TRANSCRIPCIÓN 🔗
speaker-0: I realized that I began to manipulate people unknowingly to get tasks done. This task is really important, so we gotta get it done and we're gonna use people resources to get it done. And I would push people in those directions to get the task done and I wouldn't care about those people as much as I needed to or wanted to. But some of those insights then, I got to work on those muscles too, which led to that. story of sitting down and taking off my hat. So I think maybe I've improved a little bit.
speaker-1: For sure. It's hard to like see the growth of personal growth of leadership growth. It's only when you really look back and you or conversations come to your memory and you're like, wow, I didn't, I didn't handle that. Or I've heard clients say like, ⁓ my heart breaks from the former version of myself. I'm like, yep. That's every single human. Ever think leadership would be great if it weren't for the people? Welcome to Think Outside the Boss, a podcast for leaders who are done managing team drama and ready to lead in a new way. I'm Katie Armantrout, a recovering corporate leader, turned entrepreneur, and I teach people how to stop being nice and start being courageous. Are you ready to think outside the boss? Let's go. On today's episode of Think Outside the Boss, I interview Paul Spence, who is the Chief Development Officer of Pillar Media, which is a national Christian media company that includes radio stations like Star 93.3 in Cincinnati and 107 Flow in Denver. And Paul has such a rich experience in leadership. He talks about when he was 12 years old, he was voted, like actually elected the leader of a break dancing group. Stick around for that conversation. But he also has this rich history in faith based nonprofit. In his mid 20s, he was the executive director of a homeless shelter and talks about how they moved into a new building. And then he served at City Gospel Mission as the VP of Development for 19 years. Paul talks about the difference between what is it like to work for a for-profit company and a non-profit company? What does leadership look like in those two scenarios? Finally, Paul shares a couple of times when he really had to hear constructive criticism, and he's a guy that doesn't just ask for it to check a box. He shares about how he really had to look in the mirror and realize, wow, I think what they're saying is true. Now, what do I do about it? And he took action and it's was part of his journey in becoming the leader he is today. So with that, Paul Spence, welcome to Think Outside the Boss.
speaker-0: Thank you, Katie. It's an honor to be here.
speaker-1: So this isn't typically my first question, but you've got to explain. You're 12 years old and you are elected as leader of a break dance group.
speaker-0: Yeah, and you know, that was kind of my thrust into leadership positions. So God had kind of placed me there and then I always seemed to be captain or coach or leader or president of clubs and organizations. That was my launch into it. But yeah, I was flexible when I was 12 and I was a pretty good break dancer back then. I cannot show my kids today what it meant to break dance, but yeah, a thing of the past.
speaker-1: Is there any video?
speaker-0: I don't think we had video cameras. I'm old enough that if it was, it was really grainy.
speaker-1: Like the camcorder that you have to hold. Yeah, I grew up on VHS. I know my favorite movies when I was younger were break in and break into. So that is what I'm picturing. Is that what it was like?
speaker-0: Bye. was, it was. The crab crawl, the spinning, the wave, all that kind of moves and things. I looked like a robot when I moved around the dance floor. Yeah, it was fun.
speaker-1: I love it. I love it. That is like one of the best facts I have ever heard about someone. So now as you mentioned in that that was like your first foray into leadership. So one of the questions I ask every guest on the show is when did you realize that you were a leader?
speaker-0: Yeah, it wasn't really until college when I reflected back on all the positions that God had put me in with soccer teams and clubs and things like that. We saw a real need on our campus for Christian fraternity. And so myself and another classmate prayed about it and we decided, hey, this is something that we believe God is putting on our heart. And so I was already the president of Fellowship Christian Athletes. I was the captain of the tennis team. And I was like, why not one more thing? Because... I don't like to study, so we'll try this fraternity thing. But it was at that moment I was like, man, God has really put me in a lot of leadership positions throughout my life. And it's continued into my 50s. For me, and it's a little bit different from everyone else, I love Maxwell and Lencioni and all those guys and their definitions of leadership. For me, it's more of a coach's mentality. Because I've loved sports all my life. I've played sports all my life. And I love being the coach that inspires players to be better.
speaker-1: does leadership mean to you?
speaker-0: And so for me, is how can I elevate the people around me? How can I come into that coaching style that really benefits the team to elevate them? Because at the end of the day, it's the players on the field that get the results. It's a little bit about the coaching and a lot about the players. And so for me, that's my mentality and my approach.
speaker-1: all of your experience and you can pick from any one, where is a time when you really hit a wall when it came to leading others and you just thought to yourself, I've got to do something different.
speaker-0: My first serious roadblock was, was in my late 20s, I was running a homeless rescue mission back in Nebraska. And we were moving from a building that was about 8,000 square foot and it was run down and people shouldn't even been living in this situation. But we had successfully done a large capital campaign and
Load full transcript
we were about to move into a building that was eight times the size. So we're going from about 8,000 square foot to... almost 60,000 square feet and we were looking at this going, okay, this is a great opportunity. We're gonna be able to do all these things and serve more people. But then I saw this look of fear in my staff's eyes as we began to talk about that. And I realized that they were comprehending this large move. At the same time, they were thinking, ⁓ my gosh, what does this mean? How are we gonna operate? We've never done it this way. And so thinking about those kinds of fears, I decided. let's give them an opportunity to be in that space and to do some trial runs. And so as soon as we were out of the hard hat, the phase of the building campaign, I started to tell the team, hey, let's meet on Saturday mornings. And it's completely optional. I'm going to bring breakfast in and we're just going to talk through how to operate this building. And anticipating that a few people would show up, I went into the first Saturday and I had food for about half the team and the whole team showed up. And I thought, okay, I'm going to have to really start stepping up my game on breakfast. But they all showed up and they wanted to walk through. And so we started saying, OK, let's go through a lunch hour. What it means to call people for lunch and how we're going to do men and women and families. Are we going to have one meal time? We're going to have three meal times. What's this going to be like? How are we going to do med calls? How are we going to keep security in the building? How are we going to do check-ins? How are we going to operate just on a daily basis as people are walking through the building and getting to their case management appointments and everything? And then they started coming up with, how are we going to do this? And how are we going to do that? And so for almost two months, we met on Saturday mornings and we figured out how to operate in this new space before we even got there. And we had to figure out some hiccups and things like that when we actually moved in, things we didn't anticipate, but we were much better prepared for it. And I saw a sense of relief and excitement from the staff the day we moved in rather than fear.
speaker-1: So how many people were on the team?
speaker-0: There were about 10 people at that time on the team, and honestly that was one of things we identified was we didn't have enough staff to cover this building. We hadn't even anticipated having to hire very quickly after we moved into the new building, which was great insight that my staff was able to give me.
speaker-1: So you're in your 20s, right? Okay, you're in your mid 20s. What is your role? you like leading the homeless shelter? Executive director of a homeless shelter in your mid 20s.
speaker-0: May 20th, yeah. Executive Director, yep. Yeah, never never having gone into nonprofit is my first venture in a nonprofit to
speaker-1: a venture and nonprofit. And you've got this team of 10 people and you're moving to a new location. Did you have a mentor? Because I got to think while you're like, it was a good gut instinct to like call that Saturday morning meeting, but like, that's a huge thing. So I see how you were helping get your team through it. How were you getting yourself through it?
speaker-0: I was getting myself through it by leading. mean, part of my joy is seeing the staff flourish, right? And when they're so capable of great things and then they accomplish great things, I get a lot of self-satisfaction in saying I helped them get there. It was a joy for me to add that extra day of work to try and come and be prepared. And then the excitement of the staff was just... It was enthralling. mean, they were embracing it. I don't know where I came up with it. Yeah, was probably definitely a God breathe in some dream or something that gave me the reason to be able to do something like that. Yeah.
speaker-1: So take us back to that first meeting or it could even be the second, but take us back to that meeting. So you're there and you're like, ⁓ I've got some donuts, get some, couple people will show up. We'll just talk through it. What happened when you saw all 10 people? How did you run the meeting when you saw that it was, this was an impromptu thing. And then suddenly everybody showed up.
speaker-0: Well, thankfully I had a little bit of an agenda, but everybody showed up and I just took a moment to celebrate. I said, we have talked about these kinds of moments for a long time. It had been about six years that we had been thinking about and planning for and praying for this move to this building and just sitting there and celebrating with the staff and just saying, no, we're on the doorstep of this. You guys have helped us get here. This is the vision that we've been working toward. Isn't this incredible moment for us to, and so let's just take it in. There's a little bit of paint on the walls, the carpet's not laid, there's a lot of work yet to be done in this building. Let's just take it in. Take it in for a moment that God has given us favor to get to this point. And so we started with thankfulness.
speaker-1: I love that, because I don't know that a lot of people would have started there. I think it would be like, well, let's dive in. And the fact that you started with celebration, like y'all are here, casting the vision and you started with celebration, you started with gratitude. I think that's incredible. So you had some experience in the for-profit world and then most of your career in the nonprofit world. And I've been in both as well. Before I was in nonprofit, I always had a heart for it. I've spent most of my career in the for-profit industry and private companies, public companies, you name it, startups. And when I went to nonprofit, before I launched my own company, I had a heart for it. I was excited. I'm like, ⁓ yay, there's a mission, there's meaning. And then I
got into it and a nonprofit is just another company. There's a lot of mission, there's a lot of meaning to it. But what I mean by that is like there's still conflict or if nothing else, I think people were almost nicer and maybe more conflict avoidant. Did you experience that in the nonprofit world or were there any big differences between like nonprofit and for-profit?
speaker-0: Yeah, major differences, right? I mean, the pace is one of the things. You go into non-profit, it's like, okay, we don't have the resources to go do that, so we have to raise the resources and wait on things. And most people are doing four or five jobs at one time, and so the pace is completely different. I had to learn that right away. Definitely what you spoke about, the conflict avoidance, people trying to be too nice, because we're, especially in faith-based non-profits, it's... avoiding conflict or trying to treat it as, this is just going to pass by. We don't have to worry about that. God's going to take care of that. It's even more so that people need to be real with each other and give an opportunity and permission to be real and say, look, I'm struggling. I'm having a bad day. You said something in that meeting that I took offense to. I need to clear my heart. So I think, especially in the faith-based space, that that needs to be done even more. And so leaders have a responsibility. to give permission to their teams to speak up and say, how are you really feeling? There's a lot of times too in faith-based nonprofits that people feel allowed to bring their home problems to work, or that doesn't happen in the corporate space, right? If somebody's getting a divorce or somebody has a death in the family, you're supposed to come to the corporate space and just be, hey, it's business as usual. You took your day off to mourn, it's back to work. In the nonprofit space, especially the faith-based, there's that, you know, But Sally has a sad face. What's going on with her? ⁓ well, she just lost her brother. You know, she just lost her mother. And then we need to give her some space. And so there's that combination of, I need to go care for Sally. But then Sally needs to do her work, too. And so it's a delicate balance when it comes to nonprofit, about giving people permission to speak into that. Wearing that hat of compassion, addressing the issues, but then also saying, hey, I love you. I'm going to care for you. I'm going to pray for you. I'm going to give you some space. at the end of the day, how do we together help you get your work done because we still have to deliver too.
speaker-1: Yeah. So part of this podcast too, I love the insights and also getting into some of the weeds of like, what were your specific actions? Like for the leaders that are listening today that aren't in nonprofit, but you know, they don't want to be the like, okay, you had your day off, now get back to work. Like you had your four hours of bereavement leave and now show up again. So they're not quite in that space, but they do want to open it up and they want they want people to show up fully as themselves, which does include not only celebration and joy, but it does include grief and trauma. What are some steps or like what are ways that they can do that, especially if they don't work in a faith-based organization and it might be taboo?
speaker-0: I think a lot of the rules and approach are the same, whether you're in secular or nonprofit, whether you're in business. It doesn't matter the platform. It really comes down to how do you treat people. And I'll tell you a scenario that I would have done regardless of if I was in a for-profit, nonprofit, faith-based, secular. I was told that I could make some structural changes on my team. because I really needed to create some more middle management to take some pressure off of me as I was trying to do too much and had way too many direct reports. So I was told that I could elevate someone to a higher position and we would change the title, but there was gonna be no compensation with it too. We were just asking them to rise to another position, be in leadership, have a team under them and we would change their title and then potentially compensation would come in the next. six months or a year, if the money was there. And so I went to this person and I sat down with them and I said, hey, would you be willing to, the team needs you, the organization needs you to step up and take this role. How do you feel about that? Are you willing to do this? And this person said, I did this in a previous role and I was not treated well. There was no compensation and I was overworked and I felt lesser about the organization that I was working for. And in fact, even that, that's what led to me leaving. And I don't want to put myself in that position. I'm worth more if you're asking me to do this. And so I have to dig my feet in and say, I will accept if you pay me. And so in that meeting, I said, I'm going to lean in and I'm going to take my supervisor hat off. And here's my friend hat. Good for you. Don't change this position. You should stay steadfast to this. And so I think it's a balancing act of being in those dual roles, but then letting your staff know too, hey, this is the hat that I'm wearing. I'm gonna wear the boss's hat right now. I'm gonna wear the supporter's hat right now. I'm gonna wear the friend hat right now. And I think it's okay to be those different people, but let them know too, clearly where you're coming from. And that... probably goes right to communication, right? Which is our leadership is communicate well and let people know, understand exactly where you're coming from and exactly your expectations.
speaker-1: Yeah, and don't sugarcoat it for sure. In that example, you so did that person they did not end up taking?
speaker-0: Not.
speaker-1: How did your leadership reply to that? What happened after that?
speaker-0: I have experienced a lot of different types of
leaders, right? And some I learned from and say, I want to emulate that. And some I look back on and say, I'm not going to act like that. And so in this particular case, leadership said, well, if that didn't work, then find a solution. And so I was left to come up with a solution.
speaker-1: So what was the solution?
speaker-0: I just continued to take on too much work because I didn't see one. Without proper resources and without trying to do that again, which I felt was wrong to another member of my team, I was asking them to do the same thing that I was experiencing. Take on more with no pay and I wasn't gonna do that. And so in this case, I took one for the team and I bared the brunt of that and continued to work probably too hard. And in hindsight, I should have set better boundaries for myself and taken a little more personal care.
speaker-1: I appreciate you sharing those details because this is a very real scenario, especially in larger companies. I'm like, I relate, think of an exact situation where I did do something very similar, where I had to tell someone like she was going to relocate or there was a job she wanted to take where she'd be reporting to me and she didn't want to relocate. And I'm like, that's fine. You don't need to. But the company was like, no, she has to. And I was like, I can't in good faith tell you. I can't do it. Yeah, I appreciate you sharing all that because it is so common. It's so relatable. And the other thing too that you did really well that I want to call out for the audience listening is that when you said you put on those different hats and that is so important because people like we all wear a lot of hats. But when you're the leader of the team, like when you're the boss, I mean, people tend to only see you as that or that is your primary role. And so in that situation when you actually said I'm taking off my leadership hat and I'm putting on my friend hat, or you could say, hey, I'm not your boss right now, I'm not your manager, but as your friend, let me tell you this. I've also to just build on that for the people listening, I've also seen leaders do that really well and just everyday medians of, hey, I'm offering this suggestion. as a member of this team, not as the leader of it. So I want your input on it. I'm offering an idea, not a directive. So I love that you used that and it sounds like it made a huge difference in that conversation.
speaker-0: Well, I like what you just said and I'm going to borrow that from you. So as a member of this team, I'm putting out, I like that. That's great.
speaker-1: I know one of your teams had done Working Genius before. And that's something too, where the leader has twice the impact of anyone else's presence, of anyone else's decision. And sometimes we say things as leaders and we're like, no, I'm part of the, like I'm saying this isn't part of the team, or I'm saying this out of invention and not, like I'm just providing an idea. So it's really helpful. And although people will feel cheesy doing it, I'm like... You can feel cheesy doing it, but lean into it. It's really helpful. I mean, you've had such a diverse set of experiences and a lot of really like meaty leadership roles. When you like look back over, what was the time when you like you had to look in the mirror and realize I need to change and I need to do something like it's not the team, it's me.
speaker-0: I like all of the assessments, right? The working genius, the Myers-Briggs, the disc. Enneagram, I mean all those give you certain insights to who you are and and you got to use them to a point They shouldn't define you and you shouldn't operate according to you know If I'm a but to on the Enneagram that that's how I behave all the time But but it does frame it in an inform and I think I was in my mid 30s When I realized and something you just alluded to with the voice of the leader that when I was requesting things Somebody had told me that hey, you know When you came to us and you asked us to do something and you were trying to be gentle about it, you don't have a gentle voice. And it was amazing to look in the mirror and then reflect on even my marriage and being a father. It like, if that's true, then when I think I'm being soft and nurturing, I'm not being soft and nurturing. And I asked a lot of people to give me feedback on that. And majority of people said, yeah, you don't have... a really soft side. It's kind of a hard soft. And it was a blind spot. was, know. Yeah, it was. But it was a blind spot for me. And I have always loved constructive criticism because that's how we grow. And so I leaned into that to say, OK, how how do I become more empathetic and soft? And I realized that I began to manipulate people.
speaker-1: It's not over easy.
speaker-0: unknowingly to get tasks done. This task is really important so we got to get it done and we're going to use people resources to get it done. And I would push people in those directions to get the task done and I wouldn't care about those people as much as I needed to or wanted to. But some of those insights then I got to work on those muscles too which led to that story of sitting down and taking off my hat. So I think maybe I've improved a little bit.
speaker-1: For sure. It's hard to like see the growth of personal growth of leadership growth it's only when you really look back and you or conversations come to your memory and you're like wow, I didn't I didn't handle that or I've heard clients say like ⁓ my heart breaks from the former version of myself. I'm like, yep That's every single human. So before we go into the lightning round, what advice would you give to? leaders now in 2026.
speaker-0: I loved feedback, I loved coaching, I loved leaning into mentors and mentorship and things. Constructive criticism is huge. One of the things that I was not good at was really studying and reading. And now that you've got all of these leadership materials at your fingertips and
podcasts and everything else, I would encourage people to be a learner. And even if that's not your forte, find what speaks to you that can. to help you grow because we've never arrived as leaders. I still look at leadership approaches and I see people do things. I'm like, ooh, I wanna do that better or I wanna do that like they're doing it. And so I'm still on that journey and that path of learning and reading and consuming. I love, like I said, Patrick Lincione and John Maxwell, you those are the old ones, but then there's these books by Chip and Dan Heath that are fantastic about Switch and made to Switch.
speaker-1: Which is one of my favorites.
speaker-0: Power of Moments, one of their new books. It's fantastic. ⁓ well, Guadera that wrote Unreasonable Hospitality. Todd Bolesinger writes Canoeing the Mountains. And Katie, ⁓ I wouldn't even be able to tell you book titles four years ago, but I went into that. And man, has it been fruitful just to sit down and highlight. I don't sit down with a book without a highlighter and a pen. and writing thoughts in the margins now. And that's not something I would have done. And so I would encourage people, what is your style of learning? And lean into that. We should not ever feel like we've arrived. We can always get better.
speaker-1: Oh, I love that. I also sit down with a highlighter and a pen and mark up books for sure. And I think it's a part of like the one of the like wonderful things about the world today with so many more books being published and podcasts is like there's more voices to listen to. Education just doesn't end when you get your degree. If you get a degree, it's like it's an ongoing thing. And so there's a lot of beauty and a lot of a lot of good stuff in that. Cool. Paul, are you ready for the lightning round?
speaker-0: Okay, who do I win if I answer correctly?
speaker-1: There's no right or wrong answers. These are just the same five questions that I ask every guest on the show. The first one is what is your favorite personality assessment?
speaker-0: I gotta say Working Genius now, and I like them all. I really like Working Genius because it kinda takes you through a project from start to finish. And it allows you with that wonder and the innovation and then you've got your Ds saying why you can or can't do this and what kind of resources you need. And you've got the galvanizers saying let's go and you've got the E's saying let's engage, let's get this enabled, let's get this project done. And then you've got the T's which I am not, that's my frustration saying. And I'm always looking to the T's going is it done? Is it done? Can we move on? Can we do the next? So I love the working genius because you really can tackle. projects with that model.
speaker-1: Mm Yeah, I love it. I'm biased in that one. But yeah, I hope you didn't say it because of me. thank you.
speaker-0: No, but the trainer we had was fantastic. And she has your same name. don't know where... She was fantastic.
speaker-1: That's awesome. Question number two, what is a book that was instrumental in your life?
speaker-0: There's so many now, but one that really shaped my leadership and I stand by is Patrick Lenci. I think he's the advantage. I think every leader should read that.
speaker-1: Yes, I call it the business Bible and my copy is full of Post-It notes and highlights and marker like
speaker-0: Yeah, good luck.
speaker-1: Yeah, I don't just read it. implement it. Number three, what is the best advice you've ever received?
speaker-0: There's so much in there too, but ⁓ early on in my childhood, my dad had a sticky note on his bed and it's super cheesy, but it just always kind of shaped me and the way that I would approach things. And it's just simply sad. I don't know who to attribute this to, but those that have never failed have never tried.
speaker-1: So true. So true.
speaker-0: I could thank my father for a Post-It note on that one.
speaker-1: Yes. Oh, and that leads perfectly into the fourth question, which what is a failure that you cherish?
speaker-0: Which one?
speaker-1: I know, right? So many for all of us. What a great attitude, by the way, to have about failure. Yeah, well. one?
speaker-0: Yeah. ⁓ Yeah, and how fast can you fail and what can you learn from it? And those are two things because I I love taking tactical chances and trying new things and so many times we would try things and and and fail and learn from them my people failure My biggest people failure. I'll talk about that because there's a lot of tactical failures that you know don't fit this podcast, but one that really resonates with me and that I learned from is that when I was at odds with someone that reported to me, really don't enjoy conflict, extended conflict. I will approach a problem, I'll address a problem in real time, I have no problem pulling somebody aside and saying, hey, there's an issue with this, there's a problem with this. What's difficult for me is when Somebody and I are not right and there's tension between the two of us on an extended period. And so I went too far in trying to repair the relationship when it wasn't repairable from their side. I tried to do my work and their work and I made it worse. What I realized through that is I can do my part and the rest is up to them and I got to be okay with it.
speaker-1: That's such a good lesson, a good lesson, a hard lesson to learn is like you can't control other people. That's a whole other podcast we can have on that conversation. But yes, that's good stuff. All right. The last question of the lightning round and my personal favorite. So since you're a sports guy, let's say you're going onto the field, name is called, what is your walk on music? What's your hype song as you go onto the field?
speaker-0: Yeah, my hype song, would be back in the day, it isn't oldie but a goodie, but I loved DC Talk's Jesus Freak. ⁓ That would be my hype song.
speaker-1: Nice. I love it. Yeah, I love it. Cool. Paul, thank you so much for joining us on the the podcast today. Before we go, why don't you share with us where can people find you if they want to follow you? Talk about what you're doing, anything you want to promote. This is this is your time.
speaker-0: Yeah, well I would say hey, I'm a little biased now because I absolutely love my new position at Pillar Media, but you know Star 93.3 FM in Cincinnati is a fantastic station. You can download it on your smart TV. You can download as an app. We also have the flow 107.1 in Denver, but that's also an app. So if anybody is interested in Christian hip hop, it's super cool. Yes, it's awesome. But if anyone wants to talk to me and talk leadership, love it because I can learn from you too. But I'm on LinkedIn. Reach out to me.
speaker-1: Awesome. And we will link to all of that in our show notes as well.
speaker-0: It's been a privilege. I hope you know that there's a nugget of wisdom in there somewhere, but what an awesome opportunity. Thank you,
speaker-1: Thank you so much. Thanks for listening. If you liked something from this episode, hit share and send it to a friend or fellow leader. Don't forget to follow the show and leave a review because it helps leaders like you find us faster. This episode of Think Outside the Boss was produced by Volt Productions. I'll see you next week and until then, keep moving forward.