TRANSKRIBEERI 🔗
[0:01] Welcome to the e-commerce IP report.
[0:04] Hello, everyone, and welcome back to the e-commerce IP report.
[0:10] Adam Urbanschak is the principal attorney at AULLC.
[0:14] A Chicago law firm focused on intellectual property litigation, e-commerce disputes,
[0:19] and helping businesses protect their brands and are rapidly evolving marketplace.
[0:24] I'm Sean O'Connor, and today Adam and I are talking about how businesses
[0:29] protect their brand from online counterfeit sellers.
[0:33] Hi, Adam.
[0:35] Hi, Sean.
[0:36] How are you doing?
[0:37] I'm doing pretty well.
[0:38] Thank you very much.
[0:39] How about you?
[0:41] Keeping busy.
[0:42] There's a lot of activity as usual.
[0:44] Yeah, yeah.
[0:45] Well, I feel like this kind of thing is maybe rampant, but I don't have an informed opinion.
[0:51] How common is online counterfeiting for businesses who are selling in a digital marketplace?
[0:59] It's extremely common.
[1:02] I mean, you can look at your customs data that's published on an annual basis,
[1:08] at least, that'll identify the, you know, losses suffered by businesses just in the United States as a result of fake products.
[1:17] And that could be counterfeit products.
[1:20] That is, you know, capital C counterfeit products under the land impact, or just fakes generally.
[1:26] So products that are ostensibly covered under a US designer utility patent.
[1:32] Or are just generally not authorized to exist the way that they do.
[1:38] They're sold using other, you know, other rates of those images, or they.
[1:43] Embodies some some copyright protectable character or something without authorization.
[1:48] So rather than like fakes or counterfeit products, the best, the best term to, to talk about all of it is probably just unauthorized products.
[1:55] Yeah, okay.
[1:57] Yeah, and various levels of sophistication and intent.
[2:02] What are, what are some early signs that another seller may be offering counterfeit versions of a company's products online?
[2:11] I suppose if you a prototypical example might a business that has a website, maybe they have a storefront on Amazon or eBay or some other marketplace.
[2:24] And in the course of advertising their products, they just come across other versions of it.
[2:30] If they don't have an, you know, an active IP enforcement.
[2:36] Like a service provider, or they're not, they're not really paying attention to it that much.
[2:40] They might just see a different sales.
[2:43] And when they, when they dig into it, they can see an Amazon, for example, maybe some other seller is in their buy box.
[2:51] Or they see, you know, unfortunately, what your strategy that.
[3:00] So counterfeiters or pirates are, or those engaged in the activity.
[3:05] What the employee is, you know, rather than trying to engage in a contest to see who might spend more on paper click advertising or other like traditional forms of advertising to get their products.
[3:21] Above the, above the threshold such that the average consumer is going to notice them.
[3:25] Often what happens is they will instead just create a number of different storefronts that are, that are usually kind of ambiguously named.
[3:35] It's just a string of characters sometimes.
[3:37] And that way they kind of, you know, they, they flood the marketplace so to speak, not necessarily with lots of fake products.
[3:46] But just vet, you know, venues or storefronts at which those products can can be purchased.
[3:52] Even maybe what, each individual store might not mean, may not be selling lots of a particular product.
[3:59] There's just so many of them that the, the genuine retailer can't get above the threshold.
[4:04] They can't get to the, the top of the list.
[4:06] So the customer is just assuming everything is legit and will buy the top one or the top two.
[4:13] Yeah, it's just like a super broad net almost.
[4:16] I mean, it's like a lot of numbers or it's like, okay, well, certain number of people are just going to fall into that store, that store, that store and they're all sort of owned by the same operator.
[4:26] Interesting strategy.
[4:27] Anyone who you go to Amazon or almost any marketplace or almost any website in this day and age, it's panic inducing amount of information that is shoved it to you immediately.
[4:38] Sometimes you really look, you can tell if you scrolled on an Amazon listing, you can see what the brand is identified as or who the manufacturer might be or what that product is actually sold or who the product is actually sold by, but yeah.
[4:53] If we're on our phones, the phone is maybe five to six inches in diameter, diagonal, you know, you're not, you're going to miss it.
[4:59] You just see the product that looks okay.
[5:02] You know, one click by now and then there you go that that's that's how it happens.
[5:06] Oh, yeah, I mean, it's happened to be just for, you know, in certain, just innocuous ways where I'm like, wait, I thought I was buying that from, you know, Dick sporting goods, let's say, and it turns out it came from, you know, some guy named Dick, who is, you know, we're just, you know, selling you sporty goods.
[5:23] It's like, wait, what happened?
[5:25] Usually I was seeing too much of a hurry, but yeah, you're right. There's so many so much fine print.
[5:31] What about, you know, beyond just lost sales, what kind of damage can counterfeit sellers cause to a business and its reputation even.
[5:42] It can hurt the brand in so far as a potential customer who was looking for a product.
[5:50] If they, if they get the impression that the particular brand is being knocked off, very, very casual, that maybe that, maybe not casual, but often that might make the, the potential customer wary about shopping around, I mean, they may not want to spend the time to ensure that they're getting the authentic one.
[6:16] In some sense, yeah, so they rather than trying to find a particular brand of something that isn't like
Load full transcript
a particular target, like, you know, there are some brands are, you know, at some threshold brands are they get sufficiently popular such that them being knocked off or unauthorized versions of them being produced and sold as an indicator that well, I guess your sale, you know, you have enough of a commercial footprint that there is a motivation to rip the brand off.
[6:44] So like Rolex is a great example. There is a probably a multi billion dollar industry of just fake Rolexes and that's just because Rolex, the brand is hugely powerful and people know the very desirable pieces generally right.
[6:59] But for for smaller brands, it might, if for for smaller brands and for products that aren't so particularly desirable, whereas the consumer isn't thinking, I really want this brand of something they just want a something and they hope it's produced by some brand that isn't selling me something that's toxic or is going to kill me.
[7:24] Then I'll go find this, but if that there isn't a sensitivity there and it's just, you know, the fungible purchases that's not important, if they see a particular brand is getting ripped off all over the place, they might not want to have to deal with it at all is like, you know, I was going to buy this, but there's 10 different versions it sold by 13 different sellers, I don't know what's authentic and what's not, I'm just going to go to the other one and not have to worry about it.
[7:52] If it's, if it's not an important purchase, if it's not, if I'm not buying a Rolex, I'm going to pay attention that I'm going to go into the authorize dealer or some reputable, you know, marketplace or something, but for many things that are purchased, but for probably for most things that are purchased online, finding the actual branded version of it might not be as important, it's more about finding the best price.
[8:15] And that's good enough is good enough is good enough for or you'll try it once you'll try some knockoff so to speak and be like, not as good, you know, sometimes that happens, I think it'll come down to a lot, I mean, ultimately it's the problem is potential customers are buying your authentic product for a number of related reasons, that's the ultimate problem.
[8:40] The the the the the corrosion of the brand is the results of the corrosion of the brand is that people just start buying your products that are branded as such, so there could be an initial loss of sales because there are unauthorized versions out there and then like in the long run, other products that might be under the same brand may become less desirable because of an issue with.
[9:09] A particular product being being knocked off, yeah, yeah, where's that happening most like where to businesses most often encounter counterfeit sellers today.
[9:19] Well online, I think you know, the very to entry to anybody can throw anybody with with I guess an ID and maybe bag a couch can can throw up a storefront and source products from somewhere and engage in drop shipment.
[9:35] It's been a you know, Amazon eBay, you know, team moves, some of these are the marketplaces have it's been a great to democratization of the seller economy.
[9:47] Yeah, for better and for worse, anybody can do it so that there's just you know that that's where that's where the issues going to come up first and foremost, other than that, I mean you're you're down to.
[10:02] You know the fake Gucci bags on the street corner in New York City or something like that, I mean you'll run into there and then there are other versions of that in different parts of the country is certainly not limited to New York City.
[10:12] But the you know, the products will come in and they'll be sold out of a warehouse or a truck or public storage facility, sometimes yeah.
[10:24] But you know, first and foremost it be me because the very to entry in opening up an e-commerce store is the lowest are going to see that being like the, you know, the 80% of the problem is probably e-commerce got it.
[10:37] And so you find out you're discovered, you know, that someone someone's doing this, they're ripping you off in some way, what legal options to businesses have, you know, once they've once they've discovered that, you know, counterfeit versions of their product or being sold out.
[10:54] Well, there are legal administrator practical options legal options administrative options that are sort of interrelated.
[11:03] It's your brand owner and you see that there is there are two storefronts that are selling some bogus version of your product that's branded it's not it's not authentic, you're confident of that based on what it looks like in the image and what the price point is, for example.
[11:20] Do you have to run the court and sue those two maybe maybe not, maybe the initial, the initial response is a your platform complaint, maybe you're raising a trademark dispute on the platform itself, it's like an administrative remedy sort of.
[11:39] Maybe it's a DMC notification those will be addressed and handled much more quickly than a lawsuit will.
[11:47] At some threshold, if you're facing us, but there's a swarm of sellers who are selling unauthorized products and it really isn't some either it isn't something that platform complaints would likely take care of in bulk.
[12:05] And or the volume of what they're doing meet some threshold that might result in litigation, then, you know, perhaps the perhaps the platform complaint isn't the first thing to do.
[12:20] Maybe it's you're consulting an attorney conducting an investigation and then, you know, trying to get some some some relief through the court system.
[12:29] At least, you know, at least in e-commerce, much of the activity is occurring from sellers who are based overseas and to where funds from the unauthorized, you know, purchases or unauthorized product purchases are sending back to.
[12:46] They're going to be not judgment proof exactly know the prospect of getting a relief
against them.
[12:55] It is can be challenging, there are processes by which you can domesticate US judgments and forward countries, but that's another step that the average brand owner lit again in the United States may not be in the position to take at least that anytime soon.
[13:12] So, you know, the leverage you have over these e-commerce sellers generally is going to be the extent to which you can restrain their activities and the funds associated with those activities that are located here in the US or are held by entities that are reachable by a US judgment.
[13:36] So you can you can stop it that way.
[13:40] If if it looks like there is just the mistake or there is, for example, a US like a US based seller, you can confirm that there is some some distributor here in the US that is just mistaken.
[13:51] You can always send a cease and a cease letter and try to negotiate the resolution of that type of dispute.
[14:00] Often there are just misunderstandings and you know, litigation is going to be the last resort, but under certain circumstances, the last resort, why is it being the first resort at the same time, why is it being the same, this new activity.
[14:16] Does timing matter, does speed matter, like how quickly should a business act after making that discovery that somebody is selling counterfeit stuff.
[14:28] Well, the sooner the better, I suppose what you want to avoid, if you're a seller and you see somebody selling unauthorized, you know, unauthorized versions of your products, if you're a brand owner and you see somebody selling unauthorized versions of your products.
[14:43] You know, on Tuesday morning, do you have to file a lawsuit on Wednesday? No, you'll, you, there will be some time that you need to investigate the matter, perhaps conduct some test purchase to make sure the products are in fact an authentic or there's lots of gray market activity that isn't necessarily counterfeit.
[15:06] But you know, at a minimum, you don't want to wait too long for a couple of reasons, one, if it's damaging your brand, you want to stop that.
[15:17] Right.
[15:18] And then two, if you wait too long, that can, that can work to defeat an argument, you would raise in litigation that, you know, what, what is transpiring is creating some irreparable harm.
[15:31] So if you, you see some activity and then you wait a year and a half to file a lawsuit that, well, I mean, there may not be a statute of limitations problem or maybe even a like a latches problem to your claims.
[15:47] If you ask the court for the preliminary and junk to relieve for, you know, at the end of the temper restraining or because what's going on is so serious, you need this extraordinary remedy.
[15:56] The court might say like, well, if it was that bad, why did you wait, yeah, more or less, like, why do you wait this long? And there are, you know, examples of that really being denied because the rates hold a way to too long.
[16:09] Long is, is too long. I think it's going to depend under the circumstances, like most things.
[16:15] But I mean, you probably want to do something within three months.
[16:20] Yeah.
[16:21] That makes sense.
[16:22] It's really better.
[16:23] Yeah.
[16:24] You're going to do some, do some sniffing around and figuring out who's who and what's what.
[16:28] Take a few weeks.
[16:29] What about a real world example?
[16:32] I mean, I'm sure in your practice, I mean, you're dealing with this all the time, of course, Adam, and sort of a situation where, you know, a business discovered counterfeit sellers and then you could describe like, what steps did they take to protect their brand?
[16:46] I mean, we've had examples where we clients, we have, you know, we have a client that has as a reasonably sized intellectual property portfolio.
[17:00] They sell products saying like a skincare, skincare segment.
[17:07] And they noticed that there were other versions of their products being sold online.
[17:17] And they weren't, they weren't necessarily, they weren't necessarily inauthentic. They just weren't authorized to be sold in the United States.
[17:29] So the step one would be, well, let's get the scope of the, the, the offending activity.
[17:35] So, yeah.
[17:36] Somebody, somebody throughout these defendants, you look through the look at the offenders business, what they're selling, obtain some out of it.
[17:45] Get some evidence, you're taking screenshots, you'll be conducting some test purchases, making sure that what is being represented on the screen is what is being sold.
[17:54] If there's a difference there, that's a separate problem to basically make, you know, qualified that the nature of your claims.
[18:00] And then if, if it, if it doesn't look like it's a, it's a foreign seller problem, we would send a cease and a cease letter, basically laying out the case, you know, informal letter.
[18:13] Maybe it's four pages long with exhibits like, here's, here's what you're looking at.
[18:18] This is, you know, we represent this rights holder. This is the nature of our clients rights.
[18:25] Here's what we found out.
[18:27] These are the basis for the claims. These are the remedies you're potentially facing.
[18:32] Here's a list of demands, including, you know, give us all the sales you have of, all the sales records you have of all these products or anything else that's related there too.
[18:42] You know, litigation holds and all of that and then wait to see if they come back to you.
[18:47] Sometimes, you know, sometimes they do, sometimes they don't.
[18:50] I think that they do. If it's at, you know, at some point, if the, if the, if the, at the end of receiving end of the demand is sufficiently large, they will have counsel either in house or they will have an attorney who has helped them conduct their business.
[19:01] And then you'll receive a response from them and maybe it's resolved.
[19:05] Maybe it's not.
[19:06] In this case, it wasn't. So we sent
follow-up letter.
[19:09] That wasn't responded to and then we wound up opening a case.
[19:14] That got everyone's attention. And then that will, that will lead to additional discussions and then, you know, potentially resolve the matter or if there isn't a resolution, then we just proceed to litigation.
[19:27] So.
[19:30] That's kind of typical.
[19:33] Most of the time, a rights holder after having an attorney sent a season to cis letter, you should get a response.
[19:39] But that's not always the case. Sometimes the organization isn't very tightly wound and correspondence like that just goes away.
[19:47] There's no shortage of letters that are sent that are ostensibly legal in nature, but are just spam.
[19:57] Often what, you know, the substance of the letter isn't taken seriously for better for worse. So yeah, that can result in some discommunication of rights holders claims.
[20:09] But ultimately, you know, the litigation aspect is going to be the last resort. I mean, most.
[20:15] Most intellectual property infringement disputes writ large can be resolved through some form of negotiation.
[20:21] And then it's a matter of like, well, what is it worth to the parties to actually not have to go to the next step. And, you know, most of the time that that can be worked out. Sometimes it can't.
[20:31] And that's why you, that's why the courts are there.
[20:34] Have you are there mistakes that people commonly make that.
[20:40] You know, causes a problem. You know what I mean? In terms of trying to stop the activity, the illegal activity.
[20:46] Other things you shouldn't do, I guess.
[20:49] Waiting too long to address the matter is probably the number one problem.
[20:55] Because the nature of the nature of the conduct tends to, it's the breed.
[21:03] If, if you are, if you're vigilant over what's going on with your, your trademarks and your patents and your copyrights and the products being sold that render.
[21:13] These are the numbers marketplaces and you're, you're quick to stamp them out.
[21:18] The, I guess, communities that are interested in selling producing or Android selling in authentic versions of those.
[21:29] We'll see that resistance and they may move off to something else.
[21:33] older and you're asleep at the wheel somewhat, they will, you know, they're actors who will
[21:41] take advantage of that. So if you wait too long, the problem will grow. There's some, you
[21:48] know, logarithmic measure of the type of damage that can occur as more and more sellers are
[21:54] seeing that you're not actually enforcing any of your rights. And as soon goes on, there are
[21:58] more and more tools available for whether the platform tools or otherwise, you know, other activities,
[22:06] rights owners can engage in whether the platform complaints or arbitration negotiation, whatever,
[22:11] that will help stamp that out. So I don't think a rights holder isn't making a mistake by addressing
[22:21] them out of properly, whatever, you know, and even stepping back, you know, prefacing that,
[22:27] ensuring that your rights are secured in the form of a trademark registration, ideally on the
[22:33] principal register, if you have some, securing your invention under a US utility or design pad design,
[22:41] if you have creative works, you want to secure them under US copy registrations. If you don't have
[22:48] those that it may be we've been talking, we've been assuming throughout the course of this
[22:53] conversation that the rights holders rights are all secured in these things with the US federal
[22:58] government, that that's been going without saying and maybe should back up and write step zero
[23:03] is to make sure that whatever rights you purport to have are secured with the US federal government
[23:09] in the form of a trademark registration or a US patent of some kind or a copyright registration,
[23:14] that's going to be very important, not only because it's doing that is going to allow you to
[23:20] bring a suit, bring a claim in the first place in federal court, it's going to give you
[23:24] additional remedies in US federal courts and then the platforms are going to be honoring
[23:31] complaints about those things a bit more readily. I mean, you don't, you generally don't want to be
[23:37] like arguing with the platform over your common law rights to some unregistered trademark
[23:42] and then here I mean, they don't, they don't want to hear, they want to, they're going to
[23:45] defer to what the US federal government has already acknowledged as your exclusive rights, that is your
[23:51] trademark registration, your patent or your copyright registration, that's what they want to see.
[23:56] So then maybe that's, that's, you know, that's problem number one would be not securing your rights
[24:02] in the first place. Yeah, I mean, that, you know, ground zero advice before you go selling your stuff
[24:08] online, make sure you've got your rights sewn up, you know, federally and such. Adam,
[24:14] thank you so much. We're out of time for this particular episode, but always informative.
[24:19] Thanks for sharing your expertise and I look forward to connecting on a future episode.
[24:23] Likewise, thanks, Adam. That's it for this episode of the e-commerce IP report. To learn more about
[24:30] Adam or Ben, check, visit the website AU-LLC.com. Thanks for listening and don't forget to like,
[24:38] subscribe to the show, or share a link to this episode with someone who might be interested in
[24:43] the topic. I'm Sean O'Connor. Have a great day. Thanks for watching. Be sure to hit that like
[24:53] and subscribe button and leave us a review in the comments.