TRANSKRIBEERI 🔗
00:00:05
Speaker 1: Brian Reed here, and I'm in the studio with our newest producer, Tracy Hunt, who recently was pulled into a weird cranny of the Internet, which made her wonder if there might be something bigger going on.
00:00:17
Speaker 2: Yes. I admittedly spend way too much time on TikTok. And the TikTok algorithm knows I'm Black. And so I get like beauty and fashion stuff. But a lot of that is just like Black woman focused as well.
00:00:31
Speaker 1: And that's what you like. That's what you're going on TikTok for.
00:00:34
Speaker 2: Yeah, that's what I like. I want to listen to Black women talk about Love Island. But then I'll also get these videos where it's like, you know, a Black guy on some Manosphere podcast and he's talking about how No one wants to be with Black women and Black women don't deserve good relationships. And then I'll see a video where a Black woman is talking about how Black men are terrible and violent. And then, oh, the diaspora wars. And that's like Black Americans talking about how African and Caribbean people just like steal their culture from Black Americans and how awful they are. And then I'll see some Black person in the UK talking about how Black Americans have no culture. And it's just very, very divisive and awful. And it just feels like it was created in a lab to piss me off.
00:01:26
Speaker 1: Can you play me one of these videos just so I can kind of see or hear what you're getting?
00:01:30
Speaker 2: Sure.
00:01:31
Speaker 3: Sure.
00:01:32
Speaker 4: You people come over here and y'all are disrespectful. And we don't go to your homelands and disrespect your homelands. If 20 million Black Americans went to Nigeria and started disrespecting the Nigerians, started taking from the culture, started operating the culture, and they're acting like the culture was theirs, y'all wouldn't let none of that fly.
00:01:47
Speaker 2: I should also add that I don't really hear these debates in real life, but online it feels like they're everywhere.
00:01:54
Speaker 4: There's a reason why Black women in general do very poorly when it comes to the dating scene. And the reason why is because they have masculine attitudes coming from single mother households.
00:02:04
Speaker 2: So it makes me wonder if this is just all designed to tear Black people apart and undermine our solidarity. And I'm not the only one wondering this because I see a lot of comments saying things like, this is the CIA. This is a PSYOP. Wait, what? Yeah. So I will look at some screenshots that I took to give you an idea what I'm talking about. So under one of these videos, a woman says, I swear it's the CIA doing this. I'm glad some of us are smart enough to see it. Another quote, I'm convinced this narrative has been pushed as a psyop. And somebody responds, oh, it's definitely a psyop. Here's another one. thank you for posting this. There's so much misinformation being passed around online, like it's a psyop.
00:02:55
Speaker 1: And when people are saying psyop, just to put a fine point on it, they mean a psychological operation, like a government operation that plays on people's psychology. What are they actually proposing they think might be going on?
00:03:10
Speaker 2: I think what they think is going on is that There may be like, you know, government intelligence groups that are maybe paying people to say these things. Maybe they're all bots that are like, you know, coming out of some Russian troll farm. Or maybe there are like people being seated in the community to spread these ideas who might not even necessarily believe them. Like agents?
00:03:36
Speaker 3: Yeah.
00:03:37
Speaker 2: I think they're drawing on a real history of And we haven't even said the big word yet, COINSELPRO, or Counterintelligence Program. And that was a series of covert, illegal operations run by the FBI in the 50s to early 70s that were trying to infiltrate leftist political groups, including the civil rights movement, and destroy them from the inside. So we're not pulling this PSYOP thing out of nowhere.
00:04:05
Speaker 5: I know, but one of the tricky things about PSYOPs is it's like, hard to know if it's a PSYOP when it's happening. And that's the thing that kind of like sends you into a dangerous spiral.
00:04:16
Speaker 2: Whether or not it is a PSYOP, it sure is effective. It's just very, very convenient that there would be a lot of Black people yelling at each other on social media. So I can't tell you whether the stuff in my feed is a PSYOP. Honestly, a lot of it is probably just, you know, people fighting on the internet like real people do. But it made me want to know about the things we can prove are psyops, where organizations or people deliberately tried to manipulate Black people. I wanted to know how they did it and why.
00:04:50
Speaker 1: Got it. And that's the story you have for us today, right? That's the story. From KCRW and Placement Theory, this is Question Everything. I'm Brian Reed. We investigate how the truth gets buried, distorted, denied, and the ways people are fighting to make it matter again. And what Tracy found when she dug into this is that the disinformers who are targeting Black people in America, they don't make things up out of thin air. They have a tried and true strategy where they find something that already hurts with real history behind it and press on it.
00:05:20
Speaker 6: Mailman voting sounds great. But did you know that if you vote by mail, your personal information will be part of a public database that will be used by police departments to track down old warrants?
00:05:33
Speaker 2: Those are pain points in the Black community where we've already seen abuse from our government.
00:05:40
Speaker 1: Today, how psyops on social media target Black Americans and their vote. Stick around.
00:05:55
Speaker 2: So I was on TikTok looking for examples of online disinformation, and then I came across a video from a professor. She was talking about how
Load full transcript
harmful messages to and about Black people spread online.
00:06:09
Speaker 7: One of the biggest threats to Black life with AI is the fact that it is becoming more and more undetectable, which leads us into a space where misinformation, disinformation, and malinformation are able to proliferate.
00:06:23
Speaker 2: Her name is Dr. Christine McWhorter. She teaches broadcast reporting and media history at Howard University. And while she is an academic and a journalist, Professor McWhorter is also a person who experiences the internet day in and day out like the rest of us. And I like that she was on social media talking directly to Black people about all the BS that's always coming at us.
00:06:49
Speaker 1: So I called her up.
00:06:51
Speaker 2: So I got in touch with you because I saw a clip of you, I think on TikTok, talking about disinformation campaigns and how they're targeted towards Black people. And so I was wondering, what kind of research are you currently studying about this? My research centers around something called critical race media literacy.
00:07:13
Speaker 1: And yes, absolutely, I know that's a mouthful.
00:07:16
Speaker 2: But critical race media literacy talks about how media does racial harm, how we can get people to understand and evaluate that harm, and how we can challenge that harm. She walked me through three campaigns where media was used to target Black voters— Each one turned out to be fake. The first started around the 2016 presidential election. Piggybacking off the growing popularity of the Black Lives Matter movement, two groups popped up on Facebook and Twitter, Black Matters U.S. and Blacktivist. They posted very, like, extremely pro-Black.
00:07:54
Speaker 1: Messages, right?
00:07:55
Speaker 2: Things about police brutality, things about Black maternal health, things about the Black community and education. And so they were gaining followers. They were gaining community. Black Matters U.S. would grow to have about 200,000 followers on Facebook. The fake Blacktivist group had more than 360,000 likes, and they were capital I involved. And they did this for almost two years. It got to the point where they were helping organizations plan protests. There was a, right, like real in-person protests. With Black Matters U.S., there was even money involved. Someone from an actual Black activist group met with a woman who gave him a debit card to help pay for a protest. Like, that's how real it was. But while these groups were highlighting real issues for Black people, and even organizing and supporting protests, their solutions to these issues started to look a little suspicious the closer we got to Election Day. Not that long before the election, the online messaging changed to voter suppression messages. So then they would say things like, well, we shouldn't vote. There's no point in it. The system isn't for us. There are no good options. They're using narratives like this so that— it would suppress the Black vote. The election came and went. Donald Trump was elected president over Hillary Clinton. Whether the campaign convinced Black people to vote or not, we still don't know. But it was too little, too late. It wasn't until the fall of 2017, almost a year later, that the truth came out.
00:09:40
Speaker 1: A Twitter and Facebook account, both disguised to look like they were run by the same Black activists, were actually the work of Russians.
00:09:47
Speaker 8: This campaign used both Facebook and Twitter to basically advance a message that would exploit the racial tensions that exist in this country effectively as part of the larger Russian goal of undermining American democracy, sowing political discord, contributing to an atmosphere of partisanship and incivility.
00:10:12
Speaker 2: The social media sites shut down these accounts in 2017. And later, the Senate Intelligence Committee confirmed the pages were run by Russia's Internet Research Agency, a troll farm, in a campaign that targeted Black Americans more than any other group. So to your point about psyops, yes, covert operations exist, and they're very sophisticated and they're very detailed. The second campaign didn't need fake activists. It hid behind a real nonprofit and pretended to be something it wasn't. There was a nonprofit called Building America's Future. And Building America's Future is important because it was funded through something called dark money. Dark money is money that goes through organizations like nested organizations. So there'll be one organization that feeds money to another organization that feeds money to another organization, and it makes that money untraceable. And the reason for that is there are certain types of nonprofits that do not have to disclose who their donors are. So one, for example, is a 501c4. Most people have heard of a 501c3. That's a regular nonprofit like the Red Cross or NPR. 501c3s aren't allowed to dabble in politics. A 501c4 is an organization that can receive large donations and they don't have to say who gave them that money. So what someone will do, a very rich person will do, is give the money to the 501c4 organization. So they more or less serve as a go-between for rich donors who want to remain anonymous and super PACs who have political agendas. Here's how it works. A secret donor gives money to Building America's Future. Then Building America's Future sends that money to a super PAC who can use that money any way it likes in political campaigns with no links to the original person who donated the money. That's why it's called dark money. I should point out that both parties use dark money. But what made Building America's Future different is it pretended to be something it wasn't. It had these many organizations underneath, and each one of those organizations targeted a different community to give information to. And much of that information was disinformation. Disinformation aimed at keeping Kamala Harris out of the White
House. Building America's Future funded a super PAC that ran ads telling Muslim voters in Michigan that Harris was pro-Israel, while Jewish voters in Pennsylvania got ads depicting Harris as an enemy to Israel. Building America's Future also created a fake pro-Harris group called Progress 2028. According to the Washington Post, Progress 2028 made ads praising Harris for policies she didn't support, like mandatory gun buybacks, and universal health care for undocumented immigrants. And for Black voters in several swing states, there were ads about cigarettes, menthol cigarettes specifically. And like a lot of these PSYOP campaigns, they were blending the truth with fiction. In 2022, the Biden administration had proposed banning menthol cigarettes, then dropped the ban two years later, citing feedback from several groups. Building America's Future picked up on that issue and distorted it.
00:13:44
Speaker 4: Yeah, you heard that right. Instead of solving the problems that matter to you, Kamala Harris and D.C. Democrats are coming after your menthol cigarettes.
00:13:53
Speaker 2: Most Black people who smoke do smoke menthol cigarettes. And Professor McWhorter says that's why they focused on them in the first place. And they had done that based on research that they had that there was a large group of Black people that preferred menthol cigarettes. It turned out that two Republican consultants actually created Building America's Future during the first Trump administration. In the lead up to the 2024 election, they got a Republican pollster to ramp up all these anti-Harris attack ads to the tune of around $ 35 million. Reminder, the funders are supposed to remain anonymous, which is probably why the sources who came forward to expose the truth behind Building America's Future were also anonymous. Not one, not two, not three, but four separate anonymous sources verified Elon Musk is funding building America's future. It was Reuters that reported this, and we would never have known if it weren't for good journalism. There is this one term that kept coming up in my conversation with Dr. Christine McWhorter. Those are pain points in the Black community. Pain points in the Black community. And that's a pain point. A legitimate, actual pain point. McWhorter says online disinformation campaigns that target Black people try to locate and exploit very specific fears in the Black community. When people identify with those pain points in the narrative... it makes it easy for the narrative to take you to a false place. Can I give one more example? Yeah, absolutely. In 2020, there was a disinformation campaign that involved robocalls, and the robocalls were targeted to Black voters. The calls were coming from someone calling themselves Tamika Taylor from Project 1599, and they targeted Black voters in swing states like Ohio, Pennsylvania, and Michigan. And it said, if you use mail-in ballots, they will have your data and they will use your data for these three things.
00:16:11
Speaker 6: Mail-in voting sounds great. But did you know that if you vote by mail, your personal information will be part of a public database that will be used by police departments to track down old ones? Can we use our credit card companies to collect outstanding debt? The CDC is even pushing to use records for mail-in voting to track people for mandatory vaccines.
00:16:32
Speaker 2: And they will use your data to look at your medical records and force you to get vaccinated. And we know in 2020, that was a huge thing. And then her final message to would-be mail-in voters, correction, mail-in Black voters.
00:16:46
Speaker 6: Don't be finesse into giving those types of information to the main. Stay safe and be aware of those type of emails.
00:16:55
Speaker 2: The reason why I bring this up is because those are pain points in the Black community where we've already seen abuse from our government. We already have abuse from imprisonment. And that's a pain point because of the way that the government has misused and abused us in regards to arrest, imprisonment, the whole complex. Obviously, there's been economic abuse historically. And then also medical trust issues. A lot of black and brown people did not want to get vaccinated because of Tuskegee, because of Henrietta Lacks, because a lot of our community doesn't trust the government because they have, in fact, lied about medical issues and we don't want to be involved. But if it feels like an extra hurt, if it feels like a fear and specifically a black fear of a fear where we've been harmed before by our own government, that's a sign and that's a trigger. The robocall was especially nefarious because, according to a lawsuit, they hired a Black actress to voice the commercial. And I couldn't help but notice that Project 1599 sounds a lot like the Pulitzer Prize-winning 1619 Project. They also, in my opinion, clumsily used Black slang like finesse and the man. And of course, her name was Tamika. Who is Blacker than Tameka Taylor?
00:18:19
Speaker 5: You know, yeah.
00:18:21
Speaker 2: Yeah, that's a Black woman. It was relatively easy to figure out who was behind this scheme. It's right there at the start of the call.
00:18:31
Speaker 6: Hi, this is Tameka Taylor from Project 1599, a civil rights organization founded by Jack Berkman and Jacob Wool.
00:18:40
Speaker 2: Jacob Wool and Jack Berkman, two white Republican operatives from Virginia. They faced charges for voter intimidation and telecommunication fraud in several states, and a civil rights group sued them in federal court for civil rights violations, including the Ku Klux Klan Act. The FCC fined them $ 5 million for the robocall campaign, and they agreed to pay the New York attorney general's office more than a million dollars in a settlement. In Michigan, they were sentenced to one year of probation. They were back in the news this fall after 60 Minutes investigated them for their latest side hustle. They allegedly
told people they could broker pardons with the Trump administration in exchange for hundreds of thousands of dollars. So that's three elections, 2016, 2020, 2024, and three operations aimed at Black voters that we know about from Russia and far-right groups. And we only found out about them because of investigative journalism. anonymous sources and lawsuits, usually long after the elections already happened. We just had the midterms. Black voters turned out against Republicans. But was anyone running a PSYOP against them this year? We may not know for a while. But Professor McWhorter says there's a new tool out there that could make the next PSYOP even harder to catch. AI and digital blackface.
00:20:09
Speaker 1: After the break.
00:20:14
Speaker 2: Lately, Professor McWhorter has been using her TikTok to talk about how AI fits into the disinformation landscape. Sometimes Black people are so fake. And I mean that literally because sometimes Black people are AI-generated. She's talking about digital Blackface, which, with AI, has become even easier to pull off. Digital Blackface is when someone who isn't Black performs Black identity or pretends to be Black online. But instead of pretending to be Black, disinformers can now just create fake Black people to do and say the things to fit their narrative. Here's an example. There was a radio host in Florida. His name is Mark Kay, and he has something like a million followers. He made a picture of President Trump, and he's surrounded by Black women online. And they're, you know, smiling, getting along in the picture. And it's manufacturing this sense of the Black community loves me. Like, I'm, you know, all of this stuff. Y'all are saying I'm racist, but clearly I'm not.
00:21:18
Speaker 3: Look at these.
00:21:19
Speaker 2: And not just Black people, but Black women, right? Black women, especially, yeah. You know, and people look at that and use it as evidence of something that the Black community did not necessarily say. But all those women, they're A.I., McWhorter says she's worried that these kind of stunts with AI-generated Black people are increasingly harder to detect. And we're not saying, you know, that there are no Black people that love President Trump.
00:21:46
Speaker 1: Of course, there are some.
00:21:48
Speaker 2: But my point is, you can manufacture a consensus where there is none. And so AI is making everything trickier. We used to be able to say, oh, this person has like six fingers. So obviously, like, that's not a person. AI is too good now. Yeah, they got really good at hands and it was over for us.
00:22:09
Speaker 4: Yeah, it's over.
00:22:10
Speaker 6: It's over.
00:22:11
Speaker 4: We can't. We don't know.
00:22:12
Speaker 2: We can't tell.
00:22:13
Speaker 8: Yeah.
00:22:14
Speaker 2: So I'm wondering, like, how do you counteract that? How do you get the truth out there?
00:22:19
Speaker 1: I have some solutions for this.
00:22:22
Speaker 6: OK, yeah, yeah.
00:22:23
Speaker
2: One of the biggest things that I am an advocate of is that people should be making counter narratives. It's important to say that a counter-narrative can only be told from a member of the racially marginalized community. So if I'm going to tell a counter-narrative about Black people, I pretty much better be Black, right? The 1619 Project, Nicole Hannah-Jones, was one of my favorite counter-narratives. Our Black historians tell the truth about what history is censored about, and that did great work. Nick Warder told me, if you're Black and you have something positive to say about our community, hop on social media and say it. We need all the counter-narratives we can get. There are people who do, they have the absolute gift of gab. hilarious and fun. Like Khalil Green, who does history about Black people and he counters falsehoods. And he's really great, right?
00:23:18
Speaker 3: So did y'all know that Tupac Shakur was named after one of history's greatest indigenous resistance leaders? The name Tupac comes from a Quechua language spoken by the Incan people of this region in South America.
00:23:30
Speaker 2: I think one of the things we have to make sure that we do is put out things that are engaging, that they're entertaining, that people really want to hear and listen to, that they would listen to anyway, if it wasn't even necessarily, you know, me teaching you about disinformation, wagging my finger at you about, you know, fact-checking. Now, is it, you know, is the algorithm going to pick it up as quickly as they pick up a fight in the street? Maybe not. But I think it goes a long way in making sure that people hear what we actually have to say. I asked Professor McWhorter what disinformation she's paying attention to right now. And she said, after the blue wave midterms, to look out for disinformation blaming Democrats for programs that the Republicans have cut. The biggest one, in my opinion, this is just my two cents, narratives about... What will happen economically are extremely important because there are several things that were triggered in the big, beautiful bill that will not take place until after the midterms. In that bill, Republicans cut nearly a trillion dollars over 10 years from Medicaid. Now that they've lost control of Congress, she says the GOP may try to shift the narrative and the blame. And so that's going to make it seem like Democrats got in office and they took away access to Medicaid. They took away, you know, further access to SNAP.
00:25:08
Speaker 8: They took away these.
00:25:10
Speaker 2: Supports that many black and brown communities depend on. And so. One thing I'm looking for is narratives that say, well, you know, the Democrats actually, you know, don't help and they want to take away these things. And they, you know, they are not for communities because to the not as informed person, it will look like they said they were going to take away these things. And then after the midterms, oh, no, they were taken away. Right. Specifically targeted for pain points in the black community. After we talked, I decided to follow Khalil Green, who goes by the Gen Z Historian.
00:25:53
Speaker 3: Did you know that the first woman to be accused of witchcraft during the infamous Salem witch trials.
00:25:58
Speaker 2: He has videos about how the South inspired the Hunger Games novels and how the true victims of the Salem witch trials were Native Americans. My algorithm is still a mess, especially after reporting this story. But every time I watch one of his videos instead of a comment war, I'm teaching my algorithm something. When I see these kinds of messages, I need to be more critical of them so that I don't get caught up. I don't fall for the okey-doke.
00:26:31
Speaker 1: You explained it perfectly well.
00:26:33
Speaker 2: If you understand how to deconstruct the narrative, you won't fall for the okey-doke.
00:26:46
Speaker 1: That was Tracy Hunt, one of the producers of our show. talking to Professor Christine McWhorter at Howard University. Please follow our show on whatever app you're using to listen to us right now. Check us out on Instagram at questioneverything.podcast or on Substack, questioneverything.substack.com. Today's show was edited by Executive Editor Kevin Sullivan. Robin Semi and I are the Executive Producers of Question Everything. Our team also includes Producers Sam Egan and Zach St. Louis, Contributing Editors Neil Drumming and Jen Kinney, Associate Producer Kevin Shepard, and Contributing Reporter Sean Cole. This episode was fact-checked by Annika Robbins, mixing and sound design by Brendan Baker. Our music is by Matt McGinley. Evie Kwong runs our social media. Our partners at KCRW include Arnie Seipel, Tejla Jamera, Natalie Hill, and Jennifer Farrow.
00:27:31
Speaker 2: See you next week.