TRANSCRIPCIÓN 🔗
Nix: What if the reason so many women feel they're not enough has less to do with who they are and more to do with the stories they've inherited? What if women were taught to earn their worth while men were taught to assume theirs? in this episode, We'll explore the stories of sin, purity, obedience, silence and sacrifice, and how these ideas continue to influence modern expectations of women.
Tons: Wow, that seems like a heavy topic.
Nix: it is a heavy topic. When I was doing the research for this, I went all the way down the rabbit hole
Tons: I that some of the problem is that some of the things that I look at, I'm sure the same for you, is that you come away with a sense of outrage and just sheer frustration. I think I should be isolated while I do some of the research sometimes because when I come out of there, I want to kill all men.
Nix: I'm pretty sure my other half knows when I've been researching a particularly contentious topic.
Tons: Yes, yes. It's the same in my house,
Nix: Yeah. but you know what? It's a righteous anger. it's completely appropriate. so just thinking about this issue and what it means to us in day to day life, worthiness is treated as something that women have to prove through their behavior rather than something that they possess inherently. And Worthiness for women is something that is gifted Which I think is an extraordinary place for the world to have have gotten to.
Tons: Yeah, I know what you mean when you were reading out your question. It did resonate in the way that. I feel like I am constantly needing to prove myself as a mother, as a wife, as a colleague at work, a contributing member of society, always having to give a little more, always having to show up a little more. in a way that the men in my life don't seem to feel driven to do and other women seem to be feeling the same as far as I can tell.
Nix: Yeah. I think that that is the only outcome when we live in a culture which is shaped by religious traditions which grant men power or control over women. Men become the arbiters of What a good woman is.
Tons: Do you not feel that women sometimes judge each other really harshly as well?
Nix: They absolutely do, but they are judging themselves by the measure that men have already decided on. I think that the culture we've inherited from these religious teachings means that women are disadvantaged.
Tons: talking about original sin here?
Nix: Yes. I think that when women grow up in a world where we're taught that women are the originators of sin, that things like menstruation are dirty, that women enjoying any sexual pleasure outside of marriage is impure. I think that there's a a very rich well to make women feel like they should be behaving in certain ways because that's what our religious teachings tell us. and conveniently those religious teachings tell men that they should be controlling women. and how that feeds down through the generations is that even if you're not a religious person, our laws are all
Load full transcript
based around these religious teachings. We've inherited all of the behavioral expectations from these religious teachings. and That women are expected to sacrifice for the good of men. I can only speak from a Western society perspective, but I imagine this goes throughout the world, especially for the Abrahamic religions, that women are expected to themselves second for the good of other people. I don't know if you've had that experience where, you've sacrificed something and it's not even really acknowledged. It's just an expectation because our culture says that men's goals and ambitions should come first.
Tons: I think that every woman has had this and even if you can't articulate it, it's the feeling that you bring something of less quality to anything, whether that was at work or a meeting or... anyway, where there are men present, to be honest, I think that in a group of women, it's not assumed that one person is going to get up and make the tea or going to offer the biscuits, But in a group of mixed company, there is an expectation that a woman will get up and serve. without being asked to do so and just because there's a set of expectations on women that's not present for men.
Nix: Absolutely. think that there's a mistaken assumption that women are naturally more nurturing and self sacrificing. And therefore it's okay
Tons: Yeah.
Nix: to ask women to sacrifice because it's natural.
Tons: They want to, that's what they really want to do.
Nix: And that that kind of selflessness is a virtue. in women. when all it really does is mean that men expect women to sacrifice. and we expect ourselves to sacrifice because that is the that that's the message that we grow up with.
Tons: Yeah, that's true. So if the baseline is self-sacrifice, then what does it mean if you want to be better than the baseline?
Nix: It's a bit of a trap then, isn't it?
Tons: Yeah, if that's where the bar is, how do you step over that?
Nix: first of all, self sacrifice is a virtue. So to be a good woman, you have to be happy to be selfless.
Tons: So is this where the old saying about behind every good man is a good woman my favorite?
Nix: it absolutely is. And actually, I have a personal story on this, it's a small story and probably doesn't mean that much in the grand scheme of things, but when we were growing up I feel like there was a significant amount of cognitive dissonance in the messaging that we heard from adults Our parents were relatively on board with women's rights and people having equal opportunities, albeit they didn't really seem to know what that should actually look like. growing up, we were told that we could achieve anything that we wanted to achieve. And to do that, we should get good grades and we should strive to achieve, these great things. At the same time, we were surrounded by messaging that we should defer to men, and that we should behave in ways that wouldn't offend men or make them uncomfortable, and that men were the default leaders in a family or a business. and that dissonance is exactly how life played out. I had really big dreams and I tried to make them a reality, but the fact is that I sacrificed my ambitions in favor of my husband's and there wasn't even a conversation about it. neither of us questioned it. it was just what we'd both been taught. I consider myself to be a relatively intelligent person, and I didn't think to question it. And that makes me so resentful now. I'm not resentful that I gave up anything, but I'm resentful of the fact that It was never even discussed. It was never even considered. the messaging was so ubiquitous that the conversation wasn't required. And this isn't me blaming anybody, it's how it was. But this is me wishing that it wasn't the way that it was.
Tons: Yeah. Do you think people are more aware of it and they have these conversations now or do think things are still the same?
Nix: I think that things are still the same in the majority of cases. I think there are cases where if a woman is earning significantly more than a man, then man may give up his job and move to accommodate the woman's job.
Tons: It's not the majority of the case.
Nix: I don't see that as being the norm at all. I think that women are expected to give up their aspirations in favour of a man's aspirations.
Tons: it's much more nuanced than we actually realize. Like you said that at the time you didn't even question it, you didn't realize it and I think that that is still the case. people might have conversations and this is something that I've had. lots of thought over, even if we'd had the conversation about who was going to be the primary caregiver at the home and who was going to go back to work. The practicality of it is that one of us was earning more money than the other and the decision was made on financial terms but the complex issue is that As long as men out-earn women, these same conversations are still going take place. And when it comes to who's actually better at the job of staying at home and raising children or making the different decisions, that doesn't come into it at all. Until we can equalize the gender pay gap, women are always going to fall with the same job. a proper conversation about expectations and who's going to take care of which roles and who's going to be the main character and who's going to play a supporting character. It seems like it's just going to keep going.
Nix: I think you're right. because the social systems that we live in and again I can only talk about our experience of where we live, but those systems were developed within a Christian cultural framework, which shaped attitudes. towards marriage and leadership and the different values that we put on men's work versus women's work.
Tons: Yeah. So it's feeding itself.
Nix: I think it's a very hard nut to crack. but I worry that we're living in a society where even if you've never attended church, you're still living with the values shaped by religious traditions. and those
traditions Don't work in favour of women.
Tons: Yeah. I mentioned earlier about original sin, not everyone understands original sin, and I don't know if I understand it completely, but as my understanding goes, original sin belongs to women, women are born with sin in them. inherited from Eve who succumbed to temptation and took the apple off the tree.
Nix: and and then coerced Adam into eating the apple, obviously.
Tons: it was the woman's fault! How did
Nix: Yes.
Tons: I not know that? So the fact that it was the woman's fault is another thing that we've inbred into ourselves from religious education.
Nix: going back to the creation of humanity in as as far as some people believe. So it is genuinely always the women's fault, in that mindset.
Tons: it's always been.
Nix: Yeah, so that is the story of original sin. Humanity's first woman is remembered as the one who brought sin into the world. And historical interpretations place a disproportionate responsibility of the introduction of sin on Eve. women are obviously the daughters of Eve and therefore we are responsible for temptation, weakness, moral risk, and all sorts of other nasty things that we brought into the world.
Tons: And we should be punished. I think it also expands into that the reason why women suffer in childbirth is because of original sin. for millennia, we're talking, since this story first came about. medical interventions into helping women deliver children safely and in a pain-free manner was delayed by a huge huge amount of time because this was something that women were supposed to suffer in order to pay for this and I know that you're talking about worthiness and maybe are we talking about financial worthiness being affected by religious doctrine.
Nix: It's broader than that. It it is it's the worth that is placed on women in the world, but it's also women's sense of worth for themselves. because I think if you are born into a world where the foundational stories of women would begin with blame, I don't know how any person grows up with a healthy sense of self worth without deconstructing that.
Tons: Yeah.
Nix: And when men grow up in a world where women can be blamed for all the bad things, I'm fairly certain that that is not healthy.
Tons: No.
Nix: and the way that our biology is portrayed as shameful,
Tons: So it comes back to the same thing you said earlier about menstruation being something shameful. Is this what you mean?
Nix: Yeah, menstruation being framed historically as unclean or impure. Again, going back to what you were saying about women needlessly suffering through childbirth for much longer than they should have done, simply because there was this idea that women were supposed to suffer to pay for their sin. menstrual cramps has had the the same disadvantage given to it. the fact that, period products were not tested with real blood it illustrates how little worth and I'm going to say men because there's no one else to blame. Women aren't, responsible for
that. So
Tons: Well, if you consider that 89 % of world leaders are men.
Nix: Yes, exactly. and I don't know the statistics for the percentage of CEOs, but it's going to be above eighty percent.
Tons: Yeah.
Nix: how little do you have to value a group of human beings to not even test the products properly that those human beings are going to use? And we're talking about half the population of the world.
Tons: Yeah.
Nix: the other thing is female sexuality being subjected to so much scrutiny and control. where men's isn't
Tons: No.
Nix: and somehow there's this sense of worth linked to that sexuality which to me is such an arbitrary thing. our bodies as women are problematic in all sorts of ways when it comes to how men perceive them. Whether it's control
Tons: Yes.
Nix: of our bodies or the biology of our bodies or the temptation that our bodies offer.
Tons: Yes, it's all our fault.
Nix: Yes.
Tons: it strikes me the, colloquial term when somebody gets pregnant is quite often spoken about certainly in the past, maybe not so much now as she got herself knocked up. And it just seems again like this was what she did to herself and it's all her fault. And it seems like that there is blame inherent in there when the blame was not hers, especially if she was an unwilling participant, which happened a lot in the past and even today. Women being expelled from their jobs, women being expelled from their homes by their fathers, all of these things and saying it was her fault. It wasn't. It wasn't. And the unfairness seems unconscionable to me. how do we treat women in our society so badly.
Nix: Well, I think when you have some religious text to back you up and God says that it's okay to do that. I think that's the only way. Because I think without that it would be unconscionable.
Tons: Yeah, it's... for good people to do bad things takes religion.
Nix: I think that's religion teaches men that they can be the arbiters of women's worth. and it teaches women shame before it teaches any kind of ownership or pride in your own body. And so yeah, I do think that religion can be extremely problematic, when it comes to women's worth, both external and internal.
Tons: Do you think that men feel the same way?
Nix: No, I think that the messaging for men as far as that religious messaging and and therefore the inherited cultural messaging is that men are the default leaders, that they get to expect obedience of women or consideration or sacrifice. I think that's the message that they're given. I don't think that that kind of religious messaging or inherited religious messaging is damaging to men. At all.
Tons: It's hard to think that men are born with the idea that they... they didn't need to change anything about themselves in order to exist.
Nix: Their worth is inherent.
Tons: Yeah. Yeah, it's hard for me to get my head around that I suppose having lived only prove myself, it's hard to imagine what it must be like where you didn't have to do that.
Nix: I think it is very difficult. And I think it would be very difficult men to try and imagine what it's like growing up with the messaging that we've had. And I actually I had this conversation with my other half and he was quite appalled actually, when I pointed it out and I asked him, Do you think that you would feel differently about yourself if you grew up from the very, earliest memories being told that men were the originators of sin and that men were, dirty at certain times in their lives. and that if you had more than I don't know, a certain number of sexual experiences before you got married that that lowered your worth. or that If women behaved badly, it would be because it was your fault. and yeah, he was very upfront about the fact that it wasn't something that had ever occurred to him as being problematic, but probably because it was never problematic for him.
Tons: I suppose You only know your own perspective. And unless someone points it out, it's really difficult to understand that that perspective even exists. Never mind to understand the lived experience of that perspective.
Nix: Yeah.
Tons: Yeah, I've never really thought about it either, actually. I suppose your life and you get on with it.
Nix: Yes. I think that there there's a helpful metaphor that this is the water we swim in and therefore you don't see it. And that's the same for
Tons: Yeah.
Nix: so many of the the topics that we talk about on our podcast. but when you think about the restrictions that historically have been placed on Women speaking, teaching, leading, that women's voices were considered to be less credible than men's. and when women did speak, their testimony was given less weight than men's.
Tons: I'm questioned.
Nix: yeah, any kind of expertise would have been questioned.
Tons: Yeah, and the evidence in that is clearly that so many women publish their work under a man's name.
Nix: Yes.
Tons: You don't need to look far for evidence.
Nix: when your religion teaches that that is right, that women's voices shouldn't be heard or only heard in very defined circumstances and on very defined subjects, then there is no pushback to the narrative.
Tons: No, that's true.
Nix: I have to say that I think that there are a lot of modern faith communities that do reject these kinds of interpretations of religious texts and do support gender equality. And my focus and my outrage is certainly not on individual believers, but it is on the lasting cultural impact and damage that has been done to women from these historical teachings of the religious texts.
Tons: Yeah. I think it's the internalized message that is the harmful thing.
Nix: I think both sides are equally important. I think the way that women feel about themselves is directly impacted by how we're told we should feel about ourselves. but I also think that when boys are taught that women don't have the same worth as them, that certainly reinforces how women feel about themselves,
Tons: Yeah.
Nix: but impacts hugely on how women
live in the world.
Tons: Yeah, and when we say impact, it's not light impact, is it? this is something, this is very heavy impact across multiple spheres of your life, nearly anything where you contribute your labor or your thoughts or your anything at all. It's like what you bring is worth less to what a band brings. talking about salary here, we're talking about voluntary contributions, we're talking about at home, we're talking about your voice at school, advocating for your children and all these sorts of things are different. You turn up at A &E with a wound, women are frequently not treated as quick as men.
Nix: Yes, and then under prescribed pain medication.
Tons: Yeah.
Nix: because when women describe their pain, there's an assumption that you're making it up. Whereas
Tons: Yeah.
Nix: men seem to be believed. and that's because the man's voice has more weight.
Tons: Yeah.
Nix: what they're saying is more true. Because they're men.
Tons: Yeah.
Nix: but you are right, it goes across so many aspects of women's lives, it's everything from women's skills and achievements being less valued. or negotiating pay or promotion, women are always going to be the underdogs in that situation. And you've got to really outshine a man to get that promotion.
Tons: Yeah. And it's not just underdog as in like you're quietly being ignored. It is also that you are the loudest dog, but you're still being ignored. I can make a lot of noise and still be not taken seriously.
Nix: Well, I think actually women and I think this is different for men, for women, the more noise you make, the less credibility you're given.
Tons: That explains it.
Nix: but I think one of the most damaging things that this messaging does for women is that it means that women stay in unhealthy relationships far longer than they should.
Tons: because they're not worth anymore or because they don't value themselves.
Nix: I think because they don't value themselves as much as they should, but also they are taught that they should sacrifice. and sometimes that is sacrificing your safety and sacrificing your sanity. Unfortunately, I think that women are taught that they should put up with emotional pain on a far greater level than than men should.
Tons: Yeah. And I suppose also commenting about that state, the pain, emotional and physical pain, comes with the reinforcement of the message that you aren't able to cope or that you are complaining or whining or whinging or... being overly solicitous to your own self-need when women should actually be naturally self-sacrificing. yeah, so it goes around, it? You can't advocate for yourself without being thought of as being complaining, but at the same time, You don't advocate for yourself because you don't think it's worth it and you should be quietly Sacrificing for the good of the family for the good of the relationship for the good of the company for the good of society and that's just your position and this message that you're not worthy is So internalized you don't even realize that you're doing it
Nix: no, absolutely not. And when women's worthiness is measured through things like likability and sacrifice and purity and obedience, it's really not surprising. that women don't advocate for themselves and that no one else advocates for them.
Tons: Yeah, and I suppose those women that do speak out and say what they need are labelled in really negative terms like bossy or bitchy or needy.
Nix: On mag.
Tons: Yes, exactly. So again, it discourages us from speaking up amongst each other as well as in society in general.
Nix: Yeah,
Tons: But it begs belief for me because I just, think of women in my experience, the people in my life, all of the most capable people in my life are all women. I don't know too many women who are not one of the most capable people that I know. and yet maybe that idea of the capable woman has come about because that woman has had to work so hard. to prove herself worth.
Nix: I think that's right. firstly to others, I think that normally comes first, and then to herself. I think that journey to self-worth for women takes a very long time because there are so many barriers to break through to get there. whereas I I do think that men are pretty much born with self-worth.
Tons: Yeah.
Nix: they are special because they're boys.
Tons: Yeah. And if the self-worth in a man disturbed in any way or interrupted or lessened, it's probably a woman's Did you know I was getting there? You made me
Nix: I yes, I I I knew.
Tons: feel like that. it was a woman's fault.
Nix: always, always. we really need to combat this idea of earned worth for women. worth is inherent. It's not something that should be earned.
Tons: How do we do that?
Nix: Well, we I think we encourage people to examine own, internal dialogue and where that's coming from. And, if those messages are damaging to your self worth, are they real? do they matter?
Tons: Yeah.
Nix: but also, that Boundaries are not selfish and having boundaries is a healthy thing to do. you're not being selfish by having boundaries. And even if you were, selfishness doesn't seem to be a sin for anybody unless you're a woman.
Tons: I was just thinking that.
Nix: So, it's okay. It's fine to be a little bit selfish. you're not actually hurting anybody.
Tons: think it's fine to be a lot selfish, actually. I think that the term selfish means that you're taking something for yourself. It doesn't necessarily mean that you're taking it from somebody else. It's not
Nix: You're not depriving anybody.
Tons: stealing. It is thinking of yourself first, which a lot of men seem to do. naturally. Selfish only seems to be something that applies to women.
Nix: Yeah.
Tons: you're selfish if you don't have children and you're selfish if you decide that you want to go back to work instead of staying home to raise your children. you being selfish. Where that term doesn't seem to apply to men nearly as often.
Nix: No. No.
Tons: because women are supposed to be
giving up and sacrificing.
Nix: there's an expectation that that is the case. and again, boys and men have been taught that that's what they can expect from women, and women have been taught that that is what is expected.
Tons: Yeah.
Nix: I would like to challenge women to examine where they feel their sense of value lies. and if their value is determined by how useful they are to other people, then I would like them to reframe that and just understand that they are valuable. simply because they exist, not because of any utility that they provide to other people.
Tons: think that that is a hard ask, if I'm honest with you, because I think it's ingrained behavior. I think that the idea that you a useful member of society and a useful person to your family just because you showed up. seems a difficult thing to do, but I also think that it is a very worthwhile thing to do and to try to adjust the way we think as women that are valuable just the way we are and we don't have to work so hard at trying to prove that we are worthy.
Nix: I understand what you're saying, but I also think that it's worth differentiating between self worth and showing up. I think Self worth is something that is inherent. by all means there is joy to be had in showing up for your family or your friends or giving of yourself. and that is worth a lot to the people that you serve. But those those two things, self worth and the worth that you give willingly to other people, shouldn't be linked. You have value as yourself, regardless of the the service that you provide to other people.
Tons: Okay, you're right. That is a very important distinction because you can seek meaning for yourself by giving something of yourself. But You are still worthy whether or not you do that.
Nix: And if all of those things that you give to, all the the people or the charities, if all of those disappeared, it wouldn't make you worth less.
Tons: Yeah.
Nix: okay, so Again, this is one of those podcasts where other than asking people to challenge their internal dialogue around self worth to just maybe think about the narrative that you've been surrounded by when it comes to women's worth in society. there aren't a lot of actions that we can take away from this you can identify the inherited beliefs and notice the guilt if that appears for you self-advocate but other than that it's just being aware that these narratives exist
Tons: Yeah, Sometimes it's enough to understand motivations of why you did something or why you felt the way you did. and that the understanding is enough for you to feel different about your life. You look at yourself differently. You look in the mirror and you see a whole person the services that you give to your family and society and everything else, those are acts of love and that they are to be measured in that way for yourself to view it as even more fulfilling. because you don't have to do it you are doing it willingly and separately of yourself.
Nix: Yes. Which I think makes it mean more.
Tons: Yeah, that's exactly what I'm trying to say. You said it much simpler. I do the longer explanation.
Nix: I think that's probably all I've got for this podcast. but did you have any final thoughts, Toms?
Tons: I think I'm going to go away with a lot of things spinning around my head because what you've raised is something I've never considered before and I quite frequently feel at my wit's end with all of the things that I feel like I have to do as a mother, as a wife, as a woman contributing to society and I'm talking about my charity work and as colleague, a female colleague. I quite frequently feel like I've been pulled to the end of what I can manage, but the way that we've talked today makes me think that... All of those things that are pulling me apart are not pulling me apart because they're not really a part of me. Those are things that I have willingly given. The whole part of me is still whole despite all of those things because I don't have to do all of those things to prove who I am. Does that make any sense at all?
Nix: it makes perfect sense and I think that is a beautiful way to the podcast. So that's it for another week.
Tons: Leave us a comment or. give us a thumbs up follow subscribe do all those things it makes a difference
Nix: lots of love. Bye.
Tons: Bye lots of love, bye.
riverside outro nix un leashed: Thanks for spending time with us. If you enjoyed this episode, we'd love it if you subscribe, leave a review, and share it with someone who'd enjoy the conversation. And remember, the stories we inherit don't have to become the stories we live by. See you next time.