TRANSCRIPCIÓN 🔗
1
00:00:00,400 --> 00:00:02,990
>> Peter Robinson: Two events
in the life of today's guest.
2
00:00:02,990 --> 00:00:07,962
He just turned 93, and
he just published his latest book,
3
00:00:07,962 --> 00:00:11,479
Thomas Sowell on Uncommon Knowledge now.
4
00:00:11,479 --> 00:00:21,237
[MUSIC]
5
00:00:21,237 --> 00:00:24,134
>> Peter Robinson: Welcome to uncommon
Knowledge, I'm Peter Robinson.
6
00:00:24,134 --> 00:00:28,897
After growing up in Harlem, Thomas Sowell
served in the United States Marine Corps,
7
00:00:28,897 --> 00:00:31,943
then received an undergraduate
degree from Harvard,
8
00:00:31,943 --> 00:00:36,658
a master's degree from Columbia, a
doctorate from the University of Chicago.
9
00:00:36,658 --> 00:00:41,294
After teaching at universities that
included Cornell, Brandeis, and
10
00:00:41,294 --> 00:00:46,266
UCLA, Dr. Sowell became a fellow
at the Hoover Institution in 1977.
11
00:00:46,266 --> 00:00:52,766
Thomas Sowell is the author of some 40
books, including his newest volume,
12
00:00:52,766 --> 00:00:58,336
Social Justice Fallacies and
this past spring, he turned 93.
13
00:00:58,336 --> 00:01:00,414
Tom, welcome back to Uncommon Knowledge.
14
00:01:00,414 --> 00:01:01,283
>> Thomas Sowell: Good being here.
15
00:01:01,283 --> 00:01:04,066
>> Peter Robinson: I can't help thinking,
reading your background,
16
00:01:04,066 --> 00:01:06,786
if only you'd been a little
bit more industrious,
17
00:01:06,786 --> 00:01:09,580
you might have been able to
make a name for yourself.
18
00:01:11,120 --> 00:01:17,647
Social justice Dr. Martin Luther King
in 1963, quote, I have a dream.
19
00:01:17,647 --> 00:01:20,841
>> [APPLAUSE].
20
00:01:20,841 --> 00:01:23,850
>> Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.: My poor
little children will one day live
21
00:01:23,850 --> 00:01:28,806
in a nation where they will not be
judged by the color of their skin,
22
00:01:28,806 --> 00:01:33,340
but by the content of their character,
I have a dream today.
23
00:01:34,800 --> 00:01:39,877
>> Peter Robinson: And you write, Dr.
King's message was equal opportunity for
24
00:01:39,877 --> 00:01:43,160
individuals, regardless of race.
25
00:01:43,160 --> 00:01:50,200
In the years that followed, the goal
changed to equal outcomes for groups,
26
00:01:50,200 --> 00:01:55,600
what now rose to dominance was
the social justice agenda.
27
00:01:57,020 --> 00:02:01,976
If the social justice, those backing
the social justice agenda could
28
00:02:01,976 --> 00:02:07,300
have everything they wanted,
what would the country look like?
29
00:02:07,300 --> 00:02:08,880
>> Thomas Sowell: We'd
be killing each other.
30
00:02:12,460 --> 00:02:16,000
>> Peter Robinson: All right,
can you give me intermediate steps?
31
00:02:17,110 --> 00:02:19,518
In other words,
what is the social justice agenda?
32
00:02:19,518 --> 00:02:21,350
What do they want?
33
00:02:21,350 --> 00:02:24,618
>> Thomas Sowell: They want
everybody to have equal outcomes or
34
00:02:24,618 --> 00:02:27,070
as close as they can get to it.
35
00:02:27,070 --> 00:02:33,023
Unfortunately, you don't
have the preconditions for
36
00:02:33,023 --> 00:02:36,558
that, even in the same family.
37
00:02:36,558 --> 00:02:41,710
One of the examples I use
in the book is among,
38
00:02:41,710 --> 00:02:47,134
among five child families,
the national Merit
39
00:02:47,134 --> 00:02:53,168
finalist is the firstborn
just over half the time.
40
00:02:53,168 --> 00:02:57,837
That is, more often than
the other four siblings combined,
41
00:02:57,837 --> 00:03:01,320
the fifth born is 6% of the time.
42
00:03:01,320 --> 00:03:05,616
And so it was even where you
have almost ideal conditions.
43
00:03:05,616 --> 00:03:09,753
They're born to the same parents,
raised under the same roof, and
44
00:03:09,753 --> 00:03:11,142
they are not the same.
45
00:03:11,142 --> 00:03:15,146
>> Peter Robinson: Because all kinds of
things matter, including birth order.
46
00:03:15,146 --> 00:03:16,896
>> Thomas Sowell: Absolutely, absolutely.
47
00:03:16,896 --> 00:03:19,959
>> Peter Robinson: All right,
let's you take on various fallacies here,
48
00:03:19,959 --> 00:03:21,864
let's take on a couple of them.
49
00:03:21,864 --> 00:03:26,064
The equal chances fallacy,
even in a society,
50
00:03:26,064 --> 00:03:30,456
I'm quoting you, social justice fallacies.
51
00:03:30,456 --> 00:03:34,647
Even in a society with equal opportunity,
people from different
52
00:03:34,647 --> 00:03:38,810
backgrounds do not necessarily
even want to do the same things.
53
00:03:38,810 --> 00:03:43,898
In American sports, blacks are very
overrepresented in professional
54
00:03:43,898 --> 00:03:50,270
basketball, whites in professional tennis,
and Hispanics in major league baseball.
55
00:03:51,450 --> 00:03:53,770
Why is that telling?
56
00:03:53,770 --> 00:03:56,163
>> Thomas Sowell: Because
the implicit assumption, and
57
00:03:56,163 --> 00:04:00,878
sometimes explicit assumption is that
in a world where everything was fair,
58
00:04:00,878 --> 00:04:03,137
where everyone was treated fairly.
59
00:04:03,137 --> 00:04:07,816
You would have things would be
representative of the population
60
00:04:07,816 --> 00:04:12,670
demographics as a whole, and
all these various activities.
61
00:04:12,670 --> 00:04:17,672
Imagine a black kid born in Harlem,
and he's born with
62
00:04:17,672 --> 00:04:23,890
a body identical that of Rudolf Nureyev,
the great ballet dancer.
63
00:04:25,390 --> 00:04:31,270
The odds are 1000 to one that he'll become
a ballet dancer, much less Rudolf Nureyev.
64
00:04:31,270 --> 00:04:35,281
I mean, he would be looked at
strangely by all his friends in
65
00:04:35,281 --> 00:04:38,472
the neighborhood if he
even wanted to do that.
66
00:04:38,472 --> 00:04:39,960
>> Peter Robinson: What you mean?
67
00:04:39,960 --> 00:04:41,496
>> Thomas Sowell: He wouldn't
even think about it?
68
00:04:41,496 --> 00:04:44,481
>> Peter Robinson: Right, so you mean
to say that when you tried out for
69
Load full transcript
00:04:44,481 --> 00:04:45,870
the Brooklyn Dodgers,
70
00:04:45,870 --> 00:04:49,758
you tried out for the pitching
position in the Brooklyn Dodgers and
71
00:04:49,758 --> 00:04:54,600
they didn't hire you,
you were not being discriminated against?
72
00:04:54,600 --> 00:04:56,816
>> Thomas Sowell: [LAUGH] Actually,
I was trying out off of phrase base.
73
00:04:56,816 --> 00:05:00,706
And the real reason I messed up was
that my position was center field.
74
00:05:00,706 --> 00:05:04,946
But in order to be a good center fielder,
I need hours and
75
00:05:04,946 --> 00:05:08,714
hours of practice, and
it was a very bad spring.
76
00:05:08,714 --> 00:05:12,473
I got very little practice and so
I figured, at least I won't go out and
77
00:05:12,473 --> 00:05:14,818
make an idiot of myself and
send it to feel.
78
00:05:14,818 --> 00:05:18,250
So I made an idiot of
myself at first base.
79
00:05:18,250 --> 00:05:20,971
>> Peter Robinson: Right,
chess pieces fallacy,
80
00:05:20,971 --> 00:05:25,066
the chess pieces fallacy,
explain that one.
81
00:05:25,066 --> 00:05:30,773
>> Thomas Sowell: Well, Adam Smith had a
very low opinion of abstract theorists who
82
00:05:30,773 --> 00:05:35,858
imagine that they can control
a whole society with the ease
83
00:05:35,858 --> 00:05:42,084
with which one puts chess pieces
where you want them on a chessboard.
84
00:05:42,084 --> 00:05:46,221
And so there's this notion of this
inert mass of people down there,
85
00:05:46,221 --> 00:05:50,796
and then the wonderfully brilliant people
at the top who ought to be telling
86
00:05:50,796 --> 00:05:51,996
them what to do.
87
00:05:51,996 --> 00:05:56,705
And there's no thought that, first of all,
those at the top don't even know
88
00:05:56,705 --> 00:06:01,842
the people's individual conditions,
who are very different from themselves.
89
00:06:01,842 --> 00:06:06,690
And when they try to help,
they can make things disastrous.
90
00:06:06,690 --> 00:06:10,042
>> Peter Robinson: You discuss a theory of
justice, this is under knowledge balance.
91
00:06:10,042 --> 00:06:11,650
>> Thomas Sowell: Yes.
>> Peter Robinson: A theory of justice,
92
00:06:11,650 --> 00:06:14,762
which is in certain circles,
certain circles.
93
00:06:14,762 --> 00:06:18,634
Every university in the country, the
philosophy department, political science,
94
00:06:18,634 --> 00:06:20,130
you'll get it in sociology.
95
00:06:20,130 --> 00:06:24,315
This is the big book on social
justice written by John Rawls,
96
00:06:24,315 --> 00:06:26,790
philosopher at Harvard.
97
00:06:26,790 --> 00:06:32,726
I'm quoting you Tom, Rawls refers to
things that society should arrange.
98
00:06:32,726 --> 00:06:35,718
You quote him arrange,
that's the word he uses.
99
00:06:35,718 --> 00:06:42,246
And then Tom Sowell says, interior
decorators arrange, governments compel.
100
00:06:42,246 --> 00:06:46,170
It is not a subtle distinction,
explain that.
101
00:06:47,250 --> 00:06:50,712
>> Thomas Sowell: Well, if you're going
to try to get some kind of result,
102
00:06:50,712 --> 00:06:55,898
you have to specify through what kinds of
mechanism you expect to get that result.
103
00:06:55,898 --> 00:06:59,727
And different mechanisms whether
it's the government, the market,
104
00:06:59,727 --> 00:07:01,346
the Red Cross, whatever.
105
00:07:01,346 --> 00:07:06,286
They have their own individual things that
they're good at and not so good at and
106
00:07:06,286 --> 00:07:10,416
so you can't get the social justice
result that you want unless you
107
00:07:10,416 --> 00:07:14,882
have the kind of institution that's
likely to produce that result.
108
00:07:14,882 --> 00:07:17,126
Politics is not that kind of institution.
109
00:07:17,126 --> 00:07:19,794
>> Peter Robinson: And yet
they all implicitly rely on government.
110
00:07:19,794 --> 00:07:21,628
>> Thomas Sowell: Yes.
>> Peter Robinson: Redistribution of
111
00:07:21,628 --> 00:07:24,957
wealth, adjusting, using legal regimes to
112
00:07:24,957 --> 00:07:29,818
adjust the proportions of various
groups that get certain jobs.
113
00:07:29,818 --> 00:07:33,747
They all rely on government and
what's distinctive about government
114
00:07:33,747 --> 00:07:36,954
is it's the one institution
that can send you to jail.
115
00:07:36,954 --> 00:07:37,714
>> Thomas Sowell: Yes.
116
00:07:37,714 --> 00:07:40,327
>> Peter Robinson: All right and
the point is that's dangerous,
117
00:07:40,327 --> 00:07:43,946
we shouldn't want more hands in
the power of the politicians.
118
00:07:43,946 --> 00:07:47,766
>> Thomas Sowell: Yeah, one of the real
problems is you have people making
119
00:07:47,766 --> 00:07:51,829
decisions for which they pay
no price when they're wrong,
120
00:07:51,829 --> 00:07:54,853
no matter how high
a price other people pay.
121
00:07:54,853 --> 00:07:59,545
And right now the homicide
rates are beyond anything
122
00:07:59,545 --> 00:08:04,242
that were around,
let's say, prior to 1960.
123
00:08:05,302 --> 00:08:10,043
And I mentioned 1960 in this case
because that's when the Supreme Court
124
00:08:10,043 --> 00:08:12,062
remade the criminal law.
125
00:08:12,062 --> 00:08:16,492
They discovered rights in the Constitution
that no one had noticed for
126
00:08:16,492 --> 00:08:20,782
over a century and
they were impervious to evidence.
127
00:08:20,782 --> 00:08:24,710
>> Peter Robinson: So contrast your
neighborhood in Harlem when you were
128
00:08:24,710 --> 00:08:26,193
an eight and nine and
129
00:08:26,193 --> 00:08:31,668
ten year old boy with what we see
in neighborhoods in Chicago today.
130
00:08:31,668 --> 00:08:32,902
>> Thomas Sowell: My gosh.
131
00:08:32,902 --> 00:08:36,054
People are astonished when I
tell them I grew up in Harlem.
132
00:08:36,054 --> 00:08:40,726
I can't remember ever hearing a gunshot
and then I've checked with my relatives
133
00:08:40,726 --> 00:08:45,502
who grew up in similar neighborhoods in
Washington and down in North Carolina.
134
00:08:45,502 -->
00:08:48,162
They never heard us gunshot
when they were growing up.
135
00:08:50,262 --> 00:08:55,232
I remember going back to Harlem some years
ago to do some research at high school and
136
00:08:55,232 --> 00:08:59,832
I looked out the window and there's
this park there near the high school.
137
00:08:59,832 --> 00:09:05,478
And I mentioned in passing that when I
lived in Harlem as a kid I would take
138
00:09:05,478 --> 00:09:11,612
my dog for a walk in that park and looks
of horror came over the students faces.
139
00:09:12,672 --> 00:09:17,331
People have no idea how much has
retrogressed over the years in
140
00:09:17,331 --> 00:09:22,259
the black community and how much
of what progress has been made has
141
00:09:22,259 --> 00:09:26,572
not been made by politicians or
by charismatic leaders.
142
00:09:29,992 --> 00:09:36,598
One of the things that drives me crazy
are people who cite trends over time
143
00:09:36,598 --> 00:09:42,680
without deciding where they're
going to start the time period.
144
00:09:42,680 --> 00:09:48,150
For example, as I said, all sorts of
wonderful things happened in the 1960s and
145
00:09:48,150 --> 00:09:52,972
beyond and especially for
the minorities and the poor and so forth.
146
00:09:52,972 --> 00:09:54,584
So what I did, I said no.
147
00:09:54,584 --> 00:09:58,241
If you still have the data in 1960,
we don't know
148
00:09:58,241 --> 00:10:03,132
how much was a result of that and
how much was a result of other things.
149
00:10:03,132 --> 00:10:04,900
That also applies in other things.
150
00:10:04,900 --> 00:10:11,876
For one simple one, many people say
Rolf native wrote this book in 1965.
151
00:10:11,876 --> 00:10:17,031
And as about the automobile safety and
so on, as a result, there were laws
152
00:10:17,031 --> 00:10:22,926
by the government and the death rates went
down after that which is true in itself.
153
00:10:22,926 --> 00:10:28,344
But the death rate went down at a far
higher rate prior to his writing the book
154
00:10:28,344 --> 00:10:34,292
and this was the continuation of a trend
that went back another 20 or 30 years.
155
00:10:34,292 --> 00:10:37,609
>> Peter Robinson: Because the market, car
manufacturers when it came right down to
156
00:10:37,609 --> 00:10:40,470
it had very little interest
in getting people killed.
157
00:10:40,470 --> 00:10:43,312
>> Thomas Sowell: Yes, if you kill off
your customers your chances are you won't
158
00:10:43,312 --> 00:10:43,962
sell as many.
159
00:10:46,082 --> 00:10:47,169
>> Peter Robinson: The big fallacy,
160
00:10:47,169 --> 00:10:52,202
at least I take this as in many ways
the heart of the book, racial fallacies.
161
00:10:52,202 --> 00:10:56,414
Now, in this section,
in this chapter on racial fallacies,
162
00:10:56,414 --> 00:11:01,258
you begin almost all of this book
is addressed to the current moment.
163
00:11:01,258 --> 00:11:06,823
But in racial fallacies,
you start by going back about 100
164
00:11:06,823 --> 00:11:12,389
years to
lay out the progressive
position in the 1910s and
165
00:11:12,389 --> 00:11:16,040
twenties and for some years afterward.
166
00:11:16,040 --> 00:11:20,563
I'm quoting you in addressing the massive
increase in immigration from eastern and
167
00:11:20,563 --> 00:11:21,646
southern Europe.
168
00:11:21,646 --> 00:11:24,933
This begins this massive increase in
immigration begins toward the end of
169
00:11:24,933 --> 00:11:27,662
the 19th century and
carries on through the 1920s.
170
00:11:27,662 --> 00:11:31,334
In addressing the massive
increase in immigration,
171
00:11:31,334 --> 00:11:36,965
progressives claimed that these new
immigrants were inherently genetically and
172
00:11:36,965 --> 00:11:40,082
therefore permanently inferior.
173
00:11:40,082 --> 00:11:43,362
So your argument is that a century or
so ago,
174
00:11:43,362 --> 00:11:47,621
progressives believed roughly
the same about polish and
175
00:11:47,621 --> 00:11:53,788
Italian immigrants that whites in
the south had long believed about blacks.
176
00:11:53,788 --> 00:11:54,722
>> Thomas Sowell: Yes.
177
00:11:54,722 --> 00:11:56,746
>> Peter Robinson: All right,
social justice fallacies,
178
00:11:56,746 --> 00:12:01,642
I'm going to read a quotation, then I'd
like you to take us through this material.
179
00:12:01,642 --> 00:12:03,743
With the passing years, more and
180
00:12:03,743 --> 00:12:08,992
more evidence undermined the conclusion
of the genetic determinists.
181
00:12:08,992 --> 00:12:14,315
Jews, who had scored low on the 1917
Army mental test, began to score above
182
00:12:14,315 --> 00:12:20,752
the national average on various tests as
they became a more English-speaking group.
183
00:12:20,752 --> 00:12:26,756
A study showed that black orphans raised
by white families had significantly
184
00:12:26,756 --> 00:12:31,572
higher average IQs than other
black children, close quote.
185
00:12:32,732 --> 00:12:37,182
So in the century since this,
you call them genetic determinants,
186
00:12:37,182 --> 00:12:40,892
which is one way of putting it,
they were racist.
187
00:12:40,892 --> 00:12:43,244
They believed that some races
were permanently inferior.
188
00:12:43,244 --> 00:12:45,860
>> Thomas Sowell: Yes,
and should be eliminated.
189
00:12:45,860 --> 00:12:48,452
>> Peter Robinson: And
we've learned that's total nonsense.
190
00:12:48,452 --> 00:12:52,756
But even more than that, we've learned
that IQ is malleable, is that correct?
191
00:12:52,756 --> 00:12:54,236
>> Thomas Sowell: I'm not sure
what you mean by malleable.
192
00:12:54,236 --> 00:12:58,406
>> Peter Robinson: Well,
that is to say that this ranking of.
193
00:12:58,406 --> 00:13:00,053
>> Thomas Sowell: The ranking changed.
194
00:13:00,053 --> 00:13:04,070
>> Peter Robinson: Jews are stupid in 1917
because they score badly on tests, but
195
00:13:04,070 --> 00:13:06,304
these tests are written in English.
196
00:13:06,304 --> 00:13:06,854
Okay.
>> Thomas Sowell: And
197
00:13:06,854 --> 00:13:10,046
people who spoke English
did better on those tests.
198
00:13:10,046 --> 00:13:13,477
>> Peter Robinson: Or that blacks
have a certain fixed IQ ranking and
199
00:13:13,477 --> 00:13:17,370
then you have black orphans
raised by white families.
200
00:13:17,370 --> 00:13:19,482
In other words, a different cultural.
201
00:13:19,482 --> 00:13:22,896
>> Thomas Sowell: Yeah, but even before
that, that study wasn't done until 1976.
202
00:13:22,896 --> 00:13:23,579
>> Peter Robinson: That's a lot.
>> Thomas Sowell: But
203
00:13:23,579 --> 00:13:26,789
even as of the time of world war one,
204
00:13:26,789 --> 00:13:33,242
the data show that black soldiers
scored below white soldiers.
205
00:13:33,242 --> 00:13:36,042
And this is one of the reasons it's so.
206
00:13:36,042 --> 00:13:41,682
You need people with contrary opinions
to be able to be free to attack things.
207
00:13:41,682 --> 00:13:45,557
The people who believe that this was
genetically determined, they said,
208
00:13:45,557 --> 00:13:46,282
that's it.
209
00:13:46,282 --> 00:13:48,306
That's the answer and they moved on.
210
00:13:48,306 --> 00:13:51,082
Some other people said,
let's look at it more closely.
211
00:13:51,082 --> 00:13:55,631
And they discovered that
black soldiers from New York,
212
00:13:55,631 --> 00:14:00,857
Pennsylvania, Ohio, and one or
two other states scored higher
213
00:14:00,857 --> 00:14:06,170
than white soldiers from Mississippi,
Alabama, etc, etc.
214
00:14:06,170 --> 00:14:08,045
And as I mentioned in the book,
215
00:14:08,045 --> 00:14:11,662
people's genes do not change
when they cross a state line.
216
00:14:14,082 --> 00:14:17,325
The problem is when you have
people who are crusading for
217
00:14:17,325 --> 00:14:20,637
some idea, whatever the idea is,
and they find some data
218
00:14:20,637 --> 00:14:25,622
that fits what they believe that's the end
of the story as far as they're concerned.
219
00:14:25,622 --> 00:14:28,684
Which is fine if there
are other people with contrary
220
00:14:28,684 --> 00:14:32,523
ideas who will look closer for
something that goes the other way.
221
00:14:32,523 --> 00:14:34,576
>> Peter Robinson: And
then get listened to.
222
00:14:34,576 --> 00:14:35,672
>> Thomas Sowell: Yes.
223
00:14:35,672 --> 00:14:39,337
>> Peter Robinson: By the way,
you describe in the book the Flynn effect
224
00:14:39,337 --> 00:14:42,800
discovered by your friend
the late James Flynn.
225
00:14:42,800 --> 00:14:43,688
Can you describe that?
226
00:14:43,688 --> 00:14:45,192
That's fascinating.
227
00:14:45,192 --> 00:14:49,404
>> Thomas Sowell: Well, the idea of the
genetic determinist is that you had to rid
228
00:14:49,404 --> 00:14:54,650
the country of these inferior races
because otherwise the national IQ would go
229
00:14:54,650 --> 00:15:00,232
down over time because the poorer people
had more children than the richer people.
230
00:15:01,572 --> 00:15:03,592
And so that went on.
231
00:15:05,012 --> 00:15:08,678
Here again,
the IQ data that the genetic determinists
232
00:15:08,678 --> 00:15:12,932
were relying on looked like
it supported what they said.
233
00:15:12,932 --> 00:15:16,829
But Jem Flynn decided that,
well first of all,
234
00:15:16,829 --> 00:15:21,282
you have to understand how
an IQ score is arrived at.
235
00:15:21,282 --> 00:15:26,277
Whatever number of questions
answered correctly is
236
00:15:26,277 --> 00:15:32,322
the average at a given time
is given the number 100.
237
00:15:32,322 --> 00:15:36,784
Because when you do these tests
especially with children,
238
00:15:36,784 --> 00:15:41,334
if a 6 year old child scores
the same as a 12 year old child,
239
00:15:41,334 --> 00:15:46,599
that means the 60 year old child is
either much brighter than usual or
240
00:15:46,599 --> 00:15:50,193
the 12 year old child is
a lot less than usual.
241
00:15:50,193 --> 00:15:54,592
And so you compare all the 6 year old
children and whatever the 6 year old
242
00:15:54,592 --> 00:15:59,226
children how many questions they
answer correctly, that becomes 100.
243
00:15:59,226 --> 00:16:01,375
And then similarly for all the other ages.
244
00:16:01,375 --> 00:16:02,675
>> Peter Robinson: Right.
>> Thomas Sowell: So you can do that.
245
00:16:02,675 --> 00:16:07,681
And adulthood at some point you simply
say adult and non-adult, all right?
246
00:16:07,681 --> 00:16:10,800
Now that sounds very innocent in itself,
but
247
00:16:10,800 --> 00:16:16,464
what happens when people start answering
more questions correctly than before,
248
00:16:16,464 --> 00:16:19,680
the next generation
answers more questions.
249
00:16:19,680 --> 00:16:24,709
Now the number of questions answered
by the second generation becomes 100.
250
00:16:24,709 --> 00:16:30,647
And so over time, as more and
more people, black, white, and whatever,
251
00:16:30,647 --> 00:16:36,510
are answering more and more questions
correctly, the tests are renorm.
252
00:16:36,510 --> 00:16:41,112
So, having an IQ of 100
in 1925 is not the same
253
00:16:41,112 --> 00:16:46,042
thing as having an IQ of 100 in 1935 or
1950.
254
00:16:46,042 --> 00:16:47,757
>> Peter Robinson: And
this is exactly what was going on.
255
00:16:47,757 --> 00:16:49,481
>> Thomas Sowell: Yeah.
>> Peter Robinson: People of all different
256
00:16:49,481 --> 00:16:52,310
kinds were getting smarter,
to put it crudely.
257
00:16:52,310 --> 00:16:57,741
>> Thomas Sowell: But once Jim Flynn
decided to go back to the raw data,
258
00:16:57,741 --> 00:17:03,182
not just take the IQs,
how many questions was this?
259
00:17:03,182 --> 00:17:07,460
And he discovers that
the number of questions being
260
00:17:07,460 --> 00:17:12,037
answered correctly was
increasing by large amounts,
261
00:17:12,037 --> 00:17:17,823
roughly one statistical deviation
from one generation to the next.
262
00:17:17,823 --> 00:17:18,538
>> Peter Robinson: Which is big.
263
00:17:18,538 --> 00:17:24,055
>> Thomas Sowell: Yes, and so
the number of questions that the blacks
264
00:17:24,055 --> 00:17:28,803
were answering, say around 2000, and
265
00:17:28,803 --> 00:17:36,136
having an IQ of 85 would have
been an IQ of 104 back in 1947.
266
00:17:36,136 --> 00:17:41,675
And so all this information was
being ignored because people
267
00:17:41,675 --> 00:17:48,960
took the IQ test as if that was a fixed
number of questions I answered correctly.
268
00:17:48,960 --> 00:17:53,071
>> Peter Robinson: And so you take
the lid off that one the Flynn effect.
269
00:17:53,071 --> 00:17:55,633
>> Thomas Sowell: Shows that
the opposite was happening,
270
00:17:55,633 --> 00:17:59,485
that instead of the national IQ
going down, it was going up.
271
00:17:59,485 --> 00:18:03,731
>> Peter Robinson: It was going up and so
we have this fascinating discovery that
272
00:18:03,731 --> 00:18:09,142
somehow or other, the conditions of
modern life that requires more abstract
273
00:18:09,142 --> 00:18:12,632
thinking somehow it's bringing in-
>> Thomas Sowell: The whole group
274
00:18:12,632 --> 00:18:13,255
is rising.
275
00:18:13,255 --> 00:18:14,490
>> Peter Robinson: The whole
group is rising.
276
00:18:14,490 --> 00:18:18,950
All right, from the progressive position
a century ago to the progressive
277
00:18:18,950 --> 00:18:22,845
position today, racial assertions
have ranged from the genetic
278
00:18:22,845 --> 00:18:25,128
determinism that we just discussed.
279
00:18:25,128 --> 00:18:31,018
Which proclaimed that race is everything
as an explanation of group differences,
280
00:18:31,018 --> 00:18:37,085
to the opposite view, that racism is the
primary explanation of group differences.
281
00:18:37,085 --> 00:18:38,425
>> Thomas Sowell: Yes.
282
00:18:38,425 --> 00:18:39,995
>> Peter Robinson: How did this happen?
283
00:18:39,995 --> 00:18:44,368
>> Thomas Sowell: It happened because
a lot of people arrived at the same
284
00:18:44,368 --> 00:18:48,157
conclusion and
they had high IQs and PhDs, and
285
00:18:48,157 --> 00:18:53,522
that was the end of the story as
far as many people were concerned.
286
00:18:53,522 --> 00:18:54,621
>> Peter Robinson: All right.
287
00:18:54,621 --> 00:18:56,413
>> Thomas Sowell: I mean, a high IQ and
288
00:18:56,413 --> 00:19:00,956
low information is a very
dangerous combination.
289
00:19:00,956 --> 00:19:03,388
>> Peter Robinson: I have to,
sorry, but you once told me,
290
00:19:03,388 --> 00:19:07,478
I'm talking to a Harvard man of
course I'm very conscious of this.
291
00:19:07,478 --> 00:19:09,215
And you once told me, Peter,
292
00:19:09,215 --> 00:19:13,872
the main advantage of earning a Harvard
degree is that you never again in all your
293
00:19:13,872 --> 00:19:17,579
life have to be intimidated by
anyone who has a Harvard degree.
294
00:19:17,579 --> 00:19:19,789
>> Thomas Sowell: [LAUGH]
>> Peter Robinson: Listen, Tom, for
295
00:19:19,789 --> 00:19:25,543
the most, as I read this book, for
the most part, it's objective.
296
00:19:25,543 -->
00:19:26,825
It's objective throughout.
297
00:19:26,825 --> 00:19:27,490
It's calm.
298
00:19:27,490 --> 00:19:29,021
It's analytical.
299
00:19:29,021 --> 00:19:33,769
But when you take on this modern,
progressive position that racism
300
00:19:33,769 --> 00:19:38,612
accounts for anything,
there are passages in which you're angry.
301
00:19:38,612 --> 00:19:40,057
I felt that there are passages.
302
00:19:40,057 --> 00:19:40,953
>> Thomas Sowell: Yeah.
>> Peter Robinson: In which there's
303
00:19:40,953 --> 00:19:42,437
emotion that is very close to this.
304
00:19:42,437 --> 00:19:43,722
So let me just read a little bit.
305
00:19:43,722 --> 00:19:44,294
>> Thomas Sowell: Okay.
306
00:19:44,294 --> 00:19:48,161
>> Peter Robinson: Median black family
income has been lower than median white
307
00:19:48,161 --> 00:19:50,335
family income for generations.
308
00:19:50,335 --> 00:19:56,359
But the median per capita income of
Asian groups is more than 15,000 a year,
309
00:19:56,359 --> 00:20:00,827
higher than the media per capita
income of white Americans.
310
00:20:00,827 --> 00:20:04,294
Is this the white supremacy we're so
often warned about for
311
00:20:04,294 --> 00:20:06,246
more than a quarter of a century?
312
00:20:06,246 --> 00:20:11,777
In no year has the annual poverty rate
of black married couple families,
313
00:20:11,777 --> 00:20:15,505
married couple families
been as high as 10%.
314
00:20:15,505 --> 00:20:21,935
And in no year has the poverty rate of
Americans as a whole been as low as 10%.
315
00:20:21,935 --> 00:20:26,766
If black poverty is caused
by systemic racism,
316
00:20:26,766 --> 00:20:32,580
do racists make an exception for
blacks who are married?
317
00:20:32,580 --> 00:20:34,846
I guess you're allowed to be angry.
318
00:20:34,846 --> 00:20:39,980
>> Thomas Sowell: Yes, my lord yes.
319
00:20:39,980 --> 00:20:46,075
>> Peter Robinson: So do you have
the feeling, when you're addressing
320
00:20:46,075 --> 00:20:52,041
this notion that racism accounts for
everything?
321
00:20:52,041 --> 00:20:57,202
Do you have the feeling that the arguments
are subtle, it's persuasive.
322
00:20:57,202 --> 00:21:00,054
You can forgive someone for
buying that argument.
323
00:21:00,054 --> 00:21:04,352
Or do you have the feeling that
it's willful, that the case is so
324
00:21:04,352 --> 00:21:08,346
clearly mistaken,
that there's a willfulness about it?
325
00:21:08,346 --> 00:21:13,311
>> Thomas Sowell: No, I think that
people don't look for certain evidence,
326
00:21:13,311 --> 00:21:16,304
and therefore they don't find it.
327
00:21:16,304 --> 00:21:23,255
And so on the basis of what they know at
a given time, this may be very plausible.
328
00:21:23,255 --> 00:21:27,920
The problem is that what you really
need are other people with different
329
00:21:27,920 --> 00:21:32,274
orientation who are skeptical and
who will then look for things and
330
00:21:32,274 --> 00:21:35,398
find things that are very
different from that.
331
00:21:35,398 --> 00:21:40,754
One of the things that I found
interesting was the fact
332
00:21:40,754 --> 00:21:45,991
that there are various
counties in the United States
333
00:21:45,991 --> 00:21:51,362
which are among the poorest
counties in the country.
334
00:21:51,362 --> 00:21:56,342
And six of those counties
have a population that ranges
335
00:21:56,342 --> 00:21:59,814
from 90% white to 100% white.
336
00:21:59,814 --> 00:22:00,831
>> Peter Robinson: Appalachian counties.
337
00:22:00,831 --> 00:22:01,751
>> Thomas Sowell: Yeah.
>> Peter Robinson: Kentucky.
338
00:22:01,751 --> 00:22:02,535
>> Thomas Sowell: Yeah.
>> Peter Robinson: Kentucky,
339
00:22:02,535 --> 00:22:03,425
and Ohio, as I recall.
340
00:22:03,425 --> 00:22:08,398
>> Thomas Sowell: Yeah, but
mainly it's the hillbilly communities.
341
00:22:08,398 --> 00:22:09,017
>> Peter Robinson: Right.
342
00:22:09,017 --> 00:22:09,634
>> Thomas Sowell: And of course,
343
00:22:09,634 --> 00:22:12,155
there was that great book that
was written in hillbilly elegy.
344
00:22:12,155 --> 00:22:16,056
It was on the best seller list for
more than a year, consecutively.
345
00:22:16,056 --> 00:22:17,634
>> Peter Robinson: JD White
is now Senator Vance.
346
00:22:17,634 --> 00:22:23,878
>> Thomas Sowell: Yes and these
are people who have faced zero racism.
347
00:22:23,878 --> 00:22:24,738
>> Peter Robinson: They are white.
348
00:22:24,738 --> 00:22:27,355
>> Thomas Sowell: And
they are white and zero racism.
349
00:22:27,355 --> 00:22:32,191
And also, back in the thirties,
when they did IQ studies, their IQs were
350
00:22:32,191 --> 00:22:36,958
not only at the same level as those
of blacks, they had the same pattern.
351
00:22:36,958 --> 00:22:43,044
Namely, that the young people,
whether they were black or hillbilly,
352
00:22:43,044 --> 00:22:48,248
would have an IQ very close to
the national average at age six.
353
00:22:48,248 --> 00:22:53,366
But by the time they were teenagers it
just kept going down and down cause it's
354
00:22:53,366 --> 00:22:58,896
relative to the other people of that age
group and they simply were falling behind.
355
00:22:58,896 --> 00:23:01,430
So it was clearly not biological.
356
00:23:01,430 --> 00:23:07,256
It was social but
despite that these hillbilly counties had
357
00:23:07,256 --> 00:23:13,199
incomes that were not only lower
than the national average,
358
00:23:13,199 --> 00:23:18,326
they were lower than the average
of black incomes for
359
00:23:18,326 --> 00:23:21,027
a period of half a century.
360
00:23:21,027 --> 00:23:25,493
It may have been longer than that because
I only went through half a century but
361
00:23:25,493 --> 00:23:29,563
in every study that was done over
that half century they scored lower.
362
00:23:29,563 --> 00:23:33,344
Their family incomes were lower
than the family incomes of blacks.
363
00:23:33,344 --> 00:23:38,166
So obviously there must be other things
that cause people to be poor other than
364
00:23:38,166 --> 00:23:38,768
racism.
365
00:23:38,768 --> 00:23:43,198
>> Peter Robinson: All right people in
low income American hillbillies counties
366
00:23:43,198 --> 00:23:47,812
already face zero racism because
they are virtually all white.
367
00:23:47,812 --> 00:23:48,527
>> Thomas Sowell: Yeah.
368
00:23:48,527 --> 00:23:51,881
>> Peter Robinson: They have lower incomes
than blacks just as you were saying.
369
00:23:51,881 --> 00:23:57,823
In other words some behavior
patterns seem to pay off.
370
00:23:57,823 --> 00:24:01,453
Now this book is dedicated to fallacies,
371
00:24:01,453 --> 00:24:06,229
to showing errors in premises and
errors in analysis.
372
00:24:06,229 --> 00:24:09,983
It's not dedicated to
an alternative explanation.
373
00:24:09,983 --> 00:24:14,939
Nevertheless, you've got this argument
lurking in here that it's the way people
374
00:24:14,939 --> 00:24:17,365
live, it's the way culture patterns.
375
00:24:17,365 --> 00:24:21,009
So what are the patterns that pay off?
376
00:24:21,009 --> 00:24:25,968
>> Thomas Sowell: Well, my heaven,
that's a much larger book than those.
377
00:24:25,968 --> 00:24:27,920
>> Peter Robinson: Well,
you've got time on your hand.
378
00:24:27,920 --> 00:24:32,670
>> Thomas Sowell: [LAUGH],
In terms of fallacy for public policy,
379
00:24:32,670 --> 00:24:36,946
what does not pay off
is having charismatic
380
00:24:36,946 --> 00:24:41,958
leaders depending upon
government to do things.
381
00:24:41,958 --> 00:24:47,286
Because if you look what has
happened to blacks before and
382
00:24:47,286 --> 00:24:53,289
after, there was a massive
government effort on their behalf.
383
00:24:53,289 --> 00:24:57,411
The poverty rate among blacks,
if you start in 1940 instead of 1960,
384
00:24:57,411 --> 00:25:01,470
cuz 1960 is the magic number for
people who are saying, the government,
385
00:25:01,470 --> 00:25:05,240
he did all these wonderful things,
and blacks advanced because of it.
386
00:25:05,240 --> 00:25:11,488
In 1940, the black poverty rate was 87%.
387
00:25:11,488 --> 00:25:15,608
By 1960, it was down to 47%.
388
00:25:15,608 --> 00:25:16,706
>> Peter Robinson: That's dramatic.
389
00:25:16,706 --> 00:25:24,008
>> Thomas Sowell: But
from 1960 to 1970, it went down to 30%.
390
00:25:24,008 --> 00:25:31,975
And in 1970, affirmative action was
now in place, it went down to 29%.
391
00:25:31,975 --> 00:25:35,750
So in the 20 years prior to 1960s,
392
00:25:35,750 --> 00:25:40,636
the black poverty rate went
down by 40 points, and
393
00:25:40,636 --> 00:25:46,542
in the 20 years after 1960,
it went down by 18 points.
394
00:25:46,542 --> 00:25:48,679
But again,
you have the same thing you had with,
395
00:25:48,679 --> 00:25:50,513
what was the Rolf Nader effect, you see.
396
00:25:50,513 --> 00:25:52,420
>> Peter Robinson: Starting in 1960,
you missed this.
397
00:25:52,420 --> 00:25:53,611
>> Thomas Sowell: You missed all of that.
398
00:25:53,611 --> 00:25:58,682
>> Peter Robinson:
So you've got in this
book, this is a point you make again and
399
00:25:58,682 --> 00:26:04,660
again in the section on racial fallacies
that I started thinking of it.
400
00:26:04,660 --> 00:26:08,091
I don't think you use these terms, but
this is not an original thought with me.
401
00:26:08,091 --> 00:26:13,343
I started thinking of it as
a hidden century of black progress.
402
00:26:13,343 --> 00:26:14,246
>> Thomas Sowell: Yes.
403
00:26:14,246 --> 00:26:19,930
>> Peter Robinson: From emancipation with
the end of the civil war through to 1965,
404
00:26:19,930 --> 00:26:24,242
let's say the Civil Rights act of 1964,
65,
405
00:26:24,242 --> 00:26:27,674
through the early through the mid 60s.
406
00:26:27,674 --> 00:26:32,487
You've got a century, and
you argue black educational
407
00:26:32,487 --> 00:26:37,824
attainment rises,
black poverty rate drops dramatically.
408
00:26:37,824 --> 00:26:38,597
>> Thomas Sowell: Yeah.
409
00:26:38,597 --> 00:26:41,220
>> Peter Robinson: And these are people
who started with no property,
410
00:26:41,220 --> 00:26:42,814
overwhelmingly illiterate.
411
00:26:42,814 --> 00:26:48,777
This is from the moment,
sort of year zero in 1865 for
412
00:26:48,777 --> 00:26:53,010
African-Americans, and they climb.
413
00:26:53,010 --> 00:26:57,496
And the other point that you make
at a number of places is that
414
00:26:57,496 --> 00:27:00,919
the black family is overwhelmingly intact.
415
00:27:00,919 --> 00:27:02,744
Right up to 1960, most black people.
416
00:27:02,744 --> 00:27:03,505
Go ahead, explain.
417
00:27:03,505 --> 00:27:07,066
>> Thomas Sowell: Yeah,
not only do people take credit for
418
00:27:07,066 --> 00:27:12,515
things that were not there doing,
they overlook the negative
419
00:27:12,515 --> 00:27:17,978
things that came in after
the 1960s as a result of policy.
420
00:27:17,978 --> 00:27:22,618
In 1940, 17% of black children
421
00:27:22,618 --> 00:27:26,985
were raised in single parent homes.
422
00:27:26,985 --> 00:27:28,174
>> Peter Robinson: 17%.
423
00:27:28,174 --> 00:27:32,910
>> Thomas Sowell: 17, I forget
the exact date in the 20th century,
424
00:27:32,910 --> 00:27:37,120
but after these wonderful
reforms were put in,
425
00:27:37,120 --> 00:27:44,826
that quadrupled to 68% of black children
were being raised in single parent homes.
426
00:27:44,826 --> 00:27:49,071
Now, there's a whole literature on all
the bad things that happen to kids who
427
00:27:49,071 --> 00:27:53,861
are raised by single parents, whether they
are black or white, American or British.
428
00:27:53,861 --> 00:27:55,639
The study show the same things.
429
00:27:55,639 --> 00:28:03,492
One study said that flawlessness has a
bigger effect than even race and poverty.
430
00:28:03,492 --> 00:28:07,673
And certainly,
I think back in my own life,
431
00:28:07,673 --> 00:28:12,871
I realized how fortunate I was,
because even though my
432
00:28:12,871 --> 00:28:18,521
biological father died before
I was born and I was adopted,
433
00:28:18,521 --> 00:28:25,991
I was adopted into a family where I was
the only child in a family of four adults.
434
00:28:25,991 --> 00:28:29,611
And these are not people who were out
having an active social life someplace,
435
00:28:29,611 --> 00:28:31,069
the life was there in the home.
436
00:28:31,069 --> 00:28:32,022
>> Peter Robinson: They
gave you their time.
437
00:28:32,022 --> 00:28:35,156
>> Thomas Sowell: Yes, yes, and I remember
years later when I became a parent and
438
00:28:35,156 --> 00:28:39,059
like other new parents, I wanted to know,
when is the kid supposed to do this,
439
00:28:39,059 --> 00:28:40,676
when he's supposed to do that?
440
00:28:40,676 --> 00:28:46,485
And I said,
how old was I when I started to walk?
441
00:28:46,485 --> 00:28:50,686
And this lone surviving member of
the family that raised me said, tommy,
442
00:28:50,686 --> 00:28:52,664
nobody knows when you could walk.
443
00:28:52,664 --> 00:28:54,951
Somebody was always carrying you.
444
00:28:54,951 --> 00:28:58,786
>> Peter Robinson: [LAUGH], so
you had four adults on you.
445
00:28:58,786 --> 00:29:03,289
>> Thomas Sowell: Yes, yes,
yes, and that's what, and
446
00:29:03,289 --> 00:29:08,191
part of the rise of
blacks before was because
447
00:29:08,191 --> 00:29:12,177
of things that were done by blacks.
448
00:29:12,177 --> 00:29:18,525
Example, I think of a lot was a kid who
grew up in Harlem at the same time I did.
449
00:29:18,525 --> 00:29:22,904
We were in the same school,
lived two blocks from me, and
450
00:29:22,904 --> 00:29:28,013
we met many years later by accident
on the street in San Francisco,
451
00:29:28,013 --> 00:29:30,677
and we talked about the old times.
452
00:29:30,677 --> 00:29:35,677
And one of the things he mentioned to me,
because he had gone on, he was making more
453
00:29:35,677 --> 00:29:40,168
money than I was, and he would become
wealthy, and he lived overseas with
454
00:29:40,168 --> 00:29:45,046
servants, and he came back and moved out
to the wine country and all that stuff.
455
00:29:45,046 --> 00:29:47,300
But one of the things that struck me,
456
00:29:47,300 --> 00:29:52,247
he said that he could remember times when
he was growing up, when his father would
457
00:29:52,247 --> 00:29:57,149
sit at the dinner table watching the
children eat and not eat anything himself.
458
00:29:57,149 --> 00:30:00,215
Now it's not, that's what.
459
00:30:00,215 --> 00:30:01,729
>> Peter Robinson: And
now the father isn't even there.
460
00:30:01,729 --> 00:30:04,019
>> Thomas Sowell: Yes,
that's right, that's right.
461
00:30:04,019 --> 00:30:08,936
So those kinds of things
are what do it right.
462
00:30:08,936 --> 00:30:10,983
>> Peter Robinson: Social
justice fallacies,
463
00:30:10,983 --> 00:30:15,247
the Civil Rights Act of 1964
was a major factor in ending
464
00:30:15,247 --> 00:30:20,036
the denial of basic constitutional
rights to blacks in the South.
465
00:30:20,036 --> 00:30:24,465
But there is no
point trying to
make that the main source of
466
00:30:24,465 --> 00:30:26,878
the black rise out of poverty.
467
00:30:26,878 --> 00:30:31,919
Nor can the left act as if the Civil
Rights Act of 1964 was solely their work.
468
00:30:31,919 --> 00:30:38,868
A higher percentage of Republicans than
Democrats voted for the act, close quote.
469
00:30:38,868 --> 00:30:43,256
So this is,
you're saying something here which is-
470
00:30:43,256 --> 00:30:44,309
>> [CROSSTALK].
471
00:30:44,309 --> 00:30:47,039
>> Peter Robinson: It is,
it's shocking, it's heretical.
472
00:30:47,039 --> 00:30:51,435
You're saying, well,
you're saying the Civil Rights Act ensured
473
00:30:51,435 --> 00:30:56,232
equality before the law that was overdue,
it was necessary, it was just.
474
00:30:56,232 --> 00:30:58,381
That's an accomplishment
in American history.
475
00:30:58,381 --> 00:30:59,146
>> Thomas Sowell: Yeah.
476
00:30:59,146 --> 00:31:03,936
>> Peter Robinson: But at about the same
time, we get the creation of a vast
477
00:31:03,936 --> 00:31:08,847
expansion of the welfare state and
it does people harm.
478
00:31:08,847 --> 00:31:09,714
>> Thomas Sowell: Yes.
479
00:31:09,714 --> 00:31:13,469
>> Peter Robinson: It harms
the African-American family.
480
00:31:13,469 --> 00:31:17,197
It leads to fatherless,
have I got your argument right?
481
00:31:17,197 --> 00:31:18,099
>> Thomas Sowell: Yeah.
482
00:31:18,099 --> 00:31:19,434
>> Peter Robinson: And
you want to stand by that?
483
00:31:19,434 --> 00:31:23,339
>> Thomas Sowell: And the other thing,
too, the Civil Rights Act
484
00:31:23,339 --> 00:31:28,029
was not what got blacks into
professional occupations.
485
00:31:28,029 --> 00:31:30,889
In the decade prior to 1964,
486
00:31:30,889 --> 00:31:36,112
the number of blacks in
professional occupations doubled.
487
00:31:36,112 --> 00:31:42,613
So this is not the result of
the Civil Rights Act of 1964.
488
00:31:42,613 --> 00:31:49,578
>> Peter Robinson: All right, Tom,
a few closing questions here.
489
00:31:49,578 --> 00:31:52,449
First of all, may I read to you?
490
00:31:52,449 --> 00:31:56,797
This is a note to readers from
the New York Times in 2020.
491
00:31:56,797 --> 00:32:01,407
The nationwide protests over racism and
police violence have prompted
492
00:32:01,407 --> 00:32:07,110
a renewed focus on a longstanding debate
whether to capitalize the term Black.
493
00:32:07,110 --> 00:32:11,350
We here at the New York Times have
talked to more than 100 staff members.
494
00:32:11,350 --> 00:32:15,742
The feedback has been thoughtful and
nuanced, thoughtful and nuanced, mind you.
495
00:32:15,742 --> 00:32:20,719
We've decided to start using uppercase
black to describe people and
496
00:32:20,719 --> 00:32:23,907
cultures of African origin, close quote.
497
00:32:23,907 --> 00:32:28,167
The New York Times capitalizes black,
but you don't,
498
00:32:28,167 --> 00:32:32,800
Thomas Sowell, how dare you
engage in this act of defiance?
499
00:32:32,800 --> 00:32:38,877
>> Thomas Sowell: [LAUGH] It is amazing
the things that people can focus on,
500
00:32:38,877 --> 00:32:44,362
it may seem to be a big
issue to the New York Times.
501
00:32:44,362 --> 00:32:48,990
I suspect that people who are being
murdered in these big cities,
502
00:32:48,990 --> 00:32:50,925
like New York and Chicago,
503
00:32:50,925 --> 00:32:56,726
may have a somewhat different view of
what is capitalized and not capitalized.
504
00:32:56,726 --> 00:32:59,928
>> Peter Robinson: Tom, let me read
a few single sentences from social
505
00:32:59,928 --> 00:33:05,230
justice fallacies, I'll read a sentence,
you tell us what you meant.
506
00:33:05,230 --> 00:33:08,437
Stupid people can create problems, but
507
00:33:08,437 --> 00:33:13,444
it often takes brilliant people
to create a real catastrophe.
508
00:33:13,444 --> 00:33:16,810
>> Thomas Sowell: That is so
my gosh, think of the catastrophes
509
00:33:16,810 --> 00:33:22,250
of the 20th century,
you mentioned genetic determinism.
510
00:33:22,250 --> 00:33:27,474
They drew the conclusion from their
reasoning that you had to put
511
00:33:27,474 --> 00:33:32,793
an end to certain races because
they had what they call eugenics,
512
00:33:32,793 --> 00:33:35,906
but what was later called genocide.
513
00:33:35,906 --> 00:33:39,580
And so that idea originated
with the progressives, and
514
00:33:39,580 --> 00:33:43,332
there was a progressive who
wrote a book with that theme,
515
00:33:43,332 --> 00:33:47,960
which was translated into German,
and Hitler called it his Bible.
516
00:33:47,960 --> 00:33:50,790
And so this Holocaust,-
>> Peter Robinson: You draw a line from
517
00:33:50,790 --> 00:33:54,080
the progressive eugenicists
to Adolf Hitler?
518
00:33:54,080 --> 00:33:55,424
>> Thomas Sowell: He drew the line.
519
00:33:55,424 --> 00:34:01,023
He drew the line and wrote a letter, a fan
mail letter to the author of that book,
520
00:34:01,023 --> 00:34:05,551
saying that that book was his Bible,
and we see what that led to.
521
00:34:05,551 --> 00:34:10,201
During the 1920s,
in reaction to World War I,
522
00:34:10,201 --> 00:34:15,284
which was so bad,
the idea arose among the intellectual
523
00:34:15,284 --> 00:34:20,330
elites that the way to prevent
war was to stop arming.
524
00:34:20,330 --> 00:34:24,975
You see,
disarmament was the way to avoid a war.
525
00:34:24,975 --> 00:34:29,238
No evidence made the slightest
impression on them, and
526
00:34:29,238 --> 00:34:35,043
they blundered the west into a war that
probably would never have happened,
527
00:34:35,043 --> 00:34:40,138
because the totalitarian dictatorships,
the start of that war.
528
00:34:40,138 --> 00:34:43,509
Were well aware that the United States,
Britain, and
529
00:34:43,509 --> 00:34:47,038
France had an industrial
capacity greater than theirs.
530
00:34:47,038 --> 00:34:51,384
And you wouldn't ordinarily attack
countries that have greater
531
00:34:51,384 --> 00:34:56,520
industrial capacity
than yours unless
you thought that they were gutless and
532
00:34:56,520 --> 00:34:59,600
were foolish enough not to remain armed.
533
00:34:59,600 --> 00:35:04,703
And for three years of that war,
the Axis powers won every single battle,
534
00:35:04,703 --> 00:35:10,650
the western democracies lost in Europe and
Asia, wherever they fought.
535
00:35:10,650 --> 00:35:16,545
In 1942, Winston Churchill made
a speech in which he said,
536
00:35:16,545 --> 00:35:20,722
we have a new experience, we have victory.
537
00:35:20,722 --> 00:35:25,220
And when they won that victory in
El Alamein in northern Africa,
538
00:35:25,220 --> 00:35:30,220
that was the first battle won by
the western democracies in a war that was
539
00:35:30,220 --> 00:35:32,242
already three years old.
540
00:35:32,242 --> 00:35:35,925
And from that point on, especially
when the United States came in and
541
00:35:35,925 --> 00:35:40,480
the American productive capacity was
mobilized, then it turned around.
542
00:35:40,480 --> 00:35:43,383
Today, people who are trying to say,
543
00:35:43,383 --> 00:35:48,008
we need to disarm in order to
have peace don't understand.
544
00:35:48,008 --> 00:35:52,656
In a nuclear age, you're not gonna get
three years to figure out what's going on.
545
00:35:52,656 --> 00:35:58,500
You're either gonna be ready on the first
day of that war, or you are gonna lose it.
546
00:36:00,320 --> 00:36:05,010
>> Peter Robinson: In politics,
the goal is not truth, but votes.
547
00:36:05,010 --> 00:36:06,031
>> Thomas Sowell: Absolutely.
548
00:36:06,031 --> 00:36:08,350
>> Peter Robinson: And
why does that matter?
549
00:36:09,606 --> 00:36:14,660
>> Thomas Sowell: It matters because if
you can get people to believe that their
550
00:36:14,660 --> 00:36:19,970
problems are all due to racists,
you will get their votes.
551
00:36:19,970 --> 00:36:23,736
But if you look at a lot of
data on different things,
552
00:36:23,736 --> 00:36:26,371
you discover that's not the case.
553
00:36:26,371 --> 00:36:31,299
I'm very doubtful if all the races
in the country today have half
554
00:36:31,299 --> 00:36:36,058
the negative effect on blacks,
as the teachers unions have.
555
00:36:36,058 --> 00:36:40,982
Because the teachers unions keep
the schools lousy in areas where
556
00:36:40,982 --> 00:36:44,740
the people who send their
kids to school do not have
557
00:36:44,740 --> 00:36:50,220
the option to send them to a private
school if the schools are bad.
558
00:36:50,220 --> 00:36:54,831
>> Peter Robinson: You make the point that
in Harlem, there were charter schools
559
00:36:54,831 --> 00:36:59,218
that rent space in public schools,
and there were tests.
560
00:36:59,218 --> 00:37:00,922
Well, go ahead,
do you know what I'm referring to?
561
00:37:00,922 --> 00:37:04,110
>> Thomas Sowell: Yes,
in fact, there's a school.
562
00:37:05,490 --> 00:37:09,711
I thought the way to figure out the
difference between the public school and
563
00:37:09,711 --> 00:37:12,659
the charter schools,
regularly public schools and
564
00:37:12,659 --> 00:37:16,170
the charter schools is to
compare them in the same.
565
00:37:16,170 --> 00:37:19,070
When both schools are located
in the same buildings, so
566
00:37:19,070 --> 00:37:22,210
you have comparability,
it's the same group, when you.
567
00:37:22,210 --> 00:37:23,434
>> Peter Robinson: Same neighborhood,
same building.
568
00:37:23,434 --> 00:37:24,510
>> Thomas Sowell: Yeah, everything.
569
00:37:25,920 --> 00:37:31,295
And when you do that, what I found
was that the charter school kids
570
00:37:31,295 --> 00:37:37,747
in these low income black neighborhoods
passed the math test at a rate more than
571
00:37:37,747 --> 00:37:44,329
six times as high as that of the public
school located in the very same building.
572
00:37:44,329 --> 00:37:47,494
>> Peter Robinson: And the main
difference between the charter school and
573
00:37:47,494 --> 00:37:50,255
the public school,-
>> Thomas Sowell: Is that public school is
574
00:37:50,255 --> 00:37:51,985
run by the teachers unions,
575
00:37:51,985 --> 00:37:56,100
the charter schools do not have
unions at all in most cases.
576
00:37:56,100 --> 00:38:00,547
One of the most extreme examples was
a school that I went to when I was in
577
00:38:00,547 --> 00:38:01,356
Harlem.
578
00:38:01,356 --> 00:38:04,131
And in that particular school,
579
00:38:04,131 --> 00:38:10,700
only 7% of the regular public
school kids passed the math test.
580
00:38:10,700 --> 00:38:15,886
In the charter school, 100% passed it,
581
00:38:15,886 --> 00:38:19,340
they have different levels.
582
00:38:19,340 --> 00:38:21,026
Proficient means you passed, and
583
00:38:21,026 --> 00:38:25,270
there's a level above that when you've
done more than what is necessary for that.
584
00:38:25,270 --> 00:38:27,397
In that particular school,
585
00:38:27,397 --> 00:38:32,270
only 2% of the charter school
kids scored as low as proficient,
586
00:38:32,270 --> 00:38:36,890
the other 98% were in the top bracket,
above proficient.
587
00:38:37,990 --> 00:38:42,020
>> Peter Robinson: Last question here,
last quotation, Tom,
588
00:38:42,020 --> 00:38:47,113
one of many things that no individual,
no institution,
589
00:38:47,113 --> 00:38:51,556
and no society has any
control over is the past.
590
00:38:51,556 --> 00:38:54,240
>> Thomas Sowell: Yes.
>> Peter Robinson: Why does that matter?
591
00:38:55,460 --> 00:38:59,314
>> Thomas Sowell: Because when we talk
about groups and we talk about their
592
00:38:59,314 --> 00:39:04,596
environment, we usually mean their
tangible, current surroundings.
593
00:39:04,596 --> 00:39:07,640
But of course,
all the groups have had different paths.
594
00:39:08,660 --> 00:39:11,301
When the Irish, the Jews, and
595
00:39:11,301 --> 00:39:16,892
the Italian immigrants were coming
to America, it was common for
596
00:39:16,892 --> 00:39:21,975
Italian and Jewish neighborhoods
in New York's Lower east
597
00:39:21,975 --> 00:39:27,176
side to be represented by Irish
politicians, why is that?
598
00:39:27,176 --> 00:39:31,437
Because if you look at what happened
before they ever got to America,
599
00:39:31,437 --> 00:39:36,272
you can see that the Irish had reasons
to organize in a political kind of way.
600
00:39:36,272 --> 00:39:38,851
The Jews and the Italians did not,
their circumstances,
601
00:39:38,851 --> 00:39:40,784
it wouldn't have made any difference.
602
00:39:40,784 --> 00:39:44,740
And now, when they get to New York, they
may be living in the same neighborhoods
603
00:39:44,740 --> 00:39:47,871
and so forth, and the tangible
surroundings are the same, but
604
00:39:47,871 --> 00:39:50,696
the whole past of the three
groups is very different.
605
00:39:50,696 --> 00:39:54,448
And even when the Italians and
the Jews rise to prosperity,
606
00:39:54,448 --> 00:39:58,740
it's in different industries,
it's in different occupations.
607
00:40:00,200 --> 00:40:04,420
>> Peter Robinson: And the past means that
we should never expect groups to end up
608
00:40:04,420 --> 00:40:06,816
evenly distributed across,.
609
00:40:06,816 --> 00:40:09,643
>> Thomas Sowell: But even such
a thing as age people don't realize,
610
00:40:09,643 --> 00:40:13,195
some American ethnic groups
are a decade older than others, and
611
00:40:13,195 --> 00:40:16,126
some are more than two
decades older than others.
612
00:40:16,126 --> 00:40:18,663
So the Japanese,
the difference between blacks and
613
00:40:18,663 --> 00:40:21,358
white is not the largest
difference in the country.
614
00:40:21,358 --> 00:40:26,191
The Japanese Americans are higher
than Mexican Americans
615
00:40:26,191 --> 00:40:28,518
by an even larger amount.
616
00:40:28,518 --> 00:40:34,038
Japanese Americans have a median age of
52, Mexican Americans have it somewhere in
617
00:40:34,038 --> 00:40:39,110
the twenties, 52 year old people make
more money than 20 year old people.
618
00:40:40,170 --> 00:40:45,177
>> Peter Robinson: Tom,
would you close our discussion by
619
00:40:45,177 --> 00:40:52,210
reading a passage from
social justice fallacies?
620
00:40:52,210 --> 00:40:56,070
>> Thomas Sowell: Well, if I still agree
with it, do we want the mixture of
621
00:40:56,070 --> 00:41:00,917
students who are going to be trained
to do advanced medical research,
622
00:41:00,917 --> 00:41:06,620
to be representative of the demographic
makeup of the population as a whole?
623
00:41:06,620 --> 00:41:12,640
Or do we want students with the highest
probability of finding cures for
624
00:41:12,640 --> 00:41:15,420
cancer and Alzheimer's?
625
00:41:15,420 --> 00:41:20,178
Do you want airline pilots chosen for
demographic representation of
626
00:41:20,178 --> 00:41:25,180
various groups, or would you prefer
to fly with pilots who are chosen for
627
00:41:25,180 --> 00:41:29,198
their mastery of all the complex
things that increase your
628
00:41:29,198 --> 00:41:33,640
chances of arriving safely
at your destination?
629
00:41:33,640 --> 00:41:36,688
Consequences matter, or should matter,
630
00:41:36,688 --> 00:41:40,960
more than some attractive or
fashionable theory.
631
00:41:40,960 --> 00:41:42,547
More fundamentally,
632
00:41:42,547 --> 00:41:47,470
do we want a society in which some
babies are born into the world as heirs
633
00:41:47,470 --> 00:41:52,405
of pre-packaged grievances against
other babies born the same day.
634
00:41:52,405 --> 00:41:57,136
Blighting both their lives, or
do we want to at least leave them
635
00:41:57,136 --> 00:42:03,050
the option to work things out better
in their lives than we have in ours?
636
00:42:03,050 --> 00:42:06,106
>> Peter Robinson: Thomas Sowell,
author of some 40 books,
637
00:42:06,106 --> 00:42:09,738
including Social Justice Fallacies,
thank you.
638
00:42:09,738 --> 00:42:10,478
>> Thomas Sowell: Thank you.
639
00:42:10,478 --> 00:42:14,685
>> Peter Robinson: For Uncommon Knowledge,
the Hoover Institution and Fox Nation,
640
00:42:14,685 --> 00:42:16,120
I'm Peter Robinson.
641
00:42:16,120 --> 00:42:16,620
[MUSIC]