TRANSKRIBEERI 🔗
Jackie Slaght: Welcome to Beyond Tech, where innovation meets insight. I'm your host, Jackie Slatt, joined by my guest co-host, Business Development Manager Ben Culla, and our guest, Seth Hancock, program manager at eTech Group. Today we're talking about something that's not always top of mind, but probably should be. What happens when your motion systems are no longer supported? Across many manufacturing environments, especially in food and beverage, we're seeing more and more legacy servo systems reaching the end of their life cycle. That means limited parts availability, reduced vendor support, and increased risk of unplanned downtime. And in many cases, that leads to something manufacturers try to avoid: forced upgrades. So instead of asking if modernization will happen, the real question becomes how do you get ahead of it before it becomes a problem? In this episode, we'll break down what servo obsolescence looks like, why it's accelerating, and how manufacturers can proactively plan for upgrades rather than reacting under pressure. So with that, let's get into it. I will start with you, Seth. what does it an end of life or end of support mean when it comes to servo and motion systems?
Seth: So end of life and end of support are very similar items. end of life is an item that has been discontinued that you can no longer get any any new versions of that you can no longer buy that you can't get from a what we would consider a reputable supplier. end of support is something that you can no longer get support from from the OEM manufacturer.
Ben Kalla: Seth, we see a lot more modernizations becoming a priority across manufacturers, really across all industries, but particularly in food and beverage. do you think you can talk through why modernizing while running has become such a big focus and and how we're able
Seth: Yeah.
Ben Kalla: to attack it?
Seth: Yeah, absolutely. So mo modernization as part of a maintenance plan is is obviously I think everyone's recommendation. The the big concern with with server modernizations and server projects is when you don't modernize or plan to modernize, you end up with with what we can consider emergency upgrades or emergency repairs, which often lead to extended unplanned unplanned downtime windows. So the goal of of everything that we do when it when it comes to obsolescence is to to decrease downtime, to decrease that unplanned downtime. And server modernization is is one of the big steps there because the the server modernization paths are quite a bit more complicated than just a PLC to PLC or or simple HMI upgrade or something like that. What we're really trying to do is is to prevent that unplanned downtime.
Jackie Slaght: can you do give a quick overview of what a servo system is?
Seth: Yeah, yeah. So I'll I'll give my my interpretation of it. and then and then I'll let those on LinkedIn dive into to the more more in-depth version of what what that is. But but
Jackie Slaght: Ha ha
Seth: I I think the easy way to explain to explain servos and and and and what a servo system is is is you you're you're talking advanced position systems. So anything that needs to have very specific positioning, anything that has specific coordinated positioning. most of those systems are are using servos or some type of what we would consider to be a motion hardware. so a lot of times that could be could be servo amplifiers and motors, that could be robotics, that could be a lot of different things that we would all lump into what we consider the servo modernization path.
Jackie Slaght: so we're we're talking like specifically servo modernization because there's a need for that, but I assume also across the board there's other equipment that is just kind of reaching the end of life in different aspects of the production process. okay.
Seth: Absolutely. And with with our end of life and and what end of life looks like, I know there's been I I think we've even had a few a few episodes now on on obsolescence and and what it means to to move forward, right, to to new new offerings and and things that are supported. So what we're we're trying to to get to is a point where we can support everything. So servo modernization is is part of that. Oftentimes it builds on top of modernization of other pieces of equipment if we're going into to modernize communications protocols and and you know go to Ethernet or or some type of some type of Ethernet based media, we then have to oftentimes upgrade different different aspects of the system as well. So usually that's like an HMI, we'll get into some VFDs and and now I think what we're seeing a lot of is is the server modernization as part of that.
Jackie Slaght: Yeah, so we we definitely have covered a couple different episodes of obsolescence and modernization. And I think one of the big concerns is when you start one of these projects, it's kind of like a home renovation project. you upgrade one thing and then it becomes something else and something else, which is I think a scary thought for for a home renovation project or a upgrade for a manufacturing facility, but that's part of what we would say why you want to get in front of it because you can better control it and have more ability to keep it from getting out of hand if you're in a situation where you just got to get up and running. you are reacting versus taking the time to think through a better longer term plan. So that's my little scale.
Seth: yeah. that that's a very good feel. It's the server systems always go down on Fridays and they always go down on Fridays before a before a holiday weekend. And that's that is that is when it always happens. it feels like that's that is always the the issue with with old hardware we'll call it or obsolete hardware. so we're we're just trying to prevent that, right? Bring some awareness to to what it is, to what we we can provide in doing that. and how we can how we can help build that into a multi year plan, whether it be a
Load full transcript
controls, a a corporate controls plan or if it's a local maintenance budget, whatever that looks like, that's that's what we're trying to do is to help to help build that into those.
Jackie Slaght: Yeah. so What are the the biggest risks manufacturers face when they continue operating an unsupported servo system?
Seth: Yeah. So we we talked a little about unplanned downtime. and unplanned downtime comes from a a lot of different things. I I think that's everyone's big big item right now, right? It it's you know, to for for a plant to make money they the plant has to run, right? So if it can't run then then we're not producing. And with this, the the risk that we run with servo systems specifically is the length of upgrade. a lot of these systems aren't a direct one-to-one replacement. Most of the time there aren't simple converters or things that you can you can do off the shelf to just add into that system and and get that system up and running. oftentimes there's a mechanical piece in that where you know new hardware may not necessarily match up with with old existing obsolete hardware, and you may have to do some mechanical changes to it. So there's there's just a lot more development that goes into a servo motion project. that then leads to those projects taking a longer longer downtime window to achieve, which if you're not planning for, leads to to longer, unplanned downtime windows and and more production loss.
Ben Kalla: Yeah, and I think we're starting to get to a point where most of our larger clients have pretty detailed modernization assessments done. They know where a lot of those risks are and they know what needs to get changed. what can be difficult is at a local plant level, everyone still has their same immediate production goals, right? So it can be very hard to find a time to to take a machine down for a few days to work on that sort of longer term risk. while the plant itself is being judged by what they're able to output this week, this month, this quarter. there can there can always be a little bit of friction there and I I'm curious, Seth, in in your time, how have you seen companies being able to bridge that gap, I guess, through that sort of a lot of time more corporate oriented longer term risk aversion versus the, you know, immediate production goals for a local plant?
Seth: Yeah, so the there's there's a few ways to help help mitigate what we'll call the the schedule debacle. so obviously we have a lot of weekends and holidays. a lot of weekends and holidays is when this work takes place. and then trying to capture capture existing downtime windows. because there's so much mechanical work that goes into into a lot of these upgrades and and back end panel electrical work, oftentimes that can be done. in coordination with with larger corporate projects. So if there's a certain part of the plant that has to be shut down and and while that part of the plant shut down, we have a a small window where we can put up barriers
and and do things to to get our crews in to to perform those upgrades. That's when we're trying to to complete these projects. We're trying to to make sure that we can coordinate with with what that local plant need is with the downtown windows that they already have and and make sure that those those corporate folks are engaged in what's going on and and what that overall schedule needs to look like.
Jackie Slaght: So what happens when a legacy servo system fails and a replacement part or support are no longer available? what kind of options is the manufacturer left with in that situation?
Seth: Yeah, so a few options. most of them end end with a call to to your favorite systems integrated. is is usually where most people start. And and then we have a a team internally that is our server motion team that starts looking at that system. Hopefully it's a system we're already familiar with from from doing a site evaluation of some sort. oftentimes it's always a system we haven't looked at. when that happens, we
Jackie Slaght: Okay.
Seth: we then try to get get some immediate feedback on what hardware do you have? What One, what is the problem that you're facing? Is is the problem that it just stopped working? Is the problem that something's hot? Is you know what what type of problem are we looking at? We try to get one of those experts engaged in in that immediate problem to see if there are any workarounds. Is there anything that we can do just from a service standpoint to get at least some version of production up and running? from there, everyone wants to always know cost and downtime or cost and lead time in in in this matter. so we we reach out to a few different a few different organizations that we can get some hardware from. We have a couple places that do some rebuilds and some things like that of of some old hardware. A lot of that's getting a lot harder to get, a lot harder to find and and significantly more expensive. I I think everyone has has has heard the the stigma of of trying to buy a BLC f a PLC five card from eBay for twenty five thousand dollars or whatever it is when when you know you haven't had an issue with that card in in ages, right? very similar with with hardware and and servo hardware that we're seeing now. So usually that's the next step. Can we get something? Can we get something promptly to at least get the the plant up and running? If that is not tangible, if that is not doable with servos, there's a lot of different brands and and it just in the US, you you have you know 10 to 15 different different server hardware brands that you can find in in all of our food and beverage clients today. And Finding hard that hardware through the different acquisitions of hardware companies and things like that can become very difficult. So it's usually 50-50 on if we can find them something or not. either way, we'll then try to immediately look at what we can do to replace this with new hardware. are the new motors going to going
to fit? Is this going to require new gearboxes, new adapters? what is that going to look like? what what type of power is supplying this system? a lot of times some of our older plants and older systems. aren't on 480 volt power. Most of the time we're recommending them go to 480 volt power. So can we get motors and and and amplifiers that are not 480 volt? Can we get something that is a direct conversion? Do we need to run this through a motion analyzer? There's a lot of different steps that that we immediately go into and oftentimes those are are immediately engaged when we get that call. So it can look Very, very simple and very easy is is kind of the goal to the to the end customer that they make the call and and then we're able to provide them here's your your three different solutions for what we can do starting tomorrow or starting today even. and often in on the back end there's four or five people that are all scrambling to to get all of those all of those parts and pieces in place and and figure out if if we can get those those pieces and hardware specifics from our vendors.
Jackie Slaght: So I assume that of course always happens on a Friday evening of a long holiday weekend.
Seth: Yep. Yep.
Jackie Slaght: But are you looking at days to be down normally or hours or longer, or does it really vary?
Seth: Yeah. Yeah. So it it's very dependent on the size of the system. So if we have a we'll call a relatively simple system, maybe a two axis system where we have call it two motors, that system in hope we can get you back up and going in days, i is the hope. if obviously if there's some hardware available and some things like that, then then we can shorten that lead time a lot, but almost every time you're you're talking about some sort of a a complete electrical rebuild of the panel that houses whatever drives or amplifiers you currently have, new new motor cables, new motors, new encoders if if that is is an item. the PLC has to be looked at depending on on what devices you're you're currently running with and what your plan is to go to. most corporations now and I and Vin might have touched on this a little, have at least some sort of a standard as to what we should be going to for hardware. So if if you're standard says that we have to have have to have control of the Ethernet for all of all of your servos, but we c but your PLC doesn't have Ethernet, then we have to have a separate conversation, right, of of what does that entail. So the they can they can snowball very quickly from, you know, the three or four day mark to to fourteen to twenty days. And that's really what we're trying to avoid by by having these conversations early.
Jackie Slaght: So and that Ben, this might be yeah, I'm sure you've talked to a lot of different clients. So are they when something like this goes down, is it like, my gosh, I'm shocked, I had no idea, or do they kind of like, yeah, no, we knew it was getting getting to that point and we were kind of running on borrowed time, or is it like a my gosh, out of nowhere we
Ben Kalla: Yeah.
Jackie Slaght: gotta fix this?
Ben Kalla: It's usually sort of somewhere in the middle in the sense that people aren't usually surprised, right? When something's been running for thirty, forty years and they know it's obsolete and it's not supported, no one's really gonna be shocked when it goes down. but that doesn't negate any of the urgency of that machine going down, right? So it's still a all hands on deck, total fire drill. like Seth said, usually on a Friday afternoon before the weekend, just about to close your
Jackie Slaght: Yeah.
Ben Kalla: computer. but, you know, it it's an actively producing machine, right? So any anything going down becomes incredibly important. just trying to get it back up as soon as you can. there is hopefully usually some type of contingency plan, right? Like hopefully someone has looked at it and has some type of idea of what they they would want a future state to look like. but that's certainly not always the case, especially when you get to sort of smaller standalone facilities. sometimes that that hasn't really all been thought out. so I know Seth, one thing you talked about was trying to standardize hardware or different automation practices across facilities can really help out in a situation like this. getting things back up and running as soon as we can if we have some type of idea of the current state and the preferred future state. Do you have any other advice on what companies, particularly national clients or global clients can be doing across facilities to Really set the groundwork for future modernization.
Seth: Yeah, absolutely. So the the big conversation to have is is what platform do you want to do you want to work with, right? What platform is available by you, what platform do you currently support, what platform do you currently get support from? oftentimes we're we're spending a lot of time a lot of time with the kinetics platform, obviously big big partners with with Rockwell and Alan Bradley. On our end, it's a platform that we're very familiar with. there are a couple different platforms within that kinetics. family we'll call it that that can help decide what what's best for for the client specifically. So we're doing a lot of work with with the kinetics 5500 platform and then some of our more advanced systems or systems that that require a lot more axes we'll get into the to the kinetics 5700 family. So a lot of that is just building off of of what has already existed from like the Ultra 3000s to build on what we were talking about a a minute ago. The Ultra 3000s most people have have had no issues with. They've ran for years and years and years. And only recently have they started to see some small issues arise with them and everyone logged on and realized that they can't buy those anymore and they've been obsolete for for a number of years. So it's very similar to to what we're seeing in the PLC
world where no one knows it's an issue because no one's had an issue with it. And now all of a sudden all of those those parts and pieces have become obsolete and they've all approached what is what is the end of their useful life in in manufacturing environments. So getting getting those decisions made on on what family you're going with, what brand and what what do your techs know is is really the key there.
Jackie Slaght: so I guess you talked a little bit about the standardization and and kind of knowing where you want to go, but what I guess aside from we already kind of talked about guiding buying parts on eBays, but what how do issues like the spare parts availability and vendor support impact the long-term decision making?
Seth: Yeah, so vendor support is is obviously very very big. and I think for those of us that that spend a lot of time with vendors and spend a lot of time with with customers that have healthy relationships with their vendors, seeing that that we're all able to to work in unison really to get these solutions, that that I think is is the the most important thing. You want to make sure that that when you're going in and selecting your hardware, it's something that your preferred systems integrator is comfortable with, is familiar with, that The softwares that you're going to use in in that hardware is something that your your local teams and if you're someone that's in the in the corporate controls department that that you understand it and that your local teams are familiar with it. And then is is that vendor someone that that you can get feedback from, right? Is that vendor someone that that you can get hardware from, that hardware lead times aren't aren't astronomical? what what does that look like? And I think that's that's usually the the direction that we try and try and and lead the the customer in w when selecting hardware brands.
Jackie Slaght: I
Ben Kalla: I know we're talking a lot about how much standardization can help in sort of an emergency situation, right? getting getting us up off the ground running as as quickly as we can. I think another way it can be really, really helpful is finding solutions we can roll out to multiple plants, particularly when we're looking at clients that have a a very large footprint across the country or or even across the globe. one thing that we like to do is do a pilot. plant, right? So find one particular plant that we can carry out a project at that we know is gonna be replicable at at other sites across the country. And what that does is it gives us an opportunity to really drill into how things are gonna go at that one facility, usually with some additional eyesight from corporate engineering, make sure we get a lot of feedback from everybody we can think of and identify any possible roadblocks in the future. And then once we get that first site done, not only is it much quicker to roll it out at other plants, but there's so much less engineering, right? It it's it saves
a a ton of money as well. just having something you you've already done before. Obviously there's still gonna be that on site commissioning, and there's gonna be some verification and troubleshooting, but you know, having all the heavy lifting done goes a really long way. I guess Have you seen a lot more success when you're able to start with a pilot plant versus just trying to take plants down one at a time and can you talk through that a little bit?
Seth: Yeah, of course. This is is my preference. I when when working with customers, specifically customers that have very similar lines in a lot of their manufacturing facilities, being able to go in and and have one plant that is the pilot plant where where we are familiar with their control scene, familiar with with the electricians doing work in the plant, familiar with the mechanical contractors in the plant, being able to get with that team and and really develop that solution for a pilot project at that pilot plant. That really helps us down the road. So few few examples that we've gone through on a lot of actually a lot of different equipment now. We've we've done this numerous times. So we go in and we are able to fully develop and fully integrate one of these systems and one of these conversions. And then from that we are able to build a package. And we can take that package, being the mechanical installation package, electrical installation package, and then obviously the controls package, and take that to the rest of the facilities and then it's vetted. and and and proven out and we have all of the data on the back end from from that line running with those upgrades to go to those other other plants and show them that that this is the approved solution, this is the solution that the the corporate engineering team, the local plant team at that facility, and our team are all behind and and all supporting. So that can make using those upgrades and upgrading those specific pieces of equipment a lot simpler for for those planks. It also gives us a very specific timeline that we're able to work in and we know what that downtime and what those commissionings are going to look like.
Jackie Slaght: So can you share an example of a situation where a system kind of reached the end of life and forced an upgrade for a client? And then like looking back, are there things that that could have been done differently or did they use it kind of as like, well, we better get a plan in in place for four other facilities or kind of make it the pilot plant once they've gone through one of them?
Seth: Yeah, absolutely. So we have joked a few times about lines going down on Friday afternoon and it being the time that Ben and I get the most calls and and all of these things happening. So that comes be that is funny because it's happened, right? And we're able to to laugh through the pain on on some of those upgrades. So have a a couple of clients and it it's always interesting to work with with clients that are with with different companies because they all tend to go through very similar pain points. usually at very similar times. So I would say within six months of each other, we had two of our two of our major clients that both called us on a I think one was a Thursday afternoon and one was a Friday afternoon, with a server system that was hard down, that they could not get going, they could not find hardware for, there was no replacement. It was an emergency. We need to source hardware and and get this upgraded over the weekend. And Both of those instances, thankfully, one one was a single access system, one was a two-access system. We were able to do those in in four days from phone call to line being up and running. But those require a lot more help on the back end. So while we were doing that, we were able to go in, get the hardware swapped, get the machine up and up and running. Usually there's a lot of of on-site support that that's required. on the back end to get those get those systems up to performance the performance level that they they were seeing before they went down. both of those clients were then then had asked us to look through some of their other equipment that had very similar similar hardware in it, similar levels of obsolescence and and obscurity, I think we'll call that hardware. so we were then able to turn that into to more of a long term plan for them on getting the rest of those machines upgraded.
Ben Kalla: Cool. S Seth, one thing I wanna get your take on, something that used to be a little bit more of an afterthought and has become much more talked about as it should be, particularly in the past I would say four and five years, is cybersecurity and network infrastructure. especially when we're looking at some of these sort of big modernizations and upgrades and especially when we're talking about future state goals for a plant. these are these are things that are integral to anything that we're doing. I think maybe ten, fifteen years ago they were kind of you figure it out at the end, right? Worry about the modernization worry about the modernization first. but nowadays it's becoming sort of something that gets talked about much more early. w how do you see those conversations progressing? Who are you usually having them with? And what advice do you have for manufacturers on things to make sure they're keeping an eye on as often as they can?
Seth: Biggest advice is to make sure that someone's having the conversation. I I I think by now most most entities are having a cybersecurity conversation. most of the time, that cybersecurity conversation is happening before a network infrastructure conversation has happened, and that is the pain point that we see. A lot of times there is a network cybersecurity engineer or someone from from the corporate IT team that knows that that they have issues with cybersecurity in their facilities. And is wanting to enact change in those facilities, which is 100% the correct thing to do.
The predicament that we have there is really that convergence between IT and OT. And I know we talk about that a lot as as eTech group, that being one of the things that that we are really putting an emphasis on going in and assisting our customers with is that that convergence between the two. But we are doing that because it's it's an issue. So when we have someone coming in wanting to enact this this change to to make everything even better from a from a cybersecurity and an IT IT world. Oftentimes we haven't done any any infrastructure whatsoever on the OT side. So the plant floor is is oftentimes a disaster. And there's usually one one controls technician or controls engineer in the plant, maybe a maintenance tech in the plant that knows where all of the mystery IDFs are. Most of the time those IDFs are completely full and no one has has spent any time with them in in years. maybe ever. So going and having those conversations early, we are trying to make sure that we're having that conversation both with with the local plant maintenance and with with anyone we can anyone we can really talk to on the corporate engineering level to to make sure that when we're going in and adding this new hardware that has all of these additional benefits that that we can provide, that at least someone is aware of that so that we can make a plan. When when talking servos specifically and and network architecture specifically, When we're doing these these server modernization upgrades, a lot of the time we're going from a system that was not part of the network to a system that that is networked. oftentimes there's a there's a few different ways that we can go about that. most of what we're doing with with servos in involves an entirely new network solely for solely for the servo system. So there's a lot of conversations that need to be had around that and and a lot of a lot of new I I would say to those conversations that that most clients aren't aren't currently looking at.
Jackie Slaght: So what is one thing that a that a client could do to be to start being proactive in their upgrade strategy?
Ben Kalla: I I think a big thing that any manufacturer can be doing to make sure they're staying a step ahead of of their modernization goals and being proactive about risk is first it's gonna sound simple, but just making sure they're documenting what they currently have, right? Doing some evaluation of their current install base, what is actively running, opening up all of your electrical panels, seeing what's in there, looking in the storeroom, seeing what you have there. right. And that way you can really start sort of Looking up what do I have that's obsolete? where could I replace it? If I can't, how many do I have as spares if I don't have any? you know, what's the contingency plan, right? and sort of starting to figure out where your highest risk areas are and start trying to think of what are what are some paths to mitigate risk there. and and that's one place that we can help out a lot. through any step of that process, whether it's getting on site and and doing that documentation, or if you have it, you know, having one of our engineers take a look and telling you where we've seen the most problems, where we're starting to be the most concerned about supply chain, that sort of thing, making sure you at least have in your head some sort of idea what items are gonna be the most likely to cause you headache in the future and how we can start trying to attack those as soon as we can.
Seth: Absolutely. I I like to liken this to the dishes. Modernization is is just like the dishes. You can leave sitting in the sink and know you have a problem and know you have no plan to do it, or you can load the dishwasher as you And you at least have a plan. You may not have have done it yet, but at least the dishes are in the dishwasher.
Jackie Slaght: Well, I think that's especially becoming prevalent with like cybersecurity, isn't it? I feel like we've had conversations or heard conversations of cybersecurity, like not being able to get insurance if you don't have a plan or some like a yeah, some sort of plan in place that shows how you're gonna tackle compliance and cybersecurity.
Seth: absolutely. And and cybersecurity is is is building out so much more now, right? We're we're past past the point of of just going in and and making sure that we have correct firewall rules, right? We're we're getting much more into the into the OT side of cybersecurity, and with that comes comes additional additional hardware requirements all the way down to the PLC level. And when when those PLC level changes are occurring, oftentimes that is like we I think we talked about a little earlier. That is leading to some of these other modernization efforts that we're having to do.
Jackie Slaght: what advantages does a modern servo platform have compared to the legacy ones?
Seth: So a lot of what we're doing here is is centered around trying to have a truly connected maintenance professional and and connected shop floor worker. So with these upgraded systems, we're able to go in and do a lot more analytics into how is the motor, how is the server amplifier, really even even VFDs and and motors on VFDs, not necessarily servos, all of the newer hardware does a lot more diagnostics into that. we're then able to take that and and create actual predictive maintenance. predictive maintenance has become one of the the biggest I think pushes that we're we're going to see in modern industry. So that's definitely a a big plus and a a big advancement to it. The other side of that is is having the support and having the availability for the next whatever the next round of upgrades is, right? I I think that anyone that's been been in this business and and doing this long enough understands that that we'll never get out of obsolescence upgrades. there's always new technology and new software coming and and usually most things that we're doing are
on that ten to fifteen year cycle. So when we're able to go through and and do these platforms, a lot of these platforms are bringing us to a very specific very specific Again. Monday. It's Monday. Yeah.
Jackie Slaght: Monday at the end of the day.
Seth: standard. Standards are what I was really important. Okay. a lot of these upgrades that we're doing are bringing us to a much more modern standard or really any standard at all. So when we're going in and and connecting these motors and and hooking these systems up, we're able to bring those electrical control panels as well as the mechanical systems up to some sort of a standard. the hope then is that w in ten to fifteen years when we see this system come back through and and need its next round of of modernization or obsolescence upgrade, we're then able to maintain that standard, which in theory should make that upgrade a lot simpler.
Ben Kalla: Seth, I know we're getting to the end here, but I was wondering if you could maybe tell us about back when in your younger days if you had any modernization projects that maybe didn't go so well and what you learned, what happened and how you avoid that now.
Seth: Yeah, yeah, a absolutely. I I think anyone that's ever done modernization has had a project that hasn't gone well. So I am not unique in in that. I definitely have had have had a few that that we've had to go back to the drawing board on. So a lot of times what that comes down to is making sure that that the the extent of what that system does is is fully understood and vetted. oftentimes there's one small feature that the machine does and that maybe isn't captured when we do an on-site investigation, isn't captured in any old documentation and isn't used for for really anything other than than one maintenance mechanic on third shift that only works Sundays, that does it once every quarter. you know, so a lot of times that's that's what it is. And and that got me a lot. I say probably my first first two or three upgrades that I did, we had something small like that that and there were they're usually callbacks, right? It's Thankfully with with things like that, it's not always something that prevents the line from running. Definitely have had one that prevented the line from running, but it's not always something that has the line from running, but definitely ends with with a bunch of panicked phone calls, you know, at Sunday at two AM when when that maintenance person is is in there trying to make the machine run backwards for two seconds, and the machine should never have ran backwards for any amount of seconds, but they've been able to do that for thirty years. So why would it not be able to do it now, right? So that's just one of those things that that one makes makes servos very difficult, but also makes them a lot of fun, right? There's a lot of a lot of pre work, a lot of a lot of really true engineering that gets to go into these projects. And and that's why I enjoy That's why the the
servo motion team that we have here at ETEC, that's why they enjoy that's why we all we all love and love to hate these projects. They're they're just a lot of fun.
Jackie Slaght: Yeah.
Ben Kalla: They certainly keep us on our toes.
Seth: They do, they do. That's it's as as our dear friend Pedro says, it's it's all fine.
Jackie Slaght: What would you say to a manufacturer, what's the first step they should take to get ahead of any forced motion system upgrades?
Seth: Yeah. It's very simple. call eTech and get some sort of an evaluation. If you don't have an evaluation, call us. Let's get an evaluation. If you do have an evaluation, and when I'm talking evaluation, touching on on what Ben spoke to earlier, we want to know what currently exists in your facility. We want to know what exists in the facility, what's the end of life status of all those items, and then what do you currently stock in in your spare parts inventory. So if you have that. call us so that we can start having a conversation about what actually is achievable and what is not achievable in the downtime windows that you have. What can you get hardware for? What can you not get hardware for? What does that look like? But but really just making that phone call to to find out what you have. You want it it's terrifying because it's a lot easier to just not know that you have a hundred problems than it is to to have all of those all of those sitting on your shoulders. But but it definitely makes it a lot easier when You have to call us because the system's down and you're able to tell us what hardware currently exists in that system.
Jackie Slaght: Yeah, I said I would imagine that is kind of a overwhelming fear. Like, if I just don't know it, we can just keep running and and I don't have to But it
Seth: Yes. Yeah,
Jackie Slaght: I assume like I said, the evaluation can be scary, but that is the first step in getting that plan and breaking it into smaller steps of like what do we want to tackle
Seth: I know it doesn't yeah, absolutely. And and Ben and I know it doesn't make anyone feel better, but we have to say if it does make anyone feel better, we we know all of all of the old legacy obsolete systems in all of the plants. So it's with us too. And and more often more often than not, there's a significant amount of those plants that we're all sitting there thinking about in the middle of the night when we can't sleep, because we know that one day we're just
Jackie Slaght: Ha ha ha.
Seth: gonna get a call and there's gonna be fifteen lines down. And and and
Jackie Slaght: huh.
Seth: everyone'll be scrambling. So it's it's definitely a a a fun time in the industry because we're getting to go through this and and we're kind of all getting to go through this at the beginning of of what we feel is going to be a big push towards server modernization. but it but it's scary. It's it's very scary.
Jackie Slaght: Yes, I said we can we can all be scared together and figure it out.
Seth: Absolutely.
Jackie Slaght: but I I want to thank you guys for taking taking some time out of out of your day and hopefully I didn't make you miss any important phone calls from people whose lines are going down right now. but before I let you guys go, I always like to end on some fun questions they're just fun way to wrap up the shows. So my first question is if you could automate one thing in your life, what would it be?
Seth: Dicies.
Ben Kalla: Mine would probably be some type of food manufacturing, funny enough. I'd be it'd be a cooking. you know, if I could have something automating, you know, fresh made tacos or sandwiches even, anything like that, I'd I'd think that would be very helpful. Especially you know, Seth and I have plenty of days we we can't get away from the computer, right? So having something that could automate some quick made food as well as in the morning and dinner that I that would be a game changer for me.
Jackie Slaght: That's what we've had a lot
Seth: Absolutely.
Jackie Slaght: of people say like meal prep or something like as their
Ben Kalla: Okay.
Seth: Mm-hmm.
Jackie Slaght: answer. So I mine is always like dishes. I don't mind cooking the food, but I don't want
Seth: That's fine.
Jackie Slaght: to clean it up.
Ben Kalla: I hear that. That would
Seth: Yep.
Ben Kalla: be good too.
Seth: Yeah, I would definitely be the dishes. Just not not having
Jackie Slaght: What about you said? Yeah.
Seth: to do the dishes one day would be amazing. It would be so good. If if you just put them in the sink and then magically they're done and put away, that would be really awesome. Because the doing them part is okay. It's the putting them away
Ben Kalla: You know what's funny is
Seth: part.
Ben Kalla: sixty years
Jackie Slaght: Yeah.
Ben Kalla: ago someone would have said the dishwasher is is the automating the dishes, right? It's the best thing ever. And now it's that's not enough for us. But I'm with ya, I'm in the same boat. It's still there's still a few steps there. There's still some steps.
Seth: Yes. Yep. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Jackie Slaght: No. It's
Seth: I want batching and a packaging line. I don't just want batch.
Ben Kalla: Yeah, exact exactly.
Jackie Slaght: I will say aside from dishes, it's laundry and it's not the doing the laundry.
Seth: Mm-hmm.
Jackie Slaght: I want it put away. That is where it can't, that's what I want a robot
Seth: Yeah.
Jackie Slaght: to do is come and hang up and put my clothes away for all of the people in my house.
Ben Kalla: Yeah, yeah.
Seth: Yeah. It gets it gets pretty bad when I when I get home from being on the road and and I just take the clothes out of my suitcase and put them into the washer and wash and dry and then put them back in the suitcase because it's just easier that way and I don't have to put away or fold them or do anything like that. works exceptionally
Jackie Slaght: Ready to go.
Seth: well. But I haven't been traveling as much the last few weeks, so it's it's
difficult to to maintain that rhythm. Yeah.
Jackie Slaght: Well, that's good. okay, my other fun question is how would you explain your career or your job to a five year old?
Ben Kalla: One thing that's made it much easier for me to explain my job is the T V show how it's made. I think to crutch a lot of people use. If anyone's seen that show, they they're somewhat familiar with the manufacturing facility, right? and then from there what we do here at ETEC is try and make sure those manufacturing facilities are running smoothly, producing as much as they can produce, reducing risk, reducing downtime. making any changes that need to be made, particularly in today's age. variety seems to be the big thing and for any manufacturer, right? So coming out with different flavors and different sizes and, you know, the consumer likes their customizable options. So there's always changes being
Jackie Slaght: Yeah.
Ben Kalla: made to those manufacturing processes and and anytime anything's happening in a manufacturing facility where they're helping out somehow.
Jackie Slaght: That's good answer. And I'm one of
Seth: Mm-hmm.
Jackie Slaght: those people, I will try any new flavor, whatever it is. I just want to know how it like sure, let's give it a
Ben Kalla: Yeah, me too. Me too. total sucker for it. Yeah. You never know when you might find your favorite one, right?
Jackie Slaght: Yeah. It
Seth: That's right.
Jackie Slaght: might be good. We don't know.
Seth: my answer isn't nearly as fun or as complex as Ben's. I
Jackie Slaght: No.
Seth: have gotten to do this a few times recently and my favorite thing to tell small children when they ask what I do is that I press screen buttons and then things come out.
Jackie Slaght: Perfect.
Ben Kalla: Hopefully.
Jackie Slaght: I had somebody answer it. they said I make the tunes that the machines dance to. And I thought that was like a really good way to describe it too. I was like, that's that is
Seth: Mm-hmm. Yep.
Ben Kalla: great.
Jackie Slaght: that's a great way to explain it. okay, my last question is what other topics or yeah, what other conversations would you like to see us have on episodes of Beyond Tech?
Seth: I'd love to see a Beyond Tech episode on lab automation. It's not something that I really get to do much with. not something that that I think Ben or I spends spends a lot of time in. So there's a lot of lot of new and and exciting information and exciting things I think happening in that space. So getting to see one with with that part of the ETEC team I think would be very cool.
Jackie Slaght: Yeah, awesome.
Ben Kalla: Most of my ideas I know have already been covered on Beyond Tech.
Jackie Slaght: I know we're we're getting to a lot of episodes.
Ben Kalla: I think one thing that would be cool to see covered on Beyond Tech is sort of what in the industry they call a digital twin. it's sort of setting up your production facility in a digital environment, and then using that environment to test different things, add add new lines, try different products. can be super beneficial for a lot of the stuff that that Seth and I have talked about today as far as future state ideas or mitigating risk, having that sort of digital environment to play on can help out a lot so you're not actually moving any real gears, right? I think that's something a lot of customers are getting a lot more serious about and it that would be cool to explore a little bit further.
Jackie Slaght: Yeah, these are great ideas. Thank you guys. I know I've bothered Cole is kind of my go to person for digital twins and I've bothered him
Ben Kalla: There you go.
Jackie Slaght: for a lot of other things, but we'll I think he likes talking to me, so it will be good. I wanna just thank you guys for spending some time this afternoon and yeah, well maybe we'll get you back on here again for for another episode. We'll come up with something else to talk about. So but thank you.
Ben Kalla: Cool. Thanks, Jackie.
Seth: Sounds great. Thanks, Jackie.