TRANSKRIBEERI 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:00.130 --> 00:00:02.169
The first video is, as you said, Jay, moving the
2
00:00:02.189 --> 00:00:05.830
goalposts was there is no evidence. We all responded and
3
00:00:05.889 --> 00:00:10.220
showed evidence. We had, we had Nestorians going online to respond.
4
00:00:10.240 --> 00:00:14.580
We had Oriental Orthodox, Eastern Orthodox Catholics responding, and he
5
00:00:14.619 --> 00:00:17.039
got hit hard. I mean, he showed multiple tweets. He
6
00:00:17.079 --> 00:00:21.199
showed multiple online comments that were coming in. He knew
7
00:00:21.260 --> 00:00:24.219
it was coming in hot. And so he had to
8
00:00:24.480 --> 00:00:28.670
either take the video down, which I encouraged him to do.
9
00:00:29.370 --> 00:00:32.090
In our response, I encouraged him to revise his statement
10
00:00:32.189 --> 00:00:34.979
and say something like, I don't see a lot of evidence.
11
00:00:35.020 --> 00:00:37.939
There's maybe some evidence, or I just don't think we're
12
00:00:37.979 --> 00:00:40.780
mandated in Scripture. So by the second video, that's exactly
13
00:00:40.799 --> 00:00:42.299
what he said. He ends up coming in the second
14
00:00:42.320 --> 00:00:45.560
video and saying, no, we don't have any authority from
15
00:00:45.619 --> 00:00:48.909
God to do this. It's like, wow, you really changed
16
00:00:49.609 --> 00:00:54.049
your tone by video two after everybody called you out
17
00:00:54.070 --> 00:00:59.509
and showed you patristic, scriptural evidence. Pseudo and Second Temple
18
00:00:59.549 --> 00:01:04.870
Judaism evidence. It's amazing how quickly that shifted. So what
19
00:01:04.890 --> 00:01:07.109
I want to do is I want to review this
20
00:01:07.170 --> 00:01:09.709
section here, and I'm going to pull the screen back
21
00:01:09.750 --> 00:01:11.510
up one more time to show the new video. This
22
00:01:11.549 --> 00:01:14.840
is the one that ends up coming into play. That
23
00:01:14.879 --> 00:01:17.840
was his response. And in his response, he said, if
24
00:01:17.879 --> 00:01:19.060
you think we're not going to play the whole thing,
25
00:01:19.099 --> 00:01:21.560
but specific clips that we're going to show, and we're
26
00:01:21.579 --> 00:01:22.879
going to see what Gavin says here.
27
00:01:23.099 --> 00:01:26.099
Should Christians pray to the saints in heaven to ask
28
00:01:26.120 --> 00:01:28.349
for their intercession? This is one of the most important
29
00:01:28.390 --> 00:01:31.709
dividing lines between Protestants and other Christians. In this video,
30
00:01:31.730 --> 00:01:34.290
I'm going to defend the Protestant position that God has
31
00:01:34.349 --> 00:01:37.530
not authorized this. So if you're interested in this topic.
32
00:01:37.670 --> 00:01:39.750
And by the way, I did a... I was on
33
00:01:39.769 --> 00:01:42.390
Cameron Bartuzzi's channel with Jimmy Akin responding to this. I've
34
00:01:42.409 --> 00:01:45.030
been on three responses. I think, Alex, you're on two
35
00:01:45.069
Load full transcript
--> 00:01:50.090
or three yourself. It's already a problem. It's already a
36
00:01:50.129 --> 00:01:54.849
problem when somebody says I'm defending the Protestant position. And
37
00:01:54.870 --> 00:01:56.530
I don't mean to cut him off here, but it's
38
00:01:56.670 --> 00:02:00.189
already a problem when you say I'm defending the Protestant position.
39
00:02:00.450 --> 00:02:04.750
I was in Anglicanism for almost three years. And the
40
00:02:04.790 --> 00:02:07.680
last year I was in Anglicanism, I was an Anglo-Catholic.
41
00:02:08.780 --> 00:02:13.560
And we asked intercession. We had saints, like the church
42
00:02:13.620 --> 00:02:17.460
is named after a saint. We asked intercession of that saint. So...
43
00:02:17.949 --> 00:02:20.430
In my mind, I was already going, well, wait a minute.
44
00:02:20.810 --> 00:02:24.509
Let's not act like all Protestants agree with a singular.
45
00:02:24.550 --> 00:02:29.009
There's no ecumenical Protestant council on the subject of intercession
46
00:02:29.050 --> 00:02:33.449
of the saints. There's Lutherans that subscribe to invocation. So
47
00:02:33.909 --> 00:02:36.210
when I hear somebody say that, I'm already throwing up
48
00:02:36.719 --> 00:02:41.280
a huge red flag saying, wait, you're defending the Protestant position?
49
00:02:41.300 --> 00:02:43.280
I don't even think that's a good way to go.
50
00:02:43.300 --> 00:02:43.919
What do you think, Jay?
51
00:02:44.370 --> 00:02:45.069
Yeah, it's exact.
52
00:02:45.150 --> 00:02:47.490
We've made the same critique of Gavin and his circles
53
00:02:47.610 --> 00:02:50.189
for a few years now because it gives the impression
54
00:02:50.250 --> 00:02:54.449
that there's this lowest common denominator Protestant position that's out
55
00:02:54.490 --> 00:02:56.389
there that they all agree. But you notice even within
56
00:02:56.449 --> 00:02:59.129
his opening statement, he has to try to walk the
57
00:02:59.189 --> 00:03:02.569
line of being an ecumenist by saying that other Christian groups,
58
00:03:02.590 --> 00:03:06.750
so he's identifying Catholics and Orthodox as Christians, but also
59
00:03:06.810 --> 00:03:11.039
that they're doing practices that are not explicitly mandated by Christ.
60
00:03:11.180 --> 00:03:13.680
But the problem here is that If we rewind to
61
00:03:13.699 --> 00:03:18.250
the Reformation beginnings, the Reformation would kill it. The reformers
62
00:03:18.289 --> 00:03:22.210
would drown people that disagreed over baptism. Luther had, you know,
63
00:03:22.229 --> 00:03:25.530
the Anabaptists drown. And so this idea that there is
64
00:03:25.689 --> 00:03:28.590
a common Protestant position on these basics is just simply
65
00:03:28.629 --> 00:03:31.300
not true. It's not true historically or in terms of
66
00:03:31.379 --> 00:03:32.719
modern ecumenism either.
67
00:03:33.770 --> 00:03:36.569
Yeah, we know Luther subscribed to at least a form
68
00:03:36.610 --> 00:03:39.960
of the rosary even early on. He abandoned it later,
69
00:03:40.039 --> 00:03:42.919
but I mean, he encouraged the prayers to the Blessed
70
00:03:42.960 --> 00:03:45.680
Virgin very, very early on in his conversion, even into
71
00:03:45.699 --> 00:03:49.580
the 1520s. So it's kind of surprising. There's still Lutherans.
72
00:03:49.639 --> 00:03:51.680
I have friends that are Lutherans that say, I don't
73
00:03:51.699 --> 00:03:53.439
agree with that. I don't like him speaking for me
74
00:03:53.479 --> 00:03:55.960
on that. I'm sure you feel the same way, Alex,
75
00:03:56.000 --> 00:03:59.120
when somebody says, and I'm careful like this, even as
76
00:03:59.159 --> 00:04:01.750
a Catholic, I'm careful about saying, well, the Catholics say,
77
00:04:01.770 --> 00:04:03.629
I mean, it's like, well, I mean, It depends what
78
00:04:03.650 --> 00:04:05.849
it is and depends what you're talking about, because Catholics
79
00:04:06.349 --> 00:04:08.849
have different opinions on stuff, too. And I'm not going
80
00:04:08.870 --> 00:04:11.740
to speak for all of Catholicism. I'm defending the unless
81
00:04:11.780 --> 00:04:15.080
it's something in the church's dogma where there's actually either
82
00:04:15.139 --> 00:04:18.519
an ecumenical council or it's it's been dogmatized by the church.
83
00:04:18.920 --> 00:04:20.660
I can't just get up and say I'm representing the
84
00:04:20.699 --> 00:04:23.250
Catholics position on such if the church has not been
85
00:04:24.230 --> 00:04:27.730
universally connected on it or even within Rome's own laws
86
00:04:27.810 --> 00:04:30.410
or canon laws objected to it. I can't do that.
87
00:04:30.470 --> 00:04:32.509
It's just a dangerous thing to do when you start saying,
88
00:04:32.670 --> 00:04:35.490
I'm going to represent the Protestant position because now you
89
00:04:35.509 --> 00:04:38.310
just turned yourself against other Protestants who don't share your thoughts.
90
00:04:38.379 --> 00:04:40.189
And why are you speaking for me? I don't understand this.
91
00:04:40.620 --> 00:04:42.379
I mean that your position, Alex, I mean, it's a little,
92
00:04:42.939 --> 00:04:45.220
little hard to come after and say, I'm representing. Oh,
93
00:04:45.300 --> 00:04:47.339
can you, Alex, can you even say that on most positions,
94
00:04:47.720 --> 00:04:50.100
the Protestant position is you fill in the blank. Is
95
00:04:50.120 --> 00:04:53.160
there actually a Protestant position on most things?
96
00:04:54.000 --> 00:04:57.560
I think for Protestantism, that's extremely difficult because Protestantism is
97
00:04:57.600 --> 00:05:00.839
not a church. It's a movement made up of 40,000
98
00:05:00.839 --> 00:05:04.259
different churches or like people complain about that number. Let's,
99
00:05:04.420 --> 00:05:06.839
you know, take 10% of that. Let's just say it's 4,000
100
00:05:06.839 --> 00:05:09.860
different churches. That's still an insane amount. Even if it's
101
00:05:09.860 --> 00:05:13.360
400 churches, that's still an
insane amount of churches, right?
102
00:05:13.399 --> 00:05:17.240
So there is no like Protestant position. You have the
103
00:05:17.300 --> 00:05:20.399
Lutheran position, the Calvinist position, and then a bunch of
104
00:05:20.439 --> 00:05:24.649
evangelical positions is what you have within Protestantism. I think
105
00:05:25.069 --> 00:05:27.589
for us, you know, for you as a Roman Catholic,
106
00:05:27.629 --> 00:05:29.699
for Jay and I as Orthodox Christians, you know, we,
107
00:05:30.399 --> 00:05:32.500
look at the tradition and we say, okay, these things
108
00:05:32.860 --> 00:05:35.779
are not a matter of opinion on these issues. You
109
00:05:35.800 --> 00:05:38.060
have to believe these things. And then there are other
110
00:05:38.120 --> 00:05:41.029
issues where there's like a range of permissible views. And I,
111
00:05:41.810 --> 00:05:43.670
you know, throughout looking at the views of the saints
112
00:05:43.750 --> 00:05:46.970
and whatnot on whatever topic it is. So I think that,
113
00:05:47.329 --> 00:05:50.110
you know, when we're talking about assurance, which is something
114
00:05:50.129 --> 00:05:52.829
that Gavin likes to talk about so much, you actually
115
00:05:52.889 --> 00:05:57.199
find it in, in my opinion, in the Orthodox Christian tradition.
116
00:05:57.420 --> 00:05:59.899
So it's awfully ironic for him.
117
00:06:00.939 --> 00:06:03.100
By the way, everybody's upset you're not wearing a hat,
118
00:06:03.160 --> 00:06:05.399
I guess, because you're not matching Jay and myself. I
119
00:06:05.420 --> 00:06:07.459
can do that. And the joke is you actually had
120
00:06:07.600 --> 00:06:09.019
one before we hit live.
121
00:06:09.040 --> 00:06:10.819
I did, yes.
122
00:06:10.870 --> 00:06:13.389
Not sure what's going on there. But I will say this.
123
00:06:13.829 --> 00:06:16.529
As we get into this, I see some Super Chats
124
00:06:16.550 --> 00:06:18.310
have come in. We will get to your Super Chats.
125
00:06:18.329 --> 00:06:20.449
We're not going to ignore them. Some of these are very,
126
00:06:20.589 --> 00:06:26.189
very relevant, particularly to the second and third point we're
127
00:06:26.209 --> 00:06:27.930
going to get into. So most of those are going
128
00:06:27.949 --> 00:06:29.920
to be relevant in a minute. So I will I'll
129
00:06:29.959 --> 00:06:32.180
tie your super chats into point two and three. So
130
00:06:32.220 --> 00:06:34.279
I'm not ignoring them. So if you want to keep
131
00:06:34.300 --> 00:06:36.579
sending them, that's totally fine. Just letting you know, I
132
00:06:36.800 --> 00:06:40.060
have not ignored what I'm seeing on the screen here.
133
00:06:40.230 --> 00:06:41.149
All right, let's continue.
134
00:06:42.810 --> 00:06:44.569
Watching to the end of this video will hopefully give
135
00:06:44.610 --> 00:06:46.990
you a one-stop shop on many of the kind of
136
00:06:47.110 --> 00:06:50.329
leading issues for and against and how they clash together
137
00:06:50.410 --> 00:06:52.829
just to try to represent the Protestant side. What I
138
00:06:52.850 --> 00:06:55.230
want to work through is four categories of evidence. Number
139
00:06:55.310 --> 00:06:58.790
one is praying to saints directly taught in scripture. Number two,
140
00:06:58.910 --> 00:07:03.439
is it a valid... theological inference. Number three, was praying
141
00:07:03.500 --> 00:07:07.240
to the righteous dead a practice in pre-Christian Judaism, especially
142
00:07:07.279 --> 00:07:11.089
the Second Temple period? And number four, when does praying
143
00:07:11.129 --> 00:07:12.829
to saints emerge in church history? And I want to
144
00:07:12.870 --> 00:07:15.069
defend my claim of it's not there for the first
145
00:07:15.069 --> 00:07:17.189
200 years. We'll look at the strongest counter-argument.
146
00:07:19.339 --> 00:07:21.100
So he repeated that point. I just want to leave
147
00:07:21.120 --> 00:07:22.560
that on the screen for everybody to see for just
148
00:07:22.579 --> 00:07:24.540
a minute. He repeated the point about the 200 because
149
00:07:24.699 --> 00:07:26.360
he's not going to back down on it. He's going
150
00:07:26.399 --> 00:07:29.220
to defend it. He's not going to back down on it.
151
00:07:29.220 --> 00:07:30.939
He's going to defend it. By the way, point three
152
00:07:30.980 --> 00:07:34.980
was not in the first video. Point three was added
153
00:07:35.399 --> 00:07:38.959
as a response to all of the responses to him
154
00:07:39.480 --> 00:07:43.420
from first Enoch. We also covered Tobit, Maccabees, which he
155
00:07:43.459 --> 00:07:46.180
did cover in the first video, but he kind of
156
00:07:46.199 --> 00:07:47.819
waved the hand at him, had to go in more depth.
157
00:07:48.569 --> 00:07:51.009
And then he also answered a lot of the ones
158
00:07:51.029 --> 00:07:53.149
like the Testament of Levi and some of these others
159
00:07:53.189 --> 00:07:55.629
that we showed in our channel and you did as well, Alex.
160
00:07:56.170 --> 00:07:58.060
So just keep in mind, point three is kind of
161
00:07:58.129 --> 00:08:01.540
new in this video that was not around in the other.
162
00:08:01.949 --> 00:08:03.579
So let's see what he says. He starts his video
163
00:08:03.620 --> 00:08:05.639
very different here. And I was a little bit surprised
164
00:08:06.459 --> 00:08:09.560
by how he handled this point. So let's let him
165
00:08:09.920 --> 00:08:10.439
speak on that.
166
00:08:11.379 --> 00:08:12.600
Argument from Hippolytus.
167
00:08:13.240 --> 00:08:16.740
Before diving into those, let me address three unhelpful tactics
168
00:08:16.759 --> 00:08:20.850
that reflected in some of the responses to my previous
169
00:08:20.870 --> 00:08:23.910
video on this topic. Number one, motive attribution. These are
170
00:08:23.930 --> 00:08:26.790
worth addressing because you see them escalating these days and
171
00:08:26.870 --> 00:08:30.569
they're unhelpful. They are distracting us from the
issue. All
172
00:08:30.610 --> 00:08:33.230
of us lose when these tactics are engaged. But I
173
00:08:33.269 --> 00:08:35.970
see this a lot more these days, unfortunately. For example,
174
00:08:36.029 --> 00:08:38.529
in Alex Sorin's livestream rebuttal to me when he gets
175
00:08:38.600 --> 00:08:42.679
a super chat stating that my financial livelihood depends on
176
00:08:42.799 --> 00:08:47.289
intentionally lying to myself and my audience, He unfortunately states
177
00:08:47.309 --> 00:08:49.389
his agreement with this, and then he adds his own
178
00:08:49.450 --> 00:08:52.169
speculations about how I'd have so much to lose financially
179
00:08:52.210 --> 00:08:55.860
and so forth. But my motive for defending Protestantism is
180
00:08:55.909 --> 00:08:56.419
that I.
181
00:08:56.360 --> 00:08:57.779
Believe … Alex, I'm going to pause and let you
182
00:08:57.980 --> 00:09:00.419
just respond to that real quick because it addressed you personally.
183
00:09:00.460 --> 00:09:02.860
He gets to me and Pat and William in a minute,
184
00:09:02.940 --> 00:09:05.440
but I'll just go ahead and let you respond here
185
00:09:05.460 --> 00:09:07.279
because you did a video on this, but not everybody
186
00:09:07.299 --> 00:09:10.320
has seen it that's on this channel too. So he
187
00:09:10.360 --> 00:09:11.580
called you out on that. What do you think?
188
00:09:12.340 --> 00:09:16.649
That just strikes me as blatantly true still on its face.
189
00:09:16.809 --> 00:09:20.309
Of course, if Gavin, let's say all of his intellectual
190
00:09:20.370 --> 00:09:24.070
objections to holy orthodoxy are assuaged, and he has no
191
00:09:24.129 --> 00:09:27.909
objections left, it would still be an enormously difficult thing
192
00:09:28.000 --> 00:09:33.539
for him to convert to an ancient Christian tradition. For me,
193
00:09:33.639 --> 00:09:37.039
when I converted, I lost a ton of friends. I
194
00:09:37.080 --> 00:09:40.059
lost a ton of community, a lot. It was a
195
00:09:40.139 --> 00:09:43.159
very painful journey. It was not like filled with a
196
00:09:43.179 --> 00:09:46.100
bunch of people supporting me along the way. And that
197
00:09:46.139 --> 00:09:48.879
was a form of a blessing, I guess, because it
198
00:09:49.230 --> 00:09:53.490
ensured in a way that my motives were proper and honest.
199
00:09:54.830 --> 00:09:57.230
But that just seems true on its face. Of course,
200
00:09:57.250 --> 00:10:01.580
he has an enormous sunken cost economically. also socially i
201
00:10:01.580 --> 00:10:05.419
mean it's i'm gonna invoke the truth as a defense
202
00:10:05.539 --> 00:10:08.500
on this one i his his uh the fact that
203
00:10:08.539 --> 00:10:11.840
it offends his sensibilities is not a valid objection and
204
00:10:11.879 --> 00:10:14.860
it's not a motive attribution either because he in in
205
00:10:14.879 --> 00:10:18.629
this clip he presents uh He presents my comment on
206
00:10:18.690 --> 00:10:21.509
sunken cost as if I presented this in lieu of
207
00:10:21.529 --> 00:10:25.370
an argument. In that video, I presented many arguments. I
208
00:10:25.409 --> 00:10:27.470
think it is one heck of a thing for him
209
00:10:27.509 --> 00:10:29.610
to do to take a stray remark from a four
210
00:10:29.649 --> 00:10:32.269
and a half hour stream and try to present that
211
00:10:32.590 --> 00:10:36.090
as if I was speculating about his sensibilities and sunken
212
00:10:36.129 --> 00:10:39.549
cost for four hours instead of presenting arguments, which is
213
00:10:40.149 --> 00:10:42.049
it's ridiculous. I presented many arguments.
214
00:10:42.740 --> 00:10:44.440
Well, let me ask Jay this, because when you hear
215
00:10:44.460 --> 00:10:48.759
the word motive attribution, like what's the first thing we're
216
00:10:48.779 --> 00:10:51.120
supposed to think of when somebody makes that claim? Like
217
00:10:51.379 --> 00:10:53.669
what kind of what kind of evidence is shown when
218
00:10:53.690 --> 00:10:57.889
somebody says this is motive attribution and then poses this
219
00:10:57.990 --> 00:11:01.789
quote on the screen here? Like, is it? Are we
220
00:11:01.809 --> 00:11:03.690
being too loose with the word? Because to me, I
221
00:11:03.710 --> 00:11:06.519
think there should be a stricter form to understanding motive
222
00:11:06.580 --> 00:11:10.379
attribution when you accuse somebody publicly in front of 95,000, 100,000 people.
223
00:11:10.740 --> 00:11:14.840
I just think of it as passive aggressive silliness. I mean,
224
00:11:14.860 --> 00:11:19.879
it's like standard, standard fare business as usual with these people. So,
225
00:11:20.610 --> 00:11:23.070
I mean, the thing is that, you know, with this
226
00:11:23.350 --> 00:11:27.039
ecumenist mindset that we have with Gavin, for example, Wouldn't
227
00:11:27.080 --> 00:11:28.960
that mean, and this is a critique that we've made
228
00:11:29.019 --> 00:11:31.820
of God logic as well, wouldn't that mean that we're
229
00:11:31.860 --> 00:11:35.919
all Christians? So why would it actually matter if he
230
00:11:35.970 --> 00:11:39.789
was to convert to something that his denomination sees as
231
00:11:39.929 --> 00:11:43.350
also just Christian, just with different sort of practices that
232
00:11:43.389 --> 00:11:44.210
he doesn't agree with?
233
00:11:44.269 --> 00:11:45.389
So what we.
234
00:11:45.330 --> 00:11:48.240
Find out is that really the problem that the people
235
00:11:48.259 --> 00:11:51.179
in that sphere, whether it's God logic or Gavin or whoever,
236
00:11:51.769 --> 00:11:55.409
Their problem actually is with exclusivist claims. And since Rome
237
00:11:55.450 --> 00:11:59.120
and the Orthodox Church have exclusivity claims, what we find
238
00:11:59.220 --> 00:12:01.899
out is that the real root of this problem is
239
00:12:02.659 --> 00:12:06.220
you can have any kind of position except an exclusivist claim.
240
00:12:06.419 --> 00:12:11.809
But what's ironic is that the
non-exclusivist position is also
241
00:12:12.070 --> 00:12:15.669
exclusivist because they reject the people who are exclusivists.
242
00:12:15.690 --> 00:12:19.980
It's true. That's so true. And I've noticed that that's
243
00:12:20.039 --> 00:12:22.179
the trigger point, Jay, for me. I see in a
244
00:12:22.200 --> 00:12:24.850
lot of these guys. And I felt the same way
245
00:12:24.899 --> 00:12:29.629
because if you add at the end of things anathema, well,
246
00:12:29.730 --> 00:12:32.429
I mean, that's offensive. I mean, it doesn't make you
247
00:12:32.450 --> 00:12:35.389
feel good about it when you know that, like, all
248
00:12:35.409 --> 00:12:38.669
of a sudden there's a statement about the anathema clauses
249
00:12:38.710 --> 00:12:41.409
at the end of Nicaea 2. Or recently some of
250
00:12:41.429 --> 00:12:43.909
them were mad about the Council of Trent. If you
251
00:12:43.950 --> 00:12:47.419
don't affirm this canon, you know, anathema. And it's like, well,
252
00:12:47.580 --> 00:12:51.049
that's ridiculous. Why are you putting anathema clauses after a
253
00:12:52.110 --> 00:12:54.830
list of scripture books? And it's like, well, I mean,
254
00:12:56.169 --> 00:12:58.490
when you have people that are in the Protestant Reformation
255
00:12:58.529 --> 00:13:00.960
that are pretty much saying, I wish this book never
256
00:13:01.000 --> 00:13:04.159
came to us. I wish we didn't have it. Like
257
00:13:04.659 --> 00:13:09.620
Luther said about Esther, or you delegate books like James, Hebrews,
258
00:13:09.740 --> 00:13:11.720
and you put them at the end of your canon
259
00:13:11.759 --> 00:13:13.710
because your canon and what the canon view says, well,
260
00:13:14.149 --> 00:13:16.080
these don't preach Christ and I don't like the way
261
00:13:16.139 --> 00:13:18.419
James is combating Sol Vidae. So, you know, we're going
262
00:13:18.440 --> 00:13:21.240
to delegate it to the end. Well, yeah, because now,
263
00:13:21.820 --> 00:13:24.940
because your list of books based on rejecting certain books,
264
00:13:25.019 --> 00:13:29.049
because you don't agree with their doctrine is damnable. I mean, it's,
265
00:13:29.110 --> 00:13:32.990
it's offensive. It's against the church's teaching. So they hear
266
00:13:33.009 --> 00:13:35.570
the word anathema and they're just, they sit around and
267
00:13:35.629 --> 00:13:39.289
I've watched Gavin do this on icons. We were mentioning
268
00:13:39.620 --> 00:13:44.690
James Gilbert, Jay, James and I responded to him. how
269
00:13:44.710 --> 00:13:46.929
long ago, James, that was probably three months ago on
270
00:13:46.970 --> 00:13:49.809
his icons. And we played the part over and over.
271
00:13:49.850 --> 00:13:53.350
He was so offended about the anathema clauses in ICU.
272
00:13:53.769 --> 00:13:57.610
They can't cope with hearing the words anathema. It's more like,
273
00:13:57.629 --> 00:14:00.889
why can't we just gather around the campfire and sing
274
00:14:00.909 --> 00:14:01.779
the campfire song?
275
00:14:01.860 --> 00:14:06.320
I mean, Paul in Corinthians includes this idea of excommunicating
276
00:14:06.360 --> 00:14:09.559
people explicitly. And so this, they're in this weird position
277
00:14:09.620 --> 00:14:12.179
where They'd be forced to say, well, I guess that's
278
00:14:12.320 --> 00:14:13.720
only an apostolic power.
279
00:14:13.799 --> 00:14:15.039
Only Paul had that power.
280
00:14:15.600 --> 00:14:17.879
Of course, we all know that the church fathers in
281
00:14:17.899 --> 00:14:21.240
the succeeding centuries definitely believed that they had the same
282
00:14:21.279 --> 00:14:24.740
power to excommunicate people. And even many of these Protestant
283
00:14:24.779 --> 00:14:26.659
groups will say, yeah, you can kind of do a
284
00:14:26.700 --> 00:14:29.620
kind of an excommunication, I guess. But at the same time,
285
00:14:29.639 --> 00:14:31.700
we have a problem with it. So it's really makes
286
00:14:31.740 --> 00:14:32.139
no sense.
287
00:14:34.899 --> 00:14:35.159
Alex?
288
00:14:36.539 --> 00:14:39.210
I mean, I had a debate with a Lutheran pastor yesterday.
289
00:14:40.169 --> 00:14:43.950
on this. And the argument was like, whether the Lutheran
290
00:14:43.970 --> 00:14:46.870
church is the true church, you know, descending from Western Christianity,
291
00:14:46.889 --> 00:14:49.049
or whether the Eastern Orthodox church is the true church.
292
00:14:49.549 --> 00:14:52.600
And my whole argument revolved around, based on their definition
293
00:14:52.639 --> 00:14:56.960
of the church, they're unable to actually excommunicate people, which
294
00:14:57.100 --> 00:14:59.840
by their own criteria is a standard of what a
295
00:14:59.860 --> 00:15:03.519
true church is. So I said, the argument is basically
296
00:15:03.539 --> 00:15:05.769
that by his own definition, he fails, and he conceded
297
00:15:05.830 --> 00:15:08.350
to that. So I think there is a huge underlying
298
00:15:08.370 --> 00:15:11.500
ecclesiological problem. I think Jay is completely right when he
299
00:15:11.529 --> 00:15:14.639
talks about in 1 Corinthians, I think it's chapter 5
300
00:15:14.639 --> 00:15:18.379
when it talks about the young man who was engaging
301
00:15:18.480 --> 00:15:23.159
in sensual behaviors, improper behaviors with his father's wife, I
302
00:15:23.179 --> 00:15:26.120
think is how it's phrased, that he is cast out
303
00:15:26.179 --> 00:15:30.659
to Satan. And these churches, these assemblies, they're unable to
304
00:15:30.700 --> 00:15:33.470
do that. So it is a major problem for them.
305
00:15:34.639 --> 00:15:37.840
By the way, somebody challenged me. I just pulled it
306
00:15:37.879 --> 00:15:40.399
up on the screen. You can go look to Table
307
00:15:40.440 --> 00:15:44.100
Talk on Martin Luther. He's recorded saying these exact words.
308
00:15:44.120 --> 00:15:46.659
There's different translations to it. I'm so great as an
309
00:15:46.759 --> 00:15:49.340
enemy to the second book of Maccabees and to Esther
310
00:15:49.580 --> 00:15:52.559
that I wish they had not come to us at all,
311
00:15:52.980 --> 00:15:57.179
but they have too many heathen unnatural teeth. So, Yes.
312
00:15:57.740 --> 00:15:59.850
Martin Luther, somebody challenged me on that, so I just
313
00:15:59.970 --> 00:16:02.210
took a minute to go, yes, Martin Luther did say that.
314
00:16:02.309 --> 00:16:05.490
So this is why anathemas are attached at the end
315
00:16:05.529 --> 00:16:10.370
of books right there. Stuff like that. Just saying. So
316
00:16:10.490 --> 00:16:12.169
let's continue in. Let's see what he has to say
317
00:16:12.350 --> 00:16:14.529
in this next part. So he calls you out first.
318
00:16:14.649 --> 00:16:16.149
We get a break on the number two, and then
319
00:16:16.169 --> 00:16:17.350
he comes after us on number three.
320
00:16:17.929 --> 00:16:21.269
But my motive for defending Protestantism is that I believe
321
00:16:21.370 --> 00:16:25.379
it is true. Speculating about other people's motives, whether financial
322
00:16:25.429 --> 00:16:28.590
motives or anything else, distracts us from the issues being
323
00:16:28.620 --> 00:16:31.710
debated let's avoid that tactic and let's deal with the
324
00:16:31.909 --> 00:16:34.409
arguments because that's going to be more helpful to our
325
00:16:34.450 --> 00:16:36.629
viewers and more honoring to christ.
326
00:16:36.809 --> 00:16:39.250
By the way what i meant by this is where
327
00:16:39.269 --> 00:16:42.210
you try to damage someone's reputation i wanted to say
328
00:16:42.230 --> 00:16:45.870
i wasn't calling alex passive aggressive what i was saying
329
00:16:45.909 --> 00:16:50.850
was anytime the debate turns into speculating about motives which
330
00:16:50.889 --> 00:16:52.629
is what gavin sort of tried to turn it to
331
00:16:52.830 --> 00:16:55.500
right i think for all of us, especially if you're
332
00:16:55.519 --> 00:16:59.350
a Protestant pastor or in that sphere, uh, you know,
333
00:16:59.370 --> 00:17:03.289
when I left Protestantism for Rome Catholicism, I had a
334
00:17:03.330 --> 00:17:05.630
huge loss. I lost a lot of friends. I lost
335
00:17:05.670 --> 00:17:08.250
my church community. Um, a lot of those people wouldn't
336
00:17:08.289 --> 00:17:10.529
talk to me ever again. So it was a big
337
00:17:10.549 --> 00:17:14.200
decision and it was a huge, huge loss in many ways.
338
00:17:14.400 --> 00:17:18.089
And so, that's just a factual statement, whether it's, you know,
339
00:17:18.470 --> 00:17:20.680
it doesn't even seem to be motive related, but the
340
00:17:20.779 --> 00:17:24.140
irony is that Gavin is sort of attributing bad motives
341
00:17:24.200 --> 00:17:26.680
to Alex with the comment.
342
00:17:27.079 --> 00:17:28.519
Right. And so that's what I'm saying.
343
00:17:28.539 --> 00:17:30.819
When you get into the meta debate about motives, that's,
344
00:17:30.839 --> 00:17:33.299
I absolutely hate that
because it's just, it never ends.
345
00:17:33.339 --> 00:17:34.789
But anyway, I just want to make that clear. I
346
00:17:34.829 --> 00:17:37.230
wasn't saying Alex was being passive aggressive.
347
00:17:38.289 --> 00:17:41.869
No, I, and I think we all know, especially myself.
348
00:17:42.029 --> 00:17:45.460
I mean, yeah, We've all counted some sort of loss
349
00:17:46.079 --> 00:17:47.940
shifting where we did. I mean, I was a Baptist
350
00:17:47.960 --> 00:17:49.799
pastor for a lot of years. I lost a lot
351
00:17:49.839 --> 00:17:52.640
of friends just becoming Anglican and then to move to Catholicism,
352
00:17:53.240 --> 00:17:56.430
which on my wife's side, you know, her family prided
353
00:17:56.450 --> 00:17:58.829
themselves in leaving the Catholic church to be Protestant. And
354
00:17:58.890 --> 00:18:03.089
on my side, especially my, my grandfather's Italian, very deep
355
00:18:03.150 --> 00:18:06.130
rooted in the Catholic church. He prided himself in leaving
356
00:18:06.170 --> 00:18:08.849
the Catholic church. And so did my grandmother who was
357
00:18:08.890 --> 00:18:11.730
born in Holland. She was Dutch Catholic. She prided herself
358
00:18:11.769 --> 00:18:14.819
in the, So I had family that prided themselves in leaving.
359
00:18:14.859 --> 00:18:17.200
And then their grandson and their nephew and all this
360
00:18:17.259 --> 00:18:22.859
other stuff is going back. And it hurt at first,
361
00:18:23.019 --> 00:18:26.039
especially with friendships, all of a sudden I'm a heathen
362
00:18:26.200 --> 00:18:29.019
or whatever. I mean, there is a cost to it.
363
00:18:29.109 --> 00:18:31.450
And we all count the cost. I mean, Jesus said
364
00:18:31.470 --> 00:18:32.930
we got to count the cost. So, I mean, I
365
00:18:32.950 --> 00:18:35.829
don't understand why. To me, a lot of this, gentlemen,
366
00:18:35.910 --> 00:18:37.930
and I'm going to say this as charitably as possible.
367
00:18:37.950 --> 00:18:40.710
A lot of this was virtue signaling. It's a lot
368
00:18:40.730 --> 00:18:43.009
of virtue signaling to me. It's like, really? I mean,
369
00:18:43.789 --> 00:18:46.710
Alex did almost four hours of content. Pat, William, and
370
00:18:46.750 --> 00:18:49.670
myself did almost three and a half hours of content.
371
00:18:50.690 --> 00:18:54.019
He snipped out two sections of our video and just
372
00:18:54.059 --> 00:18:57.500
a few of Alex's video. Didn't actually engage the stuff
373
00:18:57.539 --> 00:19:00.589
that actually disproved his point, only engaged stuff to further
374
00:19:00.700 --> 00:19:03.509
argue his point. And he took the beginning of his
375
00:19:03.529 --> 00:19:06.049
video to do this, and I thought it was completely unnecessary.
376
00:19:07.079 --> 00:19:10.609
And again, so I'm going to pull his triumphalism up
377
00:19:10.640 --> 00:19:14.670
here because he said we had unwarranted triumphalism, which kind
378
00:19:14.710 --> 00:19:17.589
of threw me off because I didn't even remember being
379
00:19:17.650 --> 00:19:20.670
triumphant in any way, shape or form. But this is
380
00:19:20.710 --> 00:19:22.789
the way this section of the video went here.
381
00:19:23.609 --> 00:19:23.990
Arguments.
382
00:19:25.430 --> 00:19:25.690
Whoops.
383
00:19:27.059 --> 00:19:30.319
A third issue I see is unwarranted triumphalism. I noticed
384
00:19:30.359 --> 00:19:33.079
this in the rebuttal from William Albrecht, Stephen Boyce and
385
00:19:33.140 --> 00:19:37.369
Pat May. They repeatedly say things like we've demolished his arguments.
386
00:19:37.549 --> 00:19:40.049
He must grant this. And even on a few points,
387
00:19:40.410 --> 00:19:42.630
if someone doesn't agree with one of the things we're saying,
388
00:19:42.670 --> 00:19:46.410
then they're dishonest. And yet this triumphalism is not.
389
00:19:46.529 --> 00:19:48.130
I want to pause here. I actually thought it was
390
00:19:48.170 --> 00:19:50.559
really interesting. You said that because I, I. actually put
391
00:19:50.680 --> 00:19:53.279
out and I pinned the comment on the original video
392
00:19:54.460 --> 00:19:57.750
and I challenged anybody because I I'm sitting there thinking, okay,
393
00:19:57.769 --> 00:19:59.670
I know it's three hours long. You say things when
394
00:19:59.690 --> 00:20:01.670
you're really tired and you say things when it's late
395
00:20:01.710 --> 00:20:03.630
at night and you're been going at it for hours
396
00:20:03.670 --> 00:20:06.119
and hours. I was like, I don't remember anybody ever saying,
397
00:20:06.160 --> 00:20:08.480
we demolished his argument or anything like that. And I'm like, okay,
398
00:20:08.529 --> 00:20:11.130
first of all, this is petty. Secondly, where did we
399
00:20:11.210 --> 00:20:13.789
say that? So I actually put out and pinned a
400
00:20:13.829 --> 00:20:18.029
comment and said, if anybody can find where myself, William,
401
00:20:18.190 --> 00:20:21.690
or Pat ever said the words, we demolished his arguments,
402
00:20:22.269 --> 00:20:25.609
I will gladly retract my point and we'll move on.
403
00:20:26.470 --> 00:20:31.329
And multiple people, including people that defended Gavin said, well,
404
00:20:31.890 --> 00:20:36.410
you actually never said those words. But your posture felt
405
00:20:36.609 --> 00:20:39.849
like you were saying those kinds of things. Like, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa. Okay,
406
00:20:39.869 --> 00:20:44.970
first of all, fine, whatever. You can interpret our posture
407
00:20:45.009 --> 00:20:51.529
if you want. But he accused us of saying things
408
00:20:51.589 --> 00:20:55.569
like that and gave example quotes and used that for
409
00:20:55.690 --> 00:21:00.190
unwarranted triumphalism. Wait a minute. We didn't even say that.
410
00:21:01.009 --> 00:21:03.390
And I'm still waiting. And Gavin, if you ever watch this,
411
00:21:03.450 --> 00:21:07.099
I'm sure you'll see some of this. If I said that,
412
00:21:07.170 --> 00:21:09.720
or Pat said
that, or William said that, show me
413
00:21:10.019 --> 00:21:13.660
where those are. We checked the transcripts. We went back
414
00:21:13.740 --> 00:21:16.440
on the videos. You had your own followers double-check this.
415
00:21:16.660 --> 00:21:20.380
Nobody said that. Nobody said that. I don't even know
416
00:21:20.400 --> 00:21:22.759
where that's coming from. Again, to me, this is a
417
00:21:22.779 --> 00:21:27.380
bunch of virtue signaling that we ignored... all of the
418
00:21:27.420 --> 00:21:29.920
data that we brought to the table to focus on
419
00:21:30.059 --> 00:21:33.220
this kind of stuff. Then you accused us of lying
420
00:21:33.299 --> 00:21:37.299
about you. And this is what you did to us.
421
00:21:37.519 --> 00:21:39.779
And I'm just trying, I'm just asking you to be consistent.
422
00:21:39.819 --> 00:21:42.099
That's all I'm asking. I'm just asking to be consistent.
423
00:21:42.759 --> 00:21:45.160
If you don't like the being lied about, which I, again,
424
00:21:45.180 --> 00:21:46.759
I don't think anybody's lied yet and we're going to
425
00:21:46.799 --> 00:21:49.319
get to that, but you can't turn around and then
426
00:21:49.359 --> 00:21:52.460
accuse us of saying things and then quoting us for quotes.
427
00:21:52.529 --> 00:21:57.619
We absolutely never said at any point in our time. So, Let's,
428
00:21:58.240 --> 00:21:59.500
I want to jump to this one part because this
429
00:21:59.519 --> 00:22:01.460
is really where the rubber meets the road. I want
430
00:22:01.480 --> 00:22:04.839
to spend most of our time around the arguments themselves
431
00:22:04.900 --> 00:22:09.220
because this part here bothered me the most because he
432
00:22:09.259 --> 00:22:12.539
gets into the early patristics. He gets into some of
433
00:22:12.559 --> 00:22:16.279
the discussions about the Bible itself. He concedes something on
434
00:22:16.440 --> 00:22:21.720
Cyprian and he talks about Cyprian teaching prayer for the deceased.
435
00:22:21.740 --> 00:22:25.240
And I'm going to go back. That's around 604. Let's
436
00:22:25.289 --> 00:22:25.640
play that.
437
00:22:25.680 --> 00:22:26.109
We agree.
438
00:22:26.559 --> 00:22:30.160
That Cyprian teaches we should pray for deceased believers. I've
439
00:22:30.200 --> 00:22:32.460
talked about that in various videos, like my videos on
440
00:22:32.500 --> 00:22:35.839
purgatory and also Protestant views of that. I also totally
441
00:22:35.880 --> 00:22:39.380
agree that Cyprian thinks they are praying for us. This
442
00:22:39.420 --> 00:22:41.880
is why I'm always trying to distinguish the arrow up
443
00:22:42.059 --> 00:22:47.109
and the arrow down. Intercession for us, us invoking them.
444
00:22:48.150 --> 00:22:50.089
You can argue from one to the other. We'll deal
445
00:22:50.109 --> 00:22:52.029
with that in this video, but you can't just conflate
446
00:22:52.049 --> 00:22:53.109
them as though they were the same thing.
447
00:22:54.769 --> 00:22:57.799
See, this part here bothered me the most here because
448
00:22:59.819 --> 00:23:02.319
he said in another video that he referenced on purgatory.
449
00:23:02.339 --> 00:23:04.180
I went back and found it. It's about two years old.
450
00:23:05.339 --> 00:23:07.539
He said that he admitted, and he said these words,
451
00:23:08.559 --> 00:23:12.480
that the teaching of praying for the dead in the
452
00:23:12.599 --> 00:23:17.440
early church is extremely widespread and extremely early. Those are
453
00:23:17.559 --> 00:23:21.559
his words. Extremely widespread and extremely early. And I want
454
00:23:21.579 --> 00:23:26.630
to point this out, gentlemen. If you can concede that
455
00:23:26.809 --> 00:23:31.549
the doctrine and the teaching of praying for the dead
456
00:23:32.390 --> 00:23:36.630
is extremely early and extremely widespread, and you still refuse
457
00:23:36.690 --> 00:23:40.369
to affirm that, then what difference does it make if
458
00:23:40.589 --> 00:23:45.410
Alex and I pull up 150 church father quotes on invocation,
459
00:23:46.339 --> 00:23:49.519
and we show you every single quote on invocation that's
460
00:23:49.740 --> 00:23:53.920
early and widespread? Are you going to accept it anyway?
461
00:23:54.589 --> 00:23:58.549
Because you just admitted, even here, and then you refer
462
00:23:58.609 --> 00:24:00.950
back to a video where you admit that praying for
463
00:24:01.009 --> 00:24:04.470
the dead is widespread and early, but you don't believe
464
00:24:04.970 --> 00:24:07.740
we should pray for the dead. So it really is
465
00:24:07.799 --> 00:24:10.980
about sola scriptura, Jay. To me, it is. Because it
466
00:24:11.019 --> 00:24:13.539
doesn't matter how many quotes we can show somebody, if
467
00:24:13.579 --> 00:24:16.500
you can admit it about another teaching and you still
468
00:24:16.539 --> 00:24:18.240
reject it, it really doesn't matter how many quotes we
469
00:24:18.279 --> 00:24:20.460
can come up with to show intercession of the saints.
470
00:24:22.309 --> 00:24:25.089
Yeah, well, he mentioned in the a list of four
471
00:24:25.130 --> 00:24:30.740
things about valid inference and that's interesting because that's a
472
00:24:30.779 --> 00:24:34.059
huge problem for the protestant world i was in the
473
00:24:34.099 --> 00:24:36.369
protestant world for most of my life before i you
474
00:24:36.400 --> 00:24:38.410
know went to bible college and all that left it
475
00:24:39.130 --> 00:24:41.369
because this was something that was always coming even even
476
00:24:41.410 --> 00:24:43.509
in bible college in the dorms we'd sit around having
477
00:24:43.549 --> 00:24:46.980
these debates about well, but yeah, I guess the Trinity
478
00:24:47.039 --> 00:24:49.920
isn't explicit in the scriptures, like the word and exactly these,
479
00:24:50.220 --> 00:24:51.740
you know, Homoousius concepts.
480
00:24:51.920 --> 00:24:53.849
But it's a necessary inference.
481
00:24:54.009 --> 00:24:56.549
And it's
like, well, wait a minute, how do we
482
00:24:56.609 --> 00:25:00.849
critique these other positions that will make the same necessary
483
00:25:00.890 --> 00:25:05.670
inference move, you know, to ideas of like having liturgy
484
00:25:05.809 --> 00:25:07.990
or intercession of the saints or this kind of stuff.
485
00:25:08.029 --> 00:25:11.069
And it was always very arbitrary. Well, they're departing from
486
00:25:11.109 --> 00:25:13.819
the clear necessary inference, right? So, so it becomes this
487
00:25:13.859 --> 00:25:17.650
really arbitrary thing. game of, you know, again, moving the
488
00:25:17.690 --> 00:25:20.809
goalposts and saying that, well, you know, I guess the
489
00:25:20.829 --> 00:25:23.039
church was corrupted earlier than I thought, and so this
490
00:25:23.099 --> 00:25:26.700
practice was widespread, this is an accretion, and again, it's
491
00:25:26.740 --> 00:25:28.960
just sort of like begging the question of, well, how
492
00:25:29.000 --> 00:25:33.380
do we know and determine the valid inferences versus the
493
00:25:33.539 --> 00:25:38.519
invalid inferences? Because if it's not explicit, obviously then Sola
494
00:25:38.539 --> 00:25:41.559
Scriptura is incapable of solving this dilemma.
495
00:25:43.789 --> 00:25:47.690
That's a big A big problem. Solus Catoric doesn't answer
496
00:25:47.809 --> 00:25:49.799
any of this. It doesn't, and this is my issue
497
00:25:49.819 --> 00:25:54.720
with him too, Jays, because technically, by his definition, God
498
00:25:54.759 --> 00:25:58.400
doesn't authorize this, nor does he actually say we can't.
499
00:25:59.279 --> 00:26:02.160
There's no prescriptive. So go ahead and speak to that.
500
00:26:02.180 --> 00:26:03.789
Yeah, and that's where the Protestant has to, and this
501
00:26:03.809 --> 00:26:06.930
is what we would do as a Calvinist, we would say, well,
502
00:26:07.650 --> 00:26:12.349
the regulative principle of worship necessitates that you can't do
503
00:26:12.410 --> 00:26:17.410
anything unless it's explicitly mandated in divine worship. And it's like, well,
504
00:26:17.430 --> 00:26:20.509
who decides what's explicit? Because on the one hand, if
505
00:26:20.529 --> 00:26:24.079
you've admitted that there's valid inferences and you're going to
506
00:26:24.119 --> 00:26:27.180
say the most important doctrine of Christianity, the Trinity is
507
00:26:27.220 --> 00:26:31.720
a valid inference from all of these passages, then obviously
508
00:26:31.900 --> 00:26:35.519
wouldn't the worship of God also potentially be a valid inference? No,
509
00:26:35.599 --> 00:26:38.089
that one doesn't count. That one has to be explicitly
510
00:26:38.130 --> 00:26:41.079
mandated because, My favorite argument for this is what I
511
00:26:41.140 --> 00:26:44.240
used to raise to my Protestant pastor before I left Protestantism.
512
00:26:44.259 --> 00:26:47.039
I was like, well, how come there's no New Testament liturgy?
513
00:26:47.720 --> 00:26:49.660
Like there
should be a very bare form part of
514
00:26:49.680 --> 00:26:52.460
the New Testament canon where Paul says, and by the way,
515
00:26:52.480 --> 00:26:54.579
this is very important because you don't.
516
00:26:54.500 --> 00:26:56.160
Want to be like Nadab and Abihu. Here's how you
517
00:26:56.200 --> 00:26:58.460
do the worship service, right?
518
00:26:58.480 --> 00:27:01.359
Because God kills them for offering the incense in an
519
00:27:01.420 --> 00:27:04.240
improper way, getting creative with DIY, right?
520
00:27:04.759 --> 00:27:05.900
They went full mega church.
521
00:27:05.940 --> 00:27:09.099
They were having smoke machines and rock bands. And God says,
522
00:27:09.140 --> 00:27:13.539
your dad, no. Why didn't Paul give us some basic
523
00:27:13.660 --> 00:27:18.210
pattern of worship? And the Protestant position is always just, well,
524
00:27:18.250 --> 00:27:20.210
they got basic ideas in the New Testament.
525
00:27:20.250 --> 00:27:22.490
No, there's not. There's not a layout of how, I mean,
526
00:27:22.769 --> 00:27:26.029
do we say a creed? No creed? Do we sing
527
00:27:26.069 --> 00:27:27.069
a song? No songs?
528
00:27:27.109 --> 00:27:30.009
I mean, yeah, Paul says sing hymns and spiritual songs,
529
00:27:30.049 --> 00:27:31.450
but he doesn't say do that in the liturgy.
530
00:27:31.710 --> 00:27:32.410
He just says do it.
531
00:27:33.019 --> 00:27:36.000
So how do I know how I'm supposed to worship
532
00:27:36.019 --> 00:27:38.529
God unless there's an absolute tradition of of.
533
00:27:38.509 --> 00:27:39.450
How to worship God.
534
00:27:39.470 --> 00:27:42.829
To me, that's always been a huge, just massive stumbling block,
535
00:27:42.930 --> 00:27:44.269
especially for the Calvinists.
536
00:27:44.369 --> 00:27:45.670
And I know Gavin's.
537
00:27:45.390 --> 00:27:49.500
Loosely Calvinist, not a strict Calvinist, but where is the
538
00:27:49.559 --> 00:27:52.579
regulative principle of how you're supposed to worship in the
539
00:27:52.619 --> 00:27:53.119
New Testament?
540
00:27:54.400 --> 00:27:56.000
What do you think, Alex, on that?
541
00:27:57.119 --> 00:28:00.460
Well, I think in my response to him, the one
542
00:28:00.500 --> 00:28:03.960
that I actually had scripted and recorded I had a
543
00:28:04.220 --> 00:28:06.700
whole section about his standard of proof, talking about how
544
00:28:06.740 --> 00:28:09.970
he's requiring of us this divine warrant, the standard of proof,
545
00:28:10.730 --> 00:28:14.630
where he says you don't need an explicit scriptural passage,
546
00:28:14.670 --> 00:28:16.829
but at least you need very good reasons to think
547
00:28:16.910 --> 00:28:20.150
that this is something that God authorized for us to do.
548
00:28:21.230 --> 00:28:24.119
And it cuts both ways, because, okay, if this is
549
00:28:24.150 --> 00:28:26.700
the standard we're going to use to determine faith and practice,
550
00:28:27.079 --> 00:28:30.200
where on earth, I have yet a Protestant to
show me,
551
00:28:30.640 --> 00:28:33.519
where there's divine warrant for sola scriptura, or if we're
552
00:28:33.619 --> 00:28:37.180
independent Bible churches, because every single thing that I see
553
00:28:37.240 --> 00:28:40.099
on those topics in scripture is you're not allowed to
554
00:28:40.180 --> 00:28:43.960
engage in factions or dissensions. You must maintain unity, be
555
00:28:44.019 --> 00:28:47.529
of one mind, be of one judgment. And I fail
556
00:28:47.569 --> 00:28:51.210
to see how he doesn't fall under that prohibition just
557
00:28:51.349 --> 00:28:54.089
by definition and what he's doing in other areas. And
558
00:28:54.710 --> 00:28:58.690
as a whole, his worldview is very clunky and self-contradicting.
559
00:28:58.789 --> 00:29:02.150
So he ends up imposing some like high standard on us,
560
00:29:02.170 --> 00:29:04.660
which I think we meet anyway, because I think you
561
00:29:04.680 --> 00:29:09.539
see direct addresses to heavenly intercessors in the Psalms. You see,
562
00:29:09.559 --> 00:29:12.240
I would argue in Nehemiah 9, you have the Israelites
563
00:29:12.359 --> 00:29:16.690
are asking for, or they're confessing the iniquities of their ancestors.
564
00:29:16.710 --> 00:29:19.349
I think it's how it's worded, a form of prayer
565
00:29:19.410 --> 00:29:21.609
for the dead. So you have all the elements that
566
00:29:21.630 --> 00:29:25.599
you need for appealing to a heavenly intercessor already just
567
00:29:25.630 --> 00:29:28.180
in the scriptures. I think we meet the divine warren
568
00:29:28.200 --> 00:29:31.920
standard and exceed it because we also have historical attestations
569
00:29:31.980 --> 00:29:36.349
to this. Nonetheless, I think a lot of his doctrines
570
00:29:36.450 --> 00:29:39.009
don't meet the very standard that he imposes on us,
571
00:29:39.250 --> 00:29:40.960
and it's a sword that cuts both ways.
572
00:29:42.059 --> 00:29:44.900
That's a great point jay were you about to read something.
573
00:29:45.089 --> 00:29:48.150
Yeah i was gonna say uh uh i don't know
574
00:29:48.170 --> 00:29:49.869
if this we want to get into this later but
575
00:29:49.910 --> 00:29:51.690
you know there's a lot of textual evidence but just
576
00:29:51.710 --> 00:29:54.930
some ones that i think are uh overlooked at times
577
00:29:55.109 --> 00:29:57.289
in this discussion is if you, if you go into
578
00:29:57.509 --> 00:29:59.809
the Jewish tradition, how they viewed this, how they still
579
00:29:59.849 --> 00:30:02.589
view this stuff. And, you know, you can look at
580
00:30:02.609 --> 00:30:05.109
something like the Jewish study Bible, which has a lot
581
00:30:05.150 --> 00:30:08.670
of rabbinic commentary and commentaries on the Psalms and most
582
00:30:08.690 --> 00:30:11.619
of the old Testament. And they'll note things like in
583
00:30:11.680 --> 00:30:15.480
Psalm 99, it says, for example, that here, God is
584
00:30:15.519 --> 00:30:19.779
presented in a, or Jesus presented
Messiah, whoever Jesus for us,
585
00:30:19.799 --> 00:30:22.099
but you know, the Messiah here, King is presented as
586
00:30:22.140 --> 00:30:25.490
the King of Zion and, And there is this liturgical
587
00:30:25.529 --> 00:30:29.710
celebration of the entire congregation of Israel. And then it lists,
588
00:30:30.029 --> 00:30:33.059
and this is, of course, after these people have passed on,
589
00:30:33.490 --> 00:30:37.039
Moses and Aaron are among his priests. Samuel are among
590
00:30:37.079 --> 00:30:38.079
those who call.
591
00:30:37.859 --> 00:30:40.559
On the name of the Lord. Now, remember when Jesus.
592
00:30:40.180 --> 00:30:43.640
Is interacting with the Sadducees and he's having these debates
593
00:30:43.700 --> 00:30:47.220
and they say, well, how could you know Abraham and
594
00:30:47.240 --> 00:30:48.160
the patriarchs?
595
00:30:48.180 --> 00:30:50.119
You're not 50 years old. They're dead.
596
00:30:50.880 --> 00:30:52.980
And Jesus says, they're not dead. They're alive to God.
597
00:30:53.420 --> 00:30:56.619
And this is a passage where even the Jewish tradition
598
00:30:56.680 --> 00:31:01.319
will note that it's interesting that these people are presented
599
00:31:01.920 --> 00:31:07.180
as alive in the liturgical celebration. And even the Jews
600
00:31:07.240 --> 00:31:11.720
cite Jeremiah 15.1, even if Moses.
601
00:31:11.380 --> 00:31:12.250
And what does it say?
602
00:31:12.799 --> 00:31:16.240
Samuel, I forget the exact passage, but Jeremiah 15.1, you know,
603
00:31:16.380 --> 00:31:16.900
Jeremiah says.
604
00:31:16.920 --> 00:31:18.299
Yeah, I think it's Moses and Samuel.
605
00:31:19.130 --> 00:31:22.140
Even if Moses and Samuel stood before me, the righteousness
606
00:31:22.180 --> 00:31:25.220
that they had would not be enough. But that's, again,
607
00:31:25.240 --> 00:31:30.420
the mindset of the ancient Jewish tradition. Hebrew tradition was,
608
00:31:30.539 --> 00:31:31.259
they're not dead.
609
00:31:31.579 --> 00:31:34.750
They're in the presence of God. They're worshiping God liturgically.
610
00:31:35.430 --> 00:31:38.029
And also, as we know, presenting the prayers of the
611
00:31:38.049 --> 00:31:42.309
saints and so forth. So this idea of heavenly liturgical worship,
612
00:31:42.769 --> 00:31:44.730
as well as angelic.
613
00:31:44.210 --> 00:31:45.970
Liturgical worship, is very crucial here.
614
00:31:47.049 --> 00:31:49.750
Not just for how the church formed its liturgical worship,
615
00:31:50.410 --> 00:31:58.269
but what was really a very common, very well-known Hebrew practice.
616
00:31:58.650 --> 00:31:59.509
So this is the thing.
617
00:32:00.089 --> 00:32:02.529
And I know we're not getting off into other theological issues,
618
00:32:02.549 --> 00:32:05.529
but it relates to stuff like theosis because one of
619
00:32:05.549 --> 00:32:09.430
the reasons why the belief is that the patriarchs and
620
00:32:09.450 --> 00:32:13.220
these people were able to intercede or angels were able
621
00:32:13.240 --> 00:32:16.240
to intercede was because they're participating in the same worship
622
00:32:16.299 --> 00:32:20.369
and in fact it's already a hebrew tradition that the
623
00:32:20.440 --> 00:32:24.089
righteous men of the old testament that died are replacing
624
00:32:24.170 --> 00:32:28.009
fallen angels in the heavenly council so it's it's not
625
00:32:28.049 --> 00:32:30.769
just now people say oh that's a you know who's
626
00:32:30.789 --> 00:32:33.529
that protestant dude that died that wrote on the divine
627
00:32:33.569 --> 00:32:36.710
council forget his name but oh michael dr heiser dr
628
00:32:36.769 --> 00:32:38.930
michael heiser no it's it's actually a hebrew thing in
629
00:32:38.990 --> 00:32:41.750
fact um there's other independent scholars who i don't even
630
00:32:41.769 --> 00:32:45.049
think are aware of him so uh there's a great
631
00:32:45.089 --> 00:32:48.450
book by andre orlov who is a pretty famous um
632
00:32:48.750 --> 00:32:53.119
he's a professor of judaic studies at marquette university and
633
00:32:53.160 --> 00:32:55.660
i put a link into the chat for the maquette
634
00:32:55.700 --> 00:32:58.519
study page which has dozens and dozens and dozens of
635
00:32:58.759 --> 00:33:03.519
academic papers many from dr orlov on early Judaism in
636
00:33:03.559 --> 00:33:07.869
the first, second, third century, the relationship to Christianity, liturgical worship, etc.
637
00:33:08.380 --> 00:33:08.990
Theophanies.
638
00:33:09.190 --> 00:33:11.609
Theophanies are a big point of this because, again, the
639
00:33:11.829 --> 00:33:14.809
righteous men of the Old Testament were already believed to
640
00:33:14.849 --> 00:33:19.559
be deified and in the presence of God, celebrating liturgical
641
00:33:19.599 --> 00:33:23.200
worship and thus also praying for Israel on earth.
642
00:33:23.460 --> 00:33:24.700
So all of this is 100% Hebrew tradition.
643
00:33:26.960 --> 00:33:28.940
Yeah, and I just put the link to that also
644
00:33:29.000 --> 00:33:30.940
for anybody that wants to click it. We'll look at
645
00:33:30.960 --> 00:33:33.029
a couple of those, but it's right here if you
646
00:33:33.049 --> 00:33:33.789
want to click on that.
647
00:33:33.809 --> 00:33:37.349
And Gavin could make good use of that to discover that, no,
648
00:33:37.390 --> 00:33:41.250
there's actually profuse amounts of scholarly evidence that first, second,
649
00:33:41.269 --> 00:33:45.849
third century Judaism and Christianity have very similar practices in
650
00:33:45.890 --> 00:33:46.309
this regard.
651
00:33:47.170 --> 00:33:51.329
Yeah, and it's not just about them being with us
652
00:33:51.410 --> 00:33:53.950
or seeing us or hearing us or knowing what we're praying.
653
00:33:54.029 --> 00:33:56.559
There's actually invocations. I want to tie that into our
654
00:33:56.579 --> 00:33:59.700
next point, gentlemen, because it really comes down to one
655
00:33:59.720 --> 00:34:01.430
of the
things that he showed here. We brought this
656
00:34:01.509 --> 00:34:04.890
up in our video. And I couldn't believe he actually
657
00:34:04.930 --> 00:34:08.510
conceded a element of this, because when Jesus is on
658
00:34:08.530 --> 00:34:12.210
the cross, you know, you hear the words, Eli, Eli,
659
00:34:12.269 --> 00:34:16.510
lema sabachthani, right? You have this whole statement. And the
660
00:34:16.570 --> 00:34:19.619
first thing that happens is the Jews don't go, hey,
661
00:34:19.659 --> 00:34:23.440
I wonder if he's quoting scripture. Their first inclination is
662
00:34:23.780 --> 00:34:28.199
he's calling for Elijah. Like, who thinks that way? So
663
00:34:28.239 --> 00:34:30.619
let's hear what Gavin has to say about this, because
664
00:34:30.659 --> 00:34:33.110
I thought it was really, really interesting how he tried
665
00:34:33.130 --> 00:34:35.869
to explain this, but actually used a word that I'm
666
00:34:35.909 --> 00:34:37.710
going to use the rest of this video.
667
00:34:39.030 --> 00:34:44.429
And the statement in verse 47, some say, some misconstrue
668
00:34:44.710 --> 00:34:50.789
Christ to be calling Elijah, but the misunderstanding of bystanders
669
00:34:51.489 --> 00:34:55.250
establishes at most that this was a conceivable idea, not
670
00:34:55.269 --> 00:34:58.650
that jesus is actually doing this or that matthew is
671
00:34:58.710 --> 00:35:02.869
commending such a practice again the protestant position is about.
672
00:35:02.730 --> 00:35:07.090
I want to pause right here because he said something
673
00:35:07.289 --> 00:35:12.489
that disproves his whole first video at most what we
674
00:35:12.530 --> 00:35:15.969
have is that the jews this that the people standing
675
00:35:16.010 --> 00:35:21.360
by we can say it's conceivable that they believe that
676
00:35:22.119 --> 00:35:28.329
right Yes, therefore, your first 200 years mentality is gone.
677
00:35:29.329 --> 00:35:32.710
That was, in fact, I wonder if you watched our
678
00:35:32.750 --> 00:35:34.710
video because he clipped things, but I don't think he
679
00:35:34.750 --> 00:35:37.590
actually watched it because we explicitly said, no, that isn't
680
00:35:37.659 --> 00:35:41.599
proof Jesus was calling to Elijah. It's the mere fact
681
00:35:43.099 --> 00:35:46.920
that the Jews would think that somebody saying those words
682
00:35:46.960 --> 00:35:51.519
would be invocating not only Elijah to call on him,
683
00:35:51.900 --> 00:35:55.699
but gentlemen, The scriptures, both in Matthew and Mark, say
684
00:35:56.320 --> 00:36:00.050
that the Jews waited to see if Elijah would come
685
00:36:00.309 --> 00:36:05.909
and rescue him, save him, which means it was conceivable.
686
00:36:05.929 --> 00:36:11.510
I always think of them as inconceivable. Conceivable to believe
687
00:36:11.780 --> 00:36:16.179
that Jews in the first 200 years didn't think it
688
00:36:16.219 --> 00:36:19.300
would be odd or even condemn Jesus and say, I
689
00:36:19.300 --> 00:36:20.980
can't believe he's calling on a lot. Doesn't he know
690
00:36:21.000 --> 00:36:23.030
we're not allowed to call on saints? Like, what in
691
00:36:23.050 --> 00:36:25.309
the world are you doing up there? They didn't condemn him.
692
00:36:25.329 --> 00:36:27.260
They actually stood back and said, let's see if Elijah comes.
693
00:36:27.340 --> 00:36:30.239
Let's see if Elijah comes. And he said a second thing.
694
00:36:30.280 --> 00:36:33.639
He said that, like, basically Matthew and Mark are not
695
00:36:33.739 --> 00:36:36.679
using this for, like, prescriptive. But here's what Matthew and
696
00:36:36.699 --> 00:36:41.329
Mark did. They reported it. Out of all of the
697
00:36:41.389 --> 00:36:45.050
things that happened at the cross, why did Matthew and
698
00:36:45.090 --> 00:36:50.429
Mark feel the need to let us, the reader, the Christians,
699
00:36:51.409 --> 00:36:55.610
especially Matthew, who's writing to converted Jews, why did they
700
00:36:55.650 --> 00:36:59.349
feel like it was necessary to tell us that the
701
00:36:59.449 --> 00:37:03.250
Jews were thinking and waiting for Elijah to come? Obviously,
702
00:37:03.289 --> 00:37:06.880
there's prophetic nature to that in the Old Testament. But they,
703
00:37:07.559 --> 00:37:09.360
of all the things that happened at the cross, we
704
00:37:09.380 --> 00:37:11.800
would want Matthew, Mark to report. There's way more stuff
705
00:37:11.840 --> 00:37:14.639
I'd rather them report. But they wanted us to know
706
00:37:14.679 --> 00:37:18.019
that's the thinking of the Jews. Alex, to me, that
707
00:37:18.039 --> 00:37:21.670
disproves the whole first video by saying it's conceivable. that
708
00:37:21.690 --> 00:37:23.250
the Jews would think that way.
709
00:37:23.510 --> 00:37:23.730
Right.
710
00:37:23.909 --> 00:37:27.210
So therefore your first 200 year hypothesis is, is dead.
711
00:37:27.409 --> 00:37:30.059
It's gone just on Matthew alone. We didn't even go
712
00:37:30.079 --> 00:37:33.039
to the church fathers. We didn't hit second temple Judaism.
713
00:37:33.320 --> 00:37:35.159
We're still in Matthew's gospel. What do you think?
714
00:37:36.340 --> 00:37:39.559
Well, I agree. And, uh, you know, I think, uh, it,
715
00:37:39.679 --> 00:37:43.110
it only is exacerbated by the numerous second temple period
716
00:37:43.150 --> 00:37:46.230
documents that we have, like, uh, the numerous appeals to
717
00:37:46.329 --> 00:37:50.349
Enoch that we have in first Enoch, uh, chapter 9
718
00:37:50.349 --> 00:37:52.590
you have the appeals to the archangels from the souls
719
00:37:52.650 --> 00:37:56.489
of men chapter 65 of first enoch you have noah
720
00:37:56.530 --> 00:38:00.119
calling out to enoch as a heavenly intercessor in chapter
721
00:38:00.119 --> 00:38:03.579
106 of first enoch you have uh methuselah calling out
722
00:38:03.619 --> 00:38:06.219
to enoch and in all of these places it's seen
723
00:38:06.360 --> 00:38:10.079
as a
good practice the text treats it favorably it's
724
00:38:10.139 --> 00:38:14.099
never treated unfavorably in any of these texts you have
725
00:38:14.119 --> 00:38:16.539
uh from the kumran the dead sea scrolls you have
726
00:38:16.579 --> 00:38:20.710
the seventh sabbath song of sacrifice which The commentators in here,
727
00:38:20.889 --> 00:38:24.769
Michael Wise, Martin Abick Jr., and Edward Cook, they're three scholars.
728
00:38:24.829 --> 00:38:27.090
They don't really have a bone to pick in this fight.
729
00:38:27.550 --> 00:38:31.699
They very clearly say these songs have appeals to angels.
730
00:38:31.840 --> 00:38:35.039
These were liturgical documents that you see in the Qumran community.
731
00:38:35.059 --> 00:38:39.300
You also have the Testament of Levi, which talks about Levi,
732
00:38:39.360 --> 00:38:42.119
who's going to appeal to an angel. He asks the angel,
733
00:38:42.139 --> 00:38:43.440
what is your name, so that I can appeal to
734
00:38:43.460 --> 00:38:45.769
you on the day of tribulation, whenever I'm having a
735
00:38:45.809 --> 00:38:49.829
bad day. or maybe an eschatological day of tribulation, right?
736
00:38:50.110 --> 00:38:53.139
But nonetheless, that presupposes that there were no qualms that
737
00:38:53.179 --> 00:38:56.639
anybody had about appealing to a heavenly intercessor like an
738
00:38:56.800 --> 00:38:59.360
angel at that time. And when you pile on all
739
00:38:59.400 --> 00:39:03.480
that evidence to what you see in the Gospels, and again,
740
00:39:03.500 --> 00:39:08.650
just a casual in-passing reference to this practice of appealing
741
00:39:08.690 --> 00:39:13.250
to someone like Elijah, a heavenly intercessor, It just does
742
00:39:13.329 --> 00:39:16.300
not bode well for Gavin, because not only is his
743
00:39:16.360 --> 00:39:18.480
claim that you don't see this in the first 200
744
00:39:18.480 --> 00:39:22.019
years of church history, it's totally bogus. You see that
745
00:39:22.039 --> 00:39:25.849
this goes prior to that. This is an ancient Hebrew practice.
746
00:39:26.190 --> 00:39:29.210
This is not some pagan accretion that he's arguing entered
747
00:39:29.230 --> 00:39:31.230
the church in the year 2000. 200. You see this
748
00:39:31.269 --> 00:39:34.389
happening in 250 BC. You see it happening earlier than
749
00:39:34.429 --> 00:39:37.449
that in the Psalms. And then when you consider those things,
750
00:39:37.469 --> 00:39:40.880
it's just his whole argument on this collapses on itself.
751
00:39:44.699 --> 00:39:47.340
You're muted, Doc Boyce. Sorry.
752
00:39:47.659 --> 00:39:50.869
Jay, sorry. Jay, to me, this is kind of odd
753
00:39:50.909 --> 00:39:54.329
because if it's conceivable, doesn't that go back to his
754
00:39:54.389 --> 00:39:59.070
criteria earlier when we're talking about prescriptive and non-prescriptive things?
755
00:39:59.769 --> 00:40:03.019
If it's conceivable to think, then is it no longer
756
00:40:03.219 --> 00:40:07.260
condemned on us for thinking it's possible? How do the
757
00:40:07.320 --> 00:40:09.500
rules work here? I'm not as good with putting these.
758
00:40:09.920 --> 00:40:14.400
He set a criteria. Now he's conceded that it's conceivable
759
00:40:14.780 --> 00:40:17.150
to think that Jews at that time would think that way.
760
00:40:17.800 --> 00:40:20.280
Or are we overstating our point in Matthew here? Or
761
00:40:20.480 --> 00:40:21.219
is there something to it?
762
00:40:23.760 --> 00:40:27.699
Yeah, again, I don't know where we're supposed to go
763
00:40:27.760 --> 00:40:32.239
with this on his position. Because the history of Protestantism
764
00:40:32.320 --> 00:40:37.119
is usually this attempt at a supposed purification, reform, or
765
00:40:37.179 --> 00:40:41.820
return to this idea, this amorphous idea of the, quote,
766
00:40:41.860 --> 00:40:44.630
early church. But we never have a clear idea as
767
00:40:44.670 --> 00:40:48.280
to what exactly the early church is. depending upon which
768
00:40:48.320 --> 00:40:51.400
Protestant we're talking to, that's going to differ radically between
769
00:40:51.440 --> 00:40:57.170
them all. Because I remember having a similar conversation over
770
00:40:57.190 --> 00:41:02.929
this with Paul Washer many years ago. And the only
771
00:41:02.949 --> 00:41:05.530
reason I bring that up is that at one point
772
00:41:05.550 --> 00:41:07.869
when I first started talking to Paul Washer about this,
773
00:41:07.929 --> 00:41:10.090
he was at the same position as Gavin, kind of
774
00:41:10.170 --> 00:41:14.239
a Baptist adjacent Calvinist, but a big fan of the
775
00:41:14.300 --> 00:41:17.139
reformers and Calvinists. and the deeper that he got into
776
00:41:17.159 --> 00:41:19.880
church history and the reformers, the more he started leaning
777
00:41:20.519 --> 00:41:23.659
Anabaptist because he came to the conclusion that there were
778
00:41:23.699 --> 00:41:27.099
so many accretions in the first, second, and third century
779
00:41:27.139 --> 00:41:30.880
that he couldn't really make fit with his sort of
780
00:41:30.920 --> 00:41:33.719
Baptist presuppositions that he ended up saying, I'm going to
781
00:41:33.739 --> 00:41:36.420
have to adopt a restorationist position. So I think it's
782
00:41:36.460 --> 00:41:38.900
important to call these people out in terms of church
783
00:41:38.940 --> 00:41:43.000
history to say, yeah, we all think Anabaptists are crazy, right?
784
00:41:43.039 --> 00:41:46.989
Radical Reformation is crazy, but on this point, they're more
785
00:41:47.030 --> 00:41:51.449
consistent because if the church has this stuff going on
786
00:41:51.510 --> 00:41:55.909
that early, then doesn't it seem like the apostasy happened
787
00:41:55.949 --> 00:41:58.320
much earlier than you would think? And if that's the case,
788
00:41:58.949 --> 00:42:00.539
then you seems like you want to move in the
789
00:42:00.559 --> 00:42:01.840
direction of some kind of blackout.
790
00:42:02.920 --> 00:42:06.079
That is a great point because that now, now the
791
00:42:06.119 --> 00:42:09.420
falling away, I've said this before. Like, I think if
792
00:42:09.739 --> 00:42:13.340
you're going to take a position of the reform view
793
00:42:13.360 --> 00:42:16.119
and I think the Mormons are far more consistent on
794
00:42:16.139 --> 00:42:19.340
this than anybody because they can just say, you know what,
795
00:42:19.400 --> 00:42:22.380
after John died, that was it. Everybody fell apart. I mean,
796
00:42:22.400 --> 00:42:26.190
to me, they're far more consistent. Let's get to some
797
00:42:26.230 --> 00:42:27.969
of these super chats. I don't want to keep getting
798
00:42:28.030 --> 00:42:31.010
piled up on these. The devil led him up to
799
00:42:31.050 --> 00:42:34.030
a high place, showed him in an instant all the
800
00:42:34.070 --> 00:42:38.300
kingdoms of the world. Obviously, that's coming from the temptation
801
00:42:38.320 --> 00:42:43.989
of Luke 4. Revelation 5, living beings replied, amen to praise.
802
00:42:44.690 --> 00:42:46.309
So I guess he's trying to show in a couple
803
00:42:46.329 --> 00:42:51.510
of places. Gavin would fight you back on Luke 4
804
00:42:51.510 --> 00:42:56.340
because it's earth to earth situation. He would say, again,
805
00:42:56.360 --> 00:42:59.440
I'm not saying that even makes sense. It's earth to earth,
806
00:42:59.480 --> 00:43:04.320
so it doesn't count as invocation. However, maybe the argument,
807
00:43:04.340 --> 00:43:07.320
and we made the argument, of course, from Revelation 5,
808
00:43:07.320 --> 00:43:12.119
just as others did. Jimmy says, what's the Pratt's obsession
809
00:43:12.159 --> 00:43:15.420
with this? I always bring up, show me any church
810
00:43:15.440 --> 00:43:19.820
father's writing stating this was a later invention, not part
811
00:43:20.000 --> 00:43:23.909
of the early church. And I mean, obviously we've seen
812
00:43:23.969 --> 00:43:26.050
examples of that. Obviously Jay gave one a minute ago
813
00:43:26.070 --> 00:43:29.940
as well, particularly with, ucs and homo ucs and ucs
814
00:43:30.019 --> 00:43:31.519
and all of this big debate.
815
00:43:31.320 --> 00:43:33.920
Well there is there is an example of someone saying
816
00:43:33.960 --> 00:43:37.519
that this was an accretion vigilantius said that uh yeah
817
00:43:37.800 --> 00:43:41.780
yeah that praying for the praying or invoking you know
818
00:43:41.800 --> 00:43:44.519
appealing to the saints is a is a pagan accretion
819
00:43:44.760 --> 00:43:49.320
jerome saint jerome had some some words for vigilantius.
820
00:43:49.320 --> 00:43:52.260
Saint jerome pray for us i'm telling you man i'm
821
00:43:52.360 --> 00:43:56.869
i'm a jerome fan sorry guys Protestants can't read the
822
00:43:56.909 --> 00:44:00.710
Bible without cherry picking. Why would they be better reading
823
00:44:00.769 --> 00:44:05.869
the academic scholarship? Somebody watched your video, Alex. That's
all
824
00:44:05.909 --> 00:44:09.050
I'm seeing in that Super Chat right there. I do
825
00:44:09.070 --> 00:44:11.190
want to speak to this one, and it came up.
826
00:44:11.230 --> 00:44:13.789
Thank you for the Super Chat, by the way. 1
827
00:44:13.789 --> 00:44:17.329
Timothy 5. I think you brought this up, Alex. I
828
00:44:17.349 --> 00:44:18.250
think a couple of people brought this up.
829
00:44:18.250 --> 00:44:19.610
This is one of my favorites, yes.
830
00:44:20.010 --> 00:44:22.170
Okay, so let's talk about this one for a minute. Jay,
831
00:44:22.190 --> 00:44:24.949
I want your thoughts on this too. where we see
832
00:44:25.690 --> 00:44:30.750
Paul charging. Is this one where Paul charges them? Okay,
833
00:44:30.829 --> 00:44:32.630
take your thought, and then I'll let Jay chip in
834
00:44:32.690 --> 00:44:32.889
on that.
835
00:44:33.489 --> 00:44:36.889
Yeah, so St. Paul is instructing St. Timothy on how
836
00:44:36.909 --> 00:44:39.630
to be a good bishop in Ephesus, basically. And in
837
00:44:39.710 --> 00:44:42.250
a certain section of chapter five, he talks about these
838
00:44:42.650 --> 00:44:45.949
disciplinary hearings for elders. And he instructs Timothy to make
839
00:44:46.010 --> 00:44:49.730
sure that when you're overseeing these complaints against elders, make
840
00:44:49.750 --> 00:44:51.750
sure there are at least two or three witnesses to
841
00:44:52.320 --> 00:44:56.000
that provide a foundation that can testify at this, whatever
842
00:44:56.059 --> 00:44:59.059
disciplinary hearing this is, they can provide their testimony to
843
00:44:59.099 --> 00:45:03.170
whatever misconduct it is that the elder engaged in, right? Otherwise,
844
00:45:03.710 --> 00:45:06.789
you should disregard it. You need at least the foundation
845
00:45:06.809 --> 00:45:10.050
of two or three witnesses. When he's summarizing this section
846
00:45:10.210 --> 00:45:13.949
up in St. Paul, he tells Timothy, he says, I
847
00:45:13.989 --> 00:45:17.469
charge you in the presence of God, of Christ Jesus,
848
00:45:17.869 --> 00:45:20.820
and of the elect angels to carry out these duties
849
00:45:20.860 --> 00:45:27.530
without bias, and without partiality. And the parallel there is intentional, obviously,
850
00:45:27.550 --> 00:45:30.699
because he's following his own two to three witnesses rule
851
00:45:31.030 --> 00:45:33.480
that he established earlier in the chapter. So when he
852
00:45:33.519 --> 00:45:35.340
says that, I charge you in the presence of God,
853
00:45:35.780 --> 00:45:39.159
Christ Jesus, and the elect angels, he's calling upon them
854
00:45:39.239 --> 00:45:42.460
as witnesses in the same way that he's referencing earlier
855
00:45:42.500 --> 00:45:45.070
in the chapter, where he would expect these two or
856
00:45:45.090 --> 00:45:48.789
three witnesses to appear at a hearing, to testify against
857
00:45:48.869 --> 00:45:51.510
an elder, to be able to provide a factual basis.
858
00:45:52.110 --> 00:45:55.170
To be able to, you know, I have some experience
859
00:45:55.289 --> 00:45:57.710
in dealing with witnesses. You have to be able to
860
00:45:57.769 --> 00:46:00.010
communicate with them in a way that they understand what
861
00:46:00.030 --> 00:46:02.750
you're saying. If they do not receive the subpoena, if
862
00:46:02.769 --> 00:46:05.269
they do not receive the summons to appear at the hearing,
863
00:46:05.710 --> 00:46:08.550
they are useless witnesses. They have to be able to
864
00:46:08.590 --> 00:46:11.820
receive your communications in an intelligible way and to do
865
00:46:11.900 --> 00:46:17.360
something about it. Otherwise, this entire invocation of God, Christ Jesus,
866
00:46:17.400 --> 00:46:20.119
and the elect angels has absolutely no force and no
867
00:46:20.159 --> 00:46:22.340
power at all. So I think this is something that
868
00:46:22.420 --> 00:46:26.219
is just on its face, a very obvious invocation of
869
00:46:26.420 --> 00:46:29.739
angels as a witness. Now, Gavin, in his video, he
870
00:46:29.800 --> 00:46:32.099
mentions this in passing. He doesn't do any more than
871
00:46:32.139 --> 00:46:34.619
try to hand wave this passage away. And he says,
872
00:46:34.800 --> 00:46:38.179
this is not an invocation. It's a presupposed angelic witness.
873
00:46:38.820 --> 00:46:40.940
And I'm left over here wondering, Gavin, what on earth
874
00:46:41.000 --> 00:46:43.699
is the difference? You have to be able to communicate
875
00:46:43.719 --> 00:46:46.079
with a witness in a way that they can hear
876
00:46:46.139 --> 00:46:49.760
you and act upon what you're telling them to do. Okay.
877
00:46:50.110 --> 00:46:52.170
I think this is one of the strongest passages for
878
00:46:52.230 --> 00:46:56.150
appealing to heavenly intercessors. And the fact that it's in
879
00:46:56.210 --> 00:46:59.750
like a witness capacity, that's totally irrelevant to whether you
880
00:46:59.769 --> 00:47:00.730
can appeal to them or not.
881
00:47:02.010 --> 00:47:04.860
And by the way, these Deuteronomy passages are connected where
882
00:47:05.639 --> 00:47:08.980
heaven and earth and angels are being called into judgment
883
00:47:09.139 --> 00:47:11.159
as well. So Jay, kind of talk about that. Like,
884
00:47:11.239 --> 00:47:14.059
what do you think when you see passages like that?
885
00:47:14.099 --> 00:47:16.940
Can invocation be defended from them?
886
00:47:19.000 --> 00:47:20.840
Yeah, I mean, it's the same principle as when Paul
887
00:47:20.880 --> 00:47:23.059
tells the Corinthians that women should have their head covered
888
00:47:23.079 --> 00:47:26.320
because of the angels. In other words, assuming that the
889
00:47:26.400 --> 00:47:29.019
angels are present at the liturgy. And, you know, in
890
00:47:29.260 --> 00:47:32.610
the Slavic Orthodox churches, at least, we take that very seriously.
891
00:47:32.659 --> 00:47:35.869
Everybody is pretty strict about women wearing head coverings. So
892
00:47:35.909 --> 00:47:38.010
sometimes the Antiochian and Greek churches are a little more
893
00:47:38.050 --> 00:47:40.489
flexible with that. But we do take that tradition very
894
00:47:40.530 --> 00:47:43.909
seriously because we really believe, you know, the angels are present.
895
00:47:44.650 --> 00:47:47.489
at the divine liturgy because you know if you read
896
00:47:47.590 --> 00:47:50.349
there's a great text people overlook uh it's saint germanus
897
00:47:50.369 --> 00:47:54.710
of constantinople's uh commentary on the divine liturgy and it's
898
00:47:54.769 --> 00:47:58.269
all about the parallels with the heavenly liturgy um there's
899
00:47:58.309 --> 00:48:01.570
a text that's really good too from the hebrew professor
900
00:48:01.929 --> 00:48:04.670
rachel elior called elior's abstract and it's just a little
901
00:48:04.730 --> 00:48:09.010
summation of her research on the angelic liturgy and what
902
00:48:09.030 --> 00:48:10.550
exactly is going on there. And if you read the
903
00:48:10.570 --> 00:48:12.449
book of Job early on in the book of Job,
904
00:48:12.550 --> 00:48:15.239
you see the same sons of God being present there
905
00:48:15.880 --> 00:48:19.760
in what scholars call the heavenly court. So I don't
906
00:48:19.800 --> 00:48:23.659
want to restrict it only to a courtly setting. Obviously
907
00:48:23.739 --> 00:48:27.070
worship is more than court, but there is that courtly
908
00:48:27.190 --> 00:48:29.230
aspect to it to where we want to see if.
909
00:48:29.210 --> 00:48:31.690
People are being obedient. Right.
910
00:48:32.130 --> 00:48:36.920
Um, a lot of this literature deals with court assessments, obedience.
911
00:48:37.079 --> 00:48:39.599
And in the case of Job, there's a question of
912
00:48:39.800 --> 00:48:42.119
Job's obedience and Satan is there kind of in this
913
00:48:42.260 --> 00:48:46.420
adversarial courtroom role to sort of call Job into question.
914
00:48:47.119 --> 00:48:50.360
And so the same thing happens in the liturgical celebrations
915
00:48:50.460 --> 00:48:53.380
where there's a courtly setting, there's a judgment that's made.
916
00:48:53.780 --> 00:48:55.880
This is why Paul says, if you take the Eucharist
917
00:48:56.980 --> 00:49:00.800
in a bad state, that can result in your physical
918
00:49:00.860 --> 00:49:04.869
death and spiritual death. So, There's a courtly judgment that's
919
00:49:04.949 --> 00:49:08.789
being essentially assessed at that time period. You get the
920
00:49:08.829 --> 00:49:12.690
same idea, by the way, when, for example, at various times,
921
00:49:12.969 --> 00:49:17.289
angels are sent out to mark people within the city,
922
00:49:17.369 --> 00:49:18.989
those who are of God and so forth. This is
923
00:49:19.150 --> 00:49:19.949
angelic judgment.
924
00:49:20.159 --> 00:49:20.920
And assessment.
925
00:49:21.360 --> 00:49:25.000
So I think Alex is perfectly correct there to call
926
00:49:25.019 --> 00:49:26.139
that into.
927
00:49:27.340 --> 00:49:27.590
View.
928
00:49:27.639 --> 00:49:31.210
There is this legal court assessment here, which if we
929
00:49:31.250 --> 00:49:34.550
are not, like you said, heaven up, able to make
930
00:49:34.590 --> 00:49:37.929
those kinds of appeals, court appeals.
931
00:49:39.130 --> 00:49:41.309
What's the purpose of this language? It's silly.
932
00:49:42.010 --> 00:49:44.550
And he sent another follow-up super chat with that from
933
00:49:44.610 --> 00:49:52.769
John 545, where Jesus says, Moses, whom you trust, accuses you.
934
00:49:53.030 --> 00:49:56.909
That's court language. You're sitting in a state where Moses
935
00:49:56.989 --> 00:50:00.489
is accusing you. Now, Gavin could talk himself out of
936
00:50:00.510 --> 00:50:04.360
that being invocation, but he would say, well, Moses, obviously,
937
00:50:04.539 --> 00:50:06.619
we can see he knows what's going on. Moses is
938
00:50:06.639 --> 00:50:08.809
seeing how the Jews have rejected these things. he would
939
00:50:08.829 --> 00:50:10.829
concede all those points, but he would say, nobody is
940
00:50:10.889 --> 00:50:14.050
calling on Moses. And then I guess you could say, well,
941
00:50:14.090 --> 00:50:17.210
Jesus is, but then he would maybe, I'm just trying
942
00:50:17.230 --> 00:50:17.590
to think.
943
00:50:17.469 --> 00:50:19.389
Like, well, what's funny is in a lot of this
944
00:50:19.469 --> 00:50:21.829
rabbinic literature, in a lot of this rabbinic literature, there.
945
00:50:21.730 --> 00:50:23.570
Is this idea of calling on Moses.
946
00:50:23.630 --> 00:50:27.909
In fact, there's several chapters in here about actually Moses
947
00:50:28.699 --> 00:50:31.780
being deified, right? So the idea of theosis with Moses
948
00:50:31.800 --> 00:50:34.619
going up on the mountain and his face shining, the
949
00:50:34.639 --> 00:50:37.880
Jews attributed quite a bit of, you know, high status
950
00:50:37.920 --> 00:50:40.420
to that, like Enoch and others. And they believe they
951
00:50:40.440 --> 00:50:43.739
were part of that, uh, uh, divine court, the divine council.
952
00:50:43.800 --> 00:50:46.639
It's not just the angels making these assessments. It's also,
953
00:50:47.260 --> 00:50:50.929
you know, righteous men. They're able to, uh, from heaven
954
00:50:51.190 --> 00:50:51.969
make these judgments.
955
00:50:52.969 --> 00:50:54.630
Now I want to, I want to point something out
956
00:50:54.690 --> 00:50:58.170
here because you got, you guys have said something and Alex,
957
00:50:58.230 --> 00:50:59.829
I can't remember if it was you that brought this
958
00:50:59.929 --> 00:51:04.159
up in your video talking about the dead. in relation
959
00:51:04.199 --> 00:51:07.250
to old Testament saints, because one of the things that
960
00:51:07.849 --> 00:51:09.710
Gavin brought up and it may have been in his
961
00:51:09.769 --> 00:51:11.929
first or second video, it's his first or second. I
962
00:51:11.969 --> 00:51:14.409
can't remember. He
showed a line of like, well, if
963
00:51:14.449 --> 00:51:16.510
this is the pattern that we would have been seeing,
964
00:51:17.030 --> 00:51:19.719
you know, once Mo remember that Moses died and then
965
00:51:19.739 --> 00:51:22.199
people would have been asking for Moses. And then later
966
00:51:22.659 --> 00:51:24.960
this person died, this prophet died. They'd be asking. And
967
00:51:25.000 --> 00:51:26.840
all the way down, then Peter died. People would be
968
00:51:26.900 --> 00:51:29.139
asking for Peter on and on and on. He's saying,
969
00:51:29.159 --> 00:51:31.519
we just don't have any evidences. There's no evidence where
970
00:51:31.800 --> 00:51:35.940
next generations are calling on the previous generations and so forth.
971
00:51:36.699 --> 00:51:40.380
There's a couple elements to this. One, does the place
972
00:51:40.420 --> 00:51:44.559
of the dead in relation to Jewish thought before the
973
00:51:44.599 --> 00:51:49.239
harrowing of Hades, one, does that change anything to this
974
00:51:49.380 --> 00:51:54.090
teaching on intercession? Two, how would the Jews view that statement?
975
00:51:54.730 --> 00:51:56.969
And you just touched on it, Jay. That's what made
976
00:51:56.989 --> 00:52:01.199
me think about it. So one, Before the harrowing happening,
977
00:52:01.539 --> 00:52:04.920
does that change anything here? And two, how would the
978
00:52:04.940 --> 00:52:08.070
Jews perceive his statement of, well, we don't see generations
979
00:52:08.190 --> 00:52:11.090
after calling on these other Old Testament saints? I'll start
980
00:52:11.110 --> 00:52:12.269
with you, Alex, and we'll come to Jay.
981
00:52:13.329 --> 00:52:15.630
I think, first of all, that section in the first
982
00:52:15.670 --> 00:52:19.590
video was one of the most horrendous, blatant arguments from silence,
983
00:52:20.010 --> 00:52:22.949
improper arguments from silence that I think I've ever seen.
984
00:52:22.969 --> 00:52:26.449
He said that we know Moses didn't pray to Abel.
985
00:52:26.949 --> 00:52:29.969
We know that David didn't pray to the patriarchs. We
986
00:52:30.010 --> 00:52:34.809
know that Ezra didn't pray to so and so on
987
00:52:34.829 --> 00:52:38.110
and so forth. It's like, okay, it's pretty easy to
988
00:52:38.130 --> 00:52:40.690
get around a fallacy that's an argument from silence if
989
00:52:40.710 --> 00:52:43.550
you just talk about it probabilistically. But no, he like
990
00:52:44.449 --> 00:52:47.230
fell into the fallacy of saying, no, we know for
991
00:52:47.269 --> 00:52:49.429
a fact they didn't do that because it's not written down.
992
00:52:49.590 --> 00:52:52.619
It's like, you're not allowed to reason that way. There
993
00:52:52.659 --> 00:52:55.860
are rules. You're not allowed to commit fallacies in your arguments.
994
00:52:56.079 --> 00:52:58.250
I don't care who you are. Second of all, I
995
00:52:59.010 --> 00:53:01.469
think you're spot on doc boys that like, look, we
996
00:53:01.510
--> 00:53:03.769
believe in the harrowing of Hades. We believe that when
997
00:53:03.829 --> 00:53:06.769
Christ went into Sheol, when he went into Hades and
998
00:53:06.789 --> 00:53:09.690
he brought the souls of the righteous and now they're
999
00:53:09.710 --> 00:53:12.909
participating in the first resurrection and they are deified in
1000
00:53:12.969 --> 00:53:16.320
heaven under the old covenant, this was extremely rare. You
1001
00:53:16.340 --> 00:53:19.139
have only a few exceptional figures like Jay pointed out
1002
00:53:19.760 --> 00:53:24.619
that are deified that can act as heavenly intercessors outside of, uh,
1003
00:53:25.110 --> 00:53:29.400
the angelic beings. So you have like Moses, Elijah, Enoch,
1004
00:53:29.559 --> 00:53:32.820
like this was not the norm where everybody is becoming
1005
00:53:32.900 --> 00:53:36.599
a deified, a holy one on God's divine counsel. They're
1006
00:53:36.619 --> 00:53:41.360
not all becoming Kedoshim in the sense of these heavenly intercessors.
1007
00:53:41.440 --> 00:53:44.820
They are, everybody went to Sheol outside of a few
1008
00:53:44.880 --> 00:53:48.519
exceptions under the old covenant. But a great part of
1009
00:53:48.539 --> 00:53:53.590
the gospel is that We participate in the first resurrection
1010
00:53:53.630 --> 00:53:58.409
now because of Christ defeating death by death, and we
1011
00:53:58.550 --> 00:54:03.340
join that divine council. So I think he's totally missing
1012
00:54:03.420 --> 00:54:06.679
this point that is, I think, crucial to the gospel.
1013
00:54:07.260 --> 00:54:09.119
And the fact that he overlooks it so casually is,
1014
00:54:09.619 --> 00:54:16.050
for me, concerning. You are once again muted.
1015
00:54:16.179 --> 00:54:21.960
Us communicating to them is nowhere taught or modeled anywhere
1016
00:54:22.000 --> 00:54:25.059
in God's revelation to us, despite hundreds.
1017
00:54:25.340 --> 00:54:27.059
This is where I'm going to play it. Sorry. I
1018
00:54:27.099 --> 00:54:29.619
was going to show this exact part because before Jay
1019
00:54:29.679 --> 00:54:33.260
answers this, we're being challenged. I'm like, where was that said?
1020
00:54:33.320 --> 00:54:35.559
Passages about the nature of prayer. Here's one way we
1021
00:54:35.599 --> 00:54:39.059
can make this concern. Noah did not ask for the
1022
00:54:39.099 --> 00:54:43.099
intercession of Abel. Abraham didn't ask for the intercession of Noah.
1023
00:54:43.730 --> 00:54:47.550
Moses didn't ask for the intercession of Abraham. David didn't
1024
00:54:47.670 --> 00:54:50.710
ask for the intercession of Moses. The latter prophets didn't
1025
00:54:50.789 --> 00:54:53.860
ask for the intercession of David. The apostles didn't ask
1026
00:54:53.880 --> 00:54:57.219
for the intercession of the Old Testament saints. Polycarp didn't
1027
00:54:57.320 --> 00:55:00.679
ask for the intercession of the apostle Paul. Irenaeus didn't
1028
00:55:00.760 --> 00:55:03.000
ask for the intercession
of Polycarp, and so on and
1029
00:55:03.050 --> 00:55:06.929
so forth, until long after The period.
1030
00:55:06.630 --> 00:55:08.050
Of the long after.
1031
00:55:08.070 --> 00:55:08.530
All right.
1032
00:55:08.610 --> 00:55:11.420
So that's what we're going to easily avoid this fallacy
1033
00:55:11.480 --> 00:55:14.440
by saying we don't have reason to believe X, Y, Z.
1034
00:55:14.980 --> 00:55:17.960
But no, he makes the most definitive statement you can.
1035
00:55:18.059 --> 00:55:24.989
It is a textbook argument from silence fallacy. Jay. Well, again, it's.
1036
00:55:27.000 --> 00:55:29.760
Like we're saying, I like to point out when this
1037
00:55:29.800 --> 00:55:32.159
comes up, because this always comes up with Protestants, is
1038
00:55:32.510 --> 00:55:34.409
are you sure you want to have that level of
1039
00:55:34.469 --> 00:55:38.050
a standard for what you consider proof? Because if we
1040
00:55:38.090 --> 00:55:40.289
turn that, I don't mean in a too quoque way sense,
1041
00:55:40.329 --> 00:55:43.610
but if you want to use that same level of necessity,
1042
00:55:43.710 --> 00:55:48.960
I'm assuming he means a written textual evidence for this
1043
00:55:49.119 --> 00:55:51.360
in the first, second or third century or whatever he
1044
00:55:51.400 --> 00:55:54.530
thinks that time frame is. Where is the Protestant canon
1045
00:55:54.550 --> 00:55:56.449
in the first, second, and third century? I'm not aware
1046
00:55:56.489 --> 00:56:01.130
of anybody. Of course, you know, the one that Milito
1047
00:56:01.150 --> 00:56:03.489
of Sardis' canon is not the Protestant canon, so that's
1048
00:56:03.530 --> 00:56:07.090
not going to work. There is no Protestant canonical list
1049
00:56:07.369 --> 00:56:10.570
prior to, as far as I'm aware, Jerome having the
1050
00:56:10.710 --> 00:56:13.769
Protestant list. And of course, Jerome submitted to Pope Damasus
1051
00:56:14.469 --> 00:56:18.230
and included the Deuterocanonical text in the Vulgate. So even
1052
00:56:18.269 --> 00:56:21.300
Jerome doesn't really work for the Protestant case. So if
1053
00:56:21.320 --> 00:56:23.539
we're going to have this idea that there must be
1054
00:56:23.599 --> 00:56:28.039
written evidence of a doctrine before it's some required belief
1055
00:56:28.199 --> 00:56:30.139
or something like that, that's just not going to work
1056
00:56:30.179 --> 00:56:32.769
for Protestants. And as we pointed out, it's an argument
1057
00:56:32.789 --> 00:56:37.489
from silence. It also ignores liturgical texts and the liturgical traditions,
1058
00:56:37.650 --> 00:56:40.449
which are at least so far as I'm aware, the
1059
00:56:40.489 --> 00:56:43.429
earliest are like the third century. liturgy of saint mark
1060
00:56:43.469 --> 00:56:46.449
and others which do include the idea of angels and
1061
00:56:46.510 --> 00:56:50.150
saints interceding so there is liturgical evidence protestants don't ever
1062
00:56:50.190 --> 00:56:52.139
think about liturgy as evidence i know it used to
1063
00:56:52.159 --> 00:56:54.780
be protestant no if somebody came to me with well
1064
00:56:54.820 --> 00:56:56.639
the liturgy of saint mark says blah blah blah i'd
1065
00:56:56.659 --> 00:56:59.119
be like what what are you talking about oh that's
1066
00:56:59.139 --> 00:57:01.480
uh you know of traditions of men or whatever i
1067
00:57:01.500 --> 00:57:03.639
would say but so they would just they're sort of
1068
00:57:03.659 --> 00:57:09.079
selectively um you know poisoning the well with like the
1069
00:57:09.119 --> 00:57:11.699
only types of evidence that they will accept, right? Well,
1070
00:57:11.739 --> 00:57:15.440
I will only accept written evidence for my position. It's like, well,
1071
00:57:15.639 --> 00:57:17.480
first of all, you don't have the same standard for
1072
00:57:17.500 --> 00:57:19.659
your own belief about the canon of scripture.
1073
00:57:20.539 --> 00:57:21.280
You don't have the same.
1074
00:57:21.760 --> 00:57:24.420
And that's an argument from silence because it ignores the
1075
00:57:24.500 --> 00:57:28.139
other possible types of evidences like the Hebrew tradition at
1076
00:57:28.179 --> 00:57:30.829
that time, like the liturgical tradition.
1077
00:57:30.489 --> 00:57:31.650
At that time. So it's very selective.
1078
00:57:31.670 --> 00:57:33.170
And I would add that, I mean, I think you
1079
00:57:33.190 --> 00:57:36.679
could potentially read Psalm 99 and, uh, 98, if you're
1080
00:57:36.699 --> 00:57:39.710
reading the orthodox study Bible. Um, and that was a
1081
00:57:39.730 --> 00:57:43.369
great one because it's not just the pastors that talks about, uh,
1082
00:57:43.909 --> 00:57:48.130
Moses and Aaron, uh, and Samuel are, are presently among
1083
00:57:48.170 --> 00:57:49.289
those that call upon his name.
1084
00:57:49.469 --> 00:57:51.710
It doesn't say that they once did. It says they are.
1085
00:57:52.289 --> 00:57:54.690
This is the type of reasoning that Jesus uses when
1086
00:57:54.710 --> 00:57:56.719
he's arguing with the Sadducees. He says they are alive
1087
00:57:56.760 --> 00:58:00.000
to God. They're not dead. They are alive to God. These.
1088
00:58:00.559 --> 00:58:04.159
And so David progresses in that Psalm. And then he says, uh,
1089
00:58:06.639 --> 00:58:08.760
you could read it as he's speaking to the entire
1090
00:58:08.780 --> 00:58:16.010
liturgical congregation or also to the heavenly saints, you righteous people,
1091
00:58:16.070 --> 00:58:21.309
you people of God, including Moses, Aaron, Samuel, exalt him,
1092
00:58:21.570 --> 00:58:22.289
pray to him.
1093
00:58:23.090 --> 00:58:24.090
So you could read that.
1094
00:58:24.030 --> 00:58:28.539
One also as specifically referring to previous generations of holy men.
1095
00:58:29.639 --> 00:58:31.219
And so in other words, the fact that we don't
1096
00:58:31.260 --> 00:58:35.980
have every generation explicitly having a reference to Every single
1097
00:58:36.019 -->
00:58:38.099
person that was righteous in the previous generation is a
1098
00:58:38.139 --> 00:58:39.440
ridiculous requirement.
1099
00:58:40.579 --> 00:58:42.369
I think it's interesting you brought up Polycarp. I'm going
1100
00:58:42.389 --> 00:58:45.750
to bring it on the screen here. Look what they
1101
00:58:45.769 --> 00:58:49.449
did to the bones after Polycarp was martyred. The centurion
1102
00:58:49.489 --> 00:58:52.909
damned the strife, excited by the Jews, placed the body
1103
00:58:52.929 --> 00:58:55.019
in the midst of the fire, consumed it accordingly. We
1104
00:58:55.159 --> 00:58:58.360
afterwards took up his bones, being more precious, the most
1105
00:58:58.500 --> 00:59:03.420
exquisite jewels, more purified than gold, deposited them to a
1106
00:59:03.460 --> 00:59:07.280
fitting place. With her being gathered together as opportunity has
1107
00:59:07.340 --> 00:59:09.710
allowed us with joy and rejoicing, the Lord shall grant
1108
00:59:09.730 --> 00:59:12.739
us to celebrate the anniversary of his martyrdom, but the
1109
00:59:12.800 --> 00:59:16.219
memory of those who have already finished their course and
1110
00:59:16.239 --> 00:59:18.940
for the exercising of preparation for those yet to walk
1111
00:59:19.000 --> 00:59:21.760
in the steps. All right. So we see a practice very,
1112
00:59:21.780 --> 00:59:24.750
very early on with relics of the martyrs and that
1113
00:59:24.789 --> 00:59:28.050
they would actually put them in a place and every
1114
00:59:28.090 --> 00:59:34.389
anniversary of their martyrdom, celebrate. That practice is not just
1115
00:59:34.429 --> 00:59:39.500
some new, created, brand new, out of nowhere. What do
1116
00:59:39.539 --> 00:59:43.039
they think they were doing with those relics, those bones?
1117
00:59:43.059 --> 00:59:45.599
And we see a continuity of this. I mean, even
1118
00:59:45.639 --> 00:59:48.789
Augustine talks about when they found St. Stephen's bones in
1119
00:59:48.869 --> 00:59:51.650
City of God and all the miracles that were happening.
1120
00:59:51.710 --> 00:59:54.420
They put a shrine together. And then he was actually
1121
00:59:54.480 --> 00:59:57.260
changing his homilies based on miracles that were happening where
1122
00:59:57.280 --> 01:00:00.440
people were going to the shrine, asking for the intercession
1123
01:00:00.480 --> 01:00:04.119
of St. Stephen. Where did Augustine get that? Well, he
1124
01:00:04.159 --> 01:00:06.530
got from the same tradition that led people to do
1125
01:00:06.570 --> 01:00:09.949
this with the bones of polycarp. I mean, they didn't
1126
01:00:09.969 --> 01:00:12.769
just keep the bones around, put it in a nice
1127
01:00:12.869 --> 01:00:16.630
little small spot. No, they actually decorated. They actually celebrated.
1128
01:00:16.710 --> 01:00:18.630
And they would bring them out once a year. And
1129
01:00:18.670 --> 01:00:21.369
then they would process. And all of these things that
1130
01:00:21.389 --> 01:00:26.010
are going on, To bring that example up on the
1131
01:00:26.050 --> 01:00:28.750
screen to me is problematic because we already see the
1132
01:00:28.789 --> 01:00:32.800
veneration of relics, which we know the continuity of that
1133
01:00:32.880 --> 01:00:39.119
practice involved invocation to the saint that's being venerated. So
1134
01:00:39.420 --> 01:00:43.500
I don't understand. You can't disconnect those two things. Am
1135
01:00:43.559 --> 01:00:45.840
I overstating my case on the idea?
1136
01:00:45.949 --> 01:00:49.550
I believe it's pretty well known that ancient Jewish prayer
1137
01:00:49.590 --> 01:00:54.309
books from these time periods as well the same idea
1138
01:00:54.469 --> 01:00:57.550
of going to the tomb of a righteous man and
1139
01:00:57.690 --> 01:00:58.969
asking for intercession as well.
1140
01:01:00.219 --> 01:01:04.519
Yeah, in fact, there's a Jewish tradition of Jacob burying
1141
01:01:04.679 --> 01:01:09.719
Rachel very, very close to the pilgrimage highway where people
1142
01:01:09.760 --> 01:01:13.260
could actually walk by her bones. In fact, I'm going
1143
01:01:13.300 --> 01:01:15.750
to find that. Alex, did you mention that one too?
1144
01:01:15.769 --> 01:01:20.610
I mentioned that in my debate with JP Uncut over
1145
01:01:20.630 --> 01:01:22.210
this topic.
1146
01:01:22.639 --> 01:01:24.480
Oh, he's been all about you the last two weeks,
1147
01:01:24.539 --> 01:01:24.960
by the way.
1148
01:01:26.460 --> 01:01:28.320
Yeah, it's a little it's a little weird. He's got
1149
01:01:28.360 --> 01:01:30.800
a bit of a fixation there, it seems. But, you know,
1150
01:01:31.239 --> 01:01:34.199
some people, you know, JP, go debate someone else. You
1151
01:01:34.219 --> 01:01:36.719
got to get over it, man. Anyway, I did make
1152
01:01:36.760 --> 01:01:39.070
mention to that. That is a tradition within, you know,
1153
01:01:40.210 --> 01:01:43.329
referencing rabbis from, you know, the 300s A.D. that are
1154
01:01:43.349 --> 01:01:46.710
talking about this as if it's already a longstanding tradition
1155
01:01:47.030 --> 01:01:47.889
referencing Jeremiah.
1156
01:01:47.909 --> 01:01:48.110
Yeah.
1157
01:01:48.730 --> 01:01:52.710
And also, these are the Jewish commentaries on that Talmudic
1158
01:01:52.869 --> 01:01:55.670
passage as well. Not only is it a sighting to
1159
01:01:55.710 --> 01:01:59.530
a rabbi from the 300s, these contemporary Jewish scholars also
1160
01:01:59.570 --> 01:02:02.050
think that's an invocation of Rachel.
1161
01:02:03.230 --> 01:02:07.519
Yeah, so right here is the tradition, Rachel seeks mercy
1162
01:02:07.539 --> 01:02:10.239
for the exiles. Jacob foresaw that the exiles would pass
1163
01:02:10.320 --> 01:02:14.239
by there. Hence, he buried her there so that she
1164
01:02:14.320 --> 01:02:19.019
might seek mercy there. And then the next slide after that,
1165
01:02:20.260 --> 01:02:23.139
so that people would be able to identify the spot
1166
01:02:23.320 -->
01:02:28.260
and pray there. And they tie this into the prophet Jeremiah,
1167
01:02:28.739 --> 01:02:31.820
where it talks about Rachel weeping for her children and
1168
01:02:31.840 --> 01:02:36.690
then repeated in the gospel of Matthew. So what that
1169
01:02:36.769 --> 01:02:40.329
means is in the minds of these second temple Jews is,
1170
01:02:40.889 --> 01:02:43.900
they didn't think that Rachel weeping for her children was
1171
01:02:43.940 --> 01:02:46.599
some figurative language, like in the sense of like, Oh,
1172
01:02:46.619 --> 01:02:50.219
well that's just a really cool concept of hypothetically Rachel
1173
01:02:50.280 --> 01:02:52.699
would have cried. Had she seen this guy? No, they
1174
01:02:52.760 --> 01:02:57.559
actually think that she is, they believe that Jacob buried
1175
01:02:57.599 --> 01:03:01.179
her in a very open highway spot where a lot
1176
01:03:01.219 --> 01:03:05.730
of pilgrims are going to pass. So that right here,
1177
01:03:06.610 --> 01:03:10.349
the exiles would pass there and see the burial and,
1178
01:03:10.960 --> 01:03:16.320
And so that she might seek mercy for them. Well,
1179
01:03:16.579 --> 01:03:19.139
doesn't that involve invocation somewhere if you're going to be
1180
01:03:19.159 --> 01:03:23.449
getting mercy at her request? And then people would be
1181
01:03:23.510 --> 01:03:27.010
able to identify the spot and pray there for that mercy.
1182
01:03:27.510 --> 01:03:29.670
And then when we see where the children of Israel
1183
01:03:29.690 --> 01:03:33.090
are being slaughtered, these young babies are being slaughtered, she's
1184
01:03:33.650 --> 01:03:36.780
not hypothetically weeping. I think there's probably an element where
1185
01:03:36.820 --> 01:03:40.679
there's real tears and she's very, very aware of what's happening.
1186
01:03:41.219 --> 01:03:44.090
all the way to when Jesus was born, and we
1187
01:03:44.130 --> 01:03:47.789
see Matthew repeat this same language. Is this what we're
1188
01:03:47.809 --> 01:03:50.050
talking about, gentlemen? Is this kind of what we're getting at?
1189
01:03:51.250 --> 01:03:55.449
Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, that's a very important feast in the
1190
01:03:55.469 --> 01:03:58.110
Orthodox Church. Absolutely. The slaughter of the innocents.
1191
01:03:58.329 --> 01:03:58.510
Yeah.
1192
01:03:59.269 --> 01:04:00.750
Can you explain that a little bit for those that
1193
01:04:00.829 --> 01:04:01.510
don't know, Jay?
1194
01:04:02.369 --> 01:04:08.199
Well, just because there's a repeated archetypal structure of, in
1195
01:04:08.500 --> 01:04:11.989
egypt the persecution and murder of the innocence of the
1196
01:04:12.030 --> 01:04:15.309
firstborn in that same pattern herod is another type of
1197
01:04:15.510 --> 01:04:18.650
pharaoh he's a type of antichrist who seeks to stamp
1198
01:04:18.710 --> 01:04:22.150
out the messianic you know lineage by murdering uh the
1199
01:04:22.170 --> 01:04:23.869
firstborn to try to get rid of you know the
1200
01:04:23.929 --> 01:04:26.519
seed and so herod you know is impelled to do
1201
01:04:26.559 --> 01:04:28.679
the same type of thing to stamp out the messianic
1202
01:04:28.739 --> 01:04:33.159
lineage and so um my understanding is i've always it's
1203
01:04:33.179 --> 01:04:35.800
always been sort of grafted into our minds that these
1204
01:04:35.960 --> 01:04:40.469
innocence are by extension also saints these these children are
1205
01:04:40.510 --> 01:04:44.179
saints in our orthodox liturgical tradition and so they pray
1206
01:04:44.219 --> 01:04:47.119
for us and so it just seems logical and natural
1207
01:04:47.159 --> 01:04:49.519
that rachel would also be engaged in that same type
1208
01:04:49.539 --> 01:04:54.090
of intercession that's cool that is so cool also too
1209
01:04:54.119 --> 01:04:57.230
i forgot to mention i forgot the the psalm 99
1210
01:04:57.230 --> 01:04:59.449
is great not just for that idea of moses and
1211
01:04:59.809 --> 01:05:03.900
sam samuel praying but Shout out to David Erhan because
1212
01:05:03.940 --> 01:05:06.780
he pointed out that if you read the original, it
1213
01:05:06.820 --> 01:05:10.780
actually says, worship his footstool. And if we're going to Protestants,
1214
01:05:11.019 --> 01:05:14.219
it literally says, worship the footstool, which of course is
1215
01:05:14.260 --> 01:05:17.840
referring to the temple and the Ark and the presence
1216
01:05:17.949 --> 01:05:20.650
of God over the Ark of the Covenant. But it's
1217
01:05:20.670 --> 01:05:25.030
telling us, worship the Ark, right? So unless Protestants want
1218
01:05:25.050 --> 01:05:30.010
to be ridiculous, clearly there's a veneration principle there for
1219
01:05:30.090 --> 01:05:33.550
created objects. So even within the passage where we're talking
1220
01:05:33.590 --> 01:05:37.070
about intercession of righteous men and the divine council, we
1221
01:05:37.110 --> 01:05:40.710
also have a statement of the veneration of created holy objects.
1222
01:05:41.949 --> 01:05:44.050
Yeah, and then also I think to just add on
1223
01:05:44.070 --> 01:05:47.369
to that, in Ezekiel when it says that the presence
1224
01:05:47.409 --> 01:05:49.590
of God left the temple and then they come back
1225
01:05:49.630 --> 01:05:52.730
at the time of Ezra, they rebuild it. Nothing says
1226
01:05:52.750 --> 01:05:54.889
that God's presence returned in that same way that it
1227
01:05:54.929 --> 01:05:58.630
was there prior to the destruction. But there's no asterisk
1228
01:06:01.769 --> 01:06:03.670
on that psalm anywhere that says, well, now stop doing
1229
01:06:03.710 --> 01:06:06.829
that because the way God specially manifested his presence there,
1230
01:06:06.849 --> 01:06:09.050
he's no longer doing that. They were still bowing towards
1231
01:06:09.110 --> 01:06:13.309
the temple, worshiping the footstool, regardless of whether there was
1232
01:06:13.329 --> 01:06:16.050
that special manifestation of God there or not. So
there
1233
01:06:16.090 --> 01:06:17.650
is already an iconic principle.
1234
01:06:17.670 --> 01:06:20.349
They'll say you only do that when the theophany is there,
1235
01:06:20.429 --> 01:06:22.849
which doesn't say that. By the way, in Joshua, when
1236
01:06:22.889 --> 01:06:24.630
they bow before the ark in the temple, it doesn't
1237
01:06:24.690 --> 01:06:26.369
say that the theophany is present.
1238
01:06:26.869 --> 01:06:27.070
Right.
1239
01:06:27.409 --> 01:06:31.500
Yeah, and they laid prostrate all the evening long. with
1240
01:06:31.539 --> 01:06:33.690
all the elders right in front of the Ark of the,
1241
01:06:34.079 --> 01:06:37.119
I'm just saying, I mean, either that's idolatry or veneration.
1242
01:06:37.219 --> 01:06:41.519
I'm just saying, uh, we'll save ourselves from going down
1243
01:06:41.539 --> 01:06:43.519
a rabbit trail there. I do want to point this out.
1244
01:06:43.619 --> 01:06:46.159
He actually gets Enoch wrong. Not only is he getting
1245
01:06:46.179 --> 01:06:46.860
wrong here.
1246
01:06:46.889 --> 01:06:47.610
Oh yeah.
1247
01:06:47.800 --> 01:06:50.789
He gets Enoch wrong and get your slides already, Alex.
1248
01:06:51.250 --> 01:06:54.510
He gets it wrong twice. And he even had time
1249
01:06:54.550 --> 01:06:57.329
to study the second time. So this one is, is
1250
01:06:57.530 --> 01:07:01.590
a little bit odd that, uh, He ended up getting
1251
01:07:01.710 --> 01:07:04.309
it in the video. I was surprised because all he
1252
01:07:04.329 --> 01:07:05.590
had to do is read it and see that he
1253
01:07:05.610 --> 01:07:06.190
got this wrong.
1254
01:07:06.369 --> 01:07:09.329
That person's talking to the angel. Again, that is not
1255
01:07:09.349 --> 01:07:12.880
a good proof text for having an ongoing devotional practice
1256
01:07:13.360 --> 01:07:17.360
of speaking to angels who are not locally present. And
1257
01:07:17.400 --> 01:07:20.840
number three, you could have texts dealing with people going
1258
01:07:20.940 --> 01:07:24.440
to heaven and then speaking with people while locally themselves
1259
01:07:24.519 --> 01:07:28.400
present in heaven. Like in 1 Enoch, when Methuselah actually
1260
01:07:28.559 --> 01:07:31.880
goes to Enoch, who is not deceased, but he's been
1261
01:07:31.920 --> 01:07:35.250
translated to heaven. And of course, Methuselah can speak to him.
1262
01:07:35.650 --> 01:07:38.690
If God transports you to heaven, like Paul in 2 Corinthians,
1263
01:07:39.150 --> 01:07:41.329
of course you can talk to people there. But that's
1264
01:07:41.349 --> 01:07:44.190
not a good proof text for establishing that people who
1265
01:07:44.309 --> 01:07:45.409
are still on earth.
1266
01:07:46.070 --> 01:07:48.159
I just think these rules are made up as they go.
1267
01:07:48.179 --> 01:07:53.079
He can go here. If they're on earth with you,
1268
01:07:53.139 --> 01:07:55.420
it's cool. If you're in heaven with them, it's cool.
1269
01:07:56.269 --> 01:08:00.349
They can pray for you on earth. So you can have, again, heaven,
1270
01:08:00.409 --> 01:08:03.530
earth is okay. Heaven, heaven, okay. Earth, earth, okay. You
1271
01:08:03.550 --> 01:08:05.989
can talk to an angel and all these things, but
1272
01:08:06.650 --> 01:08:10.019
it's just that one arrow pointing up you can't do.
1273
01:08:11.179 --> 01:08:14.559
That's number one. Just hearing that explained again, it gets
1274
01:08:14.639 --> 01:08:17.300
worse every time. Second, that's not what the text says.
1275
01:08:18.840 --> 01:08:21.560
The text does not say he was transported into heaven
1276
01:08:22.319 --> 01:08:26.300
and had a conversation with like Paul being taken into
1277
01:08:26.319 --> 01:08:29.680
the third heaven. Alex, tell us what the text actually says,
1278
01:08:29.720 --> 01:08:30.500
because it's not what it says.
1279
01:08:31.479 --> 01:08:34.100
Yeah. So the way Gavin delivered this so confidently, I
1280
01:08:34.149 --> 01:08:36.710
started questioning myself. I said, did I misread the text?
1281
01:08:36.750 --> 01:08:40.010
Was there like, is my translation off here? So I
1282
01:08:40.069 --> 01:08:43.449
reread the text and then I contacted father, Dr. Stephen DeYoung,
1283
01:08:43.510 --> 01:08:47.449
who he has his PhD in second temple period is
1284
01:08:47.949 --> 01:08:51.119
his area. The second temple period is his area of expertise.
1285
01:08:52.180 --> 01:08:54.579
He's very familiar with these texts. I said, father, Stephen,
1286
01:08:55.140 --> 01:08:57.960
Am I reading this wrong? Like, what is going on here?
1287
01:08:58.539 --> 01:09:01.739
Father Stephen, who this is, his doctoral area of expertise,
1288
01:09:01.779 --> 01:09:05.119
agrees with me on how to understand this passage. It says,
1289
01:09:05.600 --> 01:09:08.100
when Methuselah heard the words of his son Lamech, he
1290
01:09:08.119 --> 01:09:11.100
came to me, Enoch, to the ends of the earth,
1291
01:09:11.539 --> 01:09:13.539
for he had heard that I was there, and he
1292
01:09:13.600 --> 01:09:15.819
cried aloud, and I heard his voice, and I came
1293
01:09:15.880 --> 01:09:18.060
to him. I said unto him, Behold, here I am,
1294
01:09:18.100 --> 01:09:21.319
my son, wherefore hast thou come to me? Prior to that,
1295
01:09:21.739 --> 01:09:24.569
it says that Enoch is in the realm of the angels.
1296
01:09:24.649 --> 01:09:27.350
He's dwelling with the angels. So what we see here
1297
01:09:27.489 --> 01:09:30.010
is you have to understand also ancient cosmology at this
1298
01:09:30.050 --> 01:09:34.420
point to understand what these terms mean. So this might
1299
01:09:34.460 --> 01:09:37.579
trigger some people. In the Bible, in ancient cosmology, they
1300
01:09:37.640 --> 01:09:41.039
saw the earth as a disc that had a dome
1301
01:09:41.159 --> 01:09:43.039
over the top of it. So when they're talking about
1302
01:09:43.079 --> 01:09:45.560
the ends of the earth, literally as you get closer
1303
01:09:45.619 -->
01:09:48.270
to the ends of the earth, you are closer to
1304
01:09:48.329 --> 01:09:51.850
where that dome is. where the heavens meet the earth, right?
1305
01:09:51.869 --> 01:09:54.069
So the fact that you were getting closer to the
1306
01:09:54.130 --> 01:09:56.170
ends of the earth, it's just referring to going to
1307
01:09:56.229 --> 01:09:59.510
some remote area, to like some high mountain that brings
1308
01:09:59.550 --> 01:10:02.390
you higher to the heavens, or some desert or some
1309
01:10:02.609 --> 01:10:05.329
island somewhere. It's not saying that you went to heaven.
1310
01:10:05.510 --> 01:10:08.319
And you see this in the book of Acts as well,
1311
01:10:08.380 --> 01:10:11.340
when Jesus says that you will be my witnesses in Jerusalem,
1312
01:10:11.659 --> 01:10:15.060
all Judea, Samaria, to the ends of the earth. It
1313
01:10:15.079 --> 01:10:17.420
doesn't say He's not saying that they're going to be,
1314
01:10:17.439 --> 01:10:20.199
you know, Christ's witnesses in heavens. He's in the heavens.
1315
01:10:20.239 --> 01:10:25.119
He's talking about their missionary journey throughout Jerusalem, Judea, Samaria,
1316
01:10:25.189 --> 01:10:29.010
and all the remote areas of the earth. So ends
1317
01:10:29.050 --> 01:10:31.529
of the earth is a well-known phrase that just refers
1318
01:10:31.590 --> 01:10:34.090
to remote areas of the planet, right? It's like a
1319
01:10:34.130 --> 01:10:36.449
form of asceticism to go out into the desert and
1320
01:10:36.470 --> 01:10:39.350
to see these, to be able to get closer to God,
1321
01:10:39.390 --> 01:10:42.289
to get rid of distractions. So the way to understand
1322
01:10:42.329 --> 01:10:45.510
this passage is that Methuselah goes to some remote area
1323
01:10:45.569 --> 01:10:48.069
to call out to Enoch. Enoch is dwelling in the
1324
01:10:48.109 --> 01:10:52.279
realm of the angels. Enoch hears Methuselah. And in response
1325
01:10:52.319 --> 01:10:56.300
to that, he descends down and they meet at this intersection,
1326
01:10:56.380 --> 01:10:59.399
this like inflection point of heaven and earth. And that's
1327
01:10:59.439 --> 01:11:02.649
what that's the way to understand it. Enoch descends to Methuselah.
1328
01:11:02.899 --> 01:11:05.659
Methuselah is not translated to heaven. And I'm not sure
1329
01:11:05.699 --> 01:11:07.699
where he got that from. I'm not sure if there
1330
01:11:07.729 --> 01:11:10.670
was a secondary source he's relying on that I'm not
1331
01:11:10.750 --> 01:11:16.270
aware of. But every mainstream source understands this in this way.
1332
01:11:16.369 --> 01:11:20.380
That Enoch descended down from the heavens to Methuselah. So
1333
01:11:20.409 --> 01:11:22.840
that he just got completely wrong.
1334
01:11:23.720 --> 01:11:29.319
But he didn't back down. Because we've got your whole...
1335
01:11:29.399 --> 01:11:31.979
This is fresh off the press. This is yesterday.
1336
01:11:32.770 --> 01:11:32.979
I mean.
1337
01:11:34.210 --> 01:11:36.630
Alex, I've never seen you so startled before. You were,
1338
01:11:36.729 --> 01:11:39.329
you couldn't even pump a tank of gas. I mean,
1339
01:11:39.430 --> 01:11:42.989
you're sitting there like video chatting with me or audio
1340
01:11:43.010 --> 01:11:44.850
chatting with me through text. You're like, I don't even,
1341
01:11:44.979 --> 01:11:47.140
this stupid thing won't even work. I'm so mad right now.
1342
01:11:47.180 --> 01:11:49.020
Like you couldn't even get, you couldn't even pump gas.
1343
01:11:49.460 --> 01:11:54.340
I mean, so what happened? Because he speaks to the
1344
01:11:54.439 --> 01:11:58.420
Enoch situation and, and, and it gets worse, not better, worse.
1345
01:11:59.880 --> 01:12:02.329
Yeah it's true so that particular passage didn't come up
1346
01:12:02.350 --> 01:12:04.970
but he's talking about first enoch chapter nine here and
1347
01:12:04.989 --> 01:12:07.010
i guess there was a little back and forth prior
1348
01:12:07.029 --> 01:12:08.770
to that i guess if you guys are interested you
1349
01:12:08.789 --> 01:12:11.850
guys can zoom in and read this basically here he
1350
01:12:11.909 --> 01:12:15.670
says that uh i am misunderstanding larry hurtado which i
1351
01:12:15.689 --> 01:12:18.100
guess at some point we'll get to this is entirely
1352
01:12:18.140 --> 01:12:21.079
a non-sequitur which i explained on a stream on my
1353
01:12:21.119 --> 01:12:22.539
channel if you guys want to learn more you guys
1354
01:12:22.560 --> 01:12:25.479
can go watch that uh basically i called him a
1355
01:12:25.520 --> 01:12:28.399
liar here i said he misrepresented a bunch of scholarship
1356
01:12:28.479 --> 01:12:31.920
which I think he did. And, you know, I, I'm
1357
01:12:31.939 --> 01:12:35.010
not the only one who believes that anymore. Uh, the
1358
01:12:35.050 --> 01:12:39.229
part in question is, uh, first Enoch nine, where you
1359
01:12:39.270 --> 01:12:40.989
have this, it says that the.
1360
01:12:40.949 --> 01:12:41.750
Souls of men.
1361
01:12:41.770 --> 01:12:45.390
So the men on earth were, uh, they were abused
1362
01:12:45.449 --> 01:12:48.329
by these fallen angels. The fallen angels are running amok
1363
01:12:48.689 --> 01:12:52.270
on earth. They're causing all this damage, whatever their people
1364
01:12:52.310 --> 01:12:55.409
being unalived. Uh, and it says that the souls of
1365
01:12:55.470 --> 01:13:00.069
men called out to the archangels, uh, Gabriel, Michael, Raphael,
1366
01:13:00.130 --> 01:13:03.510
and Uriel, and ask them to bring their petitions to
1367
01:13:03.569 --> 01:13:06.569
the Most High God. And I have in my response
1368
01:13:06.590 --> 01:13:12.770
video to Gavin, a Baptist scholar, Dr. Hübscher, who says
1369
01:13:12.829 --> 01:13:15.850
that in this passage, it is clear that the petitions
1370
01:13:16.109 --> 01:13:19.479
are to be made to the archangels in like some
1371
01:13:19.520 --> 01:13:22.260
sort of priestly fashion, and that the archangels
are supposed
1372
01:13:22.300 --> 01:13:25.409
to bring those petitions to the Most High God. So
1373
01:13:25.430 --> 01:13:28.170
this is not just me saying that. This is also
1374
01:13:28.329 --> 01:13:32.350
an evangelical scholar who agrees with me on this, and
1375
01:13:32.989 --> 01:13:35.810
numerous Orthodox scholars that would also agree with me on this.
1376
01:13:36.479 --> 01:13:40.760
So Gavin's objection here, where he's interpreting 1 Enoch 9
1377
01:13:40.760 --> 01:13:45.000
to have some distinction between earth and heaven or Sheol
1378
01:13:45.140 --> 01:13:49.220
and heaven, it doesn't really make sense because he's saying that, yes,
1379
01:13:49.220 --> 01:13:52.149
1 Enoch 9 is an attestation to souls in Sheol
1380
01:13:52.199 --> 01:13:54.149
being able to call out to the archangels in heaven.
1381
01:13:54.539 --> 01:13:57.520
But it's not appropriate for souls on earth to do that.
1382
01:13:58.000 --> 01:14:00.880
And then there was also this Ryan Beamish guy who had,
1383
01:14:01.319 --> 01:14:03.560
I think, a productive comment as well, who said that
1384
01:14:03.600 --> 01:14:06.850
if you're reading 1 Enoch 8, it's not very clear
1385
01:14:06.930 --> 01:14:09.189
that these are the souls of men that have reposed,
1386
01:14:09.229 --> 01:14:10.470
that have gone to Sheol.
1387
01:14:10.569 --> 01:14:11.550
I agree with him on that.
1388
01:14:11.590 --> 01:14:15.170
Yeah, it's very much an open option that these are
1389
01:14:15.189 --> 01:14:17.770
the men, as they are dying, that they are calling
1390
01:14:17.829 --> 01:14:20.350
out to God, that they are calling out to the archangels,
1391
01:14:21.600 --> 01:14:24.300
to bring their petition to God to save them and
1392
01:14:24.319 --> 01:14:27.899
to have vengeance on these fallen angels. So he is
1393
01:14:28.000 --> 01:14:32.380
like really, really misapplying and misinterpreting these ancient texts. And
1394
01:14:32.399 --> 01:14:35.460
they're in such a weird way that he's reading these.
1395
01:14:36.079 --> 01:14:38.460
It wouldn't be intuitive to anyone. And even when you
1396
01:14:38.479 --> 01:14:42.800
take a heightened scrutiny to it by scholarly standards, he
1397
01:14:42.840 --> 01:14:45.720
doesn't even meet those readings either. They are very unusual.
1398
01:14:45.920 --> 01:14:48.020
And it's just all the telltale signs of him trying
1399
01:14:48.039 --> 01:14:49.810
to fit a square peg in a round hole, trying
1400
01:14:49.819 --> 01:14:51.090
to make his view work where it doesn't.
1401
01:14:51.939 --> 01:14:55.640
Yeah, I would think it's harder to do invocation from
1402
01:14:55.760 --> 01:14:59.340
Sheol than it would be from Earth.
1403
01:15:00.079 --> 01:15:00.659
One would think.
1404
01:15:01.800 --> 01:15:04.090
Now, Jay, I shared on the screen here one of
1405
01:15:04.119 --> 01:15:07.270
the links that you have. I'll have to zoom in
1406
01:15:07.310 --> 01:15:10.689
on some of it. But you shared, you want to
1407
01:15:10.829 --> 01:15:13.510
walk us through this human and angelic prayer in light
1408
01:15:13.529 --> 01:15:14.350
of the Dead Sea Scrolls?
1409
01:15:15.000 --> 01:15:18.229
Yeah, this one is interesting because it ties in very closely.
1410
01:15:18.399 --> 01:15:20.250
It's not a very long paper. I recommend that I
1411
01:15:20.289 --> 01:15:23.069
read it earlier today. It ties in with what we
1412
01:15:23.090 --> 01:15:26.170
were talking about with angelic liturgy, and it begins by
1413
01:15:26.210 --> 01:15:31.390
talking about Psalm 148, where you have the invocation of
1414
01:15:31.689 --> 01:15:35.449
the angels specifically, as well as all of creation, to
1415
01:15:35.560 --> 01:15:39.119
participate in the divine liturgy. And this is very important
1416
01:15:39.140 --> 01:15:41.850
because one of the big missing elements here that the
1417
01:15:41.890 --> 01:15:45.789
Protestants don't understand when they hear these passages or when
1418
01:15:45.829 --> 01:15:48.550
we cite these passages or they don't.
1419
01:15:48.430 --> 01:15:49.829
Understand the context, right?
1420
01:15:49.869 --> 01:15:53.949
Because Protestants are thinking about these as doctrinal theological proof
1421
01:15:53.970 --> 01:15:59.670
text manuals. Psalm 148 is a liturgical celebration. So this
1422
01:15:59.729 --> 01:16:02.850
is within the temple liturgy that these, most of these
1423
01:16:02.869 --> 01:16:05.689
Psalms are constructed to be sung as part of the
1424
01:16:05.729 --> 01:16:08.539
worship service and And that's very important because it's not
1425
01:16:08.579 --> 01:16:12.880
just about theological disputations and standing at the pulpit and teaching.
1426
01:16:13.659 --> 01:16:18.430
It's what is the heavenly cosmic liturgy? And this paper
1427
01:16:18.510 --> 01:16:22.810
is arguing that the context of those passages, as understood
1428
01:16:22.869 --> 01:16:31.510
by various Qumran community theological scrolls and whatnot, is liturgical celebrations.
1429
01:16:31.850 --> 01:16:35.899
And that's because they understood, as the Hebrew tradition understood,
1430
01:16:36.079 --> 01:16:41.460
the whole universe is actually a giant cosmic liturgical service, right?
1431
01:16:41.699 --> 01:16:43.359
St. Maximus makes a big.
1432
01:16:43.220 --> 01:16:47.479
Deal of this with his cosmic theology when he talks
1433
01:16:47.560 --> 01:16:53.789
about Christology really being the renovation and rejuvenation source of
1434
01:16:53.810 --> 01:16:56.850
the entire cosmos. So it's a very cosmic scope of
1435
01:16:56.909 --> 01:17:00.350
Christ's natural resurrection. But it's not just theological, it's a
1436
01:17:00.409 --> 01:17:05.369
liturgical presentation and implementation. So this paper talks about how
1437
01:17:05.449 --> 01:17:08.449
important it is, not just in like Psalm 148, but
1438
01:17:08.489 --> 01:17:12.029
it goes into the song of the three youths with
1439
01:17:12.069 --> 01:17:18.220
Daniel when
Daniel says, praise him all angels in the firmament.
1440
01:17:19.020 --> 01:17:21.399
So in other words, he's speaking to the angels saying,
1441
01:17:22.340 --> 01:17:25.420
bless the Lord, which blessing by the way, this also
1442
01:17:25.460 --> 01:17:30.340
can be prayers. So it's not just there's also prayer
1443
01:17:30.359 --> 01:17:35.119
that's part of this liturgical tradition. But the idea is, again,
1444
01:17:35.159 --> 01:17:38.880
in this example, that the earthly realm and the heavenly
1445
01:17:38.939 --> 01:17:42.260
realm come together at a certain appointed time because the
1446
01:17:42.319 --> 01:17:45.659
times and the seasons are determined liturgically. And on those
1447
01:17:45.729 --> 01:17:48.810
appointed times, particularly here, they're talking about the Sabbath, right?
1448
01:17:48.850 --> 01:17:51.550
But that can apply also to the other Jewish feasts
1449
01:17:51.609 --> 01:17:55.409
and Sabbaths where there's a time appointed for holy things
1450
01:17:55.449 --> 01:17:58.750
to be set aside, holy days, right? that's when there's
1451
01:17:58.789 --> 01:18:01.710
this meeting point of heaven and earth in a special way, right?
1452
01:18:01.750 --> 01:18:03.750
It's not that we don't have contact with God outside
1453
01:18:03.770 --> 01:18:05.729
of the liturgy, but there's a special presence.
1454
01:18:06.529 --> 01:18:08.569
And this is so important because Protestants.
1455
01:18:08.170 --> 01:18:12.020
Don't understand that we still have this idea of holy
1456
01:18:12.100 --> 01:18:14.640
places and holy times in the New Testament.
1457
01:18:14.680 --> 01:18:17.319
They think that that's all sort of Old Testament.
1458
01:18:16.899 --> 01:18:21.699
Stuff, and now all that's privatized to my individual devotional status.
1459
01:18:21.840 --> 01:18:22.239
No, no, no.
1460
01:18:22.590 --> 01:18:25.229
There's still, in the New Testament, Peter calls it the
1461
01:18:25.310 --> 01:18:29.300
holy mountain of transfiguration. why is Peter calling a mountain
1462
01:18:29.340 --> 01:18:32.380
holy in the New Testament if he's a Protestant? They're
1463
01:18:32.399 --> 01:18:34.609
not supposed to be holy mountains in the New Testament, right?
1464
01:18:35.310 --> 01:18:37.409
And there's other examples, right? We have the pool of
1465
01:18:37.449 --> 01:18:41.010
Bethesda or the pool of Siloam, or the pool where
1466
01:18:41.090 --> 01:18:42.550
the angel, you know, starts the water.
1467
01:18:42.609 --> 01:18:43.710
Yeah, John's gone.
1468
01:18:43.750 --> 01:18:48.119
Yeah, so we've got these examples of holy places, holy objects, right?
1469
01:18:48.199 --> 01:18:50.800
We know about those passages, but it's all within the
1470
01:18:50.840 --> 01:18:55.960
context of a liturgical mindset where there are specific days
1471
01:18:56.020 --> 01:18:59.500
and times that the angels and the men meet together
1472
01:18:59.819 --> 01:19:04.229
to worship and serve the Lord. But it's also not
1473
01:19:04.270 --> 01:19:07.970
just worship and intercessional. That's also a courtly judgment that occurs.
1474
01:19:08.090 --> 01:19:11.590
Every liturgy is also a judgment. That's also part of
1475
01:19:11.609 --> 01:19:14.609
this tradition. Anyway, I'm rambling, but this paper is basically, again,
1476
01:19:14.689 --> 01:19:19.970
just illustrating stuff that's just obvious, right, with all the
1477
01:19:20.329 --> 01:19:24.850
Hebrew tradition. It's just bizarre that the Protestants ignore all this.
1478
01:19:24.930 --> 01:19:27.590
They don't understand the liturgical context. They just think of
1479
01:19:27.649 --> 01:19:30.989
all this as, well, it's just theological disputations. No, it's
1480
01:19:31.390 --> 01:19:32.310
liturgical context.
1481
01:19:32.590 --> 01:19:33.229
That's what you're missing.
1482
01:19:34.029 --> 01:19:38.310
Yeah, and we know that Gavin... tried to address these
1483
01:19:38.489 --> 01:19:43.949
as well as Hippolytus on poetic apostrophe so this got
1484
01:19:44.010 --> 01:19:47.649
hand waved it's poetic apostrophe now.
1485
01:19:47.430 --> 01:19:49.789
Alex well could you can you because I watched about
1486
01:19:49.789 --> 01:19:52.310
40 minutes of the responses that you guys have done
1487
01:19:52.550 --> 01:19:54.649
um so I didn't what does he mean by that
1488
01:19:54.829 --> 01:19:57.399
hand wave there go ahead Alex you had a three-point
1489
01:19:57.439 --> 01:19:58.060
outline on it.
1490
01:19:58.619 --> 01:20:01.199
Yeah, when he's talking about poetic apostrophe, it's like that
1491
01:20:01.239 --> 01:20:05.310
rhetorical device that you'll see when St. Paul says, like, death,
1492
01:20:05.369 --> 01:20:07.510
where is your sting? Or when Juliet says at the
1493
01:20:07.529 --> 01:20:09.829
end of Romeo and Juliet, like, oh, dagger, this is
1494
01:20:09.869 --> 01:20:12.869
thy sheath. She's not expecting the dagger to come back
1495
01:20:13.229 --> 01:20:15.810
to respond to her. He's saying that this is just
1496
01:20:15.880 --> 01:20:19.439
a rhetorical device and that there's not really any meaning
1497
01:20:19.520 --> 01:20:22.300
attached to it. They're not expecting a response from the
1498
01:20:22.460 --> 01:20:24.939
angels or the sun, moon, and stars or from the
1499
01:20:25.000 --> 01:20:28.239
mountains or the winds. Or this stuff that he's saying,
1500
01:20:28.279 --> 01:20:29.300
it's just poetry.
1501
01:20:29.359 --> 01:20:29.800
No, no, no.
1502
01:20:29.880 --> 01:20:32.060
Well, see, here's the thing is that all these past,
1503
01:20:32.140 --> 01:20:35.560
all this, the scholarship will point out that the Hebrew
1504
01:20:35.699 --> 01:20:38.659
understanding of the cosmos and the universe is that it
1505
01:20:38.739 --> 01:20:42.600
is governed by the angelic hierarchies. Those angelic hierarchies are
1506
01:20:42.640 --> 01:20:47.460
in charge of the entire universe. They govern with God
1507
01:20:47.560 --> 01:20:51.140
and God's providence.
So they are apportioned various powers to
1508
01:20:51.220 --> 01:20:55.369
govern the natural world. And thus, that's why they participate
1509
01:20:55.409 --> 01:20:58.970
in this liturgical service. So that's actually completely contrary to
1510
01:20:59.010 --> 01:21:02.689
just dozens and dozens of papers at the Marquette University
1511
01:21:03.149 --> 01:21:04.909
link where they all discuss this.
1512
01:21:06.050 --> 01:21:08.560
Yeah, and numerous, even like somebody in Gavin's neck of
1513
01:21:08.569 --> 01:21:12.319
the woods, like James B. Jordan, Presbyterian scholar, he talks
1514
01:21:12.439 --> 01:21:15.800
at length about that, about how angels control the weather,
1515
01:21:15.939 --> 01:21:19.000
different elements of nature. I did a stream with Father
1516
01:21:19.020 --> 01:21:23.579
Stephen DeYoung discussing this, about this ancient cosmology. Even in
1517
01:21:23.739 --> 01:21:27.340
ancient Near East studies, just including the Israelites across the
1518
01:21:27.420 --> 01:21:29.979
ancient Near East, the way ancient people thought, there was
1519
01:21:30.100 --> 01:21:33.340
no dichotomy between the natural and spiritual world.
1520
01:21:36.260 --> 01:21:39.060
If I recall, I could be wrong about this because
1521
01:21:39.239 --> 01:21:43.060
I read Calvin's entire 1559 Institutes when I was a Calvinist.
1522
01:21:43.840 --> 01:21:46.970
I recall even Calvin says that angels were given the
1523
01:21:47.010 --> 01:21:50.289
charge of the governance of the universe under God's providence.
1524
01:21:50.350 --> 01:21:53.779
So even Calvin believed that. Yes, and you see this
1525
01:21:53.840 --> 01:21:57.560
in St. Athenagoras of Athens, you see it in St.
1526
01:21:57.600 --> 01:22:00.380
Epiphanius of Salamis, St. Gregory of Nyssa, and his great
1527
01:22:00.399 --> 01:22:04.279
catechism talks about this. It's well attested to in not
1528
01:22:04.399 --> 01:22:09.939
only the pre-incarnation Jewish tradition, it's also received by the
1529
01:22:10.020 --> 01:22:10.880
Christian Church.
1530
01:22:11.140 --> 01:22:13.420
Well, they don't understand it's a cosmic liturgy, that's why
1531
01:22:13.439 --> 01:22:14.720
I keep hammering this point.
1532
01:22:14.779 --> 01:22:15.640
It's very important.
1533
01:22:16.439 --> 01:22:22.779
That little paper that summarizes Rachel Elior's research the little
1534
01:22:22.859 --> 01:22:25.960
elior abstract text she says in that passage that all
1535
01:22:25.979 --> 01:22:28.510
of her research she's a hebrew university professor on these
1536
01:22:28.590 --> 01:22:31.829
topics and she says no again this whole this whole
1537
01:22:31.850 --> 01:22:34.970
mindset of this time period whether it's the scripture text
1538
01:22:35.010 --> 01:22:39.590
itself kumran literature uh enoch jubilees testament of levi the
1539
01:22:39.630 --> 01:22:43.079
heck a lot literature which is the chariot literature this
1540
01:22:43.100 --> 01:22:47.039
whole idea is that the entire universe is a bigger
1541
01:22:47.180 --> 01:22:51.560
macrocosm temple, right? So God's temple isn't just the earthly temple.
1542
01:22:51.600 --> 01:22:55.039
It's also ultimately intended to be not just the body
1543
01:22:55.060 --> 01:22:58.989
of Christ, not just the church, not just the physical temple,
1544
01:22:59.289 --> 01:23:03.590
but also the entire universe will in the, you know, cosmic, uh,
1545
01:23:03.670 --> 01:23:09.270
restoration recapitulation sense be, uh, restored to be the temple.
1546
01:23:09.869 --> 01:23:14.590
And so that's all of, uh, the universe is understood liturgically. Um,
1547
01:23:15.770 --> 01:23:19.800
and she says the Angela angelic liturgy, uh, the liturgy
1548
01:23:19.840 --> 01:23:23.180
of the angels is a holy ritual. It's a foundation
1549
01:23:23.279 --> 01:23:27.079
point of holy time. And it's based around, uh, of
1550
01:23:27.220 --> 01:23:29.659
course the Jewish calendar, but the angelic liturgy reflects the
1551
01:23:29.699 --> 01:23:32.319
interrelationship between the priests and the angels, as well as
1552
01:23:32.359 --> 01:23:35.199
the worship, which performed in both the heavenly and the
1553
01:23:35.239 --> 01:23:38.659
earthly temple. All these principles and concepts and values of
1554
01:23:38.699 --> 01:23:41.659
the priestly literature are concerned with the angelic. The angels
1555
01:23:41.699 --> 01:23:43.899
are depicted as the heavenly source of authority for the
1556
01:23:43.939 --> 01:23:47.380
priesthood and the eternal witnesses of the cosmic order. They
1557
01:23:47.439 --> 01:23:51.000
serve as the archetype for priestly ritual, and the priests
1558
01:23:51.149 --> 01:23:55.229
view themselves as the earthly expression of the angelic entities.
1559
01:23:55.270 --> 01:23:58.189
You'll get the same thing if you read Dionysius the Areopagite,
1560
01:23:58.829 --> 01:24:02.050
or if you read St. Germanus of Constantinople's Commentary on
1561
01:24:02.069 --> 01:24:04.659
the Divine Liturgy. It's all the same principles there. The
1562
01:24:04.699 --> 01:24:07.539
sacred calendar was the foundation of all ritual, whether performed
1563
01:24:07.579 --> 01:24:09.640
on earth or in heaven, and that was preserved and
1564
01:24:09.680 --> 01:24:11.079
enacted by these priests.
1565
01:24:11.390 --> 01:24:12.329
And angels alike.
1566
01:24:12.810 --> 01:24:15.550
This is the reason why the division of time into
1567
01:24:15.710 --> 01:24:18.949
seven daily units marked by the Holy Seventh Day is
1568
01:24:18.989 --> 01:24:22.170
the foundation of all the cosmic order. So notice reality
1569
01:24:22.210 --> 01:24:27.539
itself in the creation week is patterned on this seven-day
1570
01:24:27.619 --> 01:24:31.760
Sabbath liturgical week, and the whole world still operates on
1571
01:24:31.779 --> 01:24:33.359
this seven-day week, which to me I think is a
1572
01:24:33.829 --> 01:24:36.750
points towards creation. Uh, so we live in a world
1573
01:24:36.789 --> 01:24:39.220
created with that. Uh, I'm not saying Jewish creation that
1574
01:24:39.319 --> 01:24:42.380
I'm not being a Sabbatarian. I'm saying that the creation
1575
01:24:42.399 --> 01:24:46.300
of the world still bears the imprint of the angelic
1576
01:24:46.340 --> 01:24:50.239
liturgical cycle that she is outlining here. Anyway, she goes
1577
01:24:50.359 --> 01:24:53.369
on in this short paper called Ilior abstract, where she
1578
01:24:53.390 --> 01:24:58.029
just summarizes like that, like you can't really escape that.
1579
01:24:58.430 --> 01:25:02.289
This is the presupposition of the mindset of, of the Hebrew,
1580
01:25:02.470 --> 01:25:06.869
you know, ancient Hebrew prophets. And that's what we adopted in,
1581
01:25:07.010 --> 01:25:10.750
you know, I know you're Catholic, but the Orthodox Catholic
1582
01:25:10.789 --> 01:25:13.720
Church of the first thousand years, it is bearing this
1583
01:25:13.819 --> 01:25:18.619
same Hebrew imprint when it comes to this liturgical mindset
1584
01:25:18.640 --> 01:25:20.260
about how we view the world and the universe.
1585
01:25:21.020 --> 01:25:24.500
Yeah, I think that is tremendous because every scholar I've
1586
01:25:24.560 --> 01:25:29.829
ever read, especially in Hebrew, Aramaic, or any Hebrew poetry
1587
01:25:29.970 --> 01:25:34.220
has pointed out those elements that are connected to that
1588
01:25:34.270 --> 01:25:36.699
mindset of the Jew. I've never heard differently. So when
1589
01:25:37.159 --> 01:25:37.840
he hit.
1590
01:25:37.960 --> 01:25:39.479
One, I was going to say that can't, that can't
1591
01:25:39.520 --> 01:25:41.979
be true doc boys, because Gavin said that this is
1592
01:25:42.100 --> 01:25:43.779
unclear in the scholarship.
1593
01:25:44.359 --> 01:25:44.479
Yeah.
1594
01:25:44.500 --> 01:25:46.729
But that like, like, like Ben saying, like all the,
1595
01:25:46.770 --> 01:25:48.630
this is common. It's weird that he would even say
1596
01:25:48.649 --> 01:25:49.750
that because it's so common.
1597
01:25:50.340 --> 01:25:53.439
Well, here's an example. He took Psalm 148, I'm pretty sure.
1598
01:25:53.470 --> 01:25:56.390
And then I think you worked through Psalm 148 as well, Alex.
1599
01:25:56.510 --> 01:26:00.210
And you gave three criteria for something that has to
1600
01:26:00.250 --> 01:26:02.770
be poetic apostrophe. Can you give us the three on
1601
01:26:02.829 --> 01:26:05.869
here and then walk through 148 on the screen? Because
1602
01:26:05.890 --> 01:26:07.649
you actually see the example. So you can put to
1603
01:26:07.689 --> 01:26:12.159
practice Psalm 148 with what poetic apostrophe is supposed to
1604
01:26:12.199 --> 01:26:12.560
be doing.
1605
01:26:13.460 --> 01:26:16.960
Yeah. So poetic apostrophe applies to inanimate objects. It applies
1606
01:26:17.039 --> 01:26:21.720
to abstract concepts like abstractions these like ideas or it
1607
01:26:21.760 --> 01:26:24.420
applies to people that are like not present that couldn't
1608
01:26:24.439 --> 01:26:28.850
be present like the departed deceased people right so it
1609
01:26:28.909 --> 01:26:31.789
wouldn't apply to a person that is present and like
1610
01:26:31.850 --> 01:26:34.949
participating in the activity that would be a direct address
1611
01:26:35.409 --> 01:26:39.510
you would have to show some extraordinary circumstances for that
1612
01:26:39.569 --> 01:26:41.840
to be a poetic apostrophe where there's a person that's
1613
01:26:41.899 --> 01:26:45.289
present that's also participating in the activity right so You
1614
01:26:45.310 --> 01:26:47.649
can kind of solve this just by looking at the psalm, right?
1615
01:26:47.680 --> 01:26:49.800
So if you look at verse two, it says, praise
1616
01:26:49.840 --> 01:26:52.079
him all his angels, praise him all his hosts, right?
1617
01:26:52.100 --> 01:26:54.539
You know that the angels and the hosts, they are
1618
01:26:54.640 --> 01:27:00.340
not inanimate objects. They are intelligences. They are cosmic intelligences.
1619
01:27:01.680 --> 01:27:04.789
And they're personal in a way as well. They are
1620
01:27:04.890 --> 01:27:09.869
not abstractions. They're not abstract concepts. Again, they are intelligences.
1621
01:27:11.399 --> 01:27:15.079
and they're not absent. They are present during the liturgy
1622
01:27:15.119 --> 01:27:17.699
when this would be being sung in the temple, in
1623
01:27:17.729 --> 01:27:22.210
the tabernacle. They would be right there with the manifestation
1624
01:27:22.250 --> 01:27:24.510
of God's glory. You know, who is in the temple?
1625
01:27:24.850 --> 01:27:25.310
God.
1626
01:27:25.390 --> 01:27:28.229
Who is God surrounded by? Angels, right? So, if you
1627
01:27:28.250 --> 01:27:30.609
put yourself in the shoes of, like, an ancient person,
1628
01:27:30.689 --> 01:27:34.020
as best as we can, say it's 700 BC, you're
1629
01:27:34.039 --> 01:27:36.800
a Levitical priest, you're going to the temple, you're going
1630
01:27:36.819 --> 01:27:39.680
to sing Psalm 148 today, but Who's going to be
1631
01:27:39.699 --> 01:27:41.779
at the temple when you go there? God. Who's God
1632
01:27:41.800 --> 01:27:42.300
surrounded by?
1633
01:27:42.520 --> 01:27:42.899
Angels.
1634
01:27:42.960 --> 01:27:44.760
So the angels are there. You're going to sing out,
1635
01:27:44.800 --> 01:27:46.720
praise him, all his angels, praise him, all his hosts.
1636
01:27:47.220 --> 01:27:49.819
They are there and they are present, right? So this
1637
01:27:49.880 --> 01:27:53.430
is a direct address. The way that Gavin in his video, even,
1638
01:27:53.470 --> 01:27:55.270
I don't even think he hides this very well. The
1639
01:27:55.310 --> 01:27:57.529
way he gets to poetic apostrophe is he goes to
1640
01:27:57.550 --> 01:28:00.369
the next few verses and he says, oh, sun, moon,
1641
01:28:00.470 --> 01:28:04.130
and stars. We know that those are inanimate objects, which
1642
01:28:04.350 --> 01:28:06.710
it's not.
It's a false premise, as Jay already pointed out.
1643
01:28:06.850 --> 01:28:10.689
It's also, including the angelic powers that oversee and supervise
1644
01:28:10.750 --> 01:28:15.029
all these celestial bodies and forces of nature. So praise him,
1645
01:28:15.050 --> 01:28:17.340
you highest heavens, you waters. But we know those are
1646
01:28:17.380 --> 01:28:20.659
inanimate objects. So all of this must be poetic apostrophe.
1647
01:28:20.720 --> 01:28:23.260
So then what he does is a hasty generalization fallacy.
1648
01:28:23.279 --> 01:28:25.600
And instead of looking at verse two, he says, well,
1649
01:28:25.619 --> 01:28:28.079
we know all the other verses after it are poetic apostrophe.
1650
01:28:28.460 --> 01:28:30.869
So then verse two must be poetic apostrophe as well.
1651
01:28:31.310 --> 01:28:34.250
And not only is it a hasty generalization it's also
1652
01:28:34.270 --> 01:28:37.109
a non sequitur, and it's an arbitrary standard, because why
1653
01:28:37.130 --> 01:28:39.130
are you going to read this back into verse 2,
1654
01:28:39.130 --> 01:28:41.029
but you're not going to read it back into verse 1,
1655
01:28:41.029 --> 01:28:44.229
which is a direct address to the Lord. It's inconsistent,
1656
01:28:44.350 --> 01:28:47.880
it's arbitrary, and it's not a good application of this
1657
01:28:47.979 --> 01:28:52.119
principle of poetic apostrophe, because it also involves reading his
1658
01:28:52.279 --> 01:28:56.739
modern cosmology that has a dichotomy between spiritual and natural.
1659
01:28:57.760 --> 01:29:01.819
He's reading back his modern cosmology into a text about
1660
01:29:02.100 --> 01:29:06.840
ancient cosmology. So like, like at the entry level, Gavin's
1661
01:29:06.899 --> 01:29:10.420
interpretation of this passage is wrong. And he ends like
1662
01:29:10.659 --> 01:29:13.239
starting a course a few degrees off. He ends up
1663
01:29:13.279 --> 01:29:15.899
in a totally different destination where he ought to be.
1664
01:29:18.579 --> 01:29:20.479
Somebody brought this up and I want both of your
1665
01:29:20.500 --> 01:29:23.970
thoughts on this too. I would imagine most Protestants that
1666
01:29:24.010 --> 01:29:30.270
hold his position believe that demonic powers are can be
1667
01:29:30.329 --> 01:29:35.430
invoked that a lot of people experience demon possession and
1668
01:29:35.489 --> 01:29:37.970
it didn't come. And I mean, I've heard sermons. I
1669
01:29:38.250 --> 01:29:41.979
I'm going to tell myself here as a Baptist pastor,
1670
01:29:42.840 --> 01:29:46.760
I preached against Ouija boards and all kinds of things
1671
01:29:46.859 --> 01:29:51.180
where invocation was happening. And I actually sat in a
1672
01:29:51.260 --> 01:29:54.539
room with a woman. I was in my 20s. I
1673
01:29:54.560 --> 01:29:56.380
started pastoring at like 21 years old, way too young.
1674
01:29:57.069 --> 01:29:58.909
And I'm sitting there in my early 20s. I think
1675
01:29:58.949 --> 01:30:01.420
I was probably 23, 24 at this time. And this
1676
01:30:01.539 --> 01:30:05.819
lady's telling me how she's being tortured by demons and
1677
01:30:05.859 --> 01:30:08.729
that she's she's naming the demon. She's got the name.
1678
01:30:08.750 --> 01:30:12.430
She talks to him on this regular basis and so forth.
1679
01:30:13.289 --> 01:30:16.189
And I mean, I'm I'm. I didn't know what to do.
1680
01:30:16.239 --> 01:30:18.479
I'm in my twenties and I've heard sermons. I've been
1681
01:30:18.500 --> 01:30:21.720
in chapel at Bible college and all this other stuff.
1682
01:30:22.399 --> 01:30:25.619
And we've heard sermon after sermon about how, you know,
1683
01:30:25.699 --> 01:30:28.699
these demon possessions happen. People are invoking and calling upon
1684
01:30:28.739 --> 01:30:33.079
these demons. So I have a question. If many of
1685
01:30:33.119 --> 01:30:36.439
them believe that demons can be invoked and hear their
1686
01:30:36.479 --> 01:30:41.050
invocations and take full possession of their bodies, minds, et cetera,
1687
01:30:43.229 --> 01:30:47.359
Is it only demons that can hear invocation then? And
1688
01:30:47.399 --> 01:30:54.239
not God's righteous angels? I wonder about this because wouldn't
1689
01:30:54.399 --> 01:30:57.399
Gavin concede, and I mean, I'm not gonna speak for him,
1690
01:30:57.420 --> 01:31:00.159
but wouldn't he conceive that there's people that can invoke
1691
01:31:00.239 --> 01:31:05.300
demonic beings and that by that invocation that demons, I've
1692
01:31:05.340 --> 01:31:07.579
always heard in the Baptist circles, you can't be possessed
1693
01:31:07.640 --> 01:31:11.159
unless you allow them. Well, that would mean you're interacting with,
1694
01:31:11.449 --> 01:31:12.210
With spirits.
1695
01:31:12.550 --> 01:31:13.649
You have to give consent.
1696
01:31:14.250 --> 01:31:18.210
There's consent. That means there's invocation. So if that's true
1697
01:31:18.250 --> 01:31:21.699
of the fallen, why can't that be true of the righteous?
1698
01:31:21.819 --> 01:31:24.020
Is that an inconsistent standard there? What do you guys think?
1699
01:31:24.579 --> 01:31:26.680
I have a very short answer, so I'll go first,
1700
01:31:26.760 --> 01:31:30.779
and then I'll let Jay go. But St. Jerome talks
1701
01:31:30.819 --> 01:31:35.199
about this in Against the Vigilantias. That's where I'm going.
1702
01:31:35.500 --> 01:31:38.050
You think the demons roam free, but the saints are
1703
01:31:38.729 --> 01:31:43.000
cooped up in some senatorial office? They can't leave this place,
1704
01:31:43.239 --> 01:31:45.439
but the demons, no, they can go everywhere. They can
1705
01:31:45.500 --> 01:31:47.539
hear everything and they can go like the wind in
1706
01:31:47.579 --> 01:31:50.510
an instant. They're there. But I think what he refers to,
1707
01:31:50.590 --> 01:31:54.270
I think in a way he's talking about theosis indirectly
1708
01:31:54.289 --> 01:31:56.750
because he appeals to revelation where he
says that, look,
1709
01:31:56.770 --> 01:31:58.789
if they're with Christ, wherever Christ is, the saints are.
1710
01:31:59.489 --> 01:32:02.329
It's a form of theosis. It's like a very integral
1711
01:32:02.350 --> 01:32:06.310
doctrine to that. If you read in the Orthodox tradition, St.
1712
01:32:06.350 --> 01:32:09.300
Gregory of Palamas and the triads talks a lot about this.
1713
01:32:10.560 --> 01:32:12.680
Well, and this is, I mean, this is sarcasm, but
1714
01:32:12.720 --> 01:32:16.020
he says, his demons are strong, his saints are weak. Duh,
1715
01:32:16.060 --> 01:32:16.500
don't you know?
1716
01:32:16.600 --> 01:32:17.699
That's the implication.
1717
01:32:17.920 --> 01:32:19.840
But that's the point, right, Jay? I mean, at the
1718
01:32:19.859 --> 01:32:21.460
end of the day, what are we concluding if we
1719
01:32:21.500 --> 01:32:22.359
say that?
1720
01:32:22.380 --> 01:32:25.560
Yeah, part of the reason for this, you're right. There's
1721
01:32:25.579 --> 01:32:27.619
two things that come to mind. I'm thinking back to
1722
01:32:27.649 --> 01:32:29.949
when I was Calvinist, how I would have answered that question.
1723
01:32:30.010 --> 01:32:33.510
I think it's a great question. And what you kind
1724
01:32:33.569 --> 01:32:36.529
of get with these guys is something akin to the
1725
01:32:36.569 --> 01:32:39.189
way that Muslims will kind of explain stuff because they're
1726
01:32:39.899 --> 01:32:42.850
The way that Muslims reply to these kinds of questions, like,
1727
01:32:42.890 --> 01:32:46.430
for example, you have in a lot of Islamic texts
1728
01:32:46.470 --> 01:32:48.489
this idea that you've got to follow some of these
1729
01:32:48.529 --> 01:32:50.949
ceremonial laws of the Old Testament, you've got these various
1730
01:32:51.210 --> 01:32:54.619
washings and ablutions, and then you're like, okay, why? What
1731
01:32:54.659 --> 01:32:57.319
is the purpose of these things? Well, Allah just said so.
1732
01:32:58.300 --> 01:33:01.739
And there's never any purpose beyond the fact that Allah
1733
01:33:01.760 --> 01:33:02.670
just wills you to do it.
1734
01:33:03.140 --> 01:33:05.710
Okay, but why? Because he says so, right?
1735
01:33:05.750 --> 01:33:07.569
So it's not, you know, in Christianity we have the
1736
01:33:07.590 --> 01:33:10.180
idea that a lot of the ceremonial laws have a
1737
01:33:10.199 --> 01:33:14.140
typological function they foreshadow the work of christ in islam
1738
01:33:14.159 --> 01:33:16.439
it's very different it's just sort of no allah tells
1739
01:33:16.479 --> 01:33:18.520
you to do it for the purpose of you doing
1740
01:33:18.579 --> 01:33:22.289
it right so there's no greater purpose and with calvinism
1741
01:33:22.329 --> 01:33:25.390
because it's in many ways similar to that sort of
1742
01:33:25.649 --> 01:33:29.750
uh you know deterministic islamic type of view you will
1743
01:33:29.770 --> 01:33:33.149
get these very arbitrary sort of ideas that well it
1744
01:33:33.229 --> 01:33:36.289
may work that way, but God says, you're not having
1745
01:33:36.350 --> 01:33:40.050
anything to do with those spiritual realities, those people that
1746
01:33:40.090 --> 01:33:42.630
have already passed on. So they're just going to say
1747
01:33:42.710 --> 01:33:45.489
that you just, God tells you not to write the
1748
01:33:45.529 --> 01:33:50.050
principles of don't practice necromancy. Don't try to contact the dead.
1749
01:33:51.899 --> 01:33:54.140
We don't know why or how, or we.
1750
01:33:54.039 --> 01:33:55.989
Just aren't, we're not supposed to, God says not to.
1751
01:33:56.000 --> 01:34:01.020
So it's very, it's very much like, because God, in
1752
01:34:01.119 --> 01:34:04.460
Calvinism is the sort of all determining direct cause of
1753
01:34:04.500 --> 01:34:05.079
all events.
1754
01:34:05.140 --> 01:34:05.800
Yep. Yep.
1755
01:34:06.590 --> 01:34:09.989
It's the same idea with Islam that it's much more
1756
01:34:10.050 --> 01:34:14.970
of a, a position of sort of willed obedience over
1757
01:34:15.029 --> 01:34:17.989
anything else. And don't even try to ask those kinds
1758
01:34:18.029 --> 01:34:20.600
of questions. You shouldn't even be thinking that way. You
1759
01:34:20.640 --> 01:34:21.579
just do what you're told.
1760
01:34:21.640 --> 01:34:22.100
Basically.
1761
01:34:22.720 --> 01:34:24.399
The other thing I want to say is that there's
1762
01:34:24.439 --> 01:34:29.340
a similar idea too, because of that deterministic, theological volunteerism
1763
01:34:29.420 --> 01:34:32.100
that you have having Calvinism and a lot of Protestantism,
1764
01:34:32.300 --> 01:34:36.949
unless they're evangelical, you know, the Reformation tradition stresses this
1765
01:34:37.210 --> 01:34:41.229
direct sovereignty of God, which even though there might be verbal,
1766
01:34:41.250 --> 01:34:45.010
you know, credence given to the idea of secondary causes
1767
01:34:45.109 --> 01:34:48.659
and other agencies in the universe, Calvinism doesn't really think
1768
01:34:48.680 --> 01:34:51.859
that way, right? It's not thinking about salvation as this
1769
01:34:51.960 --> 01:34:55.039
battle that you're undergoing where you need people helping you,
1770
01:34:55.079 --> 01:34:57.569
that you need people praying for you. Those are just
1771
01:34:57.609 --> 01:35:00.250
sort of, you know, they're not really, yeah, it might
1772
01:35:00.270 --> 01:35:01.970
be cool to ask your friends to pray for you,
1773
01:35:02.010 --> 01:35:03.939
but it doesn't really matter, right? Because you're either elect
1774
01:35:03.989 --> 01:35:06.500
or you're not. You're either regenerate or you're not. And
1775
01:35:06.520 --> 01:35:10.260
if you're regenerate, like, you're saved. But, you know, so
1776
01:35:10.300 --> 01:35:14.420
this idea of angels and demons battling over your soul,
1777
01:35:14.520 --> 01:35:17.159
it's not even really there in Calvinism. Because the first
1778
01:35:17.199 --> 01:35:21.890
thought process is, well, God's determined this, and it's already
1779
01:35:21.989 --> 01:35:26.359
under God's sovereign decree. God controls it all anyway. So
1780
01:35:26.390 --> 01:35:29.829
there's not a thought of, I am in an ascetic warfare.
1781
01:35:30.210 --> 01:35:32.489
You see, that's very, very different from the way Calvinists
1782
01:35:32.510 --> 01:35:34.170
think about it. So they just don't even think about
1783
01:35:34.890 --> 01:35:38.149
this idea of, you know, yeah, I might admit that
1784
01:35:38.170 --> 01:35:40.939
there's demonic possession, but that doesn't even really come into
1785
01:35:40.949 --> 01:35:42.579
their mindset. I mean, when I was a Calvinist, I
1786
01:35:42.579 --> 01:35:44.520
never even thought about demonic possession.
1787
01:35:44.619 --> 01:35:46.079
But it's a fair question.
1788
01:35:46.199 --> 01:35:48.020
I just think they're going to be, they're just going
1789
01:35:48.039 --> 01:35:51.140
to say, God says not to, don't do it.
1790
01:35:52.140 --> 01:35:52.340
Yeah.
1791
01:35:52.380 --> 01:35:54.939
I just thought it was weird. Even as a Calvinist pastor,
1792
01:35:55.810 --> 01:35:57.670
I didn't think about it either until sitting in a
1793
01:35:57.710 --> 01:35:59.630
room with a woman who told me she was asking
1794
01:35:59.670 --> 01:36:02.130
some demon by whatever name it was to, I'm like,
1795
01:36:02.189 --> 01:36:04.510
Oh my gosh, is this, is this a movie or
1796
01:36:04.529 --> 01:36:07.210
am I talking like, what is it? What do I do?
1797
01:36:07.289 --> 01:36:10.760
I'm 20 something years old. I wasn't trained for this.
1798
01:36:10.779 --> 01:36:14.079
I mean, I, there was a, I will say this
1799
01:36:14.239 --> 01:36:16.140
and now I can admit it. There was a thought
1800
01:36:16.159 --> 01:36:18.750
in my mind to call a Catholic priest at one point, uh,
1801
01:36:19.569 --> 01:36:21.449
I mean, if you don't know what you're doing, get
1802
01:36:21.470 --> 01:36:25.510
a priest involved or something. But those things cross my mind.
1803
01:36:25.569 --> 01:36:28.979
It's like if they can hear and these demonic powers
1804
01:36:29.020 --> 01:36:32.340
can hear and then they can participate in what you're doing,
1805
01:36:32.359 --> 01:36:36.699
your ritual, your act. How much more with the glory
1806
01:36:36.720 --> 01:36:40.140
of our Lord and all of his holy angels would
1807
01:36:40.180 --> 01:36:41.479
there be coming to us?
1808
01:36:41.560 --> 01:36:41.819
Because.
1809
01:36:42.520 --> 01:36:45.760
Hebrews says that we've entered into this new city with
1810
01:36:45.920 --> 01:36:49.479
myriads and myriads of angels and the souls of the
1811
01:36:49.550 --> 01:36:54.010
righteous made perfect. So that's that great liturgical. That's the
1812
01:36:54.109 --> 01:36:59.310
great ceremony that we're participating in every single mass or
1813
01:36:59.350 --> 01:37:02.409
every single time we come to the liturgy. And so
1814
01:37:02.869 --> 01:37:05.930
to me, I just think it's an inconsistent standard on
1815
01:37:05.970 --> 01:37:09.050
that as well. I do want to take some super
1816
01:37:09.090 --> 01:37:10.529
chats and then we'll get into a couple more things
1817
01:37:10.600 --> 01:37:12.420
and we'll close this out gentlemen i want to hold
1818
01:37:12.439 --> 01:37:15.500
you hostage all night i am enjoying the conversation though
1819
01:37:15.520 --> 01:37:18.439
because this stuff is uh i nerd out about this
1820
01:37:18.479 --> 01:37:21.350
kind of stuff thanks for the jewels high five thank
1821
01:37:21.359 --> 01:37:25.890
you so much let's see the other paul anglican all
1822
01:37:25.949 --> 01:37:29.689
right we got an anglican in the room when presented
1823
01:37:29.729 --> 01:37:33.390
with all this evidence in the matter scripture judaic context
1824
01:37:33.590 --> 01:37:37.670
and patristic is a protestant obligated i guess that's going
1825
01:37:37.689 --> 01:37:42.109
to be a key word obligated to reject his protestantism
1826
01:37:42.310 --> 01:37:49.250
and seek an apostolic communion well um paul my friend
1827
01:37:49.270 --> 01:37:52.529
i i would shoot that question right back at you
1828
01:37:52.649 --> 01:37:54.960
and say well what do you think um but i'll
1829
01:37:54.979 --> 01:37:57.920
leave this up for you gentlemen to answer first.
1830
01:37:58.920 --> 01:38:01.300
And i think the other paul should become orthodox that's
1831
01:38:01.319 --> 01:38:03.979
i mean this is just one of many reasons i
1832
01:38:04.020 --> 01:38:07.979
just ecclesiology um Yeah, I think if you look at
1833
01:38:08.020 --> 01:38:10.819
the prophecies about the fulfillment of the church in the
1834
01:38:10.939 --> 01:38:16.409
Old Testament, like Daniel 2, Isaiah 1, and to numerous
1835
01:38:16.470 --> 01:38:20.510
other passages, Malachi 1, you see that there's really only,
1836
01:38:20.529 --> 01:38:24.609
you can just go by process of elimination and see that,
1837
01:38:24.649 --> 01:38:28.350
you know, the Anglican communion does not fulfill those criteria.
1838
01:38:28.350 --> 01:38:31.380
uh but yeah among many reasons i would say that
1839
01:38:31.649 --> 01:38:35.619
you cannot you know consistently believe the bible and still
1840
01:38:35.640 --> 01:38:39.100
be part of one of these protestant assemblies.
1841
01:38:40.159 --> 01:38:43.159
So you think this matter is big enough to undo
1842
01:38:43.420 --> 01:38:47.779
a lot of uh i mean is that.
1843
01:38:47.640 --> 01:38:51.760
Big Indirectly, not directly. I think it is a strong
1844
01:38:51.779 --> 01:38:55.960
showing of continuity that maybe Anglicans might be the exception,
1845
01:38:56.079 --> 01:38:57.300
but generally.
1846
01:38:57.319 --> 01:39:00.369
Maybe an Anglo-Catholic. Maybe an Anglo-Catholic. I don't know. There's
1847
01:39:00.409 --> 01:39:02.949
some low church Anglican. I mean, there's very Pentecostal Anglicans.
1848
01:39:02.970 --> 01:39:08.149
There's
charismatic Anglicans. Yeah, exactly. Pentecostal Anglicans, too. So, yeah,
1849
01:39:08.350 --> 01:39:11.109
this issue by itself, I think it's... Isn't it compelling, Paul?
1850
01:39:11.130 --> 01:39:14.069
What do you think, Jay?
1851
01:39:14.100 --> 01:39:14.670
That's where I leave it.
1852
01:39:15.039 --> 01:39:17.100
How big of a deal is that for a Protestant
1853
01:39:17.140 --> 01:39:18.119
if they had to change their mind?
1854
01:39:18.180 --> 01:39:21.239
I mean, I think the idea of intercession is sort
1855
01:39:21.279 --> 01:39:25.250
of a subset of a bigger idea of what is
1856
01:39:25.270 --> 01:39:28.010
the pattern of worship and how does God want to
1857
01:39:28.029 --> 01:39:30.109
be worshipped. And one of the reasons that this was
1858
01:39:30.390 --> 01:39:33.720
such a strong indicator for me, I mean, just liturgical
1859
01:39:33.760 --> 01:39:37.579
worship itself, which includes the idea of relics and icons
1860
01:39:37.619 --> 01:39:40.119
and intercession and all that. reason it was such a
1861
01:39:40.159 --> 01:39:43.939
strong motivator for me was that i didn't even realize
1862
01:39:44.100 --> 01:39:46.390
until i got deep into the history of the formation
1863
01:39:46.399 --> 01:39:48.869
of the canon that liturgy also played a big role
1864
01:39:49.010 --> 01:39:52.789
in how the canon was determined and once i got
1865
01:39:52.829 --> 01:39:54.930
into that mindset it was just sort of like a
1866
01:39:55.029 --> 01:39:57.489
bunch of dominoes just sort of fell so for me
1867
01:39:57.510 --> 01:40:01.300
uh yeah overall to me this is a subset of
1868
01:40:01.359 --> 01:40:05.000
liturgical worship and if liturgical worship is the case and
1869
01:40:05.039 --> 01:40:06.880
i know he might say well yeah but i'm anglican
1870
01:40:06.920 --> 01:40:08.590
so I don't have a problem with this.
1871
01:40:08.630 --> 01:40:09.789
Well, but it's not just.
1872
01:40:09.710 --> 01:40:13.630
A question of picking and choosing like little niche things
1873
01:40:13.689 --> 01:40:17.090
within the worship of, you know, well, I want this,
1874
01:40:17.149 --> 01:40:19.939
but not that. It's sort of like there's a consistent
1875
01:40:19.979 --> 01:40:23.300
pattern of worship and normative authority that goes along with this.
1876
01:40:23.399 --> 01:40:26.220
Normative authority is a big part of this because doesn't
1877
01:40:26.260 --> 01:40:29.539
the church have authority within history to sort of make
1878
01:40:29.739 --> 01:40:31.979
judgment calls about how God.
1879
01:40:31.819 --> 01:40:32.649
Is to be worshiped?
1880
01:40:33.289 --> 01:40:36.159
And I think we're in a worse position if we say, Yeah,
1881
01:40:36.180 --> 01:40:39.069
I guess, but the Seventh Council in that whole time period,
1882
01:40:39.109 --> 01:40:42.489
they all just fell away, and it was all crap.
1883
01:40:42.630 --> 01:40:45.529
They just went to hell with icons after the Seventh Council,
1884
01:40:45.609 --> 01:40:48.649
and we had to reform it to where it was optional.
1885
01:40:49.229 --> 01:40:51.819
So they were wrong to have icons as mandatory for
1886
01:40:51.840 --> 01:40:55.000
several centuries, and then the Reformation, well, we'll make it optional.
1887
01:40:55.800 --> 01:41:00.560
But again, if that's optional, then paedo-communion is optional. Infant
1888
01:41:00.579 --> 01:41:01.859
baptism becomes optional.
1889
01:41:02.840 --> 01:41:03.689
Relics are optional.
1890
01:41:04.170 --> 01:41:07.170
Imagery itself is optional. And this is what happened within Anglicanism.
1891
01:41:07.229 --> 01:41:09.760
There's high church and there's low church, right? You've got
1892
01:41:10.140 --> 01:41:16.619
basically Anglo-Catholics fighting against Puritan Anglicans who are essentially Puritans.
1893
01:41:16.739 --> 01:41:17.899
And they went to war.
1894
01:41:18.560 --> 01:41:22.329
Cavaliers, royalists or whatever, killing each other over church government.
1895
01:41:22.949 --> 01:41:25.649
So the idea that you can make all these things
1896
01:41:25.890 --> 01:41:30.090
adiophora for the sake of lowest common denominator, let's all
1897
01:41:30.109 --> 01:41:33.069
just be Christians. It's just not at all the way,
1898
01:41:33.229 --> 01:41:35.789
for example, the church operates in the first seven centuries
1899
01:41:35.850 --> 01:41:36.909
when you get to 787.
1900
01:41:36.909 --> 01:41:40.949
Yeah, and that's true because when I first came to Anglicanism,
1901
01:41:40.989 --> 01:41:44.630
the first parish we were around, the priest would speak
1902
01:41:44.670 --> 01:41:47.630
of the first four ecumenical councils and what was accepted
1903
01:41:47.649 --> 01:41:50.210
and it was only the Christological side of things. And
1904
01:41:50.250 --> 01:41:53.369
then we end up in Anglo-Catholicism and it's like, no,
1905
01:41:53.390 --> 01:41:55.229
we accept all seven. Look at the icons we got
1906
01:41:55.270 --> 01:41:57.630
on the walls. It's like, okay, it's like being in
1907
01:41:57.649 --> 01:42:01.819
two different churches. I mean, they did. Genuflecting, all of it.
1908
01:42:01.859 --> 01:42:02.770
I mean, it was all there.
1909
01:42:03.149 --> 01:42:06.250
Well, when I was a Calvinist, we had the same idea.
1910
01:42:06.289 --> 01:42:09.810
We would say, yeah, we like 1, 2, 3, 4 Chalcedon.
1911
01:42:09.829 --> 01:42:10.729
Of course, I'd even read them.
1912
01:42:10.770 --> 01:42:14.229
I didn't know that all the argumentation in Ephesus from
1913
01:42:14.270 --> 01:42:16.510
Cyril is based on the real presence. So I didn't
1914
01:42:16.529 --> 01:42:19.649
even know that. I just thought I agree with the
1915
01:42:19.689 --> 01:42:23.750
proposition that Jesus is divine hypostasis, etc.
1916
01:42:23.770 --> 01:42:24.949
whatever. Yeah, I agree with Ephesus.
1917
01:42:25.409 --> 01:42:27.659
But And then eventually it was like, oh, wait a minute.
1918
01:42:27.680 --> 01:42:29.840
What about, you know,
fifth and sixth council? And so
1919
01:42:30.319 --> 01:42:33.260
my ideas kept changing over time of like, well, I
1920
01:42:33.279 --> 01:42:37.319
guess the church kind of went bad at the sixth council,
1921
01:42:37.350 --> 01:42:40.289
maybe seventh council. And then it was like, but then
1922
01:42:40.529 --> 01:42:43.529
you're back in the same boat of like, what's the
1923
01:42:43.569 --> 01:42:46.689
point of even having councils if everybody can just kind
1924
01:42:46.729 --> 01:42:49.430
of pick and choose what they want. And there's no
1925
01:42:49.529 --> 01:42:51.970
normative authority. And I think that was the key point, which,
1926
01:42:52.869 --> 01:42:56.199
you know, for me, what I'm trying to say in
1927
01:42:56.880 --> 01:42:59.680
brief is just that all of these issues kind of
1928
01:42:59.840 --> 01:43:00.199
all go.
1929
01:43:00.140 --> 01:43:02.079
Together, right? They're not piecemeal.
1930
01:43:02.539 --> 01:43:04.720
And I think when you're Protestant, I thought this way,
1931
01:43:04.739 --> 01:43:07.079
it sounds like you thought the same way. Like you think, yep,
1932
01:43:07.500 --> 01:43:11.670
I'll solve these like piecemeal. And then you kind of
1933
01:43:11.710 --> 01:43:14.670
realize this is actually, they all kind of go together, right?
1934
01:43:14.689 --> 01:43:14.770
Yeah.
1935
01:43:14.810 --> 01:43:15.189
You can't.
1936
01:43:15.489 --> 01:43:16.430
Yeah. Yeah.
1937
01:43:16.449 --> 01:43:19.130
And that's the thing, like the, the criteria for Nicaea
1938
01:43:19.430 --> 01:43:21.909
two is the same criteria that happened in Nicaea one.
1939
01:43:22.390 --> 01:43:24.869
So you're going to fundamentally look at the criteria of
1940
01:43:24.909 --> 01:43:27.479
what brought Nicaea together. And if you want to throw, oh, well,
1941
01:43:27.640 --> 01:43:31.420
emperor and empress and okay. Okay. But didn't an emperor
1942
01:43:31.479 --> 01:43:35.039
call Nicaea one? I mean, like, so like what point
1943
01:43:35.239 --> 01:43:38.279
is the criteria of Nicaea one and Nicaea two different?
1944
01:43:38.340 --> 01:43:42.079
They're not. And so therefore, if they can get the
1945
01:43:42.159 --> 01:43:47.149
judgment of Homo Ouseus over against Homo Ouseus correct by
1946
01:43:47.189 --> 01:43:50.270
the same standard that they applied everything else in Nicaea two,
1947
01:43:51.119 --> 01:43:54.699
then to reject one is to reject the other, in
1948
01:43:54.760 --> 01:43:56.960
my opinion. And that's what I came to. It was like,
1949
01:43:57.000 --> 01:44:00.079
you know what? I'm fighting a system and sounding stupid
1950
01:44:00.119 --> 01:44:02.380
doing it. So I'm honestly, well, just like, you know what?
1951
01:44:02.960 --> 01:44:05.319
If the process is the same here and the same here,
1952
01:44:05.939 --> 01:44:09.369
I'm not, I shouldn't be fighting this anymore. Thanks again
1953
01:44:09.430 --> 01:44:13.550
for the five jewels go team. I'm a few minutes behind.
1954
01:44:13.649 --> 01:44:17.930
I legitimately laughed out loud in the invoking keyword, the
1955
01:44:17.970 --> 01:44:22.470
SpongeBob campfire song. Yeah, sorry. I don't know where that
1956
01:44:22.510 --> 01:44:24.609
got on my mind today. I said that to somebody else, too,
1957
01:44:24.630 --> 01:44:25.829
and they looked at me like, did you grow up
1958
01:44:25.869 --> 01:44:28.989
on Spongebob? I was like, unfortunately. Yes, I did. Thank you.
1959
01:44:29.750 --> 01:44:34.500
Let's see. I don't claim, I think that's to know,
1960
01:44:34.779 --> 01:44:38.380
to know a lot about fathers, but I know a
1961
01:44:38.420 --> 01:44:41.800
decent amount about the history of baptism, and Gavin's view
1962
01:44:41.960 --> 01:44:47.130
is not in the first 200 years of the church. Well,
1963
01:44:47.390 --> 01:44:52.909
I'm assuming he's referring to baptismal regeneration here. And that
1964
01:44:52.930 --> 01:44:54.250
kind of goes to my point, what I was saying
1965
01:44:54.289 --> 01:44:59.010
when he conceded the idea that Cyprian believed that you
1966
01:44:59.069 --> 01:45:01.010
could pray for the dead. And then he referenced his
1967
01:45:01.069 --> 01:45:04.300
video from two years ago where he says it's extremely widespread,
1968
01:45:04.359 --> 01:45:07.789
extremely early. Again, so do you accept it?
1969
01:45:07.920 --> 01:45:08.340
Well, no.
1970
01:45:08.420 --> 01:45:10.739
Well, why not? Well, because it's not mandated in scripture.
1971
01:45:10.800 --> 01:45:13.119
So it really is Sola Scriptura. Even though you're saying
1972
01:45:13.140 --> 01:45:15.909
this isn't a Sola Scriptura argument. if you can show
1973
01:45:15.970 --> 01:45:17.970
something in the first 200 years and you can give
1974
01:45:18.050 --> 01:45:22.310
extremely early and extremely widespread examples and you still reject it,
1975
01:45:22.819 --> 01:45:25.439
who cares how many, if we have one quote, two quotes,
1976
01:45:25.500 --> 01:45:29.239
three quotes, or 500 quotes of invocation, it doesn't matter
1977
01:45:29.279 --> 01:45:32.510
if you've already determined you're not going to accept it.
1978
01:45:32.960 --> 01:45:34.260
And that's what he had to do, by the way,
1979
01:45:34.300 --> 01:45:37.699
in his second video, it went from, should we pray
1980
01:45:37.720 --> 01:45:40.840
to the saints or can the saints hear you? And
1981
01:45:40.859 --> 01:45:43.000
that's why I changed the name of it. The saints
1982
01:45:43.060 --> 01:45:46.939
can hear you today. But he went from there's no
1983
01:45:47.039 --> 01:45:49.439
evidence for 200 years to, well, we're not mandated by scripture.
1984
01:45:50.380 --> 01:45:53.800
We completely shifted the goalposts from video one to video two.
1985
01:45:54.000 --> 01:45:58.039
And to me, that just bothers me so much. All right.
1986
01:45:58.119 --> 01:46:02.699
So let's get a couple. Is Paul Washer publicly a restorationist?
1987
01:46:04.130 --> 01:46:07.369
That was that conversation that the argument that we had
1988
01:46:07.470 --> 01:46:10.909
was probably around the year 2005.
1989
01:46:10.909 --> 01:46:12.949
I don't know what his present positions would be.
1990
01:46:13.869 --> 01:46:16.770
I don't either, actually. I know he had a bad
1991
01:46:16.829 --> 01:46:19.550
health condition come up a few years ago, and I
1992
01:46:19.590 --> 01:46:21.369
don't think he's been very public. Did he have a
1993
01:46:21.409 --> 01:46:22.289
heart attack or something?
1994
01:46:22.369 --> 01:46:23.050
I don't know.
1995
01:46:23.369 --> 01:46:25.710
I know that I can tell you that at that
1996
01:46:25.770 --> 01:46:29.970
time he was selling Anabaptist texts at his conferences, because
1997
01:46:29.989 --> 01:46:32.310
I remember going to that conference and we had that argument,
1998
01:46:32.970 --> 01:46:35.399
and he had a book table selling Anabaptist texts.
1999
01:46:35.439 --> 01:46:39.340
So he was leaning very heavily Anabaptist back at that time. Goodness.
2000
01:46:40.939 --> 01:46:45.060
Beowulf. Thank you for saving me from Protestantism, Jay and Alex.
2001
01:46:45.119 --> 01:46:49.010
God bless you. Former youth pastor here wrestled with EO
2002
01:46:49.310 --> 01:46:54.289
and Gavin's arguments for years. I have a theory and
2003
01:46:54.350 --> 01:46:56.050
I can't prove this theory, so I'm not going to
2004
01:46:56.189 --> 01:46:59.350
like make any kind of dogma statements here, but I
2005
01:46:59.369 --> 01:47:01.970
think the reason these guys are scrounging so hard is
2006
01:47:02.010 --> 01:47:05.050
because this is the norm right now in both Eastern
2007
01:47:05.109 --> 01:47:09.670
Orthodox and Catholic circles. Um, And there's, you know, for
2008
01:47:09.829 --> 01:47:13.060
for the many, many years, it was James White who
2009
01:47:13.109 --> 01:47:16.779
was getting pinned with this. And I remember when I first,
2010
01:47:16.880 --> 01:47:18.640
by the way, of all the people, they are really
2011
01:47:18.680 --> 01:47:20.939
mad at me. White was mad at me when I converted.
2012
01:47:21.140 --> 01:47:23.000
And he was like, he didn't even call me. It's like, well,
2013
01:47:23.039 --> 01:47:24.199
what am I going to call you? What are we
2014
01:47:24.220 --> 01:47:24.899
going to talk about?
2015
01:47:25.939 --> 01:47:27.699
He said he would have talked to you. Then you
2016
01:47:27.720 --> 01:47:28.960
would have stayed Baptist.
2017
01:47:30.720 --> 01:47:32.279
I guess he thinks he would have changed my mind
2018
01:47:32.340 --> 01:47:35.550
or something as if I didn't. think through his arguments already, but,
2019
01:47:36.149 --> 01:47:38.189
but this is what we're seeing. Like there's, there's a,
2020
01:47:38.329 --> 01:47:42.539
there's jokes going around that, um, the best OCIA teacher
2021
01:47:42.579 --> 01:47:45.460
in Catholicism is James White, Gavin Orlin, and people go
2022
01:47:45.479 --> 01:47:49.600
down the list because all these people have,
I think
2023
01:47:49.659 --> 01:47:52.140
it's so good that we do what we're doing right now.
2024
01:47:52.380 --> 01:47:55.609
It's not, it's not for Gavin because he's probably not
2025
01:47:55.630 --> 01:47:57.869
going to change. And it's not for people that want
2026
01:47:57.890 --> 01:48:01.250
to name inquire. There are guys like this gentleman right
2027
01:48:01.329 --> 01:48:06.079
here who have watched your videos, watched your debates, and
2028
01:48:06.140 --> 01:48:08.539
they had to wrestle. And I think about what he
2029
01:48:08.560 --> 01:48:12.800
just says, former youth pastor who wrestled with Eastern Orthodoxy
2030
01:48:13.380 --> 01:48:17.189
and Gavin's arguments for years, which means this took time.
2031
01:48:17.409 --> 01:48:20.939
This means they probably, Jay, watched multiple debates, multiple debates. podcasts,
2032
01:48:21.000 --> 01:48:24.439
and I would assume the same. We do these videos
2033
01:48:24.680 --> 01:48:28.979
because I think they're so desperate right now because they're
2034
01:48:29.020 --> 01:48:33.699
losing this fight with evidence and arguments. Now we have
2035
01:48:33.899 --> 01:48:38.010
the Church Fathers available in volumes for free in English
2036
01:48:38.149 --> 01:48:40.409
on the internet. I mean, when I was undergrad, you
2037
01:48:40.430 --> 01:48:42.630
had to pay big dollars for some of these that
2038
01:48:42.649 --> 01:48:46.630
are now available. And then books that are almost extinct,
2039
01:48:46.670 --> 01:48:48.529
we have scanned images of them. I'm going to show
2040
01:48:48.550 --> 01:48:52.810
you one in a minute. And it's exciting because now
2041
01:48:52.850 --> 01:48:57.319
that the internet has made available to people, podcasts, YouTube,
2042
01:48:58.199 --> 01:49:02.000
free access to documents, scanned books that are almost impossible
2043
01:49:02.020 --> 01:49:04.640
to find in libraries, you'd be paying five, $ 600 for,
2044
01:49:05.000 --> 01:49:08.640
people can read them now. And now you have We're
2045
01:49:08.659 --> 01:49:11.659
in an age of Google Translate. If it's in Latin,
2046
01:49:11.699 --> 01:49:15.180
you can just copy the Latin section, let Google Translate
2047
01:49:15.319 --> 01:49:18.100
a messy version for you and still get the basic
2048
01:49:18.399 --> 01:49:22.319
gist of it. So I think this is why they're
2049
01:49:22.340 --> 01:49:25.770
freaking out, guys. This is why they're freaking out. And
2050
01:49:26.939 --> 01:49:29.310
Gavin went from, and go look at his videos in
2051
01:49:29.329 --> 01:49:34.229
the last year, most of his videos now are polemics
2052
01:49:34.310 --> 01:49:40.979
against orthodoxy or Catholicism. Almost always, every week, there's another
2053
01:49:41.020 --> 01:49:44.119
video that jabs at this position and the Orthodox are
2054
01:49:44.260 --> 01:49:47.520
jabs at this position. And unfortunately, I'm even seeing guys
2055
01:49:47.539 --> 01:49:51.460
like my friend Wes Huff do this. And I called
2056
01:49:51.500 --> 01:49:53.180
him out on the last one and I sent him
2057
01:49:53.199 --> 01:49:54.699
the script and told him I was going to be
2058
01:49:54.720 --> 01:49:58.500
responding to a statement. They got to be getting desperate, right?
2059
01:49:58.520 --> 01:50:01.319
I mean, that's why we're seeing all these ongoing and
2060
01:50:01.359 --> 01:50:04.619
instead of just concede, they can't concede. They can't concede.
2061
01:50:05.180 --> 01:50:09.329
You have 95,000 people Watching your shows to concede would
2062
01:50:09.369 --> 01:50:12.750
be to say that they're presenting arguments that are a
2063
01:50:12.810 --> 01:50:17.430
historic in nature and that the Catholic got it right
2064
01:50:17.449 --> 01:50:20.710
or the Orthodox got it right. Therefore, you know, their
2065
01:50:20.750 --> 01:50:23.149
credibility is shot. And that's why he's not backing down
2066
01:50:23.189 --> 01:50:26.899
in these these engagements with you, Alex, because I think
2067
01:50:26.909 --> 01:50:29.880
they know how much is on the line. But maybe
2068
01:50:29.920 --> 01:50:32.119
I'm overstating my point. What do you guys think?
2069
01:50:33.439 --> 01:50:35.920
No, I think you're absolutely right. I think that on
2070
01:50:35.960 --> 01:50:38.180
the merits, they don't really have much. That's why they
2071
01:50:38.239 --> 01:50:41.729
refuse to actually engage in a formal debate setting with
2072
01:50:42.159 --> 01:50:46.229
a moderator, equal speaking time, the ability to cross-examine so
2073
01:50:46.250 --> 01:50:48.470
that we can push them on certain points. I think
2074
01:50:48.510 --> 01:50:51.810
from the top guys, you don't see that at all.
2075
01:50:51.869 --> 01:50:54.470
It's a total refusal to engage on the merits. And
2076
01:50:54.489 --> 01:50:56.789
I think at this point, we should probably start taking
2077
01:50:56.829 --> 01:51:00.130
that as a concession because You do see in their podcasts,
2078
01:51:00.210 --> 01:51:03.880
these are concessions. I just reviewed a video from Founders Ministries,
2079
01:51:03.909 --> 01:51:06.840
which I think is like Baptist or just generally more
2080
01:51:07.319 --> 01:51:08.380
Reformed Calvinist.
2081
01:51:08.819 --> 01:51:09.659
Yeah.
2082
01:51:09.779 --> 01:51:12.699
More non-denom. So, yeah, they're talking about how they did
2083
01:51:12.739 --> 01:51:15.840
a video on Eastern Orthodoxy. Is it good or bad? Whatever.
2084
01:51:16.380 --> 01:51:19.270
And the very first thing out of their mouth was,
2085
01:51:19.850 --> 01:51:22.529
Eastern Orthodoxy has affected all of our churches. And I'm
2086
01:51:22.550 --> 01:51:25.979
just sitting like... Glory to God. Thank God.
2087
01:51:26.399 --> 01:51:29.340
I'm getting sent videos of mega church pastors, like some
2088
01:51:29.380 --> 01:51:32.699
of the biggest mega churches in California talking about us
2089
01:51:33.520 --> 01:51:35.819
and that people are converting and they don't
know what
2090
01:51:35.859 --> 01:51:36.140
to do.
2091
01:51:38.020 --> 01:51:40.020
Well, think about it. I mean, who is talking about,
2092
01:51:40.239 --> 01:51:42.689
and we're in the United States. I mean, how many
2093
01:51:42.770 --> 01:51:45.850
Orthodox churches are there probably now that exists that were
2094
01:51:45.909 --> 01:51:48.289
not around 20 years ago? I mean, I know of
2095
01:51:48.310 --> 01:51:50.949
new plants happening all the time. Like I said, my good,
2096
01:51:51.010 --> 01:51:54.449
my good, good friend is Orthodox pastor. many of the
2097
01:51:54.510 --> 01:51:58.819
followers of my channel are Orthodox and they're excited. They're
2098
01:51:58.840 --> 01:52:01.920
talking about this new work that's happening. And then they're
2099
01:52:02.020 --> 01:52:04.380
opening a new priest are being ordained. New deacons are
2100
01:52:04.399 --> 01:52:06.560
being ordained. I mean, all kinds of things are happening.
2101
01:52:07.520 --> 01:52:09.859
It's everywhere. I mean, you can go to, I mean,
2102
01:52:10.220 --> 01:52:13.130
we joke about it. Even in the Catholic churches around
2103
01:52:13.170 --> 01:52:15.850
here in South Carolina, they're blowing it.
2104
01:52:15.850 --> 01:52:16.569
We're in the Bible belt.
2105
01:52:16.609 --> 01:52:22.149
We're in the Baptist world and the Catholic churches are exploding.
2106
01:52:22.770 --> 01:52:26.899
I mean, Looking at, I was sitting there Sunday, the
2107
01:52:27.039 --> 01:52:30.520
Eucharist is taking much longer than it used to, which
2108
01:52:30.539 --> 01:52:33.770
thank God. But my wife and I kind of sat
2109
01:52:33.789 --> 01:52:35.829
toward the back. If you don't get to church 20
2110
01:52:35.829 --> 01:52:39.810
minutes early, you're standing probably at that point, the whole
2111
01:52:39.850 --> 01:52:44.409
entire mass. We're sitting there, we went through, we received
2112
01:52:44.439 --> 01:52:46.619
the body and blood of Christ, and we come back around.
2113
01:52:47.270 --> 01:52:49.409
And we're toward the back. And it went on another
2114
01:52:49.409 --> 01:52:51.729
15 minutes because of all the people that were standing
2115
01:52:51.750 --> 01:52:53.829
in the back and the vestibular. And they're all coming in.
2116
01:52:53.829 --> 01:52:55.890
I was like, my goodness, where are all these people
2117
01:52:55.989 --> 01:52:59.340
coming from? And the OCIA classes, they had to turn
2118
01:52:59.359 --> 01:53:01.420
them into two instead of one because of how many
2119
01:53:01.460 --> 01:53:03.840
people are coming to the church. Some of my closest
2120
01:53:03.880 --> 01:53:11.220
friends are in catechesis classes, learning of the Orthodox faith
2121
01:53:11.340 --> 01:53:14.229
and things like that. And I'm like, this is insane.
2122
01:53:14.310 --> 01:53:16.380
We're in the Bible. I'm in the Bible Belt. I'm
2123
01:53:16.399 --> 01:53:18.640
like right in the middle of South Carolina, North Carolina.
2124
01:53:19.279
--> 01:53:21.239
And so I think they're freaking out. I really do.
2125
01:53:21.300 --> 01:53:23.340
And I don't think they know what to do. And
2126
01:53:23.359 --> 01:53:27.220
they're trying to send their best apologists to engage this.
2127
01:53:28.159 --> 01:53:30.439
But a lot of them won't debate. And I know
2128
01:53:30.460 --> 01:53:31.659
a lot of them won't debate you, Alex. And a
2129
01:53:31.659 --> 01:53:34.680
lot of them won't debate you, Jay. And when they do,
2130
01:53:34.720 --> 01:53:36.880
it usually doesn't look very good for them. So I
2131
01:53:36.920 --> 01:53:40.979
can understand their reasoning on some of that. But I'm
2132
01:53:41.020 --> 01:53:43.560
telling you, I think they're freaking out because men like
2133
01:53:43.619 --> 01:53:46.979
this in this chat right here, There's a lot of
2134
01:53:47.079 --> 01:53:51.449
people like this. And sometimes, you know, somebody said to
2135
01:53:51.489 --> 01:53:53.390
me years ago, I can't remember where, I think I
2136
01:53:53.409 --> 01:53:56.789
was in a master's course somewhere. The professor said something like,
2137
01:53:56.829 --> 01:53:58.890
we don't answer the fools for the sake of the fool.
2138
01:53:59.710 --> 01:54:02.109
We answer the fools for those that are quietly sitting
2139
01:54:02.149 --> 01:54:06.039
by and listening. And sometimes I think that we have
2140
01:54:06.060 --> 01:54:08.600
to like answer this stuff. I don't want to, I
2141
01:54:08.619 --> 01:54:10.279
didn't want to do the show tonight, but we don't
2142
01:54:10.300 --> 01:54:14.020
know how many more Beowulf guys are watching this who
2143
01:54:14.100 --> 01:54:17.079
are wrestling through the content. And they're going to realize
2144
01:54:17.100 --> 01:54:20.560
really quickly, you know, this argument doesn't fly and it
2145
01:54:20.600 --> 01:54:26.680
doesn't work. Red Robin, Protestants saying we should reform, yet
2146
01:54:26.720 --> 01:54:30.310
they've never walked anything back except maybe the Pope being
2147
01:54:30.350 --> 01:54:31.970
the Antichrist.
2148
01:54:32.590 --> 01:54:33.289
Strong maybe.
2149
01:54:34.069 --> 01:54:38.569
Why can't they reform and accept intercession of the saints?
2150
01:54:40.329 --> 01:54:45.199
Good question. Thank you for the two jewels. And what
2151
01:54:45.260 --> 01:54:49.189
is this? Eliphaz asked, I think that's asking, asking Job,
2152
01:54:50.050 --> 01:54:52.119
call Saint, show Job, practiced it.
2153
01:54:52.689 --> 01:54:55.510
That's Job 5.1. Yeah.
2154
01:54:56.810 --> 01:54:58.630
Eduardo, if you'd have sent five bucks, we could have
2155
01:54:58.850 --> 01:55:00.909
crammed that in there and read it better. Just kidding.
2156
01:55:01.050 --> 01:55:01.800
I'm just kidding.
2157
01:55:02.399 --> 01:55:05.119
So I think you referenced this briefly in your video.
2158
01:55:06.000 --> 01:55:10.359
You got into Job. I'm almost positive. One could say
2159
01:55:10.399 --> 01:55:18.380
that Gavin's ecumenical mission is being accomplished. You want to
2160
01:55:18.420 --> 01:55:19.239
explain this to me?
2161
01:55:19.260 --> 01:55:23.600
Because we have Roman Catholic and two Orthodox on the
2162
01:55:23.619 --> 01:55:28.170
same stream. His ecumenical mission is being accomplished because we're
2163
01:55:28.189 --> 01:55:31.670
putting the same takes together. I don't think anybody here
2164
01:55:31.729 --> 01:55:35.289
is an ecumenist. I know Octavian knows that. I know
2165
01:55:35.310 --> 01:55:39.409
he's being tongue-in-cheek. He's a mod in my chat. For
2166
01:55:39.430 --> 01:55:42.729
those who don't know, nobody here is an ecumenist.
2167
01:55:43.579 --> 01:55:49.510
Thank God. 50 plus years Protestant, 25 year law enforcement.
2168
01:55:50.289 --> 01:55:54.439
I never viewed the great cloud of witnesses like the
2169
01:55:54.500 --> 01:56:00.199
witnesses and investigations present, aware, and with whom we communicated.
2170
01:56:00.579 --> 01:56:04.529
I was blind, but now orthodox. Dang.
2171
01:56:04.550 --> 01:56:04.729
Dang.
2172
01:56:05.859 --> 01:56:09.800
You know, I get usually police officers and other law enforcement,
2173
01:56:10.220 --> 01:56:14.060
parole officers or prison guards in my chat frequently because
2174
01:56:14.079 --> 01:56:17.720
they like my legal analogies. And look, they are witnesses.
2175
01:56:17.939 --> 01:56:20.680
And especially in 1 Timothy 5, where St. Paul is
2176
01:56:20.720 --> 01:56:23.689
talking about a disciplinary hearing, like, how do you oversee
2177
01:56:23.729 --> 01:56:26.670
complaints about elders? You need the witnesses there. You need
2178
01:56:26.689 --> 01:56:28.029
at least two or three of them so you can
2179
01:56:28.069 --> 01:56:30.510
lay a foundation for the charge brought against this elder.
2180
01:56:30.550 --> 01:56:34.189
I think it's it's very oddly enough, here's the Orthodox
2181
01:56:34.250 --> 01:56:38.710
person talking about the legal analogies in scripture, right? They're there.
2182
01:56:39.710 --> 01:56:42.680
That's quite a testimony just in a super chat. What
2183
01:56:42.689 --> 01:56:43.220
do you think, Jay?
2184
01:56:45.340 --> 01:56:45.619
Yeah.
2185
01:56:45.880 --> 01:56:48.500
Um, I mean, coming from the Protestant world, you know,
2186
01:56:48.539 --> 01:56:51.199
this is kind of what dominated our, our thought process.
2187
01:56:51.239 --> 01:56:52.800
And it was so much of that kind of stuff
2188
01:56:52.819 --> 01:56:56.699
that I think was over, uh, overstressed in the Protestant
2189
01:56:56.720 --> 01:56:59.680
world that, you know, I kind of got tired of, um,
2190
01:57:00.630 --> 01:57:06.310
But then, you know, being really interested in biblical theology,
2191
01:57:06.350 --> 01:57:08.569
I think, you know, we have to be clear and
2192
01:57:08.609 --> 01:57:11.329
honest that, well, that language is there. It doesn't necessarily
2193
01:57:11.369 --> 01:57:14.930
mean penal substitutionary atonement the
way that the Protestants and
2194
01:57:14.949 --> 01:57:18.289
the Reformers meant it. But, you know, there's obviously a
2195
01:57:18.310 --> 01:57:20.750
lot to be gained from that type of.
2196
01:57:20.409 --> 01:57:22.270
Analysis, that level of analysis.
2197
01:57:22.590 --> 01:57:25.369
And it's funny you were mentioning earlier the emperors calling
2198
01:57:25.390 --> 01:57:29.100
the councils. When I gave a talk recently on The
2199
01:57:29.109 --> 01:57:31.979
History of Byzantium and Christian Law and the Duty of
2200
01:57:32.020 --> 01:57:33.539
the State to God on my channel.
2201
01:57:33.560 --> 01:57:35.319
And I would say people should check that out.
2202
01:57:35.359 --> 01:57:38.020
I was reading actually a liberal scholar who wrote a
2203
01:57:38.039 --> 01:57:43.020
book recently, John McGuckin's book called The Formation of Christian Law.
2204
01:57:43.880 --> 01:57:47.699
And he talked about how the model of the emperors
2205
01:57:47.920 --> 01:57:53.779
calling the councils is what basically created the Christian Byzantine
2206
01:57:53.920 --> 01:57:58.880
legal tradition, which led to Justinian's law and the nomo
2207
01:57:58.920 --> 01:58:01.859
canon and these other later byzantine legal traditions and what's
2208
01:58:01.880 --> 01:58:04.250
funny is that what began as kind of the state
2209
01:58:04.310 --> 01:58:10.939
sort of calling the councils and Constantine wanted a giant
2210
01:58:10.989 --> 01:58:15.460
ecumenical version of what were the pre-existing local synods of
2211
01:58:15.500 --> 01:58:20.619
Gangra and Ancyra, that became the norm, which then eventually
2212
01:58:20.659 --> 01:58:23.600
in Byzantium, the church had such a powerful influence that
2213
01:58:24.420 --> 01:58:32.390
the canonical lawyers were basically more powerful than the secular lawyers. So, uh,
2214
01:58:32.899 --> 01:58:35.630
we have this great tradition, um, which we think of
2215
01:58:35.689 --> 01:58:38.949
orthodoxy as like, Oh, you're, you guys hate the legal
2216
01:58:38.989 --> 01:58:42.510
language of scripture. And it's like, it actually gave Western civilization,
2217
01:58:42.569 --> 01:58:45.449
its whole like legal tradition. So that's completely nonsensical. There's
2218
01:58:45.470 --> 01:58:49.949
all these famous Byzantine, like judges and lawyers that people
2219
01:58:49.970 --> 01:58:51.869
don't even, don't even know these people, but they're very
2220
01:58:51.909 --> 01:58:54.090
famous and they were very important for the formation of
2221
01:58:54.149 --> 01:58:57.569
Christian law. So I think we have a very, uh, measured, uh,
2222
01:58:58.069 --> 01:59:03.750
you know, appropriate place for, uh, Christian law that should
2223
01:59:03.810 --> 01:59:07.189
not be ignored with, you know, at the same time,
2224
01:59:07.250 --> 01:59:09.399
not going into the extremes. Cause what's funny is that
2225
01:59:09.409 --> 01:59:12.060
you read these Byzantine theologians talking about law, even St.
2226
01:59:12.079 --> 01:59:16.960
Phodia said the purpose of Christian law is to, we
2227
01:59:17.000 --> 01:59:22.000
bring deification to even secular law, even secular law is
2228
01:59:22.300 --> 01:59:25.810
illuminated by the minds of the deified saints, right? which
2229
01:59:25.869 --> 01:59:27.449
I think is just so foreign to the way that
2230
01:59:27.489 --> 01:59:30.949
we think now that that's our heritage, so that's how
2231
01:59:30.989 --> 01:59:31.369
we should.
2232
01:59:31.270 --> 01:59:31.630
Think of it.
2233
01:59:34.079 --> 01:59:37.079
Ash Mays, did Jay cause Alex to become blurry as
2234
01:59:37.140 --> 01:59:40.260
he's trying to usurp his king of the Orthobros? PSA,
2235
01:59:40.319 --> 01:59:42.579
if you don't kiss icons, you're not saved.
2236
01:59:43.880 --> 01:59:46.399
I think the general consensus is that Jay is the
2237
01:59:46.520 --> 01:59:49.430
emperor of Exantium and the Orthobros have dubbed me like
2238
01:59:49.470 --> 01:59:52.699
attorney general or something, so... I am fully satisfied.
2239
01:59:52.819 --> 01:59:55.260
Alex would be like the, you know, like the, Alex
2240
01:59:55.279 --> 01:59:59.699
would be like the Supreme, like Byzantine, uh, you know, canonical,
2241
02:00:00.689 --> 02:00:03.329
like the, like there's this list in the McGuckin book
2242
02:00:03.350 --> 02:00:06.810
of all these great judges in Byzantium. It's really cool section.
2243
02:00:06.850 --> 02:00:09.109
Like these guys were, these guys were bad asses. Like
2244
02:00:09.130 --> 02:00:11.789
they were doing all this stuff and nobody even knows
2245
02:00:11.829 --> 02:00:12.329
about these people.
2246
02:00:12.350 --> 02:00:18.489
Yeah. Other than vigilantes, who do Protestants, the first, uh,
2247
02:00:18.810 --> 02:00:24.020
Way to go, man. You created this second. Vigilantius the first.
2248
02:00:24.619 --> 02:00:25.899
I hope it sticks.
2249
02:00:26.579 --> 02:00:29.699
Gavin, he's Vigilantius the second, man. It's the same argument
2250
02:00:29.859 --> 02:00:30.640
all over again.
2251
02:00:32.220 --> 02:00:34.500
There's not a Jerome the second. Can I call dibs
2252
02:00:34.720 --> 02:00:38.420
on Jerome the second? By the way, to those that
2253
02:00:38.460 --> 02:00:43.539
are watching, I just recently released my second paper on St. Jerome,
2254
02:00:44.640 --> 02:00:49.199
specifically arguing that he's kind of a hidden undercover... factor
2255
02:00:49.359 --> 02:00:53.279
in the revision of the Nicene Creed from 325 to 381,
2256
02:00:53.279 --> 02:00:55.560
along with something he was able to accomplish with the
2257
02:00:55.600 --> 02:00:58.000
Vagris of Antioch that was not able to be done
2258
02:00:58.039 --> 02:01:02.119
by St. Basil, trying to appeal to Damasus for a revision,
2259
02:01:02.140 --> 02:01:04.899
especially with Sabellianism and so forth that was going around.
2260
02:01:05.529 --> 02:01:11.590
The whole miscommunication between Ussius, particularly the
Latin going into
2261
02:01:11.670 --> 02:01:13.789
from the Greek and trying to work out the idea
2262
02:01:13.810 --> 02:01:17.569
of three persons in one essence, How that was fleshing
2263
02:01:17.710 --> 02:01:20.109
out in Latin was not coming out the way that
2264
02:01:20.189 --> 02:01:23.109
Jerome wanted it to. He was concerned it was leading
2265
02:01:23.170 --> 02:01:27.100
to three persons, three essences. So I wrote on that
2266
02:01:27.449 --> 02:01:30.409
and I think his appeal to Pope Damasus, the tome
2267
02:01:30.449 --> 02:01:34.739
of Damasus that was accepted in Constantinople, issuing and also
2268
02:01:34.760 --> 02:01:38.399
the revision of the 381 Creed. It is of my opinion,
2269
02:01:38.619 --> 02:01:41.239
after spending, I can't even tell you how many hours now,
2270
02:01:42.140 --> 02:01:48.770
studying letters 15 and 16 of particularly and his correspondent
2271
02:01:48.810 --> 02:01:53.220
with Damas, Damas' tome and Damas' letter to Paulinus of
2272
02:01:53.319 --> 02:01:57.220
Antioch that there was most definitely, most people don't realize this, St.
2273
02:01:57.260 --> 02:02:02.100
Jerome was in Constantinople while the council was meeting and
2274
02:02:02.149 --> 02:02:06.630
he was being trained by Gregory of Nazianzus. Gregory of
2275
02:02:06.710 --> 02:02:11.210
Nazianzus headed up the council at the beginning and he's
2276
02:02:11.250 --> 02:02:14.550
sitting there in his home learning Greek polemics and he
2277
02:02:14.590 --> 02:02:18.810
got to hear Gregory of Nyssa, while in Constantinople, read
2278
02:02:19.140 --> 02:02:22.300
his work against Eunomius, so he got to hear Basil's
2279
02:02:22.579 --> 02:02:25.779
actual brother defend the belief against the heresies of the
2280
02:02:25.800 --> 02:02:30.079
Holy Spirit in person, goes back to Rome as a
2281
02:02:30.159 --> 02:02:33.949
delegate of communication between the East and the West, translating
2282
02:02:34.149 --> 02:02:38.729
Eastern Greek writings to Damasus in Latin. Damasus responding back
2283
02:02:38.789 --> 02:02:41.170
in Latin, he translated in the Greek, sent it out
2284
02:02:41.210 --> 02:02:43.899
while translating the Gospels of the Vulgate. So, That is
2285
02:02:43.939 --> 02:02:45.720
out and available. It's on my sub stack. I did
2286
02:02:45.779 --> 02:02:49.800
not put it up on academia.edu yet. It's going to
2287
02:02:49.840 --> 02:02:52.960
be submitted all together in a journal at some point,
2288
02:02:52.979 --> 02:02:55.399
but I've got to finish a few more, but that
2289
02:02:55.500 --> 02:02:56.100
one just came out.
2290
02:02:56.199 --> 02:02:56.439
Yes.
2291
02:02:57.260 --> 02:02:59.000
I don't even remember now. I've been up so late
2292
02:02:59.039 --> 02:03:00.920
at night finishing it. It was either a day ago
2293
02:03:00.960 --> 02:03:02.899
or two days ago. Check that out on my sub stack.
2294
02:03:03.239 --> 02:03:05.420
If you can't find my sub stack on the channel here,
2295
02:03:05.579 --> 02:03:07.380
just hit the different links. It'll take you right to it.
2296
02:03:08.399 --> 02:03:10.380
I looked at pictures of my church from three years ago.
2297
02:03:11.340 --> 02:03:14.649
There were 12 people at the service. Six were Chanters.
2298
02:03:15.090 --> 02:03:17.949
There's 160 now.
2299
02:03:18.520 --> 02:03:18.739
Wow.
2300
02:03:19.359 --> 02:03:21.319
That's what I'm saying. We're seeing more and more and
2301
02:03:21.340 --> 02:03:23.939
more of this. All right. I want to cover two
2302
02:03:23.960 --> 02:03:27.439
more things, gentlemen, and then we'll bow out here. The
2303
02:03:27.479 --> 02:03:31.300
first thing I want to talk about, and I know
2304
02:03:31.340 --> 02:03:34.850
that everybody eye rolls when Origin's brought up, but we're
2305
02:03:35.210 --> 02:03:38.050
going to do this. It's okay. And the reason I'm
2306
02:03:38.069 --> 02:03:40.989
bringing up Origin is because Gavin brought up Origin before.
2307
02:03:42.130 --> 02:03:45.609
I thought it was unique that Gavin would not concede
2308
02:03:45.750 --> 02:03:52.149
Origen taught this intercession. He specifically addressed on prayer and
2309
02:03:52.210 --> 02:03:55.949
against Kelsus. First of all, just on those alone, I
2310
02:03:56.430 --> 02:04:00.579
think he's wrong. And I have methodically walked through why
2311
02:04:00.659 --> 02:04:03.579
he's wrong. But what he did not do in the
2312
02:04:03.720 --> 02:04:09.039
second video is address our statements that came from his
2313
02:04:09.159 --> 02:04:13.130
work on the commentary of the Song of Songs, which
2314
02:04:13.210 --> 02:04:19.189
is preserved by Rufinus, Jerome's opponent, friend, then enemy. And
2315
02:04:19.880 --> 02:04:22.260
it's been preserved in Latin. And it's very hard to
2316
02:04:22.300 --> 02:04:24.079
find this. I found it, once again, I'm talking, this
2317
02:04:24.100 --> 02:04:26.520
is what I'm saying. We got scanned books now from
2318
02:04:26.539 --> 02:04:30.079
the 50s, translations that we didn't have access to. Just,
2319
02:04:30.220 --> 02:04:34.149
it's free. You can look it up. He argues that
2320
02:04:34.170 --> 02:04:38.350
Origen did not teach invocation and he did not answer
2321
02:04:38.939 --> 02:04:41.189
this citation i thought it was really interesting and i
2322
02:04:41.199 --> 02:04:42.970
want to point this out gentlemen kind of with all
2323
02:04:42.989 --> 02:04:47.930
the the the imagery and the poetic way of thinking
2324
02:04:47.970 --> 02:04:50.529
that he uses here from the song of songs because
2325
02:04:50.609 --> 02:04:55.630
obviously he takes an allegorical approach he says now that
2326
02:04:55.670 --> 02:04:58.789
we have explained about these orders of of charity to
2327
02:04:58.829 --> 02:05:01.569
the best of our ability it's easy to understand what
2328
02:05:01.609 --> 02:05:06.210
the bride that is to say the church or the
2329
02:05:06.329 --> 02:05:09.739
soul in pursuit of perfection So in the imagery of
2330
02:05:09.819 --> 02:05:13.300
Song of Songs, he takes the bride to mean the
2331
02:05:13.399 --> 02:05:18.739
church or a soul, the soul, singular. And in Latin,
2332
02:05:18.760 --> 02:05:21.640
it is ver, so it is or, not and, it's or.
2333
02:05:21.680 --> 02:05:25.199
It could be an individual pursuing love and charity. They're
2334
02:05:25.239 --> 02:05:29.159
not perfect, so they're able to do what about their imperfection? Well,
2335
02:05:29.180 --> 02:05:33.310
it says, ask the bridegroom's friends to do for her.
2336
02:05:33.850 --> 02:05:36.350
So they want to be helped in this subject of charity.
2337
02:05:37.079 --> 02:05:41.050
the bride is not perfect in charity, but wants to
2338
02:05:41.149 --> 02:05:46.149
ask the bridegroom's friends who are perfect in charity so
2339
02:05:46.189 --> 02:05:49.229
that they can enter the house of wine where doubtless
2340
02:05:49.270 --> 02:05:51.590
she had understood that among these things had been seen
2341
02:05:51.609 --> 02:05:53.949
the grace of charity was best and first of all,
2342
02:05:54.529 --> 02:05:58.479
and had learned that the same charity was greater than
2343
02:05:58.539 --> 02:06:00.960
all and the charity alone never fails. And then he
2344
02:06:01.020 --> 02:06:04.140
explains here particularly that All of us are trying to
2345
02:06:04.159 --> 02:06:07.199
get into this giant banquet, this banqueting with the Lord
2346
02:06:07.270 --> 02:06:09.810
where we all reach perfection in our acts of charity.
2347
02:06:10.590 --> 02:06:16.090
Then he brings people into this and he uses scripture. Rejoice,
2348
02:06:16.409 --> 02:06:19.930
you nations, with his people and may all the angels
2349
02:06:19.989 --> 02:06:22.850
of God comfort them. And then he talks about the
2350
02:06:22.930 --> 02:06:25.229
angel of the Lord encamping round about those who fear
2351
02:06:25.250 --> 02:06:28.310
and deliver them. And then he gets into this whole idea.
2352
02:06:28.350 --> 02:06:31.420
Despise not one of these least ones that are in
2353
02:06:31.439 --> 02:06:34.210
the church. For the angels always see the face of
2354
02:06:34.250 --> 02:06:37.069
the Father who's in heaven. So he's even believing that
2355
02:06:37.090 --> 02:06:40.930
there's angels assigned to individuals. In the Apocalypse of John,
2356
02:06:40.989 --> 02:06:43.880
the Son of God testifies to the angel of Thyatira
2357
02:06:43.899 --> 02:06:46.760
of charity, which he ordered in the church committed to
2358
02:06:46.800 --> 02:06:49.260
his care, for it is thus written, I know thy
2359
02:06:49.279 --> 02:06:52.060
works in the charity and faith and ministry and patience, etc.
2360
02:06:52.859 --> 02:06:54.779
It's interesting when you get into this point right here,
2361
02:06:55.079 --> 02:06:57.060
and this is where we can talk about it. It
2362
02:06:57.149 --> 02:07:01.079
seems to that there's nothing incongruous in taking this passage
2363
02:07:01.100 --> 02:07:04.000
of referring to the prophets who ministered the word of
2364
02:07:04.060 --> 02:07:07.560
God before the bridegrooms coming. The church will be desiring
2365
02:07:07.579 --> 02:07:10.020
in that case to learn the order of charity from
2366
02:07:10.119 --> 02:07:13.119
their teaching, that is, to be instructed out of the
2367
02:07:13.159 --> 02:07:16.800
prophetic books. Neither will be unsuitable if we should say
2368
02:07:16.840 --> 02:07:21.460
that all the saints who have departed this life still
2369
02:07:21.539 --> 02:07:25.140
have charity toward those who are in this world. and
2370
02:07:25.180 --> 02:07:29.329
are concerned for their salvation, and help them with their
2371
02:07:29.390 --> 02:07:32.710
prayers and intercessions before God. And then what is it? Quote,
2372
02:07:32.789 --> 02:07:35.149
for it is written in the book of Maccabees. This
2373
02:07:35.229 --> 02:07:39.050
is Jeremiah, the prophet of God, who always prays for
2374
02:07:39.090 --> 02:07:41.569
the people of God. So he gives the picture of
2375
02:07:41.590 --> 02:07:44.140
the bride, the bridegroom, the bridegroom's friends. Who are the
2376
02:07:44.180 --> 02:07:50.460
bridegroom's friends? Angels here, and saints, those who have reached
2377
02:07:50.500 --> 02:07:54.270
perfection here, who have departed this life, as he says,
2378
02:07:54.340 --> 02:07:58.189
departed this life, still having charity toward those in the world.
2379
02:07:58.210 --> 02:08:02.699
And they're able to help. with prayers and intercessions. And
2380
02:08:02.739 --> 02:08:06.260
then he uses an example of Jeremiah coming and bringing
2381
02:08:06.319 --> 02:08:10.270
a sword and praying for the people of Israel. So Gavin,
2382
02:08:10.449 --> 02:08:15.529
I'm still waiting for you to argue why you continually
2383
02:08:15.649 --> 02:08:20.720
say that Origen did not believe invocation could happen. He clearly,
2384
02:08:21.439 --> 02:08:26.890
by illustration of bride, bridegroom's friends, and the church and
2385
02:08:26.930 --> 02:08:31.050
the soul seeking perfection of charity can call to those
2386
02:08:31.090 --> 02:08:34.109
who have reached perfection, who are with the Lord, who
2387
02:08:34.149 --> 02:08:37.460
have departed this life and achieved charity. They're in the
2388
02:08:37.520 --> 02:08:40.899
banqueting feast and they can help us with our prayers
2389
02:08:40.960 --> 02:08:44.760
intercession and they can be called upon. So I don't
2390
02:08:44.800 --> 02:08:47.539
know why you keep saying origin didn't teach this. What
2391
02:08:47.560 --> 02:08:50.079
do you guys think about the imagery here? Obviously, origin
2392
02:08:52.279 --> 02:08:55.720
had some heretical issues, but in his commentary of Song
2393
02:08:55.739 --> 02:08:58.359
of Psalms, kind of like the Jewish mindset, does he
2394
02:08:58.399 --> 02:09:00.619
follow the Jewish mindset with some of these imageries?
2395
02:09:02.520 --> 02:09:04.399
I think that one seems pretty straightforward to me. I mean,
2396
02:09:04.659 --> 02:09:07.930
I'm usually reticent to take the advice of someone who,
2397
02:09:08.029 --> 02:09:12.850
you know, castrated themselves. But nonetheless, that one seems pretty straightforward.
2398
02:09:14.779 --> 02:09:16.840
Well, I mean, you take Gavin's advice sometimes, so I
2399
02:09:16.840 --> 02:09:18.880
don't know if that's true.
2400
02:09:18.939 --> 02:09:19.420
Oh, man.
2401
02:09:19.680 --> 02:09:22.460
I'm just kidding. I'm just joking. I couldn't resist. It
2402
02:09:22.479 --> 02:09:25.710
was too obvious. This whole stream has been debunked now.
2403
02:09:25.729 --> 02:09:27.710
All he's going to talk about is that one comment.
2404
02:09:29.310 --> 02:09:29.850
It's a joke.
2405
02:09:31.350 --> 02:09:33.970
I just think that whether you... I'm looking at the
2406
02:09:34.010 --> 02:09:36.050
first 200 years at the end of the day. I mean,
2407
02:09:36.109 --> 02:09:38.090
his whole point was first 200 years, and he brought
2408
02:09:38.149 --> 02:09:40.529
up Origin. By the way, Wes conceded that Origin did
2409
02:09:40.590 --> 02:09:44.600
teach that there's invocations. So I just don't know why
2410
02:09:44.619 --> 02:09:46.979
he didn't take Wes's position on that and move on.
2411
02:09:47.649 --> 02:09:50.710
But this one, we responded to his first video with
2412
02:09:50.750 --> 02:09:54.729
this quote and he ignored it and only focus. He
2413
02:09:54.770 --> 02:09:57.750
skipped that line, clip the section where we talked about
2414
02:09:57.810 --> 02:10:01.859
on prayer and totally ignored this one. I don't know
2415
02:10:01.880 --> 02:10:03.979
the reason I'm not going to judge his motive, but
2416
02:10:04.340 --> 02:10:07.460
I mean, to me, this one's obvious that the angels
2417
02:10:07.579 --> 02:10:10.399
and the departed souls of the righteous are the bridegroom's
2418
02:10:10.479 --> 02:10:14.020
friends and they can be asked. I mean, it's, it's
2419
02:10:14.279 --> 02:10:19.140
right here at the bottom of 193, is asking the
2420
02:10:19.180 --> 02:10:22.359
bridegroom's friends to do for her. What are they asking?
2421
02:10:22.960 --> 02:10:26.159
To help in the pursuit of perfection because they've already
2422
02:10:26.199 --> 02:10:29.479
achieved perfection in charity and they, the bride, have not
2423
02:10:29.539 --> 02:10:32.380
yet learned it fully. I don't understand why this one
2424
02:10:32.420 --> 02:10:34.619
gets skipped. Is there any imagery here that's connected to
2425
02:10:34.659 --> 02:10:39.250
Jewish thought at all? I'm not familiar with their interpretations. Obviously,
2426
02:10:39.270 --> 02:10:42.060
they wouldn't tie it to the church, of course. But
2427
02:10:42.159 --> 02:10:44.520
is the imagery pretty consistent with what we see in
2428
02:10:44.560 --> 02:10:46.699
these writings like the Song of Songs?
2429
02:10:50.670 --> 02:10:52.630
I mean, I think they would
tie it to the
2430
02:10:52.689 --> 02:10:54.970
love between, you know, God and Israel. I think they
2431
02:10:54.989 --> 02:10:55.670
would go that far.
2432
02:10:56.250 --> 02:10:56.489
Okay.
2433
02:10:56.510 --> 02:10:58.939
Sort of, you know, the marriage, because that marriage imagery
2434
02:10:58.949 --> 02:11:01.880
is very common in the Old Testament. And my assumption
2435
02:11:01.899 --> 02:11:06.789
would be, you know, this, that, as I'm sure you've
2436
02:11:06.829 --> 02:11:08.949
heard many, I mean, I mean, even when I was Catholic,
2437
02:11:08.970 --> 02:11:11.340
I remember people arguing that Psalm 45, you know, you
2438
02:11:11.399 --> 02:11:16.460
have the, the, the queen mother imagery there with Mary and,
2439
02:11:16.720 --> 02:11:20.239
you know, the king. And so Mary is a great
2440
02:11:20.279 --> 02:11:23.680
example of this, which would drive the Protestants crazy because the,
2441
02:11:23.779 --> 02:11:26.779
the best of these intercessors would of course be the Theotokos.
2442
02:11:27.220 --> 02:11:27.439
Yes.
2443
02:11:27.720 --> 02:11:31.329
And if the, the Theotokos is predicted in Psalm 45,
2444
02:11:31.329 --> 02:11:33.390
as the queen is, you know, stands in gold of
2445
02:11:33.470 --> 02:11:36.739
Ophir next to the king, then that's a pretty good
2446
02:11:36.840 --> 02:11:39.539
idea that, you know, she's pretty close to Jesus. So
2447
02:11:39.579 --> 02:11:43.390
she's probably got his ear. I think that comes out
2448
02:11:43.430 --> 02:11:44.529
of all that comes out of the.
2449
02:11:44.470 --> 02:11:45.930
Jewish queen mother tradition.
2450
02:11:46.689 --> 02:11:48.090
A hundred percent. Totally.
2451
02:11:48.109 --> 02:11:49.789
And that would, that would be reflected on a thing.
2452
02:11:49.829 --> 02:11:50.489
Song of songs.
2453
02:11:51.050 --> 02:11:52.550
I mean, obviously I'm not saying that the love, the
2454
02:11:52.609 --> 02:11:56.640
sexual love elements in the song of songs, that's typological
2455
02:11:56.779 --> 02:11:58.539
of Israel and the church.
2456
02:11:58.659 --> 02:12:01.159
I'm sorry. Agreed.
2457
02:12:01.399 --> 02:12:03.619
I just want Gavin to answer that one and not clip.
2458
02:12:04.199 --> 02:12:07.000
that section out to go to the next. Um, I
2459
02:12:07.039 --> 02:12:09.319
wish he would. Thanks for the super chat on that one. Uh,
2460
02:12:09.319 --> 02:12:12.399
really quick. And then, uh, we'll, we'll close it out
2461
02:12:12.439 --> 02:12:14.859
gentlemen with the sources. I want to get into the
2462
02:12:14.920 --> 02:12:18.180
sources cause this is the newest and that's a part
2463
02:12:18.199 --> 02:12:19.939
of what you showed a second ago, Alex, and your
2464
02:12:19.960 --> 02:12:24.039
most recent chat, ask him if intercession of the saints
2465
02:12:24.260 --> 02:12:28.180
is a sin, then why does God heal, resurrect people
2466
02:12:28.920 --> 02:12:35.520
through them? John nine 33 infallible deception. not entirely sure
2467
02:12:35.560 --> 02:12:40.119
i understand the full question um by the way gavin
2468
02:12:40.140 --> 02:12:43.090
did answer something like this when i think it was
2469
02:12:43.229 --> 02:12:47.250
peter raising was it the example of peter raising somebody
2470
02:12:47.289 --> 02:12:50.069
from the dead and calling the name of the deceased
2471
02:12:50.270 --> 02:12:52.729
to come to come back to life and then the
2472
02:12:53.810 --> 02:12:55.329
did he address that in the second video or the
2473
02:12:55.369 --> 02:12:58.270
first one do you remember alex i i do not
2474
02:12:58.310 --> 02:13:02.670
recall no Yeah, so maybe this is attached to that concept.
2475
02:13:02.789 --> 02:13:05.210
I'm not entirely sure. Sky Knight, if you want to
2476
02:13:05.250 --> 02:13:07.270
actually send a follow-up of what you mean by that,
2477
02:13:07.289 --> 02:13:08.449
you don't have to super chat it.
2478
02:13:08.529 --> 02:13:11.369
That is kind of funny, though, because Pentecostals do pray
2479
02:13:11.430 --> 02:13:14.630
for the dead. Whenever somebody dies, they will pray, like, God,
2480
02:13:14.689 --> 02:13:17.210
please bring them back to life. They're praying for the dead,
2481
02:13:17.470 --> 02:13:21.270
by definition. They think they can resurrect these people.
2482
02:13:21.289 --> 02:13:24.409
Well, and this is the weird thing, too. So my grandfather,
2483
02:13:24.510 --> 02:13:27.869
he's 84. but we're now, he's a converted Catholic to
2484
02:13:28.770 --> 02:13:32.149
a Protestant, very much against the Catholic church now. And
2485
02:13:32.909 --> 02:13:38.989
he went to Calabria, Italy, which is where my family
2486
02:13:39.020 --> 02:13:41.000
has been from for many, many years. I think I've
2487
02:13:41.020 --> 02:13:44.159
traced him back to the 1600s at this point. And
2488
02:13:44.220 --> 02:13:45.640
he said, what's that?
2489
02:13:46.420 --> 02:13:47.500
Barlam of Calabria.
2490
02:13:48.500 --> 02:13:53.180
Calabria. I like the Calabrian food though. Anyway, he was
2491
02:13:53.220 --> 02:13:56.329
sitting across the coast looking at Sicily. And he said,
2492
02:13:56.350 --> 02:13:57.710
he told me that he was telling me this just
2493
02:13:57.750 --> 02:13:59.149
a few months ago. He's like, I looked over at
2494
02:13:59.170 --> 02:14:01.060
the coast and I'm sitting there on a bench and
2495
02:14:01.069 --> 02:14:03.979
I see this Catholic church on the hill. And I
2496
02:14:04.000 --> 02:14:08.880
just started talking to my ancestors and this is Anthony.
2497
02:14:09.699 --> 02:14:12.159
You don't, you never met me. I'm your grandson, great,
2498
02:14:12.180 --> 02:14:15.619
great grandson. And, you know, it's just like checking in
2499
02:14:15.729 --> 02:14:19.069
on him. It's like, what, what would motivate a, a,
2500
02:14:19.350 --> 02:14:23.869
a Protestant who's like denied all of this stuff. He's
2501
02:14:23.930 --> 02:14:26.909
in a moment. He's sitting across the, sure
they're looking
2502
02:14:26.949 --> 02:14:29.430
at Sicily, looking at a Catholic church that his ancestors
2503
02:14:29.470 --> 02:14:31.649
probably attended. And then all of a sudden you're going
2504
02:14:31.670 --> 02:14:34.649
to start talking to them. I mean, how many Protestants
2505
02:14:34.670 --> 02:14:37.229
go to graves and talk to their loved ones as
2506
02:14:37.289 --> 02:14:40.880
if they're right there? I don't find this consistent or
2507
02:14:40.909 --> 02:14:45.779
compelling at all. I think it's inconsistent on their practice
2508
02:14:45.899 --> 02:14:49.420
when it comes to stuff like this. And my own grandfather,
2509
02:14:49.439 --> 02:14:51.079
I'm not, I mean, I love him to death. He's
2510
02:14:51.100 --> 02:14:53.920
a tremendous person, but it's like, I'm sitting there as
2511
02:14:53.960 --> 02:14:55.239
his grandson saying, are you serious?
2512
02:14:55.600 --> 02:14:57.720
Like, I think you see a lot of this, especially
2513
02:14:57.760 --> 02:15:01.359
in arguments about like, uh, iconography that the, it's kind
2514
02:15:01.390 --> 02:15:04.250
of impossible to live out, uh, to live in a
2515
02:15:04.270 --> 02:15:07.409
way that is consistent with the Protestant commitments, right? Uh,
2516
02:15:07.609 --> 02:15:09.750
you go to the, like the, the grave of the
2517
02:15:09.810 --> 02:15:12.449
unknown soldier, everybody takes off their hat. It doesn't matter
2518
02:15:12.470 --> 02:15:15.029
if anybody's watching or not. Everybody puts their hand over
2519
02:15:15.069 --> 02:15:17.770
their heart. They all venerate the graves of the soldiers
2520
02:15:17.829 --> 02:15:20.270
that died so that they could enjoy the liberties that
2521
02:15:20.310 --> 02:15:23.569
they have in this country today. Uh, But, you know,
2522
02:15:23.630 --> 02:15:26.710
when it's the martyrs that preserve the scriptures for us
2523
02:15:26.750 --> 02:15:28.850
and the faith for us and pass that down, suddenly
2524
02:15:28.909 --> 02:15:31.149
this is such a bad thing to do. It's a
2525
02:15:31.170 --> 02:15:32.250
blatant double standard.
2526
02:15:33.770 --> 02:15:36.670
Ash Mays gets it five fax memberships. Thank you so
2527
02:15:36.710 --> 02:15:39.789
much for doing that. Really, really appreciate that. Oh, my gosh.
2528
02:15:39.829 --> 02:15:44.829
I hope you're joking. Thanks heaps for your analysis of St. Origin,
2529
02:15:45.170 --> 02:15:50.210
doctor of the church whose intercession before God. Oh, my gosh.
2530
02:15:51.069 --> 02:15:53.130
You know, I had to get under my skin, I think.
2531
02:15:54.069 --> 02:15:57.470
I hope. I need you, my friend, please, to tell
2532
02:15:57.510 --> 02:15:59.850
me that that's a joke, right? Please. If you're in
2533
02:15:59.869 --> 02:16:02.109
the comments, for the love of God, tell me that's
2534
02:16:02.149 --> 02:16:06.909
a joke. All right. There's... Oh, sorry. I missed one.
2535
02:16:06.920 --> 02:16:10.359
The fact that Eliphaz attacks... Oh,
my goodness. I feel
2536
02:16:10.380 --> 02:16:11.600
so bad. I told him if he were to put
2537
02:16:11.640 --> 02:16:13.319
a $ 5 super chat, he could have fit it all
2538
02:16:13.380 --> 02:16:13.680
in there.
2539
02:16:13.779 --> 02:16:14.140
He did.
2540
02:16:14.159 --> 02:16:22.300
Whoops. The fact that Eliphaz attacks Colin Saint. And Job
2541
02:16:22.420 --> 02:16:28.020
establishes that Job practices this. There was no practice to
2542
02:16:28.079 --> 02:16:32.360
attack in Job. Do you know what he's getting at
2543
02:16:32.399 --> 02:16:33.120
when he's saying this?
2544
02:16:33.420 --> 02:16:38.079
Yeah, so in Job 5.1, Eliphaz, kind of sarcastically with
2545
02:16:38.159 --> 02:16:42.909
Job's misfortunes, he says, call out to the holy ones.
2546
02:16:43.010 --> 02:16:45.850
Call out to the Kedoshim in the Hebrew, and it's
2547
02:16:45.989 --> 02:16:48.790
Agui in the Greek, which is the saints. Call out
2548
02:16:48.809 --> 02:16:50.549
to the holy ones to see if any of them
2549
02:16:50.610 --> 02:16:54.209
will respond to you. The idea being that because Job
2550
02:16:54.290 --> 02:16:57.250
is in such a miserable state, albeit he was a
2551
02:16:57.290 --> 02:17:00.129
righteous man, because he's in such a miserable state that
2552
02:17:00.190 --> 02:17:01.690
nobody's going to want to go to bat for him
2553
02:17:01.819 --> 02:17:05.579
on God's divine assembly. Right. But that presupposes that it's
2554
02:17:05.600 --> 02:17:07.959
like it's the idea is that it's an awfully weird
2555
02:17:08.020 --> 02:17:10.979
thing to say if nobody had any idea of what
2556
02:17:11.020 --> 02:17:14.379
this practice was. Like, clearly, this is presupposing the practice
2557
02:17:14.420 --> 02:17:17.000
already existed in the time of Job. to call out
2558
02:17:17.059 --> 02:17:18.700
to the holy ones in the divine assembly.
2559
02:17:20.379 --> 02:17:22.909
Does this go back to what you were talking about earlier, Jay,
2560
02:17:23.389 --> 02:17:26.590
with the way that they were thinking back then, particularly?
2561
02:17:29.049 --> 02:17:34.489
Yeah, I mean, the thought process is that because we
2562
02:17:34.549 --> 02:17:39.469
are all one people, we're connected and linked, even though
2563
02:17:40.200 --> 02:17:42.139
Some of them have passed on. I think that's partly
2564
02:17:42.180 --> 02:17:45.860
why Jesus uses that phraseology of they, they're not dead.
2565
02:17:45.899 --> 02:17:46.959
They're asleep in the Lord.
2566
02:17:47.020 --> 02:17:47.180
Right.
2567
02:17:47.200 --> 02:17:49.260
He's not, they're not dead.
2568
02:17:49.299 --> 02:17:49.979
They're asleep.
2569
02:17:50.379 --> 02:17:52.940
They're alive to God. Um, even all the way back
2570
02:17:52.979 --> 02:17:56.579
in Genesis, right. Which, you know, you see that preservation
2571
02:17:56.620 --> 02:17:58.659
at the end of Genesis of the body of Joseph,
2572
02:17:59.520 --> 02:18:02.629
which shows us not just belief in the resurrection, but
2573
02:18:02.709 --> 02:18:06.850
belief in the, the live that they live on. Right.
2574
02:18:06.889 --> 02:18:09.350
So if they're going to be resurrected, then they're alive.
2575
02:18:09.889 --> 02:18:12.170
And even though they're separated from the body, they're still alive.
2576
02:18:12.229 --> 02:18:15.120
And I mean, it's just, to me, it's really odd.
2577
02:18:15.159 --> 02:18:17.700
By the way, it also shows like holy objects because
2578
02:18:17.739 --> 02:18:23.120
they venerate and want to bury Joseph. You know, they
2579
02:18:23.159 --> 02:18:26.750
want to preserve the body because they care for the body,
2580
02:18:26.809 --> 02:18:28.190
which if you're Protestant.
2581
02:18:28.229 --> 02:18:29.610
Like, I don't understand, like, why do you even care
2582
02:18:29.629 --> 02:18:30.450
about the body? Right.
2583
02:18:30.510 --> 02:18:32.969
Like God's going to resurrect it all. There's no, there's
2584
02:18:33.010 --> 02:18:35.979
no reason to care about these things. because God's going
2585
02:18:36.020 --> 02:18:38.479
to just arbitrarily resurrect it all. But yeah, anyway, back
2586
02:18:38.500 --> 02:18:38.959
to your point.
2587
02:18:38.979 --> 02:18:39.120
Yeah.
2588
02:18:39.139 --> 02:18:41.079
I think the book of Job is very interesting because
2589
02:18:41.120 --> 02:18:43.180
when I was Protestant, I never thought about this as
2590
02:18:43.989 --> 02:18:47.670
like a way to understand that we're still connected to
2591
02:18:47.709 --> 02:18:51.350
those who have moved on. And, you know, he, Eliphaz
2592
02:18:51.409 --> 02:18:54.510
is not saying something that's insane. He's saying like, what
2593
02:18:54.549 --> 02:18:57.540
would be an expected practice, whether it's a book about
2594
02:18:57.559 --> 02:19:00.100
a Jew or a Gentile, like this idea that there
2595
02:19:00.139 --> 02:19:02.870
is a contact with, those that are holy. And I
2596
02:19:02.909 --> 02:19:05.610
want to say it's been a while since I read Maccabees,
2597
02:19:05.670 --> 02:19:08.569
but isn't there a very similar type of situation where
2598
02:19:08.590 --> 02:19:14.159
they're praying for, you know, against the Romans and the enemies,
2599
02:19:14.180 --> 02:19:18.500
the Greeks, and they're praying that something would happen with
2600
02:19:18.540 --> 02:19:21.360
the temple or that somebody would stop the temple from
2601
02:19:21.399 --> 02:19:21.879
being defiled.
2602
02:19:21.899 --> 02:19:24.600
And then an angel appears, right?
2603
02:19:24.799 --> 02:19:27.799
And then there's an interaction with an angel and, I'm
2604
02:19:27.819 --> 02:19:29.360
forgetting all the details because it's been a while since
2605
02:19:29.389 --> 02:19:32.170
I've read Maccabees, but this would seem to suggest like
2606
02:19:33.149 --> 02:19:38.110
angelic interactions, right? So you see what I'm getting at?
2607
02:19:38.170 --> 02:19:39.709
I mean, this is not a theophany where it's an
2608
02:19:39.770
--> 02:19:41.450
angel of the Lord that's supposed to be Christ. This
2609
02:19:41.489 --> 02:19:44.399
is like specifically an angel. Do you know what I'm
2610
02:19:44.440 --> 02:19:47.059
talking about? I'm going a little fuzzy on this, but
2611
02:19:47.520 --> 02:19:51.540
that might also conceivably be like from man to angel
2612
02:19:51.579 --> 02:19:52.379
type interaction.
2613
02:19:53.860 --> 02:19:54.760
Which I don't know.
2614
02:19:55.090 --> 02:19:56.209
I don't know if he would count.
2615
02:19:56.290 --> 02:19:58.850
It's either... It might be in 2 Maccabees, but it's when...
2616
02:19:58.590 --> 02:20:00.170
There's like a.
2617
02:20:01.989 --> 02:20:04.030
I wonder if he would count that as angel. I
2618
02:20:04.049 --> 02:20:05.670
wonder if he would count that earth to earth.
2619
02:20:05.770 --> 02:20:06.049
I wonder.
2620
02:20:06.069 --> 02:20:08.270
I'm trying to use Gavin's rules.
2621
02:20:08.299 --> 02:20:10.559
Well, no, there's a prayer by the high priest. I
2622
02:20:10.600 --> 02:20:11.799
want to say... Oh, yeah.
2623
02:20:11.920 --> 02:20:12.459
Onius?
2624
02:20:12.520 --> 02:20:13.040
Is it Onius?
2625
02:20:13.059 --> 02:20:16.100
The high priest is Jason, and then he prays, and
2626
02:20:16.120 --> 02:20:20.229
then an angel appears... And gives hands a sword or something?
2627
02:20:20.729 --> 02:20:23.409
Yes, Jeremiah brings the sword. I've got it. Actually, it's
2628
02:20:23.450 --> 02:20:25.790
in my notes here. I've got it right here. I'll
2629
02:20:25.950 --> 02:20:30.229
share it. 2 Maccabees 15, 12 through 16. Let me
2630
02:20:30.629 --> 02:20:32.750
actually pull it up. I actually have it right here.
2631
02:20:34.350 --> 02:20:38.579
One second, one second. Why aren't you sharing my screen?
2632
02:20:40.360 --> 02:20:42.120
There we go. Can we see it?
2633
02:20:45.520 --> 02:20:47.829
There it is. All right, so this might be what
2634
02:20:47.950 --> 02:20:49.889
we're dealing with because we use this in our first
2635
02:20:49.950 --> 02:20:52.469
response to Gavin. What he saw was this.
2636
02:20:52.649 --> 02:20:53.549
I'm sorry.
2637
02:20:54.129 --> 02:20:56.590
No, no, you're good. No, this is perfect. It just
2638
02:20:56.610 --> 02:20:58.500
dawned on me in the first response to Gavin, we
2639
02:20:58.579 --> 02:21:03.180
actually mentioned this passage. What he saw was this. Onias,
2640
02:21:03.239 --> 02:21:09.479
the former high priest, he's died. A noble and good man,
2641
02:21:09.579 --> 02:21:13.450
modest and bearing, gentle manner, distinguishes and trains from childhood.
2642
02:21:13.979 --> 02:21:17.500
and all that belongs to his excellence, was praying with
2643
02:21:17.760 --> 02:21:21.719
outstretched arms for the whole Jewish community. Then in the
2644
02:21:21.760 --> 02:21:24.700
same way, another man appeared, distinguished by his white hair
2645
02:21:24.729 --> 02:21:28.129
and dignity, and with his air of wondrous and majestic authority.
2646
02:21:28.350 --> 02:21:31.270
Onias then said to him, this is a man who
2647
02:21:31.329 --> 02:21:35.010
loves his fellow Jews and fervently prays for the people
2648
02:21:35.909 --> 02:21:39.159
and the holy city, the prophet of God, Jeremiah. So
2649
02:21:39.190 --> 02:21:44.670
Jeremiah shows up. So you have Onias praying, The former Hebrides.
2650
02:21:45.500 --> 02:21:47.520
And then it says, stretching out his right hand. By
2651
02:21:47.559 --> 02:21:52.739
the way, this is the exact passage that Origen was
2652
02:21:52.819 --> 02:21:56.979
talking about by defending his position on invocation to the
2653
02:21:57.020 --> 02:22:00.739
bride and the bridegroom's friends. He used this very passage.
2654
02:22:00.780 --> 02:22:04.540
By the way, he called it Holy Scripture. Stretching out
2655
02:22:04.860 --> 02:22:09.399
his right hand, Jeremiah presented a gold sword to Judas.
2656
02:22:10.200 --> 02:22:12.450
That's Judas Maccabeus. And he gave it to him and
2657
02:22:12.469 --> 02:22:15.930
he said, accept this holy sword as a gift from God.
2658
02:22:16.110 --> 02:22:20.850
With it, you shall shatter your adversaries. Now, according to Gavin,
2659
02:22:21.719 --> 02:22:24.680
in this situation, Judas would not be able to respond
2660
02:22:24.719 --> 02:22:28.399
to Jeremiah, I guess. I'm trying to follow rules here.
2661
02:22:28.639 --> 02:22:32.260
So could he actually grab the sword from him too?
2662
02:22:32.420 --> 02:22:35.069
Or does that count as it? I like, what's the limit?
2663
02:22:35.170 --> 02:22:39.229
So here's Jeremiah. He shows up. There's invocation going. A
2664
02:22:39.290 --> 02:22:43.920
dead priest is around. jeremiah stretches it out presents this
2665
02:22:44.000 --> 02:22:47.579
gold sword and says shatter your adversaries and poor i
2666
02:22:47.600 --> 02:22:49.969
mean poor judas over here he can't even accept the
2667
02:22:50.010 --> 02:22:52.510
gift and say thank you nothing i mean according to
2668
02:22:52.549 --> 02:22:57.229
the rules he can't talk to jeremiah so i don't
2669
02:22:57.250 --> 02:22:59.010
know how this would work is this the passage we're
2670
02:22:59.049 --> 02:23:01.090
talking about gentlemen is this the one we were referring.
2671
02:23:00.850 --> 02:23:05.889
To yeah that's it all right there's also a go
2672
02:23:05.909 --> 02:23:09.370
ahead in second maccabees chapter three you start from verse
2673
02:23:09.370 --> 02:23:16.379
22 there's a an episode with angelic intercession or intervention rather,
2674
02:23:16.659 --> 02:23:19.399
but starting from verse 22 in the Orthodox study Bible,
2675
02:23:19.420 --> 02:23:21.819
it says they called upon the almighty Lord to keep
2676
02:23:21.879 --> 02:23:24.059
safe and secure what had been entrusted for those who
2677
02:23:24.100 --> 02:23:26.840
had placed them in trust. But Heliodorus continued with what
2678
02:23:26.860 --> 02:23:28.989
had been decided when he arrived at the treasury with
2679
02:23:29.030 --> 02:23:32.110
his bodyguard, the Lord of spirits and all authority was
2680
02:23:32.250 --> 02:23:35.170
already present. He caused such a great manifestation that all
2681
02:23:35.190 --> 02:23:37.590
who dared to accompany him were panic stricken at God's power.
2682
02:23:38.219 --> 02:23:40.579
They turned about and fled in feebleness, for a certain
2683
02:23:40.659 --> 02:23:44.120
horse appeared to them, having a fearful rider. It was
2684
02:23:44.170 --> 02:23:47.870
arrayed with a very beautiful pack saddle. It rushed furiously
2685
02:23:47.930 --> 02:23:50.969
at Heliodorus and struck him with its front hooves. He
2686
02:23:51.010 --> 02:23:53.870
who sat thereon was seen wearing full armor of gold.
2687
02:23:54.270 --> 02:23:56.879
Two other young men also appeared to him, remarkable in
2688
02:23:56.899 --> 02:24:00.620
bodily strength, very beautiful in grandeur and illustrious in dress.
2689
02:24:01.139 --> 02:24:03.559
They stood on either side of him and pummeled him continually,
2690
02:24:04.159 --> 02:24:08.350
inflicting him with many wounds. And then the Onias intercedes
2691
02:24:08.430 --> 02:24:14.909
for Heliodorus. And then these young men, these remarkable beings
2692
02:24:15.030 --> 02:24:18.309
appear again. And they say that the Most High God
2693
02:24:18.350 --> 02:24:23.030
has had mercy and granted life to Heliodorus because of
2694
02:24:23.069 --> 02:24:27.270
the intercessions of Onias. So it's just another example in
2695
02:24:27.270 --> 02:24:29.370
2 Maccabees of angelic intervention. So....
2696
02:24:34.229 --> 02:24:38.879
So in your mind, 2 Maccabees could qualify invocation in
2697
02:24:38.920 --> 02:24:41.899
both circumstances. Both sections.
2698
02:24:44.040 --> 02:24:46.520
There's nothing in there to disqualify it. I think that
2699
02:24:46.620 --> 02:24:50.500
there's definitely... There are no qualms. I'll put it this way.
2700
02:24:50.520 --> 02:24:54.520
It seems that there are no qualms with interacting with
2701
02:24:54.559 --> 02:24:57.940
spiritual beings. Yeah.
2702
02:24:58.280 --> 02:24:58.750
I just think.
2703
02:24:58.989 --> 02:25:00.049
Through the high priest.
2704
02:25:00.639 --> 02:25:02.659
Well, I just think it's a weird situation that all
2705
02:25:02.680 --> 02:25:08.079
of this activity can be happening around Judas Maccabeus. Somebody's
2706
02:25:08.120 --> 02:25:12.100
praying for him and the people. Jeremiah the prophet shows up,
2707
02:25:12.309 --> 02:25:14.709
has a sword in his hand. I mean, I'm just
2708
02:25:14.729 --> 02:25:19.430
trying to picture Judas. Is he duct taped? Can't receive
2709
02:25:19.450 --> 02:25:22.729
the sword? Can't say thank you? At what point does
2710
02:25:22.770 --> 02:25:27.270
he violate Gavin's rules of invocation in this scene? Some
2711
02:25:27.290 --> 02:25:30.100
things are just like, okay, well... this is happening. This
2712
02:25:30.180 --> 02:25:33.250
is happening. It would stand to reason
that Judas probably
2713
02:25:33.290 --> 02:25:38.670
grabbed the sword and said something. I mean, but I
2714
02:25:38.690 --> 02:25:42.049
don't know. I I'm concerned about the, the methodology we're
2715
02:25:42.170 --> 02:25:44.350
using to make rules because I just don't think they're
2716
02:25:44.370 --> 02:25:45.770
consistent and I don't think they work.
2717
02:25:46.469 --> 02:25:49.559
Well, every piece of direct evidence is just poetic or
2718
02:25:49.739 --> 02:25:50.159
you just.
2719
02:25:50.020 --> 02:25:52.860
Hand away poetic apostrophe. That's what it is. Uh, or
2720
02:25:52.879 --> 02:25:55.260
it's a vision and it's a third person in heaven
2721
02:25:55.299 --> 02:25:59.040
with other heavenly beings. And therefore it doesn't qualify. And, Again,
2722
02:25:59.059 --> 02:26:01.819
we're just making stuff up as we go. Job calling
2723
02:26:01.879 --> 02:26:05.979
on saints doesn't prove anything because Job is just a
2724
02:26:06.020 --> 02:26:09.250
legend like St. Ignatius. Lord, forgive me for even saying
2725
02:26:09.290 --> 02:26:12.930
that in jest. As long as your jest is $ 5,
2726
02:26:12.670 --> 02:26:16.530
we'll take it. Oh, my goodness. So a little history there.
2727
02:26:16.569 --> 02:26:18.049
Wait a minute, wait a minute, wait a minute. Go ahead,
2728
02:26:18.170 --> 02:26:20.229
go ahead, go ahead. In 2 Maccabees 15, look at
2729
02:26:20.290 --> 02:26:20.750
verse 14. All right.
2730
02:26:34.649 --> 02:26:36.309
I knew there was something in here because I had
2731
02:26:36.350 --> 02:26:38.489
this circle. I hadn't been in this in a long time,
2732
02:26:38.549 --> 02:26:43.319
but Maccabees was another great one for helping me leave Protestantism.
2733
02:26:43.459 --> 02:26:46.479
I mean, I guess you already have to kind of
2734
02:26:46.579 --> 02:26:51.159
accept it as canonical, but still it's evidence for.
2735
02:26:53.159 --> 02:26:54.299
Jewish beliefs at that time.
2736
02:26:55.100 --> 02:27:00.290
So 2 Maccabees 15 and verse 14, I think, unless
2737
02:27:00.729 --> 02:27:01.530
the number is different.
2738
02:27:02.819 --> 02:27:04.760
Yeah, I'm going to pull this off stage. Sorry.
2739
02:27:05.040 --> 02:27:06.399
I'm going to bring it up. Actually, I'm going to
2740
02:27:06.440 --> 02:27:08.139
share it on the screen for everybody. You said it's
2741
02:27:08.159 --> 02:27:09.879
chapter 15, verse 14?
2742
02:27:09.879 --> 02:27:12.159
Yeah, 15, 14.
2743
02:27:12.159 --> 02:27:19.600
All right. And Ananias spoke, saying, This is a man
2744
02:27:19.659 --> 02:27:23.020
who loves the family of Israel and prays much for
2745
02:27:23.040 --> 02:27:26.739
the city and the holy city, Jeremiah the prophet of God.
2746
02:27:27.940 --> 02:27:31.200
So Jeremiah, who has passed away, Yes.
2747
02:27:31.520 --> 02:27:35.579
Is righteous and praise often for the Holy city and
2748
02:27:35.600 --> 02:27:38.600
the people of God. now i know you're i know
2749
02:27:38.659 --> 02:27:43.000
gavin's gonna say that that's from heaven down right you
2750
02:27:43.040 --> 02:27:46.399
can't go from earth up but um i mean doesn't
2751
02:27:46.420 --> 02:27:49.290
the text in revelation says that the uh is that
2752
02:27:49.370 --> 02:27:50.829
one i guess another one he would just say well
2753
02:27:50.850 --> 02:27:55.909
that's heaven down that's not earth up but um yeah
2754
02:27:56.389 --> 02:27:57.729
that's why it's arbitrary.
2755
02:27:58.770 --> 02:28:03.670
Agreed Job calling on saints doesn't prove anything. That was
2756
02:28:03.729 --> 02:28:07.329
the joke about St. Ignatius. So that's what's interesting. That
2757
02:28:07.350 --> 02:28:09.290
was the whole thing with James White because I called
2758
02:28:09.329 --> 02:28:11.350
him out on the whole Ignatius thing because he was
2759
02:28:12.229 --> 02:28:15.659
debating Joe Heschmeyer and made a ridiculous comment. Then he
2760
02:28:15.690 --> 02:28:18.200
tried to backtrack, very similar to what we're seeing happen
2761
02:28:18.219 --> 02:28:21.180
in this whole discussion. And so I said, you know,
2762
02:28:21.200 --> 02:28:23.760
because then he claimed that there was no bishop in Rome.
2763
02:28:24.239 --> 02:28:27.100
During the time of Ignatius, the bishopric started in the
2764
02:28:27.239 --> 02:28:29.020
East and made it later to the West in the
2765
02:28:29.079 --> 02:28:32.360
second century, which is insane. And so I'm sitting there
2766
02:28:32.500 --> 02:28:34.360
listening to him say this, and I'm like, he's got
2767
02:28:34.379 --> 02:28:37.700
to be kidding. This is satire. And he wasn't kidding.
2768
02:28:37.739 --> 02:28:39.799
He was dead serious. He actually did a second follow-up
2769
02:28:39.840 --> 02:28:44.120
video responding to me again and argued once again that
2770
02:28:44.180 --> 02:28:46.329
Ignatius does not prove that there's a bishop in Rome
2771
02:28:46.340 --> 02:28:49.610
because no bishop in Rome is mentioned. I argued, well,
2772
02:28:49.629 --> 02:28:52.510
there's no presbyters or deacons mentioned either, so therefore there
2773
02:28:52.549 --> 02:28:54.489
must not be any deacons or presbyters in Rome.
2774
02:28:54.909 --> 02:28:57.209
Noticing a pattern with these arguments from silence.
2775
02:28:57.829 --> 02:29:00.170
It's insane. It's like it could be that he's heading
2776
02:29:00.239 --> 02:29:02.579
toward the city where he's about to be executed, and
2777
02:29:02.620 --> 02:29:05.979
it's probably not wise to be putting these men's names
2778
02:29:06.180 --> 02:29:10.469
in this letter, putting their lives in jeopardy. So you
2779
02:29:10.510 --> 02:29:15.149
have protective anonymity going on here. That's number one. Also,
2780
02:29:15.229 --> 02:29:17.870
he already qualified in his other letters that in order
2781
02:29:17.909 --> 02:29:20.350
to have a church, you must have a bishop. So
2782
02:29:20.430 --> 02:29:23.790
that would follow that if he's writing to the church
2783
02:29:23.969 --> 02:29:26.899
in Rome, they have a bishop. So I challenged him
2784
02:29:27.319 --> 02:29:29.139
on a debate on this publicly. I even had a
2785
02:29:29.170 --> 02:29:32.059
guy in Texas, a Lutheran, who is willing to host
2786
02:29:32.100 --> 02:29:34.659
it at his church and pay for the travel for
2787
02:29:34.719 --> 02:29:36.969
he and I to go there and debate it. And
2788
02:29:37.010 --> 02:29:40.389
he said, unless I was willing to debate the Immaculate Conception,
2789
02:29:40.909 --> 02:29:42.829
he wasn't going to debate Ignatius. And it's like, what
2790
02:29:42.850 --> 02:29:45.090
does the Immaculate Conception have to do with anything you've
2791
02:29:45.110 --> 02:29:47.239
been touting on the internet for the last two weeks?
2792
02:29:47.620 --> 02:29:50.819
This is insane. So since I wouldn't take the bait
2793
02:29:50.979 --> 02:29:54.459
on that, um, I, the daughter white, I know you
2794
02:29:54.500 --> 02:29:57.299
watch my channel because you respond to me all the time. Hey,
2795
02:29:57.780 --> 02:30:01.979
old friend, I Texas, let me know. Uh, I'll buy
2796
02:30:02.040 --> 02:30:06.879
your barbecue while I'm down there. And, um, But Ignatius
2797
02:30:06.940 --> 02:30:09.860
is your claim. Ignatius is my field of study. So
2798
02:30:09.989 --> 02:30:12.250
I think it makes sense for us to debate the
2799
02:30:12.290 --> 02:30:15.629
subject you brought up. I'm assuming that's what Ash is
2800
02:30:15.670 --> 02:30:18.950
getting at because he's jesting at the whole situation. They
2801
02:30:18.969 --> 02:30:21.010
could be playing basketball. You don't know.
2802
02:30:21.969 --> 02:30:24.690
They could be on spaceships for all you know.
2803
02:30:26.010 --> 02:30:28.959
I cleared up in chat. Let's talk about the scholars
2804
02:30:29.000 --> 02:30:30.760
and let's end this thing, gentlemen. Let's talk about the
2805
02:30:30.780 --> 02:30:34.100
scholars and let's end this. Alex, this is your fault,
2806
02:30:34.219 --> 02:30:37.360
number one. Number two, well, it's Gavin's fault. It's your
2807
02:30:37.399 --> 02:30:41.270
fault for drawing attention to it. What I thought was
2808
02:30:41.309 --> 02:30:45.739
really weird is that we had a conversation, you and I,
2809
02:30:47.670 --> 02:30:49.190
and one of the things that he brought up, one
2810
02:30:50.790 --> 02:30:53.159
of the things that he brought up was multiple sources
2811
02:30:53.170 --> 02:30:55.760
that he cited in his first and then defended in
2812
02:30:55.799 --> 02:31:00.500
his second video. And he jumped on you about one.
2813
02:31:01.760 --> 02:31:03.329
And then he didn't defend some of the other ones
2814
02:31:03.340 --> 02:31:05.110
you called out, which I thought was interesting because I
2815
02:31:05.149 --> 02:31:07.409
compared it to, it's kind of like, all right, you
2816
02:31:07.430 --> 02:31:11.950
got four total here. You missed three and you're fighting
2817
02:31:12.010 --> 02:31:15.950
for the one. It's like a student coming to me saying, hey,
2818
02:31:16.069 --> 02:31:17.770
I know I made a zero, but I really think
2819
02:31:17.809 --> 02:31:20.110
I should get a 25 because I got this one.
2820
02:31:20.510 --> 02:31:23.229
My F is better than the zero F you're giving me.
2821
02:31:23.690 --> 02:31:26.850
I want my 25 F. Like, first of all, acknowledge
2822
02:31:26.870 --> 02:31:30.770
that you messed up the first few. Like, let's just
2823
02:31:30.809 --> 02:31:33.340
go ahead and, stop ignoring the fact that you didn't
2824
02:31:33.379 --> 02:31:36.700
defend the others because you know that's indefensible you went
2825
02:31:36.760 --> 02:31:39.319
straight to her tato which is going to come up
2826
02:31:39.360 --> 02:31:42.860
here her tato's the big one um so go ahead
2827
02:31:43.100 --> 02:31:45.479
and and walk us through jay were you caught up
2828
02:31:45.520 --> 02:31:47.969
with this did did he yeah i did see all
2829
02:31:47.989 --> 02:31:51.270
this oh my goodness all right so walk us through
2830
02:31:51.290 --> 02:31:52.149
what happened because this.
2831
02:31:52.069 --> 02:31:55.500
Is insane yeah so my response video i'd I basically
2832
02:31:55.559 --> 02:31:58.000
site checked a lot of Gavin's sources. Do they really
2833
02:31:58.059 --> 02:32:00.319
say what he says they're saying? Because then it might
2834
02:32:00.340 --> 02:32:02.270
be the case that I have to change my position. And,
2835
02:32:02.520 --> 02:32:05.319
you know, that's fine. I'm open to that. But I
2836
02:32:05.399 --> 02:32:08.340
actually looked up the sources and it's interesting that they
2837
02:32:08.389 --> 02:32:11.170
say exactly what I am saying, in fact, and they
2838
02:32:11.329 --> 02:32:14.649
do not support Gavin. They refute Gavin and they confirm
2839
02:32:14.790 --> 02:32:17.569
my position. Then after talking to Jay, I talked to
2840
02:32:17.590 --> 02:32:19.370
Jay a little bit today, brought up a bunch of
2841
02:32:19.469 --> 02:32:23.450
other scholarly sources I wasn't even aware of. that this
2842
02:32:23.530 --> 02:32:29.350
is like a very long standing, resounding notion in academia,
2843
02:32:29.489 --> 02:32:32.770
in scholarship. This is like this is like Gavin's position
2844
02:32:32.829 --> 02:32:35.010
is not something that's taken seriously. But I ended up
2845
02:32:35.079 --> 02:32:39.579
buying the Larry Hurtado's book because it's a good book
2846
02:32:39.659 --> 02:32:42.639
and it's useful in more ways than just one. But
2847
02:32:42.680 --> 02:32:45.559
here's the book. It's Lord Jesus Christ, Devotion to Jesus
2848
02:32:45.600 --> 02:32:47.780
in Earliest Christianity. You have to keep in mind the
2849
02:32:47.819 --> 02:32:51.260
context of Larry Hurtado as well. He's responding to a
2850
02:32:51.299 --> 02:32:54.139
lot of scholars that are saying, well, oh, Christian worship
2851
02:32:54.159 --> 02:32:56.540
of Jesus is not that unique. It's not a big
2852
02:32:56.579 --> 02:33:00.059
deal because they were already worshiping angels ahead of time
2853
02:33:00.159 --> 02:33:02.930
in those centuries leading up to the Christian worship.
2854
02:33:03.190 --> 02:33:06.250
The Orlov book, by the way, cites Hurtado quite a bit.
2855
02:33:06.290 --> 02:33:09.790
They're both kind of scholars in this domain, and he
2856
02:33:09.829 --> 02:33:11.510
says a lot of the same stuff in this text.
2857
02:33:12.129 --> 02:33:15.899
What year is that book, Jay? About roughly what year
2858
02:33:15.959 --> 02:33:16.420
is that book?
2859
02:33:17.209 --> 02:33:19.250
It's pretty new. He's still a living.
2860
02:33:19.430 --> 02:33:20.559
He's a living scholar.
2861
02:33:20.579 --> 02:33:21.420
Let me see what the public.
2862
02:33:21.440 --> 02:33:24.280
Because I think Hurtado passed away not too long ago.
2863
02:33:24.399 --> 02:33:26.440
Don't quote me on that, but I'm pretty sure.
2864
02:33:26.579 --> 02:33:27.979
I think in 2020 he passed away.