TRANSCRIPCIÓN 🔗
[0:01] If you're applying for disability benefits or help people that are, the path to success
[0:05] has never been more complicated.
[0:07] Welcome to the Disability Expert Podcast, where we tackle the difficult issues and interview
[0:11] the country's top experts to help you better navigate the disability process.
[0:16] Winning a disability case is hard and keeps getting tougher every day.
[0:19] We can't promise you'll win your case by listening, but we sure think it's going to help.
[0:24] This really isn't that complicated.
[0:26] I mean, you want to win your case, don't you?
[0:29] Well then listen to what I say.
[0:31] Hey, it's Chad Brown, welcome to another episode of the Disability Expert Podcast,
[0:35] where we dive into all things disability, it's up here.
[0:39] Hey, ready to talk about an important topic?
[0:41] I know they all are, but this one today is especially.
[0:43] I mean, it really is, honestly, I think, in terms of things that are within your control,
[0:49] it might be the most important thing you can do to not kill your disability case.
[0:58] So we were joking earlier that there should be an 11th commandment that I'll
[1:03] shall comply with your doctor's orders.
[1:08] So we're going to talk about noncompliance today.
[1:09] We talk about noncompliance a lot in the course of the different episodes,
[1:14] because you can't really, you can't talk about building medical records,
[1:19] or, you know, going to the doctor, smoking, alcohol, medical,
[1:24] you can't talk about anything without sort of touching on compliance,
[1:27] but I don't think we've ever stopped and talked about what actually does it mean in disability case?
[1:33] What are the actual rules related to why a judge can use noncompliance to deny your case?
[1:38] And then, practically, how noncompliance factors into most cases.
[1:43] So I thought we'd stop and do that today.
[1:44] I think to start with, people need to understand there's a very technical failing to follow
[1:49] prescribed treatment regulation that in a very summary way says if the medical problem you have
[2:01] could be managed with medication or treatment or whatever it is.
[2:06] And that's a wonder and you don't comply with it.
[2:09] You can't win your case.
[2:10] Think that's fair.
[2:12] Okay, so, but we have federal court practice, too.
[2:16] And we review lots and lots of, I don't know how many unfavorable decisions we review a year,
[2:19] it's hundreds, if not more.
[2:21] And it's very, very rare that you see a judge write a decision that says,
[2:27] well, I really think they're disabled, but they have failed to follow,
[2:30] they have failed to follow prescribed treatment.
[2:33] I'm going to reassess it.
[2:34] I do a full reassessment of what would happen if treatment was complied with.
[2:39] And now I'm going to deny them.
[2:40] Almost never happens.
[2:42] Yeah, I don't, I don't, I don't remember, I don't, I don't,
[2:45] I'm sure there are decisions that are said to have it.
[2:47] I don't, I don't remember anyone for sort of context.
[2:51] It's similar to drug and alcohol abuse or the whole specific set of rules about drug
[2:56] and alcohol abuse that basically you have to evaluate the person not using drugs and alcohol,
[3:00] then you have to evaluate them using drugs and alcohol and sort of write to completely separate decisions.
[3:05] And so just the starting point is you do have to follow prescribed medical treatment
[3:11] in order to win your disability case.
[3:14] If failing to follow prescribed medical treatment would leave you such that you could work competitively
[3:22] at the workplace.
[3:24] Yeah, I mean, it's just not a very clear, very, but that's not the reality of what happens.
[3:30] That's where you get into the situation where you're like, well,
[3:34] you need to follow the treatment and they're like, well, I'll lose my case if I don't.
[3:38] And technically, the answer would be you very well could if the judge just sort of went down that road.
[3:46] That's not actually what really happens in most cases.
[3:49] What happens in most cases is, and just to stop there's like a failing to follow prescribed treatment without good cause.
[3:57] How good cause? There's always an exception.
[3:59] Yeah. And so there are reasons for you to failing to follow prescribed treatment.
[4:03] Cost is the main one, you know, questioning whether it would actually improve.
[4:08] Because now it's it's only that you have to follow the prescribed treatment following the prescribed treatment
[4:14] have to improve your medical condition.
[4:16] Says that you were able to work, but that's not how most cases are cited.
[4:21] Most cases are decided based on the secondary question of does failing to follow prescribed treatment
[4:30] mean that you're not credible or that your medical condition is really not that severe.
[4:36] So talk a little bit about in your experience, what are judges doing?
[4:40] And we're going to go through a bunch of examples.
[4:41] By the way, that's what this episode is mostly about if I ever get to it.
[4:45] We're going to go through some examples, some clear examples of issues that come up in everyday cases.
[4:50] But just generally when you're reviewing unfavorable decisions,
[4:52] when you're reviewing favorable decisions, how do you see compliance actually evaluated by the judge
[4:59] in hearings, like what actually is happening?
[5:01] So let's start with the hearing sort of moving chronologically.
[5:04] So at the hearing, you know, the judge is going to be asking questions like,
[5:09] you know, I see that your doctor prescribed such and such medication.
[5:14] Are you taking that medication all the time?
[5:17] Are you taking it sometimes?
[5:19] You know, why aren't you taking it all the time?
[5:21] Or, you know, I see that the doctor referred you out to this specialist.
[5:25] Why didn't you go?
[5:26] And so what the judge is really doing is
Load full transcript
trying to figure out,
[5:31] are there those good reasons for not following the treatment?
[5:35] Is it due to cost?
[5:37] Is it due to religious objections?
[5:39] You know, sometimes is it that you don't understand due to a mental impairment,
[5:43] what the treatment is supposed to be?
[5:46] In the decision how that usually plays out is the judge writes the RFC
[5:52] and then spends five or six pages talking about all the things that you did not do.
[5:57] And so it's sort of an accounting of your shortcomings as a patient.
[6:01] And so you're reading that and the judge might never actually say noncompliance
[6:06] in that decision, but you're reading it and you're like,
[6:09] oh, the judge didn't believe the testimony about the symptom severity
[6:13] because the judge thinks, well, if your symptoms were that severe,
[6:16] you would have done what the doctor told you to do.
[6:18] And so you end up with this sort of gap.
[6:22] And it's sort of like, well, they haven't seen a specialist.
[6:26] But we know from the file that there was a recommendation that they go to a specialist
[6:30] that they chose not to go to.
[6:32] We also know that they chose not to go
[6:33] because they didn't have medical insurance and they couldn't afford it.
[6:37] So a lot of times there's these sort of,
[6:39] I would call them omissions in the record and in the decision that is.
[6:44] And the omission is pointing to something
[6:47] that the judge felt was important.
[6:49] You didn't take a medication, you didn't see a doctor,
[6:54] you didn't stop smoking, you didn't stop drinking,
[6:56] you didn't go to the gym, you continue to use alcohol, whatever it is,
[7:01] which all have their own range of issues in and of themselves.
[7:05] But what you see is in the decision is the judge is looking,
[7:08] is the judge is telling you a lot by what they sometimes don't tell you.
[7:14] And the key is understanding that if you had the ability
[7:20] to look down the tunnel of time, right?
[7:22] And know what you're just, which is whether he says you buy it out of higher lawyer
[7:25] because lawyers are pretty good at looking down the tunnel of disability decision time
[7:29] and telling you where these things are going to end up.
[7:32] If you're able to look down the tunnel of time,
[7:34] what you would do is you would stop at the beginning and say,
[7:37] okay, these are the things the doctors telling me I need to do.
[7:42] One, the easiest thing to do, just do them.
[7:45] Just do it.
[7:46] Right, yeah, just, I mean, Bojack, we have a Bojackson episode, right?
[7:51] Bono's disability cases.
[7:54] So the easiest way is just to comply,
[7:57] just to do what they're asking you to do.
[8:01] Sometimes that's not really what maybe you want to do
[8:03] or that's convenient for you to do.
[8:06] The second thing I would tell people looking down the tunnel of time
[8:09] of the disability denial that's coming your way
[8:12] for dog compliance is if you're not going to do what they tell you to do,
[8:16] you need to document why.
[8:17] Yes.
[8:18] Because noncompliance in and of itself is not an indicator
[8:23] that you're sort of noncompliant as a person, that you're difficult.
[8:27] It's not necessarily an indicator that you don't have levels of severity
[8:31] that you say you do.
[8:33] But without explanation that you leave open,
[8:38] you sort of leave open that inference from the facts.
[8:41] And we want to avoid that.
[8:42] And we avoid that by giving very, very solid reasons
[8:45] for why you didn't do the thing your doctor told you.
[8:50] Okay, so let's go through some specific examples
[8:54] because we're sort of talking around this.
[8:55] And let's just go back to medications.
[8:57] Because I think one of the biggest issues we see
[9:00] in cases is medication noncompliance.
[9:03] It is prescribed treatment because they have to write a prescription for the medication.
[9:07] And they're going to recommend that you use it.
[9:09] And they're going to write you the prescription.
[9:10] And then you don't take it.
[9:12] So walk through like what are some reasons
[9:16] that you might not take medication?
[9:18] And how do you go about sort of mitigating the damage
[9:22] that comes in that scenario?
[9:23] So let's just talk to you.
[9:24] Because I think it's probably the most the most prevalent one that we do.
[9:27] Yeah, I think we see the medications the most often.
[9:30] So one one that I hear pretty frequently is,
[9:33] well, the medication didn't work.
[9:35] So I stopped taking it.
[9:38] The better thing to do is to tell your doctor the medication's not working
[9:43] and work with your provider to figure out, okay,
[9:45] do we need to change the dose?
[9:47] Do we need to change the medication?
[9:49] Same thing with side effects.
[9:50] Some medications have really bad side effects.
[9:52] You might be thinking, oh, this is worse than the thing I'm taking the medication for.
[9:56] That's fine.
[9:57] Tell your doctor.
[9:58] They will stop the prescription and change it for you.
[10:01] But don't just go cold turkey and say, well,
[10:03] I'm throwing this bottle out.
[10:04] It's not working.
[10:06] The other thing that comes flat around beside that is cost.
[10:11] And this is a bigger theme with medical treatment as a whole,
[10:15] but often non-compliance is directly related to cost.
[10:19] So what do you tell people?
[10:21] How do you deal with that scenario?
[10:23] Best case scenario, what I like to see when I'm reviewing a record
[10:27] if we're going to be talking about cost.
[10:29] I like to see it where we know how much it's going to cost.
[10:33] And it's in the record that, oh, this medication's
[10:35] going to cost $500 a month or $700 each injection or whatever it is.
[10:40] And you're telling your provider, I cannot afford that.
[10:43] We've got to do something different.
[10:45] That sets us up very well for
[10:49] arguing that
the compliance is related to cost.
[10:52] What I don't like to see in the records is nothing.
[10:57] The doctor prescribed it.
[10:59] And I can see that the prescription was not filled.
[11:02] And I don't know why.
[11:03] And I don't know how much it would have cost you out of pocket.
[11:06] Because what the judge is going to look at that and think in the judge's mind is,
[11:10] oh, well, this was a common prescription.
[11:15] And the judge might assume, oh, well, you could have done good Rx
[11:18] or something and gotten it for $5 a month.
[11:20] And then the judge is going to go through and look at all the other things
[11:23] that you're spending money on and say, well, you know,
[11:27] if you were really serious, maybe you would have spent
[11:30] what I think is going to be $5 a month, because we don't actually know
[11:34] on the medication instead of on, you know, going out to eat or whatever it is.
[11:39] Right. I mean, I think there's a couple of pieces there you have to unpack.
[11:42] One is cost is relative.
[11:46] So a medication that's very expensive for one person who does not have insurance,
[11:51] who cannot get a good Rx coupon to knock the price down to $10 or $15 or $20 or whatever it is.
[11:58] To another person who has good health insurance and that medication is $40 a month
[12:04] and they're in a household that makes $50,000 a year, it becomes almost inexcusable
[12:08] than the judge's eyes. So to start with, you need to establish what the cost is.
[12:12] Then you have to establish what the cost is relative to your client's actual facts.
[12:17] Then you get into this additional issue of your specific facts,
[12:21] but also how you spend other money. We didn't we didn't episode once
[12:25] on whether you should apply for disability or not. I mean, I've been in that episode.
[12:29] But one of the things that's difficult is so let's just say your client needs a medication
[12:34] and they don't have medical insurance, but they can get the medication on good Rx for $80 a month.
[12:39] It's not really cheap, but $80 a month.
[12:42] Right. And they're like, well, I don't have a job and I don't have any income.
[12:45] And the judge starts asking them all of these questions like, well, do you smoke?
[12:50] Not where you smoke. How much do you smoke? I don't know. I smoke two packs a week.
[12:55] So I smoke eight packs a month. So how much does cigarettes cost? Mr. Client who's
[12:59] non-compliant and not doing the thing your doctor told you and is here asking me for disability
[13:03] because you say you can't get better. Even if they don't say that, that's what they think.
[13:08] And you will fill that. You will fill. You are in the hot seat.
[13:12] Yeah, it is not comfortable. It's like, well, you know, I love the people who all of a sudden
[13:17] become cigarette rollers. Like a robot. Maybe the case. And if you do roll your own and you're spending,
[13:24] you know, $20 a month for tobacco and I
don't know, I don't know, it's the exact cost, but whatever.
[13:29] You're rolling your own. Okay, well, that may make sense, you know, but if you're out here going
[13:34] last month, Marble Reds and a $12 pack, well, you just spend a hundred dollars a month on cigarettes.
[13:38] And the judge is like, well, now we're in a different cat question of, then you're all
[13:44] doctor also take a quick smoking, right? And so what you understand is you're making lifestyle choices,
[13:50] but your lifestyle choices that you make and how you spend your money are going to be evaluated.
[13:54] Yes, fair, not fair. Doesn't matter. They're going to do it. And so I think with medication, it's one,
[14:01] you know, can you, this cost analysis is the cost of the meds cost to your relevant situation. Do you
[14:07] have interest? Do you not have insurance? And then also how are you using the money that you have?
[14:12] Because if the doctor looks at it, if the judge looks at it and says, well, it can't be that serious,
[14:16] because you'd rather smoke than then take the medication. And that, I mean, that really hurts your case.
[14:21] The second thing that goes with that is effort. So it's not just can you afford it. What
[14:26] efforts did you make to obtain the medication in a cost you could afford? So it's, you know, good
[14:34] RX and some of these places have sort of prescription coupons for lack of a better word. But sometimes
[14:41] there's free samples, not as much as there used to be, but there used to be free samples.
[14:45] You know, did you apply for Medicaid? You know, did you go to the, you know, there's literally like
[14:51] 50 foundations in the country that give people medication for free? Did you, did you go to your doctor
[14:56] and say, I can't afford this medication or other alternatives? And the doctor said, well, you know,
[15:00] we use the lily hope foundation or whatever it is. And I think people can get this medication for
[15:06] freeing like, I don't know if it's application. Like that doesn't, so the reality is is that, yes,
[15:12] it, it's, it's, it may very well be plausible that you could not take the medication, but understand,
[15:18] it's not as simple as you saying I couldn't afford it. It's never that simple. Even if we don't go
[15:23] through this sort of extended conversation and the hearing, the reality is, is that the judge,
[15:31] I mean, these aren't unique thoughts. Like we didn't just come up with this on the fly for this
[15:35] episode. This is because I've said in all of these hearings where judges question their effort,
[15:41] they question their income, they question their insurance, they question their, you know, how they
[15:47] spent their money, you know, and the reality is is that's how that's going to be assessed. I think
[15:54] medication is the biggest issue non-compliance that we see. It is prescribed. And the reality is is that
[15:59] very often due to advances in medications, often the medication is effective. And so if you
[16:06] are left saying, well, I don't know if it had been effective or not, you know, and the judge is like,
[16:11] well, I mean, I see 400 clients a year, I see 400 cases a year and like, you know, I don't ever see
[16:16] this problem with people who took that medicine, it doesn't get better. Now, are they supposed to
[16:20] do that? Absolutely not, but they do. Right? And so I think that's, I think that's a real issue. So
[16:26] let's hit a few other ones out too, because I think some of them are a little less clear,
[16:29] recommended surgery. What about that? This one's interesting. I think we get a little bit more wiggle room
[16:34] with recommended surgery just because, you know, it's one thing to say, well, take the medication,
[16:39] see if it works, if not, you can always stop taking the medication. It's really hard to
[16:43] unsurgery a surgery that didn't work. And so the judges, I think, by and large are more understanding,
[16:50] especially we see this with back cases a lot. Maybe you had, you know, the initial surgery where
[16:56] they go in and shave the disc. That didn't work. They go in and shave the disc again. That didn't work.
[17:01] Now you're looking at a fusion and you're thinking, well, the first two didn't work. Do I really want
[17:05] to go through this again? Or maybe you've had a fusion already and they're talking about going in
[17:10] and doing more levels. That's a much better position to be in to explain to the judge. You know,
[17:15] I really, I tried it. I don't want to do more surgeries or you had a close friend or
[17:20] relative who had the same surgery and you've seen, oh my goodness, they got worse. And being able to
[17:26] explain that to the judge, I think they're more open. Yeah. I think for sure, especially, we see
[17:33] a lot of back surgery, knee replacements, hip replacements, sort of major weight bearing joint
[17:38] surgeries. A lot of times, you know, the doctor's not going to promise you you're going to get better.
[17:43] And sometimes you actually can get worse. Sometimes we see it with the residuals of traumatic
[17:50] accidents or someone has a horrific ankle injury. And now they're like, hey, we want to go in and
[17:55] basically fuse your ankle and, you know, do X, Y and Z. And you're like, God, it's, you know,
[18:00] it's just no guarantee you're going to walk any better, but you may actually be worse.
[18:05] Um, you know, I think with those issues, it's not as difficult. What about sort of lifestyle
[18:15] recommendations? Because a lot of times you see, and we've hit on this already, stop smoking,
[18:19] stop drinking, lose weight, those are the big ones. How are those actually handled under the rules?
[18:23] Because technically they're not, they're typically not, they're not prescribed treatment. So it's not
[18:28] a failure to follow the prescribed treatment per se, even though it could be, we'll talk about
that.
[18:35] So how do you deal with those issues? Like you said, usually we're not seeing those in a failure
[18:39] to follow prescribed treatment. Generally, the judge is looking at that more of a credibility issue.
[18:45] So the judge is is going to say, well, you know, the doctor recommended that you stop smoking and
[18:50] stop drinking. You didn't. Therefore, I don't believe that this was actually that bad.
[18:57] Um, some lifestyle recommendations though, like weight loss, uh, we can explain, well, judge,
[19:05] I've got two bad knees and a bad back. I cannot go to the gym to try to lose the weight. And it's sort
[19:10] of this vicious cycle of, I gain weight because I'm not active, but I can't be active because of my
[19:15] other severe impairments. Right. And I think it's important, but it's not just important for us to say
[19:21] that. Right. Like it's got to be documented. And we're back to the same things we're always talking
[19:25] about is it's got to be in the medical record. But it doesn't need to be in the medical record
[19:29] just as your statement. It needs to be in the metal record in terms of, okay, the doctor told you
[19:34] to lose weight. You have, you need to lose weight because you need to have knee replacement. But
[19:39] you got knee issues because in part because of the weight. And so you go to the Y twice and you
[19:45] ended up in a recliner for seven days. And so, and so I'm the first person that hears that in your
[19:52] pre hearing, it's like, oh, come on, please tell me you told me, I didn't see that anywhere in the
[19:57] medical record. It's because, well, why does it tell? But you got to tell them, you got to get it in
[20:02] the record. And then today though, you get into some of these other issues. And honestly, I don't
[20:07] mean know how they would fare. I mean, so you're severely obese and they want to put you on
[20:13] GLP one or some of these weight loss medications. If they recommend that and you don't do it, is that
[20:20] now not a lifestyle modification? Is that failure to follow prescribed medication? Are you thoughts
[20:26] on that? I think it could be considered failure to follow prescribed medication. I do think though with
[20:33] with what might be called experimental treatments or treatments that are are still new. I do think
[20:39] they get a little bit more leeway. So if you're talking to your doctor when the doctor says, you know,
[20:44] I'd like you to try GLP one and you say, well, I've read all these headlines or I've, you know,
[20:49] my cousin tried it and now they have all these problems. And it's a new drug that's probably going
[20:54] to carry more weight with the judge, especially if it's documented in the record. Yeah, but once again
[20:58] that's the key phrase. Is it documented in the record as to why you don't want to pursue that? So
[21:06] I think, I think generally when you look at noncompliance with whether it be medicines or surgeries
[21:13]
or lifestyle modifications, which are really more recommendations and then prescribed treatment,
[21:20] the reality is is that we save cases with good calls. Good calls cost certainly good calls, but as we
[21:31] talked about earlier, it's not necessarily that simple. Disagreement, some of those are disagreement
[21:37] with medical sources. One doctor thinks you should, we had a case not long ago, we were, I think,
[21:42] yesterday one doctor said they should be on oxygen. Now their doctor said they shouldn't be on
[21:46] oxygen. Okay, I don't think that's a great example for in terms of what builds a case, but there was a
[21:52] disagreement in the record because we said we talked about yesterday because we're trying to
[21:55] fare word of appeal or not. Um, middle and capacity is one, I don't think we've, we've hit on enough,
[22:00] I don't want to spend a ton of time on it, but sometimes your client doesn't actually understand
[22:05] the significance of why they're being asked to do that. And so we have these pre hearings and
[22:10] it's high in your client, maybe, maybe your client will slow. And you're like, well, why didn't you
[22:14] do that? Like that would have made this better. And you're like, well, I didn't understand that.
[22:18] I didn't really understand the significance. Um, that's more difficult to get in the record because
[22:24] the person who doesn't understand the significance is alpha dot explaining why they're not doing something
[22:29] to the doctor. Kind of flip side of that is sometimes we see, especially like with schizophrenia, there
[22:34] may be a, uh, maybe a denial about the diagnosis. And so there's, there's a client who, you know,
[22:39] is, well, that's not me. I don't have that. I don't need to do that. Yeah. And those cases become
[22:44] difficult too, even though sometimes the denial and of itself comes evidence of the severity of the
[22:49] condition. So, you know, now we're lawyering, but I mean, we are lawyers. I guess, I guess you have to,
[22:54] I guess that's what we do. So practically, I think the, the big takeaway for people, though, is
[23:01] if you can comply and there's not a good reason, just comply. But if you're not going to comply
[23:06] for whatever reason, whether it's medication or surgery or smoking or whatever it is,
[23:10] you need to be prepared to not only answer for that at the hearing, but be prepared to get pushback.
[23:15] If your answer is not consistent with what you've been telling people all along, and if you haven't
[23:20] ever told anybody, I can tell you it's going to be inconsistent because there's going to be nothing
[23:23] to compare it to. A couple of takeaways, just leave people with a few takeaways. You can't leave
[23:31] this non-compliance unchallenged in the chart. I just think that's so, so important. I think you can't
[23:38] get angry at the end of the process if you're not willing to do the work at the beginning of the
[23:44] process to understand what's going on. The doctor, the judge is looking at your case saying,
[23:51] I need to show, I need to believe that this person is unable to sustain competitive employment
[23:57] in spite of their best efforts to treat their medical condition. That's not what the reg actually
[24:03] says, but that's what every judge who evaluates a case is deciding. They're looking at you saying,
[24:09] could this person work based on the rules which are different for people who are under 50 and 50,
[24:14] 54 over 55, and those who have physical conditions and mental only conditions or a combination,
[24:20] based on your set of circumstances, wherever you are, can this person return to competitive
[24:27] employment in evaluating their medical conditions to see have they done everything that I think they
[24:36] could do? That's really the root of compliance. The root of compliance is back to this concept we talk
[24:42] about periodically, which is good hands, clean hands, where you say, I'm coming to the court with
[24:47] clean hands, I've done everything I could possibly do to be better, but despite my best efforts, I'm still
[24:52] unable to meet the demands of full-time work. And if you can't do that, you better have a really good
[24:56] reason. And if you have a good reason, okay, I mean, except for Judge Denosmal, like most of the judges
[25:02] are going to be okay with that. And more importantly, if they're not okay with that, and they deny you
[25:07] anyway, at least we can appeal and say, because usually in those cases they don't document these
[25:12] correctly. They don't do the proper assessments in the decisions. They make a lot of, when judges
[25:16] deny you and there's good calls, there's a lot of opportunity there for us to win appeal. That's
[25:25] never where we want to be. We don't want to be in the federal process. We can help it. But there will
[25:30] be opportunity there, but only if you've done what you need to do to start with. Very good. Now,
[25:35] shall comply. There we go. That's all I got for today. Tune in next time. We'll be talking about
[25:43] some of the great topic. I don't even know what we're talking about yet. We haven't got that far ahead.
[25:46] Till then, subscribe. Take care. Thanks for watching.