TRANSKRIBEERI 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:00.740 --> 00:00:13.940
Morgan Stanley thinks TeraWolf is going to more than quadruple. It's the most bullish call for the stock that we've seen from any investment bank this year, and we are going to dive into the numbers here on this show.
2
00:00:14.900 --> 00:00:25.520
Also, on the episode today, we have Eiron refinancing $363 million worth of GPUs. Can Eiron survive Elon Musk's Neocloud extinction event?
3
00:00:26.460 --> 00:00:39.900
And for our final story, the memory trade may be back, as SK Hynix post-record profits. And when I say record profits, I mean they just joined Nvidia as one of the most profitable companies in tech.
4
00:00:39.940 --> 00:00:53.820
You're listening to Block Space Live, hosted by Charlie Spears and my co-host, William Boxley, who's subbing for Colin, who is on a R&D expedition across the Atlantic. Block Space goes live every weekday at 1:00 p.m.
5
00:00:54.040 --> 00:01:07.460
Eastern. We are Compute's daily live show. If you want more Block Space media content, go to our website blockspace.media, newsletter, articles, et cetera. And we kick off every episode with a tweet.
6
00:01:08.720 --> 00:01:18.680
Will, what's this tweet say? Really quick, I think we picked the wrong tweet, 'cause I'm realizing now that the Fed decision goes live in 10 minutes, so [laughs] Oh my God.
7
00:01:18.720 --> 00:01:25.940
Do we wanna, do we wanna, like, pull [laughs] do we wanna just talk about the Fed decision? [laughs] I mean, that's... I guess everything kinda comes back to the Fed at the end of the day.
8
00:01:26.000 --> 00:01:34.360
But we got a few people in the chat talking about that- Yeah, yeah... now it's like, Fed decision, what's happened? So it's funny. Maybe, uh, we'll keep an eye on that, give an update once it, once it happens.
9
00:01:34.780 --> 00:01:43.600
Uh, no, this is, uh, a, a tweet from the Information, "OpenAI plans to use Google's TPUs." We were chatting about this before the stream.
10
00:01:43.900 --> 00:01:49.980
Think a lot of people would be like, "Oh, oh my, like, OpenAI, they're cheating on Nvidia. They're..." [laughs] "You can't do that." Yeah.
11
00:01:50.480 --> 00:02:00.900
But come on, like, all this hardware is gonna be commoditized, uh, even the information sector itself, intelligent layer, looks like it's gonna be commoditized with distillation, so can you really be that upset?
12
00:02:00.960 --> 00:02:08.520
I, I don't even see this as much of a headline. Uh, I just think it's more to come. E- even Elon is cheating on Nvidia. They're gonna make their own chips.
13
00:02:09.000 --> 00:02:19.420
Yeah, I mean, if he can, he's, he's gonna build the largest, uh, the largest building mankind's ever built. Well, okay, I mean, Jensen does have to be feeling a little bit like this tweet from Neg- Negligible Capital.
14
00:02:19.900 --> 00:02:33.580
"Jensen invests billions into OpenAI. OpenAI then starts making Jalapeno, invests in Cerebras, and buys Google TPUs." It's the meme
Load full transcript
of the kid. Jensen's saying, "Congrats. Happy for you. Nice," et cetera.
15
00:02:33.660 --> 00:02:42.000
So, um, you know, if you're, if you... The financing was circular. [laughs] Let's just look at the chips, baby. So we are gonna roll on.
16
00:02:42.040 --> 00:02:48.440
We're gonna talk about the Eiron story at the top, but before that, a word from our sponsor, Soluna.
17
00:02:48.440 --> 00:03:06.980
[Relaxing music] Soluna Holdings, NASDAQ listed ticker SLNH, develops data centers co-located with wind and solar plants, turning surplus renewable energy into computing power for AI and other intensive applications.
18
00:03:07.540 --> 00:03:17.620
We are proud to partner with Soluna Holdings here at Block Space, and if you would like to learn more, please visit solunacomputing.com. That's solunacomputing.com.
19
00:03:23.220 --> 00:03:34.020
Eiron closed $363 million of refinancing of deployed GPUs with Wing Spire, according to a press release this morning, Wednesday. The financing is securing principal...
20
00:03:34.220 --> 00:03:40.920
i- is secured principally by GPU servers and network gear, which is already deployed and generating revenue.
21
00:03:41.660 --> 00:03:54.640
Eiron share price closed at 27.44 on Tuesday, down 27.35% year to date, after a tremendous 2025, where it gained 284% in the year.
22
00:03:55.620 --> 00:04:02.280
This might look like a small deal, and in terms of financing it is, but it's also notable for a few reasons. First, why it's small.
23
00:04:02.800 --> 00:04:15.340
The company is guided to project CapEx of $25 to $30 billion for building out its dream of a complete verticalized AI Neocloud. $300 million doesn't do a lot there.
24
00:04:16.600 --> 00:04:24.060
It's also notable because Elon Musk recently said that the financing market for Neoclouds is basically gone.
25
00:04:24.480 --> 00:04:34.060
Quote, "As of Sunday, as of the past few weeks, debt markets have almost entirely shut off access to money for any company that doesn't have substantial revenue-independent AI data centers.
26
00:04:34.660 --> 00:04:45.540
SpaceX closed 40 billion of debt from GPUs, but we're investment grade F Starlink and launch revenue. That means the 200 plus Neoclouds are going to see guppy level death and consolidation.
27
00:04:46.080 --> 00:05:00.240
Some will make it through, but not many." End quote. Charlie, gotta ask the question, is Elon wrong? Is he manipulating markets again? Is Elon ever wrong, or is he ever right? I mean, it's a little bit of both.
28
00:05:00.320 --> 00:05:14.080
I'm gonna say both, and look, Elon talks his own book. We know this. He makes projections which shock you, and occasionally he delivers on those. Um, he said there's 200 plus Neoclouds.
29
00:05:14.100 --> 00:05:25.400
Now, I could probably personally name, like, 30. There's probably more, there's definitely more than that. Um, but we do know there's just gonna be a lot of disappointed investors, a lot of disappointed clients.
30
00:05:25.440 --> 00:05:38.040
There's gonna be a lot of GPUs collecting dust once deliveries start coming in Q1 of 2027. But my question is, like, does Eiron specifically, are they stuck holding the bag?
31
00:05:38.460 --> 00:05:46.560
Um, I would say they're much higher on the totem pole than some of these other companies that I, I couldn't name, less, less maybe even haven't even heard of.
32
00:05:46.640 --> 00:05:54.780
So, like, they're in a much better position here, and so I'm trying to fend off the Eiron haters, 'cause I see them furiously typing in the comments right now as I speak.
33
00:05:56.560 --> 00:06:01.900
Yeah, I mean, they, we had a few of those, so we've certainly taken some heat from some Eiron fans over the last few weeks covering some of the news.
34
00:06:03.292 --> 00:06:12.072
The gist of it is, like, the stock has not done super well this year compared to last year. And so we, we've seen a lot of investors get a little spooked by that CapEx number I said earlier.
35
00:06:12.612 --> 00:06:17.972
I think what you're seeing right now, though, is the maturity of the debt stack for a company like Iren.
36
00:06:18.452 --> 00:06:24.972
So if we look at the broader picture, especially from the, the latest earnings call, they forecasted, again, that $25 to $30 billion in CapEx.
37
00:06:25.352 --> 00:06:30.612
They have about $14 billion on hand in cash as of la- the last earnings call in August.
38
00:06:31.032 --> 00:06:37.372
And then they also have the ability to debt finance their builds once they are finished, or use debt from their builds, I should say.
39
00:06:37.812 --> 00:06:46.572
So, you know, they have the Sweetwater sites or the Childress sites, and this looks like maybe the, the Prince George site, I think, is, is probably what they're referring to here in this notice.
40
00:06:47.292 --> 00:06:59.292
They're basically going to, like, reverse mortgage that, in a sense, and be able to get cash back from it, and then use that to continue to build out their vision of this verticalized AI neo cloud.
41
00:06:59.692 --> 00:07:07.892
To Elon's point, it does help a lot when you have Starlink revenue, launch revenue, or, you know, anything else. Maybe if they merge one day with Tesla, they'll have Tesla revenue.
42
00:07:08.291 --> 00:07:21.972
And then you're able to get better, uh, investment-grade, uh, benefits from having more revenue than just, like, what you're reinvesting in, which at the end of the day for Iren is energy, land, and GPUs. Yeah.
43
00:07:22.092 --> 00:07:32.452
Here's the tweet from Elon. I mean, this went giga viral. It was in response, obviously, to Chamath, so obviously two of the heavy hitters, two of the talking heads for the AI movement.
44
00:07:33.112 --> 00:07:47.232
Um, Iren chart, Will, look at this. Down on the day. It looks like it started the morning at, what, like, 28, down to 27. So market initially not a fan of this, which I don't really understand why.
45
00:07:47.352 -->
00:07:59.392
Maybe that- that's animal spirits. Um, I'm curious- Well, I mean, I would, I would just zoom out. Like, this is a drop in the bucket, uh, what they need for CapEx spending. So if they came out with a much larger deal...
46
00:07:59.612 --> 00:08:01.472
Look at the, the Cipher note, right?
47
00:08:01.532 --> 00:08:10.112
Their convertible note a few weeks ago, $850 million, and that really spooked the market, 'cause there was some rationale for needing that convertible note, but it was also at a bad time.
48
00:08:11.032 --> 00:08:19.292
I think, like, a smaller financing plan like this, it's fairly vanilla at the end of the day. Like, they already have those GPUs on hand. They're humming along.
49
00:08:19.372 --> 00:08:28.112
I think it's, like, pooled together, or it's Together AI, uh, and some other companies that they're, uh, using already, have those leased out. So they're already making money on this.
50
00:08:28.152 --> 00:08:39.072
They're just, you know, using that money to go get credit and make more money. A few comments. I see Fairfax says, "Ah, but can they triple net lease?" Uh, unsure if they triple net on all these.
51
00:08:39.292 --> 00:08:48.172
Uh, a lot of the times that happens during the initial tenant agreement. And for, uh, Iren here, they're not always gonna go that decision to be kind of like a landlord.
52
00:08:48.392 --> 00:09:00.272
They're going to own everything, all the infrastructure pay for itself, and then get some sort of deal like they did with Microsoft, right? Where, like, Microsoft is coming in and using the GPUs that Iren builds.
53
00:09:00.572 --> 00:09:08.312
It's different than, say, like, a CleanSpark build, where CleanSpark's just like the tenant, owns the power and the land, but they don't own the GPUs. And, and there could be, like, a few differences there.
54
00:09:08.392 --> 00:09:20.952
But I think, uh, and they, Fairfax adds up similar to Ionic. I think that's probably fair. I haven't looked into Ionic since this summer. But I think in general, Charlie, going back to it, we have a Fed decision today.
55
00:09:21.552 --> 00:09:30.952
This wasn't a huge notice from Iren. Year to date, it's, it's down. They got a little bit of, uh, execution before we see any more growth in the stock, I think, for the moment.
56
00:09:31.132 --> 00:09:42.872
But not, not to say it's bearish, just, like, there's more to come. Yeah, I mean, any, any few pennies you can scrounge up, maybe you call 363 million pennies these days in the scale of things.
57
00:09:43.452 --> 00:09:59.992
You know, whatever cash you can have on hand to front these deals and put towards projects, the better. So cash is king, and investment grade is, uh, the usurper. So, um, we are gonna keep on rolling.
58
00:10:00.072 --> 00:10:08.172
Next story we have on the dock is Morgan Stanley. Very bullish on TeraWulf, another one of our favorite portfolio companies. How high do you think their, their projection is?
59
00:10:08.212
--> 00:10:25.932
You'll have to wait till the story after a word from our sponsor, Luxor. [static sound] This episode is brought to you by Luxor's Commander, Bitcoin miner management software built for enterprise operations.
60
00:10:26.572 --> 00:10:40.012
Commander gives you real-time fleet monitoring, bulk remote commands across your fleet, and Intelligent Miner, which is an automated profitability engine that runs every five minutes, adjusting power settings to a live hash rate and energy markets.
61
00:10:40.972 --> 00:10:52.272
ERCOT back tests show over 10% more profitability versus binary mining. Commander Pro is 100 bucks per megawatt or 25 basis point pool fee adder,
62
00:10:53.312 --> 00:11:02.312
which is roughly half the price of competitors, and comes with a 60-day free trial. Get started at luxor.tech/commander.
63
00:11:06.452 --> 00:11:15.872
Morgan Stanley reiterated an overweight rating on five AI data center stocks, including Hut8, TeraWulf, Riot, Galaxy Digital, and Cipher Digital.
64
00:11:16.532 --> 00:11:26.992
Of the five, Morgan Stanley gave TeraWulf the most bullish boost, with the price target 413% over its current market price at $12.67.
65
00:11:27.732 --> 00:11:36.972
The bank argues that months of underperformance reflect misconceptions about the PowerShell providers, and it's keeping an attractive view on the entire industry.
66
00:11:37.612 --> 00:11:52.792
Its bull and bear case is set at $104 and $17 for the stock. Other targets include $43 for Galaxy, 15-- oops, excuse me, $35 for Riot, and Cipher at 15 bucks.
67
00:11:53.072 --> 00:12:06.652
All those numbers significantly higher than their current trading average. The bank's core claim is that these operators are landlords, not neo clouds. They sign 15 to 20 year leases instead of two to three years.
68
00:12:07.012 --> 00:12:15.672
They build shells at nine to $14 per watt versus 30 to 50 per watt, and they took no risk on chips or GPU allocation.
69
00:12:16.560 --> 00:12:28.200
Morgan Stanley values, values expected TeraWolf contracts at 9% equity discount rate and a 7% terminal cap rate, which says, which is above what most real estate investors expect.
70
00:12:29.020 --> 00:12:38.540
Charlie, these bullish price targets look a little bit better after the Anthropic IPO filing paperwork, which showed a deep cash balance and profitable compute segments.
71
00:12:39.060 --> 00:12:51.100
What's your take on these new price targets from Morgan Stanley, given the Anthropic IPO? Well, I can't say a whole lot about what I think a 4X would look like, but I'll point out this.
72
00:12:51.220 --> 00:13:04.520
I mean, uh, Morgan Stanley is, uh, down over fif- I'm sorry, TeraWolf is down over 50% from their all-time highs this past summer at, what, like 28 bucks, 29 bucks? They're down at 12, so that's
73
00:13:05.780 --> 00:13:07.540
more than 50% retracement.
74
00:13:07.840 --> 00:13:26.820
So technically, Morgan Stanley at 441%, uh, would actually only be a two, a slightly over 2X from TeraWolf's all-time highs, which are down maybe not because the fundamentals of TeraWolf have changed, but because the data center sector has just taken a bunch of beatings over the past few months.
75
00:13:27.580 --> 00:13:37.000
Um, I do wanna mention that there have been a number of other bank notes and investment notes predicting the price that we've covered over the past few months.
76
00:13:37.740 --> 00:13:48.100
October 7th, Wells Fargo, TeraWolf had a $30 price target, which would be h- you know, roughly 100% upside from there. Actually, 120% upside.
77
00:13:48.760 --> 00:14:04.580
Morgan Stanley, as of, I believe, August, had TeraWolf at a $62 price target, which by the way, would only be, would be a, uh, would be a, uh, 500% increase from where we are today.
78
00:14:05.520 --> 00:14:19.120
And then also Needham, John Todaro, friend of the show here, I've got... We reported on this, again, in August. Um, they kept their TeraWolf target at 33 bucks, um, which again, is slightly over their all-time high.
79
00:14:19.240 --> 00:14:21.580
So the thing is, like, everybody's bullish TeraWolf.
80
00:14:21.640 --> 00:14:35.160
It's really just a matter of, like, uh, is it, is it how many, how, how much multiple increases from here, which is a flat from the start of the year, or is it, are we just benchmarking to the previous all-time high of, like, 28 bucks?
81
00:14:35.500 --> 00:14:42.380
The long story short is everybody's bullish TeraWolf. It, you know, how bullish are you is the question. A few thoughts here.
82
00:14:42.440 --> 00:14:52.800
So one, disclosure, I do hold TeraWolf in my personal portfolio, and I'm a, a long-term holder at it. I enjoy what the team is building over there, and I do think that the PowerShell model makes a lot of sense.
83
00:14:53.360 --> 00:15:05.100
And there are, uh, th- there is a big divergence in the market that I think a lot of people don't know about when they're first looking at these stocks, that Neocloud, "Hey, we're going to not only own the power and the land, but we're also gonna buy the chips.
84
00:15:05.160 --> 00:15:11.720
We're gonna build the orchestration layer for GPUs. We're gonna go sign contracts with AI labs, or we're gonna sell our compute into a generalized market."
85
00:15:12.240 --> 00:15:19.400
And then there's the PowerShell model, where it's like, "Hey, we're pretty happy with just owning the power and the land. We will be the landlord. You can be the tenant.
86
00:15:19.600 --> 00:15:27.160
You get certain rights to come use our facilities." They typically sign 15 to 20-year deals, uh, and, and that's pretty stable.
87
00:15:27.200 --> 00:15:36.760
You can kinda, like, look at the, the net expectation for that over 15 to 20 years, and it's almost like the people who move in as tenants own the space for 15 to 20 years.
88
00:15:37.240 --> 00:15:45.400
Uh, but not quite, because there's that profitable layer in between that companies like Wolf
are able to sit in. And so I'm a huge fan of that.
89
00:15:45.720 --> 00:15:57.720
Now, on the other hand, I do think that there are some dangers here, and I'm just gonna pull up this chart, if you can help me do that. But there's, there's the other layer, which is the funding risk for these sites.
90
00:15:57.800 --> 00:16:08.160
This is Cipher Digital, which I mentioned earlier in the show. They put out that convertible note, bad time in the market. They needed a little more money because co- cost overruns, expensive and hot to build.
91
00:16:08.440 --> 00:16:17.160
It's not expensive building in Texas, but it's hot to build in Texas. They need a little more cash, uh, and the market kinda puked on it, and they've been trying to recover for a while.
92
00:16:17.220 --> 00:16:21.800
You can see that market seems to try to be getting going again, and it, it's struggling.
93
00:16:21.900 --> 00:16:31.620
But, uh, you can look at over, once these ads drop off, look at the, the year-to-date levels and things like that, and it, it's kinda struggling. I think so is TradingView at the moment.
94
00:16:32.120 --> 00:16:43.740
But it's, uh, yeah, pretty brutal in a, in a percentage term. Like, we're not necessarily getting where we want to with, with Cipher at the moment, uh, because of those cost overruns.
95
00:16:44.180 --> 00:16:53.460
So moving away from that segment and, and getting away from it, I want to pull up this video from Paul Prager. He's the CEO over at TeraWolf, and I think he does a good job explaining this.
96
00:16:53.520 --> 00:17:02.420
We love a good Paul Prager video. Was this, is this the CNBC one? He had a great- Yeah... he had some great content. I linked it in the show notes, so we should be able to pull that up in a second. Uh-huh.
97
00:17:02.440 --> 00:17:12.460
But I'll let you grab that, and in, in between I'll just kinda mention that the way that TeraWolf is thinking long-term at the moment is, "Let's go find more sites."
98
00:17:12.560 --> 00:17:19.000
And I expect them to have more lease announcements going into next year, and maybe even to earnings. Like, that, that's what these guys do.
99
00:17:19.040 --> 00:17:24.380
They're almost like real estate investors, where they go and find plots of power land and build that out.
100
00:17:24.800 --> 00:17:33.900
Uh, and it's excellent for investors because there's a little bit of risk diversification there versus the GPU market, where it's like, "Hey, we gotta go find debt.
101
00:17:33.960 --> 00:17:44.960
We gotta go find, uh, installation teams, orchestration. We have to go find customers." The two to three-year contracts, there's a lot of problems with that versus, like, "Hey, we need a plot of land, we need energy.
102
00:17:45.140 --> 00:17:49.140
Let's go." Let's watch this from Paul Prager, the CEO over at TeraWolf.
103
00:17:49.180 --> 00:18:02.480
Between companies like CoreWeave, Neoclouds, versus companies like ours, we're a co-location company, which means we own the land, we own the energy, we build the building, and we operate the data center.
104
00:18:02.980 --> 00:18:16.200
So we have long-term predictable cashflow, and we get quality energy from an investment-grade credit like Utility, Kentucky Power, AP, and we sell it to a high-quality credit.
105
00:18:16.420 --> 00:18:30.376
In this case, our customer, Elite Mariner effectively as Anthropic in the announced deal Hawesville Anthropic. But what the investors also need to understand is that we have an investment-grade backstop.
106
00:18:30.496 --> 00:18:41.076
In Lake Mariner, it's from Google. In, in Kentucky, in Hawesville, we have an investment-grade backstop commitment, so we can raise the capital at very competitive rates.
107
00:18:41.556 --> 00:18:52.316
I think the other thing that the investors need to understand is we're not all the same. You have to focus on execution. You must focus on execution.
108
00:18:53.056 --> 00:19:02.616
We have guided the markets that we're building at our facilities at 8 to 10 per megawatt, 8 to 10 million a megawatt. We are squarely right in that range.
109
00:19:02.796 --> 00:19:18.936
We haven't changed our story, and we're delivering Data Hall 4 at the, at, at the, the fourth quarter, and CB5 in the first quarter of next year. So we're on schedule. We are on track to deliver within a timely fashion.
110
00:19:19.396 --> 00:19:33.096
We are delivering at the cost that we told the customer we would deliver at, and we have the capital. He's right. I mean, it's like, think about how long and persistent this narrative has been, that they've been on time,
111
00:19:34.336 --> 00:19:44.396
at the budget they targeted, and they have investment-grade counterparties. Like, it's almost like they saw the playbook happening, uh, a year before it came to fruition.
112
00:19:44.556 --> 00:19:51.536
So shout out to TeraWolf for- Yeah, we're just, we're just bull, bull posting here for TeraWolf. Yeah, but, but the stock's down 60% [laughs] on the year, so, you know.
113
00:19:51.556 --> 00:20:03.556
[laughs] Yeah, I mean, like, a lot of these got spooked, and there was a ton of compression in the, in the markets since July, uh, because it's like, oh, this tenant thesis. You do need to have multiple tenants.
114
00:20:03.656 --> 00:20:15.716
Remember, I remember a year ago we were thinking about this with who's going to sign next, who's gonna get the next deal, and then it became not the next deal, but how many different types of counterparties are you gonna have this deal?
115
00:20:15.776 --> 00:20:25.236
Is it gonna be hyperscalers? Is it gonna be different AI labs? And then it became, okay, execution, we'd see the revenue start flowing in. And then it became, oh, are you keeping your costs down?
116
00:20:25.656 --> 00:20:34.816
Uh, oh, then it became, can you keep your debt levels within the boundaries? The game's always changing. Only a few teams are gonna be able to execute. Right now I like Wolfe.
117
00:20:35.216 --> 00:20:43.696
Morgan Stanley also makes note of a few other companies, so I think we can leave the, the levels there. As always, check out the website, uh, Blockspace.media for more content.
118
00:20:44.416 --> 00:20:55.196
Yeah, we publish a lot on TeraWolf, and, uh, if new price targets from the banks and investment banks that we cover drop, we'll turn them around quickly. You'll hear it on our channels first, Blockspace.media.
119
00:20:55.876 --> 00:21:06.316
We're gonna talk about the memory trade. Is it so back? Um, it is not clear, but SK Hynix up big this morning. We'll talk about that after a word from our sponsor, Ligos.
120
00:21:06.316 --> 00:21:23.216
[static party music] Hedge funds are getting liquidated. Is your Bitcoin safe? It's not just Bitcoin price drying up. Big whales, hedge funds, and lending desks are going under after the notorious
121
00:21:24.116 --> 00:21:36.016
crypto winter. Counterparty risk is rampant, so it's more important than ever to understand who actually controls your Bitcoin. Don't be the next FTX or Celsius victim.
122
00:21:36.516 --> 00:21:41.936
If you're working with another loan provider, do yourself a favor before it's too late and check out Ligos Finance.
123
00:21:42.356 --> 00:21:53.276
Ligos Finance is Blockspace's preferred non-custodial Bitcoin lender, which uses native Bitcoin smart contracts to protect your Bitcoin stack. With Ligos, you always know where your Bitcoin is.
124
00:21:53.896 --> 00:22:05.436
Hold your keys, no wrapping, no bridging, no rebuy, re-hypothecation, and get competitive rates as low as 10% APR. Go to Ligos.finance to learn more.
125
00:22:05.436 --> 00:22:18.756
[clears throat] Is the memory trade back? SK Hynix just reported an eye-watering profits and is up 12% today.
126
00:22:19.636 --> 00:22:35.456
Here's what's going on and why investors may be piling back into the memory trade. So last summer, memory stocks like Samsung and SK Hynix soared upwards, and then there was a bloodbath as the memory trade collapsed.
127
00:22:35.936 --> 00:22:45.256
Across the major memory and storage makers, roughly a trillion dollars in market value was erased in a single week just earlier this month.
128
00:22:46.436 --> 00:22:55.796
SK Hynix, the industry leader in high bandwidth memory, HBM for short, fell nearly 60% from its peak in June.
129
00:22:57.056 --> 00:23:05.956
However, last night, SK Hynix reported third quarter results, and the numbers tell a very, very different story than the doom and gloom you've been seeing.
130
00:23:06.756 --> 00:23:23.816
Revenue for SK Hynix topped 100 trillion won for the first time in the company's history, which is more, sit down, than it earned all of last year. Operating profit came in nearly $60 billion at an 80% operating margin.
131
00:23:24.076 --> 00:23:32.216
That's the sixth consecutive record quarter for the company, and it beat consensus by about 10%.
132
00:23:33.016 --> 00:23:45.736
I will go deeper into the
numbers behind SK Hynix, but first, throw it to Will, who, granted, Will is not a memory trader here. But Will, these profit numbers are about as good as it can possibly get.
133
00:23:46.776 --> 00:23:58.236
Why do you think investors were so ready to bail on this trade just a few weeks ago? I mean, I remember this summer and the, and the craziness that we saw with this stock.
134
00:23:58.616 --> 00:24:03.476
Uh, South Korean markets were big on it, and there was a lot of margin calls.
135
00:24:03.596 --> 00:24:13.296
There was some stat about the sizable percentage of the South Korean population had been margin called over the summer, and I, I think this IPO had a lot of reasons to do with it.
136
00:24:14.276 --> 00:24:24.896
Look, the, the, it, entire game is predicated on having all of the stack. Memory is part of that stack. So if you're an AI bull, then you can't just say, "Hey, I'm gonna sit out on part of this."
137
00:24:25.016 --> 00:24:33.336
And parts of that stack have more of a bottleneck than others, right? So we talk about power land on this show because that's a lot of the counterparties we're used to working with.
138
00:24:33.376 --> 00:24:42.856
We just talked about Morgan Stanley and, like, their bullish price targets on the PowerShell providers Think about the hardware layer. There's all this hardware that needs to be talked about.
139
00:24:42.915 --> 00:24:53.576
We met up with Dylan Patel at Yotta just a few weeks ago, and we asked him, "What's the biggest bottleneck people aren't thinking about?" And he said, "Drill bits for PCB boards."
140
00:24:53.936 --> 00:25:00.636
PCB boards- I had to, I had to, I had to Google that. I was like, "What?" And then I got... Quickly I was like, "Oh, it's the little drill tips. They go in and they- Yeah...
141
00:25:00.676 --> 00:25:09.476
drill the actual, like, electronics boards that sit, that the stuff sits on. So yeah. Just- I mean, that's a niche trade right there... just think about that. Yeah, just think about that. Like, the...
142
00:25:09.976 --> 00:25:21.136
There is a need on every single layer of this stack, and that's when people talk about this AI bubble as being something scary. I think you can take that
143
00:25:22.116 --> 00:25:29.896
kind of inside a little bit, because a bubble like this does touch everything in the market. And I think as, like, humans, we have a hard time thinking about exponentials.
144
00:25:30.436 --> 00:25:33.716
This is one of those cases with the memory stock. So there's an exponential.
145
00:25:33.756 --> 00:25:43.956
There is a need for this equipment on every part of the globe, and you're going to see the few companies that can provide this at scale have huge markups on all their numbers.
146
00:25:44.436 --> 00:25:57.516
Uh, last thing I'll say, I throw it back to you, just what a reversal versus a few weeks ago. And this is so classic, right? But you think it's all over, all of our stocks are down 50, 60% year to date.
147
00:25:57.556 --> 00:26:07.436
Like, we're off way from the highs. Like, is situational awareness gonna make it? Things are only getting worse. And then there's, like, a little bit of good news, and then, like, a little more good news comes out.
148
00:26:07.476 --> 00:26:18.036
And then all of a sudden, like, Meta's doing a huge raise because, like, they're so bullish on the whole thing, and, like, Claude and Anthropic are having huge usage growth despite everyone saying it's on.
149
00:26:18.416 --> 00:26:28.196
And then you see stuff like this, like, oh, the memory trade is back. So never, never doom pill, never dark pill, never red pill. Like, s- stay- Yeah... with the trade is what I kinda think after seeing this.
150
00:26:28.916 --> 00:26:38.576
Look, look, if the memory trade is so back, we... You need to refer back to this show that you heard it here first. And if it's not so back and we keep going down, just forget we ever even covered this story.
151
00:26:38.616 --> 00:26:48.256
But let me, like, pull up the actual numbers, 'cause the fundamentals are very impressive. I think people just got way too reactive about the stocks. We'll s- so here's the numbers from the quarterly earnings.
152
00:26:48.535 --> 00:27:05.516
One, revenue was up nearly 80 billion US dollars. That is a company record, and it's up 32% from last quarter, and more than 400% from this quarter last year. Operating profit was about $63 billion.
153
00:27:06.096 --> 00:27:16.396
So [laughs] of that 80 billion revenue, 63 billion was operating profit, which is sevenfold increase year over year. This is the sixth straight record quarter, as I said.
154
00:27:16.616 --> 00:27:28.116
And then that one quarter, this one past quarter, brought in more revenue than all of last year. And this is happening everywhere you, you look. Micron just posted an operating margin above 80%.
155
00:27:28.816 --> 00:27:42.136
And then Samsung, I got the chart here, it's up great this week. Up 9, 10%. Samsung is also rebounding this week. And the interesting thing is, like, like, why did memory just become all of a sudden the trade?
156
00:27:42.676 --> 00:27:59.636
It's historically been the commodity with the low margin layer of the chip business. It's been the story. [upbeat music] Riddled with drama. Morgan Stanley thinks Terawulf is going to more than quadruple.
157
00:28:00.496 --> 00:28:08.136
It's the most bullish call for the stock that we've seen from any investment bank this year, and we are going to dive into the numbers here on this show.
158
00:28:09.036 --> 00:28:19.676
Also, on the episode today, we have Airen refinancing $363 million worth of GPUs. Can Airen survive Elon Musk's Neocloud extinction event?
159
00:28:20.596 --> 00:28:34.056
And for our final story, the memory trade may be back as SK Hynix posts record profits. And when I say record profits, I mean they just joined Nvidia as one of the most profitable companies in tech.
160
00:28:34.096 --> 00:28:44.996
You're
listening to Block Space Live, hosted by Charlie Spears and my co-host William Foxley, who's subbing for Colin, who is on a R&D expedition across the Atlantic.
161
00:28:45.756 --> 00:28:57.716
Block Space goes live every weekday at 1:00 PM Eastern. We are Compute's daily live show. If you want more Block Space Media content, go to our website, blockspace.media, newsletter, articles, et cetera.
162
00:28:57.776 --> 00:29:12.276
And we kick off every episode with a tweet. Will, what's this tweet say? Really quick, I think we picked the wrong tweet, 'cause I'm realizing now that the Fed decision goes live in 10 minutes.
163
00:29:12.296 --> 00:29:20.096
So [laughs] maybe- Oh my God, do we wanna do it? Like, well, do we wanna talk about the Fed decision? [laughs] I mean, that's... I guess everything kinda comes back to the Fed at the end of the day.
164
00:29:20.136 --> 00:29:28.516
But we got a few people in the chat talking about that. Yeah, yeah. Now it's like, Fed decision's about to happen, so it's funny. Maybe, uh, we'll keep an eye on that and give an update once it, once it happens.
165
00:29:28.916 --> 00:29:37.736
Uh, no, this is, uh, a, a tweet from the Information, "OpenAI plans to use Google's TPUs." We were chatting about this before the stream.
166
00:29:38.036 --> 00:29:44.976
I think a lot of people would be like, "Oh, oh my, like, OpenAI, they're cheating on Nvidia. They're... You can't do that." [laughs] Yeah. But come on.
167
00:29:44.996 --> 00:29:55.036
Like, all this hardware is gonna be commoditized, uh, even the information sector itself, intelligence layer, looks like it's gonna be commoditized with distillation. So can you really be that upset?
168
00:29:55.136 --> 00:30:03.476
I, I don't even see this as much of a headline. Uh, I just think it's more to come. E- even Elon is cheating on Nvidia. They're gonna make their own chips. Yeah.
169
00:30:03.536 --> 00:30:13.556
I mean, if he can, he's, he's gonna build the largest, uh, the largest building mankind's ever built. Well, okay, I mean, Jensen does have to be feeling a little bit like this tweet from Neg- Negligible Capital.
170
00:30:14.036 --> 00:30:27.736
"Jensen invests billions into OpenAI. OpenAI then starts making Jalapeno, invests in Cerebras, and buys Google TPUs." It's the meme of the kid. Jensen's saying, "Congrats. Happy for you. Nice," et cetera.
171
00:30:27.796 --> 00:30:36.156
So, um, you know, if you're, if you... The financing was circular. [laughs] Let's just look at the chips, baby. So we are gonna roll on.
172
00:30:36.176 --> 00:30:42.536
We're gonna talk about the Airen story at the top, but before that, a word from our sponsor, Soluna.
173
00:30:47.792 --> 00:31:01.132
Soluna Holdings, NASDAQ-listed ticker SLNH, develops data centers co-located with wind and solar plants, turning surplus renewable energy into computing power for AI and other intensive applications.
174
00:31:01.692 --> 00:31:11.652
We are proud to partner with Soluna Holdings here at Blockspace, and if you would like to learn more, please visit solunacomputing.com. That's solunacomputing.com.
175
00:31:17.352 --> 00:31:26.092
Eron closed $363 million of refinancing of deployed GPUs with Wing Spire, according to a press release this morning, Wednesday.
176
00:31:26.612 --> 00:31:35.072
The financing is securing principle, is secured principally by GPU servers and network gear, which is already deployed and generating revenue.
177
00:31:35.812 --> 00:31:48.792
Eron's share price closed at 27.44 on Tuesday, down 27.35% year to date, after a tremendous 2025, where it gained 284% in the year.
178
00:31:49.772 --> 00:31:56.432
This might look like a small deal, and in terms of financing it is, but it's also notable for a few reasons. First, why it's small.
179
00:31:56.952 --> 00:32:06.612
The company is guided to project CapEx of $25 to $30 billion for building out its dream of a complete verticalized AI neo cloud.
180
00:32:07.412 --> 00:32:18.792
In August, Eron said during its earnings call that they needed at least $25 to $30 billion to, to see that, uh, come to life, and $300 million doesn't do a lot there.
181
00:32:20.052 --> 00:32:27.512
It's also notable because Elon Musk recently said that the financing market for neo clouds is basically gone.
182
00:32:27.932 --> 00:32:37.512
Quote, "As of Sunday, as of the past few weeks, debt markets have almost entirely shut off access to money for any company that doesn't have substantial revenue independent of AI data centers.
183
00:32:38.112 --> 00:32:50.632
SpaceX closed 40 billion of debt from GPUs, but we're investment grade, have Starlink and launch revenue." That means that 200 plus neo clouds are going to- Story. Riddled with drama.
184
00:32:53.792 --> 00:33:06.992
Morgan Stanley thinks Terawulf is going to more than quadruple. It's the most bullish call for the stock that we've seen from any investment bank this year, and we are going to dive into the numbers here on this show.
185
00:33:07.892 --> 00:33:18.532
Also on the episode today, we have Eron refinancing $363 million worth of GPUs. Can Eron survive Elon Musk's neo cloud extinction event?
186
00:33:19.452 --> 00:33:32.912
And for our final story, the memory trade may be back as SK Hynix post record profits. And when I say record profits, I mean they just joined Nvidia as one of the most profitable companies in tech.
187
00:33:32.952 --> 00:33:47.492
You're listening to Blockspace Live, hosted by Charlie Spears and my co-host William Foxley, who's subbing for Colin, who is on a R&D expedition across the Atlantic. Blockspace goes live every weekday at 1:00 PM Eastern.
188
00:33:47.672 --> 00:34:03.712
We are Compute's daily live show. If you want more Blockspace media content, go to our website, blockspace.media, newsletter, articles, et cetera. And we kick off every episode with a tweet. Will, what's this tweet say?
189
00:34:05.692 --> 00:34:11.692
Really quick, I think we picked the wrong tweet, 'cause I'm
realizing now that the Fed decision goes live in 10 minutes, so [laughs] Oh my God.
190
00:34:11.712 --> 00:34:18.932
Do we wanna do it, like, pull up-- Do we wanna just talk about the Fed decision? [laughs] I mean, that's, I guess everything kinda comes back to the Fed at the end of the day.
191
00:34:18.992 --> 00:34:27.372
But we got a few people in the chat talking about that. Yeah, yeah. Now it's like, Fed decision's about to happen, so it's funny. Maybe, uh, we'll keep an eye on that, give an update once it, once it happens.
192
00:34:27.772 --> 00:34:36.592
Uh, no, this is, uh, a, a tweet from the information. OpenAI plans to use Google's TPUs. We were chatting about this before the stream.
193
00:34:36.892 --> 00:34:46.092
I think a lot of people would be like, "Oh, oh my, like, OpenAI, they're cheating on Nvidia. They're, you can't do that." Yeah. But come on, like, all this hardware is gonna be commoditized.
194
00:34:46.312 --> 00:34:56.392
Uh, even the information sector itself, intelligence layer, looks like it's gonna be commoditized with distillation. So can you really be that upset? I, I don't even see this as much of a headline.
195
00:34:56.692 --> 00:35:07.032
Uh, I just think it's more to come. E- even Elon is cheating on Nvidia. They're gonna make their own chips. Yeah. I mean, if he can, he's, he's gonna build the largest, uh, the largest building mankind's ever built.
196
00:35:07.451 --> 00:35:15.192
Well, okay, I mean, Jensen does have to be feeling a little bit like this tweet from Neg- Negligible Capital. Jensen invests billions into OpenAI.
197
00:35:15.412 --> 00:35:26.792
OpenAI then starts making Jalapeno, invests in Cerebras, and buys Google TPUs. It's the meme of the kid. Jensen saying, "Congrats. Happy for you. Nice," et cetera. So,
198
00:35:27.692 --> 00:35:35.012
um, you know, if you're, if you have the financing with Circular [laughs] let's just look at the chips, baby. So we are gonna roll on.
199
00:35:35.032 --> 00:35:41.432
We're gonna talk about the Eron story at the top, but before that, a word from our sponsor, Soluna.
200
00:35:46.652 --> 00:35:59.972
Soluna Holdings, NASDAQ-listed ticker SLNH, develops data centers co-located with wind and solar plants, turning surplus renewable energy into computing power for AI and other intensive applications.
201
00:36:00.532 --> 00:36:10.512
We are proud to partner with Soluna Holdings here at Blockspace, and if you would like to learn more, please visit solunacomputing.com. That's solunacomputing.com.
202
00:36:16.212 --> 00:36:24.952
Eron closed $363 million of refinancing of deployed GPUs with Wing Spire, according to a press release this morning, Wednesday.
203
00:36:25.452 --> 00:36:33.932
The financing is securing principle, i- is secured principally by GPU servers and network gear, which is already deployed and generating revenue.
204
00:36:34.652 --> 00:36:47.632
Eron's share price closed at 27.44 on Tuesday, down 27.35% year to date, after a tremendous
2025, where it gained 284% in the year
205
00:36:48.604 --> 00:36:55.284
This might look like a small deal, and in terms of financing it is, but it's also notable for a few reasons. First, why it's small.
206
00:36:55.804 --> 00:37:05.404
The company is guided to project CapEx of $25 to $30 billion for building out its dream of a complete verticalized AI Neo cloud.
207
00:37:06.264 --> 00:37:17.644
In August, Iren said during its earnings call that they needed at least $25 to $30 billion to, to see that, uh, come to life, and $300 million doesn't do a lot there.
208
00:37:18.904 --> 00:37:26.364
It's also notable because Elon Musk recently said that the financing market for Neo clouds is basically gone.
209
00:37:26.784 --> 00:37:36.364
Quote, as of Sunday, "As of the past few weeks, debt markets have almost entirely shut off access to money for any company that doesn't have substantial revenue-independent AI data centers.
210
00:37:36.964 --> 00:37:47.844
SpaceX closed 40 billion of debt from GPUs, but we're investment grade at Starlink and launch revenue. That means that 200 plus Neo clouds are going to see guppy level debt and consolidation.
211
00:37:48.404 --> 00:38:02.564
Some will make it through, but not many." End quote. Charlie, gotta ask the question, is Elon wrong? Is he manipulating markets again? Is Elon ever wrong, or is he ever right? I mean, it's a little bit of both.
212
00:38:02.644 --> 00:38:16.384
I'm gonna say both and. Look, Elon talks his own book. We know this. He makes projections which shock you, and occasionally he delivers on those. Um, he said there's 200 plus Neo clouds.
213
00:38:16.424 --> 00:38:27.704
Now, I could probably personally name, like, 30. There's probably more-- There's definitely more than that. Um, but we do know there's just gonna be a lot of disappointed investors, a lot of disappointed clients.
214
00:38:27.764 --> 00:38:40.344
There's gonna be a lot of GPUs collecting dust once deliveries start coming in Q1 of 2027. But my question is, like, does Iren specifically, are they stuck holding the bag?
215
00:38:40.784 --> 00:38:48.864
Um, I would say they're much higher on the totem pole than some of these other companies that I, I couldn't name, less, less maybe even haven't even heard of.
216
00:38:48.944 --> 00:38:58.963
So, like, they're in a much better position here, and so I'm trying to fend off the Iren haters 'cause I see them furiously typing in the comments right now as I speak. Yeah.
217
00:38:59.004 --> 00:39:04.264
I mean, they-- we got a few of those, and we've certainly taken some heat from some Iren fans over the last few weeks covering some of the news.
218
00:39:05.604 --> 00:39:14.384
The gist of it is, like, the stock has not done super well this year compared to last year, and so we, we've seen a lot of investors get a little spooked by that CapEx number I said earlier.
219
00:39:14.924 --> 00:39:20.284
I think what you're seeing right now, though, is the maturity of the debt stack for a company like Iren.
220
00:39:20.764 --> 00:39:27.284
So if we look at the broader picture, especially from the, the latest earnings call, they forecasted again that $25 to $30 billion in CapEx.
221
00:39:27.664 --> 00:39:39.684
They have about $14 billion on hand in cash as of la-the last earnings call in August. And then they also have the ability to debt finance their builds once they are finished or use debt from their builds, I should say.
222
00:39:40.124 --> 00:39:48.884
So, you know, they have the Sweetwater sites or the Childress sites, and this looks like maybe the, the Prince George site, I think is, is probably what they're referring to here in this notice.
223
00:39:49.604 --> 00:40:01.604
They're basically going to, like, reverse mortgage that in a sense and be able to get cash back from it and then use that to continue to build out their vision of this verticalized AI Neo cloud.
224
00:40:01.984 --> 00:40:10.204
To Elon's point, it does help a lot when you have Starlink revenue, launch revenue, or, you know, anything else. Maybe if they merge one day with Tesla, they'll have Tesla revenue.
225
00:40:10.604 --> 00:40:24.284
And then you're able to get better, uh, investment grade, uh, benefits from having more revenue than just, like, what you're reinvesting in, which at the end of the day for Iren is energy, land, and GPUs. Yeah.
226
00:40:24.404 --> 00:40:34.764
Here's the tweet from Elon. I mean, this went giga viral. It was in response obviously to Chamath, so obviously two of the heavy hitters, two of the talking heads for the AI movement.
227
00:40:35.424 --> 00:40:49.544
Um, Iren chart will look at this down on the day. It looks like it started the morning at, what? Like, 28 down to 27. So market initially not a fan of this, which I don't really understand why.
228
00:40:49.664 --> 00:41:01.704
Maybe the-that's animal spirits. Um, I'm curious. Well, I mean, I would, I would just zoom out. Like, this is a drop in the bucket, uh, what they need for CapEx spending. So if they came out with a much larger deal...
229
00:41:01.924 --> 00:41:03.784
Look at the, the Cipher note, right?
230
00:41:03.844 --> 00:41:12.424
Their convertible note a few weeks ago, 850 million, and that really spooked the market 'cause there was some rationale for needing that convertible note, but it was also at a bad time.
231
00:41:13.344 --> 00:41:21.604
I think, like, a smaller financing plan like this, it's fairly vanilla at the end of the day. Like, they already have those GPUs on hand. They're humming along.
232
00:41:21.684 --> 00:41:30.424
I think it's, like, pooled together, or it's together AI, uh, and some other companies that they're, uh, using already have those leased out. So they're already making money on this.
233
00:41:30.444 --> 00:41:41.384
They're just, you know, using that money to go get credit and make more money. A few comments. I see Fairfax says, "Ugh, but can they triple net lease?" Uh, unsure if they triple net on
all these.
234
00:41:41.604 --> 00:41:50.484
Uh, a lot of the times that happens during the initial tenant agreement. And for, uh, Iren here, they're not always gonna go that decision to be kind of like a landlord.
235
00:41:50.704 --> 00:42:02.584
They're going to own everything, all the infrastructure pay for itself, and then get some sort of deal like they did with Microsoft, right? Where, like, Microsoft is coming in and using the GPUs that Iren builds.
236
00:42:02.884 --> 00:42:10.624
It's different than, say, like, a CleanSpark build where CleanSpark's just, like, the tenant, owns the power and the land, but they don't own the GPUs. And there could be, like, a few differences there.
237
00:42:10.704 --> 00:42:23.244
But I think, uh, and the Fairfax adds up similar to Ionic. I think that's probably fair. I haven't looked into Ionic since this summer. But I think in general, Charlie, going back to it, we have a Fed decision today.
238
00:42:23.864 --> 00:42:34.904
This wasn't a huge notice from Iren. Year to date, it's, it's down. They got a little bit of, uh, execution before we see any more growth in the stock, I think, for the moment. But not, not to say it's fair.
239
00:42:34.944 --> 00:42:45.124
It's just, like, there's more to come. Yeah. I mean, any, any few pennies you can scrounge up, maybe you call 363 million pennies these days in the scale of things.
240
00:42:45.764 --> 00:43:02.296
You know, whatever cash you can have on hand to front these deals and put towards projects, the better. So cash is king, and investment grade Is, uh, the usurper. So, um, we are gonna keep on rolling.
241
00:43:02.396 --> 00:43:10.476
Next story we have on the dock is Morgan Stanley. Very bullish on Terawatt, another one of our favorite portfolio companies. How high do you think their, their projection is?
242
00:43:10.536 --> 00:43:28.196
You'll have to wait till the story after a word from our sponsor, Luxur. [static sound] This episode is brought to you by Luxur's Commander, Bitcoin miner management software built for enterprise operations.
243
00:43:28.876 --> 00:43:42.316
Commander gives you real-time fleet monitoring, bulk remote commands across your fleet, and Intelligent Miner, which is an automated profitability engine that runs every five minutes, adjusting power settings to a live hash rate and energy markets.
244
00:43:43.276 --> 00:43:54.596
Ercot back tests show over 10% more profitability versus binary mining. Commander Pro is 100 bucks per megawatt, or 25 basis point full fee adder,
245
00:43:55.636 --> 00:44:04.616
which is roughly half the price of competitors, and comes with a 60-day free trial. Get started at luxur.tech/commander.
246
00:44:08.756 --> 00:44:18.196
Morgan Stanley reiterated an overweight rating on five AI data center stocks, including Hut8, Terawatt, Riot, Galaxy Digital, and Cipher Digital.
247
00:44:18.856 --> 00:44:28.836
Of the five, Morgan Stanley gave Terawatt the most bullish boost, with the price target 413% over its current market price at $12.67.
248
00:44:30.056 --> 00:44:39.196
The bank argues that months of underperformance reflect misconceptions about the PowerShell providers, and it's keeping an attractive view on the entire industry.
249
00:44:39.916 --> 00:44:55.096
Its bull and bear case is set at $104 and $17 for the stock. Other targets include $43 for Galaxy, 15-- oops, excuse me, $35 for Riot, and Cipher at 151 bucks.
250
00:44:55.376 --> 00:45:09.016
All those numbers significantly higher than their current trading average. The bank's core claim is that these operators are landlords, not Neo clouds. They sign 15 to 20-year leases instead of two to three years.
251
00:45:09.316 --> 00:45:18.016
They build shells at nine to $14 per watt versus 30 to 50 per watt, and they took no risk on chips or GPU allocation.
252
00:45:18.876 --> 00:45:30.516
Morgan Stanley values, values expected Terawatt contracts at 9% equity discount rate and a 7% terminal cap rate, which says-- which is above what most real estate investors expect.
253
00:45:31.316 --> 00:45:40.836
Charlie, these bullish price targets look a little bit better after the Anthropic IPO filing paperwork, which showed a deep cash balance and profitable compute segments.
254
00:45:41.356 --> 00:45:53.416
What's your take on these new price targets from Morgan Stanley, given the Anthropic IPO? Well, I can't say a whole lot about what I think a four X would look like, but I'll point out this.
255
00:45:53.536 --> 00:46:06.836
I mean, uh, Morgan Stanley is, uh, down over fif- I'm sorry, Terawatt was down over 50% from their all-time highs this past summer at, what, like, 28 bucks, 29 bucks. They're down at 12, so that's
256
00:46:08.076 --> 00:46:09.836
more than 50% retracement.
257
00:46:10.136 --> 00:46:29.116
So technically, Morgan Stanley at four to 41%, uh, would actually only be a two-- a slightly over two X from Terawatt's all-time highs, which are down maybe not because the fundamentals of Terawatt have changed, but because the data center sector has just taken a bunch of beatings over the past few months.
258
00:46:29.896 --> 00:46:39.316
Um, I do wanna mention that there have been a number of other bank notes and investment notes predicting the price that we've covered over the past few months.
259
00:46:40.056 --> 00:46:50.416
October 7th, Wells Fargo, Terawatt had a $30 price target, which would be, you know, roughly 100% upside from there. Actually, 120% upside.
260
00:46:51.056 --> 00:47:06.976
Morgan Stanley, as of, I believe, August, had Terawatt at a $62 price target, which by the way, would only be-- would be a, uh, would be a, uh, 500% increase from where we are today.
261
00:47:07.836 --> 00:47:21.436
And then also Needham, John Todaro, friend of the show here, I've got-- we reported on this again in August. Um, they kept their Terawatt target at 33 bucks, um, which again, is slightly over their all-time high.
262
00:47:21.536 --> 00:47:23.916
So the thing is,
like, everybody's bullish Terawatt.
263
00:47:23.956 --> 00:47:37.456
It's really just a matter of, like, uh, is it, is it how many-- how, how much multiple increases from here, which is a flat from the start of the year, or is it, are we just benchmarking to the previous all-time high of, like, 28 bucks?
264
00:47:37.836 --> 00:47:44.696
Long story short is everybody's bullish Terawatt. It-- you know, how bullish are you, is the question. A few thoughts here.
265
00:47:44.756 --> 00:47:55.076
So one, disclosure, I do hold Terawatt in my personal portfolio, and I'm a, a long-term holder of it. I enjoy what the team is building over there, and I do think that the PowerShell model makes a lot of sense.
266
00:47:55.656 --> 00:48:07.396
And there are, uh, th-there is a big divergence in the market that I think a lot of people don't know about when they're first looking at these stocks, that Neocloud, "Hey, we're going to not only own the power and the land, but we're also gonna buy the chips.
267
00:48:07.476 --> 00:48:14.036
We're gonna build the orchestration layer for GPUs. We're gonna go sign contracts with AI labs, or we're gonna sell our compute into a generalized market."
268
00:48:14.556 --> 00:48:21.696
And then there's the PowerShell model, where it's like, "Hey, we're pretty happy with just owning the power and the land. We will be the landlord, you can be the tenant.
269
00:48:21.916 --> 00:48:29.476
You get certain rights to come use our facilities." They typically sign 15 to 20-year deals, uh, and, and that's pretty stable.
270
00:48:29.516 --> 00:48:46.476
You can kinda, like, look at the, the net expectation for that over 15 to 20 years, and it's almost like the people who move in as tenants own the space for 15 to 20 years, uh, but not quite, because there's that profitable layer in between that companies like Wolf are able to sit in.
271
00:48:46.516 --> 00:48:57.196
And so I'm a huge fan of that. Now, on the other hand, I do think that there are some dangers here, and I'm just gonna pull up this chart, if you can help me do that. But there's, there's the other layer, which is-
272
00:48:58.312 --> 00:49:05.752
The funding risk for these sites. This is Cipher Digital, which I mentioned earlier in the show. They put out that convertible note, bad time in the market.
273
00:49:05.852 --> 00:49:13.252
They needed a little more money because co- cost overruns, expensive and hot to build. It's not expensive to build in Texas, but it's hot to build in Texas.
274
00:49:13.732 --> 00:49:24.112
They need a little more cash, uh, and the market kind of puked on it, and they've been trying to recover for a while. You can see that market seems to try to be getting going again, and it, it's struggling.
275
00:49:24.212 --> 00:49:33.932
But, uh, you can look at over, once these ads drop off, look at the, the year-to-date levels and things like that, and it, it's kind of struggling. I think so is TradingView at the moment.
276
00:49:34.432 --> 00:49:46.052
But it's, uh, yeah, pretty brutal in a, in a percentage term. Like, we're not necessarily getting where we want to with, with Cipher at the moment, uh, because of those cost overruns.
277
00:49:46.492 --> 00:49:55.772
So moving away from that segment and, and getting away from it, I want to pull up this video from Paul Prager. He's the CEO over at TeraWulf, and I think he does a good job explaining this.
278
00:49:55.832 --> 00:50:04.912
We love a good Paul Prager video. Was this... Is this the CNBC one? He had a great- Yeah... he had some great content. I linked it in the show notes, so we should be able to pull that up in a second. Uh-huh.
279
00:50:05.212 --> 00:50:12.572
But I'll let you grab that, and in, in between, I'll just kind of mention that the way that TeraWulf is thinking long-term at the moment is,
280
00:50:13.512 --> 00:50:21.312
let's go find more sites, and I expect them to have more lease announcements going into next year, and maybe even to earnings. Like, that- that's what these guys do.
281
00:50:21.352 --> 00:50:26.692
They're almost like real estate investors, where they go and find plots of power land and build that out.
282
00:50:27.112 --> 00:50:36.212
Uh, and it's excellent for investors because there's a little bit of risk diversification there versus the GPU market, where it's like, "Hey, we gotta go find debt.
283
00:50:36.272 --> 00:50:41.392
We gotta go find, uh, installation teams, orchestration. We have to go find customers."
284
00:50:41.512 --> 00:50:51.212
The two to three-year contracts, there's a lot of problems with that versus, like, hey, we need a plot of land, we need energy, let's go. Let's watch this from Paul Prager, he's the CEO over at TeraWulf.
285
00:50:51.212 --> 00:51:04.852
Let's take a look. Companies like CoreWeave, Neoclouds, versus companies like ours, we're a co-location company, which means we own the land, we own the energy, we build the building, and we operate the data center.
286
00:51:05.292 --> 00:51:18.512
So we have long-term predictable cashflow, and we get quality energy from an investment-grade credit like utility, Kentucky Power, AEP, and we sell it to a high-quality credit.
287
00:51:18.732 --> 00:51:32.752
In this case, our customer in Lake Mariner effectively is Anthropic. In the announced deal Hawesville, Anthropic. But what the investors also need to understand is that we have an investment-grade backstop.
288
00:51:32.812 --> 00:51:43.452
In Lake Mariner, it's from Google. In, in Kentucky and Hawesville, we have an investment-grade backstop commitment. So we can raise the capital at very competitive rates.
289
00:51:43.872 --> 00:51:54.692
I think the other thing that the investors need to understand is we're not all the same. You have to focus on execution. You must focus on execution.
290
00:51:55.352 --> 00:52:04.932
We have guided the markets that we're building at our facilities at 8 to 10 per megawatt, 8 to 10 million a megawatt. We are squarely
right in that range.
291
00:52:05.112 --> 00:52:14.892
We haven't changed our story, and we're delivering Data Hall 4 at the, at the, the fourth quarter, and CB5 in the first quarter of next year.
292
00:52:15.272 --> 00:52:29.472
So we're on schedule, we are on track to deliver within a timely fashion, we are delivering at the cost that we told the customer we would deliver at, and we have the capital. He's right.
293
00:52:29.532 --> 00:52:40.252
I mean, it's like, think about how long and persistent this narrative has been, that they've been on time, at the budget they targeted, and they have investment-grade counterparties.
294
00:52:40.312 --> 00:52:50.912
Like, it's almost like they saw the playbook happening, uh, a year before it came to fruition. So shout out to TeraWulf. Yeah, we're just, we're just bull- bull posting here for TeraWulf.
295
00:52:50.972 --> 00:52:53.852
Yeah, but, but the stock's down 60% [laughs] on the year, so you know.
296
00:52:53.852 --> 00:53:05.872
[laughs] Yeah, I mean, like, a lot of these got spooked, and there was a ton of compression in the, in the markets since July, uh, because it's like, oh, this tenant thesis, you do need to have multiple tenants.
297
00:53:05.952 --> 00:53:18.011
Remember, I remember a year ago we were thinking about this with who's going to sign next, who's gonna get the next deal, and then it became not the next deal, but how many different types of counterparties are you gonna have in this deal?
298
00:53:18.092 --> 00:53:27.552
Is it gonna be hyperscalers? Is it gonna be different AI labs? And then it became, okay, execution, we'd see the revenue start flowing in. And then it became, oh, are you keeping your costs down?
299
00:53:27.972 --> 00:53:37.052
Uh, oh, then it became, can you keep your debt levels within the boundaries? The game's always changing. Only a few teams are gonna be able to execute. Right now I like Wulf.
300
00:53:37.532 --> 00:53:46.012
Morgan Stanley also makes note of a few other companies, so I think we can leave the, the levels there. As always, check out the website, uh, blockspace.media for more content.
301
00:53:46.712 --> 00:53:57.512
Yeah, we publish a lot on TeraWulf, and, uh, if new price targets from the banks and investment banks that we cover drop, we'll turn them around quickly. You'll hear it on our channels first, blockspace.media.
302
00:53:58.192 --> 00:54:08.632
We're gonna talk about the memory trade. Is it so back? Um, it is not clear, but SK Hynix up big this morning. We'll talk about that after a word from our sponsor, Ligos.
303
00:54:08.712 --> 00:54:20.672
[static sound] Hedge funds are getting liquidated. Is your Bitcoin safe? It's not just Bitcoin price drying up.
304
00:54:20.912 --> 00:54:34.892
Big whales, hedge funds, and lending desks are going under after the notorious crypto winter. Counterparty risk is rampant, so it's more important than ever to understand who actually controls your Bitcoin.
305
00:54:35.732 --> 00:54:44.252
Don't be the next FTX or Celsius victim. If you're working with another loan provider, do yourself a favor before it's too late and check out Ligos Finance.
306
00:54:44.672 --> 00:54:55.572
Ligos Finance is Blockspace's preferred non-custodial Bitcoin lender, which uses native Bitcoin smart contracts to protect your Bitcoin stack. With Ligos, you always know where your Bitcoin is.
307
00:54:56.212 --> 00:55:07.748
Hold your keys, no wrapping, no bridging, no rebuy, uh, rehypothecation, and get competitive rates as low as 10%. APR. Go to lygos.finance to learn more.
308
00:55:07.748 --> 00:55:21.068
[clears throat] Is the memory trade back? SK Hynix just reported an eye-watering profits and is up 12% today.
309
00:55:21.948 --> 00:55:37.768
Here's what's going on and why investors may be piling back into the memory trade. So last summer, memory stocks like Samsung and SK Hynix soared upwards, and then there was a bloodbath as the memory trade collapsed.
310
00:55:38.248 --> 00:55:47.508
Across the major memory and storage makers, roughly a trillion dollars in market value was erased in a single week just earlier this month.
311
00:55:48.748 --> 00:55:58.108
SK Hynix, the industry leader in high bandwidth memory, HBM for short, fell nearly 60% from its peak in June.
312
00:55:59.368 --> 00:56:08.267
However, last night, SK Hynix reported third quarter results, and the numbers tell a very, very different story than the doom and gloom you've been seeing.
313
00:56:09.068 --> 00:56:26.108
Revenue for SK Hynix topped 100 trillion won for the first time in the company's history, which is more, sit down, than it earned all of last year. Operating profit came in nearly $60 billion at an 80% operating margin.
314
00:56:26.388 --> 00:56:34.528
That's the sixth consecutive record quarter for the company, and it beat consensus by about 10%.
315
00:56:35.328 --> 00:56:48.048
I will go deeper into the numbers behind SK Hynix, but first, throw it to Will, who, granted, Will is not a memory trader here. But Will, these profit numbers are about as good as it can possibly get.
316
00:56:49.088 --> 00:57:00.548
Why do you think investors were so ready to bail on this trade just a few weeks ago? I mean, I remember the summer and the, and the craziness that we saw with this stock.
317
00:57:00.928 --> 00:57:05.788
Uh, South Korean markets were big on it, and there was a lot of margin calls.
318
00:57:05.908 --> 00:57:15.588
There was some stat about the sizable percentage of the South Korean population had been margin called over the summer, and I, I think this IPO had a lot of reasons to do with it.
319
00:57:16.588 --> 00:57:27.228
Look, the, the, uh, the entire game is predicated on having all of the stack. Memory is part of that stack. So if you're an AI bull, then you can't just say, "Hey, I'm gonna sit out on part of this."
320
00:57:27.328 --> 00:57:35.648
And parts of that stack have more of a bottleneck than others, right? So we talk about power
land on this show because that's a lot of the counterparties we're used to working with.
321
00:57:35.688 --> 00:57:45.148
We just talked about Morgan Stanley and, like, their bullish price targets on the PowerShell providers. Think about the hardware layer. There's all this hardware that needs to be talked about.
322
00:57:45.228 --> 00:57:55.388
We met up with Dylan Patel at Yotta just a few weeks ago, and we asked him, "What's the biggest bottleneck people aren't thinking about?" And he said, "Drill bits for PCB boards."
323
00:57:55.388 --> 00:58:06.108
PCB boards- I had to, I had to, I had to Google that. I was like, "What?" And then I, I quickly was like, "Oh, it's the little drill tips. They go in and they drill- Yeah... actual, like, electronics boards that sit...
324
00:58:06.148 --> 00:58:11.788
that the stuff sits on. So yeah. Just- I mean, that's a niche trade right there... just think about that. Yeah, just think about that. Like, the...
325
00:58:12.288 --> 00:58:23.448
There is a need on every single layer of this stack, and that's when people talk about this AI bubble as being something scary. I think you can take that
326
00:58:24.428 --> 00:58:32.208
kind of inside a little bit because a bubble like this does touch everything in the market. And I think as, like, humans, we have a hard time thinking about exponentials.
327
00:58:32.748 --> 00:58:36.028
This is one of those cases with the memory stocks. There is an exponential.
328
00:58:36.068 --> 00:58:46.268
There is a need for this equipment on every part of the globe, and you're going to see the few companies that can provide this at scale have huge markups on all their numbers.
329
00:58:46.748 --> 00:58:59.828
Uh, last thing I'll say, I throw it back to you. Just what a reversal versus a few weeks ago, and this is so classic, right? But you think it's all over. All of our stocks are down 50, 60% year to date.
330
00:58:59.868 --> 00:59:09.748
Like, we're off way from the highs. Like, is situational awareness gonna make it? Things are only getting worse. And then there's, like, a little bit of good news, and then, like, a little more good news comes out.
331
00:59:09.788 --> 00:59:20.348
And then all of a sudden, like, Meta's doing a huge raise because, like, they're so bullish on the footprint. And, like, Claude and Anthropic are having huge, huge growth despite everyone saying it's on.
332
00:59:20.728 --> 00:59:30.508
And then you see stuff like this, like, oh, the memory trade is back. So never, never doom pill, never dark pill, never red pill. Like, s- Yeah... stay with the trade is what I kinda think after seeing this.
333
00:59:31.228 --> 00:59:40.888
Look, look, if the memory trade is so back, we... you need to refer back to this show that you heard it here first. And if it's not so back and we keep going down, just forget we ever even covered this story.
334
00:59:40.928 --> 00:59:44.868
But let me, like, pull up the actual numbers 'cause the fundamentals are very impressive.
335
00:59:44.968 --> 01:00:41.508
I think people just got way too reactive about the stocks [clears throat]
336
01:00:41.548 --> 01:00:50.728
Like, why did memory just become all of a sudden the trade? It's historically been the commodity with the low margin layer of the chip business. It's been not flashy.
337
01:00:51.008 --> 01:01:00.948
It's been a consistent part of the Korean economy particularly. And right now, it's, like, the most profitable business in tech alongside Nvidia. SK Hynix's $63 billion
338
01:01:01.948 --> 01:01:11.728
in operating profit is within about a billion dollars of Nvidia's last quarter. So it's kinda crazy to see these two companies have roughly the same, uh, operating profit.
339
01:01:12.320 --> 01:01:27.720
Only Samsung and NVIDIA earn more operating profit among these global tech companies. [lips smack] What is driving this? Well, it's the high-bandwidth memory, specifically HBM4, high-bandwidth memory version four,
340
01:01:29.040 --> 01:01:34.920
which is the newest high-bandwidth memory, and that's the mem- the memory that goes on all of the AI chips.
341
01:01:35.560 --> 01:01:46.100
Um, it started full mass production, and it's, uh, happening at SK Hynix's new fab, which is called M15X, which is fully online by the year-end.
342
01:01:46.680 --> 01:01:58.520
And then you also have a new type of RAM, DDR5, but it's specifically for servers. So it's server DDR5, specifically data center memory. Sales are up 40% from last quarter. So back to Will.
343
01:01:59.860 --> 01:02:09.320
Will, you're not a memory investor. You're a data center guy. But I'm still gonna put you in the hot seat. Put your investor hat on. The stock was down 60%. You've seen bubbles.
344
01:02:09.380 --> 01:02:21.000
We've been in crypto [chuckles] for, like, nearly a decade. Um, the company just posted some of the best numbers it's ever posted, at the highest in its category in manufacturing and tech.
345
01:02:21.860 --> 01:02:31.060
Is this the moment to get back into memory? Or people stopped out- Oh, wow. Yeah. What do you, what do you d- You can just, like, sense the vibes in the timeline. What do you think?
346
01:02:32.220 --> 01:02:41.820
I mean, good earnings, get in there, right? Like, especially if the expectation going forward is just more and continuous growth. That's all I can really say about it. I'm not a memory trader.
347
01:02:41.880 --> 01:02:50.120
I don't, I don't touch it too much. But if you're beating consensus by 10%, and that's how all these hedge funds kinda do things now. It's not really like, "Oh," like, "what was your revenue?
348
01:02:50.180 --> 01:02:56.400
What was your profitability on that?" Like, it's all consensus. Like, are, are you beating? Are you under? Were you under? How are you over? And,
349
01:02:57.320 --> 01:03:08.580
and if it's over that much, for one, I think a lot of these buy-side, sell-side firms need to get better information. Uh, and, and two, probably a good place to look at. I don't think that we're gonna see a slowdown
350
01:03:09.480 --> 01:03:13.820
in these sort of applications, desire for these applications, cost for these.
351
01:03:14.360 --> 01:03:24.960
It would be interesting if there was, like, some sort of metric you could kinda look at, like the cost to purchase new GPUs and how that plays into, uh, the demand for memory, things like that.
352
01:03:25.060 --> 01:03:30.200
But I guess it would all be pretty, like, backwards-looking, maybe not that helpful. Uh, but yeah, I...
353
01:03:30.240 --> 01:03:42.300
my brain is kinda thinking around this now that it's popping again, like how can we think about actual deployments, purchase price for these things, and then tie it back into bottlenecks like memory. Yeah.
354
01:03:42.400 --> 01:03:52.700
You don't hear people talking about the bottleneck trade right now, but I bet you they start doing it. Like, I got this tweet pulled up, um, this went viral today in light of the SK Hynix news. And again, it's sarcasm.
355
01:03:53.140 --> 01:04:00.940
So he says, "Oh, no. Bad news for the memory bulls. SK Hynix only made $62 billion of profit in one quarter.
356
01:04:01.380 --> 01:04:13.580
For perspective, that's about seven years' worth of Tesla profits, or about 15 years of Palantir's current yearly profits, or six years of AMD's current yearly profits, all in one quarter, not one year.
357
01:04:13.960 --> 01:04:23.140
But it doesn't really matter, 'cause memory, it's cyclical, and cyclical money is like Monopoly money. And all these really smart people on X taught me that cyclical money doesn't really count."
358
01:04:23.720 --> 01:04:37.940
So it, the tweet goes on and on, but, like, it does underscore that when you compare [chuckles] how much profit SK Hynix just made compared to all the other cool companies worth way more than it, it does boggle the mind.
359
01:04:38.500 --> 01:04:53.280
So is the memory trade back? Let us know in the comments. Let us know what you think. We will respond. Thank you for listening to Block Space Live, co-hosted by Charlie Spears and William Foxley.
360
01:04:53.740 --> 01:05:06.220
My co- my former co-host, Colin Harper, is somewhere in the middle of the Atlantic Ocean, I hope, doing some R&D on, uh, prevailing trade winds. If you like the show, leave us a comment.
361
01:05:06.420 --> 01:05:16.760
We do this every single weekday at 1:00 PM Eastern. However, there is a slight change of the schedule. Given that Colin is out, we may be doing this Monday, Wednesday, Friday.
362
01:05:17.300 --> 01:05:30.399
Still, make sure to hit that like and subscribe, turn the notification bell on so you get the push notification on your device when we're live, 1:00 PM Eastern. This is Compute's daily live show. Thank you for watching.
363
01:05:31.120 --> 01:05:48.600
I'm Charlie. I'm Will. We'll see you tomorrow. [upbeat music]