TRANSKRIBEERI 🔗
Marshall Sheldon: huh.
Josh Arnold: Marshall, if you're on the technician's social medias at all, you probably saw the video that blew up recently. A Toyota Tech with a huge following literally packed up his box, walked away from the job entirely over warranty time. When an influencer with that kind of reach hits their breaking point publicly, it blows the lid off what technicians across the country like are dealing with behind their closed bay doors.
Marshall Sheldon: The comments under the post were wild. Thousands of techs are saying, I'm right behind ya. And the dealers on the other side were scratching their heads. But an online viral moment rarely tells the whole story. Today on Within Spec, we're talking about the viral flashpoint, the breakdown and and breaking down the entire machine, the technician in the bay, the dealership in the middle, and the LEM calling shots.
Josh Arnold: Peter Patter.
Marshall Sheldon: Patter boys.
Josh Arnold: All right, well, let's start with everyone's favorite. Two technicians, right? I mean, where where do you think we're gonna start? We're not starting with the OEM. We're not starting with the dealership, okay?
Marshall Sheldon: We're starting with two ticks, one cup. Censored.
Josh Arnold: And we're already censored, just like that. All right, so I mean,
Marshall Sheldon: Monetization gone.
Josh Arnold: yep. Well, good thing we weren't making any money anyway, for love of the game. But I mean, the honestly, like why we're doing this here today. Is because the everyone's been talking about it, right? All the big names, everyone's getting their 10 cents on there. And I think that we should take the higher road here. I'm not saying that what Yoda Tech went through is not something that we all experience, but that being said, we do need to look at the bigger picture of things. Starting off with the technician mentioning that the point eight that he got paid versus the 2.4 that was on all data. Of course, we're gonna say That's absolute crap, right? No matter what.8 for a fuel tank is it it is absolutely worth
Marshall Sheldon: Is wild work. I don't care what fuel tank it is, dude.
Josh Arnold: if that fuel tank's sitting on the ground, point eight is still probably not enough to drop that down and take out
Marshall Sheldon: Yeah.
Josh Arnold: the fuel pump on it. All right. So either way, point eight is is not great. That being said, from the technician's perspective, of course he's frustrated. We've all experienced this, especially dealer techs. I know you hourly boys over there don't give two flying craps what book time is.
Marshall Sheldon: Whoa, whoa, whoa. We still we're still held accountable too. Our efficiencies, okay.
Josh Arnold: Well, no one's hitting efficiency on that thing. But
Marshall Sheldon: No, not on a point eight fuel tank.
Josh Arnold: but point eight isn't good, right? And the whole point from the technician's standpoint is this is how much I would get paid on CP. and this is how much I'm getting paid on warranty. It makes absolutely no sense. It's the same job. We're still doing the same work and we're it's it's the same, right? Now, the biggest thing is a technician that works in the dealership is you understand the product. You know how to work on it. You're familiar with it, right? You're not guessing socket size on what bolts are. Like you know what Toyota is about. You've been doing it a long time. You should be efficient. That being said, again, just point eight in any way. Those these fuel tanks are probably a little bit rusty. You know that they're covered in dirt. You know that you're going to get the shop tool over there. That's a pain in the butt that everybody else has, or it's broken, or it's sitting in a corner buried by three other things. No matter what, this job doesn't come out and justify that expense. That being said, this is where we need to kind of zoom out a little bit. So, how did it get to be that 0.8 is the big question. Now I'm gonna add a little bit of my touch of the Toyota Tech. Now, back in the day when we had fuel pump recalls, the original time I believe was something around 2.1. Which don't get me wrong, isn't great, isn't bad. And I can't remember specifically. So for the Toyota techs out there, please don't blast me apart for getting it right. But that being said, it does yeah,
Marshall Sheldon: You're about to get eight alive. It was two point three.
Josh Arnold: that being said, it doesn't matter. It was more than point eight. Okay. It was
Marshall Sheldon: Yeah.
Josh Arnold: more than point eight. But what happens in the modern day with technicians is that, well, that somebody finds a faster way to do it. I know on the fuel pump recalls, I would see people potentially dropping the tank halfway down, not taking all the stuff out, like technicians just doing what they do flat rate. Now, as long as the quality of the job stays the same, no problem. You're you're playing the game, right? That being said, in the modern day, we have social media and we have technicians that love to brag about how they're getting it all done that quick. And that's ex
Marshall Sheldon: Or sharing it with their sharing it with their buddies, you know what I mean? Like yeah.
Josh Arnold: Or sharing it with their buddies. But then the real big problem is it goes online and Toyota's a smart company and they're also a big company. They know when that video goes online, they see these videos, they watch their technicians and their dealerships. And when that happens, the difficulty comes because Toyota then sees that and knows that that technician is not following the protocols, but also they see how fast those technicians are doing it. And so I've experienced this in my career only a few times, but Toyota literally dropping the times on recalls after technicians have found a faster way to do it. How do you feel about that, Marshall?
Marshall Sheldon: Well, I I think it dude, I'm not you know, full disclosure, I don't
Load full transcript
come from the automotive world, so I think it's really ridiculous that you have a different time, you know, outside looking in, you have a different time for warranty and a different time for customer pay. You know, I think that's pretty wild. I think it should, you know, be the same, you know. I I think a lot of times like at least in heavy duty it'll be like the warranty time times 30% or something like that. there's not like we don't have like a CP differential. so our time is pretty much the same. but I I saw from that perspective, I think that's pretty crap. I think I I'm not a big fan of that, you know what I'm saying? I'm not I really am not because it's just it makes it confusing. It makes it confusing for the text, makes it confusing for the clients. If it you know what I mean? And then if you're not in if you're not in a in a dealership and you're at a independent and your you know your warranty work would be like a a comeback or you know like you put a part on it it's still under the manufacturer's warranty, they bring it back and you're gonna change it out again. and so now you're doing it based off of all data or pro demand, what you know, these other outfits get to justify your time. And then you know, I'm not quite sure how the warranty works on those side of things when you're trying to get, you know, a warranty for an autozone or Napa
Josh Arnold: And then
Marshall Sheldon: or one of those outfits.
Josh Arnold: so how do you feel about the whole like thing about him leaving the job? Because he left the job not because of the point eight. He was frustrated like every tech is that goes through it in the day. But how do you feel like the dealership says, hey, don't post that online? That's not okay.
Marshall Sheldon: Well, I mean, that guy's been posting for a while. I've been watching this stuff on online for a while. They knew he was posting. So like from my point of view it's like they if they didn't want him to post stuff, they should have said something a long time ago. It should be like, Hey, we don't want you to post this you know, video and in the shop or whatever. so they knew he was recording and if they wanted to
Josh Arnold: Mm-hmm.
Marshall Sheldon: do something about it, they should have done it beforehand or given him some guidelines to continue. I think a lot of outfits that
Josh Arnold: Yeah.
Marshall Sheldon: I've worked at they have, you know, social media guidelines like, Hey, we don't care if you guys do this, but this is the guidelines we have. Can't have any client information in there. We can't have any negativity about our OEM or something like that. You know, they would put something
Josh Arnold: Mm.
Marshall Sheldon: in there that said, Hey, if you're gonna if you're gonna post we're cool. with it but these are the guidelines you're gonna have to follow if you're gonna do it.
Josh Arnold: Mm.
Marshall Sheldon: so what that I'm assuming that they didn't have anything really narrowed down there, based on how
this went down. And had they done that, it probably would have never escalated to that point, for one. And for two, you know, they put themselves in a crap position with a with an employee that, you know, had been there a long time. I think they said twelve years or something, they had twelve years of toilet three, ten.
Josh Arnold: I think it was ten. At least that's what he said when he was packing up his box and everything like that. But
Marshall Sheldon: So yeah, so you know, a ten year tech, if you're invested ten years, I mean you're invested in a lot of money and training and mentoring and all of those things with that employee. it's gonna be costly to replace that guy. You know?
Josh Arnold: A hundred percent. I mean, I'm I have I have mixed feelings about it. So first off, if the manufacturer has a problem with the time being shown online, if Toyota has a problem with it saying point eight and being shown online, isn't there a problem there? Right? Like
Marshall Sheldon: Yeah, it's pretty apparent that they they're ashamed of it or something, you know, along those lines.
Josh Arnold: Now that being said, Toyota didn't respond to this, but the dealership did. The dealership perceived that Toyota would not enjoy that content, right? And so I'm not gonna speak for Toyota, and I'm very loyal to Toyota. I love the brand. That being said, like if Toyota's ashamed of that time, well there's a bigger problem there, and all that did was
Marshall Sheldon: Was
Josh Arnold: bring the shop.
Marshall Sheldon: now was what he was showing was that on Toyota's SRT's?
Josh Arnold: I believe so. I we honestly we we we we really couldn't see the full picture, but from what I saw, it looked like that was Toyota's lime time guide. And
Marshall Sheldon: Okay.
Josh Arnold: then the warranty company, the extended warranty company was only gonna pay manufacture warranty, which makes no sense. And we're not even gonna go into that because that's just asinine. Manufacture warranty is for manufacturers that have dealerships. That's the agreement when you have a dealership. You give a little bit of the discount, you have your tax trained, like they have all the tools. At least they're supposed to. and that's that's how it's supposed to be. But the next thing I think we should do here is we should talk a little bit about something that probably usually gets missed from the technician perspective, which is the dealership in the middle. Now, I don't agree with the dealership going the route that they did. I personally preferred that maybe the dealership, instead of requesting him take it down, maybe have him follow up with a little bit more information or just handle it a little bit differently. It just didn't seem like the right thing to do. but dealer
Marshall Sheldon: Yeah, they they could have seized that moment and been like, Hey, well let's explain this, why, you know
Josh Arnold: Yeah, or just said that we took care of them, right? Like that would be a good thing. Like they just the dealership said, Hey, we took care of this situation. Yeah. Yeah.
Marshall Sheldon: Hey, to be fair, yeah, we paid him, you know, two or whatever, one point five or w whatever they came up with and we we paid the guy. He's square on his point eight, so don't let them s worry about it.
Josh Arnold: And then I mean, and then and that brings up a good question too, is like, so okay, when a manufacturer says that they're only gonna pay a flat rate. The technician loses, but also flat rate works in the way that if the technician loses, usually the business loses as well. Now, obviously keep in mind business has scale where technicians don't. So it hurts also a little bit more, I would say. But that being said, the dealership loses too in these situations. It's not like the dealership is separate at that point. Like they are having a technician loot that is on the clock losing efficiency. And you can speak to that because you're hourly, right? You were just talking about it. Your business needs you to be efficient because they pay you hourly. So if you work 10 hours and you only bill six, what's that business going to do?
Marshall Sheldon: Yeah. They're gonna get w they're gonna get jacked up over it, you know what mean? Yeah. They're losing money, yeah.
Josh Arnold: Because they're, I mean, they're losing money, right? The same way that we fe we feel we're losing money too. So I do think it's important in this situation to remember that dealerships are also losing as well. And they're not as happy at the same time either. That being said, dealerships are big. They're supposed to take care of their people. They're supposed to look at the bigger picture. And when it comes to losing a 10-year technician, especially in today's market, couple of tenths.
Marshall Sheldon: Yeah. And today's economy? Yeah. Crazy work. I'm I'm also curious, like this is totally off kilter, but I'm gonna drive us down a road that has nothing to do with what we're
Josh Arnold: Off in the weeds, here we go.
Marshall Sheldon: it's in line, but it's it's unrelated kind of. I'm curious, like I haven't seen anything. I'm trying to figure out did Homeboy have a job before he got home or like what's the deal?
Josh Arnold: Are you trying to recruit him like normal?
Marshall Sheldon: Well no, I'm just I'm just curious because there's another guy that I watch, a diesel guy, and he actually outed the dealership that he worked for. So he works in heavy duty like I do, and I won't say who they were, but because we don't need to get sued. But yeah, he said like he went into the office and was recording the whole time. the whole time. And he put it all on there.
Josh Arnold: boy.
Marshall Sheldon: and and it was all s over some random little crap that he said online. It wasn't even that serious, I didn't think, over, you know, they must have been trying to get rid of him or something. Like I was like, what are you guys doing?
Josh Arnold: Mm.
Marshall Sheldon: But I
mean that was like I commented on his on the on the old gram there and I like, Bro had a job before he got home. I mean, like You know, these guys these outfits firing a tech over some shenanigans is y forcing
Josh Arnold: Or forcing to quit. I think it was acquitting here.
Marshall Sheldon: them to quit. Or, you know, whatever I think is is kinda dumb because it doesn't do really a whole lot to the tech. The tech's got it literally you know, I've said it before, like, dude, I'd have a job before I got home. Like I would go out to my car, I'd get in a freaking I'd before I pulled out of the parking lot, I would have another job. All I would have to go do is the formalities, you know, the urinalis and the background check and I'd have a job. I think most good technicians do. And so for them to, you know, you got a tenure tech with a a large following, that Joker can make one post. He'd probably have 30 job offers before he got home. And they did they did nothing but hurt themselves.
Josh Arnold: I I would agree and I think that it probably damaged that dealership's reputation too. I imagine the techs around him probably felt the same way. And so again, like I just feel like at this point the dealership could have handled it a little bit differently. I get asking for the post to come down, but it just in today's light, when you ask for a video to come down that isn't, I would say, damaging anything. I personally. I think it just shows that you're trying to hide something. At least that's how it's
Marshall Sheldon: Yeah.
Josh Arnold: perceived to me, right? Like
Marshall Sheldon: Yeah, and there's there's not a clean way. Once it's out there, it's out there and that one went viral. It had a bajillion likes on it. I mean, I have to look it up, but it had a crap load of following on it and
Josh Arnold: Course.
Marshall Sheldon: across multiple platforms. There's no getting rid of it after that. It was downloaded by people
Josh Arnold: Mm-hmm.
Marshall Sheldon: and copied and everything shared and everything
Josh Arnold: Right.
Marshall Sheldon: else. It's gone after there's no taking it down. It don't matter if they took it down
Josh Arnold: I
Marshall Sheldon: or not. You know, he could have he could have deleted that video. It was it was gone after that.
Josh Arnold: It was gone. Yeah, i it's taken off, right? So it's happening.
Marshall Sheldon: You know, so there's yeah, there's nothing they taking it down would was would have been pointless and
Josh Arnold: Yeah.
Marshall Sheldon: and so they they should have played that totally different and you know
Josh Arnold: I agree. But I mean let's let let's let's play the devil's advocate here. This is gonna be now hold on. Hold on, everybody. No, no, no, no.
Marshall Sheldon: Gotta put your fucking service manager hat on here? Or what?
Josh Arnold: I'm gonna put my my OEM hat on. I'm gonna wear I'm gonna go even bigger. The and
Marshall Sheldon: Okay, okay.
Josh Arnold: and this is gonna be, you know, really hard as a technician to zoom out, but let's look at it from the manufacturer standpoint. Now again, knowing the information I know about the Toyota recall, they originally paid 2.1. They catch technicians online talking like, look at me, I got it down. Like, I'm not even taking all this shit. Like, you guys are idiots if you're taking all this crap off. Like, just do it like this, right? Toyota sees that. They look at it as they're creating this recall for customer safety, satisfaction, whatever you want to say. They're trying to take care of their customers, right? They're also paying a buttload of money for this, right? And when you're talking 400,000, 500,000 vehicles, when you have a recall go out, that is some big dollars. And each one of those tents, I mean, from a financial standpoint, you can imagine it's just huge. Okay. Not advocating here, but I'm saying that when they see those videos online of those technicians doing it that much faster. And I and I want to bring back into a specific instance. Honda had like a steering rack recall. And I saw this online. Techs found a way with a wrench or a special tool to like come up with a great way to not drop the rack down. And Honda got wind of that. And you know what they did? They updated the recall, they sent out the tool to the dealerships and the tech. Technicians got a reduction in hours because the tool, following the procedure that was found out after the re recall had been completed, was given to the techs. And so what this led to was technicians making less money for the ones that had figured it out, right? But it also led to manufacturer having to pay less, probably faster time in and out for customer. And overall a better procedure. But that being said, again, and again, we've got to be real careful here, but like there is something to be said that that manufacturer, that those technicians found a better way to do it. That is what flat rate's all about. Right. The whole point of flat rate is that you tell me what the book time is, and I find a way to beat it, keeping my quality and doing it as fast as possible.
Marshall Sheldon: Yeah, I I don't feel like they should be able to like cut slash it like that. I don't know. So let's roll let me roll this into something a little sweet here. So starting October 1st, when a factory disputes the hours on a Rhode Island warranty claim, the burden of the proof is on the factory. Rhode Island
Josh Arnold: you found that one?
Marshall Sheldon: is the first state to make a factory pay warranty labor on well make a factory pay warranty labor on technicians' actual clock time. The rate is the dealer's own non warranty labor rate and the clock includes diagnostic and tech line time.
Josh Arnold: And and I get it there. Now my question to you is with that policy change, what happens in Rhode Island? And also say this goes nationwide. Do recalls become less? Do customer satisfaction bulletins happen less because the money involved is now so much more? What do you think what do you think the effect of it is, right?
Marshall Sheldon: Well, the effect of it is is they're just not gonna be able to make as much money, I guess. These guys are you know
Josh Arnold: Yeah.
Marshall Sheldon: you know, they're making a car for twenty grand and selling it for a hundred and then you know, I guess they're just gonna take a chunk out they're gonna raise the prices on the car or they're gonna eat it. I mean I don't know what else to tell but like, you know, the you know, Illinois and some of these other states have already started paying you know the guarantees there now, so
Josh Arnold: Yep. I think it's I think it's a good thing for I think it's a good thing for our industry. I just hope that it happens across the nation. I don't want it to just happen in secular things. I really want it to be let's just go for it all the way. Let's take care of our technicians, making sure they're getting paid fairly for the jobs that they do. but we're about that twenty minute mark right now. All right. Now this is a very special case. Because I watched one of this guy's video. And you know what happened, Marshall? What did the dealership say to him?
Marshall Sheldon: They said catch you on the next
Josh Arnold: Yeah, right.
Marshall Sheldon: one.