رونوشت 🔗
speaker-1: Hi there everyone. Welcome back to Beyond the White Coat. Now, one of the things that we talk about frequently in this podcast is that physicians and other healthcare professionals spend years learning how to practice medicine, but very little time learning how to manage, protect, and grow income that medicine eventually creates. And taxes is one of the probably one of the best examples of that. You can hurt earn a very high income. And still make relatively poor financial decisions if you're not thinking proactively about taxes. Today I'm thrilled to be joined by Spencer Carroll, CPA, part of GELT, or partner.stock. And Spencer works specifically with high-income professionals and other healthcare business owners on what's called proactive tax planning, business structures, and broader financial strategy. Spencer, before we jump into the details, what's the biggest misconception you see high income health professionals have about taxes.
speaker-0: Yeah, great question. And thanks for having me on, Dr. Marshall. I'm excited to be here. Probably the biggest, I mean, there's a lot of misconceptions, right? But but the biggest misconception is that there's nothing they can do about their tax bill. They think I make good money. With good money comes high taxes. And that it that is definitely true. and it doesn't mean that you're going to wipe your taxes away. But oftentimes there are wise planning. steps and opportunities available to high earners, physicians. and sometimes it just requires asking the right questions, meeting with the right person to kind of open those doors.
speaker-1: I think doctors are particularly guilty of treating taxes like an annual compliance exercise, right? We gather documents, send them to the CPA in March or April, find out what we owe and then move on. But by the time we get to April, how many planning opportunities have already disappeared?
speaker-0: Most of I would say. there's still a couple that we could talk about maybe later on in this episode that are still available to you after the end of the calendar year. But probably a good rule of thumb and just to keep you on top of things and not procrastinating, best to think about the deadline as December thirty-first, because that is truly the deadline for most tax strategies out there.
speaker-1: What's the difference between someone who prepares your taxes and someone who's actually helping with the plan?
speaker-0: Well, it can be the same person, but those are two separate tasks. And so preparing your tax return is a compliance exercise. It's basically sending the IRS, the federal and state governments a summary of your financial year that happened the last twelve months. It's saying, I made this much, this is what I got into, and this is the taxes that I owed you. I've already paid in this much, I either have a little bit more to pay. Or maybe you're getting a little bit of a refund, but it is a summary of what has already happened. Planning is making
Load full transcript
proactive decisions in real time. And what I mean by in real time means during the actual tax year. So this is tax year 2026. We're recording this in October. It would be proactive to make moves while we're still in the calendar year 2026. And then your compliance CPA or tax preparer would prepare that summary and send it in. either in the spring or in the fall of twenty twenty seven.
speaker-1: I think I've learned this more and more as I've personally gone from being a practicing physician to owning multiple businesses is that you have to stop thinking about the tax return as a strategy. And the tax return is really the result of decisions you've made in the prior year. So one place that gets really, really interesting for doctors is when income starts coming from multiple sources. So the W two versus the 1099 income, right? And a common example that we see within our portfolio of doctors here is A doc might earn three hundred and fifty K from their W two job, but now they're moonlighting, they're doing locums, they're medical consulting, they're doing expert witness work, or some other side hustle, and they make another call it a hundred K ten ninety nine income. What changes there, Spencer?
speaker-0: It gives you the ability to be more creative with how you report that income. So to your point, the tax return is a listing of the numbers, a summary of the numbers. Your W-2 is going to be included in there and the 1099 is going to be included in there. But with tax planning, especially on the 1099 moonlighting side of things, you can manipulate the numbers a little bit more, legitimately and legally. Now you are a business owner, you're self-employed. That income that you bring in, if it was W2, you just slap it at the top, box number one, it works its way down the tax return, and here's your taxes. But with 1099, you file what's called a schedule C, as in CAT, and that gross money does still get reported at the top, but you get all these other boxes where you can throw in expenses. And some of the expenses are. money that you would have spent no matter what, right? We need a place to live. You're gonna pay for some your home office. You need a cell phone, you're gonna pay for your cell phone bill. You're able to deduct those against that income, which pretty much means that you're going to make more money, which is always a good thing, and you should pay a lesser tax rate on that money compared to your W two.
speaker-1: Got it. Now, it's funny that social media's made everyone an expert at everything. And on Instagram everyone says that I've got to create an L L C I've got to elect as an S score. When does that actually make financial sense?
speaker-0: Yeah, that's a good question. And that that is one of the the fads and the hype going out in social media, especially right now, is the S-Corp. So the S Corp isn't even an entity type. It is a tax election for an entity. And that the entity that we're talking about is still an LLC. So the LLC is the actual entity. And when you form an LLC, if you're the only owner, It is considered a single member LLC, disregarded by the IRS. So what that means is the IRS doesn't even really acknowledge that it exists. They don't really care. It's considered as your own personal income, still business income, still self-employed, but just being reported as you know, Spencer or Dr. Marshall, if we had Schedule C income. so I tell clients when you're thinking about forming an LLC. Just that act alone does not create some magic superpower where bam, we started an LLC and you're going to save all this money on taxes. Electing S-Corp for your LLC can save you money on your taxes. primarily the benefit is on your self-employment taxes, so Social Security and Medicare. When you're self-employed business owner, you pay both the employee and the employer half of. Self employment tax, social security, Medicare. So 15.3%. when it makes sense, it's very case by case. And and I'll apologize ahead of ahead of time, Dr. Marshall, because I'll probably have a lot of answers in this episode where it's it depends. And it's because it really does depend on the unique yeah, it is nuanced, and yeah it depends on the unique situations of the taxpayer. Typically, we would say it's time to start thinking about an S Corp election. When your net profit, so the income that you're gonna report after you've deducted your expenses, when that net profit gets around eighty, a hundred, a hundred and twenty K, it might make sense to start thinking about it. But again, it's nuance because if if you give me that example you gave me a few minutes ago of a physician making, you know, 300K W2 and then 100K on the side. That person I would probably say it doesn't make sense because you're paying so much of your social security or all of your social security, excuse me. You're paying all of your social security with your W two that you're actually not saving that much with the S Corp and the S Corp is more complicated, more costly to maintain. So the juice has to be work to squeeze.
speaker-1: I think that's an important distinction. I think and I'm glad you use real numbers there, because that's gonna be my follow-up at at what point does it become important to think about it, right? and more income creates opportunity, but also creates complexity. and so how the income is structured can almost become as important, as important as how much you earn. I think we focus a lot on are we investing appropriately, how much return did your financial advisor get you? Whereas tax liability can eviscerate all those gains. if you're not being thoughtful and proactive up front, right? So let's get practical. Cause I love how practical you are here. give me three tax strategies that high that a high income doctor, whether it be a physician, a dentist, a nurse practitioner, should at least know exist.
speaker-0: at least know exist. Okay, I'm gonna give you three and I'm gonna kinda mix and match whether
this is a full-time W-2 physician that's making really good money or let's say full-time self-employed, private practice, 1099 locums, they're doing something like that. Sure. If you if you are W-2, I'm assuming that this person already knows about retirement, HSA, charitable giving, stuff like that. So what I would consider for that person, or that I would want them to at least know exists, is tax loss harvesting. So that is where you are investing your money, like you mentioned just a a bit ago. some of those positions might show a loss. If we can sell at a loss, we're going to harvest those losses and that's going to offset future capital gains. And every year, even if you do fully offset the capital gains, you can write off an additional $3,000 on your taxes for that, that capital loss that you harvested. Not crazy exciting, but just something that they should be aware of. It's a wise tax move to make. I'll also throw a donor advice fund in there as well. So that's an extra fourth one for the high earning W two. If you give to charity, might as well bunch your deductions in a in a given year. Or at the very least, avoid future capital gains by donating appreciated stock. So tax loss harvesting, donor advice fund. If you are a self-employed individual, then I would I would bring up entity structuring. So I know this might be cheating because we just talked about it, but if you don't have a high W-2 and you are a physician that is full-time locums or private practice, you do need to consider S-Corp structure. reasonable compensation and how that reasonable comp is going to play an effect on your QBI if you're eligible for that. So that's the qualified business income deduction, which not all not all physicians are because you're an SSTB. We're getting into the jargon in the weeds here that, you know, maybe is a little bit too over the head, but it matters. And then retirement contributions. and then I think the last one, And I'm sure we'll talk about this later as well, but the short term rental loophole, and that's for both sets. So if you are a higher earning W two or if you're a higher earning business owner, the short term rental loophole, which plays with cost segregation and bonus depreciation, can also be very valuable for the right person.
speaker-1: Man, this is brilliant, Spencer. I love how you kind of demystify all this and make it make sense. Cause I've personally been advised on much of this already and you're kind of crystallizing it for me. many of the folks with within our network at Doc to Doc that are have invested in us are also doing a lot of investing, especially in real estate. Like that's hot for physicians. Like we're we're doing syndicates and buying into apartment buildings together on aggregate. We're doing short-term rentals to get the investment, real real estate professional title. and what becomes surprising to many is like a few years ago, there's been a decimation of real estate in certain markets when interest
rates began to spike. And so there are a lot of losses, but I think folks need to know that they can harvest those losses to your point and have them roll into offsetting future tax burdens. so I think that's that's very topical for the folks within our ecosystem right now. donor advice giving similarly, I think we all get hit up because we're perceived as being high b but being wealthy people, even though we were high income may not be wealthy and we're asked to donate all the time. And sometimes it's good to have an organized pool where it's segregated and you're able to kind of direct folks to a manager who will help you say yes or no and if it makes sense. But all of the all of the proceeds from those investments must go in a charitable giving and and and it's a way to build legacy, right? So if if you and your family, you've got kids and you want to understand and learn about being being benevolent and and how to give in a way that they're ways we can donate back to your alma mater. You can help to endow a chair within the anesthesia department, like in my case, I'm an anesthesiologist. So those things all matter and they're tax advantaged if you set up the right way.
speaker-0: Yeah, absolutely. All important points and can make a real difference in your your taxes. And even a step further with the charitable contribution to get your kids involved. Some of our clients will even take it a step further and do the family foundation, which is nice because the money still has to go to charity, but for legitimate and reasonable tasks. family members can pull salary for managing the family foundation. So that can be a really cool one. It's it's tricky. It's a five one C three. You've got to manage a non profit. but we ha we have seen it done.
speaker-1: Talk about hiring family and and getting kids involved. Can you really hire our kids on our b on your practice and find ways to contribute on on their behalf? What is what is the what is the detail around that?
speaker-0: Yeah. So you really can. but again, everything goes back to legitimate. Yeah, yeah, it depends and legitimate business purpose, reasonable, right? And so I will say that for physicians it can be a little bit more difficult because the service that you guys provide is your expertise and you're usually on site at a medical facility providing that expertise. So to bring, a 12-year-old daughter along with you to go provide anesthesiology services could be difficult, right? It could be hard to involve the kid in that way. But that doesn't mean it's impossible. There could still be some administrative tasks that that a child could get involved in. There could be some marketing tasks that a child might get involved in, setting up a website, social media, something along those lines. could still fit, but then also the work that they do, the wage has to be reasonable. So to, post a couple of times on Instagram and pay your child ten thousand dollars to do that, it would could raise some audit risk. So it needs to be legitimate work that they're doing and the wage needs to be reasonable. But yes, it is a real strategy.
speaker-1: Fair. Fair, fair, fair. tell me about a famous another famous kind of online TikTok, quote unquote tax hack. Buy a G Wagon and write it off. What's the story about that?
speaker-0: Yeah. So it's another one that is legitimate if done correctly. you can use a vehicle for your business. It has to be used more than 50% for business and it has to be over 6,000 pounds to get the full write-off. And that's why people famously cite the G-Wagon because it is over 6,000 pounds. Doesn't mean you can't buy a car that is under 6,000. It just means that you won't get the full bonus depreciation in the first year that you buy it.
speaker-1: That's gross weight or net?
speaker-0: That is gross weight. The G G V W R or something like that. It needs to be six thousand. And I don't quote me on this, but I think there's something about you can calculate the weight with passengers inside the vehicle. But there's, you know, you can Google all this stuff. They've got websites that give you what this weight is. You could ask the dealership what the weight of the car is. so yes, it it is legitimate. It is Very hype. And do you need a G Wagon, a Corvette, a Ferrari to do this? Probably not. and you might be raising some additional risk with the IRS coming around and asking questions if you go that route. Doesn't mean you should be afraid of an audit. If you've done things correctly, you should be able to prove the position that you took. And if it is correct, the IRS can leave you alone. but the more aggressive you get with these things, the more likely you are to. possibly raise some flags. And we like to say at GET, you don't want to go buy a hundred thousand dollar car to save forty thousand dollars on your taxes. That cash is still gone. You are a hundred thousand dollars cash less in your bank account. Yes, you're getting the tax deduction, but you wouldn't want to buy something just to get pennies on the dollar of benefit. So keep that in mind.
speaker-1: I think someone I know got the souped up version of the sports car that he was gonna get anyway that took it over six thousand pounds. that way you got the pleasure of driving a car that you like, but you do get the benefit of the deduction as well. and so and so there's there's being able to double dip. If you're a car person, it kind of works. Yeah. Yes. Now
speaker-0: Exactly.
speaker-1: A solid fifteen percent of our audience are practice owners. And all of this becomes a different game when you go from being W two to owning your practice, right? And I've seen this firsthand. I've I'm now dealing with payroll, equipment, real estate, retirement planning, entity structure, depreciation, and ultimately enterprise value, because I intend to have my entire enterprise generate value for me by exiting at some point in time in the future. I'm certain based upon everything
you just said that the tax opportunity of of tax planning opportunity becomes even more significant when you're an owner. What should folks be thinking about early as they begin to launch their first practice? And when should they engage someone like you? Is it at the thought, at the ideation phase? Is it after they've kind of begun to, you know, get the loan and move money around and meet with their business consultants? When does a good CPA become involved?
speaker-0: Yeah, that's a good question. probably the the cliche answer is as soon as possible right away. realistically, you could probably wait until you start to have your first expenses or revenue come in, not very long after that, but possibly an ideation phase where you might be months to years out from actually pulling the trigger. could be a little bit early because it's just going to be hypothetical conversations that it no action is going to be tied to. but once you start actually, you know, making business decisions and money is going in and out, then it definitely makes sense. And I would say what they should be thinking about right away. Is what you just described. So you already, you already have goals years in the future of where you want your businesses to lead and the legacy that you want them to create for you and your family. Setting up your entity structure, it's important to be thinking about where you think the business could go when you're setting that up. Because I've seen plenty of clients who never thought their business would grow to a certain extent. And here they are five years into it with a certain structure that isn't quite as efficient for them and their partners. and they would have done it differently had they known they were gonna bring on partners and have a lot of W two employees and a desire to exit in the future.
speaker-1: This is timely because we're in the fourth quarter. As you said earlier, we're in October of twenty twenty six currently. If someone listening to us has basically done no proactive tax planning so far this year, what should they be doing between now and december thirty first?
speaker-0: They should be contacting their CPA and asking to do some tax planning. If their CPA does not want to do it or is too busy to do it, they should probably be considering searching for a different CPA that can provide that service. although I will say that, you know, all good CPAs are going to get crunched for time here towards the end of the year, because this is the important time to be doing it. But having that conversation, if you haven't already, I would be reviewing your books. So your bookkeeping, if you're a business owner, with bad data comes bad advice. we can only provide as good of information as the data we have feeding the advice that we give. So good bookkeeping. and yeah, you know, I this is very vague, but it's hard for me to say exactly what somebody should be doing without knowing what their situation is. So I would just take step one, which is get organized and get that conversation as soon as possible.
speaker-1: Spencer, thank you so much for joining us. And thanks to Gelt for helping us have this conversation. and to everyone listening, the goal isn't simply to earn more money, it's to make smarter decisions with what you earn, protect what you've built, and to create greater financial freedom beyond the white coat. Thank you so much for the time.
speaker-0: Yeah, thank you, Doctor Marshall. It's been great.