TRANSKRIBEERI 🔗
00:00:02
Speaker 1: Well, it's a big amount of money. Sixteen billion dollars. That's how much tax Australia's biggest banks paid last year. And at the same time, organizations like Apple, Google and matter. You think about the ease with which and the frequency with which we now go double click on our iPhones when we're paying for stuff, when we're doing online shopping, the amount of tax that is paid by these big offshore multinationals, and talking here about you know, companies like Apple and Google, biggest companies in the world today, they're doing absolutely none of the heavy lifting in Australia compared to our banks. Now. I know that people are reluctant to get the violin out for the banks, but on this case they have a bit of a point and it's a point that was made forcefully yesterday at an Australian Financial Review banking seminar that was attended by our next guest, long standing friend of the program, former Liberal Senator Simon Birmingham, who now heads up the Australian Banking Association BERMO. Thanks for joining us. The piece you wrote it ye great to have you on the show. The piece you wrote in the Financial Review yesterday, I thought made some compelling points and as I said, then you're smart enough a person to know that the banks aren't going to win the public over with a SOB story. But it's not a level playing field at all, is it.
00:01:22
Speaker 2: Well, that's the level playing field argument indeed is whether we have focused the argument PEMBO. But yes, banks pay big taxes and Australians think they should and that's fair enough. And so around sixteen billion dollars in taxes paid by Australia's banks second only to the mining industry in terms of the amount of tax paid. And to put that in some perspective understanding is it's more than fully funds GP bulk billing or could pay for essentially the pharmaceutical benefits scheme. Almost these are big things our country depends upon, and those taxes paid by banks pay for them. Fine. But what we're seeing is that increasingly companies like Apple when it comes to payment systems or META when it comes to scams, they are not pulling their weight and aren't treated the same by regulation in Australia and certainly aren't paying the same when it comes to tax. They also aren't the same when it comes to jobs and the five largest banks in Australia employ nearly one hundred and eighty thousand people, and yet Meta, Google, Apple employ fewer than six thousand. So when you stack it up by contribution of tax or jobs, or indeed actual regulatory impact, it's just a disproportionate balance. And we've got to make those big multinational tech companies start to pay their way and face the regulatory equivalents of Australian industries and Australian businesses.
00:02:55
Speaker 3: So, Iman, you've been a form of finance minister, explain to us what the difficulty is with pinning these months nationals down and getting them to pay a fair rate of tax. Because we've just come out of a
Load full transcript
chat with Phil Career. We're talking about tax reform potentially that the treasure might contemplate at the next budget. But I can't believe there is a Treasurer in the history of Australia who would say I would rather make reforms to things like negative gearing and capital gains tax and so forth that affect Australian tax players, then go after Apple. So there must be some regulatory hurdle or difficulty with pinning them down that the average person doesn't see what is.
00:03:28
Speaker 2: That so will It is about how costs for companies like Apple are attributed to the parent body and how they make their contribution in terms of branding, R and D, those sorts of factors that minimize the degree of profit that they record in a country like Australia and therefore pay tax against. Now, we had sought to try to make sure that in terms of that incentive to profit shift. In the past, there'd been an agreement through the OECD to try to get minimum company tax levels across all the relevant countries and that was going to be a way to remove the incentive to be shifting those profits around different parts of the world. In the last year or so, that's fallen over and it's no longer an option. So governments do have to go back and look at things like diverted profit taxes and other ways to really try to capture that part of it. Now that's for governance the day to try to find those ways in a tax sense to capture the revenue. But it's also important that we don't let evermore revenue leap off to those companies. And so the Reserve Bank now has powers that it can start to use in terms of how it regulates our payment system. It caps the amount that banks can charge in terms of fees on credit cards and debit cards, but there's nothing about the amount that Apple can charge when you're using that double click on your five And those are powers that with those new newer laws that the Reserve Bank has, we're eager to see them use so that we stop that leakage of revenue from Australian companies into those global multinationals who aren't paying their way in tax.
00:05:17
Speaker 1: Just to be clear, though, timber Birmingham, you're the bank, the banks, the big four banks who you represent, and the other medium sized ones as well. They're not arguing we want to pay less tax or we want to be able to charge higher fees for digital banking transactions. Rather, you're saying, if we have to do all of this, why don't the tech giants have to do more of it too?
00:05:43
Speaker 2: Spot On, Pembo. I'm not silly enough to think that anybody is out there saying thanks need to be paying less tax. Our point is that we would argue we pay our fair share under Australia's tax structure. I said, second only to the mining industry. You know, more than any other industry sector, and that sixteen billion dollars doesn't include, you know, the two and a half billion dollars that banks spend fighting fraud and scams and investing in things to try to keep consumers safer. These are all critical additional investments that you don't see from those big tech companies, and that is where we're just calling for equivalent treatment. It's not easy, I know that from my past life. But we've got new laws in place and there's capacity now for regulators like the RBA to use those laws and to try to make sure that we keep that sovereign capability for Australians of having strong Australian banks, employing Australian people and paying taxes in Australia.
00:06:45
Speaker 1: Simon Birmingham, the CEO of the Australian Banking Association, thank you for joining us this morning. I've been scammed twice with my credit card. Once was after that big family trip we did years ago to Mexico. We're sick. Months later, all of these transactions popped up on my credit card in can Kun, thinking that's funny. I'm pretty sure I was in Heimar Square for the last month and not trying to pay for flights and hotel rooms in the Yakatan Peninsula. You ring a bank in Australia and say, I've just noticed this on my credit card. They are generally completely excellent in helping you with something that is not their fault. But conversely, you look at Facebook like, you know, how good mate Koshi. He has spent years trying to get Google and Facebook to act on those scam ads that they run using his image, saying what happens next, You won't believe it. They do it to Carl Stephano. Facebook just flat out refuses to do anything about that, despite the fact that ten percent of their advertising revenue comes from scam advertising.
00:07:52
Speaker 3: It's extraordinary, isn't it.
00:07:53
Speaker 1: They all care and no responsibility.