TRANSKRIBEERI 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:33.000
I was always, like, focused on the security aspect. Even though there was no such thing as cybersecurity 40 years ago, it was just something I always looked towards. It was what I always wanted to do. So when I was working through it and talking about how we can do security and securing our networks, and people just thought I was crazy. And even you talk to a million people in IT and you'd have very few people, you know, talking about cybersecurity.
2
00:00:33.000 --> 00:00:53.000
You're listening to PrOTect IT All, where Aaron Crow expands the conversation beyond just ot, delving into the interconnected worlds of IT and OT cybersecurity. Get ready for essential strategies and insights. Here's your host, Aaron Crow Awesome.
3
00:00:53.000 --> 00:01:15.000
Hey, thank everybody for joining me on another episode of PrOTect IT All podcast. If you're watching or even if you saw the title, you obviously know who I'm talking to today. So with all that, there may be some folks out there that don't know who you are, Mike. So please, first of all, thank you for being here. Second of all, why don't you introduce yourself, tell us who you are and a little bit about your background and how you got into this crazy thing called ot.
4
00:01:15.000 --> 00:03:34.000
Sure, yeah. No, thanks for having me back, Garrett. It's good to see you and get to catch up. So, yeah, I'm Mike Holcomb. I really focus on helping people learn about OT and IC cybersecurity. So it's really about whether it's people like myself, coming from an IT cybersecurity background that want to get into the world of protecting critical infrastructure, or if it's working with engineers and PLC techs and other folks that are already in the plants today running operations on a daily basis, but they want to understand, well, how do I secure these things from cyber attack or folks that lead programs. And they're either just getting started and that doesn't. I mean, that could be a really large environment, very small environment, everything in between, and then those that have a program, but they just kind of feel like they're stuck maybe, and they need to get unstuck and know where to go next, where it makes sense for them. So focus on a lot, I guess, when you look at it that way, but it's really about helping people just learn more in OT and ICS cybersecurity, kind of no matter where they come from or what they're doing to today. And then I have a small boutique shop, which pretty much me, myself and I. Where I try to do, you know, some field work, you know, at least each Month and, and I do different speaking engagements and of course build training and do some private training for, for companies and entities. I was just actually out in LA where I got to work with like 50 of, you know, some of the largest water districts in California and, and, and some of the smaller ones as, as well and started working with some of those folks as well, so which is really exciting because water was just not one of those. Probably about the only sector I didn't get to work in that much in my last role because we did everything in engineering, but my only water was limited to, you know, what you see in power plants or data centers and you know, not dedicated like water treatment and wastewater facilities. So I was really excited to have that opportunity. So.
5
00:03:34.000 --> 00:03:35.000
That's awesome.
6
00:03:35.000 --> 00:03:41.000
Yeah, that's, yeah, it's a little bit about me and I do stuff on LinkedIn and YouTube, so.
7
00:03:41.000 --> 00:05:06.000
Well, the funny thing is, is, you know, as, as I get people reaching out and, and hey, how do I get into cybersecurity? How do I get into ot? How do I learn and from all those, you know, kind of avatars that you just mentioned earlier. You know, I, I, I brag about the OT industry and, and, and it's fairly small, but there's a lot of folks that love to help and you're one of the people I point them at as, hey, go check out Mike. He's got, follow him on LinkedIn. Look at his YouTube, look at the training things that he's posting. Like that's, that's so critical. It's the same reason why I do this podcast, right? Like I'm, I want to get the knowledge out there. I think we both see this from a, a value add to, you know, what's good for the, the goose is good for the gander. However you want to say that, right? I want my electricity to work and, and I know that we need more and more people in, in the industry to, to protect the, the critical things, our electricity. And we just don't have enough training and knowledge transfer going on in the OT side of the world. And there's so many of us that are also going to be retiring. You know, people that have been in the industry for 30, 40 years of OT before they called it that. But there isn't this, there's not enough on, you know, in people coming into the industry to, to be able to take all the, the hats from the old timers that are, they're going to be leaving in the next five, 10, 15 years.
8
00:05:06.000 --> 00:06:26.000
Yeah, absolutely. And one of the things I learned this is working in my last company, which one of the world's largest engineering construction companies was. We had 4,000 electrical and control system engineers. Right. And if talking with, I mean, I didn't work with every single one, but the majority in some way, shape or form. Most went through some of my courses internally that we had done. And there were probably less than 10 that really, really were passionate about OT or ICS cybersecurity, at least I was aware of. You know, we had a really strong, you know, we had, you know, over 30 folks on the IT cyber security team. And you know, there was one person on that team passionate about OT ICS cyber security, and that was me. Right. And that was how I was able to make that, make that transition. And so, yeah, there's just not a lot of folks out there that are really interested or passionate or
Load full transcript
believe in the mission. And, and so it's. And we need people from, from both of those kind of backgrounds and coming together and working together to, to protect power and water and make sure we have food that's safe to eat on the, on the table because yeah, it's, it's few and far people come into OT cyber, even though it's something that we all rely on every single day of our, our lives.
9
00:06:26.000 --> 00:07:07.000
Yeah, well, it's, it's an interesting problem that we have. And I know we don't necessarily know the answers to these things, but interested to get your take on why do that is like, why do you think there's not more people that are interested, more people that are aware? I mean, we go to these conferences like RSA, obviously, S4, everybody knows about OT, but you go to RSA, you go to Black Hat. And so many people have maybe heard of ot, they really can't define it. They really don't really have a grasp of exactly what IT is and they really have no real desire because everybody's going towards this, the it, the AI, the cloud, all that kind of stuff. And there's just not this big like banner or billboard saying, hey, come over here. We need help here too.
10
00:07:07.000 --> 00:10:57.000
Right, right. And for me, so I come from an IT cybersecurity background. Since I was a little kid, all I wanted to do was something with computers. And I grew up with a kind of typical hacker kitty. And so I was always like, focused on the security aspect. Even though there was no such thing as cybersecurity 40 years ago, it was just something I always looked towards. It was what I always wanted to do. So when I was working through IT and talking about how we can do security and securing our networks and people just thought I was crazy, you know, and even, you know, you talk to a million people in IT and you'd have very few people, you know, talking about cybersecurity. And it took, right. It was not only years, but it was decades, right, for a lot of bad things to happen before people really started to take advantage of, you know, pay attention. And even then, right. There's still a lot of people that work in IT that want nothing to do with cybersecurity. But then you also have those that say, hey, I believe in the mission. I want to protect our environments. I want to keep, you know, I want to keep the bad people out. I want to make sure our information and our systems, right, stay safe and they're up and running. And you know, like, for me, as a big, I want to make sure nobody loses their job. Because if our company got hit, right. Could the company afford that? Right. Most small, medium sized businesses, they'll fold their doors in like six months, you know, after just a typical ransomware attack. And that's, I would never want to see that. So it just takes, you know, different mindset, you know, and, and then there were some people that they just got into cyber because they wanted to make more money. And it's like, you know what? Okay, you know, if you can do the job, more power to you. But of course, the landscape is very different these days and, and right. The market is flooded. And so it really is for the people that really believe in the message mission and they' to stick to it. And then you only amplify that a million times for, for ot and that it's still one of those, it's a. Some, you know, it's a niche within a niche. It's a niche within a niche within a niche within a niche. Right. You know, it's, you really have to be, you know, believe in the mission wholeheartedly. There's, you know, you're going to probably be making less money than your IT counterparts. You're going to probably have more stress more than likely than your IT counterparts. You're probably going to have to work site most of the time, unlike a lot of your IT counterparts. Right. So there's just a lot of, when you look at it from that perspective, I'm not trying to dissuade anybody. We should be talking about all the great things. But it really is the people that come to OT Security really want to believe in the mission and protecting critical infrastructure. Right. Making sure. That our families, our friends, our communities, they have, you know, the services that they use every second of every day in their, their lives, you know, and that's really, I think, a big part of why it comes down to me. It doesn't matter where you live. Right. I mean, we're in the US but you could be in the middle of China or the middle of Russia. Right. Or, or Iraq. Right. And we always think of these as, you know, at least for like Americans. Right. Our immortal enemies. But yeah, at the end of the day, we're all people and we just want to take care of our families. And you see the struggle you everywhere, you know, across the globe, which is why I really appreciate LinkedIn and YouTube being global platforms and you can, you know, reach, you know, so many people around the world because, yeah, we're just trying to take care of our family, you know.
11
00:10:57.000 --> 00:11:26.000
Well, and, and ot problems here are the same as very similar as they are everywhere. Right. You know, I think you've been on it. I, I've been on the ICS Arabia podcast and you know, that obviously that's for, you know, the Middle east and, and, but power plants, a power plant, it doesn't matter if it's sitting in Texas or if it's in Japan. Yes, maybe there's some differences, but it's still the basic principles. I'm going to heat up some, some water, make some steam, turn a turbine, turn a generator and that's, that's power plant, right?
12
00:11:26.000 --> 00:12:29.000
Yeah. Great. Electricity. Yeah. It's always funny and I've heard this joke multiple times and I have, you know, I still have clients with, with plants all around the the world and you know, when you talk with the, you know, or may like the cso, he'll say, yeah, when we're in the United States and our plants, right. Our number one job is always keeping the Chinese out of our plants.
Of course, you go to our China plants and our number one job is keeping the Americans out of the plants. Right, right. You know, everybody does it. It's, you know, of course we always want to draw that line between you're targeting critical infrastructure, you know, that especially that would impact anybody in the, in the public. So which of course that brings up a whole other discussion these days. But, but you know, whether it's cyber or, or kinetic warfare, right. No, nobody should touch critical infrastructure, period. The end. Even just watching, you know, the Russians bomb, you know, power infrastructure in the Ukraine continually, especially in the middle of winter with sub zero temperatures that just, I, you know, it's hard to justify any of that.
13
00:12:29.000 --> 00:13:15.000
Yeah, it's bad. Yeah, I know it's. And, and to your point, though, right, and we see that. I mean, the analogy I always give is, is, you know, in the States we have hurricanes that come through. And. And when Katrina came through New Orleans, like it was a third world country within a few days, right? Because there was no power, no water, no electricity, no nothing. Right. And. And all of a sudden, and you've got, you know, people going door to door because they don't have any electricity, they don't have any food. Like, you can't pump gas. Like, everything stops like just like that. And how quickly we go to. My fridge doesn't work now. The food in my fridge is bad now. I don't have anything to eat. I can't. I don't have a can opener that I can use because my can opener is electric. And I don't have any backup to run that. Like, I can't get. I can't do anything.
14
00:13:15.000 --> 00:15:04.000
Yeah, yeah. And then what do you. What do you do? Yeah, we had. The hurricane came through here in Greenville, South Carolina, which we normally, you know, it's like one of those ones in the generation type things. And we were actually out of town. My girlfriend and I were out of town. So we came back after like two days. And it was. Our apartment had. Had power. But where. The house I have, where my daughters live, right, they're all adults, but they didn't have power for 10 days. And where my mom was, right, they didn't have power for 10 days. And it looked like, you know, those first four or five, six days, right? Everybody's barbecuing to take up all the frozen food in the freezer. And everybody's having gay all time. And then it's, you know, they come down to, I don't know, day seven, day eight, day nine, you know, it's. It was stretching, I think, people's tolerance and patience and kind of their goodwill more than a little, you know, probably two weeks. You know, it's more. And you start, you know, to see the breakdown in society. So we're lucky that it came back on 10 days. But those are the questions that we ask, you know, in OT and ics. Cyber is, you know, what would happen if a cyber attack brought down even part of the grid or the entire grid? And how would you
even start to bring it back up? Because there is no coordinated team that's responsible for that. We've seen kind of how these types of situations can have Impact. And then of course, we don't have to look very far across other places on the planet where there's real suffering because these critical infrastructure there just doesn't exist the next day.
15
00:15:04.000 --> 00:15:05.000
Right?
16
00:15:05.000 --> 00:15:08.000
Yeah, yeah. Heartbreaking it is.
17
00:15:08.000 --> 00:15:53.000
So as you start seeing, you know, you, you're fortunate enough to be able to go and, and do these, these conferences and train folks and have people come to B sides and, and everything in between, like, what do you see as the, as the hurdles to get over? Whether it be training somebody that's been in the industry, like you said earlier in the IT space, or maybe they were operations, they were a understand the ot, the cyber side of those things, or hey, I'm new in the industry and I want to get into this, like, what are, what are those things that we can start fast tracking and making people have the knowledge and skill sets that we need to start filling some of these voids that we have on the enterprise side, but also helping people to understand, like, what is the path? How do I go? What is step A through Z to get me from where I am to where I'm trying to get to?
18
00:15:53.000 --> 00:16:06.000
Yeah, for sure. You know, there's just common themes that you see year after year. I'm sure you, you see them, you know, all the time. It's, you know, there's still a lack of awareness and education for leadership.
19
00:16:06.000 --> 00:16:07.000
Right?
20
00:16:07.000 --> 00:22:21.000
There's still so many environments out there that still don't realize they need to do something about cybersecurity and their plans. It's like, wait, that's everybody, right? That's, that's where you make your money. You, you, you probably would want to protect those and say, well, they, you know, we don't have those types of attacks in that we do now. Colonial Pipeline, you know, for almost five years ago, really changed a lot because every type of attacker out there, OT is a thing and right. They're either going to want to impact ot, right, the plant network or the IT network it's connected to that could also still have an impact on, on, on ot. So there's that lack of, you know, awareness and education. If the leaders in the management team, they don't realize there's an issue, right. How are you ever going to get support? You're not, you're not, you know, and I've been there and done that. And then of course, for the people that want to be able to do the job and learn more, to get the skills and the knowledge, then it's a matter of getting the education. And that's one of the reasons why I started posting on LinkedIn and YouTube and it's mostly interesting because of folks at Sans like Rob Lee and Tim Conway in conversations with them that I then started doing LinkedIn and, and YouTube because, you know, to get the information out. Because, you know, all the folks at Sans are great, right? They're great classes, they're great people. You can learn so much. But they're also very expensive and not everybody, right? Most people don't have, you know, 10,000 to take a class and an exam. They just don't. And so I've been very fortunate to be able to go through all of those and same thing with the ISA courses for 62443. But they, they're not as expensive as Sans and they're good classes, they have good content, but they're, you know, there's still what, six, seven thousand dollars to take all four classes that you have to take before you take the exams and, and that the, the knowledge isn't getting out there. So yeah, I, you know, so that was kind of, you know, my first foray into. I just wanted to create, you know, when I started my. Right. My first class was, hey, this is the class I wish I had like before I went to the sans because I was so fr. Right trying to talk with people and learn about OT and ics, cybersecurity. We didn't talk about OT right back then, but you know, we had ICS or, or, you know, I got from engineering company so it was control systems. They were, they always were like, what's OT or what's ICS or control systems. Sorry. Then they're like, oh, okay. Or IACs, right? They get, you know, so, so yeah, it's really about just those fundamentals and keeping it, you know, just practical and simple. The best thing about the GRID class I remember because Rob just takes, you know, he's very good at taking very complex, complicated topics and breaking them down into very simple terms that, that anybody can understand. And you leave that class realizing, wow, this, this isn't as hard as I thought about. It's actually pretty darn straightforward. These are very complex and complicated environments we're protecting, but protecting them from cyber attack doesn't, it doesn't have to be complex or complicated. And so I just focus on the fundamentals. I always talk about my big five controls is the basic approach. So I do backup and recovery. So it's not preventative, but every environment, just like in it, it's going to get hit. So you need to be Able to restore as quickly as possible. Right. Do you have the right firmware file? Do you have the PLC logic backed up? Can you restore that system in a timely manner? Right, so backup and recovery then. I do asset management because no, it's not fun and sexy to talk about, right? But at the end of the day, it feeds so much, especially in OT cyber, because we're not doing things like actively scanning for vulnerabilities. Right. But we can query, we have firmware versions to determine, hey, are there any vulnerabilities in this system or not? Right. Or if you bring in like a Mandian or a Dragos to help you with incident response, if you're having some type of significant incident, right. The first thing they're going to ask for is your asset register. And if you don't have
that, you're going to have to sit there and explain to them the environment, which takes hours or days and that's time you need for response. So yeah, then we'll get into the secure network architecture. Everything from having that firewall between IT and OT and further segmentation and other controls and within the OT network, right. Slow down the attacker or complete. Keep them out completely. Right. And then when we look at incident response planning, which is a big, I think a lot of companies get a big F in incident response and it's just not doing tabletops. But most organizations, if they took the time, even it's like five minutes a week just to look at what's going on in the outside world and saying, hey, oh, this happened over here. Could this happen to us? And if so, what can we do to protect ourselves? And if they did that, they would be so much better off. But there's so many cases where a port or a pipeline or, you know, gets hit and it's like, well, yeah, this, the same thing happened to this other company like three months ago and it was all over the news, but you weren't paying attention apparently, you know, and, and so we would be so much better off. And then see for. I'm a big vulnerability management person, so continuous vulnerability management, just understanding what's in the environment. And of course OT is very different in how we do vulnerability management and it. But it's still, you know, we still have to understand what's. Meet with the right people, like engineers and people in operations to understand, hey, is this something we need to do something about or, or not, right? And it's still weird saying like, oh, we have this really bad vulnerability, but we're not going to do anything about it still, still cringe a little bit even though I've been doing this for almost 15 years at this point.
21
00:22:21.000 --> 00:23:11.000
So yeah, I remember having it going to a site, doing an assessment and they're being stuck snap in the environment. And I, and we made a decision that it wasn't a risk because there was no Siemens equipment on site. So yes, it existed in the world but there was no way that it could actually, the payload could impact anything. Now we knew we were going to change it eventually, but we were going to wait till an outage and we, we'd fix that thing. Like we'd bring the vendor and all that kind of stuff. But it's just weird to say I left stuxnet in an OT environment and didn't do anything about it day one. I mean I did something about it, but it wasn't like stop the plant. Like we're, you know, bring in the, the, the, the black helicopters and helicopter in and all the things because it just, you know, it's really getting to understand what the risk is and, and exactly.
22
00:23:11.000 --> 00:23:21.000
Yeah. If, yeah, if it's not going to impact safety, if it's not going to impact operations, well, I really don't care. You know, it's weird still to say that. It's true.
23
00:23:21.000 --> 00:25:11.000
It is. Well. And you know, a couple other things you hit on I want to double down on. Like I remember being an asset owner, so you know, I came from, you know, I've been in technology for 30 years, but half my career has been spent in OT. You know, the operation side critical infrastructure, whatever you want to call it, way before we called it ot, it was not that. Right. But I was, I was working at a power plant, right. Or a power company and I, I had zero budget to go to a conference or take a training or do any of those types of things. Right. So the irony of the sans ten thousand dollar course or you know, and to your point, I know it's worth it, I know those things are value add. But you know, I built a team of six and I had to fight to get a budget for training and you know, all that kind of stuff. And it definitely wasn't going to be $10,000 per person. There's no way that would happen. But you know, maybe two or three thousand. So we went to you know, other like CH classes, certified ethical hacking classes and you know we go to you know, Schneider or Foxborough or Emerson or GE training and different things like that and go to Black Hat and some of those other places. But you know, it Was just a matter of of there was no way I could send my team. We just didn't have the budget for those things. And the space I'm at and I'm my group was probably the ones that should have been doing those things that should have been in those classes because we were frontline doing those things and had. And again a lot of this is before any dragons didn't exist when I'm starting this conversation, right. That none of those OT products even existed so there wasn't an S4. But even that just, just going in and getting those next level training so that we can stay on the leading edge of constant continuing improvement and, and all that kind of stuff is what we should be thinking about from, from all of these things, whether you're IT or ot, right?
24
00:25:11.000 --> 00:25:41.000
Yeah, absolutely. Yeah it. Yeah. I've just seen a lot of organizations and, and they'll put a lot of training into it. Cyber security sometimes but there's very little that goes to, to the OT. Just like in general, right. With you know, 95% of security budgets go to it and you might be lucky and have 5% go over to OT and, and that's changing slightly, but we still have a long, long way to go. Yeah, for sure.
25
00:25:41.000 --> 00:26:32.000
Well the irony of that is, is, you know, when I was doing this and again this is before OT existed when I first started this track of OT cyber security stuff that became OT cyber security stuff, you know, we didn't have budget, right. So I was going to the plant saying hey, this new outage you're doing control system upgrade with you know, blah blah blah blah blah. We I have to add $300,000 to do this cyber security stuff. And you're going to have to take that out of Bowler feed pump maintenance or whatever the thing is that you're doing. But when
I was able to tie those things. So a lot of the things in your critical, you know, controls that you just talked about, right. A lot of those things help the business. Even if you don't align it to cyber by having a recovery, it doesn't have to be a cyber incident that brings them down. If they have a fox higher and they need to be able to recover that back, recovery helps.
26
00:26:32.000 --> 00:27:24.000
Equipment goes on the fritz, right? I mean it's electrical equipment stuff happens, correct? Yeah, for sure. Yeah. And I try to position any. Pretty much just about anything we do for security in the OT world. It's all about operations first. I'm going to help you keep up the plant. Right. You think we can deploy Network security monitor and you're going to find 99.999% of the time you're finding operational issues, you're not finding an attacker in the environment. So yeah, let's help you keep the plan up and running, keep everybody safe. And oh yeah, by the way, we do get cybersecurity out of it, but honestly it's not, it's not the main focus and like you mentioned, yeah, all of those controls, it's really about ensuring safety, keep the plant up and running and oh yeah, by the way, way it helps us stay secure.
27
00:27:24.000 --> 00:28:50.000
Correct. Well, and the funny thing is, is one of the first plants we turned on, we did this massive architecture and we're doing spans on every switch and east, west and we're, we're capturing every packet, we're splunk and we got four scout knack environments and all the things that are going on. We spin it up in the first power plant and we're monitoring as soon as it comes up the first log. We're like watching the logs. It's like all of us sitting around this, like this little screen that came up is there. There was a switch that was part of the control system and it was a redundant everything. Redundant. You know, it was a, I think it was a Fox Pro control system had redundant switches all up and down the whole stack. Everything was multiple redundancies and one switch of the core switches was not. And it was the backup. So the primary it was running no problems. But the backup, which was their redundancy was offline and nobody knew it. So we started and it was, it was screaming logs that it had a problem. We walked over to the switch and there was a zip tie stuck in the fan. So it was overheating. So we removed the zip tie and the, and the switch spun back up. Right. And it was like, oh my God, we just solved an operational problem with all these tools that we brought in and it was a stupid problem, but nobody had noticed it. Who knows how long that zip tie had been sitting there because somebody was doing something else in the cabinet and it just happened to fall into the fan of the, of the switch and it was overheating.
28
00:28:50.000 --> 00:29:50.000
Yeah, we had one instance, yeah where it was a PLC was starting to, to overheat because it was in a cab that the Vince were all clogged with dust.
And so eventually, you know, five, ten years goes by and the only way they actually caught it was yeah, with the monitoring platform and you know where you would normally have the HMI query the PLC like once every. I was like 30 seconds. And then all of a sudden it was, it was, was checking every second and it's like, well, let's do what's going on. It's like, well, it was programmed that if the PLC starts to overheat, then it would start querying every second. So apparently somebody missed the whole. I need to program an alarm for when the PLC is overheating. Right. To let an operator know that, hey, they need to come check on this. Right. Clean out the vents. But yeah, for sure. We find those operational issues that could result in downtime, safety issues, and yeah, get those fixed. And oh, by the way, yeah, we get security out of this.
29
00:29:50.000 --> 00:30:39.000
It's kind of a byproduct. And it's all about the messaging that we do as we go forth as security practitioners, as we go to the plant managers or, or whomever it is that has the budget, whether it's the CEO, the CISO or the plant manager, or the operations folks. It's all around messaging and understand, making sure they understand what we're trying to come forth. Because, because we can put on the lens of, or the hat of the cyber security guy or the hat of the, the financial guy. How can it, how can it make it more efficient? What can we, how can we help with downtime? How can we help with safety? How can we help with, like, what is the thing that the person that's sitting across from you cares about and how is the things that we're bringing. How can we, how can the things that we're talking about, things they care about? Because if you talk about things they don't care about, it's in one ear and out the other. Like, yeah, it doesn't help me whatsoever. Right. So it's really.
30
00:30:39.000 --> 00:30:40.000
Right.
31
00:30:40.000 --> 00:30:45.000
Understand being intelligent enough to know what the things they care about are or just freaking ask them.
32
00:30:45.000 --> 00:31:34.000
Yeah, yeah, yeah. And it really comes down to. Yeah. Keeping plants up and running, keeping, you know, people safe and, and ultimately. And one of the things that I think was new to me in OT was so many owners, you know, are really focused on ensuring the trust of their customers. You know, if I have power, yeah, I don't want a bad name because we have blackouts, you know, every six months. Right. Or I, you know, if I'm a water provider that, you know, I, I don't want to have a bad name by, you know, having, you know, water outages or, you know, dirty, dirty water going out to, to clients, those or customers, you know, that type of thing. And it you know, didn't really have that necessary. You have that. Yes, in the IT world but it's very, it's just very different in ot. For sure. Yeah.
33
00:31:34.000 --> 00:32:05.000
So, so talk to me about I. The. The B sides. How. How did B sides ICS come about? And, and it goes along this, this kind of path. That thing of. Of you giving back, you reaching out and again, I wish something like that existed. When I was starting out in OT cyber and I didn't have budget to go to sans and, and I was looking for a place for my team. Like I understood it more but some of my team had, they came from IT or they came from operations and they had zero, zero coverage of any of this type of stuff and didn't know how A plus B equals C. Right?
34
00:32:05.000 --> 00:35:22.000
Yeah, for sure, for sure. And that's why I've always loved B sites, you know, B sites for those aren't aware. It's. It's a. Basically it started as an IT cyber security conference and really didn't even start as a conference. It was a bunch of folks that they got denied at Black Hat or defcon which are the, the largest hack. You know DEFCON is the largest hacker conference in the world in Vegas every August and right before that now they have Black Hat which is more the professional vendor. Vendor. Vendor side and sales guy and Right. And so you had a bunch of folks that were pretty big and you know in, in the community at the time said hey I got denied. This sucks but I really, I'm excited. I really still want to talk about this stuff. So bunch got together at a bar pretty much across the street from from defcon and, and that was the first B sites just hanging out and, and talking about what they wanted to talk about. And so it's just grown up to where I think last year they had like 140 it b size events around the world which is just amazing. I started the one here in Greenville. Yeah I started the one here in Greenville like nine years ago. So. And I just had to step down last year because of besides ICS really taking off and so yeah, we started the first one not this year but last year, so 2025 and it was really, it started in fact I told this story at S4 in front of front of Dale Peterson that runs S4 on the unsolicited stage because you know, I had submitted for a couple years to go to S4 and I kept getting rejected and then one day it just clicked. I'm like, you know what? You know defcon Start or B side started, you know, out of defcon because of, you know, rejected papers. And. And I was like, and we don't really have anything like this for ics. And I was like, why. Why don't we. And so the first person I pinged was Rob Lee. And he's like, yeah, f. Yeah, you know, everybody knows. Yeah, right? He's like, yeah, you have to do this. You know, he's like, we'll be there. We'll help you with whatever you need. Right? And I was like, awesome. And, you know, I talked to, like, one or two others, and they were like, yes, you have to do this. I only met one person that. That was kind of like, because they were worried, I think, about what Dale was going to think. And because we started, we have B size the day before S4. And like, you mentioned, like, S4 is. Is a great conference, right, but it's like $2100 or whatever it is to go. And not
everybody has. Has that type of, you know, money. We, you know, our tickets are 40, you know, dollars, you know, and it's half if you're a student or active military, but veteran, you know. And we put. Because of our sponsors, we're very lucky. I think we put like, $130 per person into the conference this year. Right. All the money goes into the. Into the conference. And. And so it was just really amazing. We had a, you know, another great lineup. You know, last year we had 200 people based. Little over 200. We had, like, 120 on the wait list. This year, we had over 400 people signed, lined up. I think we had a little bit over probably 300 because of all the weather. Crazy mishaps. This year. It was like 50 degrees in Miami, which is a little crazy.
35
00:35:22.000 --> 00:35:24.000
We were outside.
36
00:35:24.000 --> 00:35:57.000
Yeah. Yeah. People were too happy with that. So I'm sorry. I mean, it's like, can't control the weather. Yeah. But, yeah, we, yeah, started it last year, I think, and, you know, it's just. It's grown. I'm going to England next week. We have our first international one in Bristol. So the. Yeah, the ncse, I think, you know, the kind of the UK version of CISA had seen what we had done, and they had contacts at the University of Bristol and were like, hey, look what the Americans did. You have to do one of those.
37
00:35:57.000 --> 00:35:58.000
So.
38
00:35:58.000 --> 00:36:32.000
And then Bruce Large is spinning one up in Australia called BSides ICS down under. So that's really cool. And we have one in Singapore in October, and then there's Folks looking at like, Belgium, Mexico City, Rio. You know, we talked with folks about some cities in, in India and a couple other countries, which is really, really, really exciting. So, so yeah, it'll be kind of cool to go there. Actually, it's this Friday, the one in Bristol, so I'm really excited.
39
00:36:32.000 --> 00:36:33.000
That's right.
40
00:36:32.000 --> 00:36:44.000
Go and, and see. And. And then, of course, yeah, my girlfriend, her best friend's in London, so. Right. That doesn'. So she's going to. Of course. So, yeah.
41
00:36:44.000 --> 00:37:14.000
But yeah, that's awesome, man. I mean, I love seeing the growth. I love seeing the passion. It's clear to see with you, but it's also like all the volunteers that are there, everybody that's there in general, the students that are there, just hungry to learn and grow and, and listen to the talks and, you know. Yeah, obviously there's some sponsors there, but even the sponsors that are there, like, I'm, you know, I'm there with ICS Village. I'm helping with you. Like, I'm. I don't care. I put on a shirt, registrations, and I was handing out the badges and like.
42
00:37:14.000 --> 00:37:32.000
Right. I was gonna say, yeah. I mean, there's folks like you, I think Sasha last year, Najo was there this year, Sam Ryder's been there. You know, Van Ryder's been there the last two years. And, you know, you're all, you know, everybody's just, always just put us in where you need us, coach where we need to be.
43
00:37:32.000 --> 00:37:33.000
You tell us where to go.
44
00:37:33.000 --> 00:37:40.000
Yeah, I always, like, feel bad and I'm like, I don't want to use you to abuse you. But everybody's like, no, use us and abuse.
45
00:37:40.000 --> 00:38:25.000
Absolutely. Well, again, I think it's, it's from what we talked about in the beginning of this conversation, like, as, as we see the big picture, I'm passionate about this. Like, I love ot. I think it's, it's hugely important. I feel it is a calling and I think it's vastly important on, on humankind to do this well across around the world and teach others to do this in a. In a safe and reliable and respectable way. Right. And, and things like this help that because again, as I said, like my, my team at, at the power utility, we didn't have budget even, even if I could to S4. Miami's expensive and the hotels are expensive and the food's expensive and the flights are expensive. Like, all those things just add up and that $2,000 ticket turns into $5,000 of expenses. It's just like, I don't know if I can afford that. Right.
46
00:38:25.000 --> 00:39:29.000
Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's. Yeah, it's one of those that a lot of folks face. And so that's why. Yeah. You have so many vendors there and you get some owners and operators and a few engineers, which is awesome. Yeah, it's. You're leaving so, so many people out. So that's why. Yeah. I really. B side is. B sides is much more approachable. Right. And we're not taking anybody away from, from S4. If anything, there's probably people coming to B sides today that, that will, you know, start going to S4 in the, in in the future. Yeah, there's, there's just so many people that, that again goes back to education and awareness. Right. And we need to, to get that out there and you know, it, it's just hard. Yeah. For you know, those folks that just don't have those resources. Yeah. They can't go to those conferences or they can't go to those, those trainings, you know, so. Well, you know, that's. Yeah. Why we have peace sides and, and that's why we have YouTube and LinkedIn. And so I, you know, we'll take advantage of all those as much, as much as possible to get the word out. For sure.
47
00:39:29.000 --> 00:39:54.000
Well, and it's also that, that chicken and egg conversation. Right. It's, it's the. How do you get into OT unless you're in ot? Like, it's that. I think you posted something the other day like OT is not an entry level position. It really isn't. Right. You really have to have understanding and all this type of stuff. But how do you get that experience Unless you've like, it's that, that, that roundabout of, of, of of how do I get into this space?
48
00:39:54.000 --> 00:42:20.000
Yeah, for sure. And I get it. I'm like, I've been there, right. And there's, there's, you know, folks that either come from OT or icr, you know, they're engineers or they work in operations.
Right. PLC techs and get into it. So they, you know, need to learn things like networking and the basics of cyber security and, and if you're coming like myself from cyber. Right. You have to learn what the heck a PLC is and, and an hmi and you know, what are all of these things and, and how physics actually works. You know, it's very, you know, it's very different. But yeah, you can't, you just can't jump in. I feel bad because like people reach out to me on LinkedIn every single day and they're very excited and they want to do it and they. I'm like, that's awesome. I just want to set expectations. And that was the reason for that post is like you, you know, you either need the IT and the IT cyber basics and then you can start to learn the engineering side or you need to be an engineer or kind of in the operations world and then start learning the IT and the cybersecurity basics and then those come together to then become, you know, to give you a firm foundation for OT cybersecurity. But there's no. Yeah, there's no shortcuts. You know, you can't go from high school to just being a doctor. You know, you have to go to med school and have to. It's. It's, you know, it's. And I wouldn't want anybody in a power plant, you know, that hadn't, you know, at least had right. The foundations, at least from both sides or you. Somebody at least looking over their shoulders and, and, and helping them along the path. So. And once one person like said, oh, well, you're just a gatekeeper and you don't want people. I'm like, wait a minute. I'm the last person to be called like a OTICS gatekeeper. I'm just trying to, you know, set, you know, again, realistic expectations because, you know, someone's like, yeah, it's also weird. I get a lot of parents that reach out for their, you know, oh, my son or my daughter wants to do this. I'm like, okay, they're probably old enough where they should be reaching out, right? So they're probably not really interested, but their parents are. But it's like, I'll humor you. Right? But it's like, yeah, it's. Again, it's not some. It just doesn't happen over overnight, you know, so it, it does take. Take, Take time. So again, just trying to set expectations.
49
00:42:20.000 --> 00:42:50.000
Well, and it's not something. And so much today is this way. But specifically ot, it's not something I can just even sans. So if, if I could afford a sans course and I could go take Rob's. Rob Sands course and, and Don sand course and whomever's. I could take three or four sans courses. Having those certifications is still pro. Probably not. Well, I know. But not probably. It is definitely not enough to probably land me a job in ot. Right. It's not a. I can go get a certification and check. I'm good now.
50
00:42:50.000 --> 00:44:54.000
Yeah. OT is not really a. It's not like it. Right. Where you can go well, get a certification and at least it would help you get a job. I mean it can help you. But I see a lot of times more people, especially like the engineers I used to work with or like myself, like when I had, when I went to get the ISA courses, it was because it was required by a client. It was one of the largest companies in the world, big gas company, oil and gas. And, and they wanted to see on paper that you have these qualifications to run things like, you know, 62443 risk assessments. So I was like, okay, you know, like, I'll go. That's how I ended up taking those, you know, so it's, I think it's. A lot of people take them. Yeah. At least if they're in the OT world, they take them to show expertise, to demonstrate because a client's requesting it more, more than anything, it's not going to help them get a job or a different role somewhere else. And it's same thing for other folks. Now I would say that it does help. Let's say if you're looking for kind of like that first entry level role in ot, it's like one of those things that shows, you know, it demonstrates, right. You have the passion, right. And then you win and you learn and you took the test where, where a lot of other people didn't do that. So like whether it's sans or isan, I'm really excited, you know, with Comptian, the SECO T plus exam coming out. It launches, you know, officially in November. The, the beta launches in early summer. So we're almost there and I'm really excited because, you know, that's a 450 exam that you can go and you know, you can self study. I'm actually helping Comptia write the, their official course that they do online. So I'm really excited about that because I, it's, it is, it's one of those. Because again, most people, I think they want those certs, but it's because they want to make that transition again. Whether they're coming from OT or IT and it cyber, they want to make that transition. They want something that shows, hey, I have a base level of knowledge.
51
00:44:54.000 --> 00:44:55.000
Yep.
52
00:44:55.000 --> 00:45:13.000
I might not have practical experience yet, but I'm just, hey, I'm just trying to get my foot in the door. And so it's like, hey, right here is a way you can do that at a much more affordable rate than, than these other, other options. So yeah, I'm really, really excited about it.
53
00:45:13.000 --> 00:45:29.000
That's awesome. So, so where all can people. I mean you, you kind of mentioned it before, but where all can people dive into your courses, go to a B sides, take your training, see you at conferences. What is that call to action for you, Mike? Obviously being, being at London this week.
54
00:45:29.000 --> 00:45:42.000
Yeah, I'll be in, I'll be in London through Friday and then we're going to Paris. So see him on the street, the tourist thing. So we've never been to Paris before. So I'm really excited.
55
00:45:42.000 --> 00:45:43.000
Yeah, that's cool.
56
00:45:43.000 --> 00:46:28.000
But yeah, so yeah, everything's@mikeholcom.com so there's pointers to everything whether it's LinkedIn. So feel free to reach out and connect. Of course, YouTube, you can
look for Mike Holcomb or, or Util Sec is the name of my company, which is the channel channel name right now and that's where you can find my course. I think I have four different full courses out there and I'm just about to relaunch. As soon as I'm back, the updated version of the Getting started OTICS cybersecurity course will start. So I'm really, really excited about that. So it's all. Because that original class is like 2 1/2 years old. So it's all very valid. But even the first, first parts were recorded with my like laptop microphone. Come, come, come a long way.
57
00:46:28.000 --> 00:46:30.000
Yeah, that's awesome.
58
00:46:30.000 --> 00:47:19.000
Yeah. So my girlfriend got me a really nice podcaster like for Chris for Christmas. Yeah. So, but yeah, so yeah, that's YouTube and then I have a newsletter so that's place to get the updates. But folks can sign up. You can see it on my LinkedIn profile. So those are all the places and feel free to reach out@mikeholcomb.com and I definitely respond to everybody on LinkedIn messages. Do back up a little bit because I spend about an hour a day responding to people is crazy and emails there. But yeah, that's where everybody can find me. But most of the resources are on mikeholcomb.com including all my infographics that I post on LinkedIn as well. They're just there in one place for everybody. Thanks to my girl. Sure.
59
00:47:19.000 --> 00:47:20.000
Good job to her.
60
00:47:20.000 --> 00:47:22.000
Yeah, exactly.
61
00:47:22.000 --> 00:48:45.000
Well, well, thanks man. I, man, it is, it is awesome to be. Be part of this organization or this group and OT and, and the larger community and, and, and I see the success and when folks come in and, and because of folks like you, because of your will willingness to respond to all Those people on LinkedIn, even the moms that are saying, hey, my son's interested like that. It, it just goes to show the type of person that you are and the type of community this is and how important it is to you that you're willing to spend that. And, and I appreciate that. And that's why, you know, I love this organization, this, this, you know, OT group and the larger community of ot because there's so many folks like you in this space. And I am appreciative. I'm very, very proud to, to be part of B side sides and, and handing out registrations or whatever and, and, and, and love, you know, just great to be connected with you and friend with you all the things. So thank you for your time and, and best of luck with all the B sides things and the training and all that is everybody, please definitely reach out to Mike. Take his trainings, reach out to him on LinkedIn, go see him, go to the B sides. Think about having to be sides in your city, your country or wherever. If, if there isn't one. Reach out to Mike. I'm sure he'd be happy to have a conversation if there's not already already one, or he'll connect you with the one that' and coming up in that space. Anything to close out Mike.
62
00:48:45.000 --> 00:48:52.000
Thanks, Aaron. It is good to see you and catch up. Thanks everybody. So. But definitely, yeah, reach out anytime. For sure.
63
00:48:52.000 --> 00:48:53.000
All right. Thanks, buddy. Appreciate it, man.
64
00:48:53.000 --> 00:49:17.000
Thanks for joining us on PrOTect IT All, where we explore the crossroads of IT and OT cybersecurity. Remember to subscribe wherever you get your podcasts to stay ahead in this ever evolving field. Until next time.