TRANSCRIPCIÓN 🔗
00:00:05
Speaker 1: You're listening to the Weekend Collective podcast from Newstalk ZB.
00:00:11
Speaker 2: Debating all the issues.
00:00:12
Speaker 1: And more, it's the panel on the Weekend Collective on Newstalk ZB.
00:00:18
Speaker 2: Yes, and joining me for the panel, it's my great pleasure to, look, I'll mention the guy who's in the studio first. He's the CEO of Field Days. He's become somewhat of a rural type, being a bit of a city slicker. It's Richard Lindrews. Hi, Richard. How are you? Good afternoon, everyone.
00:00:33
Speaker 3: Great to be here again. Hi to everyone.
00:00:37
Speaker 2: You were going to introduce me. You were about to introduce my panellist, but you were about to say hi, Brad Olsen, who needs no other introduction. Hey, Brad, how are you doing?
00:00:45
Speaker 4: I'm well. I'm well. Is that all I get, Tim? Normally, you'll give me some sort of stick in the lead up to an introduction. I feel... Like I've gotten away scot-free this time.
00:00:53
Speaker 2: I'm worried about teasing. Sorry, what's that, Richard?
00:00:56
Speaker 3: Well, no, I think you should do a bit more of an intro for Brad.
00:00:59
Speaker 4: Oh, Brad.
00:00:59
Speaker 2: Brad, economist to the stars, man about town.
00:01:03
Speaker 3: Potential political candidate.
00:01:05
Speaker 4: Oh, my goodness.
00:01:06
Speaker 2: Where have you been, Brad? Where haven't I been?
00:01:09
Speaker 4: Woof. I don't know.
00:01:11
Speaker 2: That's a Blackadder quote, by the way, just for fun.
00:01:15
Speaker 4: I think I prefer now to have stuck with no intros.
00:01:20
Speaker 2: Anyway, nice to see you. How are things in... You're in Wellington today?
00:01:26
Speaker 4: I'm in the Wairarapa. It's been a pretty miserable day, to be honest. It's not that nice. But to be fair, I hear that it's going to become better.
00:01:35
Speaker 2: Can I ask, just out of curiosity, are you visiting your old family home and are you in your old room that you grew up in? Because there's a picture of Kermit the Frog on the wall behind you. And I was thinking, is this....
00:01:48
Speaker 4: No, it's not. I'm at a friend's place, and this is the office. But it's also the Lego building room. So it's got all the fun stuff. And now it's a radio recording studio.
00:02:01
Speaker 2: It's not easy being green. Anyway, there we go. I don't know why. That's Kermit the Frog. And I was thinking, time to the political hour. Because let's get on with the panel, guys. Oh, God. Random segues from Beveridge there. Right, the election campaign debates so far. You know, I've got a quick question. So we've got, you know, everyone's pushing their message. Everyone's out and about doing glad handing and all that sort of thing. And I see there were debates. There was the minor sort of parties debate and there was another debate. I think the Mount Albert one. And I actually am just curious what you guys have taken away from the campaign so far. But whether a lot of these stories are stuff
Load full transcript
that resonate with the average voter, because I would say that it's sort of beltway stuff in a lot of ways. But what's standing out to you, Brad? We'll go with you first.
00:02:46
Speaker 4: Well, I think probably most importantly, the fact that the campaign has apparently only just started. What have we been doing the last couple of months? I mean, it's been all on. We've had campaigns. I mean, if this is the start of the campaign, does that mean all of the policies that have been announced up until now were sort of just fakies that aren't going to make it through or what? Because... I don't know. I sort of feel like I'm, I'm at the end of the campaign rather than the start of it.
00:03:09
Speaker 2: Is that because Winston started a year or so ago and you're running, because I'm running out of steam and it's like, it's just the race is just hotting up.
00:03:16
Speaker 4: That's the thing. I feel a bit stuffed from this.
00:03:18
Speaker 2: Yeah. Okay. Brad's knackered.
00:03:20
Speaker 3: Well, um, the campaign started at field days this year, um, when there was some good policy announcements coming out from field day. So it's been a long time. I mean, for me, what are the policies that are going to be materially changed? New Zealand changed the dial, uh, And I think what I'm saying is there doesn't seem to be too much ambition for New Zealand in a long-term view, a lot of retail politics and playing to your audience.
00:03:43
Speaker 2: Well, the long-term ambition, the big picture stuff, I don't know, what captures the voter? Because you've got Labour offering 10% off student loans. I mean, so somebody's a doctor with a $ 100, 000 loan who's probably not too worried about that. They get a gift from the people who are paying tax who've never got a student loan. But that's ideologically true.
00:04:02
Speaker 4: Pork barrel.
00:04:03
Speaker 3: Pork barrel politics.
00:04:04
Speaker 2: What is pork barrel? Does it win the day, Brad?
00:04:07
Speaker 4: Well, it might do, right? Because as much as I'm totally there for long-term policy, I wish that we'd have more of it. I also get that every time you see the polls coming out, one of the biggest questions that voters are asking is, what's going to happen to the cost of living? So as much as everyone are going, look, I'm worried about the long-term... Actually, most people go, and I'd just like to get through the next week or the next month. So I understand it. It's just, it feels like we're sort of, you know, it's becoming more and more tribal. We sort of, you know, my side's right, your side's wrong. What's most interesting, though, of the last week, I think, is that at least one party's come out with its apparent bottom lines for potential coalition negotiations at the end of all of this. And that's just interesting, because at the moment, I don't know what policies the political parties have got out there, that they actually do care about enough and want to say, this is my absolute do or die
if we get around the coalition table. And until you get that, I sort of go, is the 7th of November going to be anything important, or are we going to get there and then really the real work starts and we all have to figure out who actually signs up to what seat?
00:05:06
Speaker 2: But Brad, I mean, you've got to have some ambition.
00:05:08
Speaker 3: We want to be able to grow the pie, not policies that actually spend it. I mean, there was some good stuff coming out of field days in terms of both parties, both centralist parties and National and Labour, about KiwiSaver changes. They were good policies. Okay, a bit of differences on the method. In the last week, we've seen commentary around debt, which was really good to see. You know, Michelola's coming out and said, as we turn to surplus, we'll start paying debt. And that was doubled down by Chris Hipkins. But where are the big ambitious plans for New Zealand, the long-term views, the infrastructural chats? It should be about growing the pie, not the policies that spend it.
00:05:44
Speaker 2: You sound like you're about to stand for politics actually, Richard.
00:05:47
Speaker 3: I think Brad is the more opportunistic way of doing that.
00:05:52
Speaker 4: Tim, normally it's you trying to push my apparent political aspirations.
00:05:57
Speaker 2: No, Richard has heard me push your buttons before and say where you're standing. You gave me a heads up there. I was going to leave it alone, but Richard said, oh, I'll give it a crack. Hey, look, actually, here's one thing that stood out for me was Securely Wong recently spelt out some sort of bottom lines. But the strange one that struck me was, and I know that she doesn't like what I would see as some of the bigoted sort of stuff that Winston plays, like the butter chicken samami and all that, go back to your own country. But I also found it strange that she said she wouldn't be part of a government that had Winston Peters as foreign minister, because much as I might not be ringing Winston's bells of praise all the time, I thought he was a pretty good foreign minister. And that seemed a strange thing for her to say. What do you think? Let's go to Brad first.
00:06:41
Speaker 4: Well, I think, look, Winston Peters is a good foreign minister. That has become a little bit harder to sort of, I guess, watch in the last couple of months where he's been both foreign minister, but at the same time, you know, a campaigning New Zealand first leader. And some of the comments that he's made around some of our big trading partners, you look at some of the stuff he's said around the India Free Trade Agreement, sort of pretty hard to be in that position as a party leader saying one thing and then also representing the government's foreign views in another. I mean, It does. What's New Zealand's foreign policy on India at the moment? Because depending on who you talk to in a coalition government, it's different. So I think that's the challenge.
00:07:18
Speaker 2: I'm not sure it's for her to say, though. I think that's a prime minister's call.
00:07:21
Speaker 3: I mean, Winston Peters has been a very effective foreign minister. I think the views of the Opportunities Party, I mean, they've got some strange policies. You know, the law to order policy is just, naive, you know, in terms of up to 24 and under, you'd be regarded as a minor in front of the law. I mean, just ridiculous stuff. And, you know, the bottom lines, I.
00:07:45
Speaker 2: Mean, they're, you know.
00:07:46
Speaker 3: Year 10 projects, you know, 10-year health plan.
00:07:50
Speaker 2: We all have these. So it's pretty limited.
00:07:52
Speaker 3: It's quite a naive view.
00:07:54
Speaker 4: Brad? It's more interesting, right, though, that in the last week, you've not only seen that, you've had big discussions from Chloe Swarbrick and the Greens saying that, you know, I'm going to be the next finance minister and Chris Hipkins having to say, hang on, no, you're not.
00:08:07
Speaker 3: Well, if Chloe's going to be the next finance minister, she needs to get a bit more credibility in that space.
00:08:11
Speaker 2: To be honest, if she wants to say she wants to be finance minister, that's fine. I mean, she won't be. There's no chance it'll happen. But I think the biggest controversy in what we've heard this afternoon is Brad calling her Chloe Swarbrick.
00:08:24
Speaker 4: Swarbrick, sorry, sorry.
00:08:27
Speaker 2: Mate, I'm just ringing your bells just for fun.
00:08:30
Speaker 4: There was, oh.
00:08:31
Speaker 2: Now, just on the political thing, and sort of escaped my attention this, but Andy Burnham, just going international for a moment, he's flagged a Brexit change, and there's a chance, I think I saw, that he might even run the next election on a sort of referendum on Brexit on returning to the EU. Richard? Well, I think he has to.
00:08:53
Speaker 3: I mean, the UK economy is hemorrhaging from the policy since Brexit, and that policy collaborate to compete, one market. That's why they went in there. So I think he probably has to, particularly his audience that he's talking to.
00:09:09
Speaker 4: I mean, I was in the UK when they last voted to get out of it. So it would be fascinating to see them sort of go through what was a pretty, I mean, the thing, right, is that the reason, I think one of the reasons they left back in the day was because they had all sorts of, you know, various promises that never came true. What's to stop them going through the exact same this time? You know, I find it fascinating that, you know, is that the best that the UK can do in terms of a policy discussion at the moment? Sort of a hopscotch between in or out of the UK, the EU, every sort of decade or so? Yeah.
00:09:40
Speaker 2: That's wild. I guess it'll be interesting to see people who voted for Brexit who are now in the economy that's resulted after it.
00:09:47
Speaker 3: They might not need to be voted. They might not go to referenda. You
might make it the re-elect me and.
00:09:52
Speaker 2: This is what happens. That's what I mean, yeah. You might make it a, yeah.
00:09:54
Speaker 4: But when you've got Nigel Farage who's, you know, sitting there and going, well, you know, he's got still a pretty big share of the vote. He was like the main man behind leaving. That's a very polarizing.
00:10:05
Speaker 3: View.
00:10:05
Speaker 4: You're either sort of, you know, you really might well split the country even stronger against or sort of through political lines.
00:10:13
Speaker 2: Yeah. Oh, well, it's not something we have to worry about today, is it? We've got our own election to get on with. Hey, now, ACT, this is an interesting one. The ACT policy... They want a planning law changed to prevent resource consents requiring developers to take part and pay for karakia or other religious and spiritual observances. Actually, I didn't realize that there was some compulsion to this sort of thing, that you had to pay for a karakia or spiritual observance in relation to getting some certain consents. Do you know much about this, Brad?
00:10:48
Speaker 4: Well, so... It depends on– there has been some of that, by the sounds of it, and some resource consents when they've been issued. At the same time, it's not– I don't think it's particularly widespread. And more importantly, the government has literally just gone through and signed off its changes to planning laws. And I sort of look at that and go, why didn't they either include it there– or at least wait until the new stuff has been bedded in before they change it again. I mean, when everyone talks about policy consistency and similar, you've literally just done a whole overview and overhaul of the law. Do it properly, do it once, do it properly, rather than sort of this, again, piecemeal stuff. But also, the worry I think about sort of outright banning it is, what happens if you're buying a bit of land or you want to develop a bit of land that you've had to buy from, you know, local iwi or whatever it might be, That might be one of their conditions. I'll sell it to you, but you've got to do this. I mean, if people want to enter in that.
00:11:41
Speaker 2: But they'll do that, Brad, anyway. That would be okay because it's part of the negotiation between the parties.
00:11:48
Speaker 4: Yeah.
00:11:49
Speaker 2: And that's fine. But with council sticking it as a condition of the consent, that seems to me... And this is not even to do with maridom or anything. It's just like if somebody's saying it's part of the thing, you've got to get the pope in to do a blessing or something. Spirituality and stuff... You know, don't shove it down anyone's throat. We're a secular country. So broadly speaking, I'm not going to be voting on this, but broadly speaking, I agree with it.
00:12:13
Speaker 4: Richard?
00:12:14
Speaker 2: Yeah, look, government interference again. Just stay out.
00:12:18
Speaker 3: Get people on and do it. If it's culturally significant, have some involvement. Compulsion isn't good for anyone in some of these areas, particularly this.
00:12:26
Speaker 2: Well, any further comment there, Brad? You've gone on what you look like. Don't ask me another question. No, no, no.
00:12:33
Speaker 4: It's just one of those things where I sort of go, like, look, I take all the points, but I also go, I feel like there are going to be so many edge cases where I go at the same time as, yes, it might be good to get government out of this stuff. Having government have to insert itself to rule itself out is sort of inserting itself, and then it creates all sorts of edge cases.
00:12:51
Speaker 2: It's central government ruling out councils being a pain.
00:12:54
Speaker 3: I mean, government should provide frameworks and guardrails and get people on to doing the business between the two parties. That's how it is for me. I think this is about talking to the audience, actually. It's not really moving the dial.
00:13:07
Speaker 2: No, it's not going to shift the dial. No, but anyway.
00:13:10
Speaker 4: We can agree on that.
00:13:11
Speaker 2: Yeah, there we go. Oh, we can agree on that. That was a passive aggression there from Bradford.
00:13:17
Speaker 3: Well, he's in the Wairarapa, which is Mike Butterick and Kieran McAnulty country, I think.
00:13:22
Speaker 2: Anyway, hey, look, we'll be back in a moment. Look, speaking of cultural sensitivity or otherwise, there's been a development or some further news around what may or may not happen with Chateau Tongariro. And we're going to ask these guys whether they think we should take steps to preserve it or do what the iwi want, which is to bowl it. Yes, indeed. Welcome back to the show. And my panellists today are Richard Lindrews and Brad Olsen. Now, guys, there's been a bit of some more news develop around the Chateau Tongariro. And Mayor Weston Curtin is calling for a commitment to restore the chateau. An OIA from Newstalk CB revealed that iwi want to demolish it. whereas dock want to keep it because of the importance as well to visitor, you know, just to hold the whole tourism thing and to keep the visitor sort of capacity up. And eventually, of course, no one can stay there at the moment. My opening comment would be, I just sort of think it is like, you know, I mean, it seems to be this thing about just because it's of European heritage, it's not valued as much. But I think of the generations of people, whether they be New Zealanders or people from overseas, The chateau is now a part of that landscape. And I actually think, you know, if they can spend $ 55 million on Tomatatini over a couple of years, let's spend some money on restoring the chateau. And I think it is, I've got some fun facts about it, but that's where I'm at. I really think we should do whatever to keep it. It would be an absolute shame if they got rid of it. What's the state of it now?
00:14:57
Speaker 3: Is it in disrepair?
00:14:58
Speaker 2: Well, it's the
earthquake thing. Okay. So it's going to cost upwards of $ 100 million. Why does it cost so bloody much to do all these things? Anyway, $ 100 million to fix it and get it back up and running, which is a lot of money. It's a lot of money. What do you reckon, Brad?
00:15:16
Speaker 4: Well, I mean, they've already spent $ 4. 5 million in just the last, what, three years or so to keep it operational, doing nothing to stop it getting sort of into further disrepair. So Oh, look, I think on one hand, I genuinely think there's probably better uses of 100 mil in terms of what else it could do around the country for either other vital infrastructure or similar. Like at the moment, I'm not feeling like, by goodness, the tourism sector is not going well. And if we just had the Chateau, it would just be amazeballs. Like that's, it's a lot of money for potentially not the immediate payoff. But the other point, right, is that this looks like it's going to go to a private investor to look after and to fund in some way. I do think government's got to be pretty cautious here given the number of different projects that have been announced with a claim and there's all this money going to happen and then they've sat there for a couple of years and done nothing and there's all sorts of excuses that come through over the funding's not available or it's a bit hard to do this or it's a bit hard to do that or it's not the right time. So I think government's got to be cautious that yes, it looks like it's got a good proposal on the table but they've also got to have, I think, some pretty sharp teeth there that yes, you've either got to get this going or actually, sorry, we're going to have to pull the pin and we might have to bowl it because I don't know if keeping on life support for 10 years or so is going to be any worth.
00:16:28
Speaker 2: Well, how much did we spend on just that major events package? $ 70 million or something? To bring Robbie Williams over here, who is already coming, and a few questionable allocations of money. I'd rather see all that cancelled and stick some money. Well, not all of it, but let's take a chunk, give it to the Chateau.
00:16:46
Speaker 3: There needs to be a good business case for this. I think decisions have to be made a lot quicker than drifting along.
00:16:53
Speaker 2: Where are your sentiments? Keep it or get rid of it? Keep it, but I need a business case.
00:16:57
Speaker 3: You made a point there, it was quite interesting, about the major events, boost funding. The Minister, Upston, has come out with the support of Glen Bennett Labour, bipartisanship, working with a major event review. There's now a clear pathway for a national event strategy, trade and business involved.
00:17:15
Speaker 2: That is good. That could be an outcome. Depends what they spend it on, you know. I mean, that's the thing. And I'm always suspicious of bureaucrats deciding where money should go because, well, the track record ain't great, is it? Yeah.
00:17:26
Speaker 4: I was going to say, am I too much of a whinger, Tim, to say that I probably wouldn't put any money into the shadow. I also wouldn't pay for Robbie Williams or other acts to come here. Realistically, if you're going to do that from a government point of view, give me my money back in taxes and I'll decide myself if it's worthwhile to go there.
00:17:43
Speaker 2: You sound like an activist.
00:17:45
Speaker 3: I don't know what he's going between left and right in terms of what party he is. But look, the government and Glenn Bennett from Labour have come out and done a really good thing.
00:17:54
Speaker 2: This major events review.
00:17:56
Speaker 3: is given a clear pathway, native event strategy involving trade of business, payback periods, that is good. And if they adopt those changes, we're going to actually be moving in the right direction rather than ad hoc event-based decisions.
00:18:08
Speaker 2: Can I share with you guys a really fun fact?
00:18:10
Speaker 4: Yeah, get us to your fun facts. I might ask you. You've been waiting then twice.
00:18:13
Speaker 2: Have you stayed at the Chateau? Of course I've stayed at the Chateau. And I used to go, a mate of mine, There you go. I'll give his first name, Paul. He's a very successful business guy now. He was the manager of food and beverages for, I don't know who ran it. Was it THC at one stage? He was manager of food and beverages when he was 18. That's not the fun fact because he wasn't even old enough to drink. And I said, hey, mate, you're not even old enough to be in the bar. And he goes, shush, bro. But here's the thing. How long do you reckon it took to build the Chateau? And do you know, without Googling it, how long do you reckon it would have taken to build the Chateau?
00:18:46
Speaker 4: Five years.
00:18:47
Speaker 1: Yeah.
00:18:47
Speaker 2: Okay. Five years. Okay. Ready for the drum roll? It took five and a half months. Oh, how good. You know, and that's why you look at it and you go $ 100 million to restore it. Okay, I know that there's different issues around work safety and all that sort of thing. They took five and a half months from laying the foundation stone to opening it.
00:19:10
Speaker 4: So why the hell has it taken three years for it to sit there and do nothing?
00:19:13
Speaker 1: I know.
00:19:14
Speaker 2: This is the thing.
00:19:15
Speaker 4: Five and a half months.
00:19:17
Speaker 3: Yeah, but that's the New Zealand disease. We don't have the decision. We don't do things at pace.
00:19:22
Speaker 2: Anyway, you can text in, hands up, who wasn't surprised. You might have known this, but everyone I say this to, they always go, I don't know, four or five years, five and a half months. I'll tell you what, in the old days.
00:19:32
Speaker 4: If the government funds it, am I allowed one free stay, or is that sort of I have to pay for it, but I don't get it myself?
00:19:39
Speaker 2: Look, I'd shout you, you know. We might have to top and
tail, but, you know. God, I'm random today. Anyway, look, let's move on, guys. Wellington Council are being prosecuted for Moa Point wastewater disaster Who's at fault? So, yeah, the Wellington Regional Council prosecuting Wellington City Council over this disastrous failure at Moa Point. If you need refreshing, billions of litres of raw sewage spilled into the city's south coast since it flooded in February. The ratepayer's going to be picking up a bit of the tab. One organisation suing another. I need the economics on what does this mean for the average punter in Wellington, Brad?
00:20:23
Speaker 4: I suspect it means money going from one coffer to another. Look, it wasn't surprising to see Greater Wellington start to prosecute Wellington City Council. To be fair, there does have to be something on record for sending poo into the harbour. You can't sort of just get away scot-free. realistically, I don't think it's the sort of thing where the fine's going to be enormous, enormous, but you've got to have something coming through. I guess my worry is more than, okay, so you've got this, you've got now umpteen dozen studies that have been done or similar. Will this change the risk appetite? Because like the design, right? The idea of prosecuting should be that you sort of scare everyone into not wanting to do such dumb stuff again. I want it at work. I'm not sure.
00:21:06
Speaker 2: Well, the thing is, no individuals pay the price for this stuff. It's just one body suing another. I mean, remember when Tamatha Paul came out outraged about it, and yet she chaired the committee which was responsible for infrastructure and three waters, you know, before that.
00:21:20
Speaker 4: Yeah, I mean, to be fair, I think this one's built up over time, though.
00:21:24
Speaker 2: No, but I mean, she pretended she didn't know. You know, like, oh, this is a shock to me. How do you not... Anyway, look, let's not have a crack at her, maybe. Richard?
00:21:32
Speaker 4: Well, this.
00:21:33
Speaker 3: It goes back to your opening question about, you know, having ambition for this country and policies, et cetera. This is an investment in basic infrastructure. This is third world stuff. You know, we've got to be ambitious in this country, but you've got to have the foundations of good infrastructure on it. And, you know, I don't mind a prosecution. Not an issue I have, but like Brad was saying, it's the ratepayers paying twice. They're paying once to fix the problem and two in terms of the prosecution and time wasting this is taking place.
00:22:00
Speaker 2: I feel sorry for the average punter who is playing for the rates and the council rates and all that sort of stuff in Wellington. It's just... It's excessive in Wellington.
00:22:09
Speaker 4: I'd also say, though, look, if you're going to go to the council, Wellington City Council, maybe go the operator as well, because to be fair, they seem to be just as in the mix with this stuff. And so far, I haven't seen their name on any court documents either.
00:22:22
Speaker 2: Hey, look, I thought I might approach this next one with a slightly different angle. So New Zealand's been accused by this Dutch environmental group of breaking its climate change promises. I mean, to be honest, I mean, it doesn't really resonate a lot with me. The Trade Minister said it's not for overseas countries, organisations and lobby groups to tell New Zealand how to meet its obligations. Fair enough. But I've just got a simple question for you guys. Are you more conscious of the environment in terms of your output and what you do, even just in terms of recycling food, plastic, whatever? You know, getting on your scooter and catching the train in Auckland on the CRL, which I'm going to rave about till the cows come home. Of course, you've got trains and everything in Wellington. You've had it for ages, Brad. Have you got anything you do that can inspire the people who are listening to save the planet?
00:23:08
Speaker 4: Oh, I mean, I try to do the usual day to day. And I think that's the thing, right? Some of this is now just baseline, like recycling that should just be a normal one. I'm also not going to lie, though. I clearly have to fly across the country quite a lot to go through and, you know, see parts of the economy. But importantly, we have schemes that deal with that. All of my domestic flights are covered by the emissions trading scheme. So in terms of policy, we've actually got some pretty solid stuff here. I do think, though, this challenge, though, that the EU sort of, or that's coming out of the EU, says that I don't actually think we're in the wrong here, and I think we still do have better outcomes coming through than the Europeans, but we've got to be cautious. I mean, you talk to what's happening with some of our trading partners. They care a lot about this as well. Getting offside with them makes it that little bit harder to put New Zealand goods out across the world, and so I think it's a wake-up call for us.
00:23:58
Speaker 2: Richard, did you get the e-bus in here today?
00:24:00
Speaker 4: No, I didn't.
00:24:00
Speaker 3: I don't think it was a wake-up call, Brad. I mean, catastrophe porn.
00:24:05
Speaker 2: Isn't it?
00:24:06
Speaker 3: You know, climate, climate, I mean, I like another view on this. I think as New Zealand, we are very sustainable and it's right through our businesses and our daily life. So good spotting there, Brad. But I think if we want to actually, we all know that we have to do the reduction net emissions and we're doing it. It's just how we go about doing it. We need to double down on some of our climate tech and to reduce emissions to be more competitive than less.
00:24:32
Speaker 2: Yeah. Actually, you know what? I do, I love the, idea, and I hope that it ends up working. I like the fact that we are, you know, the human race. We're pretty clever at innovating on things as well, and some of the scientific advancements, even
just in the farming space with the types of feed that produce less methane and all that sort of stuff. And I do get a bit tired of the Greens having a crack at farmers all the time. Well, I mean, why couldn't they have a crack at my appointment in Wellington? I mean, the greatest polluters in this country aren't farmers. They're urban city dwellers. You did that pretty quickly, moved on on that topic.
00:25:04
Speaker 4: I mean.
00:25:06
Speaker 3: agri-business in New Zealand are very sustainable.
00:25:09
Speaker 2: So we'll just leave it there. You are feisty today, Richard. Hey, look, he's freshened.
00:25:14
Speaker 3: I think we just move on too quickly on some things where we need to pull out.
00:25:18
Speaker 4: Sorry, mate.
00:25:18
Speaker 2: You need to drag me back. Is there something you'd like to follow up?
00:25:21
Speaker 4: I was just going to say, I've seen the run sheet, Tim. I know that it's not because we're moving away from stuff. It's just we've got so many topics we're trying to cover. Because the week's been so busy.
00:25:30
Speaker 2: There might be a few that don't make the grade, actually. You can see where there's a big break in the document there. Those ones are not going to make the grade. We won't mention it, but we'll be back in just a moment because we'll talk about the Rocket Lab protesters in Christchurch for the New Zealand Aerospace Summit. Back soon. 21 minutes to four. Yes, welcome back to the panel with Richard Lindrews and Brad Olsen. Now, guys, the... The Rocket Lab protest is in Christchurch for the New Zealand Aerospace Summit. Look, for one, I still look at that headline and just go, there's a New Zealand Aerospace Summit? It still blows me away. And there's the question around, is the aerospace sector getting too involved with foreign aid and defence? And so there are a couple of men who have been arrested after vehicles blocked emergency entrances to Christchurch's Te Pai Convention Centre. um there are dozens of protesters there opposed to the aerospace industry industries links to defense um anyway we're riding on the car included new zealand complicit in genocide and this car blocks war crimes i mean i guess for every success there's going to be a protest do they have a point i mean rocket lab apparently does you know send up some military payloads what do you reckon brad.
00:26:40
Speaker 4: I think some of these people are just tools um i mean let's be quite blunt the there is an absolute right to protest. Go hard. But the minute you put a car in front of an emergency exit, that there is just reckless. And again, that goes well beyond the pale. I mean, OK, from the point of view that, you know, apparently the aerospace industry might engage better than the defence industry. Don't know if anyone's noticed, New Zealand has a literal defence force. They've got missiles and bombs and weapons and that that blow stuff up anyway. Like, As a country, we seem to be okay with that, and I think that's because we live in the real world here. Are they allowed to protest? Yes, totally. Do we still need the aerospace industry? Very much so, because they're quite important to the economy, and they give us real options in terms of research, development, all sorts of investment. That's where we're going to have the economy coming from in days to come. But look, my frustration there was much more around just I mean, that sort of action of blocking emergency entrances, that is way beyond the pale and says that these are not peaceful protesters, they're pillocks.
00:27:40
Speaker 2: Brad, amen. Richard? Well, you sound like a political candidate there. That was fantastic. Oh, God.
00:27:47
Speaker 3: Look, I just think space infrastructure, you know, this is what about aerospace and, you know, it's an increasing part of national security. Avoiding all defence work may be actually unrealistic, but this is about high-skilled jobs, investment in tech and, New Zealand's strategic capability.
00:28:03
Speaker 2: It's an amazing success story. And it just, look, okay, we shouldn't just blindly go everything's wonderful if there are genuine questions to be asked. But I think people live in this world where, as you say, you put it so well, Brad, that we don't live in a safe world. And actually, we know who our allies are. I would have a problem if Rocket Lab was sending up military assets for China. Okay? I would have a problem with that. But define ethical boundaries. Despite the fact that President Trump is also a complete tool. America and Britain are still our military allies. And you're right. And as you say, blocking emergency exits is silly and a little bit sinister as well, because if something did go on and you've got those tools with their stuff in the way, then I don't know.
00:28:50
Speaker 3: I think New Zealand just needs to be pragmatic about that. I don't think that's... Activism is not sensible protest.
00:28:56
Speaker 4: I think more importantly as well, though, Like, we need to, that's why we have to have our own capabilities at home. You know, that's why we need some of these options, be it for our own Defence Force or for those that we might sort of interact with. I mean, I'm on record, I still think we should need to put a lot more money into Defence because they're the people we turn to when everything, you know, goes to hell in a handbasket. And it is more and more. They're the ones that we call on when there's natural disasters and everything else in between too. I mean, this stuff is important. Shouldn't be protested, it should be celebrated.
00:29:27
Speaker 2: Actually, we have a company in New Zealand that's quite good at building drones, which has made a big difference in Ukraine.
00:29:34
Speaker 4: I think we've got a couple that do components as well, too. Yeah.
00:29:37
Speaker 2: I mean, it does. I mean, it's an amazing success story. I mean, you look at Peter beck's from those humble beginnings with rocket lab to the you
know the the empire that he's built and i just think that it's it's amazing isn't it and we've got our own seriously a new zealand aerospace summit would we have imagined that even five years ago brad i don't well to.
00:29:58
Speaker 4: Be fair yeah i think it has been going probably that long because it's that good but 10 years ago no It is a remarkable accomplishment. It's very cool to have seen the launch site that Rocket Lab have out on the Mahia Peninsula. I can't wait to see what they do next. I think they're very impressive.
00:30:14
Speaker 2: Yeah. Right, we might take a break and we'll be back in just a moment. I'm with Brad Olsen and Richard Lindrews. It is 13 and a half minutes to four, Newstalk ZB. Yes, welcome back. This is, well, we're getting close to wrapping up the panel with Richard Lindrews and Brad Olsen. By the way, for rugby fans, it looks like Canterbury have prevailed over Manawatu, 22-12. So, yeah, a little bit of a tussle there in Palmerston North. It doesn't look like a very nice day there. The uncovered stands are deserted. But anyway, Canterbury will be... Well, I reckon they'd probably rather keep hold of the shield. Who's going to win the shield, do you think? Hawke's Bay and... Counties. Yeah.
00:30:57
Speaker 3: Counties at home.
00:30:58
Speaker 2: They did so well last week. I'm not sure.
00:31:01
Speaker 3: I think Canterbury go to the top of the table there, Tim, with that one.
00:31:03
Speaker 2: Oh, really? Still haven't got the shield, though. Brad, any rugby NPC commentary? Just Olsen on sport?
00:31:11
Speaker 4: I was up in Whangarei last week and watched Northland lose the shield, which was pretty gutting for the one game I made at home for this season. But I think, to be fair, I think counties might lose at Hawke's Bay today. I'm just hoping, though, controversial view, that it goes through and it gets lost to a Heartland team at the start of next year so it can go through some of the others.
00:31:28
Speaker 2: Across the country. I agree. Now, one person who would have enjoyed the victory today, just a quick note. I don't like to say it that way, actually. I just want to note the passing of Phil Gifford, who I was very sad to hear the news about Phil. He was a lovely guy. My wife and I, when we first met, when he and Simon were on More FM, this is years ago, And Phil, and he interviewed me a couple of times with my concerts, but I still remember he used to do an imitation. He'd have different characters we'd interview, they'd interview each other, and Phil would be Louis Leight from Johannesburg with a magnificent yet terrible South African accent. And I remember we used to wake up every morning and just be laughing to start the day with Phil Gifford. But I think he's, you know, loose-head Len, of course, The iconic Auckland rugby supporter moved to Christchurch and suddenly switched to Canterbury. What was that about, Richard?
00:32:24
Speaker 3: He lived in a few different places. He lived in Waihi too. So he was a great man, gone too soon. Just a great New Zealander and such an impact he made on different forms of media too.
00:32:36
Speaker 2: It wasn't just radio. Well, the number of books he wrote. He wrote a lot of books. Anyway, you were probably too young to really... Brad, you are too young to really know too much about Phil.
00:32:55
Speaker 4: Having done a lot of pretty hardcore interviews in my time, even at that point, I thought that was a bit of fun. And the thing that always got me, he enjoyed it. He was so interested in it. He always wanted to have a little sort of side gossip about the stuff alongside the main bits. And I don't know. He was just always pretty fun and engaging to talk to. And I really rated that.
00:33:14
Speaker 2: Yeah. Now, just looking ahead to the week that will be or the weeks that will be, and I'm not sure if we'll be speaking to you guys before the actual election. It might even get you the day. Oh, of course. If you're on election day, we won't be able to. We can't even talk politics. Oh, don't put me on. We have to talk about, you know, what Florida Tim Tams you like. We've been talking about it for months. Hey, are you going to go to, I'll ask you first, Richard, are you going to go to any political debates? Because I'd love to go to a local one. In Tamaki.
00:33:44
Speaker 3: Well, I had one last week at Mystery Creek, Field Day Society. We had Heather Dupas-Helen with all the rural ag.
00:33:50
Speaker 2: It was fantastic.
00:33:51
Speaker 3: 400 mature adults in a room having good discussion with no protest in action.
00:33:57
Speaker 2: It was just good debate. No sledging people from alternative points of view? Just quality debate. No, it was excellent, actually.
00:34:04
Speaker 3: So we've had one at Mystery Creek last week. Heather Dupas-Helen did that well.
00:34:08
Speaker 2: Anyone's minds changed, do you think?
00:34:10
Speaker 4: Oh, no.
00:34:10
Speaker 3: No, but it was a good debate, and yeah, it was good.
00:34:14
Speaker 2: Who was the least impressive from your point of view? Oh, don't put me on that. No, no, no. What? The most impressive was McLean.
00:34:21
Speaker 1: Oh, well.
00:34:22
Speaker 4: Oh, if you give a positive, you've got to give a negative.
00:34:24
Speaker 2: Okay, fair enough. Who sucked? Well, each had enough time.
00:34:28
Speaker 3: I thought Steve Abel from The Green spoke very well until he went down some rabbit holes, but Steve still had a beer with everyone at the end.
00:34:36
Speaker 2: Well, that's the thing. Okay, who sucked, though? Come on. Who didn't do well. No, he's not going to say it. He's not going to say it. He's going to let her off the hook. Brad?
00:34:47
Speaker 4: I don't know if I would. I mean, look, I feel like I'm too much of a tragic for this stuff that I'm already, you know, I just about watch every different debate there is.
00:34:56
Speaker 2: Did you watch the little, the minor parties?
00:34:58
Speaker 4: The Kingmakers.
00:34:59
Speaker 2: Yeah, that one.
00:35:00
Speaker 4: I mean, it was the only way they could get Winston Peters on was not to call it the minor leaders debate. They had to call it the Kingmakers. Of course.
00:35:08
Speaker 2: I had a watch.
00:35:09
Speaker 4: Again, I actually thought that was a pretty good debate and fairly vital because of how important that vote for not the two major parties is. I mean, I'm interested in how both the Chrises go this week with, you know, one of the leaders' debates coming up, only because Jack Tame... He would scare the heck out of me being an interviewer for something. I mean, he's on his game. He knows his stuff. I'm worried these guys are going to show up with too many slogans and not enough detail.
00:35:33
Speaker 2: Just answer the question. Look, I had Simeon Brown on my show last week, and he's on message, but I actually said to him during the interview, I said, if you say party vote national one more, I'm going to fine you. I literally said that to him. I was going to get my producer to have a buzzer. Every time he said it, we're going to go, ah. But I thought that might have been maybe getting a little bit too A bit too random. A mate of mine who is not particularly interested in the right-wing side of politics, he watched the Mount Albert one, and he said he was, he told me, he said, I actually thought the guy, the person who stood out the most, he was really impressed with the ACT candidate. He's like, I'm a bit conflicted because, you know, not a big fan of them, but he seemed like a really nice guy and really smart and switched on. But anyway, look, you know, it's the season to, I don't know why I can't finish that phrase. Help me out with it. Anyway, hey, Richard, thanks for joining us, mate. Great to see you again. And Brad, always good, mate.
00:36:31
Speaker 1: For more from The Weekend Collective, listen live to Newstalk ZB weekends from 3pm or follow the podcast on iHeartRadio.