAKER_02]: what you create, the structure that you bring in allows for this kind of spontaneous or collective knowledge and these these beautiful answers.
01:14:58.560 --> 01:15:00.845
[SPEAKER_02]: So I think I mean this is a great place to close.
01:15:00.885 --> 01:15:12.325
[SPEAKER_02]: I think it's really the combination of both and it's to me the structure that creates the safety and the ability to have the freedom for the unknown.
01:15:12.878 --> 01:15:22.649
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, you might at some point want to invite Wheeler Michael to talk to you, the book is the art of negotiation.
01:15:23.069 --> 01:15:23.510
[SPEAKER_01]: Yes.
01:15:23.930 --> 01:15:41.029
[SPEAKER_01]: He's a Harvard Business School professor who wanted to distinguish his way of teaching negotiation from those who were teaching the science of negotiation.
01:15:41.009 --> 01:15:45.215
[SPEAKER_01]: for the artistic part of the negotiation.
01:15:45.295 --> 01:15:51.523
[SPEAKER_01]: Anyway, he's a wonderful person to speak to about an negotiation and mediation.
01:15:52.144 --> 01:15:55.448
[SPEAKER_01]: And any of it, it's not nice to chat with you.
01:15:56.289 --> 01:16:00.695
[SPEAKER_02]: Tell us, Larry, people that want to support you that when I get involved, that need your help.
01:16:00.775 --> 01:16:09.126
[SPEAKER_02]: What are the best ways to connect with you or with your organization?
01:16:10.372 --> 01:16:12.195
[SPEAKER_01]: And I'm not there all the time.
01:16:12.235 --> 01:16:24.915
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm sort of the past president, but if something comes up, there's people there who I taught, who I have 100% confidence in, who can do any of the things that I'm describing.
01:16:25.456 --> 01:16:33.088
[SPEAKER_01]: And then at MIT, the sort of central holder for all of the things I do is called the science impact.
01:16:33.254 --> 01:16:35.117
[SPEAKER_01]: dot MIT dot edu.
01:16:35.618 --> 01:16:39.083
[SPEAKER_01]: It's the science impact collaborative and that's the community we work with.
01:16:39.103 --> 01:16:43.169
[SPEAKER_01]: So communities show up online and say can you help us with it?
01:16:43.289 --> 01:16:49.499
[SPEAKER_02]: Okay, and that's where we want to send people and I'm going to link those in the show notes.
01:16:49.999 --> 01:16:52.603
[SPEAKER_02]: I mean, I know neighbors in dispute.
01:16:52.884 --> 01:16:55.127
[SPEAKER_02]: I know a land dispute.
01:16:55.167 --> 01:16:56.950
[SPEAKER_02]: I mean, as we're talking,
01:16:56.930 --> 01:17:08.387
[SPEAKER_02]: We have a lot of projects to send you and I would also hope that one day you will be in the UN the way you describe because that sounds a good lofty goal.
01:17:08.407 --> 01:17:10.791
[SPEAKER_02]: I'm putting it out there to anyone who has influence.
01:17:11.211 --> 01:17:12.293
[SPEAKER_02]: We don't know who's listening.
01:17:13.234 --> 01:17:20.886
[SPEAKER_01]: A lot of this is my 54th year at MIT and I'm not highly unlikely.
01:17:20.926 --> 01:17:22.448
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm going to change careers.
01:17:22.428 --> 01:17:26.212
[SPEAKER_01]: And my wife won't let me add any more into the channel.
01:17:26.232 --> 01:17:33.820
[SPEAKER_02]: I bet not, I bet not, but at least your practices can go on, you know, throw all the people that you're teaching and that's it.
01:17:33.840 --> 01:17:35.342
[SPEAKER_02]: And that we want an opt-in.
01:17:35.402 --> 01:17:46.674
[SPEAKER_02]: We want it opt yet you're, you're automatically opted-in to mediation, to negotiation, to dialogue, and you have to opt out of it if you want to go and battle it out.
01:17:47.054 --> 01:17:47.955
[SPEAKER_02]: That's what we want.
01:17:48.055 --> 01:17:51.439
[SPEAKER_02]: And I think Larry, thank you so much for your work.
01:17:51.419 --> 01:17:56.669
[SPEAKER_02]: I think people are going to be thinking about that now and they're going to be delving into your work and your books.
01:17:57.090 --> 01:18:01.117
[SPEAKER_02]: I appreciate so much what you're doing and your time today.
01:18:01.157 --> 01:18:01.718
[SPEAKER_01]: Thank you.
01:18:01.758 --> 01:18:02.940
[SPEAKER_01]: Nice to meet you.
01:18:02.960 --> 01:18:06.026
[SPEAKER_01]: If something urgent comes up just email me.
01:18:06.046 --> 01:18:06.587
[SPEAKER_02]: Okay.
01:18:06.607 --> 01:18:07.749
[SPEAKER_02]: I absolutely will.
01:18:07.850 --> 01:18:08.771
[SPEAKER_02]: Thank you so much.
01:18:09.412 --> 01:18:10.294
[SPEAKER_02]: Bye bye.
01:18:10.494 --> 01:18:10.795
[SPEAKER_02]: Bye bye.
01:18:12.158 --> 01:18:19.546
[SPEAKER_00]: As we buzz around the busy world, It becomes clear, there are billions of paths.
01:18:19.566 --> 01:18:26.034
[SPEAKER_00]: As we buzz around the busy world, We will appear in other people's photographs.
01:18:26.755 --> 01:18:31.840
[SPEAKER_00]: As we speak through the centuries, We will collide and the light will bend.
01:18:33.923 --> 01:18:37.627
[SPEAKER_00]: We will be accidentally more relaxed.
01:18:38.248 --> 01:18:40.410
[SPEAKER_00]: And someone else is land.