TRANSCRIPCIÓN 🔗
Brian: Welcome to the Decision Advantage, a fusion intelligence podcast by Fermin Consulting. I'm Brian Leclerc, and today's guest is Kyle King, founder of Crisis Lab. Kyle, welcome to the show.
Kyle King: All right, thanks for having me. Happy to be here.
Brian: Now Kyle, you've spent decades working across international organizations, European security frameworks, and now you're leading Crisis Lab. But before we jump into our discussion, can you tell us a little bit about your background and maybe what you're focused on right now?
Kyle King: Sure, absolutely. So, you know, I started out my career as as many of us have in the United States. You know, I sort of went into the military. So I started out my career in the Marine Corps for a few years and then I went into the emergency services. I got out, was a civilian, went into the emergency services, and then one day I got a call from a friend of mine who was working overseas in in Bosnia during that time in the conflict. And he had a very interesting job proposal, which was to go over there and to help sort of reestablish the emergency services and also work under US Army Europe as a civilian. And so I I was young and dumb enough and I said, Sure, yeah, I'll absolutely do that. And then that launched me into a thirty year career of working internationally. And out throughout those thirty years, I spent fourteen years in deployed operations, directly supporting, deployments in Bosnia and Kosovo and Afghanistan and things like that. But I also spent seven years with NATO as a the first civil emergency advisor who was advising on postconflict operations and security sector reform. And so my real role there was to Take what we currently view in the US as emergency services slash emergency management and then integrate that into security sector reform and rebuilding institutions after conflict. And so it's simply the question of who rebuilds the fire station and all sorts of things like that. and then I spent I was seconded by state to the OSCE in in Ukraine for two and a half years and then left when the war started. And then that's when I started working and founding Crisis Lab because I found that What what I was learning in the field on sort of these sort of cutting edge of discussions about how we manage a crisis and a conflict was really sort of not represented anywhere. So we started from a position of we view the the ability to manage an emergency with civilian institutions as an indicator of stability and how stable nations are. And so transitioning from that into okay, well, if that's the truth that we're going with, and that's what we're our view is. Then we started working with crisis labs like what does that actually translate into, once a nation goes into conflict. So what's the reverse of that? If we're building stability, what happens when we are attacked by an adversarial nation and they want to create instability? And so how do we maintain that? And so our focus has largely been on
Load full transcript
now on complex crisis, multi-domain crisis, and how these things all converge. You know, you use the words like effusion center and fusion intelligence and things like that. And so This is where we're looking at from a civilian complex crisis perspective. It's not just emergency management, but it's also what we call more internationally the broader crisis management pr and spectrum that we look at from individual emergencies all the way national security and defense and conflict and then back down.
Brian: so you might be looking at major attacks as as well as small things or
Kyle King: Mm-hmm.
Brian: or n not necessarily attacks either, right?
Kyle King: Absolutely. Right. So this is what we call the spectrum of crisis to conflict. This is one of the things that we also teach in the the NATO courses, but it's where we're looking at, okay, there's there's degrees of emergencies and disasters in our civilian institutions that we look at, you know, and in Europeans it's more civil protection oriented. But it's simply going from anywhere on that spectrum from you having a personal emergency or crisis in your household, you know, a fire, whatever the case is. And then growing up to a multi-agency response and a multi multi-jurisdictional response into a state level response to a federal response and just walking up that sort of escalation of crisis and you just getting more and more agencies involved up until that threshold of where it starts to become a national security event. So you've created it's the instability in the environment so much that it starts to draw in the topics of national security. And then how do we sort of de-escalate things, bring things back down to normal, and then start to, recover. And so that's when we w that's the spectrum that we're talking about when we we really start focusing on multi-agency, multi-jurisdictional complex crisis leading up to national level events. And that's our our predominant focus. But it's it all starts, right? So it all starts with the a basic car accident, right? That's all force responder stuff. But then if it turns into a chemical accident, you know, think of What was it? The train accident and was it Pennsylvania, I think it was. Correct me if I'm wrong.
Brian: Okay. Yeah, yeah. Just a couple of years ago. Yeah.
Kyle King: Yeah, a few years ago, right? So major accident. It was just a train accident, but just the catastrophic event leads into another and another event and another event. So this sort of cascading effect. Yeah. Or
Brian: Right,
Kyle King: Flint, Michigan. You know, and so what we also do now is and and sort of going down the rabbit hole here, but we also look at the policy choices behind it, because you know, what is the version of mitigation at national policy level? And then what is the version of that unwinding all the way back down to the municipality? And that's what we find when you're saying what are we working on now? That's the biggest problem that we see right now is
translating national imperative. We need to be a more resilient nation, so to speak, down into actual what does a municipality do about that? Right. And so that's
Brian: Right.
Kyle King: our biggest gap that we're seeing.
Brian: So trying to prepare for these events that may be coming. you mentioned Flint, so like if if Flint had prepared more for what was coming.
Kyle King: so that's really the difficult thing because, what we have seen is that what really focused on right now is trying to get people to understand the next twenty-four months. Because we feel like if we can just try and predict the next twenty-four months, we can make better decisions. And where we don't want to be is sitting in a committee meeting in two years, you know, answering questions about why we made our decisions the way we did. And so we focus on sort of the next twenty-four months, which is already hard. I think to a certain extent, and it might it might grate on the ears of some of your listeners, but but it's like the strategy's almost the easy part. Right? It's like we want to defend the nation. You know, these big, broad ideas. We see that a lot in NATO and the European Union and things like that. But to be honest, you can issue a policy paper from NATO with broad, comprehensive strategy. It hits a desk in DC, but nobody in Tulsa, Oklahoma reads it. Right? And so this is where we see this this sort of big gap. And so we've tried to focus down on what is the next 24 months showing us what is what are some practical steps that we can make and that we can take to to b mitigate some of these issues. And so when we come back to Flint, it's like, a few years before the accident, they were trying to have cost savings measures. They replaced the pipes. They made conscious decisions, which ended up undermining the security of of the communities. And so what are the decisions that, learning from that, what are the decisions we're making today that will have an impact in two years? This is the puzzle that we're trying to work with.
Brian: Right, right. So so you're you're you know working in Europe now, are are you seeing some of the same threats that the United States is seeing? so like what are some of the major issues that are happening there with hacks and sabotage and and that sort of thing?
Kyle King: well it's almost every day, right? So just this week alone. So I think there was I don't know the exact number. Somebody have to look it up because it's currently happening at the time of this recording. But I think seven hundred stores were had a cyber attack on the refrigeration systems and raised them to fifty Celsius, you know, which is roughly a hundred degrees or so, if I my math is right. which you never know. But but it's warm. It's warm.
Brian: It's warm. It's warm is what it is. Yeah. Yeah. Right. Too warm for food. Yep.
Kyle King: That's the important part, right? Do more for food. Right. Exactly. That's exactly the point. That's the core issue. so that's happening across the the the space there, you know, and then we're seeing sort of the trends coming out. So there's sort of three different things that are happening if I relate that back to the US very briefly. So you have the eastern flank of Europe and you have sort of the the the consumption there and the viewpoint of the war and Russia's invasion of Ukraine and what's happening there. And everybody's trying to learn from that experience because we don't know what conflict looks like domestically in the United States in that way, right? So we're looking at Ukraine, we're saying, what are we learning? What are the mayors doing? What is a what does martial law look like in implementation? Because that's something we also don't have a lot of experience with in the United States, right? So what is the actual interpretation of martial law? How does it actually function and work? And I think we had a conversation about this, but even we have ideas of martial law, we have perceptions of we what we think that will be, we have perceptions of civil defense and what that means, and then we have ideas about what that should mean. But what are the practical realities of it? People still need a driver's license, people still get married, people still need to go to court, they still have daily lives, even under martial law. So how does that work? And so that's where, you know, we spent a lot of time supporting NATO and other organizations and looking at that. So we've got this the Ukraine piece, you've got this whole eastern flank piece, you've got GPS jamming at the airports. I think also today they had 15 bomb threats on aircraft flying over Europe in airspace today.
Brian: Just in the one day.
Kyle King: just in one day, right? And so there's always this sort of persistent, antagonistic sort of environment in Europe, which you know don't see it on the daily news, but it's it's happening. You can Google it, you can find it, and it's just this sort of the the undertones of conflict on the European continent. Now if you come back to the United States, it's largely very different. This is that compare and contrast piece where in the United States we're still very oriented around, in my view, big disasters, right? So big disasters, big plans, big events, and that's what's driving it. And it makes sense, right? It makes sense. There's nothing wrong with it. It makes sense to a certain extent because that's what the United States has. It not necessarily has conflict on domestically, there's Not being invaded by anybody. but essentially, you know, you have major disasters, hurricane seasons, tornadoes and earthquakes and everything else. And so it makes sense to plan for all of that. But where the gap we start to see is where, you know, between, you know, there's no huge hurricanes and things like that in Europe. So what is it that Europeans are are preparing for is more the warfront, right? How do we manage society in a time of conflict when you're constantly
being attacked? And in the United States, it's like big disasters, and then okay, there's a little bit of cyber, there's a little bit of this, a little bit of that, but it's still oriented around, I think, all of our plans, most of our plans, I'd say that with a grain of salt, around the emergency management spectrum of big disasters, respond, recover, mitigate, plans, all that sort of things like that. So when we're looking across those three, just to wrap that up, you're seeing conflict and and war fronts. You see preparations on the eastern flank. driving policy changes throughout Europe. And then you see this persistent escalatory tactics being used across Europe. And and so Europe is preparing for war. And then conversely, you see in the United States, there's, just generally I think institutionally more focused on emergency and big disasters. And then starting to get indications and hints of conversations moving around to okay, there's there's something more going on that we should pay attention to. And I think that's the space that the US is getting into these days.
Brian: So yeah, it sounds like maybe i perhaps they had been missing the mark on that, but they're they're getting there.
Kyle King: True. I and also why? the the US has
Brian: Mm-hmm.
Kyle King: two oceans and Canada and Mexico and it is in a great place geographically. So
Brian: Right.
Kyle King: the but you know, recent events, you know, the US is not completely out of touch with the sort of, you know, cyber attacks and sort of agentic AI and everything else that's going on and the attacks on IOT systems and water infrastructure and everything else. So it's the US isn't immune. I think that unless you're in the European environment and understanding that environment, it's difficult to be in the US and try and articulate how the Europeans are preparing, right? You don't have a direct correlation to that. So if I were to use an example, and I say this just to make a point with to sort of just to draw sort of a stark contrast and and which is that I I won't believe the US is really prepared for anything in civil defense until they change the building codes and all the houses are made out of concrete. Right. So and and so
Brian: Right.
Kyle King: he like are these those are the big huge policy decisions you have to make if you really want to start preparing. The rest is sort of semantics. Right. But unless you're gonna change the way we build societies and make everybody have a shelter like they do in Finland, then you're not really taking it seriously, right?
Brian: As you said, the United States has h has not had to worry about that sort of thing. So
Kyle King: Exactly.
Brian: well so in different parts of Europe they're they're taking different strategies and
Kyle King: Mm.
Brian: we had been talking offline about the Sweden total defense strategy. might this be a good model for the United States or and maybe the rest of the world, but but can you explain that a little bit?
Kyle King: Yeah, so that's super interesting. to to me and and probably just to to your listeners as well. but Sweden's model
Brian: very different than here.
Kyle King: Well, so there's there's size and scale issues, of course, you know, the United States is huge. but I think if we look at it from a philosophical perspective about what Sweden's recognized, they s Sweden's has has spent a lot of time and effort learning from Ukraine and the experience of Ukraine. And what they have seen is that a decentralized approach is helping make decisions faster and to support the civilian population faster in a conflict. And so they have made some real institutional changes, established new institutions, reformed older institutions, joined NATO, you know, it's sort of all these policy reforms that have then driven this perspective of we're not going to drive a centralized government and conflict. We're going to decentralize into these sort of regions, and these regions will be integrated with the military. So we'll have military components that are integrated. And are so all the decision making can be made more locally. It doesn't mean that there's complete authority to do whatever they want. There's still institutional structures and everything else like that. But the the key theme I would take away from that is the effort to decentralize decision making and bring it to a lower level with integrated planning on a consistent basis and looking at how will we actually protect the population in the time of conflict. Conversely. and I think everybody's seen it, but the the memo that came out from the FEMA administration about defining min FEMA administrator about defining emergency management as being the strategic coordination of emergency services was ironic to me because that was driving it in the opposite direction, right? Because it defined emergency management as only the strategic coordination of emergency services. And if you take it at face value in what it says, that's basically what it is: the coordination of emergency services. So, okay, so there's also been a movement in the states with the current administration in terms of decentralizing or at least moving everything back to the states right at the state level. So that exists to a certain extent. But I think if we're comparing and contrasting, one of the things that's happening is, there's the the movement to put everything back to the to the state level in the United States, but then the resources didn't follow with it. Right. So it was more like a cut. And not necessarily an empowerment. If that makes sense, right? Because if you're saying we are going to decentralize in a Swedish model, we're going to establish these regional committees, we're going to fund them to be prepared so they can make decisions when they need to without always asking for support from a central government level, then you would make that decision, and this is the point I'm making, is like you would make that decision
to cut federal support, move it to the states, but then also fund it more if you want the states to do it, right?
Brian: That seems to be a major issue, is where is the funding coming in coming from and and how is that being coordinated?
Kyle King: And you would also regulate it a bit, right? So you would be changing laws and standards and requirements to say you need to have an emergency manager in every municipality, right? Or you need to have a working committee on something, you know? And so this is where I start to see the difference because it is a decentralization decentralization on both sides, but one was as a cost cutting measure and the other was as in with intent. And purpose, right?
Brian: Right.
Kyle King: And so this is where I draw the contrast between the two. And so then it leaves the US in a position of okay, If strategic coordination emergency services is the role, then who's doing the rest of it? Right. And so then that becomes the issue on a policy standpoint. Is that gonna be like Homeland Security? Is that DHS? And like that then then where does the rest of this plug in? Or is it all just the states now? Because the states are also underfunded and don't have capabilities across all the municipalities. And that just brings it down to another point that I would raise is even though we talk about all these big macro ideas and policy issues, what we've seen directly in the conflict coming out of the Ukraine is the role of municipalities. And the mayor is the last one to make those decisions, right? So municipalities are the front line. And if municipalities are the front line, and we know this, it's verified, everybody knows this at this point, after the last four years, then because that's where the conflict is occurring. It's the same mantra in emergency management. Everything is local. It starts and ends locally. The same is with war as it is a disaster. And so then how are these communities being empowered? How are they being able to how are they resourced to to make decisions, to act on their own when it's you're in an environment where you have no centralized support and communication? And so this is where we see on these in a compare and contrast, these sort of two movements that are happening across Europe and the United States. And then also when you look vertically across government, from federal down to state and municipal level. And then we see municipal levels where the actual war and the conflict is happening, is that that's where the empowerment needs to be at a local level.
Brian: It seems to make sense. these these events or disasters or whatever are local events. And especially
Kyle King: Mm.
Brian: in the NSH with such a large country, you know, if something happens in California, these coasters don't really have a stake in it. So it makes sense that it would be localized and and those people would be the ones that would be taking
Kyle King: Mm-hmm.
Brian: care of things, it seems anyway.
Kyle King: No, absolutely. the the US is in a is in a great place. I mean, you know, it's huge, right? So that's where there's there's an advantage there, but it again it doesn't mean the US is a mutant. You know, I think things are trending and changing so fast. I my concern is we're gonna be caught sort of flat footed at some point.
Brian: I think you had hinted at this, but it sounds like clear messaging and communication is is one of the key key things that sometimes we're missing, maybe?
Kyle King: Yeah, it's interesting you say that 'cause one of the the briefings that we put out, we were talking about early warning systems and this was also very I was even shocked. Which is, when we anybody who's in in this field and in this practice, I think one of the things that you learn over time is okay, you see everybody talking, but where is the actual proof, right? And it it sounds negative, but it's not I'm not trying to be negative. What I'm just trying to say is like there's just lots of discussions, but unless you and I come back to that one example, which is why I use it, unless you're gonna build a house out of concrete, you're not really taking it seriously, we have a lot of policy discussions, a lot of security forums, a lot of defense forums. We talk about all these things, but I think in many cases it's still sort of very difficult in the United States to to have clear communication on this point. Because if you're saying we're preparing for war, it's very difficult. The US isn't a protected place, nobody will believe you anyway when they're sitting in Montana. You know, they're just gonna say, Okay Sure. To your point, there's an earthquake in California. Well, that's terrible. But then you go to work when you're in New York, right? And so it's just it's so huge, so massive, such a large landmass that you're just sort of disconnected from anything, which means the messaging almost has to be sort of hyperlocal at that point. And that's where we encourage municipal managers and and city managers and things like that to be more invested in this process. And when I was coming back to the to the early warning point, when I was looking at that, it was really surprising because when we look at early warning and messaging. we we really focus on the message and what to tell people. Which makes sense, right? You've got to go somewhere. and you want people to go the direction that you tell them. But ironically, we have no way to confirm that anybody got a message. Right? So it's like
Brian: Yeah. So we're putting it out there but we don't know if there's th yeah.
Kyle King: It's it's a one way thing, right? So you throw it out there and you hope people listen to it and you hope that that you get it. But what happens in a disaster, right? All the communications are flooded and everything's broken anyway. So you're doing this this alert and warning, and everybody says alert and warning as if it's sort of there, right? Does that make sense? It's like we we say it
and take it for granted to a certain extent, right? No, we're gonna do a we have IPAUS, we're gonna send a message, we're gonna do all this stuff and then you know, warn the population. But how many people actually get the message? And then the con conversely from that is is also the fact that, you know, how many people want to know? Like municipalities don't have the capability to receive messages back. Right? You've got one duty officer or watch officer that's like, I'm gonna hit this button and warn people to evacuate, and you get a thousand messages back. And it's like, how are you there's no capacity
Brian: Right. What are you gonna do with those?
Kyle King: for that.
Brian: Right.
Kyle King: So it comes it's this we're coming full circle now, and just like how is the municipality going to do anything when they're not resourced and empowered to do it? Because then you get a thousand messages back. Well, in the in the public service, as soon as you get a message, you have a legal obligation, right? Especially if you're a first responder, you have to try and do something, or at least they fall into a cue of prioritization. So then it opens up a whole nother thing and discussion around that. So then the system becomes, well, I'm not sure I want to know at that point. Because then you open Pandora's box of legal obligations and I told you that I was, trapped in a building and nothing happened. Right. So when we say communications, I think we have to have, to your point, very clear intent on the policies that are being drafted and why. but I think communication is still so just geographically difficult and and diverse that it you know, the one thing that we do need to be is on one real page about what, you know, what does resilience look like, for example, in the United States in terms of that. So It's probably more than what what you were asking. But that's that's where my that's where my head went, yeah.
Brian: So yeah, communication good. But yeah. Well
Kyle King: Yeah.
Brian: as we wrap up, are there any additional insights you'd you'd like to share that could increase US companies as they you know seek to shore up their resilience?
Kyle King: So I just I think one of the greatest things that's been a b an advantage for me is is really just trying to gain perspective. I think that what we do is when we become experts, we become institutionally siloed. And I view careers as a bit sort of a bit like a tree, right? So you we you know, when you're forming your roots, when you're just getting started, you're really digging in, trying to understand everything, and then you sort of as your career progresses, you're you're building that portfolio and you're building the foundation. From which you you become a senior professional. But when you're at that expert level, you really need to branch out. You've really got to start looking across other professions and seeing what people are doing. You've got to learn from what Sweden is doing. At least try you don't have to mimic, you don't have to copy it, but you have to understand the rationale why they're doing what they're doing. And then you have to have the ability to take that and interpret it to your environment. And so, what I think is what people with companies is what they need to start paying attention to is what our nations are saying. I think there's 33 nations now that are saying that people need to be prepared for for possible conflict scenarios. And what does that impact on your global supply chain? How is it going to impact your business? the technology advancing, what's that how's that gonna impact with your business? And I'm sure most people are thinking about all these things. But I would just encourage them to really look at, you know, look at peek over the fence and see what people are doing. Break down the silos and the the the perceptions that you have, work really hard at questioning your own assumptions. because you might be surprised that you might be wrong. So, you know, that's I've been humbled more than once in terms of the way I was thinking, just by talking with international partners. And so I encourage people to really get outside perspective and opinion on on the assumptions that they're making. And I I view that as a as a as a quality, you know, as a as a strength and you know, being solid enough in your own organization, your own team to be able to take outside criticism. You don't have to do anything but get the feedback. I think that's so important.
Brian: Continue to seek information at all times.
Kyle King: Absolutely. Yeah.
Brian: All right. All right, well, thank you for joining us today.
Kyle King: My pleasure.
Brian: great. Thank you for the conversation. And to everyone out there, thank you for tuning in today. And just a reminder that all of our podcasts are available in video form on YouTube and also available as audio only on Apple Podcast, Spotify, and many other services. And you can find those links to all those services and more at podcast.fernon.com. And I am Brian LeClaire, and this has been another episode of the Decision Advantage. Thanks for tuning in.