TRANSKRIBEERI 🔗
Serge Prengel (00:02)
So we're going to be talking about gentle presence.
John Amodeo (00:06)
Sounds good.
Serge Prengel (00:07)
And our intention is to not just talk about it, but embody what we're talking about and kind of sharing with people that experience.
John Amodeo (00:20)
Sounds good. I'm already noticing when I speak, I always get a little nervous. My stomach gets a little tight, contracted, like am I going to come across well and explain what gentle presence is and a way people can understand or not. I'm just noticing that inner sense of mild anxiety, not overwhelming, but just the gentle, just a little bit of nervousness.
Serge Prengel (00:40)
Yeah, yeah.
Yeah, thank you for sharing that. So in a way, we're normalizing how it's not that you have that quality or you don't, but there's a very human factor that we have skillful means to try and deal with.
John Amodeo (01:08)
Yeah, yeah, I mean, the path is to notice whatever we happen to be experiencing without judging it, without judging ourselves for whatever we happen to be feeling. So your general presence to me is making a space for whatever we happen to be noticing inside. may be moments we feel joyful and happy and at peace. Other moments we feel a little anxious or feel some shame or feel sad about something or afraid or fearful.
And whatever we experience, if we can learn how to meet it with general presence, it begins to shift or open up or reveal more of itself to us. And it's very subtle, quiet practice, but very powerful and very self-affirming.
Serge Prengel (01:45)
Yeah.
Yeah, yeah. And so I'm noticing myself that as we started talking a little bit, there is a little bit of the tension that's moving that, you know, and I in a way, I'm more aware of the tension as it's lifting a little bit than when I was when it was more tense.
And the lifting of it as that sense, I feel like some of my energy is about connecting with you. so shifting from in a way just being inside myself and in relation with my fears or my inner critic, but a little bit more toward.
you and toward what we're talking about. So more bandwidth for that than was that inner loop.
John Amodeo (02:45)
Beautiful. And you're saying that reminds me of what resonates for me is when I shared that I have a little bit of anxiety being here, it did begin to shift and release and open up, which enabled me to be more present, to be more here, just to acknowledge what I was noticing. I feel more at ease already, more at peace. feeling your presence too gives me some inner peace as well, because I...
Serge Prengel (03:02)
Yeah.
John Amodeo (03:11)
I feel that connection with you and that's also calming me.
Serge Prengel (03:15)
Yeah, yeah. And so I'm noticing that as you say that I notice I either because you're smiling a little bit or I'm perceiving it more of a smile. So in some way, maybe there was something that was there that I was not able to see or I'm seeing that. And so there is an impact. And that as I'm noticing
Load full transcript
that I'm feeling that my back is like my spine is straightening up ever so little, know, ever so slightly.
but so like a sense of some of the tension lifting with a sense of greater connection.
John Amodeo (03:48)
Beautiful. Noticing me taking a deeper breath, setting up a little more straight, hearing you share that.
Serge Prengel (03:54)
Yeah, yeah. And what feels very nice is that, you know, what you demonstrated is instead of first going into describing what it takes, you demonstrated sharing about, you know, the fears that happened there, a little bit of anxiety and so on. And only then afterwards did you go and you say, so gentle presence happens when we...
acknowledge what's happening, we kind of have a more of a welcoming to it instead of, you know, trying to hide it or and so you did it and that brings us to this place.
John Amodeo (04:33)
Beautiful. Yeah, it's really interesting to me because, you know, when I've been speaking the last number of years, it almost always goes well. And so I say to myself, well, you know, why be anxious about it? You know, it's going to go well. So when my head, my head says it's going to go well, don't worry. But my bodily sense of it, wait a minute, buddy. You don't know that for sure. It could go different. It could be different this time. It go south really fast. You might sound really dumb or something. My inner critic then kind of takes hold.
Serge Prengel (04:52)
you
John Amodeo (05:02)
So I just try to have some humility around it, just be open to the moment. It's okay to have anxiety. It's okay, even though it's probably gonna go well. Just notice the anxiety, just let it be there, just be with it in a gentle way. usually, as like now, it usually shifts and opens up and then I'm more present.
Serge Prengel (05:20)
Yeah, yeah, yeah. So making room for it instead of in a way running in parallel, you know, the sense I have is, okay, so I'm trying to deal with this and then deal with you and hiding that I'm dealing here and being here. And it's like, no, okay, here, come in. And so yes, the anxiety is here and or whatever other feeling and it's part of it. But as it's invited, it takes less room.
John Amodeo (05:39)
Hey.
Yeah, it's welcoming whatever we happen to be noticing. That's really the essence of gentle presence, that practice of noticing, being with what we're experiencing. And even if we're judging, criticizing ourselves, then notice that, you know, be with that. I'm criticizing myself, be curious about it. That's kind of the core of it too, be curious about what we're feeling inside.
Serge Prengel (06:07)
Yeah.
Yeah. And so that is an attitude that's very consistent with say the practice of meditation or other mindful practices like focusing. So do you want to maybe just talk a little bit about how that inspires your practice?
John Amodeo (06:24)
Yeah, I've been very steeped in mindfulness practice and focusing since like around just since like late 1970s. So I've been doing this stuff for
how many years is that like over 45 years now. So really, you know, I've
Studied learned for possible from Jack cornfield Joseph Goldstein when I was at Naropa Institute in 1974 and focusing shortly after that so when I was in graduate school and study with little bit with John well would mostly with Peter Campbell and Ed McMahon cops the priest psychologists and it's
Yeah, it's a lovely practice. I mean, I see focusing as a mindfulness practice, being mindful of our feelings, being mindful of our body, what we're noticing inside. And it's kind of aligned with the four foundations of mindfulness, mindfulness of body, mindfulness of feelings. Those are two parts of the four foundations of mindfulness. It was a very core practice in Buddhist practice and parallels so beautifully with focusing, which is also a practice of...
meeting whatever we happen to be experiencing in our body, kind of dropping down of our, getting out of our head and dropping down into our senses.
Serge Prengel (07:40)
Yeah. So
just to paraphrase what you're saying, the sense of shifting from your head to your senses, to your body, and being curious and welcoming of whatever emerges from there.
John Amodeo (07:54)
Back, you're curious and welcoming,
right? Right. Reminds me of Fritz Perl's famous saying, lose your mind and come to your senses. Although there's a place for the mind too. But a of us are in our heads more than we need to be. We're gonna control things, figure things out, understand them with our head, has limited value.
Serge Prengel (08:03)
Yeah.
Yes.
Yeah.
Yeah, but so I'm going to be the devil's advocate a little bit and say, yeah, usually when we talk to people who are not familiar with these kinds of practices, the comment that comes is, well, but how do I lose my mind or how do I shift from that? And so that sense of in a way, well, there's a secret that I don't know. And so I'm disempowered and disskilled. I don't know how to do that. And so what would you say to something like that?
John Amodeo (08:41)
Right,
yeah, that's a good point. First I'd say, you know, it's okay to be in our mind, you know, not to judge yourself for that. I try not to judge myself for not thinking, but asking ourselves, you know, is this a useful thought or is this kind of discursive thinking? I'm just kind of going in circles, going down a rabbit hole. It's not really productive. If so, just gently notice that. Be curious about that. maybe there's another way to be inside of myself other than just in that part of my mind that's...
repetitive thinking and unproductive. I would recommend take a breath. The body breathing is really a very powerful practice. Take a breath. I'll do that right now. Just maybe close your eyes for a moment and just it's okay to just be here in your body. Notice how you're feeling in your abdomen, your chest. Often in our head our body is like
constricted or tight in a way we're not even noticing. So just do a little bit of scanning. This is like a vipassana practice too, the gwenka toward scanning the body, noticing what's happening in the body. Is your stomach contracted, tight, gripping, holding your chest or your throat? And if so, it's fine. Just notice that and maybe it wants to soften as you be with that in a gentle way.
And just notice what happens.
Serge Prengel (10:03)
So I want
to paraphrase a little bit what you said just to kind of summarize. In the spirit of focusing, know, we're part of what we do in focusing is summarizing, echoing, resonating with what the other person says so that there is a sense of understanding.
And so I'm doing that and so John will have the possibility of saying, yeah, that's it. Or, you know what, you got some of it, but not quite. And so it's a way in which we can do that. And so John, what I appreciated is you were saying, okay, so if you are in your head,
and you're trying to do this and so the temptation is to try and figure it out from your head and what you're saying is instead engage in something that brings you in engagement with your body and so for instance the breathing is you're not performing it but you're engaging with the breathing and curious about what the experience of breathing is and following it.
John Amodeo (11:03)
Exactly.
Right, and there are two ways to do that. One is you increase the breath for a moment just to help bring your awareness to it. Take a few slow deep breaths, bring more mindfulness to the breathing process, or just simply notice your breathing exactly as it is without trying to change it. You can experiment. People can experiment with that. Just being with what you're noticing, not trying to change it, and noticing the abdomen rising and falling as you inhale and exhale.
and it could become a quiet rhythm that's very soothing, very calming.
Serge Prengel (11:37)
Yeah, yeah. And so again, I'm going to be playing devil's advocate. You know, the person who is not familiar with that and say, but if I do that, then, you know, like I'm totally moving away from the conversation. What will the person I'm talking to say? You know, am I? And so maybe how to reassure people that actually you can do that while being engaged in talking.
John Amodeo (12:01)
Right, excellent point. Yeah, so there are times maybe we're just by ourselves and we can just practice this on our own. And then the more challenging, maybe even more interesting part is practicing it when we're in relationship. So there's a process I learned in graduate school called toggling, where you take a moment and you just notice yourself. It's kind of like what Georgi referred to as self-remembering, or just mindfulness of your body.
So you just really come into your own process. Well, some say somebody's talking and that's sharing something with you. And in order to get present, you have to stay connected to your body. mean, the more you stay connected to your body and your being, the more you're to be able to listen in a good way. So you don't have to put all
your attention on them and kind of merge with them and lose yourself. That's what people often do. I've got to really listen here. I hear what it's trying to say. And that's, there's a strain. There's too much efforting in that. Just relax, come back into yourself. Take a breath. You'll be able to listen much better.
And so the toggling is noticing yourself, noticing your body. You're just relaxed. You have a relaxed presence. You're tensing. You're worried. Are you planning what you're going to say in response before you even hear what there's to say? Because you're nervous and you want to show how smart you are or something occurs to you and you're so eager to say it. So just notice all that and just be present with yourself. You'll get your turn. So it's toggling between being connected to yourself and then really being present with the other.
And there comes a point where you're simultaneously with yourself and present with the other, which is very powerful, interesting, expansive, opening, very beautiful field gets created between you and another as you begin with that general presence with yourself.
Serge Prengel (13:42)
Yeah, yeah. And so as you were talking, I was very consciously practicing breathing and paying attention to my breathing and of course noticing that I can do that and also hear you and listen to you, that I don't have to leave myself. Yes. And so what I'm inviting people to do as they listen,
John Amodeo (13:58)
Beautiful, yeah. That's a good demonstration.
Serge Prengel (14:06)
you know, to what we're saying, to take this as an opportunity to pay attention to their breathing. So you know, as you're listening, just practice this while John and I talk. And you pay attention to your breathing. And so notice. And it's possible that you just say, wow, that's wonderful. I can be present with myself and I don't lose them.
It's possible that you also notice, well, I'm kind of losing them because I'm kind of so caught up in trying to do my breathing that I lose them. And so it's okay when you realize that, maybe come back and pay a little bit more attention to what we're saying, but just in a way playing with the dosage.
John Amodeo (14:47)
Good, the deltas, I like that, exactly. Right, yeah, yeah, yeah, moderate it a bit. Yeah, it's interesting, I think people lose the connection with the other, not so much when they're breathing and in their body, but when they're in their head. People can, you know, listen to your own experience, see if that's true. And when I say in your head, I mean, like I said, planning your response or...
Maybe it triggers some feeling in you that you're not comfortable with. mean, this happens a lot if somebody's sharing a feeling, especially like in a partnership, if somebody's sharing feelings they're having about you, the complaints they have about you, the tendency is to get defensive or feel shame or argue, you know, that's not true or, you know, we just get kind of tightened up inside and, you know,
want to defend our position or we want to keep, so we're to be heard.
Serge Prengel (15:33)
Yeah.
John Amodeo (15:34)
You can just
relax, just hear them. you're in more, whether you're in your body, practicing self-soothing, just connected, you can just listen non-defensively. You know, what they have to say, maybe it resonates with you, maybe it doesn't. Maybe there's some piece of truth in what they're saying that you agree with or say, think you're right about that.
And you can say that without being defensive. Yeah, I could write about that. I didn't fix the force of like I said I would. I know I promised. I know I was late for the meeting for meeting you for lunch and really sorry. You don't have to be defensive. It's because I was late, you know, because I get stuck at work and all this happened. You know, all these defenses and all these reasons or excuses that don't fly really well with the other person. They just want to be heard, but they're a little disappointed and maybe a little tiff that we're late. Just listen.
I'm sorry, you know.
Serge Prengel (16:28)
Yeah,
yeah. So you're pointing out of one way in which we get sidetracked in conversation is, you know, that sense of feeling defensive. And so defensive is literally in a defense mode because we feel attacked. And so the point is that sense of noticing it. And
John Amodeo (16:47)
Right.
Serge Prengel (16:49)
You know, like if you're not noticing that you're being defensive, then you're going to continue there. Yeah.
John Amodeo (16:58)
Exactly.
Yeah, the beginning of wisdom is noticing that you're getting defensive. And that's a natural response, you know, because we go into fight-flight response really easily whenever there's a real or imagined sense of danger, a real or imagined threat to our sense of safety and well-being. We tend to go into the fight-flight-freeze or fawn mode as a defense. So...
That's what we're up against. That's how we're wired. You know, the brain has a negativity bias. We tend to look at the negative side of things. I want to be an attacker. This conversation isn't going to go well. They're going to abandon me or reject me. I was late or something.
Serge Prengel (17:33)
Yeah, yeah,
yeah, so.
John Amodeo (17:35)
I just noticed
that reactivity and it's okay. Just notice it, be with it. Okay, that's interesting. My amygdala just got activated. You know, that part of the brain that scans for danger. But maybe this is not a real dangerous situation. Maybe I'm overestimating the danger and underestimating my capacity to be with the situation.
Serge Prengel (17:57)
Yeah, So that sense of that defensiveness, it's not about, bad guy, I'm being defensive, but hey, I'm being defensive, I feel attacked, it's a normal reaction, it's a natural reaction, and coming to the place where there is a choice.
John Amodeo (18:13)
Right, there's a choice and there's a discernment too. You know, am I really being attacked or is this like an old pattern where even the slightest sense of displeasure on someone's part creates that reaction of danger like I'm going to be rejected. Old patterns, know, it's an old trigger because nobody wants to feel rejected. We want to belong. We want to connect. We want to feel accepted. We want to feel loved. So any hint of rejection, it triggers that fear. We don't want that, so we defend ourselves.
Serge Prengel (18:41)
Yeah.
John Amodeo (18:41)
Very natural, very
normal, but not very helpful usually.
Serge Prengel (18:46)
And so in a way, the turning point is realizing I am feeling defensive, I feel attacked. so not, you I shouldn't feel that way, but of course, of course, what else would I expect? You know, this is difficult and it's difficult to change that. And so simply staying in a way with, this is a difficult moment.
And how can I possibly try something different and see that I'm kind of safe? Maybe I'm safer than I thought I would be, you know.
John Amodeo (19:22)
Exactly. And some of that safety we just really need to find within our own being, like through gentle presence coming back in our body and self-regulating, because we be dysregulated so easily.
Serge Prengel (19:32)
Yeah.
And so
we come to one definition of gentle presence, which is really, not about trying to be something you're not, but trying to find a way to be safer. And as you feel safer, then it becomes more natural to be gentle.
John Amodeo (19:47)
Yeah.
Yeah, to feel safer, feel safer in ourselves. You know, this isn't necessarily the threat that we're making it out to be. And we can, I also distinguish between blame and responsibility. We can take responsibility if we were off in some way, you know, maybe we have a little bit of healthy shame around something that we did that was a little bit off.
promise not kept or whatever harsh words we use with somebody and upset them and they're telling us about it and we can take responsibility for that and simply say yeah I can see where I did that sorry but that's different than blaming ourselves we don't have to blame ourselves or sink into this toxic shame where we think we're an awful person really bad
Serge Prengel (20:36)
So maybe let's talk a little more about shame because that's a very, very intense emotion and we all go through it in some way or another. So maybe let's just like bring it a little bit more of how do we notice it, what's it like?
John Amodeo (20:52)
Yeah, it's kind of that really uncomfortable feeling that I'm flawed or defective or I'm going to lose connection with somebody. So say somebody has some issue with this, they're a little angry or they were hurt by something we said, they're complaining about something. Our initial reaction might be to be defensive and maybe even say, you you're attacking me, which is kind of an unhelpful kind of use statement.
which may or may not be true, you may be experiencing it or interpreting it as an attack, but maybe they're just trying to share their feelings. you know, attacked is kind of one of those
ED words. ED words are not exactly feelings, like I'm feeling attacked isn't quite a feeling. It's in their direction. Sorry.
Serge Prengel (21:30)
Yeah, like I feel like you're an idiot. When I say,
what do you feel? Well, I feel you're an idiot, you know, and not quite a spelling word. Yes.
John Amodeo (21:36)
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. I feel you're stupid.
So it's in the direction of a feeling. It's just like, I wouldn't totally just, in the direction of a feeling, say I'm feeling attacked or I'm feeling judged. But the feeling, if you pause and go a little deeper, it's probably something like, it could be shame. Like, oh, I feel, your comment, I'm feeling bad. Hearing that comment, I'm feeling like.
Like I did something wrong, I'm flawed in some way, I'm defective. Or maybe it brought up hurt or sadness or anger even. So then those are, more, then you can open to the felt sense of that. Like, yeah, that sense of shame for like I did something wrong.
And you can work with that. Just explore that a little bit, investigate it, inquire a little bit. Well, did I do something wrong? yeah. I did promise to be on time because I know I tend to be late and I wasn't. really sorry. It doesn't have to be a big deal. I am sorry I'm late. I feel bad about it.
Serge Prengel (22:30)
Yeah, so what
you're talking about is how the actual trigger is much smaller than probably where we go with it. Like shame feels like an all-encompassing feeling that's about your whole being is not worthy of existence, not worthy of love, not worthy of recognition. And actually what happened is something that's much smaller.
John Amodeo (22:52)
Exactly, right. This person is a little upset. It's not the end of the world. It's not that big a deal. Like your psyche is experiencing it. It's a really big deal. It's, you know, they're having a feeling about, I mean, it may be a big deal at times, but much of the time it's not that big a deal. They're just having a feeling. They just want to be heard. You know, we don't want to be heard. They just, people want their feelings heard. They displeasure heard. They're hurt. They're sad. They're sort of, they're experiencing. And if you can just be there and hear them, they'll probably calm down.
And then you can reconnect. You can be repaired by a simple apology. And then there's also a difference between healthy shame and toxic shame. A lot of times we sink into toxic shame. go like this.
Serge Prengel (23:30)
So let
me just stay with the, we'll go back to the toxic shame, but I wanna just kind of not stay slower on the notion of say, somebody says something and it feels bad, but in a way, if I know it feels bad, I'm already halfway there. But most of the time what happens is something's said and there's kind of a knee jerk reaction.
John Amodeo (23:47)
Yeah, beautiful.
Serge Prengel (23:54)
because it's so powerful and it's so unpleasant and it's so damaging that there is a sense of closing in to what the experience is and striking back.
John Amodeo (24:05)
Right, exactly. Yeah, well, you do that too, you You were like the other day yourself. Don't blame me. Something defensive like that. It's so tempting to want to say that. It kind of gratifying in the short run, but in the long run, it just creates more tension and dis-ease in the relationship.
Serge Prengel (24:09)
Right.
Maybe so that's good. you point out, you do this and my response at the time, well, you do that too and you're worse. But so maybe at that moment, you know, say you can't prevent from doing it, but you're feeling a sense of comfort in a way having said that. And so maybe that's a nice way to turn the turning point. Like, you know, from that place of relative strength of, know, I'm righteous. Go back to him.
Maybe I can be a little, if I'm feeling stronger, I can be a little more generous. Yeah.
John Amodeo (24:54)
I like that
word. Yeah, be more generous when you're listening. Give them the benefit of the doubt. Just really hear their feeling. And you don't have to let it land so painfully in you. It's their feelings, not about you.
Serge Prengel (24:57)
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah, yeah. So maybe it's like, you know, after the reaction is saying, well, you know, actually, I'm sorry, I kind of maybe overreacted, but let me hear more about what you have to say.
John Amodeo (25:16)
Yeah, yeah, yeah. And a great thing to even say if you catch it is, oh, wait a minute, I think I'm being a little defensive right now. When you say, oh, yeah, you do the same thing, or you notice the tendency to want to say it, but don't. But you can wait a second. Take pause. Pausing is so powerful. It's something in focusing that we all practice, too. Before reacting, pause so that you can respond instead of react.
Serge Prengel (25:43)
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. So definitely it's something that you probably can't go wrong with taking a pause, you know, and give yourself a chance to see where you are and maybe choose how you respond.
John Amodeo (25:59)
Exactly. Taking a pause is so powerful. You don't have to respond immediately. Just get more of a sense of what you're experiencing before you say anything.
Serge Prengel (26:08)
Yeah. So I'm wondering if actually one way to leave people with something to take away from this conversation might be to say that experiment with taking pauses. know, one gentle presence. You don't want to be so reactive to shame and defensiveness and so on, but just maybe train yourself to take pauses.
John Amodeo (26:29)
Train yourself to take pauses. I like that. Yeah. Even if you're pretty clear that you know what you want to say, pause before you say it. And then the way you say it might even be with a softer, more gentle tone, which then becomes more hearable. We all want to be heard, but how much energy do we put into speaking in a way where we're more likely to be heard? And if you can speak with more gentleness, kindness.
The other person is less likely to get defensive and more likely to really hear you and let in what you're It creates more intimacy, creates more connection, more intimacy, which is we're all learning.
Serge Prengel (27:00)
Yeah.
So I like what you added is that in addition to the description of what you do, you added and then you're going to be able to see that actually you can be heard more. So that sense of being able to pay attention to what happens because in a way if you notice that you're more effective, that you're heard more, that's going to encourage you to do that because you're not doing it just to be good, but you're doing it because it works better for you.
John Amodeo (27:34)
Right, you're doing it because you're being authentic, you're being kind, gentle with yourself, you're having loving kindness to yourself, and you're responding in a way where you're more likely to be heard and appreciated and respected, and it's more likely to create a positive synergy, positive flow, and more connection, which is what we're all deeply longing for, is intimacy, connection, being seen. So sometimes, you know, we shoot ourselves in the foot, we're our enemy because...
We don't know how or it's hard to practice. I mean, I always tell my psychotherapy clients, know, this is simple, but it's not easy.
Serge Prengel (28:11)
Yeah, yeah. So this feels like a good place to end. I just want to see if it feels right for you to do that. Yeah. Thanks, John.
John Amodeo (28:18)
There, sounds good. Yeah.
Welcome. Welcome.
Copyright 2026 ProactiveMindfulness.com. All rights reserved.